S.A. ENGINEERING COLLEGE, CHENNAI-600 077.

(An Autonomous Institution, Affiliated to Anna University)

Accredited by NAAC 'A'Grade, NBA Accredited

& ISO 9001:2015 Certified Institution

DEPARTMENT OF COMPUTER SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING

LECTURE NOTES
Subject Code : GE8076

Subject Name : PROFESSIONAL ETHICS IN ENGINEERING

Academic Year : 2021-22 (EVEN)

Semester : VIII

Year/ Semester : IV/VIII

Submitted By :Ms.Rajalakshmi J, Ms.Belshia Jebamalar G,

Ms.Aloysie Anisha T

Faculty In-charge Signature of the HOD

 S.A.ENGINEERING COLLEGE
( An Autonomous Institution,Affiliated to Anna University)
DEPARTMENT OF COMPUTER SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING

VISION
To conceive our department as Centre of Academic Excellence by catering quality education with
ethical standards.

MISSION
To create a conducive atmosphere to achieve active professionalism by fortifying academic
proficiency with ethical standards and to enhance the confidence level to develop sustainable solutions
to upgrade the society forever.

PROGRAMME EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVES

1. To enable graduates to pursue higher education and research, or have a successful career in
industries associated with Computer Science and Engineering, or as entrepreneurs.
2. To ensure that graduates will have the ability and attitude to adapt to emerging technological
changes.

PROGRAMME SPECIFIC OUTCOMES

1. To analyze, design and develop computing solutions by applying foundational concepts of
Computer Science and Engineering.
2. To apply software engineering principles and practices for developing quality software for
scientific and business applications.
3. To adapt to emerging Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) to innovate ideas
and solutions to existing/novel problems.
 S.A.ENGINEERING COLLEGE
( An Autonomous Institution,Affiliated to Anna University)
DEPARTMENT OF COMPUTER SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING
PROGRAM OUTCOMES (POs)
Engineering Graduates will be able to:
1. Engineering knowledge: Apply the knowledge of mathematics, science, engineering fundamentals, and an
engineering specialization to the solution of complex engineering problems.
2. Problem analysis: Identify, formulate, review research literature, and analyze complex engineering
problems reaching substantiated conclusions using first principles of mathematics, natural sciences, and
engineering sciences.
3. Design/development of solutions: Design solutions for complex engineering problems and design system
components or processes that meet the specified needs with appropriate consideration for the public health
and safety, and the cultural, societal, and environmental considerations.
4. Conduct investigations of complex problems: Use research-based knowledge and research methods
including design of experiments, analysis and interpretation of data, and synthesis of the information to
provide valid conclusions.
5. Modern tool usage: Create, select, and apply appropriate techniques, resources, and modern engineering
and IT tools including prediction and modeling to complex engineering activities with an understanding of
the limitations.
6. The engineer and society: Apply reasoning informed by the contextual knowledge to assess societal,
health, safety, legal and cultural issues and the consequent responsibilities relevant to the professional
engineering practice.
7. Environment and sustainability: Understand the impact of the professional engineering solutions in
societal and environmental contexts, and demonstrate the knowledge of, and need for sustainable
development.
8. Ethics: Apply ethical principles and commit to professional ethics and responsibilities and norms of the
engineering practice.
9. Individual and team work: Function effectively as an individual, and as a member or leader in diverse
teams, and in multidisciplinary settings.
10. Communication: Communicate effectively on complex engineering activities with the engineering
community and with society at large, such as, being able to comprehend and write effective reports and
design documentation, make effective presentations, and give and receive clear instructions.
11. Project management and finance: Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the engineering and
management principles and apply these to one’s own work, as a member and leader in a team, to manage
projects and in multidisciplinary environments.
12. Life-long learning: Recognize the need for, and have the preparation and ability to engage in independent
and life-long learning in the broadest context of technological change.
 S.A.ENGINEERING COLLEGE, CHENNAI 600 077
DEPARTMENT OF CSE
NAME OF FACULTY: Ms.Rajalakshmi J,Ms.Belshia Jebamalar G,Ms.Aloysie Anisha T
YEAR/SEMMESTER : IV/VIII CSE A, B, C
SUBJECT CODE/ NAME : GE6075- PROFESSIONAL ETHICS IN ENGINEERING
ACADEMIC YEAR : 2021-2022(EVEN)

COURSE OBJECTIVES:
The student should be made to:
● To understand the moral values that ought to guide the engineering profession
● To resolve the moral issues in the profession of engineering
● Justify the moral judgment concerning the profession.

COURSE OUTCOMES:
Upon the successful completion of the Course, the Student would be able to

GE8076.1: Ability to understand the values and ethics

GE8076.2: Ability to understand the moral issues.
GE8076.3: Ability to understand the codes of ethics.
GE8076.4: Ability to understand the concept of safety and rights
GE8076.5: Ability to understand the moral leadership.
.
CO PO PO PO PO PO PO PO PO PO PO PO PO PSO PSO
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2
GE8076.1 3 2
GE8076.2 3 2 1 1 2 2 1 2

GE8076.3 2 1 1 1 1 2

GE8076.4 2 1 1
GE8076.5 2 1 1

Enter correlation levels as 1,2,and 3

1 Slight(Low) 2 Moderate (Medium) 3 Substantial (High)

COs PSO1 PSO2 PSO3

GE8076.1 1 1
GE8076.2 1 1
GE8076.3 1 1
GE8076.4 1 1
GE8076.5 1 1
GE8076 PROFESSIONAL ETHICS IN ENGINEERING

COURSE OBJECTIVES:
• To understand the moral values that ought to guide the engineering profession
● To resolve the moral issues in the profession of engineering
● Justify the moral judgment concerning the profession.

UNIT I HUMAN VALUES 10

Morals, values and Ethics – Integrity – Work ethic – Service learning – Civic virtue – Respect for others –
Living peacefully – Caring – Sharing – Honesty – Courage – Valuing time – Cooperation – Commitment –
Empathy – Self confidence – Character – Spirituality – Introduction to Yoga and meditation for professional
excellence and stress management.

UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS 9

Senses of ‗Engineering Ethics‘ – Variety of moral issues – Types of inquiry – Moral dilemmas –
Moral Autonomy – Kohlberg‘s theory – Gilligan‘s theory – Consensus and Controversy – Models of
professional roles – Theories about right action – Self-interest – Customs and Religion – Uses of
Ethical Theories.

UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION 9

Engineering as Experimentation – Engineers as responsible Experimenters – Codes of Ethics – A Balanced

Outlook on Law..

UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS 9

Safety and Risk – Assessment of Safety and Risk – Risk Benefit Analysis and Reducing Risk – Respect for
Authority – Collective Bargaining – Confidentiality – Conflicts of Interest – Occupational Crime – Professional
Rights – Employee Rights – Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) – Discrimination.

UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES 8

Multinational Corporations – Environmental Ethics – Computer Ethics – Weapons Development – Engineers as

Managers – Consulting Engineers – Engineers as Expert Witnesses and Advisors – Moral Leadership –Code of
Conduct – Corporate Social Responsibility..

COURSE OUTCOMES:

At the end of the course, the students should be able to:

● Ability to understand the values and ethics
● Ability to understand the moral issues.
● Ability to understand the codes of ethics.
● Ability to understand the concept of safety and rights
● Ability to understand the moral leadership.
TEXT BOOKS:-
1. Mike W. Martin and Roland Schinzinger, Ethics in Engineering, Tata McGraw Hill, New Delhi,2003.
2. Govindarajan M, Natarajan S, Senthil Kumar V. S, Engineering Ethics, Prentice Hall of India, New Delhi, 2004
REFERENCES:

1. Charles B. Fleddermann, ―Engineering Ethics, Pearson Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 2004.

2. Charles E. Harris, Michael S. Pritchard and Michael J. Rabins, ―Engineering Ethics – Concepts and Cases,
Cengage Learning, 2009.

3. John R Boatright, ―Ethics and the Conduct of Business, Pearson Education, New Delhi, 2003

4. Edmund G Seebauer and Robert L Barry, ―Fundamentals of Ethics for Scientists and Engineers, Oxford
University Press, Oxford, 2001.

5. Laura P. Hartman and Joe Desjardins, ―Business Ethics: Decision Making for Personal Integrity and Social
Responsibility Mc Graw Hill education, India Pvt. Ltd.,New Delhi, 2013.

6. World Community Service Centre, Value Education‘, Vethathiri publications, Erode, 2011.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

Morals, values and Ethics – Integrity – Work ethic – Service learning – Civic virtue – Respect for
others – Living peacefully – Caring – Sharing – Honesty – Courage – Valuing time – Cooperation –
Commitment – Empathy – Self confidence – Character – Spirituality – Introduction to Yoga and
meditation for professional excellence and stress management.

What are human values?

Human values are basic moral values one have to posses to live as a citizen or as a person
The key principles that compose the foundation of Human values are:
1. The inborn dignity of human life
2. Respect and consideration for the other
3. The interconnection between people and the environment and thus the need to take care for and
preserve the earth
4. Importance of integrity and service
5. An attitude of non – violence
6. Peace and Happiness
Human values and sub values
The tree of Human values

The Human have been broadly classified keeping the following values
a. Love : it is the under current that flows through and support the other four values
b. Truth : Love in speech
c. Right conduct : Love in action
d. Peace : Love in thought
e. Non violence : Love in understanding
Theory of Human values

This can be achieved by silence, prayers, storytelling , group singing and group activities
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

Five Human values and 108 sub values is been framed by Sathya Sai Baba and he want us to follow
them to have a pleasant life. IN SathyaSai association April 24th of every year is celebrated has Human
value day.
Love Truth Right conduct Peace Non violence
Love in speech Love in action Love in thought Love in
understanding
Bliss, Consciousness, Cleanliness, Attention, Appreciation of
caring, creativity, contentment, calm, other cultures and
compassion, curiosity, courage, concentration, religions,
dedication, discrimination, dependability, contentment, brotherhood,
devotion, equality, duty, dignity, ceiling on desires,
empathy, honesty, ethics, discipline, citizenship,
friendship, integrity, gratitude, endurance, compassion,
forgiveness, intuition, goals, focus, concern for all life,
generosity, natural good behaviour, happiness, consideration,
helping, environment, healthy living, honesty, co-operation,
human dignity, optimism, helpfulness, humility, forgiveness,
inner happiness, quest for initiative, inner silence, global awareness,
joy, knowledge, leadership, reflection, good manners,
kindness, reason, perseverance, satisfaction, inclusiveness,
patience, self-analysis, time management, self-acceptance, loyalty,
purity, self-knowledge, resourcefulness, self-confidence, national awareness,
sharing, self-worth, respect, self-control, recycling,
sincerity, sense control, responsibility, self-discipline, respect for
sympathy, spirit of inquiry, sacrifice, self-respect, property,
tolerance, synthesis, self-sufficiency, understanding, service to other,
wisdom (21) truthfulness, self-confidence, care for social justice,
unity in thought simplicity (22) environment, sustainable growth,
word and deed, national universal love,
unity in diversity responsibility (22) unwilling to hurt
(21) (22)
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

1 Morals, values and ethics

1.1. Morals:

Definition
a. Moral refers to the generally accepted standards of right or wrong in a society.
b. Moral refers to the standards of right conduct and the judgment of particular actions as right or
wrong by those standards.
c. Moral theory is a set of moral principals which systematically links moral beliefs to one other.
Characteristic of Moral value
✔ Moral value can exist only in free personal being and in that person’s voluntary or human acts
✔ Moral value in universal in the sense that what one holds for all in the same conditions
✔ Moral value in self justifying
✔ Moral value has importance over every other value
✔ Moral value implies obligation
1.2. Values
Definition
Humans have the unique ability to define their identity, choose their values and establish their beliefs. All
three of these directly influence a person’s behavior. People have gone to great lengths to demonstrate the
validity of their beliefs, including war and sacrificing their own life! Conversely, people are not motivated to
support or validate the beliefs of another, when those beliefs are contrary to their own. People will act
identical with their personal values or what they deem to be important
1. A value is defined as a principle that promotes well-being or prevents harm.
2. Values are our guidelines for our success
3. Personal values are defined as: “Emotional beliefs in principles regarded as particularly
favorable or important for the individual.” Our values associate emotions to our experiences and
guide our choices, decisions and actions.
4. “Values are the scales we use to weigh our choices for our actions, whether to move towards
or away from something.”
Types of Values
The five core human values are: (1) Right conduct, (2) Peace, (3) Truth, (4) Love, and (5)
Nonviolence.
1. Values related to RIGHT CONDUCT are:
a) SELF-HELP SKILLS: Care of possessions, diet, hygiene, modesty, posture, self reliance, and tidy
appearance
b) SOCIAL SKILLS: Good behavior, good manners, good relationships, helpfulness, No wastage,
and good environment, and
c) ETHICAL SKILLS: Code of conduct, courage, dependability, duty, efficiency, ingenuity,
initiative, perseverance, punctuality, resourcefulness, respect for all, and responsibility
2. Values related to PEACE are: Attention, calmness, concentration, contentment, dignity, discipline,
equality, equanimity, faithfulness, focus, gratitude, happiness, harmony, humility, inner silence,
optimism, patience, reflection, satisfaction, self-acceptance, self-confidence, self-control, self-discipline,
self-esteem, self-respect, sense control, tolerance, and understanding
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

3. Values related to TRUTH are: Accuracy, curiosity, discernment, fairness, fearlessness, honesty,
integrity (unity of thought, word, and deed), intuition, justice, optimism, purity, quest for knowledge,
reason, self-analysis, sincerity, sprit of enquiry, synthesis, trust, truthfulness, and determination.
4. Values related to LOVE are: Acceptance, affection, care, compassion, consideration, dedication,
devotion, empathy, forbearance, forgiveness, friendship, generosity, gentleness, humanness,
interdependence, kindness, patience, patriotism, reverence, sacrifice, selflessness, service, sharing,
sympathy, thoughtfulness, tolerance and trust
5. Values related to NON-VIOLENCE are:
a) PSYCHOLOGICAL: Benevolence, compassion, concern for others, consideration, forbearance,
forgiveness, manners, happiness, loyalty, morality, and universal love
b) SOCIAL: Appreciation of other cultures and religions, brotherhood, care of environment, citizenship,
equality, harmlessness, national awareness, perseverance, respect for property, and social justice.
6. PERSEVERANCE is defined as persistence, determination, resolution, tenacity, dedication,
commitment, constancy, steadfastness, stamina, endurance and indefatigability. To persevere is
described as to continue, carry on, stick at it (in formal), keep going, persist, plug away, (informal),
remain, stand firm, stand fast, hold on and hang on. Perseverance builds character.
7. ACCURACY means freedom from mistake or error; conformity to truth or to a standard or model and
exactness. Accuracy is defined as correctness, exactness, authenticity, truth, veracity, closeness to truth
(true value) and carefulness. The value of accuracy embraces a large area and has many implications.
Engineers are encouraged to demonstrate accuracy in their behavior through the medium of praise and
other incentives. Accuracy includes telling the truth, not exaggerating, and taking care over one’s work.
8. DISCERNMENT means discrimination, perception, penetration, and insight. Discernment means the
power to see what is not obvious to the average mind. It stresses accuracy, especially in reading
character or motives. Discrimination stresses the power to distinguish or select what is true or genuinely
excellent. Perception implies quick and often sympathetic discernment, as of shades of feelings
Penetration implies a searching mind that goes beyond what is obvious or superficial. Insight suggests
depth of discernment.

Characteristics of Values
✔ Values are bipolar, with a positive and negative pole such as pleasant, painful, easy, difficult, strong,
weak, rich, poor, beautiful, ugly, true, false, good and bad. The positive pole is the one preferred and
the negative pole is disvalue
✔ Value are nt homogenous
✔ Value should exist
✔ Value or worth is a term used for anything that appeals to us in anyway.

1.3. Ethics /ethical – Set of moral principles

✔ Ethics is the word that refers to morals, values, and beliefs of the individuals, family or the society.
The word derives from the Greek word “ethos”, which means “the characteristic spirit or attitude
of a community, people or system”
✔ Ethics is systematic analysis of morality. It is the scientific evolvement and demonstration of
morality
✔ The study on ethics helps to know the people’s beliefs, values, and morals, learn the good and bad of
them, and practice them to maximize their well-being and happiness. It involves the inquiry on the
existing situations, form judgments and resolve the issues. In addition, ethics tells us how to live, to
respond to issues, through the duties, rights, responsibilities, and obligations.
✔ Ethics may be defined as the discipline that deals with what is right or wrong and doing the
right thing.
✔ Meaning of ethics:
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

Ethics in relation to other studies:

1. Psychology and ethics: Both of this deal with human behavior, with the abilities people has and the
acts they perform.
2. Anthropology and ethics: Both of these deals with human customs on various levels of culture and
civilization. This studies the origin and development of human customs without passing any
judgment on their moral rightness or wrongness.
3. Social sciences and ethics: Social sciences such as social, economic and political science deal with,
what they are and how they function and ethics decide it.
4. Law and ethics: the study of law is closely related with ethics. It goes with moral law and civil law.
The study of civil law deals with the acts what all is permitted and prohibited to us

Ethics can be again classified as:

● Ethics: A practical science - this deals with human form to develop inner clarity and to
apply intelligence wisely and thoughtfully in the ups and downs of everyday life experience
● Ethics in a pluralistic society: societies comprised of many sub groups or sub communities,
each of which has its own view of the morality good life. Here we have to know that a
mature persons are free to articulate and choose for themselves the life style, religious
benefits, moral convictions and sentiments they want as long as they do no harm to
others

1.4. Law:-
1) Law indicates rules and regulations to be obeyed in the organization.
2) Once the law is implemented in the organization then it is binding to the employees follows it.
3) Laws are rules in written format and governed by authority.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

The Importance of Integrity

● Integrity is used to refer to people who act in ways that are consistent with their own code of
principles.
● You often reflect on your principles when you consider what you “ought” to do in different
situations.

Ethics in the Business World

● Globalization of organizations has created a complex business world.
● Risk is the likelihood of a negative event time’s the impact of the event.

Why Business Ethics are Important

● Protect the organization and its employees from legal action.
● Create an organization that operates consistently.
● Produce good business.
● Avoid unfavourable publicity.
● Gain the goodwill of the community.
Code of Conduct

● A guide that highlights an organization’s key ethical issues and identifies the overarching values and
principles that are important to the organization and that can help in decision making.
● The code of conduct helps ensure that employees:
o Abide by the law.
o Follow necessary regulations.
o Behave in an ethical manner
Ethical Decision Making
1. Get the facts.
2. Identify the stakeholders and their positions.
3. Consider the consequences of your decision.
4. Weigh various guidelines and principles (Virtue, Utilitarian, Fairness, Common Good).
5. Develop and evaluate options.
6. Review your decision.
7. Evaluate the results of your decision.

Four Common Approaches Used in Ethical Decision-Making

Approach to dealing with Moral values Principle
Virtue ethics approach The ethical choice best reflects moral virtues in yourself
and your community
Utilitarian Approach The ethical choice produces the greatest excess of
benefits over harm.
Fairness approach The ethical choice treats everyone the same and shows no
Favoritism or discriminations
Common good The ethical choice advances the common good.

Ethics in Information Technology

● The increased use of information technology has raised many ethical issues for today’s IT
professional.
● Licensing of IT professionals
● Internet communication
● Intellectual property
● Employee/employer issues
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

1.5. Integrity
“Integrity is telling myself the truth”. – Spencer Johnson
● Integrity is defined as the unity of thought, word and deed (honesty) and open mindedness.
● It includes the capacity to communicate the factual information so that others can make well-
informed decisions. It yields the person’s ‘peace of mind’, and hence adds strength and consistency
in character, decisions, and actions.
● Integrity refers to a quality of a person’s character. When it is applied to object, it refers to the
wholeness , intactness or purity of a ting
● Integrity paves way to one’s success. It is one of the self-direction virtues. It enthuse people not only
to execute a job well but to achieve excellence in performance.
● It helps them to own the responsibility and earn self-respect and recognition by doing the job.
● Moral integrity is defined as a virtue (quality), which reflects a consistency of one’s attitudes,
emotions, and conduct in relation to justified moral values.
Integrity involves in two fundamental intuitions:
● It is primarily a formal relation one has to oneself
● It is connected in an important way to acting morally.
● Integrity is a bridge between responsibility in private and professional life. Integrity makes possible
the virtues of self-respect and pride in one’s work. It precludes the attitude that one is not personally
accountable for one’s work. It implies a concern for achieving excellence in the technical aspects of
one’s work, a strong desire to see the work done well. In turn, this desire constituted a potent
stimulus for professional conduct.
● Integrity is accounted in the following aspects
(i) Integrity as self-integration : Viewing integrity as self-integration is a practice of integrating
various parts of their personality into a harmonious use. It is a matter of keeping self intact and
without corruption.
(ii) Integrity as maintenance of identity: A specific identity has to be maintained in practicising
integrity. This action should be according to their commitments not based on certain acceptance of
desires.
(iii) Integrity as standing for something: Integrity should not be just an act of consistently but should
stand for something. As such the social character of integrity is a matter of a person’s proper regards
for their best judgment
(iv) Integrity as moral purpose: Integrity in terms of moral purpose is uses dedication to the pursuit of
a rural life.
(v) Integrity as a virtue: Integrity is a complex and thick virtue turn. Integrity stands as a mean to
various excesses.
Consider this Moral story for integrity
In Africa many years ago, there lived a great King. This king ruled his kingdom with wisdom and might, but
he had a problem. There was no child to succeed him when he dies. He had married many wives, but none of
them could give him a male child. He thought about it deeply and decided to choose a successor from the
kingdom. He told his town crier to make an announcement to all the villagers about his intention requesting
that they present just one of their children to come the next day at the village square so he could make his
selection.
The next day, the King's palace was filled to the edge with children from different homes in the community.
The King handed each of them a particular seed and told them to go home, plant their seeds in a jar and
nurse its growth for 8 months. Once the eight months were due, they should return to the palace and he
would access how well they've done, then select the best as his heir. There was a young boy from a poor
home named Ikeh who received his seed and returned to his village. When he got back, his mom helped him
to find a vessel and put some soil into it. Ikeh made sure he watered his pot every day. After each month, the
children of the villagers who were given the seed would gather and compare their plants. All the seeds of the
other kids have started sprouting and budding, but there was no sign of life in Ikeh's pot despite his efforts.
Ikeh was disappointed, but he kept watering his pot daily. A few months passed and now all the other
children's pot really came to life. Some had short trees growing in them, some had beautiful flowers and
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

some had leafy shrubs. Poor Ikeh still had nothing growing in his pot and the other children started to make
fun of him. They said he wasn't good enough and couldn't even grow a seed. They jeered at him and called
him names. Ikeh was unhappy, but he never for one day failed to water his pot.
Soon, the eight months was over. It was time for the king to choose his heir. Ikeh didn't want to go. He felt
there was no need and sat down crying. "I have watered this plant every day." "Why should I go to the
palace?" "I have nothing to show for it." Ikeh said to his mother with sadness on his face. His looked at him
in the eye and told him to return and show the King his barren vessel, no matter the consequences.
Ikeh reluctantly went to the palace where he met other children dressed in their best and carrying their well
grown plants with so much pride. He found more reasons to be sad from what he saw.
The wise King came out of his palace and started to walk through the crowd, looking at the many beautiful
trees, shrubs and flowers that were on display by the children. The boys all puffed their chests out and tried
to look as royal as possible, hoping that they would be chosen as the successor to the throne.
Then the King came across Ikeh, who was bowing his head in shame. He looked at his pot then he looked at
him closely. “What happened?” He asked.
“I watered the pot every day, but nothing ever grew.” Ikeh replied nervously.
Then the King smiled, nodded his head in admiration and moved on. After a few hours of reviewing other
children's plants, the Emperor finally completed his assessment.
He stood in front of the children and congratulated them on their efforts.
“Clearly, some of you desperately want to be my heir and would do anything to make that happen, but there
is one boy that I would like to point out as he has come to me with nothing. Ikeh, come here please.”
“Oh no,” thought Ikeh. There must be another boy with his name with a grown plant. But the King directed
his servants to bring him up. He slowly sauntered to the front of the group, holding his barren pot.
The King held up the vessel for all to see and the other children laughed. Then the King continued, “Eight
months ago, I gave you all a seed. I told you to go away, plant the seed and return with your plant. The seeds
that I gave you all were burnt up with fire until they were no longer useful and wouldn’t grow, then they
were coated to look like good seeds. Now, I see before me thousands of plants and only one barren pot."
Therefore, Ikeh is the successor to my throne.

Integrity is vital for success. Most people are ready to do anything to get successful, but few people
actually get there. Because those few people value their integrity. The people who are ready to do
anything often make serious mistakes which mar their chances of success. The fact that we want to
become successful does not mean we should not have value, sound principles, good judgment and
character. No!

1.6. Work Ethics

Definition: The work ethic is a cultural norm that advocates being personally accountable and
responsible for the work that one does and is based on belief that work has intrinsic value.
● Industry and Society are the two systems which interact with each other and are interdependent.
Society requires industry/business system which provides manufacturing, distribution and
consumption activities. It needs investment (capital input), labor (input), supply (raw materials),
production (industries, business organizations), marketing and distribution (transport), and
consumption (public, customer). A lot of transactions (and interactions) between these sub-
systems involving people are needed for the welfare of the society. It is here, the work ethics plays
an essential role.
● Work ethics is defined as a set of attitudes concerned with the value of work, which forms the
motivational orientation.
● The ‘work ethics’ is aimed at ensuring the economy (get job, create wealth, earn salary),
productivity (wealth, profit), safety (in workplace), health and hygiene (working conditions), privacy
(raise family), security (permanence against contractual, pension, and retirement benefits), cultural
and social development (leisure, hobby, and happiness), welfare (social work), environment (anti-
pollution activities), and offer opportunities for all, according to their abilities, but without
discrimination.
● Elements of work ethics:
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

o Interpersonal skills
o Imitative
o Being dependable
Many complex social problems exist in the industrial/business scenario, because:
● The people desire to be recognized as individuals and treated with dignity, as living human beings.
Work is intrinsically valuable so far as it is enjoyable or meaningful in allowing personal expression
and self-fulfillment. Meaningful work is worth doing for the sense of personal identity and the self-
esteem it holds.
● Economic independence: Work is the major instrumental good in life. It is the main source of
providing the income needed to avoid economic dependence on others, for obtaining desired
materials and services, and for achieving status and recognition from others.
● Privacy (personal freedom) of the employee, including women, is to be protected. At the same time,
confidentiality of the employer is also to be protected. Mutual trust and loyalty both ways play major
roles in this aspect.
● Security during job and upon retirement: This concept is being accepted only in government jobs,
public limited companies, and corporate organizations. The western thought has influenced the
Indian private industries and multinationals in a paradigm shift from ‘lifelong employment’ to
policies such as ‘merit only’, ‘hire and fire’, ‘pay and use’ etc. This situation has no doubt created
tension in the Indian scene.
● Recognition to non-work activities, such as leisure, paid holiday on the day of visit of a dignitary,
social service, and other developmental activities. The workers in prosperous countries are less
willing to consider ‘work’ as their prime interest in life. They claim that such service activities give
them peace of mind and happiness. However, such a trend is likely to decline the work ethics.
● Hard work and productivity are very essential for the success of an industry. The quality of work
life deserves to be improved. Hard labor, undignified jobs (human-drawn rikshaw, people carrying
night soil), and hazardous jobs are to be made less straining, dignified, and safer. Hard work
cannot be replaced by ‘virtual work”.
● A different view of work ethics: Work is considered as a necessary evil. It is a thing one must do in
order to avoid worse evils, such as dependency and poverty. That is a major source of anxiety and
unhappiness.
● To work (job), is not for monetary considerations only. Human beings believe that it is good to work.
Work is good for the body and mind. It promotes self-respect, self-esteem, good for the family, and
obligation to the society and allow the world to prosper. Work lays a moral and meaningful
foundation for life. That is why, work ethics affirms that, the work per se is worthy, admirable and
valuable at personal and social levels. It improves the quality of life and makes life purposeful,
successful, and happy.
● By work ethics, duties to the self, family, society, and nation are fulfilled. Rights of the individuals
are respected and nourished. Values and virtues are cultivated and enjoyed by all human beings.
Further, the quality of life is improved and the environment protected. On the other hand,
unemployment and under-employment lead to frustration, social tensions, and occasional militancy.
For a developing economy and society, like ours, we need to promote work ethics, at all levels, to
flourish as developed nation.

Short story for work ethics:

This is the story of first Indian lady army officer.
Daughter of a policeman was always inspired with the uniform of INDIAN POLICE. She always desired to
be there with her father, with uniform.One day in a school function, an army officer was called as Chief
Guest. Throughout the function, Man was appraised beyond levels for his bravery and medals he had with
him. All girls said" we will marry an army officer". But then came the voice from corner "I will become the
army officer".
This was priya jhinghan, who decided to serve Indian army. But it was the time in 1980s, where there was
no allocation for women in army. No internet or any family connections with army, but you can't stop the
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

desire which includes dedicated heart. She went Delhi to contact and wrote a letter to the army admiral of
India. After few days, she received a letter with approval to her request but just an unofficial one. There was
no official announcement of women recruitment in army.
But she continued to ask the army through various ways, letters and calls were the priorities. Family also
helped her but since she completed higher secondary, she moved to get degree from a law college. One day
when she was reading newspaper she read the news which gave her goose bumps. It was an announcement
calling applicants for women in army. Ahh that was the moment. She filled the form with all her
achievements and some answers. On first round 250 were selected. And after interviews, 25 were officially
recruited in army. But priya was the first cadet at merit list, admiral himself provided her the way towards
army headquarters.
Next was first day of training, but pain in abdomen increased. Priya was admitted to hospital and reported
that her kidney has multi stones. The worst throwback to her dreams. Doctors prescribed a full month bed
rest, but army rules stated that "if before joining, any officer has long term disorder or he/she suffers 6 days
in hospital, then the registration would be cancelled."
Priya knew that, so even with that killing pain, she said "I am absolutely fine and do not have any pain now".
Doctors discharged her, but then a hard training was waiting. A 2.5 km run with stones in kidney, who can
imagine of that. But her hormones beaten every else reaction of the body and she won the race.

● Service Learning
“It is time that the ideal of success should be replaced by the ideal of service” – Albert Einstein

Service learning is a teaching and learning strategy that integrates meaningful community service
with instruction and reflection to enrich the learning experience, teach civic responsibility, and
strengthen communities.
Service learning may be defined as the non-paid activity, in which service is provided on voluntary basis
to the public (have-nots in the community), non-profitable institutions, and charitable organizations. It is the
service during learning. This includes training or study on real life problems and their possible solutions,
during the formal learning, i.e., courses of study.
Service learning combines service objectives with learning objectives with the intent that the activity
changes both the recipient and the provider of the service. This is accomplished by combining service tasks
with structured opportunities that link the task to self-reflection, self-discovery, and the acquisition and
comprehension of values, skills, and knowledge content.
It is a tool used widely by sociologists to encourage students to make connections between classroom
learning and the larger community.
Service learning refers to learning the service policies, procedures, norms, and conditions, other than
‘the technical trade practices’. The service learning includes the characteristics of the work, basic
requirements, security of the job, and awareness of the procedures, while taking decisions and actions.
Short story for Service Learning
For example, if college students collect trash out of an urban streambed, they are providing a service
to the community as Volunteers; a service that is highly valued and important. When the students analyze
what they found in the trash bed and possible sources, they can share the results with residents of the
neighborhood along with suggestions for reducing pollution. Now we can say that they are engaging in
service-learning. In the service-learning, the students are providing an important service to the community
and, at the same time, learning about water quality and laboratory analysis, developing an understanding of
pollution issues, learning to interpret science issues is to public and practicing communications skills by
speaking to residents. They may also reflect on their personal and career interests in science, the
environment, public policy or other related areas. Thus, service learning combines SERVICE with
LEARNING in intentional ways.
Why Is Service-Learning Important?
Many surveys suggest that effective service-learning programs improve grades, increase
attendance in school/College, and develop students' personal and social responsibility. A growing
body of research recognizes service learning as an effective strategy to help students by:
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Promoting learning through active participation in service experiences;

● Providing structured time for students to reflect by thinking, discussing and writing about their service
experience;
● Providing an opportunity for students to use skills and knowledge in real-life situations;
● Extending learning beyond the classroom and into the community; and
● Fostering a sense of caring for others.
Service learning also strengthens both education and Iocal communities by:
● Building effective collaborative partnerships between schools or colleges and other institutions and
organizations;
● Engaging parents and other adults in .supporting student learning;
● Meeting community needs through the service projects conducted; and
● Providing engaging and productive opportunities for young people to work with others in their
community.
In the industrial scenario, adoption, study, and development of public health or welfare or safety
system of a village or school is an example of service learning by the employees. The engineering student
analyzing and executing a socially-relevant project is another example of service learning.
The service learning is a methodology falling under the category of experiential education. It is one
of the forms of experiential learning and community service opportunities. It is distinguished in the
following ways:
a) Connection to curriculum: Integrating the learning into a service project is a key to successful service
learning. Academic ties should be clear and built upon existing disciplinary skills.
b) Learner’s voice: Beyond being actively engaged in the project, trainees have the opportunity to select,
design, implement, and evaluate their service activity.
c) Reflection: Structured opportunities are created to think, talk, and write about the service experience.
The balance of reflection and action allows the trainee to be constantly aware of the impact of their
work.
d) Partners in the community: Partnership with community agencies are used to identify genuine needs,
provide mentorship, and contribute input such as labor and expertise towards completing the project.
Service Learning Vs Volunteerism
Volunteer activities without learning component are equally important as service learning, but that
the two approaches are fundamentally different activities with different objectives. Both are valued
components of a national effort to increase citizen involvement in community service, and at every age.

Characteristics Of Service-Learning
● Service Learning links to academic content and standards.
● It involves young people in helping to determine and meet real, defined community needs.
● It is a reciprocal nature, benefiting both the community and the service provide by combining a
experience with a learning experience.
● It can be used in any subject area so long as It is appropriate to learning goal
● It works at all ages, even among young children
● It is positive, m e a n i n g f u l and real to the participants.
● It involves cooperative rather than competitive experiences and thus promo skills associated with
teamwork and community involvement and citizenship
● It offers powerful opportunities t o acquire the habits of critical thinking, i.e. ability to identify
the most Important questions or issues within a real-world situation.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

Differentiating Service-Learning from Other Forms of Education

● Experiential Learning: The knowledge and skills acquired through life, work experience and study
which have not been formally attested through any educational or professional certification.
● Internship: A work-related learning experience for individuals who wish to develop hands on work
experience in a certain occupational field
● Practicum: A college course that is designed to give students supervised practical application of a
previously studied theory

● Civic virtue
“Wisdom is knowing what to do next, virtue is doing it” – David Star Jordan

Definition: Civic v i r t u e is m o r a l i t y o r a standard of righteous behaviour in

relationship to a citizen's involvement in society.
● An individual may exhibit civic virtue by voting, volunteering and organizing other community
activities like group, or attending a public-oriented meeting.
● Civic means, "of, relating to, or belonging to a city, a citizen, or citizenship, municipal or civil
society" .
● Responsibility refers to "the state or quality of being responsible or something for which one is
responsible such as a duty, obligation or burden".
● A citizen is · a person owing loyalty to and entitled by birth or naturalization to the protection of a
state or union".
● Citizenship means "a productive, responsible, caring and contributing member of society
● Civic virtue or civic responsibility is comprised of actions and attitudes associated with d
e mo c r a t i c governance a n d s o c i a l participation.
● Civic responsibility can include participation in government, church, volunteers a n d
memberships of voluntary associations. Actions of civic responsibility can be displayed in
advocacy for various c a u s e s , such as political, economic, civil, and environmental or quality of
life issues.

What are civic virtues

Civic virtues are the moral duties and rights, as a citizen of the village or the country or an integral part of
the society and environment. An individual may exhibit civic virtues by voting, volunteering, and organizing
welfare groups and meetings.
The duties are:
To pay taxes to the local government and state, in time.
To keep the surroundings clean and green.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Not to pollute the water, land, and air by following hygiene and proper garbage disposal. For
example, not to burn wood, tyres, plastic materials, spit in the open, even not to smoke in the open,
and not to cause nuisance to the public, are some of the civic (duties) virtues.
● To follow the road safety rules.
On the other hand, the rights are:
● To vote the local or state government.
● To contest in the elections to the local or state government.
● To seek a public welfare facility such as a school, hospital or a community hall or transport or
communication facility, for the residents.
● To establish a green and safe environment, pollution free, corruption free, and to follow ethical
principles. People are said to have the right to breathe in fresh air, by not allowing smoking in public.
● People have inalienable right to accept or reject a project in their area. One has the right to seek legal
remedy, in this respect, through public interest petition.

George Washington embodied the civic virtues as indispensable for a self-governing administration.
These virtues are divided into four categories:
a) Civic Knowledge: Citizens must understand what the Constitution says about how the government is
working, and what the government is supposed to do and what not to do. We must understand the basis
of our responsibilities as citizens, besides duties and rights. We must be able to recognize when the
government or another citizen infringes upon our rights. It implies that the government requires the
participation of the enlightened citizens, to serve and survive.
b) Self-Restraint: For citizens to live in a free society with limited government each citizen must be able to
control or restrain himself; otherwise, we would need a police state—that is, a dictatorial government to
maintain safety and order. He advocated for morality and declared that happiness is achieved and
sustained through virtues and morals. He advocated and demonstrated self-restraint several times in his
private and public life, and naturally he was a great leader.
c) Self-Assertion: Self-assertion means that citizens must be proud of their rights, and have the courage to
stand up in public and defend their rights. Sometimes, a government may seize the very rights that it was
created to protect. In such cases, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish that government (e.g.,
voting rights, rights call back).
d) Self-Reliance: Citizens who cannot provide for themselves will need a large government to take care of
them. Once citizens become dependent on government for their basic needs, the people are no longer in
a position to demand that government act within the confines of the Constitution. Only a strong self-
reliant citizenry will be able to enjoy fully the blessings of liberty. These civic virtues, applicable to local,
state, and central governments, nourish freedom and civil liberty at the root of democracy.

● Respect for others

● Respect is a feeling of admiration or deference toward a person, group, ideal, or indeed almost any
entity or concept, as well as specific actions and conduct representative of that esteem.
● Respect is of great importance in everyday life. As children we are taught to respect our parents,
teachers, and elders, school rules and traffic laws, family and cultural traditions, other
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

people's feelings and rights, our country's flag and leaders, the truth and people's differing opinions.
● Whether between spouses, friends, co-workers, or business acquaintances, if there is a history of
mutual respect and sincere gratitude, the people involved are generally happier and more successful.
We live in a world where there are many differences between people, but with an open mind and an
appreciation of each person’s contributions to this world, we strengthen our relationships and our
community.
● We may learn both that our lives together go better when we respect the things that deserve
to be respected and that we should respect some things independently of considerations of
how our lives would go.
Why Should W e Respect O t h e r s ?
● Having born as a human being and having been a member of the society, he has to be one
with the social environment which can be achieved with fellow beings and gives respect to
them.
● To be a happy individual, one has to adjust with his friends, relatives, neighbours, and
colleagues, etc and give due value to their ideas and actions. In fact being in society itself
means a community life which calls for mutual understanding, cooperation and respect.
● Others deserve our respect, o u r regard, our good thinking a b o u t them. It is our moral
duty to treat them with respect in order to spread joy and happiness in the family as well as
the society. O n e should live in proportion to ones standing i n society. This calls for higher
v a l u e s o f friendship, sacrifice. Empathy, sympathy, forgiveness, generosity. Patience.
tolerance, equality, integrity and satisfaction.
How to Show Respect
● Listen it sounds easy, but listening–truly listening–can be one of the hardest skills to master. If you
want a person to know you respect him or her, then tune into what that person is saying. Look them
in the eye and offer feedback when necessary. Everyone appreciates the person who willing listens
to them and shows genuine interest in what they have to say.
● Encourage If you’ve ever had a bad day, then you know the power a little encouragement can have.
We’ve all had moments when we need someone to tell us, “don’t worry, things will work out.” It
might not seem like much at the time, but that person will remember that you took the time and
● Congratulate If someone does a great job, let them know about it. In fact, let everyone know about
it. Openly congratulate someone for a job well done, especially if you’re a manager. Employees will
work harder and happier knowing their manager has a mutual respect for them and is willing to
express praise and gratitude when it’s deserved.
● Be Helpful If you find a friend or co-worker in a jam, be willing to help them if at possible. Not to
say you should take on half their project, but offering some advice or throwing in a bit of your time
will mean a lot. If that friend or co-worker has helped you in the past, then returning the favour will
be a nice way to show both your respect and gratitude.
● Say Thank You I’m sure this one seems like common sense, but many people just forget to say
thank you or at least forget how to say it with sincerity. A thank you can be as small as two words or
as much as buying someone a gift; nevertheless, if the action is not done with 100% sincerity then it
is wasted. Make sure people know you appreciate them and their actions. Simply saying
Moral story for Respect Elders
“Respect Your Elders”
“Do not let your parents down, they only brought you up"
Once there was a village named Singapuram. There lived a carpenter named Kasi. He had a younger son
who is five years old. His name was Vasu. Kasi’s father Ramu was too old and he also stayed with them in
their house. Kasi began to think that his father is of no use to him since he became too old and unable to do
any work. Kasi always spoke angrily to his father. Ramu was old man and he remained silently whenever
Kasi spoke in anger. One day, Kasi gave food in a clay plate for his father to eat. Being too old, Ramu was
not able to hold the clay plate properly. He dropped it down and the clay plate broke off. Kasi became so
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

much angry and scolded his father. Vasu observed this.

The next day, Kasi gave a new clay plate. He went to work. When he came back, he was angry to see the
new clay plate also broken into pieces. He scolded his father badly and warned him, “Hey old man, if you
break the next clay plate also, there will be no food for you and you have to leave the house”. Vasu was
listening to his father’s words silently. Next day, in the evening, he came back to home after his work. He
saw his son Vasu doing some work with his carpentry tools. He became surprised to see this and happily he
went near him, Kasi asked Vasu “What are you doing my son?” Vasu replied “Dad, I am making a wood
plate for you. When you become old, I will give you this wood plate so that you will not break it and I do not
have to send you out of the house”
Kasi realized his mistake on hearing his son’s words. He felt sorry for hurting his old aged father. He
apologised to his father for his mistakes and his angry words. Kasi, Vasu and his grandfather went into home
to have a nice dinner together.

● Living Peaceful
“Unless you can find some sort of loyalty, you cannot find unity and peace in your active living”
Josiah Royce

Moral story for Peace

A Legend goes that when God was creating Man he decided to bless him with exceptional talents, skills,
gifts in bounty and accessible to almost everything. When it came to peace, he decided to keep it in a place
where man could never reach it. There were many suggestions put forth. One thought was to place it high on
a mountain, beyond the reach of man. While one was to place it deep below in the ocean where man
wouldn't dare to fathom while another was to place it deep in a gorge, where man wouldn't go. God smiled
and said there is no such place on earth that man would not look for and reach it. The only place he could
find was in a man's mind. This is a place where man will never look and never find it. Most of us would
agree with it. Our past and present tells us about mans' adventure, conquests, inventions, research, giant
studies in science and technology. But when it comes to living peacefully as neighbors, as society, as
neighboring countries... it leaves much to be desired.

● To live peacefully, one should start install peace within (self). Charity begins at home. Then one can
spread peace to family, organization where one works, and then to the world, including the environment.
Only who are at peace can spread peace.

One should adopt the following means to live peacefully, in the world:
Nurture
1. Order in one’s life (self-regulation, discipline, and duty).
2. Pure thoughts in one’s soul (loving others, blessing others, friendly, and not criticizing or hurting others
by thought, word or deed).
3. Creativity in one’s head (useful and constructive).
4. Beauty in one’s heart (love, service, happiness, and peace).
Get
5. Good health/body (physical strength for service).
Act
6. Help the needy with head, heart, and hands (charity). Service to the poor is considered holier than the
service to God.
7. Not hurting and torturing others either physically, verbally, or mentally.
The following are the factors that promote living, with internal and external peace:
1. Conducive environment (safe, ventilated, illuminated and comfortable).
2. Secured job and motivated with ‘recognition and reward’.
3. Absence of threat or tension by pressure due to limitations of money or time.
4. Absence of unnecessary interference or disturbance, except as guidelines.
5. Healthy labor relations and family situations.
6. Service to the needy (physically and mentally-challenged) with love and sympathy.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Here are the steps which can help you to discover your journey towards living in peace.
o Seek to love, not control others. ...
o Find Your Inner Peace. ...
o Moderate your convictions. ...
o Be tolerant. ...
o Be Peace. ...
o Reflection of thought. ...
o Seek forgiveness, not revenge. ...
o Live in joy.
o Be the change you wish to see in the World.

● Caring
1. “Caring i s know ing, feeling, a n d acting in the interests of others”. - Forcey
2. “To care f o r another person is to help him/her grow and actualize h i m /herself”. - Milton Meyer
off.
3. “To be concerned about and to facilitate the growth and actualization of other people,
the planet, and even oneself”. - Harriet Heath.
4. Any t h o u g h t f u l human response (or non-response) that enables o t h e r s to thrive. -
Nel Noddings.

Moral Story For Caring Is In The Heart

In a ram-shackled house, far from the village, lived a young man who was mentally impaired. He was
always seen in the village, working hard to fill his old bag with discarded items and scraps of food. The
children of the village sneered at him; the elderly villagers looked down on him and scolded their children
from coming near him. One day, the villagers learned that the young man had passed away. He had died
alone. When they went to his house, they were surprised to find the man's parents, sickly and bed-ridden in
the lonely and secluded house. The shock of their discovery brought them to their senses. They quickly
realized that the young man whom they had disregarded in their village, despite his mental and physical
impairments, was devoted to taking care of his sick and bedridden parents until the day he died. With his
death, he taught the villagers a valuable lesson: We can never make assumptions about others, for sometimes
the most caring individuals are those we wouldn't suspect.

● Being caring allows you to have empathy for others and to live a life based on affection, love, and
compassion for the people around you. Being caring means providing a listening ear, noticing when
someone needs help, and helping your community without asking for a reward. If you want to know how
to be more caring today, see Steps to get started.
● To help others to actualize himself: To care for another person, in the most significant sense, is to
help him grow and actualize himself ... Caring is the antithesis of simply using the other person to
satisfy one's own needs",
● Caring is an extension of one's self. "In caring as helping the other grow, I
experience what I care for as an extension of myself and at the same time as something separate
from me that I respect in its own right. ... For a caring parent, the child is felt to have a worth
of his own apart from his power to satisfy the parent's needs. "
● Devotion and constancy are essential elements of carin:. "Devotion i s essential to
caring, just as it is an integral' part of friendship.
● Caring for another helps the other to care for and about others: To help another person
grow is at least to help him to care for something or someone apart from himself.
● Help in a way that the cared for can go on to help himself: Responsive to his own nee care
to become responsible for his own life
● Learning and living a life of caring involves all others: This disclose the relationship of
caring to other concepts like trust, honesty and humility
● Be polite: You don't have to be overly formal to be polite. You just have to be considerate of
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

other people and make them feel comfortable in your presence.

● Be affectionate: Actions really can speak louder than words sometimes. Though telling a person you
care can make a big difference, sometimes giving that person a hug or putting your arm around him or
her can have that extra impact.
● Listen to people: When someone is talking to you, make eye contact, put away your phone or other
distractions, and don't interrupt them

Caring Steps to get started

● Be more generous: Being generous, whether it's with your time or your money, can go a long way
in being a more caring person.
● Treat others like you want to be treated: If you want to be more caring, then you have to be kind
and thoughtful toward others, and think of how you would feel if you were in their shoes.
● Be considerate of others: Being considerate is another major aspect of being caring. If you want to
be considerate, then you have to respect the people around you, and to avoid making a nuisance of
yourself.

