Vault Guide PE
Vault Guide PE
Vault Guide PE
HERE’SASAMPLINGOFOURCOVERAGE.
“For those hoping to climb the ladder of success, [Vault’s] insights are priceless.”
– Moneymagazine
“[Vault guides] make for excellent starting points for job hunters and should be
purchased by academic libraries for their career sections [and] university career
centers.”
– LibraryJournal
“A killer app.”
– TheNewYork Times
“Vault has a wealth of information about major employers and job-searching strategies
as well as comments from workers about their experiences at specific companies.”
– The WashingtonPost
“A key reference for those who want to know what it takes to get hired by a law firm
and what to expect once they get there.”
– NewYork Law Journal
“Vault [provides] the skinny on working conditions at all kinds of companies from
current and former employees.”
– USA Today
VAULTGUIDETO
PRIVATEEQUITY
ANDHEDGEFUND
INTERVIEWS
ALICE DOO
AND THE STAFF AT VAULT
Copyright © 2009 by Vault.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
All information in this book is subject to change without notice. Vault makes no claims as to the
accuracy and reliability of the information contained within and disclaims all warranties. No part of
this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or
mechanical, for any purpose, without the express written permission of Vault.com, Inc.
Vault, the Vault logo, and “The Most Trusted Name in Career InformationTM” are trademarks of
Vault.com, Inc.
For information about permission to reproduce selections from this book, contact Vault.com, Inc.,
75 Varick Street, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10013, (212) 366-4212.
ISBN 13 : 978-1-58131-696-4
ISBN 10 : 1-58131-696-8
Acknowledgments
Alice Doo’s acknowledgments: The author would like to thank her family,friends, and
colleagues for all their support and help. First, thanks to Vault editor, Matt Thornton
for taking a random chance. Mom and Dad, thank you for a lifetime of
encouragement. This book would not been possible without my friends who are
infinitely smarter notably, Hugh Au, Holly Bui, Brian and James Castiglioni, Eric
DeNatale, Angeline Hsu, Jagan Pisharath, Roman Smurkler, Bo Tang, Andrew Yeh
(left!), and Andrew Yim. Thanks to all the firms who interviewed me and said no,
because how else could I have gained the credentials to write this book? Special
thanks to Leo, Susan, Jessica, Grishma, Helis, Kevin and Annie at the Carlyle Group
for finally giving me a job.
Vault’s acknowledgments: We are extremely grateful to Vault’s entire staff for all their
help in the editorial, production and marketing processes. Vault also would like to
acknowledge the support of our investors, clients, employees, family and friends.
Thank you!
v
TableofContents
INTRODUCTION 1
Preparation is Key .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1
WHAT TO EXPECT 7
Overview of the Interview .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7
Why You at XYZ Firm .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
Behavioral Questions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .10
WORK/DEAL EXPERIENCE 15
Switch Perspectives ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15
Sample Questions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .16
ACCOUNTING 23
Solid Foundation ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .23
Sample Questions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .24
FINANCE 31
Sample Questions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .31
BR A I NT EASERS 41
Standardized Acumen ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .41
Sample Questions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .42
vii
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Table of Contents
CONSULTING 47
Case Questions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .47
Sample Questions .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .50
APPENDIX 125
Abbreviations .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .127
Finance Glossary .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .128
Headhunters ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .147
Whyyou?
Getting a coveted position in the prestigious industry of hedge funds (“HF”) and
private equity (“PE”) boils down to one question: Will you make money for the firm?
The entire interview is devoted to determining that answer.
Seriously, whyyou?
Most likely, you are already in the industry or working in a breeder field like
investment banking, sales and trading, or consulting. Even more likely, you are at a
prestigious firm that you already sacrificed blood, sweat,and tears to break into.
First, pat yourself on the back for being successful. But next, realize the competition
for buy-side gets much worse. If you aren’t already at Goldman Sachs or Morgan
Stanley with an Ivy League education, then you better fine-tune your strategy. Also,
unfortunately, this book is being written in early 2009 when buy-side jobs are
particularly scarce.
You’ll need to make it past the headhunters who pre-judge you, answer technical
finance and accounting questions about a field in which you may have zero
experience, and even be tested on the spot by being creating an Excel model from
scratch or presenting a case study. In addition to being intelligent and capable, you
absolutely must fit into the culture.
Essentially, positions above associates need only to look at the first four chapters, until
“Work/Deal Experience” as technical questions are rare unless you’re from another
industry and needs to prove your financial capability.
1
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Introduction
Entry point
Private equity shops have clearly defined hierarchies of roles versus hedge funds,
which may have looser structures. Responsibilities at both can be divided into three
groups; the juniors handle the details, the middle manages the details, and the
seniors focus on the bigger picture.
From junior to senior, typical roles at PE shops include associates, vice presidents,
principals, managing directors and partners. The associates focus on the grunt
quantitative work in which they create complex models to illustrate future company
cash flows. The middle tier, the vice presidents, manage and coordinate the day-to-
day needs of the deals. The top will emphasize the bigger picture, such as sourcing
deals with existing or new management contacts.
Hedge funds vary depending on the size of the firm. Typical titles include research
analyst, junior trader, trader, vice president, risk manager, portfolio manager, and
partner. The hierarchy culture at HFs tends to be much flatter than PE.
The “pedigreed”
At the lowest entry point, a college undergrad may join a hedge fund as an analyst.
Rarely do recent undergrads go directly into PE. Typically, firms look for traditional
buy-side (HF/PE) or sell-side (investment banking) experience. It is possible to have
neither, but very difficult, so focus on networking or spend some time at an
investment bank.
Typical pre-MBA associates will have had a one- to two-year stint in an investment
bank, or to a lesser extent, at a consulting firm. Typical post-MBA associates will
already have relevant buy-side experience but may also be recruited from other
finance or corporate backgrounds. Pedigrees at prestigious colleges (Wharton,
Harvard) and bulge bracket investment banks (Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley)
improve your marketability.
3
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Breaking into the Industry
The firstobstacle
Headhunters provide the greatest accessibility to jobs in the financial industry. SG
Partners, CPI, Dynamics, Glocap, and Oxbridge are the five most popular firms and
represent many ofthe big names. SG’s and CPI’s clients include the most prestigious
firms like Bain Capital, Carlyle, Och Ziff, Perry Capital and TPG. Dynamics handles
mostly hedge funds, including Citadel. An inclusive listing can be found in the
appendix of this guide. You can also draw upon other resources such as networking
connections and classifieds.
For the most part, headhunters are the gatekeepers to PE and HF interviews. They
will gather thousands of applicants’ resumes and then handpick only a dozen to
interview at each client. They are usually genuinely helpful people but remember
who fills their coffers; firms pay them anywhere from 10 to 50 percent of first year’s
salary. The recruiter’s job is find appropriate candidates and to get them to accept
the offer.
Typically,a major PE firm will kick offits interviewing season (in 2008, The Blackstone
Group started in April); then others follow and there is a month of hot and heavy
interviewing for the bulk ofPE firms, though plenty ofjobs can also be acquired later.
It’s quite comical how early the process begins, despite the interviewees barely
knowing how to add, much less model, as they have not yet finished their first year
working.
Other levels
For those who are looking for jobs immediately after undergraduate college, you can
try to contact some headhunters, but don’t expect a call back. You’ll need to rely on
your career center or your own resourcefulness.
For senior levels, it’s a good idea to keep in constant contact with headhunters even
if you are satisfied with your current job.It keeps you updated on your market worth.
Data gathering
The headhunters will collect your resume and ask you to fill out an informational sheet
about your work and education history as well as your career interests and
geographical preferences. Be careful if you are interested in something that is very
different from your current job. For instance, you are an investment banker covering
the energy sector but you’d really like to join the healthcare group at XYZ firm and get
out of the energy sector. The recruiter may still slot you for energy specific firms or
wherever your experience is most relevant. So position yourself as best you can.
“First-round” interview
Your first test will actually be with the headhunters. They’ll ask you about your
background and what you’re interested in. They are already sizing you up to see how
you would perform in a real interview,so remember to take these seriously. Show that
you are professional, well prepared and earnest.
Some headhunters contact everyone at the big bulge bracket banks or big name
firms, but make sure you reach out to all of them. Their high season is the official PE
season, so it’s good to schedule appointments with them up to three months before
they are too busy to meet you.
The aesthetics
As with any interview, be well groomed and wear a suit. Your interviewer has an eye
for detail and is accustomed to the finer things in life; pick an outfit that is
conservative and of good quality. Don’t neglect your shoes and fingernails. Have an
extra outfit hand y—you could be called back for a second round the next day, and
the night can be betterspent preparing versus ironing.
The supplies
Bring business cards to exchange. Carry a portfolio (a leather folder available at office
supply stores) to hold resume copies, a notepad and a pen. Some candidates keep a
calculator handy, but rarely would it be appropriate to use one during an interview.
The time
Be there at least five minutes early. Factor in traffic. If you have a current job,
overestimate the amount oftime you will be gone from the office,since interviews will
often start late or run over the allotted time.
Tip: Create discreet study materials that you can peruse while waiting. For instance,
this author was an investment banker so she had a pitch book (spiral-bound client
presentation) of her study materials made. Kinko’s and other photocopy stores can
assist you. She was able to refresh her memory immediately before an interview while
implying she was dedicated to her current job.
The rounds
Few firms will hire you after one round. Your first round will be a filtering session,
either with H R or the individual most junior in the decision process. One approach
uses short verbal technical questions in the beginning to bring back the smartest
candidates and then interview for personality and culture fit. Vice versa, a first round
may only consist ofbehavioral questions and then the second round uses a modeling
test or case study to evaluate technical skills. Most firms use a mix of behavioral and
technical questions in the first round to filter for intelligent yet personable candidates.
To give you a data point, the typical interview for a junior position is as follows: The
first round is an hour of a basic question-and-answer session with one or two
interviewers at the associate or VP level. Questions will consist of a mix of the
behavioral and technical variety, with a heavy emphasis on deal experience. The
second round is either a modeling test or case study. The third and final round will
7
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
What to Expect
have the candidate meet with senior-level people and will be more conversational,
with you asking the majority of questions. This example is only a median point;
interviews can be as short as two rounds or take longer than five. So me have zero
technical assessments while others give both in-office modeling tests and take-home
case studies. The larger firms tend to have the quickest turnarounds, with some even
calling back for a second round the same day. Some of the smaller firms will drag
their feet to ensure you are the perfect fit for the firm.
Senior positions will have as many rounds as necessary to meet the relevant superiors
or peers to work with.
Your final round will always focus on meeting with the head honchos, the most
relevant senior people. Sometimes, only the people in your final round will make the
decision but since most groups are small and take recruiting seriously, usually
everyone will convene formally to discuss their opinions. The senior people, the
group head in particular, have veto power. Those who will be responsible for your
work are likelyto be the most vocally opinionated.
The questions
Expect to start with either “Tell me about yourself” or “Walk me through your
resume.” Prepare an answer but make sure not to sound rehearsed. If you are not
already in the industry, you can be certain you will be asked why you want to join.
The behavioral questions usually consist of some variation of “Why did you choose
your path,” like how did you pick your college, your current firm, your previous job,
etc. Your answers illustrate the strength ofyour desire to be in the finance industry.
If you’re interviewing for a senior position, you are likely to experience zero technical
questions; the focus is on work experience, strength of industry relationships and
investment opinions.
Aim for pointed and concise answers; think less than a minute, with 30 seconds
being the sweet spot forin-depth questions. A minute is much longer than you think;
observe your interviewer’s body language forsigns of boredom or interest.
The attitude
Punctuality and preparation convey requisite employee qualities but your attitude and
personality will make the strongest impression. Start with a firm handshake and
smile. Radiate confidence, intelligence, reliability, dependability and a personality
that your interviewer would enjoy spending most ofhis waking life with.
Even when you are given an easy question, your body language might imply
uncertainty that will discredit your answer. Many people have a tendency to roll their
eyes up and speak haltingly when they are thinking. Look at your interviewer (but do
not bore into his eyes) and speak loudly, clearly and slowly with your shoulders up
and hands neatly clasped.
Interviewing implies you do not want to be at your current job,but leave it as the silent
elephant in the room. Even if your interviewer knows you just pulled a miserable all-
nighter, focus on the positives rather than accept his sympathy. Enthusiastic
underlings who express a desire for more responsibility means someone one can
guiltlessly push work down onto. Of course, too much enthusiasm is a line closer
than you think; don’t be the overly chipper weirdo. A good guideline is to match your
interviewer's energy level. Pre-offer, do not ask about pay and especially do not ask
about hours. People appreciate confidence but most people dislike arrogance, so
refrain from going on tangents about yourself; the interviewer is asking enough
questions about you. Rather, aim to sound interested by asking your own questions.
Flowing conversations are inherently more enjoyable than punctuated questions and
answers.
This guide can help you formulate the syntax of a good answer, but mock interviewing
will refine your interview attitude. You can do it alone with just the mirror or ask a
friend to sit in. When watching yourselfin the mirror,think about who you would hire.
With others, have mock interviewers give real criticism.
Disinterest is a turnoffto anyone, so do the research on the firm. Truly understand its
investment strategy, and tailor your answers to reflect that. For example, one firm
asked five characteristics of an ideal investment; the website listed precisely five
requirements of its own investments. The offer was given to the person who listed
those five plus a few others.
In addition to conveying your interest to the interviewing firm, many shops will ask
about the level of interest in you by its peers. They will often ask about whom else
you are interviewing with and where you are in the process, which really means
whether you already have other offers on the table. Popularity basically serves as a
measure of credibility. If you are not asked directly and do have exploding offers, let
the H R contact know; he will relay the information to the team.
Beyond having the requisite job capabilities, your culture fit will make or break the
offer decision. Don’t force yourself to be someone you’re not because then you’ll just
be unhappy on the job when you end up spending more time with these colleagues
than your own spouse. Just present the best version ofyourself.
Know the market: Stay updated on relevant news, both macro and micro. If
you're going into an entry-level job, you'll need to know at least the basics ofthe
state of the economy and the HF or PE market. As you go up the ladder, you'l l
need tohave more detailed opinions on specific market niches,like “what do you
think of Company X Versus Company Y as an investment?”, “which emerging
market do you think has the best investing opportunities?” (HF) and “whatdo you
think of LBO opportunities in the mining industry?” (PE). You'll get grilled for
anything within your current realm ofexperience, but don't be surprised if you’re
asked to broadly discuss an industry you've never worked with.
Know yourself: Show that you have the desire totake on the job and have gained
the appropriate experience to be able to perform. Be prepared to explain
everything on your resume, especially deal experience ifyou have it.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
BEHAVIORAL QUESTIONS
There are no right answers to these questions. Be honest, but always lay out a
response in its most flattering light.
1. Tell meaboutyourself/Walkmethroughyourresume.
An easy way to begin the interview—prepare a short spiel in advance that
highlights your path to finance.
2. Whyhedgefunds orprivateequity?
Prepare a thoughtful answer as you are guaranteed to receive this question. This
is the motivation question. Why are you here in the first place? Show that you
have the personality traits that support the investing strategy of the firm. For
example, what is your time horizon preference: short term versus long term? Are
you interested in how Ben Bernanke’s interest rate change affect a stock price
tomorrow (macro strategy focused HF) or do you prefer to watch companies that
you can shape from the inside for three to five years (PE). Don’t allow someone
to poke holes in your answer by saying “Well if you like that aspect, why don’t
you pursue X profession instead?” At minimum, you should be an analytical
thinker that enjoys looking at companies.
4. Whyareyouworkingin yourcurrentindustry?
The motivation should complement your reason to join the HF or PE industry. In
fact, it can be exactly the same answer. If it is radically different, be prepared to
explain why.
Everyone appreciates the money, but the successful employees are the ones
who truly enjoy the process of making money.
industry?
Do the research as to what skills are the prioritized in the industries. Naturally,
analytical and insightful thinking rank at the top.
willing to relocate. Firms know it’s tough to go somewhere if you do not have
family or friends there, and so they will not give you an offerif they think you will
reject it based on location.
21. Fromwhattransactiondidyoulearnthemost?
Your current job should be great preparation for this next job. Ideally, you have
learned what makes a great investment and developed the skill set that makes a
valuable employee.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
SWITCH PERSPECTIVES
Ideally, you show that you play a role that is above your title. You fullyunderstand the
big picture as well as the nuts and bolts of the deal. Finally, you need to prove that
you understand what makes a great investment and identify the major points ofrisk.
You may list transactions that are not yet public knowledge. Do not include the
parties’ names or details that would give them away.
For PE firms, focus on mergers and acquisitions and the relationship between the
price paid versus your opinion of the value of the company. If the acquirer is public,
how did its stock price react and why? Understand the financing structure and know
deal multiples.
Tell astory
Either the interviewer will point to a project based on your experience and tell you to
elaborate or he will ask you to choose one yourself. Prepare good introductions that
establish the parties, transaction value, capital structure and strategic rationale for
each one. As you grow comfortable with interviewing, you should learn how to
structure your stories so that they hook your interviewer. That can produce a
predictable line ofquestioning you can anticipate. For instance, ifyou say the
15
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Work/Deal Experience
If the deal is about a specific company, be sure you understand its competitors and
the overall industry outlook. Or, if your work experience is more industry-focused,
know specific company names you would suggest as an investment and why.
Again, if you can anticipate the kinds of questions they will ask, you can prepare for
them. Questions are always geared to understanding the investment rationale and
pitfalls. A candidate who can pinpoint and articulate the heart of a deal will be an
indication ofa good investor.
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
Both the PE and HF questions will center around whether it was a good investment
in various disguises like strategic rationale and projected performance. Some of the
following structure-oriented questions are more relevant to a merger and acquisition
(“M&A”) transaction and PE interview.
1. Whatwasthestrategicrationale?
Be able to list at least three to five points of the merits of the deal. Have the
answer flow in a way that creates a story so you don’t sound like a monkey who
can only memorize a confidential information memorandum (“CIM”). Be
prepared to have concrete evidence that backs up each point, such as projected
growth rates, gross margin percentages, etc.
2. Discuss theindustryoutlookandtrends.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Know historical, current and projected themes of the industry. Understand the
competitors and where they trade in relation to the target company. Recognize
how the target company should outperform, underperform, or be neutral with its
industry. You might also be asked to opine on industries outside of your work
experience. The interview is probably reviewing the industry or company himself
and wants to bounce ideas off you. Unfair if you have no experience in the
industry, but handle it gracefully.
3. Whatwerethecomps?Howdidyouchoosethem?Whatweretheytradingat?
It’s a routine rookie mistake to not think about this question when you study for
your interview since you’re so focused on the target company. You choose
comps based on how similar they are to your target company. The similarities
are a combination ofindustry, geography, cash flow characteristics and capital
structure. Key ratios are price to earnings (“P/E”), enterprise value to EBITDA
(“EV/EBITDA”), debt to equity (“D/E”), debt to capitalization (“D/cap”). Don’t
forget important industry multiples like enterprise value/sales (“EV/sales”) for
non-profitable companies.
