The Orbital Welding Handbook
The Orbital Welding Handbook
The Orbital Welding Handbook
PN-0509078
Original edition: 2009 - updated edition: 01/2016 - Polysoude Nantes France SAS
Photos, plans and drawings are used as help to the understanding and are thus not
contractual.
All rights reserved. No total or partial reproduction of this work can be made, under any for-
mat or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or computer
techniques, without the written authorization of the publisher.
Printed in France.
Published by Polysoude, Nantes, Fr
www.polysoude.com info@polysoude.com
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
INDEX
1. Preface 7
3
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
4
THE ART OF WELDING
14.5. Electrode preparation 38
14.6. Backing gas 39
14.7. Chemical composition and repeatability of the welds 39
15. Tube-to-tube or pipe-to-pipe orbital welding with filler wire 40
15.1. Applications 40
15.2. Choice of the equipment 40
15.3. Weld preparation 41
15.4. Positioning of the tubes 42
15.5. Multilayer welding 42
15.6. AVC requires precise electrode geometry 43
15.7. Backing gas 43
15.8. Boundary parameters 43
15.9. Geometrical adjustments 44
15.10. Possibilities to increase the performance of orbital TIG welding 44
16. Orbital tube-to-tubesheet welding 46
16.1. Range of materials and tube dimensions 46
16.2. Welding equipment 46
16.3. Specific requirements of tubes and weld preparations 47
16.4. Welding of flush tubes 48
16.5. Welding of protruding tubes 49
16.6. Welding of recessed tubes 51
16.7. Internal bore welding behind the tubesheet 52
17. Conclusion 53
5
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
6
THE ART OF WELDING
1. Preface
Among industrial welding processes, orbital and the related equipment: technical
TIG welding has meanwhile become a approach, advantages, common and
well-established method, although a consid- special applications, but also restrictions
erable lack of information about the various and limits. To give practical examples, the
possibilities of this challenging technique text is illustrated by numerous application
still remains in public. Aerospace industry, examples.
aviation, high speed trains, nuclear indus-
try, pharmaceutical industry, food industry, Tables and designs can help engineers and
tiny microelectronic devices - to name but a welding experts, as well as project managers,
few of the most exciting applications - rely to get quick answers as to whether orbital
on orbital welding, but the equipment to welding could offer solutions corresponding
ensure our daily supply with electric current, to their needs. To get specific answers for
oil and gas also depends on orbital welding your questions, visit the Polysoude website
techniques. (www.polysoude.com) and consult the
In this booklet, basic information is customer service team.
provided about the orbital weld process
7
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
3.1.1. Advantages
1- Nearly all metals can be joined. reduced to less than 1%.
2- Different kinds of steel, stainless steel 5- No slag or fumes are developed during
included, can be welded as well as refrac- welding.
tory or wear-resistant nickel alloys, alumin- 6- The affecting weld parameters can be
ium, copper, gold, magnesium, tantalum, adjusted in a wide range and mostly inde-
titanium, zirconium, and their alloys; even
pendent one of each other.
brass and bronze can be welded in certain
cases; if filler wire is applied, workpieces 7- TIG welding can be carried out with or
consisting of dissimilar alloys or batches can without filler wire.
also be joined together. 8- The arc voltage, which is directly related
3 - All welding positions are possible. to the arc length, and the weld current
intensity offer a wide range of variations
4 - The process is very stable and reliable;
and can be controlled automatically.
the occurrence of weld defects can be
3.1.2. Inconveniences
1- Compared to other arc welding pro- and the exact values of weld parameters
cesses, the deposition rate of the TIG pro- which are necessary to control the process.
cess is relatively low. 3- The welding equipment is sophisticated;
2- Time-intensive and costly development is it requires much more capital investment
necessary to determine the weld procedures cost than gear for manual welding.
8
THE ART OF WELDING
3.3. Tungsten electrodes
3.3.1. Types of electrodes
Tungsten is a highly refractory metal with a grinding equipment is required to ensure a
melting point of 3,410 °C. It withstands the safe disposal of the grinding particles.
heat of the electric arc and keeps its hard- Today, different alloyed tungsten electrodes
ness even if it becomes red hot. In the past, are preferred, e.g. Ceriated or Lanthanated
thoriated tungsten electrodes have been types, which are free of any radioactivity. In
widely used for TIG welding, but as thorium addition, their performance is comparable
is a low-level radioactive element, special to that of thoriated tungsten electrodes.
