PSY1020 Ezine
PSY1020 Ezine
PSY1020 Ezine
5
ADDICTION & SUBSTANCE USE SCHIZOPHRENIA & PSYCHOSIS PSYCHOSOMATICS
CME
CREDITS
Cannabis: Medicolegal
Issues
Recovery in
Delusional Disorder
The Importance
of Being There
OCTOBER 2020
COMMENTARY
Presidential
Election Anxiety
and the Role of Psychiatry
» H. Steven Moffic, MD
“Without a full spectrum of voices from partisan political elites, though, anxious
citizens in search of protection from threats to their health and way of life may support
charlatans or madmen who offer bodily protection while destroying the body politic.”1
There are plenty of reasons to be anxious about the calling 2020 “the worst year ever.”
T H E V O I C E O F P S Y C H I AT R Y
state of the nation: the coronavirus pandemic, the econo- As if that were not enough, now we have a presi-
my, climate instability, physician burnout, an endless war dential election happening in the midst of partisan
on terrorism, returning to the classroom (or not), and rac- political warfare, civil unrest, and frightening con-
ism, among other societal and personal stressors. All spiracy theories on TV and the internet. The stakes
these major dangers are on top of the still-looming seem sky high, perhaps because the president has so
nuclear risk that could blot out human life on earth in much influence on how we address every other crisis.
virtually an instant. No wonder some individuals are CONTINUED ON PAGE 18
COMMENTARY
A
s a psychiatrist, I do not need cently released survey from the Cen- ments, the CDC survey found that, DISORDERS
much convincing that millions ters for Disease Control found that 40.9% of 5470 respondents reported Trauma-Informed Approaches
of people are suffering emo- from June 24-30, 2020, adults in the an adverse mental or behavioral for Health Care Workers
tionally as a consequence of the coro- United States reported “considerably health condition, including symp- Gertie Quitangon, MD
navirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) elevated adverse mental health con- toms of anxiety disorder or depres-
sive disorder, trauma-related symp- NEUROPSYCHIATRY
toms, new or increased substance Easy to Miss, Hard to Treat
Rajesh R. Tampi, MD, MS, DFAPA, DFAAGP,
use, or thoughts of suicide (Figure). Deena J. Tampi, MSN, MBA-HCA, RN,
The prevalence of anxiety and depres- DFAAGP, and Michael Parish, MD
sion symptoms were substantially
higher than reported in 2019, and MOOD DISORDERS
people with preexisting (clinically The Role of Oxcarbazepine
diagnosed) psychiatric disorders re- David N. Osser, MD
ported an even higher prevalence of
symptoms, compared with those
CONTINUED ON PAGE 21 COMPLETE CONTENTS, PAGE 9
VISIT US
ONLINE PsychiatricTimes.com
NOW APPROVED
SPRAVATO®, IN CONJUNCTION WITH AN ORAL
ANTIDEPRESSANT, IS NOW APPROVED FOR
THE TREATMENT OF DEPRESSIVE SYMPTOMS
IN ADULTS WITH MDD WITH ACUTE SUICIDAL
IDEATION OR BEHAVIOR (MDSI)1
Limitations of Use:
• The effectiveness of SPRAVATO® in preventing
suicide or in reducing suicidal ideation or
behavior has not been demonstrated. Use of
SPRAVATO® does not preclude the need for
hospitalization if clinically warranted, even if
patients experience improvement after an
initial dose of SPRAVATO®.1
Please see additional Important Safety Information and Brief Summary of full Prescribing Information, including Boxed WARNINGS,
on following pages. © Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. 2020. September 2020 cp-178407v1
ADVERSE REACTIONS Dizziness includes: dizziness; dizziness exertional; dizziness postural; procedural dizziness
The following adverse reactions are discussed in more detail in other sections of the labeling: Dysarthria includes: dysarthria; slow speech; speech disorder
• Sedation [see Warnings and Precautions] Dysgeusia includes: dysgeusia; hypogeusia
Headache includes: headache; sinus headache
• Dissociation [see Warnings and Precautions]
Hypoesthesia includes: hypoesthesia; hypoesthesia oral, hypoesthesia teeth, pharyngeal hypoesthesia
• Increase in Blood Pressure [see Warnings and Precautions] Lethargy includes: fatigue; lethargy
• Cognitive Impairment [see Warnings and Precautions] Nasal discomfort includes: nasal crusting; nasal discomfort; nasal dryness; nasal pruritus
• Impaired Ability to Drive and Operate Machinery [see Warnings and Precautions] Sedation includes: altered state of consciousness; hypersomnia; sedation; somnolence
• Ulcerative or Interstitial Cystitis [see Warnings and Precautions] Tachycardia includes: extrasystoles; heart rate increased; tachycardia
• Embryo-fetal Toxicity [see Warnings and Precautions] Vertigo includes: vertigo; vertigo positional
Clinical Trials Experience Depressive Symptoms in Patients with Major Depressive Disorder with Acute Suicidal Ideation or Behavior
Because clinical trials are conducted under widely varying conditions, adverse reaction rates SPRAVATO was evaluated for safety in 262 adults for the treatment of depressive symptoms in adults
observed in the clinical trials of a drug cannot be directly compared to rates in the clinical trials of with major depressive disorder (MDD) with acute suicidal ideation or behavior [see Clinical Studies
another drug and may not reflect the rates observed in clinical practice. (14.2) in Full Prescribing Information] from two Phase 3 studies (Study 3 and Study 4) and one Phase 2
Treatment-Resistant Depression study. Of all SPRAVATO-treated patients in the completed Phase 3 studies, 184 (81%) received all eight
doses over a 4-week treatment period.
SPRAVATO was evaluated for safety in 1709 adults diagnosed with treatment-resistant depression
(TRD) [see Clinical Studies (14.1) in Full Prescribing Information] from five Phase 3 studies (3 short-term Adverse Reactions Leading to Discontinuation of Treatment
and 2 long-term studies) and one Phase 2 dose-ranging study. Of all SPRAVATO-treated patients in the In short-term studies in adults (pooled Study 3 and Study 4), the proportion of patients who discontinued
completed Phase 3 studies, 479 (30%) received at least 6 months of treatment, and 178 (11%) received treatment because of an adverse reaction was 6.2% for patients who received SPRAVATO plus oral
at least 12 months of treatment. AD compared to 3.6% for patients who received placebo nasal spray plus oral AD. Adverse reactions
Adverse Reactions Leading to Discontinuation of Treatment leading to SPRAVATO discontinuation in more than 1 patient were (in order of frequency): dissociation-
related events (2.6%), blood pressure increased (0.9%), dizziness-related events (0.9%), nausea (0.9%),
In short-term studies in adults < 65 years old (Study 1 pooled with another 4-week study), the proportion
and sedation-related events (0.9%).
of patients who discontinued treatment because of an adverse reaction was 4.6% in patients who
received SPRAVATO plus oral AD compared to 1.4% for patients who received placebo nasal spray Most Common Adverse Reactions
plus oral AD. For adults ≥ 65 years old, the proportions were 5.6% and 3.1%, respectively. In Study The most commonly observed adverse reactions in patients treated with SPRAVATO plus oral AD
2, a long-term maintenance study, the discontinuation rates because of an adverse reaction were (incidence ≥5% and at least twice that of placebo nasal spray plus oral AD) were dissociation, dizziness,
similar for patients receiving SPRAVATO plus oral AD and placebo nasal spray plus oral AD in the sedation, blood pressure increased, hypoesthesia, vomiting, euphoric mood, and vertigo. Table 3 shows
maintenance phase, at 2.6% and 2.1%, respectively. Across all Phase 3 studies, adverse reactions the incidence of adverse reactions that occurred in patients treated with SPRAVATO plus oral AD and
leading to SPRAVATO discontinuation in more than 2 patients were (in order of frequency): anxiety greater than patients treated with placebo nasal spray plus oral AD.
(1.2%), depression (0.9%), blood pressure increased (0.6%), dizziness (0.6%), suicidal ideation (0.5%),
dissociation (0.4%), nausea (0.4%), vomiting (0.4%), headache (0.3%), muscular weakness (0.3%), Table 3: Adverse Reactions Occurring in ≥2% of Adult Patients with MDD and Acute Suicidal Ideation or
vertigo (0.2%), hypertension (0.2%), panic attack (0.2%) and sedation (0.2%). Behavior Treated with SPRAVATO + Oral AD and at a Greater Rate than Patients Treated with
Placebo Nasal Spray + Oral AD
Most Common Adverse Reactions
SPRAVATO + Oral AD Placebo + Oral AD
The most commonly observed adverse reactions in patients treated with SPRAVATO plus oral AD
(incidence ≥5% and at least twice that of placebo nasal spray plus oral AD) were dissociation, dizziness, (N=227) (N=225)
nausea, sedation, vertigo, hypoesthesia, anxiety, lethargy, blood pressure increased, vomiting, and Cardiac disorders
feeling drunk. Tachycardia* 8 (4%) 2 (1%)
Table 2 shows the incidence of adverse reactions that occurred in patients treated with SPRAVATO Ear and labyrinth disorders
plus oral AD at any dose and greater than patients treated with placebo nasal spray plus oral AD. Vertigo 14 (6%) 1 (0.4%)
Table 2: Adverse Reactions Occurring in ≥2% of Adult TRD Patients Treated with SPRAVATO + Oral AD Gastrointestinal disorders
at Any Dose and at a Greater Rate than Patients Treated with Placebo Nasal Spray + Oral AD Nausea 61 (27%) 31 (14%)
SPRAVATO + Oral AD Placebo + Oral AD Vomiting 26 (11%) 12 (5%)
(N=346) (N=222)
Constipation 22 (10%) 14 (6%)
Cardiac disorders
Dry mouth 8 (4%) 6 (3%)
Tachycardia* 6 (2%) 1 (0.5%)
Toothache 5 (2%) 2 (1%)
Ear and labyrinth disorders
General disorders and administration site conditions
Vertigo* 78 (23%) 6 (3%)
Feeling drunk 8 (4%) 1 (0.4%)
Gastrointestinal disorders
Feeling of relaxation 5 (2%) 3 (1%)
Nausea 98 (28%) 19 (9%)
Vomiting 32 (9%) 4 (2%) Investigations
Diarrhea 23 (7%) 13 (6%) Blood pressure increased* 34 (15%) 14 (6%)
Dry mouth 19 (5%) 7 (3%) Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Constipation 11 (3%) 3 (1%) Myalgia 5 (2%) 1 (0.4%)
General disorders and administration site conditions Nervous system disorders
Feeling drunk 19 (5%) 1 (0.5%) Dizziness* 103 (45%) 34 (15%)
Feeling abnormal 12 (3%) 0 (0%) Sedation* 66 (29%) 27 (12%)
Investigations Dysgeusia* 46 (20%) 29 (13%)
Blood pressure increased* 36 (10%) 6 (3%) Hypoesthesia* 30 (13%) 4 (2%)
Nervous system disorders Lethargy* 10 (4%) 4 (2%)
Dizziness* 101 (29%) 17 (8%) Confusional state 5 (2%) 0 (0%)
Sedation* 79 (23%) 21 (9%) Psychiatric disorders
Headache* 70 (20%) 38 (17%) Dissociation* 108 (48%) 30 (13%)
Dysgeusia* 66 (19%) 30 (14%) Anxiety* 34 (15%) 20 (9%)
Hypoesthesia* 63 (18%) 5 (2%) Euphoric mood 17 (7%) 1 (0.4%)
Lethargy* 37 (11%) 12 (5%) Intentional self-injury 7 (3%) 3 (1%)
Dysarthria* 15 (4%) 0 (0%)
Dysphoria 5 (2%) 0 (0%)
Tremor 12 (3%) 2 (1%)
Renal and urinary disorders
Mental impairment 11 (3%) 2 (1%)
Pollakiuria* 5 (2%) 2 (1%)
Psychiatric disorders
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Dissociation* 142 (41%) 21 (9%)
Anxiety* 45 (13%) 14 (6%) Oropharyngeal pain 10 (4%) 3 (1%)
Insomnia 29 (8%) 16 (7%) Throat irritation 9 (4%) 5 (2%)
Euphoric mood 15 (4%) 2 (1%) Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders
Renal and urinary disorders Hyperhidrosis* 11 (5%) 5 (2%)
Pollakiuria 11 (3%) 1 (0.5%) * The following terms were combined:
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders Anxiety includes: agitation; anxiety; anxiety disorder; fear; irritability; nervousness; panic attack;
Nasal discomfort* 23 (7%) 11 (5%) psychomotor hyperactivity; tension
Blood pressure increased includes: blood pressure diastolic increased; blood pressure increased;
Throat irritation 23 (7%) 9 (4%) blood pressure systolic increased; hypertension
Oropharyngeal pain 9 (3%) 5 (2%) Dissociation includes: depersonalization/derealization disorder; derealization; diplopia; dissociation;
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders dysesthesia; feeling cold; feeling hot; hallucination; hallucination, auditory; hallucination, visual;
Hyperhidrosis 14 (4%) 5 (2%) hallucinations, mixed; hyperacusis; paresthesia; paresthesia oral; pharyngeal paresthesia;
photophobia; time perception altered; tinnitus; vision blurred
* The following terms were combined: Dizziness includes: dizziness; dizziness exertional; dizziness postural
Anxiety includes: agitation; anticipatory anxiety; anxiety; fear; feeling jittery; irritability; nervousness; Dysgeusia includes: dysgeusia; hypogeusia
panic attack; tension Hyperhidrosis includes: cold sweat; hyperhidrosis
Blood pressure increased includes: blood pressure diastolic increased; blood pressure increased; Hypoesthesia includes: hypoesthesia; hypoesthesia oral; intranasal hypoesthesia; pharyngeal
blood pressure systolic increased; hypertension hypoesthesia
Dissociation includes: delusional perception; depersonalization/derealization disorder; derealization; Lethargy includes: fatigue; lethargy; psychomotor retardation
diplopia; dissociation; dysesthesia; feeling cold; feeling hot; feeling of body temperature change; Pollakiuria includes: micturition urgency; pollakiuria
hallucination; hallucination, auditory; hallucination, visual; hyperacusis; illusion; ocular discomfort; oral Sedation includes: sedation; somnolence; stupor
dysesthesia; paresthesia; paresthesia oral; pharyngeal paresthesia; photophobia; time perception altered; Tachycardia includes: heart rate increased; sinus tachycardia; tachycardia
tinnitus; vision blurred; visual impairment
cp-81105v6
The Importance
Editors in Chief Emeriti Addiction & Substance Disorders: Cornel Stanciu, MD
John L. Schwartz, MD | Founder Book Reviews: Howard L. Forman, MD
Climate Change: Elizabeth Haase, MD
Ronald Pies, MD Digital Psychiatry: John Torous, MD
Emeritus Professor of Psychiatry, SUNY Upstate Medical Center,
Ethics: Cynthia M. A. Geppert, MD, MA, MPH, MSBE, DPS, FAPM
Syracuse, and Tufts University School of Medicine
Mood Disorders: Chris Aiken, MD and James Phelps, MD
of Learning
James L. Knoll IV, MD Neuropsychiatry: Rajesh R. Tampi, MD, MS
Director of Forensic Psychiatry, Professor of Psychiatry, Psychosomatics/C&L Psychiatry: James A. Bourgeois, MD
SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse
Schizophrenia & Psychosis: Brian Miller, MD
Allan Tasman, MD
Professor and Emeritus Chair, Department of Psychiatry and EDITORIAL
Behavioral Sciences, University of Louisville School of Medicine
A
Associate Editorial Director..................... Heidi Anne Duerr, MPH
Deputy Editor in Chief Emeritus Senior Digital Managing Editor..............................Laurie Martin
Associate Editor............................................. Paul Gleason, PhD
lbert Einstein once said, “Intellectual growth should commence at
Michelle B. Riba, MD, MS
Assistant Editor......................................................... Leah Kuntz
Professor, Integrated Medicine and Psychiatric Services; Associate
Director, Comprehensive Depression Center; Director, PsychOncology
birth and cease only at death.” Nowhere is that truer than in medi-
DESIGN & PRODUCTION
Program; Director, Psychosomatic Fellowship Program, University of
Michigan
cine. As research uncovers new mechanisms of action for pharma-
Creative Director..................................................Robert McGarr
Senior Art Director................................................ Nicole Slocum cology and etiologies of disorders, physicians must keep up with the latest
John J. Miller, MD | Editor in Chief Graphic Designer................................................... Maia Thagard
Medical Director, Brain Health, Exeter, NH
Staff Psychiatrist, Seacoast Mental Health Center
Circulation Director.......................................... Jonathan Severn and most effective ways to help their patients.
Production Director..........................................Keyonna Graham
Renato D. Alarcón, MD, MPH John J. Miller, MD, sets the stage with his editorial, a personal reflection
Emeritus Professor, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine
Richard Balon, MD
For comments, suggestions, or questions, contact the on a lifetime of learning. Even after nearly 30 years of practice, he admits he
editorial staff by e-mail at: PTEditor@mjhlifesciences.com
Professor of Psychiatry, Wayne State University
Articles are invited. If you would like your work to be considered for
has mastered only the first 5 letters of the “psychiatric alphabet.” He exhorts
Robert J. Boland, MD
publication, please send an Abstract to PTEditor@mjhlifesciences.com.
Vice Chair for Education, Department of Psychiatry, Brigham clinicians to join him as he seeks a deeper understanding of the psychiatric
and Women’s Hospital/Harvard Medical School
Peter F. Buckley, MD ADVERTISING INFORMATION ABCs. And Psychiatric Times® is honored to support you in that endeavor.
Dean, School of Medicine Virginia Commonwealth University Executive Vice President..........................................Brian Haug
Gregory Eghigian, PhD
bhaug@mjhlifesciences.com Perhaps the most exciting learning happens at the frontiers of knowl-
Professor of Modern History, Penn State University Group Publisher..................................................... Aviva Belsky
abelsky@mjhlifesciences.com edge, where new discoveries are made. In this issue you will find clinical
Michael B. First, MD
Professor of Clinical Psychiatry, Columbia University Associate Publisher.................................................Erik Hogger
ehogger@mjhlifesciences.com and commentary pieces that explore new research, outline novel strategies
Tony P. George, MD
Professor of Psychiatry, University of Toronto
Classified Sales Manager......................................... Jules Leo
jleo@mjhlifesciences.com to overcome challenges, and share lessons from experiential learning. Our
Cynthia M. A. Geppert, MD, MA, MPH, MSBE, DPS, FAPM continuing medical education article, for example, discusses considerations
Professor of Psychiatry, Director of Ethics Education,
CORPORATE
University of New Mexico School of Medicine
Chairman and Founder................................. Mike Hennessy Sr
surrounding medical cannabis. Although it is gaining medical acceptance
Thomas G. Gutheil, MD
Professor of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School
Vice Chairman....................................................Jack Lepping and piquing patient interest, cannabis raises important medicolegal ques-
President and CEO.......................................Mike Hennessy Jr
Jerald Kay, MD
Emeritus Professor of Psychiatry, Wright State University
Chief Financial Officer........................... Neil Glasser, CPA/CFE tions, and clinicians need to know what they are and how to answer.
Chief Marketing Officer...................................... Michael Baer
Thomas Kosten, MD
Executive Vice President, Operations...................... Tom Tolvé
At the same time, there is always something new to learn, even about the
JH Waggoner Chair and Professor of Psychiatry, Neuroscience,
Pharmacology, Immunology & Pathology, Baylor College of Medicine Executive Vice President, ................................ Joe Petroziello
Global Medical Affairs and Corporate Development
most familiar topics. Within these pages, we include articles that explore
Helen Lavretsky, MD, MS
Professor of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences,
Senior Vice President, Content............................. Silas Inman core clinical areas, including mood disorders, schizophrenia and psychosis,
David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA Senior Vice President, .....................................John Moricone
CLINICAL
FROM THE EDITOR ANXIETY & STRESS
The Practice
DISORDERS
30 Managing Distress in Health Care
Workers During COVID-19: Lessons
F
or me, the fall has always con-
jured excitement about a new
COVER STORIES Rajesh R. Tampi, MD, MS, DFAPA, DFAAGP,
Deena J. Tampi, MSN, MBA-HCA, RN,
Presidential Election Anxiety DFAAGP, and Michael Parish, MD
odyssey of learning. With the
and the Role of Psychiatry
first days of school came both ex- H. Steven Moffic, MD
citement and fear, wondering if I
had the ability to learn all that was Is the Country Experiencing a
expected of me. During the previous Mental Health Pandemic?
COLUMNS
academic year, I had listened with Ronald W. Pies, MD MOOD DISORDERS
awe as students in the grade ahead BIPOLAR UPDATE
of mine discussed their subject mat- 32 Oxcarbazepine: Does It Have
ter, and each year I wondered how I a Role in Bipolar Disorder?
FROM THE CHAIRMAN David N. Osser, MD
could ever learn that complex mate- 07 The Importance of Learning
rial. One memory in particular re- Mike Hennessy Sr MEDICAL ECONOMICS
mains alive and well, and it visits 13 The Ethics of Reopening
me a few times each year. FROM THE EDITOR Tia Powell, MD
I was in the first grade at St 09 The Practice of Medicine
James Elementary School, a paro- DR MILLER is Medical Director, John J. Miller, MD POETRY OF THE TIMES
chial elementary school in Salem, Brain Health, Exeter, NH; Editor in 26 I Don’t Want to Die
MA. An intimidating nun informed Chief, Psychiatric Times; Staff Here in Timbuktu
Psychiatrist, Seacoast Mental Richard M. Berlin, MD
us we would be learning the com-
plete alphabet. Fear filled me as I Health Center, Exeter, NH; CATEGORY 1 CME
Consulting Psychiatrist, Exeter 38 Between Stoned and a Hard
anticipated what felt like the impos- Place? Navigating Cannabis
Hospital, Exeter, NH; Consulting
sibility of learning all 26 letters of
Psychiatrist, Insight Meditation Medicolegal Issues COMMENTARY
the alphabet. Somehow, I succeed- Chandler Hicks, DO, Maria Lapchenko, DO,
Society, Barre, MA. ADDICTION & SUBSTANCE USE
ed, and these 26 letters have served Adrienne Saxton, MD, and Sara West, MD
36 The Case for
me well over the years. Medication-Assisted
course started with the accretion of Treatment: An Ethical Priority
the planet earth from stardust and Kultaj Kaleka, RN, and Juliette M.
Each academic year had its own CASE REPORT
moved through the theoretical pro- Perzhinsky, MD, MSc
curriculum to be mastered, and
cesses that created the molecules SCHIZOPHRENIA & PSYCHOSIS
each course of study initially 28 Documenting Recovery ANXIETY & STRESS
that eventually would become the
seemed impossible: building blocks of life. in Delusional Disorder With DISORDERS
Learning to construct a sentence Reflecting on that experience, I the MMPI-2 37 Behind Closed Doors
Alan D. Blotcky, PhD Omar Reda, MD
with nouns, verbs, and adjectives. realized that if the necessary ele-
Understanding the history of the ments were all present, learning
SPECIAL REPORT
United States as it was taught at could be fun, meaningful, and could
that time. actually be driven by passion. Sev-
eral of these elements are unique to
Playing a simple melody on a each person. Arguably, being ex- Forensic Psychiatry, Part II
xylophone. posed to a wide-ranging curriculum
Special Report Chair: James L. Knoll IV, MD
Becoming familiar with the during the high school years in-
periodic table of the elements in creases the likelihood that each stu- 14 Assessing Competency to Stand Trial
chemistry. dent will discover their passion, and Barry Wall, MD, and Ruby Lee, MD
Writing a complete term paper, hopefully they will be given the op-
16 Psychopathy: Insights for General Practice
with references expected. portunity to follow it.
Barbara Burton, MD, and Fabian M. Saleh, MD
During my 12 years of study in
It was not until the second semes- college, medical school and psychi-
ter of my sophomore year of college atry residency, I naively expected
at the University of Massachusetts that I would ultimately learn all that
COVER IMAGE: RRICE@STOCK.ADOBE.COM
gized and excited about what the and curious about the remaining 21 Periodicals postage paid at Trenton, NJ 08650 and additional mailing offices.
next lesson would teach me. The (CONTINUED ON PAGE 13) POSTMASTER: Please send address changes to Psychiatric Times ® MJH Life Sciences, PO Box 457, Cranbury NJ 08512-0457.
• Orthostatic Hypotension and Syncope. Monitor heart Drug Interactions: Avoid concomitant use with CYP3A4 inducers,
rate and blood pressure and warn patients with known cardiovascular moderate or strong CYP3A4 inhibitors and UGT inhibitors.
or cerebrovascular disease. Orthostatic vital signs should be monitored
in patients who are vulnerable to hypotension.
Special Populations: Neonates exposed to antipsychotic drugs during
the third trimester of pregnancy are at risk for extrapyramidal and/or
• Falls. CAPLYTA may cause somnolence, postural hypotension, withdrawal symptoms following delivery. Breastfeeding is not recommended.
and motor and/or sensory instability, which may lead to falls and, Avoid use in patients with moderate or severe hepatic impairment.
consequently, fractures and other injuries. Assess patients for
risk when using CAPLYTA.
Adverse Reactions: The most common adverse reactions in
clinical trials with CAPLYTA vs. placebo were somnolence/sedation
• Seizures. Use CAPLYTA cautiously in patients with a history of (24% vs. 10%) and dry mouth (6% vs. 2%).
seizures or with conditions that lower seizure threshold. Please see the accompanying Brief Summary of Prescribing Information on the following page.
• Potential for Cognitive and Motor Impairment. Advise Reference: 1. CAPLYTA prescribing information, 2019.
patients to use caution when operating machinery or motor vehicles
until they know how CAPLYTA affects them. SEE ITS EFFICACY AT CAPLYTAHCP.COM
• Body Temperature Dysregulation. Use CAPLYTA with
caution in patients who may experience conditions that may increase
core body temperature such as strenuous exercise, extreme heat,
dehydration, or concomitant anticholinergics.