● Sharing
“These keys to more abundant living: caring about others, daring for others, sharing
with others”
“Happiness is not so much in having as sharing. We make a living by what we get, but we
make a life by what we give. Norman Maceven
● Caring influences ‘sharing’. Sharing is a process that describes the transfer of knowledge (teaching,
learning, and information), experience (training), commodities (material possession) and facilities
with others. The transfer should be genuine, legal, positive, voluntary, and without any expectation
in return.
● Through this process of sharing, experience, expertise, wisdom and other benefits reach more people
faster. Sharing is voluntary and it cannot be driven by force, but motivated successfully through
ethical principles. In short, sharing is ‘charity’
● For the humanity, ‘sharing’ is a culture. The ‘happiness and wealth’ are multiplied and the
‘crimes and sufferings’ are reduced, by sharing. It paves the way for peace and obviates militancy.
Philosophically, the sharing maximizes the happiness for all the human beings. In terms of
psychology, the fear, divide, and distrust between the ‘haves’ and ‘have-nots’ disappear.
● Sharing not only paves the way to prosperity, early and easily, and sustains it. Economically
speaking, benefits are maximized as there is no wastage or loss, and everybody gets one’s needs
fulfilled and satisfied. Commercially speaking, the profit is maximized.
● Technologically, the productivity and utilization are maximized by sharing.
● In the industrial arena, code-sharing in airlines for bookings on air travels and the common
● Effluent Treatment Plant constructed for small-scale industries in the industrial estates, are some of
the examples of sharing. The co-operative societies for producers as well as consumers are typical
examples of sharing of the goods, profit and other social benefits.
Moral story for Sharing
The shouting...the screaming…the fighting. That was the breaking point for me as I poured out my woes
to my mother. “How can I get them to share as well as we did as kids?”, I pleaded. Laughter was her reply.
“Well, thanks a lot, mom,” I said. “I’m sorry,” she chuckled, “but you didn’t always share.” She went on to
explain about the “Box of Misbehaved Toys.”
Every time we fought over a toy, she would quietly take that and put it into the box. Yes, I did remember
that box. I also remember it wasn’t always fair since one person may have caused all the commotion. But my
mother was consistent. No matter what the reason for the struggle was, the toy disappeared into the box for
one week. No questions asked, and no chance of parole. My siblings and I soon learned that sharing a toy
was better than losing it. Often, one person would decide to just wait for a time when no one else was
playing with the toy, rather than fight and lose it. It was not a perfect system, but I tried it anyway
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

That box was a shock to my kids and it was close to full, within a few days…..As the weeks progressed,
I noticed the box was emptier and the arguing was less. Today, I heard quiet music to my ears as my son said
to his sister, “That’s OK, you can play with it.”
This story illustrates the worthy joy of sharing as compared to the pain of losing. Sharing is the joint use
of a resource or space. In its narrow sense, it refers to joint or alternating use of inherently finite goods, such
as a common pasture or a shared residence. It is also the process of dividing and distributing.
Apart from obvious instances, which we can observe in human activity, we can also find many examples
of this happening in nature. When an organism takes in nutrition or oxygen for instance, its internal organs
are designed to divide and distribute the energy taken in, to supply parts of its body that need it. Flowers
divide and distribute their seeds. In a broader sense, it can also include free granting of use rights to goods
that can be treated as non rival goods, such as information

● Honesty
“Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom” – Thomas Jefferson
“Honesty is the best policy" is a proverb of Benjamin Franklin;
Honesty means expressing your true feelings. To be emotionally honest we must be emotionally aware
which is related to emotionally intelligent. This will also give us the ability to decide when it is in our best
interest to be emotionally honest by sharing our feelings. It takes awareness, courage, and self confidence to
be emotionally honest.

It is a behaviour showing high moral standards. Honesty has two aspects:

a) Truthfulness is to face the responsibilities upon telling truth. One should keep one’s word or promise.
By admitting one’s mistake committed (one needs courage to do that!), it is easy to fix them. Reliable
engineering judgment, maintenance of truth, defending the truth, and communicating the truth, only
when it does ‘good’ to others, are some of the reflections of truthfulness.
b) Trustworthiness is maintaining integrity and taking responsibility for personal performance. People
abide by law and live by mutual trust. They play the right way to win, according to the laws or rules
(legally and morally). They build trust through reliability and authenticity. They admit their own
mistakes and confront unethical actions in others and take tough and principled stand, even if unpopular.
Honesty is mirrored in many ways. The common reflections are:
(a) Beliefs (intellectual honesty).
(b) Communication (writing and speech).
(c) Decisions (ideas, discretion).
(d) Actions (means, timing, place, and the goals). and
(e) Intended and unintended results achieved.
a) Honesty in acts - It includes not stealing, not engaging in bribes and kickbacks and respecting property
of others.
b) Honesty in speech - It means not deceiving lying and willingly revealing all pertinent information.
c) Honesty in beliefs - It means forming one’s beliefs without self-deception or other forms of unpleasant
truth.
d) Honesty in Discretion - It means involving in the legitimate areas of privacy of the employer or client
especially with regard to confidential information.
Honesty is a fundamental virtue for those who engage in the relationships between engineers and then employers
and clients.
As against this, some of the actions of an engineer that leads to dishonesty are:
(a) Lying: Honesty implies avoidance of lying. An engineer may communicate wrong or distorted test
results intentionally or otherwise. It is giving wrong information to the right people
(b) Deliberate deception: An engineer may judge or decide on matters one is not familiar or with
insufficient data or proof, to impress upon the customers or employers. This is a self deceit.
(c) Withholding the information: It means hiding the facts during communication to one’s superior or
subordinate, intentionally or otherwise.
(d) Not seeking the truth: Some engineers accept the information or data, without applying their mind and
seeking the truth.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

(e) Not maintaining confidentiality: It is giving right information to wrong people. The engineers should
keep information of their customers/clients or of their employers confidential and should not discuss
them with others.
(f) Giving professional judgment under the influence of extraneous factors such as personal benefits and
prejudice. The laws, experience, social welfare, and even conscience are given a go-bye by such
actions. Certainly this is a higher-order crime.

● Courage
1. “Courage is the first of human qualities because it is the quality which guarantees all
others?” – Winston Churchill
2. “Courage means the ability to face down those imaginary fears in reclaim the far more
powerful life that we have denied ourselves”
3. “Courage is not the absence of fear, but rather the judgment that something else IS
more important than fear.” - Ambrose edmoon.
4. “Courage i s resistance to fear, mastery of fear - not absence of fear.” –
MarkTwain
● The word courage derives from the Latin cor, which means “heart”. But true courage is more a
matter of mental power than of feeling.
● Courage (also called bravery, bravado or valour) is the choice and willingness to confront agony,
pain, danger, uncertainty or intimidation. Physical courage is courage in the face of physical pain,
hardship, death or threat of death, while moral courage is the ability to act rightly in the face of
popular opposition, shame, scandal, discouragement, or personal loss.
● Courage is the tendency to accept and face risks and difficult tasks in rational ways. Self-confidence
is the basic requirement to nurture courage.
● Courage is classified into three types, based on the types of risks, namely
a) Physical courage: In physical courage, the thrust is on the adequacy of the physical strength, including
the muscle power and armaments. People with high adrenalin, may be prepared to face challenges for
the mere ‘thrill’ or driven by a decision to ‘excel’.,
b) Social courage: The social courage involves the decisions and actions to change the order, based on the
conviction for or against certain social behaviors. This requires leadership abilities, including empathy
and sacrifice, to mobilize and motivate the followers, for the social cause.
c) Intellectual courage: The intellectual courage is inculcated in people through acquired knowledge,
experience, games, tactics, education, and training. In professional ethics, courage is applicable to the
employers, employees, public, and the press.
● One should perform Strengths, Weakness, Opportunities, and Threat (SWOT) analysis. Calculate
(estimate) the risks, compare with one’s strengths, and anticipate the end results, while taking
decisions and before getting into action.

Incident to witness courage:

Facing the criticism, owning responsibility, and accepting the mistakes or errors when committed and
exposed are the expressions of courage. In fact, this sets their mind to be vigilant against the past
mistakes, and creative in finding the alternate means to achieve the desired objectives. Prof. Sathish
Dhawan, Chief of ISRO, was reported to have exhibited his courage and owned responsibility, when the
previous space mission failed, but credited Prof. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam (now our revered President), when
the subsequent mission succeeded.

Characteristics of owned by courageous people

a) Perseverance (sustained hard work),
b) Experimentation (preparedness to face the challenges, that is, unexpected or unintended results),
c) Involvement (attitude, clear and firm resolve to act), and
d) Commitment (willing to get into action and to reach the desired goals by any alternative but ethical
means).
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Valuing Time
● “Time is measure of one’s usefulness and success”
● “Life is best enjoyed when time periods are evenly divided between labor, sleep and
recreation. All people should speed one-third of their time in recreation which is
rebuilding, voluntary activity, never idleness” – Brigham young
● “Time is money”
● A first step in good time management is to understand the value of your time. Hard working people
have no time for rest and recreation. Time management is the rational way to ensure that our
limited time is always used effectively
● If you are employed by someone else, you need to understand how much your employer is paying
for your time, and how much profit he or she expects to make from you.
● If you are working for yourself, you should have an idea of how much income you want to bring in
after tax. By working these figures back to an hourly rate, this gives you an idea of the value of your
time.
● By knowing the value of your time, we have to take it as a resource. It is unique, which cannot be
accumulated and stored like money. . we have to use it effectively and efficiently.
● Time is rare resource. Once it is spent, it is lost forever. It cannot be either stored or recovered.
Hence, time is the most perishable and most valuable resource too. This resource is continuously
spent, whether any decision or action is taken or not.
● We can identify the wasters of time by following ways:
o Unscheduled and schedule meetings
o Lack of adequate planning
o Poor delegation
o Too much socializing
o Ineffective communication
o Unnecessary public responsibilities
o Lack of goals and objectives
o Poor supervision
o Poor use of telephone
Time management principles:
● Clear objective
● Prioritize task
● Greatly increase your productivity and effectiveness
● Feel less stress and worry
● Control your schedule and the way you spend your time
● Achieve more with less time
● Have more time for fun and the things and people you love
● The history of great reformers and innovators have stressed the importance of time and valuing time.
The proverbs,
‘Time and tide wait for nobody’ and
‘Procrastination is the thief of time’ amply illustrate this point.
Moral story for Valuing Time:
An story to highlight the ‘value of time’ is as follows: To realize the value of one year, ask the
student who has failed in the examinations;. To realize the value of one month, ask the mother who has
delivered a premature baby; to realize the value of one week, ask the editor of weekly; to realize the value of
one day, ask the daily-wage laborer; to realize now the value of one hour, ask the lovers longing to meet; to
realize the value of one minute, ask a person who has missed the train; to realize the value of one second,
ask the person who has survived an accident; to realize the value one millisecond, ask the person who has
won the bronze medal in Olympics; to realize the value of one micro second, ask the NASA team of
scientists; to realize the value of one nanosecond, ask a Hardware engineer
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Cooperation
Teamwork requires cooperation of all the members of the team. The sayings are:
"Pulling together can move mountains"; "Unity gives strength"; "United we stand, divided we fall ";
"A bundle of sticks cannot be broken as it is, but individual sticks can be broken easily'. Thus
cooperation in any work adds strength and leads to success.
● Cooperation is the process of groups of organisms working or acting together for common or mutual
benefit, as opposed to working in competition for selfish benefit.
● Man is a social animal. He lives in a society on which he is largely dependent and to which his
contribution matters. Man cannot make his living all by himself. He has to depend on others for
many things. Usually many w o r k s have to be done by several persons collectively. Construction
of a building, r un nin g an institution, organizing a community function or a meeting requires the
work and help of many individuals.
● Man must learn to cooperate with others. It gives not only strengths and success in completing a
work, but also a peace of mind and happiness in contributing the pleasures of that collective effort
and s u c c e s s . Without cooperation there would be disorder, confusion, inadequacy, and fear of
failure.
● There are departments of cooperation in government. They help and supervise in the formation and
running of cooperative organizations, which are meant to collect and channelize people to form
cooperative organizations to help themselves in managing their affairs such as cooperative banks,
cooperative societies which cater to needs of people
● Industry is a place where the successful manufacturing of a product is the outcome of the collective
efforts, cooperation and dedication of a team of engineers with expertise along with skilled workers.
An engineer basically has to learn the art to communicate, coordinate, cooperate with various other
units to complete a task;

Moral story for Cooperation

Once upon a time, there was a flock of doves that flew in search of food led by their king. One day,
they had flown a long distance and were very tired. The dove king encouraged them to fly a little
further. The smallest dove picked up speed and found some rice scattered beneath a banyan tree. So
all the doves landed and began to eat.
Suddenly a net fell over them and they were all trapped. They saw a hunter approaching carrying a
huge club. The doves desperately fluttered their wings trying to get out, but to no avail. The king had
an idea. He advised all the doves to fly up together carrying the net with them. He said that there was
strength in unity.
Each dove picked up a portion of the net and together they flew off carrying the net with them. The
hunter looked up in astonishment. He tried to follow them, but they were flying high over hills and
valleys. They flew to a hill near a city of temples where there lived a mouse that could help them. He
was a faithful friend of the dove king.
When the mouse heard the loud noise of their approach, he went into hiding. The dove king gently
called out to him and then the mouse was happy to see him. The dove king explained that they had
been caught in a trap and needed the mouse’s help to gnaw at the net with his teeth and set them free.
The mouse agreed saying that he would set the king free first. The king insisted that he first free his
subjects and the king last. The mouse understood the king’s feelings and complied with his wishes.
He began to cut the net and one by one all the doves were freed including the dove king.
They all thanked the mouse and flew away together, united in their strength.

● Commitment
“The quality of a person’s life is in direct proportion to their commitment to excellence, regardless
of their chosen field of endeavour” - Vince Lambradi
“Never, never, never, give up” – Winston Churchill
● Every individual when grown up has to perform one or other duty, not only for his livelihood but
even for the betterment of social and nation conditions.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● It starts from the student’s day. He has to be committed to studying with devotion. This is a basic
requirement for any profession. For example, a design engineer shall exhibit a sense of commitment,
to make his product or project designed a beneficial contribution to the society. Only when the
teacher (Guru) is committed to his job, the students will succeed in life and contribute ‘good’ to the
society. The commitment of top management will naturally lead to committed employees, whatever
may be their position or emoluments. This is bound to add wealth to oneself, one’s employer,
society, and the nation at large. A solider should be committed to his duties to save the nation. A
farmer should be dedicated to farming then only he can feed all of without scarcity of food.
● Commitment is willingness to give your time and energy to something that you believe in, or a
promise or firm decision to do something.
● Commitment means acceptance of the responsibilities and duties and cooperation means help and
assistance. By developing team commitment and cooperation in a work team you are assisting the
team to meet its goals and objectives. Work teams that are committed and cooperative are more
likely to achieve the goals the business has set.
Moral story for Commitment – Story of Geppetto - more joy than any other famous puppet-maker
ever got from any of their creations.
There was once a young man who liked puppets so much that he became an apprentice to a master puppet-
maker. Sadly, the young man was very clumsy, and his teacher and the other apprentices were always telling
him he had no ability when it came to making puppets, and that he would never amount to anything.
Even so, he enjoyed it so much that he worked day after day to improve. Despite his efforts, they would
always find something wrong with the puppets he had made, and they ended up throwing him out of the
workshop.
He wasn't going to give up, so the young man decided that from then on he would spend all his time making
just one kind of puppet. On he went, and whenever he found a fault in his puppet he would abandon it and
start again right from square one. The years passed, and with each new attempt his puppet became a little bit
better. By now, his puppet was much better than anything his old fellow apprentices could make, but he kept
making improvements, seeking perfection. Living like that, the man wasn't making any money, and many
people laughed at how poor he was.
By the time he was an old man, his puppet was truly wonderful. So much so, that finally one day, after so
many years of work, he finished work on his puppet, and said: "I can't find anything wrong with it. This time
it is perfect", and for the first time in all those years, instead of abandoning his puppet, he put it up on the
shelf, feeling truly satisfied and happy.

● Empathy
Definition:
● “The ability to imagine oneself in anther’s place and understand the other’s feelings, desires, ideas
and actions”
● Empathy is closely related to the ability to read other people’s emotion. It depends on one’s capacity to
put oneself in the other person’s place and to experience an appropriate emotional response. It also to
expertise that emotion our self.
Elements of Empathy
● Ability to imagine
● Self awareness or self consciousness
● The existence of an available other
● The existence of accessible feelings, desires, ideas and representations of actions or their outcomes both
in empathizing self and others.
Characteristics of Empathy
1. Understanding others: It means sensing others feelings and perspectives, and taking active interest
in their welfare.
2. Service orientation: It is anticipation, recognition and meeting the needs of the clients or customers.
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

3. Developing others: This means identification of their needs and bolstering their abilities. In
developing others, the one should inculcate in him the ‘listening skill’ first.
Communication = 22% reading and writing + 23% speaking + 55% listening
One should get the feedback, acknowledge the strength and accomplishments, and then coach the
individual, by informing about what was wrong, and giving correct feedback and positive expectation of the
subject’s abilities and the resulting performance.
4. Leveraging diversity (opportunities through diverse people): This leads to enhanced
organizational learning, flexibility, and profitability.
5. Political awareness: It is the ability to read political and social currents in an organization.
The benefits of empathy include:
● Empathy connects people together: Good customer relations (in sales and service, in
partnering).
● Empathy Heals: Caring - Harmonious labour relations (in manufacturing).
● Empathy builds Trust
● Empathy closes the loop: Good vendor-producer relationship (in partnering.) Through the above
three, we can maximize the output and profit, as well as minimizing the loss. While dealing with
customer complaints, empathy is very effective in realizing the unbiased views of others and in
admitting one’s own limitations and failures. According to Peter Ducker, purpose of the business is
not to make a sale, but to make and keep a customer. Empathy assists one in developing courage
leading to success.

Empathy is the ability to experience the feelings of another person. It goes beyond sympathy, which is
caring and understanding for the suffering of others. Both words are used similarly and often
interchangeably (incorrectly so) but differ subtly in their emotional meaning.
Empathy Sympathy
Definition Understanding what others are feeling because Acknowledging another person's
you have experienced it yourself or can put emotional hardships and providing
yourself in their shoes. comfort and assurance.
Example "I know it's not easy to lose weight because I "Trying to lose weight can often feel like
have faced the same problems myself." an uphill battle."
Relationship Personal understanding Understanding the experience of others
Nursing A doctor relating with a patient because he or Doctors comforting patients or their
context she has been in a similar situation or experience families
Scope Personal; it can be one to many in some From either one to another person or one
circumstances to many (or one to a group).

Moral story for Empathy

The following is a fantastic, true story from a teacher:
“I work as a resource room teacher with children who have learning disabilities. A few years ago a young
boy began taking lessons in my resource room. I could not figure out what had brought him to seek my help.
He clearly had no difficulty with his lessons and did well on all his tests. Yet, time after time he consistently
came to my resource room for his lessons. I was determined to find his area of weakness but, as hard as I
tried, I could not find any type of learning disability or difficulty. Finally, out of frustration, I took him aside
and told him I could not continue giving him lessons. It was a waste of his time and his parent’s hard earned
money and he clearly did not need any sort of remedial help. The boy turned to me and said, “ I will tell you
why I am here but I am asking you not to tell anyone else. I have a friend with a learning disability. Our
teacher told him that he needed remedial classes in the resource room. He was so embarrassed to be singled
out as having to go to your classes. I told him that it was no big deal and that I also take remedial classes.
That is why I come to you- so that my friend will not be embarrassed”.
● Self Confidence
“Success comes to those who dare and act, it seldom comes to the timid” – Jawharlal Nehru
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Certainty in one’s own capabilities, values, and goals, is self-confidence. These people are usually
positive thinking, flexible and willing to change. They respect others so much as they respect themselves.
● Self-confidence is positive attitude, wherein the individual has some positive and realistic view of
himself, with respect to the situations in which one gets involved. The people with self-confidence
exhibit courage to get into action and unshakable faith in their abilities, whatever may be their positions.
They are not influenced by threats or challenges and are prepared to face them and the natural or
unexpected consequences.
● The self-confidence in a person develops a sense of partnership, respect, and accountability, and this
helps the organization to obtain maximum ideas, efforts, and guidelines from its employees.
The people with self-confidence have the following characteristics:
a) A self-assured standing,
b) Willing to listen to learn from others and adopt (flexibility),
c) Frank to speak the truth, and
d) Respect others’ efforts and give due credit.
The factors that shape self-confidence in a person are:
a) Heredity (attitudes of parents) and family environment (elders),
b) Friendship (influence of friends/colleagues),
c) Influence of superiors/role models, and
d) Training in the organization (e.g., training by Technical Evangelists at Infosys Technologies).
The following methodologies are effective in developing self-confidence in a person:
a. Encouraging SWOT analysis. By evaluating their strength and weakness, they can anticipate and be
prepared to face the results.
b. Training to evaluate risks and face them (self-acceptance).
c. Self-talk. It is conditioning the mind for preparing the self to act, without any doubt on his capabilities.
This make one accepts himself while still striving for improvement.
d. Study and group discussion, on the history of leaders and innovators (e.g., Sam Walton of Wal-Mart,
USA).
Moral Story for self confidence and courage
A tired bird landed on a branch. The bird rested, enjoying the view from the branch and the protection it
offered from dangerous animals. Just as the bird became used to the branch and the support and safety it
offered, a strong wind started blowing, and the tree swayed with such intensity that it seemed the branch
would snap in half. But the bird was not worried for it knew two important truths. The first truth – even
without the branch it was able to fly, and thus remain safe through the power of its own two wings. The
second truth – it also knew that there are many other branches upon which it can temporarily rest. This
small story tells us a lot about our own self-confidence and courage.

● Character
● Character traits are all the aspects of a person's behaviour and attitudes that make up that person's
personality. Everyone has character traits, both good and bad.
● Some character traits have to do with your underlying values or beliefs. Some examples of these
types of character traits include: Religious, Honest, Loyal, Devoted, Loving, Kind, Sincere, Devoted,
Ambitious, Satisfied, Happy, Faithful, Patient, Determined, Persistent, Adventurous, Homebody,
Considerate, Cooperative, Cheerful, Optimistic, Pessimistic and Funny.
● Some character traits can be bad, and you may not want these traits associated with you. Some
examples of these types of character traits include: Dishonest, Disloyal, Unkind, Mean, Rude,
Disrespectful, Impatient, Greedy, Angry, Pessimistic, Repugnant, Cruel, Unmerciful, Wicked,
Obnoxious, Malicious, Grumpy, Quarrelsome, Caustic, Selfish, Unforgiving
● A leader or person who likes to be in charge may have the following character traits: Domineering,
Boorish, Persuasive, Ambitious, Bossy, Disparaging, Picky, Sly, Cold-hearted, Rude, Self-centred,
Conceited
● Some character traits can be consciously developed, learned or acquired. For example, character
traits that you may consciously choose to learn or adopt include: Educated or Informed
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Some character traits for children include: Playful, Zany, Active, Wild, Silly, Affectionate, Funny,
Rough, Talkative, Rowdy, Smart, Fidgety, Shy, Lively, Submissive, Stubborn
Education and Character
The aim of education is not only the cultivation of the intellect but also the formation of moral character.
Increased intelligence or physical skill may as easily be employed to the detriment or benefit of the
community, if not accompanied by improved will. It is the function of ethics to determine the ideals of
human character. The theory and science of education are to study the processes by which that end may be
attained.
Building Character in the Workplace
Managers have to influence and employ creative means of stressing the importance of good character in the
workplace, in the following ways:
a) Employee Hiring, Training, and Promotion Activities:
a) Institute and adopt an organization policy statement to positive character in the workplace. For
example, commitment to civility pledges. This may be communicated through printing on the back
of the business cards of the employees.
b) Prominently and explicitly include character considerations in recruiting procedures, during
interviews and in the hiring deliberations.
c) Emphasize the importance of character and adherence to the ‘six pillars’ of character in orientation,
initial job training, and during in-service training. The six pillars of character are the ethical values,
such as: trustworthiness, respect, responsibility, fairness, caring and citizenship. Respect means
showing high regard for self, others, authority, property and country. It includes showing
appreciation for cultural diversity by valuing all people as human beings. Responsibility is
i. being accountable for one’s actions,
ii. being dependable in carrying out obligations and duties,
iii. being reliable and consistent in word and action, and
iv. being committed to community development. Integrity or fairness means showing the inner
strength and courage to be truthful, trustworthy, fair and honest in all things. It includes acting
justly and honorably. Caring means being kind, considerate, courteous, helpful, friendly and
generous to others, and being compassionate by treating others as you would like to be treated.
Citizenship means accepting and adopting civic rights and duties as a citizen of the country.
d) Include evaluation of fundamental character values such as honesty, promise keeping,
accountability, fairness, and caring, in appraisals/reviews.
e) Institute recognition and reward system for the employees who exemplify the positive character.
For example, awards and medals.
f) Think of your employees, especially the younger ones, as people whose personal and work values
will be influenced by what you expect of them and how you treat them.
g) Think of your employees as present or future mentors, coaches, and volunteers.
2. Internal Communication
Use internal communication channels to create a friendly environment that praises positive role modeling at
the workplace and in the community by encouraging voluntarism, and mentoring, e.g., through
a) Internal newsletters,
b) Workplace posters in canteens and recreation rooms,
c) Mailers, and
d) Electronic mails.
3. External Communication
In relations with customers, vendors and others, consciously communicate affirming messages about
character and ethics, such as
(a) Advertise and market honoring consensual values (the six pillars),
(b) Assure that none of your products and services undermines character building,
(c) Include positive messages about voluntarism and celebrate, and
(d) ‘Character counts’ week in advertising, billings and other mailers.

● Spirituality
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

● Spirituality is a way of living that emphasizes the constant awareness and recognition of the spiritual
dimension (mind and its development) of nature and people, with a dynamic balance between the
material development and the spiritual development. This is said to be the great virtue of Indian
philosophy and for Indians. Sometimes, spirituality includes the faith or belief in supernatural
power/ God, regarding the worldly events. It functions as a fertilizer for the soil ‘character’ to
blossom into values and morals.
● Spirituality includes creativity, communication, recognition of the individual as human being (as
opposed to a life-less machine), respect to others, acceptance (stop finding faults with colleagues and
accept them the way they are), vision (looking beyond the obvious and not believing anyone blindly),
and partnership (not being too authoritative, and always sharing responsibility with others, for better
returns).
● Spirituality is motivation as it encourages the colleagues to perform better. Remember, lack of
motivation leads to isolation. Spirituality is also energy: Be energetic and flexible to adapt to
challenging and changing situations. Spirituality is flexibility as well. One should not be too
dominating. Make space for everyone and learn to recognize and accept people the way they are.
Variety is the order of the day. But one can influence their mind to think and act together.
Spirituality is also fun. Working is okay, but you also need to have fun in office to keep yourself
charged up. Tolerance and empathy are the reflections of spirituality. Blue and saffron colors are
said to be associated with spirituality.
● Creativity in spirituality means conscious efforts to see things differently, to break out of habits and
outdated beliefs to find new ways of thinking, doing and being. Suppression of creativity leads to
violence. People are naturally creative. When they are forced to crush their creativity, its energy
turns to destructive release and actions. Creativity includes the use of color, humor and freedom to
enhance productivity. Creativity is fun. When people enjoy what they do, it is involvement. They
work much harder.
Spirituality in the Workplace
Spirituality is promoted in the workplace by adhering to the following activities:
a) Verbally respect the individuals as humans and recognize their values in all decisions and actions.
b) Get to know the people with whom you work and know what is important to them. Know their goals,
desires, and dreams too.
c) State your personal ethics and your beliefs clearly.
d) Support causes outside the business.
e) Encourage leaders to use value-based discretion in making decisions.
f) Demonstrate your own self-knowledge and spirituality in all your actions.
g) Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
Spirituality for Corporate Excellence
The spiritual traits to be developed for excellence in corporate activities are listed as follows:
a) Self-awareness — Realization of self-potential. A human has immense capability but it needs to be
developed.
b) Alertness in observation and quickness in decision making, i.e., spontaneity which includes quick
reflexes, no delay but also no hasty decisions.
c) Being visionary and value based — This includes an attitude towards future of the organization and the
society, with clear objectives.
d) Holism — Whole system or comprehensive views and interconnected with different aspects. Holistic
thinking, which means the welfare of the self, family, organization and the society including all other
living beings and environment.
e) Compassion — Sympathy, empathy and concern for others. These are essential for not only building the
team but also for its effective functioning.
f) Respect for diversity — It means search for unity in diversity i.e., respect others and their views.
g) Moral Autonomy — It means action based on rational and moral judgment. One need not follow the
crowd or majority i.e., band-wagon effect.
h) Creative thinking and constant reasoning — Think if we can do something new and if we can
improve further?
 UNIT I HUMAN VALUES

i) Ability to analyze and synthesize — Refrain from doing something only traditional.
j) Positive views of adversity — Make adversities one’s source of power—a typical Karma yogi’s
outlook! Every threat is converted into opportunity.
k) Humility - The attitude to accept criticism (it requires courage!) and willing to correct. It includes
modesty and acknowledging the work of colleagues.
l) Sense of vocation — Treat the duty as a service to society, besides your organization.

● Introduction to Yoga and meditation for professional excellence and stress

management YOGA
● Yoga is an ancient discipline designed to bring balance and health to the physical, mental, emotional,
and spiritual dimensions of the individual, when adopted as a way of life, yoga improves physical,
mental, intellectual, and spiritual health.
● Yoga offers an effective method of managing and reducing stress, anxiety, and depression, and
numerous studies demonstrate the efficacy of yoga on mood-related disorders.
● Yoga is often depicted metaphorically as a tree and comprises eight aspects, or limbs: yama (universal
ethics), niyama (individual ethics), asana (physical postures), pranayama (breath control), pratyahara
(control of the senses), dharana (concentration), dyana (meditation), and samadhi (bliss)
Tree of Yoga
● Roots: Foundation for living honourably and clearly
● Trunk: Establishing a base of purity in one’s body and mind
● Branches: Strong and flexible to move with the wind of life
● Leaves: Drawing in life force through the exchange of breath
● Bark: Protecting the tree from outer elements and preventing its essence from flowing outward
● Sap: Juice which carries the energy on this inward journey, links the whole tree as one
● Fruit: The essence of the tree
● Yoga is a complete process of perfection of man by developing his personality so that he may reach his
ultimate goal, thereby fulfilling the purpose of his birth. Value of Yoga:
● Yoga is a science of life to develop the sixth sense to its fullness and to enable and equip man to enjoy
peaceful and blissful life. It is essentially an art of understanding all about the soul, which is one of the
life force and realizing its relationship with the body, the society, the world and the universe,
maintaining its harmony and finally getting it merged with the universal soul.
● In nature, man is an unique living being in that he alone is gifted with sixth sense. The sixth sense is a
higher level of mind which is able o understands its own existence and functions. It is a divine meter
measuring all the functions of the universe and understanding oneness among multiplicity and unit in
diversity.
Purpose of Yoga:
● For the liberation of the soul,
(i) The attachment with material enjoyments should be neutralized and full satisfaction should be achieved,
and
(ii) The impressions of sins should be obliterated.
In order to attain these two, Soul Consciousness is very important.
● Yoga provides all the facilities and opportunities for improving the unsolved awareness to get
satisfaction with worldly enjoyment and also to obtain detachment and eliminate the impressions of sins
by streamlining the activities of the mind.
● Yoga will help man in the performance of all his duties in harmony with the Law of Nature and the
sentiments and conventions of the society, enable him to lead a successful life and to achieve satisfaction
and peace of sharpening his intellect, cultivating constant awareness and strengthening the will,
streamlining the mind and moralizing the behaviour. Yoga is a well-balanced and perfect process for
success and peace in life.
● Meditation is a practice in which an individual trains the mind or induces a mode of consciousness,
either to realize some benefit or for the mind to simply acknowledge its content without becoming
 UNI HUMAN

identified with that content, or as an end in it. Meditation often involves an internal effort to self-
regulate the mind in some way.
● Meditation is often used to clear the mind and ease many health concerns, such as high blood pressure,
depression, and anxiety. Meditation may involve generating an emotional state for the purpose of
analyzing that state such as anger, hatred, etc. or cultivating a particular mental response to various
phenomena, such as compassion.

The role of yoga in stress management

● Stress can also be defined as the harmful physical and emotional responses that occur when the
requirements of the job do not match the capabilities, resources, or needs of the worker.
● Job stress can lead to poor health and even injury. Hence we can say that stress is a silent killer, and
prolonged exposure to stress may exert harmful effects on physical, psychological, and behavioural
well-being of an individual.
● According to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 80% of workers experience
job stress.

IMPACT OF STRESS
● One of the studies quoted that stress-related disorders evolve gradually through four recognizable
stages.
1. In the first, psychological changes such as anxiety, irritability, and insomnia arise, due to over-
stimulation of the sympathetic nervous system.
2. In the second stage symptoms such as high blood pressure, elevated heart rate, and increased
intestinal motility surface.
3. In the third stage, a more profound physical or biochemical imbalance sets in,
4. In the final fourth stage, irreversible symptoms that often require surgical or long-term management
appear.
● Increased sympathetic activation and the release of stress hormones, including adrenaline, lead to
increases in heart rate, blood pressure, breathing, body temperature, and muscle tension.
● In contrast, the relaxation response has been proposed as an remedy to stress; relaxation decreases
heart rate, breathing, body temperature, and muscle tension.
● Similar to stress in the workplace, college students are also often impacted by stress. Academic
stress can result from many different imperative stressors, such as final grades, term papers,
examinations, and excessive homework. Stress has exhibited a negative correlation with cognitive
performance, thus negatively impacting academic performa
EFFECT OF YOGA IN STRESS
● Yoga significantly decreases heart rate and systolic and diastolic blood pressure.
● Studies suggest that yoga reverses the negative impact of stress on the immune system by increasing
levels of immunoglobulin A as well as natural killer cells.
● Yoga has been found to decrease markers of inflammation such as high sensitivity C-reactive protein
as well as inflammatory cytokines such as interleukin-6 and lymphocyte-1B. These studies suggest
that yoga has an immediate quieting effect on the SNS-HPA axis response to stress. While the
precise mechanism of action has not been determined, it has been hypothesized that some yoga
exercises cause a shift toward parasympathetic nervous system dominance, possibly via direct vagal
stimulation. Shapiro et al noted significant reductions in low-frequency heart rate variability
(HRV)—a sign of sympathetic nervous system activation—in depressed patients following an 8-
week yoga intervention.
● Regardless of the path physiologic pathway, yoga has been shown to have immediate psychological
effects: decreasing anxiety and increasing feelings of emotional, social, and spiritual well-being.
● Several literature reviews have been conducted that examined the impact of yoga on specific health
conditions, including cardiovascular disease, metabolic syndrome, diabetes, cancer, and anxiety.
● Another study has shown improvement of mental health of both the young and seniors by reducing
stress through yoga. Yoga can be wisely applied in welfare programs to improve the quality of life in
all age groups.
● Yogic science includes yogasanas (postures), pranayama (breathing practices), dhyana (meditation),
and relaxation techniques which benefit human beings at every level.
 UNI HUMAN

Steps used to relive the stress:

● Find a quiet, relaxing atmosphere
● Find a comfortable position
● Take in a deep breath
● Try to clear your mind and avoid distractions, if you can -
● Imagine yourself in a happy place -
● Close your eyes continue to breathe deeply, and imagine all your body slowing down
● Take your time

Page 29
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Senses of “Engineering Ethics‟ – Variety of moral issues – Types of inquiry – Moral dilemmas – Moral
Autonomy – Kohlberg‟s theory – Gilligan‟s theory – Consensus and Controversy – Models of
professional roles - Theories about right action – Self-interest – Customs and Religion – Uses of Ethical
Theories

2.1. What is Ethics?

✔ The term 'ethics' is derived from the Greek word ‘ e t h o s ’ , which meant 'customs'.
✔ Ethics· is the study of the characteristics of morals.
✔ First of all, ethics is the quest for and the understanding of the good life, living well, a life
worth living.
✔ In a wider perspective, ethics is putting every activity and goal In its place. It is concerned with
knowing what Is worth doing and what Is not worth doing; knowing what is worth wanting and
knowing what is not worth wanting.
✔ Ethics according to the Oxford advanced dictionary means moral principles that govern or
Inftuence • person's behavior.
✔ Ethics is defined as the discipline dealing with what is good and bad with moral duty and
obligation (responsibility)
✔ Some of the universal accepted ethical principles are :
o Integrity, honesty, confidentiality, discipline, humanity, responsibility, accountability,
discipline, loyalty, diligence, wisdom, courage, collegiability, conscientiousness,
competency, temperance, justice, etc.
✔ Various Disciplines Of Ethics
The term 'ethics' is a broad, general term. In practice, there different disciplines of ethics. They
are:
✔ Personal Ethics
● Personal ethics is concerned with the rules by which an individual lives his or her
personal life.
● It also deals with how we treat others in our day-to-day lives.
✔ Business Ethics
● Business ethics is concerned with truth and justice and has a variety of aspects such as the
expectation of society, fair competition, advertising, public relationa, social responsibilities,
consumer autonomy, and corporate behavior .
● It involves choices on an organization level rather than a personal level.

✔ Engineering Ethics
● Engineering ethics is concerned with the rules and standards governing the
conduct of engineers in their role as professionals.
● It is a body of philosophy guiding tt,e ways that engineers should conduct themselves
in their professional capacity.
✔ Medical Ethics
✔ Medical ethics is concerned with the rules and standards governing the conduct of
doctors and other medical practitioners in their role as professionals
✔ Legal Ethics
✔ Legal ethics is concerned with the codes that guide the professional conduct of lawyers,
judges, etc.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

✔ Accounting Ethics
✔ Accounting ethics is concernedwith the codes that guide the professional conduct
of accountants.
2.2. What is engineering ethics?
✔ Engineering ethics Is concerned with:
● The study of the moral issues and decisions confronting mdlvidual and
organizations engaged in engineering field; and
● The study of related issues about the moral ideals, characters, policies, an .
relationships of people and corporations involved In technological activity
● It refers to the ethical obligations that engineers have to follow because of their
professional status.
● It not only emphasizes how engineers should conduct themselves; it also
encompasses how the engineers ought to be having in their professional world
● Definition: Engineering ethics may be defined as the identification, study and
resolution of ethical problems occurring in the practice of the engineering
profession .
● The concept of engineering ethics is not applicable only for engineers. It can also
be applied to others who engage in any technological enterprises, such as
scientists, technicians, technical writers, production staffs, supervisors, sales
staffs, doctors, lawyers, and the general public.
✔ Engineering Ethics Vs Professional Ethics
● In general, the terms engineering ethics and professional ethics are used
interchangeably. But the professional ethics is wider in scope than the
engineering ethics. In fact, the engineering ethics is a part of professional
ethics.
● Professional ethics is the discipline aimed at understanding the moral values that
ought to guide all professional practices, including engineering, medicine, law
and other practices. But the engineering ethics refers to the set of specific moral
problems and issues related to engineering profession only
✔ Why it is necessary for Engineering students to study Engineering Ethics?
o Stimulating the moral Dimension
▪ It is to stimulate the moral imagination of engineering students
▪ Imagination is necessary for Engineers in anticipating the consequences of
actions as professionals and in finding solutions to ethical problems
encountered in their professional life
o Recognizing ethical issues
▪ The ethical problems encountered in engineering practice, often are very
complex. Also they involve conflicting ethical principles
o Developing analytical skills
▪ The technical and analytical skills required for analyzing moral issues are quite
different than that are exercising good engineering projects
▪ While analyzing moral issues, one requires clear thinking about concepts such
as utility, justice, rights, duties, and respect for persons
▪ The aim of engineering ethics is to train the engineers to analyze
complex problems.
o Drawing out of sense of responsibility
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

▪ The engineering ethics course encourages the engineers to desire to fulfill

ethical ideals rather than ethical requirements
▪ Ethical requirements Vs Ethical Ideals: Ethical requirements are basic
obligations and duties. Thus engineering ethics promotes a sense of
responsibility and the moral autonomy of future engineers.
o Addressing unclarity, uncertainty, and disagreement
▪ The engineering ethics helps the engineers In addressing unclarity,
uncertainty, and disagreement about moral issues.
▪ As we know, resolving ethical issues expose a certain amount of
vagueness, ambiguity, uncertainty, and disagreement. The study of
engineering ethics helps engineers to learn to resolve these problems in
the most ethical manner.

✔ Note: Engineering ethics is also referred as 'prevention ethics'. Similar to

the concept of preventive medicine, prevention ethics deals with anticipating all
sorts of ethical Issues and preventing them from occurring.
✔ The Scope of engineering ethics are twofold:
o Ethics of the workplace which involves the co-workers and employees in an
organization.
o Ethics related to the product or work which involves the transportation, warehousing,
and use, besides the safety of the end product and the environment outside the factory.
2.3. Senses or Dimensions of Engineering Ethics
Four senses:

✔ When we interpret Ethics is an activity and area of inquiry. It is the activity of understanding moral
values, resolving moral issues and the area of study resulting from that activity. It can be defined as
o Engineering ethics is an activity and discipline aimed at understanding the moral values
that ought to guide engineering practices, resolve moral issues in Engineering,
and Justifying moral judgments concerning Engineering
✔ When we speak of ethical problems, issues and controversies, we mean to distinguish them from
non moral problems. It can be defined as:
o Engineering ethics refer to set of specific moral problems and issues related to engineering
✔ When Ethics is used to refer to the particular set of beliefs, attitudes and habits that a person or
group displays concerning moralities. It may be defined as:
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

o Ethics has widely accepted codes and standards of conduct, which are to be followed by
the group of Engineers and Engineering Societies
✔ When Ethics and its grammatical variants can be used as synonyms for ‘morally correct’. It may be
defined as:
o Engineering ethics is concerned with the set of justified moral principles of obligation,
rights and ideals that are to be followed by Engineers.

2.4. Morality And Moral Reasons

2.4.1.What Is Morality?
The word morality is concerned with:
✔ What morally ought or ought not to be given in a given solution
✔ What morally right or wrong about the handling of the situation; and/or
✔ What is morally good or bad about the people, policies and ideals involved in it
✔ According to the oxford dictionary, morally means principles concerning right
and wrong or good and bad behavior
✔ Moral reasons are required to support an act (or an ideal) to be called as morally
right act (or an ideal is moral)
2.4.2.What are moral reasons?
Some of the important moral reasons include:
o Respecting others and ourselves,
o Respecting the rights of others;
o Keeping promises to others;
o Avoiding unnecessary offence and pain to others:
o Avoiding cheating and dishonesty;
o Showing gratitude for favor to others; and
o Encouraging teamwork,
2.4.3.Variety of moral issues
2.4.3.1. Approaches to Engineering ethics
✔ There are conventionally two approaches in the study of ethics:
✔ Micro-ethics which deals with decisions and problems of individuals, professionals, and
companies.
✔ Macro-ethics which deals with the societal problems on a regional/national level. For example,
global issues, collective responsibilities of groups such as professional societies and consumer
groups
✔ Moral Problems In Engineering
● Engineers carry out various activities and decision making exercises involving technical,
financial, managerial, environmental and ethical issues. The variety of moral issues and their
relationship with the issues are depicted below:
● Organizational oriented issues.
o Being an employee to a firm, the engineer has to work towards the achievement of the
objectives of his /her organization
o Engineers have to give high priority to the benefits of the organization than one’s own
benefits
o Engineers should be able to work collectively with colleagues and other members in
order to achieve firm’s goal
● Clients and customers oriented issues
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

o Engineers have a major role to play in identifying the customers voice and
incorporating the voice of the customer into product design and manufacture
o Apart from technical issues he has to face other moral and ethical issues with their
clients/customers
● Competitors oriented issues
o In order t withstand in the market, engineers should produce things better than the
competitor
o He should not practice cut-throat competition. They should follow professionalism
o He should go with safety, health and welfare of their clients/ customers in the
performance of their professional duties
● Law , government and public agencies oriented issues
o Engineers should obey and voluntarily comply with all the government rules and
regulations related to them
o They should also respect and honestly practice all other similar laws, policies and
regulations
● Professional societies oriented issues
o Engineers should follow strictly the code of ethics by various professional societies
such as National Society of Professional Engineers (NSPE), the Institute of Electrical
and electronics Engineers(IEEE),and American Society of Mechanical Engineers
(ASME).
o The professional code of ethics reflect the basic norms of conduct that exist within a
particular professional and provide guidance
● Social and Environmental Oriented Issues:
o Engineers should be dedicated to the protection of the public health, safety and welfare
o He should also be aware as role as experimenters. They should be committed in
protecting the environment. They should not involve in unethical environmental
activities such as misusing scarce resources and polluting them
● Family oriented issues
o Engineers do have family responsibility and he has to take care of their needs. But
should not take any decisions for their own benefits at the cost of public, clients or
employers
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

(Some Examples)
● Resource Crunch
o Due to pressure, through time limits, availability of money or budgetary constraints,
and technology decay or obsolescence. Pressure from the government to complete the
project in time (e.g., before the elections), reduction in the budget because of sudden
war or natural calamity (e.g., Tsunami) and obsolescence due technology innovation by
the competitor lead to manipulation and unsafe and unethical execution of projects.
o Involving individuals in the development of goals and values and developing policies
that allow for individual diversity, dissent, and input to decision-making will prevent
unethical results.
● Opportunity
o Double standards or behavior of the employers towards the employees and the public.
The unethical behaviors of World Com (in USA), Enron (in USA as well as India)
executives in 2002 resulted in bankruptcy for those companies,
o Management projecting their own interests more than that of their employees. Some
organizations over-emphasize short-term gains and results at the expense of themselves
and others,
o Emphasis on results and gains at the expense of the employees, and
o Management by objectives, without focus on empowerment and improvement of the
infrastructure.
o This is best encountered by developing policies that allow ‘conscience keepers’ and
whistle blowers and appointing ombudsman, who can work confidentially with people
to solve the unethical problems internally.
● Attitude
Poor attitude of the employees set in due to
o Low morale of the employees because of dissatisfaction and downsizing, (b) Absence of
grievance redressal mechanism,
o Lack of promotion or career development policies or denied promotions,
o Lack of transparency,
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

o Absence of recognition and reward system, and

o Poor working environments.
o Giving ethics training for all, recognizing ethical conduct in work place, including ethics in
performance appraisal, and encouraging open discussion on ethical issues, are some of the
directions to promote positive attitudes among the employees.
o To get firm and positive effect, ethical standards must be set and adopted by the senior
management, with input from all personnel.
o An inspector discovered faulty construction equipment and applied a violation tag,
preventing its use. The supervisor, a construction manager viewed the case as a minor
abrasion of the safety regulations and ordered the removal of the tag to speed up the project.
When the inspector objected to this, he was threatened with disciplinary action.
o An electric utility company applied for a permit to operate a nuclear power plant. The
licensing agency was interested in knowing what emergency measures had been established
for humans safety in case of reactor malfunctioning. The utility engineers described the
alarm system and arrangements with local hospitals for treatment. They did not emphasize
that this measures applied to plant personnel only and that they had no plans for the
surrounding population. When enquired about their omission, they said it was not their
responsibility.
▪ A chemical plant dumped wastes in a landfill. Hazardous substances found their way
into the underground water table. The plant’s engineers were aware of the situation but
did not change the method of disposal because their competitors did it the same cheap
way, and no law explicitly forbade the practice.
▪ Electronics Company ABC geared up for production of its own version of a popular
new item. The product was not yet ready for sale, but even so, pictures and impressive
specifications appeared in advertisements. Prospective customers were led to believe
that it was available off the shelf and were drawn away from competing lines.

2.5. Types of Inquiry

▪ The three types of inquiries, in solving ethical problems are: normative inquiry, conceptual
inquiry,and factual or descriptive inquiry.
▪ The three types of inquiries are discussed below to illustrate the differences and
preference.
2.5.1. Normative Inquiry
It seeks to identify and justify the morally-desirable norms or standards that
should guide individuals and groups. It also has the theoretical goal of justifying
particular moral judgments. Normative questions are about what ought to be and what is
good, based on moral values. For example,
▪ How far does the obligation of engineers to protect public safety extend in any given
situation?
▪ When, if ever, should engineers be expected to blow whistle on dangerous practices of
their employers?
▪ Whose values ought to be primary in making judgment about acceptable risks in
design for a public transport system or a nuclear plant? Is it of management, senior
engineers, government, voters or all of them?
▪ When and why is the government justified in interfering with the organisations?
▪ What are the reasons on which the engineers show their obligations to their employees
or clients or the public?
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

2.5.2. Conceptual Inquiry

It is directed to clarify the meaning of concepts or ideas or principles that are
expressed by words or by questions and statements. For example,
▪ What is meant by safety?
▪ How is it related to risk?
▪ What is a bribe?
▪ What is a profession?
o When moral concepts are discussed, normative and conceptual issues are closely
interconnected.
2.5.3. Factual or Descriptive Inquiry
It is aimed to obtain facts needed for understanding and resolving value issues.
Researchers conduct factual inquiries using mathematical or statistical techniques. The
inquiry provide important information on business realities, engineering practice, and the
effectiveness of professional societies in fostering moral conduct, the procedures used in
risk assessment, and psychological profiles of engineers. The facts provide not only the
reasons for moral problems but also enable us to develop alterative ways of resolving
moral problems. For example,
▪ How were the benefits assessed?
▪ What are procedures followed in risk assessment?
▪ What are short-term and long-term effects of drinking water being polluted?
and
▪ Who conducted the tests on materials?