9
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
3.5. Gases
3.5.1. Welding gases
Argon is commonly used as shielding gas aluminium and titanium they are strictly
in the TIG process. It provides good arc strik- forbidden.
ing characteristics and excellent arc stability The weld energy can also be increased by
even at low amperages, the energy of the argon/helium mixtures with helium contents
arc is confined to a narrow area. Argon of 20%, 50% or 70% or even pure helium.
is also compatible with all types of base Helium has no detrimental effects on tita-
materials. nium, so it is used especially to weld the
Shielding gas for standard TIG welding pure metal or titanium containing alloys.
purposes should have a purity of 4.5, i.e. a Mixtures of argon, helium and nitrogen
purity level of 99.995%. Metals which are are used to weld Duplex and Super Duplex
classified as delicate to weld for example; steels.
titanium, tantalum, zirconium and their
alloys require a purity of at least 4.8, which Unlike argon, helium is a good heat con-
means a purity level of 99.998%. ductor. The arc voltage under helium is much
higher than under argon, so the energy
To increase the weld energy, 2% to 5%
content of the arc is strongly increased. The
hydrogen can be added to the argon.
arc column is wider and allows deeper pen-
Besides a higher energy input of 10% to
etration. Helium is applied for the welding
20% resulting in a better penetration and
of metals with high heat conductivity like
faster welding speeds, argon / hydrogen
copper, aluminium and light metal alloys.
mixtures have reducing properties helping
As helium is a lightweight gas, compared to
to protect the molten metal against the
argon its flow rate for identical gas coverage
influence of oxygen from the surrounding
atmosphere. However, mild and carbon must be increased two to three times.
steels absorb hydrogen with the possible The following table indicates the qualifica-
result of porosity and cold cracking, so the tion of different welding gases and mixtures
use of hydrogen containing gas mixtures according to the base materials to be joined:
is not recommended; for the welding of
Ar Ar + H2 Ar + Hé Ar + N2 He Ar Argon
x Prohibited
10
THE ART OF WELDING
3.5.2. Backing gases
Most applications of orbital welding require must be prevented from coming in contact
an outstanding quality to the inside of the with oxygen in the atmosphere. Depending
root, as this is the part of the weld which on the material to be welded, reducing
will be in direct contact with the transported components like N2 or H2 are added to the
medium. To avoid any risk of oxidation, backing gas. The most typical backing gases
before, during and after the welding opera- and mixtures applicable for the different
tion the hot metal at the inside of the tube base metals are:
Ar N2 Ar + H2 ou N2 + H2 Ar Argon
11
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
12
THE ART OF WELDING
4. Reasons to select orbital welding
The decision for the use of mechanised or factor. The orbital welding process offers a
automatic orbital TIG welding can be taken large range of benefits which qualifies it for
for different reasons: economic, technical, industrial applications. The major advan-
organisational, and others may be more or tages are:
less important or even become the decisive
4.4. Environment
Orbital welding can be executed even head is positioned properly, the weld can
under harsh environmental conditions. be accomplished without problems from a
Restricted space or access, lack of visibility, safe distance; often supported by a video
presence of radiation; once the welding transmission.
13
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
14
THE ART OF WELDING
5.4. Fabrication of semi-conductor devices
For the fabrication of semi-conductor installations are very stringent: uniform
devices, electro-polished stainless steel welds with small weld beads to minimize
tubes are installed as process gas lines, the weld surface in the tubes, full penetra-
mostly with an OD of 6.3 mm and a wall tion on the ID, absence of discoloration,
thickness of 0.9 mm. The ultra-pure process etc. Only experienced operators working
gas must pass the tubes without picking up with reliable orbital welding equipment are
moisture, oxygen, particles or other con- able to perform this task, often even under
taminants. The acceptance criteria for these adverse conditions on site.
15
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
( 1) ( 2)
16
THE ART OF WELDING
6.3. Programming of sectors
In many cases, the only use of a pulsed weld
current is not sufficient to obtain acceptable D
0°
orbital weld results. The parameters must be 360° 90°
S1
adapted with regard to the actual require-
ments of the weld. The course covered
during the weld cycle is hence divided into S4 S2
different zones, which are called sectors.
The weld parameters are modified if the
S3
border of one sector to the next is crossed. 270° 180°
To explain the sector layout, a circle of 360°
as symbol of the cross-section of the tubes
to be welded is divided into four sectors, Depending on the weld position and the
each covering 90°. The first sector begins at thermal conditions of the workpiece, which
the starting point D of the orbital weld, in is heated up perpetually by the energy input
this case at the 10.30 position, and ends at of the electric arc, the parameter values are
the 01.30 position. modified at the beginning of each sector.
Each sector corresponds to a specific weld- In the orbital weld practice, most often the
ing position: sectors are not divided as regularly as shown
sector S1 from 0° to 90° flat position; in the example. The number of sectors
can also vary due to the different welding
sector S2 de 90° à 180° vertically
applications.
down position;
sector S3 de 180° à 270° overhead
position;
sector S4 de 270° à 360° vertically up
position.
17
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
18
THE ART OF WELDING
operations. A closed loop Cooling System or suggests weld parameters determined by
is present to operate water-cooled orbital progressive calculations. The proposed weld-
welding heads and welding tools and is inte- ing procedure can be finally optimised by an
grated as part of the machine. expert help menu or Welding Assistant.
A recently launched power source allows us To relieve the operator from further error-
to find matching weld programs, (if the user prone tasks, the power source detects and
specifies basic information about size and recognises connected peripherals auto-
material of the tubes to be joined), using a matically, (plug and play), as well as auto-
touch screen or PC. The system consults its matically adapting itself to available mains
in-built database to find similar applications supply voltages.
19
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
20
THE ART OF WELDING
9.1.2. Open welding heads of the U type
Open welding heads were conceived as a
tool for orbital TIG welding with or with-
out filler wire. The diameters of the tubes to
be welded cover a range from 8 mm up to
275 mm (ANSI 5/16" to 11").
