Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRIMA HFE Orange Book - Rev-2 1
PRIMA HFE Orange Book - Rev-2 1
019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
DOCUMENT HISTORY
Page 2 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page 3 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.7 GUARDRAILS............................................................................................................................... 24
3.7.1 Design & Installation .............................................................................................................. 24
3.8 TOE BOARDS............................................................................................................................... 24
3.8.1 Design.................................................................................................................................... 24
3.9 SIGNAGE ...................................................................................................................................... 24
3.10 MAN-WAY DIMENSIONS ......................................................................................................... 25
3.10.1 Universal - Columns, Vessels, Tubulars, etc......................................................................... 25
3.10.2 Columns – Cylindrical & Conical Skirt ................................................................................... 25
3.10.3 Furnaces & Related ............................................................................................................... 25
3.10.4 Storage tanks......................................................................................................................... 25
3.10.5 Columns................................................................................................................................. 25
3.10.6 Column Trays......................................................................................................................... 25
3.10.7 Pressure Vessels ................................................................................................................... 26
3.10.8 Water Tube Boilers ................................................................................................................ 26
3.10.9 Fired Heaters ......................................................................................................................... 26
3.11 ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS............................................................................................... 27
3.11.1 Emergency Egress ............................................................................................................. 27
3.11.2 Secondary Means of Escape ............................................................................................. 27
3.11.3 Walking Surface ................................................................................................................. 28
3.11.4 Floor-plate, Grating/ Decking ............................................................................................. 28
3.11.5 Finishing ............................................................................................................................. 28
3.11.6 Walkway Width................................................................................................................... 28
3.11.7 Stairways............................................................................................................................ 29
3.11.8 Ramps ................................................................................................................................ 29
3.11.9 Stair Treads........................................................................................................................ 29
3.11.10 Handrails ............................................................................................................................ 29
3.11.11 Ladder Orientation ............................................................................................................. 30
3.11.12 Ladder Reach..................................................................................................................... 30
3.11.13 Ladder Dimensions & Clearance ....................................................................................... 30
3.11.14 Ladder Rungs..................................................................................................................... 30
3.11.15 Step-through Ladders ........................................................................................................ 30
3.11.16 Gate.................................................................................................................................... 30
3.11.17 Landings............................................................................................................................. 31
3.11.18 Platforms & Decks.............................................................................................................. 31
3.11.19 Platform Clearance ............................................................................................................ 31
3.11.20 Platform Space................................................................................................................... 31
3.11.21 Platform live-loads.............................................................................................................. 32
3.11.22 Guardrails........................................................................................................................... 32
3.11.23 Toe-plate & Pipes............................................................................................................... 32
3.11.24 Manway Clearance ............................................................................................................ 33
3.11.25 Manway Size ...................................................................................................................... 33
3.11.26 Vessel Skirt Manways ........................................................................................................ 34
4.0 EQUIPMENT LAYOUT & ACCESS......................................................................................................35
4.1 GENERAL WORKER ACCESS.................................................................................................... 35
4.1.1 Worker Envelope ................................................................................................................... 35
4.1.2 Access & Clearance .............................................................................................................. 35
4.2 COLUMNS & INTERNALS ........................................................................................................... 36
4.2.1 Access – Installation & Removal ........................................................................................... 36
4.2.2 Fractionating Tray Installation & Removal ............................................................................. 36
4.2.3 Fractionating Trays & Access Within ..................................................................................... 37
4.2.4 Draw-off Trays, Liquid Collectors & Gravity Liquid Distributors............................................. 38
4.2.5 - and provisions for installation and removal ........................................................................ 38
4.2.6 - and provisions for access ................................................................................................... 38
4.2.7 Gravity liquid distributors ....................................................................................................... 38
4.2.8 Packing & Loads .................................................................................................................... 38
4.2.9 Packing & Provisions for Installation & Removal................................................................... 39
4.2.10 Feed Inlet Device - Installation & Removal............................................................................ 39
4.2.11 O & M Tasks & Considerations (Columns, Reactors, Vessels)............................................. 39
Page 4 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 5 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.11.4 O & M Tasks & Considerations for Pumps & Compressors .................................................. 51
4.12 COMPRESSORS ...................................................................................................................... 52
4.12.1 Layout .................................................................................................................................... 52
4.12.2 Air Compressor Intake Filters – Design & Access................................................................. 52
4.13 CENTRIFUGAL FANS .............................................................................................................. 53
4.13.1 Noise Control ......................................................................................................................... 53
4.13.2 Bolting Access ....................................................................................................................... 53
4.14 LUBRICATION .......................................................................................................................... 53
4.14.1 O & M Tasks and Considerations .......................................................................................... 53
4.15 LUBRICATION, SHAFT-SEALING & CONTROL OIL SYSTEMS & AUXILIARIES ................. 53
4.15.1 Outdoor Operation ................................................................................................................. 53
4.15.2 Accessibility ........................................................................................................................... 54
4.15.3 Filter Access .......................................................................................................................... 54
4.15.4 Transfer Valves...................................................................................................................... 54
4.15.5 Instruments ............................................................................................................................ 54
4.15.6 Self-acting Gas Seal .............................................................................................................. 54
4.16 HGV LOADING FACILITIES ..................................................................................................... 55
4.16.1 Manual Product Flow Control Valves .................................................................................... 55
4.16.2 Top Loading Gantry – Working Platform ............................................................................... 55
4.16.3 Top Loading Gantry – Access Ramp..................................................................................... 55
4.16.4 Top Loading Gantry - Guard Rails......................................................................................... 56
4.16.5 Visibility & Access .................................................................................................................. 56
4.16.6 Other Requirements .............................................................................................................. 56
4.17 ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS............................................................................................... 56
4.17.1 Worker Envelope................................................................................................................ 56
4.17.2 Reach Limitations............................................................................................................... 56
4.17.3 Hand Openings .................................................................................................................. 56
4.17.4 Platforms ............................................................................................................................ 57
4.17.5 Standing Surface................................................................................................................ 57
4.17.6 Priority of Access ............................................................................................................... 57
4.17.7 General Equipment Layout ................................................................................................ 57
4.17.8 Relief Valve Location ......................................................................................................... 58
4.17.9 Air Coolers (Fin Fans) ........................................................................................................ 58
4.17.10 Air Cooler Platforms ........................................................................................................... 58
4.17.11 Heat Exchangers................................................................................................................ 59
5.0 INSTRUMENTATION ............................................................................................................................61
5.1 INSTRUMENT NAME AND WARNING PLATES ......................................................................... 61
5.1.1 General .................................................................................................................................. 61
5.1.2 Language ............................................................................................................................... 61
5.1.3 Field-mounted Nameplates.................................................................................................... 61
5.1.4 SIL1 IPF Initiators .................................................................................................................. 61
5.1.5 Other Identification Requirements ......................................................................................... 61
5.1.6 Nameplates for Indoor Use.................................................................................................... 61
5.1.7 Labels inside Instrument Cabinets ........................................................................................ 62
5.1.8 Abbreviations ......................................................................................................................... 62
5.2 PLANT INSTRUMENTS ............................................................................................................... 62
5.2.1 Finish ..................................................................................................................................... 62
5.2.2 Lamp Test Facilities ............................................................................................................... 62
5.2.3 Integral and Receiving Indicators .......................................................................................... 62
5.2.4 Diaphragm Seals ................................................................................................................... 62
5.3 LOCATION AND ACCESSIBILITY ............................................................................................... 62
5.3.1 On-line Instruments ............................................................................................................... 62
5.3.2 Limited accessibility ............................................................................................................... 63
5.3.3 Rodding-out ........................................................................................................................... 63
5.3.4 Insulation Enclosures............................................................................................................. 63
5.3.5 Model Reviews....................................................................................................................... 63
5.3.6 Hoisting Requiremements ..................................................................................................... 64
5.3.7 Toxic Service ......................................................................................................................... 64
Page 6 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 7 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 8 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 9 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 10 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 PURPOSE
This document is a collection of minimum acceptable Human Factors Engineering (HFE) requirements for
the design and layout of equipment and work-spaces to be used throughout Pernis PRIMA Projects.
In compliance with Shell Health Management Standards, all new facilities projects must consider human
factors engineering principles during design. The aims are to minimise risk to health as well as to provide
a workplace with easy and safe access for operation and maintenance under all conditions (i.e. normal,
upset/emergency and in all weather conditions).
Requirements and technical specifications for workplace layout are currently spread across a large
number of Shell Design Engineering Practices (V.26 understood), standard drawings and other sources.
This document brings all of these requirements and specifications under a single cover providing a single
point of reference for all workplace design specifications for use by the PRIMA Projects.
The book also provides project managers, engineers, designers and HSE professionals with a convenient
source of HFE-related design detail.
Most of the specifications in this document are directly traceable to existing Shell standards or drawings:
the principle behind this document is not to change or amend existing specifications. The only exceptions
to this are either;
1. where there are specific Dutch regulations that are not consistent with Shell standards.
2. where operational experience requires defining details not currently addressed by a DEP.
Some existing engineering standards require that projects customise dimensions to match the
anthropometrics (human body dimensions) or societal norms of the local workforce, the nature of the work
or the work environment. So far as possible, this document includes these customised details where they
are necessary for the PRIMA projects.
This document does not cover information displays, alarms and controls within the control room and DCS
system. These aspects are covered in DEP 30.00.60.15.GEN Human/Machine Interface and Control
Room Design and DEP 30.00.60.16.GEN Human Machine Interface Design for Situation Awareness.
This document is based on version prepared for the Canadian Oil Sands Project (document OSG-P9.15, Rev
1, Feb 2008). Some of the SCAN material has been retained and is included here in Chapters 3 to 7 as
‘Additional Requirements’ (the final sub-section in each section). This is generally material that is
considered both important and useful (particularly from the experience gained from operations &
maintenance), and/or which addresses an issue existing DEP’s or Drawings do not cover. Where the
original source is a North American Shell standard, this is referenced accordingly.
Page 11 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Part of this includes a ‘transparent standards structure’, illustrated below as it applies to this document
and it is important to note that there is a hierarchy or priority to the sources of the data it contains.
Industry standards
Standard drawings
In all cases where it applies, national law or derived guidelines (i.e. Bouwbesluit, AI-bladen) take
precedence. After that, where an external, international/industry standard applies or is relevant, its
specifications form project/design baselines, followed, and supplemented, by Shell Group DEP-GEN’s
(V.26 in this instance) in order to reflect the minimum, additional Group requirements.
Some DEP’s make reference to particular Standard Drawings and these are used to supplement the DEP.
Finally, there are OU and Project Standards which should be referred to in the absence of a standard or
DEP-GEN; (i.e. DEP-SCAN, ESTG’s).
1.4 DEFINITIONS
1.5 RESPONSIBILITY
The CONTRACTOR shall be solely responsible for providing complete and operable equipment in full
accordance with the latest edition of applicable Industry Codes/Standards and all Government
Regulations.
This document is intended as a convenient source of HFE content contained in adopted project standards,
but the CONTRACTOR shall be solely responsible for providing equipment and facility structures in
accordance with adopted project standards.
All conflicts between HFE requirements defined herein and other Technical Requirements, applicable
codes and standards including Government Regulations shall be submitted in writing to COMPANY for
resolution.
Page 12 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
The CONTRACTOR shall submit in writing to COMPANY any and all exceptions to HFE requirements for
approval. Any applicable impact on cost or schedule must be stated along with the proposed exception.