• Dysphagia. Use CAPLYTA with caution in patients at risk
for aspiration. CAPLYTA is a trademark of Intra-Cellular Therapies, Inc. © 2020 Intra-Cellular Therapies, Inc. All rights reserved. 05/2020 US-CAP-1900006
Continued from Page 9 know, and consult with a colleague usually evolves into a specific area of educational opportunities to support us
who likely knows more than I do, practice that fits like a comfortable in our ongoing, self-directed learning.
letters, and I try to remain aware of when necessary. One of the many glove. It is our responsibility as phy- We at Psychiatric Times® are excited
their current contribution and appli- to invite our readers, and in fact all
cation to clinical psychiatry, but in all psychiatric providers, to join us later
honesty it is hard. this month in our Annual Psychiatric
Hence the term practice of medi-
"Even with all the right elements of Times® World CME Conference™. It
cine. Even with all the right elements interest, commitment, passion, and will be held virtually this year from
of interest, commitment, passion, October 15th through 17th. We feel priv-
and effort, my view is that it is not effort, in my view it is not humanly possible ileged to have top-quality faculty who
humanly possible to ever master psy- to ever master psychiatry. We simply will present on a wide range of topics.
chiatry. We simply must keep on The conference is directed to psychiat-
practicing, learning new information, must keep on practicing, learning new ric clinicians and will offer a wide
and honing new skills. information, and honing new skills." range of presentations that run from 15
But such is the case in every field to 30 minutes in length. Our hope is
of study, and why should medicine be that participants will be eager to apply
any different? Our primary responsi- gifts of psychiatry as a field of medi- sicians, however, to remain up to date what they have learned immediately
bility is to do no harm. In many clin- cine is its extreme diversity. The with what is happening in our field of after the conference.
ical situations this requires me to menu of specialty options we have in psychiatry in general. So please, we would love it if you
know what I know, know what I don’t the field is vast, and each psychiatrist Fortunately, there is no paucity of would come and learn with us! ❒
For more information on our Annual Psychiatric Times® World CME Conference™ and to register, please click on the
LEARN MORE following link: www.gotoper.com/conferences/psychtimes/meetings/psychtimes20conference
D
uring the fight against coronavi- ative to state the estimated results of Historically, risk communication its peak to fewer than 5.
rus disease 2019 (COVID-19), various interventions clearly, whether has been a challenge for the medical Transparency, and ultimately hon-
every American has made daily or not those results are favorable to a community, but big data and artificial esty, will help Americans make deci-
choices that could affect their health, particular political ideology. A failure intelligence (AI) can provide a useful sions based on data and facts, not on
their family’s health, and the health of to root decisions in data and analysis c h a n n e l fo r c o m muni cat i ng fear and bias. Throughout this jour-
their larger community. The deci- ultimately leads to moral failures. COVID-19-related information to ney, the governor of Rhode Island
sion-making process can feel uncer- and public health officials were very
tain and chaotic, especially when the clear about what the risks were, the
science around this virus is constantly "Transparency, and ultimately honesty, will challenges the state was facing, and
evolving. At some level, every indi- the struggles everyone was going
vidual, business owner, and politician help Americans make decisions based on through. Despite all that uncertainty,
is grappling with the same questions. data and facts, not fear and bias." the state still made impressive prog-
Unfortunately, much of the dialogue ress in containing the virus.
around reopening the country lacks This morally sound approach can
the empirical and ethical foundations During past crises, we have seen both employees and employers. My protect human life and also preserve
necessary to return to normalcy in a how those moral failures have played current work with Buoy Health and the economic opportunities individu-
sustainable way. out. Fear during the AIDS crisis led its Back with Care platform—an AI als need to survive. Honest assess-
The country cannot flourish un- to rampant discrimination against the tool designed to help employers re- ment of data and best practices en-
less we have both population and lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, open safely—is motivated by the ables individuals to respond better to
economic health. Fortunately, these 2 and queer (LGBTQ) community, in need to incorporate as much trans- changing circumstances. Strategies
goals are not really in conflict. The addition to an irrational fear of indi- parency as possible into the reopen- can shift and evolve as new informa-
strategy to maintain the safety and viduals from specific countries, most ing process for businesses. tion emerges. This pandemic has
financial well-being of our country notably Haiti. After September 11th, When leadership follows the data, made it crystal clear that what works
must be based on the best available the nation saw an uptick in hate good outcomes will follow. In Rhode 1 week may not work the next, and as
data. It must be acquired and ana- crimes against Sikhs, a religious Island, the smallest state in the coun- those facts on the ground change, so
lyzed through rational processes, group with no connection to the at- try, businesses are reopening and un- should the response to those facts.
rather than wishful thinking. Individ- tacks on our country, in addition to employment is falling. Why? Rather
uals, business owners, and politicians attacks on Muslims, millions of than ignore the impacts of the virus, Dr Powell is a bioethicist and psychi-
all face an incredibly complex puz- whom are peaceful and productive state leadership looked at what we atrist who directs the Center for
Bioethics and Masters in Bioethics at
zle, but data and technology can help American citizens. None of the fear knew about the pandemic and acted
Montefiore Health Systems and Albert
us reopen the economy and preserve and violence against these groups accordingly. The state mandated in- Einstein College of Medicine, and is a
the public’s health at the same time. made Americans safer. tensive testing, tracing, and isolation, fellow of the Hastings Center. She is
Politics in the United States are in These irrational responses to un- and they broadcasted clear messages also a member of the Buoy Health
an incredibly polarized state, which is precedented circumstances arise from about the importance of wearing Back with Care advisory board. ❒
in itself a serious problem. Reopening fear, and they are unproductive at the masks. Now, Rhode Island has one of
must be rooted in a rational deci- end of the day. What is productive— the best testing rates in the country Read more: https://bit.ly/2DKYFei
IN THIS
SPECIAL REPORT
14 Assessing Competency
to Stand Trial
Barry Wall, MD, and
Ruby Lee, MD
16 Psychopathy: Insights
for General Practice
Barbara Burton, MD, and
Fabian M. Saleh, MD
T
he United States legal system munity results in the overuse of the records from jail, prior competency In contrast, a criminal responsibility
has long recognized that crimi- CST-CR system.4 Public mental evaluations, and information shared by evaluation determines the mental
nal defendants must be compe- health care systems are in crisis, and the lawyer are some of the data that are state of the defendant at certain point
tent to stand trial (CST) prior to pro- increasingly they must devote dol- an integral part of the competency eval- in the past, specifically at the time of
ceeding with the legal process to lars to those facing criminal charges uation although they are not included in the alleged criminal incident. Addi-
allow for fairness for the accused and for costly forensic evaluations and typical psychiatric evaluations. tionally, CST trial is moment specif-
protect the integrity of the justice sys- lengthy state hospitalization stays.5 In addition to assessing the defen- ic. Therefore, a defendant could be
tem. Trying a defendant who is un- The minimum legal standard for dant’s psychiatric, medical, and so- initially recommended as CST and
able to assist in their own defense competency to stand trial was set cial histories, the defendant’s compe- later, as the case progresses, may be-
would call into question the dignity of by the US Supreme Court in Dusky tence as it relates to trial-related tasks come IST. In fact, the issue of com-
the proceedings and render the adver- v United States.6 In 1960, the court is evaluated. This includes assessing petency can be raised at any point in
sarial process unfair. Psychiatrists and determined that “it is not enough an understanding of the charges and the court process.
psychologists assist courts by evaluat- for the district judge to find that their potential consequences, an un-
ing defendants’ CST and, when nec- ‘the defendant [is] oriented to time derstanding of the trial process,
essary, providing treatment to restore and place and [has] some recollec- knowledge about the various partici- CASE EXAMPLE
competency in defendants initially tion of events,’ but that the ‘test pants in a trial, and whether the de-
found to be incompetent to stand trial must be whether he has sufficient fendant has the ability to help in their “John,” a 35-year-old man with a
(IST). The term competence resto- present ability to consult with his own defense and make decisions history of schizoaffective disorder, is
ration (CR) is used to describe the lawyer with a reasonable degree of about their case.7,8 arrested; he has been treatment non-
treatment and education process used rational understanding—and CST is a present tense evaluation, adherent for several months. Once
to transform the defendants classified whether he has a rational as well as meaning it is an evaluation that deter- detained, he is restarted on treat-
as IST to CST (Table 1).1 factual understanding of the pro- mines the current mental state of the ment. By the time the evaluators saw
CST, therefore, is a legal deci- ceedings against him.’”
sion made by a judge that deter- Defense attorneys have concerns
mines if a criminal defendant is able regarding their client’s competency in Table 1. Important Competency Terms
to proceed with the legal process. It about 8% to 15% of felony prosecu-
is also called adjudicative compe- tions, and it is estimated that about CST - Competent to stand trial
tence or fitness to proceed. It is the 20% to 30% of evaluated defendants Mental ability to stand trial; a person is mentally competent to stand trial
most commonly conducted crimi- are found incompetent to stand trial.1 if they are able to understand the character and consequences of the
nal forensic evaluation in the United If a judge determines a defendant is proceedings against them and is able properly to assist in their defense.
States. There has been a surge in CST, the legal case proceeds. If the IST - Incompetent to stand trial
CST evaluation requests in recent judge determines a defendant is IST,
MAKIBESTPHOTO@STOCK.ADOBE.COM
Table 2. Common Competency and that a clinical evaluation cannot a factual understanding of the case managed to get probation.
Assessment Tools be replaced by a competency assess- (such as case travel, various pleas, Tony violates a no contact order,
ment instrument, consider the fol- etc), the law student’s ability to ap- and because of his history of intellec-
CAI - Competency Assessment Instrument lowing case. ply the information to her own case tual disability, his competency to
13 areas of functioning
would be impaired, as she does not stand trial is questioned. After an
Takes about 1 hour
“Jodi,” a 25-year-old law student with have a rational understanding of the evaluation, including a clinical evalu-
Scoring not standardized
a long history of treatment nonadher- situation. She is viewing the situa- ation and the CAST-MR, it is clear that
GCCT - Georgia Court Competence Test ence, once again stops her medica- tion through a psychotic process. he has an understanding of the
21 items that fall into 3 domains tions because they made her thinking This defendant would also be recom- charges and their potential conse-
Takes about 10 minutes “too slow.” She becomes increasingly mended as IST, despite her in-depth quences. Plus, as a result of years of
CAST-MR paranoid. On a particularly bad day, knowledge of the law, as she was un- experience in the court system, Tony
Competence Assessment for Standing Trial Jodi calls the police for backup, as able to comport her behavior appro- also has a good handle on the trial
for Defendants with Mental Retardation she believes that people are walking priately in the civil mental health process. He tells you that he is inter-
50 questions around downtown with bombs in court. By extrapolation, if the crimi- ested in accepting a deal, because it
backpacks. The police arrive as she is nal court judge ordered a CST evalu- will allow him to avoid going to jail.
being arrested—she was trying to ation, she would likely be recom- Tony further explains he would prefer
him in jail, John was no longer take a backpack from a passerby, be- mended to the court as IST because to admit to some form of guilt to be
SPECIALREPORT
thought-disordered because his con- lieving a bomb to be inside. she was unable to work with her at- quickly paroled so that he can see his
dition had improved with treatment. Since she refuses medication, the torney in civil court due to mental newborn child.
He, therefore, had an understanding treatment team requests the court to illness symptoms.
of his charges and potential conse- medicate despite objection. During Although there are no diagnoses
quences. However, given his history the hearing in mental health court to that equal IST, psychosis and intel- This case illustrates that an intel-
of mental illness and his bizarre be- determine treatment, Jodi, being a lectual disability are the 2 most com- lectual disability does not automati-
havior at the time of the arrest, a CST law student, starts to question the mon clinical reasons that defendants cally equate with incompetence. Pri-
evaluation was ordered. psychiatrist. She is well versed in the are found incompetent to stand trial. or experience in the legal system
John was recommended as CST, requirements that are needed for in- Nonetheless, a defendant with would be an important factor in this
which was accepted by the court. voluntary medication, and she insists schizophrenia can be competent and, case. The defendant had repeated ex-
However, as months passed, the de- on cross examining the psychiatrist, similarly, a defendant with intellectu- posure to the system, giving him a lot
fendant started having difficulty despite the judge advising her to de- al disability can be competent. Con- of practical experience. As such, it is
sleeping and became increasingly fer to her attorney. sider the following case example. likely that he would be competent to
paranoid. He ultimately stopped tak- stand trial, even though he has an in-
ing his medicines. When his defense “Tony” is a 25-year-old man who has tellectual disability.
attorney tried to meet with him, John In such a case, a law student who been in and out of the legal system
began muttering under his breath is knowledgeable about the legal sys- since he was a teenager. He was not Concluding thoughts
that the lawyer was conspiring with tem would do well on scoring instru- a high school graduate; he dropped Currently, public mental health ser-
the judge and the police. ments. However, in undergoing a out in the middle of tenth grade as he vices are inundated with court refer-
thorough CST evaluation, the evalu- no longer wanted to go to school. He rals for CST evaluations. When de-
ator would realize that the defendant successfully worked with his attorney fendants are IST, the CST-CR system
In the above scenario, the defen- is paranoid and likely unable to assist on several other misdemeanors, both often cannot keep up with demand.
dant was disorganized during the time in her own defense despite having a in family court as a juvenile and in the This has resulted in wait lists for
of arrest, but by the time the CST strong factual base of knowledge. criminal court system as an adult. He competency-related services for jail
evaluation was ordered, he was back Therefore, while the law student has has never served time, as he always detainees. States have been sued for
on medications and was overall func-
tioning well. Therefore, he was first
recommended as CST. However, Figure. Example of the CST Process
once he stopped taking his medica-
tions in jail, he became psychotic, re- IST COMMITMENT PROCESS
fused to work collaboratively with his
Defendant returns to court. If
attorney, and believed the legal sys- substantial evidence is presented
Defendant’s competency has Defendant is given an evaluation
tem was conspiring against him. At on defendant’s incompetency, then
been questioned by attorney(s). and, if needed, treatment.
that point, if a second evaluation were a competency hearing is scheduled.
ordered, he would likely be found IST
and remanded for CR services.
There are multiple competency
assessment instruments that supple-
ment clinical evaluations (Table 2). Generally, those accused of
While these formalized checklists misdemeanors are handled in an
and structured interviews can assist outpatient setting or released. If the defendant is found
evaluators with competency assess- incompetent, community Competency hearing held
ments, they do not replace a thorough mental health program which includes 1 or 2 psychiatrists
clinical evaluation. Some examples director is ordered by a who testify on their evaluation of
court to evaluate the best the defendant.
include the Competency Assessment
Instrument (CAI), the Georgia Court Generally, those accused of place to restore competency.
Competence Test (GCCT), and the felonies wait in county jail to be
Competence Assessment for Stand- transferred to a state hospital
ing Trial for Defendants with Mental to receive IST treatment.
IST = Incompetent to stand trial.
Retardation (CAST-MR).8
To illustrate how critical the clini- Source: Legislative Analyst’s Office, The California Legislature’s Nonpartisan Fiscal and Policy Advisor. Accessed September 2, 2020.
cal evaluation is in CST evaluations, https://lao.ca.gov/reports/2012/hlth/ist/incompetent-stand-trial-010312.aspx
P
T here is no diagnosis that automatically sychopathy is a personality disorder charac- tional processing.5,6 The brains of individuals
renders a defendant IST. terized by lack of empathy, grandiosity, with psychopathy have identifiable structural and
N
o competence test can substitute for a shallow affect, deceitfulness, impulsivity, functional differences from the brains of those
thorough clinical competence evaluation. irresponsibility, and disregard for the well-being without, which appear to account for some of the
or rights of others. Few syndromes in medicine cognitive and behavioral manifestations of the
T he current CST-CR system is have carved as deep of a niche in human cultural disorder. Reduced gray matter volumes in the
SPECIALREPORT
Diagnosis PCL-R and PCL-SV may help guide the condition is capable of respond- fourth year psychiatry resident at Beth
The gold standard instrument for as- formulation, the diagnosis of psy- ing to treatment. Although data are Israel Deaconess Medical Center in
sessing psychopathy is the Hare Psy- chopathy in the general outpatient still limited, the treatment of psy- Boston, MA. She will be matriculating
chopathy Checklist Revised or setting must be made carefully and chopathy has begun to gain traction to the forensic psychiatry fellowship
PCL-R.11 In the forensic setting, per- only with substantial amounts of data as a target for clinical research. The program at the University of
formance of the PCL-R is accompa- Massachusetts Medical School.
nied by extensive collateral investiga- REFERENCES
tion, psychiatric interview, and
review of the individual’s medical, “While incarceration is the definitive ‘treatment’ for 1. Walsh A, Wu H-H. Differentiating antisocial personal-
ity disorder, psychopathy, and sociopathy: evolutionary,
social, and criminal history. There is some, psychopathy exists on a spectrum like any other genetic, neurological, and sociological considerations.
Criminal Justice Studies. 2008;21(2):135-152.
also a screening version of the
PCL-R, the PCL-SV, which can be mental disorder; more recent research suggests the 2. Werner, KB, Few, LR., Bucholz, KK. Epidemiology,
comorbidity, and behavioral genetics of antisocial
performed outside of the specialized
forensic setting (Table).12 The PLC-R condition is capable of responding to treatment.” personality disorder and psychopathy. Psychiatr Ann.
2015;45(4):195-199.
3. Hart, SD, Storey, JE. Clinical and forensic issues in the
and its derivatives have demonstrated assessment of psychopathy. In: Weiner, IB, eds. Handbook
good interrater reliability and can po- of Psychology. John Wiley & Sons, Inc; 2013: 556-578.
tentially be useful when leveraged by gathered through the physician-pa- substantial evidence supporting the 4. Babiak, P, Neumann, CS, Hare, RD. Corporate psy-
SPECIALREPORT
objective and ethical evaluators who tient relationship over time. existence of cognitive and emotional chopathy: Talking the walk. Behav Sci Law.
2010;28(2):174-193..
are trained to interpret the instru- The differential diagnosis for psy- processing deficits in people with 5. Anderson, NE, Steele, VR, Maurer, JM, Rao, V, Koe-
ments and to provide honest and im- chopathy includes a personality dis- psychopathy suggests that these are nigs, MR, Decety, J, Kosson, DS, Calhoun, VD, Kiehl, KA.
partial professional opinions. How- turbance due to another mental illness potential treatment targets. Indeed, 2017. Differentiating emotional processing and atten-
ever, concerns have been raised about or physical condition. For example, cognitive behavioral and cognitive tion in psychopathy with functional neuroimaging. .
Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci. 2017;17(3):491-515.
the susceptibility of the tests to bias individuals with frontotemporal de- remediation techniques have shown
6. Baskin-Sommers AR, Curtin JJ, Newman JP. Altering
when performed by individuals who mentia may present with impulsive some promise.6,17,18 Some have also the Cognitive-Affective Dysfunctions of Psychopathic and
lack this expertise.13 These tools have behavior and an apparent lack of re- suggested that the interpersonal and Externalizing Offender Subtypes with Cognitive Remedi-
also exhibited wide variability in gard for others. Autism spectrum dis- affective symptoms of psychopathy ation. Clin Psychol Sci. 2015;3(1):45-57.
7. Johanson M, Vaurio O, Tiihonen J, Lähteenvuo M. A
their ability to predict future violence orders may also present with impaired may be amenable to modified dialec-
Systematic Literature Review of Neuroimaging of
and their use in the assessment of risk mentalization and apparent lack of tical behavioral therapy techniques.19 Psychopathic Traits. Front Psychiatry. 2020;10:1027
must be approached with caution. empathy. Psychotic illnesses may Data are limited regarding the use of 8. Contreras-Rodríguez O, Pujol J, Batalla I, et al. Dis-
There are significant ethical concerns produce a flattened affect with the ap- medication to target psychopathic rupted neural processing of emotional faces in psychop-
athy. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2014;9(4):505-512
regarding the potential misuse of pearance of shallow or blunted emo- personality traits. The best approach
9. Geurts DE, von Borries K, Volman I, Bulten BH, Cools R,
these tests in legal and clinical deci- tional responses. Patients who are to pharmacotherapy is to target and Verkes RJ. Neural connectivity during reward expectation
sion making when the fate of an indi- dependent on a substance may exhib- treat comorbid psychiatric disorders. dissociates psychopathic criminals from non-criminal
vidual’s liberty or the safety of others it manipulativeness and recklessness individuals with high impulsive/antisocial psychopathic
traits. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2016;11(8):1326-1334.
is at stake.14,15 While the items in the when their disorder is decompensat- Conclusion 10. Steinert SW, Lishner DA, Vitacco MJ, Hong PY.
ed, and then improve when receiving Although it may be daunting to en- Conceptualizing successful psychopathy: An elabora-
Table. Items in the Screening appropriate treatment. counter a patient with psychopathy in tion of the moderated-expression model. Aggression
Version of the Hare The concept of psychopathy in pe- the general practice setting, this syn- and violent behavior. 2017;36:44-51.
11. Hare RD. The Psychopathy Checklist–Revised,
Psychopathy Checklist- diatric patients is complex and contro- drome is well defined and can be ap-
2nd ed. Multi Health System; 2003.
Revised (PCL-SV) versial. Psychopathy is similar to oth- proached clinically in a manner sim- 12. Hare RD, Hart SD, Cox DN. The Hare PCL:SV—
er personality disorders in that it is not ilar to other personality disorders. Psychopathy Checklist Screening Version. Multi-
1 Superficial diagnosed prior to adulthood, due to Essential elements include examina- Health Systems; 1995.
13. Hare RD. Psychopathy, the PCL-R, and criminal jus-
the fluidity of personality traits during tion of the history and patient’s moti-
2 Grandiose tice: Some new findings and current issues. Canadian
early development and the inability to vation for care, assessment and treat- Psychology/psychologie Canadienne. 2016;57(1):21-34.
3 Deceitful predict which children will go on to ment of comorbid conditions, and 14. DeMatteo D, Hart SD, Heilbrun K, et al. Statement
develop a disorder and which will not. collaboration with family members of concerned experts on the use of the Hare Psychop-
athy Checklist—Revised in capital sentencing to as-
4 Lacks remorse Furthermore, multiple items in the and other treatment providers. Psy-
sess risk for institutional violence. Psychol Public
adult diagnostic criteria are predicat- chopathy is associated with an in- Policy Law. 2020;26(2):133-144.
5 Lacks empathy ed on the patient having had sufficient creased risk of violence; however, 15. Singh JP, Fazel S, Gueorguieva R, Buchanan A.
Does not accept years of life to fulfill them (such as this relationship is more complex Rates of violence in patients classified as high risk by
6 parasitic lifestyle or multiple short- than it appears and remains the sub- structured risk assessment instruments. Br J Psychi-
responsibility atry. 2014;204(3):180-187.
term marital relationships). Any as- ject of ongoing research.20 As neuro- 16. Larsen RR. Psychopathy Treatment and the Stig-
7 Impulsive sessment of psychopathic traits in a logical and psychological investiga- ma of Yesterday’s Research. Kennedy Inst Ethics J.
child or adolescent patient must be tions continue, the future appears more 2019;29(3):243-272.
8 Poor behavioral controls 17. Sewall LA, Olver ME. Psychopathy and treatment
approached with extreme caution. promising than previously thought.
outcome: Results from a sexual violence reduction
9 Lacks goals program. Personal Disord. 2019;10(1):59-69.
Treatment Dr Saleh is a child & adolescent and fo- 18. Wong SCP, Gordon A, Gu D, Lewis K, Olver ME. The
10 Irresponsible A perilous belief once persisted in the rensic psychiatrist. He is the director of effectiveness of violence reduction treatment for psy-
scientific community that psychopa- the Sexual Violence Prevention & Risk chopathic offenders: Empirical evidence and a treat-
Adolescent antisocial ment model. International Journal of Forensic Mental
11
behavior
thy was not only untreatable, but that Management Program at Beth Israel Health. 2012;11:336-349.
attempting to treat a psychopath was Deaconess Medical Center, and a 19. White BA, Oliver ME, Lilienfeld SO. Psychopathy:
12 Adult antisocial behavior affirmatively harmful.16 While incar- Harvard Medical School faculty. His Its relevance, nature, assessment, and treatment. The
ceration is the definitive “treatment” forensic practice focuses on criminal Behavior Therapist. 2016;39(5):154-161.
Items are assigned scores of 0 (does not 20. Camp JP, Skeem JL, Barchard K, Lilienfeld SO,
apply), 1 (somewhat applies), or 2 for some, psychopathy exists on a and civil cases including sex offender, Poythress NG. Psychopathic predators? Getting spe-
(definitely applies), with a score >= 18
considered indicative of psychopathy. spectrum like any other mental disor- threat, competency, and criminal re- cific about the relation between psychopathy and vio-
Adapted from: Hare et al. (1995). der; more recent research suggests sponsibility assessments. Dr Burton is lence. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2013;81(3):467-480. ❒
cesses, and McGovern lost in a land- Black President. Did those reactions ish flu and the public panic that accom- the Assembly of the American
slide. McGovern may have been too last and influence the election of panied it was the need for the govern- Psychiatric Association in 2002. He
anxious about Eagleton’s depressive President Trump? ment to be honest and open.19 has recently been leading Tikkun
episodes, which may have cost him the Whatever the case, the period after Since psychiatry has expertise in Olam advocacy movements on cli-
seat. And, as we psychiatrists know, the 2020 election may be more anx- distinguishing fantasy from reality, as mate instability, burnout,
recurrence may be a risk, but it is not a ious still. There are already wide- well as managing anxiety, we are es- Islamophobia, and Anti-Semitism for
a better world. He serves on the ination and depression, even as their education and in anxiety: an integrated neurobiological and psycholog- com/us/blog/anger-in-the-age-entitlement/201604/
incomes rise. The Conversation. July 21, 2020. ical perspective. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2013;14(7):488-501. do-you-suffer-election-stress-disorder
Editorial Board of Psychiatric Times.
5. Assari S. Interaction between race and gender on 11. Lykken DT. A study of anxiety in the sociopathic 17. Stosny S: Post election stress disorder. Psychology To-
implicit racial bias against blacks. Intern J Epidemio- personality. J Abnorm Psychol. 1957;55(1):6-10. day. November 4, 2008. Accessed September 11, 2020.
