Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Hafta

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Technology in Society
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/techsoc

The impact of digital transformation and digital marketing on the brand


promotion, positioning and electronic business in Montenegro
Boban Melović a, Mijat Jocović a, Marina Dabić b, c, *, Tamara Backović Vulić a, Branislav Dudic d, e
a
Faculty of Economics Podgorica, University of Montenegro, Podgorica, Jovana Tomaševića, 37, 81000, Montenegro
b
Department of International Economics, Faculty of Economics and Business, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia
c
Department of Management, Nottingham Trent University, Nottingham Business School, Nottingham, UK
d
Faculty of Economics and Engineering Management, University Business Academy, Novi Sad, Serbia
e
Faculty of Management, Comenius University in Bratislava, Bratislava, Odbojarov 10, 82005, Slovakia

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: The paper assesses the ways in which digital transformation in Montenegro influences the use of digital mar­
Digital transformation keting in business, determining the impact of this concept on promotion and brand positioning, i.e. electronic
Digital marketing business development through electronic services. This facilitates the integrated analysis of the context of
Electronic services
electronic business, thus providing innovative and value-creating insights for Montenegro – a transition country.
Brand
This research was conducted using a survey on a stratified random sample and the data was subsequently
Electronic business
Montengero analyzed using the Structural Equation Model (SEM), Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) test, and eta-coefficient.
Multivariate analysis was applied to data obtained from 172 companies. The results showed that a number of
factors determine the ways in which companies apply digital marketing and use differing levels of influence,
amongst which the period of implementation, the abilities of people in charge for its usage, perception of digital
marketing cost-effectiveness, measurability of its effects and sufficiency of traditional marketing have a key role.
The period in which digital marketing is used was especially significant and notably affects the choice of digital
marketing instruments, the way its performances are measured and the managers’ perception of its cost-
effectiveness. Social networks were the most commonly used form of digital marketing in the market under
analysis, and Google analytics was the most common way to measure the effects of digital marketing.
Furthermore, the results showed that the more a company relies on the use of digital marketing in its business,
the more significant its impact on promotion and brand positioning.

1. Introduction demonstrated that the best companies go beyond routine processes and
digitalize their capabilities in order to distinguish themselves from their
The development and widespread use of technology [1] and Internet competitors.
technologies have transformed the way society communicates, both in Globalization and the increased usage of the Internet are two
daily and professional life [2,3]. The same applies to the business of important motivations behind the transition from a traditional market­
companies operating in modern (digital) conditions [4]. The Internet ing approach to a digital one. Digital transformation constitutes an
has become a key component – or, one could say, a strategic weapon [5] evolutionary process, changing our ways of life and the ways in which
– in that it represents one of the most significant technologies of the we do business through digital technologies; primarily through the
twentieth century [6,7]. On the other hand, in rapidly evolving business implementation of new technological solutions based on Internet ser­
environments, precise analysis and accurate planning can be key to the vices and modern information technologies [12]. Digital transformation
selection of the “right” strategies for IT investment and the imple­ refers to “the process of using digital technologies to create new—or modify
mentation of any new technologies [8]. Ross, Weill, and Robertson [9]; existing—business processes, culture, and customer experiences to meet
Ritter and Pedersen [10]; and Pearce and Pearce [11] have changing business and market requirements” (Sales force 2019 in Ref. [13].

* Corresponding author. Department of International Economics, Faculty of Economics and Business, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia.
E-mail addresses: bobanm@ucg.ac.me (B. Melović), mijatj@ucg.ac.me (M. Jocović), marina.dabic@ntu.ac.uk, mdabic@efzg.hr (M. Dabić), tassabacc@ucg.ac.me
(T.B. Vulić), branislav.dudic@fm.uniba.sk (B. Dudic).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2020.101425
Received 4 September 2020; Received in revised form 28 September 2020; Accepted 5 October 2020
Available online 6 October 2020
0160-791X/© 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

Although digital transformation cannot bridge the economic and more active participants than ever when it comes to decision-making
social gap, its implementation may accelerate its reduction. This is processes regarding their needs for products and services. When it
therefore a great opportunity for less developed countries [14] such as comes to increasing customer numbers, the advantage of the Internet as
Montenegro. When it comes to using digital forms of communication, a communication medium likewise lies in the fact that it allows us to
such as the Internet, social networks, and mobile phone services, target the conveyed information towards a specific audience segment
Montenegro does not lag behind other countries [15], however its use of [24]. Additionally, one of the most important benefits of digital
digital technologies in other areas is often insufficient, especially with communication is the ability to support feedback, interactivity, and
regards to companies. 74% of the total population in Montenegro have responses - a factor that provides vital information on customers and can
Internet access, creating more opportunities for the application of digital be used to fine-tune communications.
marketing. In order to strengthen this as much as possible, action has While a significant number of papers have analyzed the role of digital
already been taken regarding the development of a digital trans­ marketing in modern business, no similar research has thus far been
formation strategy for the period 2021–2025 [16]. Further development conducted in Montenegro - a country in transition. A review of existing
of digitalization depends on various elements: the availability and academic literature, especially when it comes to less developed coun­
accessibility of telecommunication infrastructures; existing legal tries, found that there is a gap between the impact of digital marketing
frameworks; the development and availability of state administration and the company’s brand positioning in the minds of its consumers, as
services, local governments, banks, and other financial institutions; well as their connection with the development of electronic business.
changes in the education system and the education of citizens; and the There is a lack of research studies examining the analysis of influential
development of the Information Technologies (IT) sector in Montenegro. factors, such as the type of activity, the size of the company, the bearers
In recent years, significant progress has been made in each of these areas of marketing activities, etc., on the use of digital marketing. The authors
[17]. A particularly important segment of digital transformation is, have tried to fill these gaps. Furthermore, this research focuses on a
therefore, the digital economy, because the digitalization of companies transitioning economy, contributing to the relative gap in research
increases their efficiency, productivity, and profit. In this sense, the assessing the impact of digital marketing, brands, and electronic busi­
process of digital (r)evolution of Montenegro is inevitable, which is why ness which, in the authors’ opinions, validate this work through integral
the issue of digital marketing is becoming increasingly important. multi-context analysis. More precisely, considering research in other
Considering the aforementioned information, it is clear that there are countries [25–28], this study tests the impact of the identified key fac­
many benefits when it comes to conducting a survey in a transition tors that affect the implementation of digital marketing in the context of
economy such as the one in this study. The percentage of the population a transition economy. Additionally, it measures the influence of the
in Montenegro that have Internet access and regularly use it on a daily application of digital marketing on brand perception, again in the
basis is above the world’s average, while the percentage of mobile context of a less developed transition country, in which domestic com­
connections is equivalent to 191% of the total population [18]. These panies often lack experience with regards to using Internet technologies
results clearly suggest that potential consumers in Montenegro are easily to attract and strengthen customer bonds [22,29,30]. Finally, it places
accessible via the Internet and that digital marketing implementation the implementation of digital marketing in a broader context by estab­
could be a very effective way of targeting a large number of people lishing links between acquiring knowledge about the effects of digital
within the Montenegrin population. Additionally, digital transformation marketing and the development of e-business as a positive consequence
has been recognized as a necessary process through which global for both companies and end users [31–34].
modern trends of doing business and strengthening competitiveness can Alongside its theoretical implications, the paper offers significant
be achieved [16]. However, the use of digital technologies by domestic practical implications. It identifies the organizational factors that have a
companies lags behind, especially when compared to developed coun­ significant role in the implementation of digital marketing and dem­
tries [15]. Therefore, the analysis of factors that affect these levels, as onstrates the ways in which these factors affect the level of application.
well as methods of application, when it comes to digital marketing are of Additionally, this paper provides insights into the different ways in
great importance. However, to the authors’ best knowledge, no previous which digital marketing is applied, the instruments that are chosen, and
research on this topic exists in the context of Montenegro. Additionally, the means used to measure its effectiveness depending on the period of
the high degrees of Internet usage by the population suggests that the time. In this way, it shows how the experiences and perceptions of
insufficient implementation of digital marketing is mostly affected by managers change over time and condition the ways in which digital
organizational and institutional factors, which makes Montenegro a marketing is understood, applied, and measured. Finally, in analyzing
suitable transition country in which to investigate these phenomena. the measures used to estimate digital marketing performance, it pro­
Piccinini et al. [19] demonstrated that technologies are essentially vides insights into how the digital performance and needs of organiza­
shifting the producer– consumer relationship. The significance of digital tions change over time as a consequence of previous digital marketing
(online) marketing is currently increasing and, as such, we can observe results and managerial experience.
changes in the ways people communicate [20,21] as well as the ways in This paper is organized into six sections. Following the introduction,
which companies communicate with their customers. The last several in the second section, a review of the results of previous research
years have also seen a dramatic increase in the amount of time and regarding digital marketing is provided, as well as a literature review in
money consumers spend online [20]. In such modern business condi­ which the motivations behind this research are outlined. This section
tions, which are characterized by strong competition and highly sensi­ contains an analysis of the key aspects of digital marketing, which are
tive customers, digital marketing has become increasingly important. viewed in the context of the topic being addressed. The third section
Through digital marketing and media, consumers can access informa­ provides a conceptual framework, including a conceptual model and
tion at any time and in any place [22]. Thanks to the aforementioned hypothesis development. The next section refers to materials and
processes, which are not static, digital marketing has been gaining more methods. This section also includes a description of the research meth­
and more importance [23]. It is evident that its development and its use odology, i.e. data collection and simple, measures, and instrument
provide numerous benefits for companies, such as greater market pres­ validation. The fifth section presents the results of the research and
ence, cost reductions, measurability of results, personalization, open­ discussions of the results. Finally, the paper finishes with concluding
ness, and better communication. Understanding the Internet’s impact remarks, a review of the implications, an elaboration of the research
and its potential impact on major aspects of business can result in better constraints, and recommendations for future studies in this area.
marketing programs and sustainable marketing strategies [20]. On the
other hand, consumers, as the main objects towards which marketing
strategies are directed, face facilitated interaction, which makes them