COMPANY has no obligation to consider or accept any exceptions that have been offered. Any deviations
shall be considered on a case-by-case basis and must receive prior approval from the COMPANY.
Shell Operations and Maintenance personnel shall hold final approval of design details concerning access
to equipment and egress from work-spaces.
If any discrepancies (i.e. a contradiction with a Building Code requirement), errors or omissions are noted
or suspected, please report them to the custodian at the email address in the Comments section below.
Page 13 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
1.8 REFERENCES
Page 14 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
ANSI/IESNA RP-7-01 Recommended Practice for Lighting Industrial Facilities. Annex A2 Figure
A2-3 Recommended Illuminance Values for Specific Industries – Petroleum, chemical and
petrochemical industry.
ASHRAE 62.1-2004 Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality
ENG0072SP Human Factors Specifications for Workplaces, Shell Exploration & Production
Company, December 2007
Ergonomics and Health, Chapter 10 Shell Works Toolkit, Shell Real Estate, 2007
ISO 13705: 2006 - Fired Heaters for General Refinery Service
ISO 13706: 2005 - Air-Cooled Heat Exchangers
ISO 15664:2001(E) - Acoustics — Noise Control Design Procedures for Open Plant
ISO 16182: 2007 – Shell and Tube Heat Exchangers
Page 15 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 16 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Ensure that the layout of equipment allows for easy access during the operation and maintenance of the
units under all normal, upset/emergency and weather conditions by the full range of potential employees
(i.e. 5th percentile female to the 95th percentile male, with personal protective equipment). The operability
of the equipment also ensures the usability of display and control design including local control panels.
This would mean that the placement and orientation of all controls and displays/instruments are
appropriate to ensure safe and effective viewing, reach, and operation by COMPANY personnel.
2.2 MAINTAINABILITY
Ensure the efficient and safe movement of equipment requiring maintenance without removal of other
items such as piping, motors, etc. This includes the provision of adequate space and lay down areas for
all anticipated activities. Consideration should also be given to the provision and configuration of doors
and access hatches.
2.3 ACCESS/EGRESS
Ensure that all areas of the facility and equipment can be accessed and evacuated safely under normal
and emergency conditions.
Ensure requirements for manual lifting, pulling, pushing, and carrying of equipment, with respect for the
biomechanical and physiological capabilities and limitations of the personnel, are included during design.
Associated needs include the availability of mechanical lifting aids for assisted lifting and appropriate
storage or placement of lifting aids for safe reach and effective operation.
Ensure the clear communication of information and equipment identification, including effective viewing,
reading, and understanding of instructions, signs, labels, operations and maintenance manuals.
2.6 ENVIRONMENTAL
Ensure that environmental requirements regarding noise, lighting, vibration, climatic conditions and indoor
air quality have been addressed to optimize human performance. Environmental requirements to eliminate
or minimize impacts on worker health and safety are included in other standards and not duplicated here.
Page 17 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 18 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.1.2 Doors in Egress External doors shall always open outwards and in the direction of the
Route escape route.
Revolving doors and sliding doors are not allowed for emergency exits.
DEP 34.17.00.32 6.6.1
3.2 WALKWAYS
3.2.1 Headroom A minimum of 2300 mm of head clearance shall be provided above the
walking surface for the full length and width of all walkways, at the access
point of an area and around equipment, valves, etc. where operators pass.
3.2.3 Over Ground-level The minimum width of walkways over ground level pipe racks shall be 800
Pipes mm.
Bouwbesluit; Article 2.28
(supersedes DEP 34.28.00.31: 2.4.4)
3.2.4 Interconnecting Where practical, pressure vessels, which are grouped together shall have
Walkways platforms and interconnecting walkways at the same elevation. The
number of stairways and ladders to the platforms shall be sufficient to
meet safety requirements.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 4.5
3.2.5 Buildings: Doors & The minimum dimensions of access points (i.e. doors) and circulation
Corridors routes (i.e. corridors) for new buildings are a clear unobstructed width of
850 mm, and free passage (headroom/clearance) of 2300 mm.
Page 19 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.3.2 Stairways Stairways are required for access to elevated work platforms, walkways,
and other elevated work areas where the frequency of use is once per shift
or less if access is required to Category 1 valves
DEP 31.38.01.11 and DEP 30.00.60.13
3.3.3 Ladders Ladders may be installed instead of staircases if the ladders are only
required for occasional use and escape routes.
DEP 34.28.00.31: 2.4.4
3.3.4 Ramps/Sloped Sloped walkways shall have a maximum 15 degree angle of inclination
Walkways and the walking surface shall be slip-resistant. For inclinations greater
than 5 degrees, cleats shall be added, which run the full width of the
walkway at right angles to the direction of travel.
adapted from ASTM F1166 HFE for Marine Industry
3.4.2 Consistency The angle of inclination, the width of treads and the height of risers shall
be uniform throughout the length of a stairway. Stairs servicing similar
equipment should be of similar dimensions.
3.4.3 Stair Angle The maximum slope of a stair in a new building shall be 3:4.
3.4.4 Risers & Treads For risers and goings in new buildings, the following shall apply:
For stairs in onshore steel structures, the maximum riser height shall be
200 mm.
S 28.002-B; Note 4.
Page 20 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.4.5 Number of Steps The maximum height of any staircase shall be 4 metres.
On onshore steel structures, any flight of stairs shall not have more than
20 steps. For a single stair, the number of steps shall be 25 maximum.
On tanks, one (1) landing shall be provided every 6 m of vertical rise. For
tanks that do not exceed 20 m in height, no more than 2 intermediate
landings are necessary.
Straight-run landings on tank stairs shall have a minimum length of 1100
mm.
3.4.8 Handrails Hand- or guard-rails shall be provided on stair landings and at any edge or
floor where there is drop of 1 or more metres to grade or the level below or
adjacent.
Bouwbesluit; Article 2.15
Hand- or guardrails shall be provided on both sides of the stairs where any
tread is greater than 1 metre over grade or the adjacent level.
On onshore steel structures, the height of handrail above the leading edge
of the tread shall be 1000 mm and the height of the handrail above the
landing shall be 1100 mm.
Bouwbesluit; Article 2.16 & 2.31;
DEP 34.28.00.31 (S.28.006) & DEP 34.17.00.32: 6.9.2
Page 21 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Lighting fixtures, junction boxes, etc. shall not be supported by the hand-
railing.
GSI Best Practice requirement
3.5.1 Dimensions & Single-stage ladders shall be no longer than 9 metres. Multiple-stage
Clearance ladders shall be staggered every 6 metres.
Ladders shall be 500 mm in width, with ladder rungs spaced on 300 mm
centres. The rungs shall be 20 mm diameter.
A minimum clearance of 200 mm shall be provided between the ladder
rungs and the structure to which it is affixed, including all piping,
electrical conduit, fireproofing, and other protrusions that may be
present.
The ladder shall extend at least 1200 mm above the level of the platform
or landing.
S 28.011-001-H; Note 8.
3.5.2 Rungs The surface of the rungs shall have a slip resistant walking surface and
be designed to minimise build up of ice or compacted mud, etc.
ISO 14122:4-2004
3.5.4 Cage Ladders serving platforms or landings more than 3 m above grade or
platform shall be fitted with cages.
S 28.011-001-H; Note 4
Ladder cages shall begin at a height not less than 2300 mm or more
than 2700 mm above grade or the landing platform.
Page 22 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.5.5 Landings Single-stage ladders shall be no more than 9 metres in length. Multiple-
stage ladders shall be staggered at least every 6 metres, with a landing
provided.
S 28.011-001-H; Note 2
750 750
750
Page 23 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.6.2 Connected Decks Where practical, pressure vessels which are grouped together shall have
platforms and interconnecting walkways at the same elevation. The
number of stairways and ladders to the platforms shall be sufficient to meet
safety requirements.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 4.5
3.7 GUARDRAILS
3.7.1 Design & Installation The top rails of guardrails shall not be less than 1100 mm in height above
the top of the platform and an intermediate knee-rail shall be located
approximately midway between the top rail and the walkway level at 600
mm.
The maximum spacing of railing posts shall be 1500 mm centre to centre.
S28.006
3.8.1 Design Where hand-railing is installed, floors, platforms and walkways shall be
provided with toe plates of a minimum of 100 x 6 mm.
S 28.006-C
3.9 SIGNAGE All signage shall comply with the requirements of EU Directive 92/58/EEC
and site code BBS 05.00.1081 - Veiligheids en Gezondheidssignalering.
Page 24 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.10 MAN-WAY The following table of man-way dimensions is compiled from the Standard
DIMENSIONS Drawings and DEP’s.
305 150
3.10.2 Columns –
Cylindrical & Conical S 20.001
Skirt 500
Page 25 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 26 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.2 Secondary Means of Escape at grade towards safe areas shall be provided from all areas by
Escape a minimum of two (2) routes (at opposite directions).
Page 27 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.4 Floor-plate, Grating/ Unless otherwise noted, solid flooring shall be used only for interior or
Decking other applications free of precipitation or frequent wetting. Grating may
be used for both interior and exterior applications.
3.11.5 Finishing All ragged edges, welds, protruding bolts, or other fasteners that might
cause injury to personnel shall be avoided, or if required, ground smooth.
(ESTG 13-2.01 6.1.3)
3.11.6 Walkway Width The minimum unobstructed width of walkways, including walkways on
skids, modules and between equipment and building wall shall be 1000
mm, and for operating aisles the minimum distance shall be 1500 mm.
Larger horizontal clearance shall be provided where necessary to
perform all maintenance work including, but not limited to, the complete
removal of rotating equipment and heat exchanger tube bundles and
channels.
(SCAN DEP 31.38.01.11 3.3.1)
Page 28 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.7 Stairways Stairs or fixed vertical ladders shall be provided whenever operators or
maintainers must change elevation abruptly by more than 300 mm.
(ESTG 13-01.02 3)
Stairways shall be used for primary access to:
• all battery limit valves, blinds, vents and drains.
DEP 31.38.01.11
• main operating levels and main service levels, and
• elevated work platforms, walkways, and other elevated work areas
where the frequency of use is more than once per shift.
Stairways are required for access to elevated work platforms, walkways,
and other elevated work areas where the frequency of use is once per
shift or less if:
• access is required to Category 1 valves, or
• material, tools or other equipment must be carried for operations
and/or maintenance, or
• there is a potential for exposure to hazardous chemicals or
materials (e.g. H2S) at the elevated location
Reason: operator safety & efficiency of rounds, outcome of valve
criticality analysis
3.11.8 Ramps Ramps shall not be used unless otherwise approved by the COMPANY.
Sloped walkways adjacent to operating equipment or conditioning and
transport piping are not considered ramps.
Reason: Lessons learned re safety incidents
3.11.9 Stair Treads The top tread of stairs shall be flush with the walking surface. The height
of the bottom tread above the walking surface shall be the same as the
riser height used throughout the length of the stairs.
The leading edge of each tread shall have a non-slip skid-resistant
material to prevent slips and falls and the leading edges shall be visually
distinctive (e.g. yellow) from the colour of the rest of the tread to create a
contrast between the stair treads and/or the walking surface below.
(SCAN)
3.11.10 Handrails A clearance of 75 mm shall be provided for the user's hand between the
outside edge of the handrail and the surface on the closed side.
Reason: usual practice is 50 mm, but additional space is required for
hands in winter gloves.