2.6. Moral Dilemmas

2.6.1. Definition
a. Dilemmas are situations in which moral reasons come into conflict, or in which the application
of moral values are problems, and one is not clear of the immediate choice or solution of the
problems.
b. Moral reasons could be rights, duties, goods or obligations. These situations do not mean that
things had gone wrong, but they only indicate the presence of moral complexity. This makes
the decision making complex.
c. For example, a person promised to meet a friend and dine, but he has to help his uncle who is
involved in an accident — one has to fix the priority.
2.6.2. Causes of Moral Dilemmas
d. There are some difficulties in arriving at the solution to the problems, in dilemma. The three
complex situations leading to moral dilemmas are:
a. The problem of vagueness: One is unable to distinguish between good and bad (right or
wrong) principle. Good means an action that is obligatory. For example, code of ethics
specifies that one should obey the laws and follow standards. Refuse bribe or accept the gift,
and maintain confidentiality
Example: consider an engineer, starting a new assignment as quality inspector checking the
incoming raw materials/spare parts from the suppliers. Suppliers offer gift during festival
occasions. This situation causes moral dilemma to engineers whether to accept the gift or
whether it will be treated as bribe and whether it will create conflict of interest. Thus this
problem of vagueness – unclarity, causes moral dilemma
b. The problem of conflicting reasons: One is unable to choose between two good moral
solutions. One has to fix priority, through knowledge or value system.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Example: let us examine the space shuttle Challenger explosion, focusing on the dilemma
faced by the Engineer cum Manager Bob Lund. He had following issues:
● Launching the Challenger space shuttle despite there was an unknown probability
that the shuttle would explode, which will kill all the persons on the board.
● Postponing the launch will lead to loss of future contracts from NASA , the loss of job
to many workers
Thus this problem of moral dilemma is due to problem of conflicting reasons
c. The problem of disagreement: There may be two or more solutions and none of them
mandatory. These solutions may be better or worse in some respects but not in all aspects. One
has to interpret, apply different morally reasons, and analyze and rank the decisions. Select the
best suitable, under the existing and the most probable conditions.
Example : In most corporations, there are disagreements among managers regarding whether
customers can be allowed to inspect their plants and procedures, as a confidence building
measure
2.6.3. Steps to Solve Dilemma
The logical steps in confronting moral dilemma are:
a. Identification of the moral factors and reasons. The clarity to identify the relevant
moral values from among duties, rights, goods and obligations is obtained conceptual
inquiry). The most useful resource in identifying dilemmas in engineering is the
professional codes of ethics, as interpreted by the professional experience. Another
resource is talking with colleagues who can focus or narrow down the choice of values.
b. Collection of all information, data, and facts (factual inquiry) relevant to the situation.
c. Rank the moral options i.e., priority in application through value system, and also as
obligatory, all right, acceptable, not acceptable, damaging, and most damaging etc. For
example, in fulfilling responsibility, the codes give prime importance to public safety
and protection of the environment, as compared to the individuals or the employers
(conceptual inquiry).
d. Generate alternate courses of action to resolve the dilemma. Write down the main
options and sub-options as a matrix or decision tree to ensure that all options are
included.
e. Discuss with colleagues and obtain their perspectives, priorities, and suggestions on
various alternatives.
f. Decide upon a final course of action, based on priority fixed or assumed. If there is no
ideal solution, we arrive at a partially satisfactory or ‘satisfying’ solution.
2.7. Moral Autonomy
2.7.1.Definition
o Moral autonomy is defined as, decisions and actions exercised on the basis of moral
concern for other people and recognition of good moral reasons.
o Alternatively, moral autonomy means ‘self determinant or independent’. The
autonomous people hold moral beliefs and attitudes based on their critical reflection
rather than on passive adoption of the conventions of the society or profession.
o Moral autonomy may also be defined as a skill and habit of thinking rationally about the
ethical issues, on the basis of moral concern.
● Viewing engineering as social experimentation will promote autonomous participation and retain
one’s professional identity.
● Periodical performance appraisals, tight-time schedules and fear of foreign competition threatens
this autonomy.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

● The attitude of the management should allow latitude in the judgments of their engineers on moral
issues. If management views profitability is more important than consistent quality and retention of
the customers that discourage the moral autonomy, engineers are compelled to seek the support
from their professional societies and outside organizations for moral support.
● It appears that the blue-collar workers with the support of the union can adopt better autonomy than
the employed professionals. Only recently the legal support has been obtained by the professional
societies in exhibiting moral autonomy by professionals in this country as well as in the West.
2.7.2. Factors influencing Moral concern
a. Atmosphere in which person is brought up in his childhood
b. One's relationship with friendsand relatives.
c. One's interaction with his neighbors.
d. One's family structure and the family's economy.
e. Influence of religious Institutionssuch as temples, churches , Mosques etc.
f . Influence of educational Institutionssuch as school, c o l l e g e s e t c
g. Influence of teachers and other mentors.
h. Influence of media like newspapers, novels, television, movies etc
i. Influence of some social events.
2.7.3. Skills needed to improve Moral Autonomy
The engineering skills related to moral autonomy are listed as follows:
o Proficiency in recognizing moral problems in engineering and ability to distinguish as
well as relate them to problems in law, economics, and religion,
o Skill in comprehending, clarifying, and critically-assessing arguments on different
aspects of moral issues,
o Ability to form consistent and comprehensive view points based on facts,
o Awareness of alternate responses to the issues and creative solutions for practical
difficulties,
o Sensitivity to genuine difficulties and subtleties, including willingness to undergo and
tolerate some uncertainty while making decisions,
o Using rational dialogue in resolving moral conflicts and developing tolerance of
different perspectives among morally reasonable people, and
o Maintaining moral integrity.
2.8. Theories of Moral Development
2.8.1.Kohlberg’s Theory
✔ Born on October 25, 1927 in Bronxville, New York
✔ Attended Andover Academy in Massachusetts, a private high school for bright and
usually wealthy students
✔ Before college he was an engineer on an old freighter carrying refugees from parts
of Europe to Israel
✔ Studied psychology at the University of Chicago
✔ First became a clinical psychologist before creating his own theory
✔ Spent many years researching how an individual develops their own moral codes
There are three Stages of Moral Development
Pre-conventional Level
• It is based on the desire to derive benefits for oneself
• In the first level, individuals behave according to socially acceptable norms, which
are taught mainly by parents and teachers
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

• In this first level, individuals are motivated mainly by their interest to avoid
punishment, or by their desire to satisfy their own needs or by external power exerted
on them
• Whatever benefits oneself or avoids punishment. This is the level of development of all
young children. -Avoid punishment & Gain Reward
Conventional Level
• In the second level, the moral thinking and behavior of the individual are determined
by the standards of their family, community and society. Uncritical acceptance of
one’s family, group or society are accepted as final standard of morality.
• At this level, individuals are motivated by the desire to please others and to meet the
social unit’s expectations, without bothering much about their self interest.
• Here in the second level, individuals give more importance to loyalty and close
identification with others than their own self interest
• Most adults do not mature beyond this stage.
1. Gain Approval & Avoid Disapproval &
2. Duty & Guilt
Post-conventional Level
▪ Here in this level, the individuals are guided by strong principles and convictions, not
by selfish needs or pressure from society
▪ These individuals are called as autonomous, because they think for/by themselves and
also they do not believe that customs are always right
▪ The people of this level live by principles that can be accepted by all
▪ But majority of people do not reach this level
1. Agreed upon rights &
2. Personal moral standards
Kohlberg’s level of Moral development

Level Appropriate age range Moral Development

Pre conventional Birth to 9 years ✔ Self centered attitude
✔ Willingness to avoid punishment
✔ Desire to gain reward
Conventional Ages 9 to 20 years ✔ Respect for conventional rules and
authority
✔ Willingness to please or satisfy
others
✔ Importance to loyalty and close
identification with others
Post conventional Over 20 years or may be ✔ Thinking for and by themselves
never ✔ Agreed upon universal general
principles
✔ Personal moral standards
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

✔ Drawbacks of Kohlberg’s theory

o How to judge, whether the individual belongs to first level, second level or
third level?
o What are the criteria?
o What is the exact stage for moral development?
o What is the stage of moral maturity?
o Only few people are in post conventional level. Hence it does recor
majority followers
2.8.2.Carol Gilligan Theory
Carol Gilligan is a contemporary psychologist who has conducted extensive research into
women's approach to moral problems.
Carol Gilligan was born in New York City on November 28, 1936. She studied literature at
Swarthmore College as an undergrad, and she graduated from Radcliffe in 1960 with a master's
in psychology.
She continued to Harvard, where she received her PhD in psychology in 1964. Three years
later, Gilligan took a teaching position at Harvard where she worked alongside Erik
Erikson and Lawrence Kohlberg.
While Gilligan worked as a research assistant under Kohlberg, known for his theory of moral
development, she began focusing on the moral dilemmas and development of young girls.
Kohlberg’s theory demonstrates that children progress through several stages of moral
reasoning, though not everyone reaches the highest levels
of moral reasoning, where justice and individual rights are guiding principles in a person’s life.
Kohlberg found that more men reached this stage of moral reasoning than women and that men
tended to be heavily focused on justice.
Gilligan criticized this theory, arguing that it was biased in favor of men. In her own research,
Gilligan found that women placed a stronger emphasis on caring in moral decision making.
The three stages of Moral development
Pre-conventional Level
This is the same as Kohlberg’s first level in that the person is preoccupied with self
centered reasoning, caring for the needs and desires of self.
Conventional level
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

✔ Here the thinking is opposite in that, one is preoccupied with not hurting others and a
willingness to sacrifice one’s own interests in order to help or nurture others (or retain
friendship).
Post-conventional Level
Achieved through context-oriented reasoning, rather than by applying abstract rules
ranked in a hierarchy of importance. Here the individual becomes able to strike a
reasoned balance between caring about other people and pursuing one’s own self-interest
while exercising one’s rights.
Gilligan’s level of Moral development
Level Appropriate age range Moral Development
Pre conventional Not listed ✔ Goals is individual survival. i.e.,
self centered attitude
✔ Transition is from selfishness to responsibility to others
Conventional Not listed ✔ Self sacrifice is goodness. i.e.,
individuals sacrifice their interest
to others.
✔ Transition is fromm foodness to truth that she is a person too
Post conventional May be never ✔ Principle of Non violence – do not
hurt others or self
✔ To balance between one’s own
needs with the needs of others
Note: thus the Kohlberg gives greater emphasis to recognizing rights and abstract universal rules.
Whereas, Gilligan stresses the importance of maintaining personal relationships based on mutual
caring

1. Differences between the TWO THEORIES

 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Example :
The difference in these two theories is explained through the well-known example, Heinz’s
dilemma
2. Heinz being poor and a debtor could not buy the costly medicine for his sick wife, at ten times
the normal cost. Initially he begged the Pharmacist to sell at half the price or allow him to pay
for it later. Pharmacist refused to oblige him either way. Finally he forcibly entered the
Pharmacy and stole the drug.
3. According to Kohlberg study, men observed that the theft was morally ‘wrong’ at the
conventional level, because the property right was violated. But men at the post-conventional
level, concluded that the theft was ‘right’, as the life of the human being was in danger. But
women observed that Heinz was wrong. They observed that instead of stealing he could have
tried other solutions (threatening or payment in installments?) to convince the Pharmacist.
4. Gilligan however attributed the decision by women as context-oriented and not on the basis of
rules ranked in the order of priority.
2.9. Consensus and controversy
Consensus means “agreement “ and controversy means disagreement
✔ When an individual exercise moral autonomy , he may not able to attain the same
results as other people obtain in practicing their moral autonomy.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

2.10. Professions
2.10.1. What is Profession?
The Latin root of word “profession” means the making of a public declaration
Profession is defined as any occupation/job/vocation that requires advanced
expertise (skills and knowledge), self regulation and concerted service to the public
good. It brings a high status, socially and economically
How do job and Occupation differ from profession
● Ant work for hire can be considered as job , irrespective of skills level involved
and the responsibility approved
● Occupation means employment through which someone makes a living
● Engineering is a job and also occupation. They are paid for services. They make
living out of it. But skills and responsibilities involved in engineering is more
than job
● The professions are occupations requiring sophisticated knowledge, group
commitment to some public good, and significant degree of self Regulation
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

2.11. Characteristics of Profession

2.11.1. Who is Professional?

The criteria for achieving and sustaining professional status or professionalism are:
● Advanced expertise: The expertise includes sophisticated skills and theoretical knowledge
in exercising judgment. This means a professional should analyse the problem in specific
known area, in an objective manner.
● Self-regulation: One should analyse the problem independent of self-interest and direct to
a decision towards the best interest of the clients/customers. An autonomous judgment
(unbiased and on merits only) is expected. In such situations, the codes of conduct of
professional societies are followed as guidance.
● Public good: One should not be a mere paid employee of an individual or a teaching
college or manufacturing organization, to execute whatever the employer wants one to do.
The job should be recognised by the public. The concerted efforts in the job should be
towards promotion of the welfare, safety, and health of the public.
2.11.2. Characteristics
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

The characteristics of the ‘profession’ as distinct from ‘non-professional occupation’ are

listed as follows:
o Extensive Training: Entry into the profession requires an extensive period of training
of intellectual (competence) and moral (integrity) character. The theoretical base is
obtained through formal education, usually in an academic institution. It may be a
Bachelor degree from a college or university or an advanced degree conferred by
professional schools.
o Knowledge and Skills: Knowledge and skills (competence) are necessary for the well-
being of the society. Knowledge of physicians protects us from disease and restores
health. The lawyer’s knowledge is useful when we are sued of a crime, or if our
business is to be merged or closed or when we buy a property. The Chartered
Accountant’s knowledge is important for the success of recording financial
transactions or when we file the income return. The knowledge, study, and research of
the engineers are required for the safety of the air plane, for the technological advances
and for national defense.
o Monopoly: The monopoly control is achieved in two ways:
▪ the profession convinces the community that only those who have graduated
from the professional school should be allowed to hold the professional title.
The profession also gains control over professional schools by establishing
accreditation standards
▪ By persuading the community to have a licensing system for those who want to
enter the profession. If practicing without license, they are liable to pay
penalties.
o Autonomy in Workplace: Professionals engaged in private practice have considerable
freedom in choosing their clients or patients. Even the professionals working in large
organizations exercise a large degree of impartiality, creativity and discretion (care
with decision and communication) in carrying their responsibilities. Besides this,
professionals are empowered with certain rights to establish their autonomy.
▪ Accordingly physicians must determine the most appropriate medical
treatments for their patients and lawyers must decide on the most successful
defense for their clients. The possession of specialized knowledge is thus a
powerful defense of professional autonomy.
o Ethical Standards: Professional societies promulgate the codes of conduct to regulate
the professionals against their abuse or any unethical decisions and actions
(impartiality, responsibility) affecting the individuals or groups or the society.
2.11.3. Models Of Professional Roles
Promotion of public good is the primary concern of the professional engineers. There are
several role models to whom the engineers are attracted. These models provoke their thinking,
attitudes and actions.
Savior: The engineer as a savior, save the society from poverty, illiteracy, wastage,
inefficiency, ill health, human (labor) dignity and lead it to prosperity, through technological
development and social planning. For example, R.L. Stevenson.
Guardian: He guards the interests of the poor and general public. As one who is conversant
with technology development, is given the authority befitting his expertise to determine what is
best suited to the society. For example, Lawrence of Arabia (an engineer).
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Bureaucratic Servant: He serves the organization and the employers. The management of an
enterprise fixes its goals and assigns the job of problem solving to the engineer, who accepts
the challenge and shapes them into concrete achievements. For example, Jamshedji Tata.
Social Servant: It is one who exhibits social responsibility. The engineer translates the interest
and aspirations of the society into a reality, remembering that his true master is the society at
large. For example, Sir M.Viswesvarayya.
Social Enabler and Catalyst: One who changes the society through technology. The engineer
must assist the management and the society to understand their needs and make informed
decisions on the desirable technological development and minimize the negative effects of
technology on people and their living environment. Thus, he shines as a social enabler and a
catalyst for further growth. For example, Sri Sundarlal Bahuguna.
Game Player: He is neither a servant nor master. An engineer is an assertive player, not a
passive player who may carry out his master’s voice. He plays a unique role successfully
within the organization, enjoying the excitement of the profession and having the satisfaction
of surging ahead in a competitive world. For example, Narayanamurthy, Infosys and Dr.
Kasthurirangan, ISRO.

2.12. Professional Responsibility

2.12.1. Senses
There are different senses of responsibility, such as:
Characteristic Quality - Primarily responsibility implies duty with care and efforts.
Obligations - These are one’s moral responsibility i.e., duty to act right and in moral ways.
The obligations such as honesty, fairness, and decency are incumbent on every one. In addition
to this, we have role responsibilities assigned by taking up various roles, such as parents,
inspectors, and employees. For example, a Safety Engineer has a responsibility to make regular
inspections in a factory shops.
General Moral Capacity - One has the general capacity for moral agency, including the
understanding and action on moral reasons.
Liability and Accountability - Liability and Accountability for actions. It means that one is
liable (with a legal sense) to meet the obligations in better ways. The person is likely to respond
legally, if necessary. Accountable means that one is willing to justify or defend the decisions,
actions or means and outcomes. It could include offering a reasonable excuse or accepting the
shame for not having met the end results or accepting the guilt for harming others. One is also
answerable to the assessment by others on one’s actions (means) or outcomes.
Praiseworthiness/Blameworthiness: When accountability for wrong actions or results is at
issue, responsibility means blameworthy. When the right conduct or successful result is at
issue, responsible is synonymous with praiseworthy.

2.12.2. Types of Responsibility

Different types of responsibilities exhibited in human transactions are:
Moral Responsibility:
Moral responsibility as applied to a professional: A professional must be responsible
morally, in creating internal good or good outcomes, and eliminating /minimizing un-
intended side-effects, from engineering and technology. It includes:
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

✔ Obligations: A commitment to moral actions (primary obligation to protect the safety of

the human beings and respect their rights),
✔ Conscientious: A comprehensive perspective to accept the duties, and diligently do the
right things by putting their heart, head and hands (awareness of the experimental nature of
the product/project, anticipating possible and unexpected outcomes and putting efforts to
monitor them),
✔ Accountability (being accountable for the decisions, actions, and the results of product/
project including safety), and
✔ Praiseworthy/Blameworthy as applied to context of doing things right/doing things
wrongly, respectively.
Causal Responsibility
It is being a cause of some event. For example, a child playing with matches cause a house to
burn. The child is causally responsible, but the parent who left the child with matches, is morally
responsible.
Job Responsibility - It consists of assigned tasks at the place of employment and achieving the
objectives.
Legal Responsibility - It is the response required by law and includes legal obligations and
accountability to meet them.Many of these responsibilities overlap with moral responsibility.
2.12.3. Responsible Professionalism
The most comprehensive virtue of engineers is responsible professionalism. It can also be
called Professional Responsibility. This consists of five types of virtues, as follows:
Self-direction (Self-governance) virtues are fundamental and necessary in exercising
moral responsibility. On the basis of ‘understanding and cognition’, it includes self-
understanding, humility (proper assessment of one’s character), and good moral judgment
(termed as ‘practical wisdom’ by Aristotle). On the basis of ‘commitment and action’, it
covers courage, self discipline, perseverance, self-respect, and integrity. Honesty a virtue
common to both bases as it implies truthfulness in thoughts and words and trustworthiness
in actions.
Public-spirited virtues focus on the good of the clients and the public. It includes the
respect for rights (to make decisions and face the risk), non-malfeasance (not harming
others intentionally). Engineering codes go a step further and prescribe beneficence that
includes preventing or removing harm to others and also promoting the public safety,
health, and welfare, generosity (helping the community by voluntarily giving their time,
talent, and money-voluntary service to the professional society and community), and justice
(unbiased) in all decisions and actions.
Team-work virtues enable the professionals to work successfully with others. They
include collegiality, cooperativeness, communicative ability, and respect for legitimate
authority. Responsible exercise of authority and the ability to motivate other to achieve are
also the relevant to team-work virtues.
Proficiency virtues, which mean the mastery of technical skills (called as Intellectual
Virtue by Aristotle). It includes competence (having qualified, licensed, and prepared to
execute the job that is undertaken), diligence (alert to dangers, careful attention, and
avoidance of laziness or workaholic nature), creativity (learning to respond to the changing
technological society), excellence (perform at the highest level), and self-renewal through
continuing education.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Cardinal (chief) virtues: Wisdom (prudence), courage (fortitude), temperance and justice.
Some of these may overlap other virtues. They are called ‘cardinal’ (Latin: cardo, hinge)
because they are hinges on which all virtues depend. These are also called moral (Latin:
mores, fixed values) because they govern our actions, regulate our passions, and guide our
conduct according to faith and reason. Wisdom is perception of truth and ability to
distinguish between the right and wrong. Courage means a firm and elevated mind.
Temperance represents order in words and actions. Justice is preserving humanity and
observing the faith of contracts. Although these virtues ring religious tones, they are very
relevant to the engineering practice.
2.12.4. Social Responsibility
Corporate organizations have social responsibility to all of their ‘stakeholders’. This includes
the wellbeing of the employees and their unions, socially responsible investors, customers,
dealers, suppliers, local communities, governments, non-governmental organizations, and the
business owners and managers. Besides showing concern with employee relations and other
internal organizational matters, the organization is concerned with
o how the product/project is marketed, used or misused, how it fails, and how it is
disposed or discarded. The ways in which the used battery cells and computers are
discarded have been debated in the engineers’ forums.
o protecting the work environment during manufacture as well as the external
environment during transport or use
o training the disadvantaged or physically-challenged workers
o subcontracting and hiring practices, and
o contribution to local communities to enrich their cultural, social, and civic life. It may
be
o even compensatory against the harm to environment (e.g., planting trees).
Various types of responsibilities such as causal, moral, and legal are distinguished through
appropriate examples, as shown below:

Events Responsibility
A stray cattle on the rail track caused (a) Although cattle is the cause, the owner
the derailment of goods train of the cattle is morally responsible
(b) For letting the cattle go astray on the
railway track, that is trespassing the owner
is legally responsible
A child playing with (safety?) matches causes Although the child is the cause, the parents
fire who who have left the match box within
the reach of the child, are morally
responsible
(a) Seth was driving a car. He failed to stop at (a) Seth is causally responsible
the red signal, which caused (b) Seth has been negligent of
an accident maintenance of brakes
(b) Suppose he applied brakes, but they failed
There was a forest fire. It was traced to camp Raj is causally responsible for the forest
fire at specific site and Raj was the last to use fire he failed to put out the camp fire.
the campsite. Although the temperature was high, and
the dry leaves helped the fire to spread,
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Raj allowed the fire to spread. Hence, he is

the cause
The products sold have caused harm while The engineer or the engineering firm is
being used legally responsible for the harmful effects
of defects in their products. But they are
not morally responsible for the harm or
defects
A fitter lost one his eyes while inserting a The hammer manufacturer was legally
chip by using a hammer responsible on the basis of the doctrine of
strict liability, which does not require any
proof of effect in the design of the hammer.
Morally the manufacturer was not
responsible
In a contract, it is not implied that the The engineer is free from legal
engineer to be held for not observing the responsibility, but he has moral
possibility of danger. But an accident occurs responsibility to observe the work done
A pandal erected by the contractor, in a No legal responsibility for pandal
marriage hall catches fire, due to a leakage of contractor. Owner of the hall is morally
electric current responsible for the leakage

Question papers were leaked out by some Controller of Examinations can not be held
persons, during transport legally responsible, although he is morally
responsible

2.12.5. Accountability
Accountability means:
The capacity to understand and act on moral reasons
Willingness to submit one’s actions to moral scrutiny and be responsive to the assessment of
others. It includes being answerable for meeting specific obligations, i.e., liable to justify (or
give reasonable excuses) the decisions, actions or means, and outcomes (sometimes
unexpected), when required by the stakeholders or by law.
Conscientiousness: It means:
o Being sensitive to full range of moral values and responsibilities and
o The willingness to upgrade their skills, put efforts, and reach the best balance possible
among those considerations, and
Blameworthy/Praiseworthy: Own the responsibility for the good or wrong outcomes. Courage
to accept the mistakes will ensure success in the efforts in future.
The terms ‘corporate responsibility’ and ‘corporate accountability’ have different meanings.
Corporate responsibility emphasizes the voluntary compliance of a particular organization to
particular codes of conduct. The groups of individuals in the organization are assigned
responsibilities through policy manuals and flow charts. The corporate accountability means
holding all the corporate organizations accountable to the public, employees, customers, and
stock holders, as empowered by rules and laws.
2.12.6. Obligation
The safety and other obligations of professional engineers are justifiable based on the
following aspects.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Moral obligations through laws and enforced codes of conduct

Through membership of professional society
Contractual agreement with the employers
By entry into career as engineer upon graduation from Engineering institutions and
By special employment agreements or agreement with professional societies.
The paramount obligation means, giving importance to the safety, health, and welfare of the
public in performing the professional duties.
Case Study: Choice of the Theory
The choice of the ethical theory to study a problem is illustrated herein with an example. In
tackling ethical problems, we can apply all the theories and analyze the actions and results from
different angles and see what result each theory gives rise to. This enables us to examine the
problem in different perspectives. Many a time, the result will be the same though we have
applied various theories.
A chemical plant near a small town is discharging hazardous wastes into the fields nearby. The
ground water gets contaminated and significant health problems surface in the community.
Since harm is caused to the residents, the action is unethical as per rights ethics. The
agriculturists who have the agrarian right of water supply have been over looked. The
pollutants may endanger their profession and welfare. Hence, rights ethics also concludes that
the action is unethical.
The effects of polluted water and the cost to purify the water by the municipality may out
weigh the economic benefits of the plant. Hence, the utilitarian analysis leads to the same
conclusion.
The groundwater harms the people and caused health problems. Hence, discharging the
pollutants is unethical as per duty ethics.
Generally, because the rights of the individuals should weigh strongly than the needs of the
society as a whole, rights and duty ethics take precedence over utilitarian considerations.
Caution is necessary in applying theory of virtue ethics. When we use the word ‘honor’, we
mean it to be a measure of dignity and integrity. It is a positive virtue. When it points to ‘pride’
it is not a virtue and has a negative connotation. History abounds with examples of war, which
have been fought and atrocities were committed on innocent people in order to preserve the
honor (pride) of an individual or a nation. In using virtue ethics, we have to ensure that the
traits of virtue are actually virtuous and will not lead to negative consequences.
2.13. Theories of Ethics
2.13.1. Types of Ethical Theories
S.NO TYPES BASED ON
1 Virtue ethics Virtues and vices
2 Utilitarianism Most good for most people
3 Duty ethics Duties to respect persons
4 Rights ethics Human Rights
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

2.13.2. Virtue Ethics Theory

Virtue Too much Too less

(Golden mean between extremes)
Courage Foolhardiness Cowardice
Truthfulness Revealing all in violation of tact Being secretive or lacking in
and confidentiality candor
Generosity Wasting one’s resources Being miserly
Friendliness Being annoyingly effusive Sulky or surly

● Virtue is often defined as moral distinction and goodness. A virtuous person exhibits good and
beneficial qualities. In virtue ethics, actions are considered right if they support good
character traits (virtues) and wrong if they support bad character traits (vices)
● Virtue ethics focuses on words such as responsibility, honesty, competence, and loyalty,
which are virtues. Other virtues might include trustworthiness, fairness, caring, citizenship,
and respect. Vices could include dishonesty, disloyalty, irresponsibility, or incompetence.
● Virtue ethics is closely tied to personal character.
● In many ways, this theory may seem to be mostly personal ethics and not particularly applicable to
engineering or professional ethics. However, personal morality cannot, or at any rate should not, be
separated from professional morality. If a behavior is virtuous in the individual’s personal life, the
behavior is virtuous in his or her professional life as well.
● Virtues are desirable ways of relating to other individuals, groups and organizations. They are very
much related to the motives, attitudes and emotions that are responsible for right or wrong conduct
of an individual.
● Professionalism is mainly based on the virtue rather than the technological development,
knowledge, economy etc

Do Engineers need Virtues?

 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

● According to a professional code of Ethics, the professional responsibilities include virtues that go
beyond fulfilling the basic duties of their professions.

Theories about Virtues

● The virtue ethics is about determining what kind of people should be
● In virtue ethics, one’s actions are considered right if he holds good character virtues and
wrong if we hold bad character vices. Thus virtue ethics is closely related to personal
character.
● The two basics old good theories about virtues are:
▪ Aristotle’s theory of the Golden Mean and
▪ Macintyre’s theory of virtue
a. Aristotle’s theory of the Golden Mean

● The concept of Aristotle’s theory of golden mean is represented in his work called
“Nicomachean Ethics”, in which Aristotle explains the origin, nature and development of
virtues which are essential for achieving the ultimate goal, happiness (Greek: eudaimonia),
which must be desired for itself.
● The virtue or excellence of a thing causes that thing both to be itself in good condition and to
perform its function well. Virtue, then, is a kind of moderation as it aims at the mean or
moderate amount.
● Aristotle’s ethics is strongly teleological, practical, which means that it should be the action that
leads to the realization of the good of the human being as well as the whole.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

● According to his theory, the virtue of wisdom highly essential for

or good judgment is accomplishing the rational
activities successfully
● Virtues or tendencies deficiency to find the Golden Mean between the extremes of
excess and
● In “The virtue of Aristotle’s ethics “, Gottlieb (1) identifies the three core aspects of the
doctrine of the mean. First, virtue, like health, is produced and preserved by avoiding
extremes. Second, virtue is a mean relative to us. Third, each virtue is a mean between
two vices, one of excess and one of deficiency.
● The golden mean represents a balance between extremes or vices. For example, courage is the
middle between one extreme of deficiency (cowardness) and the other extreme of excess
(recklessness).
● The mean as concerns fear and confidence is courage: those that exceed in fearlessness are
foolhardy, while those who exceed in fear are cowardly.
● The mean in respect to certain pleasures and pains is called temperance, while the excess is
called profligacy. Deficiency in this matter is never found, so this sort of person does not have a
name.
● In the matter of giving and earning money, the mean is liberality, excess and deficiency are
prodigality and miserliness. But both vices exceed and fall short in giving and earning in
contrary ways: the prodigal exceeds in spending, but falls short in earning; the miser exceeds in
earning, but falls short in spending.
● With respect to honor and disgrace, the mean is “high-mindedness,” the excess might be called
vanity, and the deficiency might be called humility or small-mindedness.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

b. Macintyre’s Theory of Virtues

● Alasdair Macintyre, a contemporary ethicist, related the social practices.
virtues with
That is cooperative activities that are aimed at achieving public goods. These public goods should not
be related to external goods such as money and prestige
● According to Macintyre, any profession should develop for the sake of public goods. He
calls the public goods as internal goods.
● (MacIntyre 1981) Action-based theories neglect the communal context. He argues that the
Enlightenment elevated autonomy (self-rule) which ends in individualism.
● Morality is rooted in practices, traditions and forms of life: a moral tradition which provides a
narrative structure.
● Out of primary loyalty to family, friends and community proper virtues flow.
● Moral psychology is important: a theory of how we learn and how we are motivated to be good.
● Examples
o Good of medicine is the promotion of health
o Good of law is social Justice
o Good of Engineering is the safety, health and welfare of the Public
o Good of Teaching is learning and self development
● Thus this theory defines professionalism as the services required for accomplishing the
public goods, in addition to practice of advanced theoretical and practical Knowledge

Strengths of Virtue Ethics

● It provides a motivation for good behaviors.

o Utilitarianism and Kantianism’s reasons behind the action is cold and analytical;
o Virtue ethics stresses the importance of loyalty, thoughtfulness, courteousness of
health social interactions
● It provides a solution to the problem of impartiality
o Utilitarianism and Kantianism require being completely impartial and treating all
human beings as equals.
o Virtue ethics justifies you to take your children to Disneyland, instead of donating the
money to starving children in Africa.
Weakness of Virtue Ethics
● The multiple virtues can allow the justification of injustices.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

● One cannot apply virtue ethics alone in many cases.

● One has to set different priorities to different virtues in different situations.
● Example: You have limited resource to fight one of the two fires
o Prudence: Fight the fire that can cause more property damage (Utilitarianism)
o Fight the fire in the area that paid the city tax (Duty)
2.14. Theories of Right Action
2.14.1. Theory of Utilitarianism
● Utilitarianism says the sole standard of right action is good consequences. There is only
one general moral requirement: Produce the most good for the most people, giving equal
consideration to everyone affected.
● The word utility is sometimes used to refer to good consequences and other times to the
balance of good over bad consequences.
● The utilitarian standard seems simple and reasonable. Surely morality involves producing good
consequences— especially in engineering. Indeed, utilitarian modes of thinking are reflected in
cost-benefit analyses
● Utilitarianism also seems a straight-forward way to interpret the central principle in most
engineering codes: “Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the
public in the performance of their professional duties.”
● Welfare is a rough synonym for overall good (utility), and safety and health might be viewed as
especially important aspects of that good.
● We can measure good consequences by what is intrinsic good—that is, good considered just
by itself. All other good things are instrumental goods in that they provide means (instruments)
for gaining intrinsic goods. Some utilitarian’s consider pleasure to be the only intrinsic good.
But that seems counterintuitive—there is nothing good about the pleasures of tyrants and
sadists take in inflicting suffering.
● John Stuart Mill believed that happiness was the only intrinsic good, and hence he understood
utilitarianism as the requirement to produce the greatest amount of happiness.
● Sometimes Mill confused happiness with pleasures and enjoyments, which are short-term, feel-
good states of consciousness.
● Mill thought of happiness as (a) a life rich in pleasures, especially the “higher” pleasures of
friendship, love, and intellectual endeavors, mixed with some inevitable pains, plus (b) a
pattern of activities and relationships that we can affirm as the way we want our lives to be.
● Some utilitarian’s understand intrinsic goods as those which a reasonable person would pursue,
or those which satisfy rational desires—those that we can affirm after fully examining them in
light of relevant information, for example, love, friendship, appreciation of beauty, in addition
to happiness.
● Most economists adopt a preference theory: What is good is what individuals prefer, as
manifested in what they choose to purchase in the marketplace.
● In addition to developing a reasonable view of intrinsic good, we need to decide whether to
focus on individual actions or general rules.
● Act Utilitarianism
o Classical, nineteenth-century utilitarian’s such as Mill believed in act-utilitarianism a
particular action is right if it is likely to produce the most good for the most people in a
given situation, compared with alternative options available. The standard can be
applied at any moment. Each option would have both immediate and long-term
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

consequences that can be estimated. The right action is the one that produces the most
overall good, taking into account everyone affected.
o Act-utilitarianism seems vulnerable to objections. It apparently permits some
actions that we know, on other grounds, are patently immoral. Suppose that stealing a
computer from my employer, an old one scheduled for replacement anyway, benefits
me significantly and causes only miniscule harm to the employer and others. We know
that the theft is unethical, and hence act-utilitarianism seems to justify wrongdoing.
Again, suppose that in a particular situation more good is promoted by keeping the
public ignorant about serious dangers, for example, by not informing them about a
hidden fault in a car or building. Or suppose that it will improve company morale if
several disliked engineers are fired after being blamed for mistakes they did not make.
Doing so is unfair, but the overall good is promoted.
● Rule Utilitarianism
o An alternative version of utilitarianism that says we should maximize the good through
following rules that maximize good consequences, rather than through isolated actions.
o According to this view, called rule-utilitarianism, right actions are those required
by rules that produce the most good for the most people.
o Because rules interact with each other, we need to consider a set of rules. Thus, we
should seek to discover and act on an optimal moral code—that set of rules which
maximizes the public good more than alternative codes would (or at least as much as
alternatives).
o Rule-utilitarian’s have in mind society-wide rules, but the same idea applies to rules
stated in engineering codes of ethics. Thus, an engineering code of ethics is justified in
terms of its overall good consequences , and so engineers should abide by it even when
an exception might happen to be beneficial.
2.15. Theory of Duty Ethics
● Rights and duties are typically correlated with each other. For example, our right to life places
duties on others not to kill us, and our right to liberty places duties on others not to interfere
with our freedom. Duty ethics reverses the order of priority by beginning with duties and
deriving rights from them. Although the similarities between duty ethics and rights ethics are
pronounced, historically they developed as distinct moral traditions.
● Duty ethics says that right actions are those required by duties to respect the liberty or
autonomy (self-determination) of individuals. One duty ethicist suggests the following list of
important duties: “(1) Do not kill. (2) Do not cause pain. (3) Do not disable.
2.15.1. Kant’s theory of Duty Ethics
● The duty ethics theory, proposed by Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) states, that actions are
consequences of performance of one’s duties such as, ‘being honest’, ‘not cause suffering of
others’, ‘being fair to others including the meek and week’, ‘being grateful’, ‘keeping promises’
etc. The stress is on the universal principle of respect for autonomy i.e., respect and rationality
of persons.
● As per Kant we have duties to ourselves, as we are rational and autonomous beings. We ought
always to treat persons as having their own rational aims, and not merely use them for our ends.
Immorality occurs when we reduce other people to mere means to our ends and needs. Violent
acts such as murder, rape, and torture are obvious ways of treating people as mere objects
serving our own purposes. We also fail to respect persons if we fail to provide support for them
when they are in desperate need, and we can help them at little inconvenience to ourselves.
Some duties, then, are to refrain from interfering with a person’s liberty, and some express
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

requirements to help them when they are in need, thereby paralleling the distinction between
liberty and positive rights
● We have a duty not to commit suicide; a duty to develop our talents and a duty to avoid harmful
drugs. Kant insisted that moral duties are categorical necessary. They are commands that we
impose on ourselves as well as other rational beings. A businessperson who is honest solely
because honesty pays—in terms of profits from customers who return and recommend their
services, as well as from avoiding jail for dishonesty—fails to fully meet the requirements of
morality. In this way, morality involves attention to motives and intentions, an idea also
important in virtue ethics.
2.15.2. John Rawls’s modern Theory of Duty Ethics
● On the other hand, the DUTY ethics theory, as enunciated by John Rawl, gave importance
to the actions that would be voluntarily agreed upon by all persons concerned, assuming
impartiality. His view emphasized the autonomy each person exercises in forming agreements
with other rational people.
● Rawl proposed two basic moral principles; (1) each person is entitled to the most extensive
amount of liberty compatible with an equal amount for others, and (2) differences in social
power and economic benefits are justified only when they are likely to benefit everyone,
including members of the most disadvantaged groups.
● The first principle is of prime importance and should be satisfied first. Without basic liberties
other economic or social benefits cannot be sustained for long.
● The second principle insists that to allow some people with great wealth and power is justified
only when all other groups are benefited.
● In the business scenario, for example, the free enterprise is permissible so far it provides the
capital needed to invest and prosper, thereby making job opportunities to the public and taxes
to fund the government spending on the welfare schemes on the poor people.
● C.W.D. Ross, the British philosopher introduced the term prima facie duties, which
means duties might have justified exceptions.
● In fact, most duties are prima facie ones; some may have obligatory or permissible exceptions.
Ross assumed that the prima facie duties are intuitively obvious (self-evident), while fixing
priorities among duties. He noted that the principles such as ‘Do not kill’ and ‘protect innocent
life’ involve high respect for persons than other principles such as, ‘Do not lie’ (less harmful).
● He has listed various aspects of Duty Ethics that reflect our moral convictions, namely:
o Fidelity : duty to keep promises.
o Reparation : duty to compensate others when we harm them.
o Gratitude : duty to thank those who help us.
o Justice : duty to recognize merit.
o Beneficence : duty to recognize inequality and improve the condition of others.
oSelf-improvement: duty to improve virtue and intelligence.
Non-malfeasance: duty not to injure others.

2.16. Theory of Right Ethics

o The ethical theory called rights ethics is distinctive in that it makes human rights the ultimate
appeal. Human rights constitute a moral authority to make legitimate moral demands on others to
respect our choices, recognizing that others can make similar claims on us.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

o The rights ethics emphasizes respecting the inherent dignity and worth of individuals as they
exercise their liberty. Rights ethics is the most familiar ethical theory, for it provides the moral
foundation of the political and legal system of the United States.
o Thus, in the Declaration of Independence Thomas Jefferson wrote: “We hold these truths to be
self-evident; that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with
certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.”
o Unalienable—or inalienable, natural, human—rights cannot be taken away (alienated) from us,
although of course they are sometimes violated. Human rights have been appealed to in all the
major social movements of the twentieth century, including the women’s movement, the civil rights
movement, the farm workers’ movement, the gay rights movement, and the patients’ rights
movement (in health care).
o The idea of human rights is the single most powerful moral concept in making cross-cultural moral
judgments about customs and laws. As such, the notions of human rights and legal rights are
distinct. Legal rights are simply those the law of a given society says one has, whereas human rights
are those we have as humans, whether the law recognizes them or not.

o Rights ethics applies to engineering in many ways. It provides a powerful foundation for the special
ethical requirements in engineering and other professions. Most engineering codes of ethics enjoin
holding paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public, a requirement that can be
interpreted as having respect for the public’s rights to life, rights not to be injured by dangerous
products, rights to privacy, and rights to receive benefits through fair and honest exchanges in a free
marketplace.
o In addition to human rights, there are special moral rights— rights held by particular individuals
rather than by every human being. For example, engineers and their employers have special moral
rights that arise from their respective roles and the contracts they make with each other. Special
rights are grounded in human rights, however indirectly.
o Rights ethics are of two kinds they are liberty rights and welfare rights. Liberty rights (negative
rights) are rights to exercise our liberty, and they place duties on other people not to interfere with
our freedom. Welfare rights are rights to benefits needed for a decent human life, when we cannot
earn those benefits, perhaps because we are severely handicapped, and when the community has
them available. (They are sometimes called positive rights.)
o Another influential version of rights ethics, however, denies there are welfare human rights.
Libertarians believe that only liberty rights exist; there are no welfare rights.
a. Locke’s version of right ethics
o John Locke (1632–1704), who was the first philosopher to carefully articulate a rights ethics, is
often interpreted as a libertarian. Locke’s version of human rights ethics was highly individualistic.
He viewed rights primarily as entitlements that prevent other people from meddling in our lives.
The individualistic aspect of Locke’s thought is reflected in the contemporary political scene in the
Libertarian political party and outlook, with its emphases on protecting private property,
dismantling welfare systems, and opposition to extensive government regulation of business and
the professions.
o Libertarians take a harsh view of taxes and government involvement beyond the bare minimum
necessary for national defense, a legal system, and the preservation of free enterprise.
o Locke thought of property as whatever we gained by “mixing our labor” with things—for
example, coming to own lumber by going into the wilderness and cutting down a tree. Even so,
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

Locke’s followers tended to insist that property was sacrosanct and that governments continually
intruded on property rights, particularly in the form of excessive taxation and regulation.
b. Melden’s version of right theory
o As per A.I. Melden’s theory based on rights, nature mandates that we should not harm others’ life,
health, liberty or property. Melden allowed welfare rights also for living a decent human life. He
highlighted that the rights should be based on the social welfare system.
c. Human rights:
o Human rights are explained in two forms, namely liberty rights and welfare rights. Liberty rights
are rights to exercise one’s liberty and stresses duties on other people not to interfere with one’s
freedom. The four features of liberty rights (also called moral rights), which lay the base for
Government Administration, are:
1. Rights are natural in so far as they are not invented or created by government.
2. They are universal, as they do not change from country to country.
3. They are equal since the rights are the same for all people, irrespective of caste, race,
creed or sex.
4. They are inalienable i.e., one cannot hand over his rights to another person such as
selling oneself to slavery.
o The Welfare Rights are the rights to benefit the needy for a decent human life, when one cannot
earn those benefits and when those benefits are available in the society.
d. Economic rights:
o In the free-market economy, the very purpose of the existence of the manufacturer, the sellers
and the service providers is to serve the consumer. The consumer is eligible to exercise some
rights. . The consumers’ six basic rights are: Right to Information, Right to Safety, Right to
Choice, Right to be Heard, Right to Redressal, and Right to Consumer Education.
o A few rights are absolute, i.e., unlimited and have no justifiable exceptions. For example, rights
ethicists view that the rights have not been violated if the people purchase a (technological
product) hang glider and they get injured by flying them carelessly or under bad weather
conditions. But human rights imply that one not to be poisoned or killed by technological
products, whose dangers are not obvious or wantonly hidden. They imply a right to be informed,
when the purchase was made, of the possible dangers during use or service (obtaining informed
consent).
Rights ethics is distinctive in that it makes human rights the ultimate appeal — the moral
bottom line. Human rights constitute a moral authority to make legitimate moral demands on
others to respect our choices, recognizing that others can make similar claims on us. Thus, we
see that the rights ethics provides a powerful foundation for the special ethical requirements in
engineering and other professions.
2.17. Interconnectedness among virtues
2.17.1. Integrity
● Moral Integrity is the unity of character based on the moral concern and honesty
● Integrity is a bridge that links the responsibilities between one’s personal life and
professional life
● According to the principle of unity, there should be perfect morality both in personal life
and professional life
● The virtues of self respect and pride in one’s work are possible only through the virtue of
integrity
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

● Maintaining integrity often requires the value of compromise. Compromises are

sometimes good and sometimes bad. Therefore, in order to maintain moral integrity, the
ability to identify the reasonable compromises is essential
● Integrity also implies basic honesty
o Truthfulness - meeting responsibilities concerning truth telling
o Trustworthiness - meeting responsibilities concerning trust
2.17.2. Self Respect
● Self respect refers to the virtue of properly valuing oneself in morally appropriate ways.
Valuing oneself property is essential in finding meaning of one’s life and work
● It is defined as valuing oneself in morally suitable ways.
● Self-respect includes (a) recognition, which means respect to others, their ideas, decisions,
ability, and rights and (b) appraisal, which means properly valuing ourselves as to how well
we face moral standards and our personal commitments (aims). An intensive but balanced
feeling of self-respect is sense of honor.
● This includes intense agony and guilt for wrong doings. Self-control is a virtue of
maintaining personal discipline (self-regulation).
● Courage is a bye-product of self-respect, which makes a person face the hardship in
rational way
● Self-respect is different from self-esteem in the following manner:

● The other related Virtues include:

o A sense of honor
o Self control
o Courage and
o Good judgment
● A sense of honor
o It is also known as dignity. It is the virtue of stressing the emotions of self
respect and also its minimum requirements. This involves pride in maintaining high
professional standards, shame for failing to meet minimum standards of
professionalism and guilty of wrongdoing
● Self control
o It is a virtue of maintaining personal discipline. It means a strong will and
motivation and avoidance of fear, hatred, lack of efforts, temptation, self-deception,
and emotional response. It encompasses courage and good judgment also. Self-
respect promotes self-control.
● Courage
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

● It is the virtue of controlling dangers and difficult tasks in rational ways and with
self control
● Courage supports self respect and in turn self respect support courage
● Courage is classified into three types, based on the types of risks, namely
a) Physical courage: In physical courage, the thrust is on the adequacy of the physical
strength, including the muscle power and armaments. People with high adrenalin, may be
prepared to face challenges for the mere ‘thrill’ or driven by a decision to ‘excel’.
b) Social courage: The social courage involves the decisions and actions to change the order,
based on the conviction for or against certain social behaviors. This requires leadership
abilities, including empathy and sacrifice, to mobilize and motivate the followers, for the
social cause.
c) Intellectual courage: The intellectual courage is inculcated in people through acquired
knowledge, experience, games, tactics, education, and training. In professional ethics,
courage is applicable to the employers, employees, public, and the press.
● Good Judgment
o It is the practical wisdom in moral matters of all vitues, including sel respect.
o It is very essential to strike a balance between any two extremes, such as one’s
concern for self oriented goods (like income and prestige) and for society
oriented goods (like producing worthy products)

2.18. Self Interest

● Self-interest is being good and acceptable to oneself. It is pursuing what is good for oneself.
It is very ethical to possess self-interest. As per utilitarian theory, this interest should
provide for the respect of others also. Duty ethics recognizes this aspect as duties to
ourselves. Then only one can help others.
● Right ethicist stresses our rights to pursue our own good. Virtue ethics also accepts the
importance of self-respect as link to social practices.
● In Ethical Egoism, the self is conceived in a highly individualistic manner. It says that
every one of us should always and only promote one’s own interest. The ethical egoists do
not accept the well being of the community or caring for others. However this self interest
should not degenerate into egoism or selfishness, i.e., maximizing only own well in the
pursuit of self-interest.
● The ethical egoists hold that the society benefits to maximum when (a) the individuals
pursue their personal good and (b) the individual organizations pursue maximum profit in a
competitive enterprise.
● This is claimed to improve the economy of the country as a whole, besides the individuals.
In such pursuits, both individuals and organizations should realize that independence is not
the only important value. We are also interdependent, as much as independent. Each of us
is vulnerable in the society.
● Self-respect includes recognition of our vulnerabilities and interdependencies. Hence, it is
compatible with caring for ourselves as well as others.
● Self-interest is necessary initially to begin with. But it should be one of the prime motives
for action; the other motive is to show concern for others, in the family as well as society.
One’s self-interest should not harm others. The principles of ‘Live and let (others) live’,
and ‘reasonably fair competition’ are recommended to professionals by the ethicists.
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

2.19. Custom
● Ethical Pluralism: Various cultures in our pluralistic society lead to tolerance for various
customs, beliefs, and outlooks. Accordingly ethical pluralism also exists. Although many moral
attitudes appear to be reasonable, the rational and morally concerned people cannot fully accept
any one of the moral perspectives. There are many varied moral values, which allow variation
in the understanding and application of values by the individuals or groups in their everyday
transactions. It means that even reasonable people will not agree on all moral issues and
professional ethics.
● Ethical Relativism: According to this principle, actions are considered morally right when
approved by law or custom, and wrong when they violate the laws or customs. The deciding
factor is the law or the customs of the society. Should we accept the principle of relativism or
not?
A few reasons to accept this are explained in the following paragraphs:
1. Laws appear to be objective ways for judging values. The laws and customs tend to be definite, clear
and real, but not always. Further moral reasons allow objective criticism of laws, as being morally
lacking. For example, the Apartheid laws of South Africa violated the human rights of the native
Africans. No legal protection was available for native citizens for a long time. Now, of course, these
laws have been repealed.
2. Ethical relativism assumes that the values are subjective at the cultural level. Moral standards also
vary from culture to culture. The objectivity is supported by the existing laws of that society. The
relative morality accepted, supports the virtue of tolerance of differences among societies. This
argument is also not fully acceptable. As per ethical relativism, the actions and laws of the Nazis and
Hitler who vowed on Anti-Semitism and killed several million Jews would be accepted as right.
3. Moral relationalism or moral contextualism: According to this, the moral judgments must be made in
relation to certain factors, which may vary from case to case. The morally important factors for making
judgments include the customs and laws. The virtue ethicists hold that the practical wisdom should
prevail upon assessing the facts and in the judgment.
● This principle was accepted by the early anthropologists because they had a specific tendency to
over-stress the scope of moral difference between cultures. The human sacrifices and cannibalism
were accepted. But the modern anthropologists insist that all cultures shall exhibit the virtue of
social welfare and safety against needless death or physical or mental harm. Moral differences were
based on the circumstances and facts and not on the difference in moral attitudes. For example, the
pharaohs buried the live attendants along with their dead king with the belief that they would
continue to serve the king in his afterlife.