REFERENCES logic Research. 2018;5(2):43-49. 12. Lebrecht N. Genius & Anxiety: How Jews Changed https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/do-the-right-
1. Albertson B. Anxious Politics: Democratic Citizenship in 6. Lerer L, Plott E, Gamio L. How Americans feel the World, 1847-1947. Scribner; 2019. thing/201702/post-election-stress-disorder-is-it-thing
a Threatening World. Cambridge University Press; 2015. about the country right now: Anxious. Hopeful. New 13. Dickinson MJ, Fava EJ. Anxiety and depression may 18. Maslow A. Toward a Psychology of Being. Sub-
2. Bethune, S. Americans are stressed about the presi- York Times. June 27, 2020. have an evolutionary role as negative reinforcers, encourag- lime Books, 2014.
dential election. Monitor on Psychology, 51(1). January 7. Moffic HS. FDR, the Bene Gesserit, and the Psychi- ing socialization. Medical Hypotheses. 2006;66(6):796-800. 19. Barry JM. What the 1918 flu pandemic teaches
1, 2020. Accessed September 11, 2020. http://www. atry of Fear. Psychiatric Times. March 31, 2020. 14. The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump: 37 Psychi- us. Yesterday’s lessons inform today’s prepared-
apa.org/monitor/2020/01/news-stressed-election https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/fdr-be- atrists and Mental Health Experts Assess a President. ness. MLO Med Lab Obs. 2006;38(9):26-28.
3. Czeisler MÉ, Lane RI, Petrosky E, et al. Mental ne-gesserit-and-psychiatry-fear. Lee B, ed. Thomas Dunne Books; 2019. 20. The Principles of Medical Ethics, With Annotations
Health, Substance Use, and Suicidal Ideation During 8. Yalom I. Existential Psychotherapy. Basic Books; 1980. 15. McGovern G. Grassroots: The Autobiography of Especially Applicable to Psychiatry. American Psychi-
the COVID-19 Pandemic - United States, June 24-30, 9. Kim MJ, Shin J, Taylor JM, Mattek AM, Chavez SJ, George McGovern. Random House; 1977. atric Association Publishing, 2013 Edition.
2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2020;69(32): Whalen PJ. Intolerance of uncertainty predicts in- 16. Stosny S. Do you suffer from election stress dis- 21. Moffic HS. Should the 2020s be the psychiatric
1049-1057. Published 2020 Aug 14. creased striatal volume. Emotion. 2017;17(6):895-899. order? Psychology Today. April 15, 2016. Accessed decade of the social? A debate. World Social Psychi-
4. Assari S, Curry TJ. Black men face higher discrim- 10. Grupe DW, Nitschke JB. Uncertainty and anticipation September 11, 2020. https://www.psychologytoday. atry. 2020;2(2):156-158. ❒
INDICATION
SECUADO (asenapine) transdermal system is indicated for the treatment of adults with schizophrenia.
®
IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION
WARNING:
INCREASED MORTALITY IN ELDERLY PATIENTS WITH DEMENTIA-RELATED PSYCHOSIS
Elderly patients with dementia-related psychosis treated with antipsychotic drugs are at an increased
risk of death. SECUADO is not approved for the treatment of patients with dementia-related psychosis
Please see additional Important Safety Information and Brief Summary of full
Prescribing Information, including BOXED WARNING, on following pages.
All this has led many news outlets awkward term. (Ironically, mental TRAUMA/STRESSOR-RELATED DISORDER SYMPTOMS 26%
and even some psychiatrists to de- health pandemic understood in epide- STARTED OR INCREASED SUBSTANCE USE 13%
clare a “mental health pandemic” or miological terms would mean some-
SERIOUSLY CONSIDERED SUICIDE† 11%
“secondary pandemic” amidst the al- thing like “a worldwide outbreak of
ready devastating COVID-19 pan- mental health.”) While well-inten- *Based on a survey of US adults aged ≥18 years during June 24-30, 2020
demic.2 I found about 145,000 results, tioned, the casual and colloquial use †
In the 30 days prior to survey
searching the term mental health pan- of the term pandemic is not warranted
SOURCE: CDC.gov
demic on Google. Indeed, several re- in this context.
ACTOR PORTRAYAL
Tardive Dyskinesia (TD): Risk of TD and the likelihood that it will become irreversible increases with the duration of
treatment and the cumulative dose of antipsychotic drugs, including SECUADO. TD can develop after relatively brief
treatment periods, even at low doses, and may also occur after discontinuation of treatment. Prescribe SECUADO in
a manner most likely to reduce the risk of TD. If signs and symptoms of TD appear, drug discontinuation should
be considered.
Metabolic Changes: Atypical antipsychotic drugs, including SECUADO, have caused metabolic changes, including
the following:
• Hyperglycemia and Diabetes Mellitus: Hyperglycemia, in some cases associated with ketoacidosis, hyperosmolar
coma, or death, has been reported in patients treated with atypical antipsychotics. Hyperglycemia has been
reported in patients treated with sublingual asenapine. Assess fasting plasma glucose before or soon after initiation
of treatment, and monitor periodically during long-term treatment.
• Dyslipidemia: Atypical antipsychotics cause adverse alterations in lipids. Before or soon after initiation of
antipsychotic medication, obtain a baseline fasting lipid profile and monitor periodically during treatment.
• Weight Gain: Weight gain has been observed with atypical antipsychotics, including SECUADO. Monitor weight at
baseline and frequently thereafter.
Orthostatic Hypotension, Syncope, and Other Hemodynamic Effects: Atypical antipsychotics cause orthostatic
hypotension and syncope. The risk is greatest during the initial dose titration and when increasing the dose. Monitor
orthostatic vital signs and patients who are vulnerable to hypotension. Use SECUADO cautiously with other drugs
that can cause hypotension, bradycardia, respiratory or central nervous system depression. Consider a dose reduction if
hypotension occurs.
Of course, I understand that the in- ported that bogus claim.3,4 And this is to a disease epidemic that has spread Upon careful, clinical evaluation,
tention underlying the term is to high- more than a semantic quibble. The use over several countries or continents, such self-reported symptoms may or
light a worldwide upsurge in mental or misuse of language can have powerful usually affecting a large number of may not turn out to be a clinically sig-
health issues and symptoms, which is effects on the public’s beliefs and percep- people.7 The critical term here is dis- nificant disease or mental illness. The
a valid concern. But problems often tions—witness the baneful effects of the ease, and the critical point is that CDC report itself notes this limitation
arise when we co-opt terms and apply “schizophrenogenic mother”5 or “chem- self-reported symptoms obtained from of its survey, stating “a diagnostic
them to psychiatry. For example, the ical imbalance” tropes.6 a screening survey do not establish the evaluation for anxiety disorder or de-
same casual misuse of epidemiologi- Let us back up a bit and explore the presence of a psychiatric disease, ill- pressive disorder was not conducted.”1
cal terms has been commonly used in definitions of these terms. An epidemic ness, or disorder. Many people can ex- Consider the diagnosis of general-
the popular press for years when refer- refers to an increase, often sudden, in perience a new onset of—or an increase ized anxiety disorder (GAD). Accord-
ring to various “epidemics” of psychi- the number of cases of a disease above in—one or more symptoms of anxiety ing to the DSM-5, symptoms must be
atric illness in the United States—even what is normally expected in that pop- or depression, but not meet clinical cri- present for at least 6 months—so no
though no credible evidence ever sup- ulation in that area. A pandemic refers teria for a psychiatric disorder. one who responded to the CDC sur-
Potential for Cognitive and Motor Impairment: Somnolence was reported in patients treated with SECUADO. Cereb
In pla
Caution patients about operating hazardous machinery, including motor vehicles, until they are reasonably certain aripip
that SECUADO does not affect them adversely. stroke
Body Temperature Regulation: Use SECUADO with caution in patients who will experience conditions that increase Neuro
body temperature (strenuous exercise, extreme heat, dehydration and concomitant anticholinergics). A pote
been
Dysphagia: SECUADO should be used cautiously in patients at risk for aspiration. Esophageal dysmotility and hyper
may i
aspiration have been associated with antipsychotic drug use. NMS i
and m
External Heat: Avoid direct external heat sources while wearing SECUADO.
Tardiv
Application Site Reactions: During wear time or immediately after removal of SECUADO, local skin irritation may Tardiv
occur. Instruct patients to select a different patch application site each day to limit the occurrence of skin irritation. devel
amon
to dev
Adverse Reactions: Commonly observed adverse reactions (incidence ≥5% and at least twice the rate of placebo) is mo
were extrapyramidal disorder, application site reaction and weight gain. be res
drugs
Drug Interactions: Monitor blood pressure and adjust antihypertensive drugs when taken with SECUADO. Based appro
on clinical response, SECUADO dose reduction may be necessary when used with strong CYP1A2 inhibitors of trea
(fluvoxamine). Reduce paroxetine (CYP2D6 substrate and inhibitor) dose by half when taken with SECUADO. contin
discon
the pr
Pregnancy: Studies have not been conducted with SECUADO in pregnant women. Advise patients to notify
their healthcare provider of a known or suspected pregnancy. The National Pregnancy Registry for Atypical Metab
Antipsychotics monitors pregnancy outcomes in women exposed to antipsychotics, including SECUADO, during Hyper
pregnancy. For information, contact 1-866-961-2388 or http://womensmentalhealth.org/clinical-and-research- Hyper
programs/pregnancyregistry/. has b
in pat
To report suspected Adverse Reactions, contact Noven at 800-455-8070 or FDA at 800-FDA-1088 or antips
Repor
www.fda.gov/medwatch. from
Please see brief summary of full prescribing information on following pages. Table
Schizo
Reference: 1. Secuado® (asenapine) transdermal system [prescribing information]. Miami, FL: Noven Therapeutics,
LLC; October 2019.
Cha
No
Hig
Bor
Hig
N* = N
In the
patien
Dyslip
Atypic
medic
SECUADO is a registered trademark of Hisamitsu Pharmaceutical Co., Inc. the pl
© 2020 Noven Therapeutics, LLC. All rights reserved.
For US audience only.
SDO-2124-16 7/20
vey in June 2020 would have met that threshold—much less, that you have a demic. I suspect—although I cannot reaction to life’s “slings and arrows”
criterion if their anxiety symptoms mental disorder. The difference be- prove—that many of the respondents and its manifold, painful losses.10
began, say, in March 2020. Further- tween symptoms and disorder is not were reporting symptoms reflecting In my experience, only a careful clin-
more, DSM-5 criteria for nearly all merely semantic. A formal, clinical understandable demoralization and ical evaluation could distinguish pro-
the major disorders require that the diagnosis of a mental disorder has grief—and these are not mental disor- found demoralization and grief from
person demonstrates “clinically sig- wholly different implications—medi- ders. On the contrary, as psychologist major depressive illness among the
nificant distress or impairment in so- cal, legal, and psychological—than John F. Schumaker9 has elegantly put CDC survey respondents. Screening in-
cial, occupational, or other important those associated with, say, a normal or it, demoralization is “an overarching struments like the 4-item Patient Health
areas of functioning.”8 adaptive response to the stress and psycho-spiritual crisis in which vic- Questionnaire (PHQ-4)—used in the
Experiencing an uptick in some strain of the COVID-19 pandemic. tims feel generally disoriented and CDC survey—simply cannot do the job.
symptoms of anxiety or depression The nebulous term depression may unable to locate meaning, purpose, or None of this is to minimize the
does not necessarily mean that you be misleading when considering ma- sources of need fulfilment.” And mental health challenges posed by the
have reached that distress-impairment ny emotional reactions to the pan- grief, of course, is a normal, adaptive COVID-19 pandemic. Individuals
SECUADO® (asenapine) transdermal system Table 2: Changes in Lipids in Adult Patients in the 6-Week, Placebo-Controlled, Fixed Dose
Schizophrenia Trial
Falls
SECUADO may cause somnolence, postural hypotension, motor and sensory instability, which may
discomfort, pain, ede
adult trial, application
BRIEF SUMMARY OF FULL PRESCRIBING INFORMATION. SEE PACKAGE INSERT FOR lead to falls and, consequently, fractures or other injuries. For patients with diseases, conditions, hours and in 13.7% (2
SECUADO or medications that could exacerbate these effects, complete fall risk assessments when initiating
FULL PRESCRIBING INFORMATION placebo patients. The
Placebo 3.8 mg/24 7.6 mg/24 antipsychotic treatment and recurrently for patients on long-term antipsychotic therapy. 9.3% (19/204) of patie
WARNING: INCREASED MORTALITY IN ELDERY PATIENTS WITH DEMENTIA-RELATED PSYCHOSIS hours hours mg/24 hours compar
See full prescribing information for complete boxed warning. Leukopenia, Neutropenia, and Agranulocytosis was pruritus, which w
Eldery patients with dementia-realted psychosis treated with antipsychotic drugs are at an increased Mean Change from Baseline In clinical trials and/or postmarketing experience, events of leukopenia and neutropenia have been 3.9% (8/204) of patie
risk of death. SECUADO is not approved for the treatment of patients with dementia-related psychosis. reported temporally related to antipsychotic agents, including asenapine. Agranulocytosis (including One patient develope
Total Cholesterol (mg/dL) (N*) 0.7 (174) 5.1 (174) 4.5 (172) fatal cases) has also been reported with other agents in the class. Possible risk factors for leukopenia/ sites that persisted fo
INDICATIONS AND USAGE neutropenia include pre-existing low white blood cell count (WBC) or absolute neutrophil count (ANC) reactions occurred m
SECUADO is an atypical antipsychotic indicated for the treatment of adults with schizophrenia. LDL (mg/dL) (N*) 1.6 (172) 1.4 (170) 4.2 (169) and history of drug-induced leukopenia/neutropenia. In patients with pre-existing low WBC or ANC or Inform patients of the
history of drug-induced leukopenia or neutropenia, perform a complete blood count (CBC) frequently if applied for a longer
HDL(mg/dL) (N*) -0.8 (174) 0.2 (174) -0.7 (172) during the first few months of therapy. In such patients, consider discontinuation of SECUADO at the patients to select a di
CONTRAINDICATIONS
SECUADO is contraindicated in patients with: first sign of a clinically significant decline in WBC in the absence of other causative factors. Monitor
Fasting triglycerides (mg/dL) (N*) -2.6 (174) 17.3 (174) 6.7 (172) patients with clinically significant neutropenia for fever or other symptoms or signs of infection ADVERSE REACTIONS
• Severe hepatic impairment (Child-Pugh C).
• A history of hypersensitivity reactions to asenapine or any components of the transdermal system. and treat promptly if such symptoms or signs occur. Discontinue SECUADO in patients with severe Clinical Trials Experie
Proportion of Patients with Shifts from Baseline to Endpoint (n/N*) neutropenia (absolute neutrophil count <1000/mm3) and follow their WBC until recovery.
Reactions with asenapine have included anaphylaxis, angioedema, hypotension, tachycardia, swollen Because clinical trials
tongue, dyspnea, wheezing, and rash. Total Cholesterol in the clinical trials of
1.0% (2/197) 2.6% (5/196) 1.0% (2/199) QT Prolongation and may not reflect t
Normal to High <200 to ≥ 240 mg/dL (n/N*) The effects of sublingual asenapine on the QT/QTc interval were evaluated in a dedicated adult
WARNINGS AND PRECAUTIONS The safety of SECUAD
Increased Mortality in Elderly Patients with Dementia-Related Psychosis LDL Normal to High <100 to ≥ 160 mg/dL (n/N*) 0.5% (1/195) 1.0% (2/194) 0% (0/197) QT study. This trial involved sublingual asenapine doses of 5 mg, 10 mg, 15 mg, and 20 mg twice were exposed to SECU
Elderly patients with dementia-related psychosis treated with antipsychotic drugs are at an increased risk daily, and placebo, and was conducted in 151 clinically stable patients with schizophrenia, with Adverse Reactions Le
of death. Analyses of 17 placebo-controlled trials (modal duration of 10 weeks), largely in patients taking HDL Normal to Low ≥ 40 to <40 mg/dL (n/N*) 8.1% (16/197) 10.7% (21/196) 12.1% (24/199) electrocardiographic assessments throughout the dosing interval at baseline and steady-state. At A total of 4.9% (10/20
atypical antipsychotic drugs, revealed a risk of death in the drug-treated patients of between 1.6 to 1.7 times these doses, sublingual asenapine was associated with increases in QTc interval ranging from 2 to 5 treated with SECUADO
Fasting Triglycerides msec compared to placebo. No patients treated with sublingual asenapine experienced QTc increases to adverse reactions i
that seen in placebo-treated patients. Over the course of a typical 10-week controlled trial, the rate of death 1.1% (2/185) 7.0% (13/185) 3.2% (6/186)
in drug-treated patients was about 4.5%, compared to a rate of about 2.6% in the placebo group. Although Normal to High <150 to ≥ 200 mg/dL (n/N*) ≥60 msec from baseline measurements, nor did any patient experience a QTc of ≥500 msec. In led to discontinuation
the causes of death were varied, most of the deaths appeared to be either cardiovascular (e.g., heart failure, the placebo-controlled trial, there were no reports of QT prolongations exceeding 500 msec for discontinuation in no
sudden death) or infectious (e.g., pneumonia) in nature. SECUADO is not approved for the treatment of N* = Number of patients who had assessments at both Baseline and Endpoint. SECUADO and placebo. There were no reports of Torsades de Pointes or any other adverse reactions treated with SECUADO
patients with dementia-related psychosis. associated with delayed ventricular repolarization with sublingual asenapine or with SECUADO. The Commonly Observed
In the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial with SECUADO, the proportion of patients with total use of SECUADO should be avoided in combination with other drugs known to prolong QTc including The most common ad
cholesterol elevations ≥240 mg/dL (at Endpoint) was 10.7% for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 Class 1A antiarrhythmics (e.g., quinidine, procainamide) or Class 3 antiarrhythmics (e.g., amiodarone, patients with schizop
Cerebrovascular Adverse Reactions, Including Stroke, in Elderly Patients with Dementia-Related Psychosis hours and 13.6% for patients treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours versus 10.2 % for placebo-treated
In placebo-controlled trials in elderly subjects with dementia, patients randomized to risperidone, sotalol), antipsychotic medications (e.g., ziprasidone, chlorpromazine, thioridazine), and antibiotics disorder, application
patients. The proportion of patients with elevations in triglycerides ≥200 mg/dL (at Endpoint) was 17.8% (e.g., gatifloxacin, moxifloxacin). SECUADO should also be avoided in patients with a history of cardiac Adverse Reactions Oc
aripiprazole, and olanzapine had a higher incidence of stroke and transient ischemic attack, including fatal for SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 12.4% for SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours treated patients versus 10.3% for
stroke. SECUADO is not approved for the treatment of patients with dementia-related psychosis. arrhythmias and in other circumstances that may increase the risk of the occurrence of torsade de Adverse reactions ass
placebo-treated patients. pointes and/or sudden death in association with the use of drugs that prolong the QTc interval, percent, and SECUADO
Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome including bradycardia; hypokalemia or hypomagnesemia; and presence of congenital prolongation are shown in Table 5.
Weight Gain of the QT interval.
A potentially fatal symptom complex sometimes referred to as Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome (NMS) has Weight gain has been observed with atypical antipsychotic use, including SECUADO. Monitor weight at
been reported in association with administration of antipsychotic drugs. Clinical manifestations of NMS are Table 5: Adverse Rea
baseline and frequently thereafter. Data on mean changes in body weight and the proportion of subjects Hyperprolactinemia Greater Incidence Tha
hyperpyrexia, muscle rigidity, altered mental status, and evidence of autonomic instability. Additional signs meeting a weight gain criterion
may include elevated creatine phosphokinase, myoglobinuria (rhabdomyolysis), and acute renal failure. If Like other drugs that antagonize dopamine D2 receptors, SECUADO can elevate prolactin levels, and
of ≥7% of body weight from the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial are presented in Table 3. the elevation can persist during chronic administration. Galactorrhea, amenorrhea, gynecomastia, and
NMS is suspected, immediately discontinue SECUADO and provide intensive symptomatic treatment
and monitoring. impotence have been reported in patients receiving prolactin-elevating compounds. Long-standing System Organ
Table 3: Change in Body Weight in Adult Patients from Baseline in the 6-Week, Placebo-Controlled, Fixed hyperprolactinemia when associated with hypogonadism may lead to decreased bone density in Preferred T
Dose Schizophrenia Trial both female and male subjects. In the SECUADO placebo-controlled trial, galactorrhea, amenorrhea,
Tardive Dyskinesia
Tardive dyskinesia, a syndrome of potentially irreversible, involuntary, dyskinetic movements may gynecomastia and impotence were not reported for patients treated with SECUADO or placebo. Gastrointestinal
SECUADO In sublingual asenapine adult pre-marketing clinical trials, the incidences of adverse events related to
develop in patients treated with antipsychotic drugs, including SECUADO. The risk appears to be highest Placebo
among the elderly, especially elderly women, but it is not possible to predict which patients are likely abnormal prolactin levels were 0.4% versus 0% for placebo. Tissue culture experiments indicate that Constipation
3.8 mg/24 hours 7.6 mg/24 hours approximately one-third of human breast cancers are prolactin-dependent in vitro, a factor of potential
to develop the syndrome. Given these considerations, SECUADO should be prescribed in a manner that
is most likely to reduce the risk of tardive dyskinesia. Chronic antipsychotic treatment should generally importance if the prescription of these drugs is considered in a patient with previously-detected breast
Mean Change from Baseline (kg) (N*) 0.62 (167) 2.10 (168) 2.02 (164) cancer. Neither clinical studies nor epidemiologic studies conducted to date have shown an association Dyspepsia
be reserved for patients: (1) who suffer from a chronic illness that is known to respond to antipsychotic
drugs; and (2) for whom alternative, effective, but potentially less harmful treatments are not available or between chronic administration of this class of drugs and tumorigenesis in humans, but the available
Proportion of Patients with a ≥7% Increase in Body Weight evidence is too limited to be conclusive. Diarrhea
appropriate. In patients who do require chronic treatment, use the lowest dose and the shortest duration
of treatment producing a satisfactory clinical response should be sought. Periodically reassess the need for % with ≥7% increase in body
3.9% (8/203) 18.3% (37/202) 14.3% (29/203) Seizures General Disorder
continued treatment. If signs and symptoms of tardive dyskinesia appear in a patient on SECUADO, drug weight (n/N*)
discontinuation should be considered. However, some patients may require treatment with SECUADO despite In the SECUADO placebo-controlled trial, there were no reports of seizures in adult patients treated with
the presence of the syndrome. N* = Number of subjects with data at Endpoint. doses of 3.8 mg/24 hours and 7.6 mg/24 hours of SECUADO. During adult pre-marketing clinical trials Application si
with sublingual asenapine, including long-term trials without comparison to placebo, seizures were
In the sublingual asenapine 52-week, double-blind, comparator-controlled adult trial that included reported in 0.3% (5/1953) of patients treated with sublingual asenapine. As with other antipsychotic
Metabolic Changes primarily patients with schizophrenia, the mean weight gain from baseline was 0.9 kg. The proportion of Investigations
Hyperglycemia and Diabetes Mellitus drugs, SECUADO should be used with caution in patients with a history of seizures or with conditions
patients with a ≥7% increase in body weight (at Endpoint) was 14.7%. Table 4 provides the mean weight that potentially lower the seizure threshold. Conditions that lower the seizure threshold may be more
Hyperglycemia, in some cases extreme and associated with ketoacidosis or hyperosmolar coma or death, change from baseline and the proportion of patients with a weight gain of ≥7% categorized by Body Mass Blood glucose
has been reported in patients treated with atypical antipsychotics. There have been reports of hyperglycemia prevalent in patients 65 years or older.
Index (BMI) at baseline.
in patients treated with sublingual asenapine. Assess fasting plasma glucose before or soon after initiation of
antipsychotic medication, and monitor periodically during long-term treatment. Potential for Cognitive and Motor Impairment Weight increa
Table 4: Weight Change Results Categorized by BMI at Baseline: Comparator-Controlled 52-Week Study SECUADO, like other antipsychotics, has the potential to impair judgment, thinking or motor skills.
Reports of hyperglycemia in patients treated with SECUADO were <1% in the placebo-controlled trial. Data with Sublingual Asenapine in Adults with Schizophrenia Hepatic enzym
from the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial are presented in Table 1. Patients should be cautioned about operating hazardous machinery, including motor vehicles, until
they are reasonably certain that SECUADO therapy does not affect them adversely. Somnolence increased*
BMI 23 - ≤27 was reported in patients treated with SECUADO. In the short-term, fixed-dose, placebo-controlled
Table 1: Changes in Fasting Glucose in Adult Patients in the 6-Week, Placebo-Controlled, Fixed Dose BMI <23 Sublingual BMI >27 Sublingual Infections and In
Schizophrenia Trial Sublingual Asenapine schizophrenia adult trial, somnolence was reported in 4.4% (9/204) of patients on SECUADO 3.8 mg/24
Asenapine N=295 Asenapine N=302 hours and in 3.4% (7/204) of patients on SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours compared to 1.5% (3/206) of placebo
N=290
SECUADO patients. There were no reports of somnolence that led to discontinuation in the placebo-controlled Nasopharyng
Placebo Mean change from Baseline (kg) 1.7 1 0 trial. During adult pre-marketing clinical trials with sublingual asenapine, including long-term trials
3.8 mg/24 hours 7.6 mg/24 hours without comparison to placebo, somnolence was reported in 18% (358/1953) of patients treated with Upper respira
% with ≥7% increase in sublingual asenapine. infection
22% 13% 9% Metabolism and
Mean Change from Baseline in Fasting Glucose at Endpoint body weight
Body Temperature Regulation Disorders
Change from Baseline (mg/dL) (N*) 0.03 (174) 3.28 (174) 3.72 (172) Hypersensitivity Reactions Atypical antipsychotics may disrupt the body’s ability to reduce core body temperature.
Hypersensitivity reactions have been observed in patients treated with asenapine, including SECUADO. Strenuous exercise, exposure to extreme heat, dehydration, and anticholinergic medications may Increased app
Proportion of Patients with Shifts from Baseline to Endpoint In several cases, these reactions occurred after the first dose. These hypersensitivity reactions included: contribute to an elevation in core body temperature; use SECUADO with caution in patients who may
anaphylaxis, angioedema, hypotension, tachycardia, swollen tongue, dyspnea, wheezing and rash. experience these conditions. Nervous System
Normal to
0% (0/198) 3.1 % (6/196) 3.0 % (6/199)
High <100 to ≥ 126 mg/dL (n/N*) Orthostatic Hypotension, Syncope, and Other Hemoodynamic Effects Dysphagia Headache
Borderline to Atypical antipsychotics cause orthostatic hypotension and syncope. Generally, the risk is greatest during Esophageal dysmotility and aspiration have been associated with antipsychotic drug use. There
2.0% (4/198) 1.0% (2/196) 1.0% (2/199) initial dose titration and when increasing the dose. In the placebo-controlled trial, orthostatic hypotension were no reports of dysphagia with SECUADO; however, dysphagia has been reported with sublingual Extrapyramid
High ≥ 100 and <126 to ≥ 126 mg/dL (n/N*)
was reported in 1.5% (3/204) of patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 0% (0/204) of asenapine. SECUADO and other antipsychotic drugs should be used cautiously in patients at risk for symptoms*
N* = Number of patients who had assessments at both Baseline and Endpoint. patients treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours, compared to <1% (1/206) of patients treated with placebo. aspiration.