A single-tier stair rail for maintaining balance while going up or down the
stairs shall be installed on the enclosed side(s) of stairs.
Reason: provide a grip along the wall side of the stairs.
Page 29 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.11 Ladder Orientation Ladders shall be installed in the vertical. In no case shall a ladder be
installed with a forward pitch.
3.11.12 Ladder Reach A vertical ladder used by workers to reach an object while standing on
the ladder shall be located so the object is no more than 800 mm from
the centreline of the ladder and is at least 900 mm below the top rung.
(ISO 13705; 15.5)
Tasks performed at this maximum distance shall only involve simple
adjustments or such tasks as can be performed with light tools and one
(1) hand while the other maintains a grip on the ladder.
Ladders, used by workers to access a work area to perform tasks that
require the use of two (2) hands, shall be provided with a work platform
(to allow the use of both hands and provide a stable standing surface).
(SCAN)
3.11.13 Ladder Dimensions & Ladders shall be 500 mm in width, with ladder rungs spaced on 300 mm
Clearance centres.
A minimum horizontal clearance of 200 mm shall be provided from the
outside edge of each stringer to the nearest obstruction on both sides of
the ladder.
SCAN - Reason: room to either side to prevent banging against objects
& snagging of clothing or tools
3.11.14 Ladder Rungs The top rung on all vertical ladders shall be top flush with the walking
surface or platform.
Ladder rungs shall be square bar and rotated 45 degrees to provide a
sharp edge at the top and alleviate ice build up.
SCAN - Reason: lessons learned - safety, reduces ice accumulation;
provides better grip for mud/snow/caked boot-insteps; provides boot
scrape
3.11.15 Step-through Ladders Step-through ladders, where approved, shall have the side rails carried
to a support point at the top landing. Grab rails, with a diameter of 22
mm, shall be attached to the handrail post on either side of the access,
and shall project 300 mm from the handrail post as a continuation of the
ladder side rail. A 600-mm clearance shall be provided between the
grab bars.
(ESTG 13-1.02 3.6.3k)
3.11.16 Gate Safety gates shall be installed at the top entrance to all ladders.
(ESTG 13-1.02 3.6.3)
Page 30 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Safety gates shall be self-closing double bar type and cover the full width
of the opening between the ladder stringers. The safety gate shall be
installed at a height 920 mm above the landing/walking surface.
(Alberta OH&S Code 130-4)
(SCAN)
3.11.17 Landings Where it is not practical to install landing platforms or install ladder
cages, a certified fall arresting device shall be provided.
3.11.18 Platforms & Decks Platforms shall typically be provided where items are not accessible from
the surrounding facilities. Examples of locations requiring platforms shall
include, but not be limited to, the following:
• Access to equipment inspection or service opening, such as
manholes;
• Access to equipment which requires inspection, adjustment or
servicing during operations, such as control valves and level
controls; and
• Access to valves on towers or equipment elevated above grade.
Any elevated work area where tasks require the use of both hands shall
be provided with a work platform to give workers a stable standing
surface without requiring them to stand on stair treads or ladder rungs
while performing work.
Note: Valve hand wheels greater than 125 mm are considered to be a
two-handed operation; DEP 30.00.60.13-SCAN 1.2.1
(SCAN)
3.11.19 Platform Clearance For clearance on walkways on elevated work platforms between guard-
rail and any object (including insulation), Shell in North America has
adopted 1000 mm to allow for winter clothing, PPE and breathing
apparatus.
Page 31 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.21 Platform live-loads The calculation of live loads for platforms should consider:
• the placement of tools, spare parts, and/or equipment on the
platform preparatory to, and during the work,
• the lay down of heavy and/or large vessel internals and machine
parts during maintenance activities, and
• temporary storage of catalyst, desiccants etc. prior to loading
vessels as needed.
(ESTG 13-1.01 3.2)
3.11.22 Guardrails Guardrails shall be installed along all the edges of open sided decks,
floors, walkways, platforms, runways, and balconies at all locations 910
mm or greater above grade.
(ESTG 13-1.02 3.7.2)
Walkways and platforms not provided with guardrails (less than 910 mm)
shall have a guard at least as wide as the walkway at any sharp change
of direction (L or T-shaped).
(SCAN)
Floor or deck openings 300 x 300 mm or greater which are left exposed
and unattended require guard railings or barriers.
(SCAN)
3.11.23 Toe-plate & Pipes As an alternative to steel toe-plates around piping that penetrates a
platform, flush-fitting flexible toe plates can be used to minimize the
opportunity for dropping objects to a lower level.
Page 32 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.24 Manway Clearance Around manways, a minimum of 760 mm on each side of the manway
and a minimum of 1220 mm out in front of the manway shall be provided
clear of obstruction to allow for entry and exit.
3.11.25 Manway Size Manways shall be sized and located to accommodate the safe and
efficient removal of vessel internals where the removal of those internals
is a regular part of inspection.
(SCAN)
Manways for vessels up to 1220 mm in diameter shall be a minimum
diameter of 510 mm.
Manways for vessels larger than 1220 mm in diameter shall be a
minimum diameter of 610 mm, with 760 mm being preferred.
SCAN - Reason: larger diameter is required for entry with winter
clothing, PPE and RPE requirements. Under new OH&S Code
requirements being adopted in North American sites and operations,
entries require a documented rescue plan and fully equipped rescue
personnel must be able to quickly respond, enter and extract a worker.
For top manways in horizontal vessels, in sour or toxic services (where a
portable ladder is inserted through a manway is necessary for entry), the
access manway shall have 710 mm minimum inside diameter.
(ESTG 8-1.04 3.10.1)
For vessels 915 mm or less in diameter that require manways,
consideration should be given to providing a top- or end-break flange
instead of a nozzle-type manway. A dished head or blind flange shall be
used on top of break flange, and marked with the symbol "M" for
manway.
(ESTG 8-1.04 3.10.3)
Page 33 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
3.11.26 Vessel Skirt Manways Manways for vessel skirts up to 1220 mm in diameter shall be a
minimum diameter of 510 mm.
Manways for vessel skirts larger than 1220 mm in diameter shall be a
minimum diameter of 610 mm, with 760 mm being preferred.
SCAN - Reason: larger diameter is required for entry with winter
clothing, PPE and RPE requirements. Under new OH&S Code
requirements being adopted in North American sites and operations,
entries require a documented rescue plan and fully equipped rescue
personnel must be able to quickly respond, enter and extract a worker.
Page 34 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.1.1 Worker Envelope Working space shall be provided wherever an operator or maintainer is
required to work. Using anthropometric data for a Dutch workforce, our
climatic conditions and required personal protective equipment (e.g. hard-
hat, Self-contained Breathing Apparatus) this space shall be:
• a minimum of 1000 mm x 1000 mm with a minimum head clearance
of 2300 mm for a walking or standing working position, and
• at least 1300 mm deep with a minimum head clearance of 1700 mm
for kneeling or squatting positions.
1700
2300
1300
1300
1000
1000
4.1.2 Access & Clearance Operators shall have access to equipment and skid-mounted equipment
(vendor packages) from all sides.
DEP 30.00.60.18.GEN
Page 35 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Access to the column via a manhole in the top column shell ring is
preferred.
The internals Supplier shall verify that the manholes and top flange or top
dome necessary for the installation of the column internals will be provided
on the column.
All parts should have durable markings, in paint or ink, relating to the
erection plan from which the internals can be unmistakably identified
Page 36 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
The column manufacturer shall ensure that a man can pass through the
man-ways of the fractionating trays as installed.
Where this is impossible for construction reasons, the use of smaller man-
ways shall be subject to the approval of the Principal. The man-way shall
not be smaller than 270 mm x 450 mm.
If the clearance between the tray deck and the bottom of the main
supporting beams of the tray above is less than 400 mm, tray man-ways
shall be installed on each side of the beams.
For HiFi trays, the Manufacturer shall ensure suitable access to the tray
below on both sides of the beam.
For the sake of flexibility, bolting and unbolting of tray man-ways should be
possible from both sides of the tray. If access from one side is impossible,
e.g., in case of small-diameter Hifi trays, this requirement may be relaxed if
approved by the Principal.
Exposed edges of trays at locations where people may have access shall
be bevelled or rounded off, e.g., at man-ways and top edges of weirs.
Page 37 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
All parts should have durable markings, by means of paint or ink, and by
means of stamping relating to the erection plan from which the internals
can be unmistakably identified.
The support beams of the tray above shall be located so as to allow ready
access via the man-ways to all parts of the draw-off tray, liquid collector or
gravity distributor. If appropriate, e.g., in the case of a draw-off tray close
below a packed bed, the tray should be removable from below.
Only in the case of single-deck draw-off trays may access be provided
through a removable section of the riser cap. Minimum width of such a
removable section shall be 270 mm.
Page 38 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
All parts should have durable markings, by means of paint or ink and by
means of stamping, relating to the erection plan from which the internals
can be unmistakably identified.
All parts should have durable markings, by means of paint or ink, and by
stamping relating to the erection plan from which the internals can be
unmistakably identified.
Page 39 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.3.2 Manholes & Manholes shall have a minimum clear inside diameter of 460 mm;
Inspection Openings however, nominal pipe sizes DN 500 (20"), DN 600 (24") and DN 750
(30") are preferred.
Davits shall be provided for all openings DN 300 (12") nominal up to and
including DN 750 (30"). Typical details are shown in Standard Drawing S
10.070, except for vessels in low temperature
service, for which the covers shall be hinged.
Hand hole covers shall be provided with a grip, see Standard Drawings S
10.039, S 10.053 and S 10.054.
The manholes shall be located so that the plate pack internals can easily
be installed, and are accessible from both sides.
DEP 31.22.05.12: 3.2.2
4.4.2 Vane Packs - The vessel shall provide sufficient access for inspection, cleaning,
Mounting maintenance and the removal and installation of the vane pack and other
internals.
In the case of a vertical vessel, the vessel can be provided with a full top
flange or with manholes. A full top flange allows for the installation of
internals as a prefabricated box; this is preferred for vessel diameters
below 1.2 m.
Page 40 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.5.1 Platforms Where practical, all safety valves shall be accessible from platforms for
servicing and inspection.
DEP 31.38.01.11 4.6
Relief devices require periodic inspection and maintenance and hence
they should be easily accessible.
DEP 80.45.10.10: 2.8.1
4.5.2 O & M Tasks & Flare sumps must be serviceable without a total shutdown.
Considerations
Critical Equipment to have sufficient relief valves to prevent shutdown if
one fails (ability to repair on the run)
Design / lay out to ensure that no liquid backpressure or stagnant liquid on
the downstream can occur.
Flawless Operability & Maintainability
Page 41 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.6.1 Access A derrick structure shall be supplied with the following access equipment:
a) a stairway from grade to the riser removal/replacement platform;
b) a ladder from the riser removal/replacement platform to the top
platform;
c) step-off platforms at intervals of 9 m (30 ft) to the top platform at
the flare tip;
d) platforms with ladder access for all manways and handholes;
e) ladders from the riser removal/replacement platform to all eyes
attached to the derrick structure that are used to raise, lower and
tilt the riser sections.
DEP 80.45.10.10: 6.2
4.6.2 Riser Platform Riser removal/replacement platforms may comprise more than one level
and shall be of a retractable type.
4.6.3 Heat shields A proper heat shield at the first platform and temporary shelters at grade
shall be provided within the sterile area to protect personnel.