4. Howdid youvalueit?
There are three main methods ofmarket valuation. There is the discounted cash
flow (“DCF”) methodology, trading comparable company multiples (“trading
comps”), and comparable transactions multiples (“acquisition comps”). For PE,
a fourth technique is the LBO valuation, which is a subset of the DCF. You
should know how the company was valued by each methodology. At the end of
the day, the DCF shows the intrinsic value of a company, but trading and
acquisition comps provide the general boundaries of how the market will
perceive the investment.
5. Wasit agooddeal?Why?
Have a fantastically thoughtful answer to this. Prepare evidence to back up your
theory, i.e., the answers to the other questions in this chapter.
6. Howdid theinvestment/dealperform?
If you are an investment banker or consultant, remember to refresh your memory
on what happened after you finished your work. Especially if the investment is
public, check how its stock performed and whether research reports opine on
the deal. Sell-side people usually only focus on getting the deal done and then
work on getting the next deal versus evaluating the aftermath. Buy-side people
are actually tied to performance and thus monitor investments closely until exit.
For people who are already traders in the HF/PE industry, or in other buy-side
positions, you need talk about your investment track record; what was the entry
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
and exit price, giving what percentage return over what duration of the
investment?
7. Whatwerethesourcesandusesof funds(“S&U”)?
This refers to an M&A transaction, and the sources are the financing, like debt,
equity, proceeds from targets’ options, and cash. Each deal uses a different mix;
be able to explain why this particular mix was used forthe deal. Know the names
of the different tranches of financing instruments used (such as senior versus
mezzanine debt) and the cost (interest rate for debt, exchange ratio for stock) of
each. The uses include the price of the asset or equity, transaction costs,
purchase of the target’s options, and debt paid off or refinanced. You can apply
S&U to a equity or debt offering by discussing the structure and covenants ofthe
financial instrument and the intended purpose of the funds (general corporate
purposes, pay down debt,acquisitions, organic growth, etc.).
8. Whatwerethecreditstats?
For M&A, this is the S&U in multiple form; for an existing company, this is its
current capital structure in multiple form. The relevant numbers are debt,
earnings before interest, depreciation and amortization (“EBITDA”), capital
expenditures (“capex”), interest, and funds from operations (“FFO”). They can
be combined to form various credit statistics such as total debt/EBITDA, senior
debt/EBITDA, EBITDA/interest, (EBITDA – Capex)/interest, FFO/total debt, (FFO
+ interest)/interest. Especially relevant for PE, this is a measure of how a
company can support debt. E BITDA is a proxy for cash flow to debt and equity
holders, where debt holders are first in line. Unlike equity,paying debt holders is
mandatory, so if interest cannot be paid, then the company is in danger of
bankruptcy. Therefore, debt/EBITDA of 6.0x means it would take the company
about six years to pay off the debt if EBITDA stayed constant. The higher the
metrics of amounts owed/cash flow like debt/EBITDA, the higher leverage and
riskier capital structure. Reversely, cash flow/amounts owed metrics like
EBITDA/interest are better when they are higher and cannot dip below 1.0x.
Note that capex is not an income statement expense but is an outgoing cash
flow, so (EBI TDA – Capex)/interest is a relevant metric. EBITDA/interest is
usually considered to be minimally safe at 2.0x. PE firms will hound you for this
kind of data.
9. Whatweretheacquisitionmultiples?
This refers to price paid/cash flows, giving a benchmark to the value of the
transaction. The numerator can be enterprise value or just equity value.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
11. Whatwasthepremium?
If this is a public company that was bought, then this refers to the relationship
between the price paid per share versus the market price paid per share at the
time of the offer. The offer price in order to induce shareholders to sell their
shares. Sometimes theycall this a change ofcontrol premium. Premiums are
18. What were the margins? What is the growthrate of revenue?What is the
growthrateofEBITDA?Whatis thegrowthrateofnetincome?Whatis their
marketshare?Whois thecustomerbase?Whoarethesuppliers?
Interviewers can ask many more of these questions. You must fully grasp the
business model ofthe company. Study the historical and projected financials.
Fixed costs and maintenance capex must be paid, regardless of the current
profit. Variable costs are only paid if a new product is made, and growth capex
can be canceled. High fixed costs and maintenance costs create riskier
operating incomes.
Deal/InvestmentNotes
Studyyour workexperiencebycreating worksheetsfor each dealorinvestmentyoulisted on
yourresume. Tailor asneeded.
Name/Date
CompanyName(s)
SituationOverview/History
Myresponsibilities
1) InvestmentThesis
2)Model drivers
a) Revenuedrivers
- Volumes
- Price perunit
b) Revenue#s,%growth
- Historical
- Projected
c) Cost drivers
- Rawmaterials
- Other
d) Gross Profit#s,%margin
- Historical
- Projected
e) EBITDA#s,%margin
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
- Historical
- Projected
f) FreeCash Flow#s
- EBITDA
- Capex
- ChangeinNWC
- Cashinterest
- Other
3)Factorsaffectingcompanyvalue
a) Competitive landscape/Company advantages
- Growthandprofitabilityvs.peers
- Industry-specificdata(subscribers,etc.)
b)Sectoroutlook
c) Specific#s:
- EV
- EV/EBITDA
- EV/EBITDA(comps)
- EV/Industry-specific fundamental data
4) Capitalstructure
a) Pre-transaction/Post-transaction
b) WhereIwouldinvest/why
c) Intercreditor issues
d) Negotiating position(strengths andweaknesses) ofvariouscreditorconstituencies
6) Situation-specific nuances(legal,etc.)
7) Situationoutcome(priceperformance,etc.)
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
You may read the Vault Guide to Finance Interviews for a review of basic concepts.
Cash, cash,cash
When Nike builds a sneaker manufacturing plant for $100 million, it records this as
capital expenditures on the CFS. This plant will produce sneakers that will be sold
for revenue, but it will produce sneakers formultiple years, so you would not expense
the entire $100 million in one year. Instead, to match revenue to expenses on the IS,
you would depreciate it. So you assume a lifespan of the plant (let’s say 10 years)
and given the method of straight-line deprecation, you would record $100 million/10
years=$10 million of depreciation expense on the IS after the first year. Note that on
the B S, you would have an asset of $90 million under plant, property and equipment
(“PP&E”) which is $100 million but $10 million is “used up” or depreciated.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
However, depreciation and amortization (“D&A”) is made up. It does not represent
real cash. While a company can have great profits, not all of it is cash. At the end of
the day, only cash is worth anything. If something does not produce or turn into
cash, it is useless. If the sneaker plant burns down tomorrow, then Nike will not see
future revenue until it builds a new one in its place. Thus, when HF and PE people
review accounting statements, they are most concerned with what is actually
valuable. For example, D&A is non-cash; the money has already been spent via
capex. Items on the statements issued to shareholders are referred to as “book”; in
the U.S., these procedures are regulated by GAAP. In contrast, a different set of
statements will be sent to the I RS to calculate the amount of taxes charged.
Differences between book and tax line items can cause temporary or permanent cash
differences. Another example of misrepresentation of market value to book value is
land. On the balance sheet, land is recorded at its price paid or historical value. It is
never depreciated because land has an infinite useful life. Conditions in the
geographic area can cause the land to wildlyfluctuate in value. A New York office
23
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Accounting
building bought in the 1950s is of significantly higher value today. If the company is
bought, this will be taken into account and assets will be “written up” to records its
current market value.
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
book value when sold. Therefore, you have a $400 million “sale of asset” under
cash from investing activities. Your net cash flow is $460 million. On the BS,
cash increases by $460 million and PP&E decreases by $400 million. The $60
million increase on the left side of the B S is offsest by the $60 million increase
in shareholder’s equity on the right side.
In cash flow from operating, the key items are net income, depreciation and
amortization, equity in earnings, non-cash stock compensation, deferred taxes,
changes in working capital and changes in other assets and liabilities.
In cash flow from investing, the key items are capital expenditures and asset
sales.
In cash flow from financing, the key items are debt raised and paid down, equity
raised, share repurchases and dividends.
5. If youcould have only one of the three main financial statements, which
wouldit be?
The IS is definitely inappropriate to pick. Income statements are full of non-cash
items, which work fine for theoretical purposes, like matching revenue to
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
retained earnings. Next, the interest expense on the IS is charged on the debt
that is recorded on the BS. D&A is a capitalized expense from the IS that will
reduce the PP&E on the asset side ofthe BS.
people frequently pay with credit for the company’s products, the amount is
listed as accounts receivable (“AR”), which represents future profits but is non-
cash. Therefore, if the company cannot collect this owed cash in time to pay its
creditors, it runs of the risk of bankruptcy. This is an issue to note and watch,
but it is not a deal killer if you have an adequate revolver and can predict the
seasonal WC requirements with some clarity. In general, any recurring event is
fine as long as it continues to perform as planned. The one-time massive
surprise event is what can kill an investment.
When the PIK is triggered and all else is equal, interest on the IS will be
increased by $10 million, which will reduce net income by $6 million (assuming
a 40 percent tax rate). This carries over onto the CFS where net income
decreases by $6 million and the $10 million ofPIK interest is added back (since
it is non-cash), resulting in a net cash flow of $4 million. On the BS, cash
increases by $4 million, debt increases by $10 million (the PIK interest accretes
on the balance sheet as debt) and shareholders equity decreases by $6 million.
Which structuredoesthesellerpreferandwhy?Whataboutthebuyer?
A stock deal generally favors the seller because of the tax advantage. An asset
deal for a C corporation causes the seller to be double-taxed; once at the
corporate level when the assets are sold, and again at the individual level when
proceeds are distributed to the shareholders/owners. In contrast, a stock deal
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
avoids the second tax because proceeds transfer directly to the seller. In non-C
corporations like LLCs and partnerships, a stock purchase can help the seller
pay transaction taxes at a lower capital gains rate (there is a capital gains and
ordinary income tax difference at the individual level, but not at a corporate
level). Furthermore, since a stock purchase transfers the entire entity, it allows
the seller to completely extract itself from the business.
A buyer prefers an asset deal for similar reasons. First, it can pick and choose
which assets and liabilities to assume. This also decreases the amount of due
diligence needed. Second, the buyer can write up the value of the assets
purchased—known as a “step-up” in basis to fair market value over the
historical carrying cost, which can create an additional depreciation write-off,
becoming a tax benefit.
Please note there are other, lesser-known legal advantages and disadvantages to
both transaction structures.
HF will focus on free cash flow and the time value of money finance questions. PE
will ask many M&A-oriented questions. Both will overlap, so the finance questions
are combined in one chapter forboth audiences to read.
If you need to review basic finance concepts, pick up the Vault Guide to Finance
Interviews. The following sample questions represent a higher level of difficulty, but
many of the questions in the Vault Guide to Finance Interviews may be asked in your
HF or PE interviews.
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
companies acquired?
Discounted cash flow (“DCF”): Based on the concept that value of the company
equals the cash flows the company can produce in the future. An appropriate
discount rate is used to calculate a net present value ofprojected cash flows.
31
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Finance
benchmark).If the buyer believes it can achieve synergies with the merger,then
the buyer may pay more. This is known as the synergy premium.
Between LBOs and DCFs, the DCF should have a higher value because the
required I RR (cost ofequity) ofan LBO should be higher than the public markets
cost of equity in WACC for the DCF. The DCF should be discounted at a lower
rate and yield a higher value than an LBO.
When debating whether precedents or DCFs yield higher values, you should note
that DCFs are a control methodology, meaning you select the assumptions that
determine the value. Some interviewers have mentioned that you get projections
from management, which tends to be optimistic and can often make the DCF
the highest value. Regardless, all interviewers are looking for you to say that the
DCF and precedents yield higher valuations than the other two methodologies for
the reasons listed above.
5. Whatis aWACC?
The “WACC,” weighted average cost ofcapital, is the discount rate used in a DCF
analysis to determine the present value of the projected free cash flows and
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
terminal value. Conceptually, the WACC represents the blended opportunity cost
to lenders and investors of a company. The WACC reflects the cost of each type
of capital: debt and equity, weighted by the respective percentage of each type
of capital assumed for the company’s capital structure. Specifically the WACC is
defined as:
WACC = [(% Equity) * (Cost ofEquity)] + [(% Debt) * (Cost ofDebt)(1-tax rate)]
9. Walkmethroughanaccretion/dilutionanalysis.
An accretion/dilution analysis (sometimes also referred to as a quick-and-dirty
merger analysis) analyzes the impact of an acquisition on the acquirer’s EPS.
Essentially, it is comparing the pro-forma EPS (the “new” EP S assuming the
acquisition occurs) against the acquirer’s stand-alone EPS (the “old” EPS of the
status quo). To perform an accretion/dilution analysis, you need to project the
combined company’s net income (pro-forma net income) and the combined
company’s new share count. The pro-forma net income will be the sum of the
acquirer’s and target’s projected net income plus/minus certain transaction
adjustments. Such pro-forma net income adjustments include synergies
(positive or negative), increased interest expense (if debt is used to finance the
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
purchase), decreased interest income (if cash is used to finance the purchase)
and any new intangible asset amortization resulting from the transaction. The
pro-forma share count reflects the acquirer’s share count plus the number of
shares to be issued to finance the purchase (in a stock deal). Note that in an
all-cash deal, the share count will not change. Dividing pro-forma net income by
pro-forma shares gives us pro-forma EPS, which you can then compare to the
acquirer’s original EPS to see if the transaction results in an increase to EPS
(accretion) or a decrease in EPS (dilution). Usually, this analysis looks at the EP S
impact over the next two years.
times used to value firms that have negative income (but have positive EBITDA).
EBITDA multiples do not factor in the effect of interest and therefore allow for
comparability across firms regardless of their capital structure. Note this is why
you will never see EV/earnings or Price/EBITDA ratios; the numerator and
denominator must correspond to the same set ofstakeholders.
and is roughly comparable to the Fed Funds rate. LIBO R is used as a reference
rate for several financial instruments, such as interest rate swaps or forward rate
agreements, and they provide the basis for some of the world’s most liquid and
active interest rate markets.
market value assumes a meeting of the minds. The going-concern value is the
firm’s value as an operating business to a potential buyer,so the excess of going-
concern value over liquidation value is booked as goodwill in acquisition
accounting. If positive goodwill exists, i.e., the company has intangible benefits
that allow it to earn better profits than another company with the same assets;
the going-concern value should be higher than the fair market value.
27. Why would you use options outstanding over options exercisable to
calculatetransactionpriceinanM&Atransaction?
Options outstanding represent the total amount of options issued. Options
exercisable are options that have vested and can actually be exercised at the
strike price. During a potential M&A transaction however, all of the target’s
outstanding options will vest immediately and thus the acquirer must buy out all
option holders.
Third, it can repurchase some of its equity from the market. Fourth, it can pay
down debt and decrease leverage.
32. Whataresomereasonswhyacompanymighttapthehigh-yieldmarket?
Companies with low credit ratings are unable to access investment grade
investors and would have to borrow at higher rates in the high-yield markets.
Other companies might have specific riskier investments that they must pay a
higher cost ofcapital for.
35. Explainput-callparity.
It demonstrates the relationship between the price of a call option and a put
option with an identical strike price and expiration date. The relationship is
derived using arbitrage arguments, and shows that a portfolio of call options and
x amount of cash equal to the PV of the option’s strike price has the same
expiration value as a portfolio comprising the corresponding put option and the
underlying option. The parity shows that the implied volatility of calls and puts
are identical. Also, in a delta-neutral portfolio, a call and a put can be used
interchangeably.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
What if this was anLBO scenario and youhad a sponsor putting in 500
millionofequity?
The company would be less risky because it has more liquidity now.
Resume Tip
Junior Positions
Finance people really are obsessed with standardized testing. Include your
SAT/GMAT scores on your resume. Show the breakout; firms especially care
about your math score.
Obviously, accuracy is key but so is your thinking process. You should expect to
explain your reasoning, and a logical verbal breakout followed by a wrong answer is
better than just a wrong answer. Pay attention to your interviewer’s face for clues to
whether you are going in the right or wrong direction. Brainteasers are meant to be
tough, so it’s fine to take a minute to collect your thoughts and outline the steps to
calculating the answer.
“Suppose you’re on a game show and you're given the choice ofthree doors. Behind
one door is a car; behind the others, goats. The car and the goats were placed
randomly behind the doors before the show. The rules of the game show are as
follows: After you have chosen a door, the door remains closed for the time being.
The game show host, Monty Hall, who knows what is behind the doors, now has to
open one of the two remaining doors, and the door he opens must have a goat behind
it. If both remaining doors have goats behind them, he chooses one randomly. After
Monty Hall opens a door with a goat, he will ask you to decide whether you want to
stay with your first choice or to switch to the last remaining door. Imagine that you
chose Door 1 and the host opens Door 3, which has a goat. He then asks you, ‘Do
you want to switch to Door Number 2?’ Is it to your advantage to change your choice?
(Krauss and Wang 2003:10)”
41
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Brainteasers
Most people assume that each door has an equal probability (1/3) and conclude that
switching does not matter. Actually, the player should switch—doing so doubles the
probability ofwinning the car from 1/3 to 2/3.
Think ofit this way:let’s say Door 1 is the winning door. Look at the outcome for each
door that the player could pick and decide to switch.
1. Picks Door 1 (win). Monty shows Door 2 or 3 with goat. Player switches, and
loses.
2. Picks Door 2 (goat). Monty shows Door 3 with goat. Player switches and wins.
3. Picks Door 3 (goat). Monty shows Door 2 with goat. Player switches and wins.
Two out ofthe three scenarios are wins ifthe playerswitches (ifthe player had stayed,
two of the three scenarios are losses), so therefore there is a 2/3 probability that the
player wins ifhe switches.
Put another way, the probability that the player initially chooses the winning door is
1/3,since there are three doors each ofwhich has an equal chance ofconcealing the
car. The probability that the door Monty Hall chooses conceals the car is 0, since he
never chooses the door that contains the prize. Since the sum of the three
probabilities is 1, the probability that the prize is behind the other door is 1 – (1/3 +
0), which equals 2/3. Therefore, switching is more advantageous due to the doubled
probability.
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
possibility. The average of all the potential die rolls, which each have equal
probabilities,is $3.50, the midpoint between 1 and 6.
If youweregiventworopes, howwouldyoumeasure45minutes?
For two ropes, take one rope and burn both ends like the previous situation. At
the same time, light the second rope on only one end. When the first rope burns
out, a half hour has passed. The second rope only has 30 more minutes on it.
Immediately burn the opposite end ofthe second rope. The fire will meet at both
ends again, which is fifteen minutes.
3. Whatis 22 times22?
The interviewer wants you to solve these types of questions quickly and without
using paper. Just break down the numbers to simple ones you can do in your
head. 22 times 20 is 440. There is an additional two instances of 22, which is
44 and then you can add it to 440 so that the answer is 484.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
nickel because three quarter, two dimes, and the additional nickel would create
a dollar. But you can add four pennies fora maximum total of$1.19 = 1.15 +
.04.
9. A closet has three light bulbs inside. Next to the door (outside) are three
switchesforeachlight bulb. Ifyoucanonlyenterthecloset onetime, how do
youdeterminewhichswitchcontrolswhichlight bulb?
Turn on two switches, A and B, and leave them on for a few minutes. Then turn
off switch B and enter the room. The bulb that is lit is controlled by switch A.