There were no reports of syncope for both doses of SECUADO in the placebo-controlled trial. During adult Akathisia
In the sublingual asenapine 52-week, double-blind, comparator-controlled trial that included primarily pre-marketing clinical trials with sublingual asenapine, including long-term trials without comparison to External Heat
patients with schizophrenia, the mean increase from baseline of fasting glucose was 2.4 mg/dL. placebo, syncope was reported in 0.6% (11/1953) of patients treated with sublingual asenapine. Orthostatic When heat is applied to SECUADO after application, both the rate and extent of absorption are Somnolence*
Dyslipidemia vital signs should be monitored in patients who are vulnerable to hypotension (elderly patients, patients increased. After application of a heating pad, asenapine exposure (partial AUC0-8) was about 3.9 times
Atypical antipsychotics cause adverse alterations in lipids. Before or soon after initiation of antipsychotic with dehydration, hypovolemia, concomitant treatment with antihypertensive medications), patients with greater than without heating pad application. Advise patients to avoid exposing SECUADO to direct Dystonia
medication, obtain a fasting lipid profile at baseline and monitor periodically during treatment. Data from known cardiovascular disease (history of myocardial infarction or ischemic heart disease, heart failure, or external heat sources such as hair dryers, heating pads, electric blankets, heated water beds, etc., while
the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial presented in Table 2. conduction abnormalities), and patients with cerebrovascular disease. SECUADO should be used cautiously wearing SECUADO. Vascular Disorde
when treating patients who receive treatment with other drugs that can induce hypotension, bradycardia,
respiratory or central nervous system depression. Monitoring of orthostatic vital signs should be considered Application Site Reactions
in all such patients, and a dose reduction should be considered if hypotension occurs. Local skin reactions, such as irritation, were reported with SECUADO. During wear time or immediately Hypertension
after removal of SECUADO, the skin at the site of application may develop erythema, pruritus, papules,
with established psychiatric diagnoses must also carefully monitor the long- undeserving of insurance coverage COVID-19 pandemic, nor should it
(eg, posttraumatic stress disorder, term psychological effects the pan- for, say, telemedicine counseling. We diminish our efforts at comforting
schizophrenia, or bipolar disorder) may demic may have on children and ado- know, for example, that subclinical and supporting them.
be experiencing serious, pandem- lescents.12 Finally, we must remain depression—ie, falling just short of
ic-related exacerbation of their ill- vigilant regarding the enormous phys- full DSM criteria for major depres- Dr Pies is professor emeritus of psy-
ness, and they may require immediate ical and emotional toll the pandemic is sion—can nevertheless be a disabling chiatry and lecturer on bioethics and
treatment or refinement of their cur- taking on our physicians, nurses, and condition that needs treatment, and humanities, SUNY Upstate Medical
rent treatment. There is also strong, other frontline health care workers.13 may respond to psychotherapy.14 University; clinical professor of psychi-
emerging evidence that COVID-19 And, let me clarify: the mere fact So, no—the term, mental health atry, Tufts University School of
may lead to serious and enduring neu- that someone may not meet full pandemic is not really helpful or ac- Medicine; and editor in chief emeritus
rological complications.11 Care and DSM-5 criteria for a mental disorder curate. But that observation does not of Psychiatric Times®.
treatment of these seriously affected does not mean that the person is un- negate the distress and loneliness of
individuals should be our priority. We worthy of professional attention, or so many who are enduring the Acknowledgments — I wish to thank
Table 2: Changes in Lipids in Adult Patients in the 6-Week, Placebo-Controlled, Fixed Dose Falls discomfort, pain, edema, or irritation. In the short-term, fixed-dose, placebo-controlled schizophrenia *Th
Schizophrenia Trial SECUADO may cause somnolence, postural hypotension, motor and sensory instability, which may adult trial, application site reactions were reported in 15.2% (31/204) of patients on SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 disc
lead to falls and, consequently, fractures or other injuries. For patients with diseases, conditions, hours and in 13.7% (28/204) of patients on SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours compared to 3.9% (8/206) of and
SECUADO or medications that could exacerbate these effects, complete fall risk assessments when initiating placebo patients. The most common application site reaction was erythema, which was reported in hem
Placebo 3.8 mg/24 7.6 mg/24 antipsychotic treatment and recurrently for patients on long-term antipsychotic therapy. 9.3% (19/204) of patients on SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and in 9.8% (20/204) of patients on SECUADO 7.6 Hep
D PSYCHOSIS hours hours mg/24 hours compared to 1.5% (3/206) of placebo patients. Another common application site reaction am
Leukopenia, Neutropenia, and Agranulocytosis was pruritus, which was reported in 4.9% (10/204) of patients on SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and in incl
rugs are at an increased Mean Change from Baseline In clinical trials and/or postmarketing experience, events of leukopenia and neutropenia have been 3.9% (8/204) of patients on SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours compared to 1.9% (4/206) of placebo patients. mu
mentia-related psychosis. reported temporally related to antipsychotic agents, including asenapine. Agranulocytosis (including One patient developed application site discoloration (hyperpigmentation) at multiple application incl
Total Cholesterol (mg/dL) (N*) 0.7 (174) 5.1 (174) 4.5 (172) fatal cases) has also been reported with other agents in the class. Possible risk factors for leukopenia/ sites that persisted for at least several weeks after discontinuing SECUADO treatment. Application site Dos
neutropenia include pre-existing low white blood cell count (WBC) or absolute neutrophil count (ANC) reactions occurred more frequently in Black or African American patients compared to Caucasians. extr
zophrenia. LDL (mg/dL) (N*) 1.6 (172) 1.4 (170) 4.2 (169) and history of drug-induced leukopenia/neutropenia. In patients with pre-existing low WBC or ANC or Inform patients of these potential reactions and that increased skin irritation may occur with SECUADO Dys
history of drug-induced leukopenia or neutropenia, perform a complete blood count (CBC) frequently if applied for a longer period than instructed or if the same application site is used repeatedly. Instruct Sym
HDL(mg/dL) (N*) -0.8 (174) 0.2 (174) -0.7 (172) during the first few months of therapy. In such patients, consider discontinuation of SECUADO at the patients to select a different application site each day to minimize skin reactions. dur
first sign of a clinically significant decline in WBC in the absence of other causative factors. Monitor pro
Fasting triglycerides (mg/dL) (N*) -2.6 (174) 17.3 (174) 6.7 (172) patients with clinically significant neutropenia for fever or other symptoms or signs of infection ADVERSE REACTIONS ton
nsdermal system. and treat promptly if such symptoms or signs occur. Discontinue SECUADO in patients with severe Clinical Trials Experience wit
Proportion of Patients with Shifts from Baseline to Endpoint (n/N*) neutropenia (absolute neutrophil count <1000/mm3) and follow their WBC until recovery.
tachycardia, swollen Because clinical trials are conducted under widely varying conditions, adverse reaction rates observed is o
Total Cholesterol in the clinical trials of a drug cannot be directly compared to rates in the clinical trials of another drug xtra
1.0% (2/197) 2.6% (5/196) 1.0% (2/199) QT Prolongation and may not reflect the rates observed in practice. In t
Normal to High <200 to ≥ 240 mg/dL (n/N*) The effects of sublingual asenapine on the QT/QTc interval were evaluated in a dedicated adult The safety of SECUADO was evaluated in a total of 315 adult patients diagnosed with schizophrenia who Ang
LDL Normal to High <100 to ≥ 160 mg/dL (n/N*) 0.5% (1/195) 1.0% (2/194) 0% (0/197) QT study. This trial involved sublingual asenapine doses of 5 mg, 10 mg, 15 mg, and 20 mg twice were exposed to SECUADO for up to 6 weeks in a placebo-controlled trial. Ass
re at an increased risk daily, and placebo, and was conducted in 151 clinically stable patients with schizophrenia, with Adverse Reactions Leading to Discontinuation of Treatment 3.8
ely in patients taking HDL Normal to Low ≥ 40 to <40 mg/dL (n/N*) 8.1% (16/197) 10.7% (21/196) 12.1% (24/199) electrocardiographic assessments throughout the dosing interval at baseline and steady-state. At A total of 4.9% (10/204) patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours, 7.8% (16/204) patients the
between 1.6 to 1.7 times these doses, sublingual asenapine was associated with increases in QTc interval ranging from 2 to 5 treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours, and 6.8% (14/206) patients on placebo discontinued due eve
Fasting Triglycerides msec compared to placebo. No patients treated with sublingual asenapine experienced QTc increases to adverse reactions in the placebo-controlled trial. The adverse reaction that most commonly 12.8
d trial, the rate of death 1.1% (2/185) 7.0% (13/185) 3.2% (6/186)
lacebo group. Although Normal to High <150 to ≥ 200 mg/dL (n/N*) ≥60 msec from baseline measurements, nor did any patient experience a QTc of ≥500 msec. In led to discontinuation among SECUADO-treated patients in this trial was akathisia, which led to the
scular (e.g., heart failure, the placebo-controlled trial, there were no reports of QT prolongations exceeding 500 msec for discontinuation in no (0/204) patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours, 1.5% (3/204) patients pat
or the treatment of N* = Number of patients who had assessments at both Baseline and Endpoint. SECUADO and placebo. There were no reports of Torsades de Pointes or any other adverse reactions treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours, and 0.5% (1/206) patients on placebo. Lab
associated with delayed ventricular repolarization with sublingual asenapine or with SECUADO. The Commonly Observed Adverse Reactions Tran
In the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial with SECUADO, the proportion of patients with total use of SECUADO should be avoided in combination with other drugs known to prolong QTc including The most common adverse reactions (≥5% and at least twice the rate of placebo) reported in adult trea
cholesterol elevations ≥240 mg/dL (at Endpoint) was 10.7% for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 Class 1A antiarrhythmics (e.g., quinidine, procainamide) or Class 3 antiarrhythmics (e.g., amiodarone, patients with schizophrenia treated with SECUADO in the placebo-controlled trial were extrapyramidal for
entia-Related Psychosis hours and 13.6% for patients treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours versus 10.2 % for placebo-treated
to risperidone, sotalol), antipsychotic medications (e.g., ziprasidone, chlorpromazine, thioridazine), and antibiotics disorder, application site reaction, and weight gain. 1.1 u
patients. The proportion of patients with elevations in triglycerides ≥200 mg/dL (at Endpoint) was 17.8% (e.g., gatifloxacin, moxifloxacin). SECUADO should also be avoided in patients with a history of cardiac Adverse Reactions Occurring at an Incidence of 2% or More in SECUADO-Treated Patients nor
c attack, including fatal for SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 12.4% for SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours treated patients versus 10.3% for
d psychosis. arrhythmias and in other circumstances that may increase the risk of the occurrence of torsade de Adverse reactions associated with the use of SECUADO (incidence of ≥2%, rounded to the nearest hou
placebo-treated patients. pointes and/or sudden death in association with the use of drugs that prolong the QTc interval, percent, and SECUADO incidence greater than placebo) that occurred during the placebo-controlled trial In a
including bradycardia; hypokalemia or hypomagnesemia; and presence of congenital prolongation are shown in Table 5. sch
Weight Gain of the QT interval. Pro
nt Syndrome (NMS) has Weight gain has been observed with atypical antipsychotic use, including SECUADO. Monitor weight at
nifestations of NMS are Table 5: Adverse Reactions in ≥ 2% of Patients in Any SECUADO Dose Group and Which Occurred at for
baseline and frequently thereafter. Data on mean changes in body weight and the proportion of subjects Hyperprolactinemia Greater Incidence Than in the Placebo Group in 6-Week Schizophrenia Trials plac
tability. Additional signs meeting a weight gain criterion
d acute renal failure. If Like other drugs that antagonize dopamine D2 receptors, SECUADO can elevate prolactin levels, and In a
of ≥7% of body weight from the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial are presented in Table 3. the elevation can persist during chronic administration. Galactorrhea, amenorrhea, gynecomastia, and wit
matic treatment
impotence have been reported in patients receiving prolactin-elevating compounds. Long-standing System Organ Class/ Placebo SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hrs was
Table 3: Change in Body Weight in Adult Patients from Baseline in the 6-Week, Placebo-Controlled, Fixed hyperprolactinemia when associated with hypogonadism may lead to decreased bone density in Preferred Term N=206 (%) hrs N=204 (%) N=204 (%) Crea
Dose Schizophrenia Trial both female and male subjects. In the SECUADO placebo-controlled trial, galactorrhea, amenorrhea, and
ovements may gynecomastia and impotence were not reported for patients treated with SECUADO or placebo. Gastrointestinal Disorders to 1
SECUADO In sublingual asenapine adult pre-marketing clinical trials, the incidences of adverse events related to find
ppears to be highest Placebo
patients are likely abnormal prolactin levels were 0.4% versus 0% for placebo. Tissue culture experiments indicate that Constipation 4 5 4 Oth
3.8 mg/24 hours 7.6 mg/24 hours approximately one-third of human breast cancers are prolactin-dependent in vitro, a factor of potential
d in a manner that Oth
nt should generally importance if the prescription of these drugs is considered in a patient with previously-detected breast sch
Mean Change from Baseline (kg) (N*) 0.62 (167) 2.10 (168) 2.02 (164) cancer. Neither clinical studies nor epidemiologic studies conducted to date have shown an association Dyspepsia 1 1 3
nd to antipsychotic rea
nts are not available or between chronic administration of this class of drugs and tumorigenesis in humans, but the available in t
Proportion of Patients with a ≥7% Increase in Body Weight evidence is too limited to be conclusive. Diarrhea 1 3 1
the shortest duration Gas
y reassess the need for % with ≥7% increase in body Gen
3.9% (8/203) 18.3% (37/202) 14.3% (29/203) Seizures General Disorders Mus
nt on SECUADO, drug weight (n/N*)
ent with SECUADO despite In the SECUADO placebo-controlled trial, there were no reports of seizures in adult patients treated with Oth
N* = Number of subjects with data at Endpoint. doses of 3.8 mg/24 hours and 7.6 mg/24 hours of SECUADO. During adult pre-marketing clinical trials Application site reactions* 4 15 14 Foll
with sublingual asenapine, including long-term trials without comparison to placebo, seizures were ase
In the sublingual asenapine 52-week, double-blind, comparator-controlled adult trial that included reported in 0.3% (5/1953) of patients treated with sublingual asenapine. As with other antipsychotic
primarily patients with schizophrenia, the mean weight gain from baseline was 0.9 kg. The proportion of pat
drugs, SECUADO should be used with caution in patients with a history of seizures or with conditions Investigations dru
patients with a ≥7% increase in body weight (at Endpoint) was 14.7%. Table 4 provides the mean weight that potentially lower the seizure threshold. Conditions that lower the seizure threshold may be more
molar coma or death, change from baseline and the proportion of patients with a weight gain of ≥7% categorized by Body Mass this
prevalent in patients 65 years or older. Blood glucose increased* 1 3 1 liste
reports of hyperglycemia Index (BMI) at baseline.
or soon after initiation of pat
Potential for Cognitive and Motor Impairment Weight increased 2 4 6 in t
Table 4: Weight Change Results Categorized by BMI at Baseline: Comparator-Controlled 52-Week Study SECUADO, like other antipsychotics, has the potential to impair judgment, thinking or motor skills.
o-controlled trial. Data with Sublingual Asenapine in Adults with Schizophrenia pat
Patients should be cautioned about operating hazardous machinery, including motor vehicles, until Hepatic enzyme Blo
0 2 2
they are reasonably certain that SECUADO therapy does not affect them adversely. Somnolence increased* Card
BMI 23 - ≤27 was reported in patients treated with SECUADO. In the short-term, fixed-dose, placebo-controlled Eye
olled, Fixed Dose BMI <23 Sublingual BMI >27 Sublingual Infections and Infestations
Sublingual Asenapine schizophrenia adult trial, somnolence was reported in 4.4% (9/204) of patients on SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 Gas
Asenapine N=295 Asenapine N=302 hours and in 3.4% (7/204) of patients on SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours compared to 1.5% (3/206) of placebo
N=290 Gen
SECUADO patients. There were no reports of somnolence that led to discontinuation in the placebo-controlled Nasopharyngitis 2 3 1 Inve
Mean change from Baseline (kg) 1.7 1 0 trial. During adult pre-marketing clinical trials with sublingual asenapine, including long-term trials Ner
urs 7.6 mg/24 hours without comparison to placebo, somnolence was reported in 18% (358/1953) of patients treated with Upper respiratory tract 2 3 1 Pos
% with ≥7% increase in sublingual asenapine. infection
22% 13% 9% Cho
int body weight Metabolism and Nutrition dys
Body Temperature Regulation Disorders DRU
3.72 (172) Hypersensitivity Reactions Atypical antipsychotics may disrupt the body’s ability to reduce core body temperature. CLIN
Hypersensitivity reactions have been observed in patients treated with asenapine, including SECUADO. Strenuous exercise, exposure to extreme heat, dehydration, and anticholinergic medications may Increased appetite 0 3 1
Ant
point In several cases, these reactions occurred after the first dose. These hypersensitivity reactions included: contribute to an elevation in core body temperature; use SECUADO with caution in patients who may Alp
anaphylaxis, angioedema, hypotension, tachycardia, swollen tongue, dyspnea, wheezing and rash. experience these conditions. Nervous System Disorders ma
) 3.0 % (6/199) ant
Orthostatic Hypotension, Syncope, and Other Hemoodynamic Effects Dysphagia Headache 6 9 9 Ase
Atypical antipsychotics cause orthostatic hypotension and syncope. Generally, the risk is greatest during Esophageal dysmotility and aspiration have been associated with antipsychotic drug use. There Cm
1.0% (2/199) initial dose titration and when increasing the dose. In the placebo-controlled trial, orthostatic hypotension were no reports of dysphagia with SECUADO; however, dysphagia has been reported with sublingual Extrapyramidal 2 8 13 inh
was reported in 1.5% (3/204) of patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 0% (0/204) of asenapine. SECUADO and other antipsychotic drugs should be used cautiously in patients at risk for symptoms* me
patients treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours, compared to <1% (1/206) of patients treated with placebo. aspiration. par
There were no reports of syncope for both doses of SECUADO in the placebo-controlled trial. During adult Akathisia 2 4 4
USE
t included primarily pre-marketing clinical trials with sublingual asenapine, including long-term trials without comparison to External Heat Pre
s 2.4 mg/dL. placebo, syncope was reported in 0.6% (11/1953) of patients treated with sublingual asenapine. Orthostatic When heat is applied to SECUADO after application, both the rate and extent of absorption are Somnolence* 1 4 3 Pre
vital signs should be monitored in patients who are vulnerable to hypotension (elderly patients, patients increased. After application of a heating pad, asenapine exposure (partial AUC0-8) was about 3.9 times The
tion of antipsychotic with dehydration, hypovolemia, concomitant treatment with antihypertensive medications), patients with greater than without heating pad application. Advise patients to avoid exposing SECUADO to direct Dystonia 0 1 3 ant
g treatment. Data from known cardiovascular disease (history of myocardial infarction or ischemic heart disease, heart failure, or external heat sources such as hair dryers, heating pads, electric blankets, heated water beds, etc., while Reg
conduction abnormalities), and patients with cerebrovascular disease. SECUADO should be used cautiously wearing SECUADO. Vascular Disorders and
when treating patients who receive treatment with other drugs that can induce hypotension, bradycardia, Risk
respiratory or central nervous system depression. Monitoring of orthostatic vital signs should be considered Application Site Reactions Ne
in all such patients, and a dose reduction should be considered if hypotension occurs. Local skin reactions, such as irritation, were reported with SECUADO. During wear time or immediately Hypertension* 1 2 2
and
after removal of SECUADO, the skin at the site of application may develop erythema, pruritus, papules,
Awais Aftab, MD, for his helpful comments 3. Pies RW. The bogus “Epidemic” of mental illness in to Epidemiology. In: Principles of Epidemiology in 11. Heidt A. Dozens more cases of neurological prob-
on an earlier draft of this piece; and Ms the US. Psychiatric Times. June 18, 2015. Accessed Public Health Practice. October 2006; updated May lems in COVID-19 reported. Scientist. July 8, 2020.
August 21, 2020. https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/ 2012. Accessed August 21, 2020. https://www.cdc. Accessed August 21, 2020. https://www.the-scien-
Grace Huckins for prompting my consider- view/bogus-epidemic-mental-illness-us gov/csels/dsepd/ss1978/lesson1/section11.html tist.com/news-opinion/dozens-more-cases-report-
ation of this issue. 4. Pies RW. The astonishing non-epidemic continues. 8. American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic & ed-of-neurological-problems-in-COVID-19-67717
PsychCentral. October 5, 2017. Accessed August 21, Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th ed. Amer- 12. Harris NB. Children will pay long-term stress-re-
REFERENCES 2020. https://pro.psychcentral.com/the-astonish- ican Psychiatric Publishing, Inc; 2013. lated costs of Covid-19 unless we follow the science.
1. Czeisler MÉ , Lane RI, Petrosky E, et al. Mental ing-non-epidemic-continues/ 9. Schumaker J. The demoralized mind. New Interna- Stat News. August 4, 2020. Accessed August 21,
health, substance use, and suicidal ideation during 5. Johnston J. The ghost of the schizophrenogenic tionalist. April 1, 2016. Accessed August 21, 2020. 2020. https://www.statnews.com/2020/08/04/chil-
the COVID-19 pandemic — United States, June 24– mother. Virtual Mentor. 2013;15(9):801-805. https://newint.org/columns/essays/2016/04/01/ dren-long-term-stress-related-costs-COVID-19/
30, 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 6. Pies RW. Debunking the two chemical imbalance psycho-spiritual-crisis 13. Kelly M. The pandemic’s psychological toll: An
2020;69:1049-1057. myths, again. Psychiatric Times. August 2, 2019. Ac- 10. Pies RW, Geppert CMA. Clinical depression or “life emergency physician’s suicide. Ann Emerg Med. Ann
2. Gold J. Covid-19 might lead to a ‘Mental Health cessed August 21, 2020. https://www.psychiatric- sorrows”? Distinguishing between grief and depres- Emerg Med. 2020;76(3):A21-A24. [Epub ahead of print]
Pandemic.’ Forbes. August 6, 2020. Accessed August times.com/view/debunking-two-chemical-imbal- sion in pastoral care 1. Ministry. May 2015. Accessed 14. Cuijpers P, Koole SL, van Dijke A, et al. Psycho-
21, 2020. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jessica- ance-myths-again August 21, 2020. https://www.ministrymagazine. therapy for subclinical depression: meta-analysis. Br
gold/2020/08/06/COVID-19-might-lead-to-a-men- 7. Center for Disease Control. Lesson 1: Introduction org/archive/2015/05/depression J Psychiatry. 2014;205(4):268-274. ❒
tal-health-pandemic/#333f0013706f
nia *The following terms were combined: Application site reactions includes application site dermatitis, are no available human data informing the drug-associated risk. The background risk of major birth defects
/24 discoloration, discomfort, dryness, edema, erythema, exfoliation, induration, irritation, pain, papules, pruritis, and miscarriage for the indicated populations are unknown. However, the background risk in the U.S. general
and reaction. Blood glucose increased includes blood glucose increased, blood insulin increased, glycosylated population of major birth defects is 2-4% and of miscarriage is 15- 20% of clinically recognized pregnancies.
n hemoglobin increased, hyperglycemia, Type 2 diabetes mellitus, diabetes mellitus, and hyperinsulinemia. Clinical Considerations
O 7.6 Hepatic enzyme increased includes hepatic enzyme increased, alanine aminotransferase increased, aspartate Fetal/Neonatal Adverse Reactions:
ion aminotransferase increased, and gamma-glutamyltransferase increased. Extrapyramidal symptoms Extrapyramidal and/or withdrawal symptoms, including agitation, hypertonia, hypotonia, tremor, somnolence,
includes dyskinesia, dystonia, extrapyramidal disorder, parkinsonism, tardive dyskinesia, muscle spasm, and respiratory distress and feeding disorder have been reported in neonates who were exposed to antipsychotic
s. musculoskeletal stiffness. Somnolence includes somnolence, sedation, lethargy, and hypersomnia. Hypertension drugs during the third trimester of pregnancy. These symptoms have varied in severity. Some neonates
includes hypertension, blood pressure increased, diastolic hypertension, and hypertensive crisis. recovered within hours or days without specific treatment; others required prolonged hospitalization. Monitor
te Dose-Related Adverse Reactions: In the placebo-controlled schizophrenia trial, the incidence of an neonates for extrapyramidal and/or withdrawal symptoms and manage symptoms appropriately.
extrapyramidal disorder and weight increased appear to be dose-related (see Table 5). Lactation
DO Dystonia: Lactation studies have not been conducted to assess the presence of asenapine in human milk, the effects of
uct Symptoms of dystonia, prolonged abnormal contractions of muscle groups, may occur in susceptible individuals asenapine on the breastfed infant, or the effects of asenapine on milk production. Asenapine is excreted in rat
during the first few days of treatment. Dystonic symptoms include: spasm of the neck muscles, sometimes milk. The development and health benefits of breastfeeding should be considered along with the mother’s
progressing to tightness of the throat, swallowing difficulty, difficulty breathing, and/or protrusion of the clinical need for SECUADO and any potential adverse effects on the breastfed infant from SECUADO or from the
tongue. While these symptoms can occur at low doses, they occur more frequently and with greater severity underlying maternal condition.
with high potency and at higher doses of first generation antipsychotic drugs. An elevated risk of acute dystonia Pediatric Use
ed is observed in males and younger age groups. Safety and effectiveness of SECUADO in pediatric patients have not been established.
ug xtrapyramidal Symptoms: Geriatric Use
In the short-term, placebo-controlled schizophrenia adult trial, data were objectively collected on the Simpson The SECUADO placebo-controlled trial for the treatment of schizophrenia did not include sufficient numbers of
who Angus Rating Scale for extrapyramidal symptoms (EPS), the Barnes Akathisia Scale (for akathisia) and the patients aged 65 and over to determine whether or not they respond differently than younger patients.