Page 42 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.7.1 Structure Design of support structures providing access to air coolers shall follow
Section 3 Structural Design Requirements of this document.
4.7.2 Tube Bundle Design The width of the tube bundle shall be chosen with due regard to
transport and handling aspects, and unless otherwise specified shall not
exceed 3 metres.
DEP 31.21.70.31: 7.1.1.1
4.7.3 Air-Side Design For two fans per bay, the height of the underside of the fan inlet bell (on
forced draft units) or of the underside of the bundle (on induced draft
units) shall be at least 2 m or one fan diameter (whichever is the
greater) above the ground level, elevated floor or pipe bridge.
For three or more fans per bay, the height of the underside of the bundle
shall be agreed with the Principal.
4.7.4 Heat Shielding If the air outlet temperature at design conditions exceeds 90 °C,
personnel heat protection shielding shall be installed along the side
platforms of forced-draught heat exchangers.
Page 43 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.8.2 Water Level Water level shall be easily visible from the operating platform by means
of either a drum gauge image transmission system or a remote level
indicator.
DEP 30.75.10.30: 2.5.2
4.8.3 Drums Drum internals shall be accessible and cleanable and they shall be
removable through manholes. Elliptical or circular manholes may be
used.
DEP 30.75.10.30: 2.2.7
4.8.4 Observation Air-cooled observation windows shall be provided and shall afford an
unrestricted view of all burners, tips, throats and flames. The windows
shall be at least 250 mm by 100 mm (10 x 4 in) and shall also allow
observation of all surfaces on the back and side walls and the screen or
super-heater gas inlet on which flames can impinge: the line of sight
shall be parallel to these surfaces.
Observation windows shall be installed at each side of the boiler front to
allow viewing along the side walls.
Air purging shall be provided to keep observation windows sealed, clean
and cool. The glasses shall have external covers to prevent cracking by
rain ingress and shall be protected on the hot side by a pivoting metal
plate (protection flapper).
It shall be possible to renew the glasses during operation.
4.8.5 Access There shall be a sufficient number of access and inspection doors and
access space for each section or tube bank of the boiler.
Page 44 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.8.6 Dampers Dampers shall be easily accessible for manual operation and shall have
a position indicator, clearly visible from ground level.
4.8.7 Steel structure Further to the requirements of the specifications contained in DEPs
34.00.01.30, 34.28.00.31 and Standard Drawing S 28.006, stairs and
platforms shall provide easy access to all valves, gauges, instrument
fittings, observation points and access doors, and for all other
operational purposes.
Page 45 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
for oil firing further inspection lanes correspond with soot-blower lanes
(see ISO 13705 Clause 14.2.4).
DEP 31.24.00.30: 6.3.4
4.9.2 Access Door – Box Two access doors having a minimum clear opening of 600 x 600 mm
Cabin Heater (24 x 24 in.) shall be provided for each radiant chamber of a box or
cabin heater.
ISO 13705:2006: 12.3.2.1
4.9.3 Access Door – Box One access door having a minimum clear opening of 450 x 450 mm (18
Vertical Cylindrical x 18 in.) shall be provided in the floor for vertical cylindrical heaters. A
Heater bolted and gasketed access door shall also be provided in any air
plenum below the floor accessway. Where space is not available,
access via a burner port is acceptable.
4.9.4 Access Door – Damper One access door having a minimum clear opening of 600 x 600 mm (24
& Convection x 24 in.), or 600 mm (24 in.) in diameter, shall be provided in the stack
or breeching for access to the damper and
convection sections.
ISO 13705:2006: 12.3.2.3
Page 46 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.9.5 Access Door – Vertical One tube-removal door having a minimum clear opening of 450 x 600
Tube Heaters mm (18 x 24 in.) shall be provided in the arch of each radiant chamber
of vertical tube heaters.
ISO 13705:2006: 12.3.2.4
4.9.6 Observation Ports Observation doors shall be installed in the heater walls to provide a
clear view of the burner(s), flame(s) and flame-exposed tube surfaces in
the radiant sections.
Particular attention shall be given to the arrangement and positioning of
peepholes for burner viewing to ensure that there is an unobstructed
view of each burner throat and flame zone up to 1 m outside the burner
throat.
Due account shall be taken of the radiant coil layout to prevent tubes
from obstructing the view of the burners.
All observation windows in forced draught heaters shall be provided with
a glass cover, protection flapper and purge air connection. Horizontal
observation windows shall be provided with rain protection.
Observation windows and ports in forced draught heaters shall be in line
with Standard Drawings S 24.101, S 24.102, S 24.108 or S 24.109.
Each forced draught vertical radiant cell shall have at least one circular
200-mm peephole in the roof, providing a clear view to all burner
throats.
For automatically started systems, the ignition flame shall be visible via
either the burner peep hole or the main burner observation window.
Access doors shall have a minimum clear opening of 600 x 600 mm.
4.9.7 Removable Wall If the return bends of convection section tubes are located in the flue
gas path, one end wall shall be removable to enable removal of the tube
bundle for maintenance purposes. The opposite end wall may also
contain removable panels to provide access for field welds.
Page 47 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
a) at burner and burner controls that are not accessible from grade;
4.9.9 Circular Platform All vertical cylindrical heaters shall have a full circular platform at the
floor level.
DEP 31.24.00.30 12.4.2
4.9.10 Platform Clearance Platforms shall have a minimum clear width as follows:
Walkways 0.8 m
4.9.11 Dual Access Dual access shall be provided to each operating platform, except if the
individual platform length is less than 6 m (20 ft).
4.9.12 Stairways Stairways shall be provided for platforms where operators require
access at least once per shift or under emergency conditions. Burner
platforms and soot blower platforms shall always be accessible by
stairways. Stairways giving access to various levels shall be combined
in a flight of stairs.
DEP 31.24.00.30 12.4.5
4.9.13 Landing An intermediate landing shall be provided if the vertical rise exceeds 9
m (30 ft) for ladders and 4,5 m (15 ft) for stairways.
4.9.14 Ladders Ladders should conform to the requirements of ISO 13705:2006: 12.4.7
and Sections 3.3 & 3.5 of this document.
Page 48 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Ladders shall be made so as to provide a side step at the top. The hand
railing shall extend at least one metre above the top platform.
4.9.15 Railing Railings shall be mounted on the top of the radiant section and the top
of a side mounted convection section where access is necessary and
platforms are not required.
4.9.16 Burner Piping Burner piping shall be arranged to minimize obstruction to access.
Below the heater, the piping shall be arranged so that the operator has
a clear unobstructed route of emergency escape from below the heater
over 270°.
4.9.17 Damper Controls A manually operated flue gas damper shall be operated from grade or
the firing platform.
DEP 31.24.00.30: 14.4.8
Unless the damper is open to view and close to grade a direct shaft
connected position indicator visible from grade shall be provided.
The actuating mechanism and the linkage and damper bearings shall be
accessible for servicing. The actuator should normally be located close
to the damper shaft and be accessible from grade or a platform.
4.9.18 Combustion Ducts & The air ducts shall be provided with inspection panels near the dampers
Plenums to allow for damper blade inspection and maintenance.
Page 49 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.9.19 O & M Tasks & View ports correctly orientated, easy/safe to clean/replace and provide
Considerations adequate view of fires and furnace internals.
Ability to air blow/clean fuel gas systems/lines when flow is restricted
due to fouling.
Ensure design has considered sufficient turn down for refractory dry-out.
Flame-eyes preferably in a 2 out of 2 set-up.
Ensure that flame eyes are functional at maximum turndown
Permanently installed pilot and initiator design should be verified by
plant technologists and operations on operability: (easy to ignite, easy to
visually confirm functioning and reliability).
Air/fuel ratio control system must be reliable and a proven technology.
Correct position and reliability of skin temperature thermocouples should
be verified by operations.
Automated starting is preferred to ensure proper purging and ignition.
Flawless Operability & Maintenance
4.10.1 Access Adequate space based on the minimum worker envelope for standing,
kneeling or squatting positions shall be provided around pump and
compressor seals, couplings, bearings and stuffing boxes for removal and
replacement activities as appropriate.
Maintenance decks shall be considered for all large pumps.
Pumps, compressors and turbines shall, when practical, be located on the
outside periphery of a module or skid for ease of access for maintenance
purposes.
DEP 30.00.60.18
4.10.2 Piping Auxiliary piping shall be neatly routed along the base-plate and shall not
extend across the operating floor. This piping shall not obstruct inspection
covers, bearing caps, upper halves of casings or any other items which
require access for operations or maintenance.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 4.2.1
Arrange the piping around compressors to allow free clearance completely
around each machine and to permit removal and access of critical machine
parts.
DEP 31.38.01.11
4.10.3 Valves Valves in the piping shall be arranged in a logical sequence for
convenience in start-up, shutdown and operating modes.
DEP 31.38.01.11
Page 50 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.10.4 Utility Station Utility stations shall be located in close proximity to compressors. Ensure
platform access and access to bottom suction and discharge lines where
applicable.
4.10.5 Pumps Piping shall be arranged around pumps to allow sufficient clearance
completely around each pump and to permit the removal of the entire
pump.
DEP 31.38.01.11
Start/stop switch shall be located at the motor end of pump such that
discharge pressure gauge is visible to the operator when starting up the
pump.
Reason: efficiency of operation
4.11 CENTRIFUGAL
PUMPS
4.11.1 Auxiliary Piping Heat Insulation or guarding shall be provided as an integral part of the auxiliary
Protection piping system to provide personnel protection if the non-insulated metal
temperature exceeds 70 °C (160 °F) and the auxiliary piping system is in
an area where it can be touched during normal operation and maintenance
activities.
4.11.2 Mounting of All auxiliary equipment such as instrumentation, seal support components,
Auxiliaries lube-sets, etc. shall be mounted in a manner that does not interfere with
normal maintenance or operator surveillance activities.
4.11.3 Flange Alignment Threaded connections shall be limited to the final connections at the gland
plate. The last flanged connection before the gland plate shall be made
with a lap joint or clamped joint (e.g. Graylock) flange at the gland plate
side in order to facilitate proper flange alignment after maintenance.
Beyond these limits, a clamped joint shall be used.
4.11.4 O & M Tasks & Correct size for temporary suction filters if they are required.
Considerations for
Rotational lock-outs clearly visible and securely lockable in the Open and
Pumps &
Closed positions.
Compressors
Protect trip and shutdown transmitters from weather conditions; (i.e. hot,
cold, wet, sand).
Design must include the ability to check with 100% certainty that “hot”
service pumps and vacuum pumps are water-free.
Priming and venting requirements should be confirmed with operations.
Flawless Operability & Maintenance
Page 51 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.12 COMPRESSORS
4.12.1 Layout In deciding upon the location of a compressor, consideration shall be given
to maintenance and process operations.
The overall layout of a compressor installation shall allow safe access to all
operating positions and to overhead lifting equipment if provided. There
shall be no unguarded floor openings around machines.
If two or more compressors are located on the same floor, provision shall
be made for a clear floor area that is adequate for the simultaneous
overhaul of all compressors, their drivers and associated auxiliary
equipment. The permissible floor loading shall be able to withstand the
maximum cumulative weight that arises during maintenance.
The layout of auxiliary equipment and the provision of permanent steps and
platforms and of adequate clear floor space shall permit easy and safe
access to all components for operation and maintenance.
4.12.2 Air Compressor Satisfactory access shall be provided by means of doors in the filter
Intake Filters – housing and ducting and no undue hazard shall be created.