Touch the other two bulbs, which are off. The one that is still warm is controlled
by switch B. The third bulb, offand cold, is controlled by switch C.
11. Alily in apond doubles everyminute. After anhour, the lily fills theentire
pond. Whenis it one-eighthfull?
Work backwards. At 59 minutes, it is half full. At 58 minutes, it’s one-fourth full.
Thus, after 57 minutes, it is one-eighth full.
CASE QUESTIONS
Consulting questions present a business situation for you to evaluate. Great
candidates quickly ask the fundamental questions and then concisely summarize the
situational highlights and risks. Usually, there is no one “right answer,” but there is
usually at least one targeted “point” that you should hit.
Interviewers expect you to walk through your thought process aloud to note your logic
skills. Ask a few questions and then take five seconds to think of your starting point.
As you speak, watch his body language for any clues that you are going in the right
or wrong direction. These questions are among the toughest since there is no specific
mathematical formula to memorize.
Think ofwhat constitutes a great investment as per the capital markets chapter forH Fs
and the leveraged buyout chapter for PE firms. Use those criteria as a starting point
for probing questions like, “What kind of experience does the current management
have?” and “Can you describe the working capital requirements as it relates to the
volatility of the company’s cash flows?” The maximum amount oftime spend on these
questions is probably 15 minutes; ideally you ask a few specific questions that attack
the heart of the situation and then provide a neat explanation ofyour viewpoint.
Potential
Entrants
Substitutes
47
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Consulting
Take, for example, entryinto the copy store market, like Kinko’s. How attractive is the
copy store market?
Potential entrants: What is the threat of new entrants into the market? Copy stores are
not very expensive to open—you can conceivably open a copy store with one copier
and one employee. Therefore, barriers to entry are low, so there’s a high risk of
potential new entrants.
Buyer power: How much bargaining power do buyers have? Copy store customers
are relatively price sensitive. Between the choice ofa copy store that charges 5 cents
a copy and a store that charges 6 cents a copy, buyers will usually head for the
cheaper store. Because copy stores are common, buyers have the leverage to
bargain with copy store owners on large print jobs, threatening to take their business
elsewhere. The only mitigating factors are location and hours. On the other hand,
price is not the only factor. Copy stores that are willing to stay open 24 hours may be
able to charge a premium, and customers may simply patronize the copy store
closest to them ifother locations are relatively inconvenient.
Supplier power: How much bargaining power do suppliers have? While paper prices
may be on the rise, copier prices continue to fall. The skill level employees need to
operate a copy shop (for basic services, like copying, collating, and so on) are
relatively low as well, meaning that employees will have little bargaining power.
Suppliers in this situation have low bargaining power.
Threat of substitutes: What is the risk of substitution? For basic copying jobs, more
people now possess color printers at home. Additionally, fax machines have the
capability of fulfilling copy functions. Large companies will normally have their own
copying facilities. However, for large-scale projects, most individuals and employees
at small companies will still use the services of a copy shop. The internet is a
potential threat to copy stores as well, because some documents that formerly would
be distributed in hard copy will now be posted on the Web or sent through e-mail.
However, for the time being, there is still relatively strong demand for copy store
services.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Production LifeCycle
Dollars
Sales
Profits
Time
Strategic Focus
Big tosmall
When giving an answer, a logical outline always sounds more harmonious during an
interview. Aim for a flowing conversational tone, bulleting each point so the
interviewer can mentally check offthe requisite answers you covered.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
The easiest way to do this is to begin with the most general relevant points and work
to the specifics. Go from macro economics to industry to operations to structural
considerations, leaving out or minimizing whatever is not applicable.
There are additional frameworks that can organize your thoughts. There are many
types; you can read the Vault Guide to Consulting Careers for a more comprehensive
review. However, understanding what constitutes a good investment is the best
framework to use in HF and PE interviews.
Consultingbackgrounds
If you can tell that many of current employees are ex-consultants like PE firms
Audax and Bain Capital, or if the firm’s strategy centers on operational
improvements, beware! You can bet that you’ll get some consulting-focused
questions.
Hit thehighs
It cannot be stressed enough: try to narrow your answer down to the most key
elements as soon as possible. For instance, one large PE firm requested, “Estimate
the annual revenue a pizza shop makes.” Many participants began with bottom-up
approaches, like the average price of a bill * customers, etc. However, the firm
wanted to see if you could identify the “limiting factor,” which was that pizza shops
only have X amount of registers which limits how many customers can be handled at
a time.
When given business scenarios to evaluate, always begin with the biggest value
drivers.
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
Top down approach: Assume that 10 million people live in New York City and that
80 percent of them, or eight million people, eat pizza. Let’s say that the average
New Yorker eats pizza twice a month, and will eat two slices each time. If a slice
of pizza costs $2, then that’s $4 spent at each sitting and $8 spent each month.
That equates to $96 (round to $100 for simplicity) every year. Multiply that by
eight million pizza eaters, and the market size for pizza in New York is
approximately $800 million.
under water means the wood is not oxizable and, thus, doesn’t rot. Ask if there
is already an industry that does this. There is, and it is profitable. Ask about all
the regular factors that comprise a good investment, including the experience of
management. The interviewing firm passed on this opportunity because the
scuba driver had no industry experience. Management is incredibly important
because finance guys need to rely on current management to turn around the
company (relying on equity incentives) or else hire industry experts.
The CEO thinks that SanFrancisco is a great idea, but this new operation
mustbreakeveninfive years.Should HummusPalace expandinto this new
market?
Ask questions about the revenue and cost structure. How much will each tub of
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
hummus cost and how many do they expect to sell? What are the variable and
fixed costs? What are the needed capital expenditures, both maintenance and
growth? What are the working capital needs?
5. You own a Christmas tree business. What are your working capital needs
throughoutthecourse oftheyear?
Inventory would likelyneed to be accumulated starting in November, since many
people start hanging up Christmas lights and putting up Christmas trees the
weekend after Thanksgiving. The inventory buildup would continue through late
December. After Christmas however, demand for Christmas trees disappears.
Hopefully by then there is very little inventory left, if managed properly. Since
this is a cash business, where customers are paying for the trees in cash,
receivables have little effect on the working capital balance and are insignificant
relative to the company’s inventory requirements. Payables would likelyincrease
in the fall as the company accumulates inventory in anticipation ofthe upcoming
holiday season and pays forthe trees with credit.
Whatdoyouthink aboutthepaperphonebookbusiness?
It’s a maturing business, so future growth rate is likely to be negative. It is an
increasingly outdated form of advertising, especially in comparison to the
internet. Also, the growth rate in the U.S. is slowing down due to the aging
population, which further decreases the future growth rate in comparison to the
historical growth rate. The key age demographic to focus on is the elderly, who
may not use other prevalent forms of advertising. The main advantage of a
phone book that it appeals to a niche audience—the local city population who
refers to the phone book to look for local businesses. But the industry continues
to mature rapidly because this niche information is increasingly being uploaded
to the internet. Paper phone books need to take advantage of the internet
channel, which enjoys lowerdistribution costs, and focus on ways to make online
HED GE FUND S
Interview strategy
In theory, all investors have all the available information for public
companies/financial instruments. Generally, a hedge fund aims to beat the overall
market and produce outsized returns. Usually at the cost of being aggressive, some
succeed and others implode.
HFs would love to hire psychics: candidates who could effortlessly tell them which
stocks will go up in the next year, but no one has a crystal ball. So the hardest part
about the HF interview is that your interviewer will grill you on your market opinion
and outlook, but both ofyou may make the wrong predictions.
To ace the interview, have a strong opinion on whatever your interviewer asks about,
but also be prepared to equally argue the opposite side. Furthermore, show depth
over breadth. It’s the tiny tidbits of knowledge that demonstrate your prowess as an
investor.
Enunciate a logical and succinct thought process; quickly separate the big factors
that affect value the most. Always discuss an investment in light ofits rationale,risks,
peers, industry and macroeconomics. Furthermore, remember that anyone can
argue the case for a hypothetical “good” investment, but hedge funds would like to
put their limited amount of money to work in the “best” investments. The best
investments have the lowest risk and highest growth.
Technicalquestions
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Finance: Many ofthe technical questions zero in on the time value ofmoney and
free cash flow. Valuation measures a company’s future cash flows. Unlevered,
free cash flow is the focus ofmany investors because it provides a good measure
of a firm’s ability to generate cash,independent ofits capital structure.
Markets: You will be quizzed on your knowledge of the current market, like
today’s interest rate.
Investment ideas: You may also be asked specific investment ideas, like stock
pitches; this occurs in over 50 percent of interviews. Have at least two ideas
prepared.
55
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Capital Markets (Hedge Funds Only)
Today, the term “hedge fund” tells an investor nothing about the underlying
investment activities, similar to the term “mutual fund.” Technically, a hedge fund is
a private, unregistered investment pool encompassing all types of investment funds,
companies and private partnerships that can use a variety of investment techniques
such as borrowing money through leverage, selling short, derivatives for directional
investing and options.
Given the devastation that the current economic crisis has wreaked on the market,
hedge funds have seen millions to billions of dollars disappear under their
management. Many will cease to exist in the near future (try to suss this out before
taking an offer!) and expect new distressed funds to pop up.
INVESTMENT STRATEGIES
Hedge fund managers utilize a variety of complex and interesting trading strategies.
There are many different ways for managers to value stocks, but that is beyond the
scope of this book; there are many popular trading investment theory books that you
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
can read.
Here is a basic overview of the valuation process that a hedge fund manager or
analyst goes through in picking stocks to invest in.
Valuation process
When an analyst is looking to value a company (to determine what he thinks should
be the correct stock price) he goes through a process to determine what he believes
the stock price to be. This is similar to the process of buying new clothes or buying a
car or house when you figure out how much it is worth to you and how much you are
willing to pay.You are looking forthe best deal available—if a price is above what you
are willing to pay,you do not buy the product; ifthe price is below what you are willing
to pay, you do buy it.
According to Reilly and Brown in their book Investment Analysis and Portfolio
Management, there are two basic approaches to valuing stocks: the “top down” and
the “bottom up” process:
The manager believes that the economy, the stock market and the industry all have a
significant effect on the total returns for stocks
Without going into the complex valuation methodologies, the basic process of
valuation requires estimates of (1) the stream of expected returns and (2) the
required rate of return in the investment. Once the analyst has calculated these
expected returns he can then compute his expected value ofthe stock.
The hedge fund trading strategies aim to maximize investor return while hedging
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Ineichen describes the fixed income manager as one who invests in related fixed
income securities whose prices are mathematically or historically interrelated but the
hedge fund manager believes this relationship will soon change. Because the prices
of these fixed income instruments are based on yield curves, volatility curves,
expected cash flows and other option features, the fixed income managers use
sophisticated analytical models to highlight any potential trading opportunities. When
these sophisticated models highlight relationships of two or more bonds that are out
of line, the manager will buy the undervalued security and sell the overvalued
security.
(Sell T-Bill @ 94.25 (loss of 5 basis points $25 per basis point 10 contracts)
(Buy 10 Eurodollar contracts @ 92.25 = 15 basis points $25 per basis point 10 contracts
Callie’s analysis proved correct when the spread widened to 130 basis points and she
made a profit of $2,500.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Convertible arbitrage
Convertible arbitrage encompasses very technical and advanced hedging strategies.
At its simplest, the hedge fund manager has bought (and holds) a convertible bond
and has sold short the overvalued underlying equities of the same issuer. The
manager identifies pricing inefficiencies between the convertible bond and stock and
trades accordingly.
million Lyondell Chemical Corp convertible bond at 95¾ and sells short 20,000 of
Lyondell Chemical company stock. The bond positions were sold at 101½ and the
common equity was covered at a loss at $14.43. Even though the short position
produced a loss of $18,400, the bonds made $65,521. Overall, Heather made a
profitable trade with an overall gain of $47,121.
NET
$47,121
Statistical arbitrage
Statistical arbitrage encompasses a variety of sophisticated strategies that use
quantitative models to select stocks. The hedge fund manager buys undervalued
stocks and sells short overvalued stocks. This is also referred to as the “black box”
strategy since computer models make many of the trading decisions for the hedge
fund manager.
large basket of stocks to buy and a separate basket to short based on parameters.
The model is used to help predict where the market is going and whether a stock is
over- or under-priced. The model uses various data as inputs (historical stock prices,
liquidity, pricing inefficiencies, etc.) and these are set forth by the manager.
Based on the imputs, the QuantHedge model generates automatic buy or sell orders.
Suzi monitors what the model is doing and notices that the model “HedgeIt” shows
AT&T usually trades at $20 and has recently risen to $24. HedgeIt’s analysis predicts
that the AT&T is overvalued and automatically generates a sell order.These computer
models generate hundreds and thousands oftrade orders each day.
Equitymarketneutral
The most popular statistical arbitrage strategy is equity market neutral. An equity
market neutral strategy (also known as statistical arbitrage) involves constructing
portfolios that consist of approximately equal dollar amounts of offsetting long and
short positions. The equity market neutral strategy is one that attempts to eliminate
market risk by balancing long and short positions equally, usually offsetting total dollar
amount of long positions with an equal dollar position amount of short positions. Net
exposure to the market is reduced because if the market moves dramatically in one
direction, gains in long positions will offset losses in short positions, and vice versa. If
the long positions that were selected are undervalued and the short positions were
overvalued, there should be a net benefit.
Adam is an equity market neutral hedge fund manager. He tries to eliminate market
risk by balancing long and short positions equally.He normally uses futures to totally
eliminate market risk but here is an example where he balances the long and short
equity in the portfolio. Adam believes that shares of AB C are overvalued and XYZ are
undervalued and hopes to offset any dramatic market movements by holding
offsetting equity (total value oflongs—total value ofshores) positions.
Although Adam was wrong on ABC’s price declining, he was correct about XYZ
appreciating. Therefore,he made an overall profit of $500.
Long/shortequity
Long/short equity strategies involve taking both long and short positions in equity.
Unlike market neutral portfolios, long/short equity portfolios will generally have some
net market exposure, usually in the long direction. This means that managers are
“long biased” when they have more exposure to long positions than short. Long/short
fund managers may operate with certain style biases such as value or growth
approaches and capitalization or sector concentrations.
Denver is a long/short equity hedge fund manager whose primary trading strategy
focuses on sector trades. After conducting analysis of the financial condition of G M
and Ford, Denver notices that in the automotive sector,G M is a relatively cheap stock
when compared with Ford. Denver purchases 100 shares of G M because GM is
undervalued relative to the theoretical price (what Denver calculates) and the stock
market is expected to correct the price. Simultaneously, Denver sells short 100 shares
of Ford because Ford is overvalued relative to its theoretical price according to
Denver’s fundamental analysis.
Total $600
Denver predicted that the price of G M would rise and the price of Ford would fall. He
was correct and made a total profit of $600.
Jane works for a distressed debt hedge fund manager. As an analyst it is her
responsibility to evaluate low-grade debt and calculate the probability that it will pay
more when it matures. Jane notices that the low-grade high-yield bonds for
AlmostBankrupt Inc are trading for 20 percent to 30 percent ofpar value. This means
that Jane would pay 20 to 30 cents on the dollar for the AlmostBankrupt Inc, bond.
After careful evaluation, Jane believes that the bonds will appreciate or have a high
percentage chance ofpaying full par at maturity.
Jane was correct and when she decided to sell, the bonds were selling for 25 percent
more at 25 cents on the dollar. But Jane sees that many ofthese bonds won’t pay off
the full par value. By constructing a diversified portfolio of high yield bonds the
manager reduces the risk ofthe portfolio through diversification.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Commodities
Increasingly, hedge funds have been investing in commodities. Indeed, hedge funds
were blamed for the sharp 2005 increase in natural gas futures—and the subsequent
burst bubble in 2006 that prompted Amaranth Advisors LLC to go out of business.
Most of the time, hedge funds simply see commodity trading as yet another tool for
hedging against risk and increasing returns. They trade commodity futures much like
any other investor. Hedge funds’ success in commodities trading in the first half of
the decade prompted major investment firms like Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley
to bolster theirown energy trading operations.
Currencies
Hedge funds have taken to playing the currency markets as another way to find
alpha. Investing in foreign equities or bonds often require that investment to be made
in local currency. In a good investment, the fund will not only see returns based on
the investment itself, but also in a beneficial exchange rate.
In recent years, hedge funds and other investors have also used the carry trade to
boost returns. In this scenario, a hedge fund hoping to leverage a trade will borrow
money from a bank in a country that has a low interest rate—Japan has been a
particular favorite in the past few years. With the benchmark rate in the U.S. at 5
percent and Japan’s at 1 percent, that generally means a 400-basis-point difference.
Currencies example
For example, CarryTrade Hedge Fund wants to buy up Company XYZ stock and use
leverage to do so. It has $10 million and wants to borrow another $40 million in
leverage.If it were to borrow in the U.S., it might have to pay 10 percent on the loan,
or $4 million. But in Japan, the loan only has 6 percent interest, or $2.4 million. So
on top ofwhateverprofit it makes on the trade,the fund saves $1.6 million in interest.
And ifit plays its cards right,it can also gain a few hundred thousand dollars by timing
the currency market right.
Private equity
As hedge funds are playing an increasingly important role in taking companies
private. At times they partner with more traditional private equity firms, while other
times they’ll buy up the bonds used as leverage in the buyout, or even directlyextend
credit to the buyers in exchange fora stake in the company. The returns are generally
longer-term than most hedge funds are used to, so only the biggest hedge funds
generally engage in any private equity plays.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Real estate
Hedge funds have increasingly invested in hard assets, particularly real estate.
Commercial real estate, in particular, has remained strong despite the downturn in
the residential housing market in the United States. Commercial leasing can provide
steady returns for hedge funds, which can hedge against risks in other markets. And
commercial real estate has generally appreciated in value far more consistently than
residential holdings.
Event-driven
An “event-driven” fund is a fund that utilizes an investment strategy that seeks to
profit from special situations or price fluctuations. Various styles or strategies may be
simultaneously employed. Strategy may be changed as deemed appropriate – there
is no commitment to any particular style or asset class. The manager invests both
Visit the Vault Finance Career Channel at www.vault.com/finance —with
insider firm profiles, message boards, the Vault Finance Job Board and more. 63
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Capital Markets (Hedge Funds Only)
long and short in equities or fixed income of companies that are expected to change
due to an unusual event.
Event-driven example
Rob is an event-driven manager who invests in companies that are going through
various restructures. Rob and his team at EventsRUs hedge fund analyze many
company balance sheets and research industries to find any news that could affect
the price of the companies’ stocks. These events include: corporate restructurings
(mergers, acquisitions, and spin-offs), stock buy-backs, bond upgrades, and
earnings surprises.
Rob has noticed that the market is predicting poor sales for AutoZone (AZO) for the
fourth quarter. Ro b has researched the company and noticed that while the industry
is doing well, other analysts are not pricing in price improvements. He therefore
makes a decision to buy AZO under the premise that they will surprise at earnings
and the stock price will go up.