2
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

2. Theoretical frameworks on digital transformation and digital has become associated with electronic communications more widely
marketing [43]. There are many elements of digitalization that companies use in
their business, from mobile marketing optimization of the site, to email
The concepts of digital transformation and digital marketing are marketing, banners, blogs etc. Some researchers claim that the greatest
interlinked in many ways. Both assess the ways in which the sector uses potential for companies or their brands in terms of approaching con­
Information Technologies (IT) to develop the delivery of a service, alter sumers is to have social networks [44–46]. Each of these forms, which
organizational processes, make changes to organizational culture, and are an integral part of digitalization and e-business, have multiple ad­
impact upon value creation. Mergel et al. [35]; p.2) stated that two of vantages, but social media is particularly important with regards to the
the most foundational theoretical works framing the research are topic analyzed in this paper. The correlations between social networks
Fountain’s technology enactment framework and Dunleavy et al.’s Digital and electronic business are the specific subject or analysis of this
Era Governance approach. Fountain’s [36] approach assesses the effect of research. This is due to the fact that the primary advantages of social
technologies on companies from an institutional perspective standpoint, media marketing are reducing costs and enhancing reach [22] by
differentiating between objective and enacted technologies. Objective engaging with a larger number of customers, thus contributing to
technology includes developments such as the Internet and enacted business development. The cost related to social media platforms are
technology pertains to the use, creation, and perceptions related to these typically lower than other marketing platforms, such as face-to-face
technologies in the minds of those working within the company. The use sales or sales with the help of middlemen or distributors. Generally,
and perceptions of technology are restricted by institutional arrange­ the main advantage of social media is that it can enable companies to
ments, however enacted technology can also impact upon an organiza­ increase reach and reduce costs [47–49]. Through social networks, the
tion. Technology’s role thus differs and is reliant on the particular company can increase product and brand awareness, increase web
company and what those working within the organization believe. traffic, increase customer loyalty, and increase the success of new
“Digital Era Governance”, by Dunleavy, Margaretts, Bastow, and Tinkler product launches [50]. There is no doubt that digital marketing has a
[37]; is another framework assessing organizational change enabled by significant role - i.e. influence - in the branding of companies as it is a
technology. This research focuses on organizational change, organiza­ powerful tool through which businesses can be promoted and with
tional culture, and the new ways in which society deals with information which their visibility and market image can be strengthened. In this
and with contemporary demands for government services. way, digital marketing encompasses an extensive range of services and
The era of digitalization (which arose as a consequence of the swift product and brand marketing tactics, which mainly use the Internet as a
development of IT capabilities) affects every aspect of society. It requires core promotional medium [22].
speedy adaptation in line with social and economic changes and presents Growth in digital marketing has been largely due to rapid advances
additional challenges with regards to the ways in which companies run in technology and changing market dynamics [51]. Accordingly, in the
their business [34,38]. As such, new business models are required in developed world, many companies have recognized the importance of
order to produce and attain a competitive advantage. The original focus digital marketing. In order for businesses to be successful, they must
on internal resources has now shifted towards the acquisition of external merge online and traditional methods to better meet the needs of cus­
resources through cooperation with numerous independent subjects. tomers [52]. This suggests a need for a stronger application of digital
Therefore, the era of digitalization represents a shift from tangible to marketing in markets in which it is not strongly developed. This is due to
intangible resources, championing creativity, cooperation, and intel­ the fact that online service tools are more influential than traditional
lectual capital as the basis for the creation of a successful business model methods of communication [53]. Unlike traditional marketing, which
[31–33]. External changes necessitate the development of new man­ involves a one-way dissemination of information, the use of the Internet
agement strategies focused on the formulation and development of allows for two-way communication, posing different ethical and privacy
cooperation with other companies, demonstrating the importance of considerations for marketers [54]. The introduction of new technologies
creating and maintaining trusting relationships between numerous has created new business opportunities for marketers to use when
stakeholders [31,39]. Efficient communication with stakeholders thus managing their websites and achieving their business objectives [55]. In
underpins this competitive advantage, highlighting the importance of this way, digital (Internet) advertising is a powerful marketing tool
digital marketing and the benefits it offers. when it comes to building brands and increasing traffic, facilitating
Digital marketing is widely used to promote products or services and success [56] and ensuring customer loyalty.
reach consumers through digital channels [22,40]. In terms of concep­ The importance of digital marketing is especially evident with
tual determination, it may be argued that digital marketing is the use of regards to customer loyalty and cost-effectiveness. In recent times, the
technologies when it comes to assisting marketing activities and development of information technology and the knowledge economy
improving customer knowledge by matching their needs [41]. The have made customer loyalty a central issue for marketing scholars [20].
Digital Marketing Institute defines digital marketing as “the use of digital On the other hand, digital marketing is cost effective and has a great
technologies to create an integrated, targeted and measurable communication commercial impact on the business. It can create closer and yet more
which helps to acquire and retain customers while building deeper relation­ cost-effective relationships with customers in sales, marketing, and
ships with them” [42]. The main advantage of digital marketing is that a customer support [55,57]. This is extremely important considering to­
targeted audience can be reached in a cost-effective and measurable day’s challenges and the ways in which increasing competition forces
way. Additionally, some key advantages to digital marketing include companies to cut budgets and be more creative in terms of customer
increasing brand loyalty and driving online sales. In this context, one orientation. Digital marketing allows marketers to be cost effective and
recent study investigated the trend of using digital marketing tools and offers a new mode of interaction with consumers [58]. The consumer
the impact level of digital marketing tools in generating brand aware­ enters the market to satisfy his economic wants [20], tending to behave
ness in companies [2]. It is therefore important to point out that other rationally. Contrary to the early image, which suggested that the
concepts related to digital marketing include Internet/online marketing Internet was a place for bargain hunting, the Internet has become more
and electronic marketing (i.e., e-marketing). Although these concepts frequently viewed as a place to seek/provide a superior service [59] and
are often used synonymously with digital marketing, some distinctions enhance consumer relationships [60]. Additionally, meeting and satis­
can be made [42]. Studies show that the term Internet/online marketing fying customer needs has become much more difficult as customer de­
refers only to one technology (i.e., the Internet), whereas digital mar­ mands have increased [61]. Digital methods of communication support
keting includes an array of other technologies, including SMSs, MMSs, a process known as “intelligent marketing”, in which content is refined
mobile applications, and databases that can be used without an Internet in line with campaign responses and feedback [62]. This helps com­
connection. E-marketing is a similar concept to digital marketing, but it panies to make better use of their budgets and increase the positioning of

3
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

their brand in the consciousness of consumers. In addition to this, digital constantly rising since its users can connect, share, and interact among
marketing allows companies to reach customers that may not be themselves [86].
accessible due to the temporal and locational limitations of existing
distribution channels [48]. Many companies have started using digital 2.1. Business development through electronic services
marketing tools efficiently in the process of “creating brand awareness”,
which is considered the first and one of the most important steps of Many companies have built innovative, interactive, and digitized
marketing [2]. All companies and organizations need to be more nimble platforms in which customers conveniently obtain product information
and more responsive. It is vital that they are more reactive to ideas and and communicate in real-time with companies and other consumers
customer input than they have been in the past [20]. All must be pre­ [87]. As such, electronic services influence business development. In this
pared to test out new business ideas, not just for the sake of innovation, way, companies may receive timely feedback suggestions from users,
but in order to survive [63]. With this in mind, digital marketing creating greater brand value and a competitive advantage for companies
governance refers to the overall management of resources for digital [88]. Consumers may get information about products through in­
marketing within an organization. This includes both internal and teractions [89] that could benefit those who have created a strong and
external staff resources, financial resources, and infrastructures, such as sustainable connection with their preferred brands [90]. Cader and Al
software tools and data sources [64]. Tenaiji [79] demonstrate that companies must strive for a complete view
The idea of market promotion has also been changed by the devel­ of their customers as the relationship shifts from commerce to collabo­
opment of the Internet and digitalization. It has moved customers from ration, which also contributes to better brand positioning. In accordance
magazines, daily papers and, in a few cases, TV and radio to the Internet with this, developing strong relationships with customers is the main
[65]. All of these developments have enabled the use of digital objective of marketing programs [91]. Customer relations are improved
communication tools for marketing purposes [2]. The reason behind this using social media, which reflects positively on the development of
is that, in contrast with traditional communication tools, digital e-business. Just as the use of digital and social media is changing how
communication tools have become popular global marketing channels people live, learn, and connect with one another [92–94], fundamental
with which companies can communicate with target groups directly, shifts are also taking place within businesses that take advantage of
quickly, and continuously. social media [95]. This necessitates adjusted business strategies. Those
With digital media, it is possible to improve the presentation of in business realize the importance of this and are adopting strategies and
product information, replacing single static images with interactive tools to engage with social media [96]. In this context, Alalwan explains
models that allow users to manipulate the product just as they would in that the customers who find social media advertising beneficial are more
real life [60]. Over the last decade (and, presumably, over the next likely to be willing to purchase targeted products [97]. Additionally, a
decade), in order to survive in a competitive business world and satisfy key part of effective customer relations is delivering pertinent infor­
customer needs and wants, proper messages and good communication mation at the correct time and forming a personalized connection with
are both integral to the promotion and better positioning of a brand customers (Peppers & Rogers, 2017). Used correctly, such personalized
[66]. Digital marketing tools are actually overtaking traditional mar­ offers can deliver five to eight times the return on investment on mar­
keting tools and becoming more important as they allow consumers and keting expenditure and increase sales by more than 10% [95].
producers to interact with the marketing process [67]. Investments in Existing research shows that digital and web experiences affect the
digital marketing are motivated by the fact that results are more easily mental processes of consumers and enhance their online buying de­
measurable in comparison with those of traditional marketing [68]. As cisions [98]. In this way, the Internet is the most powerful tool for
customers increasingly interact with companies through digital chan­ businesses [99]. Marketing managers who fail to exploit this in their
nels, organizations have recognized the benefits of tracking these in­ business marketing strategies may become disadvantaged by not
teractions and measuring their performance [69]. Digitalization has adopting changing approaches to brand, pricing, distribution, and pro­
resulted in major changes to customer behavior and communication motions [55].
patterns [70,71]. These changes have encouraged companies to alter Despite the numerous advantages of digital marketing, few studies
their strategies and tactics [72,73] and have provided new opportunities investigate the strategic application of digital marketing in developing
for collecting data on customer behavior, measuring marketing perfor­ countries and transition economies. Existing research mostly focuses on
mance through the use of digital analytics [74,75]. Various marketing developed countries and mainly looks at individual aspects of digital
studies have shown that the use of marketing performance measurement marketing. In conducting preliminary research, the authors discovered
data when making marketing decisions results in positive performance that there was a significant deficit in studies integrating different aspects
implications [76–78]. of the digital marketing analysis. Digital technologies influence eco­
Digital marketing and media means better value for customers since nomic processes and societal development and thus strongly affect the
companies can send personalized communications and special offers business of companies. Meanwhile, the implementation of new tech­
that are tailored to customers’ individual preferences [79]. Companies nological solutions based on Internet services and modern information
increasingly bring brands closer to consumers’ everyday life and the technologies can revolutionize both business practice and day-to-day
customer’s role as coproducer of value is becoming increasingly life [12]. Digital transformation cannot bridge economic and social di­
important [80]. Social media plays a particularly important role in this vision, but it may reduce it. It therefore represents a significant oppor­
process, as these are valuable forums through which customers can tunity for less developed countries [14] such as Montenegro. By
directly contact brands to exchange experiences [29,81]. Consumers use exploring the links between influential factors of digital transformation,
social media to generate information with their friends, companies, and the impact of digital marketing on promotion and brand positioning,
broader online communities via posts, tweets, shares, likes, and reviews and the correlation of digital marketing and e-business development,
[82,83]. Social media marketing is used across sectors and refers to “the this paper fills a notable gap in existing scholarly literature.
utilization of social media technologies, channels, and software to
create, communicate, deliver, and exchange offerings that have value 3. Hypothesis development and conceptual model
for an organization’s stakeholders” [84]. Hence, promoting now has a
computerized structure [65]. In a systematic review of the surrounding Taking into account the recognized gap in the literature, as well as
literature, it is evident that social media has been widely adopted for the stated motives for this research, the authors created a conceptual
marketing [85]. Social media is now everywhere and has taken on model based on three hypotheses.
greater importance over the past five years. At its core, social media is a Montenegro is a 14,026 sq. meter transition country situated in
communications and networking tool whose popularity has been South Eastern Europe and the Balkans. According to Internet World