Design & Access
DEP 31.29.40.10; 5.3.1
Page 52 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.13.1 Noise Control The Contractor shall comply with DEP 31.10.00.31-Gen., Noise Control,
and thereby communicate to the Vendor the specified equipment noise
limitations by using data sheet DEP 31.10.00.94-Gen., which forms part of
the requisition.
The Vendor shall submit guaranteed sound power levels and sound
pressure levels (including octave band spectrum) of the equipment,
together with any other relevant information as requested on the data
sheet, DEP 31.10.00.94-Gen.
The Vendor shall indicate what special silencing measures, if any, are
proposed in order to meet the specified levels.
4.13.2 Bolting Access Clearance shall be provided at bolting locations to permit the use of socket
or box wrenches.
4.14 LUBRICATION
4.14.1 O & M Tasks and Consider use of head tanks to allow for bulk loading of lube-oil.
Considerations
Flawless Operability & Maintainability
4.15.1 Outdoor Operation As a minimum the systems shall be suitable for unsheltered outdoor
operation. The anticipated weather and environmental conditions shall be
indicated by the Principal on the data/requisition sheets, and so shall the
need for any special precautions (e.g. "winterizing").
Page 53 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.15.2 Accessibility Oil systems shall conform to the data sheet and shall include the following
features:
4.15.3 Filter Access The access area for filter maintenance shall be a minimum of 600 mm x
600 mm (2 ft x 2 ft).
4.15.4 Transfer Valves In systems with a pressure rating of ASME rating class 900 and higher,
spectacle blinds shall be used for tight shut-off purposes to facilitate
maintenance.
4.15.5 Instruments Pump discharge pressure indicator shall be visible to the operator while
starting pumps.
4.15.6 Self-acting Gas Seal As far as possible, the layout should be such that the functions of control
valves and changeover valves for spared items are clearly evident and the
valves themselves are easily accessible.
The location and arrangement of the DGS module or modules shall not
cause obstruction to normal operation and maintenance of the
compressor. Maintenance, particularly of the compressor bearings and
seals, shall be possible with a minimum of disconnections.
Page 54 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.16.2 Top Loading Gantry Gantry platforms should allow a free passage at least 0.75 m wide over
– Working Platform their entire length to enable operators to move freely, regardless of
whether the loading arms are in use or stowed. Equipment should be
positioned to cause minimum interference; it should not expose the
operator to the risk of physical contact with equipment, nor prevent him
from crossing the platform at each loading arm position.
4.16.3 Top Loading Gantry Each working platform should be provided with two balanced and hinged
– Access Ramp access ramps on either side, to enable personnel to walk easily and safely
to and from the tops of road vehicles (see Figure 8.17 of the DEP for an
example of a hinged access ramp).
The ramp should be easily adjustable by one man to cater for vehicles of
various heights, and any treads fitted should be of the self-levelling type.
A long (6 m) hinged grid side panel, (see Figure 8.18 of the DEP), offers
operational convenience, but as it is narrower its use should be restricted
to gantries where vehicle sizes/heights are fairly uniform.
DEP 31.06.11.11: 8.3.2.2
Page 55 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.16.4 Top Loading Gantry - The working platform, all stairways, hinged ramps etc., should be fitted
Guard Rails with guard rails on all open sides; handrails (see Figure 8.19 of DEP)
should be constructed opposite the ramp at each bay to provide protection
for personnel standing on top of the vehicle tanks. Unless conditions
dictate otherwise, the height of the guardrails should be 1 m.
4.16.5 Visibility & Access Meter heads or meter pre-set readings should be clearly visible and
readable from the product loading control points.
4.16.6 Other Requirements Bays and loading islands should be clearly numbered to enable vehicles to
be directed to filling points.
Product grade plates should be provided at the entry side of the gantry to
clearly indicate product availability at the bay concerned.
The construction of barriers at the exit of loading bays (when used) should
be such that they can be driven through in an emergency (e.g. barrier
bends or snaps off).
DEP 31.06.11.11: 8.3.6
4.17 ADDITIONAL
REQUIREMENTS
4.17.1 Worker Envelope Equipment parts, instrumentation, instrument stands, pipe supports, valve
hand-wheels, piping etc. shall not protrude into worker envelopes.
4.17.2 Reach Limitations Maximum effective forward reach (i.e. allowing the ability to grasp, turn,
push/pull) shall be 610 mm directly in front of the operator's body.
Jobs requiring the operator to lift more than 3 kg or produce torque (e.g.
turning a wrench) shall be kept within 300 mm of the operator's body.
For light tasks (e.g. turning a small valve or applying minimal torque to a
nut), maximum extended reach of the worker shall be no more than 1800
mm above the standing surface.
(SCAN)
4.17.3 Hand Openings The nominal minimum diameter for inspection openings (hand holes) is
255 mm.
(ESTG 8-1.04 3.10.1)
Page 56 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.17.4 Platforms Work platforms shall be located and sized to allow the workers to perform
tasks:
• in whatever posture is necessary to accomplish the tasks,
• without having to assume an awkward or unsafe body posture,
• without having to extend tools beyond the platform railings, and
• without having to manipulate equipment, tools and internals beyond
the guard/handrail.
SCAN - Reason: lessons learned and incidents with falling objects
4.17.5 Standing Surface At no time, shall an operator or maintainer be required to stand on any
surface not specifically designed to be used as a standing surface. Work
platforms may be used to meet this requirement.
SCAN - Reason: safety, experience, lessons learned.
4.17.6 Priority of Access Items most critical to system operation and which require rapid
maintenance shall be most accessible.
When relative criticality is not a factor, items requiring most frequent
access shall be most accessible.
High-failure rate items shall be accessible for replacement without moving
non-failed items.
Access to items maintained by one trade or craft should not require
removal of critical equipment maintained by another trade or craft,
particularly where highly specialized skills are involved.
Page 57 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
4.17.8 Relief Valve Location Where safety valves have an associated isolation valve in close proximity,
these isolation and relief valves shall be grouped together on a common
platform accessible by stairs for inspection and servicing.
SCAN - Reason: RV isolation valves are Category 1 and therefore need
access by stairs. Safety and ease of access during emergency situations
(stairs to common deck versus several ladders to top of columns).
Minimizes crane needs for RV removal
4.17.9 Air Coolers (Fin Header box level walkways shall be provided for all air-cooled heat
Fans) exchangers.
(ESTG 7-1.21 3.10.1)
Where work is performed (e.g. tube header boxes) the width of the header
walkway shall be at least 1500 mm. Where work is not performed and the
walkway is used only as an access route, the width shall be at least 1000
mm. (See Walkway Width).
(SCAN)
4.17.10 Air Cooler Platforms Pipe-rack-mounted exchangers shall have drive assembly access
platforms. Multiple bay exchanger banks mounted on a pipe rack shall
have walkways that connect the drive assembly access platforms in each
bay. Platforms and walkways shall be at the same elevation.
(GS Addendum 7.3.5.3 & 7.3.5.12)
Page 58 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Stairways shall be used for primary access to main operating levels and
main services levels.
(GS Addendum 7.3.5.14)
For forced draft coolers, the minimum clearance between the fan inlet bell
and access platform shall be 2250 mm. For induced draft coolers, the
minimum clearance between the tube bundle frame and access platform
shall be 2700 mm.
(GS Addendum 7.3.5.19)
Fan guards for forced draft units shall have one hinged section to provide
maintenance access.
(GS Addendum 7.3.5.11)
4.17.11 Heat Exchangers Adequate space shall be provided for heat exchanger tube bundle pulling
activities and for walkway/lay down area accessibility.
Pull spaces provided for maintenance or repair (e.g. areas needed for the
pulling of tube bundles from heat exchangers or condensers) shall be kept
clear of all piping, cable trays, panels, and any other obstructions.
Guardrails restricting pull spaces shall be removable.
In addition, the pull space shall provide room for the personnel performing
the tasks, tools required, lifting or support equipment, and transport
devices (if used) to move the item from the area.
Page 59 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 60 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
5.0 INSTRUMENTATION
5.1.3 Field-mounted Nameplates All plant-mounted instruments, e.g. inline instruments, transmitters,
local indicators, converters, control valves, limit switches, solenoid
valves etc., and junction boxes shall be provided with nameplates.
The nameplate shall be properly secured, for instance to the
instrument support and the colour shall be as specified by the
Principal.
DEP 32.31.00.32: 2.7.2
5.1.4 SIL1 IPF Initiators IPF initiators of SIL 1 and higher shall have a red nameplate with
white lettering.
DEP 32.31.00.32: 2.7.2
5.1.6 Nameplates for Indoor Use All panel-mounted instruments shall be provided with nameplates in
accordance with the Manufacturer's standard.
Page 61 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
5.1.7 Labels inside Instrument Labels and marking methods used inside instrumentation cabinets
Cabinets shall be to Manufacturers' standards provided they are secure and
permanent.
5.2.1 Finish IPF trip initiators of SIL 1 and higher should have a red colour and
the finish of plant-mounted instruments in oxygen service should be
yellow. The finish of all other plant-mounted instruments may be in
the Manufacturer's standard colour (but not red or yellow).DEP
32.31.00.32: 3.1
5.2.2 Lamp Test Facilities All indication lamps shall be provided with test facilities in the vicinity
of the lamp, so that one man can execute the test. The test logic
should be located in the DCS or IPS.
DEP 32.31.00.32: 2.10
5.2.3 Integral and Receiving Where a local indicator is required to support operating personnel,
Indicators the physical location of the indicator should be selected so that it
can be read from the intended operator position. If this requirement
cannot be met by an integral indicator, a receiving indicator shall be
applied.
5.2.4 Diaphragm Seals Particular care shall be taken while handling diaphragm seals.
Diaphragm seal transmitters are heavy and shall be properly
supported.
5.3.1 On-line Instruments On-line instruments are to be mounted on or in the direct vicinity of
the instrument process connection(s).
DEP 32.31.00.32: 3.7
Page 62 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
5.3.3 Rodding-out Instruments and their impulse lines shall be surrounded by sufficient
free space to allow rodding-out of process connections and the
removal of:
5.3.5 Model Reviews In the event of a model check, special attention shall be given to:
Page 63 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
5.3.6 Hoisting Requiremements Heavy equipment such as control valves and inline flow meters of
DN 100 and larger and all positive displacement meters and turbine
meters should be accessible by mobile hoisting equipment. Where
this is not possible, permanent hoisting facilities shall be considered.
5.3.7 Toxic Service Consideration shall be given to any special requirements for the safe
handling of toxic substances, as dictated by the relevant piping
class.
5.3.8 Mounting Height Whenever possible, instruments shall be mounted at eye level (circa
1600 mm), but in any case not lower than 750 mm from the base.
Max. 1600 mm
Min. 750 mm
unacceptable
5.4.1 Relief Valve Location Relief valve systems require periodic inspection and maintenance
and hence they should be easily accessible.
DEP 80.45.10.10: 2.2.1
5.4.2 Level Gauges If the visible level range in a gauge is continued in a second
(staggered) level gauge, or the level is used to check another level
instrument, both levels shall be readable from the same location.
To ensure clear visual access for the operator, level gauges shall
not be placed behind pipes or other obstacles. The level gauge
shall be positioned so that it can be read from ground level, platform
or ladder.
If a light is needed to read the level gauge, the level gauge shall be
less than 1000 mm away from where the operator is standing. If this
is not possible, an illuminator shall be installed behind the level
gauge.