Assessments of Involuntary Movement Scales (for dyskinesias). The mean change from baseline for the SECUADO Multiple factors that might increase the pharmacodynamic response to SECUADO, causing poorer tolerance
3.8 mg/24 hours or 7.6 mg/24 hours treated group was similar to placebo in each of the rating scale scores. In or orthostasis, could be present in elderly patients, and these patients should be monitored carefully. Based
the short-term, placebo-controlled schizophrenia adult trial, the incidence of reported extrapyramidal disorder on a pharmacokinetic study in elderly patients with sublingual asenapine, dosage adjustments are not
events, excluding events related to akathisia, was 7.8% for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours, recommended based on age alone.
12.8% for patients treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours SECUADO and 2.4% for placebo-treated patients; and Elderly patients with dementia-related psychosis treated with SECUADO are at an increased risk of death
the incidence of akathisia-related events was 3.9% for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours, 4.4% for compared to placebo. SECUADO is not approved for the treatment of patients with dementia-related psychosis.
s patients treated with SECUADO 7.6 mg/24 hours and 2.4% for placebo-treated patients. Renal Impairment
Laboratory Test Abnormalities: No dosage adjustment for SECUADO is required on the basis of a patient’s renal function. The effect of renal
Transaminases: Transient elevations in serum transaminases (primarily ALT) were more common in SECUADO- function on the excretion of other metabolites and the effect of dialysis on the pharmacokinetics of asenapine
treated patients. The mean increase in ALT levels for SECUADO-treated patients was 6.0 units/L and 3.8 units/L has not been studied.
dal for the SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 7.6 mg/24 hours treated groups, respectively, compared to a decrease of Hepatic Impairment
1.1 units/L for placebo-treated patients. The proportion of patients with ALT elevations ≥3 times upper limit of SECUADO is contraindicated in patients with severe hepatic impairment (Child-Pugh C) because asenapine
normal (ULN) (at any time) was 1.6% and 3.1% for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 7.6 mg/24 exposure is 7-fold higher in subjects with severe hepatic impairment than the exposure observed in subjects
hours, respectively, and 0% for placebo-treated patients. with normal hepatic function. No dosage adjustment for SECUADO is required in patients with mild to moderate
trial In a 52-week, double-blind, comparator-controlled trial that included primarily adult patients with hepatic impairment (Child-Pugh A and B) because asenapine exposure is similar to that in subjects with normal
schizophrenia, the mean increase from baseline of ALT was 1.7 units/L for sublingual asenapine. hepatic function.
Prolactin: The proportion of patients with prolactin elevations ≥4 times ULN (at Endpoint) were 0.0% and 1.3% OVERDOSAGE
for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 7.6 mg/24 hours, respectively, as compared to 2.4% for Human Experience: In the placebo-controlled trial in adults for SECUADO, there were no reports of accidental
placebo-treated patients in the short-term placebo-controlled trial. or intentional acute overdosage of SECUADO. In adult clinical studies involving more than 3350 patients and/or
In a long-term (52-week), double-blind, comparator-controlled adult trial that included primarily patients healthy subjects for sublingual asenapine, accidental or intentional acute overdosage of sublingual asenapine
with schizophrenia, the mean decrease in prolactin from baseline for sublingual asenapine-treated patients was identified in 3 patients. Among these few reported cases of overdose, the highest estimated ingestion of
4 hrs was 26.9 ng/mL. sublingual asenapine was 400 mg. Reported adverse reactions at the highest dosage included agitation and
Creatine Kinase (CK): The proportion of adult patients with CK elevations ≥3 times ULN at any time were 1.6% confusion.
and 2.1% for patients treated with SECUADO 3.8 mg/24 hours and 7.6 mg/24 hours, respectively, as compared Management of Overdosage There is no specific antidote to SECUADO. The possibility of multiple drug
to 1.5% for placebo-treated patients in the short-term, placebo-controlled trial. The clinical relevance of this involvement should be considered. An electrocardiogram should be obtained and management of overdose
finding is unknown. should concentrate on supportive therapy, maintaining an adequate airway, oxygenation and ventilation, and
Other Adverse Reactions Observed During the Premarketing Evaluation of SECUADO management of symptoms. Consult a Certified Poison Control Center at 1 800-222-1222 for up to date information
Other adverse reactions (<2% frequency) within the 6-week placebo-controlled trial in patients with on the management of overdosage. Hypotension and circulatory collapse should be treated with appropriate
schizophrenia are listed below. The reactions listed are those that could be of clinical importance, as well as measures, such as intravenous fluids and/or sympathomimetic agents (epinephrine and dopamine should not
reactions that are plausibly drug-related on pharmacologic or other grounds. Reactions that appear elsewhere be used, since beta stimulation may worsen hypotension in the setting of SECUADO-induced alpha blockade).
in the SECUADO label are not included. In case of severe extrapyramidal symptoms, anticholinergic medication should be administered. Close medical
Gastrointestinal disorders: vomiting, dry mouth supervision and monitoring should continue until the patient recovers.
General disorders and administration site conditions: asthenia
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders: myalgia Please see full Prescribing Information. including BOXED WARNING at www.secuado.com
Other Adverse Reactions Reported in Clinical Trials with Sublingual Asenapine
Following is a list of MedDRA terms that reflect adverse reactions reported by patients treated with sublingual This brief summary is based on SECUADO Full Prescribing Information, issued October 2019.
asenapine at multiple doses of ≥5 mg twice daily during any phase of a trial within the database of adult Manufactured by: Hisamitsu Pharmaceutical Co., Inc., Japan Saga Tosu © 2019, Hisamitsu Pharmaceutical Co.,
patients. The reactions listed are those that could be of clinical importance, as well as reactions that are plausibly Inc. All rights reserved.
drug-related on pharmacologic or other grounds. Reactions already listed for adult patients in other parts of Distributed by: Noven Therapeutics, LLC, Miami, Florida USA.
this brief summary are not included. Reactions are further categorized by MedDRA system organ class and SECUADO is a registered trademark of Hisamitsu Pharmaceutical Co., Inc.
listed in order of decreasing frequency according to the following definitions: those occurring in at least 1/100 Based on [PI Part Number] [Rev. Date] SDO-1007-16 6/20 Issued:10/2019
patients (frequent) (only those not already listed in the tabulated results from placebo-controlled trials appear
in this listing); those occurring in 1/100 to 1/1000 patients (infrequent); and those occurring in fewer than 1/1000
patients (rare).
Blood and lymphatic disorders: infrequent: anemia; rare: thrombocytopenia
Cardiac disorders: infrequent: temporary bundle branch block
Eye disorders: infrequent: accommodation disorder
Gastrointestinal disorders: infrequent: swollen tongue
General disorders: rare: idiosyncratic drug reaction
Investigations: infrequent: hyponatremia
Nervous system disorders: infrequent: dysarthria
Postmarketing Experience
Choking has been reported by patients, some of whom may have also experienced oropharyngeal muscular
dysfunction.
DRUG INTERACTIONS
CLINICALLY IMPORTANT DRUG INTERACTIONS WITH SECUADO
Antihypertensive drugs (Examples: Diuretics, ACE Inhibitors, Angiotensin Receptor Blockers, and Beta-Blockers,
Alpha-Blockers). Because of its α1-adrenergic antagonism with potential for inducing hypotension, SECUADO
may enhance the effects of certain antihypertensive agents. Monitor blood pressure and adjust dosage of
antihypertensive drug accordingly. Strong CYP1A2 Inhibitors (Examples: Fluvoxamine, ciprofloxacin, enoxacin).
Asenapine is metabolized by CYP1A2. Concomitant use of SECUADO with a CYP1A2 inhibitor increases AUC and
Cmax of asenapine. Consider dose reduction for SECUADO based on clinical response. CYP2D6 substrates and
inhibitors (Example: Paroxetine): Asenapine may enhance the inhibitory effects of paroxetine on its own
metabolism by CYP2D6. Concomitant use of SECUADO with paroxetine increases paroxetine AUC and Cmax. Reduce
paroxetine dose by half when paroxetine is used in combination with SECUADO.
USE IN SPECIFIC POPULATIONS
Pregnancy
Pregnancy Exposure Registry:
There is a pregnancy exposure registry that monitors pregnancy outcomes in women exposed to atypical
antipsychotics, including SECUADO, during pregnancy. For more information contact the National Pregnancy
Registry for Atypical Antipsychotics at 1-866-961-2388 or visit http://womensmentalhealth.org/clinical-
andresearch-programs/pregnancyregistry/.
Risk Summary
Neonates exposed to antipsychotic drugs during the third trimester of pregnancy are at risk for extrapyramidal
and/or withdrawal symptoms. Studies have not been conducted with SECUADO in pregnant women. There
OCTOBER 2020
Psychosomatics w w w. p s y c h i a t r i c t i m e s . c o m
FROM THE ACADEMY OF CONSULTATION-LIAISON PSYCHIATRY
I
n the early days of the shelter-in- What took longer to establish were logic solution. Arguments in favor of our bridge to the patient by wheeling
place edict that was established in the policies for providing psychiatric this version of consultation were in the computer cart on which the
the San Francisco Bay Area in re- consultation-liaison (C/L) service to made to suggest that the quality of technology runs and being present
sponse to the COVID-19 pandemic, medically hospitalized patients. remote consultation would be ade- with the patient while our team en-
there was some debate about wheth- These policies were hospital-specific quate for the care provided. That may gages with them; and our clinical
er clinical services for patients with and ultimately diverged on the basis be true for straightforward cases. acumen to detect subtle changes in
psychiatric illness were “essential.” of the philosophies held by the lead- However, more often than not, there facial expression, affect, and engage-
The department of psychiatry at my ers of the respective C/L services. are cases that are far from straightfor- ment on a small screen. These tech-
home institution installed a COV- Each university-affiliated hospital ward, which flummox clinician ef- nologic factors are moot when pa-
ID-19 Task Force for patient care, was tasked with developing the proto- forts to use communication-enabling tients refuse to interact with their
appointed by departmental leader- cols that would allow for consulta- technology. consultant over the computer or to
ship and composed of clinicians, re- tions to be provided while taking into The university hospital where I even consent to such an intervention.
searchers, and administrative staff. A account the patient’s COVID-19 sta- am an attending on the adult C/L ser- Even when patients consent to a vir-
remarkable number of departmental tus. The solution that was adopted by vice had years of experience with tual visit, there may be circumstances
meetings were held to eventually the psychiatry C/L services of the 2 remote psychiatric consultation long when their level of disorganization,
conclude that patients with psychiat- hospitals where I attend (a university- before the COVID-19 pandemic. paranoia, distractibility, agitation, or
ric symptoms could still receive care affiliated tertiary care center and a Our team provides consultation to distress prevents them from interact-
from behavioral health clinicians, public safety net hospital) was a ver- multiple affiliated hospitals within ing in a meaningful way with their
psychiatrists included, who were sion of remote consultation via tele- the university health network but is consultant.
now expected to be working from health. headquartered in just one of them. The experiences of the adult psy-
home, even though it has been ar- Most medical specialists who From where we are stationed, our ef- chiatry C/L service described above
gued that psychiatry is an essential were still providing care and meeting forts to provide psychiatric consults informed the child and adolescent
medical service and should be deliv- the expectation of social distancing via technology have been and re- psychiatrists (CAPs) providing con-
ered in person if and when neces-
sary.1 The strategy adopted for ac- Figure. Flowchart of Workflow and Decision Tree for Inpatient Psychiatric Consultations
complishing this goal in the
outpatient setting was conversion of (Daytime 8am - 5pm, Weekdays) Inpatient C/L Service (Nighttime 5pm-8am, Weekends)
all office-based appointments to
telehealth visits on a secure internet
platform. Embedded Child & Adolescent Psychiatrist Cross-Site Coverage
The deliberation was more com-
plicated and the decisions more con- Non-urgent Urgent Emergent
troversial (and less universally ad-
opted) in the hospital setting, for
Curbside Consultation (no SI/HI or COVID-19+) (+SI/HI, regardless of COVID-19 status)
patients, both children and adults,
who were psychiatrically hospital- (with Peds MDs, NPs) Telehealth Consult w/Pt In-Person Consult w/Pt
ized, or who were receiving care in
general medical (non-psychiatric)
hospitals and had psychiatric symp-
toms and/or comorbid psychiatric Behaviorally Appropriate and Verbal? No
illness that required consultation-li-
aison psychiatric care. Directives Yes
from departmental leadership were
rapidly evolving in the first few
weeks of shelter-in-place, and in- Nursing staff informs pt of impending Consult with Psychiatrist dons PPE and scrubs to
cluded such decisions as not psychi- Psych; wheels in iPad Cart (or ensures phone works) engage directly with patient, caregiver
atrically hospitalizing any patient
aged 60 years or older or not having
psychiatry residents interact directly
with patients in emergency rooms. C/L Psychiatry completes consultation, communicates recommendations to consulting team, documents in chart
Fortunately, directives such as these
were quickly revised, presumably
sultation to our different pediatrics units, but in dif- this protocol was an adolescent manifesting symp- University of California San Francisco, and
ferent ways. At one site, the patients in the chil- toms of excited catatonia; she paced throughout Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, San
dren’s hospital were evaluated through remote her room during the entirety of the interview and Francisco, CA. Dr Ilhe has no disclosures regarding
consultation unless strict clinical criteria (altered could barely attend to me while in the room with the subject of this article.
mental status or suicidality if not COVID-19 posi- her. It is highly unlikely that I could have engaged
Acknowledgements—Thank you to James Alan Bourgeois,
tive) were met to justify in-person (in-room) con- her and redirected her over a video monitor.
OD, MD, for his support and mentorship, and to all of the
sultation (COVID-19 positive patients were not It came as no surprise that in response to the
physicians on the front lines providing medical care for
offered in-person psychiatric consultation). This COVID-19 pandemic a number of remarkable
patients during the COVID-19 pandemic.
algorithm required the primary pediatrics teams to policy changes occurred, perhaps more quickly
engage with COVID-19 positive patients or their than they otherwise would have. Several innovative REFERENCES
caregivers as a proxy for the CAPs (in the case of programs arose at my home institution to meet the 1. Ihle EC. Psychiatry is an essential medical service during the COV-
ID-19 pandemic. J Psychiatry Reform. 2020;8:1-4.
behavioral dysregulation or other symptoms that mental health needs of medical center staff: resil- 2. Wan W. The coronavirus pandemic is pushing America into a mental
precluded the use of the telehealth device that the ience and emotional well-being videos and webi- health crisis. The Washington Post. May 4, 2020. Accessed September
CAP C/L team relied on). Furthermore, the proto- nars; self-care apps; family support programs; and 15, 2020. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/05/04/
col did not accommodate patient preference. The direct assessment and treatment for faculty, staff, mental-health-coronavirus
3. Siwicki B. Survey: Americans’ perceptions of telehealth in the COV-
COVID-19-negative patient confronting her can- and trainees. What seemed to be missing from ID-19 era. Heathcare IT News. April 3, 2020. Accessed September 15,
cer diagnosis had to engage with the team psychol- these efforts was comparable attention to the emo- 2020. https://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/survey-americans-
ogist through a device and had to forego the op- tional and functional well-being of our patients perceptions-telehealth-covid-19-era
4. Ojha R and Syed S. Challenges faced by mental health providers and
portunity for human contact. with psychiatric illness. patients during the coronavirus 2019 pandemic due to technological
The justification for remote consultation was It is becoming all the more clear that additional barriers. Internet Interv. 2020 Sep;21:100330. ❒
the effort to minimize the number of staff exposed support for the increasing mental health needs of
to COVID-19 and thus the likelihood of further patients, especially those with pre-existing psychi-
contagion (presuming staff acted as vectors). How-
ever, the technology still needed human agents to
manipulate it. Those humans were the same front-
atric illness, will be necessary.2 So far, such support
has been surprisingly limited. One program, our
autism clinic, pivoted by establishing a virtual
I Don’t Want
line staff who were expected to do the other tasks
of patient care. Not only did this expectation sug-
“coffee chat” support group function for the par-
ents of patients with autism. to Die Here
in Timbuktu
CASE STUDY
Documenting Recovery in Delusional
Disorder With the MMPI-2
» Alan D. Blotcky, PhD ity Inventory-2 (MMPI-2). There
have been hundreds of studies on the
altered to protect her privacy.)
Mary’s primary symptoms includ-
children at the time of her divorce 4
years earlier; it was not a highly ad-
D
elusional disorder is a major MMPI-2 and the treatment of psychi- ed both persecutory delusions and versarial divorce proceeding. She had
psychotic illness that is enig- atric disorders.4 Up until now, there somatic delusions. Her delusions had no medical problems. She had no
matic and poorly understood. It has been nothing in the literature that been present for about 2 years. She family history of psychosis or other
is often difficult to treat because of the addresses the utility of the MMPI-2 in believed that her colleagues at work psychiatric disorder.
individual’s denial of a problem, dif- tracking or documenting treatment ef- were concocting a scheme to have her Mary had been seeing a psychia-
ficulties in establishing a therapeutic fects in delusional disorder. fired. She believed that her mother trist for several months prior to my
alliance, and interpersonal and social This case illustrates the effective- was not her biological parent. Mary involvement in the case; I obtained
conflicts. Unfortunately, many indi- ness of the MMPI-2 in documenting also believed that drones were hover- her records from him. Mary was
viduals with this disorder refuse treat- patient recovery during treatment for ing over her home and that someone described as having depression and
ment altogether. Available research delusional disorder. Practical implica- had installed a camera in her car to anxiety. Psychosis was not noted.
suggests that 50% of patients who are tions for psychiatrists and other men- follow her. She reported unrelenting She was being treated with fluoxetine
adequately treated achieve a symp- tal health professionals are discussed. somatic symptoms that she attributed 20 mg and bupropion hydrochloride
tom-free recovery, while 90% of pa- “Mary,” a 42-year-old white fe- to an alien virus that had been planted extended-release tablets 150 mg, but
tients demonstrate at least some im- male, temporarily lost custody of her in her water at home. Because of her she was not improving. Mary had not
provement.1 It has been found that 3 children to her ex-husband 18 delusional thinking, Mary had recent- divulged any delusional material to
persecutory delusions respond least months ago due to apparent psychot- ly quit her job and was residing with her psychiatrist.
well to treatment, with 50% improve- ic-level functioning. I was appointed her parents. Clinically, Mary was appropriate-
ment rates and no reports of complete by the court to arrive at a definitive Prior to the onset of her delusions, ly attired and well-groomed for her
recovery.2 Only a handful of studies diagnosis and to provide appropriate Mary had obtained 2 master’s de- sessions with me. She wore make-up
have used objective outcome mea- guidance about her parenting abili- grees and had a full-time posi- and jewelry. She was pleasant with
sures to evaluate patient improvement ties and custody status. (Mary, a tion. She had a boyfriend, many me and made good eye contact.
during treatment for delusional disor- pseudonym, has given written in- friends, and her family relationships Mary’s cognitive abilities were in-
der.3 The best objective measure of formed consent for her case to be in- were intact. She was described as a tact. Her affect was slightly dysphor-
adult psychopathology in the world is cluded in this presentation. Identify- smart and sweet person. She had ic but within normal limits. She was
the Minnesota Multiphasic Personal- ing information about her has been been given primary custody of her 3 not manic or hypomanic. Mary’s de-
lusions were prominent, and she had
little or no insight into their nature
and severity. She was also suspicious
“It is often difficult to treat because of me; she thought I might be in-
volved in the conspiracy with her col-
of the individual’s denial of a leagues at work.
I asked Mary to provide a urine
problem, difficulties in establishing screen to rule out substance abuse.
Her urine screen the same day was
a therapeutic alliance, and negative for illicit drugs.
Mary completed the MMPI-2, an-
interpersonal and social conflicts.” swering all 567 questions in 90 min-
utes. Her responses were scored on 3
validity scales, 10 basic clinical scales,
and the PSY-5 supplementary scales.
Mary showed considerable dis-
tress but in the context of normal va-
lidity scales. She approached the test
in an open and honest fashion. She
did not exaggerate her symptoms.
AUNGMYO@STOCK.ADOBE.COM
Table. Clinical Scales of the MMPI 2 chotic medication (ziprasidone 20 to her therapeutic alliance with her
mg). This finding is contrary to the psychiatrist and me. Her motivation
Number Abbreviation Description
data that suggest that persecutory de- to get well superseded any desire to
1 Hs Hypochondriasis lusions are recalcitrant.2 Mary did not resist intervention. Therapeutic alli-
2 D Depression have a comorbid condition, and the ance is a critical building block in
absence of comorbid conditions may adequate treatment.6
3 Hy Hysteria make successful treatment of delu- Whether Mary will have a recur-
4 Pd Psychopathic deviate sional disorder more attainable.7 rence in her delusional disorder is
Overall, Mary’s recovery was unclear. Longitudinal research is
5 MF Masculinity/femininity likely due to a combination of the needed to address the question of in-
6 Pa Paranoia relatively short duration of her delu- cidence recurrence in this specific
sions (about 2 years), the lack of a illness. With other types of psychotic
7 Pt Psychasthenia
comorbid condition, the use of an an- disorders, recurrences are often ex-
8 Sc Schizophrenia tipsychotic medication, the discon- pected and even inevitable.8 As such,
Ma Hypomania
tinuance of bupropion, and her high maintenance treatment in delusional
9
level of premorbid functioning. disorder becomes extremely impor-
0 Si Social introversion The MMPI-2 proved to be a sensi- tant. Treatment should include a
tive outcome measure in evaluating combination of psychiatric medica-
10 scales. Mary’s 10 basic clinical ing. I interviewed Mary on 2 occa- this patient’s improvement. Using the tion and individual therapy.3
scales showed significant elevations sions. She completed the MMPI-2 MMPI-2 at the time of diagnosis and The impact of psychotic disorders
on scales 6-8-1-3. Scales 6 and 8 again, and I obtained updated records later during treatment is an objective, on child custody cases is a delicate mat-
were considerably higher than scales from her psychiatrist. data-driven way to assess a patient’s ter. It should be recognized by all par-
1 and 3. While this profile often indi- After 4 months on ziprasidone, response to treatment. The MMPI-2 ties that a parent’s recovery from a psy-
cates schizophrenia, Mary’s history Mary was remarkably improved. She can be administered easily and is not chotic disorder may be less than
and clinical presentation were not was tolerating it well, and her delu- overly intrusive. permanent. Child custody decisions
consistent with that illness. In my sions had remitted. She had need to be made with that psychiatric
view, Mary’s MMPI-2 profile was developed important insight about reality in mind. Maintenance treatment
reflective of her persecutory delu- her resolved delusions. They now Available research suggests that for the parent with a psychotic disorder
50%
sions (scales 6 and 8) and her somatic seemed foreign and distant to her; is the vehicle by which parenting abili-
delusions (scales 1 and 3), both com- they did not make sense to her. She ties can be regained and sustained.9,10
ponents in her psychotic illness. could not even recall her suspicious-
Supplementary scales are available ness about me. Mary’s affect was Dr Blotcky is a clinical psychologist in
on the MMPI-2 as well. Mary’s PSY- bright. She was talkative and expres- private practice in Birmingham,
5 scales showed a significant eleva-
tion on the scale having to do with
sive. She was appreciative of every-
one’s concerns. Mary was looking
of patients Alabama. He is clinical associate pro-
fessor, department of psychology,
psychosis. This was corroborative for a full-time job and planned to get who are adequately treated achieve University of Alabama at Birmingham.
data to Mary’s 10 basic clinical scales. her own apartment. a symptom-free recovery, while Much of his clinical practice is devoted
90%
Based on her history, clinical ob- Mary’s MMPI-2 after 4 months of to forensic cases, including child custo-
servations, and MMPI-2 test data, I treatment was remarkable as well. It dy, personal injury, and criminal cases.
diagnosed Mary with delusional dis- was completely normal. Her validity REFERENCES
order. Her delusional disorder was scales were normal. All 10 basic clini- 1. Bourgeois JA. Delusional disorder: Overview, diag-
primary. She did not have a comorbid cal scales were normal; there were no nosis, epidemiology. 2017. Medscape eMedicine.
condition, such as bipolar disorder or significant elevations. In fact, there of patients 2. Pillmann F, Wustmann T, Marneros A. Acute and
transient psychotic disorders versus persistent delu-
schizophrenia. Mary did not have were no near-significant elevations. Her
major depressive disorder or an anxi- PSY-5 scales were normal as well. All
demonstrate at least some sional disorders: a comparative longitudinal
study. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2012;66(1):44-52.
ety disorder nor was she abusing al- signs of psychosis had dissipated. improvement.1 3. O’Connor K, Stip E, Pélissier MC, et al. Treating
cohol or drugs. Mary will be maintained on ziprasi- delusional disorder: a comparison of cognitive-be-
havioural therapy and attention placebo control. Can
No specific stressors were identi- done for the foreseeable future. She J Psychiatry. 2007;52(3):182-190.
fied that contributed to the onset of will have monthly to quarterly visits Concluding thoughts 4. Butcher JN. Significant contributions for use of the
Mary’s delusional disorder. Howev- with her psychiatrist. Cognitive behav- Lessons learned from this case study MMPI/MMPI-2 in treatment. 2016. Semantic Scholar. Ac-
er, she was feeling “pressure” from ior therapy has been added to her treat- are clinically interesting, but only cessed September 8, 2020. https://pdfs.semantic
scholar.org/cd97/a44d879d3db42721556ca74588
juggling a full-time job with raising 3 ment regimen, since it is regarded as a suggestive. Well-designed research is 543aa68227.pdf
children. critical component in the maintenance needed to study the proposition that 5. Kesby, JP, Eyler, DW, McGrath, JJ, Scott, JG. Dopa-
Interestingly, Mary’s psychiatrist of recovery.6 Mary’s legal case is close the MMPI-2 is a highly effective in- mine, psychosis and schizophrenia: the widening gap
and I independently but simultane- to resolution. With her regained par- strument for evaluating treatment between basic and clinical neuroscience. Transl Psy-
chiatry. 2018;8:30.
ously came to the conclusion that she enting abilities, the parties are ap- outcome in delusional disorder. 6. Roudsari MJ, Chun J, Manschreck TC. Current
had delusional disorder. Mary was proaching a compromised settlement. Mary’s psychiatrist and I worked treatments for delusional disorder. Curr Treat Options
started on ziprasidone 20 mg. Fluox- independently but in a cooperative Psych. 2015; 2:151-167.
etine 20 mg was continued. A brain Discussion fashion. This was quite helpful in fa- 7. González-Rodríguez A, Molina-Andreu O, Odrio-
zola VN, Ferrer CG, Penadés R, Catalan R. Delusional
MRI at that time was negative. Bu- This case study illustrates many im- cilitating Mary’s evaluation and treat- disorder: An overview of affective symptoms and
propion was stopped because it en- portant clinical and practical points. ment with minimal delays and road- antidepressant use. The European Journal of Psy-
hances dopamine levels and can con- Mary’s persecutory delusions and blocks. The sharing of findings and chiatry. 2013;27(4):265-276.
tribute to psychosis.5 somatic delusions both abated with conclusions between us led to an excel- 8. Rajkumar RP. Recurrent acute and transient psy-
chotic disorder: A pilot study. Asian J Psychiatr.