2.20. Religion
● Religions have played major roles in shaping moral views and moral values, over geographical
regions. Christianity has influenced the Western countries, Islam in the Middle-East countries,
Buddhism and Hinduism in Asia, and Confucianism in China. Further, there is a strong
psychological link between the moral and religious beliefs of people following various religions
and faiths.
● Religions support moral responsibility. They have set high moral standards. Faith in the religions
provides trust and this trust inspires people to be moral. The religions insist on tolerance and moral
concern for others. Many professionals who possess religious beliefs are motivated to be morally
responsible.
● Each religion lays stress on certain high moral standards. For example, Hinduism holds polytheistic
(many gods) view, and virtues of devotion and surrender to high order. Christianity believes in one
 UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS

deity and emphasizes on virtues of Love, Faith, and Hope. Buddhism is non-theistic and focuses on
compassion and Islam on one deity and adherence of ishan (piety or pursuit of excellence) and
prayer. Judaism stresses the virtue of ‘tsedakah’ (righteousness). But many religious sects have
adopted poor moral standards, e.g., many religious sects do not recognize equal rights for women.
● The right to worship is denied for some people. People are killed in the name of or to promote
religion. Thus, conflicts exist between the ‘secular’ and religious people and between one religion
and another. Hence, religious views have to be morally scrutinized.
2.20.1. Divine Command Ethics
● As per this principle, the right action is defined by the commands by God. It implies that to be
moral, a person should believe in God and an action is right only if it is commanded by God. There
are some difficulties in this approach, namely, (a) whether God exists or not is not clear. (b) How to
know what are the God’s commands? and (c) How to verify the genuineness of the commands?
● Further, religions such as Hinduism, Islam, and Christianity accept the existence of God. But
Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism adopt only faith in a right path and do not believe in God.
● Socrates was said to have argued that God, an entity which is responsible, morally good, and
beyond fear or favor, would not command murder, rape, torture, immoral activities, and even mass
suicide. Many such crimes were committed in the name of God then and continue even now in
different parts of the world. Some Western leaders had claimed that God had commanded them to
invade against the Middle-East countries. If anyone claims to have obtained commands from God
to kill people merciless, then we have to conclude that the person is not religious but insane.

2.20.2. Uses of Ethical Theories

CASE STUDY: CHOICE OF THE THEORY
● The choice of the ethical theory to study a problem is illustrated herein with an example. In
tackling ethical problems, we can apply all the theories and analyze the actions and results from
different angles and see what result each theory gives rise to. This enables us to examine the
problem in different perspectives. Many a time, the result will be the same though we have applied
various theories
● Case: A chemical plant near a small town is discharging hazardous wastes into the fields nearby.
The ground water gets contaminated and significant health problems surface in the community.
Since harm is caused to the residents, the action is unethical as per rights ethics. The agriculturists
who have the agrarian right of water supply have been over looked. The pollutants may endanger
their profession and welfare. Hence, rights ethics also concludes that the action is unethical.
● The effects of polluted water and the cost to purify the water by the municipality may outweigh the
economic benefits of the plant. Hence, the utilitarian analysis leads to the same conclusion.
● The groundwater harms the people and caused health problems. Hence, discharging the pollutants is
unethical as per duty ethics. Generally, because the rights of the individuals should weigh strongly
than the needs of the society as a whole, rights and duty ethics take precedence over utilitarian
considerations.
● Caution is necessary in applying theory of virtue ethics. When we use the word ‘honor’, we mean
it to be a measure of dignity and integrity. It is a positive virtue. When it points to ‘pride’ it is not a
virtue and has a negative connotation. History abounds with examples of war, which have been
fought and atrocities were committed on innocent people in order to preserve the honor (pride) of
an individual or a nation. In using virtue ethics, we have to ensure that the traits of virtue are
actually virtuous and will not lead to negative consequences.
UNIT II ENGINEERING ETHICS
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

Engineering as Experimentation – Engineers as responsible Experimenters – Codes of Ethics –
A Balanced Outlook on Law.

3.1. Engineering as Experimentation

● Experimentation is commonly recognized as playing an essential role in the design process.
● Preliminary tests or simulations are conducted from the time it is decided to convert a
new engineering concept into its first rough design.
● Materials and processes are tried out, usually employing formal experimental techniques.
● Such tests serve as the basis for more detailed designs, which in turn are tested.
● At the production stage further tests are run, until a finished product evolves.
● The normal design process is thus iterative, carried out on trial designs with modifications
being made on the basis of feedback information acquired from tests.
● However, each engineering project taken as a whole may be viewed as an experiment.
3.1.1. Similarities to Standard Experiments
Several features of virtually every kind of engineering practice combine to make it
appropriate to view engineering projects as experiments.
a) Partial Ignorance: Any project is carried out in partial ignorance. There are uncertainties in the
● Abstract model used for the design calculations;
● Precise characteristics of the materials purchased;
● Precision of materials processing and fabrication;
● About the nature of the stresses the finished product will encounter.
✔ Engineers do not wait until all the relevant facts are in before commencing work.
✔ The theoretical exploration and laboratory testing must be avoided for the sake of
moving ahead on a project.
✔ But an engineer’s success lies precisely in the ability to complete tasks safely with
only a partial knowledge of scientific laws about nature and society.

b) Uncertainty:
✔ The final outcomes of engineering projects are also uncertain as in experiments. Often
in engineering it is not even known the possible outcomes, and great risks may also occur in
simple projects.
✔ For example, A reservoir may do damage to a region’s social structure or to its ecosystem. It
may not even serve its intended purpose if the dam leaks or breaks. An canal may bring about
a population explosion in a region where it is the only source of water, creating dependency
and vulnerability without adequate safeguards.
✔ A jumbo airplane may bankrupt the small airline that bought it as a status symbol.
✔ A special-purpose fingerprint reader may find its main application in the identification
and surveillance of protester by dictatorial command.
✔ A nuclear reactor, the scaled-up version of a successful smaller model, may exhibit
unexpected problems that cause danger to the surrounding population, leading to its
untimely shutdown at great cost to owner and consumers alike.
✔ A hair dryer may have exposed the user to lung damage from the asbestos insulation in its barrel.

1
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

c) Continuous Monitoring:
✔ Effective engineering relies on knowledge gained about products both before and after
they leave the factory. Ongoing success in engineering depends on gaining new
knowledge, as ongoing success in experimentation.
✔ Monitoring is thus as essential to engineering as it is to experimentation in general. To
monitor is to make periodic observations and tests to check for both successful
performance and accidental side effects.
✔ But as the ultimate test of a product’s efficiency, safety, cost-effectiveness,
environmental impact, and visual value lies in how well that product functions within
society,
✔ Monitoring cannot be restricted to the in-house development or testing phases
of an engineering venture. It also extends to the stage of client use.
✔ As in experimentation, both the intermediate and final results of an engineering
project deserve analysis if the correct lessons are to be learned from it.
d) Learning from the Past
✔ Engineers learn from their own earlier design and operating results, as well as from
those of other engineers
✔ Lack of established channels of communication, omitted satisfaction in not
asking for information, embarrassment at failure or fear of litigation
✔ These examples illustrate why it is not enough for engineers to rely on handbooks and
computer programs without knowing the limits of the tables and algorithms underlying their
favorite tools
i. The Titanic lacked a sufficient number of lifeboats decades after most of
the passengers and crew on the steamship Arctic had perished because of
the same problem.
ii. “Complete lacks of protection against impact by shipping caused Sweden’s
worst ever bridge collapse on Friday as a result of which eight people were
killed.” Thus reported the New Civil Engineer on January 24, 1980. Engineers
now recommend the use of floating concrete bumpers that can deflect ships, but
that recommendation is rarely heeded as seen by the 1993 collapse of the Bayou
Canot bridge that cost 43 passengers of the Sunset Limited their lives.
iii. Valves are notorious for being among the least reliable components of hydraulic
systems.It was a pressure relief valve, and a lack of definitive information
regarding its open or shut state, which contributed to the nuclear reactor accident
at Three Mile Island on March 28, 1979. Similar malfunctions had occurred with
identical valves on nuclear reactors at other locations.
iv. The required reports had been filed with Babcock and Wilcox, the reactor’s
manufacturer, but no attention had been given to them.
3.1.2. Contrasts with Standard Experiments

a. Experimental Control.
o In standard experiments, members for study are selected into two groups namely A
and B at random. Group A are given special treatment. The group B is given no
treatment and is called the ‘controlled group’. But they are placed in the same
environment as the other group A. This process is called the experimental control.
This practice is adopted in the field of medicine.

2
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

o In engineering, this does not happen, except when the project is confined to
laboratory experiments. This is because it is the clients or consumers who choose
the product, exercise the control. It is not possible to make a random selection of
participants from various groups. In engineering, through random sampling, the
survey is made from among the users, to assess the results on the product.
o For example, social scientists monitor and collect data on differences and
similarities between existing educational systems that were not initially set up as
systematic experiments.
o In doing , So they regard the current diversity of systems as constituting what has
been called a natural Experiment. Similarly, we think that engineering can be
appropriately viewed as just such a natural experiment using human subjects
o Thus the above discussion justifies the view of engineering as a social experimentation.
.
b. Humane touch:
o Engineering experiments involve human souls, their needs, views, expectations,
and creative use as in case of social experimentation. This point of view is not
agreed by many of the engineers. But now the quality engineers and managers
have fully realized this humane aspect.

c. Informed Consent.
o Viewing engineering as an experiment on a societal scale places the focus on the
human beings affected by technology, for the experiment is performed on persons,
not on inanimate objects.
o Engineering closely parallels medical testing of new drugs or procedures on
human subjects.
o Society has recently come to recognize the primacy of the subject’s safety and freedom
of choice as to whether to participate in medical experiments.
o Current medical practice has increasingly tended to accept as fundamental the
subject’s moral and legal rights to give informed consent before participating in an
experiment, contemporary engineering practice is only beginning to recognize
those rights.
o We believe that the problem of informed consent, which is so critical to the concept
of a properly conducted experiment involving human subjects, should be the
keystone in the interaction between engineers and the public.
o When a manufacturer sells a new device to a knowledgeable firm that has its own
engineering staff, there is usually an agreement regarding the shared risks and
benefits of trying out the technological innovation.
o Informed consent is understood as including two main elements:
▪ knowledge: the human subjects should be given not only the information
they request, but all the information needed to make a reasonable decision.
▪ Voluntariness. The human subjects must enter into the experiment without
being subjected to force, fraud, or dishonesty. Respect for the fundamental
rights of nonconforming minorities and compensation for harmful effects are
taken for granted here.

3
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ The mere purchase of a product does not constitute informed consent, any more than does
the act of showing up on the occasion of a medical examination. The public and clients must
be given information about the practical risks and benefits of the process or product in terms
they can understand. Supplying complete information is neither necessary nor in most cases
possible.
✔ We do not propose a process resembling the preparation and release of environmental
impact reports. We favor the kind of sound advice a responsible physician gives a patient
when prescribing a course of drug treatment that has possible side effects. The physician
must search beyond the typical sales brochures from drug manufacturers for adequate
information; hospital management must allow the physician the freedom to undertake
different treatments for different patients, as each case may constitute a different
“experiment” involving different circumstances; finally, the patient must be readied to
receive the information.
✔ Likewise, engineers cannot succeed in providing essential information about a project or
product unless there is cooperation by superiors and also openness on the part of those who
should have the information.

✔ Example:

o When Northern States Power Company (Minnesota) was planning a new power plant,
it got in touch with local citizens and environmental groups before it committed large
sums of money to preliminary design studies. The company was able to present
convincing evidence regarding the need for a new plant and then suggested several
sites. Citizen groups responded with a site proposal of their own. The latter was
found acceptable by the company. Thus, informed consent was sought from and
voluntarily given by those the project affected, and the unfriendly and prolonged
battles so common in other cases where a company has already invested heavily in
decisions based on engineering studies alone was avoided.
✔ Valid consent defined by the following conditions:
1. The consent was given voluntarily.
2. The consent was based on the information that a rational person would want, together with
any other information requested, presented to them in understandable form.
3. The consenter was competent (not too young or mentally ill) to process the information and
make rational decisions.
We suggest two requirements for situations in which the subject cannot be readily
identified as an individual:
4. Information that a rational person would need, stated in understandable form, has been
widely disseminated.
5. The subject’s consent was offered in proxy by a group that collectively represents many
subjects of like interests, concerns, and exposure to risk.
3.1.3. Knowledge Gained.
▪ According to a valuable interpretation of the social-experimentation paradigm by Taft
Broome. “Engineering projects are experiments that are not necessarily designed to
produce very much knowledge,” whereas, Scientific experiments are conducted to gain
new knowledge.

4
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

▪ The final outcomes of almost all engineering experiments are unexpected outcomes.
▪ The unexpected outcomes send us on a search for new knowledge—possibly
involving an experiment of the scientific type.
▪ It is also viewed that the best outcome is the one, who confirms that we are right
about something. Always best outcome should give us something new.
▪ Engineers should learn not only from their own earlier design and operating results but
also from those of other Engineers
▪ Engineers cannot rely only on Handbooks. They should demand updated and
detailed information at every stage of a project history.
▪ At the outset , from the subject point of view , we are concerned about the manner in
which the experiment is conducted, such as that valid consent of human subjects is
sought, safety measures are taken, and means exist for terminating the experiment at any
time and providing all participants a safe exit.

3.2. Engineers as Responsible Experimenters

What are the responsibilities of engineers to society?
✔ Engineers are the main technical enablers or facilitators; they are far from being the
sole experimenters.
✔ Their responsibility is shared with management, the public, and others.
✔ The other unique position to monitor projects, to identify risks, and to provide clients
and the public with the information needed to make reasonable decisions.
General Features of morally responsible Engineers are:
From the perspective of engineering as social experimentation, four features characterize
what it means to be a responsible person while acting as an engineer.
✔ A conscientious commitment to live by moral values: A primary obligation to
protect the safety of human subjects and respect their right of consent
✔ A comprehensive perspective A constant awareness of the experimental nature of any
project, imaginative forecasting of its possible side effects, and a reasonable effort to
monitor them
✔ Autonomy: Autonomous, personal involvement in all steps of a project
✔ Accountability : Accepting accountability for the results of a project

3.2.1. Conscientiousness
✔ Conscientiousness means commit themselves to live according to moral values
✔ By conscientious moral commitment we mean sensitivity to the full range of moral values
and responsibilities relevant to a given situation,
✔ Also engineers should have the willingness to develop the skill and apply the effort
needed to reach a reasonable balance among those considerations.
✔ Conscientiousness implies consciousness: open eyes, open ears, and an open mind.
✔ There are obvious benefits in terms of cautious self-interest and concern for one’s family
that make it easy to emphasize as primary the obligations to one’s employer.
✔ Conceiving engineering as social experimentation restores the vision of engineers as
guardians of the public interest, whose professional duty it is to hold the safety, health, and
welfare of those affected by engineering projects.

5
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ And this helps to ensure that such safety and welfare will not be disregarded in the quest for
new knowledge, the rush for profits, a narrow adherence to rules, or a concern over benefits
for the many that ignores harm to the few.
✔ The role of social guardian should not suggest that engineers force their own views of the
social good on society.
✔ As with medical experimentation on humans, the social experimentation involved in engineering
should be restricted by the participant’s voluntary and informed consent.

3.2.2. Comprehensive Perspective

✔ Conscientiousness is blind without relevant factual information. Hence showing moral
concern involves a commitment to obtain and properly assess all available information that
is relatable to meet moral responsibility.
✔ For example, in designing a heat exchanger, if I ignore the fact that it will be used in the
manufacture of a potent, illegal hallucinogen, I am showing a lack of moral concern. One
should be aware of the wider implications of one’s work that makes participation in, say, a
design project for a super weapon morally problematic—and that makes it sometimes
convenient for engineers self-deceivingly to ignore the wider context of their activities, a
context that may rest uneasily with conscience.
✔ Another way of simple context of one’s work results from the ever-increasing specialization
and division of labor that makes it easy to think of someone else in the organization as
responsible for what otherwise might be a bothersome personal problem.
✔ Engineering as social experimentation points out the importance of context, it also urges
the engineer to view his or her specialized activities in a project as part of a larger whole
having a social impact:
✔ An impact that may involve a variety of unintended effects.
✔ It might be said that the goal is to practice “preventive technology,” which parallels the idea
of preventive medicine: The solution to the problem is not in successive cures to successive
science- caused problems; it is in their prevention.”
✔ No amount of disciplined and imaginative foresight, however, can anticipate all dangers.
Because engineering projects are inherently experimental in nature, they need to be
monitored on an ongoing basis from the time they are put into effect.
✔ Individual practitioners cannot privately conduct full-blown environmental and social
impact studies, but they can choose to make the extra effort needed to keep in touch with the
course of a project after it has officially left their hands. This is a mark of personal
identification with one’s work, a notion that leads to the next aspect of moral responsibility.
3.2.3. Moral Autonomy
✔ People are morally autonomous when their moral conduct and principles of action are their
own, in a special sense derived from Kant: Moral beliefs and attitudes should be held on
the basis of critical reflection rather than passive adoption of the particular
conventions of one’s society, church, or profession. This is often what is meant by
“authenticity” in one’s commitment to moral values
✔ . Those beliefs and attitudes, moreover, must be integrated into the core of an individual’s
personality in a manner that leads to committed action.

6
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ It is a comfortable illusion to think that in working for an employer, and thereby performing
acts directly serving a company’s interests, one is no longer morally and personally
identified with one’s actions. Selling one’s labor and skills may make it seem that one has
thereby disowned and forfeited power over one’s actions.
✔ As an experimenter, an engineer is exercising the sophisticated training that forms the
core of his or her identity as a professional.
✔ Moreover, viewing an engineering project as an experiment that can result in unknown
consequences should help inspire a critical and questioning attitude about the adequacy of
current economic and safety standards. This also can lead to a greater sense of personal
involvement with one’s work.
✔ The magnitude of moral autonomy is to be experienced by engineers in highly influenced
by the attitude of company’s management
✔ When there is threat for engineer’s moral autonomy, then engineers can look for moral support
from their professional societies and other outside organization

3.2.4. Accountability
✔ The term accountability means being responsible, liable, answerable or duty-bounded
✔ The term more properly refers generally of being willing to submit one’s actions to
moral scrutiny and be open and responsive to the assessments of others.
✔ It involves willingness to present morally strong reasons for one’s conduct when called on
to do so in appropriate circumstances.
✔ Accountability was documented by some famous experiments conducted by Stanley Milgram
during the 1960s. Subjects would come to a laboratory believing they were to participate in a
memory and learning test. In one variation, two other people were involved, the
“experimenter” and the “learner.” The experimenter was regarded by the subject as an
authority figure, representing the scientific community. He or she would give the subject
orders to administer electric shocks to the “learner” whenever the latter failed in the memory
test. The subject was told the shocks were to be increased in magnitude with each memory
failure. All this, however, was a dishonesty.
✔ When the subjects were placed in an adjoining room separated from the “learner” by a
shaded glass window, more than half were willing to follow orders to the full extent: giving
the maximum electric jolt of 450 volts. The same results occurred when the subjects were
allowed to hear the (apparently) pained screams and protests of the “learner,” screams and
protests that became intense from 130 volts on. There was a striking difference, however,
when subjects were placed in the same room within touching distance of the “learner.” Then
the number of subjects willing to continue to the maximum shock dropped by one-half.
✔ Milgram explained these results by citing a strong psychological tendency to be
willing to abandon personal accountability when placed under authority.
✔ He saw his subjects ascribing all initiative, and thereby all accountability, to what they
viewed as Legitimate authority.
✔ The separation between causal influence and moral accountability is common in business
and the professions, and engineering is no exception.
✔ Such a psychological break is encouraged by several prominent features of
contemporary engineering practice.

7
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ First, large-scale engineering projects involve fragmentation of work. Each person makes
only a small contribution to something much larger. The final product is often physically
removed from one’s immediate workplace, creating the kind of “distancing” that Milgram
identified as encouraging a lessened sense of personal accountability.
✔ Second, corresponding to the fragmentation of work is a vast diffusion of accountability
within large institutions.
✔ Third, there is often pressure to move on to a new project before the current one has been
operating long enough to be observed carefully. This promotes a sense of being accountable
only for meeting schedules.
✔ Fourth, the contamination of malpractice suits currently afflicting the medical
profession is carrying over into engineering.
✔ Engineers are blameworthy for all the harmful side effects of the projects they work on,
even though they partially cause those effects simply by working on the projects. That
would be to confuse accountability with blameworthiness, and also to confuse causal
responsibility with moral responsibility

3.3. Code of Ethics

3.3.1. Importance of Codes
✔ Codes of ethics state the moral responsibilities of engineers by the profession and as
represented by a professional society. Because they express the profession’s collective
commitment to ethics.
✔ Codes are important, not only in stressing engineers’ responsibilities but also in
supporting the freedom needed to meet them.

3.3.2. Positive functional roles of Code of Ethics

✔ Codes of ethics play at least eight essential roles:
✔ serving and protecting the public, providing guidance, offering inspiration, establishing
shared standards, supporting responsible professionals, contributing to education, deterring
wrongdoing, and strengthening a profession’s image.
a. Serving and protecting the public. Engineering involves advanced expertise that
professionals have and the public lacks, and also considerable dangers to a
vulnerable public. Trust and trustworthiness are essential. A code of ethics
functions as a commitment by the profession as a whole that engineers will serve
the public health, safety, and welfare. In one way or another, the remaining
functions of codes all contribute to this primary function.
b. Guidance. Codes provide helpful guidance by communicating the main
obligations of engineers. Because codes should be brief to be effective, they offer
mostly general guidance. More specific directions may be given in supplementary
statements or guidelines, which tell how to apply the code.
c. Inspiration. Because codes express a profession’s collective commitment to ethics,
they provide a positive stimulus (motivation) for ethical conduct. In a powerful way,
they voice what it means to be a member of a profession committed to responsible
conduct in promoting the safety, health, and welfare of the public. It expresses a
collective commitment to the public good that inspires individuals to have similar
aspirations.

8
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

d. Shared standards. The diversity of moral viewpoints among individual engineers

makes it essential that professions establish explicit standards, in particular
minimum (but hopefully high) standards. In this way, the public is assured of a
standard of excellence on which it can depend, and professionals are provided a fair
playing field in competing for clients.
e. Support for responsible professionals. Codes give positive support to professionals
seeking to act ethically. A publicly announced code allows an engineer, under
pressure to act unethically, to say: “I am bound by the code of ethics of my
profession, which states that . . .” This by itself gives engineers some group backing
in taking stands on moral issues. Moreover, codes can potentially serve as legal
support for engineers criticized for living up to work-related professional obligations.
f. Education and mutual understanding. Codes can be used by professional societies
and in the classroom to prompt discussion and reflection on moral issues. Widely
circulated and officially approved by professional societies, codes encourage a
shared understanding among professionals, the public, and government
organizations about the moral responsibilities of engineers.
g. Deterrence and discipline. Codes can also serve as the formal basis for investigating
unethical conduct. Where such investigation is possible, a deterrent for immoral
behavior is thereby provided. Such an investigation generally requires paralegal
proceedings designed to get at the truth about a given charge without violating the
personal rights of those being investigated. Unlike the American Bar Association and
some other professional groups, engineering societies cannot by themselves revoke
the right to practice engineering in the United States. Yet some professional societies
do suspend or expel members whose professional conduct has been proven unethical,
and this alone can be a powerful sanction when combined with the loss of respect
from colleagues and the local community that such action is bound to produce.
h. Contributing to the profession’s image. Codes can present a positive image to the
public of an ethically committed profession. Where warranted, the image can help
engineers more effectively serve the public. It can also win greater powers of self
regulation for the profession itself, while lessening the demand for more government
regulation. The reputation of a profession, depends on reputation of an individual
professional or a corporation, is essential in sustaining the trust of the public.
3.3.3. Abuse of Codes
✔ When codes are not taken seriously within a profession, they amount to a kind of
window dressing that ultimately increases public doubt about the profession.
✔ The worst abuse of engineering codes is to restrict honest moral effort on the part of
individual engineers to preserve the profession’s public image and protect the status quo.
And an excessive interest in protecting the status quo may lead to a distrust of the
engineering profession on the part of both government and the public.
✔ The best way to increase trust is by encouraging and helping engineers to speak freely
and responsibly about public safety and well-being. This includes a tolerance for
criticisms of the codes themselves, rather than allowing codes to become sacred
documents that have to be accepted uncritically.

9
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ On rare occasions, abuses have discouraged moral conduct and caused serious harm to those
seeking to serve the public. For example, two engineers were expelled from American
Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) for violating a section of its code forbidding public
remarks critical of other engineers. Yet the actions of those engineers were essential in
uncovering a major bribery scandal related to the construction of a dam for Los Angeles
County.
✔ Consider the following entry in the pre-1979 versions of the NSPE code: The engineer “shall
not solicit or submit engineering proposals on the basis of competitive bidding.” This
prohibition was felt by the NSPE to best protect the public safety by discouraging cheap
engineering proposals that might slight safety costs to win a contract. The Supreme Court
ruled, however, that it mostly served the self-interest of established engineering firms and
actually hurt the public by preventing the lower prices that might result from greater
competition (National Society of Professional Engineers v. United States [1978]).
3.3.4. Limitations of Codes
✔ Codes are no substitute for individual responsibility in grappling with concrete dilemmas.
✔ General and vague wordings. Many statements are general in nature and hence unable to
solve all problems.
✔ Not applicable to all situations. Codes are not sacred, and need not be accepted without
criticism. Tolerance for criticisms of the codes themselves should be allowed.
✔ Often have internal conflicts. Many times, the priorities are clearly spelt out, e.g., codes
forbid public remarks critical of colleagues (engineers), but they actually discovered a
major bribery, which might have caused a huge loss to the exchequer.
✔ They cannot be treated as final moral authority for professional conduct. Codes have flaws
by commission and omission. There are still some grey areas undefined by codes. They
can not be equated to laws. After all, even laws have loopholes and they invoke creativity
in thelegal practitioners.
✔ Only a few enroll as members in professional society and non-members can not be compelled.
✔ Even as members of the professional society, many are unaware of the codes
✔ Codes are said to be coercive. They are sometimes claimed to be threatening and forceful.
✔ This last limitation of codes connects whether professional groups or entire societies can
create sets of standards for themselves that are both morally authoritative and not open to
criticism, or whether group standards are always open to moral scrutiny in light of wider
values familiar in everyday life. This is the issue of ethical relativism.
Ethical Relativism:
✔ “A code of professional ethics may be thought of as a collective recognition of the
responsibilities of the individual practitioners”; codes cannot be “used in cookbook
fashion to resolve complex problems,” but instead they are “valuable in outlining the
factors to be considered.”
✔ Unger takes codes very seriously as a profession’s shared voice in articulating the
responsibilities of its practitioners. A good code provides valuable focus and direction.
✔ Michael Davis says they are morally authoritative. “A code of ethics is, as such, not merely
good advice or a statement of aspiration. It is a standard of conduct which, if generally
realized in the practice of a profession, imposes a moral responsibility on each member of
the profession to act accordingly.”

10
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ Davis also called it as ethical conventionalism, which says that moral values are entirely
relative to and reducible to customs—to the conventions, laws, and norms of the group to
which one belongs.
✔ Anthropologist Ruth Benedict, “We recognize that morality differs in every society, and is a
convenient term for socially approved habits. Mankind has always preferred to say, ‘It is
morally good,’ rather than ‘It is habitual.’
✔ Ethical relativism also seems to allow any group of individuals to form its own society with
its own conventions. Again, an engineer might be a member of one or more professional
societies, a weapons development corporation and a pacifist religious tradition, and the
customs of these groups in matters of military work might point in different directions.
✔ Some moral requirements are indeed established by mutual agreements. Just as laws
establish the legal and moral permissibility of driving on the right side of the road (in the
United States) or the left side (in England), some requirements in engineering codes of ethics
create responsibilities.
✔ Unger is correct in holding that many of the entries in codes of ethics state responsibilities
that would exist regardless of the code—for example, to protect the safety, health, and
welfare of the public. Davis is correct that some parts of codes are conventions arrived at by
mutual agreement within the profession.
3.3.5. Justification of Codes
✔ A sound professional code will stand up to three tests: (1) It will be clear and coherent; (2) it
will organize basic moral values applicable to the profession in a systematic and
comprehensive way, highlighting what is most important; and (3) it will provide helpful and
reasonable guidance that is compatible with our most carefully considered moral convictions
(judgments, intuitions) about concrete situations. In addition, it will be widely accepted
within the profession.
✔ Testing the code in light of an ethical theory will need to take close account of both the
morally relevant features of engineering and the kinds of public goods engineering seeks to
provide for the community.
✔ Justified professional code will take account of both the profession’s public good and social
frame works and institutional settings.

3.4. A Balanced Outlook on Law

The ‘balanced outlook on law’ in engineering practice stresses the necessity of laws and regulations
and also their limitations in directing and controlling the engineering practice. Laws are necessary
because, people are not fully responsible by themselves and because of the competitive nature of
the free enterprise, which does not encourage moral initiatives. Laws are needed to provide a
minimum level of compliance.
The following codes are typical examples of how they were enforced in the past:
3.4.1. Code of Builders by Hammurabi
Hammurabi, as king of Babylon, was concerned with strict order in his realm, and he decided
that the builders of his time should also be governed by his laws. In 1758 BCE he declared:
“If a builder has built a house for a man and has not made his work sound, and the
house which he has built has fallen down and so caused the death of the householder, that
builder shall be put to death. If a builder has built a house for a man and does not make his
work perfect and the wall bulges, that builder shall put that wall into sound condition at his
own cost.” This code was expected to put in self-regulation seriously in those years.

11
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

One of the greatest moral problems in engineering, and one fostered by the very existence
of minutely detailed rules, is that of minimal compliance. This can find its expression when
companies or individuals search for loopholes in the law. That will allow them to barely keep to its
letter even while violating its spirit.
Minimal compliance led to the tragedy of the Titanic:
Why should that ship have been equipped with enough lifeboats to accommodate all its passengers
and crew when British regulations at the time required only a lower minimum, even with smaller
ships in mind?
Steam Boat Code in USA
Whenever there is crisis we claim that there ought to be law to control this. Whenever there is
a fire accident in a factory or fire cracker’s store house or boat capsize we make this claim, and soon
forget. Laws are meant to be interpreted for minimal compliance. On the other hand, laws when
amended or updated continuously would be counterproductive. Laws will always lag behind the
technological development. The regulatory or inspection agencies such as Environmental authority of
India can play a major role by framing rules and enforcing compliance.
In the early 19th century, a law was passed in USA to provide for inspection of the safety of
boilers and engines in ships. It was amended many times and now the standards formulated by the
American Society of Mechanical Engineers are followed.
3.4.2. Regulation Societies
Lawmakers cannot be expected always to keep up with technological development. Nor
would we necessarily want to see laws changed with each innovation. Instead we empower
rulemaking and inspection agencies like the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), Federal Aviation
Agency (FAA), and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) are examples of these in the United
States. Although they are nominally independent in that they belong neither to the judicial nor the
executive branches of government, their rules have, for all practical
purposes, the effect of law, but they are headed by political appointees.
Industry tends to complain that excessive restrictions are imposed on it by regulatory
agencies. But one needs to reflect on why regulations may have been necessary in the first place. For
example, the
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission’s rule for baby cribs, which specifies that “the distance
between components (such as slats, spindles, crib rods, and corner posts)shall not be greater than
inches at any point.” This rule came about because some manufacturers of baby furniture had
neglected to consider the danger of babies strangling in cribs or had neglected to measure the size of
babies’ heads.

12
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

When the Environment protection Agency (EPA) adopted rules for asbestos emissions in
1971, it was recognized that strict numerical standards would be impossible to disseminate. Asbestos
dispersal and intake, for example, are difficult to measure in the field. So, EPA many years ago
specified a set of work practice for example, that asbestos should be wetted down before handling and
disposed of carefully to keep emissions to a minimum

Modifications in the Clean Air Act eventually permitted the EPA to issue enforceable
rules on work practices, and now the Occupational Safety and Health Administration is also
involved.
3.4.3. What is law?
✔ Law is a body of rules of action prescribe by a controlling legal authority
and having binding legal force
✔ Law means all the rules established by authority or custom for regulating
the behavior of members of a community or country
✔ It is a solemn expression of the will of a supreme power the authority
✔ Law is a system of rules and guidelines which are enforced through
social institutions to govern behavior, wherever possible.
✔ There are mainly three philosophical explanations of laws:
o Utilitarian answer —- law is command, backed by threat of sanctions,
from a sovereign, to whom people have a habit of obedience;
o Natural lawyers —- law reflects essentially moral and unchangeable of
nature with justice; law arises from both a social impulse and reasons;
o Law’s positivism, which is totally contradictory to the natural ideas —- real
law is entirely separate from morality and it emanates from the will to
power.
What is ethics?

✔ Ethics is the philosophical study of morality while morality are the rules of
conduct describing what people have to and have not to do in various situations.
✔ Ethics are the rational, systematic analysis of conduct that can cause benefit or harm to
other people.
✔ Ethics stress on logic and reasons. Different people can have different opinions about
one situation as long as there are reasonable logics.
✔ The similarities between laws and ethics
o The standards of laws conform to people’s ethical ideas to some degree.
✔ The difference between laws and ethics:
o Ethics stress on the individual while laws stress on whole society.

13
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

o Ethics emphasize on logics and reasons while laws are based on the words.
3.4.4. Proper role of laws
Good laws, effectively enforced, clearly produce benefits. They authoritatively establish
reasonable minimal standards of professional conduct and provide at least a self-interested motive
for most people and corporations to fulfill. Further they serve as moral support and defense for the
people who are willing to act ethically.
Thus, it is concluded that:
a. The rules which govern engineering practice should be construed as of responsible
experimentation rather than rules of a game. This makes the engineer responsible
for the safe conduct of the experiment.
b. Precise rules and sanctions are suitable in case of ethical misconduct that
involves the violation of established engineering procedures, which are aimed at
the safety and the welfare of the public.
c. In situations where the experimentation is large and time consuming, the rules must
not try to cover all possible outcomes, and they should not compel the engineers to
follow rigid courses of action.
d. The regulation should be broad, but make engineers accountable for their decisions, and
e. Through their professional societies, the engineers can facilitate framing the rules,
amend wherever necessary, and enforce them, but without giving-in for conflicts of
interest.
3.5. Industrial Standards
✔ What is meant by standardization?
o Standardization primarily means setting up standards or measuring sticks
by which extent, quality, quantity, value performance or service may be
gauged or determined
o It is the process of defining and applying conditions required to ensure
that a given range of requirements can be easily met with minimum
changes in an economical and reproducible manner by the latest
techniques
✔ What are standards?
o Standards are framed by companies for their in-house use i.e. Internal use
and by professional associations and trade associations for industry wide use.
Sometimes standards are also prescribed as parts of Laws and official
regulations
✔ Standard facilities
o Interchangeability
o Accuracy in measurement
o Ease of handling
o Prevention of harms
o Decreased production costs
o Quality products

14
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ Benefits of Standards
o Standards help the manufacturers, the client and the public.
o They preserve some competitiveness in industry by reducing overemphasis on
name brands and giving the smaller manufacturer a chance to compete.
o They ensure a measure of quality and thus facilitate more realistic
trade-off decisions.
o International standards are becoming a necessity in European and world trade.
The International Standards Organization (ISO) that replaces the detailed
national specifications for a excess of products with statements of procedures
that a manufacturer guarantees to carry out to assure quality products.
✔ Limitations of Standards
o Standards have been a hindrance at times. For many years they were mostly
descriptive, specifying, for instance, how many joists of what size should
support a given type of floor?
o The move to performance standards, which in the case of a floor may specify
only the required load-bearing capacity, has alleviated that problem somewhat.
o But other difficulties can arise when special interests (e.g., manufacturers, trade
unions, exporters, and importers) manage to impose unnecessary provisions on
standards or remove important provisions from them to secure their own narrow
self- interest.
o Requiring metal conduits for home wiring is one example of this problem.
Modern conductor coverings have eliminated the need for metal conduit in many
applications, but many localities still require it. Its use sells more conduit and
labor time for installation.
o But standards did not foresee the dangers encountered when aluminum was
substituted for copper as conductor in home wiring, as happened in the United
States during the copper scarcity occasioned by the Vietnam War. Until better
ways were

15
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

devised for fastening aluminum conductors, many fires occurred because of

the gradual loosening of screw terminals.
3.6. CASE STUDY: THE CHALLENGER
The world has known about much number of accidents. Among them, the explosion of the space
shuttle Challenger is one of the most familiar ones. Back then, this case had been reviewed
vigorously by media coverage, government reports and transcripts of hearings. This case deals with
many ethical issues which engineers faced.
It poses many questions before us. A few questions are listed below −
1. What is the exact role of the engineer when safety issues are concerned?
2. Who should have the ultimate authority for decision making to order for a launch?
3. Whether the ordering of a launch be an engineering or a managerial decision?
✔ Challenger space shuttle mainly consisted of an orbiter, two solid propellant boosters
and a single liquid-propeller booster, which was actually designed to be a reusable one.
All the boosters were ignited and the orbiter took a lift-off from the earth. But the cold
temperature caused trouble to the O-rings which were eroded.
The cause behind the challenger accident
✔ The accident took place on 28th January 1986, due to the failure of one of the solid
boosters. In the design of the space shuttle, the main parts which needed careful design
of the fields joints where the individual cylinders were placed together.
✔ The assembly mainly consists of tang and clevis joints which are sealed by two O-rings,
whose function is to prevent the combustion gases of the solid propellant from escaping.
The O-rings were eroded by hot gases, as these were made up of synthetic rubber. But
this was not a serious problem, as the solid rocket boosters were only for reuse initially
for the few minutes of the flight. If the erosion of the O-rings could be restrained from
completely burning out then the design of the joint would be acceptable.
✔ In the post flight experiment in 1985, the Thiokol engineers noticed black soot and grease
on the outside of the boosters due to the leakage of hot gases blown through the O-rings.
This raised a doubt on the resiliency of the materials used for the O-rings. Thiokol
engineers redesigned the rings with steel billets to withstand the hot gases. But
unfortunately this new design was not ready by that time of flight in 1986.
Delay in launch
✔ The political conditions under which NASA operated are the main cause for unavoidable
delay in the decision to be taken for the shuttle performance. The launching date had already
been postponed for the availability of the then Vice President George Bush, the space NASA
supporter. Later, the launch further got delayed due to a problem in micro switch in the hatch-
locking mechanism. The cold weather problem and long discussions went on among the
engineers. The number of teleconferences further delayed the previous testing in 1985 itself.
✔ The O-rings required temperature bearings of 53°F whereas the challenger had temperature
bearings of only 29°F, which was far below the environment temperature at which NASA had
the previous trail. This might not be matter of concern, as the revised final decision made with
the available data then, was that there was no correlation between the temperature and the
degree at which O-rings had eroded by the blow-by gas in the previous launch. Assuming a
safety concern due to cold weather, though the data were not concluded satisfactorily, a
decision was taken not to delay further for so many reasons, and the launch was finally
recommended.

16
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

Unexpected Change
✔ But unexpectedly the overnight temperature at the time of launch was 8°F colder than ever
experienced. It was estimated that the temperature of the right hand booster would be only at
28°F. The camera noticed a puff of smoke coming out from the field joints as soon as the
boosters were ignited. But the O-rings were not positioned properly on their seats due to
extreme cold temperature. The putty used as heat resistant material was also too cold that it
failed to protect the O-rings. All these effects made the hot gases to burn past both the O-
rings, leading to a blow-by over an arc around the O-rings.
✔ Though immediately further sealing was made by the by-products of combustion in the rocket
propulsion, a glassy oxide formed on the joints. The oxides which were temporarily sealing
the field joints at high temperature, later were shattered by the stresses caused by the wind.
Again the joints were opened and the hot gases escaped from the solid boosters. But the
boosters were attached to the large liquid fuel boosters as per the design. This made the
flames due to blow-by from the solid fuel boosters quickly to burn through the external tank.
This led to the ignition of the liquid propellant making the shuttle exploded.

✔ At 11.38 a.m. the rockets along with Challenger rose up the sky. The cameras recorded
smoke coming out of one of the filed joints on the right booster rocket. Soon there was a
flame that hit the external fuel tank. At 76 seconds into the flight, the Challenger at a
height of 10 miles was totally engulfed in a fireball. The crew cabin fell into the ocean
killing all the seven aboard.

17
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ Some of the factual issues, conceptual issues and moral/normative issues in the space shuttle
challenger incident, are highlighted hereunder for further study.

Moral/Normative Issues
✔ The crew had no escape mechanism. Douglas, the engineer, designed an abort module to
allow the separation of the orbiter, triggered by a field-joint leak. But such a ‘safe exit’ was
rejected as too expensive, and because of an accompanying reduction in payload.
✔ The crew were not informed of the problems existing in the field joints. The principle of
informed consent was not followed.
✔ Engineers gave warning signals on safety. But the management group prevailed over and
ignored the warning
Conceptual Issues
✔ NASA counted that the probability of failure of the craft was one in one lakh launches. But
it was expected that only the 100000th launch will fail.
✔ There were 700 criticality-1 items, which included the field joints. A failure in any one of
them would have caused the tragedy. No back-up or stand-bye had been provided for these
criticality-1 components.
Factual/Descriptive Issues

18
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

✔ Field joints gave way in earlier flights. But the authorities felt the risk is not high.
✔ NASA has disregarded warnings about the bad weather, at the time of launch, because they
wanted to complete the project, prove their supremacy, get the funding from Government
continued and get an applaud from the President of USA.
✔ The inability of the Rockwell Engineers (manufacturer) to prove that the lift-off was unsafe.
This was interpreted by the NASA, as an approval by Rockwell to launch.

Roger’s Commission
✔ Later the accident was reviewed and investigations were carried out by the number of
committees involved and by various government bodies. President Regan appointed a
commission called the Rogers Commission which constituted of many distinguished
scientists and engineers. The eminent scientists in the commission after thorough
examination and investigations gave a report on the flexibility of the material and proved
that the resiliency of the material was not sufficient and drastically reduced during the
cold launch.
✔ After the hearings of the commission, Thiokol engineers and NASA investigated possible
causes of the explosion, which led to a lot of arguments among the other officials that this
investigating team is trying to look for other causes, which are not at all plausible.
However, the debacle highlights how lack of responsibility and morality, improper
functions, and lax performance of duties of the engineers resulted in the failure of the
launch

3.7. Research ethics

3.7.1. What is research ethics?
Research that involves human subjects or participants raises unique and complex ethical,
legal, social and political issues. Research ethics is specifically interested in the analysis of
ethical issues that are raised when people are involved as participants in research. There are
three objectives in research ethics. The first and broadest objective is to protect human
participants. The second objective is to ensure that research is conducted in a way that
serves interests of individuals, groups and/or society as a whole. Finally, the third objective
is to examine specific research activities and projects for their ethical soundness, looking at
issues such as the management of risk, protection of confidentiality and the process of
informed consent.
Research ethicists everywhere today are challenged by issues that reflect global concerns in
other domains, such as the conduct of research in developing countries, the limits of research
involving genetic material and the protection of privacy in light of advances in technology
and Internet capabilities.
3.7.2. Why research ethics?
● To protect participants /patients /society /resources /researcher
o Protect from harm
o Show respect -privacy /confidentiality -Informed consent
o Refrain from Coercion and undue inducement
o Refrain from indiscriminate use of resources
o Ensure Favorable Risk-Benefit Ratio: risk should be minimized & potential
benefit to society must outweigh risks
o Must be of social value: improvement of health/knowledge for the
benefit of society/science

19
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

▪ high social value: use of stem cells, to improve quality of

life for Huntington's disease patients
▪ less social value: drug studies conducted to obtain data that
allows a new drug to compete in the healthcare
marketplace even
though existing effective and often cheaper therapeutics are
already available

● To ensure accuracy of scientific knowledge

o Should be methodically rigorous - Scientific validity
o Fair subject selection: with inclusion / exclusion criteria & a valid number of
subjects in order to project results to the population
o State research method clearly so that another person can conduct advanced
study in future by using publication
o Do not gloss research method
o Should not falsify/modify/omit data
o Use actual data for analysis/cannot include someone else's data
o Report errors
o Be aware of conflict of interest
o Should not withhold and/or ‘vaguing up’ information
o Keep data and material for 5 years
o Data and material should be available to others
o Do not present/publish paper from incomplete research or from anticipated outcomes
o Should not duplicate publications and submissions
o Avoid piecemeal publication
o Should be reviewed Independently by unaffiliated individuals

● To protect intellectual and property rights

o Citation and authorship inclusion-Writing and significant, scientific contribution,
order- order of contribution
o Whenever somebody else’s work is quoted reference should be made to the original
author (Piracy vs plagiarism)
o Acknowledgement should include the names of person who helped

3.7.3. Codes and Policies for Research Ethics

Many government agencies, such as the National Institutes of Health (NIH), the National
Science Foundation (NSF), the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), and the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) have ethics rules
for funded researchers.
Ethical principles that various codes address
✔ Honesty
o Strive for honesty in all scientific communications. Honestly report data, results,
methods and procedures, and publication status. Do not fabricate, falsify, or
misrepresent data. Do not deceive colleagues, research sponsors, or the public.
✔ Objectivity

20
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

o Strive to avoid bias in experimental design, data analysis, data interpretation, peer
review, personnel decisions, grant writing, expert testimony, and other aspects of
research where objectivity is expected or required. Avoid or minimize bias or self-
deception. Disclose personal or financial interests that may affect research.
✔ Integrity
o Keep your promises and agreements; act with sincerity; strive for consistency of
thought and action.
✔ Carefulness
o Avoid careless errors and negligence; carefully and critically examine your own
work and the work of your peers. Keep good records of research activities, such
as data collection, research design, and correspondence with agencies or journals.
✔ Openness
o Share data, results, ideas, tools, resources. Be open to criticism and new ideas.
✔ Respect for Intellectual Property
o Honor patents, copyrights, and other forms of intellectual property. Do not use
unpublished data, methods, or results without permission. Give proper
acknowledgement or credit for all contributions to research. Never plagiarize.
✔ Confidentiality
o Protect confidential communications, such as papers or grants submitted for
publication, personnel records, trade or military secrets, and patient records.
✔ Responsible Publication
o Publish in order to advance research and scholarship, not to advance just your
own career. Avoid wasteful and duplicative publication.
✔ Responsible Mentoring
o Help to educate, mentor, and advise students. Promote their welfare and allow
them to make their own decisions.
✔ Respect for colleagues
o Respect your colleagues and treat them fairly.
✔ Social Responsibility
o Strive to promote social good and prevent or mitigate social harms through
research, public education, and advocacy.
✔ Non-Discrimination
o Avoid discrimination against colleagues or students on the basis of sex, race,
ethnicity, or other factors not related to scientific competence and integrity.
✔ Competence
✔ Maintain and improve your own professional competence and expertise through
lifelong education and learning; take steps to promote competence in science as a
whole.
✔ Legality
o Know and obey relevant laws and institutional and governmental policies.
✔ Animal Care
o Show proper respect and care for animals when using them in research. Do not
conduct unnecessary or poorly designed animal experiments.
✔ Human Subjects Protection

21
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

o When conducting research on human subjects, minimize harms and risks and
maximize benefits; respect human dignity, privacy, and autonomy; take special
precautions with vulnerable populations; and strive to distribute the benefits and
burdens of research fairly.
3.8. Examples:
Case 1: The research protocol for a study of a drug on hypertension requires the
administration of the drug at different doses to 50 laboratory mice, with chemical and
behavioral tests to determine toxic effects. Tom has almost finished the experiment for Dr. Q.
He has only 5 mice left to test.
However, he really wants to finish his work in time to go to Florida on spring break with his
friends, who are leaving tonight. He has injected the drug in all 50 mice but has not completed
all of the tests. He therefore decides to extrapolate from the 45 completed results to produce the
5 additional results.