Open welding heads of the U-type are
equipped with a TIG-torch with gas diffuser.
Sufficient gas protection is achieved only at
a zone around the torch which is covered by
the shielding gas streaming out of the gas
lens. During the welding process, the arc
can be watched and controlled directly by
the operator. The asymmetrical design of the
open heads allows welding to be carried out
at a very short distance to a wall or a bend.
The positioning of the welding torch can
be carried out manually or by means of Open welding head Polysoude MU
motorized slides (Arc Voltage Control and
oscillation).
21
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
22
THE ART OF WELDING
10. Wire feeders
Generally, a wire feeding device can be inte- of the filler wire, which must be available on
grated into the orbital welding head or speci- suitable spools; furthermore on the conditions
fied as an external wire feeder. The choice of of use, the constraints of the application and
the feeding device depends on the availability the requested mobility of the equipment.
Gas control functions on the synoptic board of P4-P6 series Polysoude power source
23
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
Depending on the standard of the particular welding the gas flow rate drops below a
orbital welding equipment, the welding gas factory-adjusted value, the weld cycle will
flow is continuously monitored. In case of be aborted automatically. By this measure,
an interruption of the welding gas supply, severe damage of the workpiece and equip-
the ignition of the arc is blocked. If during ment is avoided.
11.2. Current
Current control functions on the synoptic board of P4-P6 series Polysoude power source
The welding current is one of the affecting Thermal pulsation (2): this current is com-
parameters of the TIG process; therefore its monly used for standard orbital TIG welding
intensities must be controlled accurately by (see chapter 6.2); the maximum frequency of
the power sources. A precision of ± 1 Amp thermal pulsations is 10 Hz.
is guaranteed if the welding current intensity Fast pulsed current (3): the current is pulsed
rests below 100 Amps, for intensities exceed- at increased frequencies between 500 Hz and
ing 100 Amps a precision of 1% is ensured. To 10,000 Hz. The fast pulsed current resembles
meet the requirements of the different appli- an un-pulsed current but forms an arc which
cations, dissimilar current types are supplied by is much more stable. The pulses are not visible
the power sources: but audible.
Un-pulsed current (1): no variation of the
current intensity.
24
THE ART OF WELDING
Thermo-rapid pulsed current (4): this cur-
1
rent form results of a combination of Thermal
pulsation (2) and Fast pulsation (3).
Pulsed current with mono-pulses (5): the
pulsed current is superposed by an intensity 2
peak at the beginning of each pulse, which
provokes an increased arc pressure on the
weld puddle. This function is particularly
helpful to get convex root geometry when 3
welding in overhead position (the torch is
situated below the workpiece), where the
force of gravity provokes a concave weld at
the I.D. of the tube. 4
Torch rotation control functions on the synoptic board of P4-P6 series Polysoude power source
During welding the torch must rotate with ing applications require a linear travel speed
the desired linear travel speed around range between 50 mm/min and 200 mm/min.
the tube or pipe. Standard orbital weld-
25
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
In most cases the travel speed remains un- impulse emitters or tachometer encoders on
pulsed, but it can also become pulsed and request.
synchronized to the weld current pulsations. These pulses are also processed by the con-
It is possible to program different speeds dur- trol system of the power source to identify
ing base and pulse current. Usually, as in the the actual position of the torch relative to
case of step pulsed welding, rotation stops the start point, which means that the pro-
(V = 0 mm/min) during the high current level, gramming of a weld cycle can be carried out
whereas during the base current period the using angular degrees instead of time spans.
torch moves forward. Intuitive programming is possible because
The achieved speed precision is 1 % of the one tour of the torch always covers 360°
programmed value. Polysoude standard per pass, independently of the linear weld-
welding equipment can be operated using ing speed and the tube or pipe diameter.
Power sources for orbital welding are the inside of the workpiece.
equipped to control different types of wire At the end of welding, a wire retract func-
feeders; the attainable wire speeds range tion allows the reversal of the feeding direc-
from 0 to 8,000 mm/min, a precision of tion. The wire end is drawn back a few
about 1 % is attained. millimetres, avoiding the formation of a
Standard functions of wire feeding which terminal wire ball or, even worse, the wire
are managed by all power sources are the resting stuck in the weldment.
control of the wire start and stop as well Expert information:
as a pulsed feeding rates. The wire feeding
pulses can be synchronised to the pulses of 1- Common diameters of wire for welding
the weld current; the wire speed is kept at purposes range between 0.6 mm and 1.2 m;
a high level when the weld current is at its the best choice for standard orbital welding
high level, and is decreased during low level is a proper wire with 0.8 mm diameter.
current. The independence between wire 2- The melting rate of the wire depends
speed and weld current offered by the TIG not only on the precision of the wire feed
process allows the reversal of synchronisa- speed, but also on the precision of the wire
tion; the wire is fed at a high speed when itself: a variation of 0.02 mm at a wire with a
the current intensity is low; the wire arrives diameter of 0.8 mm represents a difference
at a small weld puddle and melts with resist- of already 5% of added metal.
ance. The mechanical stability of the wire
can be used to push the bath of molten
metal to get a convex root pass surface at
26
THE ART OF WELDING
11.5. AVC (Arc Voltage Control)
Arc voltage control functions on the synoptic board of P4-P6 series Polysoude power source
During welding, it is important to keep the arc length constant; but there are no simple
methods to measure it. In any case, if the welding conditions do not change, each particular
arc length corresponds to a related arc voltage. This phenomenon is used to control the
distance between the electrode and the workpiece during welding.
