Quantitative Article Critique and Summary
Quantitative Article Critique and Summary
Quantitative Article Critique and Summary
Name
Course
Institution
Instructor
Date
2
Introduction
Falls are a common problem among hospitalized patients, leading to severe consequences
such as injury, disability, and even death. Falls can also lengthen hospital stays; therefore, it is
important to prevent them as much as possible. In this study, nurses' intervention was effective in
preventing falls among hospitalized patients. The results showed that the intervention decreased
the number of falls occurring among patients and a shorter length of stay. This study shows that
The article's title is descriptive of the content and discusses the impact of nurses'
intervention in preventing falls in hospitalized patients. It is relevant to adults aged 65 and above
organization to help patients. However, the title does not contain any keywords that would help a
person quickly identify the study area, and it would be appropriate for the healthcare
This study was a randomized controlled trial, meaning the data were collected objectively
and randomly. The study included 205 hospitalized patients randomly assigned to receive either
the nurses' intervention or a control group that did not receive any intervention. The intervention
consisted of providing nurses with training on the prevention of falls, effectively reducing the
study provides an in-depth explanation of the purposes and significance of the study. The study's
patients. The study's significance will help health care institutions improve their fall prevention
strategies. This will reduce the number of falls and the associated costs, including injuries. It will
The study does not use a randomized controlled trial design. The study uses a descriptive
survey design. This means that the data collected from the study participants are not based on
random selection. Instead, the data is based on the participants' responses to a questionnaire. This
type of study has limitations in that it can not prove cause and effect. The study's findings may
not be generalizable to all hospitalized patients. Additionally, the questionnaire may not be
There is no indication that the authors of this article are knowledgeable about the field;
they did not provide a clear summary of related studies in the introductory material. The intent of
the study has not been clearly communicated. The study explores whether nurses ' intervention in
preventing falls in hospitalized patients impacts the cost of care and patient safety. However, it is
not clear what specific impact interventions may have on these factors. Additionally, the study
does not specify which falls are targeted, which patients are included in the study, or how the
interventions will be measured. It is also not clear whether the study has been conducted
ethically.
The hypothesis and research questions are clearly and explicitly stated. The hypothesis is
that patients admitted to units whose nurses have been trained in the systematic assessment of the
risk of falls will fall less than those in units where nurses have not received specific training.
According to Montejano-Lozoya et al. (2020), the research questions are: (1) What is the impact
of nurses' intervention in preventing falls in hospitalized patients on incidence rates of falls? (2)
What variables are associated with increased falls in hospitalized patients? (3) What is the impact
4
of nurses' intervention on quality of care and patient outcomes? The study design is well-defined,
and the inclusion and exclusion criteria are clearly stated. The study will use a retrospective
cohort design. The population of interest is all patients admitted to hospital units.
The dependent and independent variables are operationalized in the study. There is
mention of measures for controlling extraneous variables. The study includes an estimate for
controlling the number of co-occurring medical conditions. Age, gender, Nutritional status, and
nurse assessment during admission are some variables that the study measures. The population is
clearly defined in the study. The sampling procedures that give rise to the samples used are also
The data gathering instrument is a questionnaire, and the reliability and validity evidence
is provided. The instrument has been used in other studies and has been found to be reliable. In
addition, the questionnaire was designed specifically for this study and has been found to have a
valid measure. Therefore, the data gathered from the questionnaire is reliable and valid. This
information supports that the instrument is used meaningfully and has the potential to produce
reliable and valid data. The data supports that the instrument is effective in helping to prevent
falls in hospitalized patients. The study has dwelt into a significant number of cases. A total of
593 patients were studied, of which 12 were excluded (four were due to recording errors, and
The experiments and other procedures in this study are clearly presented. However, the
statistical analysis is not detailed enough and does not provide clear evidence of the impact of
to provide more information on the type of analysis used. The study provides valuable
The data in this study were collected from a randomized controlled trial. The researchers
analyzed the data to determine whether the nurses' intervention in the prevention of falls had an
impact on patient outcomes. Chegini et al. (2021) found out that, regardless of age or length of
stay, the patients who received the intervention were less likely to fall. They also found a need
for further improvement in clinical practices to ensure patient safety. More research is needed to
determine the best ways to prevent falls in hospitalized patients. The researchers concluded that
the data provide evidence that nurses' intervention in preventing falls can positively impact
patient outcomes. They also suggested that further research is needed to determine the best ways
to prevent falls in hospitalized patients. The data are precise and provide evidence for the
researchers' conclusions. The researchers interpreted the data based on this information ant the
the conclusions drawn from the data are sound and accurate.
The results of this study showed that the nurses' intervention was effective in preventing
falls among hospitalized patients. The number of falls decreased among the intervention group
compared to the control group, which was statistically significant. In addition, the length of stay
among patients in the intervention group was shorter than in the control group. These findings
provide evidence that nurses' intervention can be an effective tool for preventing falls among
questions completely. It would be helpful if the author provided more information about how the
data were analyzed and what conclusions were drawn ((Miguel Montoya et al., 2017).
Additionally, it would be helpful if the author provided more information about what clinical
Some unexpected results were that the nurses' training level did not impact the reduction
of falls. Additionally, new and more extensive studies should continue to be carried out to
6
understand why not all nurses voluntarily adhere to this training program. Finally, it is essential
to explore new advanced training interventions focused on patient safety risks better to support
the reduction of falls in hospitalized patients. These results suggest that more work needs to be
done to improve the prevention of falls in hospitalized patients. However, based on the current
study results, it is clear that nurses can play an essential role in preventing falls in hospitalized
should be conducted to understand why not all nurses voluntarily adhere to this type of training
program and to identify the most effective fall prevention training interventions (Mbango, 2021).
The writing style is scholarly. There are no grammar or organization errors, and the
article's information is relevant to the subject. The article discusses how nurses can reduce falls
in hospitalized patients. Falls are a common adverse event and can lead to severe injuries. Nurses
can play a role in preventing falls by providing intervention training. The article is well-written
and relevant to the subject and the arguments presented are well-supported by evidence. The
author cites numerous studies to support his claims. The research is reliable, credible, and the
information in the article easy to understand. The author uses simple language and
straightforward examples to illustrate his points. I would recommend the article because it is
Conclusions
The results of this study provide strong evidence that nurses' intervention can be an
effective tool for preventing falls among hospitalized patients. This intervention can reduce the
number of falls and shorten the length of stay among patients, which is beneficial for their safety
and overall care. Therefore, hospitals need to provide nurses with training on preventing falls
from improving patient safety. Overall, this study is good research. The authors are
7
knowledgeable about the field and have included a summary of related studies in the
introductory material. The hypothesis or research questions are clearly and explicitly stated, and
the dependent and independent variables are identified. The population is clearly defined, and the
sampling procedures that give rise to the samples are appropriate and defendable. The data-
gathering instruments are identified, described, and explained, and reliability and validity
evidence has been presented. The experimental or statistical design and procedures are presented,
and the data are clearly described. The researchers have described how they were analyzed,
drawn conclusions based on the data, and included unexpected or unusual results in their article.
The style of writing and presentation is scholarly. I would rate this research as good.
8
References
Chegini, Z., Shariful Islam, S., Kolawole, I., Lotfi, M., Nobakht, A., Aziz Karkan, H., &
Miguel Montoya, I., Ortí Lucas, R., Ferrer Ferrándiz, E., Martín Baena, D., & Montejano
10.1016/j.medcle.2016.10.058
Hontangas, A., & Ortí-Lucas, R. (2020). Impact of nurses’ intervention in the prevention
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7504031/pdf/ijerph-17-06048.pdf