Many different research ethics policies would hold that Tom has acted unethically by fabricating data.
If this study were sponsored by a federal agency, such as the NIH, his actions would constitute a form
of research misconduct, which the government defines as "fabrication, falsification, or plagiarism"
(or FFP). Actions that nearly all researchers classify as unethical are viewed as misconduct. It is
important to remember, however, that misconduct occurs only when researchers intend to deceive:
honest errors related to sloppiness, poor record keeping, miscalculations, bias, self-deception, and
even negligence do not constitute misconduct.

Case 2: Dr. T has just discovered a mathematical error in his paper that has been accepted for
publication in a journal. The error does not affect the overall results of his research, but it is
potentially misleading. The journal has just gone to press, so it is too late to catch the error
before it appears in print. In order to avoid embarrassment, Dr. T decides to ignore the error.
Dr. T's error is not misconduct nor is his decision to take no action to correct the error. Most
researchers, as well as many different policies and codes would say that Dr. T should tell the journal
(and any coauthors) about the error and consider publishing a correction or errata. Failing to publish a
correction would be unethical because it would violate norms relating to honesty and objectivity in
research.
There are many other activities that the government does not define as "misconduct" but which
are still regarded by most researchers as unethical. These are sometimes referred to as "other
deviations" from acceptable research practices and include:

● Publishing the same paper in two different journals without telling the editors
● Submitting the same paper to different journals without telling the editors
● Not informing a collaborator of your intent to file a patent in order to make sure that you
are the sole inventor
● Including a colleague as an author on a paper in return for a favor even though the colleague
did not make a serious contribution to the paper
● Discussing with your colleagues confidential data from a paper that you are reviewing
for a journal
● Using data, ideas, or methods you learn about while reviewing a grant or a papers
without permission
● Trimming outliers from a data set without discussing your reasons in paper
● Using an inappropriate statistical technique in order to enhance the significance of your research

22
 UNIT III ENGINEERING AS SOCIAL EXPERIMENTATION

● Bypassing the peer review process and announcing your results through a press
conference without giving peers adequate information to review your work
● Conducting a review of the literature that fails to acknowledge the contributions of other
people in the field or relevant prior work
● Stretching the truth on a grant application in order to convince reviewers that your project
will make a significant contribution to the field
● Stretching the truth on a job application or curriculum vita
● Giving the same research project to two graduate students in order to see who can do it the fastest
● Overworking, neglecting, or exploiting graduate or post-doctoral students
● Failing to keep good research records
● Failing to maintain research data for a reasonable period of time
● Making derogatory comments and personal attacks in your review of author's submission
● Promising a student a better grade for sexual favors
● Using a racist epithet in the laboratory
● Making significant deviations from the research protocol approved by your institution's
Animal Care and Use Committee or Institutional Review Board for Human Subjects
Research without telling the committee or the board
● Not reporting an adverse event in a human research experiment
● Wasting animals in research
● Exposing students and staff to biological risks in violation of your institution's biosafety rules
● Sabotaging someone's work
● Stealing supplies, books, or data
● Rigging an experiment so you know how it will turn out
● Making unauthorized copies of data, papers, or computer programs
● Owning over $10,000 in stock in a company that sponsors your research and not disclosing
this financial interest
● Deliberately overestimating the clinical significance of a new drug in order to obtain
economic benefits

23
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Safety and Risk – Assessment of Safety and Risk – Risk Benefit Analysis and Reducing
Risk - Respect for Authority – Collective Bargaining – Confidentiality – Conflicts of
Interest – Occupational Crime – Professional Rights – Employee Rights – Intellectual
Property Rights (IPR) – Discrimination

4.1. Safety and its concept

4.1.1. Definition
● Safety means state of being safe, safe means protected from danger harm.
● The term safety is always difficult to describe completely, what may be safe for
one person may be risk for another one.
● The American Heritage Dictionary safety as freedom from damage, injury, or risk.
● The definition for safety is defined by William.W. Lowrence as follows:
o A thing is safe if its risks are judged to be acceptable.
4.1.2. Drawbacks of the definition
● Under estimation of risks: An unsafe product may be considered to be safe
because of faulty view and misjudgment of a person. Example :Buying Improperly
designed coil type water heater, which eventually ends up with a severe electric
shock.
● Over estimation of risk: A product, whose risks are comparatively less, may be
considered unsafe because of over safety concern of a person. Example: Thinking
that adding chlorine in drinking water will kill a lot of people. In this case,
according to Lowrence's definition, the water became unsafe the moment we judged
the risks are unacceptable for us
● No estimation of risk : For the person who does not judge about the risks, the
product may be either safe or unsafe. Example: Purchasing a LPG gasoline fuel
driven car without judging anything about its safely.
4.1.3. Modified Definition
● “A thing is safe (to a certain degree) with respect to a given person or
group at a given time, If its risks went fully known, if those risks would
be judged acceptable (to that certain d e g r e e ), In light of settled value
principles". In the modified Lowrance definition the term 'things' represent
not only products, but also services, processes, etc. Therefore the definition
can be e x t e n d e d to medicines, finance, International affairs, etc.
safety and risk are essentially subjective and depend on many factors:
● Voluntary vs. involuntary risk. Many consider something safer if they
knowingly take on the risk, but would find it unsafe if forced to do so.
Voluntary risks are considered as safe and the involuntary risks are considered as
unsafe.
o If the property values are low enough, some people will be tempted to
buy a house near a plant that emits low levels of a toxic waste into the air.
They are willing to assume the risk for the benefit of cheap housing.
o However, if a person already living near a plant finds that toxic fumes are
emitted by the plant and he wasn’t informed, the risk will appear to be
larger, since it was not voluntarily assumed. This principle is true even if
the level of
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

emission is identical to that in the example of a person choosing to move

near the plant.
o Voluntary risks have to do with lifestyle choices. They are the risks
that people take knowing that they may have consequences. These risks
include smoking tobacco, driving a car, skydiving, and climbing a
ladder.
o Involuntary risks are risks that people take either not knowing that they
are at risk, or they are unable to control the fact that they are at risk, such
as secondhand smoke. These risks often include environmental hazards
such as lightning, tsunamis, and tornadoes.
● Short-term vs. long-term consequences. Something that might cause a short-
lived illness or disability seems safer than something that will result in
permanent disability. An activity for which there is a risk of getting a fractured
leg will appear much less risky than an activity with a risk of a spinal fracture,
since a broken leg will be painful and disabling for a few months, but generally full
recovery is the norm. Spinal fractures, however, can lead to permanent disability.
● Expected probability. Many might find a one-in-a-million chance of a severe
injury to be an acceptable risk, whereas a 50:50 chance of a fairly minor
injury might be unacceptable. Swimming at a beach where there is known to be
a large concentration of jellyfish would be unacceptable to many, since there
would be a high probability of a painful, though rarely fatal, sting. Yet, at the
same beach, the risk of a shark attack is low enough that it doesn’t deter anyone
from swimming, even though such an attack would very likely lead to death or
dismemberment. It is important to remember here that the expected probability is
only an educated guess.
● Reversible effects. Something will seem less risky if the bad effects are
ultimately reversible.
● Threshold levels for risk. Something that is risky only at fairly high exposures
will seem safer than something with a uniform exposure to risk. For example,
the probability of being in an automobile accident is the same regardless of how
often you drive. In contrast, studies have shown that low levels of nuclear radiation
actually have beneficial effects on human health, while only at higher levels of
exposure are there severe health problems or death. If there is a threshold for the
effects, generally there will be a greater tolerance for risk.
● Delayed vs. immediate risk. An activity whose harm is delayed for many years
will seem much less risky than something with an immediate effect. For example,
for several years now, Americans have been warned about the adverse long term
health effects of a high-fat diet. This type of diet can lead to chronic heart problems
or stroke later in life. Yet, many ignore these warnings and are unconcerned about a
risk that is so far in the future. These same people might find an activity such as sky
diving unacceptably risky, since an accident will cause immediate injury or death.
Something that one person feels is safe may seem very unsafe to someone else. This
creates some confusion for the engineer who has to decide whether a project is safe enough to
be pursued. In making a decision, some analysis methods, especially line drawing and flow
charting, can be used. Ultimately, it is up to the engineer and company management to use
their professional judgment to determine whether a project can be safely implemented.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.2. Engineers and Safety

4.2.1. Criteria to ensure safety design
● The design must comply with the applicable laws. This requirement should
be easy to meet, since legal standards for product safety are generally well
known, are published, and are easily accessible.
● A design must meet the standard of “accepted engineering practice.” For
example, federal safety laws might not require that the power supply in a home
computer be made inaccessible to the consumer who opens up her computer.
However, if most manufacturers have designed their supplies so that no
potentially lethal voltages are accessible, then that standard should be followed
by all designers, even if doing so increases the cost of the product.
● Alternative designs that are potentially safer must be explored. This
requirement requires a fair amount of creativity in seeking alternative solutions.
This creativity can involve discussing design strategies with others in your field
and brainstorming new alternatives with them. The best way to know if your
design is the safest available is to compare it to other potential designs.
● The engineer must attempt to foresee potential misuses of the product by
the consumer and must design to avoid these problems. Again, this requires a
fair amount of creativity and research. An engineer should execute designs in
such a way as to protect even someone who misuses the product.
● Once the product is designed, both prototypes and finished devices must be
rigorously tested. This testing is not just to determine whether the product meets
the specifications. It should also involve testing to see if the product is safe. The
importance of adequate testing can be illustrated by the Kursk submarine disaster.
● Case Study:The Kursk was a Russian navy submarine that sank in August of
2000, killing everyone on board. The sinking has been attributed to an
explosion in the torpedo room that ripped open a large hole in the hull. Many
crew members of the Kursk survived the initial explosion, but died because they
were unable to escape from the submarine, and no attempts at rescue by other
ships were successful. The June 3, 2002, edition of Time reported that Russian
naval engineers say that the Kursk was equipped with a rescue capsule designed
to allow crew members to float
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

safely to the surface in an emergency. However, in the rush to get the submarine
into service, this safety system was never tested. After the accident, some of the
survivors attempted to rescue themselves by using this system, but it did not
function properly. It is essential that in any engineering design, all safety systems
be tested to ensure that they work as intended.
4.2.2. Designing for Safety
Wilcox [1990] summarized how safety should be incorporated into the
engineering design process as follows:
● Define the problem. This step includes determining the needs and requirements
and often involves determining the constraints.
● Generate several solutions. Multiple alternative designs are created.
● Analyze each solution to determine the pros and cons of each. This step involves
determining the consequences of each design solution and determining whether it
solves the problem.
● Test the solutions.
● Select the best solution.
● Implement the chosen solution.
● In step 1, it is appropriate to include issues of safety in the product
definition and specification.
● In steps 2 through 5, engineers typically consider issues of how well the
solution meets the specifications, how easy it will be to build, and how
costly it will be. Safety and risk should also be criteria considered during
each of these steps.
● Safety is especially important in step 5, where the engineer attempts to
assess all of the trade-offs required to obtain a successful final design. In
assessing these trade-offs, it is important to remember that safety
considerations should be paramount and should have relatively higher
weight than other issues.
● Minimizing risk is often easier said than done. For example, the design
engineer often must deal in uncertainties. Many of the risks can only be
expressed as probabilities and especially in a new and innovative design for
which the interaction of risks will be unknown.
● Risk is also increased by the rapid pace at which engineering designs must
be carried out. The practical approach to minimizing risk in a design is a “go
slow” approach, in which care is taken to ensure that all possibilities have
been adequately explored and that testing has been sufficiently thorough.
4.3. Risk and its concepts
4.3.1. What is meant by Risk?
● A risk is the potential something unwanted and harmful may occur
● The American Heritage Dictionary defines risk as the possibility of suffering
harm or loss
● Risk is meaningfully used with the adverse effect of harm. The term harm
may be defined as an invasion of person’s freedom or well being
● The three most important types of well being are:
o Physical well being:
o Psychological well being
o Economical well being
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Mostly engineering risks comes under physical and economical well being. Like
faulty design of a chemical plant can cause accidents and economic disaster
● Effects of risk: it includes dangers of bodily harm , economic loss and
environmental degradation
● Causes of risk: risks or harms are caused by delayed jobs completion , faulty
product or system design and economically and environmentally injurious
solutions to technological problems
4.3.2. Risk defined
Safety was defined as the risk that is known and judged as acceptable. But, risk is a potential
that something unwanted and harmful may occur. It is the result of an unsafe situation,
sometimes unanticipated, during its use.
Probability of safety = 1 – Probability of risk
Risk = Probability of occurrence × Consequence in
magnitude

4.4. Risk Analysis or Determination of Risk

1. Knowledge of risk:
1. To assess a risk, an engineer must first identify it. To identify a risk, an
engineer must first know the information about the safety of standard
products.
2. Though past experience and historical data provide good information
about the safety of standard products, still it is insufficient to
completely assess the risk of a product.
3. The past experience and historical data are inadequate to access
the risk, because of the following reasons:
a. The information is not freely shared among firms, and
b. There are always new applications of old technology that makes the
available information less useful.
c. Therefore in order to access the risk, engineers and firms should share
the information and knowledge about the safety of products freely

2. Uncertainties in Assessment
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

3. Testing for safety

Once the product is designed both protypes and finished device must be
thoroughly tested.
Different methods are available to determine the risk (testing for safety)
● Testing on the functions of the safety-system components.
● Destructive testing: In this approach, testing is done till the component fails.
It is too expensive, but very realistic and useful.
● Prototype testing: In this approach, the testing is done on a proportional
scale model with all vital components fixed in the system. Dimensional
analysis could be used to project the results at the actual conditions.
● Simulation testing: With the help of computer, the simulations are done. The
safe boundary may be obtained. The effects of some controlled input
variables on the outcomes can be predicted in a better way.
▪
4.4.1. Analytical Methods
Several analytical methods are adopted in testing for safety of a product/project.
A. Scenario Analysis
1. This is the most common method of analysis. Starting from an event,
different consequences are studied. This is more a qualitative method.
2. For example, a disaster recovery plan, for an organization is discussed. When
the probability and size of loss (indicating possibility and financial
significance, respectively) are both high, risk exists. On the other hand, risk is
not associated with very low probability of occurrence, or with losses that
under any other circumstances would be considered “affordable”. But there is
a gray area between probability/loss combinations that are truly risky, and
those that are not. This reflects the fact that the boundary between risky and
non-risky events is fuzzy, not exact.
3. To assess the risk faced by the organization, the planner matches the
probability and loss characteristics of various exposures to one’s intuition of
risk. This exposure analysis can be most effectively carried out using ‘loss
scenarios’. A scenario is a synopsis of events or conditions leading to an
accident and subsequent loss. Scenarios may be specified informally, in
the form of narrative, or formally using diagrams and flow charts.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Steps for Risk Assessment

● What can go wrong that could lead to an outcome of hazard exposure? (identification
and characterization of risk)
● How likely is this to happen? (quantification of risk, likelihood, and magnitude)
● If it happens, what are the consequences? Scenarios are constructed and the ways
and means of facing the consequences are designed
Examples:

B. Failure mode and Effect analysis

1. In this method, various parts or components of the system and their modes
(patterns, propagation and nature) of failure are studied. The cause of failure or
the interrelationships between the components are not studied.
2. FMEA is one of the qualitative tools, which support proactive quality
strategies. FMEA concept was introduced in 1960s by aerospace companies.
Then the use of FMEA was extended to automobile industries and other types
of industries, understanding the value of this approach.
3. Thus, FMEA is defined as a systematic tool to
1. Identify possible failure modes in the products/process,
(b) To understand failure mechanism (process that leads to failure),
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

(c) Risk analysis, and

(d) Plan for action on elimination or reduction of failure modes.
A. STEPS TO CONDUCT FMEA
FMEA is a cross-functional team management. Throughout the product
development cycles, changes and updates will be introduced to the product and
process. These changes have to be reviewed because they can introduce new risks or
failure modes. It is thus necessary to review and update changes.
1. Product/process and its function must be understood first. This is the most
fundamental concept to be adopted in this methodology. This understanding helps
the engineer to identify product/process function that fall with the intended and
unintended users.
2. Block diagram of product/process is created and developed. The diagram shows the
major components or process steps as blocks, identifies their relations namely, input,
function and output of the design. The diagram shows logical relationship of
components and establishes a structure for FMEA. The block diagram should always
be included in the FMEA form.
3. Header on FMEA form is completed. FMEA form includes part/process name,
model date, revision date, and responsibility.
4. The items/functions are listed logically in the FMEA form, based on the block diagram.
5. Then failure modes are identified. A failure mode is defined wherein a
component, subsystem, system, and process could potentially fail to meet the
design intent.
6. A failure mode in one component can cause failure in another. Each failure
should be listed in technical terms. Listing should be done component- or
process-wise.
7. Then the effects of each risk/failure mode are described. This is done as perceived by
both internal and external customers. The examples of risk/failure effect may include
injury to the user, environment, equipment, and degraded performance. Then a
numerical ranking is assigned to each risk or failure. It depends upon the severity of
the effect. Commonly, in the scale, No.1 is used to represent no effect and 10 to
indicate very severe failure, affecting system of operation and user. By this, the
failures can be prioritized and real critical risks can be addressed first.
8. Then the causes of each failure mode have to be identified. A cause is defined as a
design weakness that results in a failure. The potential causes for each failure mode
are identified. The potential causes, for example, may be improper torque or
contamination or excessive loading or external vibration.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Responsibility: The team incharge of design or process should be included.

It also includes the company or department of the person or group
responsible for
 UNIT SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND

preparing the document. It is a common work sheet that can be used both
for design FMEA and process FMEA. In design FMEA, following points
are to be entered: name and number of item, listing the functions of the
item (system or sub-system or component-wise), Environment in which
system operates. In process FMEA, descriptions of processes, listing of
processes and complete purpose of processes have to be entered.
● FMEA team: The names of responsible individuals and departments that
have authority to perform task are included.
● FMEA date: The date of original FMEA compiled should be entered. In
revision column latest revision date is entered.

C. Fault-tree Analysis
● This is a qualitative method and was originated by Bell Telephones. It is
technology- based deductive logic. The failure (undesirable event) is initially
defined, and the events (causal relationships) leading to that failure are identified
at different components level. This method can combine hardware failures and
human failures
Example 1: Consider the failure of the steam flow in a thermal station. The
water is pumped from a big reservoir nearby. The details are shown in Fig. 4.1
The common mode event in this case is an earthquake. This quake
has affected many systems or components at the same time. Hence, we can
call the ‘earthquake’ as the common mode/cause.
 UNIT SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND

Dr.S.PADMA PRIYA Pa
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Example 2: A crash at main road junction

The details of this Fault-tree Analysis are shown in Fig. 4.2
● Consider the probability of the crash at a road junction and construct a tree with
and AND or GATE logic. The tree is constructed by deducing in turn the pre-
conditions for the final event and then successively for the next levels of events,
until the basic causes are identified.
● By ascribing probabilities to each event, the probability of a top event can be
calculated. This requires knowledge of probable failure rates. At an OR gate,
the probabilities must be added to give the probability of the next event,
whereas at an AND gate, the probabilities are multiplied. This is a powerful
technique for identifying the failures that have the greatest influence on
bringing about the end event.

Example 3: An automobile car does not

start. The details of this case are shown in
Fig. 4.3.
4. The advantages of FTA are (a) the primary cause can be located easily, and (b)
It is useful in emergent situations i.e., a fire-fighting approach.
UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

5. The figure shows the event-tree including the alternatives and different things
that could lead to the employee being ‘late again’.
6. Alternative outcomes are shown under each column.
7. Trace back from the outcomes towards the left hand side of the tree along
horizontal paths. There are series of vertical branches labeled, Yes or No,
which are connected to previous paths. The vertical branches represent the
response (Yes/No) to the question (or the systems responsible) that appear on
the top of the tree.
8. Tracing back from first ‘No’ under ‘Late again’ one comes to the first label
Y/N: Is the highway clear? The up branch represents ‘Yes’ showing that the
highway that morning was clear. The person arrived on time for duty. The
down branch representing ‘No’ means that the highway was not clear and the
person was late. This branch is attached to the earlier path and representing
the condition that the car did not start. The up branch corresponding to
question ‘car starts?’ indicates ‘Yes’. Because car did start, there is no need to
consider the backup alternatives of the colleague.
9. What are the possible outcomes, if the car does not start? Work from left to
right starting on the lower “no’’ branch for the question ‘car starts?’. The next
question is train/express bus available? The ‘Yes’ path goes straight to the
outcome of not being late. Notice the questions in the event tree are very
simple. We may even ask, is the train sufficiently frequent and are the
terminals conveniently located to go to the office in time? Is the day analyzed
a holiday with reduced trips? Has there been an accident or breakdown that
day, on the line in question?
10. If the answer is ‘No’, then we are left with the ‘colleague’ option, and if he is
available and is he willing to offer the ride in time. If not, he will be late. If
‘Yes’, the question ‘Is the highway clear?’ must be considered. Heavy
highway traffic (Monday morning) may still cause a late arrival.
Conclusions
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

ETA is a variant of FTA that can be used to explore both success and failure alternatives
at each level. Event trees are meant to show the path by which we get there. Hence, the
event trees are said to have the memory. The event tree is in a logical structure from left
to right uses only OR gate. A fault tree is organized from Top to bottom hierarchy and
uses both AND and OR gates. When there is more AND gates, then the tree contains
more fault tolerant or safer and if it is more OR gates, it indicates a failure-prone

system
4.4.2. Cost Analysis

● A stress on low risk and high safety leads to high primarily costs and
lower secondary cost and vice versa
● Total cost -= primary cost + secondary cost
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.5. Acceptability of Risk

4.5.1. What is meant by acceptable risk?
According to D.Rowe “ a risk is acceptable when those affected are
generally no longer apprehensive (fearful) about it
Apprehensiveness or doubtfulness mainly depends on how the risk is
perceived by the people
4.5.2. Elements of Risk perception
The elements of risk perception are influenced by following factors:
● Whether the risk is assumed voluntarily
● The effect of knowledge on how the probabilities of harm are perceived
● Job related or other pressures that cause people to be aware of risks
● Whether the effect of risky activities or situations are
immediately noticeable and
● Whether the potential victims are identified beforehand
1. Voluntarism and control
Voluntary risk: If prople take risk knowingly, then their involvement of
risk is know as voluntary risk
● A new friend lives near the cement plant, as they are unable to choose a
better location for their house. The group work as motor mechanics in an
automobile service station nearby.
● The air is full of dust and some drainage canals cut across their house
sites. They hold that they are exposed to involuntary risk, from dust and
drain. But the same persons have previously-owned motor cycles, with
which they travel during weekends to their villages through muddy roads.
● Now they are willing to take risk voluntarily, i.e., they have no
apprehensions on this travel. Statistical study indicates that individuals are
more ready to accept voluntary risks (hunting, skiing, fighting in wars)
than the involuntary risks (electric shock, natural calamity). Even though
the voluntary risks are thousand times more fatal than involuntary ones,
individuals meet them, for the thrill or adrenal quest or for achievement
and for a page in the Guinness record.
Controlled risk: If the risk taken is within the control limit, which
can be controlled by nay means, then the risk is known as controlled
risk
● Another stand or perception closely related to this example is that of
‘Control’. There are people who choose to play stunts such as jumping
through fire gates, skiing and flying, car racing through tortuous
terrains. Most of these people exhibit extraordinary confidence in them
and on their gadgets and also believe that the hazards are under their
control.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

2. Effects of information on risk assessment

o The information about harm and or danger should be presented in a
systematic and appropriate manner. Because this helps in making proper
decision making and has a great influence on how risks are perceived
o The threshold limit of individuals for information varies from person to
person. Some will be comfortable only when they have information of
deeper depth and quality , while some may be comfortable with minimum
information
3. Job related risks
a. The exposure of risk depends on the person’s job and his work place
b. The nature of job and the working environment will determine the risk level
of a person. People working in coal mines, oil mines, shipyards, chemical
plants, nuclear power plant etc., have more probability of being exposed to
higher risk
c. Unions and occupational and safety regulations should regulate and enforce
the employers to facilitate the standard working environment
d. Engineers who design and equip workstations must take safety issues
and workers suggestion regarding the work place
4. Magnitude and proximity
4.1.1.1.1. Our reaction to risk is affected by the magnification and
the potential identification or relationship we have within victims
4.1.1.1.2. Thus the magnitude of risk and the proximity with the
victims gratly influence the degree of reaction to the risk
4.6. Safe Exit
The ‘safe exit’ principles referred to as ‘safe exit’ are:
1. The product, when it fails, should fail safely
2. The product, when it fails, can be abandoned safely (it does not harm
others by explosion or radiation)
3. The user can safely escape the product (e.g., ships need sufficient number of life
boats for all passengers and crew; multi-storeyed buildings need usable fire
escapes)
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.7. Risk – Benefit analysis

4.7.1. Risk –Benefit value Function
1. The risk and benefits are based on the perceptions of probable gain and probable loss
2. A typical risk benefit value function is shown here
3. Here the risk benefit value function drops sharply on the loss portion that it raises
on the gain portion
4. The threshold is added on both gain and loss sides of the function
5. The threshold on the loss side is to account human habit of ignoring smaller
risk in order to avoid anxiety overload.
6. The threshold on the gain side is to account normal human inertia. It means
inherent character of people may delay the process of seeking their own gain

4.7.2. What is risk benefit analysis?

● Risk benefit analysis is similar to cost benefit analysis used to analyze the risk
in a project and to determine whether the project should be carried out or not
● The major reasons for the analysis of the risk benefit are:
.1. To know risks and benefits and weigh them each
.2. To decide on designs, advisability of product/project
.3. To suggest and modify the design so that the risks are eliminated or reduced
● There are some limitations that exist in the risk-benefit analysis. The economic
and ethical limitations are presented as follows:
● Conceptual difficulties in Risk-benefit Analysis
● Primarily the benefits may go to one group and risks may go to another
group. Is it ethically correct?
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Is an individual or government empowered to impose a risk on someone

else on behalf of supposed benefit to somebody else? Sometimes, people
who are exposed to maximum risks may get only the minimum benefits. In
such cases, there is even violation of rights.
● The units for comparison are not the same, e.g., commissioning the
express highways may add a few highway deaths versus faster and
comfortable travel for several commuters. The benefits may be in terms
of fuel, money and time saved, but lives of human being sacrificed.
● How do we then compare properly?
● Both risks and benefits lie in the future. The quantitative estimation of the
future benefits, using the discounted present value (which may fluctuate),
may not be correct and sometime misleading.
● Both risk and benefits have uncertainties. The estimated probability may
differ frm region to region and time to time
● Ethical implications of risk benefit analysis
● While performing the risk-benefit a n a l y s i s . one should
keep in mind the following ethical questions:
● Under what conditions. Someone in Society is entitled to impose a
risk on someone else on behalf of a supposed benefit to others?
● How can we consider the worst-case scenarios of persons exposed
to maximum risks white they are also obtaining only minimum
benefits? Are their rights violated? Are t h e y provided safer
alternatives?

4.7.3. Personal Risk

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.7.4. Public risk

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.7.5. Accounting publically for benefits and risks

Public accountability for risk has been affected by the following problem:
● An expert group cannot be expected to know everything. Hence the public
processes are designed to establish safeguards and regulations
● The uncertainty produced by scientists and regulators who assure the public that there is
no risk.
● The conceptions of risk vary depending on how the facts are presented.
Hence cautions should be taken when stating the probabilities of rare events
4.7.6. Becoming a responsible Engineer regarding risk
(Role of engineers to safeguard the Public from Risk)
● The engineers can provide background material to prove the faulty positions.
● Engineers should actively participate in the debates related to safety and risk .
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Engineers should always insist on meaningful numbers and figures

when assessing safety and risk.
● Engineers should also recognize the previously mentioned difficulties
with measuring risks and benefits in absolute terms.
● Engineers should not be influenced by any influential lobby or trade organization.
● Engineers need to be sensitive to various qualitative value judgments related
with human and ethical values .
● Engineers should be aware at the legal liabilities regarding risk.

4.8. Accidents
● There have been numerous studies of accidents and their causes, with attempts to
categorize different types of accidents. The goal of this type of work is to understand
the nature of accidents and therefore find ways to try to prevent them. Since the
engineer’s most important job is to protect the safety of the public, the results of this
type of research have an impact on the engineering professional.
● One method is to group accidents into three types: procedural, engineered, and systemic
● Procedural accidents are perhaps the most common and are the result of
someone making a bad choice or not following established procedures.
o For example, in the airline industry, procedural accidents are frequently labeled
as “pilot error.” These are accidents caused by the misreading of an important
gauge, flying when the weather should have dictated otherwise, or failure to
follow regulations and procedures. In the airline industry, this type of error is
not restricted to the pilot; it can also be committed by air-traffic controllers and
maintenance personnel.
o Engineers must also guard against procedural problems that can lead to
accidents. These problems can include failure to adequately examine drawings
before signing off on them, failure to follow design rules, or failure to design
according to accepted engineering practice.
o Procedural accidents are fairly well understood and are amenable to
solution through increased training, more supervision, new laws or
regulations, or closer scrutiny by regulators.
● Engineered accidents are caused by flaws in the design. These are failures of
materials, devices that don’t perform as expected, or devices that don’t perform well
under all circumstances encountered.
o For example, micro cracks sometimes develop in turbine blades in aircraft
engines. When these cracks become severe enough, the blade can fail and
break apart. Sometimes, this has resulted in the penetration of the cabin by
metal fragments, causing injury to passengers.
o Engineered failures should be anticipated in the design stage and should be
caught and corrected during testing. However, it isn’t always possible to
anticipate every condition that will be encountered, and sometimes testing
doesn’t occur over the entire range of possible operating conditions.
o These types of accidents can be understood and alleviated as more
knowledge is gained through testing and actual experience in the field.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Systemic accidents are harder to understand and harder to control. They are
characteristic of very complex technologies and the complex organizations that
are required to operate them.
o A perfect example of this phenomenon is the airline industry. Modern aircraft
are very complicated systems. Running them properly requires the work of
many individuals, including baggage handlers, mechanics, flight attendants,
pilots, government regulators and inspectors, and air-traffic controllers. At
many stages in the operation of an airline, there are chances for mistakes to
occur, some with serious consequences. Often, a single, minor mistake isn’t
signicant, but a series of minor mistakes can add up to a disaster.
o These small errors came together to cause a major accident.
o The airline industry is not the only complex engineered system in our society
that is susceptible to systemic accidents. Both modern military systems,
especially nuclear weapons, for which complicated detection and
communication systems are relied on for control, and nuclear power plants
with complicated control and safety systems, have documented failures in the
past that can be attributed to this type of systemic problem. systemic problem.

4.9. Reducing risk

3. Periodical monitoring (inspection) and testing of safety system to ensure reliability,

e.g., fire extinguishers, ‘earth’ system in electric circuits are checked periodically.
4. Issue of operation manuals, training of the operating personnel and regular audits
are adopted to ensure that the procedures are understood, followed and the systems are
kept in working condition.
5. Development of well-designed emergency evacuation plan and regular
rehearsal/drills to ensure preparedness, in case of emergency.
● Risk management may be defined as the eradication or minimization of the
adverse effects of the pure risks to which an organization is exposed
● Elements of risk management are:
o Risk identification : Risk can be identified by various techniques such as
physical inspection , safety audit, job safety analysis and workers discussion
and also historical data analysis
o Risk evaluation: Risk can be measured on the basis of economic, social and
legal considerations.
● Economic and social considerations include financial aspects, uninsured
cost of accidents, insurance premium, overall effect on the profitability, and
possible lost of production.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Legal considerations include possible constraint from compliance with

health and safety legislation, code of practice, guidance notes and accepted
standards, fire prevention, pollution and product liability
o Risk control

Risk control consists of four areas: risk avoidance, risk retention, risk transfer
and risk reduction.
● Risk avoidance: It refers to the conscious decision by the
management to avoid completely a particular risk by discontinuing
the operation producing the risk.
● Risk retention: It refers to retaining a particular risk for which
any consequent loss is financed by the organization.
● Risk transfer: It refers to the legal assignment of the cost of
certain potential losses from one party to another (example, by
insurance).
● Risk reduction: It refers to the reduction or elimination of all
aspect of accidental loss that lead to a wastage of an organization's
assets.

4.10. Safety lessons from “ the Challenger”

● Negligence in design efforts. The booster rocket casing recovered from earlier
flights indicated the failure of filed-joint seals. No deign changes were incorporated.
Instead of two O-rings, three rings should have been fixed. But there was no time
for testing with three rings. At least three rings could have been tried while
launching.
● Tests on O-rings should have been conducted down to the expected ambient
temperature i.e., to 20oF. No normalization of deviances should have been allowed.
● NASA was not willing to wait for the weather to improve. The weather was not
favorable on the day of launch. A strong wind shear might have caused the
rupture of the weakened O-rings.
● The final decision making of launch or no-launch should have been with the
engineers and not on the managers. Engineers insisted on ‘safety’ but the
managers went ahead with the ‘schedule’.
● Informed consent: The mission was full of dangers. The astronauts should have
been informed of the probable failure of the O-rings (field joints). No informed
consent was obtained, when the engineers had expressed that the specific launch
was unsafe.
● Conflict of interest (Risk vs. Cost): There were 700 criticality-1 items, which
included the field joints. A failure in any one of them would have cause the tragedy.
No back-up or stand- bye had been provided for these criticality-1 components.
● Escape mechanism or ‘safe exit’ should have been incorporated in the craft.
McDonnell Douglas, the engineer, designed an abort module to allow the
separation of the orbiter, when triggered by field joint leak. Unfortunately such a
safe exit was rejected due to the increase in the cost, simultaneously with reduction
in payload
● Ethical engineers should have given awards and encouraged to hold their
discretion (moral autonomy) in risky situations, and to report to appropriate agency
their views in the interest of public safety
4.11. Case study: Power Plants
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.11.1. Three – Mile Islands

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

When pump (14) failed, the steam generator (3) went dry. So, heat was not
removed from the reactor. Water was pouring out at 220 gallons/min but reactor has
not cooled down. Pumps (16) were started to refill water reactor core. There was too
much of water in the reactor now. The reactor fuel rods began to break to pieces.
Then the chemical reaction between steam and the Zinc alloy fuel elements
produced Hydrogen and the Hydrogen accumulated caused the explosion of the
structure. The radiation levels in the building increased and the sound alarm blew.
Immediately people contacted Nuclear Regulatory Commission and B and W, who
constructed the reactor. Nobody was there to answer the call at B and W. But
somehow people escaped without any loss of human lives. After 13 hours and a half,
the reactor was put under control.

4.12. Chernobyl, near Klev, Russia (April 1986)

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

The RBMK (Acronym for water cooled and graphite moderated) reactors were graphite
moderated and they use water tubes. A test on the turbine generator was planned to be
conducted during a scheduled plant shut-down maintenance.
To conduct the test, the power plant output was reduced to 700 MW. But due to a sudden
and unexpected demand, the power output has to be raised.
● To go ahead with the test, the reactor operators had already disconnected the
emergency core-cooling system, ignoring the raise in demand situation.
● Further, a control device was not properly reprogrammed to maintain power at 700-
100 MW level
● The test was conducted at 200 MW power out-put which is very low for the test.
They should have shut down the reactor.
● The operators blocked all emergency signals and automatic shut-down controls,
thus all safety systems were disconnected.
● The operators raised control rods to increase power output and tried to continue the test.
● This made the reactor unsafe. The temperature of RBMK reactor increased and
the fission rate increased.
● The test should have been postponed but continued. The reactor core melted and
due to the Hydrogen accumulation, the reactor caught fire and the radioactive
waste began to spread out in USSR and also Europe.
The people living around were informed after a few hours and were evacuated 12
hours after the explosion. More than 30 workers in the complex lost their lives, while 200
workers sustained burns. About 8000 people lost their lives. The agricultural products were
affected due to contaminated radioactive water, for several years.
4.13. Safety lessons from TMI and Chernobyl
1. The thickness of the containment should be more, to withstand the possible explosion
and further damage due to radiation and leakage over the surroundings (Chernobyl).
2. When the test began at low loads, the demand for increased outpower should have
been declined.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.14. Responsibilities of Engineers

4.14.1. Internal responsibilities of Engineers (responsibilities to Employers)
● In today’s competitive world, the success of any organization relies on its
team play
● Team play involves virtues of
a. Collegiality
b. Loyalty
c. Respect for Authority
d. Collective Bargaining
a. Collegiality
What is meant by collegiality?
● Collegiality is th tendency to support and cooperate with the colleagues
● According to National Society of Professional Engineers (NSPE) code,
the collegiality should include the following three characteristics
o Engineers should not attempt to injure, unkindly or falsely, directly or
indirectly, the professional reputation, prospects, practice or
employment of other Engineers
o Engineers should not untruthfully criticize other Engineers
o Engineers should bring unethical or illegal practice of other engineers to
the proper authority for action
● Collegiality is defined by Craig lhara as a kind of connectedness grounded
in respect for professional expertise and in a commitment to the goals and
values of the profession
Elements of Collegiality
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Negative aspects of collegiality

● Collegiality may be misused and distorted.
● Collegiality may degenerate more groups of self interest, rather than groups of
shared devotion to the public good
● Because of tough competition among Engineers, collegiality can focus on the
corporate goal of maximizing profit at the expense of the public good
b. Loyalty
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Example: People may not like the job they do not hate their employer, but still they
would perform their duty as long as they are employers. This sense of loyalty is
known as Agency Loyalty
2. Identification Loyalty
● It is concerned with the attitudes, emotions, and a sense of personal identity. It
includes willingness to meet moral duties, with attachment, conviction, and
trust with employer. The attitude loyalty is more a virtue than an obligation.
This type of loyalty is all right when the organizations work for productivity or
development of community. Working together in falsification of records or
serious harm to the public, does not merit loyalty. Further, with frequent
takeovers or merger resulting in large-scale layoff, employees find it difficult to
maintain attitude-loyalty
● Some of the specific duties of loyal employers are:
o To avoid conflicts of interest
o To inform employers of any possible conflicts of interest
o To protect confidential information
o To be honest in making estimates and
o To admit one’s errors
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

c. Respect for Authority

● What is meant by Authority?
● Decisions can be taken by a few people, but putting into action requires
larger participation from different groups of people, such as operation,
purchase, sales, accounts, maintenance, finance etc.
● In effectively-and efficiently-transferring decisions to actions, the
authority comes into play a great role.
● Otherwise the individual discretions may ruin the activities. Further the
authority fixes the personal responsibility and accountability uniquely on
each person. This is necessary to ensure progress in action.
● Authority can be defined as the legal right to command action by
others and to enforce compliance
● Authority provides a way to identify the areas of person’s
responsibility and accountability
● Sources of authority
● Person’s position or rank
● Personal attributes such as charisma. Knowledge and expertise
i. Institutional Authority
● Institutional authority can be defined as the institutional right given to a
person to exercise power based on the resources of institution
● It is the authority exercised within the organization. It is the right given to the
employees to exercise power, to complete the task and force them to achieve
their goals.
● Duties such as resource allocation, policy dissemination, recommendation,
supervision, issue orders (empower) or directions on subordinates are vested to
institutional authority, e.g., Line Managers and Project Managers have the
institutional duty to make sure that the products/projects are completed
successfully.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● The characteristics features of institutional authority are that they allocate

money and other resources and have liberty in execution.
ii. Expert Authority
On the other hand, the Expert Authority is (a) the possession of special
knowledge, skills and competence to perform a job thoroughly (expertise), (b) the
advice on jobs, and (c) is a staff function.

Authority vs power
Authority Power
It is the legal right of a superior which It is the ability of the person to
compel his subordinates to perform influence others to perform on an act, it
certain acts may not have legal sanction
It is delegated to an individual by a It is earned by an individual through his
superior own effects
It lies in the position held and the It rests in the individual. Even when the
authority changes with change in position has changed, his power
position remains with him
It is mostly well defined and finite It is undefined and infinite

iii. Moral Justified Authority

iv. Accepting Authority

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

v. Paramount obligations
● The code of ethics of the professional societies state that an engineer’s
paramount obligations is to protect the public health, safety, and welfare
rather than obligations of loyalty and faithful service to employers
● As professional Engineers have obligation to accept their employer’s
institutional authority. But this does not mean that they have to obey
obligations blindly. Therefore the basic moral task of engineers is to be
aware of their obligations to obey employers on the one hand and to protect
and serve the public and clients on the other hand
● Engineers must weigh their obligations to the public, their employers,
their colleagues and others when conflicts between such obligations
rise
d. Collective Bargaining
What is meant by collective Bargaining?
● International labor organization has defined collective bargaining as
“negotiation about working conditions and terms of employment
between an employer and one or more representative employee’s with
a view to reaching agreement”.
● The process is collective in the sense that the issue relating to terms
and conditions of employment are solved by representatives of
employees and employers rather than individuals
● The term bargaining refers to evolving an agreement using methods
like negotiation, discussion, exchange of facts and ideas rather than
confrontation
● The Indian Scenario:
● Gandhiji - the leader of the Ahmedabad textile workers
● Idea gathered interest only after the Second World War
● GOI took steps like setting up of machinery for negotiations, conciliation
and arbitration.
Process of collective bargaining
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Types of Collective Bargaining

Conjunctive / Distributive
Bargaining:
● Distributive bargaining is the most common type of bargaining & involves
zero- sum negotiations, in other words, one side wins and the other loses.
● Both parties try to maximize their respective gains.
● They try to settle economic issues such as wages, benefits, bonus, etc.
● For Example, Unions negotiate for maximum wages & the management
wants to yield as little as possible while getting things done through workers.
● In distributive bargaining, unions and management have initial offers or
demands, target points (e.g.: desired wage level), resistance points (e.g.:
unacceptable wage levels) & settlement ranges (e.g.: acceptable wage level).
Another name for this type of bargaining is conjunctive bargaining.
Cooperative /Integrative Bargaining:
● Integrative bargaining is similar to problem solving sessions in which both sides
are trying to reach a mutually beneficial alternative, i.e. a win-win situation.
● Both the employer & the union try to resolve the conflict to the benefit of both parties.
● Both sides share information about their interests and concerns and they create a
list of possible solutions to best meet everyone’s needs.
● For Example, when companies are hit by recession, they cannot offer the kind of
wages and benefits demanded by workers. At the same time they cannot survive
without the latter’s support. Both parties realize the importance of surviving in such
difficult times and are willing to negotiate the terms of employment in a flexible
way.
Productivity Bargaining:
• The concept of productivity bargain involves a good understanding of the
following concepts.
● Based on these concepts both the parties must develop a productivity linked scheme
● Difference between productivity & work intensity
● How to conduct work study
● ILO guidelines for work study – Personal needs allowance, Fatigue
allowance, hazardous allowance , etc.
● Other Methods like MOST (Maynard Operational Sequence Techniques)
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● Systems improvement and method improvement

● Required Skills and Knowledge for productivity settlement
Composite Bargaining:
• Workers believed that productivity bargaining agreements increased their workloads.
Rationalization, introduction of new technology, tight productivity norms have
added to this burden and made the life of a worker somewhat uneasy. As an answer
to such problems, labor has come in favor of composite bargaining.
• In this method, labor bargains for wages as usual, but goes a step further demanding
equity in matters relating to work norms, employment levels, manning standards,
environmental hazards , sub-contracting clauses etc. This works in the favor of the
workers, for e.g., when unions negotiate standards they ensure the workload of
workers don’t exceed
Concessionary Bargaining:
• Quite opposite to the other forms of bargaining, where the unions demanded from
the employers, in concessionary bargaining, the objective is to giving back to
management some of what it has gained in previous bargaining.
• Why should labor be willing to give back what it has worked so hard to obtain?
• A good example is the agreement between General Motors & the International
Union of Electric Workers that granted GM around the clock operations, wages and
benefits concessions for the new hires, and a two-week mass vacation. The
concessions were made to save over 3,000 jobs.
• In some cases, despite a financial crisis, the union may not be willing to concede.
This may be because the union doesn’t view management’s arguments as credible.
Thus, the degree of trust and credibility between the management and the union may
influence the extent to which concessionary bargaining occurs.
Faithful Agent or Trustee?
• Professional societies such as NSPE and IEI refuse to accept the ‘collective
coercive action’ of unionism, holding the principles of professional integrity as
right, e.g., as per NSPE code III, i.e., engineers shall not promote their own interest
at the expense of the dignity and integrity of the profession. The
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Service go the public

Professionalism and Unionism

o Collective bargaining assumes Unionism, legally any organization
employing more than 20 employees could have union, and as well as more
than one union is permitted
o The employee form unions to safeguard the interests of employee ad
prevent exploitation of employees
o Many professional engineers argued that the ethical aspects of
professionalism in engineering are inconsistent with union ideology and
practice
o According to John Kemper, the unionism and professionalism are conflicting
with each other. Professionalism offers paramount importance to the interests
of society and employer. But union also known as collective bargaining agents,
consider the economic interest o the members ahead of the interest of the
employer
o Professional societies have emphasized loyalty to employer and the public is
not possible with any form of collective bargaining
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

o The professional societies instruct the engineers indirectly not to become

members of Union because of the issue of conflicting loyalties and on the
grounds that it is unprofessionalism
o It is impossible for an engineer to belong to a union and at the same
time to maintain the standards of his profession

Assessment on Unionism

4.14.2. External responsibilities of Engineers (responsibilities to the outside world)

External responsibilities refer to the responsibilities of the engineers to the
outside world. They include
a) Confidentiality
b) Conflicts of Interest
c) Occupational crimes
a) Confidentiality
What is confidentiality?
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

What is meant by confidentiality Information?

