Exel NTU Fix
Exel NTU Fix
Exel NTU Fix
69
Submitted bridge cost Rp 397,408.69
Bridge cost ratio 1
Average force to strength ratio
member compression force
1 0
2 0
3 0
4 0
5 0
6 0
7 0
8 0
9 0
10 0
11 693.46
12 757.62
13 758.11
14 694.18
15 694.78
16 759.02
17 758.22
18 693.87
19 0
20 0
21 192.36
22 0
23 0
24 194.4
25 0
26 0
27 0
28 873.41
29 879.5
30 880.25
31 874.17
32 3.27
33 3.27
34 878.6
35 872.52
36 873.02
37 879.1
38 3.27
39 3.27
40 232.45
41 240.96
42 3.81
43 233.13
44 240.74
45 3.4
46 0
47 192.83
48 194.88
49 232.85
50 240.45
51 233.78
52 241.38
53 3.4
54 3.4
Green ratio
type
Carbon Steel Solid Bar
CEGV 0.139582126601045
compression strength tension force tension strength force to strength ratio
2091.29 392.92 4013.75 0.0978934911242604
2091.29 623.17 4013.75 0.15525879788228
2091.29 761.37 4013.75 0.18969043911554
2091.29 623.98 4013.75 0.155460604173155
2091.29 393.32 4013.75 0.097993148551853
2091.29 393.66 4013.75 0.0980778573653068
2091.29 624.65 4013.75 0.155627530364372
2091.29 762.12 4013.75 0.189877296792277
2091.29 623.63 4013.75 0.155373403924011
2091.29 393.15 4013.75 0.0979507941451261
2315.16 0 4655 0.299530054078336
2633.62 0 4655 0.287672481223563
2633.62 0 4655 0.287858536918766
2315.16 0 4655 0.299841047702967
2315.16 0 4655 0.300100209056825
2633.62 0 4655 0.288204068924142
2633.62 0 4655 0.287900304523811
2315.16 0 4655 0.299707147670139
1347.81 514.71 3420 0.1505
1251.2 493.35 4655 0.105982814178303
1251.2 172.71 4655 0.0954212250117438
1347.81 515.4 3420 0.150701754385965
1347.81 514.94 3420 0.150567251461988
1251.2 170.66 4655 0.0960162490625541
1347.81 514.41 3420 0.150412280701754
675.37 493.6 3420 0.144327485380117
675.37 493.54 3420 0.144309941520468
3753.83 0 4655 0.232671697972471
3753.83 0 4655 0.234294041019439
3753.83 0 4655 0.234493836961184
3753.83 0 4655 0.232874157860106
1832.1 0 3420 0.00178483707221222
1832.1 0 3420 0.00178483707221222
3753.83 0 4655 0.234054285889345
3753.83 0 4655 0.232434606788267
3753.83 0 4655 0.232567804082763
3753.83 0 4655 0.234187483183842
1832.1 0 3420 0.00178483707221222
1832.1 0 3420 0.00178483707221222
3195.29 108.28 4655 0.048004355094365
3195.29 99.77 4655 0.0484219317215421
2469.26 0 4655 0.00154297238848886
3195.29 107.59 4655 0.0480366478555361
3195.29 99.99 4655 0.0484111365560922
1471.36 0 3420 0.00231078729882558
675.37 494.07 3420 0.144464912280702
1251.2 172.23 4655 0.0955574872397471
1251.2 170.19 4655 0.0961575815680963
3195.29 107.88 4655 0.0480239826679104
3195.29 100.28 4655 0.0483969065652718
3195.29 106.95 4655 0.0480696167764033
3195.29 99.34 4655 0.0484414665599087
1471.36 0 3420 0.00231078729882558
1471.36 0 3420 0.00231078729882558
summary 7.53743483645643
average 0.139582126601045
CEGV 0.839997791078455
submitted co2
lowest co2
green ratio
6331.5918 6331.5918
6331.5918
1
design 1
Submitted bridge cost Rp 187,939.71
force to strength ratio
average 0.839997791
green ratio 1
CEGV 0.839997791
design 3
Submitted bridge cost Rp 187,939.71
force to strength ratio
average 0.839997791
green ratio 1
CEGV 0.839997791
DESIGN 1
COST DESIGN 2
DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1
COST DESIGN 2
DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1
COST DESIGN 2
DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1
COST DESIGN 2
DESIGN 3
Lowest overall bridge cost Rp 180,066.71