4
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

Statistics [100]; 628,000 people live in Montenegro, approximately 449, factors have a significant level of influence on the use of digital marketing
989 of whom accessed the Internet in December 2019. This equates to (H1). Key factors were identified: business activity, the size of the
71% of the population, as stated by Internet World Statistics [100]. company, the period of digital marketing implementation, forms of
Comparatively, 87.7% of the European population have internet access, digital marketing, the people in charge of its application, the measur­
comprising 16% of global internet use. The world average is 58.8%. In ability of effects, methods of measurement, cost-effectiveness, the
terms of social media, Montenegro had 381,800 Facebook users in application of traditional marketing, and brand perception.
January 2020, which is a 67% penetration rate. Digital marketing can, Previous academic literature suggests that one of the main roles of
therefore, contribute to the improvement of companies’ operations from digital marketing should be strengthening brand awareness and loyalty
both an operational and economic standpoint [2,20,22,41]. A wide among customers [2,6,20,29]. However, most of these studies are
range of business performances are affected by digital marketing [2,65], related to developed countries and there are insufficient studies on the
but there is a lack of research on what factors determine the use of digital impact of digital marketing on promotion and brand positioning among
marketing. Due to a lack of research on this topic, particularly in transition economies. Hence, the second hypothesis refers to the ex­
Montenegro, the authors have consulted previous research conducted in amination of relationships between the aforementioned categories. In
other countries in order to identify key factors that might have a sig­ accordance with the above, using the identified factors and the results of
nificant influence on the application of digital marketing application in prior research (Table 1), the second hypothesis is that digital marketing
transition countries. Some of these are presented below in Table 1. has a positive influence on brand promotion which correlates with brand
However, although previous research has identified the key factors positioning (H2). Additionally, based on previous research that has
affecting the implementation of digital marketing, these results do not determining that the Internet is the most powerful tool for businesses
measure its relative importance, which is another aim of this paper. [68,69,99], the authors sought to examine how increased use of digital
Therefore, considering previous research (especially the research of marketing contributes to the development of electronic business and
[25–27]; and [28] the authors established the first hypothesis: identified stronger company competitiveness. The research of Caputo et al. [33]
suggested that the development of managerial digital knowledge and
interactions with multiple partners were prerequisites for e-business
Table 1
development and the digital transformation of the national economy.
An overview of research undergrounding the hypotheses development and the
These results were also confirmed by Švarc et al. [31]; who also
conceptual model.
emphasized the overall importance of human, social, structural, and
References Sample Methodology Object of research
institutional factors. These findings were also supported by Garzella
[26] 17 marketing Thematic Identification of key et al. [32] and Caputo et al. [101]. There is, however, lack of research on
executives of large analysis factors that affect the this topic in transition countries; especially in Montenegro. This moti­
companies in Brasil adoption of different
vated the third hypothesis, which is that digital marketing positively cor­
forms of digital
marketing, especially relates with the development of e-business (H3).
social media The conceptual model, based on these hypotheses, is presented in
[27] 250 small business Structural The application of Fig. 1 given below.
owners/managers equation digital marketing using
In order to obtain objective answers to these hypotheses, a multi­
modeling internal resources and
DIY model of behavior
variate analysis was applied to the survey data.
[25] 26 managers of small Thematic data Critical success factors
and medium business analysis influencing the 4. Materials and methods
adoption of digital
marketing devices
[28] 5000 B2B Bivariate Factors that determine
The authors developed a questionnaire based on the motives and
organizations from UK correlation social media adoption goals of the research, the defined hypotheses, the results of previously
analysis by B2B organizations published research on digital marketing and e-business, and assessments
[30] 256 companies from Structural The impact of of theoretical models. The questionnaire was prepared in both Mon­
Mexico equation innovation on digital
tenegrin and English and, with the cooperation of the Chamber of
modeling marketing adoption
[2] 10 marketing and Delphi The impact of digital Commerce, it was forwarded to 250 corporate e-mail addresses in
corporate technique marketing on brand Montenegro. The 250 targeted companies were selected based on their
communications awareness generation years of existence. It was expected that new companies and their man­
specialists agers would use some form of digital marketing. This, however, was not
[22] A sample of 1050 Correlation The importance and
companies analysis effectiveness of digital
always the case for companies that had been in the market for a longer
marketing period of time. Thus, the sample only consisted of companies that had
[29] A survey of 708 South Confirmatory Factors driving been in business for at least ten years. This form of selection sought to
Korean and Chinese factor analysis consumers’ social investigate whether or not these companies had adjusted to modern
consumers media brand
trends and used the disposable resources and possibilities of the digital
experience and its
effect on customer era in order to strengthen their brand and advance its existing recog­
equity nizability. This ensured the best possible representativeness of our
[110] A sample of 70 Correlation and The effects of digital sample, which included companies from all three regions (the North, the
respondents engaged regression marketing on Centre, and the South). In terms of geographical spread, the de­
in digital marketing analysis perceived brand
quality, brand
mographic of the respondents was 48% from the central region; 28%
awareness and brand from the southern region; and 24% from the northern region. Therefore,
loyalty the sample provided a relatively balanced representation of companies
[111] A study of top 10 Multivariate The effects of firm’s from across the whole country, which led to a stratified random sample.
Romanian companies analysis online presence on
The survey was undertaken in the second quarter of 2020 and lasted 30
brand equity
[65] Indices of digital Feasible The relationship days. Respondents returned 172 fully-completed polls, giving an answer
transformation for a generalized least between digital rate of 68.80%. The poll consisted of three set of questions. The first set
group of developing squares method transformation and of questions was related to basic information about the company: years
countries economic of operation, the business field in which it operates, and the number of
development
employees. This set was made up of close-ended questions. The second

5
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

Fig. 1. Conceptual model of research.

part sought to investigate the method and degree of application with parameters were satisfactory, indicating that the model and the subse­
regards to digital marketing. It used multiple choice questions related to quent analysis was accurate. For SEM, IBM AMOS program for data
the period of digital marketing implementation, the people in charge of processing was used. The results of the research are offered below.
it, the instruments of digital marketing that were primarily used, the
perception of its cost-effectiveness, the ability to measure its effects, and 5. Results and discussion
methods of measurement. Finally, the third set of questions was related
to the managers’ perceptions of the effects of digital marketing on Managers in companies of different sizes and from different in­
promotion and brand positioning, as well as on e-business development. dustries participated in this research. The characteristics of respondents
These questions were graded on a Likert Scale of 1–5 (1 - completely are shown depending on the number of employees in the company in
disagree; 5 - completely agree). The pilot survey, which examined the which they work; then, depending on how long their companies have
validity of the questionnaire’s content, was conducted on a sample of 12 used digital marketing; and, finally, depending on who is in charge of
managers. Their suggestions influenced the questionnaire’s final form. digital marketing in the observed companies (as presented in Table 2).
In order to ensure the comprehension of the survey, it was pilot-tested The research provides a number of relevant conclusions. The largest
and checked by a proofreader. amount of respondents were employed in companies with less than 9
The data was analyzed using the Structural Equation Model, Analysis employees (34.30%), then in companies with 50–250 employees
of Variance (ANOVA) test and eta-coefficient. Structural Equation Model (30.23%), and the smallest number of respondents were employed in
(SEM) was used to provide answers to hypotheses. This included a set of large companies of more than 250 employees (9.30%). This structure
statistical methods that explained the complex relationships between reflects the economy of the analyzed market, with the largest number of
one or more independent variables and one or more dependent variables companies coming from the sector of small and medium enterprises. The
[102,103]. SEM provides a measurement model and a structural model. research shows that companies have most often used this type of mar­
The measurement model determined the relationship between the keting for between 5 and 10 years (41.28%), or less than 5 years
measured variables and the latent variables (factors), while the struc­ (36.05%). The share of companies that do not use digital marketing
tural model worked with the relationships between the latent variables. (11.63%) is similar to that of companies that have used digital mar­
Latent variables were free of random errors because errors were calcu­ keting for more than 10 years (11.05%). Finally, employees and internal
lated and eliminated, leaving only general variance. experts are most often in charge of digital marketing (52.91%), while
In order to facilitate a deeper analysis of the use of digital marketing companies hiring a combination of internal and external experts for
in companies, we applied the ANOVA test. ANOVA is an analytical digital marketing were represented the least (10.47%).
model which tests the significance of differences [104]. The advantage Most companies served the tourism and hospitality sector (30
of this method is that all variations, as well as their mutual influence, are
accounted for. These are otherwise impossible to estimate. ANOVA Table 2
represents a special mathematical-statistical procedure that allows us to Characteristics of respondents.
test the significance of the difference between arithmetic means from
N Weighted N Weighted
three or more samples. Within that, we can test the influence of one or % %
more factors on the variability of a tested numerical feature.
Size of the company (number of Period of use of digital marketing
Additionally, in order to examine the significance of the period employees)
during which digital marketing was applied to the observed variables, Up to 9 59 34.30 From 5 to 10 years 71 41.28
we used the eta-coefficient, whose squared value represents a relative 10–49 45 26.16 More than 10 years 19 11.05
measure of association. 50–250 52 30.23 Less than 5 years 62 36.05
More than 250 16 9.30 It is not used 20 11.63
We processed the collected data in the SPSS program (Statistics 20)
Who is in charge of digital marketing
and, during the analysis, used the method of descriptive statistics. The Employees 91 52.91 Combination 18 10.47
validity of the structural equation model specification was assessed (internal (internal and
using four groups of tests: chi-square, absolute fit measures, incremental experts) external)
fit measures, and parsimony fit measurement. The values of all External experts 43 25.00 Digital marketing is 20 11.63
(agency) not used