• Confidentiality Information is information deemed desirable to keep secret
• According to code of ethics of ABET ” Engineers shall treat confidential
information coming to them in the course of their assignments as confidential
• Confidential information is any information that the employer/client would like to
keep secret in order to complete effectively against business rivals
Terms related to Confidential Information

3. Trade Secrets
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

• A trade secret can be type of information that has not become public and
which an employer has taken steps to keep secret
• These trade secrets may be about designs, technical processes, plant facilities,
quality control systems, business plans, marketing strategies and so on
• Trade secrets are given limited legal protection against employer or contractor
abuse. An employer can sue employees or contractors for leaking trade secrets or
even planning to do so.
4. Patents
• Patents legally protect specific products from being manufactured and
sold by competitors without the permission of the patent holder
Patent Trade Secret
What does it Covers new, useful inventions Covers valuable, secret information
protect?
How does it Gives you the right to exclude Protects only against “misappropriation”
protect my IP? others from making, selling,
using, importing
What must you Invention becomes public Information remains secret
disclose?
How do you get Formal application, examination No application or registration required
it? by patent office
How long 2-3 years, on average As long as it takes to establish and
before it takes maintain internal procedures
effect?
How long is it 20-year term Potentially perpetual
valid?
How much does Between $30,000 to $50,000 per No application fees; only administrative
it cost? patent, per country costs for establishing internal
procedures and staffing
What types of information should be kept confidential?
• Information about the unreleased product
• Test results and data about the product
• Design or formula of a product
• Data about a technical processes
• Organization of plant facilities
• Quality control procedures
• Business information such as number of employees working on the project, the
suppliers list, marketing strategies, production cost and production yield

Justification for Confidentiality

• Confidentiality can be justified by various ethical theories. According to Rights-
based theory, rights of the stakeholders, right to the intellectual property of the
company are protected by this practice. Based on Duty theory, employees and
employers have duty to keep up mutual trust. The Utilitarian theory holds good, only
when confidentiality
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

produce most good to most people. Act utilitarian theory focuses on each situation,
when the employer decides on some matters as confidential.
• The following moral principles also justify the concept of ‘confidentiality’:
1. Respect for Autonomy
It means respecting the freedom and self-determination of individuals and
organizations to identify their legitimate control over the personal information of
themselves. In the absence of this, they can not keep their privacy and protect their self-

interest.
Changing jobs and
confidentiality Is
Switching Job Ethical?
• When persons change jobs (employers), what happens to their moral obligation? The
obligation to protect the information does not cease, when one shifts to another
employee. Otherwise, the former employee will reveal this information to the new
employer or sell it to a competitor of the former employer. The integrity of the
employee, even upon switching the employer demands that he maintains
confidentiality and does not to divulge the information. The professional integrity of
engineers is more valuable than the loyalty to the current employer.
• Many engineers value professional advancement than long-term tie and loyalty
to a single employer.
• The engineers involved in research and development and expert contribution change
jobs. Normally they are familiar with the innovative developments in the parent
organizations. For example, one manufacturing expert along with his colleagues as
well as with some secret documents left General Motors and joined Volkswagen. This
violation of trade secret, lead the V W to pay huge compensation to GM in cash and
compulsion to buy parts from GM for seven subsequent years.
• Employees, who change jobs, will not able to withhold their knowledge and
expertise. They are sought after only for their expertise. They may not carry the
papers and but their active brain always carry memories. Although some
organizations hold that this is unethical, the individuals cannot be prevented from
divulging the facts to benefit the
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

current employer. The courts have held a moral verdict. Even though the previous
employers had the right to maintain their trade secrets confidential, the personal
rights of the employees, who switched job in pursuit of career advancement, had to
be honored and balanced.
Management Policies for maintaining confidentiality
How can we protect the rights of the employers and at the same time recognize
the genuine personal rights and other rights of the engineers/employees?
Some of the management practices and their limitations are discussed hereunder:
1. One way is to restrict the future employment of employees, by using employment
contracts at the time of their exit. Details such as the restriction on geographical
location, time gap between the departure from one place and engagement with the
other employer, and on the type of jobs that one can perform with future employer,
are entered in to contracts. But such contracts have not been given legal sanction.
2. An incentive instead of threatening their rights by the employment contract, may
offer some positive benefits in exchange for the restrictions listed. A lump sum post-
employment payment or compensation over a specific period may offered as
incentive to restrict him.
3. Another approach by the management is to effect tighter controls on internal
information flow on trade secrets and other vital features. But this is likely to create a
mutual distrust in the organization and to throttle the creativity of engineers involved
in the research and development. A better understanding between the ethical
management and the professional responsibility of the engineers will fulfill both
professional concerns and employee loyalty.

b) Conflicts of Interest

Types of conflicts of Interest

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Gifts, Bribes, and Kickbacks.

(b)
o A bribe is a substantial amount of money or goods offered beyond a
stated business contract with the aim of winning an advantage in gaining
or keeping the contract, and where the advantage is illegal or otherwise
unethical.
o It is something offered to influence or convince. Substantial is a vague term,
but it alludes to amounts, beyond acceptable gratuities, that are sufficient to
distort the judgment of a typical person. Typically, although not always, bribes
are made in secret.
o Bribes are illegal and immoral because of the following reasons
▪ Bribes corrupt free market economic system and is anti competitive
▪ It corrupts justice and public policy by allowing rich people to
make all the rules. Hence in today’s business only large and
powerful companies survive, since they are capable of providing
bribes
▪ Bribery treats people as commodities that can be bought or sold. This
practice degrades the human beings and corrupts both the buyer and
seller
o Prearranged payments made by contractors to companies or
their representatives in exchange for contracts actually granted
are called kickbacks.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

▪ When suggested by the granting party to the party bidding on the

contract, the latter often defends its participation in such an
arrangement as having been subjected to “extortion.”
o Gifts are not bribes as long as they are small gratuities offered in the
normal conduct of business.

• Codes of ethics do not encourage even gifts, but employees have set forth
flexible policies. Government and company policies generally ban gifts more
than a nominal value (>Rs.1000?)
• An additional thumb rule is that the acceptance of gift should not influence
one’s judgment on merit.
(c) Moonlighting
• It is a situation when a person is working as employee for two different companies in
the spare time. This is against the right to pursue one’s legitimate self-interest. It will
lead to conflict of interests, if the person works for competitors, suppliers or
customers, while working under an employer. Another effect of moonlighting is that
it leaves the person exhausted and harms the job performance in both places.
(d) Insider Information
• Another potential conflict of interest is when using ‘inside’ information to
establish a business venture or get an advantage for oneself or one’s family or
friends.
• The information may be either of the parent company or its clients or its business
partners, e.g., engineers might inform the decision on the company’s merger with
another company or acquisition or an innovative strategy adopted.
• In such cases, their friends get information on stock holding and decide on trading
their stocks to sell or buy quickly, so that gain more or prevent a loss.
• For example, in WorldCom USA, the insider information was used to manipulate and
sell a large amount of stock holding by the Director, upon knowing that the
government has declined to admit their product.
Ways to avoid conflicts
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

• A good way to avoid conflicts of interest is

● To follow the guidance of the company policy.
● In the absence of such a policy, asking a coworker or your manager will give
you a second opinion and will make it clear that you aren’t trying to hide
something.
● In the absence of either of these options, it is best to examine your motives
and use ethical problem-solving techniques.
● Finally, you can look to the statements in the professional ethics codes that
uniformly forbid conflicts of interest. Some of the codes have very explicit
statements that can help determine whether or not your situation is a
conflict of interest.

c) Occupational Crimes
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.15. Professional Rights

● Engineers have several types of moral rights like human, employee, contractual,
and professional rights.
o As humans, engineers have fundamental rights to live and freely pursue
their legitimate interests, which implies, for example, rights not to be
unfairly discriminated against in employment on the basis of sex, race, or
age.
o As employees, engineers have special rights, including the right to receive
one’s salary in return for performing one’s duties and the right to engage
in the nonwork political activities of one’s choosing without reprisal or
coercion from employers.
o As professionals, engineers have special rights that arise from their
professional role and the obligations it involves. We begin with
professional rights.
Three professional rights have special importance: (1) the basic right of professional
conscience, (2) the right of conscientious refusal, and (3) the right of professional
recognition.
a) Right of Professional Conscience.

● The right of professional conscience is the moral right to exercise professional

judgment in pursuing professional responsibilities. Pursuing those responsibilities
involves exercising both technical judgment and reasoned moral convictions.
● It is the right to do what everyone agrees it is obligatory for the professional engineer
to do. But engineering, like other professions, calls for morally complex decisions. It
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

requires autonomous moral judgment in trying to uncover the most morally

reasonable courses of action, and the correct courses of action are not always obvious.
● As with most moral rights, the basic professional right is an entitlement giving one
the moral authority to act without interference from others. It is a “liberty right” that
places an obligation on others not to interfere with its proper exercise.
● Special resources may be required by engineers seeking to exercise the right of
professional conscience in the course of meeting their professional obligations. For
example, conducting an adequate safety inspection may require that special
equipment be made available by employers.
● There are two general ways to justify the basic right of professional conscience.
o One is to proceed gradually by repeating the justifications given for the
specific professional duties. The justification of each duty ultimately yields a
justification of the right of conscience with respect to that duty.
▪
o The second way is to justify the right of professional conscience directly,
which involves grounding it more directly in the ethical theories. Thus, duty
ethics regards professional rights as implied by general duties to respect
persons, and rule-utilitarianism would accent the public good of allowing
engineers to pursue their professional duties. Rights ethics would justify the
right of professional conscience by reference to the rights of the public not to
be harmed and the right to be warned of dangers from the “social
experiments” of technological innovation.
b) Right of Conscientious Refusal.
o The right of conscientious refusal is the right to refuse to engage in
unethical behavior and to refuse to do so solely because one views it as
unethical.
o This is a kind of second-order right. It arises because other rights to honor
moral obligations within the authority-based relationships of employment
sometimes come into conflict.
o According to this rights, no employer can force or pressure an employee to do
something that the employees considers unethical and unacceptable
o There are two situations to be considered: (1) where there is widely shared
agreement in the profession as to whether an act is unethical and (2) where
there is room for disagreement among reasonable people over whether an act
is unethical.
o It seems clear enough that engineers and other professionals have a moral right
to refuse to participate in activities that are illegal and clearly unethical (for
example, forging documents, altering test results, lying, giving or taking bribes,
or padding payrolls).
o And forcing employees into acting by means of threats (to their jobs) plainly
constitutes a violation of this right of theirs.

c) Right of Recognition.
o Engineers have a right of professional recognition for their work and
accomplishments. Part of this involves fair monetary remuneration, and part
nonmonetary forms of recognition.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

o The right to recognition, and especially fair remuneration, may seem to be

purely a matter of self-interest rather than morality, but it is both. Without a
fair remuneration, engineers cannot concentrate their energies on carrying out
the immediate duties of their jobs and on maintaining up-to-date skills through
formal and informal continuing education.
o The right to reasonable remuneration is clear enough to serve as a moral basis
for arguments against corporations that make excessive profits while engineers
are paid below the pay scales of blue-collar workers. It can also serve as the
basis for criticizing the unfairness of patent arrangements that fail to give more
than nominal rewards to the creative engineers who make the discoveries
leading to the patents.
o The recognition /reward may be given in two types:
▪ Intrinsic awards: These are related to non monetary remunerations.
Such as acknowledging achievements by issuing appreciation letters,
certificates and oral phrases
▪ Extrinsic Awards: this is related to monetary remunerations such as
increased salaries, commissions, cash bonus, gain sharing etc.
4.16. Employee Rights
● Employee rights are any rights, moral or legal, that involve the status of being an
employee.
● They overlap with some professional rights, they also include institutional rights
created by organizational policies or employment agreements, such as the right to be
paid the salary specified in one’s contract.
● Ewing refers to employee rights as the “black hole in American rights.” The Bill
of Rights in the Constitution was written to apply to government, not to business. But
we haven’t foreseen the giant corporations that have emerged in our century.
Corporations wield enormous power politically and socially, often in multinational
settings; they operate much as mini governments, and they are often comparable in
size to those governments the authors of the Constitution had in mind. For example,
American Telephone & Telegraph in the 1970s employed twice the number of people
that inhabited the largest of the original 13 colonies when the Constitution was written.

1. Privacy Right. The right to pursue outside activities can be thought of as a right to
personal privacy in the sense that it means the right to have a private life off the job.
The right to privacy means the right to control the access to and the use of information
about oneself. As with the right to outside activities, this right is limited in certain
instances by employers’ rights. For example, the personnel division needs medical
and life insurance information about employees, but immediate supervisors usually do
not.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Consider a few examples of situations in which the functions of employers conflict

with the right employees have to privacy:
● Job applicants at the sales division of an electronics firm are required to take
personality tests that include personal questions about alcohol use and sexual
conduct.
● A supervisor unlocks and searches the desk of an engineer who is away on vacation
without the permission of that engineer. The supervisor suspects the engineer of
having leaked information about company plans to a competitor and is searching
for evidence to prove those suspicions.
● A large manufacturer of expensive pocket computers has suf-fered substantial
losses from employee theft. It is believed that more than one employee is involved.
Without notifying employees, hidden surveillance cameras are installed.
● A rubber products firm has successfully resisted various attempts by a union to
organize its workers. It is always one step ahead of the union’s strategies, in part
because it monitors the phone calls of employees who are union sympathizers. It
also pays selected employees bonuses in exchange for their attending union meet-
ings and reporting on information gathered. It considered, but rejected as imprudent,
the possibility of bugging the rest areas where employees were likely to discuss
proposals made by union organizers.
2. Right to Equal Opportunity: Preventing Sexual Harassment.
● One definition of sexual harassment is: “the unwanted imposition of sexual
requirements in the context of a relationship of unequal power.”. It takes two
main forms: quid pro quo and hostile work environment.
● Quid pro quo includes cases where supervisors require sexual favors as a
condition for some employment benefit (a job, promotion, or raise). It can take
the form of a sexual threat (of harm) or sexual offer (of a benefit in return for a
benefit).
● Hostile work environment, by contrast, is any sexually oriented aspect of the
workplace that threatens employees’ rights to equal opportunity. It includes
unwanted sexual proposals, lewd remarks, sexual leering, posting nude photos,
and inappropriate physical contact.
● Sexual harassment is a particularly invidious form of sex discrimination,
involving as it does not only the abuse of gender roles and authority relationships,
but the abuse of sexual intimacy itself.
● Sexual harassment is a display of power and aggression through sexual means.
sexual harassment constitutes an infringement of one’s autonomy to make free
decisions concerning one’s body. But whether or not coercion and manipulation
are used, it is an assault on the victim’s dignity. In abusing sexuality, such
harassment degrades people on the basis of a biological and social trait central to
their sense of personhood.
● Thus a duty ethicist would condemn it as violating the duty to treat people with
respect, to treat them as having dignity and not merely as means to personal
enhancement and gratification of one’s sexual and power interests. A rights
ethicist would see it as a serious violation of the human right to pursue one’s work
free from the pressures, fears, penalties, and insults that typically accompany
sexual
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

harassment. And a utilitarian would emphasize the impact it has on the victim’s
happiness and self- fulfillment, and on women in general. This also applies to men
who experience sexual harassment.

3. Right to Equal Opportunity: Nondiscrimination.

● Discrimination because of one’s sex, race, skin color, age, or political or
religious outlook. These aspects of biological makeup and basic conviction lie
at the heart of self-identity and self-respect. This discrimination which means
a morally unjustified treatment of people on arbitrary or irrelevant grounds—
is especially destructive within the work environment, f
● Consider the following two examples:
● An opening arises for a chemical plant manager. Normally such positions are
filled by promotions from within the plant. The best qualified person in terms of
training and years of experience is an African American engineer. Management
believes, however, that the majority of workers in the plant would be disgruntled
by the appointment of a nonwhite manager. They fear lessened employee
cooperation and efficiency. They decide to promote and transfer a white engineer
from another plant to fill the position.
● A farm equipment manufacturer has been hit hard by lowered sales caused by a
flagging produce economy. Layoffs are inevi-table. During several clandestine
management meetings, it is decided to use the occasion to “weed out” some of the
engineers within 10 years of retirement to avoid payments of unvested pen-sion
funds.
● These examples involve (immoral) discrimination. They also involve the violation
of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the 1967 Age Discrimination in Employment
Act, respectively.
4. Right to Equal Opportunity: Affirmative Action.
● Affirmative action, as the expression is usually defined, is giving a preference
or advantage to a member of a group that in the past was denied equal
treatment, in particular, women and minorities.
● The weak form of preferential treatment consists in hiring a woman or a member
of a minority over an equally qualified white male.
● The strong form, by contrast, consists in giving preference to women or minorities
over better-qualified white males.
● Examples
o white male engineer, was denied entrance to the medical school at the
University of California, Davis (UC Davis), which reserved 16 of 100
openings for applicants who were either black, Latino, Asian, or American
Indian. He sued, arguing that his credentials were superior to many of the
minority students accepted. The Supreme Court ruled that the UC Davis
admissions program was unconstitutional because it used explicit
numerical quotas for minorities, which prevented person-to-person
comparisons among all applicants. Yet the court also ruled that using race
as one of many factors in comparing applicants is permissible, as long as
quotas are avoided, and the
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

intent is to ensure the goal of diversity among students—an important

educational goal.

5. Right to choose outside activities

6. Right to due process from employer

It is the right to fair process or procedures in firing, demotion and in taking
any disciplinary actions against the employees. Written explanation should be
initially obtained from the charged employee and the orders are given in writing, with
clearly- stated reasons. Simple appeal procedures should be framed and made
available to all those affected. Fairness here is specified in terms of the process rather
than the outcomes.
.
4.17. Whistle – Blowing
● Whistle-blowing is the act by an employee of informing the public or
higher management of unethical or illegal behavior by an employer or
supervisor.
● There are frequent newspaper reports of cases in which an employee of a company
has gone to the media with allegations of wrongdoing by his or her employer or in
which a government employee has disclosed waste or fraud.
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

● According to the codes of ethics of the professional engineering societies, engineers

have a duty to protect the health and safety of the public, so in many cases, an
engineer is compelled to blow the whistle on acts or projects that harm these values.
● Engineers also have the professional right to disclose wrongdoing within
their organizations and expect to see appropriate action taken.
4.17.1. Definition
● Whistle blowing is alerting relevant persons to some moral or legal
corruption, where relevant persons are those in a position to act in
response, if only by registering protested
● Whistle blowing occurs when an employee or former employee coveys
information about a significant moral problem outside approved
organization channels to someone in a position to take action on the
problem
4.17.2. Aspects
There are four aspects of whistle blowing, namely:
1. Basis of disclosure: The basis for disclosure may be intentional, or under
pressure from superiors or others not to disclose.
2. Relevance of topic: The whistle blower believes that the information is
about a significant problem for the organization or its business ally. It can be a
threat to the public or employees’ health, safety and welfare or a criminal
activity, or unethical policies or practices, or an injustice to the workers within
the organization.
3. Agent: The person disclosing the information may be a current or former
employee or a person having a close link to the organization.
4. Recipient: The person or organization, who receives the information, is in a
position to remedy the problem or alert the affected parties. Usually, the recipients
are not aware of the information fully or even partially.
4.17.3. Types of Whistle Blowing
● Based on the destination (recipient), whistle blowing is classified into types, as:
(a) Internal: In this case, the information is conveyed to a person within the
organization, but beyond the approved channels.
(b) External: This happens when the information is transmitted outside the
organization. The recipient may be a municipal chairman or member of legislature
or minister. It becomes severe if the information reaches the press and through them
the public. The damage is maximum and sometimes poses difficulty in remedying
the situation.
● Based on the origin or source (agent), this can be divided into three types,
as follows:
(a) Open: The originator reveals his identity as he conveys the information.
This information is reliable and true, but sometimes partially true.
(b) Anonymous: The identity is concealed. The information may or may
not be true. But the agent anticipates perhaps some repression or threat, if
identity is revealed.
(c) Partly anonymous (or partly open): Such a situation exists when the
individual reveals his identity to the journalist, but insists that the name be
withheld from others.
4.17.4. When should be whistle blowing be attempted
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

Whistle-blowing should only be attempted if the following four conditions are met
[ Harris, Pritchard, and Rabins, 2000 ]:
1. Need. There must be a clear and important harm that can be avoided by blowing the
whistle. In deciding whether to go public, the employee needs to have a sense of
proportion. You don’t need to blow the whistle about everything, just the important
things. For example, if an accident occurs at your company, resulting in a spill of a
small quantity of a toxic compound into a nearby waterway that is immediately
cleaned up, this incident probably doesnot merit notifying outside authorities.
However, if this type of event happens repeatedly and no action is taken to rectify the
problem despite repeated attempts by employees to get the problem fi xed, then
perhaps this situation is serious enough to warrant the extreme measure of whistle-
blowing.
2. Proximity. The whistle-blower must be in a very clear position to report on the
problem. Hear say is not adequate. Firsthand knowledge is essential to making an
effective case about wrongdoing. This point also implies that the whistleblower must
have enough expertise in the area to make a realistic assessment of the situation. This
condition stems from the clauses in several codes of ethics which mandate that an
engineer not undertake work in areas outside her expertise. This principle applies
equally well to making assessments about whether wrongdoing is taking place.
3. Capability. The whistle-blower must have a reasonable chance of success in stopping
the harmful activity. You are not obligated to risk your career and the financial
security of your family if you can’t see the case through to completion or you don’t
feel that you have access to the proper channels to ensure that the situation is resolved.
4. Last resort. Whistle-blowing should be attempted only if there is no one else more
capable or more proximate to blow the whistle and if you feel that all other lines of
action within the context of the organization have been explored and shut off.
4.17.5. Preventing whistle Blowing
● There are four ways in which to solve the whistle-blowing problem within a corporation.
● First, there must be a strong corporate ethics culture. This should include a
clear commitment to ethical behavior, starting at the highest levels of
management, and mandatory ethics training for all employees. All managers
must set the tone for the ethical behavior of their employees.
● Second, there should be clear lines of communication within the corporation.
This openness gives an employee who feels that there is something that must be fi
xed a clear path to air his concerns.
● Third, all employees must have meaningful access to high-level managers in
order to bring their concerns forward. This access must come with a guarantee that
there will be no retaliation. Rather, employees willing to come forward should be
rewarded for their commitment to fostering the ethical behavior of the company.
● Finally, there should be willingness on the part of management to admit
mistakes, publicly if necessary. This attitude will set the stage for ethical behavior
by all employees.

4.17.6. When to Justify

Under the following situations, the whistle blowing may be justified:
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

1. When the potential harm existing is identified as serious, or anticipated to occur

with a high probability, in the near future.
2. When sufficient data on the harm had been gathered and adequately documented.
This condition may not be required if revealing the information would jeopardize the
national interests or help the competitors. A request to the appropriate authority for
external investigation or permission by a court to release the information may be a
solution.
3. The concerns have been reported earlier to the immediate superiors and no
satisfactory response was forthcoming from them, within a reasonable time.

4.17.7. Before you blow a whistle

 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

4.18. Intellectual Property Rights

4.18.1. What is intellectual property Rights?
● Intellectual Property (IP) is a property that results from mental labor
● The IP is originating mainly from the activities of the human intellect
● IP is the information and original expression that derives its original value from
creative ideas, and is with commercial value.
● IPR permits people to have independent ownerships for their innovations and
creativity, like that of own physical property. This encourages the IP owners towards
innovation and benefit to the society. It is an asset that can be bought or sold, licensed,
and exchanged. It is intangible i.e., it cannot be identified by specific parameters.
4.18.2. What are IPR?
● The agreements with World Trade Organization (WTO) and Trade-Related aspects
of Intellectual Property System (TRIPS) have been adopted effective from January
2005. Besides the minimum standards set for protection of IP rights, appropriate
laws framed by the member countries are expected to reduce distortions and barriers
for and promote the international trade.
● The global IPR system strengthens protection, increases the incentives for
innovation, and raises returns on international technology transfer. However, it
could raise the costs of acquiring new technology and products, shifting the global
terms of trade in favor of technology producers.
4.18.3. Need for Protection of IP
● IP plays an essential role to stabilize and develop the economy of a nation. This
protection actually stimulates creativity, research, and innovation by ensuring
freedom to individuals and organizations to benefit from their creative intellectual
investments. The IP serves many purposes, namely
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

(a) it prevents others using it,

(b) prevent using it for financial gain,
(c) prevent plagiarism
(d) fulfill obligation to funding agency. ICICI Bank has advanced loan against
IP as security to Shopper’s Stoppe, New Delhi, and
(e) provides a strategy to generate steady income.
● Some of the challenges in the acquisition of IP are:
(a) Shortage of manpower in the industry. Educational institutions can play a vital
role in providing the same.
(b) High cost of patenting and lengthy procedure. This was being considered by
the Government and a simpler and faster procedure is expected, and
(c) Lack of strong enforcement mechanism.

4.18.4. Types and Norms

The agreements establish norms and conditions for the following instruments of intellectual
properties:
a) Patents
o Patent is a contract between the individual (inventor) and the society (all
others). Patents protect legally the specific products from being
manufactured or sold by others, without permission of the patent holder.
Patent holder has the legally- protected monopoly power as one’s own
property.
o The validity is 20 years from the date filing the application for the patent. It
is a territorial right and needs registration.
o The Patent (Amendment) Act 2002 guarantees such provisions.
o Patent is given to a product or a process, provided it is entirely new,
involving an inventive method and suitable for industrial application. While
applying for a patent, it is essential to submit the documents in detail
regarding the problem addressed, its solution, extent of novelty or innovation,
typical applications, particulars of the inventor, and the resources utilized.
Inventions are patentable and the discoveries are not.
2. Copyright
● The copyright is a specific and exclusive right, describing rights given to
creators for their literary and artistic works. This protects literary material,
aesthetic material, music, film, sound recording, broadcasting, software,
multimedia, paintings, sculptures, and drawings including maps, diagrams,
engravings or photographs. There is no need for registration and no need to
seek lawyer’s help for settlement. The life of the copyright protection is the
life of the inventor or author plus 50 years.
● Copyright gives protection to particular expression and not for the idea.
Copyright is effective in
(a) preventing others from copying or reproducing or storing the work,
(b) publishing and selling the copies,
(c) performing the work in public, commercially
(d) to make film
(e) to make translation of the work, and
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

(f) to make any adaptation of the work. Copying the idea is called
‘plagiarism’ and it is dealt with separately.
● Can software be protected through copyright? Indian copyright Act
amended in 1984 included the rights of in a computer program as literary
work. Many countries protect software as a copyright. Some holds the view
that copyright is not the right type of protection for software. They held that
the patents and trade secrets are more appropriate forms of protecting
software. While trade secret is the most conventional form of protection of
software, in the recent years, both patents and copyrights are adopted to
protect software.
● Copyright (Amendment) Act 1999, India ensures fair dealing of
broadcasting through the internet. The concerns of Book industry, Music
Industry, Film and Television Industry, Computer Industry and Database
Industry are sufficiently met by this updated Act.
3. Trademarks
● Trademark is a wide identity of specific good and services, permitting
differences to be made among different trades. It is a territorial right, which needs
registration. Registration is valid initially for 10 years, and renewable. The trademark
or service mark may be registered in the form of a device, a heading, a label, a ticket,
a letter, a word or words, a numeral or any combination of these, logos, designs,
sounds, and symbols.
● Trademark should not be mistaken for a design, e.g., the shape of a bottle in which a
product is marketed, can not be registered as a trademark. Trademarks Act 1999
made in compliance with TRIPS agreement, provides further details.
● There are three functions of trademark:
a. Just as we are identified by our names, good are identified by their
trademarks. For example, the customer goes to the shop and asks for Lux
soap. The word ‘Lux’ is a trade mark. In other words it shows the origin or
source of the goods.
b. The trademark carries with it an inherent indication or impression on the
quality of goods, which indirectly demonstrates that it receives the
customer’s satisfaction.
c. The trademark serves as silent sales promoter. Without a trademark, there can
be no advertisement. In other words, it serves as a medium for advertising the
goods.
● The marks should be distinctive i.e., it should be able to distinguish from one
good to the other. The terms used for trademarks are usually generic, descriptive,
and suggestive. Some of the term which are not distinctly distinguishing the
goods or services from others, are called generic term and are eligible for
protection under trademarks. The descriptive term should clearly indicate or
convey the specific purpose, function, physical characteristic and the end use of
the product.
4. Trade secret
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

5. Design of Integrated circuits

o It is the right granted to the inventor to prevent anybody making use of the
design of IC , semiconductor devices and other electronic devices
6. Geographical indications
o Geographical identification identifies goods as originating in the territory of
a country, an origin or a locally in that territory, where specific quality,
reputations or other characteristics of the goods is essentially attributed to
other Geographical conditions
o Examples: Tirunelveli halwa, dindugal locks, Sivakasi crackers etc.
4.18.5. Benefits of IPR’s
● Promote technological, industrial and economical developments of a country
● Provide incentives for the inventions and ensure adequate returns on
commercialization of the invention
● Prevent the competitors from using one’s invention
● Useful in identifying unprotected areas to avoid violation
● Grants exclusive rights to the inventors
● Use the invention for the public purpose
● Useful in identifying unexplored areas for undertaking research so as to become a
leader in that area

Part A
1. Define safety
● Safety means state of being safe, safe means protected from danger harm.
● The term safety is always difficult to describe completely, what may be safe for
one person may be risk for another one.
● The American Heritage Dictionary safety as freedom from damage, injury, or risk.
● The definition for safety is defined by William.W. Lowrence as follows:
o A thing is safe if its risks are judged to be acceptable.

2. What does the term collective bargaining means

i. International labor organization has defined collective bargaining
as “negotiation about working conditions and terms of
employment between an employer and one or more representative
employee’s with a view to reaching agreement”.
ii. The process is collective in the sense that the issue relating to
terms and conditions of employment are solved by
representatives of employees and employers rather than
individuals
 UNIT IV SAFETY, RESPONSIBILITIES AND RIGHTS

iii. The term bargaining refers to evolving an agreement using

methods like negotiation, discussion, exchange of facts and ideas
rather than confrontation

3. Define risk benefit analysis

● Risk benefit analysis is similar to cost benefit analysis used to analyze the risk
in a project and to determine whether the project should be carried out or not
● The major reasons for the analysis of the risk benefit are:
.1. To know risks and benefits and weigh them each
.2. To decide on designs, advisability of product/project
.3. To suggest and modify the design so that the risks are eliminated or reduced

4. What is meant by whistle blowing

● Whistle blowing is alerting relevant persons to some moral or legal
corruption, where relevant persons are those in a position to act in
response, if only by registering protested
● Whistle blowing occurs when an employee or former employee coveys
information about a significant moral problem outside approved
organization channels to someone in a position to take action on the
problem
5. What is IPR
● Intellectual Property (IP) is a property that results from mental labor
● The IP is originating mainly from the activities of the human intellect
● IP is the information and original expression that derives its original value from
creative ideas, and is with commercial value.
● IPR permits people to have independent ownerships for their innovations and
creativity, like that of own physical property. This encourages the IP owners towards
innovation and benefit to the society. It is an asset that can be bought or sold, licensed,
and exchanged. It is intangible i.e., it cannot be identified by specific parameters.

6. What is risk analysis

 UNIT GLOBAL

UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

Multinational Corporations – Environmental Ethics – Computer Ethics – Weapons
Development – Engineers as Managers – Consulting Engineers – Engineers as Expert
Witnesses and Advisors – Moral Leadership –Code of Conduct – Corporate Social
Responsibility

5.1. Multinational Corporations

o Organizations, who have established business in more than one country, are called
Multinational Corporation. The headquarters are in the home country and the business is
extended in many host countries. The Western organizations doing business in the less-
economically developed (developing, and overpopulated) countries gain the advantage of
inexpensive labor, availability of natural resources, conducive-tax atmosphere, and virgin
market for the products.
o At the same time, the developing countries are also benefited by fresh job opportunities,
jobs with higher remuneration and challenges, transfer of technology, and several social
benefits by the wealth developed. But this happens invariably with some social and cultural
disturbance. Loss of jobs for the home country, and loss or exploitation of natural resources,
political instability for the host countries are some of the threats of globalization.
5.1.1. International Human Rights
o To know what are the moral responsibilities and obligations of the multinational
corporations operating in the host countries, let us discuss with the framework of rights
ethics. Common minimal rights are to be followed to smoothen the transactions when
the engineers and employers of MNCs have to interact at official, social, economic and
sometimes political levels.
o At international level, the organizations are expected to adopt the minimum levels of
(a) values, such as mutual support, loyalty, and reciprocity, (b) the negative duty of
refraining from harmful actions such as violence and fraud, and (c) basic fairness and
practical justice in case of conflicts.
o The ten international rights to be taken care of, in this context are:
1. Right of freedom of physical movement of people
2. Right of ownership of properties
3. Freedom from torture
4. Right to fair trial on the products1
5. Freedom from discrimination on the basis of race or sex. If such discrimination
against women or minorities is prevalent in the host country, the MNC will be
compelled to accept. MNCs may opt to quit that country if the human rights
violations are severe.
6. Physical security. Use of safety gadgets have to be supplied to the workers even
if the laws of the host country do not suggest such measures.
7. Freedom of speech and forming association
8. Right to have a minimum education
9. Right to political participation
10. Right to live and exist (i.e., coexistence). The individual liberty and sanctity of
the human life are to be respected by all societies.
5.1.2. Technology Transfer
o It is a process of moving technology to a new setting and implementing it there.
Technology includes hardware (machines and installations) and the techniques
 UNIT GLOBAL

(technical, organizational, and managerial skills and procedures). It may mean moving
the technology applications from laboratory to the field/factory or from one country to
another. This transfer is effected by governments, organizations, universities, and
MNCs.
5.1.3. Appropriate Technology
o Identification, transfer, and implementation of most suitable technology for a set of new
situations, is called appropriate technology. Technology includes both hardware
(machines and installations) and software (technical, organizational and managerial
skills and procedures).
o Factors such as economic, social, and engineering constraints are the causes for the
modification of technology. Depending on the availability of resources, physical
conditions (such as temperature, humidity, salinity, geographical location, isolated land
area, and availability of water), capital opportunity costs, and the human value system
(social acceptability) which includes their traditions, beliefs, and religion, the
appropriateness is to be determined.
o For example, small farmers in our country prefer to own and use the power tillers,
rather than the high-powered tractors or sophisticated harvesting machines. On the other
hand, the latest technological device, the cell phones and wireless local loop phones
have found their way into remote villages and hamlets, than the landline telephone
connections. Large aqua-culture farms should not make the existing fishermen jobless in
their own village.
o The term appropriate is value based and it should ensure fulfillment of the human needs
and protection of the environment.
5.1.4. How Appropriate is Aptech?
o A case against the technology transfer is that the impact of borrowed or transferred
technology has been threatening the environment beyond its capacity and sustainable
development of the host countries. Large plantations that orient their efforts to exports
leave the small farmers out of jobs and at the mercy of the foreign country. For example,
genetically modified cotton have shown sufficient disturbance in Europe and Africa.
This has made the European Union to oppose the entry of G.M. cotton into Europe.
o The high technology has contributed to large-scale migration from villages to the cities
where corporations are located, leading to the undesirable side-effects of overcrowding
of cities, such as the scarcity of water, insanitation, poverty, and the increase in crimes.
o The term ‘appropriate’ should emphasize the social acceptability and environmental
protection of the host countries, and this need to be addressed while transferring
technology. Thus, we confirm the view that engineering is a continual social
experimentation with nature.
5.1.5. MNCs and Morality
o The economic and environmental conditions of the home and host countries may vary.
But the multinational institutions have to adopt appropriate measures not to disturb or
dislocate the social and living conditions and cultures of the home countries. A few
principles are enlisted here:
1. MNC should respect the basic human rights of the people of the host countries.
2. The activities of the MNC should give economic and transfer technical benefits, and
implement welfare measures of the workers of the host countries.
3. The business practices of the multinational organisations should improve and
promote morally justified institutions in the host countries.
 UNIT GLOBAL

4. The multinationals must respect the laws and political set up, besides cultures and
promote the cultures of the host countries.
5. The multinational organisations should provide a fair remuneration to the employees
of the host countries. If the remuneration is high as that of home country, this may
create tensions and if it is too low it will lead to exploitation.
6. Multinational institutions should provide necessary safety for the workers when
they are engaged in hazardous activities and ‘informed consent’ should be obtained
from them.cAdequate compensation should be paid to them for the additional risks
undertaken.
Advantages of Multinational Corporations
1. Multinational corporations provide an inflow of capital.
Multinationals are a leading source of capital inflows to the developing world, building
factories, investing in training centers, and supporting educational facilities with the
intention of improving their productive capacities overseas.
2. Multinational corporations reduce government aid dependencies in the
developing world.
The current level of trade for Europe is at 60%. North America experiences a 40% level of
trade, while the Southeast Asian Nations achieve 30%. The current level of trade for
African countries, however, is just 12%. Multinational corporations could boost this rate in
the developing world by up to 50%.
3. Multinational corporations allow countries to purchase imports.
When multinationals build a presence in the developing world, their capital inflows help
countries have more access to the import/export market. That allows them to access better
goods, create more opportunities, and eventually raise the standard of living for everyone.
4. Multinational corporations provide local employment.
If you step outside of the developed world for a moment, the average person works in an
agriculture-related position. Almost 70% of the jobs found in the poorest countries of the
world are based on this industry, compared to less than 5% which is located in the
wealthiest nations in the world. Multinationals come in, offer higher wages (which are still
low compared to global standards), then shift the standard of living.
5. Multinational corporations improve the local infrastructure.
Companies must have employees who can access job sites to become productive. That
means an investment in the local infrastructure becomes necessary before operations
even begin. Roads, bridges, and technology access are three of the largest barriers taken
down when multinationals become active in a developing country. .
6. Multinational corporations diversify local economies.
Multinationals provide these economies with more variety, creating diversity in local
production levels. That reduces reliance on commodities which often have volatile
prices because their supply and demand levels waiver so often.
7. Multinational companies create consistent consumer experiences.
Multinationals work from a centralized structure, which means there is a basic expectation
that every asset will look and perform as every other one does. Even though a McDonald’s
in India serves different products than one in the United States, the core values of the
company are still on display.
8. Multinational corporations encourage more innovation.
The average multinational corporation spends between 5% to 10% of its annual budget on
innovative research. Many of the companies with the most intensive research and
 UNIT GLOBAL

development intensity are the multinationals who are on the Fortune Global 500. Only
two
 UNIT GLOBAL

companies, Apple and Stanley Black and Decker, qualify as high-leverage innovators
because of their investments today. The world’s largest spenders increased their
investments by 11.4% in 2018 to total $782 billion.
9. Multinational corporations enforce minimum quality standards.
Most multinationals rely on vendors for their distribution work. Some even use them for
sales opportunities. Because of their size and influence, these companies put leverage on
their partners (including their suppliers) to provide an expected experience to each
customer. If there is a failure to do so, the corporation can move to a different vendor
immediately, which instantly kills some distribution businesses overseas. This structure
creates efficiencies of scale that lower customer prices while still ensuring reasonably
good product quality.
10. Multinational corporations increase cultural awareness.
When companies expand overseas, they become exposed to new cultural realities.
Multinationals are incredibly diverse, which gives them added strength because of this
necessity. One must know the pain points of the local market before you can produce goods
or services for them. When anyone expands their thinking to include new perspectives, the
world becomes a stronger place because of it. These companies offer a positive influence
on cross-culture communication if this advantage becomes a top priority for them.
Disadvantages of Multinational Corporations
1. Multinational corporations create higher environmental costs.
One primary advantage which multinationals see in doing business in the developing world
is a lack of robust environmental legislation. Weaker governments tend to exchange
environmental harm for additional profits. When these companies can outsource their
production to countries with these lower standards, it does lower prices, but it also creates
more damage. Countries like India even trade in waste and rubbish because of the revenues
they earn from recycling and disposal, creating the potential for harm to local soil and
water supplies.
2. Multinational corporations don’t always leave profits local.
There is evidence to show that the investments made by multinational companies
improve the local infrastructure. Additional education and job training offer new
opportunities for domestic workers. Once the investments are made, however, the profits
earned by the company tend to be repatriated for use in other areas. If you were to look at
the net inflow of capital instead of the gross, you usually find that the actual benefit
offered by multinationals is quite low (and sometimes even negative).
3. Multinational corporations import skilled labor.
Multinationals invest in local workers to develop their skills, but they also need to get their
venture off the ground quickly. Most companies in this position will import the skilled
labor they require from other economies to meet their needs. That means the best jobs,
especially in the developing world, are given to people who don’t even live in the local
economy.
Those wages do not offer the same economic benefits because spending occurs
internationally instead of at the local level.
4. Multinational corporations create one-way raw material resource consumption..
Many multinationals go into a new country looking to extract raw materials without
infrastructure considerations, taking oil, rubber, or precious metals to create products.
Those extraction efforts may cause several environmental concerns over time, from the
pollution of rivers to the loss of landscape. The investments pay for the materials, but
 UNIT GLOBAL

they don’t always pay for the damage left behind.

 UNIT GLOBAL

5. Multinational corporations encourage political corruption.

When multinationals enter the region, promising to pay for access to raw materials and
other needs, those in charge politically often prevent the investments from filtering down to
the general population. Money usually gets siphoned off by politicians and officials, which
creates massive disruption at the local level with only minor compensation (if any) from
the government working with the corporation.
6. Multinational corporations support “sweatshop” labor.
Sweatshop labor is typically seen as a disadvantage to local economies. Although some
experts suggest that any job and income is better than nothing at all, weak labor conditions
allow multinationals to lower wages to the greatest extent possible to pad their own profit
margins. Even when minimum salaries are legislated by the government, what workers
earn in the developing world is very small.
7. Multinational corporations remove jobs from their home country.
Several jobs are more economical for multinationals to outsource or offshore the positions
than hire domestically. Manufacturing jobs are outsourced most often, with multinationals
focusing on Southeast Asia because of the lower labor costs involved. Call centers are
outsourced frequently too, again because wages are lower overseas than in their home
market. Writers and graphic designers are often outsourced because contract employees
are cheaper than full-time staff. These companies might help other economies grow, but
they can also create employment difficulties at home.
8. Multinational corporations build legal monopolies.
Even though the assets controlled by multinational corporations are managed by a
centralized structure, governments treat each location as its own entity. That gives
the companies more leeway in how they handle their consumer markets.
9. Multinational corporations put other companies out of business.
Walmart offers a relentless push for profits. One doesn’t earn $500+ billion in revenues
each year without it. That means the retailer puts constant pressure on suppliers to offer
the lowest prices possible. On essential products which don’t change, the price Walmart
pays must drop year after year. That places a squeeze on the suppliers because the sheer
size of the retailer allows it to receive concessions that kill local profits. Instead of
“Buying American,” as the brand used to trumpet, the company is now responsible for
10% of all Chinese exports to the United States.
5.1.6. Case Study: Bhopal Gas Tragedy
o The Union Carbide had 51% and the Indian subsidiary UC India Ltd. had 49% of stock.
In 1983, there were 14 plants in India manufacturing chemicals, pesticides, and other
hazardous products. The Bhopal plant had a license to make Methyl isocyanate-based
pesticides. In November 1984, they had decided to close down the plant. For quite some
years before the production rate was going down.
o In the history of chemical plants disasters, three other wake-up calls were reported.
Flixborough accident in 1974 in U.K. when certain modifications carried out in the plant
led to the leakage and explosion of cyclohexane, which killed 28 people.
o The Piper Alpha offshore oil platform disaster in 1988, near Scotland, killed 167 people
and resulted in $ 2 billion losses. The third occurred in Toulouse, France in 2001, killing
29 people, and injuring thousands.
o A warehouse holding 300 tonnes of ammonium nitrate fertilizer exploded and damaged
10000 buildings, including schools, a university, and a hospital. But we have not learnt
from the past.
 UNIT GLOBAL

o The cumulative effects of the following factors caused the tragedy in Bhopal on
December 3, 1984.
1. Maintenance was neglected and the trained maintenance personnel were reduced as
economy measure. Need for quick diagnosis aggravates the situation by causing
considerable psychological stress on the plant personnel.
2. Training activities for the supervisory personnel were stopped. This led to inadequate
training of the personnel to handle emergencies.
3. Periodical Safety Inspection teams from U.S. which visited previously were also
stopped. From the initial U.S. Standards, the safety procedures were reduced to low
level Indian standards. The procedures had been deteriorating at these sites for weeks or
months, prior to the accident. There was clear lack of management systems and
procedures to ensure safety.
4. Vital spares for equipments and machineries were not available
5. Absence of capital replacement led to the stagnant economy of the plant.
6. The high turnover of the experienced engineers and technicians, who were demoralized
by the lack of development.
7. Lack of experienced personnel to operate and control the vital installations.
8. They have not conducted a thorough process hazards analysis that would have exposed
the serious hazards which resulted in disaster later.
9. No emergency plan was put in practice, during the shutdown and maintenance.
10. Above all, the commitment of top-level management to safety was lacking. They have
been paying only lip service to safety of people of the host country.
Technologically, the tragedy was caused by a series of events listed:
1. The safety manual of Union Carbide prescribed that the MIC tanks were to be filled
only up to 60% of the capacity. But the tanks were reported to have been filled up to
75%.
2. The safety policy prescribed that an empty tank should be available as a stand-bye in
case of emergency. But the emergency tank was also filled with to its full capacity.
These facts confirmed that the MNC had not followed and implemented appropriate
safety standards of the home country in the host country
3. The storage tanks should be refrigerated to make the chemical less reactive. But here the
refrigeration system was shut down as an economy measure. This raised the temperature
of the gas stored.
4. The plant was shut down for maintenance two months earlier. The worker who cleaned
the pipes and filters connected to the tanks and closed the valves, was not trained
properly. He did not insert the safety disks to prevent any possible leakage of the gas.
This led to the build up of temperature and pressure in the storage tanks.
5. When the gas started leaking out, the operators tried to use the vent gas-scrubber that
was designed to reduce the exhausting gas. But that scrubber was also shut down.
6. There was a flare tower that was designed to burn-off the gas escaping from the
scrubber. That was not also in working condition.
7. The workers finally tried to spray water up to 100 feet to quench the gas (which is water
soluble). But the gas was escaping from the chimney of 120-feet high.
8. The workers were not trained on safety drills or emergency drills or any evacuation
plans.
 UNIT GLOBAL

The gas escaped into the air and spread over 40 sq. km. About 600 people died and left
7000 injured and the health of about 2 million people was affected adversely. Even after 22
years, influence of the Central Government and the courts, the compensation had not
reached all the affected people.
5.2. Environmental Ethics
5.2.1. What is environmental ethics?
● Environmental ethics means conscious efforts to protect an environment and to
maintain its stability from the hazardous pollutants
● Environmental ethics is the study to explore the ethical roots of the environmental
movement and to understand what ethics tells us about our responsibility to the
environment
● Environmental ethics is the study of
(a) Moral issues concerning the environment, and
(b) Moral perspectives, beliefs, or attitudes concerning those issues.
● Engineers in the past are known for their negligence of environment, in their activities.
It has become important now that engineers design eco-friendly tools, machines,
sustainable products, processes, and projects.
● These are essential now to
(a) Ensure protection (safety) of environment
(b) Prevent the degradation of environment, and
(c) Slow down the exploitation of the natural resources, so that the future generation can
survive.
● The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) code of ethics, has specifically
requires that “engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the
public and shall strive to comply with the principles of sustainable development in the
performance of professional duties”
● The term sustainable development emphasizes on the investment, orientation of
technology, development and functioning of organizations to meet the present needs of
people and at the same time ensuring the future generations to meet their needs.
● Compaq Computer Corporation (now merged with HP) was the leader, who exhibited
their commitment to environmental health, through implementation of the concept of
‘Design for environment’ on their products, unified standards all over the world units,
and giving priority to vendors with a record of environmental concern.
● Engineers as experimenters have certain duties towards environmental ethics,
namely:
1. Environmental impact assessment: One major but sure and unintended effect
of technology is wastage and the resulting pollution of land, water, air and even
space. Study how the industry and technology affects the environment.
2. Establish standards: Study and to fix the tolerable and actual pollution levels.
3. Counter measures: Study what the protective or eliminating measures are
available for immediate implementation
4. Environmental awareness: Study on how to educate the people on
environmental practices, issues, and possible remedies.
5.2.2. Disasters
✔ Plastic Waste Disposal
 UNIT GLOBAL

● In our country, several crores of plastic bottles are used as containers for water and oil,
and plastic bags are used to pack different materials ranging from vegetables to gold
ornaments. Hardly any of these are recycled.
● They end up in gutters, roadsides, and agricultural fields. In all these destinations, they
created havoc. The worse still is the burning of plastic materials in streets and camphor
along with plastic cover in temples, since they release toxic fumes and threaten
seriously the air quality.
● Cities and local administration have to act on this, collect and arrange for recycling
through industries.
✔ E-waste Disposal
o The parts of computers and electronic devices which have served its useful life
present a major environmental issue for all the developing countries including India.
This scrap contains highly toxic elements such as lead, cadmium, and mercury.
o Even the radioactive waste will lose 89% of its toxicity after 200 years, by which
time it will be no more toxic than some natural minerals in the ground. It will lose
99% of its remaining toxicity over the next 30,000 years.
o The toxic chemical agents such as mercury, arsenic, and cadmium retain toxicity
undiminished forever. But these scraps are illegally imported by unscrupulous
agencies to salvage some commercially valuable inputs. Instead of spending and
managing on the scrap, unethical organizations sell them to countries such as India.
This is strictly in violation of the Basel Convention of the United Nations
Environment Program, which has banned the movement of hazardous waste.
o A recent report of the British Environment Agency, has revealed that the discarded
computers, television sets, refrigerators, mobile phones, and electrical equipments
have been dispatched to India and Pakistan in large quantity, for ultimate disposal in
environmentally-unacceptable ways and at great risk to the health of the labour.
o Even in the West, the electronic junk has been posing problems. Strong regulation
including
(a) pressure on industries to set up disassembling facilities,
(b) ban on disposal in landfill sites,
(c) legislation for recycling requirements for these junk and
(d) Policy incentives for eco-friendly design are essential for our country.
o The European Union through the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment
(WEEE) directive has curbed the e-waste dumping by member countries and require
manufacturers to implement methods to recover and recycle the components.
o Indian Government expressed its concern through a technical guide on
environmental management for IT Industry in December, 2004. It is yet to ratify the
ban on movement of hazardous waste according to the Basel Convention.
o A foreign news agency exposed a few years back, the existence of a successful e-
waste disposal hub in a suburb of New Delhi, operating in appallingly dangerous
conditions. Our country needs regulations to define waste, measures to stop illegal
imports, and institutional structures to handle safe disposal of domestic industrial
scrap.
✔ Industrial waste Disposal
o There has been a lot of complaints through the media, on
(a) Against the Sterlite Copper Smelting Plant in Thuthukkudi (1997) against its
pollution, and
 UNIT GLOBAL