DEP 31.38.01.11 4.7.3.1
Page 64 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
5.4.3 Positive Displacement Positive displacement meters and their ancillary equipment such as
Meters filters and vapour eliminators shall be installed so that they can
easily be reached by hoisting equipment.
DEP 32.31.00.32: 4.10
5.4.4 Displacer Level All displacer instruments shall be specified with left-hand or right-
Instruments hand mounting of the instrument with respect to the mechanism
chamber, depending on the relative position of process equipment
and displacer chamber and operator access from platforms, etc.
DEP 32.31.00.32: 5.4
5.4.5 Pressure Gauges If local pressure indication is regularly needed to support field
operator actions, a pressure gauge or receiving pressure indicator is
needed.
5.4.6 Hydrogen Fluoride Service All instruments shall be located at an elevation of maximum 1 metre
above the working floor for safe and easy handling during operation
and maintenance.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 10.4.1
5.4.7 O & M Tasks & For vacuum towers, sufficient rods for rodding-out plugged level
Considerations instrumentation shall be available.
Purge gas on level instrumentation to be maintainable at required
flow levels.
Flawless Operability & Maintainability
5.5.1 Grade access All monitored instruments required on elevated piping or non-
accessible vessel components shall be tubed to grade level or
alternatively located on access platforms.
All instruments and transmitters that require regular (nominally
monthly) testing or calibration or other access shall be located either
at grade level or have permanent access platforms.
(SCAN)
Page 65 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
5.5.2 Instrument Location All instruments shall be located and oriented in such a way that:
• operators and maintainers have safe and convenient access,
• they do not obstruct access to equipment for maintenance or
ongoing operating requirements, and
• it is possible to conduct in-place calibration and in-place
withdrawal of parts for maintenance.
Magnetic level gauges, gauge glasses and level transmitters shall
be readable from grade, platforms, or permanent ladders.
(SCAN ESTG 16-3.11)
5.5.3 Insulation Enclosures Gauges and displays associated with frequently monitored systems
shall be located outside acoustic enclosures wherever possible.
Wherever feasible, instrumentation enclosures shall be mounted
outside the guardrail of a platform as close as possible to the edge
of the platform to keep the walkway clear of obstructions but keep
the instrumentation within easy reach.
SCAN - Reason: lessons learned, when mounted inside the rail
enclosures obstruct walkway, access & egress
Page 66 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.0 PIPING
6.1 CLEARANCE
6.1.1 General Piping shall be routed so that the optimum piping layout is achieved in
terms of process requirements, ergonomics, operation, inspection and
maintenance.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 3.1
Piping with instrument connections shall be routed so that safe access to
these connections is ensured; if necessary, platforms or walkways shall be
provided (see DEP 32.31.00.32-Gen).
The distance between piping shall allow for the turning of any spectacle
blind, if present.
DEP 31.38.01.11 3.8
Page 67 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.1.2 Flange Clearance The minimum distance in a pipe-rack between a flange and a pipe, or its
insulation where applicable, and between a flange and another flange shall
be 75 mm to allow access for tools.
Reason: Learning from incidents: 30 mm is inadequate clearance for tools
to work flanges at battery limits
Derogation from DEP 31.38.01.11: 3.8
The flanges shall be lined up so that the bolts can be inserted without
force.
DEP 31.38.01.11: Appendix 12(2)
Page 68 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Drain entry into drain openings should be visible and at a safe distance
from the valve used to control the drain, taking into account the medium.
6.3.2 Hoisting A relatively large force is required to turn a large spectacle blind. A
spectacle blind cannot easily be turned using a crane or a hoisting device,
and therefore the need for cranes and hoisting facilities shall be avoided.
Page 69 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.3.3 Blinds - Weight Personnel should not pull or lift loads exceeding 250 N. If the required
force to turn spectacle blinds exceeds 250 N, spades with spacers should
be used instead. Spectacle blinds requiring a force of more than 250 N are
tabulated below.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 8.7.2
6.3.4 Spacers and Spades Spacers and spades exceeding a weight of 250 N should be provided with
- Weight a lifting lug. A mobile crane or, if this is not possible, special hoisting
facilities should be used for handling such items. Spades having a weight
of more than 250 N are tabulated below.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 8.7.2
6.3.5 Removable Spool A removable spool and blind flanges shall be used in the following
and Blind Flange situations:
• where the nozzle is used for entry into the equipment;
• where the nozzle is used for hoisting purposes (e.g. top nozzles on
columns);
• where the nozzle (e.g. the head of a heat exchanger) is used to
remove internals (e.g. the tube bundle);
• where the nozzle is used for loading/unloading of solids (e.g.
catalyst).
Page 70 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.4.2 Auxillary Piping Auxiliary piping shall be neatly routed along the base-plate and shall not
extend across the operating floor. This piping shall not obstruct inspection
covers, bearing caps, upper halves of casings or any other items which
require access for operation or maintenance.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 4.2.1
6.4.3 Strainers In a horizontal suction pipe the Y-type strainer shall be installed pointing
downwards or at an angle of maximum 45° from vertical, in order to
improve access for cleaning.
6.4.4 Heat Exchangers Where stacked heat exchangers are welded nozzle-to-nozzle, this option
eliminates flange leakage but puts restrictions on the maintenance of the
exchangers.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 4.3
6.4.5 Pressure Vessels Where practical, pressure vessels which are grouped together shall have
platforms and interconnecting walkways at the same elevation. The
number of stairways and ladders to the platforms shall be sufficient to meet
safety requirements.
Where practical, pressure vessels grouped together shall have their level
gauges at a common level.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 4.5
6.4.6 Steam Steam traps up to and including DN 40 should be welded and should have
removable internals to allow repair without performing hot work.
Steam traps shall be positioned so that they are easy to maintain and
replace.
Page 71 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.4.7 Tank Farms There shall be access to manholes, mixing nozzles, drains and other
facilities on the tanks.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 6
6.4.8 Jetty Loading/ Positive displacement flow meters, and their filters and de-aerators, shall
Unloading Facilities be accessible for operation and maintenance.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 7.1
6.4.9 Hydrogen Fluoride All valves and instruments shall be located at an elevation of maximum 1
Service metre above the working floor for safe and easy handling during operation
and maintenance.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 10.4.1
6.5.1 Valves When weld-end valves are used (i.e. very toxic service), the maintenance
requirements shall be addressed i.e. top-entry type valves shall permit the
change out of internals such as valve seats, seals, ball etc.
Actuated valves shall have provision for a hand wheel or hand pump on
the actuator. The maximum force required at the hand-wheel or wrench
shall not exceed 360 N.
DEP 31.40.10.13; 2.5.1
6.5.2 End-closures If the opening of the end closure is not in the vertical plane, i.e. on vertical
or sloped pig traps, the end closure shall be equipped with a counterweight
or hydraulic opening system or similar system to facilitate safe and easy
opening of the door. There should be a locking device to hold open the
door while personnel are loading or unloading pigs.
6.5.3 Safety Devices The end closure shall have the following safety devices:
• A safety locking device to prevent opening of the door when the pig
trap is pressurised.
• A pressure safety device that when partially released will alert the
operator to a possible hazard unless pressure in the pig trap is
relieved completely. Removal of the safety locking device shall not be
possible unless the pressure safety device is fully released. Engaging
the pressure safety device shall only be possible when the end
closure is fully closed and the safety locking device is correctly
engaged. The pressure safety device shall be designed so that there
is no risk of blockage. In very toxic service, the pressure safety
device shall be non-venting.
The devices shall be constructed and located so that they cannot readily
be rendered inoperative or replaced. The devices shall be easily
accessible for inspection.
An interlocking system between various valves and the end closure door
operating mechanism may be considered to protect personnel and
equipment, depending on the service, trap location and planned pigging
frequency. The necessity for interlocking shall be decided by the Principal.
Page 72 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.5.4 Pressure Indicators At least one pressure indicator should be clearly visible to the operator
from the end closure activation point. A second pressure indicator should
be installed on the minor barrel close to the pig trap valve. If pig
launching/receiving operations are anticipated during the hours of
darkness, night-time visibility shall also be addressed.
6.5.5 Sphere Common practice is to unload the receiver after several spheres have
Launching/Receiving been received. For spheres with a nominal diameter larger than 450 mm
Pins/Flappers this can be hazardous due to the combined weight of the spheres. In such
cases, consideration should be given to providing a restraint (e.g. flappers
or pins/fingers) to allow the spheres to be unloaded one at a time.
Alternatively, a horizontal receiving tray, long enough for the whole
consignment, should be provided and fixed into position before the end
closure is opened.
6.5.6 Layout Pig traps shall be located so that they are orientated with their end
closures pointing away from personnel areas and critical items of
equipment, i.e. those containing hydrocarbons and/or very toxic
substances or in safety service.
The requirements for pig handling depend on the type and mass of pig and
the pipeline size: normal pigs with a mass less than 30 kg may be
manually loaded into or out of the pig traps; typically, this will be the case
in pipelines of nominal diameter 300 mm and smaller.
Space shall be provided beyond the end closure door of the pig trap for pig
handling. Typical requirements are given in Figure 6 of the DEP and Item
6.5.10 below.
For pig trap systems where a reduced length barrel is installed, sufficient
working space should be provided to allow the extension spool-piece to be
installed and the intelligent pig to be loaded or retrieved.
Page 73 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.5.7 Horizontal Pig Traps The elevation of the bottom of the end closure on horizontal pig traps
should be approximately 700 mm above grade to provide sufficient room to
slope the drain lines and allow easy handling of the end closure and pigs.
Horizontal pig traps with a nominal diameter of 300 mm and larger should
normally be provided with pig lifting facilities, such as a runway beam,
unless they can be readily accessed by cranes. Provision of a trolley with a
push rod and pulling line should be considered to assist loading or removal
of pigs from the trap. In designing the pulling line, a practical and safe
means shall be provided of attaching the hook onto the front of the pig to
retrieve it. The use of these facilities, including the possible use of internal
trays, shall be agreed with the Principal.
6.5.8 Vertical Pig Traps If a vertical pig launcher is inaccessible to the platform crane, a dedicated
lifting facility shall be installed capable of lowering an (intelligent) pig into
the barrel, unless it can be shown that the pig can be manually loaded in a
safe manner.
The elevation of the barrel end closure above deck level should provide
convenient access to the door locking mechanism.
6.5.9 Access Platforms A platform shall be provided adjacent to any valve where the centre of the
hand-wheel is more than 1500 mm above grade.
work
Y
area
Page 74 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.6.1 IVA The location of a valve shall be based on its criticality of function and
frequency of use for both operation and maintenance.
DEP 30.00.60.13 Human Factors Engineering – Valve Analysis defines a
process called Identification of Valves Analysis (IVA), which optimally
locates valves for use while also recognizing design constraints.
The goal is to ensure that those valves most critical to operation and those
accessed most frequently are the ones most readily accessible and easiest
to operate.
For new projects a session should be held with the project team during
front-end design to get concurrence from engineering and operations on
the valve criticality category. This session also provides an opportunity to
adopt heights and weights that may be more applicable to the anticipated
end-user population than those assumed in the development of Table 5.4-
2. Once agreement is reached for a specific project or installation/facility,
the requirements for each valve criticality category will become mandatory.
Deviation from these requirements needs an approved variance.
The following tables are not intended to be all inclusive of all valve types.
Operations and the project HFE coordinator should be consulted on valve
types that are not listed.