I re-evaluated Mary 4 months later treatment. This result is consistent lent result after much initial confusion.
2015;14:61-64.
in preparation for her upcoming court with the literature that reports that Mary was fully adherent with her 9. Deutsch RM, Clyman J. Impact of mental illness on
appearance. The court would want to 50% of patients treated adequately evaluation and treatment, whereas parenting capacity in a child custody matter. Family
hear about my findings and conclu- achieve a symptom-free recovery.1 many patients with delusional disor- Court Review. 2016; 54(1):29-38.
10. Engur B. Parents with psychosis: Impact on par-
sions as well as any progress in her Delusional disorder in this case was der refuse treatment. Mary’s success-
enting and parent-child relationship. Journal of Child
condition since her last court hear- treated successfully with antipsy- ful treatment was largely attributable and Adolescent Behavior. 2017;5(1):327. ❒
C
COMMUNITY COHESION
oronavirus disease 2019 (CO- ter mental health assistance during the RECONSTRUCTION
VID-19) blindsided the world. acute phase is often more practical than HEROIC A NEW BEGINNING
It exposed gaps in public health psychological in nature. In this case, PREDISASTER DISILLUSIONMENT
S) IEF
emergency planning at every level, in- such assistance includes Centers for E RM GR
THREAT T H
TO OUG
cluding in the strategic planning to Disease Control information and up- WARNING IMPACT I NG THR
support mental health and wellness. dates, access to food and cleaning sup- OM G
(C KIN
R
Studies of the SARS and Ebola epi- plies, access to COVID-19 testing, pro- WO
demics as well as natural disasters tective equipment, financial assistance, INVENTORY TRIGGER EVENTS AND
have taught us lessons about the im- and links to community resources. ANNIVERSARY REACTIONS
portance of planning for and respond- After the acute phase of the disas- -----------------1 TO 3 DAYS ----------- TIME ----------- 1 TO 3 YEARS -----------------
ing to the mental health needs of health ter, long-term stress responses can
care and frontline workers.1 Thus, this emerge. Lancee et al.7 found that 2 events (Figure 1), identify the chang- high of nearly 800 per day across the
is a pivotal moment, a chance to im- years after the SARS outbreak, health ing goals of recovery at different state down to none in New York City by
plement systems and structures for care workers who treated these pa- phases (Figure 2), and inform miti- June. Now the focus is shifting to eco-
staff support in every organization and tients had elevated rates of smoking gation strategies. It is important to nomic recovery, while keeping commu-
advance staff wellness and resilience and drinking, absenteeism due to note that the timing of the phases is nity viral transmission low and bracing
initiatives. stress or illness, decreased face-to- fluid. They do not occur in an exact for a potential second wave. This could
face contact with patients, and de- sequence. Phases can overlap and be the beginning of the reconstruction
Disaster literature creased work hours.Yet rates of de- move forward or back across a time- phase: figuring out a new normal and
The literature on disasters and public pression, posttraumatic stress line, depending on the type of disaster. how to live with a persisting virus. Dis-
health emergencies describes pervasive disorder, and other mental illness were Figure 1 depicts the stages of pub- illusionment is certainly felt when other
emotional distress, feelings of extreme not elevated. This is consistent with lic reactions to natural disasters like states are unable to control the virus, in
vulnerability, uncertainty, and threats to existing research, which has found 2012’s Hurricane Sandy and even the spite of the availability of immense re-
life, particularly during the rapid spread that the long-term impact of massive 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001, but the sources and clear and concrete direc-
of an outbreak.2 A recent COVID-19 disasters is predominantly in the range community response to a pandemic tions from world-class health experts to
web-based survey supports this finding. of subsyndromal stress responses seems more unpredictable. The im- wear masks, avoid crowds, maintain
More than 40% of respondents report- rather than an increase in psychiatric mediate COVID-19 experience in social distance, and wash hands.
ed symptoms of depression, anxiety, morbidity. Limited long-term studies New York state in the spring of 2020
traumatic stress, substance use, and sui- suggest that post-disaster symptom- was marked by safety concerns, Supporting staff
cidal ideation. Symptoms were notably atology peaks in the first year and then deaths in the thousands, food and job Studies indicate that during an infec-
elevated in black and Hispanic indi- declines, but the course of recovery is insecurity, financial hardships, and tious disease outbreak, the operation-
viduals, essential workers, unpaid adult variable.8 The challenge for mental anger at government response. We al response of an organization is likely
caregivers, and those with psychiatric health clinicians is to distinguish nor- do, however, see a heroic phase ex- the single most important factor influ-
conditions.3 Fortunately, evidence from mal distress reactions to catastrophes emplified by the emergence of he- encing staff perception of both stress
disaster trauma research has shown from exacerbation of existing mental roes, such as Anthony Fauci, MD, on and safety.12 Traumatic events can dis-
that, ultimately, most people are resil- health susceptibilities or new-onset the national level and Governor An- rupt feelings of safety, trust, control,
ient even after the most severe traumat- disaster-related pathology. drew Cuomo in New York state. We esteem, and intimacy. As a result,
ic event.4,5 In the immediate aftermath Disaster trauma is characterized by then witnessed community cohesion staff can exhibit maladaptive behav-
of large-scale catastrophes, a majority exposure to personal loss and com- typical of the honeymoon phase as iors or experience traumatic stress
of negative mental health symptoms are munity disruption. Cultural, political, New Yorkers connected with each symptoms.13 Best practices to miti-
recognized as distress reactions to in- and socioeconomic factors all influ- other from stoops, windows, terraces, gate the disruptions and support staff
tense and overwhelming events. They ence the shared experience of major and rooftops, all cheering for front- during a pandemic involve 4 key ele-
are not pathologized or labeled psychi- disasters.9 Looking through a disaster line workers at 7:00 PM each night to ments: leadership, communication,
atric disorders. The disaster literature trauma lens, a better understanding of show gratitude and appreciation. education, and social support.
emphasizes the importance of ac- the emotional stages of public reac- New York successfully flattened the
knowledging the normality of distress tion can help: anticipate community curve by the summer. The number of LEADERSHIP. Strong leadership and
reactions, identifying high-risk popula- responses to large-scale catastrophic daily deaths fell dramatically, from a supportive teams influenced the re-
silience of health care workers during
the SARS and Ebola outbreaks.12 Capable and ef- of infection control, disaster mental health, and the huddles to build relationships and improve
fective leadership over the course of a major disas- disaster response system increases confidence and responsiveness.
ter makes staff feel safe and supported by the orga- moderates the risk of stress. Just as Federal Emer- Establish buddy system to check and balance
nization. Best practices include: gency Management Agency (FEMA) provides ap- each other’s stress level.
isible and prepared leaders at organizational,
V propriate resources and training for disaster re- The scarcity of existing research on staff support
departmental, and team levels. sponders before deployment, organizations have a and mitigation strategies during pandemics pres-
responsibility to provide education and training to ents an opportunity to develop new programs that
Setting the tone for a positive and supportive
better prepare for and respond to a pandemic. Or- can be tailored to specific organizational contexts
organizational culture.
ganizations should be prepared to offer staff: and cultures. Evaluation of best practices and ro-
Skilled assessment of team strengths and
weaknesses. eneral information on disasters and
G bust analysis of the impact and sustainability of
pandemics. staff support plans during COVID-19 can inform
Proactive outreach and crisis support from all
Education on infection control and universal future strategic planning and policy recommenda-
levels of leadership.
precautions. tions for staff wellness and resilience.
Creativity and innovation in increasing staff
resilience and reducing stress. Overview of disaster mental health.
Targeted education on key sources of distress
Dr Quitangon is clinical assistant professor of psy-
Role modeling infection control and safety
from COVID-19 (eg, quarantine-related distress,
chiatry, New York University School of Medicine and
practices—wear masks, practice physical
fear of contagion, concern for family, job stress,
psychiatrist at the Department of Veterans Affairs
distancing, and wash your hands.
financial concerns, interpersonal isolation,
New York Harbor. Dr Quitangon discloses that she
receives royalties from Routledge for her book
COMMUNICATION. The cornerstone of infectious stigma).
Vicarious Trauma and Disaster Mental Health:
disease management is communication, coordina-
tion, and collaboration.14 Delivery of clear, transpar- SOCIAL SUPPORT. Studies indicate that social sup- Understanding Risks and Promoting Resilience.
ent, timely, trustworthy information in a rapidly port, both personal and professional, is a consistent
protective factor and a strong mitigator of emotional Acknowledgement — The author wishes to acknowledge
evolving situation is essential. Organizations should
distress in the wake of a massive disaster.15,16 Unfor- Mary Docherty, MA, MBBS (Hons), MRCP, MRCPsych, for
be prepared to:
tunately, the battle against COVID-19 calls for de- her work in planning and development of the COVID-19
ommunicate timely and trustworthy COVID-
C staff support response at St Thomas’ Hospital and King’s
creased interpersonal contact. Quarantine, physical
19-specific guidance. College Hospital in London, England.
distancing, and remote and virtual work have all
Acknowledge and normalize feelings of anxiety increased social isolation. This unprecedented pub-
related to the pandemic. lic health crisis requires creativity and innovation to REFERENCES
Communicate efforts to address the negative 1. World Health Organization. WHO checklist for influenza pandemic pre-
restore a sense of community and connectedness. In
paredness planning. 2005. Accessed September 8, 2020. https://www.who.
impacts of the pandemic, including financial order to provide much-needed social support during int/influenza/resources/documents/FluCheck6web.pdf?ua=1
concerns. difficult times, organizations should prepare to: 2. Chong MY, Wang WC, Hsieh WC, et al. Psychological impact of severe
Communicate supportive organizational acute respiratory syndrome on health workers in a tertiary hospital. Br J
old virtual meetings and virtual lunch/coffee
H Psychiatry.2004; 185:127-133.
practices (eg, working from home, flexible work
breaks/happy hours to improve team cohesion 3. Czeisler ME, Lane RI, Petrosky E, et al. Mental health, substance use,
schedule, reduced hours, job rotation, location
and morale. and suicidal ideation during the COVID-19 pandemic. MMWR Morb Mor-
rotation, availability of PPE, testing). tal Wkly Rep. 2020; 69(32):1049-1057.
Build in formal time during work hours for peer
Widely disseminate available self-care and 4. North CS, Pfefferbaum B, Hong B. Historical perspective and future direc-
consultation to reduce feelings of isolation and tions in research on psychiatric consequences of terrorism and other disas-
wellness information and resources.
increase feelings of efficacy. ters. In: Neria Y, Gross R, Marshall R, Suzzer E, eds. 9/11: Mental Health in the
Wake of Terrorist Attacks. Cambridge University Press; 2006:95-113.
EDUCATION. Training and education on the issues Use in-person or virtual service meetings and
5. Norris, F. Community and ecological approaches to understanding and
alleviating postdisaster distress. In: Neria Y, Gross R, Marshall R, Suzzer
E, eds. 9/11: Mental Health in the Wake of Terrorist Attacks. Cambridge
Figure 2. Changing Goals of Recovery at Different Phases of Disaster11 University Press; 2006:141-156.
6. North CS, Pfefferbaum B. Mental health response to community disas-
HONEYMOON RECONSTRUCTION
ters: A systematic review. JAMA.2013;310(5):507-518.
7. Lancee WJ, Maunder RG, Goldbloom DS. Prevalence of psychiatric
COMMUNITY COHESION A NEW BEGINNING disorders among Toronto hospital workers one to two years after the
SARS outbreak. Psychiatr Serv. 2008;59(1):91-95.
HEROIC 8. Norris F, Friedman M, Watson P. 60,000 disaster victims speak. Part 1:
PREDISASTER An empirical review of the empirical literature, 1981-2011. Psychiatry.
DISILLUSIONMENT 2002; 65(3):207-239.
9. Zinner ES, Williams, MB. When a community weeps: Case studies in
WARNING S I EF group survivorship. Brunner/Mazel; 1999.
THREAT E RM GR 10. Zunin, LM, Myers, D. Training manual for human service workers in
T GH major disasters (2nd ed.). DHHS Publication No. ADM 90-538. Department
IMPACT TO OU of Health and Human Services; 2000.
G R
M IN TH 11. Quitangon, G. What do we need to know about disasters? In: Quitangon
G
CO KIN
G, Evces MR, eds. Vicarious Trauma and Disaster Mental Health: Under-
standing Risks and Promoting Resilience.: Routledge; 2015:156-172.
OR 12. Grace SL, Hershenfield K, Robertson E, Stewart DE. The occupa-
W
TRIGGER EVENTS AND tional and psychosocial impact of SARS on academic physicians in three
affected hospitals. Psychosomatics. 2005; 46(5):385-391.
INVENTORY ANNIVERSARY REACTIONS 13. Quitangon G, Evces, MR. What can organizations do to address vi-
carious trauma in disasters? In: Quitangon G,Evces, MR (eds.). Vicarious
Trauma and Disaster Mental Health: Understanding Risks and Promoting
1 TO 3 DAYS ------------------------ TIME ------------------------ 1 TO 3 YEARS Resilience. Routledge; 156-172.
14. Perrett K, Al-Wali W, Read C, et al. Outbreak of meningococcal disease in
PRE-DISASTER PHASE ACUTE PHASE POST-ACUTE PHASE Rotherham illustrates the value of coordination, communication, and collabora-
establish trusting ensure safety regain a sense of mastery tion in management. Commun Dis Public Health.2000;3(3):168-171.
relationships 15. Norris, F, Kaniasty K. Perceived and received social support in times of
diminish suffering and control stress: A test of the social support deterioration deterrence model. Journal
evaluate planning and preserve function resume roles and activities of Personality and Social Psychology. 1996; 71(3):499-511.
preparation efforts promote resilience develop new normal routine 16. Brewin CR, Andrews B, Valentine, JD. Meta-analysis of risk factors
empower by education for posttraumatic stress disorder in trauma-exposed adults. Journal of
Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 2000; 68(5):748-766. ❒
OCTOBER 2020
Mood Disorders w w w. p s y c h i a t r i c t i m e s . c o m
BIPOLAR UPDATE
Oxcarbazepine: Does It Have
a Role in Bipolar Disorder?
» David N. Osser, MD provement in the scores. However,
the response rates were 42% with ox-
often with oxcarbazepine include
liver enzyme elevations (it is not me-
mg to the maximum dose of 2400
mg, if needed and tolerated. Serum
O
xcarbazepine (formerly brand- carbazepine and 26% with placebo, tabolized and is renally excreted), se- levels are not available.
ed as Trileptal) is an anticon- which looks like it could have be- rious rashes including Stevens-John- In conclusion, it seems that oxcar-
vulsant that is structurally very come a significant difference if the son syndrome, leucopenia, sedation, bazepine could be a consideration for
similar to carbamazepine, which is cohort had been larger. and other rashes. It is a weaker induc- patients who you want to treat with
US Food and Drug Administration- carbamazepine for mania (as mono-
approved for acute or mixed mania therapy or adjunct) but for whom it
but not well studied for depression. would be unsafe or who have been
Both are thought to work by the same unable to tolerate it. It is unlikely to
mechanism(s). The drug came to “Both oxcarbazepine and carbamazepine be of value for someone who had an
market as an anticonvulsant with very adequate trial of carbamazepine and
little time left on its patent protection, are weight-neutral, but they can cause has not responded. The evidence
and it very quickly became a generic
product. There was not enough time
double vision and vertigo.” base for treating or preventing bipo-
lar depression is very weak for both.
to do any significant studies on other
possible uses such as in bipolar disor- Dr Osser is associate professor of psy-
der before the patent ran out. Hence, chiatry, Harvard Medical School, and
there are very little data pertinent to Oxcarbazepine has a somewhat er of cytochrome P450 3A4 com- Consulting Psychiatrist, US
its efficacy or effectiveness for bipo- milder adverse effect profile com- pared with carbamazepine and thus Department of Veterans Affairs,
lar mania or depression. What data pared with carbamazepine. Probably has fewer drug interactions. Both ox- National Telemental Health Center,
are available are at best inconclusive,1 the most significant risk with oxcar- carbazepine and carbamazepine are Bipolar Disorders Telehealth Program,
but Maudsley Prescribing in Psychia- bazepine is hyponatremia; this most weight-neutral, but they can cause Brockton, MA. He is a member of
try, citing 8 pertinent reports, rate it as often occurs in the first 3 months of double vision and vertigo. Slower ti- Psychiatric Times® Editorial Board.
“probably effective” for mania—the use, but it can occur later. Although tration may minimize these and other The author reports no conflicts of in-
only medication with that rating in a few head-to-head comparisons are adverse effects. Teratogenicity is a terest concerning the subject matter
table of 13 off-label possible alterna- available,2 the incidence might be severe problem with carbamazepine; of this article.
tive treatments.2 higher in oxcarbazepine than with the incidence is unclear with oxcar- REFERENCES
The only placebo-controlled study carbamazepine. The overall rate is bazepine but it probably should be 1. Vasudev A, Macritchie K, Vasudev K, et al. Oxcar-
was in children and adolescents.3 The about 2% to 3%, but concomitant se- considered to be an equally high risk bazepine for acute affective episodes in bipolar disor-
der. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2011;(12):CD004857.
study included a total of 116 patients lective serotonin reuptake inhibitors in women of child-bearing potential.
2. Taylor DM, Barnes TRE, Young AH. The Maudsley
with symptoms of mania aged 7 to 18 (which can lower sodium by a differ- Dosage of oxcarbazepine is about Prescribing Guidelines in Psychiatry, 13th Edition.
years who were randomized to ox- ent mechanism) probably increase one-third higher than with carbam- Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Blackwell; 2018: 237.
carbazepine or placebo. There was this risk. Sodium monitoring should azepine. The same dose has been 3. Wagner KD, Kowatch RA, Emslie GJ,et al. A double-
blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of oxcar-
no significant difference on the occur monthly for the first 3 months used for bipolar mania as is used for
bazepine in the treatment of bipolar disorder in chil-
Young Mania Rating Scale, nor on and every 3 to 6 months thereafter. seizure disorders; begin with 300 mg dren and adolescents. Am J Psychiatry. 2006;163:
rate of response defined as a 50% im- Adverse effects that appear less bid and increase every 3 days by 300 1179-1186. ❒
This Month on Our Website Check Out These Features on Our Website:
www.psychiatrictimes.com
PODCASTS SLIDESHOWS
Dosing Tips for Bipolar Disorder: Quetiapine Quick reference to noteworthy studies and tipsheets.
Chris Aiken, MD, Kellie Newsome, PMH-NP
psychiatrictimes.com/view/dosing-tips-bipolar-disorder-quetiapine 10 Factors That Influence Treatment Outcomes
Joseph F. Goldberg, MD
Dosing Tips: Lithium for Bipolar Disorder psychiatrictimes.com/view/
Chris Aiken, MD, Kellie Newsome, PMH-NP 10-factors-that-influence-treatment-outcomes
psychiatrictimes.com/view/dosing-tips-lithium-bipolar-disorder
w w w. p s y c h i a t r i c t i m e s . c o m
Neuropsychiatry October 2020
T
he term frontotemporal dementia (FTD) de- Table 1. Diagnostic Criteria for the FTD Variants
scribes a group of neurodegenerative disor- bvFTD Progressive deterioration of behavior or Definitive bvFTD is diagnosed when an
ders that are characterized by the clinical syn- cognition (by observation or by history individual meets the criteria for possible
drome of progressive dysfunction in executive provided by a reliable caretaker or informant). bvFTD and has 1 or both of the following:
P ossible bvFTD is diagnosed if 3 or more 1. histopathological evidence of FTD; or
functioning, behaviors, and language.1 FTD is 2. evidence of a known pathogenic
thought to be the third most common type of de- of the following are present:
1. early behavioral disinhibition mutation
mentia after Alzheimer disease (AD) and dementia 2. early apathy or inertia bvFTD is excluded if the individual’s
with Lewy bodies. FTD is also a common type of 3. early loss of sympathy or empathy presentation is better accounted by:
early-onset dementia (occurring among individu- 4. early perseverative, stereotyped, or 1. another nondegenerative nervous
als 65 years or younger).2 compulsive/ritualistic behavior system or medical disorder; or
5. hyperorality and dietary changes 2. a psychiatric diagnosis; or
FTD was noted in 1892 by Arnold Pick, MD, 6. neuropsychological profile: executive/ 3. another neurocognitive disorder or
when he described an individual who presented generation deficits with relative sparing of neurodegenerative process such as AD,
with aphasia, temporal lobar atrophy, and presenile memory and visuospatial functions which is strongly indicated by a biomarker
dementia.2 In 1911 the association between Pick P robable bvFTD diagnosis would need to
bodies and FTD was described by Alois Alzheimer, meet criteria for possible bvFTD + imaging
suggestive of frontal or anterior atrophy on
MD, PhD, who named the disorder “Pick’s dis- MRI or CT
ease.” The term Pick’s disease became synony-
mous with FTD, referring to both the clinical syn- PPA Prominent difficulty with language is the PPA diagnosis is excluded if:
principal cause of impaired daily activities, 1. the presenting symptoms are more
drome and the pathological diagnosis. Currently, with aphasia being the most prominent consistent with another neurocognitive
“Pick’s disease” is used only to describe the patho- deficit at symptom onset and during the disorder, medical condition,
logical diagnosis. In 1982, M. Marsel Mesulam, initial phase of the disease. neurodegenerative process, or psychiatric
MD, identified the language subtype of FTD: pri- diagnosis; or
2. if there are prominent initial episodic
mary progressive aphasia (PPA). memory, visual memory, or visuospatial
Available evidence indicates that FTD is the impairments; and initial behavioral
second most common cause of dementia among in- disturbance.
dividuals 65 years or younger.1 The prevalence of
nfvPPA The diagnosis requires at least 1 of 2 core The imaging-supported nfvPPA variant is
FTD among individuals with early-onset dementia is features: diagnosed when there is:
between 3% and 26%. The population prevalence of 1. agrammatism in language production 1. imaging that demonstrates predominant
FTD varies between 1 to 26 per 100,000.2 These 2. effortful and halting speech that is not left posterior fronto-insular atrophy on MRI;
numbers probably underestimate the true prevalence, consistent with speech apraxia or
and shows 2 of 3 of the following features: 2. predominantly left posterior fronto-
as the disorder is often missed or misdiagnosed. 1. impaired comprehension of complex insular hypoperfusion or hypometabolism
sentences on SPECT or PET.