6
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

companies, or 17.44% of the sample), followed by trade (22 companies, the corresponding measurable variables to the latent variable, and from
or 12.79% of the sample), finance/banking/insurance (20 companies, or the latent variable to two measurable factors, the values of the stan­
11.63% of the sample), and production (18 companies or 10.47% of the dardized regression coefficients are given. The higher their value, the
sample). The least represented activities of the companies in the sample more significant the influence of the factor on the latent variable and the
were energy, traffic/transport/logistics, and other activities (4 com­ greater its influence on the measurable variables.
panies each, or 2.33% of the sample). By analyzing the estimated regression coefficients of the SEM, we
The previously defined conceptual model of the importance of the conclude the following:
application of digital marketing on promotion, brand positioning, and e-
business development was tested using the appropriate SEM model. The (1) The high values of regression coefficients indicate the significant
authors used a combination of Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) and influence of the use of digital marketing in business, except in
SEM. CFA was used to confirm and trim these constructs and items cases where the size and activity of the company influences such
(measurement model). SEM was used to unveil potential relationships use. The effect that digital marketing has on brand perception
between these items and constructs (structural model). Collectively, also provides an exception.
these are known as CFA-SEM. The reliability coefficient for the inde­ (2) The most significant variables that affect the use of digital mar­
pendent variables was 0.713, representing an acceptable value for this keting are the period of use of digital marketing (0.768); carriers
coefficient in social science research [105]. Based on the results of CFA, in charge of the implementation of such activities (0.717); and
it is concluded that all ten independent variables (business activity, size cost effectiveness (0.643). The variable with the least influence is
of the company, period of implementation, forms of digital marketing, the size of the company, with a regression coefficient of 0.099.
people in charge, measurability of effects, ways of measurement, (3) The second part of the path diagram shows that digital marketing
cost-effectiveness, traditional marketing, and brand perception) affect positively impacts brand promotion and its positioning in the
the formation of the latent variable – the use of digital marketing. minds of consumers. The greater use of digital marketing also
The results of the SEM are given below in Fig. 2. positively affects the development of e-business, which further
The SEM includes a random error, denoted by "e". Error e1 is related benefits company competitiveness.
to the ability of the variable, which represents the “Activity of com­
panies” in explaining the variance of the factor “The use of digital The validity of the SEM specification is examined by applying a large
marketing” etc. number of tests, as given below in Table 3. The tests most commonly
The path diagram shows the impact of the analyzed factors on the use used relate to model validity indexes, and we classify them into four
of digital marketing in company business. Specifically, this is the activity groups: chi-square, absolute fit measures, incremental fit measures, and
of the company, then its size or number of employees, the period during parsimony fit measurement.
which digital marketing was used, and sub aspects of digital marketing Based on the testing, the results of the SEM assessment are taken as
(for example, carriers of digital marketing in the company, forms of valid.
digital marketing, the sufficiency of traditional marketing in promoting The next phase of research analyzed digital marketing use by
and positioning the brand in modern business, the ability to measure the examining the implementation of traditional marketing in brand pro­
effects of digital marketing, ways to measure effects, cost effectiveness, motion. We then observed differences in the application of appropriate
and brand perception). The diagram, after identifying the latent variable forms of digital marketing, who was in charge of digital marketing, ways
representing companies’ use of digital marketing, shows its impact on to measure the effects of digital marketing and the cost-effectiveness of
two measured variables: the promotion and positioning of the brand, digital marketing for promotion, and brand positioning, depending on
and the development of e-business. Above the rectilinear arrows from the time of use of digital marketing. The ANOVA test facilitated this

Fig. 2. Path diagram of SEM model The use of digital marketing and it’s impact on promotion and brand positioning, and development of e − business.

7
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

Table 3 Table 4
Goodness of fit indices. Descriptive statistics by variables for four determined answers to the question
GOF INDICES CRITERION SEM
about the period of use of digital marketing.
GUIDELINES RESULTS Dependent variables Control Mean Std. Std.
variable Deviation Error
Chi-square
Chi-square 444.647 Is traditional marketing today More than 2.00 .000 .000
Degrees of freedom 54 enough for promotion and 10 years
Probability level p > 0.05 0.161 brand positioning? Less than 5 2.00 .000 .000
Absolutes fit measures years
Root Mean Square Error Approximation <0.1 0.206 It is not 1.20 .410 .092
(RMSEA) used
Relatives fit measures Total 1.91 .291 .022
Bollen’s Incremental Fit Index (IFI) close to 1 0.963 Which forms of digital marketing 5–10 years 3.08 .627 .074
Incremental fit measures do you use most for promotion More than 3.43 1.257 .288
Normed Fit Index (NFI) >0.9 0.599 of your business (brand)? 10 years
Comparative Fit Index (CFI) >0.9 0.957 Less than 5 3.85 1.502 .191
Parsimony fit measurement years
Parsimony-Adjusted Normal Fit Index >0.5 0.546 It is not 1.00 .000 .000
(PNFI) used
Parsimony-Adjusted Comparative Fit >0.5 0.590 Total 3.18 1.371 .105
Index (PCFI) How do you measure the effects of 5–10 years 3.78 2.149 .255
digital marketing? More than 2.95 1.129 .259
10 years
examination. When the period of digital marketing use is taken as a Less than 5 4.60 1.531 .194
control variable, then comparisons between the expected values of years
It is not 6.00 .000 .000
research variables necessitates the use of ANOVA, because the number
used
of groups included in the analysis is greater than two. This research Total 4.16 1.905 .145
included five modalities of digital marketing periods, or five groups Do you consider that digital 5–10 years 1.03 .167 .020
depicting the equality of expected values. The areas included in the marketing is cost effective for More than 1.00 .000 .000
analysis were selected based on the relative importance assessed by the promotion and brand 10 years
positioning? Less than 5 1.13 .338 .043
SEM, but also in accordance with their importance in existing studies years
related to digital marketing in business. It is not 2.00 .000 .000
The ANOVA test begins by analyzing the results of descriptive sta­ used
tistics (as shown below in Table 4). Total 1.17 .381 .029
Who is in charge of digital 5–10 years 3.85 1.104 .131
The analysis of the first dependent variable (the sufficiency of
marketing in your company? More than 2.14 1.167 .268
traditional marketing in today’s business conditions) in relation to the 10 years
control variable (the period of digital marketing use) shows that com­ Less than 5 2.15 1.472 .187
panies applying digital marketing for any period of time feel that years
traditional marketing is not enough to promote and position their brand It is not 3 .000 .000
used
(the average value is 2, corresponding to "No" in this dependent vari­ Total 2.92 1.280 .098
able). These results confirm the findings of alternative studies wherein
people are bombarded with many advertisements and traditional pro­
motional styles are so thick that they cannot be relied upon to benefit that did not use digital marketing were homogeneous. This was
brand positioning. Brand positioning creates a divergent/positive/ expected.
motivational product image in peoples’ minds [65]. On the other hand, The analysis showed high standard deviation values for measure­
those respondents who stated that their companies did not apply digital ments of digital marketing effects. This suggests that companies using
marketing often believe that traditional marketing is still of great digital marketing deviate largely in their answers to this question, while
importance (the average value is 1.2, corresponding to "Yes” for the first those not using digital marketing offer a unique answer (the value of
dependent variables in the table). Based on the values of standard de­ standard deviation and standard error was 0). By analyzing the expected
viation and standard error, all respondents had a unique answer ("No") values, it was concluded that the most common way to measure the
to this first dependent variable, with the condition that these partici­ effects of digital marketing in companies and apply it across a period of
pants stated that their companies use digital marketing in their business 5–10 years was Google Analytics (expected value 4 belongs to the
(the value of standard deviations and standard error is 0). answer "Google Analytics"). These results are not surprising, as web
The research also shows that companies that have used digital analytics tools offer comprehensive information about customer
marketing for more than 5 or 10 years use "social networks" most often behavior and resulting outcomes. They are also easy to use and do not
(the average value 3 is equal to the answer "social networks"). These require direct monetary investments [42]. For companies that have been
results correlate with other research explaining that the emergence of using digital marketing for more than 10 years, the effect is measured by
new social networking platforms allows individuals to communicate applying the Social Network User Engagement Rate (expected value 3
with hundreds or even thousands of their peers about products, brands, corresponds to this way of measuring the effects of digital marketing).
and companies [106,107]. Companies that have been using digital High engagement rates indicate audience responsiveness and the num­
marketing for less than 5 years most often use e-mail marketing to ber of “real” followers, the type of content deemed most interesting, and
promote and position their brand (the average value of approximately 4 brand awareness [108,109]. In companies that have used digital mar­
corresponds to the answer "e-mail marketing"). Companies that prefer keting in business for less than 5 years, the effect is measured by
this method answer all e-mails manually to increase customer satisfac­ applying the Degree of Interaction (expected value 5 belongs to this
tion. This is a time-consuming process, particularly for Human Re­ answer). These results suggest that the instruments of digital marketing
sources. It is also necessary to point out the dispersion and diversity of are changing over time, implying that the use and perception of this
sample data that includes companies using digital marketing. Partici­ form of marketing is different at the beginning in comparison to at the
pants offered a large number of answers, influencing a high value of end, once it has had a positive impact on brand equity. However, it also
standard deviation and standard error, while the answers for companies suggests that brand perception is changing the ways digital marketing is