Submitted bridge cost Rp 180,066.71
Bridge cost ratio 1
Average force to strength ratio
member
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
Green ratio
CEGV 0.823209101661842
design 3
Submitted bridge cost Rp 180,066.71
force to strength ratio
average 0.823209101661842
green ratio 1
CEGV 0.823209101661842
DESIGN 1 0.958108906308305
COST DESIGN 2 1
DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1 0.839997791
Average force to strength ratio DESIGN 2 0.823209101661842
DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1 0.790354851997881
Green Ratio DESIGN 2 1
DESIGN 3
DESIGN 1 100
CEGV DESIGN 2 98.0013412513656
DESIGN 3
Dennis H. Mahan Memorial Bridge
Project ID: 00055D-
Designed By:
# Material T Cross SectiSize (mm)
1 QTS Hollow Tub140x140x7
2 QTS Hollow Tub160x160x8
3 QTS Hollow Tub150x150x7
4 QTS Hollow Tub150x150x7
5 QTS Hollow Tub160x160x8
6 QTS Hollow Tub140x140x7
7 QTS Hollow Tub140x140x7
8 QTS Hollow Tub160x160x8
9 QTS Hollow Tub150x150x7
10 QTS Hollow Tub150x150x7
11 QTS Hollow Tub160x160x8
12 QTS Hollow Tub140x140x7
13 QTS Hollow Tub70x70x3
14 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
15 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
16 QTS Hollow Tub80x80x4
17 QTS Hollow Tub80x80x4
18 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
19 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
20 QTS Hollow Tub70x70x3
21 QTS Hollow Tub70x70x3
22 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
23 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
24 QTS Hollow Tub80x80x4
25 QTS Hollow Tub80x80x4
26 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
27 QTS Hollow Tub75x75x3
28 QTS Hollow Tub70x70x3
29 QTS Hollow Tub100x100x5
30 QTS Hollow Tub110x110x5
31 QTS Hollow Tub110x110x5
32 QTS Hollow Tub110x110x5
33 QTS Hollow Tub100x100x5
34 QTS Hollow Tub100x100x5
35 QTS Hollow Tub110x110x5
36 QTS Hollow Tub110x110x5
37 QTS Hollow Tub110x110x5
38 QTS Hollow Tub100x100x5
Length (m)CompressioCompressioCompressioTension FoTension St Tension Status
2.83 991.7 1233.14 OK 0 1715.83 OK
4.47 1044 1251.19 OK 0 2241.09 OK
4.12 936.34 1051.59 OK 0 1844.84 OK
4.12 936.34 1051.59 OK 0 1844.84 OK
4.47 1044 1251.19 OK 0 2241.09 OK
2.83 991.7 1233.14 OK 0 1715.83 OK
2.83 991.7 1233.14 OK 0 1715.83 OK
4.47 1044 1251.19 OK 0 2241.09 OK
4.12 936.34 1051.59 OK 0 1844.84 OK
4.12 936.34 1051.59 OK 0 1844.84 OK
4.47 1044 1251.19 OK 0 2241.09 OK
2.83 991.7 1233.14 OK 0 1715.83 OK
2.83 0 117.78 OK 328.87 370.44 OK
4.47 54 58.45 OK 290.19 398.09 OK
4.47 53.44 58.45 OK 233.38 398.09 OK
5.39 0 63.28 OK 415.99 560.27 OK
5.39 0 63.28 OK 415.99 560.27 OK
4.47 53.44 58.45 OK 233.38 398.09 OK
4.47 54 58.45 OK 290.19 398.09 OK
2.83 0 117.78 OK 328.87 370.44 OK
2.83 0 117.78 OK 328.87 370.44 OK
4.47 54 58.45 OK 290.19 398.09 OK
4.47 53.44 58.45 OK 233.38 398.09 OK
5.39 0 63.28 OK 415.99 560.27 OK
5.39 0 63.28 OK 415.99 560.27 OK
4.47 53.44 58.45 OK 233.38 398.09 OK
4.47 54 58.45 OK 290.19 398.09 OK
2.83 0 117.78 OK 328.87 370.44 OK
4 0 280.02 OK 701.24 875.43 OK
4 0 377.57 OK 832.87 967.57 OK
4 0 377.57 OK 818.02 967.57 OK
4 0 377.57 OK 832.87 967.57 OK
4 0 280.02 OK 701.24 875.43 OK
4 0 280.02 OK 701.24 875.43 OK
4 0 377.57 OK 832.87 967.57 OK
4 0 377.57 OK 818.02 967.57 OK
4 0 377.57 OK 832.87 967.57 OK
4 0 280.02 OK 701.24 875.43 OK