Subtypes 2. spared single-word comprehension nfvPPA with definite pathology is
FTD has 2 main subtypes, based on their predomi- 3. spared object knowledge diagnosed when there is:
1. histopathologic evidence; or
nating presentations: the behavioral variant of FTD 2. the presence of a known pathogenic
(bvFTD), and the language variant, ie, PPA.3 Based mutation.
on the localizations and underlying cerebral dys-
function, the language variant can be further subdi- svPPA T
he diagnosis requires impairment in For an imaging-supported diagnosis, there
confrontation naming (ie, difficulty naming must either be:
vided into the nonfluent variant of PPA (nfvPPA) or recognizing objects or drawings) + 1. predominant anterior temporal lobe
and the semantic variant of PPA (svPPA). Male impaired single-word comprehension + at atrophy; or
predominance has been noted in the bvFTD and least 3 of the following: 2. predominant anterior temporal
svPPA variants and female predominance in the 1. impaired object knowledge hypoperfusion/hypometabolism on SPECT
2. surface dyslexia (ie, inability to recognize or PET.
nfvPPA variant. Table 1 details the diagnostic cri- words as a whole) or dysgraphia For a definite pathology diagnosis, there
teria of FTD’s 3 variants.4,5 3. spared repetition must be:
A third variant of PPA has been described as 4. spared speech production 1. histopathologic evidence; or
logopenic PPA (lvPPA), in which individuals ex- 2. the presence of a known pathogenic
mutation.
hibit specific impairment with confrontation nam-
ing or word-finding difficulties and impaired sen- AD, Alzheimer disease; bvFTD, behavioral variant FTD; FTD, frontotemporal dementia; nfvPPA, nonfluent variant PPA;
PPA, primary progressive aphasia; SPECT, single-photon emission CT; svPPA, semantic variant PPA.
tence repetition.1,6 Neuroimaging studies among
these individuals demonstrate predominant left evidence or the presence of a known pathogenic individuals with bvFTD have concomitant motor
posterior perisylvian or parietal atrophy/hypoper- mutation allow for a definite diagnosis of FTD. neuron disease.7 In addition, 27.3% of individuals
fusion/hypometabolism. Definite histopathologic Evidence indicates that approximately 12.5% of have features of minor motor system dysfunction,
Functional MRI Reduced connectivity in Reduced functional connectivity Reduced functional connectivity
the salience network: the in the frontal operculum, primary in the semantic network
frontal lobe, anterior and supplementary motor areas, involving the left anterior
cingulate, insula, and inferior parietal lobule temporal lobe, inferior and
amygdala, medial ventral regions of the temporal
thalamus, and ventral lobe, bilateral frontal cortex, left
striatum amygdala, hippocampus,
caudate, and occipital regions
18-fluorodeoxyglucose Hypometabolism in the Greater hypometabolism in the Temporal lobe hypometabolism Left frontotemporoparietal
PET and SPECT frontotemporal regions, left inferior frontal and superior with asymmetrical left hypometabolism, especially in
especially the orbitofrontal, temporal regions hemisphere involvement in the the lateral frontal and posterior‐
dorsolateral, and medial entorhinal and perirhinal cortex, lateral temporal lobes, caudate,
prefrontal cortex and inferior temporal poles, and posterior cingulate, and
anterior temporal poles amygdala precuneus regions
COMMENTARY
The Case for Medication-Assisted
Treatment: An Ethical Priority
» Kultaj Kaleka, RN, and Juliette In line with the goal of reducing
recidivism, a proportion of the crimi-
apparent through lenses of health
care as a source of harm, paternalism,
chological withdrawal symptoms
that they could easily avoid with
M. Perzhinsky, MD, MSc nal justice population is often divert- and violation of rights; through a re- MAT, including nausea, vomiting,
S
ubstance use disorder (SUD), ed to drug courts. According to fusal to provide access to appropriate diarrhea, agitation, anxiety, and sui-
including opioid use disorder SAMHSA, there are currently 2700 care; or through the intersection of cidality.3 This lack of access to ap-
(OUD), affects a significant operational drug courts in the United medicine and epidemiology. These proved and indicated therapy for a
proportion of the American popula- States.1 These courts adjudicate cas- considerations include issues around disease process could be construed as
tion—20.3 million (7.4%) of Ameri- es involving substance-involved of- access to MAT and the context in a punitive measure and borderline
cans aged 12 years or older had a fenders, or individuals who were ar- which consent to MAT is obtained cruel and unusual punishment. In
SUD in the past year.1 Of these, 2 rested for a drug-related offense and/ from those to whom it is offered. fact, detoxification in the absence of
million people had an OUD from or are eligible to enter a drug court MAT is an approved treatment for MAT is less efficacious than MAT
heroin and/or misuse of prescription program. Typically, an offender is OUD by the US Food and Drug Ad- and harmful to human health.4
pain relievers. Although medication- followed by a drug court for 12 to 18 ministration. The underlying phar- Surveys of drug courts and the US
assisted treatment (MAT) with meth- months. The National Drug Court In- macology of drugs used in MAT and prison systems do find practical rea-
adone, buprenorphine, or naltrexone stitute reports that more than 116,000 their physiological effects on indi- sons for not providing MAT, namely,
for OUD is the most efficacious, evi- criminal offenders were served by a viduals are well understood. MAT is the cost and lack of access to local
denced-based treatment that is rec- drug court program in 2009.4 How- known to assist in diminishing crav- providers. However, there are courts
ommended by the National Institute ever, only 56% of drug courts offer ings, and some agents can alleviate that do not permit MAT because of a
of Health, Substance Abuse and MAT to participants.5 Additionally, the withdrawal symptoms associated lack of knowledge and stigma around
Mental Health Services Administra- most individuals with SUD do not with OUD. However, many drug OUD. Many drug court teams are un-
tion (SAMHSA), and the World receive treatment while they are in- courts and prison facilities do not af- certain about the underlying physio-
Health Organization, only 11% of carcerated, or they are forced to with- ford provisions for MAT for incarcer- logical mechanisms of opioid recep-
patients with an OUD are prescribed draw from treatment they were re- ated individuals.2,5 tor agonists used in MAT and their
approved treatment. ceiving before incarceration In the absence of MAT, individu- efficacy in treating OUD. Some report
Limited access to MAT has been (Figure).2 als with OUD are forced to undergo they believe that patients with OUD
cited as a substantial barrier for pa- Ethical considerations around detoxification with full exposure to use MAT to get high and not for treat-
tients with OUD; inequities across MAT in caring for these patients are the negative physiological and psy- ment of OUD.4 Further, others think
ethnic and sociodemographic groups
speak to the health disparities evident
Figure. Availability of Medication-Assisted Treatment Within the Criminal Justice System
in society. The provision of appropri-
ate treatment and lack thereof are IN JAILS & PRISONS IN DRUG COURTS
even more troublesome when consid-
30 OUT OF 5,100
ering the vulnerable populations that In a 2018 study, participants with OUDs
bear the disproportionate burden of
SUDs and OUDs—namely, those in- prisons and jails in the U.S. offered
were 80% less likely
to graduate from drug court
volved with the corrections system methadone or buprenorphine in 2017
and those with serious mental illness Approximately 50% of drug courts required participants to discontinue
(SMI). It is no secret that a significant methadone or buprenorphine within 30 days in a 2017 study
proportion of the criminal justice 14 states offered methadone or buprenorphine maintenance
population has an SUD.1,2 for jail or prison inmates in 2018 < 50% OF DRUG COURT PARTICIPANTS
with OUDs received MAT in a 2018 study
Justice in criminal justice
Between 62% and 86% of individu- UPON REENTRY OR COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS
als arrested test positive for recent
45%
drug use,3 and 64% to 76% of arrest- Without MAT, there was a
ees meet diagnostic criteria for SUD.
29% of state and federal prisons
More than half of individuals with a IN THE U.S. PROVIDED REFERRALS FOR of state and federal prisons in the U.S. 10-40X HIGHER RISK
prescription OUD or heroin use in COMMUNITY BUPRENORPHINE PROVIDERS IN 2009 referred inmates for methadone of death from overdose within 2 weeks
of release from prison in a 2018 study
the past year report contact with the maintenance after release in 2009
criminal justice system.2 Similarly,
<5% of persons with OUDs referred to treatment in 2014 by probation, parole or court authorities
in terms of mental illness, 9.2 million received methadone or buprenorphine compared to 41% referred by non-criminal justice sources
Americans over 18 years old, or 3.7%
of American adults, had co-occurring Source: SAMHSA. Use of Medication-Assisted Treatment for Opioid Use Disorder in Criminal Justice Settings.
SUD and any mental illness in 2018.1 https://store.samhsa.gov/sites/default/files/d7/priv/pep19-matusecjs.pdf
that MAT use for OUD is essentially be voluntary and free of coercion.6,7 It forded subpar and borderline unethi- REFERENCES
1. Key Substance Use and Mental Health Indicators in
replacing one addictive substance should be obtained from someone cal care. The underlying reasons be- the United States: Results From the 2018 National Sur-
with another.4 with the capacity to make a decision hind this unsettling phenomenon is a vey on Drug Use and Health. (HHS Publication No.
The false narrative that MAT rein- after they have an understanding of lack of health literacy around MAT PEP195068, NSDUH Series H54). Rockville, MD: Cen-
forces addiction or replaces an illicit the risks and benefits of available op- and stigma associated with OUD in ter for Behavioral Health Statistics and Quality, Sub-
stance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administra-
substance (heroin) has a negative im- tions. Consent under the threat of in- nonclinical settings. tion. 2019. Accessed September 10, 2020. https://
pact on individuals.3 Additionally, carceration, or while incapacitated, is store.samhsa.gov/product/key-substance-use-and-
the intersection of medicine and epi- not informed consent and compro- Concluding thoughts mental-health-indicators-in-the-united-states-re-
demiology is evident when those mises individual autonomy.6,7 An ethical framework is needed, as sults-from-the-2018-national-survey-on-Drug-Use-
and-Health/PEP19-5068
with SUDs/OUDs who do not have Many individuals with OUDs/ well as best practice guidelines high- 2. Winkelman TN, Chang VW, Binswanger IA. Health,
access to MAT turn to unsafe prac- SUDs choose Narcotics Anonymous, lighting the efficacy of and science polysubstance use, and criminal justice involvement
tices, such as the use of unclean nee- peer support, drug-free toxification, or behind MAT specifically directed at among adults with varying levels of opioid use. JAMA
dles to inject impure heroin or heroin treatment modalities other than MAT.3 the correctional system. Addressing Network Open. 2018;1(3).
3. Ludwig AS, Peters RH. Medication-assisted treatment
laced with synthetic fentanyl. This, in Assuming a binary disposition, MAT limitations in knowledge base and for opioid use disorders in correctional settings: An eth-
turn, leads to increased morbidity versus drug-free detoxification is highlighting shortcomings in protect- ics review. Int J Drug Policy. 2014;25(6):1041-1046.
and mortality as well as to public overly punitive and a violation of vol- ing the rights of incarcerated indi- 4. Matusow H, Dickman SL, Rich JD, et al. Medication
health issues of increased transmis- untariness and self-determination of viduals are both essential, in partner- assisted treatment in US drug courts: Results from a
nationwide survey of availability, barriers and atti-
sion of infectious diseases.3 these individuals. ship with all stakeholders (including tudes. J Subst Abuse Treat. 2013;44(5):473-480.
Patients with SUDs/OUDs often incarcerated patients, rights groups, 5. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Ad-
The dangers of coercion contend with unfavorable correction- judges, the correctional system, and ministration. Adult Drug Courts and Medication-As-
The other side of the coin: being pro- al system interactions as well as SMI, medical bodies). sisted Treatment for Opioid Dependence. In Brief.
2014;8(1). Accessed September 10, 2020. https://
cessed by a drug court and given the and they predominantly comprise store.samhsa.gov/product/Adult-Drug-Courts-and-
option of either incarceration or MAT. minorities from low-income or lim- Mr Kaleka is a fourth-year medical Medication-Assisted-Treatment-for-Opioid-Depen-
Asking an individual with a mentally ited educational backgrounds and student at Central Michigan University dence/sma14-4852
incapacitating illness to consent to with reduced social support. They are College of Medicine, Saginaw, MI. 6. D’Hotman D, Pugh, J, Douglas T. When is coercive
methadone therapy justified? Bioethics. 2018;
treatment brings in to question au- a vulnerable population whom soci- Dr Perzhinsky is an associate profes- 32(7):405-413.
tonomy and validity of consent. In- ety has largely marginalized.2 Their sor of medicine at Central Michigan 7. Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Bio-
formed consent, by definition, should rights are threatened, and they are af- University College of Medicine. medical Ethics. Oxford University Press; 2019. ❒
COMMENTARY
Behind Closed Doors
» Omar Reda, MD can Muslim, strengthening fami- It became the norm to talk with munity, it may be about the immigra-
ly ties, and improving the relationship kids about their identity and self- tion system. In the Muslim commu-
N
ot only in America, but through- between the community and its neigh- worth, about micro- and macro-ag- nity, it may be about terrorism. Hate
out the world, difficult conver- bors and law enforcement agencies. gressions, about speaking up on be- is horrible, and it not only makes sur-
sations are taking place in many Fast forward to 2011, a bloody h a l f o f t h e vo i c e l e s s , bu t vivors doubt their own beauty, but it
homes. Behind closed doors, children civil war started in my home country also about how they can defend also makes us miss out on each oth-
are exposed at early ages to discus- Libya. I left my small immediate themselves when someone decides to er’s beauty.
sions about heavy topics like violence, family behind to care for my extend- attack them verbally or physically. We thought COVID-19 was only
hate, and human cruelty. ed family overseas, trying to he- After the Portland max train stabbing going to impact our ability to breathe,
I am blessed to have three daugh- al some of the many psychosocial incident and the New Zealand but then Mr Floyd’s death reminded
ters. I try to create a safe and wounds of that protracted conflict. I mosque shooting, we spent time and us of the ugly pandemic of oppres-
sane home for them, but I have never lost friends and loved ones to vio- energy brainstorming ways on how sion. In Oregon, the smoke of the
imagined engaging them in some of lence and extremism. My wife to stay alive and feel safe at our plac- wildfires stirs different discussions
these talks, especially here in the and children had to live through peri- es of social gatherings and worship. about existential themes, like our re-
United States, and in the 21st century. ods of uncertainty and high anxiety Trauma steals precious moments and lationship with God and the meaning
When I moved to Portland, Ore- every time I boarded a plane and par- impacts the potential for beauty. of life.
gon in 2009, I thought the city’s nick- took in that dangerous journey. I recently participated on a pan- Is it bad that our children are
name (the Rose City) was a sign that We thought and prayed the new el discussion about combating hate. growing up very quickly and having
things would be much safer and more decade would bring a better energy, A young black female stated that, “at these mature conversations at a
comfortable for my family. Similarly, but the year 2020 has been one of the least [things] are not as bad for this young tender age, or is that the new
my wife believed that moving from most challenging years of all. Here in generation as it was for our fellow norm? My hope is that trauma will
the southern to the northwestern part Oregon we have been struggling to citizens in the 1950s and 60s.” That eventually produce a more resilient
of the country would make things breathe, literally and metaphorically. really broke my heart. Just because generation and a more compassion-
easier for us as Muslims and people It is not only the threat of the corona- hate and violence are “not as bad,” ate and cohesive society. I believe
of color. virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) does not mean things are OK. Chil- that many trauma survivors be-
But shortly after arriving, a young to our respiratory system, but also the dren should not have to settle for a come better humans not despite, but
Somali boy was accused of planning systemic knee of injustice on the dysfunctional world. because, of their trauma stories.
a terrorist attack in one of the city’s necks of our black brothers and sis- “The talk” we thought we would
busiest spots, the Pioneer Square. We ters and the wave of hate facing mi- have with our children is about how Dr Reda is a practicing psychiatrist in
found ourselves working with com- norities and people of color. The to survive the emotional turmoil of Providence Healthcare System,
munity leaders and the Muslim youth mask can help with the former crisis, puberty. In the black community, Portland, OR. He reports no conflicts
on topics like emotional safety and but unmasking is what is needed for that talk is also about how to stay of interest concerning the subject
well-being, how to be a proud Ameri- the latter. alive in America. In the Latino com- matter of this article. ❒
for her PTSD symptoms. Julia smoked marijuana The term cannabis refers to a genus of flower-
Dr Hicks is a PGY-2 psychiatry resident at Case Western occasionally during her early 20s and found it to ing plants belonging to the family cannabaceae.
Reserve University/University Hospitals in Cleveland, OH.
have a relaxing effect. She has not used marijuana Two common species—sativa and indica as well
Dr Lapchenko is medical director at Elwyn Natale in
since becoming pregnant with her first child about as their hybrids—are consumed in the United
Norristown, PA. Dr Saxton is an assistant professor of
8 years ago. She has many questions about medical States for medical and recreational purposes. A
psychiatry at Case Western Reserve University. Dr West
cannabis including its risks, benefits, and how to third rarer species, ruderalis, is endemic to Asia
is an associate professor of psychiatry at Case Western
Reserve University.
obtain it, and she is looking to you for advice. and Eastern Europe. The cannabis plant contains
approximately 500 known chemical compounds.
History of medical cannabis Sixty-six of these compounds are cannabinoids
“J
ulia” is a 31-year-old female with depres- The concept of cannabis as medicine has existed that are unique to cannabis; cannabinoids tetrahy-
sion and posttraumatic stress disorder for millenia,1 but its legal recognition has only be- drocannabinol (THC) and cannabidiol (CBD) are
(PTSD) who presents to your outpatient gun to gain traction with western medical practi- responsible for its psychoactive and purported me-
psychiatry clinic. She is married with 2 chil- tioners in the last 2 decades. California became the dicinal properties, respectively. The remainder of
dren and works as a store manager. Julia has been first state to legalize medical cannabis in 1996 the chemicals, such as nitrogenous compounds,
taking a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor for with the passage of Proposition 215-Compassion- amino acids, and terpenes, can be found in other
the last 2 years, which alleviated her depressive ate Use Act, and many states have followed suit.2 plants and account for cannabis’ non-psychoactive
symptoms. However, Julia continues to experi- As of May 2020, all but 3 states (Idaho, South Da- properties including its color, flavor, and odor.5
ence PTSD symptoms including nightmares, kota, and Nebraska) have enacted legislation re- Although there are 3 main species of the canna-
flashbacks, and avoidant behavior. She has tried garding the use of either medical cannabis or can- bis plant, nearly 800 cultivars or strains are believed
various augmenting agents with little relief; she nabis-derived (ie, cannabidiol-containing) to exist.6 Cultivars are often described in terms of
currently engages in therapy. products (Figure).3 This trend mirrors the world- their cannabinoid content and specifically their
A friend of Julia’s recently told her that medical wide trend of increasing acceptance of medical CBD-to-THC ratios, as these account for their ad-
marijuana has been a panacea and has made it cannabis. Mexico, Australia, and much of Western vertised medicinal properties. High CBD-to-THC
much easier to function. Intrigued, Julia researched Europe and South America have legalized medical strains are believed to have anti-inflammatory and
cannabis online and found it might be beneficial cannabis.4 calming properties; they are thought to be effective
D Indications
Marijuana has long been a part of popular culture.
When smoked, vaped, or ingested, THC can pro-
Legal Legal for medical use Legal for medical use, limited THC content Prohibited for any use duce sought-after effects such as euphoria, height-
ened senses, a distorted sense of time, alterations
Source: Lokal_Profil https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5/;
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_cannabis_by_U.S._jurisdiction#/media/File:Map_of_US_state_cannabis_laws.svg in physical movements, and decreased inhibitions.
With 38 states allowing for the use of THC-con-
for the treatment of autoimmune, mood, and anxiety public interest and threatened to revoke the pre- taining medical marijuana compounds (Figure), it
disorders. In contrast, high THC-to-CBD strains are scribing privileges of those physicians who did not stands to reason that it may be effective for treat-
advertised as being helpful for pain and nausea.7 comply with the policy.9 The 1996 federal policy ing physical and mental ailments. By far, the most
(These statements have not been evaluated by the led to a landmark legal case Conant v Walters common psychiatric diagnosis listed by these
US Food and Drug Administration. The FDA has (United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cir- states is PTSD, but others include Tourette syn-
not approved a marketing application for cannabis cuit, 2002). The class action lawsuit was filed by drome, Alzheimer, and autism. As psychiatrists,
due to its federally illegal status and classification as patients with seriously medical illness and their we may be approached to diagnose some of these
a Schedule I drug.) doctors against John P. Walters, director of the conditions in our patients as part of their interest in
White House Office of National Drug Control Pol- obtaining medical marijuana.
Legislation icy and others. The court ultimately ruled that the
Laws governing cannabis cultivation and use have existing federal policy violated a physician’s first Adverse effects
not always been so favorable. While cannabis was amendment right to free speech by threatening cen- It is important to consider what can go wrong
a popular ingredient in medicinal compounds tout- sure for discussions held in the sanctity of the doc- when using THC. Common short-term side effects
ed as a cure for a variety of conditions (eg, gonor- tor-patient relationship; it further found physicians include conjunctival injection (often a tell-tale
rhea and “childbirth psychosis” in the late 19th may discuss the pros and cons of medical marijua- sign of intoxication), hyperphagia (or, in common
and early 20th centuries), laws limiting and pro- na with their patients and issue oral or written opin- parlance, “the munchies”), xerostomia “cotton-
hibiting its use were enacted as early as the 1920s. ions recommending its use. However, the court mouth,” dyspnea, tachycardia, and slowed motor
By 1931, 29 states passed legislation explicitly explicitly stated that physicians may not prescribe response leading to delayed reaction time (which
barring possession of cannabis. In the decades that or dispense marijuana or “aid and abet” the patient is particularly concerning while driving or operat-
followed, there were harsher penalties for posses- in the purchase, cultivation, or possession of mari- ing heavy machinery). One of the most common
sion, including mandatory minimum sentences for juana. This landmark decision was the first to out- psychiatric side effects is paranoia; this may be
charges of possession of cannabis. line a physician’s right to recommend, but not pre- worth noting when discussing marijuana with pa-
In 1971, the Controlled Substances Act (CSA) scribe, cannabis and provided a basis for legal tients who have a history of paranoid beliefs.
created the Drug Enforcement Agency’s drug sched- protection from sanctions against their license.10 There are also long-term issues that have been
ules that still exists today. The CSA placed cannabis In 2014, Congress passed the Rohrabacher-Farr associated with THC. These may include cannabi-
in the Schedule I category of drugs along with hero- amendment as part of Commerce, Justice, Sci- noid hyperemesis syndrome/cyclic vomiting syn-
in, LSD, ecstasy, and psilocybin, all of which are ence, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act. drome and amotivational syndrome.16 There are
believed to have no current medical use, high abuse This amendment, initially introduced in 2001, pro- potential consequences in pregnant woman, in-
potential, and lack of accepted safety data for use hibits the use of federal funds to interfere with the cluding a negative impact on fetal brain develop-
under medical supervision.8 The CSA dealt perhaps implementation of state medical cannabis laws. ment and decreased birth weight.17 Finally, some
the hardest blow to cannabis’ potential use as a ther- The Rohrabacher-Farr amendment is considered a argue that marijuana serves as a gateway drug,
apeutic agent by prohibiting the use of federal funds significant victory for proponents and consumers placing users in circumstances where they find
for any research into its efficacy and safety. of medical cannabis because it allows state medi- themselves compelled to use more dangerous
DENYS HOLOVATIUK@STOCK.ADOBE.COM
Cannabis legislation remained at a standstill for cal cannabis dispensaries to operate without fear drugs with a higher potential for addiction.
25 years after the CSA until the passage of Propo- of prosecution by the federal government, which Doctors may also be called upon to answer
sition 215 in California, which allowed patients still considers cannabis to be illegal due to its clas- questions about CBD. As it is readily available in
with a valid doctor’s recommendation to possess sification as a Schedule I drug.11 multiple forms (eg, gummies, oils, pills) at numer-
and cultivate cannabis for personal use. In direct Legislation to reclassify cannabis from a Sched- ous locations (eg, pharmacies, health food stores,
response to the proposition’s passage, the federal ule I to a Schedule III drug and decriminalize it at gas stations), one may conclude that it is relatively
government also issued a policy in 1996 indicating a federal level was introduced in the Marijuana Op- benign. The FDA, however, warns that CBD may
that a physician’s recommendation or prescription portunity, Reinvestment, and Expungement cause somnolence, gastrointestinal distress, irrita-
of Schedule I substances was not in line with the (MORE) Act of 2019. The Act was passed by the bility, and/or agitation.18 Regarding its efficacy as
CME
a treatment option for serious mental illness, the Employment restrictions are delineated at the require employers to reasonably accommodate an
results appear inconclusive.19,20 state level with varying degrees of stringency. The employee’s medical needs for off-duty/off-sight
There is much discussion regarding the rela- exception is federal employees who are prohibited use.26,27 This could entail allowing the employee to
tionship between marijuana and psychosis, as from using both medical and recreational marijua- work shifts that do not interfere with medical mari-
there is some overlap between cannabis intoxica- na. The medical cannabis laws of Nevada and juana use. Since on-duty use and related impair-
tion and primary psychotic disorders. For those Washington will be used for illustrative purposes ment are prohibited, employers may implement
experiencing a psychotic episode with concomi- due to their contrasting laws. However, each state policies to determine impairment in a variety of
tant marijuana use, the etiology of the symptoms has slight nuances that need to be reviewed before different ways. For example, suspected impairment
becomes complex. If a patient who uses marijuana discussing medical marijuana with patients. may be confirmed with a drug screen or via obser-
is later diagnosed with schizophrenia, the marijua- The pre-employment job process may involve vation of behavioral changes. However, for chronic
na can further complicate the picture. For instance, a drug screen and/or a questionnaire inquiring medical marijuana users, a drug screen is likely to
in their resistance to accept the schizophrenia di- about marijuana (medical or recreational) use. The be a poor indicator of impairment, as the non-psy-
agnosis, the patient and family may prefer to attri- employer, according to their own policies, must choactive components of marijuana can stay in the
bute the psychotic symptoms to marijuana. Unfor- choose how to handle a positive drug screen. Some body for weeks.28 The state of Arkansas recognized
tunately, this may lead to delays in receiving the may recognize medical marijuana as a legitimate this issue and ruled that an employer cannot use a drug
appropriate antipsychotic treatment. treatment and disregard a positive test. Others may test as the sole indicator of impairment.29 Other states
According to a 2016 meta-analysis, increased have a zero-tolerance drug policy. have allowed the employer autonomy over the
exposure to THC increases the odds of being diag- A zero-tolerance policy was unsuccessfully methodology of determining impairment. Regard-
nosed with schizophrenia.21 Additionally, THC use challenged by a Washington state employer in Roe ing off-duty use, restrictions are again variable.
is associated with poor medication response, med- v Teletech (Washington Supreme Court, 2011). Some states force employers to recognize medical
ication noncompliance, and higher frequency and The Washington Supreme Court upheld a ruling marijuana status, while others do not.30
temporary worsening of psychotic symptoms.22,23 that an employer does not have to accommodate
This information should be tempered when dis- an employee’s use of medical marijuana, even Driving
cussing marijuana use with patients; while a clini- when the employee is in a non-safety-sensitive po- Similar to employment, states have struggled with
cian may share concerns about marijuana use with sition and uses medical marijuana exclusively off- issues regarding people who use medical marijuana
their patients, an absolute intolerance could poten- site.24 In contrast, Nevada recognized the quandary and drive due to the difficulty of identifying suspect-
tially damage the therapeutic alliance. of allowing medical marijuana while simultane- ed impairment and corroborating it with objective
ously permitting employers to discriminate against measures that will hold up in court. Currently, there
Employment its use. Thus, Assembly Bill 132 was passed, mak- are 4 main testing methods: urine, blood, saliva, and
After reviewing Julia’s medical history and dis- ing Nevada the first state to prohibit employers breathalyzer. While urine and blood are the most
cussing the potential side effects of medical mari- from discriminating against applicants for a posi- commonly employed testing methods, they are also
juana, Julia begins to share concerns over the use tive marijuana test.25 It should be noted that some the poorest measures of impairment. Depending on
of medical marijuana for her PTSD. She asks jobs are exempt from the Nevada bill. the amount, frequency, and mode of marijuana use,
about anticipated employer problems, but she is Once employed, on-duty use of medical mari- THC may be metabolized by the liver within hours
unaware of her workplace’s policies. Julia further juana is almost universally prohibited. However, of ingestion.28 However, the nonpsychoactive metab-
questions how it may affect other facets of her life. some states (eg, Massachusetts and Nevada) may olites can remain in the system for weeks. A problem
with generic urine and drug tests is that they do not
evaluate for psychoactive versus nonpsychoactive
Table 1. Areas of State-by-State Variation in Medical Cannabis Laws metabolites. Rather, they only test for the presence of
Qualifying conditions: Most states outline qualifying conditions, but a minority allow physicians cannabinoids, which may be present for hours to
Diagnosable medical to use their discretion about constitutes such. weeks depending on the chemical compound. Thus,
conditions that qualify Most common: Severe, life-limiting illness such as cancer, HIV/AIDS, someone could ingest medical marijuana, have mul-
a patient to use medical movement disorders/multiple sclerosis, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, tiple days go by where they are no longer actively
cannabis seizure disorders, and terminal illness. intoxicated, but still test positive on a drug or urine
Psychiatric illnesses: PTSD, Tourette disorder, and autism test. This is currently the case in Pennsylvania where
Neuropsychiatric disorders: Parkinson disease, Alzheimer disease, a person using medical marijuana can be automati-
traumatic brain injury, and Huntington disease cally issued a driving under intoxication notice after
Approved recommenders In most states, only physicians can make a medical cannabis a crash if they fail a drug test.31
recommendation. However, several states allow nurse practitioners and Some states have recognized this conundrum
physician assistants to recommend medical cannabis. and sought alternative testing methods. The breath-
Some states require recommenders to complete an online training course,
alyzer is a method being explored.32 A saliva test,
Recommender training
while others only require that recommenders have an active DEA license. which is currently being used in Europe, Alabama,
and Oklahoma, is also being investigated as an op-
Home cultivation of Most states do not allow home cultivation of medical cannabis, except for tion. However, the issue remains that neither test
medical cannabis 7 states and Washington, DC. Some states only allow home cultivation
can determine impairment as there is no universal
under certain circumstances (eg, if a patient lives too far from a
dispensary); there are generally quantity limits on the number of plants
standard. Arizona and Michigan have remedied
that can be grown. this issue by ruling that a positive blood or urine
test alone is not sufficient evidence to prove intox-
Formulation While cannabis is available in numerous formulations, including edibles, ication.31 Therefore, the burden of proof is on the
oils, smokable herb, tinctures, sprays, and topicals (eg, lotion, salve, etc),
police officer alleging that a driver was intoxicated.
some states explicitly prohibit some formulations for medicinal purposes.