Sector
Sector strategies invest in a group of companies/segment of the economy with a
common product or market. The strategy combines fundamental financial analysis
with industry experience to identify best profit opportunities in the sector. Examples
could be the health care, technology, financial services or energy sectors.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Sector example
Denver is a long/short equity hedge fund manager whose primary trading strategy
focuses on sector trades. After conducting analysis of the financial condition of G M
and Ford, Denver notices that in the automotive sector,G M is a relatively cheap stock
when compared with Ford. Denver purchases 100 shares of G M because G M is
undervalued relative to the theoretical price (what Denver calculates) and the stock
market is expected to correct the price. Simultaneously,Denver sells short 100 shares
of Ford because Ford is overvalued relative to its theoretical price according to
Denver’s fundamental analysis.
Total $600
Global macro
Global macro is a style of hedge fund strategy that trades based upon macro
economic or “top-down” analysis. Normally the securities are global stock index
futures, bond futures, and currencies.
The global macro manager constructs his portfolio based on a macro top-down view
of the global economic trends. He will consider interest rates, economic policies,
exchange rates, inflation etc., and seek to profit from changes in the value of entire
asset classes. An example of a trade would be to purchase U.S. dollar futures while
shorting Eurodollar futures. By doing this, a hedge fund manager is indicating that he
believes that the U.S. dollar is undervalued but the Eurodollar is overvalued.
Short selling
The short selling manager maintains a consistent net short exposure in his/her
portfolio, meaning that significantly more capital supports short positions than is
invested in long positions (if any is invested in long positions at all). Unlike long
positions, which one expects to rise in value, short positions are taken in those
securities the manager anticipates will decrease in value. Short selling managers
typically target overvalued stocks, characterized by prices they believe are too high
given the fundamentals of the underlying companies.
Amy is a trader for a hedge fund that focuses primarily on short selling. During the
late 1990s dot-com bubble there were many opportunities for short selling
tremendously overpriced securities. Amy sold short Yahoo
(YHOO) at $60 and has maintained the position until today. She has made a
handsome profit since Yahoo currently trades at $48.
Amy believes that the companies that are prime examples for short selling are those
whose stock market values greatly exceed theirfundamental values.
Emerging markets
Emerging market investing involves investing in securities issued by businesses
and/or governments of countries with less developed economies that have the
potential for significant future growth.
the HK dollar (HKD), believing that the yuan will appreciate relative to the HKD.
Merger arbitrage
Merger arbitrage involves the investing of event-driven situations of corporations;
examples are leveraged buy-outs, mergers, and hostile takeovers. Managers
purchase stock in the firm being taken over and, in some situations, sell short the
stock ofthe acquiring company.
Mike offers one share of Company A, trading at $105, for each share of Company B
stock, currently trading at $80. Following the merger announcement, Company B’s
stock rises to $100 per share. Mike buys Company stock B at $100 and sells short
Company A shares at $105 in an equal to the exchange ratio—in this case 1-to-1. As
the merger date approaches, the $5 spread will narrow as the prices of Company B
and Company A stocks converge. When the spread narrows, Mike’s profits grow—
for example, if Company B stock rises to $101 and Company A falls to $98, Mike
earns $1 on Company B (the long investment)and $7 on Company A (the short).
Mike’s risk is that the deal will not go through and Company B’s share price will drop
back to $80 resulting in a substantial loss forhim.
Value-driven
Value-driven is a primarily equity-based strategy whereby the manager compares the
price of a security relative to the intrinsic worth of the underlying business. The
manager often selects stocks for which he or she can identify a potential upcoming
event that will result in the stock price changing to more accurately reflect the
company’s intrinsic worth.
Value-driven example
Multi-strategy
A multi-strategy manager typically utilizes two or three specific, predetermined
investment strategies, e.g., value, aggressive growth, and special situations. This
gives the investor access to multiple strategies with one investment. These funds also
allow the manager to shift between strategies so that he can make the most money.
This is similar to a situation in which a merger arbitrage manager left his investment
mandate broad enough so that he could invest in distressed debt if the opportunity
arose. Multi-strategy funds can offset some of the risk ofone strategy doing poorly by
employing other strategies simultaneously.
Like other hedge funds, funds of funds are organized as onshore or offshore entities
that are limited partnership or corporations with the general partner receiving the
management and/orperformance fee.
Funds of funds can offer an effective way for an investor to gain exposure to a range
of hedge funds and strategies without having to commit substantial assets or
resources to the specific asset allocation, portfolio construction and individual hedge
fund selection. The objective is to smooth out the potential inconsistency of the
returns from having all ofthe assets invested in a single hedge fund.
A growing number of style or category specific funds of funds have been launched
during the past few years; for example, funds offunds that invest only in event-driven
managers or funds of funds that invest only in equity market neutral style managers.
The funds of hedge funds now control roughly 35 to 40 percent of the hedge fund
market and have grown at up to 40 percent every year since 1997. This allocation
creates a diverse vehicle and provides investors with access to managers that they
may not be able to utilize on their own. A particular benefit of this type of investment
is the abilityto establish a diversified alternative investment program at a substantially
lower minimum investment than would be required were an investor to invest with
each of the hedge fund managers separately.
INVESTMENT CRITERIA
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
What makes a good investment? Answer this incorrectly and consider yourself toast.
Specific criteria vary by investment strategy, but here are some general rules if you’re
going long on a traditional stock.
Earnings growth
As a rule, think of investments as a seesaw with growth at one end and risk at the
other. You want earnings growth to be as high as possible, but not surpassed by risk.
Note, we say “earnings” growth if we are the equity holder; we care about what cash
flows to us because debt holders are in line before us to collect on interest. However,
all investors carefully monitor unlevered free cash flow to the firmas a proxy for cash
flow and to evaluate the underlying business.
Have a clear view on the expected growth. You may evaluate it based on the
company’s historical growth rate,peer historical and projected growth rates,expected
growth of the macroeconomics, growth of the market the company services, analyst
estimates and more.
Industry
Determine the attractiveness and competition of the industry. You can use Porter’s
Five Forces as outlined in Chapter 7: Consulting as a beginning point to ask
questions. The key factors are to look at the growth of the industry, consolidation,
intensity ofcompetition, pricing power and differentiation of products.
The growth of the industry is heavily dependent on the product life cycle (page 49).
Businesses that are maturing will have a much lower future growth rate than new
industries; it’s important to take note of this when observing the historical growth rate
of companies. However, don’t discredit maturing firms as they can be cash cows with
lowerlevels ofrisk. Entrepreneurial players willalso develop strategies to revitalize the
industry, like mobile firms switching to 3G networks.
Consolidation refers to companies in the same industry merging. This creates bigger
players who enjoy a competitive advantage that puts pressure on smaller peers.
Economies of scale will lower their prices and brand recognition will increase their
volumes. Consolidation is a sign of a maturing industry—growth now comes from
increases in market share versus industry growth. Rather than the pie getting bigger,
competition intensifies to gain a bigger slice. Some HFs screen for takeover
candidates to enjoy the quick stock price boost from an acquirer’s purchase
premium.
The spread between revenue and cost of goods sold is known as profit margin.
Buying power determines the ease of which price can be adjusted. It is a function of
supply and demand. Kopi Luwak is a type of coffee that can go for up to $300 per
pound because supply is so limited; it is made from coffee beans excreted by a small
mammal, the palm civet, which is indigenous to Indonesia. The cross of supply and
demand applies to suppliers as well. Also, size matters; the bigger the firm, the more
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Competitive advantage
Appraise whether the company is better or worse than its peers. Clear evidence
includes patents, exclusive contracts, brand or product differentiation, low/efficient
cost structure and superior management. Companies usually disclose this
information in annual reports. You can evaluate management based on their
experience, which is disclosed, and big hedge funds will regularly keep in direct
contact with senior management.
Capital structure
Know your place. If you are a common equity holder, you have unlimited upside but
you are last in line to collect money in liquidation. The more people (more = number
and size) in front of you decreases the likelihood you’ll be paid back in case of
bankruptcy. At the same time, you want a certain level of debt so that the company
is appropriately minimizing its cost of capital.
Risk
Look at all the previous factors and determine where everything can go wrong.
Understand the volatility of the industry and recognize that new competitors can
come in quickly, leaving existing companies in the dust. Regardless of how great an
individual company is, the overall economy and government intervention can shut it
all down in a heartbeat.
Valuation
Now take everything and attempt to affix a value to it. Given its prospects, is the
company a good value? If its price already reflects its growth, plus more, then it may
not be. Consider your entry and exit prices. Going long on equity usually means
screening for undervalued companies or taking a bet on future positive events.
Portfolio considerations
Maybe you really like Yahoo!now but already have 30 percent ofyour money invested
in Google. This increases your risk in the tech sector. Depending on your strategy
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
KEEP SHARP
Preparing your own investment pitches will sharpen your interviewing mindset. Read
research reports and other market commentary to gain knowledge depth. Even
better, track the interviewing firm’s portfolio.
Tracka hedgefundportfolio
13F: Institutional investment managers disclose their holdings on a quarterly
basis to the SEC with the 13F form. This applies toany manager overseeing over
$100 million. Note that this only applies toequity holdings, so funds specializing
in commodities, foreign markets, derivatives, etc., will be tougher to track.
Modeling test
You may need to create a model for a formal test or for your own investment ideas.
You’ll rely mostly on DCF and trading comparables, plus any other valuation
methodologies that are popular for the company’s peer group. Some research
analysts offer their research models to investors; if you can access or buy these,
definitely take a look.
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
by analysts that you won’t find anything new in a weekend. Based on the current
depression, throw out the luxury retailer and hotel chain. Before the work day
ends, call up research analysts at various investment banks for as much
information as you can get, like research reports, comps and their personal
opinions. After reviewing that information plus historical stock price charts,
company filings, and recent news, you’ll want to call those contacts up again to
answer any more questions that may have arisen. Now, hopefully, you’ve
eliminated a lot more companies. After discussing what the general steps are to
evaluating an investment, you’ll want to ask your interviewer questions that will
help you narrow the field more. The answer isn’t exactly which two industries
you pick—it is the depth and breadth of your thinking process. A slam dunk
answer incorporates industry-specific knowledge.
Again, this tests your breadth and depth of knowledge in various industries.
You’ll want to be more specific than whatever answer can be provided in this
guide. The general key thing to look for in retail is its strategy of product
differentiation and the sustainability ofthat strategy (zero in on competitors). For
tech, what is the growth of its industry or market share (zero in on longevity of
product life). For pharma, measure the current patents in terms of years to
expiration, and note the level of development of drugs in its pipeline. Really in
all three, you’re looking for the same investment criteria, but this question tests
whether you can talk the talk, so brush up on your industry lingo.
Once you have found the strategy that the fund is pursuing, research the current
environment of the fund. For example, if it is a merger arbitrage strategy, look to
find any recent announced mergers and prepare to discuss your opinions.
7. Youareontheboardofdirectorsofacompanyandownasignificantchunk of
thecompany. TheCEO, inhisannualpresentation,states that thecompany’s
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
9. Whatis meantbytheterm“securitieslending”?
This is the loan of a security from one broker/dealer to another, who must
eventually return the same security as repayment. The loan is often
collateralized. Securities lending allows a broker/dealer in possession of a
particular security to earn enhanced returns on the security through finance
charges.
interestcoverage,maximumleverage),whichoneis themostimportant?
Minimum EBITDA because EBITDA is the basis ofvaluation, and ifthe company
can’t make its EBITDA covenant, it’s a signal that there might be something
operationally wrong with the company. A company can sell assets to pay down
debt and reduce interest expense, but that will not solve underlying business
problems.
15. The current one year interest spot rate is 5.2 percent and the six-month
interest spot rate is 5.4 percent. What is the implied forward rate for the
secondhalfoftheyear?
The rate over the first six months and second half of the year must average out
to give 5.2 percent for the full year. So 5.2 percent = (5.4 percent + unknown
forward rate)/2, which solves to 5.0 percent. The spot rate is the price that is to
be paid immediately (settles in one to two business days). In contrast, forward
rates are the projected spot rates, which can fluctuate based on the market.
Basically, buying a forward means you’re locking in a price now for future
settlement, though the true spot rate that settles then may be different.
The basicdefinition
A leveraged buyout (“LBO”) employs financial leverage to acquire a company. Often,
the assets of the acquired company are used as collateral for the debt; then the
bought-out business generates cash flows, which are used to pay down the debt.
LBOs allow private equity firms to make large acquisitions without having to commit a
lot of capital (equity).
The most popular type of LBO buys a public company, which then is quoted as a
company going “private.” The rationale is that a company can be more valuable as a
private company. Perhaps the public markets are undervaluing it, or management
can be more effective without the scrutiny of quarterly earnings reports to public
shareholders. Moreover, the burden of governance, like Sarbanes-Oxley, is removed,
which frees up time and resources.
When successful, LBOs generate high return because, as the equity holder, the
sponsor receives all the benefits of any capital gains (while debt holders have a fixed
return). Leverage magnifies these gains, allowing private equity firms to make
outsized returns on investments in boom cycles.
Today, the current credit freeze and economic decline have significantly decreased
LBO prospects. Additionally, the changing political climate will affect the way private
equity is defined.
THE BEGINNING
The history of private equity can be traced back to 1901, when J.P. Mo rgan—the
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
man, not the institution—purchased Carnegie Steel Co. from Andrew Carnegie and
Henry Phipps for $480 million. Phipps took his share and created, in essence, a
private equity fund called the Bessemer Trust. Today the Bessemer Trust is more
private bank than private equity firm, but Phipps and his children started a trend of
buying exclusive rights to up-and-coming companies—or buying them outright.
Yet, although there were pools of private money in existence between the turn of the
century and through the 1950s, these were primarily invested in startups, much like
today’s venture capital firms. The notion of a private buyout of an established public
company remained foreign to most investors until 1958, when President Dwight D.
Eisenhower signed the Small Business Act of 1958. That provided government loans
to private venture capital firms, allowing them to leverage theirown holdings to make
bigger loans to startups—the first real leveraged purchases.
79
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Leveraged Buyouts (Private Equity Only)
Soon, other companies started playing with the idea of leverage. Lewis B. Cullman
made the first modern leveraged buyout in 1964 through the purchase of the Orkin
Exterminating Co. Others followed,but the trend quickly died by the early 1970s. For
one, the government raised capital gains taxes, making it more difficult for KKR and
other nascent firms to attract capital. Pension funds were restricted by Congress in
1974 from making “risky” investments—and that included private equity funds.
Carl Icahn made a name for himself as a corporate raider with his LBO of TWA
Airlines in 1985, and KKR raised private equity’s visibilityto a new high with the $31.4
billion acquisition ofRJR Nabisco in 1988.
This was a time of growing pains for private equity as well as intense success. Many
firms realized that they couldn’t act in a bubble, as KKR found out with a ton of
negative publicity surrounding the RJR Nabisco deal. Tom Wolfe’s The Bonfire of the
Vanities gave all of Wall Street a black eye, and Gordon Gecko’s “Greed is good”
mantra from Wall Street was pinned on private equity firms as a whole. B y the time
the 1990-1991 recession took hold, private equity firms resumed a low profile,
waiting forthe next boom.
But at the same time, venture capital was on the rise, fueling a surge of new
companies. As one venture capitalist put it at the time, “Look, I’ll throw $1 million at
10 different companies. If one company succeeds, that’ll bring me $50 million. So
it’s worth it in the end.” So the major private equity firms shifted gears and
participated in the boom through startup funding. LBOs still occurred, but at far less
impressive levels than in the 1980s.
Amaturing industry
The dot-com bust of 2000-2001 brought the markets back to reality and unearthed
new opportunities for private equity firms. Some firms swept in to buy good
companies on the cheap, waiting forthe bust mentality to pass before returning them
to market. Others simply enjoyed the fire sale, and bought technology and patents for
resale, dismantling the failed companies in the process.
By 2003, the market had returned to a bull cycle, but with some notable changes.
Congress had enacted the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, which tightened regulations on public
companies and what they could say and do. The new bull market was very much
focused on companies “hitting their numbers” instead oflong-terminvestment in new
business. Those pressures combined to make private buyouts seem attractive to
potential target companies.
Furthermore, the rise of hedge funds created a great deal of wealth that needed new
homes, and broadened the number of potential investors in private equity. Soon,
newly wealthy individuals, hedge funds and major Wall Street institutions were all
piling into private equity, and the firms enjoyed even more success, leveraging their
newfound capital into major multibillion-dollar deals. The record RJR Nabisco buyout
was eclipsed twice in 2007 alone.
THE S U M M E R OF 2007
Early on, 2007 was shaping up to be a remarkable year for private equity firms.
Private investors LBO’ed the nation’s largest utility, TXU Corp., in a record $44.3
billion private buyout that had the heads of Blackstone and KKR gladhanding
members of the Texas Legislature in what many saw as a symbol for private equity’s
increasing clout.
Then, in the summer, the whole private equity wave came crashing down. And it
wasn’t even the firms’ fault. LBOs became the latest victim of the housing and
mortgage crisis.
Whereit began
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Ever since the dot-com crash and subsequent recession of 2000-2002, investors
disillusioned with high-flying stocks started investing in tangible assets, mostly real
estate. B y 2004, the condo-flipping craze was in full swing. Prices had soared
considerably in just three to four years—threefold in places like Los Angeles, Las
Vegas and Miami. The national banking system helped fuel the craze with mortgages
supported by historically low interest rates and relatively easy terms.
But in June 2004, the Federal Reserve started raising interest rates, which went from
1 percent at the start of 2004 to 5.25 percent in July of 2006, where they remained.
Yet housing prices continued to climb as speculators jumped in and out of house
purchases. That left the average homeowner struggling to afford a home. In
response, mortgage lenders started pushing unusual mortgage products—everything
from 50-year mortgages to interest-only, adjustable-rate loans. And because home
prices had been on such a strong trajectory, many banks relaxed their lending
requirements for“subprime” mortgages—loans to high-risk, poor-credit borrowers.
The reasoning was that even these borrowers could refinance once theirhome prices
appreciated substantially.
The fall
The irrational exuberance in housing started falling apart in spring and summer
2006, when prices leveled off and luxury homebuilders, responsible for half-filled
communities ofMcMansions around the country,started lowering the profit forecasts.
Housing prices evened out, then started falling in the majority of cities around the
country. And all of those adjustable-rate mortgages began adjusting higher. Without
the expected jump in home value, many borrowers, especially those with subprime
mortgages, couldn’t refinance and were stuck with payments they could no longer
afford.
The effect of all of the late payments, loan defaults and home foreclosures wasn’t
limited to mortgage brokers and banks. Many mortgage lenders packaged their loans
into mortgage-backed securities—bonds backed by the expected inflow of payments
from borrowers as well as the value of the homes mortgaged. But with borrowers
defaulting and home prices falling, the value of these bonds dried up. And the big
banks and hedge funds holding this paper found themselves hit hard. Bear Stearns
had to close two billion-dollar hedge funds in June because of the hit these bonds
took, and Goldman Sachs spent $2 billion of its own money in August to prop up
another fund.
And, of course, both hedge funds and majorbanks were hit not only with depreciating
mortgage-backed securities, but also a severe correction in the equity markets and
bond yields that finally normalized afternearly two years ofinversion.