(b) When Indian companies imported the discarded French Warship Clemenceau for
disposal, the poisonous asbestos compounds were expected to pollute the
atmosphere besides exposing the labor to a great risk, during the disposal.
o The government did not act immediately. Fortunately for Indians, the French
Government intervened and withdrew the ship, and the serious threat was averted!
✔ Depletion of Ozone Layer
o The ozone layer protects the entire planet from the ill-effects of ultraviolet radiation
and is vital for all living organisms in this world. But it is eaten away by the Chloro-
fluro-carbons (CFC) such as Freon originating from the refrigerators, air
conditioners, and aerosol can spray. This has caused also skin cancer to sun-bathers
in the Western countries.
o Further NO and NO gases were also found to react with the ozone. Apart from
engineers, the organizations, laws of the country and local administration and
market mechanisms are required to take up concerted efforts to protect the
environment.
✔ Global warming
o Over the past 30 years, the Earth has warmed by 0.6 °C. Over the last 100 years, it
has warmed by 0.8 °C. It is likely to push up temperature by 3oC by 2100, according
to NASA’s studies.
o The U.S. administration has accepted the reality of global climate change, which has
been associated with stronger hurricanes, severe droughts, intense heat waves and
the melting of polar ice.
o Greenhouse gases, notably carbon dioxide emitted by motor vehicles and coal-fired
power plants, trap heat like the glass walls of a greenhouse, cause the Earth to warm
up.
o Delegates from the six countries — Australia, China, India, Japan, South Korea and
US met in California in April 2006 for the first working session of the Asia Pacific
Partnership on Clean Development and Climate. These six countries account for
about half of the world’s emissions of climate-heating greenhouse gases.
o Only one of the six, Japan, is committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions by at
least 5.2 per cent below 1990 levels by 2012 under the Kyoto Agreement.
o About 190 nations met in Germany in the middle of May 2006 and tried to bridge
vast policy gaps between the United States and its main allies over how to combat
climate change amid growing evidence that the world is warming that could wreak
havoc by stoking more droughts, heat waves, floods, more powerful storms and
raise global sea levels by almost a meter by 2100.
✔ Acid Rain
o Large emissions of sulphur oxides and nitrous oxides are being released in to the air
from the thermal power stations using the fossil fuels, and several processing
industries. These gases form compounds with water in the air and precipitates as
rain or snow on to the earth. The acid rain in some parts of the world has caused
sufficient damage to the fertility of the land and to the human beings.
5.2.3. Human centered environmental ethics
o This approach assumes that only human beings have inherent moral worth duly to
be taken care of. Other living being and ecosystems are only instrumental in nature.
Utilitarianism aims to maximize good consequences for human beings. Most of the
goods are engineered products made out of natural resources.
o Human beings have also
 UNIT GLOBAL

(a) recreational interests (enjoy leisure through mountaineering, sports, and

pastimes),
(b) aesthetic interests (enjoy nature as from seeing waterfalls and snow-clad
mountains),
(c) scientific interests to explore into nature or processes, and
(d) A basic interest to survive, by preservation as well as conservation of nature and
natural resources.
o Rights ethicists favor the basic rights to live and right to liberty, to realize the right to
a live in a supportive environment.
o Further, virtue ethics stresses importance of prudence, humility, appreciation of
natural beauty, and gratitude to the Mother Nature that provides everything.
o However, the nature-centered ethics, which ensures the worth of all living beings
and organisms, seems to be more appropriate in the present-day context. Many
Asian religions stress the unity with nature, rather than domination and exploitation.
o The Zen Buddhism calls for a simple life with compassion towards humans and
other animals. Hinduism enshrines the ideal of oneness (advaitha) in and principle of
ahimsa to all living beings. It identifies all the human beings, animals, and plants as
divine. The eco-balance is the need of the hour and the engineers are the right
experimenters to achieve this.
5.2.4. Types of concern for environment
✔ There are two type of concern for the environment. They are:
o Health related concern: Engineers can be concerned for the environment when
environmental pollution poses a direct and clear threat to human health
o Non Health related concern: Engineers can also be concerned for the environment
even with the human wealth is not directly affected.
5.2.5. World’s five biggest Environmental problems
✔ Air pollution and climate change.
o Problem: Overloading of the atmosphere and of ocean waters with carbon.
Atmospheric CO2 absorbs and re-emits infrared-wavelength radiation, leading to
warmer air, soils, and ocean surface waters. But the planet would be frozen solid
without this.
o Unfortunately, there's now too much carbon in the air. Burning of fossil fuels,
deforestation for agriculture and industrial activities has pushed up atmospheric
CO2 concentrations.
o Carbon overloading is only one form of air pollution caused by burning coal, oil, gas
and wood. The World Health Organization recently estimated that one in nine
deaths in 2012 were attributable to diseases caused by carcinogens and other poisons
in polluted air.
o Solutions: Replace fossil fuels with renewable energy. Reforestation. Reduce
emissions from agriculture. Change industrial processes.
o Examples : Ulan Bator in Mongolia is not only one of the coldest capitals on earth,
it's also a city with massive air pollution. During the winter months, yurts like
Tsegi’s are heated with coal and wood which contributes up to 70 percent of the
smog in the city. Air pollution in Ulan Bator is seven times higher than what is
considered safe by the WHO.
✔ Deforestation.
 UNIT GLOBAL

o Problem: Species-rich wild forests are being destroyed, especially in the tropics,
often to make way for cattle ranching, soybean or palm oil plantations, or other
agricultural monocultures.
o Today, about 30 percent of the planet's land area is covered by forests - which is
about half as much as before agriculture got started around 11,000 years ago. About
7.3 million hectares (18 million acres) of forest are destroyed each year, mostly in
the tropics. Tropical forests used to cover about 15 percent of the planet's land area;
they're now down to 6 or 7 percent. Much of this remainder has been degraded by
logging or burning.
o Not only do natural forests act as biodiversity reserves, they are also carbon sinks,
keeping carbon out of the atmosphere and oceans.
o Solutions: Conserve of what's left of natural forests, and restore degraded areas by
replanting with native tree species.
✔ Species extinction.
o Problem: On land, wild animals are being hunted to extinction for bushmeat, ivory,
or "medicinal" products. At sea, huge industrial fishing boats equipped with bottom-
trawling or purse-seine nets clean out entire fish populations. The loss and
destruction of habitat are also major factors contributing to a wave of extinction -
unprecedented in that it is caused by a single species: humans. The IUCN's Red List
of threatened and endangered species continues to grow.
o Not only do species inherently deserve to exist, they also provide products and
"services" essential to human survival. Think bees and their pollinating prowess -
necessary for growing food.
o Solutions. Protecting and restoring habitats is one side of this - protecting against
poaching and wildlife trade is another. This should be done in partnership
✔ Soil degradation.
o Problem: Overgrazing, monoculture planting, erosion, soil compaction,
overexposure to pollutants, land-use conversion - there's a long list of ways that soils
are being damaged. About 12 million hectares of farmland a year get seriously
degraded, according to UN estimates.
o Solutions: A wide range of soil conservation and restoration techniques exist, from
no-till agriculture to crop rotation to water-retention through terrace-building..
✔ Overpopulation.
o Problem: Human population continues to grow rapidly worldwide. Humanity
entered the 20th century with 1.6 billion people; right now, we're about 7.5 billion.
Estimates put us at nearly 10 billion by 2050. Growing global populations,
combined with growing affluence, is putting ever greater pressure on essential
natural resources, like water. Most of the growth is happening on the African
continent, and in southern and eastern Asia.
o Solutions: Experience has shown that when women are empowered to control their
own reproduction, and gain access to education and basic social services, the
average number of births per woman drops precipitously.
5.2.6. Approaches to resolve Environmental Problems
✔ The first approach is sometimes referred to as the “cost-oblivious approach”. In
this approach, cost is not taken into account, but rather the environment is made as clean
as possible. No level of environmental degradation is seen as acceptable. This approach
bears a striking resemblance to rights and duty ethics. There are obvious problems with
this approach. It is difficult to uphold, especially in a modern urbanized society. It is
 UNIT GLOBAL

also very difficult to enforce, since the definition of “as clean as possible” is hard to
agree on, and being oblivious to cost isn’t practical in any realistic situation in which
there are not infinite resources to apply to a problem.
✔ A second approach is based on cost–benefit analysis, which is derived from
utilitarianism. Here, the problem is analyzed in terms of the benefits derived by
reducing the pollution—improvements in human health, for example—and the costs
required to solve the problem. The costs and benefits are weighed to determine the
optimum combination. In this approach, the goal is not to achieve a completely clean
environment, but rather to achieve an economically beneficial balance of pollution with
health or environmental considerations.
✔ There are problems associated with the cost–benefit approach
✔ First, there is an implicit assumption in cost–benefit analysis that cost is an important
issue. But what is the true cost of a human life or the loss of a species or a scenic view?
These values are diffi cult, if not impossible, to determine.
✔ Second, it is difficult to accurately assess costs and benefits, and much guesswork must
go into these calculations.
✔ Third, this approach doesn’t necessarily take into account who shoulders the costs and
who gets the benefits. This is frequently a problem with the sitting of landfills and other
waste dumps. The cheapest land is in economically disadvantaged areas, where people
don’t necessarily have the political influence, education, or money required to
successfully oppose a landfill in their neighborhood. Although dumps have to go
somewhere, there should be some attempt to share the costs as well as share the benefits
of an environmentally questionable project.
✔ Finally, cost–benefit analysis doesn’t necessarily take morality or ethics into account.
The only considerations are costs and benefits, with no room for a discussion of whether
what is being done is right or not.
5.3. Computer Ethics
5.3.1. What is computer Ethics?
✔ Computer ethics is the study of ethical issues that are associated primarily with
computing machines and the computing profession
✔ It is the field of applied professional ethics dealing with ethical problems forced,
transformed or created by computer technology
✔ Cyber ethics is the field of applied ethics that examine moral, legal and social issues
in the development and use of cyber technology
✔ Cyber technology refers to a broad range of technologies from stand alone
computers to the cluster of networked computing., information and
communication technologies
✔ Thus computer ethics is the analysis of the nature and social impact of computer
technology and the corresponding formulation and justification policies for the
ethical use of such technology
5.3.2. Categories of computer ethics problems
Different types of problems are found in computer ethics.
(a) Computer as the Instrument of Unethical behavior
(b) Computer as the Object of Unethical Act
(c) Problems Related to the Autonomous Nature of Computer
(a) Computer as the Instrument of Unethical Behavior
 UNIT GLOBAL

✔ Computer ethics will start with an examination of ways in which computers are used as
the means for unethical behavior. Many of these uses are merely extensions to
computers of other types of unethical acts.
✔ Bank robbery
o For example, computers can be used to more efficiently steal money from a bank. A
more traditional bank-robbery method is to put on a mask, hand a note to a bank teller,
show your gun, and walk away with some cash. Computers can be used to make bank
robbery easier to perform and harder to trace. The robber simply sits at a computer
terminal—perhaps the modern equivalent of a mask—invades the bank’s computer
system, and directs that some of the bank’s assets be placed in a location accessible to
him. Using a computer, a criminal can also make it difficult for the theft to be detected
and traced.
o It is clear that from an ethical standpoint, there is no difference between a bank robbery
perpetrated in person and one perpetrated via a computer, although generally the
amounts taken in a computer crime far exceed those taken in an armed robbery. The
difference between these two types of robbery is that the use of the computer makes the
crime impersonal. The criminal never comes face to face with the victim. In addition,
the use of the computer makes it easier to steal from a wide variety of people.
o Computers can be used to steal from an employer: Outsiders can get into a system
and steal from an institution such as a bank, or a company can use the computer to steal
from its clients and customers. In these cases, the computer has only made the theft
easier to carry out, but does not alter the ethical issues involved. Unfortunately, the
technology to detect and prevent this type of crime greatly lags behind the computer
technology available to commit it. Those seeking to limit computer crime are always
playing a catch-up game.
✔ Privacy
o Similar computer ethics issues arise with regard to privacy. It is widely held that
certain information is private and cannot be revealed without consent. This includes
information about individuals as well as corporate information.
o Computers did not create the issues involved in privacy, but they certainly have
intensified them. Computers make privacy more difficult to protect, since large
amounts of data on individuals and corporations are centrally stored on computers
where an increasing number of individuals can access it. Before we look at the ways
that privacy can be abused by the use of computers.
o By privacy, we mean the basic right of an individual to control access to and use of
information about himself.
o Invasions of privacy can be harmful to an individual in two ways.
o First, the leaking of private information can lead to an individual’s being
harassed or blackmailed. In its simplest form, this harassment may come in
the form of repeated phone calls from telemarketers who have obtained
information about an individual’s spending habits. The harassment might
also come in the form of subtle teasing or bothering from a coworker who
has gained personal knowledge of the individual. Clearly, individuals have
the right not to be subjected to this type of harassment.
o Second, personal information can also be considered personal property. As
such, any unauthorized use of this information is theft. This same principle
applies to proprietary information of a corporation.
✔ How do computers increase the problems with privacy protection?
 UNIT GLOBAL

o This phenomenon is most easily seen by looking at the old system of record keeping.
For example, medical records of individuals were at one time kept only on paper and
generally resided with the individual’s physician and in hospitals where a patient had
been treated. Gaining access to these records by researchers, insurance companies, or
other healthcare providers was a somewhat laborious process involving searching
through storage for the appropriate files, copying them, and sending them through the
mail.
o Unauthorized use of this information involved breaking into the office where the files
were kept and stealing them or, for those who had access to the files, secretly
removing or copying the files. Both of these acts involved a substantial risk of being
caught and prosecuted. Generally, these records have now been computerized.
Although computerization makes the retrieval of files much easier for those with
legitimate needs and reduces the space required to store the files, it also makes the
unauthorized use of this information by others easier.
(b) Computer as the Object of Unethical Act
✔ Ethical issues also arise when computers are used for “hacking.” Hacking comes in
many forms: gaining unauthorized access to a database, implanting false
information in a database or altering existing information, and disseminating
viruses over the Internet.
✔ These activities are by no means limited to highly trained computer specialists. Many
hackers are bored teenagers seeking a challenge. Computer hacking is clearly ethically
troublesome. Accessing private information violates the privacy rights of individuals
or corporations, even if the hacker keeps this information to himself. In extreme cases,
hackers have accessed secret military information, which has obvious implications for
national security. Altering information in a database, even information about you, is
also ethically troubling, especially if the alteration has the intent of engaging in a
fraud.
✔ The issuance of computer viruses is also unethical. These viruses frequently destroy
data stored on computers. In extreme cases, this act could lead to deaths when hospital
records or equipment are compromised, to financial ruin for individuals whose records
are wiped out, or even to the loss of millions of dollars for corporations, individuals,
and taxpayers, as completed work must be redone after being destroyed by a virus.
✔ Copyright infringement is also a concern in computer ethics. Computers and the
Internet have made it easy to share music, movies, software, and other copy-righted
materials. Copyright gives the creator the exclusive right to profit from his creation.
The protection of copyright has become increasingly difficult as court cases related to
music sharing websites such as Napster and other copycat websites have illustrated.
Although computers make copyright violation easy to do and hard to detect, it is still
illegal and unethical. If creators can no longer profit from their work—if their work is
freely distributed without their consent—then the incentive to create will diminish,
and this type of creative activity that enriches everyone’s lives will diminish as well.
Copying music or software without the permission of the owner of the copyright is
illegal and unethical.
(c) Computers as an Engineering Tool
o Computers are an essential tool for all engineers. Most often, we use computers for writing
documents using a word-processing software package. We also keep track of appointments
with scheduling software, use spreadsheets to make financial calculations, databases to keep
 UNIT GLOBAL

records of our work, and use commercially available soft-ware to develop plans for how our
projects will proceed. The use of these types of software is not unique to engineering—
indeed, they are useful in various areas of business. Unique to engineering are two uses of
computers: as design tools and as components integrated into engineered systems.
o Computer Design Tools
o Numerous software packages are available for the design of engineered devices and
structures. This software includes CAD/CAM, circuit analysis, finite element analysis,
structural analysis, and other modeling and analysis programs. Software also exists that
is designed to aid in the process of testing engineered devices by performing tests,
recording data, and presenting data for analysis. These all serve to allow an engineer to
work more efficiently and to help take away some of the tedious aspects of an
engineer’s work. However, the use of this type of software also leads to ethical issues.
o For example, who is responsible when a flaw in software used to design a bridge
leads to the failure of the bridge? Is it the fault of the engineer who designed the
bridge? Or is it the fault of the company that designed and sold the defective
software?
o These questions all have the same answer: Software can never be a substitute for good
engineering judgment. Clearly, the engineer who uses software in the design process is
still responsible for the designs that were generated and the testing that was done using
a computer. Engineers must be careful to make sure that the software is appropriate to
the problem being worked on, and should be knowledgeable about the limitations and
applicability of a software package. Engineers must also keep up to date on any flaws
that have been discovered in the software and ensure that the most recent version of the
software is being used—software companies make patches and updates available, and
engineers must check to make sure they have the most up-to-date version. Finally, it is
important to verify the results of a computer-generated design or analysis. Sometimes
it’s a great idea to sit down with a piece of paper and a pencil to make sure that the
output of a computer program makes sense and is giving the right answer.
✔ Integration of Computers into Engineered Systems
✔ Computers have also become a component of many engineered systems. For example,
modern automobiles contain multiple computers, dedicated to specific tasks.
Computers control the emissions and braking systems on automobiles and allow
modern vehicles to operate more efficiently and safely. However, the ability to control
aspects of system performance using software removes humans from the control loop.
✔ There are numerous examples of situations in which computerized systems
malfunctioned without giving the operator any indication that a problem existed. In
some cases, the operator was unable to intervene to solve a problem because the
software design wouldn’t allow it.
✔ It is essential when designing systems with embedded computers and software that
engineers ensure that software is adequately tested, that humans can intervene when
necessary, and that safety systems have enough hardware redundancy without relying
solely on software to ensure the safe operation of the system
d. Autonomous Computers
o Other ethical concerns arise because of the increasingly autonomous nature of
computers. Autonomy refers to the ability of a computer to make decisions without
the intervention of humans.
o Some of the negative implications of this autonomy are chillingly spelled out in
2001: A Space Odyssey, by Arthur C. Clarke, in which an autonomous computer
 UNIT GLOBAL

responsible for running a spaceship headed for Jupiter begins to turn against the humans
it was designed to work for.
o Certainly, there are applications for which autonomy is valuable. For example,
manufacturing processes that require monitoring and control at frequent intervals can
greatly benefit from autonomous computers. In this case, the autonomy of the computer
has very little impact beyond the interests of the manufacturer.
o Other autonomous computer applications are not so caring. For example, by the
1980s, computers were widely used to automate trading on the major U.S. stock
exchanges. Some brokerages and institutional investors utilized computers that were
programmed to sell stocks automatically under certain conditions, among them when
prices drop sharply. This type of programming creates an unstable situation. As prices
drop, computers automatically start selling stocks, further depressing the prices, causing
other computers to sell, and so on until there is a major market crash.
o Autonomy of computer systems has also been called into question with regard to
military weapons. Many weapons systems rely heavily on computer sensors and
computer controls. Due to the speed with which events can happen on a modern
battlefield, it would seem valuable to have weapons that can operate autonomously.
o However, weapons systems operating without human intervention can suffer from the
instability problems described with regard to the financial markets. For example, a
malfunctioning sensor might lead a computer to think that an enemy has increased its
military activity in a certain area. This would lead to an increased activity by the enemy,
etc. This unstable situation could lead to a conflict and loss of life when really there was
nothing happening. This problem is of special concern due to the implications for the
loss of human life. It is clear from this example that although autonomous computers
can greatly increase productivity and efficiency in many areas, ultimately there
must be some human control in order to prevent disasters.
5.3.3. Computer code of Ethics
The Ten Commandments of computer code of ethics are:
1. Thou shalt not use a computer to harm other people.
2. Thou shalt not interfere with other people's computer work.
3. Thou shalt not snoop around in other people's computer files.
4. Thou shalt not use a computer to steal.
5. Thou shalt not use a computer to bear false witness.
6. Thou shalt not copy or use proprietary software for which you have not paid (without
permission).
7. Thou shalt not use other people's computer resources without authorization or proper
compensation.
8. Thou shalt not appropriate other people's intellectual output.
9. Thou shalt think about the social consequences of the program you are writing or the
system you are designing.
10. Thou shalt always use a computer in ways that ensure consideration and respect for
your fellow humans.
5.4. Weapons Development
Military activities including the world wars have stimulated the growth of technology. The
growth of Internet amply illustrates this fact. The development of warfare and the involvement
of engineers bring out many ethical issues concerned with engineers, such as the issue of
integrity in experiments as well as expenditure in defense research and development, issue of
personal commitment and conscience, and the issues of social justice and social health.
 UNIT GLOBAL

Engineers involve in weapons development because of the following reasons:

✔ It gives one job with high salary.
✔ One takes pride and honor in participating in the activities towards the defense of the
nation (patriotic fervor).
✔ One believes the he fights a war on terrorism and thereby contribute to peace and
stability of the country. Ironically, the wars have never won peace, only peace can win
peace!
✔ By research and development, the engineer is reducing or eliminating the risk from
enemy weapons, and saving one’s country from disaster.
✔ By building-up arsenals and show of force, a country can force the rogue country,
towards regulation. Engineers can participate effectively in arms control negotiations
for surrender or peace, e.g., bombing of Nagasaki and Hiroshima led to surrender by the
Japanese in 1945.
5.4.1. Involvement in Weapons Work
✔ Historically, a quick death in battle by sword was considered acceptable, whereas the use
of remote weapons (from bow and arrow to firearms) was frequently condemned as
cowardly, devoid of courage, and equivalent to plain murder.
✔ As modern weapons of war progressed through catapults, cannons, machine guns, and
bombs released from airplanes and missiles to reach further and further, the soldiers
firing them were less likely to see the individual human beings—soldiers as well as
civilians—they had as their general target. The continuing automation of the battle scene
tends to conceal the horrors of war and thus makes military activity seem less threatening
and high-tech wars more appealing.
✔ For some engineers, involvement in weapons development conflicts with personal
conscience; for others, it is an expression of conscientious participation in national
defense.
✔ The following cases illustrate the kinds of moral issues involved in deciding
whether to engage in military work.
1. Bob himself does not handle the bombs in any way, but as an industrial engineer he
enables the factory to run efficiently. He does not like to be involved in making
weapons, but then he tells himself that someone has to produce them. If he does not do
his job, someone else will, so nothing would change. Further-more, with the cost of
living being what it is, he owes his family a steady income.
2. Mary is a chemical engineer. A promotion has gotten her into napalm manufacturing.
She knows it is nasty stuff, having heard that the Nobel laureate, Professor Wald of
Harvard University, was said to have berated the chemical industry for producing this
“most brutal and destructive weapon that has ever been created.” She saw a scary old
photograph from the Vietnam War period, depicting a badly burned peasant girl running
from a village in flames. She hates war like most human beings, but she feels that the
government knows more than she does about international dangers and that the present
use of napalm by U.S. forces in Iraq may be unavoidable. But Mary knows that if she
continues to do well on her job she will be promoted, and one of these days she may
well be in the position to steer the company into the production of peaceful products.
3. Ron is a specialist in missile control and guidance. He is proud to be able to help his
country through his efforts in the defense industry, especially as part of the “war on
terrorism.” The missiles he works on will carry single or multiple warheads with the
kind of dreadful firepower which, in his estimation, has kept any potential enemy in
 UNIT GLOBAL

check since 1945. At least there has not been another world war—the result of mutual
deterrence, he believes.
4. Marco’s foremost love is physical electronics. He works in one of the finest laser
laboratories. Some of his colleagues do exciting research in particle beams. That the
laboratory is interested in developing something akin to the “death ray” described by
science fiction writers of his youth is of secondary importance. More bothersome is the
secrecy that prevents him from freely exchanging ideas with experts across the world.
5. Joanne is an electronics engineer whose work assignment includes avionics for fighter
planes that are mostly sold abroad. She has no doubts about such planes going to what
she considers friendly countries, but she draws the line at their sale to potentially hostile
nations. Joanne realizes that she has no leverage within the company, so she
occasionally alerts journalist friends with news she feels all citizens should have.
6. Ted’s background and advanced degrees in engineering physics gave him a ready entry
into nuclear bomb development. As a well-informed citizen he is seriously concerned
with the dangers of the ever-growing nuclear arsenal. He is also aware of the
possibilities of an accidental nuclear exchange. In the mean-time he is working hard to
reduce the risk of accidents such as the 32 “broken arrows” (incidents when missile
launchings may have occurred erroneously) that had been reported by the Pentagon
during the height of the Cold War, or the many others that he knows have occurred
worldwide. Ted continues in his work because he believes that only specialists, with
firsthand experience of what modern weapons can do, can eventually turn around the
suicidal trend represented by their development.
5.4.2. Role of Engineers in Defense Industry
✔ Defense industry is one of the areas, which provide number of jobs opportunities to
engineers. Engineers are capable of innovating and developing new weapons. Weapons
are designed for one purpose – to kill human beings
✔ On the one hand, many of the rational engineers feel that they cannot work on designing
weapons, which are ultimately used to kill the human beings. Even though they are not
the ultimate users of those weapons, they find it morally unacceptable to work on such
areas
✔ On the other hand, similar morally responsible engineers feel that working in defense
industry is ethical. Because they feel it as honor to work for their nation / Government.
✔ In fact, the above two different views about working in defense industry are well
justified by various ethical theories
✔ Also the engineers should not be attracted by incentives and advancements that are
being offered in the defensive industries, they must have the potential judgments to
serve in defense works that would expose the human community.
Defense Industry Problems
Many nations give privileges to defense industry, without even thinking, on serious
problems that arise in large military build-ups. Some of the problems are:
✔ The problem of waste and cost overruns is a continuing one in the defense industry.
✔ Another problem faced by the defense industry is the technology creep. It refers to the
development of new weapons, such as the cruise missile, which can change diplomatic
arrangements even as they are being negotiated. Thus it affects the political stability of
a country
✔ Secrecy creates problems for the defense industry. If the secrets of planned funding
were leaked to prospective contractors, then it may lead to high cost and poor quality
of defense materials and weapons
 UNIT GLOBAL

✔ Many countries allocate funds for the defense sector than that of the other public
welfare schemes
5.5. Engineers as Managers
5.5.1. Why do most of the Engineers move into Managerial Roles?
✔ Engineers move into management roles, because of the following two reasons
✔ Much corporate management prefer Engineers as their Managers. Because they
believe that:
▪ To manage technological corporation, the technical understanding is
necessary and
▪ The engineers have potential of understanding the business techniques of any
corporate bodies than any non engineers. Also it is comparatively easier to
teach the business techniques than to teach non engineers the engineering
techniques
✔ Engineers are attracted by various corporate incentives such as higher pay, greater
authority, wider responsibility and increased prestige and recognition.
5.5.2. Managers As Professions
Mintzberg published his Ten Management Roles in his book, "Mintzberg on Management: Inside our
Strange World of Organizations," in 1990.
The ten roles are:
Figurehead, Spokesperson
Leader Entrepreneur
Liaison Disturbance
Monitor Handler
Disseminator Resource
Allocator
The 10 roles are then divided up into three categories, as follows:

Category Roles
Interpersonal Figurehead
Leader
Liaison
Informational Monitor
Disseminator
Spokesperson
Interpersonal Category
The managerial roles in this category involve providing information and ideas.
1. Figurehead – As a manager, you have social, ceremonial and legal responsibilities.
You're expected to be a source of inspiration. People look up to you as a person with
authority, and as a figurehead.
2. Leader – This is where you provide leadership for your team, your department or
perhaps your entire organization; and it's where you manage the performance and
responsibilities of everyone in the group.
3. Liaison – Managers must communicate with internal and external contacts. You need to
be able to network effectively on behalf of your organization.
Informational Category
The managerial roles in this category involve processing information.
 UNIT GLOBAL

4. Monitor – In this role, you regularly seek out information related to your organization
and industry, looking for relevant changes in the environment. You also monitor your
team, in terms of both their productivity, and their well-being.
5. Disseminator – This is where you communicate potentially useful information to your
colleagues and your team.
6. Spokesperson – Managers represent and speak for their organization. In this role you're
responsible for transmitting information about your organization and its goals to the
people outside it.
Decisional Category
The managerial roles in this category involve using information.
7. Entrepreneur – As a manager, you create and control change within the organization.
This means solving problems, generating new ideas, and implementing them.
8. Disturbance Handler – When an organization or team hits an unexpected roadblock,
it's the manager who must take charge. You also need to help mediate disputes within it.
9. Resource Allocator – You'll also need to determine where organizational resources are
best applied. This involves allocating funding, as well as assigning staff and other
organizational resources.
10. Negotiator – You may be needed to take part in, and direct, important negotiations
within your team, department, or organization.

5.5.3. Impact of transition on ethical

issues
✔ Generally managers are changed for
a) Merely serving for narrow interests of the corporation
b) Their objective of increasing the firm’s profit only
c) Not bothering about others responsibilities to promote the public good
✔ According to Friedman, manager’s ethics is limited only to the responsibility to
maximize profits for stockholders. But Engineers ethics involve wider
responsibilities to protect the public safety, health and welfare of the public.
✔ In contrast to Friedman’s view, it is recognized that the morals roles of engineers are
complementary and symbiotic, they are associated with each other
✔ As a manager, engineers remain professionals whose primary responsibility is to
provide useful products and services while ensuring that they are safe and profitable

5.5.4. Characteristics
The characteristics of engineers as managers are:
a) Promote an ethical climate, through framing organization policies, responsibilities and
by personal attitudes and obligations.
b) Resolving conflicts, by evolving priority, developing mutual understanding, generating
various alternative solutions to problems.
c) Social responsibility to stakeholders, customers and employers. They act to develop
wealth as well as the welfare of the society. Ethicists project the view that the
manager’s responsibility is only to increase the profit of the organization, and only the
engineers have the responsibility to protect the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
But managers have the ethical responsibility to produce safe and good products (or
useful service), while showing respect for the human beings who include the
employees, customers and the public. Hence, the objective for the managers and
 UNIT GLOBAL

engineers is to produce valuable products that are also profitable.

5.5.5. Responsibilities an Ethical Climate
 UNIT GLOBAL

There are two important responsibilities of engineer – managers. They are:

1. Promoting an Ethical Climate
What is meant by an ethical climate?
✔ A favorable working atmosphere required to achieve a morally responsible
conduct is called an ethical climate
✔ Several factors such as nature of organization, informal traditions and practices
and personal attitudes directly contribute to the ethical climate
What are the defining features of an ethical corporate climate?
✔ Ethical values should be widely acknowledged and appreciated by all the
managers and employees of a company
✔ The use of proper ethical language like code of ethics should be recognized as a
legitimate part of the company
✔ The top management should accomplish a moral voice in both words and
policies and also by personal example, in other words the top level management
has to enhance confidence that the company is more serious about ethics
✔ There should be some procedures for confronting and resolving conflicts
2. Resolving/ Managing Conflicts
In solving conflicts, force should not be resorted. In fact, the conflict situations should be
tolerated, understood, and resolved by participation by all the concerned. The conflicts in case
of project managers arise in the following manners:
a) Conflicts based on schedules: This happens because of various levels of execution,
priority and limitations of each level.
b) Conflicts arising out of fixing the priority to different projects or departments. This is to
be arrived at from the end requirements and it may change from time to time.
c) Conflict based on the availability of personnel.
d) Conflict over technical, economic, and time factors such as cost, time, and performance
level.
e) Conflict arising in administration such as authority, responsibility, accountability, and
logistics required.
f) Conflicts of personality, human psychology and ego problems.
g) Conflict over expenditure and its deviations.

Most of the conflicts can be resolved by following the principles listed here:
People
Separate people from the problem. It implies that the views of all concerned should be
obtained. The questions such as what, why, and when the error was committed is more
important than to know who committed it. This impersonal approach will lead to not only early
solution but also others will be prevented from committing errors.
Interests
Focus must be only on interest i.e., the ethical attitudes or motives and not on the
positions (i.e., stated views). A supplier may require commission larger than usual prevailing
rate for an agricultural product. But the past analysis may tell us that the material is not
cultivated regularly and the monsoon poses some additional risk towards the supply. Mutual
interests must be respected to a maximum level. What is right is more important than who is
right!
Options
 UNIT GLOBAL

Generate various options as solutions to the problem. This helps a manager to try the next
best solution should the first one fails. Decision on alternate solutions can be taken more easily
and without loss of time.
Evaluation
The evaluation of the results should be based on some specified objectives such as
efficiency, quality, and customer satisfaction. More important is that the means, not only the
goals, should be ethical.

5.6. CODES OF ETHICS

5.6.1. National Society of Professional Engineers
I. Fundamental Canons
Engineers in the fulfilment of their professional duties shall
1. Hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
2. Perform services only in areas of their competence.
3. Issue public statements only in objective and truthful manner.
4. Act for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees.
5. Avoid deceptive acts.
6. Conduct themselves honourably, responsibly, ethically, and lawfully so as to
enhance the honour, reputation, and usefulness of the profession.
II. Rules of Practice
1. Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
a) If engineers’ judgment is overruled under circumstances that endanger life or property, they
shall notify their employer or client and such other authority as may be appropriate.
b) Engineers shall approve only those engineering documents that are in conformity with
applicable standards.
c) Engineers shall not reveal facts, data, or information without prior consent of the client or
employer except as authorized or required by law or this code.
d) Engineers shall not permit the use of their name or associate in business ventures with any
person or firm that they believe are engaged in fraudulent or dishonest enterprise.
e) Engineers shall not aid or abet the unlawful practice of engineering by a person or firm.
f) Engineers having knowledge of any alleged violation of this Code shall report thereon to
appropriate professional bodies and when relevant, also to public authorities, and cooperate
with the proper authorities in furnishing such information or assistance as may be required.
2. Engineers shall perform services only in the areas of their competence.
a) Engineers shall undertake assignments only when qualified by education or
experience in the specific technical fields involved.
b) Engineers shall not affix their signatures to any plans or documents dealing with the
subject matter in which they lack competence, nor to any plan or document not
prepared under their direction and control.
c) Engineers may accept assignments and assume responsibility for coordination of an
entire project and sign and seal the engineering documents for the entire project,
provided that each technical segment is signed and sealed only by the qualified
engineers who prepared the segment.
3. Engineers shall issue public statements only in an objective and truthful manner.
a) Engineers shall be objective and truthful in professional reports, statements, or
testimony.
b) They shall include all relevant and pertinent information in such reports, statements, or
 UNIT GLOBAL

testimony, which should bear the date indicating when it was current.
 UNIT GLOBAL

c) Engineers may express publicly technical options that are founded upon knowledge of
the facts and competence in the subject matter.
d) Engineers shall issue no statements, criticisms, or arguments on technical matters that
are inspired or paid for by interested parties on prefaced their comments by explicitly
identifying the interested parties on whose behalf they are speaking and by revealing the
existence of any interest the engineers may have in the matters.
4. Engineers shall at for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees
a) Engineers shall disclose all known or potential conflicts of interest that could influence
or appear to influence their judgment or the quality of their services.
b) Engineers shall not accept compensation, financial or otherwise, from more than one
party for services on the same project, or for services pertaining to the same project,
unless the circumstances are fully disclosed and agreed to by all interested parties.
c) Engineers shall not solicit or accept financial or other valuable consideration, directly or
indirectly, from outside agents on connection with the work for which they are
responsible.
d) Engineers in public service as members, advisers, or employees of a governmental or
quasi- governmental body or department shall not participate in decisions with respect
to services solicited or provided by them or their organizations in private or public
engineering practice.
e) Engineers shall not solicit or accept a contract from a governmental body on which a
principal or officer of their organization serves as a member.
5. Engineers shall avoid deceptive acts
a) Engineers shall not falsify their qualifications or permit misrepresentation of their or
their associate’s qualifications. They shall not misrepresent or exaggerate their
responsibility in or for the subject matter of prior assignments. Brochures or other
presentations incident to the solicitation of employment shall not misrepresent pertinent
facts concerning employers, employees, associates, joint ventures, or past
accomplishments.
b) Engineers shall not offer, give, solicit or receive, either directly or indirectly, any
contribution to influence the award of a contract by public authority, or which may be
reasonably construed by the public as having the effect of intent to influence the
awarding of a contract. They shall not offer any gift or other valuable consideration in
order to secure work. They shall not pay a commission, percentage, or brokerage fee in
order to secure work, except to a bonafide employee or established commercial or
marketing agencies retained by them.
III. Professional Obligations
1. Engineers shall be guided in all their relation by the highest standards of honesty and
integrity.
a) Engineers shall acknowledge their errors and shall not distort or alter the facts.
b) Engineers shall advice their clients or employers when they believe a project will
not be successful.
c) Engineers shall not accept outside employment to the detriment of their regular
work or interest. Before accepting any outside engineering employment they will
notify their employers.
d) Engineers shall not attempt to attract an engineer from another employer by false or
misleading pretenses.
e) Engineers shall not promote their own interest at the expense of the dignity and
integrity of the profession.
 UNIT GLOBAL

2. Engineers shall at all times strive to serve the public interest.

a) Engineers shall seek opportunities to participate in civic affairs, career guidance for
youths, and work for the advancement of the safety, health, and well-being of their
community.
b) Engineers shall not complete, sign, or seal plans and/or specifications that are not in
conformity with applicable engineering standards. If the client or employer insists on
such unprofessional conduct, they shall notify the proper authorities and withdraw from
further service on the project.
c) Engineers shall endeavour to extend public knowledge and appreciation of engineering
and its achievements.
3. Engineers shall avoid all conduct or practice that deceives the public.
a) Engineers shall avoid the use of statements containing a material misrepresentation of
fact or omitting a material fact.
b) Consistent with the foregoing, engineers may advertise for recruitment of personnel.
c) Consistent with foregoing, engineers may prepare articles for the lay or technical press,
but such articles shall not imply credit to the author for work performed by other.
4. Engineers shall not disclose, without consent, confidential information concerning the
business affairs or technical processes of any present or former client or employer, or
public body on which they serve.
a) Engineers shall not, without the consent of all interested parties, promote or arrange for
new employment or practice in connection with a specific project for which the engineer
has gained particular and specialized knowledge.
b) Engineers shall not, without the consent of all interested parties, participate in or
represent in adversary interest in connection with a specific project or proceeding in
which the engineer has gained particular specialized knowledge on behalf of a former
client or employer.
5. Engineers shall not be influenced in their professional duties by conflicting interests.
a) Engineers shall not accept financial or other consideration including free engineering
designs, from material or equipment suppliers for specifying their product.
b) Engineers shall not accept commission or allowances, directly or indirectly, from
contractors or other parties dealing with clients or employers of the engineer in
connection with work for which the engineer is responsible.
6. Engineers shall not attempt to obtain employment or advancement or professional
engagements by untruthfully criticizing other engineers, or by other improper methods.
a) Engineers shall not request, propose, or accept a commission on a contingent basis
under circumstances in which their judgement may be compromised.
b) Engineers in salaried positions shall accept part-time engineering work only to the
extent consistent with policies of the employer and in accordance with ethical
consideration.
c) Engineers shall not, without consent, use equipment, supplies, laboratory, or office
facilities of an employer to carry on outside private practice.
7. Engineers shall not attempt to injure, maliciously or falsely, directly or indirectly, the
professional reputation, prospects, practice, or employment of other engineers. Engineers
who believe others are guilty of unethical or illegal practice shall resent such information
to the proper authority for action.
a) Engineers in private practice shall not review the work of another engineer for the same
client, except with the knowledge of such engineer, or unless the connection of such
engineer with the work has been terminated.
 UNIT GLOBAL

b) Engineers in governmental, industrial, or educational employment are entitled to review

and evaluate the work of other engineers when so required by their employment duties.
c) Engineers in sales or industrial employ are entitled to make engineering comparisons or
represented products with products of other suppliers.
8. Engineers shall accept personal responsibility for their professional activities, provided,
however, the engineers may seek indemnification for services arising out of their practice
for other than gross negligence, where the engineer’s interests cannot otherwise be
protected.
a) Engineers shall conform to state registration laws in the practice of engineering.
b) Engineers shall not use association with a non-engineer, a corporation, or partnership as
a ‘cloak’ for unethical acts.
9. Engineers shall give credit for engineering work to those to whom credit is due, and will
recognize the proprietary interests of others.
a) Engineers shall, whenever possible, name the person or persons who may be
individually responsible for designs, inventions, writings, or other accomplishments.
b) Engineers using designs supplied by a client recognize that the designs remain the
property of the client and may not be duplicated by the engineer for others, without the
express permission.
c) Engineers before undertaking work for others in connection with which the engineer
may make improvements, plans, designs, inventions, or other records that may justify
copyrights or patents, should enter into a positive agreement regarding ownership.
d) Engineers’ designs, data, records, and notes referring exclusively to an employer’s work
are the employer’s property. The employer should indemnify the engineer for use of the
information for any purpose other than the original purpose.
e) Engineers shall continue their professional development throughout their careers and
should keep current in their specialty fields by engaging in professional practice,
participating in continuing education course, reading in the technical literature, and
attending professional meetings and seminars.
5.6.2. The Institute of Electrical & Electronics
Engineers Code of Ethics
We the members of the IEEE, in recognition of the importance of our technologies in affecting
the quality of life throughout the world, and in accepting a personal obligation to our profession,
its members and the communities we serve, do hereby commit ourselves to the highest ethical
and professional conduct and agree:
1. To accept responsibility in making engineering decisions consistent with the safety,
health and welfare of the public, and to disclose prompt factors that might endanger the
public or the environment.
2. To avoid real or perceived conflicts of interest whenever possible, and to disclose them
to affected parties when they do exist.
3. To be honest and realistic in stating claims or estimates based on available data.
4. To reject bribery in all its forms.
5. To improve the understanding of technology, its appropriate application, and potential
consequences.
6. To maintain and improve our technical competence and to undertake technological tasks
for others only if qualified by training or experience, or after full disclosure of pertinent
limitations.
7. To seek, accept, and offer honest criticism of technical work, to acknowledge and
correct errors, and to credit properly the contributions of others.
 UNIT GLOBAL

8. To treat fairly all persons regardless of such factors as race, religion, gender, disability,
age, or national origin.
9. To avoid injuring others, their property, reputation, or employment by false or malicious
action.
10. To assist colleagues and co-workers in their professional development and to support
them in following code of ethics.
5.6.3. Institution of Engineers (India)
Code of Ethics (Effective from March 2004)
The corporate members if the IEI are committed to promote and practice the profession
of engineering for the common good of the community bearing in mind the following
concerns:
1. The ethical standard
2. Social justice, social order, and human rights
3. Protection of the environment
4. Sustainable development
5. Public safety and tranquility
The Tenets of the Code of Ethics
A corporate member
1. Shall utilize his/her knowledge and expertise for the welfare, health, and safety of the
community without any discrimination for sectional or private interests.
2. Shall maintain the honour, integrity and dignity in all his professional actions to be
worthy of the trust of the community and the profession.
3. Shall act only in the domains of his competence and with diligence, care, sincerity and
honesty.
4. Shall apply his knowledge and expertise in the interest of his employer or the clients for
whom he shall work without compromising with other obligations to these tenets.
5. Shall not falsify or misrepresent his own or his associates qualification, experience etc.
6. Wherever necessary and relevant, shall take all reasonable steps to inform, himself, his
employer or clients, of the environmental, economic, social and other possible
consequences, which may arise out of his actions.
7. Shall maintain utmost honesty and fairness in making a statement or giving witness and
shall do so on the basis of adequate knowledge.
8. Shall not directly or indirectly injure the professional reputation of another member.
9. Shall reject any kind of offer that may involve unfair practice or may cause avoidable
damage to the eco-system.
10. Shall be concerned about and shall act in the best of his abilities for maintenance of
sustainability of the process of development.
11. Shall not act in any manner which may injure the reputation of the institution or which
may cause any damage to the institution financially or otherwise.
5.6.4. Indian Institute of Material
Management Code of Ethics
1. To consider first the total interest of one’s organization in all transactions without
impairing the dignity and responsibility to one’s office.
2. To buy without prejudice seeking to obtain the maximum ultimate value for each rupee
of expenditure.
3. To subscribe and work for honesty and truth in buying and selling.
4. To denounce all forms and manifestations of commercial bribery and to eschew anti-
social practices.
 UNIT GLOBAL

5. To respect one’s obligations and those of one’s organization consistent with good
business practice.
5.6.5. Institution of Electronics and Telecommunication
Engineers Code of Ethics
1. A corporate member will, at all times, endeavour to protect the engineering profession
from misrepresentation and misunderstanding.
2. A corporate member will interact with others in his profession by free exchange of
information and experience. He will contribute to the growth of the institution to
maximum effectiveness to the best of his ability.
3. A corporate member will not offer his professional services by advertisement or through
any commercial advertising media, or solicit engineering work, trading, teaching either
directly or indirectly or through agencies/organizations in any manner derogatory to the
dignity of the profession and the institution.
4. A corporate member will not directly or indirectly injure the professional reputation,
work, or practice of another corporate member.
5. A corporate member will not divulge confidential findings or actions of the council or
committee of which he is a member, without obtaining official clearance.
6. A corporate member will not take credit for an activity, professional work, engineering
proposal when engaged in a team and give due recognition to those where due.
7. A corporate member will express an opinion only when it is founded on facts and
honest conviction before a forum, court, commission or at an inquiry.
8. A corporate member will exercise due restraint in criticizing the work or professional
conduct of another corporate member which would impinge or hurt his character and
reputation.
9. A corporate member will not try to supplant another corporate member in a particular
employment, office or contract.
10. A corporate member will be upright in all his dealings with person(s), organizations, in
business, contractors, and agencies. He should not take actions that lead to groupisim,
political connotation or unethical conduct in the discharge if his official powers.
11. A corporate member will not misrepresent his qualification to gain undue advantage in
his profession.
12. A corporate member will act with fairness and justice in any office, employment or
contract.
13. A corporate member will not associate in engineering work which does not conform to
ethical practices.
14. A corporate member will not compete unfairly with another corporate member by
means, which in the opinion of others, are based on garnering support for personal gain,
enlisting uncalled for sympathy, espousing unjust cases or amounts to use of
unconstitutional methods.
15. A corporate member will act in professional matters as a faithful agent or trustee.
16. A corporate member will not receive remuneration, commission, discount or any
indirect profit from any work with which he is entrusted, unless specifically so
permitted.
17. A corporate member will not accept financial or other compensation from more than
one source for the same service or work connected thereto, unless so authorized
18. A corporate member will immediately inform his organisation/institution of any
financial interest in a business, and engineering work which may compete with,
adversely affect or hamper the growth of parent body.
 UNIT GLOBAL

19. A corporate member will engage or enlist the services of specialist/experts when in his
judgement, such services are in the best interest of his employer or to the profession.
20. A corporate member will endeavour to develop a team among his colleagues and staff
and provide equal opportunity to them for professional development and advancement.
21. A corporate member will subscribe to the principle of appropriate norms, appreciation
and adequate compensation for those engaged in office, technical and professional
employment including those in subordinate positions.
22. A corporate member, if he considers that another corporate member is guilty of
unethical, illegal, unfair practice, defalcation, will not present such information to the
Council of the Institution for necessary action, unless armed with substantial proof.
5.7. Engineers As Consultants
● Consultants are persons who give expert advice in Engineering, business, law etc.
● Consulting engineers generally exercise their consulting activities as independent. The
consulting engineers work in private. There is no salary from the employers. But they
charge fees from the sponsor and they have more freedom to decide on their projects. Still
they have no absolute freedom, because they need to earn for their living. The consulting
engineers have ethical responsibilities different from the salaried engineers, as follows:
1. Advertising
2. Competitive bidding
3. Contingency fees
4. Safety and client needs
5. Provisions for resolution of disputes

1. Advertising
✔ The consulting engineers are directly responsible for advertising their services, even if they
employ other consultants to assist them. But in many organizations, this responsibility is
with the advertising executives and the personnel department.
✔ They are allowed to advertise but to avoid deceptive ones. Deceptive advertising such as the
following are prohibited:
a) By white lies.
b) Half-truth, e.g., a product has actually been tested as prototype, but it was claimed to
have been already introduced in the market. An architect shows the photograph of
the completed building with flowering trees around but actually the foundation of
the building has been completed and there is no real garden.
c) Exaggerated claims. The consultant might have played a small role in a well-known
project.
d) But they could claim to have played a major role.
e) Making false suggestions. The reduction in cost might have been achieved along
with the reduction in strength, but the strength details are hidden.
f) Through vague wordings or slogans.
2. Competitive Bidding
✔ It means process of offering of prices at an auction or in business, and get
something in return for the service offered. The organizations have a pool of
engineers.
✔ The expertise can be shared and the bidding is made more realistic. But the
individual consultants have to develop creative designs and build their reputation
steadily and carefully, over a period of time.
 UNIT GLOBAL