8
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

being applied. This is manifested in the different measurements used to Table 5


track its effects. The companies that use this form of marketing for a ANOVA test by variables for five determined answers to the question about the
longer period of time use different measurement approaches in com­ period of use of digital marketing.
parison to those companies that use it for a shorter period of time. Variables Sum of df Mean F Sig.
The research finds that all respondents whose companies have used Squares Square
digital marketing for more than 10 years consider it cost-effective for Is traditional Between 11.312 3 3.771 197.953 .000
promotion and brand positioning. As other research studies have shown, marketing today Groups
digital marketing, and especially social media marketing, is possibly the enough for Within 3.200 168 .019
promotion and Groups
most cost-efficient advertising strategy [56,86]. However, companies
brand Total 14.512 171
that do not use digital marketing perceive such methods as expensive, positioning?
indicating some ignorance. Companies that have been using digital Which forms of Between 127.805 3 42.602 36.967 .000
marketing for less than 5 years, or between 5 and 10 years, provided digital Groups
different answers to this question (standard deviation and standard error marketing do Within 193.608 168 1.152
you use most for Groups
have a value different than 0), but most of them consider digital mar­ promotion of Total 321.413 171
keting as cost-effective for promotion and brand positioning (the your business
average value of the answers for these two categories of respondents is (brand)?
closer to the value 1, or "Yes" for cost-effectiveness). Digital marketing is, How do you Between 131.571 3 43.857 15.062 .000
measure the Groups
without a doubt, a significant part of any marketing strategy and its
effects of digital Within 489.191 168 2.912
benefits are so great that avoiding its use is a missed opportunity [55, marketing? Groups
57]. This research suggests that digital marketing is a key element to Total 620.762 171
success and that many marketers understand the potential for business Do you consider Between 15.856 3 5.285 99.641 .000
growth through online platforms, confirming the results of other studies that digital Groups
marketing is Within 8.911 168 .053
[41,68].
cost effective for Groups
The results show that, if digital marketing is applied in a company for promotion and Total 24.767 171
a period of between 5 and 10 years, then it is realized by professionals brand
who are employed within those companies (average answer for this positioning?
Who is in charge Between 37.974 3 12.658 8.786 .000
group is 3.85 or approximately 4). If digital marketing has been applied
of digital Groups
for more than 10 years, then it is overseen by internal or external ex­ marketing in Within 242.044 168 1.441
perts. This is logical in situations where digital marketing has impacted your company? Groups
business, caused company growth, and increased the volume of work. In Total 280.017 171
such cases, the company requires experts. These results suggest that
digital marketing management includes both internal and external em­
forms of digital marketing, effects of digital marketing, and cost-
ployees and infrastructure, as confirmed by Chaffey’s research [64]. On
effectiveness of digital marketing for promotion and brand posi­
the other hand, if digital marketing has been applied for less than 5
tioning, This square takes a value of between 0 and 1 and represents the
years, internal and external experts take responsibility, as unfamiliarity
proportion of variance in the dependent variable explained by the in­
means a company may need help in creating promotion strategies and
dependent variable. The formula for calculating the eta square is:
training employees. If the company does not use digital marketing, then
our sample responses show no people in charge (average answer 3 co­ SSeffect
η2 =
incides with the answer that digital marketing is not used and that there SStotal
are no people in charge of digital marketing).
Based on the obtained results, we accept hypothesis H1. where:
The results of the ANOVA test for all of the research questions
defined in observed period - those related to the usage of digital mar­ SSeffect = sum of squares for a given independent variable (factor)
keting as a control variable - are presented in the next sections, including SStotal = the total sum of squares for all factors, interactions, and
Table 5. errors in ANOVA analysis
The initial hypothesis of the ANOVA test posits that the expected
values of the variables are equal for any answer to the control variable If η2 is 0.01 then it indicates a small impact, for a value of 0.06 a
question, which asks how long digital marketing has been used in the
companies covered by the research. Based on the results of descriptive Table 6
statistics, we noticed that there is a discrepancy in the answers related to Eta-coefficient as a measure of association with the period of use of digital
the control variable. These discrepancies frequently manifest between marketing in promoting and positioning the brand.
companies that use digital marketing, no matter how long they use it,
Measures of Association
and companies that do not use this form of marketing for promotion and
brand positioning. Therefore, it was logical to expect that the result of Variables Eta Eta
Squared
the ANOVA test would confirm this conclusion of the descriptive sta­
tistics. The calculated value of F statistics for responses to the question of Is traditional marketing today enough for promotion and .883 .779
brand positioning?* How long does your company use
how long digital marketing is used in companies - obtained by
digital marketing in business?
comparing the factor and residual variance, along with the associated Which forms of digital marketing do you use most for .631 .398
probabilities - indicates that, for each individual variable, it is necessary promotion of your business (brand)?* How long does your
to reject assumptions of equality within expected variable values. The company use digital marketing in business?
risk of error, made by rejecting the initial hypothesis, is 0% for each How do you measure the effects of digital marketing?* How .460 .212
long does your company use digital marketing in business?
individual variable. Do you consider that digital marketing is cost effective for .800 .640
We used the eta-coefficient (whose squared value represents a rela­ promotion and brand positioning?* How long does your
tive measure of association) to examine the importance of the period of company use digital marketing in business?
digital marketing use on managers’ perceptions of digital marketing Who is in charge of digital marketing in your company?* How .368 .136
long does your company use digital marketing in business?
carriers, the sufficiency of traditional marketing in modern business,

9
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

moderate impact, and for a value of 0.14 or greater a large impact. The (2) Respondents whose companies do not use digital marketing, in
obtained values are given below in Table 6. response to a question about the impact of this form of marketing
The analysis of the η2 coefficient showed that all research questions on promotion and brand positioning as well as on e-business
are greatly influenced by the control variable, which is the period of use development, gave low marks (answers 1 and 2). This shows that
of digital marketing. However, the period of digital marketing has the these managers do not understand the importance of digitaliza­
greatest impact on the formation of respondents’ attitudes towards the tion. What is encouraging is that the numbers are relatively small.
sufficiency of the use of traditional marketing to promotion and brand Only 11% of respondents in this category believe that this form of
positioning (η2 = 0.779), followed by the impact on the cost- marketing does not have a great impact on brand promotion and
effectiveness of digital marketing (η2 = 0.640), forms of digital mar­ positioning (answers 1 and 2). The impact of digital marketing on
keting (η2 = 0.398), then the impact on measuring the effects of the the development of e-business is also small (answers 1 and 2) in
application of digital marketing (η2 = 0.212), and finally the impact on the opinion of 11% of respondents whose companies do not use
the carriers of implementation or people in charge of digital marketing this form of marketing. Only 1% of respondents gave a mark of 3
(η2 = 0.136). The conclusion of this analysis indicates that the longer to this question.
digital marketing is applied by a company, the more likely it is that the
use of traditional marketing will not be enough to position and promote Furthermore, using the ANOVA test, we examined whether or not
the company’s brand. The company will also tend to use more social there was a difference when answering these two research questions -
networks, websites, and other forms of digital marketing, as well as related to H2 and H3 - between two categories of respondents – those
taking more interest in measuring the effects of the application of digital whose companies used digital marketing and those who did not. The
marketing, and employees within the company will become key carriers results are given in the following table (Table 7).
of digital marketing implementation. These results correspond to the The initial hypothesis of this test shows that the expected values (the
results found in other research [41,44,45,76–78] and confirm the average answers to these two research questions) are the same regard­
importance of different forms of digitalization in modern businesses. less of whether companies use digital marketing or not. In other words,
Furthermore, in the last part of the research, the authors wanted to this research tests whether or not a company’s use (or lack thereof) of
perform a deeper analysis of respondents’ attitudes towards the digital marketing affects respondents’ attitudes towards its impact on
importance and impact of digital marketing on brand promotion and promotion, brand positioning, and development of e-business. The
positioning, while also examining e-business development depending on
whether companies apply digital marketing. The results are presented
below in Graph 1. Table 7
ANOVA test for the importance of the use of digital marketing in the promotion
When viewed through the prism of digital marketing use, the graphic
and brand positioning and the development of e-business when the use of digital
presentation of the respondents’ attitudes regarding the extent to which
marketing is taken as a control variable.
digital marketing affects positioning and brand promotion - as well as
the development of e-business - provided the following conclusions: Variables Sum of df Mean F Sig.
Squares Square

(1) Companies that use digital marketing in their business believe To what extent Between 105.522 1 105.522 175.967 .000
does digital Groups
that it significantly affects promotion and brand positioning as
marketing Within 101.943 170 .600
well as the development of e-business. 88% of respondents whose affect Groups
companies use digital marketing gave high marks (grades 3, 4, promotion and Total 207.465 171
and 5) when describing the impact of this form of marketing on brand
promotion and brand positioning. The same number of re­ positioning?
To what extent Between 123.626 1 123.626 219.342 .000
spondents (88%) whose companies use digital marketing believe does digital Groups
that this form of marketing significantly affects e-business, giving marketing Within 95.816 170 .564
high marks for this question (grades 3, 4, and 5). This correlates affect Groups
with the results of other studies [22]. development Total 219.442 171
of e-business?

Graph 1. Overview of the relationship between the use of digital marketing and its impact on the promotion and brand positioning, as well as on the development of
e-business.