Squeeze down
This resulted in a general tightening of credit. Nearly all major investment banks had
mortgage-backed investments, and those with consumer arms also felt the pinch
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
from mortgage defaults. Hedge funds, the other major source of leverage, faced the
bond and equity problems, along with increased redemptions from worried investors.
The effects were seen as early as June, as Cerberus Capital Partners had difficulty
borrowing the $12 billion needed to buy the Chrysler Group. It got the financing, but
at less beneficial terms than it had thought. And it’s unlikely that the new ownership
will find underwriters to help lever Chrysler’s dwindling assets for investor payoffs, let
alone the capital the struggling automaker needs to keep making cars.
Many deals were unable to close after the credit markets froze over. The media
watched several unravel given the financing and market conditions, such as J.C.
Flowers’s venture forSallie Mae and Blackstone’s deal forAlliance Data Systems.
“It's tough to do an LBO without ‘L,’” said Greg Ledford, managing director at private
equity firm The Carlyle Group. “Along with the industry, Carlyle is spending a lot of
time just on our portfolios to make sure they can ride out the economic slump.”
Future prospects
The defeated market has significant dropped prices, making many asset valuations
attractive. However, the problem of nonexistent credit lingers. The year 2009 will be
tough, but there’s still money in the funds to be put to work. Restructuring
opportunities will be a main focus, and deals will probably be smaller and perhaps
shifted to emerging markets.
Given the market, it may be tough to be overly bullish on private equity firms right
now. But historically, even during the worst market cycles of the last three decades,
private equity firms remained busy, buying companies and generally going about their
business. Like most things on Wall Street, private equity experiences boom and bust
cycles. The boom since 2003 has been unprecedented, and private equity investors,
management and employees made billions. Private equity firms will likely make what
acquisitions they can, and then scale back fund raising and operations fora few years
until things improve again. They won’t be going away...just retrenching.
Creating afund
Private equity firms can have multiple funds running at the same time. Some are
specialized, say in distressed debt or venture capital, while others are simply giant
pools of cash the firm can use for any investment it sees fit. To create a fund, of
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
And of course, the managing directors and ownership of the private equity firm also
puts capital into any given fund. For successful private equity investors, that can be
valued at several hundred million dollars.
All of these sources of capital, pooled together, create the private equity fund. Major
private equity firms can have more than $10 billion in assets, though outside a
handful ofthese top firms, such funds tend to be in the $2 billion to $5 billion range.
Why invest?
The funds operate much like a mutual fund, in that each participant or entity receives
a return on its investment commensurate with the performance of the fund and how
much each institution put in. Yet there are notable differences. Private equity firms
require major commitments of time for each investment—you can’t get your money
back for anywhere from three to five years, for starters. That’s roughly the same
lifespan ofa major private equity investment, and the private equity firm won’t be able
to execute on its strategy without assurance that the money will be there.
Depending on the kind of fund, there may be regular payouts for its investors, but in
many cases, investors may have to wait the full term before getting their returns. It’s
because of this wait, in part, that private equity investors start levering up their new
acquisitions almost immediately upon purchase. Yes, some of the capital is used to
expand the business and make the changes that will bring about greater profits—but
some is used simply to give investors a chunk of their money back shortly after the
investment is made.
Finding atarget
Research
Once a fund is created, the private equity firm then needs to find appropriate
investments. Depending on the market environment, the time this takes can vary
between weeks and years. Until a target is found, the fund’s resources are generally
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
put into relatively safe investments, such as high-grade corporate bonds, blue-chip
equities or Treasuries.
Private equity firms are constantly researching possible investments, even before the
funds are created. These possibilities, in part, are major selling points for potential
investors, who need to be reassured that the fund can put theircapital into action as
efficiently as possible.
Few private equity firms have the kind of massive staff of analysts on hand to do
research on the bulk of publicly traded companies around the globe. Instead, they
depend on the major investment banks for basic research, then go through daily
reports with a fine-toothed comb for signs of possible investment. Some potential
targets are easy to spot—the companies that put themselves up for sale, will attract
interest, though these are by no means certain. Some companies may simply not be
worth the time and money needed to turn them around. Even among publicly traded
companies, there’s such a thing as a bad company.
There are also companies that privately court private equity bidders. Generally, these
contacts aren’t made via press release, but are done quietly, with the head of M&A
for a major Wall Street firm making a call to a private equity firm’s managing director.
Often,the company’s books are laid open to the private equity firm’s researchers, who
can then determine if there are enough efficiencies to be gleaned to make an
acquisition worthwhile.
And that’s the key to the entire research process—creating value. The private equity
firm’s demonstrated expertise must fit well with the target company’s opportunities,
and there must be a relativelyquick “fix” that will bring the fund’s shareholders value
within the three- to five-year time frame. Most firms have several dozen potential
opportunities on their “wish list” at any given time, just waiting for the last few pieces
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
of the puzzle to fit into the investment scheme. Sometimes it’s a question of an
anticipated failure in a division, other times it’s simply waiting for the stock price to
fall enough to make a deal worthwhile.
When the opportunity seems ripe, the researchers and deal makers work together to
create a buyout offer. This offer doesn’t simply include a per-share price, but rather
is a detailed plan for the co mpany over the life of the buyout firm’s involvement. To a
degree, it includes the areas in which the private equity firm can bring additional
value to the company, as well as how much the firm plans to invest in the company’s
operations. Not all the cards are laid out on the table, however. “You don’t want to
just spell out exactly how they can unlock billions in value,” says one longtime private
equity negotiator, who asked not to be identified for fear of giving those across the
table from him an advantage. “You want to tell them the value is there, and maybe
lowball it some, but you want them believing that you’re the only one who can dig it
out.”
For one, private equity buyouts, in many cases, preserve the target company’s
identity; it’s not getting swallowed up by a larger rival. They also give current
management an opportunity to right the ship without the scrutiny that comes from
being a publicly traded company. Since the dot-com bubble burst in 2000-2002,
many investors have become increasingly insistent that companies “make their
numbers” each quarter, surpassing quarterly revenue and profit estimates from Wall
Street analysts. If they miss estimates, the stock is punished—sometimes severely.
Privately, some CEOs have complained that the drive to make their numbers has
hampered their ability to make the necessary long-term investments to drive long-
term growth of their businesses. Instead, they hit their numbers and store up cash
on their balance sheets to use in share buyback programs and higher dividends to
appease public shareholders.
And for companies not so healthy, a buyout can be a boon in other ways. For one,
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
the infusion of capital from private equity owners can bring about big changes in a
short amount of time. Private ownership can also handle the more unpopular chores
related to a turnaround, including layoffs and dealing with past creditors. The private
ownership can also help top managers save face, especially if they were responsible
for distressing the company in the first place. A top manager whose policies may
have failed can still leave with his or her reputation intact by creating shareholder
value for a buyout, usually by getting a bid with a hefty premium over the current
share price. The fact that said management also leaves with a nice golden parachute
is also compelling.
Once negotiations start, agreeing to a rough framework of a deal can take months,
but in reality is a two- to four-week process—private equity firms choose their targets
carefully, after all. Once an agreement in principle is reached, it’s announced to the
general public and the target’s management gets to enjoy the subsequent boost in
share price. From there, months of additional negotiations take place, during which
time the private equity firm gets a complete accounting of the company’s operations
and financial health, and the final details on layoffs, compensation, operational
adjustments and finances are all ironed out. The deal then goes to the target’s
shareholders for approval. Once that happens, the private equity firm pays each
shareholder the agreed-upon amount per share, and the company officially becomes
a private entity owned by the takeover firm.
Getting financing
You may have already noted that the major deals announced in 2007 are far greater
in value than the total value of a typical private equity fund. Welcome to the world of
private equity financing, which puts the “leverage” back in leveraged buyout.
It’s rare that a private equity firm will simply buy a company outright with its own
money. For one, even the biggest private equity fund could only manage to buy a
company on the small end of the large-cap scale. And as any fund manager will tell
you, it’s never wise to put all your money into a single investment. So instead, the
money that private equity firms raise is, essentially, seed money. To get the rest,
private equity firms enlist banks and hedge funds.
Loans
There are plenty of different ways to raise leverage. The first is a simple bank loan—
simple, of course, ifyou consider $10 billion a simple sum ofmoney. But, in essence,
the private equity firmpromises to repay the bank the money borrowed with a certain
amount of interest. This is generally backed by either the private equity firm’s own
resources or, more likely, the value of the enterprise to be purchased. In theory, if the
firm defaults on the loan, the bank can go after the purchased company and/or the
firm itself. In reality, this rarelyhappens; if there’s a problem, the two sides iron out a
solution that, sometimes, can even involve the bank pouring more money into the
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Sometimes these loans are simply that: loans from a bank. In many other cases, the
private equity firm will float a corporate bond, based on the perceived value of the
enterprise to be purchased. In fact, over the past few years, private equity firms have
sought to lever up their new companies as much as possible. That’s not simply
because they want as much capital as they can get to expand the companies. At
least some of that leverage goes back to the private equity fund as a “special
dividend” for the people who just bought the company. Much of that new debt stays
on the target company’s books throughout the private takeover period and on through
the exit strategy.
Here’s an example, admittedly somewhat extreme, of how financing works. The Ford
Motor Co. sold car rental chain Hertz Inc. to Clayton, Dubilier & Rice, The Carlyle
Group and Merrill Lynch Global Private Equity for $5.6 billion in September 2005.
The three private equity funds put up $2.3 billion—the rest came from debt that
Visit the Vault Finance Career Channel at www.vault.com/finance —with
insider firm profiles, message boards, the Vault Finance Job Board and more. 87
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Leveraged Buyouts (Private Equity Only)
ended up on Hertz’ balance sheet. Indeed, shortly after the sale, the private equity
firms got $1 billion back in dividends. Ten months later, Hertz Global Holdings was
re-introduced to the marketplace in an initial public offering that raised roughly $5
billion. The three private equity firms logged a $4 billion paper profit on the deal
through more special dividends and, it should be noted, about $100 million in fees
charged by the private equity firms! Hertz is still paying off the debt used by the
private equity firms to buy the company in the first place.
Over the past three to four years, private equity firms have increasingly paired up with
hedge funds, essentially coming together with pools of private capital to buy out a
company. The hedge fund, instead of getting a fixed amount for its investment, will
often go along for the ride, hoping for the same outsized returns the private equity
investors will get.
Unlockingthecompany’svalue
Some companies may not need to be “fixed,” per se, but the whole reason they were
brought private was because the private equity investors saw ways to unlock
increased value within the company that wasn’t being used. In the next one to five
years, the private equity investors go to work on leaving the company, ideally, in a
better state than they found it.
Leaving theirmark
A company bought out by a private equity firm won’t notice what happened the day
after the deal closes, but within a year, the firm will have left an indelible mark on the
company. Inefficient processes are tossed out without a second thought, activities
and supply chains are streamlined, the company’s workforce is often cut back (at
least through attrition if not outright layoffs), and new initiatives and, in some cases,
new products are introduced.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
The firm’s role in this stage of the process is to set definitive goals for improvement
and lead the company to make those goals a reality. Targets are set—often during
the deal-making process—and are reached through the leadership of the private
equity firm’s consultants and hand-picked managers. There are often those within
the newly private company who will bemoan the changes; they’re generally the ones
who will be shown the exits first. Private equity firms have neither the time nor the
inclination to be sentimental about their new purchases, and thus the changes that
take place can be jarring and drastic. A good private equity firm, however, will take
the time to get the employees to buy into the new program, which helps everyone—
the employees keep their jobs and feel good about change, while the private equity
firm gets a quicker and more efficient outcome.
Pulling it off
There are, of course, an infinite number of ways to unlock value in a given company.
Retail chains are popular targets of late be cause underperforming outlets can be
closed and the real estate sold. (There was talk that Toys “R” Us would be shuttered
entirely by private equity owners since the company’s real estate was actually worth
more than the toy business. The Times Square property alone would’ve been a
billion-dollar parcel.) Industrial companies can be improved with new machinery and
tighter supply chains. Payrolls can be reduced, debt can be restructured and a
variety of expenses can be cut through using different vendors or items. New
customers and contracts are pursued.
Alternatively, the “fix” may involve disbanding the company, either in part or
altogether.Smaller conglomerates tend to be unwieldy—so why not focus on the core
business and sell off the other divisions? Perhaps there just aren’t enough synergies
within the company, so the divisions can be sold off to rivals. So long as it generates
capital or the potential of higher profit down the road, the private equity firm will do
whatever it takes.
Sale
In an outright sale, the “fixed up” company is sold to someone else, generally a larger
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Alternatively, the private equity firm may opt for a sum-of-its-parts strategy, selling off
the company piecemeal. This is particularly popular when a private equity firm
purchases a distressed or even bankrupt company that has more than one operating
unit. The units can be broken apart and sold to competitors, who are likely to pay a
premium to buy up market share at the expense of a one-time rival. Some private
equity firms will even purchase a company solely forthe purpose of merging part of it
with another portfolio company to strengthen the latter, and then sell off the rest of
the former company. This is, of course, a necessarily broad overview of how private
equity deals work. There are many private equity funds that specialize in distressed
debt, early-stage venture capital investing and other wrinkles. But ultimately, the
roles and the process are generally the same.
IPOs
The IPO route is quite similar to that of any other company seeking to go public. The
private equity firm hires an investment bank to underwrite the offering. The
investment bank does an assessment of what it thinks the enterprise is now worth;
ideally, the private equity firm has brought enough value to the company to make it
worth more than the initial purchase price. The private equity owners and investment
bank come to a consensus ofvalue, and then the company goes on a junket with the
investment bank, giving institutional investors and Wall Street analysts a “road show”
to discuss how much the company has improved and what it’s worth now—and, of
course, what it will be worth in the years to come. Ultimately, the company sets an
offering price and a date, and stock is floated. Generally, the private equity firms will
retain large chunks ofequityin the company, floating anywhere from 20 to 90 percent
of the stock on the open market. The proceeds of the IPO usually go to the private
equity firms. Sometimes the firms will float only a minority of the outstanding shares,
leaving them with effective control of the company. The private equity firm may
unwind its position in time, of course. Other times, the firm is simply interested in
getting out with as much money as possible. It may hold on to a stake to see how
much it appreciates, however, building even more value forits own stakeholders.
Private equity firms are partial to IPOs because they bring about returns in several
stages. When the firm releases stock to the public, it receives the returns. It then gets
to see its remaining stake appreciate, and can participate in dividend and stock
buyback programs as well.
Recapitalization
Recapitalization refinances the capital structure so that the private equity firm is
leveraging to replace equity with more debt. This extracts cash from the company.
Frequently, this route is used if an immediate exit strategy is not opportune at the
time.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
GENERATING RETURN
As previously touched upon, PE firms seek to unlock value in LBO investments,
leaving the company better than first acquired. They realize this value when exiting
with a higher equity value than originally invested. The specific ways to increase
equity value can be divided in three methods.
EBITDA/earnings growth
The purchase and exit price is based on the company’s earnings prospect. You’ll
most frequently see the price quoted as a multiple of EBITDA, so EV/EBITDA.
Multiples vary by industry; expect higher multiples with higher growth industries.
Therefore, ifyou buy in at a 6.0x EV/EBITDA and exit at the same multiple, you can
FCF generation/debtpaydown
The LBO theory is premised on the large amount of debt used to acquire targets.
Using the company’s cash flows to pay down the debt increases the equity that goes
back to the sponsor. Free cash flow available to pay down debt is basically after-tax
EBIT plus depreciation and amortization, less capital expenditures, less increase in
net working capital, less interest. PE firms use as much of this FCF as possible to pay
down debt. They will also aim to increase FCF if possible, such as the previous
strategy of increasing EBITDA/earnings, as well as decreasing capex and working
capital needs.
Multiple expansion
Selling a company for more than you bought it is always desirable. Again, since
prices are usually quoted as a multiple of EBITDA, this strategy is described as
“multiple expansion.” Multiples can change based on market conditions, like the
boom periods of 2006-2007, which saw historically high multiples, while exiting in
this year (2009) may see multiple contractions from that period. Note that the
previous strategies of operational improvements can sync to multiple expansion as
multiples are linked to growth prospects and operating performance.
All together
For example, say you buy a company for $100 million with 40 percent equity and a
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
10.0x EV/EBITDA multiple. As the sponsor, you put in $40 million at acquisition for a
company that is generating $10 million in EBITDA. Five years later, you doubled that
to $20 million in EBITDA, paid down $10 million of debt and sold the company at
11.0x EV/EBITDA. This means your exit price was $220 million = 11.0x * $20
million. You’re left with debt of $50 million = $60 million - $10 million. Now you have
an ending equity value of $170 million = $220 million - $50 million, which is 4.25x
greater than the original investment of $40 million. As you benefited from all three
types ofstrategies, you yielded an equity return of34 percent.
employ consultants and operation specialists, most private equity firms rely on the
management of the company to actually execute the company improvements.
Significant due diligence is spent interviewing the management team, who provides
insights on where value can be extracted and how realistic projections are. PE firms
will change management if they feel the current team cannot perform. To align
management incentives with their own, PE firms often incorporate options as part of
pay so that management shares in the equity upside.
Limitedworkingcapitalrequirements
Same as above; increases in working capital decreases the free cash flow available to
pay down debt and benefit the equity holder.
Divestible assets
Divestible assets provide the acquirers with extra means to raise cash to pay off the
debt. Such assets can include equipment, land, brands, etc.
how the exit multiple will compare to the entrance multiple. At minimum, they would
like it to be the same, and at best, they would like it to be higher. Funds usually exit
after three to five years.
Advantages
• There is an opportunity to execute long-term strategy outside of the short-term
focus of the public markets (examples: acquisitions, cost reductions, capital
investments).
• Use of levered capital structure to increase equity returns. Debt is tax deductible
and private equity firms can put up less equity to purchase a firm.
• Private equity firms bring a sense of urgency to the entire business, disciplining the
company to quickly seize opportunities.
• Incentive compensation schemes align management incentives with the sponsor’s.
• The company gets a stable shareholder base of long-term investors.
• The company now has the capability to leverage private equity firm’s networks to
reach new customers or improve supplier relationships.
• There is also decreased regulatory governance (Sarbanes-Oxley).
Considerations
• There is an increased risk due to additional leverage.
• There is a need for return monetization within a certain timeframe (usually three to
five years).
• There is more “hands-on” ownership than what public shareholders exercise.
PAPER LBO
The “paper LBO” can be an unnerving surprise to the unprepared candidate. It’s a
type of interview question where you are verbally given financial parameters such as
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
acquisition price, capital structure, projected financials (expected growth) and exit
price. Based on this, you are expected to “model” the scenario on paper. Expect this
exercise to be given in about 10 percent ofyour interviews.
At first, it can be daunting to be away from Excel or a calculator; mental math under
pressure is a big pain. But after a little practice, these questions are a breeze.
Sometimes you are given all the relevant information up front, and sometimes you
need to ask the right questions (and perhaps be told to make logical assumptions).
The following is the minimal information needed:
On paper, your answer will consist of the calculations to get to FCF. Then you
calculate the ending equity value (“E”) = ending EV + debt – cash. Ending
E/Beginning E is the return and the crux ofthe answer to the paper LBO. The tougher
firms will ask you to estimate the I RR (see box on page 98 fordetails)!