Page 75 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Unacceptable
1295 mm
(51 in.)
Preferred
457 mm
(18 in.)
Acceptable
152 mm
(6 in.)
457 mm Grade/deck
(18 in.)
Max. horizontal distance from
obstruction or operator’s front
Unacceptable
1830 mm
(72 in.)
Preferred
610 mm
(24 in.)
Acceptable
230 mm
(9 in.)
Grade/deck
457 mm
(18 in.) Max. horizontal distance from obstruction,
or operator’s front
Page 76 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.6.5 Initial Valve Table 5.4-2 provides a typical criticality assessment for valve-types
Classification Table commonly found in refineries using the three categories defined above..
The assessment is based on type of service, reliability, frequency of
operation or maintenance, criticality to plant operation and the need for
rapid intervention.
The footnotes at the bottom of the table must be referred to.
6.6.6 Deviations It is expected that there will be specific situations where it is not possible or
it is impractical to provide the required accessibility of the assigned
category for some individual valves. In these situations, operations
personnel shall be consulted on a case-by-case basis to approve alternate
arrangements for that particular valve (e.g. change classification, height,
means of access, etc.). Such decisions shall be documented, but no
technical deviation is required.
Page 77 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 78 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
12.13 Utility Station Last Downstream Valve (Steam, Air, Nitrogen, & C-2
Page 79 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 80 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Full specifications of HFE requirements for the selection, location and orientation of
6.7 VALVE SPECIFICS valves are contained in DEP30.00.60.13-GEN (March 2009), Appendix B.
6.7.1 Block Valve and All pipes entering and leaving the process unit shall have a block valve and
Spades flanges provided to allow for spading (spades or spectacle blinds) at the
boundary of the process unit ("battery limit").
The block valves shall be located near each other unless impractical.
6.7.2 Wafer and Lug Pipes with wafer and/or lug type valves may require an extra flanged
Valves connection for installing a spade flange or removal of a pipe spool.
6.7.5 Stems in Horizontal Valves in horizontal pipes shall be positioned with their stem on or above
Pipes the horizontal, except in the exceptions (for safety and corrosion reasons)
specified in the DEP, where it shall be horizontal
6.7.6 Hand-Wheels The location of valves hand-wheels and/or stems shall not obstruct
platforms or walkways.
The minimum distance between valve hand-wheels and any other
obstruction shall be 75 mm.
DEP 31.38.01.11: 3.12.2
object
Hand wheels less than 125 mm diameter should be operable using only
one hand. Hand wheels greater than 125 mm should be operable using
two hands.
Page 81 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.7.7 Control Valves – Globe control valves shall be installed with their diaphragm actuator stem
Dismantling and in the vertical position, with sufficient clearance above the actuator and
Hoisting under the bottom flange to allow the control valve to be dismantled without
removing the valve body from the pipe.
6.8 SAMPLE POINTS ON [This section does not apply to sample points on tanks. For sample points
PIPING on tanks, see Section 7.0.]
6.8.1 Location The sampling point shall be positioned so that the valves are easy to
operate and taking the sample will not impair the safety of personnel or
plant or cause environmental impact.
Samples should be taken from a vertical pipe where possible; where this is
not possible:
• For gaseous products in horizontal pipes, sample take-off
connections shall be installed at the top of the pipe.
6.8.3 O & M Tasks & Characteristics of produced and functionality considered for final selection
Considerations of application
Tightening method should reflect frequency of tightening and loosening
(e.g. Wing-nuts vs nuts & bolts)
Install differential readings where there are considerable HSE risks to
operator.
Access to filters / strainers should provide enough space for positive
isolation, flushing, draining and purging, and the selected method for
removing, cleaning and installing baskets/filters.
Flawless Operability & Maintainability
Page 82 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.9.1 Access & Clearances Piping layout shall not inhibit safe and rapid egress from structures in case
of a leak, fire or other situation requiring personnel to rapidly evacuate an
area.
(SCAN)
50 mm
pipe to
object
500 mm
flange to object
6.9.2 Flange Height Flanges on a vertical pipe or vessel nozzle that penetrates decking shall
have a minimum of 300 mm between the top of the kick plate and the
bottom flange nut surface to allow sufficient space for a wrench and a
hand. The same space requirement applies to a flange on a pipe that
penetrates the ground.
Reason: Learning from incidents; muscular strain, hand and finger injuries.
Page 83 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
kick-plate
6.9.3 Low-point Drains Drains shall be piped open to sewer cups unless otherwise indicated.
Sewer cup shall be an open bell or pipe, minimum diameter 150 mm and
located 75 mm above paving and 150 mm above soil or grade.
6.9.4 Sewer Cups Drain lines which run to open sewers shall terminate approximately 50 mm
inside the top of the sewer inlet cup and shall be visible to a standing
operator.
Reason: History of spills in some Shell facilities.
Page 84 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.9.5 Stand-alone Vessels The hubs for draining stand-alone vessels shall be located at grade in such
a manner that an operator need not step more than 1.5 metre from a drain
valve to the edge of a platform in order to see the drain hub. Drains from
the platform shall be hard piped to an open hub at grade. Multiple drain
connections on a single platform may be piped to a common line.
1.5 m
6.9.6 Multiple Valve Sets Similar to multiple pieces of equipment on a single deck, however, to avoid
on Single Deck possible tripping hazards and congestions on the deck the valve drains
shall not be hard piped to the drain hubs on the deck. Instead, temporary
pipe shall be installed in the field by the maintenance team when needed.
Again, each level in a structure shall have its own drain header and be
piped to its own open drain hub at grade.
[*] [*]
Note 1: Temporary pipe installed by maintenance when needed (not hard-piped in model).
Figure 5.2-C: Drain hub for multiple valve sets on single deck
Page 85 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.9.7 Pump Drains The drain hubs shall be located near the pump in such a way that the drain
piping to these hubs will not create a tripping hazard.
M M M
P P P
6.9.8 Cleaning All drain lines past the last welded root valve, shall have flanged
connection on the downstream side of the root valve or unions installed to
facilitate replacement and cleaning of pipe spools.
(SCAN)
6.9.9 Blinds & Spacer Where blinding is expected to occur on a vessel and there is no
Storage permanently installed spectacle blind, permanent blind storage facilities
shall be provided in close proximity to the flange. Such blinds shall be
stored in a way that does not interfere with safe egress, access to
equipment, or create a trip hazard.
Reason: economy of workflow & effort, removes need for crane &
personnel to move blinds up and down from towers..
6.9.10 Orientation Where assisted lifting will be available, spading points should be installed
in horizontal piping; if this not feasible, special precautions shall be taken
to improve access and handling.
(SCAN)
6.9.11 Installation For spectacle blinds where the blind can be rotated on one of the bolts,
installation in a horizontal section of pipe is preferred.
SCAN - Reason: health & safety, orientation for applying force to handle
6.9.12 Differentiation Handles (tie bar) on spades and blinds shall have different shapes in order
to help visually differentiate between an installed blind and spacer.
SCAN - Reason: safety, especially on start up
6.9.13 Emergency Shut- Emergency shutdown valves shall be accessible from grade and without
down Valves exception shall be located in a clear area. Valve handles or wheels shall
be located as per Category 1 valves.
(SCAN)
6.9.14 Valve Location No valves shall be located directly under a platform grating where it is
necessary to remove the grating to operate the valve.
Platforms servicing valves shall be designed with all valve hand wheels
located within the handrails.
(SCAN)
Page 86 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.9.15 Sample Point Sample points shall be close coupled to the process and if possible from
Location the nature of the process should be located such that they are accessible
from grade level. If impractical, permanent access by stair may be
acceptable.
Sample point cabinets shall be close-coupled to the fast sample loop.
(SCAN)
6.9.16 Accessibility All sample points shall be behind a cover door with a view panel to see
Features samples bottles/bombs being filled. The see-through panel shall be a plexi-
glass type material.
The sampling cabinet shall be labelled and capable of being opened
without requiring any tools or the removal of any securing fasteners or
other devices.
A 25 mm hole at the top of the cabinet door with plug shall be provided to
allow the interior air to be gas tested prior to opening cabinet door. A min.
illuminance of 200 lux shall be provided at sample points and inside
cabinets.
6.9.17 Sample Point Top of sampling cabinet shall be no higher than 1900 mm and the bottom
Location no lower than 760 mm.
Sample points shall be located so the operator does not have to stand on
adjacent pipe work, cable trays, handrails, other equipment, or any object
not specifically designed as a standing surface for the operation and
maintenance of equipment.
6.9.18 Sample Point A minimum worker envelope of 1000 mm x 1000 mm with a head
Clearance clearance of 2300 mm shall be provided around sampling points to allow
operator to perform sampling tasks while using appropriate personal
protective equipment such as gloves and respirators.
6.9.19 Safety Sampling cabinet shall shield the operator from contact with the material
being sampled.
Volatile and/or toxic substances shall be prevented from escaping into the
local atmosphere by Venturi or by purge to flare. If vented to atmosphere,
the vapour must be released in a safe place.
Cooling water for sampling hot media shall be provided whenever practical.
Other cooling media can be considered on a case-by-case basis.
6.9.20 Sampling All connections for gas bombs shall be located inside a cabinet.
Connections Connections for liquid lines may be located outside a cabinet but must be
close coupled.
All piping and tubing associated with sampling shall be in accordance with
Shell piping specifications. The use of flexible hoses shall be subject to
COMPANY review and approval. A 90-degree connector shall be added to
the end of the sample hoses to prevent the hose from being bent
significantly to accommodate the bomb connection.
6.9.21 Sample Bottles and The sample bottles and bombs shall be properly secured in place inside
Bombs the cabinet during sampling. A minimum clearance of 50 mm shall be
provided around the circumference of the sampling bomb when connected
to allow adequate room to grip the bomb while wearing gloves.
Page 87 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
6.9.22 Cabinet Drains Sampling points shall be designed to avoid local spillage, but provisions for
spillage and containment shall be provided.
All liquid sampling cabinets shall be provided with a curbed area under the
cabinet unless the drain is routed to a drain opening hub.
Drains to the drain opening hub shall be a minimum of 20 mm diameter,
unless the sample if heavy oil in which case the drain shall be a minimum
of 50 mm.
All gas samples purge shall be routed to the flare or to a safe area.
Page 88 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
The shape of the wind girder shall be such that a minimum free
passage of 600 mm is maintained all round including around the
supporting structure of the gauger's platform.
Manholes for fixed roof tanks shall comply with EN 14015 Clause 13.
Except for 760 mm diameter manholes in the floating roof itself and
the roof compartment manholes, floating roof tanks and open top
tanks shall be equipped with bolted covers only.
DEP 34.51.01.31: 9.2.4
7.1.4 Deck height The minimum height of an internal floating roof deck should be at
least 1500 mm to allow enough head clearance for kneeling work.
7.1.5 Stairways/Walkways Stairways and walkways for tanks shall be designed and constructed
in accordance with EN 14015, Clause 13.11.
Page 89 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
7.1.7 Liquid Level Liquid level gauges shall be positioned so that they can be read from
Alarms/Indication System ground level, platform or ladder:
The rails shall be placed at such a height above the centre deck that
snow or rainwater on the deck cannot affect movement of the ladder.
7.2.2 Staircases - Elevated The staircase along the shell shall end on the top of the windgirder.
Gauger's Platform A clear vertical height between the platform and primary windgirder of
2000 mm shall be provided.