10
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

corresponding probability of F statistics indicates that the percentage of discover which factors had a significant impact on the use of digital
error, which is made by rejecting the stated initial hypothesis, is 0% for marketing, while examining whether and how digital marketing affects
both research questions. Thus, the initial hypothesis is rejected with a better promotion and brand positioning in consumer consciousness.
risk of error of 0% and it is concluded that respondents’ attitudes about Thus, the authors sought to examine the level of correlation between
the importance of digital marketing on promotion and brand posi­ digital marketing and e-business.
tioning, as well as on e-business development, differ depending on The multivariate analysis - SEM, ANOVA test, and eta-coefficient was
whether or not companies use digital marketing in business. If we con­ used. The SEM was conducted in order to better understand the dynamic
nect this conclusion to the results of descriptive statistics, then it is true nature of digital marketing, the cause-and-effect factors influencing the
that respondents whose companies do not use digital marketing believe use of digital marketing, and the impact of digital marketing on the
that this does not provide significant results in the field of brand pro­ analyzed variables. The ANOVA test and the eta-coefficient made it
motion, brand positioning, and e-business development (assigned an­ possible to determine the individual influences of the analyzed factors
swers 1 and 2 to these questions). Respondents whose companies do use related to the practice of digital marketing in the market in question. The
digital marketing believe that it contributes to better positioning and tests show that the results of the assessment using the aforementioned
promotion of the brand, as well as e-business development (they methods are valid.
assigned answers 3, 4 and 5 to these questions). This has been confirmed The research showed that the largest number of analyzed variables
in other studies [2,65]. from the model had a significant impact on the use of digital marketing.
In order to examine the importance of digital marketing use on re­ Regression coefficients, for almost all variables, had high values, indi­
spondents’ attitudes towards its impact on promotion and brand posi­ cating the significant impact of the analyzed variables on the use of
tioning, as well as e-business development, we used the eta-coefficient, digital marketing. Furthermore, the results showed that this impact
whose squared value represents a relative measure of association. See differs depending on the type of variable. The most significant variable
Table 8. influencing the degree of digital marketing use is that which examines
The analysis of the η2 coefficient showed that both research ques­ the period of digital marketing use (0.768), while the variable with the
tions are greatly influenced by the control variable, which is the use of least influence on this is the size of the company (0.099).
digital marketing. However, the use of digital marketing has a slightly Research has shown that companies that apply some form of digital
bigger impact on the formation of respondents’ attitudes regarding its marketing, no matter for how long, believe that traditional marketing is
influence on the development of e-business (η2 = 0.563), followed by its not enough to promote and position a brand in modern business. Relying
impact on brand promotion and positioning (η2 = 0.509). Based on the on the results of the research, the authors found that greater use of
results obtained, we accept hypotheses H2 and H3. digital marketing has a positive effect on the development of e-business,
Based on all the above, we conclude that there are a number of particularly with regards to electronic services that affect customer
factors that affect the use of digital marketing and that the period of use loyalty and strengthen the company’s competitiveness. This is in line
is a very important factor that determines the further implementation of with previous research [22,29,61,62], suggesting that both companies
digital marketing strategy. Research has shown that digital marketing is and customers recognize the beneftis of digitalization and e-business
an important determinant of promotion and brand positioning, as well services in developed countries and transition countries. In addition to
as of e-business development. the fact that this type of research is the first of its kind in the analyzed
market, this study offers added value to existing academic literature by
6. Conclusions and implications examining the concept of digital marketing through multi-context
analysis.
In recent years, more studies on digital transformation and digital Additionally, research has shown that social networks are the form of
marketing have been published, labelling digital technologies as inher­ digital marketing that companies use most often. This is especially
ently disruptive. Viali [12]; p. 122) reported three types of disruptions: evident in companies that use digital marketing for more than 5 or more
“consumer behavior and expectations, competitive landscape, and the than 10 years. The most common ways to measure the effects of digital
availability of data”. However, a significant number of scientific papers marketing are Google Analytics, followed by the Social Network User
in this field, especially those concerning less developed countries, were Engagement Rate and the Degree of Interaction. These results are not
of a conceptual nature and did not analyze the influence of digital surprising when considering the fact that 74% of the population in
transformation on digital marketing integrally through various aspects Montenegro actively use social networks [15]. However, it takes time
of application. It is important to note that existing academic literature and experience to attract followers on social networks, which explains
offers a limited understanding of the relationship between digital mar­ why this instrument of digital marketing is mostly used by companies
keting and e-business. According to the authors, the ways in which that have been implementing digital marketing for more than 5 years.
digital marketing affects the improvement of e-business in developing These findings are also in line with previous research [2,6,28,29], sug­
countries has not been sufficiently researched. Therefore, the authors gesting that social networks are very effective tools when it comes to the
conducted research to try to fill this gap. In particular, this study promotion of the company and the strengthening of brands.
developed and empirically tested a model that examined the relation­ Furthermore, research has shown that respondents believe that the
ship between the influencing factors of digital marketing use, as well as use of digital marketing is cost-effective for promotion and brand posi­
the impact of this form of marketing on e-business development, espe­ tioning. This is particularly demonstrated by managers whose com­
cially through the prism of a brand of the company. The study sought to panies have been using digital marketing for more than 10 years.
Through multivariate analysis, it has been shown that companies that
use digital marketing in their business believe that this form of mar­
Table 8 keting significantly affects the positioning and promotion of their brand,
Eta-coefficient as a measure of association with the use of digital marketing in as well as the development of e-business. Thus, for example, the analysis
the brand promotion and positioning and the development of e-business. of the η2 coefficient showed that the key factors are: (1) promotion and
Variables Eta Eta brand positioning and (2) the impact on the development of e-business
Squared under the influence of the control variable, which was the use of digital
To what extent does digital marketing affect promotion and .713 .509 marketing. However, the use of digital marketing has a slightly greater
brand positioning?* The use of digital marketing impact on the formation of respondents’ attitudes regarding its influence
To what extent does digital marketing affect development of e- .751 .563 on the development of e-business (η2 = 0.563) in relation to the impact
business?* The use of digital marketing
on promotion and brand positioning (η2 = 0.509). In addition, research

11
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

has shown that the longer digital marketing is applied in a company, the In addition to the practical, the authors believe that this paper has a
more likely it is that the use of traditional marketing will not be enough significant theoretical contribution. These results, in addition to
to position and promote the company’s brand. The length of time a expanding the base of empirical research on the topic of digital mar­
company uses digital marketing also spurs a greater the use of social keting, offer added value to existing scholarly literature by analyzing
networks, websites, and other forms of digital marketing, the better the this concept through different dimensions. In this way, this paper em­
effects of digital marketing can be measured, and the more likely it is for phasizes the importance of the concept of digital marketing through
employees in the company to become key players in the application of various observational approaches.
digital marketing. Based on the results, all three hypotheses were cor­
rect. Such results are not surprising when considering the fact that,
6.1. Limitations and future research
similar to the use of traditional marketing, the company must acquire
specific knowledge in order to successfully implement different forms of
The obtained results form a good basis for the conceptualization of
digital marketing. Additionally, the application of digital marketing can
further research. They are not particularly unexpected, but they reflect
be considered an investment that takes time to obtain customers’ trust
some specificities of the Montenegrin market. The obtained results
and thus gather positive feedback, which explains why companies that
suggest some key factors that all companies should consider when
implement digital marketing for longer periods of time are more able to
planning and implementing digital marketing strategies. This research
measure its effectiveness [19,20,62]. These conclusions are equally
also presents differences in terms of the instruments used and the ability
valid for both transition countries (such as Montenegro) and developed
to measure the effects of digital marketing depending on the period of its
countries.
application. Thus, it suggests which instruments should be considered
The results of the research lead to the conclusion that, in transition
appropriate and which ways of measuring its effects may be suitable for
economies, the effect of using digital marketing is similar to that of
a company, depending on the skills and knowledge of the people in
developed countries - better promotion, increasing brand awareness,
charge and the existing ways in which the company communicates with
and better positioning. This strengthens the competitiveness of com­
customers. However, this paper has several limitations in which op­
panies through the development of various forms of electronic services
portunities for future research may be found. Firstly, the research was
and electronic business. These results should not be surprising if we take
carried out in just one country – Montenegro - which is a transition
into account the fact that, even in less developed markets, we see an
country. It would be interesting to broaden this area of research to
increasing presence of international companies from developed coun­
include countries with a similar level of development, such as the
tries that operate in accordance with modern trends. Hence, in less
Western Balkans. It would also be prudent to conduct research for the
developed markets, the issue of digital marketing has become increas­
countries of Southeast Europe or Europe in its entirety, thus observing
ingly important.
the differences between developed and developing countries.
Based on the results of this research, the authors suggest managers
Secondly, the findings of this paper could be extended by analyzing
involve as many employees as possible in digital marketing activities to
the impact of digital marketing on different types of organizational
ensure that all, and not just marketing managers, are aware of the
performances linked to marketing metrics. For example, the application
importance of this practice in ensuring adequate promotion and posi­
of digital marketing in companies and organizations (profit vs non-profit
tioning in the consciousness of their customers. Undoubtedly, the
sector) could be compared.
concept of digital marketing leads to better brand promotion and posi­
Similarly, future research should focus on the analysis of factors that
tioning [29,65]. Therefore, in the opinion of the authors, it is necessary
could enable companies to profit when adopting the practices of digital
to have employees as internal stakeholders in order to adequately
marketing, electronic services, and e-business.
implement the digital marketing strategy and achieve the best possible
Finally, in addition to considering the opinions of managers, subse­
results. We conclude that more work needs to be done on the use of
quent studies should seek to uncover the interactive and combined ef­
digital marketing, especially in less developed countries.
fects of other types of stakeholders according to this concept. In this
The obtained results may serve as guidelines for managers and
way, research that includes both managers and customers would further
decision-makers in the implementation of digital marketing strategies
enlighten this study’s findings. These limitations may serve as incentives
and the development of electronic services that can ensure global reach
for researchers in the future.
for business, multi-channel customer interaction, cost-saving, and
competitiveness. These conclusions may produce more implications for
Appendix A. Supplementary data
managers and other decision-makers. Professional management support
must be present at all stages when developing a strategy for the use of
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi.
digital marketing. Decision-makers must be aware that the necessary
org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2020.101425.
knowledge, skills, and trends, serve as prerequisites for the development
of good digital marketing practice. However, without the adequate
References
integration of this concept into e-business, the implementation of digital
marketing in promotion and brand positioning is likely to fail. In other [1] P. Brey, The strategic role of technology in a good society, Technol. Soc. 52
words, it is not enough to make a decision on the implementation of a (2018) 39–45, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2017.02.002.
digital marketing strategy, but it is essential to implement it. Thus, the [2] F. Çizmeci, T. Ercan, The effect of digital marketing communication tools in the
creation brand awareness by housing companies, Megaron 10 (2) (2015)
concept of digital marketing needs to be viewed as part of a corporate
149–161, https://doi.org/10.5505/MEGARON.2015.73745.
business strategy. [3] H. Lee, C.H. Cho, Digital advertising: present and future prospects, Int. J. Advert.
The discrepancies in the analyzed factors regarding the use of digital 39 (3) (2020) 332–341.
[4] P.K. Kopalle, V. Kumar, M. Subramaniam, How legacy firms can embrace the
marketing act as signals to managers that, when planning and devel­
digital ecosystem via digital customer orientation, J. Acad. Market. Sci. 48 (1)
oping strategies, they must take into account influential factors, such as (2020) 114–131.
the sector in which they operate, the size of their company, and the [5] C.Y. Chen, The comparison of structure differences between internet marketing
diversity of their electronic services. This is especially important in the and traditional marketing, Int. J. Manag. Enterprise Dev. 3 (4) (2006) 397–417,
https://doi.org/10.1504/IJMED.2006.009088.
case of domestic companies in Montenegro that used to rely mostly on [6] H. Zhang, K.Z. Zhang, M.K. Lee, F. Feng, Brand loyalty in enterprise microblogs:
traditional marketing, especially considering the fact that Montenegro is influence of community commitment, IT habit, and participation, Inf. Technol.
a market with strong foreign competition. The application of digital People 28 (2) (2015), https://doi.org/10.1108/ITP-03-2014-0047.
[7] A. Alsaad, A. Taamneh, The effect of international pressures on the cross-national
marketing in this context can attract consumers just as efficiently as diffusion of business-, to-business e-commerce, Technology in Society 59 (2019)
large international companies do elsewhere. 101–158, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2019.101158.