For example, several states prohibit smoking of the dried herb.
Gun ownership
Possession quantities Some states indicate a specific quantity of dried herb or oil that a patient Under the Gun Control Act of 1968, any unlawful
can possess at any one time, while others allow a patient to possess the user of a controlled substance is prohibited from
quantity they use in a specific timeframe (usually 1-3 months).
purchasing or owning a gun.33 The key words at
Chemical composition About one-half of all states that have legalized medicinal cannabis have issue are “controlled substance.” Since marijuana
restrictions on the percentage of THC, excluding those states with is classified as a Schedule I controlled substance, it
legalized recreational use. In those states that allow only “low THC” is illegal for anyone who uses medical marijuana to
formulations, THC percentage limits range from 0.3-5%.15
purchase a gun.34 Gun shops screen for marijuana
CME
for indiscriminately prescribing medical cannabis dia. Accessed September 12, 2020. https://ballotpedia.org/California_ 30. Barreiro S. State Laws on Off-Duty Marijuana Use. Accessed Sep-
Proposition_215,_the_Medical_Marijuana_Initiative_(1996). tember 13, 2020. https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/state-
to patients at hotel conferences that he hosted. The 3. Cannabis in the United States. Wikipedia. Accessed September 12, laws-on-off-duty-marijuana-use.html#nevada
doctor was accused of failing to establish bona fide 2020. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannabis_in_the_United_States 31. Sullum J. After a state-authorized medical marijuana patient had an
physician-patient relationships, gather comprehen- 4. The Legalization of Cannabis is Spreading Globally. Accessed Sep- epileptic seizure and crashed her car, police arrested her for driving with
sive histories and examine patients, assess patients’ tember 13, 2020. https://static.seekingalpha.com/uploads/2018/ ‘marijuana in her system.’ Reason. March 13, 2020. Accessed Septem-
11/49795830_15411931331022_rId7.jpg ber 13, 2020. https://reason.com/2020/03/13/after-a-state-authorized-
qualifying conditions every 3 months, and keep ac- 5. Elsohly S. Chemical Constituents of Cannabis. Cannabis and Canna- medical-marijuana-patient-had-an-epileptic-seizure-and-crashed-her-
curate and complete records.47 binoids: Pharmacology, Toxicology, and Therapeutic Potential. Psychol- car-police-arrested-her-for-driving-with-marjuana-in-her-system
ogy Press;2002. 32. Paris F. Scientists unveil weed breathalyzer, launching, debate over
Criminal charges 6. Cannabis Strains: How Many Different Kinds Are There? Med Well. next steps. NPR. September 5, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020.
September 13, 2020. https://www.medwellhealth.net/cannabis- https://www.npr.org/2019/09/05/757882048/scientists-un-
In addition to state medical board discipline, doctors strains-different-kinds/ veil-weed-breathalyzer-launching-debate-over-next-steps
have rarely faced criminal charges related to medi- 7. CBD:THC ratios: Maximizing your medicine. The Apothecarium. Jan- 33. Gun Control Act of 1968. 18 U.S.C. ch. 44 § 921. Accessed Septem-
cal cannabis certificates. In 2013, a Michigan doctor uary 26, 2018. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://apothecarium. ber 13, 2020. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/STATUTE-82/pdf/
was convicted of health care fraud for selling signed com/blog/nevada/2018/1/26/cbdthc-ratios-maximizing-your-medicine STATUTE-82-Pg1213-2.pdf
8. Blaszczak-Boxe A. marijuana’s history: how one plant spread through 34. United States Drug Enforcement Agency. The Controlled Substances
medical marijuana certificates to a middleman for the world. Live Science. October 17, 2014. Accessed September 13, Act. September 13, 2020. https://www.dea.gov/controlled-substances-act
resale.48 In 2016, the Arizona Supreme Court re- 2020. https://www.livescience.com/48337-marijuana-history-how- 35. US Department of Justice. Firearms Transaction Record. Accessed
viewed a case in which a physician was indicted on cannabis-travelled-world.html September 13, 2020. https://www.atf.gov/firearms/docs/4473-part-1-
forgery and fraudulent schemes related to allegedly 9. Several marijuana-related bills pending in Congress. The Marijuana firearms-transaction-record-over-counter-atf-form-53009/download.
Policy Project. January 13, 2020. Accessed September 13, 2020. 36. Transportation Security Administration. Medical Marijuana. Ac-
lying about reviewing a patient’s medical records https://www.mpp.org/policy/federal/ cessed September 13, 2020. https://www.tsa.gov/travel/securi-
when he certified her for medical marijuana.49 10. Conant v Walters, 309 F.3d 629, 9th Cir. 2002. ty-screening/whatcanibring/items/medical-marijuana
Although medical board discipline and crimi- 11. Swerdlow L. Why marijuana users need to beware the end of 37. Wolfe J. How to travel with medical marijuana. The New York Times.
nal charges related to marijuana certifications are Rohrabacher-Farr. Cannabis Cheri. January 22, 2017. December 31, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://www.ny-
12. Gunther A. Bill that would federally decriminalize marijuana passes times.com/2019/12/31/travel/traveling-with-medical-marijuana.html
likely rare, these situations can have serious and House committee. CBS News. November 21, 2019. Accessed September 13, 38. Cotten K. Medical marijuana policy prohibits use on campus, causes
long-lasting implications for a physician’s career. 2020. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/more-act-bill-that-would-federal- problem for students. OU Daily. February 6, 2019. Accessed September
Losing one’s medical license involves a loss of ly-decriminalize-marijuana-passes-house-committee-today-2019-11-20/ 13, 2020. http://www.oudaily.com/news/ou-s-medical-marijuana-pol-
one’s livelihood, source of income, and reputation. 13. Ahn J. Breaking News: MORE Act Passes in Historic Vote. Harris Bricken. icy-prohibits-use-on-campus-causes/article_596166b6-2a4a-11e9-
November 22, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://harrisbricken. b627-e79235e6cbce.html
Should a physician decide to establish a medical com/cannalawblog/breaking-news-more-act-passes-in-historic-vote/ 39. Shankar P. Cost of Ohio’s medical marijuana is still higher than street
marijuana practice, we recommend considering a 14. Qualifying conditions for medical marijuana by state. Leafly. January prices. Cleveland Scene. April 4, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020.
number of steps to reduce risk (Table 2).50 29, 2020. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://www.leafly.com/news/ https://www.clevescene.com/scene-and-heard/archives/2019/04/04/
health/qualifying-conditions-for-medical-marijuana-by-state#alaska cost-of-ohios-medical-marijuana-is-still-higher-than-street-prices
15. Legality of Cannabis by U.S. Jurisdiction. Accessed September 13, 40. Council K. Differences between medical and recreational prices.
Concluding thoughts 2020.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_cannabis_by_U.S._ Leaf Buyer. July 9, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://www.
The use of marijuana, recreational or medical, has jurisdiction. leafbuyer.com/blog/differences-between-medical-recreational-prices/
long been part of society. There was hemp use in the 16. Sontineni SP, Chaudhary S, Sontineni V, et al. Cannabinoid hypereme- 41. Colorado Weed Prices. Budzu. Accessed September 13, 2020. http://
1600s, “Reefer Madness” in the early 1930s, the sis syndrome: Clinical diagnosis of an underrecognized manifestation of budzu.com/prices/usa/colorado
chronic cannabis abuse. World J Gastroenterol. 2009;15(10):1264-1266. 42. US Federation of State Medical Boards Medical Regulatory Trends
“peace and love” movement of 1960s, and today it 17. Thompson R, DeJong K, Lo J. Marijuana use in pregnancy: a review. and Actions 2018. December 3, 2018. Accessed September 13, 2020.
seems to be the catch-all treatment for various medi- Obstet Gynecol Surv. 2019;74(7):415-428. http://www.fsmb.org/siteassets/advocacy/publications/us-medi-
cal disorders. Throughout it all, the cultural impact of 18. US Food and Drug Administration. What you need to know (and what cal-regulatory-trends-actions.pdf
marijuana is undeniable. It is with this ever-evolving we’re working to find out) about products containing cannabis or can- 43. Young A, Chaudry H, Pei X, et al. FSMB census of licensed physicians
nabis derived compounds, including CBD. Accessed September 13, in the United States, 2018. J Med Regul. 2019;105(2):7-23.
relationship that states have increasingly changed 2020. https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/what-you- 44. Ingold J. Four Colorado doctors suspended over medical marijuana
legislation to reflect the latest societal attitudes, need-know-and-what-were-working-find-out-about-products-con- recommendations. The Denver Post. Published July 19, 2016. Updated
which currently consist of increasing openness to- taining-cannabis-or-cannabis October 2, 2016. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://www.denver-
ward the use of marijuana for medical purposes. 19. Boggs DL, Surti T, Gupta A, et al. The effects of cannabidiol (CBD) on cog- post.com/2016/07/19/four-colorado-doctors-suspended-over-medi-
nition and symptoms in outpatients with chronic Schizophrenia a randomized cal-marijuana-recommendations/
With estimates of more than 4 million people using placebo controlled trial. Psychopharmacology. 2018;235(7):1923-1932. 45. In re: Vernon Eugene Proctor, M.D. Mich. Ct. App. Unpublished. March
medical marijuana across the United States, there is 20. Leweke FM, Piomelli D, Pahlisch F, et al. Cannabidiol enhances 14, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://law.justia.com/cases/
a strong likelihood that medical professionals will anandamide signaling and alleviates psychotic symptoms of schizo- michigan/court-of-appeals-unpublished/2019/342029.html
face questions regarding its efficacy and indications phrenia. Translational Psychiatry. 2012; 2: 94. 46. Lapin T. Doctor loses license after suggesting weed cookies to con-
21. Marconi A, Di Forti M, Lewis CM, et al. Meta-analysis of the associ- trol kid’s tantrums. New York Post. January 28, 2019. Accessed Septem-
for various medical conditions.51 However, research ation between the level of cannabis use and risk of psychosis. Schizophr ber 13, 2020. https://nypost.com/2019/01/28/doctor-loses-license-af-
is sparse, making the risk-to-benefit ratio a challeng- Bull. 2016;42(5): 1262-1269. ter-suggesting-weed-cookies-to-control-kids-tantrums/
ing calculation with many missing variables. 22. Reid S, Bhattacharyya S. Antipsychotic treatment failure in patients 47. Baldwin C. State suspends license for top NJ marijuana doctor. Patch.
As we enter an era of likely increasing research with psychosis and co-morbid cannabis use: A systematic review. Psy- January 10, 2019. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://patch.com/
chiatry Res. 2019; 280:112523. new-jersey/woodbridge/state-suspends-license-top-nj-marijuana-doctor
in medicinal marijuana, it will be important for 23. Sherif M, Radhakrishnan R, D’Souza DC, et al. Human laboratory stud- 48. Cook J. Doctor convicted of health care fraud for selling medical
physicians to stay up to date on the current litera- ies on cannabinoids and psychosis. Biol Psychiatry. 2016;79(7): 526-38. marijuana certificates. Macomb Daily. January 18, 2013. Accessed Sep-
ture so that we can best advise our patients. Aside 24. Roe v TeleTech Customer Care Management (Colorado) LLC, 171 tember 13, 2020. https://www.macombdaily.com/news/doctor-con-
from the clinical aspects of medical marijuana, Wn.2d 736, 257 P.3d 586 (2011) victed-of-health-care-fraud-for-selling-medical-marijuana/article_
25. NV AB 132. 2019. 80th Legislature. Accessed September 13, 2020. 2389d0a5-7efb-5893-983d-6a61caa11032.html
there are also a myriad of social constraints that https://www.leg.state.nv.us/App/NELIS/REL/80th2019/Bill/6191/Overview 49. State v Gear. Ariz. May 6, 2016. Accessed September 13, 2020.
need to be considered. In addition, due to the in- 26. Mass. Gen. Laws Ann. Ch. 94I §§ 1 to 8; 105 Mass. Code Regs. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/az-supreme-court/1734731.html
fancy of medical marijuana, there are several op- 725.650. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://malegislature.gov/ 50. Federation of State Medical Boards. Model guidelines for the recom-
portunities for liability on the part of physicians. Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleXV/Chapter94i. mendation of marijuana in patient care. April 2016. September 13, 2020.
27. Nev. Rev. Stat. Ann. §§ 453A.800, 453D.100. Accessed September https://www.fsmb.org/siteassets/advocacy/policies/model-guide-
REFERENCES 13, 2020. https://www.leg.state.nv.us/NRS/NRS-453A.html lines-for-the-recommendation-of-marijuana-in-patient-care.pdf
1. Cannabis, Coca, & Poppy: Nature’s Addictive Plants. DEA Museum. 28. Sharma P, Murthy P, Bharath MM. Chemistry, metabolism, and toxicol- 51. The Marijuana Policy Project. Medical Marijuana Patient Numbers.
Accessed September 12, 2020. https://www.deamuseum.org/ccp/ ogy of cannabis: clinical implications. Iran J Psychiatry 2012;7(4):149-156. May 9, 2020. Accessed September 13, 2020. https://www.mpp.org/is-
cannabis/history.html. 29. Ark. Const. amend. XCVIII, §§ 3, 6. Accessed September 13, 2020. sues/medical-marijuana/state-by-state-medical-marijuana-laws/med-
2. California Proposition 215, the Medical Marijuana Initiative. Ballotpe- https://static.ark.org/eeuploads/arml/Arkansas_Medical_Marijuana_ ical-marijuana-patient-numbers/ ❒
Amendment_of_2016.pdf
Posttest, credit request forms, and activity evaluations must be completed online at https://education.gotoper.com/activity/
CME POST-TEST
ptcme20oct (requires free account activation), and participants can print their certificate or statement of credit immediately. This web-
site supports all browsers. For PER’s privacy policy, please visit https://www.gotoper.com/privacy.
PLEASE NOTE THAT THE POSTTEST IS AVAILABLE ONLINE ONLY ON THE 20TH OF THE MONTH OF ACTIVITY ISSUE AND FOR 18 MONTHS AFTER.
— wORKING WITH cENTURION — The Department of Psychiatry is a national leader in public sector psychiatry,
child and adolescent psychiatry, neuropsychiatry, biological psychiatry, psycho-
social rehabilitation, women’s mental health, and addiction psychiatry. We integrate
Centurion is a leading provider of comprehensive our clinical, research, teaching and community partnership activities to help in-
healthcare services to correctional facilities nationwide. dividuals and families transform their lives through recovery from mental illness
We are dedicated to changing lives in the community, and addiction. We are particularly interested in having Faculty join our Department
one patient at a time. who are motivated for a career in clinical research. We are the largest provider of
psychiatric services in central Massachusetts, with over 400 faculty members and
12 hospitals and community mental health centers.
Our residency program trains 7 residents per year, including general psychiatry
and specialty tracks for combined adult and child psychiatry and combined neu-
rology. We offer fellowships in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Addiction
Psychiatry, Forensic Psychiatry, Neuropsychiatry, and Adult Developmental Dis-
abilities. Interested candidates should send their curriculum vitae addressed to Dr.
Sheldon Benjamin.
California
Psychiatrist Needed
PSYCHIATRISTS
For clinical staff and leadership positions
California Correctional Facilities $275 - $325 Plus/hr. The State of New Jersey’s Division of Behavioral Health
Department of the State Hospitals $280 - $290/hr. Services is seeking motivated Psychiatrists for full-time
inpatient work in our Joint Commission accredited State
$300/hour - group rate psychiatric hospitals and forensic center. Psychiatrists
with management experience are also needed to
LA-DMH & LA County Jail $185 – $265/hr. serve as Chiefs of Psychiatry.
Post Certified - $255,541 (3+ years post certification)
Tulare County Adult Jail $200/hr. Board Certified - $237,617
Board Eligible - $224,080 ★
Tele-Psychiatry $180-$220/hr. • Facilities are in close proximity to metropolitan
centers of New York City and Philadelphia/N.J. Shore
• Psychiatrists work with a multidisciplinary team ★
New York
• Primary care physicians provide for patient’s physical
health care
★
• University affiliations/opportunities to work with forensic
fellows and psychiatry residents
Psychiatrist Needed • On-site CME activities and paid CME leave time
599.786.5228 / 599.791.0932
H Greystone Park Psychiatric Hospital
Program. Additional information provided Morristown, NJ (Northern NJ)
H Trenton Psychiatric Hospital
upon request. Trenton, NJ (Central NJ)
Fax: 888.712.2412
H Ann Klein Forensic Center
Trenton, NJ (Central NJ)
Interested candidates should send a cover letter H Special Treatment Unit
and detailed resume to: Avenel, NJ (Northern NJ)
H Ancora Psychiatric Hospital
Email: imperiallocum@imperiallocum.com MEMBER OF
Evan Feibusch, M.D. | Medical Director, DBHS Hammonton, NJ (Southern NJ)
Evan.Feibusch@doh.nj.gov | 609.913.5316
National Association of
Visit: www.imperiallocum.com Physician Recruiters The State of New Jersey is an Equal Opportunity Employer
Geriatric Psychiatrist
Cambridge Health Alliance (CHA) Psychiatrist Opportunities
Cambridge Health Alliance, a well-respected, nationally recognized and in New York City
award-winning public healthcare system is seeking part-time or full-time
For many, the draw of psychiatry is flexibility and creativity. Full-time or
Geriatric Psychiatrists. Our system is comprised of three hospital part-time in variety of settings. Inpatient, outpatient, ER — or embedded in
campuses and an integrated network of both primary and specialty a medical surgical service. Psychiatrists have many choices depending on
what they love.
outpatient care practices in Cambridge, Somerville and Boston’s Metro
In this Psychiatric Times® podcast, Maryann Popiel, MD, discusses
North Region. how developments in mental health and an evolving public perception of
psychiatry have influenced her practice in an urban community such as the
• Ideal opportunity for candidates passionate about working with older Bronx, and describes career opportunities and a potential career path for
adults. psychiatrists in Greater New York City, in the beautiful Bronx!
• Provide psychiatric care serving the local community and provide high
quality care to our underserved and diverse patient population. Go to:
www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/discovering-psychiatry
• Fully integrated electronic medical record (EPIC) is utilize.
• CHA is a teaching affiliate of Harvard Medical School and academic
appointments are available commensurate with medical school criteria.
• Offers competitive compensation and a comprehensive benefits
package including health and dental insurance, 403b retirement
accounts with matching, generous PTO, CME allotment (time and
dollars) and much more.
Ideal candidates will be BE or BC in psychiatry, possess excellent clinical/
communication skills, and have a strong commitment to and passion for
our multicultural, underserved patient population.
CVs may be sent directly to Melissa Kelley, CHA Provider Recruiter via
email at providerrecruitment@challiance.org.
We are an equal opportunity employer and all qualified applicants will receive consideration for
employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national
origin, disability status, protected veteran status, or any other characteristic protected by law.
Take the first step in joining one of our teams and contact LaTreese Phillips at
INPATIENT · OUTPATIENT (916) 691-4818 or CentralizedHiringUnit@cdcr.ca.gov. You may also apply
online at www.cchcs.ca.gov.
Effective July 1, 2020, in response to the economic crisis caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the Personal
Leave Program 2020 (PLP 2020) was implemented. PLP 2020 requires that each full-time employee receive
a 9.23 percent reduction in pay in exchange for 16 hours PLP 2020 leave credits monthly through June 2022.
Log on to health insurance; up to three retirement and Los Angeles/Orange County Area
pension programs; 35 days of vacation and Sacramento Area
CME time that increase with tenure. Signing Comprehensive Psychiatric Services
you promote
• Liaison with social service agencies,
www.telecarecorp.com/physician-jobs/ hospitals, pharmaceutical companies around
You will work as part of a multidisciplinary customer care, referrals, and medication
team. The staff is all very friendly and it is a
supportive working environment.
physician products information/management.
• Works collaboratively with all TCM team CALL TODAY
and services. members to address areas of mutual concern,
Please email your resume to
Psorecruiting@telecarecorp.com
crisis management and service delivery of
participants.
(609) 495-4367
EOE M/F/V/Disability Please apply at
www.mentalhealthpartnerships.org
Department of Psychiatry
With the continued growth of our Department of Psychiatry and our New General Psychiatry Residency Programs
at Ocean Medical Center and Jersey Shore University Medical Center our vision for Behavioral Health is Bright.
Hackensack Meridian Health is a leading not-for-profit health care network in New Jersey offering a complete range of medical
services, innovative research, and lifeenhancing care aiming to serve as a national model for changing and simplifying health care
delivery through partnerships with innovative companies and focusing on quality and safety.
Through a partnership between Hackensack Meridian Health and Seton Hall University, the School of Medicine will re-define
graduate medical education, research, and clinical practice; reverse the critical physician shortage in both the New York/New Jersey
metropolitan area and the nation; and stimulate economic development in northern New Jersey.
The School of Medicine will be the anchor in the development of a comprehensive health sciences campus that will also include
research facilities and biotechnology endeavors – all in service of educating tomorrow’s doctors, discovering novel therapies, and
facilitating compassionate and effective healthcare that will meet the ever-changing needs of tomorrow’s patients.
The School of Medicine will be the cornerstone of a dynamic venue for the exchange of ideas, the development of healthcare and
research thought leaders and practitioners, and the discovery of novel therapies to meet the medical challenges of the future.
“Ocean Medical Center’s psychiatry program will be a community-based program,’’ said Ramon Solhkhah, M.D., program director for
psychiatry as well as founding Chair of Psychiatry & Behavioral Health at the Hackensack Meridian School of Medicine at Seton Hall
University. “Our new psychiatry residency program will improve clinical care and ultimately encourage future health care leaders
to build practices in the Jersey Shore area,’’
As the area’s premier provider of psychiatric services, Hackensack Meridian Behavioral Health Services has provided comprehensive
mental health and substance abuse services to the residents of Monmouth, Ocean, Middlesex, and Bergen Counties for over forty years.
Due to continued growth and expansion, we are currently accepting applications for Psychiatrists to join our Mental Health and Addic-
tion Interdisciplinary Teams in the following positions:
• Carrier Clinic -Inpatient Attending- Child/Adolescent and Adult/Geriatric–Carrier Clinic (Belle Mead, NJ)
Carrier Clinic – Inpatient- PT House Physician (weekends)
On-Call Weekend Rounding Physician
• Child & Adolescent Section Chief – Includes Pediatric CL: Jersey Shore University Medical Center, (Neptune, NJ)
• Consultation Liaison Psychiatrists: Hackensack University Medical Center (Hackensack, NJ), JFK Medical
Center (Edison, NJ), Ocean Medical Center (Brick, NJ), Jersey Shore University Medical Center (Neptune, NJ)
• Outpatient: Ocean Medical Center (Brick, NJ)
• Staff Psychiatrist for Adult Inpatient Unit: Riverview Medical Center (Red Bank, NJ) and Hackensack Univer-
sity Medical Center (Hackensack, NJ)
• Outpatient Child& Adolescent Psychiatrist: Hackensack University Medical Center (Hackensack, NJ)
• Geriatric Psychiatry: Hackensack University Medical Center (Hackensack, NJ)
• ED/Crisis Unit: Jersey Shore University Medical Center (Neptune, NJ)
Choose INGREZZA
for results you can see1
INGREZZA® (valbenazine) capsules reduced TD severity at 6 weeks,
with results you can start to see as early as 2 weeks¹-³
Important Information
INDICATION & USAGE
INGREZZA® (valbenazine) capsules is indicated for the treatment of adults with tardive dyskinesia.
REFERENCES: 1. INGREZZA [package insert]. San Diego, CA: Neurocrine Biosciences, Inc;
2020. 2. Hauser RA, Factor SA, Marder SR, et al. KINECT 3: a phase 3 randomized, double-
blind, placebo-controlled trial of valbenazine for tardive dyskinesia. Am J Psychiatry.
©2020 Neurocrine Biosciences, Inc. All Rights Reserved. CP-VBZ-US-1040v2 02/2020 2017;174(5):476-484. 3. Data on file. Neurocrine Biosciences, Inc.
$ 50
It pays to Gift C
ard
Get a gift card*
learn more
about
4000
1234
5678
9010
Zocdoc
Dr. Liz
Blackw
ell
*Limit one (1) Visa Gift Card per practice. The terms of Visa’s Cardholder Agreement apply. Demo must be completed by a person authorized to make a
purchase decision on behalf of the practice. Offer not valid for practices with prior or existing Zocdoc accounts. Visa Gift Card will be sent upon completion
of the demo; please allow 2-3 weeks for delivery. Promotion not valid where prohibited by law.
Reach more new patients
in need of a mental health
provider.
Millions of patients visit Zocdoc’s website and mobile
app every month to search for a local provider based
on open appointment times and more. Take a free
demo today.
Visit Zocdoc.com/about/Visa50
or call 1-888-655-2190
How its
work
Reach new patients Zocdoc Fill last-minute openings 48% of See patients anywhere Video
attracts millions of users actively appointments occur within 72 visits represent over 25% of new
looking for care. hours of booking patient bookings on Zocdoc.