7.3 ADDITIONAL
REQUIREMENTS
7.3.1 Roof Manway Internal floating roof tanks shall have a main roof manway located at
the top of the internal ladder with minimum 900 mm diameter or 600
mm x 900 mm rectangular. The hatch shall be hinged with no bolting
or fastening mechanism.
(ESTG 4-1.01 4.1.6)
7.3.2 Rescue hatch A rescue hatch 915 mm x 1200 mm shall be installed on the fixed
roof of an internal floating roof tank. This hatch shall be associated
with the manway/access to the internal ladder and located close to an
external ladder or stairway.
The rescue hatch should be provided with a lifting device designed
for a 225 kg load and the roof structure reinforced to accommodate
the load.
(ESTG 4-1.03 3.5)
7.3.3 Tank Stairways Tanks above 9 m shall have a circular stairway and the base of the
stairs shall be convenient to the road or access over dyke.
One circular stairway may be provided for two tanks if the tanks are
close together and an interconnecting walkway is installed.
(ESTG 4-1.01 4.4)
Page 90 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
If the gap between the stair stringer and the tank (or its insulation) is
greater than 75 mm, guardrails and a handrail shall be provided on
both the inside and outside of stairs providing access to the top of
storage tanks.
7.3.4 Sample Connections Sample points along the stairs shall be provided with a standing
platform.
(ESTG 4-1.01 4.4.6 & ESTG 4-1.03 3.8)
7.3.5 Davitts Davits shall be provided for each tank at the primary access platform.
The davits shall be designed for 225 kg, arm length 1500 mm.
7.3.6 Additional Platforms Additional platforms shall be provided at all instrumentation stations
nd
on the tank roof. Most tanks will require a 2 platform 180 degrees
opposite the first/primary platform.
An engineered tie-off point shall be provided at each platform.
7.3.7 Guard/ handrails Non-insulated tanks shall be provided with guard/handrails around
their entire upper circumference. An engineered tie-off rail shall be
provided with such a guard rail.
(SCAN)
Where a guardrail is not provided around the entire circumference of
a tank, guard/handrails shall be provided at the top landing of the
access stairs and all other work platforms on the top of the tank.
Such guard/handrails shall extend a minimum of 3 metres in each
direction from the platform.
Alternatively, each work platform can be provided with guard/hand
rails on 3 sides (edge and each end). Where it is expected that a
work platform will be accessed using a manlift, the outer rail should
be removable to allow ease of assess to the platform from the manlift.
(SCAN)
Page 91 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Notes
Page 92 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 93 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 94 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
9.1.2 Lifting limits In line with the legislation, there are no maximum or minimum weight limits
specified: rather, it is a case of what the individual is capable of.
From a risk assessment perspective, it is assumed that a weight of up to
23 kg* can be lifted by the majority of the workforce, using two hands and
maintaining the load close to their body, without undue risk. For a two-
person lift, this level is assumed to be around 30/31 kg: (i.e. 2 x LC/3)
Where a load cannot be carried by two hands close to the body, the
maximum weight needs to be decreased accordingly.
*Note: This level is based on the NIOSH Lifting equation load constant. The recommended
weight limit assumes a single lift per day and optimum hand location, lift height, lift travel
distance, and body position, and would typically accommodate 99% of healthy male and 75%
of female population.
For any repetitive type lifting or non-optimal body positioning, lift height, or distance, and other
relevant handling factors, consult an HFE professional, as these factors will impose additional
constraints and thus reduce the maximum weight to be lifted.
9.1.3 Material Handling For all equipment in excess of the weight limits and travel distances that
Study must be lifted and transported for repair, replacement, or maintenance, the
project shall conduct a material handling study and develop a plan/strategy
for lifting and moving these heavy pieces of equipment.
9.1.4 Mechanical Lifting The plan shall identify permanent (e.g. cranes, monorails) or portable
Plan assisted lifting devices (e.g. chain falls, come-alongs) to aid in the lifting
and/or moving. When such lifting devices are provided, the design shall
allow space for the devices and the personnel who use them, and provide
area for manoeuvring the devices.
Page 95 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
9.1.5 Hoisting & Lowering Where equipment is to be removed and lowered from an elevated platform,
direct access by crane is preferred for lifting and lowering. Adequate area
at grade for the appropriately sized crane shall be provided.
Where direct crane access is not feasible, an engineered lifting point shall
be provided for the manual removal of equipment and its relocation, if
necessary, to an area accessible by crane. The distance between the
equipment's operating location and the elevated lift area shall be no more
than 33 metres.
Appropriate means for safely and efficiently relocating equipment to the
elevated lift area must be provided. This may include an overhead trolley or
a smooth and level surface for a wheeled cart.
Page 96 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
10.1 LIGHTING
10.1.1 National Guidelines The Netherlands’ requirements regarding illumination in the work place are
given in the following two national guidelines:
- NEN 1891: Binnenverlichting – Meetmethoden voor
Verlichtingssterkten en Luminanties.
- NEN 3087: Visuele Ergonomie in relatie tot Verlichting.
10.1.2 DEP Requirements Otherwise, unless specified in the national legislation, guidelines or
industry standards, the required illumination levels, measured at the
working plane or 1 m above the floor level in a horizontal plane, are given
in Appendix 9 of DEP 33.64.10.10, Electrical Engineering Design and the
table below. These values are mean values and the uniformity ratio
(Emin/Emean) is ¼ for normal installations.
These values shall be used as a basis for the design of new installations
unless higher illumination levels are required by national or local
regulations in the country of installation.
10.1.3 Fouling Factor The tabulated illumination levels apply when the luminaires are dirty, i.e.,
after taking account of the following fouling factors:
Location: Fouling Factor:
Plant areas (both indoor and outdoor): 0.80
Non-plant areas (outdoor): 0.80
Non-plant areas (indoor): 0.85
Page 97 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
Page 98 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
NOTES: 1. 300 lux applies at night and 500 lux during the daytime. Control of the
illumination level down to 100 lux should be possible either by switching off
rows/groups of luminaires, or by use of electronic dimmers, or both.
2. 150 lux applies for normal access and 300 lux for maintenance activities. The
illumination level should be controlled by switching each lamp in a twin fitting
from separately controlled circuits or by switching alternative fittings.
3. Where overhead travelling cranes are installed, floodlights should be fitted
under the crane beam to provide an illumination level of 400 lux for better
illumination during maintenance.
4. In areas where very fine work is carried out, local lighting with higher
illumination levels may be required, e.g., 750 - 1000 lux on an instrument
workshop bench.
5. Higher illumination levels apply where security fence lighting is required, e.g.,
for use with video camera surveillance. These shall be specified to be
compatible with the video system utilised.
6. At the security barrier and checkpoint in front of site entrance gatehouses,
higher illumination levels may be required.
7. In rooms where VDUs are permanently installed, the lighting shall be
designed to avoid reflections and glare from the screens.
10.1.5 Fixture Location Accessibility of the fixtures for maintenance must be incorporated in the
design (e.g. hinged poles, etc.). Lighting fixtures shall be located in a
manner to enable easy relamping, and a means of disconnecting each
fixture shall be provided within 3 metres of the fixture.
The design shall minimize the use of pole-mounted fixtures and maximize
the use of fixtures mounted on existing structures such as pipe racks and
buildings.
Stanchion-mounted lighting fixtures shall be mounted at least 2 metres
above platform level.
10.1.6 Safety Where fall protection will be required for fixture maintenance (such as
ballast replacement), a means of lowing the fixture closer to the platform
shall be provided, such as swivel poles.
Floodlights shall be located such that glare does not cause a hazardous
situation.
10.1.7 Stray Light Outdoor lights shall be equipped with shades, refractors or reflectors, as
applicable, to minimize stray light that may be objectionable to
neighbouring properties.
Page 99 of 105
Shell Pernis PRIMA Projects HE 09.019
Human Factors Engineering - Workplace Design Specification Rev. 2.0
10.2 NOISE
10.2.1 Legal Codes The EU Directive 2003/10/EC on the minimum health and safety
requirements regarding the exposure of workers to the risks arising from
physical agents (noise), Dutch national legislation (Arbowet and Arbo
Beleidsregel) arising, and national guidleines such as AI-bladen and site
BBS codes (BBS 05.05.2001) dictate the primary requirements regarding
control of noise exposure.
10.2.2 Noise Exposure In summary, the Directive fixes the exposure limit value at 87 decibels
Limits (taking into account the attenuation provided by the individual hearing
protectors worn by the workers), and the exposure action values are fixed
at:
- 80 decibels (lower value), and
- 85 decibels (upper value).
2003/10/EC
10.2.3 Absolute Noise Limit The absolute limit is the sound pressure level anywhere in the work area
that shall not be exceeded in any situation, including emergencies; for
example the operation of safety equipment.
ISO 15664:2001: 5.1.2
The absolute work area noise limit shall be 115 dB(A), unless otherwise
specified.
DEP 31.10.00.31: 5.1.2
10.2.4 Work Area Limit The work area noise limit, which may be different for different areas,
defines the noise level that shall not be exceeded in order to comply with
the limits as determined by law and the action levels.
The work area noise limit shall be 85 dB(A), unless otherwise specified.
DEP 31.10.00.31: 5.1.3
10.2.5 Restricted Areas Restricted areas are those work areas in the plant where, according to the
state of the art, it is not reasonably practicable to reduce the noise level at
or below the work area limit. The absolute limit remains valid in such areas.
Attempts shall be made to reduce the level below 90 dB(A) in such areas.
DEP 31.10.00.31: 5.1.4
10.2.6 Indoor Limits The following noise limits shall apply in indoor locations in order to keep
any disturbance of conversations and normal working, caused by
equipment, within acceptable proportions:
Maximum Allowable
Area Description: Sound Pressure Level
(SPL) – dB(A):
• Areas in workshops and machinery
buildings where communication is required. 70
• Workshops for light maintenance
• Workshop offices.
• Control rooms, not continuously manned 60
• Computer rooms
• Control rooms, continuously manned.
• Open plan offices.
50
• Social rooms, changing rooms, wash
places and toilets
• Offices and conference rooms.
45
NOTE : Noise that does not stem from equipment but is produced by users of the
various areas need not be considered.
11.1.2 Control Room A separate Human Factors assessment shall be conducted for a main
control room taking into account the varied nature of the work and how the
physical environment (location, layout, lighting, noise, furniture) and the
information presentation (screens, cameras, alarms) can be used to
promote economy of motion, optimize human efficiency and reduce the
potential for error.
DEP 30.00.60.15: Human Factors Engineering - Human/Machine Interface
and Control Room Design, March 2005
11.2.2 Indoor Environment In most Northern hemisphere cities, the following parameters are
appropriate for the indoor office environment:
indoor temperature 19 to 24 C
relative humidity 20 to 35% winter 40 to 50% summer
air motion 0.15 m/s winter, 0.25 m/s summer
2
minimum fresh air intake 2.5 L/s per person 0.3 L/s per m
air changes per hour 4 to 10
carbon dioxide below 800 ppm
ASHRAE 62.1-2004
11.2.3 Dimensions Details on dimension of offices, doors, hallways, stairs is given in DEP
34.17.00.32 Design and Engineering of Buildings Section 5 and 6.
11.2.4 Office and Computer For general ergonomic and computer workstation dimensions refer to
Workstation Chapter 10.0, pages 10.1-10.10 of Shell Works Toolkit provided by Shell
Dimensions Real Estate.
Notes
Notes