12
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

[8] N. Kryvinska, Building consistent formal specification for the service enterprise [40] J. Kim, S. Kang, K.H. Lee, Evolution of digital marketing communication:
agility foundation, Journal of Service Science Research 4 (2) (2012) 235–269. bibliometric analysis and network visualization from key articles, J. Bus. Res.
[9] J.W. Ross, P. Weill, D. Robertson, Enterprise Architecture as Strategy: Creating a (2019), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2019.09.043.
Foundation for Business Execution, Harvard business press, 2006. [41] D. Chaffey, Digital Marketing, Pearson UK, 2019.
[10] T. Ritter, C.L. Pedersen, Digitization capability and the digitalization of business [42] J. Järvinen, The Use of Digital Analytics for Measuring and Optimizing Digital
models in business-to-business firms: past, present, and future, Ind. Market. Marketing Performance, Jyväskylä: University of Jyväskylä, 2016. https://www.
Manag. 86 (2020) 180–190. semanticscholar.org/paper/The-use-of-digital-analytics-for-measuring-and-J%
[11] D.D. Pearce, J.A. Pearce II, Distinguishing attributes of high-growth ventures, C3%A4rvinen/b85502b06dfe965ceeb0be8536aa9d08bf4c5245.
Bus. Horiz. 63 (1) (2020) 23–36. [43] D. Chaffey, P.R. Smith, Digital Marketing Excellence: Planning, Optimizing and
[12] G. Vial, Understanding digital transformation: a review and a research agenda, Integrating Online Marketing, Taylor & Francis, 2017.
J. Strat. Inf. Syst. 28 (2) (2019) 118–144, https://doi.org/10.1016/j. [44] W.G. Mangold, D.J. Faulds, Social media: the new hybrid element of the
jsis.2019.01.003. promotion mix, Bus. Horiz. 52 (4) (2009) 357–365.
[13] P. Guenzi, J. Habel, Mastering the digital transformation of sales, Calif. Manag. [45] D. Korschun, S. Du, How virtual corporate social responsibility dialogs generate
Rev. 62 (4) (2020) 57–85. value: a framework and propositions, J. Bus. Res. 66 (9) (2013) 1494–1504.
[14] H. Aly, Digital transformation, development and productivity in developing [46] R. Rodríguez, G. Svensson, E.J. Mehl, Digitalization process of complex B2B sales
countries: is artificial intelligence a curse or a blessing? Review of Economics and processes – enablers and obstacles, Technol. Soc. 62 (2020), https://doi.org/
Political Science (2020) https://doi.org/10.1108/REPS-11-2019-0145 ahead-of- 10.1016/j.techsoc.2020.101324.
print No. ahead-of-print. [47] R.T. Watson, L.F. Pitt, P. Berthon, G.M. Zinkhan, U-commerce: expanding the
[15] We Are Social - Digital in, 2020 available online: https://wearesocial.com/digi universe of marketing, J. Acad. Market. Sci. 30 (4) (2002) 333–347.
tal-2020. (Accessed 24 August 2020). [48] J.N. Sheth, A. Sharma, International e-marketing: opportunities and issues, Int.
[16] Government of Montenegro, Ministry of Public Administration, Report on Market. Rev. 22 (6) (2005) 611–622, https://doi.org/10.1108/
Consulting the Interested Public in the Process of Preparation of the Digital 02651330510630249.
Transformation Strategy of Montenegro 2021-2025, Podgorica, 2020. [49] D. Herhausen, D. Miočević, R.E. Morgan, M.H.P. Kleijnen, The digital marketing
[17] Government of Montenegro, Ministry for Information Society and capabilities gap, Ind. Market. Manag. 90 (2020) 276–290, https://doi.org/
Telecommunications, Strategy for Information Society Development 2020, 10.1016/j.indmarman.2020.07.022.
Podgorica, 2016. [50] D. Baum, M. Spann, J. Füller, C. Thürridl, The impact of social media campaigns
[18] Digital in Montenegro – Digital in, 2020 available online: https://datareportal. on the success of new product introductions, J. Retailing Consum. Serv. 50 (2019)
com/reports/digital-2020-montenegro. (Accessed 26 September 2020). 289–297.
[19] E. Piccinini, R.W. Gregory, L.M. Kolbe, Changes in the producer-consumer [51] G.S. Mort, J. Drennan, Mobile digital technology: emerging issue for marketing,
relationship-towards digital transformation, Changes 3 (4) (2015) 1634–1648. J. Database Mark. Cust. Strategy Manag. 10 (1) (2002) 9–23.
[20] M.T. Nuseir, Exploring the use of online marketing strategies and digital media to [52] A.J. Parsons, M. Zeisser, R. Waitman, Organizing for digital marketing, McKinsey
improve the brand loyalty and customer retention, Int. J. Bus. Manag. 11 (4) Q. (4) (1996) 185.
(2016) 228–238. [53] R. Helm, M. Möller, O. Mauroner, D. Conrad, The effects of a lack of social
[21] O. Petit, C. Velasco, C. Spence, Digital sensory marketing: integrating new recognition on online communication behavior, Comput. Hum. Behav. 29 (3)
technologies into multisensory online experience, J. Interact. Market. 45 (2019) (2013) 1065–1077.
42–61. [54] N.K. Malhotra, S.S. Kim, J. Agarwal, Internet users’ information privacy concerns
[22] A. Yasmin, S. Tasneem, K. Fatema, Effectiveness of digital marketing in the (IUIPC): the construct, the scale, and a causal model, Inf. Syst. Res. 15 (4) (2004)
challenging age: an empirical study, International Journal of Management 336–355.
Science and Business Administration 1 (5) (2015) 69–80. [55] M. Bala, D. Verma, A critical review of digital marketing, Int. J. Manag. IT Eng.
[23] R. Cluley, W. Green, R. Owen, The changing role of the marketing researcher in (IJMIE) 8 (10) (2018) 321–339.
the age of digital technology: practitioner perspectives on the digitization of [56] Y.B. Song, Proof that Online Advertising Works, Atlas Institute, Seattle, WA,
marketing research, Int. J. Mark. Res. 62 (1) (2020) 27–42. Digital Marketing Insight, 2001.
[24] V. Roblek, Impact of internet and social media on organizational change of OTC [57] P. Mandal, N. Joshi, Understanding digital marketing strategy, International
medicines marketing management, Int. J. Electron. Market. Retailing. 6 (3) Journal of Scientific Research and Management 5 (6) (2017) 5428–5431, https://
(2015) 239–258. doi.org/10.18535/ijsrm/v5i6.11.
[25] S.C. Eze, V.C. Chinedu-Eze, C.K. Okike, A.O. Bello, Critical factors influencing the [58] A.R. Raheem, P. Vishnu, A.M. Ahmed, Impact of product packaging on
adoption of digital marketing devices by service-oriented micro-businesses in consumer’s buying behavior, Eur. J. Sci. Res. 122 (2) (2014) 125–134.
Nigeria: a thematic analysis approach, Humanities and Social Sciences [59] M. Gregus, N. Kryvinska, Service Orientation of Enterprises—Aspects,
Communications 7 (1) (2020) 1–14. Dimensions, Technologies, Comenius University in Bratislava, 2015, ISBN
[26] F. Bogea, E.P.Z. Brito, Determinants of social media adoption by large companies, 9788022339780.
J. Technol. Manag. Innovat. 13 (1) (2018) 11–18. [60] P. Thaichon, A. Lobo, A. Mitsis, Investigating the antecedents to loyalty of
[27] W. Ritz, M. Wolf, S. McQuitty, Digital marketing adoption and success for small Internet service providers in Thailand: developing a conceptual model, in:
businesses, J. Res. Indian Med. 13 (2) (2019) 179–203. Australian and New Zealand Marketing Academy Conference, Adelaide,
[28] N.T. Siamagka, G. Christodoulides, N. Michaelidou, A. Valvi, Determinants of Australia, 2012, December.
social media adoption by B2B organizations, Ind. Market. Manag. 51 (2015) [61] A. Timoshenko, J.R. Hauser, Identifying customer needs from user-generated
89–99. content, Market. Sci. 38 (1) (2019) 1–20.
[29] X. Yu, C. Yuan, How consumers’ brand experience in social media can improve [62] M. Salehi, H. Mirzaei, M. Aghaei, M. Abyari, Dissimilarity of E-marketing VS
brand perception and customer equity, Asia Pac. J. Market. Logist. 31 (5) (2019) traditional marketing, Int. J. Acad. Res. Bus. Soc. Sci. 2 (1) (2012) 510.
1233–1251, https://doi.org/10.1108/APJML-01-2018-0034. [63] A. Pandey, Optimising online marketing resources: SEO strategy, Int. J. Technol.
[30] A.M. Noyola-Medina, S.Y. Pinzón-Castro, G. Maldonado-Guzmán, Innovation and Market. 7 (3) (2012) 267–277.
digital marketing adoption in mexican small business, J. Manag. Sustain. 8 (18) [64] D. Chaffey, Applying organisational capability models to assess the maturity of
(2018) 18–27. digital-marketing governance, J. Market. Manag. 26 (3–4) (2010) 187–196.
[31] J. Švarc, J. Lažnjak, M. Dabić, The role of national intellectual capital in the [65] R. Ahmed, R. Kumar, M. Baig, M. Khan, Impact of digital media on brand loyalty
digital transformation of EU countries. Another digital divide? J. Intellect. Cap. and brand positioning, 2015. Available at: SSRN 2708527.
(2020) https://doi.org/10.1108/JIC-02-2020-0024. No. ahead-of-print. [66] T. Sunil, S.K. Chiranjeev, Can brand image move upwards after Sideways? A
[32] S. Garzella, R. Fiorentino, A. Caputo, A. Lardo, Business Model Innovation in strategic approach to brand placement, Bus. Horiz. 54 (1) (2011) 41–42, https://
SMEs: the Role of Boundaries in the Digital Era, Technology Analysis & Strategic doi.org/10.1016/j.bushor.2010.08.002.
Management, 2020, pp. 1–13. [67] R.S. Winer, New communications approaches in marketing: issues and research
[33] A. Caputo, R. Fiorentino, S. Garzella, From the boundaries of management to the directions, J. Interact. Market. 23 (2) (2009) 108–117.
management of boundaries, Bus. Process Manag. J. 25 (3) (2019) 391–413. [68] G.J. Dehkordi, S. Rezvani, M. Salehi, S. Eghtebasi, A. Hasan Abadi, A conceptual
[34] U. Leimstoll, A. Dannecker, H. Knechtli, M. Quade, C. Tanner, R. Wölfle, E- analysis of the key Success of business in terms of internet marketing, Interdiscipl.
business in the era of digital transformation, Business Information Systems and J. Contemp. Res. Bus. 4 (1) (2012) 811–816.
Technology 4 (2018) 81–101. [69] H.U.A. Ying, C.H.E.N. Jin, Research on effects of internet involvement on
[35] I. Mergel, N. Edelmann, N. Haug, Defining digital transformation: results from customer loyalty from perspective of customer participation, Int. Bus. 3 (10)
expert interviews, Govern. Inf. Q. 36 (4) (2019) 101385, https://doi.org/ (2014).
10.1016/j.giq.2019.06.002. [70] D. Court, D. Elzinga, S. Mulder, O.J. Vetvik, The consumer decision journey,
[36] J.E. Fountain, Building the Virtual State: Information Technology and McKinsey Q. (3) (2009) 96–107.
Institutional Change, Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DC, USA, 2004. [71] M.S. Yadav, K. de Valck, T. Hennig-Thurau, D.L. Hoffman, M. Spann, Social
[37] P. Dunleavy, H. Margetts, J. Tinkler, S. Bastow, Digital Era Governance: IT commerce: a contingency framework for assessing marketing potential,
Corporations, the State, and E-Government, Oxford University Press, 2006. J. Interact. Market. 27 (4) (2013) 311–323.
[38] T. Hess, C. Matt, A. Benlian, F. Wiesböck, Options for formulating a digital [72] J. Deighton, L. Kornfeld, Interactivity’s unanticipated consequences for marketers
transformation strategy, MIS Q. Exec. 15 (2) (2016) 123–139. and marketing, J. Interact. Market. 23 (1) (2009) 4–10.
[39] M.F. Manesh, M.M. Pellegrini, G. Marzi, M. Dabic, Knowledge management in the [73] M.J. Valos, M.T. Ewing, I.H. Powell, Practitioner prognostications on the future of
fourth industrial revolution: mapping the literature and scoping future avenues, online marketing, J. Market. Manag. 26 (3–4) (2010) 361–376.
IEEE Trans. Eng. Manag. (2020), https://doi.org/10.1109/TEM.2019.2963489. [74] A. Phippen, L. Sheppard, S. Furnell, A practical evaluation of Web analytics,
Internet Res. 14 (4) (2004) 284–293.