The characteristic of arc voltage at different Rule no. 3: if a different type of shield-
arc lengths and welding current intensities ing gas is used (with other weld parameters
are shown in the graph below: remaining unchanged), the arc length will
change: if the shielding gas changes e.g.
U ( V)
from argon to an argon-hydrogen mixture,
2 mm
the arc becomes significantly shorter.
U2- h 1 mm
U1- h Rule no. 4: if the geometry of the elec-
U2- b trode differs (taper angle, tip diameter), the
U1- b arc length at a given weld current changes
or, at a constant arc length, the arc voltage
I m ini I -b I -h I ( A) changes.
Rule no. 5: if a pulsed weld current is
At an arc length of 1 mm, the arc voltage applied, the arc voltage pulsations are not
measured between the electrode and the proportional.
workpiece at different welding current
intensities is characterised by the black line. I
The red line shows the result of the same I 1- h
measurement at an arc length of 2 mm.
27
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
Restriction of the voltage measurement To get optimal results with minimised
to the period of the low or of the high AVC-related torch movements, there are
welding current. During the period without more system parameters that can be set.
measurement the AVC slide is temporarily These parameters are (beginning with the
blocked, the electrode position does not most important):
change. The adjustment is simple, only one Sensitivity of the control system
parameter value is requested to get a stable
Speed of the electrode movement
arc length
Switch-off time at the beginning of
Extended arc voltage measurement dur-
each current pulse to eliminate the
ing the period of the low and of the high
effect of overshoot (rule no. 5).
welding current. This type of AVC control
can be used if thermal pulsing (pulse fre-
quency < 10 Hz) is applied.
11.5.3. Programmable distance between electrode and workpiece
Besides the AVC control, the torch position The mentioned function is often used to get
can be determined by the programmed the electrode in position e.g. with tube-to-
distance between electrode and workpiece tubesheet applications or, if special welding
function. Here, starting from a reference tools are used, to follow the complex sur-
value, the torch is moved by a motorized face geometry of a workpiece in piggyback
slide over the selected distance in mm to the position.
desired height.
11.6. Oscillation
Oscillation control functions on the synoptic board of P4-P6 series Polysoude power source
If a weld preparation is applied to the tube the groove can be covered completely by
ends, the groove to be filled becomes rel- one layer if the torch is moving perpendicu-
atively wide, especially in the case of an larly from one side to the other between the
increased wall thickness. Different to the sidewalls of the weld prep. This movement
stringer bead technique, where several is generated by a motorised slide and con-
passes are required to complete one layer, trolled by the oscillation system.
28
THE ART OF WELDING
Parameters needing to be set to get the cor- It is possible to synchronise the torch oscilla-
rect oscillation are width and speed of the tion with the pulsed current. For example, to
stroke, as well as the dwell time, during increase the penetration at the sidewall, the
which the torch remains at the end points high current intensity value is maintained
of its movement next to the sidewalls of the continuously during the dwell time.
groove.
29
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
1 2 34 5 6 7 8 9
1 Start of the weld cycle (triggered by the Start button of the control pendant)
1 to 2 Shielding gas flow during the programmed pre-flow time before the ignition of the arc
2 Ignition of the arc and beginning of the pulsed weld current. The clock is reset to zero
4 Start of the torch rotation* (initial position of the torch is set to zero position of the weld cycle)
End of wire feeding* (and wire retract if programmed). Generally, the end of wire feeding is
6 positioned at approx. 360°
Begin of the weld current downslope before the arc is finally switched off. Generally, the downs-
7 lope is positioned at 360° + 5° to 10° of overlapping to re-melt the beginning of the weld seam
and to ensure a perfect joint at the end of the weld
7 to 8 Time of the weld current downslope to finish the weld without crack and crater formation
Time period of post-gas flow to protect the weld zone of the workpiece until a sufficiently low
8 to 9 temperature has been reached and to protect the hot tungsten electrode against oxygen of the
atmosphere.
* Depending on the expected result the functions may be programmed in a different chronological order.