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
When PE says theya company at 5.0x, they usually mean total price/forward year one
EBITDA. The forward year one EBITDA is $100 million of revenue x 40 percent
EBITDA margin or $60 million.
The acquisition price is $60 million x 5.0 = $300 million. Your capital mix was 40/60
debt to equity so the beginning debt value is $120 million, and beginning equity value
is $180 million.
Now you must calculate the FCF for every year on the paper that is enclosed in the
resume portfolio you brought with you to the interview.
Taxes 3 11 19 27 35
CapEx 20 30 40 50 60
CapEx Sales 20% 20% 20% 20% 20%
Interest 12 12 12 12 12
Increase in NWC 0 0 0 0 0
Free Cash Flow $5 $7 $9 $11 $13
Ending EV 625
Beginning EV 180
Approximate EV Multiple 3.4x
You add up the accumulated free cash flow ($45 million) that pays down the debt.
Here, we assumed the exit multiple was the same as the initial multiple, which is the
assumption you usually want to make unless your interviewer indicates otherwise.
This is a good investment, as the equity more than triples. The I RR is ~28 percent.
It sounds a bit silly, but practice writing out your answer. A sloppy paper can confuse
you into the wrong answer. Also, remember the point of this question. They just want
to see that you understand the fundamental math behind a LBO. They do not expect
you to be a human calculator, so feel free to be liberal with your rounding so you can
answer more quickly; just simply ask ifit’s OK.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Estimating IRR
The CAGR formula can calculate the IR R for a paper LBO.
Simple Average
If you doubled your return, you incr eased your initia l inv estment by 1 0 0 percent. If your
investment was three years, then you ha d about 3 3 . 3 percent growth each year. However,
the com pounding effect makes the IR R markedly lower ( ~2 6. 0 percent) . This met hod just
gives y ou the upper limit of the IRR; you ca n get a feel for how strongly the com pounding
effect makes the simple average higher tha n the IRR . The longer t he duration of the
investment, the more powerful the compounding effect.
Rule of 7 2
The rule of 7 2 allows people to estimate compounded growth rates.
Rote Memorization
You can memorize benc hmark return mult iples and the c orresponding IRR s. Thus, if a five
year investment generates 3.0x then the IR R is 2 5 percent. This won’t work if you are
given a different duration other than the one you memorized. If your mult iple exceeds
6.0x, double-c heck your a nswer, beca use a return a bove 4 0 percent is excessive. Almost
always, the paper L B O uses five years. Occasiona lly you may have three years. Definitely
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Modeling test
This is the more complex version of the paper LBO; now you are actually given a
computer and more time. You absolutely must practice this in advance; there is
always a time limit and using the firm’s computer means you don’t have access to
templates or any personal shortcuts you have on your work computer (so memorize
the shortcuts that come standard in Excel!). Be able to build a simple LBO within a
half-hour from scratch. Don’t worry about fancy toggles or formatting; just
concentrate on the basics. The modeling portion is a filter test to check that you can
conduct the mechanics.
Sometimes the modeling test is very simple; you are just given minimal information
like a paper LBO and you just need to get the mathematical answer; the IRR. Other
times it is paired with a case study that asks you to make a recommendation on the
company and you may need to orally explain your answer or provide a written memo.
For details, look at Chapter 10: Investment Memorandums.
Assumptions
You may be given all the necessary assumptions, like growth and interest rates,
entrance and exit multiples that are needed to model the scenario. Sometimes,
you’re not and are asked to make “reasonable assumptions.” You’ll need to keep up
to date on the market to make informed assumptions. Remember the obvious stuff
like, lower tranches ofdebt have progressively higher interest rates, high growth rates
are not sustainable forever, exit multiples are usually set equal to entrance multiples
for the base case scenario, etc.
Basicversus full-blown
The simplest modeling tests just ask for the answer, “What’s the IRR?” of the
proposed investment. Here, all you need is the acquisition purchase price, capital
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
structure, projected exit price and operating assumptions to build a free cash flow for
debt repayment schedule.
The comprehensive modeling tests will ask for the three financial statements and/or
sensitivities. If you’re not specifically asked for the three financials, don’t waste time
building them!
SAMPLE QUESTIONS
Technicalquestions
Finance: Mostly focused on M&A accounting and financial concepts.
Industry Outlook: Understand the current market and its implications for the PE
industry. Also understand which industries may be good for LBO targets.
1. Whatarethe threewaystocreateequityvalue?
1) EBITDA/earnings growth, 2) FCF generation/debt paydown, and 3) multiple
expansion.
Then move onto questions about the company’s own operating performance.
Zero in on growth, what is projected, how much is attributed to growth of the
industry versus market share gains. What is the resilience of this company to
downturns? What demographics is the revenue focused in, and how will these
demographics change? What is the cost structure, how efficient are the supply
and distribution chains? What’s the proportion of fixed to variable costs? How
well do you utilize assets? Ask about capital expenditures, growth versus
maintenance. Also ask about how working capital is managed. How well do you
collect on account receivables or manage accounts payable?
Next, move to financials: How much cash is available right now? What are the
projected financials?
Then you want to ask about opportunities: Are there non-core or unprofitable
assets or business lines? Is there opportunity forimprovement or rationalization?
You also care significantly about the quality ofmanagement. How long have they
been in their positions, what are their backgrounds? Is the sponsor able to
replace them, if needed?
What are the legal and regulatory risks? Are there any H R issues, like union or
labor problems?
What’s your exit strategy here? Is the industry consolidating so that a sale might
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
be made easier?
7. WalkmethroughS&U?
Sources contain the variable tranches of capital structure. Some examples from
senior to junior are bank debt, junior subordinated notes, convertible preferred,
hybrids and sponsor equity. Cash belonging to the target can also be used as a
source. Finally, proceeds from options exercised at the target are a source. You
need to determine how these sources are used; the main component is the
purchase of the company, either of the assets or shares. Then is purchase of
the target’s options, refinancing debt and transaction costs (banker and lawyer
fees).
13. Let’s say you runanLBO analysis and the resulting returnis below the
required returnthreshold of your PE firm. What drivers to the model will
increasethereturn?
Some of the things that will boost return are: 1) increase leverage (debt), 2)
reduce purchase price, which decreases the amount that the firm has to pay, 3)
increase exit/sale price or multiple, which increases the return on the
investment, 4) increase the growth rate, which raises operating income/cash
flow/EBITDA in the projections, and 5) decrease costs, to also raise operating
income/cash flow/EBITDAin the projections.
16. Assume the following scenario: EBITDA of $10 million and FCF of $15
million. Entry andexit multiple are5x. Leverageis 3x. At timeofexit, 50
percent of debt is paid down. You generate a 3x return. 20 percent of
options are given to management. At what price must you sell the
business?
To make a 3x return based on the financial parameters, you must sell the
business at $90 million. You know the EV is EBITDA times entry multiple: $10
million * 5x = $50 million. Debt is equal to EBITDA times leverage: $10 million
* 3x = $30 million. EV minus debt equals equity: $50 million - $30 million = $20
million. Debt needs to be paid down by half or $30 million * 5 0 % = $15 million.
To make a 3x return, sponsor equity needs to grow to $20 million * 3x = $60
million. Since management receives 20 percent ofthe equity in options, the total
equity needs to grow to $60 million/(1 – 2 0 %) = $75 million. Since your ending
debt is $15 million and ending equity is $75 million, the EV at exit is $90 million.
Company B:
Revenue: $100 million
EBITDA: $20 million
Projected annual revenue growth: 10 percent for the next five years
Purchase price: 6x EBITDA/4x Debt & 2x Equity
minority interest in the doughnut company which is 5.0x EBITDA, so $200 * 5.0x
* (1 - 80 %) = $200 million. As a side note, when calculating enterprise value
for comps, you might take the minority value from the balance sheet. This fine
to do in such cases. However, a finance professional always chooses market
value over book value, so this question gives you enough information to calculate
the market value ofthe minority interest. Back to the answer: you total this all up
for EV, which comes to $1,500 million = $1,000 million + $300 million +
$200 million. The total EBITDA is $300 million = $100 million + $200 million.
Therefore, the EV/EBITDA multiple is $1,500/$300 = 5.0x.
The purchase price is $500 million = $100 million * 5.0x. It exits at $660 million
= $120 million * 5.5x. This is a profit of $160 million, plus you paid down debt
of $125 million = $25 * 5, so your total equity value increased by $285 million
= $160 million + $125 million. Obviously the $125 million of the total equity
value is due to debt paydown. $100 million comes from the EBITDA growth,
($120 million - $100 million) * 5. Finally, the rest of its equity value increase is
attributed to multiple expansion, (5.5x – 5.0x) * $120 million = $60 million.
Totaling these up, $125 million + $100 million + $60 million is the $285 million
of equity value increase that matches what we calculated earlier.
It’s a de-leveraging transaction because pro-forma the company will have a lower
total debt to EBITDA ratio.
OUTLINE
Use the following section as a guideline, not as hard and set rules.
Situation overview
This is only necessary if there are parameters to the investment that you’d like to
mention up front. For example, if this is an LBO investment, you can discuss the
company on offer and the proposed capital structure. You don’t need this section if
it’s a straight long/short HF/stock idea.
Investment thesis/recommendation
This is absolutely necessary; you state whether or not you would choose to invest in
this idea and what type of strategy (e.g. LBO, long/short).
Company overview
Keep this short and sweet—give basic facts about what industry the company
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Industry overview
Here, you should discuss all the Porter Five Forces-type issues about the industry, like
the outlook and level of rivalry. Highlight nuances that are unfamiliar to non-industry
participants but are important to understand for investors.
107
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge Fund Interviews
Investment Memorandums
an investment can go wrong. A successful memo will highlight the most important
risks that may or may not be obvious.
Look at the investment criteria sections of the capital markets and leveraged buyouts
chapters to understand what makes a good investment. You can also look at the 10-
Ks of the company or its peers; there, you’ll find plenty of investment points for the
positives and negatives ofthe industry/company.
Financial summary
You’ll need to build a model based on your assumptions. Fill this section with a
snapshot of important data like free cash flow, credit metrics and EV multiples.
PRACTICE
The best way to practice is to pick a public company and ask yourself if it is a good
investment. Write up a memo and create a model by using some or all the public
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Modeling exercise
You can use the example below as a quick exercise for simple modeling.
Instructions
Step 1: From a blank spreadsheet, recreate a five-year, three-statement model:
Income statement/balance sheet/cash flow.
Step 2: Create a five-year discounted cash flow analysis. Assume 12 percent WACC
and a 10x terminal multiple on forward EBITDA.
Step 3: PE ONLY: Create a leveraged buyout analysis. Calculate a three-, four-, and
five-year return with an exit multiple of 12x. Be sure to include a credit
analysis.
Operating Assumptions
2008A
Revenues $20,000
YOY Growth 10%
Amortization $12
Capex $1,750
YOY Growth 0%
Other Assumptions
2008A
Interest Rate on Revolver 6.0%
Interest Rate on Straight Debt 10.0%
Interest on Cash & Equivalents 4.5%
Minimum Cash Balance $300
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
OpeningBalanceSheet
2008A
Cash & Equivalents $30
Accounts Receivable 2,800
Inventory 2,000
Other Current Assets 100
Total Current Assets 5,250
LBOAssumptions
2009 LBO Transaction Summary
• Please spend three hours reading and analyzing the information provided on Frigid
Industries (“Frigid”).
• Your analysis should focus on the merits of a private equity acquisition in Frigid.
• As part of your analysis, you should develop a leveraged buyout analysis of Frigid
including:
- Purchase price and capitalization assumptions,
- Five-year projections for all financial statements, including revenue and
operating earnings build-up (assume transaction date of1/1/07),
- Exit price assumption and equity returns analysis.
• Please be prepared to lead a discussion ofyour evaluation ofa potential investment
in Frigid with the interview team. The discussion is meant to be open but should
address key qualitative and quantitative considerations ofthe investment.
• To aid the discussion, please be prepared to deliver print-outs of your financial
model (do not worry about formatting so long as it is clear to follow).
Executive summary
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Overview
Frigid Industries, Inc. (“Frigid” or the “Company”) is the leading independent global
manufacturer of highly engineered equipment used in the production, storage,
transportation and end-use of industrial and hydrocarbon gases. These gases are
critical to a multitude ofindustrial, commercial and scientific applications in a diverse
group of end markets totaling billions in annual sales. The Company has developed
long standing relationships with customers throughout the liquid gas supply chain
including industrial gas producers and distributors, natural gas and liquid natural gas
(LNG) pro cessors, petrochemical processors and biomedical companies.
Management believes that the Company is generally the #1 or #2 equipment supplier
in each of its primary end markets, both domestically and abroad. For the fiscal year
ended December 31, 2006, the Company generated sales of $305.5 million and
adjusted EBITDA of $56.6 million. For the fiscal year ending December 31, 2007E,
the Company expects to generate sales of$352.2 million and adjusted EBITDA of
$60.5 million.
Frigid is the preferred global supplier of engineered equipment used throughout the
liquid gas supply chain. The Company has attained this positioning by capitalizing
on its broad product offering, proprietary technologies, reputation for quality and a
flexible, low cost global manufacturing footprint. The Company utilizes its knowledge
of liquid gas handling, vacuum insulation technology and metallurgy to create and
maintain product differentiation and a sustainable competitive advantage across all of
its businesses.
Company description
Business segments
Frigid serves the liquid gas supply chain through its three operating segments: energy
& chemicals (E&C), distribution & storage (D&S) and biomedical. While each
segment manufactures and markets different products for different end-users, they
share the common proprietary technology of heat transfer and low temperature
storage.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Frigid Industries
Energy &Chemical (“E&C”) Distributution &Storage (“D&S”) Biomedical
Business Description
• Leading manufacturer of • Leading supplier of • Leading provider of
highly engineered equipment cryogenic tanks used in the cryogenic tanks and
used in the production of transportation and storage of canisters for medical
industrial and hydrocarbon liquid industrial and biological and scientific
gases hydrocarbon gases applications
Product Offering
• Heat Exchanges • Bulk Storage Systems • Respiratory Therapy
• Cold Boxes • Packaged Gas Systems Systems
• Liquefied Natural Gas • VIP Systems and • Biological Storage Systems
Vacuum Components Magnetic Resonance
• Beverage Liquid CO2 Imaging (“MRI”) Cryostat
Systems Components
• Parts, Repair, and On-Site
Service
• LNG Vehicle Fuel Systems
End-Users
• Industrial Gas Producers • Industrial Gas Producers • Home Healthcare Providers
• LNG and Natural Gas and Distributors • Medical Laboratories
processors • LNG Distributors • Phar & Research Facilities
• Petrochemical Processors • Food and Beverage • Blood and Tissue Banks
• Engineering and Businesses • Veterinary Laboratories
Construction Companies • Animal Breeders
• MRI Manufacturers
Representative Customers
• Air liquide, Air Products, BP • Airgas, Air Liquide, Air • Apria, Barnstead, CDC, GE
Amoco, Bechtel, Products, Air Water, Coca Medical, NIH, Sol, Sunrise,
ConocoPhillips, Cola, Habas, Kraft, Linde, US Air Force, Vivisol,
Cryogenmash, ExxonMobil, Messer, McDonald’s, NASA, Various universities and
Nova Chemicals NaturgassVest, NuCo2, research hospitals
Praxair
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
2006 SegmentFinancials($mm)
Sales
162.6
Gross Profit
160 EBITDA1
120
73.3
80
69.9 47.1
40 21.1 32.8 25.8
13.8 18.6
0
Margin 30.3% 19.8% 29.0% 20.2% 35.2% 25.3%
Note:
1 Excludes corporate expenses, goodwill impairment, restructuring and reorganization charges and adjustments
Customers
Frigid currently serves over 2,000 customers worldwide. The Company’s primary
customers are the large, global producers and distributors of industrial and
hydrocarbon gases. The Company has developed strong, long-standing relationships
with these customers, many of whom have been purchasing products from Frigid or
one of its predecessors for over 20 years. Frigid’s market position has benefited from
a trend by customers to concentrate their purchases with fewer suppliers. Typically,
Frigid is one of only two or three qualified suppliers on a given project. In addition,
Frigid leverages its deep customers relationships to drive sales across multiple
product lines. While the Company’s customers include many large, multinational
companies, no one customer accounted formore than 9 percent of2006 sales.
The Company’s E&C segment serves the major producers of industrial gas who use
the Company’s cold boxes and heat exchangers forthe separation and liquefaction of
air into its component parts (oxygen, nitrogen and argon). In the hydrocarbon gas
market, the E&C segment markets products to multinational natural gas and
petrochemical processors who use E&C products to cryogenically separate and purify
natural gas into liquid methane, ethane, propane, butane and ethylene for a variety
of end-uses. The E&C segment also markets products to engineering and
construction companies which fabricate hydrocarbon and LNG processing plants.
The D&S segment serves the large producers and distributors of industrial gas, as
well as the developing LNG distribution market. These customers use the Company’s
bulk storage tanks, packaged gas systems and other cryogenic systems and
components for the storage and distribution of liquid gases. In addition, Frigid sells
beverage systems to natural restaurant chains, soft drink companies and CO2
distributors.
The biomedical segment markets to a wide variety of customers due to the range of
end-uses for the Company’s products. This segment’s customers include home
healthcare providers, medical laboratories, pharmaceutical companies and research
facilities.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Manufacturing facilities
Management believes that Frigid is the low cost provider of cryogenic equipment
worldwide due to its focus on driving operating efficiencies and its global footprint of
state-of-the-art facilities. Frigid has also developed a solid reputation for high-quality
manufacturing, which when coupled with its efficient, low cost production has
created a sustainable competitive advantage. The Company serves its customers
globally via eight strategically located manufacturing facilities: five in the U.S., one in
central Europe and two in China. The Company is currently constructing a third plant
in China and plans to consolidate all of its Chinese operations in this new facility by
the end of 2007, which will triple existing capacity. The Company is also actively
pursing acquisition opportunities in China.
Reorganization overview
Investment highlights
Frigid, with its leading market positions and attractive business fundamentals, is
uniquely positioned to take advantage of the expected growth in the liquid gas market.
World-Class
Significant Barriers
Manufacturing
to Entry
Capabilities
Growth strategy
Frigid will continue to target faster growing segments within its served markets:
International expansion
Frigid will continue to build on its long track record of working successfully with
customers to develop new products to meet their increasing complex needs for
advanced cryogenic equipment. Recent examples of the Company’s ingenuity
include:
Selected acquisitions
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
• Several opportunities exist that could enable Frigid to further solidify its market-
leading position through both new business and product extension acquisitions.
• The Company is reviewing acquisition opportunities in China and expects to add to
its leading Asian market position in 2007.
Sales
Sales for 2006 were $305.5 million versus $265.6 million for 2006, an increase of
$39.9 million or 15 percent. 2006 sales were positively impacted by volume
increases, market improvements and favorable foreign currency translation as a
result ofthe weakening ofthe U.S. dollar compared to the euro.