13
B. Melović et al. Technology in Society 63 (2020) 101425

[75] T. Hennig-Thurau, E.C. Malthouse, C. Friege, S. Gensler, L. Lobschat, [94] J. Van Dijck, Facebook as a tool for producing sociality and connectivity, Televis.
A. Rangaswamy, B. Skiera, The impact of new media on customer relationships, N. Media 13 (2) (2012) 160–176.
J. Serv. Res. 13 (3) (2010) 311–330. [95] J. Jacobson, A. Gruzd, Á. Hernández-García, Social media marketing: who is
[76] P.K. Kannan, B.K. Pope, S. Jain, Pricing digital content product lines: a model and watching the watchers? J. Retailing Consum. Serv. 53 (2020).
application for the National Academies Press, Market. Sci. 28 (4) (2009) [96] N. Misirlis, M. Vlachopoulou, Social media metrics and analytics in
620–636. marketing–S3M: a mapping literature review, Int. J. Inf. Manag. 38 (1) (2018)
[77] O. Mintz, I.S. Currim, What drives managerial use of marketing and financial 270–276.
metrics and does metric use affect performance of marketing-mix activities, [97] A.A. Alalwan, Investigating the impact of social media advertising features on
J. Market. 77 (March) (2013) 17–40. customer purchase intention, Int. J. Inf. Manag. 42 (2018) 65–77.
[78] J. Järvinen, H. Karjaluoto, The use of Web analytics for digital marketing [98] I. Cetină, M.C. Munthiu, V. Rădulescu, Psychological and social factors that
performance measurement, Ind. Market. Manag. 50 (2015) 117–127. influence online consumer behavior, Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 62
[79] Y. Cader, A.A. Al Tenaiji, Social media marketing, Int. J. Soc. Enterpren. Innovat. (2012) 184–188.
2 (6) (2013) 546–560. [99] P. Yannopoulos, Impact of the Internet on marketing strategy formulation, Int. J.
[80] C.K. Prahalad, V. Ramaswamy, The Future of Competition: Co-creating Unique Bus. Soc. Sci. 2 (18) (2011).
Value with Customers, Harvard Business Press, 2004. [100] Internet World Statistics. https://www.internetworldstats.com/europa2.
[81] S.C. Chu, S. Kamal, Y. Kim, Re-examining of consumers’ responses toward social htm#me, 2020. (Accessed 24 August 2020).
media advertising and purchase intention toward luxury products from 2013 to [101] A. Caputo, G. Marzi, M. Pellegrini, The internet of things in manufacturing
2018: a retrospective commentary, Journal of Global Fashion Marketing 10 (1) innovation processes: development and application of a conceptual framework,
(2019) 81–92. Bus. Process Manag. J. 22 (2) (2016) 383–402.
[82] A.A. Bailey, C.M. Bonifield, A. Arias, Social media use by young Latin American [102] D. Hooper, J. Coughlan, M. Mullen, Structural equation modelling: guidelines for
consumers: an exploration, J. Retailing Consum. Serv. 43 (2018) 10–19. determining model, Electron. J. Bus. Res. Methods 6 (1) (2008) 53–60.
[83] R. Dimitriu, R. Guesalaga, Consumers’ social media brand behaviors: uncovering [103] Rex B. Kline, Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling, fourth ed.,
underlying motivators and deriving meaningful consumer segments, Psychol. The Guilford Press, New York & London, 2016.
Market. 34 (5) (2017) 580–592. [104] B.G. Tabachnick, L.S. Fidell, Experimental Designs Using ANOVA, Thomson/
[84] T.L. Tuten, M.R. Solomon, Social Media Marketing, Sage, 2017. Brooks/Cole, Belmont, CA, 2007, p. 724.
[85] K.K. Kapoor, K. Tamilmani, N.P. Rana, P. Patil, Y.K. Dwivedi, S. Nerur, Advances [105] J.F. Hair, W.C. Black, B.J. Babin, R.E. Anderson, R.L. Tatham, Multivariate Data
in social media research: past, present and future, Inf. Syst. Front 20 (3) (2018) Analysis, Prentice Hall Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River, NY, USA, 2006
531–558. (g).
[86] G. Anusha, Effectiveness of online advertising, Int. J. Regul. Govern. 4 (3) (2016) [106] Y.K. Choi, Y. Seo, S. Yoon, E-WOM messaging on social media: social ties,
14–21. temporal distance, and message concreteness, Internet Res. 27 (3) (2017)
[87] X. Yu, C. Yuan, J. Kim, S. Wang, A new form of brand experience in online social 495–505.
networks: an empirical analysis, J. Bus. Res. (2020), https://doi.org/10.1016/j. [107] H. Rasheed Gaber, A.M. Elsamadicy, L.T. Wright, Why do consumers use
jbusres.2020.02.011. Epub ahead of print. Facebook brand pages? A case study of a leading fast-food brand fan page in
[88] K.R. Ranjan, S. Read, Value co-creation: concept and measurement, J. Acad. Egypt, Journal of Global Scholars of Marketing Science 29 (3) (2019) 293–310.
Market. Sci. 44 (3) (2016) 290–315. [108] F. Poecze, C. Ebster, C. Strauss, Social media metrics and sentiment analysis to
[89] W.D. Hoyer, R. Chandy, M. Dorotic, M. Krafft, S.S. Singh, Consumer cocreation in evaluate the effectiveness of social media posts, Procedia computer science 130
new product development, J. Serv. Res. 13 (3) (2010) 283–296, https://doi.org/ (2018) 660–666.
10.1016/j.jbusres.2020.02.011. [109] Z. Rahman, D. Kumaran Suberamanian, H. Zanuddin, S. Moghavvemi, M.H.N.
[90] A. Morgan-Thomas, C. Veloutsou, Beyond technology acceptance: brand B. MdNasir, SNS metrics analysis-a study on fanpage interactive, Int. J. Appl. Bus.
relationships and online brand experience, J. Bus. Res. 66 (1) (2013) 21–27. Econ. Res. 14 (2016) 1405–1415.
[91] N. Soler-Labajos, A.I. Jiménez-Zarco, Social CRM: the role of social media in [110] S. Krishnaprabha, R. Tarunika, An analysis on building brand awareness through
managing customer relations, in: Managing Public Relations and Brand Image digital marketing initiatives, International Journal of Research in Engineering,
through Social Media, IGI Global, 2016, pp. 134–159. Science and Management 3 (7) (2020) 266–270.
[92] A. Quan-Haase, A.L. Young, Uses and gratifications of social media: a comparison [111] A. Niculescu, D. Dumitriu, C. Purdescu, M.A.M. Popescu, Enhancing brand value
of Facebook and instant messaging, Bull. Sci. Technol. Soc. 30 (5) (2010) of modern organizations through digital marketing tools and techniques: a study
350–361. on top ten Romanian companies, TEM J. 8 (1) (2019) 171.
[93] A. Gruzd, D. Paulin, C. Haythornthwaite, Analyzing social media and learning
through content and social network analysis: a faceted methodological approach,
Journal of Learning Analytics 3 (3) (2016) 46–71.

14

You might also like