30
THE ART OF WELDING
12.2. Interfaces for the programming of weld cycles
Generally, two different types of inter- complete weld cycles offline and to manage
faces are actually used for the interactions the weld cycle library. As the software is exe-
between the user and the orbital welding cuted under a Windows™ environment, it
equipment. is easy to handle and understand. The data
1 - On a synoptic board, the weld cycle files from the PC can also be transferred to
occurs in form a graphic presentation. The the power sources via compact flash cards.
operator has to move a cursor to choose 2 - A recently introduced user-friendly
a parameter; the related values occur on a Graphical User Interface, (GUI), for orbital
display (2 lines) and can be modified if nec- welding equipment based on a PC with
essary. At the beginning, some general con- Linux environment has been developed.
ditions must be fixed: The virtual synoptic is presented on a 10.4"
Whether pulsed or un-pulsed welding touchscreen; it allows not only the complete
current is required weld data management but offers all func-
tions to assist the operator with the devel-
If wire feeding shall be switched off or
opment and finish of any orbital welding
executed un-pulsed or pulsed.
program. Some of the features are listed
Depending on this selection, only the below:
parameters to be specified are accessible
Complete documentation of the work-
one by one. The PS 164-2 microprocessor-
piece data
controlled power source is based on this
type of interface. The programmed values Creation of chained weld cycles to carry
can be stored on memo cards. out a complete multi-pass weld sequence
This kind of technique allows handling of Detailed description of boundary param-
the main machine parameters, but the input eters, i.e. mechanical adjustments of
of additional documentation via the power devices, type and characteristics of gases
source is not possible. However, the data can used, electrodes, filler wire etc.
be stored on a compact flash card and trans- An expert system with a search function
ferred to a PC. Particular software allows to which deals with up to 8 parameters at the
addition of missing information, to create same time
31
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
The programming of weld cycles for very understand these commands and to build
complex applications and research tasks up his own weld programs autonomously.
are carried out offline by means of a per- The welding software is designed for a
sonal computer without connection to the Windows® environment; the user surface is
power source. The sequences are created similar to an Excel® worksheet.
line after line. Similar to the programming
Due to Windows® commonality, files of any
of a numerical controlled machine tool, but
format can be integrated, leading to com-
here the commands are made available to
plete documentation of the weld cycle and
the operator in his native language. After a
the attached parameters.
short training period, each welder is able to
32
THE ART OF WELDING
13. Real time data acquisition
13.1. In summary
33
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
When using PC type equipment the real- parameters. In this case, the concerned
time data acquisition is not integrated in the parameter values are continually compared
power source. The Polysoude RECORDING to a previously recorded defect-free sam-
SYSTEM which is used in place of the typi- ple weld. If the system is operated in the
cal system represents a development using passive mode, the graph changes its
DASYLab® software made available by colour as soon as a parameter limit is
National Instruments. DASYLab® is a soft- reached; switched to the active mode, the
ware environment which is specialised in data acquisition system aborts each weld
data acquisition, analysis and real-time cycle if the specified limits are exceeded.
control.
Parameters such as values for welding
and hot wire current intensities, arc volt-
age, travel speed and wire feed speed are
recorded at a frequency of 200 Hz. When
the weld cycle starts, (arc ignition), the
recording starts automatically, at the same
moment, the storing of data on the hard
disk of the PC begins. The created files are
named automatically with an unambiguous
code including date and time.
The progress of the weld cycle can be moni-
tored and occurs as a graph on the display. Example of a weld cycle report generated
The data acquisition system allows the by the Polysoude data acquisition system
operator to set limits for the different weld
Fusion welds of thin-walled tubes cover a austenitic stainless steel, but nickel alloys as
wide range of applications. Clients include well as titanium and its alloys can also be
for example: semiconductor industry, bio- found. The range covers diameters from
chemistry, instrumentation, food and bev- 1.6 to 170 mm; with wall thicknesses of
erage, pharmaceutical industry, chemical/ varying between 0.2 and 3.2 mm.
sanitary industry, and aeronautics/aero-
space. In most cases, the tubes are made of
34
THE ART OF WELDING
14.2. Equipment
35
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
36
THE ART OF WELDING
14.3. Calculation of weld parameters values
Depending on the diameter and wall thick- be calculated. The calculations are based on
ness of the tubes to be joined the parameter formulas developed for stainless steel of the
values for fusion welding without wire can 300 series (e.g. 316 L), but the results can
be transposed for other materials. Recent
power sources like the P 4 and P 6 are
equipped with software to calculate weld
parameter values automatically if the par-
ticular application cannot be found in their
integrated library.
In any case, the validity of the calculated
results must be confirmed by test welds.
Materials with the same designation, and
of an equal nominal composition, may still
have very different welding properties (see
also chapter 14.7 - Chemical composition
Menu to access existing weld procedures and repeatability of welds).
or calculated parameters
37
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
38
THE ART OF WELDING
14.6. Backing gas
During orbital welding, the inner surface nated by moisture, oxygen, particles or
of the tubes must be protected against oxi- other contaminants.
dation. Therefore, the interior of the tube During welding, the specified values of flow
system is purged by backing gas. The purity rate and internal pressure of the backing
of the backing gas depends on the required gas must be respected and kept constant.
weld quality. Before the weld can be started, The internal pressure must be controlled
a sufficient purge time must elapse, allow- because excessive pressure will produce
ing the backing gas to remove the oxygen a root weld with a concave surface at the
out of the system. The remaining oxygen outside or, even worse, cause a weld bead
content of the backing gas can be ana- short circuit.
lysed at the outlet; if it has decreased to an
If tubes with small diameters below
acceptable value, the welding operation can
9.52mm (3/8") are welded, the internal
begin. Usually in the case of UHP applica-
pressure can be used to prevent any excess
tions (Ultra High Purity) the oxygen level
of convexity or inside diameter reduction.
must fall below 10 PPM (Parts per Million),
i.e. less than 0.001%. Expert information: A light heat tint, due
Expert information: The supply of ultra- to remaining oxygen in the backing gas, can
pure process gas requires that it passes be removed by passivation.
through the tubes without being contami-
Influence of oxygen
content in the backing gas
on the colouration of the
root weld
39
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
For orbital welding with additional filler wire, standard equipment with 4 controlled axes
(shielding gas flow, weld current intensity, torch rotation speed and wire feeding speed) or
with 6 axes (4 axes + AVC and oscillation) can be used.