• Sales in the E&C segment increased by $11.0 million or 18.8 percent to $69.6
million in 2006 compared to 2005 sales of $58.6 million. Sales in 2006 were
primarily driven by volume increases in both heat exchangers and process systems,
as well as LNG pipe sales increases in Asia, Africa and the Middle East.
• Sales in the D&S segment increases by $22.2 million, or 15.8 percent to $162.6
million in 2006 compared to 2005 sales of $140.3 million. Sales in 2006 were
positively impacted by volume increases across all product lines, price increases
and significant market improvements for industrial bulk storage systems. In
addition, favorable foreign currency translation resulted in an increase in sales of
approximately $4 million.
Gross profit
Gross profit for 2006 was $94.0 million versus $77.7 million for 2006. Gross margin
for 2006 was 30.8 percent versus 29.2 percent for 2005.
• Gross profit in the E&C segment for 2006 was $21.1 million versus $18 million for
2005. The increase of $3.1 million was driven primarily by volume. Gross margin
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
remained relatively flat at 30.3 percent for2006 versus 30.7 percent for2005.
• Gross profit in the D&S segment for 2006 was $47.1 million versus $36.3 million
for 2005. Gross margin increased 3.1 percentage points to 29.0 percent in 2006
from 25.9 percent in 2005. This increase is attributable to higher volume, favorable
currency translation, product pricing increases and the realization of operational
savings from the manufacturing plant restructuring. The price increases and
restructuring savings resulted in a total margin improvement of over 300 basis
points. Favorable currency translation resulted in gross profit increases of
approximately $1 million.
• Gross profit in the biomedical segment for 2006 was $25.8 million versus $22.7
million for 2005. Gross margin for 2006 was 35.2 percent versus 34 percent for
2005. The increase in gross profit and margin percentage in 2006 was driven
Operating expenses
Operating expenses for 2006 were $49.9 million compared to $51.9 million in 2005.
As a percentage ofsales, operating expenses decreased to 16.3 percent in 2006 from
19.5 percent in 2005. This reduction in operating expenses is primarily attributable
to the operational savings due to the restructuring efforts partially offset by higher
incentive compensation expenses due to the improved operating performance in
2006.
SummaryFinancial Information
The following table sets forth Frigid’s summary historical and forecasted performance.
The projected financial results reflect various assumptions made by management
concerning the future performance of the company, which may or may not prove
correct. The actual results may vary from the anticipated results and such variations
may be material.
Sales
Energy & Chemicals $62.7 $58.6 $69.6
Distribution & Storage 146.0 140.3 162.6
BioMedical 67.7 66.6 73.3
Total Sales $276.4 $265.5 $305.5
Notes:
1 The historical selected financial data is presented on a pro forma basis to exclude discontinued operations
2 The gross profit and EBIT have been presented on a pro forma basis to exclude goodwill impairment, restructuring and
reorganization charges and adjustments
3 Adjusted EBITDA represents earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, amortization, reorganization adjustments and
restructuring charges and includes adjustments for certain other non-recurring items. See section 5 for reconciliation of
adjusted EBITDA
IncomeStatementData
Historical Dec. 311
($mm, except where noted) 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Sales
Energy & Chemicals $51.6 $57.3 $62.7 $58.6 $69.6
Distribution & Storage 196.8 190.0 146.0 140.3 162.6
BioMedical 53.5 58.0 67,7 66.6 73.3
Total Sales $301.9 $305.8 $276.4 $265.5 $305.5
Cost of Sales
Emergy & Chemicals $38.7 $47.0 $50.5 $40.6 $48.5
Distribution & Storage 141.9 139.3 111.1 104.0 115.4
BioMedical 32.8 37.4 42.3 44.0 47.5
Corporate 1.5 1.8 0.3 (0.7) 0.1
Total Cost of Sales $214.9 225.5 $204.2 $187.9 $211.5
Gross Profit
Energy & Chemicals $12.9 $10.3 $12.2 $18.1 $21.1
Distribution & Storage 54.9 50.7 34.9 36.3 47.2
BioMedical 20.7 20.6 25.4 22.6 25.8
Corporate (1.5) (1.8) (0.3) 0.7 (0.1)
Total Gross Profit $87.0 $79.8 $72.2 $77.7 $94.0
EBIT
Energy & Chemicals $3.9 $2.7 $3.6 $8.9 $12.6
Distribution & Storage 30.2 25.4 11.5 18.2 30.2
BioMedical 12.8 13.2 18.1 15.1 17.2
Corporate (22.4) (19.9) (21.3) (16.4) (15.8)
Total EBIT $24.5 $21.4 $11.9 $25.8 $44.2
EBITDA
Energy & Chemicals $6.5 $4.8 $5.6 $10.0 $13.8
Distribution & Storage 33.9 29.5 15.5 21.6 32.8
BioMedical 14.0 14.6 19.9 17.1 18.6
Corporate (12.1) (11.1) (17.8) (13.1) (12.5)
Total EBITDA $42.3 $37.8 $23.2 $35.6 $52.7
Non-Recurrin g Adjustments 1.1 1.1 1.0 0.9 4.0
Adjusted EBITDA $43.4 $38.9 $24.2 $36.5 $56.7
Notes:
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
1 Presented on pro forma basis to exclude discontinued operations and restructuring, goodwill impairment and
reorganization adjustments
IncomeStatementMetrics
Historical Dec. 311
(%) 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Sales Growth
Energy & Chemicals 11.1% 9.4% (6.5%) 18.8%
Distribution & Storage (3.5%) (23.2%) (3.9%) 15.8%
BioMedical 8.3% 16.7% (1.5%) 10.1%
Sales Growth 1.1% (9.5%) (3.9%) 15.0%
Sales Mix
Emergy & Chemicals 17.1% 18.8% 22.7% 22.1% 22.8%
Distribution & Storage 65.2% 62.2% 52.8% 52.8% 53.2%
BioMedical 17.7% 19.0% 24.5% 25.1% 24.0%
Gross Margin
Energy & Chemicals 25.0% 18.0% 19.5% 30.7% 30.3%
Distribution & Storage 27.9% 26.7% 23.9% 25.9% 29.0%
BioMedical 38.7% 35.5% 37.5% 34.0% 35.2%
Gross Margin 28.9% 26.1% 26.1% 29.2% 30.8%
EBIT Margin
Energy & Chemicals 7.5% 4.6% 5.7% 15.1% 18.1%
Distribution & Storage 15.3% 13.4% 7.9% 13.0% 18.6%
BioMedical 23.9% 22.8% 26.7% 22.7% 23.4%
EBIT Margin 8.1% 7.0% 4.3% 9.7% 14.4%
EBITDA Margin
Energy & Chemicals 12.6% 8.4% 9.0% 17.1% 19.8%
Distribution & Storage 17.2% 15.5% 10.6% 15.4% 20.2%
BioMedical 26.1% 25.1% 29.4% 25.6% 25.3%
EBITDA Margin 14.0% 12.3% 8.4% 13.4% 17.2%
Adjusted EBITDA Margin 14.4% 12.7% 8.8% 13.8% 18.5%
Notes:
1 Presented on pro forma basis to exclude discontinued operations and restructuring, goodwill impairment and
reorganization adjustments
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Capital Expenditures
Years Ending 12/311
Maintenance
Energy & Chemicals $0.6 $0.3
Distribution & Storage 3.2 2.4
BioMedical 0.4 0.6
Total Maintenance $4.2 $3.3
Initiatives
Energy & Chemicals 1.0 1.3
Distribution & Storage 1.5 5.3
BioMedical 2.0 2.7
Total Initiatives $4.5 $9.3
Corporate/Other 0.7 0.3
Total Capital Expenditures $9.4 $12.9
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Reassure them through your interview that you will; you can convey your strong
command of an industry, ability to take on responsibility and rolodex of management
contacts.
If you need incentive, these jobs pay a minimum of six figures and it’s quite feasible
to break seven before you’re 30. Moreover, the work is challenging and your
coworkers are some of the smartest people in the country. Ask for constructive
feedback and build on it. Be confident and believe in your worth.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
123
APPENDIX
Vault Guide to Private Equity and Hedge FundInterviews
Abbreviations
Finance Glossary
Headhunters
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Abbreviations
AR: Accounts receivable
BS: Balance sheet
CAGR: Compunded annual growth rate
Cap: Capitalization
Capex: Capital expenditures
CFS: Cash flow statement
CIM: Confidential information memorandum
COGS: Cost of goods sold
Comps: Comparables
D: Debt
D&A: Depreciation and amortization
DCF: Discounted cash flow
E: Equity
EBITDA: Earnings before interest, depreciation and amortization
EBITDAR: Earnings before interest, depreciation, amortization and rent
EPS: Earnings per share
EV: Enterprise value
FCF: Free cash flow
FFO: Funds from operations
FIFO: First in, first out
HF: Hedge fund
IPO: Initial public offering
IRR: Internal rate of return
IS: Income statement
L: Libor
LIBOR: London interbank offered rate
LIFO: Last in, first out
LBO: Leveraged buyout
M&A: Merger & acquisition
Memo: Memorandum
NOL: Net operating losses
NPV: Net present value
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
127
FinanceGlossary
Absolute return: An absolute return manager is one without a benchmark who is
expected to achieve positive returns no matter what market conditions. Hedge fund
managers are also referred to as absolute return managers where they are expected
to have positive returns even if the markets are declining. This compares with mutual
fund managers who have relative return objectives when compared with their
benchmarks.
Accretive merger: A merger in which the acquiring company’s earnings per share
increase.
Administrator: The offshore fund entity that manages the back office work and
individual accounts forthe fund.
AML(Anti Money Laundering from the Patriot Act): The Patriot Act was adopted in
response to the September 11 terrorist attacks. The Patriot Act is intended to
strengthen U.S. measures to prevent, detect, and prosecute international money
laundering and the financing of terrorism. These efforts include new anti-money
laundering (AML) tools that impact the banking, financial, and investment
communities.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Arbitrage: Arbitrage involves the simultaneous purchase and sale ofa security or pair
of similar securities to profit from a pricing discrepancy. This could be the purchase
and sale of the identical item in different markets to make profits - for example there
could be an arbitrage opportunity in the price of gold that is sold more expensively in
London than in New York. In this case the arbitrageur would buy gold in New York
and sell in London, profiting from the price differential. This could be applied to a
variety of transactions: foreign exchange, mortgages, futures, stocks, bonds, silver
orother commodities in one market forsale in another at a profit.
Asset classes: Asset class means a type of investment, such as stocks, bonds,real
estate, or cash.
Balance sheet: One ofthe four basic financial statements, the balance sheet presents
the financial position ofa company at a given point in time,including assets, liabilities
and equity.
Basis points (bps): The general way spreads are measured in finance. 100 basis
points = 1 percent.
Beta: A value that represents the relative volatility of a given investment with respect
to the market.
Bond price: The price the bondholder (the lender) pays the bond issuer (the
borrower) to hold the bond (i.e., to have a claim on the cash flows documented on
the bond).
Bond spreads: The difference between the yield of a corporate bond and a U.S.
Treasury security ofsimilar time to maturity.
Buy-side: The clients of investment banks (mutual funds, pension funds and other
entities often called “institutional investors”) that buy the stocks, bonds and securities
sold by the investment banks. (The investment banks that sell these products to
investors are known as the “sell-side.”)
aggregating the results, the client will usually execute the trade at the highest
bid/lowest offer given to him by the various market makers.
Callable bond: A bond that can be bought back by the issuer so that it is not
committed to paying large coupon payments in the future.
Call option: An option that gives the holder the right to purchase an asset for a
specified price on or before a specified expiration date.
Capital asset pricing model (CAPM): A model used to calculate the discount rate of a
company’s cash flows.
Capital market equilibrium: The principle that there should be equilibrium in the
global interest rate markets.
Capital structure: This refers to the composition of a company’s debt and equity,
including stock, bonds and loans.
Capital structure arbitrage: An investment strategy that seeks to exploit pricing
inefficiencies in a firm’s capital structure. Strategy will entail purchasing the
undervalued security, and selling the overvalued, expecting the pricing disparity
between the two to close out.
CFA: Chartered financial analyst. An individual who has passed tests in economics,
accounting,security analysis, and money management, administered by the Institute
of Chartered Financial Analysts of the Association for Investment Management and
Research (AIMR). Such an individual is also expected to have at least three years of
investment-related experience, and meet certain standards of professional conduct.
These individuals have an extensive economic and investing background and are
competent at a high level of analysis. Individuals or corporations utilize their services
as security analysts, portfolio managers or investment advisors.
Chapter 7: The portion of the bankruptcy code that results in the liquidation of a
company’s assets in order to pay offoutstanding financial obligations.
Chapter 11: The portion of the bankruptcy code that allows a company to operate
under the bankruptcy court’s supervision for an indefinite period of time, generally
resulting in a corporate restructuring with the assistance ofan investment bank.
Chinese Wall: The separation between public and private sections of an investment
bank, including sales, trading and research from corporate finance. Many banks even
have physical barriers and/ore-mail restrictions to support this effort.
Commercial bank: A bank that lends, rather than raises money. For example, if a
company wants $30 million to open a new production plant, it can approach a
commercial bank like Bank of America or Citibank for a loan. (Increasingly,
commercial banks are also providing investment banking services to clients.)
Common stock: Also called common equity, common stock represents an ownership
interest in a company (as opposed to preferred stock, see below). The vast majority
of stock traded in the markets today is common, as common stock enables investors
to vote on company matters. An individual with 51 percent or more of shares owned
controls a company and can appoint anyone he/she wishes to the board of directors
or to the management team.Common stock also exists in private companies.
Consumer price index (CPI): The CPI measures the percentage increase in a
standard basket of goods and services. The CPI is a measure of inflation for
consumers.
Convertible bonds: Bonds that can be converted into a specified number ofshares of
stock.
Cost of goods sold: The direct costs of producing merchandise. Includes costs of
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Coupon payments: The payments of interest that the bond issuer makes to the
bondholder.
CPA: A certified public accountant is an individual who has received state certification
to practice accounting.
Credit cycle: The general market cycle of company defaults (companies that declare
bankruptcy due to lack of an ability to meet their financial obligations). Credit cycles
tend to be at their best (their lowest) during periods of low interest rates and general
overall market health. Credit cycles generally occur in five- to seven-year periods.
Credit default swap: A credit default swap is a derivative instrument that charges a
customer a quarterly premium in exchange for protection against a corporation filing
for bankruptcy. Originally invented by JPMorgan, the CDS market is a multitrillion
Credit ratings: The ratings given to bonds by credit agencies (S&P, Moody’s, Fitch).
These ratings indicate the creditworthiness of a company or a financial instrument.
Crossed trades: This is a situation whereby a trader that is a market-maker is able to
find a buyer and a seller of the same security at the same time and thus executes
both trades without taking on any risk. By “crossing trades,” the market maker earns
the bid-ask spread, buying at her bid and selling at her offer.
Currencies: Any form of money that is in public circulation. The main traded
currencies are the U.S. dollar, Japanese Yen, British pound and the Euro.
Currency appreciation: When a currency’s value is rising relative to other currencies.
Default premium: The difference between the promised yields on a corporate bond
and the yield on an otherwise identical government bond. Also known as the “credit
spread.”
Default risk: The risk that the company issuing a bond may go bankrupt and “default”
on its loans.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Derivatives: An asset whose value is derived from the price of another asset.
Examples include call options, put options, futures, credit default swaps and interest-
rate swaps.
Dilutive merger: A merger in which the acquiring company’s earnings per share
decrease.
Discount rate: A rate that measures the risk of an investment. It can be understood
as the expected return from a project of a certain amount ofrisk.
Discounted cash flow analysis (DCF): A method ofvaluation that takes the net present
value of the free cash flows of a company. DCF is most likely the most important
concept a corporate finance analyst must master in order to be successful. It is at the
very core of most financial modeling.
DTC system: “DTC” means depositary trust company. This is a central repository
through which members electronically transfer stock and bond certificates (a
clearinghouse facility). The depository trust company was set up to provide an
infrastructure for settling trades in municipal, mortgagebacked and corporate
securities in a cost-efficient and timely manner. The “system” refers to the
mechanism whereby trades are matched up at the DTC.
8-K: A report filed with the SE C by a public company to update investors of any
material event.
very volatile, and may also involve currency risk, political risk, and liquidity risk.
Enterprise value: Levered value of the company, the equity value plus the market
value ofdebt.
ETF: Exchange-traded fund. ETF’s are listed as individual securities in the equity
markets and are used to replicate an index or a portfolio of stocks.
The Fed: The Federal Reserve Board, which manages the country’s economy by
setting interest rates. The current chairman of the Fed is Ben Bernanke and the
former chairman was Alan Greenspan.
Federal funds rate: The rate domestic banks charge one another on overnight loans
to meet Federal Reserve requirements. This rate tracks very closely to the discount
rate, but is usually slightly higher.
Financial sponsor: A general term used to refer to a firm that completes a financial
transaction, such as an LBO, on behalf of another company. Financial sponsors are
also known as private equity firms.
Fixed income: Bonds and other securities that earn a fixed rate of return. Bonds are
typically issued by governments, corporations and municipalities.
Fixed income arbitrage: Investment strategy that seeks to exploit pricing inefficiencies
in fixed income securities and their derivative instruments. Typical investment will
involve making long a fixed income security or related instrument that is perceived to
be undervalued, and shorting a similar, related fixed income security or related
instrument.
Float: The number of shares available for trade in the market times the price.
Generally speaking, the bigger the float, the greater the liquidity of a particular
security.
Floating rate:An interest rate that is pegged to other rates (such as the rate paid on
U.S. Treasuries), allowing the interest rate to change as market conditions change.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Forward contract: A contract that calls for future delivery of an asset at an agreed-
upon price.
Forward exchange rate: The price ofcurrencies at which they can bebought and sold
for future delivery.
Forward rates (for bonds): The agreed-upon interest rates for a bond to be issued in
the future.
Free cash flow: The measure of cash that a company has left over after paying for its
existing operations. FCF is generally calculated as operating income minus
maintenance CapEx minus dividends minus net increase in working capital.
FTSE (London): The Financial Times Stock Exchange 100 stock index, a market cap
weighted index of stocks traded on the London Stock Exchange. Similar to the S&P
500 in the United States.
Fund of funds: Investment partnership that invests in a series of other funds. A fund
of funds’ portfolio will typically diversify across a variety of investment managers,
investment strategies, and subcategories.
Futures contract: A contract that calls for the delivery of an asset or its cash value at
a specified delivery or maturity date for an agreed upon price. A future is a type of
forward contract that is liquid, standardized, traded on an exchange and whose
prices are settled at the end of each trading day.
General ledge entries: Abook of final entry summarizing all of a company’s financial
transactions, through offsetting debit and credit accounts.
General partner: Managing partner ofa limited partnership, who is responsible for the
operation of the limited partnership. The general partner’s liability is unlimited since
he is responsible for the debts of the partnership and assumes legal obligations (i.e
could be sued).