Independently from economic or other project-related considerations, the table below
shows the technical requirements for 4 or 6 axes equipment to be used:
Type of equipment
Criterion 4 axes 6 axes
Wall thickness small (< 4 mm) + +
to be welded medium and thick (> 4 mm) - +
reduced + -
Accessibility
free + +
simple + +
Weld sequence
difficult - +
low + +
Level of automation
high - +
40
THE ART OF WELDING
In the case of reduced accessibility of the tation of the welding tool is required, the
work area, equipment with 4 controlled equipment with 6 controlled axes should be
axes should be preferred. If easy implemen- the choice that is always recommended.
30 ° 30 °
Tube range Angle Collar
(mm) (°) (mm)
Wall thickness A T L
(mm)
3≤E≤6 30° 1
Tube end preparation commonly
used for manual tube welding 6≤E≤10 30° ou 20° 2
1,5
10≤E≤15 20°
41
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
To remove all traces of Rust as well as Oil, of magnetism or at least a very low flux
Carbon or Calamine Oxide Scale, the inside density (less than 3 gauss) is acceptable.
and the outside of tubes made from carbon Otherwise, welding problems or defects
steel must be machined. (lack of penetration, lateral sticking or
Expert information: Metals which can be porosity) can occur.
magnetised must be inspected: no remnant
42
THE ART OF WELDING
Multilayer welding with the stringer bead manual interventions. With the AVC func-
technique is quite complicated and time- tion the distance between electrode and
consuming, as the process has to be inter- workpiece is controlled, the oscillation
rupted after each pass and mechanical allows coverage of the entire joint width or
adjustments need to be made: the lateral to position the torch laterally. Once the torch
position of the torch and the distance is positioned above the joint, the electrode
between the previous pass and the elec- will be centred in the gap automatically. The
trode must be corrected. These adjustments different passes of a weld can be chained,
can only be executed if the particular parts the winding up of the hose and supply
of the welding head are accessible in its cables can also be executed automatically,
working position. and so the operator is not distracted by
Welding equipment with six controlled axes repetitive actions and can fully concentrate
significantly reduces the time required for on supervising the welding process
Backing gas: type, purity, flow rate Ground cable position and
connection.
Gas lens: type and size
43
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
Orbital GTAW welding with cold wire is relatively low (0.15 to 0.5 kg/h). In order to
an adequate choice for standard applica- boost the efficiency of the process it is pos-
tions which require high quality levels but sible to use the narrow groove or/and the
compared to other arc welding processes, hot wire technique.
the deposition rate of the TIG process is
44
THE ART OF WELDING
Expert information: The narrow groove technique is not recommended for those base
materials being sensitive to hot cracking.
-
15.10.2. Hot wire TIG welding
Increasing productivity without quality losses
can be achieved using the hot wire TIG pro-
cess. In this case, the filler wire is heated up
-
by an additional current. This hot wire cur-
rent is supplied by a second power source.
+
The hot wire technique leads to appreci- +
able higher deposition rates, i.e. 1 kg /h for
orbital welding and much more for cladding
applications. Principle of Hot Wire TIG welding
45
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
Nearly all weldable metals and alloys are and 38.1 mm (1.5") with wall thicknesses
used in the field of tube-to-tubesheet between 1.65 mm and 3.4 mm.
applications, but the range of the tube
dimensions is relatively restricted. Their Boilers and heat exchangers are used in
diameter range covers 12.7 mm to all kinds of industries, whereas the heavi-
101.6 mm, the wall thicknesses are between est equipment is found in the plants of the
0.5 mm and 5 mm. Most of the tube diam- chemical or petrochemical industries and in
eters measure between 19.05 mm (3/4") electric power stations.
In most cases, the welding equipment used * Portable power sources are rarely used for
for tube-to-tubesheet welding is strictly these applications: there is no need for the
adapted to the kind of application and the machines to be carried.
desired level of automation:
2- The welding equipment, including four
1- Welding equipment featuring three controlled axes (gas, current, rotation,
controlled axes (gas, current, rotation) is wire), is composed of a stationary installed
composed of a stationary installed power power source and an open welding head.
source* and a closed welding head. This The equipment is suitable for single pass
equipment allows for the execution of fusion welding; two passes must be welded in two
welding without addition of filler wire. separate steps.
3- The welding equipment fitted with
five controlled axes (gas, current, rotation,
wire, AVC) is composed of a power source
designed to control 6 axes and a welding
head of the type TS 8/75 with AVC configu-
ration. The equipment allows the chaining
of multiple passes with filler wire, the rais-
ing of the torch between the passes can also
be programmed and is carried out without
interruption of the weld cycle.
46
THE ART OF WELDING
4 - Welding equipment furnished with six
controlled axes, (gas, current, rotation, wire,
AVC, oscillation), comprises a PC Power
Source and a welding head of the type
20/160. The equipment allows multi-pass
welding (two or more passes); the torch can
be displaced in radial direction.
47
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
3 - In some cases, if a good thermal conduc- sion and the tube diameter at the expanded
tion is requested, the play between the tube zone as well as the original diameter.
and the bore must be eliminated by a slight 4- The contact zone between the tube and
expansion of the tube. Play is necessary the tubesheet must be clean. Grease, oil or
for the assembly of the apparatus before other residues from the tube manufactur-
the welds are carried out, but if clearances ing or machining can cause the formation
become too great, problems of repeatability of unacceptable blowholes, with outlets on
may occur. However, it is difficult to specify the surface or closed in the welds.
a maximum amount of play; it depends on
5- A strong expansion of the tubes inside
the demanded weld quality and the thick-
the tubesheet must never be carried out
ness of the tube.
before automatic welding. A strong expan-
Expert information: To get optimised cen- sion (with or without longitudinal grooves
tring tools for the tube-to-tubesheet welding in the bore) causes almost always explosive
heads, each order must be accompanied by degassing effects which make automatic
information about the depth of the expan- welding impossible.
Depending on the application, orbital welding of flush tubes with or without filler metal is
possible. Different joint designs are shown below:
1 – Standard preparation 3 – V-preparation
2 – J-preparation 4 – Relief groove
1 2 3 4
48
THE ART OF WELDING
16.4.2. Welding of flush tubes with addition of filler wire
Welding equipment fitted with four or five Expert information: The AVC function is
controlled axes can be used for this appli- recommended especially for the welding of
cation; the open tube-to-tubesheet welding flush tubes.
head should be configured with devices Generally, the tube end preparations are of
adapted to the requirements: the type 1, 2 or 3. If a preparation of the
Integrated or external wire feeder tubesheet is carried out, the V-joint can be
With or without AVC avoided. With this type of preparation, there
is always the risk of incomplete penetration
With or without shielding gas cham-
of the root. A J-preparation (with or without
ber (for the welding of titanium or
radius) should be preferred, if the depth of
zirconium)
the bevelled edge exceeds 1.5 mm, the tube
Torch angle of 0° or 15°. end should be positioned at the half of it.
The maximum value of the tube end to be
recessed is 50% of the tube thickness, the
tube becomes flush by the weld.
Depending on the dimensions and the
required weld thickness one or two passes
are necessary. One tour of the torch is
always applied in case of a pass for tight-
ness; the layers for mechanical resistance
often require a second tour.
Protruding tubes are always welded with addition of filler wire, but in some cases the weld
is beginning with a fusion pass. As shown below, different joint designs are possible.
A B C
49
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
Welding equipment fitted with four or five In any case, to avoid melting down the tube
controlled axes can be used for this applica- edge, the tube length measured from the
tion. Depending on the pitch and the pro- ground of the groove must exceed at least
truding distance, the torch inclination may 5 mm.
be varied. Standard torch angles are 15° or Remarque: If equipment fitted with five
30°: controlled axes is used, the AVC has to be
torches with an angle of 15° are pref- operated in the relative height mode. Thus
erentially used in case of thin-walled tubes it is possible to adjust the distance between
(1.6 mm to 2.11 mm), thus melting the electrode and tube plate to get the best
inside can be avoided result; independently of the torch position.
torches with an angle of 30° are applied
for thick-walled tubes (from 2.5 mm
onwards) if there is sufficient space with
regard to the tubes around (reduced pitch).
+X
50
Special attention must be paid to the training of the operators; differently to orbital tube-to-
tube welding, where the mechanical adjustments of torch and wire guide are carried out in
the same plane, tube-to-tubesheet welding requires three-dimensional operation.
α
Se
50
THE ART OF WELDING
16.6. Welding of recessed tubes
D E F G
51
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
To avoid gap corrosion between the tube and the tubesheet, gapless joints are welded from the
inside of the tubes at the backside of the plate. This type of application requires extended accu-
racy of the workpiece preparation and welding. Some possible joint designs are shown below:
X Y Z
A joint preparation of the type X is not rec- tion of the type X, where the tube end is
ommended: the greater mass difference positioned sufficiently deep in the bore (e.g.
between the tube and the plate excludes half of the tube wall thickness), a root pro-
the possibility to achieve a sufficient tection is not necessary. The protection can
penetration. be provided by flooding the entire apparatus
The joint preparation of the type Y over- with inert gas or, if the backside of the plate
comes the penetration problem by creating is accessible, by a local protection applied
a welding zone with a better balanced mass tube after tube.
of the tube and the plate. With a tube I.D. of more than about 35 mm,
For three reasons, by the joint preparation the use of welding tools with filler metal is
of the type Z the weld conditions become possible.
quite similar to those of a standard orbital
tube-to-tube weld operation:
By the recess the tube is aligned on the
bore.
Melting down the collar offers some
additional metal which increases the
mechanical strength of the weld.
The concave form of the weld is
reduced.