Glass-Steagall Act: Part of the legislation passed during the Depression (Glass-
Steagall was passed in 1933) designed to help prevent future bank failure; the
establishment of the F.D.I.C. was also part of this movement. The Glass-Steagall Act
split America’s investment banking (issuing and trading securities) operations from
commercial banking (lending). For example, J.P. Morgan was forced to spin off its
securities unit as Morgan Stanley. Since the late 1980s, the Federal Reserve has
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
steadily weakened the act, allowing commercial banks to buy investment banks.
Global macro investing: Investment strategy that seeks to profit by making leveraged
bets on anticipated price movements of global stock markets, interest rates, foreign
exchange rates, and physical commodities.
Goodwill: An account that includes intangible assets a company may have, such as
brand image.
Greenshoe option: An IPO over-allotment option that allows for underwriters to issue
up to 15 percent more of the underlying firm’s stock, in the event the offering is well
received by investors. “Greenshoe” refers to the Green Shoe Company, which was the
first to exercise such an option.
High-grade corporate bond: A corporate bond with a rating above BB+. Also called
investment-grade debt.
High water mark: The assurance that a fund only takes fees on profits unique to an
individual investment. For example, a $1,000,000 investment is made in year 1 and
the fund declines by 50 percent, leaving $500,000 in the fund. In year 2, the fund
returns 100 percent, bring the investment value back to $1,000,000. If a fund has a
high water mark, it will not take incentive fees on the return in year 2, since the
investment has never grown. The fund will only take incentive fees if the investment
grows above the initial level of $1,000,000.
High-yield bonds (a.k.a. junk bonds): Corporate bonds that pay high interest rates (to
compensate investors forhigh risk ofdefault.Credit rating agencies such as Standard
& Poor’s rate a company’s (or a municipality’s) bonds based on default risk. Junk
bonds rate at or below BB+.
“Hit the bid”: If a trader says that he’s been “hit” or someone has “hit the bid,” this
generally means that he has made a market in a particular security and a client has
opted to sell securities to the trader at his bid level. Thus, the trader has purchased
the securities, or been “hit.” When a trader is “lifted”, this is the opposite scenario,
in which securities were sold by the trader.
Holding period return: The income earned over a period as a percentage of the bond
price at the start of the period.
Hurdle rate: The return above which a hedge fund manager begins taking incentive
fees. For example, ifa fund has a hurdle rate of 10 percent, and the fund returns 25
percent for the year, the fund will only take incentive fees on the 15 percent return
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Incentive fee: An incentive fee is the fee on new profits earned by the fund for the
period. For example, if the initial investment was $1,000,000 and the fund returned
25 percent during the period (creating profits of $250,000) and the fund has an
incentive fee of 20 percent, then the fund receives 20 percent of the $250,000 in
profits, or $50,000.
Inception date:The inception date is the date that the fund began trading.
Income statement: One of the four basic financial statements, the income statement
presents the results of operations of a business over a specified period of time, and
is composed of revenue, expenses, and net income.
Initial public offering (IPO): The dream of every entrepreneur, the IPO is the first time
a company issues stock to the public. “Going public” means more than raising
Institutional clients orinvestors: Large investors, such as hedge funds, pension funds,
or municipalities (as opposed to retail investors or individual investors).
Interest rate swap: An interest rate swap is the exchange of interest payments on a
specific principal amount. An interest rate swap usually involves just two parties, but
occasionally involves more. Often, an interest rate swap involves exchanging a fixed
amount per payment period for a payment that is not fixed. (The floating side of the
swap would usually be linked to another interest rate,often the LIBOR.)
Investment adviser: The investment adviser is the individual or entity that provides
investment advice for a fee. Registered investment advisers must register with the
SEC and abide by the rules ofthe Investment Advisers Act.
Investment grade bonds: Bonds with high credit ratings that pay a relatively low rate
of interest, but are very low risk. Companies or debt securities with a B BB - or better
S&P rating (or Baa3 or better Moody’s rating) are generally considered investment
grade.
IPO: An initial public offering is often referred to as an “IPO.” This is first sale ofstock
by a company to the public.
Junk bonds: Corporate bonds with a credit rating ofB B or lower. Also known as high-
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
yield bonds, these bonds are usually issued by companies without long track records
of sales or earnings or by those with questionable credit standing.
Large cap securities: Equity securities with relatively large market capitalization,
usually over $5 billion (shares outstanding times price per share).
Leverage: Leverage measures the amount ofassets being funded by each investment
dollar. The primary source ofleverage is from borrowing from financial institutions. An
example in everyday terms is a house mortgage. Leverage is essentially borrowing by
hedge funds using their assets in the fund as a pledge of collateral toward the loan.
The hedge fund manager then uses the loan to buy more securities. The amount of
leverage typically used by the fund is shown as a percentage of the fund. For
example, if the fund has $1,000,000 and is borrowing another $2,000,000, to bring
the total dollars invested to $3,000,000, then the leverage used is 200 percent.
Leveraged: This refers to companies or debt securities with a B B+ or lower S&P rating
(or Ba1 or lower Moody’s rating).
Leveraged buyout (LBO): The buyout ofa company with borrowed money, often using
that company’s own assets as collateral. LBOs were the order ofthe day in the heady
1980s, when successful LBO firms such as Kohlberg Kravis Roberts made a practice
of buying companies, restructuring them, and reselling them or taking them public at
a significant profit. LBO volume fueled the markets in 2004-2007 due to low default
rates, low interest rates and investor cash balances.
LIBOR: London interbank offered rate. The risk-free rate by which banks lend to one
another in London. Syndicated loans are priced with spreads above LIBOR. Very
similar to the Federal Funds rate.
Limited partnership: The hedge fund is organized with a general partner, who
manages the business and assumes legal debts and obligations, and oneor more
limited partners, who are liable only to the extent of their investments. Limited
partners also enjoy rights to the partnership’s cash flow, but are not liable for
company obligations.
Liquidity: The amount ofa particular stock or bond available fortrading in the market.
For commonly traded securities, such as large cap stocks and U.S. government
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
bonds, they are said to be highly liquid instruments. Small cap stocks and smaller
fixed income issues often are called illiquid (as theyare not activelytraded) and suffer
a liquidity discount, i.e., they trade at lower valuations to similar, but more liquid,
securities.
Lockup: Time period that initial investment cannot be redeemed from the fund.
The long bond: The 30-year U.S. Treasury bond. Treasury bonds are used as the
starting point for pricing many other bonds, because Treasury bonds are assumed to
have zero credit risk take into account factors such as inflation. For example, a
company will issue a bond that trades “40 over Treasuries.” The 40 refers to 40 basis
points (100 basis points = 1 percentage point).
underwritten. (In others words, the investment bank stands willing to buy the security,
if necessary, when the investor laterdecides to sell it.)
Management company: A firm that, for a management fee, invests pools of capital,
for the purpose of fulfilling a sought-after investment objective.
Management fee: The fees taken by the manager on the entire asset level of the
investment. For example, if at the end of the period, the investment is valued at
$1,000,000, and the management fee is 1 percent, then the fees would be $10,000.
Market cap(italization): The total value ofa company in the stock market (total shares
outstanding x price per share).
Market neutral investing: Investing in financial markets through a strategy that will
result in an investment portfolio not correlated to overall market movements and
insulated from systematic market risk.
Markets (stock market): General term for the organized trading of stocks through
exchanges and over-the-counter. There are many markets around the world trading
equities and options.
Master-feeder fund: A typical structure for a hedge fund. It involves a master trading
vehicle that is domiciled offshore. The master fund has two investors: another
offshore fund, and a U.S. (usually Delaware-based) limited partnership. These two
funds are the feeder funds. Investors invest in the feeder funds, which in turn invest
all the money in the master fund, which is traded by the manager.
Merchant banking: The department within an investment bank that invests the firm’s
own money in other companies. Analogous to a private equity firm.
Money market securities: This term is generally used to represent the market for
securities maturing within one year. These include short-term CDs, repurchase
agreements, commercial paper (low-risk corporate issues), among others. These are
low risk, short-term securities that have yields similar to Treasuries.
Municipal bonds (Munis): Bonds issued by local and state governments, a.k.a.,
municipalities. Municipal bonds are structured as tax-free for the investor, which
means investors in muni’s earn interest payments without having to pay federal taxes.
Sometimes investors are exempt from state and local taxes, too. Consequently,
municipalities can pay lowerinterest rates on muni bonds than other bonds of similar
risk.
Mutual fund: An investment vehicle that collects funds from investors (both individual
and institutional) and invests in a variety of securities, including stocks and bonds.
Mutual funds make money by charging a percentage ofassets in the fund.
NAV: Net asset value per share - the market value ofa fund share. Equals the closing
market value of all securities within a portfolio plus all other assets such as cash,
subtracting all liabilities (including fees and expenses), then dividing the result by the
total number of shares outstanding.
Net present value (NPV): The present value ofa series ofcash flows generated by an
investment, minus the initial investment. NPV is calculated because of the important
concept that money today is worth more than the same money tomorrow. The basic
rule of thumb is that if a project is NPV positive, it should be accepted. NPV is also
at the very core of most financial modeling by investment bankers.
Nikkei: The Nikkei index is an index of225 leading stocks traded on the Tokyo Stock
Exchange.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
NINJA loan: A type of mortgage that requires “no income, no job and no assets.”
NYSE: The New York Stock Exchange is the oldest and largest stock exchange in the
U.S., located on Wall Street in New York City. The NYSE is responsible for setting
policy, supervising member activities, listing securities, overseeing the transfer of
member seats, and evaluating applicants. It traces its origins back to 1792, when a
group of brokers met under a tree at the tip of Manhattan and signed an agreement
to trade securities. The NYSE still uses a large trading floor to conduct its
transactions.
Options: A put option gives the holder the right to sell the underlying stock at a
specified price (strike price) on or before a given date (exercise date).A call option
gives the holder the right to buy the underlying stock at specified price (strike price)
on or before a given date (exercise date). The seller of these options is referred to as
the writer - many hedge funds will often write options in accordance with their
strategies.
Pairs trading: Non-directional relative value investment strategy that seeks to identify
two companies with similar characteristics whose equity securities are currently
trading at a price relationship that is out of their historical trading range. Investment
strategy will entail buying the undervalued security, while short-selling the overvalued
security.
Par: In trading, this refers to a debt securing trading at 100. Most loans and bonds
are issued at par. If they are issued at a discount, this is anything less than par.
Conversely, a premium is anything more than par. When trading at par, the yield of
the security can be inferred to be the same as its coupon. When trading below par,
the security has a higher implied yield, as securities are eventually redeemed at par.
Therefore, a 5 percent bond trading at 98 actually has more than a 5 percent yield,
since it will eventually be repurchased at 100. Thus, the investor will get this 2 point
increase, as well as the 5 percent coupon.
Pari passu: Latin for “without partiality,” this refers to when two or more instruments
share the same seniority in a company’s capital structure.
Patriot Act: The Patriot Act was adopted in response to the September 11 terrorist
attacks. The Patriot Act is intended to strengthen U.S. measures to prevent, detect,
and prosecute international money laundering and the financing of terrorism. These
efforts include new anti-money laundering (AML) tools that impact the banking,
financial, and investment communities.
P/E ratio: The price to earnings ratio. This is the ratio of a company’s stock price to
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
its earnings-per-share. The higher the P/E ratio, the faster investors believe the
company will grow.
Prime brokerage: Prime brokers offer hedge fund clients various tools and services
such as securities lending, trading platforms, cash management, risk management
and settlements foradministration ofthe hedge fund.
Prime rate: The average rate U.S. banks charge to companies forloans.
Private equity: Also called “financial sponsors”, this term refers to the group of
investment firms that raise cash from investors to purchase public and private
companies through LBOs. Big name firms include: Bain Capital, Blackstone, Carlyle,
Hicks, Muse, Tate & Furst (recently renamed H M Capital), JPMorgan Partners, KKR,
Madison Dearborn, Texas Pacific Group and Thomas H. Lee.
Producer price index: The PPI measures the percentage increase in a standard
basket of goods and services. PPI is a measure of inflation for p roducers and
manufacturers.
Proprietary trading: Trading of the firm’s own assets (as opposed to trading client
assets). Also occasionally referred to as principal investing.
Purchase price multiple: The ratio measuring a firm’s LBO purchase price in
comparison to its EBITDA. Purchase price multiples are crucial for private equity
firms valuing potential targets.
Put option: An option that gives the holder the right to sell an asset for a specified
price on or before a specified expiration date.
Rate of return: The rate of return is the percentage appreciation in market value for
an investment security or security portfolio.
Return on equity: The ratio of a firm’s profits to the value of its equity. Return on
equity, or ROE, is a commonly used measure of how well an investment bank is
doing, because it measures how efficiently and profitably the firm is using its capital.
Risk arbitrage: Relative value investment strategy that seeks to exploit pricing
discrepancies in the equity securities of two companies involved in a merger-related
transaction. The strategy will entail the purchase of a security of the company being
acquired, along with a simultaneous sale in the acquiring company.
Roadshow: The series of presentations to investors that a company undergoing an
IPO usually gives in the weeks preceding the offering. Here’s how it works: The
company and its investment bank will travel to major cities throughout the country. In
each city,the company’s top executives make a presentation to analysts, mutual fund
managers and other attendees, while answering questions.
S&P500: Standard & Poor’s 500 is a basket of 500 stocks that are considered to be
widely held. This index provides a broad snapshot of the overall U.S. equity market;
in fact, over 70 percent ofall U.S. equity is tracked by the S&P 500.
Secured debt: Debt that is secured by the assets of the firm is referred to as secured
debt. Although usually coming in the form of loans, secured debt can also take the
form of bonds. If a company is liquidated, those investors in the firm’s secured debt
are paid out first and foremost with the proceeds from the sale of the firm’s assets.
Secured debt is almost entirely classified as “senior debt”.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): A federal agency that, like the Glass-
Steagall Act, was established as a result of the stock market crash of 1929 and the
ensuing depression. The SEC monitors disclosure of financial information to
stockholders, and protects against fraud. Publicly traded securities must first be
approved by the SEC prior to trading.
Securitize: To convert an asset into a security that can then be sold to investors.
Nearly any income-generating asset can be turned into a security. For example, a 20-
year mortgage on a home can be packaged with other mortgages just like it, and
shares in this pool of mortgages can then be sold to investors. Collateralized debt
obligations are a form of securitization.
Selling, general and administrative expense (SG&A): Costs not directly involved in the
production of revenues. SG&A is subtracted as part of expenses from gross profit to
get EBIT.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Sell-side: Investment banks and other firms that sell securities to investors, both retail
and institutional. Naturally,investors purchasing these securities are on the buy-side.
Senior debt: Most often in the form of loans or bonds, this refers to debt that has
repayment priority in the event of bankruptcy. “Senior” also refers to the place of the
debt in the firm’s capital structure in comparison to other instruments of the same
type.If a firm is liquidated, its senior debt is paid out before its junior debt.Therefore,
junior debt usually must compensate investors with higher yield from spreads for this
increased risk.
Series 7 & 63: The NASD Series 7 General Securities Representative exam is the
main qualification for stockbrokers, and is normally taken in conjunction with the
Series 63 Uniform State Law Exam.
Short selling: Short selling involves the selling of a security that the seller does not
own. Short sellers believe that the stock price will fall (as opposed to buying long,
wherein one believes the price will rise) and that they will be able to repurchase the
stock at a lower price in the future. Thus, they will profit from selling the stock at a
higher price now.
Small cap securities: Securities in which the parent company’s total stock market
capitalization is less than $1 billion.
Special situations investing: Investment strategy that seeks to profit from pricing
discrepancies resulting from corporate “event” transactions, such as mergers and
acquisitions, spin-offs, bankruptcies, or recapitalizations. Also known as “event
driven.”
Statement of cash flows: One of the four basic financial statements, the statement of
cash flows presents a detailed summary ofall of the cash inflows and outflows during
a specified period.
Statement of retained earnings: One of the four basic financial statements, the
statement of retained earnings is a reconciliation of the retained earnings account.
Information such as dividends or announced income is provided in the statement.
The statement of retained earnings provides information about what a company’s
management is doing with the company’s earnings.
Stock swap: A form of M&A activity in whereby the stock of one company is
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Subscription period: The subscription period is the amount of time that the investor
is required to keep the investment in the fund without withdrawal, typically one to two
years.
T-Bill yields: The yield or internal rate of return an investor would receive at any given
moment on a 90-120 government treasury bill.
10-K: An annual set ofaudited financial statements ofa public company filed with the
SEC. The 10-K includes a balance sheet, cash flow statement and income statement,
as well as an explanation of the company’s performance (usually referred to as
management’s discussion and analysis). It is audited by an accounting firm before
being registered.
10-Q: A set of quarterly financial statements of a public company filed with the SEC.
The 10-Q includes a balance sheet, cash flow statement and income statement,
among other things. As the fourth quarter’s performance is captured in the 10-K,
public companies must only file three of these per year.
Tombstone: Usually found in pitchbooks, these are logos and details from past
successful deals done by an investment bank. Often times for hallmark transactions,
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
these same details will be placed on a notable object and distributed to the company
and bankers, to serve as a memento of a deal. For example, a high-yield bond for a
sporting equipment manufacturer might be commemorated with actual baseball bats
or footballs, inscribed with transaction information.
Treasury securities: Securities issued by the U.S. government. These are divided into
treasury bills (maturity ofup to two years), treasury notes (from two years to 10 years
maturity), and treasury bonds (10 years to 30 years). As they are government
guaranteed, often treasuries are considered risk-free. In fact, while U.S. treasuries
have no default risk, they do have interest rate risk; if rates increase, then the price
of UST’s will decrease.
Treasury stock: Common stock that is owned by the company but not outstanding,
with the intent either to be reissued at a later date,or retired. It is not included in the
calculations of financial ratios, such as P/E or EPS, but is included in the company’s
financial statements.
Underwrite: The function performed by investment banks when they help companies
issue securities to investors. Technically, an investment bank buys the securities from
the co mpany and immediately resells the securities to investors for a slightly higher
price, making money on the spread.
Yield to call: The yield of a bond calculated up to the period when the bond is called
(paid offby the bond issuer).
Yield: The annual return on investment. A high-yield bond, for example, pays a high
rate of interest.
Yield to maturity: The measure of the average rate of return that will be earned on a
bond if it is bought now and held to maturity.
Zero coupon bonds: A bond that offers no coupon or interest payments to the
bondholder.
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
CornellGlobal
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
CTPartners DM Stone
Customized for: Thomas (thomas.picquette@edhec.c om)
Mercury Partners
Korn/Fern International 60 East 42nd Street
1900 Avenue of the Stars Suite 760
Suite 2600 New York, NY 10165
Los Angeles, CA 90067 Phone: (212) 687-1500
Phone: (310) 552-1834 Fax: (212) 687-4102
www.kornferry.com Email: info@mercurypartner.com
www.mercurypartner.com
Email: contact@theprestongroup.net
150 East 52nd Street www.theprestongroup.net
23rd Floor
New York, NY 10022
The Quest Organization
Phone: (212) 980-0800
One Penn Plaza
Fax: (212) 888-6062
Suite 3905
Email: info@oxbridgegroup.com
www.oxbridgegroup.com New York, NY 10119
Phone: (212) 971-0033
Fax: (212) 971-6256
Email: info@questorg.com
www.questorg.com
155