Expert information: Unlike classic tube-
to-tubesheet applications, the internal bore
welding operations behind the tubesheet
require a gas protection of the root, (at the Example of welding recessed tubes
outside of the tube). Only with a prepara- to a tubesheet
52
THE ART OF WELDING
If relatively thick walled tubes of 3 mm to Welding equipment fitted with three or four
3.6 mm, (depending on the base material), controlled axes can be used for this applica-
are to be welded, a horizontal weld posi- tion, in the case of a joint preparation of the
tion with the plate at the bottom with the type X, five controlled axes are necessary.
welding head also horizontally positioned, is The welding heads must be equipped with
recommended. a particular lance for internal bore welding
The distance from the face of the plate Similar application: If nipples have to be
to the welding joint must be very precise, welded on a collector, (this is typical applica-
(close tolerance). The operator cannot see tion in the field of power plant equipment
the torch position inside the tube, he has construction), identical base materials are
no possibility of adjustment and he cannot used, and the joint preparation and the pre-
watch the welding process. cautions to be taken are similar to those of
The weldability problems resemble those internal bore welding behind the tubesheet.
discussed in Chapter 1.4 for tube-to-tube
fusion welding.
17. Conclusion
At the end of this booklet, it remains to Finally, due to the confidence of the clients
underline once again the importance of and hence the shared experience of solving
orbital TIG (GTAW) welding if sophisticated technical problems, Polysoude has become
applications require reliable outstanding the market leader in mechanised and auto-
joint quality. For several decades, the French mated TIG welding equipment. The sales
company Polysoude has developed and department, the engineering and the appli-
manufactured appropriate gear and can cation service would highly appreciate par-
offer a wide range of standard machines or ticipating in your welding activities.
adapt it for specific demands. The modular
design of the devices, i.e. welding heads
and power sources, allows the proposal of
tailor-made solutions to exigent customers,
always taking into consideration the special
constraints of the particular project.
53
THE ART OF WELDING
T H E O R B I TA L W E L D I N G H A N D B O O K
Notes
54
THE ART OF WELDING
Notes
55
THE ART OF WELDING
Your partners worldwide
ARGENTINA GREAT BRITAIN MEXICO SINGAPORE
POLYSOUDE S.A.S. POLYSOUDE UK ASTRO ARC POLYSOUDE INC. POLYSOUDE SINGAPORE
+33 (0) 2 40 68 11 00 +44 (0) 1942 820 935 +1 (0) 661 702 0141 OFFICE
AUSTRALIA GREECE NETHERLANDS +65 0734 8452
POLYSOUDE S.A.S. POLYSOUDE S.A.S. POLYSOUDE BENELUX SLOVAKIA
+33 (0) 2 40 68 11 00 +33 (0) 2 40 68 11 00 +31 (0) 653 84 23 36 POLYSOUDE CZ
AUSTRIA HUNGARY POLYSOUDE BENELUX +42 (0) 602 602 855
POLYSOUDE AUSTRIA GmbH POLYWELD Kft. (SERVICE) SOUTH AFRICA
+43 (0) 3613 2 00 36 +36 (0) 20 29 88 708 +31 (0) 653 38 85 58 POLYSOUDE S.A.S.
BELGIUM INDIA NEW ZEALAND +33 (0) 2 40 68 11 00
POLYSOUDE BENELUX POLYSOUDE INDIA POLYSOUDE S.A.S. SOUTH KOREA
+31 (0) 653 84 23 36 +91 (0) 20 400 35 931 +33 (0) 2 40 68 11 00 CHEMIKO CO. Ltd
POLYSOUDE BENELUX +82 (0) 2 567 5336
(SERVICE) SPAIN
+31 (0) 653 38 85 58 POLYSOUDE IBERIA OFFICE
BRAZIL +34 609 154 683
AJADE COMÉRCIO INSTALAÇÕES
SWEDEN
E SERVIÇOS Ltda
HALL & CO. INDUSTRI
+55 (0) 11 4524 3898
+45 (0) 39 59 06 76
BULGARIA
SWITZERLAND
KARWELD EOOD
+359 (0) 29 73 32 15 POLYSOUDE
(SWITZERLAND) INC.
CANADA
+41 (0) 43 243 50 80
MAG TOOL - West
Update 03/2016
+1 800 661 9983 TAIWAN R.O.C.
FIRST ELITE ENT. CO. Ltd
MAG TOOL - East
+1 905 699 5016 +886 (0) 287 97 88 99
THAILAND
CHINA
POLYSOUDE SHANGHAI CO. POLYSOUDE S.A.S.
INDONESIA NORWAY +86 (0) 65 6862 60 08
LTD. POLYSOUDE SINGAPORE OFFICE TEMA NORGE S.A.S.
+86 (0) 21 64 09 78 26 +65 0734 8452
TURKEY
+47 (0) 51 69 25 00 EGE MAKINE
CROATIA ISRAEL
EUROARC D.O.O.
PAKISTAN +90 (0) 212 237 36 00
Polysoude S.A.S.
ZI du Bois Briand • 2 rue Paul Beaupère
44300 NANTES - FRANCE
Tel. : +33 (0) 2 40 68 11 00 • Fax: +33 (0) 2 40 68 11 88
THE ART OF WELDING www.polysoude.com