✔ The clients will have to choose between the reputed organizations and proven
qualifications of the company and the expertise of the consultants. Although
competent, the younger consultants are thus slightly at a disadvantage.
3. Contingency Fee
✔ This is the fee or commission paid to the consultant, when one is successful in saving the
expenses for the client. A sense of honesty and fairness is required in fixing this fee.
✔ The NSPE Code III says that the engineers shall not propose or accept a commission on a
contingent basis where their judgment may be compromised.
✔ The fee may be either as an agreed amount or a fixed percentage of the savings realized.
But in the contingency fee-agreements, the judgment of the consultant may be biased.
✔ The consultant may be tempted to specify inferior materials or design methods to cut the
construction cost. This fee may motivate the consultants to effect saving in the costs to the
clients, through reasonably moral and technological means.
4. Safety and Client’s Needs
✔ The greater freedom for the consulting engineers in decision making on safety aspects, and
difficulties concerning truthfulness are the matters to be given attention.
✔ For example, in design-only projects, the consulting engineers may design something and
have no role in the construction. Sometimes, difficulties may crop-up during construction
due to non-availability of suitable materials, some shortcuts in construction, and lack of
necessary and adequate supervision and inspection.
✔ Properly-trained supervision is needed, but may not happen, unless it is provided. Further,
the contractor may not understand and/or be willing to modify the original design to serve
the clients best.
✔ A few on-site inspections by the consulting engineers will expose the deficiency in
execution and save the workers, the public, and the environment that may be exposed to
risk upon completion of the project.
✔ The NSPE codes on the advertisement by consultants provide some specific regulations.
The following are the activities prohibited in advertisement by consultant:
1. The use of statement containing misrepresentation or omission of a necessary fact.
2. Statement intended or likely to create an unjustified expectation.
3. Statement containing prediction of future (probable) success.
4. Statement intended or likely to attract clients, by the use of slogans or sensational
language format.
5. Provision of resolution of disputes
✔ Since large engineering projects require responsibilities from different values within the
organization representing owner, the consulting engineer and the construction company,
therefore it is obvious that there may be chances for overlapping responsibilities,
misplaced control, indecision, delays and inability to solve disputes quickly
✔ Filling litigation cases against consulting engineers has increased considerably
✔ As these cases are time consuming, costly and laborious process, therefore the
consulting engineer should be prepared to have contractual provisions to
resolve conflicts

5.8. Engineers As Expert Witness

✔ Frequently engineers are required to act as consultants and provide expert opinion
and views in many legal cases of the past events.
o They are required to explain the causes of accidents, malfunctions and other
technological behaviour of structures, machines, and instruments, e.g.,
 UNIT GLOBAL

personal
 UNIT GLOBAL

injury while using an instrument, defective product, traffic accident, structure

or building collapse, and damage to the property, are some of the cases where
testimonies are needed. The focus is on the past.
o Public planning, policy making that involves technology.
✔ Usually engineers are hired by one adversary in the dispute. These engineers
releases special ethical concerns
✔ It is desired that without becoming hired guns, engineers can function as advocates for
attorneys and their clients, for public officials, or for private organisation that hire
them
5.8.1. Engineers As Expert Witness In The Courts
✔ The dependent in civil or criminal cases may hire an engineer to serve as an
expert witness
✔ Some engineers may serve as experts and some may specialist in forensic
engineering. Forensic engineering means the application of engineering skills
and knowledge in criminal investigation to aid judicial system
✔ Engineers may act as witness in a wide variety of cases such as concerning
defective products, personal injury, damage to properties, traffic accidents and
airplane crashes
✔ Engineer’s evidences are considered seriously while awarding
compensatory damages for injuries, loss of property or violation of rights
✔ The functions of eye-witness vs. expert-witness

5.8.2. Abuses of Engineers As Expert witness

✔ The engineers, who act as expert-witnesses, are likely to abuse their positions in the
following manners:
✔ Hired Guns
o Mostly lawyers hire engineers to serve the interest of their clients. Lawyers are
permitted and required to project the case in a way favorable to their clients. But
the engineers have obligations to thoroughly examine the events and
demonstrate their professional integrity to testify only the truth in the court.
o They do not serve the clients of the lawyers directly. The hired guns forward
white lies and distortions, as demanded by the lawyers. They even withhold
the information or shade the fact, to favor their clients.
✔ Money Bias
o Consultants may be influenced or prejudiced for monitory considerations,
gain reputation and make a fortune.
✔ Ego Bias
✔ The assumption that the own side is innocent and the other side is guilty, is
responsible for this behavior.
 UNIT GLOBAL

✔ An inordinate desire to serve one’s client and get name and fame is another reason for
this bias.
✔ Sympathy Bias
✔ Sympathy for the victim on the opposite side may upset the testimony. The integrity
of the consultants will keep these biases away from the justice.
✔ The court also must obtain the balanced view of both sides, by examining the
expert witnesses of lawyers on both sides, to remove a probable bias.
✔ Duties
1. The expert-witness is required to exhibit the responsibility of confidentiality just as they
do in the consulting roles. They can not divulge the findings of the investigation to the
opposite side, unless it is required by the court of law.
2. More important is that as witness they are not required to volunteer evidence favorable
to the opponent. They must answer questions truthfully, need not elaborate, and
remain neutral until the details are asked for further.
3. They should be objective to discover the truth and communicate them honestly.
4. The stand of the experts depends on the shared understanding created within the
society. The legal system should be respected and at the same time, they should act
in conformance with the professional standards as obtained from the code of ethics.
5. The experts should earnestly be impartial in identifying and interpreting the observed
data, recorded data, and the industrial standards. They should not distort the truth, even
under pressure. Although they are hired by the lawyers, they do not serve the lawyers or
their clients. They serve the justice. Many a time, their objective judgments will help the
lawyer to put up the best defense for their clients.
5.9. Engineers As Expert Advisors
5.9.1. Advisors In Planning And Policy Making
Advisors
● The engineers are required to give their view on the future such as in planning, policy-
making, which involves the technology. For example, should India expand nuclear
power options or support traditional energy sources such as fossil fuels or alternative
forms like solar and wind energy? In the recent past, this topic has created lot of
fireworks, in the national media.
Various issues and requirements for engineers who act as advisors are:
1. Objectivity
The engineers should study the cost and benefits of all possible alternative means in
objective manner, within the specified conditions and assumptions.
2. Study All Aspects
They have to study the economic viability (effectiveness), technical feasibility (efficiency),
operational feasibility (skills) and social acceptability, which include environmental and
ethical aspects, before formulating the policy.
3. Values
Engineers have to possess the qualities, such as (a) honesty, (b) competence (skills and
expertise), (c) diligence (careful and alert) (d) loyalty in serving the interests of the clients and
maintaining confidentiality, and (e) public trust, and respect for the common good, rather than
serving only the interests of the clients or the political interests.
4. Technical Complexity
The arbitrary, unrealistic, and controversial assumptions made during the future planning
that are overlooked or not verified, will lead to moral complexity. The study on future is full
of uncertainties than the investigations on the past events. On the study of energy options, for
 UNIT GLOBAL

example, assumptions on population increase, life style, urbanization, availability of local

fossil resources, projected costs of generating alternative forms of energy, world political
scenario, world military tensions and pressures from world organizations such as World Trade
Organisation (W.T.O.) and European Union (EU) may increase the complexity in judgment on
future.
5. National Security
The proposed options should be aimed to strengthen the economy and security of the nation,
besides safeguarding the natural resources and the environment from exploitation and
degradation.

5.9.2. Normative Models of Advisors

For the advisors on policy making or planning, a shared understanding on balancing the
conflicting responsibilities, both to the clients and to the public, can be effected by the
following roles or models:
1. Hired Gun
The prime obligation is shown to the clients. The data and facts favourable to the clients are
highlighted, and unfavourable aspects are hidden or treated as insignificant. The minimal
level of interest is shown for public welfare.
2. Value-neutral Analysts
This assumes an impartial engineer. They exhibit conscientious decisions, impartiality i.e.,
without bias, fear or favour, and absence of advocacy.
3. Value-guided Advocates
The consulting engineers remain honest (frank in stating all the relevant facts and truthful in
interpretation of the facts) and autonomous (independent) in judgement and show
paramount importance to the public (as different from the hired guns).
5.9.3. Core Qualities Required for an Expert Advisors
According to Rosemarie Tong, an engineer should have following virtues
● Honesty – the quality of being truthfulness
● Competence – the thorough Knowledge of the work they undertake to do
● Diligence – to carry out the given tasks carefully and promptly
● Loyalty – the quality of being true and faithful in one’s support

5.10. Moral Leadership

Engineers provide many types of leadership in the development and implementation of
technology, as managers, entrepreneurs, consultants, academics and officials of the
government. Moral leadership is not merely the dominance by a group. It means adopting
reasonable means to motivate the groups to achieve morally desirable goals. This leadership
presents the engineers with many challenges to their moral principles.
5.10.1. Moral creative Leaders
● The success of corporation is to a greater extent is influenced by the quality of
leadership
● According to Barnard “Leadership refers to the quality of the behaviour of the
individuals where by, they guide people on their activities in organized effort”
● Moral leadership is essentially required for the engineers, for the reasons listed as
follows:
 UNIT GLOBAL

1. It is leading a group of people towards the achievement of global and objectives. The
goals as well as the means are to be moral. For example, Hitler and Stalin were leaders, but
only in an instrumental sense and certainly not on moral sense.
2. The leadership shall direct and motivate the group to move through morally desirable
ways.
3. They lead by thinking ahead in time, and morally creative towards new applications,
extension and putting values into practice. ‘Morally creative’ means the identification of the
most important values as applicable to the situation, bringing clarity within the groups
through proper communication, and putting those values into practice.
4. They sustain professional interest, among social diversity and cross-disciplinary
complexity. They contribute to the professional societies, their professions, and to their
communities.
● Moral leaders are those who direct, motivate, organize, manage or in other ways take
groups towards morally valuable goals
● Frederick Taylor, the father of scientific management, have pointed out that engineers
and technologists were best qualified leaders to govern because of their technical
expertise, logical, practical and unprejudiced minds
5.10.2. Participation in professional societies
● Moral leadership within engineering is clearly demonstrated by playing a significant
role in professional bodies like IEEE, ASME, NSPE etc
● The moral leadership in engineering is manifested in leadership within the professional
societies. The professional societies provide a forum for communication, and
canvassing for change within and by groups.
● Engineers have to resolve the conflicts of interest, disagreement, moral dilemmas and
other issues among themselves through these professional societies
● The engineers have to share the moral activity through these societies
● Engineers as moral leaders can help through these professional societies in sponsoring
ethics workshops, conducting surveys on matters of concern , informing their members
about recent development related to ethics and technology and encouraging educational
institutions to work forward in it
5.10.3. Voluntary services
● In past engineering code of ethics have discouraged voluntarism in the engineering
field. “engineers shall not undertake nor agree to perform any engineering
services on free basis”
● Another important avenue for providing moral leadership within communities, by
the engineers is to promote services without fee or at reduced fees (pro bono) to the
needy groups.
● The professional societies can also promote such activities among the engineers.
This type of voluntarism (or philanthropy) has been in practice in the fields of
medicine, law and education.
● But many of the engineers are not self-employed as in the case of physicians and
lawyers. The business institutions are encouraged to contribute a percentage of
their services as free or at concessional rates for charitable purposes.
5.10.4. Community service
This is another platform for the engineers to exhibit their moral leadership. The engineers
an help in guiding, organising, and stimulating the community towards morally- and
 UNIT GLOBAL

environmentally-desirable goals. The corporate organizations have come forward to adopt

villages and execute many social welfare schemes, towards this objective.
The Codes of Ethics promote and sustain the ethical environment and assist in
achieving the ethical goals in the following manner:
1. It creates an environment in a profession, where ethical behavior is the basic criterion.
2. It guides and reminds the person as to how to act, in any given situation.
3. It provides support to the individual, who is being pressurized or tortured by a superior or
employer, to behave unethically.
4. Apart from professional societies, companies and universities have framed their own
codes of ethics, based on the individual circumstances and specific mission of the
organisations.
These codes of conduct help in employees’ awareness of ethical issues, establish, and
nurture a strong corporate ethical culture.
5.11. Corporate Social Responsibility
The term "corporate social responsibility" became popular in the 1960s and has
remained a term used indiscriminately by many to cover legal and moral responsibility more
narrowly construed.[10]
CSR as "A company’s sense of responsibility towards the community and environment (both
ecological and social) in which it operates. Companies express this citizenship (1) through their
waste and pollution reduction processes, (2) by contributing educational and social programs
and (3) by earning adequate returns on the employed resources."
Scope:
Initially, CSR emphasized the official behavior of individual firms. Later, it expanded to
include supplier behavior and the uses to which products were put and how they were disposed
of after they lost value.
Incidents like the 2013 Savar building collapse pushed companies to consider how the
behavior of their suppliers impacted their overall impact on society. Irresponsible behavior
reflected on both the misbehaving firm, but also on its corporate customers. Supply chain
management expanded to consider the CSR context. Wieland and Handfield (2013) suggested
that companies need to include social responsibility in their reviews of component quality.
They highlighted the use of technology in improving visibility across the supply chain.
There are a few broad categories of social responsibility that many of today's businesses are
practicing:
1. Environmental efforts: One primary focus of corporate social responsibility is
the environment. Businesses regardless of size have a large carbon footprint. Any steps they
can take to reduce those footprints are considered both good for the company and society as a
whole.
2. Philanthropy: Businesses also practice social responsibility by donating to national and local
charities. Businesses have a lot of resources that can benefit charities and local community
programs.
3. Ethical labor practices: By treating employees fairly and ethically, companies can also
demonstrate their corporate social responsibility. This is especially true of businesses that
operate in international locations with labor laws that differ from those in the United States.
4. Volunteering: Attending volunteer events says a lot about a company's sincerity. By doing
good deeds without expecting anything in return, companies are able to express their concern
for specific issues and support for certain organizations.
Functions:
 UNIT GLOBAL

CSR policy functions as a self-regulatory mechanism whereby a business monitors and

ensures its active compliance with the spirit of the law, ethical standards and national or
international norms. With some models, a firm's implementation of CSR goes beyond
compliance and engages in "actions that appear to further some social good, beyond the
interests of the firm and that which is required by law."
The binary choice between 'complying' with the law and 'going beyond' the law must be
qualified with some nuance. In many areas such as environmental or labor regulations,
employers can choose to comply with the law, to go beyond the law, but they can also choose
to not comply with the law, such as when they deliberately ignore gender equality or the
mandate to hire disabled workers.
There must be a recognition that many so-called 'hard' laws are also 'weak' laws, weak
in the sense that they are poorly enforced, with no or little control and/or no or few sanctions in
case of non-compliance. 'Weak' law must not be confused with Soft law .
The aim is to increase long-term profits and shareholder trust through positive public
relations and high ethical standards to reduce business and legal risk by taking responsibility for
corporate actions. CSR strategies encourage the company to make a positive impact on the
environment and stakeholders including consumers, employees, investors, communities, and
others.

Part – A
1. What is moral leadership?(May/June/2016) (Nov/Dec/2015)
● Moral Leadership is a very different kind of leadership. Rather than
aspiring to being followed, Moral Leaders aim to serve. Instead of show casing
their own skills, Moral Leaders tend to develop the capacities of others.
● Whenever the goals of a leader become permissible and also morally valuable, it is
known as moral leadership. Moral leadership also means that employing morally
acceptable ways to motivate the groups to move towards morally desirable ways. The
ways are depending on thesituations.
2. What is technology transfer? (Nov/Dec/2015/2017)
Technology transfer is a process of changing the technology to a new setting and
implementing it. Technology includes hardware such as machines and installations as well as
techniques such as technical, organizational and managerial skills andprocedures.
3. What is meant by Globalization?(May/June/2016)
Our lives are increasingly dependent upon the goods/services produced over the world
and are influenced by the business from around all the corners of the world. In general world
has become a global village and have a global economy. The increasing international flow of
capital, technology, trade, and people have had the effects of changing the nature of local
organizations governments and people of countries and have led to social changes and
developments
4. What is meant by computer ethics? (Nov/Dec/2016)
Computerscontributetoavarietyofmoralproblems.Inordertoevaluateand act
appropriately with such problems, a new field of applied ethics termed as computer
ethics has been developed. The study of ethical issues that are associated with
computer, its peripheral and a c c e s s e s series and the computing profession is
called as computer ethics
5. What is code of conduct? (Nov/Dec/2016)(Apr/May/2018)
 UNIT GLOBAL

A code of conduct is a set of rules outlining the social norms and rules and responsibilities
of, or proper practices for, an individual, party or organization. Related concepts include
ethical, honour, moral codes and religious laws.
6. Deduct the responsibilities of Consulting Engineers (Nov/Dec/2017)
Some of the responsibilities of consulting engineers are in the following areas.
o Advertising,
o Competitive bidding,
o Contingency fees,
o Safety and client needs,and
o Provisions for resolution of disputes.
7. How is corporate social responsibility practiced(May/June/2017)( Nov/Dec/2018)
There are a few broad categories of social responsibility that many of today's businesses are
practicing:
• Environmental efforts: One primary focus of corporate social responsibility is the
environment. Businesses regardless of size have a large carbon footprint. Any steps they
can take to reduce those footprints are considered both good for the company and
society as a whole.
• Philanthropy: Businesses also practice social responsibility by donating to national and
local charities. Businesses have a lot of resources that can benefit charities and local
community programs.
• Ethical labor practices: By treating employees fairly and ethically, companies can also
demonstrate their corporate social responsibility. This is especially true of businesses
that operate in international locations with labor laws that differ from those in the
United States.
• Volunteering: Attending volunteer events says a lot about a company's sincerity. By
doing good deeds without expecting anything in return, companies are able to express
their concern for specific issues and support for certain organizations.
8. What is embezzlement?
The process of computing computer crimes such as stealing or cheating clients and
conspiracy in the fraudulent uses of computer networks is called embezzlement.

9. What the hired guns?

Engineers are hired by attorneys to help them to establish the facts in away favorable to
their clients. The hired guns violate the standards of honesty and also due care in conducting
investigations.

10. State the most important ethical mistake made by the multinational
corporation which caused Bhopal gas plant disaster.
● The tanks used to store Methyl Iso-cyanate were overloaded to a tune of75%.
● The emergency plant was also filled with a large amount ofchemicals.
● The entire refrigeration unit had been shut down as a measure to reduce the
cost and this led to increase of temperatures to a higherlevel.
● One of the disappointed workers unscrewed a pressure gauge on a tank and
inserted a hosepipe into it, knowing that it would cause damage, but not to
this extent.
● Scrubber has also been shutdown.
● Flare tower was also not in an operatingcondition.
 UNIT GLOBAL

● Unfortunately there were no emergency drills or evacuation plantsavailable.

11. Define Conflict resolution.

Conflict resolution is the result based on some objective standard and corporate usually uses
general standards for evaluating the results.

12. What is contextualize?

In accordance to Gilligan women try hard to preserve personal relationship will all people.
This context-oriented emphasis on maintaining personal relationship is called as ethics of
care in contrast with ethics of rules andrights.
13. What are ethical pluralism and ethical relativism?
Ethical pluralism: According to this view there may be alternative moral perspectives that
are reasonable, but no one of which must be accepted completely by all rational and morally
concerned persons.
Ethical relativism: Actions are morally right when they are approved by law or custom they
are wrong when they violate laws orcustomers.
14. What should an ethical expert witness, even though hired by a company,
expected to do?
Engineers should not become the hired-guns to their clients, but instead remain as
objective as humanly possible in their investigations and the conclusions they reach .they
should avoid biases resulting from money ego, and sympathy.
15. What are the international rights listed by Donaldson?
Thomas Donaldson in his book ‗The ethics of International Business„ has listed the
following as the International rights:
● The right to freedom of physical movement
● The right to ownership of property
● The right to freedom from torture
● The right to a fair trial
● The right to nondiscriminatory treatment
● The right to physical security
● The right to freedom of speech and association
● The right to minimal education
● The right to political participation
● The right to subsistence.
16. Define appropriate technology?
Appropriate technology refers to the identification, transfer and implementation of
the most suitable technology for a new set of conditions.

17. List out four examples for Multinational Corporation.

Large corporations having investment and business in number of countries are known as
Multinational or Transnational corporation. Some of them are : Hindustan Lever, Ford,
Toyota, Sony, LG, Smith Kline Beecham, ITC, Pondsetc.

18. What are the three senses of relative values?

Ethical Relativism
 UNIT GLOBAL

Descriptive
Relativism Moral
Relativism
19. What are the demerits of Multinational Corporation to host country?
(Nov/Dec/2018)
Ethical dilemmas faced by certain companies may be specific to their industry or company,
other types of ethical issues are common to all types of companies. Handling ethical
decisions with wisdom is especially important for small businesses, given the potentially
devastating effects these companies may face if such issues aren't handled correctly.
20. What are the advantages and disadvantages of MNC’s to host country?
(Apr/May/2018)

Advantages of Multinational Corporations

a) Multinational corporations provide an inflow of capital.
Multinational corporations reduce government aid dependencies in the developing
world
b) Multinational corporations allow countries to purchase imports
c) Multinational corporations provide local employment.
Multinational corporations improve the local infrastructure.
d) Multinational corporations diversify local economies
e) Multinational companies create consistent consumer experiences.
Multinational corporations encourage more innovation.
f) Multinational corporations enforce minimum quality standards.
g) Multinational corporations increase cultural awareness.
Disadvantages of Multinational Corporations
a) Multinational corporations don’t always leave profits local.
b) Multinational corporations import skilled labor .
c) Multinational corporations create one-way raw material resource consumption
d) Multinational corporations encourage political corruption.
e) Multinational corporations support “sweatshop” labor.
f) Multinational corporations remove jobs from their home country.
g) Multinational corporations build legal monopolies.
h) Multinational corporations put other companies out of business
i) Multinational corporations create higher environmental costs
21. Differentiate the Eye witness and expert witness in the legal system
(MAY/JUNE2014)
An eyewitness is one who testifies what they perceived through his or her senses (e.g.
seeing, hearing, smelling, touching). That perception might be either with the unaided
human sense or with the aid of an instrument, e.g., microscope or stethoscope, or by other
scientific means, e.g.a chemical reagent which changes color in the presence of a
particularsubstance
An expert witness is one who allegedly has specialized knowledge relevant to the matter of
interest, which knowledge purportedly helps to either make sense of other evidence,
including other testimony, documentary evidence or physical evidence (e.g., a fingerprint)
22. Define the term “honesty “and “moral leadership‟
Honesty: A facet of moral character that connotes positive and virtuous attributes
 UNIT GLOBAL

such as integrity, truthfulness, and straightforwardness, along with the absence of

lying,
 UNIT GLOBAL

cheating, or theft
Moral Leadership: A process of social influence in which one person enlists the aid
and support of others in accomplishing a common task.
23. What do you understand by Business ethics?
Business ethics (also corporate ethics) is a form of applied ethics or professional ethics
that examines ethical principles and moral or ethical problems that arise in a business
environment. It applies to all aspects of business conduct and is relevant to the conduct of
individuals and entire organizations.

PART B
1. Describe in details about Global issues of weapons development
Or
2. Discuss the ethical role of engineers in weapon development with suitable examples
(May/June/2016/2018)( N0v/Dec/2018) Answer 5.4 – Weapons Development

3. Justify Engineers as expert witness and Advisors with suitable examples

(May/June/2016) (Nov/Dec/2015) Answer 5.8 – Expert Witness, 5.9 – Expert Advisors

4. Discuss the ethical role of engineers in as a consulting Engineer with suitable

examples (May/June/2017/2018) (Nov/Dec/2015)Answer 5.7 – Engineers as consultants

5. What is meant by Computer ethics? State and explain the categories of ethical
problems and the unethical acts computer as an instrument of unethical behavior.
What is meant by hacking?(Nov/Dec/2017)
(OR)

6. Discuss in detail about the moral and ethical issues involved in use of computers
(May/June/2017) (Nov/Dec/2015/2017) Answer 5.3 – Computer Ethics

7. State the types of concern for environment by the engineers. Discuss the
approaches to resolve environmental problems. What do professionals codes of ethics
say about environment (Nov/Dec/2017) - Answer – 5.2- Environmental Ethics

8. Explain in detail the various advantages and disadvantages of MNC’s(Nov/Dec/2016)

Answer – 5.1 – Multinational corporations
9. Explain the Bhopal gas tragedy. Discuss the violation of moral, ethical and professional
codes of standards in it. write a conclusion to avoid such tragedy in
future.(APRIL/MAY/2018) Answer – 5.1.6- Bhopal Gas Tragedy
(OR)
10. Discuss the Bhopal disaster .Explain the responsibility of engineer in the design
stage itself before the event of an accident. (MAY/JUNE 2014)(APR/MAY2015)
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

5.4. Weapons Development

Military activities including the world wars have stimulated the growth of technology. The
growth of Internet amply illustrates this fact. The development of warfare and the
involvement of engineers bring out many ethical issues concerned with engineers, such as the
issue of integrity in experiments as well as expenditure in defense research and development,
issue of personal commitment and conscience, and the issues of social justice and social
health.
Engineers involve in weapons development because of the following reasons:
✔ It gives one job with high salary.
✔ One takes pride and honor in participating in the activities towards the defense of the
nation (patriotic fervor).
✔ One believes the he fights a war on terrorism and thereby contribute to peace and
stability of the country. Ironically, the wars have never won peace, only peace can
win peace!
✔ By research and development, the engineer is reducing or eliminating the risk from
enemy weapons, and saving one’s country from disaster.
✔ By building-up arsenals and show of force, a country can force the rogue country,
towards regulation. Engineers can participate effectively in arms control negotiations
for surrender or peace, e.g., bombing of Nagasaki and Hiroshima led to surrender by
the Japanese in 1945.
5.4.1. Involvement in Weapons Work
✔ Historically, a quick death in battle by sword was considered acceptable, whereas the
use of remote weapons (from bow and arrow to firearms) was frequently condemned
as cowardly, devoid of courage, and equivalent to plain murder.
✔ As modern weapons of war progressed through catapults, cannons, machine guns, and
bombs released from airplanes and missiles to reach further and further, the soldiers
firing them were less likely to see the individual human beings—soldiers as well as
civilians— they had as their general target. The continuing automation of the battle
scene tends to conceal the horrors of war and thus makes military activity seem less
threatening and high-tech wars more appealing.
✔ For some engineers, involvement in weapons development conflicts with personal
conscience; for others, it is an expression of conscientious participation in national
defense.
✔ The following cases illustrate the kinds of moral issues involved in deciding
whether to engage in military work.
1. Bob himself does not handle the bombs in any way, but as an industrial engineer he
enables the factory to run efficiently. He does not like to be involved in making
weapons, but then he tells himself that someone has to produce them. If he does not
do his job, someone else will, so nothing would change. Further-more, with the cost
of living being what it is, he owes his family a steady income.
2. Mary is a chemical engineer. A promotion has gotten her into napalm manufacturing.
She knows it is nasty stuff, having heard that the Nobel laureate, Professor Wald of
Harvard University, was said to have berated the chemical industry for producing this
“most brutal and destructive weapon that has ever been created.” She saw a scary old
photograph from the Vietnam War period, depicting a badly burned peasant girl
running from a village in flames. She hates war like most human beings, but she feels
that the government knows more than she does about international dangers and that
the present use of napalm by U.S. forces in Iraq may be unavoidable. But Mary
knows that if she
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

continues to do well on her job she will be promoted, and one of these days she may
well be in the position to steer the company into the production of peaceful products.
3. Ron is a specialist in missile control and guidance. He is proud to be able to help his
country through his efforts in the defense industry, especially as part of the “war on
terrorism.” The missiles he works on will carry single or multiple warheads with the
kind of dreadful firepower which, in his estimation, has kept any potential enemy in
check since 1945. At least there has not been another world war—the result of mutual
deterrence, he believes.
4. Marco’s foremost love is physical electronics. He works in one of the finest laser
laboratories. Some of his colleagues do exciting research in particle beams. That the
laboratory is interested in developing something akin to the “death ray” described by
science fiction writers of his youth is of secondary importance. More bothersome is
the secrecy that prevents him from freely exchanging ideas with experts across the
world.
5. Joanne is an electronics engineer whose work assignment includes avionics for fighter
planes that are mostly sold abroad. She has no doubts about such planes going to what
she considers friendly countries, but she draws the line at their sale to potentially
hostile nations. Joanne realizes that she has no leverage within the company, so she
occasionally alerts journalist friends with news she feels all citizens should have.
6. Ted’s background and advanced degrees in engineering physics gave him a ready
entry into nuclear bomb development. As a well-informed citizen he is seriously
concerned with the dangers of the ever-growing nuclear arsenal. He is also aware of
the possibilities of an accidental nuclear exchange. In the mean-time he is working
hard to reduce the risk of accidents such as the 32 “broken arrows” (incidents when
missile launchings may have occurred erroneously) that had been reported by the
Pentagon during the height of the Cold War, or the many others that he knows have
occurred worldwide. Ted continues in his work because he believes that only
specialists, with firsthand experience of what modern weapons can do, can eventually
turn around the suicidal trend represented by their development.

5.4.2. Role of Engineers in Defense Industry

✔ Defense industry is one of the areas, which provide number of jobs opportunities to
engineers. Engineers are capable of innovating and developing new weapons.
Weapons are designed for one purpose – to kill human beings
✔ On the one hand, many of the rational engineers feel that they cannot work on
designing weapons, which are ultimately used to kill the human beings. Even though
they are not the ultimate users of those weapons, they find it morally unacceptable to
work on such areas
✔ On the other hand, similar morally responsible engineers feel that working in defense
industry is ethical. Because they feel it as honor to work for their nation / Government.
✔ In fact, the above two different views about working in defense industry are well
justified by various ethical theories
✔ Also the engineers should not be attracted by incentives and advancements that are
being offered in the defensive industries, they must have the potential judgments to
serve in defense works that would expose the human community.

Defense Industry Problems

 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

Many nations give privileges to defense industry, without even thinking, on serious
problems that arise in large military build-ups. Some of the problems are:
✔ The problem of waste and cost overruns is a continuing one in the defense industry.
✔ Another problem faced by the defense industry is the technology creep. It refers to
the development of new weapons, such as the cruise missile, which can change
diplomatic arrangements even as they are being negotiated. Thus it affects the
political stability of a country
✔ Secrecy creates problems for the defense industry. If the secrets of planned funding
were leaked to prospective contractors, then it may lead to high cost and poor quality
of defense materials and weapons
✔ Many countries allocate funds for the defense sector than that of the other public
welfare schemes

5.5. Engineers as Managers

5.5.1. Why do most of the Engineers move into Managerial Roles?
✔ Engineers move into management roles, because of the following two reasons
✔ Much corporate management prefer Engineers as their Managers. Because they
believe that:
▪ To manage technological corporation, the technical understanding is
necessary and
▪ The engineers have potential of understanding the business techniques of
any corporate bodies than any non engineers. Also it is comparatively
easier to teach the business techniques than to teach non engineers the
engineering techniques
✔ Engineers are attracted by various corporate incentives such as higher pay, greater
authority, wider responsibility and increased prestige and recognition.
5.5.2. Managers As Professions
Mintzberg published his Ten Management Roles in his book, "Mintzberg on Management:
Inside our Strange World of Organizations," in 1990.
The ten roles are:
Figurehead, Spokesperson
Leader Entrepreneur
Liaison Disturbance
Monitor Handler
Disseminator Resource
Allocator
The 10 roles are then divided up into three categories, as follows:

Category Roles
Interpersonal Figurehead
Leader
Liaison
Informational Monitor
Disseminator
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

Spokesperson

Interpersonal Category
The managerial roles in this category involve providing information and ideas.
1. Figurehead – As a manager, you have social, ceremonial and legal responsibilities.
You're expected to be a source of inspiration. People look up to you as a person with
authority, and as a figurehead.
2. Leader – This is where you provide leadership for your team, your department or
perhaps your entire organization; and it's where you manage the performance and
responsibilities of everyone in the group.
3. Liaison – Managers must communicate with internal and external contacts. You need
to be able to network effectively on behalf of your organization.
Informational Category
The managerial roles in this category involve processing information.
4. Monitor – In this role, you regularly seek out information related to your
organization and industry, looking for relevant changes in the environment. You also
monitor your team, in terms of both their productivity, and their well-being.
5. Disseminator – This is where you communicate potentially useful information to
your colleagues and your team.
6. Spokesperson – Managers represent and speak for their organization. In this role
you're responsible for transmitting information about your organization and its goals
to the people outside it.
Decisional Category
The managerial roles in this category involve using information.
7. Entrepreneur – As a manager, you create and control change within the organization.
This means solving problems, generating new ideas, and implementing them.
8. Disturbance Handler – When an organization or team hits an unexpected roadblock,
it's the manager who must take charge. You also need to help mediate disputes within
it.
9. Resource Allocator – You'll also need to determine where organizational resources
are best applied. This involves allocating funding, as well as assigning staff and other
organizational resources.
10. Negotiator – You may be needed to take part in, and direct, important negotiations
within your team, department, or organization.

5.5.3. Impact of transition on ethical

issues
✔ Generally managers are changed for
a) Merely serving for narrow interests of the corporation
b) Their objective of increasing the firm’s profit only
c) Not bothering about others responsibilities to promote the public good
✔ According to Friedman, manager’s ethics is limited only to the responsibility to
maximize profits for stockholders. But Engineers ethics involve wider
responsibilities to protect the public safety, health and welfare of the public.
✔ In contrast to Friedman’s view, it is recognized that the morals roles of engineers
are complementary and symbiotic, they are associated with each other
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

✔ As a manager, engineers remain professionals whose primary responsibility is to

provide useful products and services while ensuring that they are safe and
profitable

5.5.4. Characteristics
The characteristics of engineers as managers are:
a) Promote an ethical climate, through framing organization policies, responsibilities and
by personal attitudes and obligations.
b) Resolving conflicts, by evolving priority, developing mutual understanding,
generating various alternative solutions to problems.
c) Social responsibility to stakeholders, customers and employers. They act to develop
wealth as well as the welfare of the society. Ethicists project the view that the
manager’s responsibility is only to increase the profit of the organization, and only
the engineers have the responsibility to protect the safety, health, and welfare of the
public. But managers have the ethical responsibility to produce safe and good
products (or useful service), while showing respect for the human beings who
include the employees, customers and the public. Hence, the objective for the
managers and engineers is to produce valuable products that are also profitable.
5.5.5. Responsibilities an Ethical Climate
There are two important responsibilities of engineer – managers. They are:
1. Promoting an Ethical Climate
What is meant by an ethical climate?
✔ A favorable working atmosphere required to achieve a morally responsible
conduct is called an ethical climate
✔ Several factors such as nature of organization, informal traditions and
practices and personal attitudes directly contribute to the ethical climate
What are the defining features of an ethical corporate climate?
✔ Ethical values should be widely acknowledged and appreciated by all the
managers and employees of a company
✔ The use of proper ethical language like code of ethics should be recognized as
a legitimate part of the company
✔ The top management should accomplish a moral voice in both words and
policies and also by personal example, in other words the top level
management has to enhance confidence that the company is more serious
about ethics
✔ There should be some procedures for confronting and resolving conflicts
2. Resolving/ Managing Conflicts
In solving conflicts, force should not be resorted. In fact, the conflict situations should be
tolerated, understood, and resolved by participation by all the concerned. The conflicts in
case of project managers arise in the following manners:
a) Conflicts based on schedules: This happens because of various levels of execution,
priority and limitations of each level.
b) Conflicts arising out of fixing the priority to different projects or departments. This is
to be arrived at from the end requirements and it may change from time to time.
c) Conflict based on the availability of personnel.
d) Conflict over technical, economic, and time factors such as cost, time, and
performance level.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

e) Conflict arising in administration such as authority, responsibility, accountability, and

logistics required.
f) Conflicts of personality, human psychology and ego problems.
g) Conflict over expenditure and its deviations.

Most of the conflicts can be resolved by following the principles listed

here: People
Separate people from the problem. It implies that the views of all concerned should be
obtained. The questions such as what, why, and when the error was committed is more
important than to know who committed it. This impersonal approach will lead to not only
early solution but also others will be prevented from committing errors.
Interests
Focus must be only on interest i.e., the ethical attitudes or motives and not on the
positions (i.e., stated views). A supplier may require commission larger than usual prevailing
rate for an agricultural product. But the past analysis may tell us that the material is not
cultivated regularly and the monsoon poses some additional risk towards the supply. Mutual
interests must be respected to a maximum level. What is right is more important than who is
right!
Options
Generate various options as solutions to the problem. This helps a manager to try the next
best solution should the first one fails. Decision on alternate solutions can be taken more
easily and without loss of time.
Evaluation
The evaluation of the results should be based on some specified objectives such as
efficiency, quality, and customer satisfaction. More important is that the means, not only
the goals, should be ethical.

5.6. CODES OF ETHICS

5.6.1. National Society of Professional Engineers
I. Fundamental Canons
Engineers in the fulfilment of their professional duties shall
1. Hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
2. Perform services only in areas of their competence.
3. Issue public statements only in objective and truthful manner.
4. Act for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees.
5. Avoid deceptive acts.
6. Conduct themselves honourably, responsibly, ethically, and lawfully so as to
enhance the honour, reputation, and usefulness of the profession.
II. Rules of Practice
1. Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
a) If engineers’ judgment is overruled under circumstances that endanger life or property,
they shall notify their employer or client and such other authority as may be appropriate.
b) Engineers shall approve only those engineering documents that are in conformity with
applicable standards.
c) Engineers shall not reveal facts, data, or information without prior consent of the client
or employer except as authorized or required by law or this code.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

d) Engineers shall not permit the use of their name or associate in business ventures with
any person or firm that they believe are engaged in fraudulent or dishonest enterprise.
e) Engineers shall not aid or abet the unlawful practice of engineering by a person or firm.
f) Engineers having knowledge of any alleged violation of this Code shall report thereon to
appropriate professional bodies and when relevant, also to public authorities, and
cooperate with the proper authorities in furnishing such information or assistance as may
be required.
2. Engineers shall perform services only in the areas of their competence.
a) Engineers shall undertake assignments only when qualified by education or
experience in the specific technical fields involved.
b) Engineers shall not affix their signatures to any plans or documents dealing with
thesubject matter in which they lack competence, nor to any plan or document not
preparedunder their direction and control.
c) Engineers may accept assignments and assume responsibility for coordination of
anentire project and sign and seal the engineering documents for the entire project,
providedthat each technical segment is signed and sealed only by the qualified
engineers whoprepared the segment.
3. Engineers shall issue public statements only in an objective and truthful manner.
a) Engineers shall be objective and truthful in professional reports, statements, or testimony.
b) They shall include all relevant and pertinent information in such reports, statements,or
testimony, which should bear the date indicating when it was current.
c) Engineers may express publicly technical options that are founded upon knowledge
ofthe facts and competence in the subject matter.
d) Engineers shall issue no statements, criticisms, or arguments on technical matters
thatare inspired or paid for by interested parties on prefaced their comments by
explicitlyidentifying the interested parties on whose behalf they are speaking and by
revealingthe existence of any interest the engineers may have in the matters.
4. Engineers shall at for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees
a) Engineers shall disclose all known or potential conflicts of interest that could
influenceor appear to influence their judgment or the quality of their services.
b) Engineers shall not accept compensation, financial or otherwise, from more than
oneparty for services on the same project, or for services pertaining to the same
project,unless the circumstances are fully disclosed and agreed to by all interested
parties.
c) Engineers shall not solicit or accept financial or other valuable consideration,
directlyor indirectly, from outside agents on connection with the work for which they
areresponsible.
d) Engineers in public service as members, advisers, or employees of a governmental
orquasi-governmental body or department shall not participate in decisions with
respectto services solicited or provided by them or their organizations in private or
publicengineering practice.
e) Engineers shall not solicit or accept a contract from a governmental body on which
aprincipal or officer of their organization serves as a member.
5. Engineers shall avoid deceptive acts
a) Engineers shall not falsify their qualifications or permit misrepresentation of their
ortheir associate’s qualifications. They shall not misrepresent or exaggerate
theirresponsibility in or for the subject matter of prior assignments. Brochures or other
presentationsincident to
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

the solicitation of employment shall not misrepresent pertinentfacts concerning

employers, employees, associates, joint ventures, or pastaccomplishments.
b) Engineers shall not offer, give, solicit or receive, either directly or indirectly,
anycontribution to influence the award of a contract by public authority, or which
may bereasonably construed by the public as having the effect of intent to influence
the awarding of a contract. They shall not offer any gift or other valuable
consideration in order tosecure work. They shall not pay a commission, percentage, or
brokerage fee in orderto secure work, except to a bonafide employee or established
commercial or marketingagencies retained by them.
III. Professional Obligations
1. Engineers shall be guided in all their relation by the highest standards of honesty and
integrity.
a) Engineers shall acknowledge their errors and shall not distort or alter the facts.
b) Engineers shall advice their clients or employers when they believe a project will
notbe successful.
c) Engineers shall not accept outside employment to the detriment of their regular
workor interest. Before accepting any outside engineering employment they will
notifytheir employers.
d) Engineers shall not attempt to attract an engineer from another employer by false
ormisleading pretenses.
e) Engineers shall not promote their own interest at the expense of the dignity and
integrityof the profession.
2. Engineers shall at all times strive to serve the public interest.
a) Engineers shall seek opportunities to participate in civic affairs, career guidance
foryouths, and work for the advancement of the safety, health, and well-being of
theircommunity.
b) Engineers shall not complete, sign, or seal plans and/or specifications that are not
inconformity with applicable engineering standards. If the client or employer insists
onsuch unprofessional conduct, they shall notify the proper authorities and
withdrawfrom further service on the project.
c) Engineers shall endeavour to extend public knowledge and appreciation of
engineeringand its achievements.
3. Engineers shall avoid all conduct or practice that deceives the public.
a) Engineers shall avoid the use of statements containing a material misrepresentation
offact or omitting a material fact.
b) Consistent with the foregoing, engineers may advertise for recruitment of personnel.
c) Consistent with foregoing, engineers may prepare articles for the lay or technical
press,but such articles shall not imply credit to the author for work performed by other.
4. Engineers shall not disclose, without consent, confidential information concerning the
businessaffairs or technical processes of any present or former client or employer, or
public body onwhich they serve.
a) Engineers shall not, without the consent of all interested parties, promote or
arrangefor new employment or practice in connection with a specific project for
which theengineer has gained particular and specialized knowledge.
b) Engineers shall not, without the consent of all interested parties, participate in
orrepresent in adversary interest in connection with a specific project or proceeding
inwhich the
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

engineer has gained particular specialized knowledge on behalf of a formerclient or

employer.
5. Engineers shall not be influenced in their professional duties by conflicting interests.
a) Engineers shall not accept financial or other consideration including free
engineeringdesigns, from material or equipment suppliers for specifying their product.
b) Engineers shall not accept commission or allowances, directly or indirectly,
fromcontractors or other parties dealing with clients or employers of the engineer
inconnection with work for which the engineer is responsible.
6. Engineers shall not attempt to obtain employment or advancement or professional
engagementsby untruthfully criticizing other engineers, or by other improper methods.
a) Engineers shall not request, propose, or accept a commission on a contingent
basisunder circumstances in which their judgement may be compromised.
b) Engineers in salaried positions shall accept part-time engineering work only to
theextent consistent with policies of the employer and in accordance with
ethicalconsideration.
c) Engineers shall not, without consent, use equipment, supplies, laboratory, or officefacilit
7. Engineers shall not attempt to injure, maliciously or falsely, directly or indirectly,
theprofessional reputation, prospects, practice, or employment of other engineers.
Engineerswho believe others are guilty of unethical or illegal practice shall resent such
information tothe proper authority for action.
a) Engineers in private practice shall not review the work of another engineer for
thesame client, except with the knowledge of such engineer, or unless the connection
ofsuch engineer with the work has been terminated.
b) Engineers in governmental, industrial, or educational employment are entitled to
reviewand evaluate the work of other engineers when so required by their
employment duties.
c) Engineers in sales or industrial employ are entitled to make engineering
comparisonsor represented products with products of other suppliers.
8. Engineers shall accept personal responsibility for their professional activities,
provided,however, the engineers may seek indemnification for services arising out of
their practicefor other than gross negligence, where the engineer’s interests cannot
otherwise be protected.
a) Engineers shall conform to state registration laws in the practice of engineering.
b) Engineers shall not use association with a non-engineer, a corporation, or partnershipas a
‘cloak’ for unethical acts.
9. Engineers shall give credit for engineering work to those to whom credit is due, and
willrecognize the proprietary interests of others.
a) Engineers shall, whenever possible, name the person or persons who may be
individuallyresponsible for designs, inventions, writings, or other accomplishments.
b) Engineers using designs supplied by a client recognize that the designs remain
theproperty of the client and may not be duplicated by the engineer for others, without
theexpress permission.
c) Engineers before undertaking work for others in connection with which the
engineermay make improvements, plans, designs, inventions, or other records that
may justifycopyrights or patents, should enter into a positive agreement regarding
ownership.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

d) Engineers’ designs, data, records, and notes referring exclusively to an

employer’swork are the employer’s property. The employer should indemnify the
engineer foruse of the information for any purpose other than the original purpose.
e) Engineers shall continue their professional development throughout their careers
andshould keep current in their specialty fields by engaging in professional
practice,participating in continuing education course, reading in the technical
literature, andattending professional meetings and seminars.
5.6.2. The Institute of Electrical & Electronics
Engineers Code of Ethics
We the members of the IEEE, in recognition of the importance of our technologies in
affecting thequality of life throughout the world, and in accepting a personal obligation to our
profession, itsmembers and the communities we serve, do hereby commit ourselves to the
highest ethical andprofessional conduct and agree:
1. To accept responsibility in making engineering decisions consistent with the safety,
healthand welfare of the public, and to disclose prompt factors that might endanger
the public orthe environment.
2. To avoid real or perceived conflicts of interest whenever possible, and to disclose
them toaffected parties when they do exist.
3. To be honest and realistic in stating claims or estimates based on available data.
4. To reject bribery in all its forms.
5. To improve the understanding of technology, its appropriate application, and
potentialconsequences.
6. To maintain and improve our technical competence and to undertake technological
tasks forothers only if qualified by training or experience, or after full disclosure of
pertinentlimitations.
7. To seek, accept, and offer honest criticism of technical work, to acknowledge and
correcterrors, and to credit properly the contributions of others.
8. To treat fairly all persons regardless of such factors as race, religion, gender, disability,
age,or national origin.
9. To avoid injuring others, their property, reputation, or employment by false or
maliciousaction.
10. To assist colleagues and co-workers in their professional development and to support
them infollowing code of ethics.
5.6.3. Institution of Engineers (India)
Code of Ethics (Effective from March
2004)
The corporate members if the IEI are committed to promote and practice the profession
ofengineering for the common good of the community bearing in mind the following
concerns:
1. The ethical standard
2. Social justice, social order, and human rights
3. Protection of the environment
4. Sustainable development
5. Public safety and
tranquility The Tenets of the
Code of Ethics A corporate
member
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

1. Shall utilize his/her knowledge and expertise for the welfare, health, and safety of
thecommunity without any discrimination for sectional or private interests.
2. Shall maintain the honour, integrity and dignity in all his professional actions to
beworthy of the trust of the community and the profession.
3. Shall act only in the domains of his competence and with diligence, care, sincerity
andhonesty.
4. Shall apply his knowledge and expertise in the interest of his employer or the clients
forwhom he shall work without compromising with other obligations to these tenets.
5. Shall not falsify or misrepresent his own or his associates qualification, experience etc.
6. Wherever necessary and relevant, shall take all reasonable steps to inform, himself,
hisemployer or clients, of the environmental, economic, social and other
possibleconsequences, which may arise out of his actions.
7. Shall maintain utmost honesty and fairness in making a statement or giving witness
andshall do so on the basis of adequate knowledge.
8. Shall not directly or indirectly injure the professional reputation of another member.
9. Shall reject any kind of offer that may involve unfair practice or may cause
avoidabledamage to the eco-system.
10. Shall be concerned about and shall act in the best of his abilities for maintenance
ofsustainability of the process of development.
11. Shall not act in any manner which may injure the reputation of the institution or
whichmay cause any damage to the institution financially or otherwise.
5.6.4. Indian Institute of Material
Management Code of Ethics
1. To consider first the total interest of one’s organization in all transactions without
impairingthe dignity and responsibility to one’s office.
2. To buy without prejudice seeking to obtain the maximum ultimate value for each
rupee ofexpenditure.
3. To subscribe and work for honesty and truth in buying and selling.
4. To denounce all forms and manifestations of commercial bribery and to eschew anti-
socialpractices.
5. To respect one’s obligations and those of one’s organization consistent with good
businesspractice.
5.6.5. Institution of Electronics and Telecommunication
Engineers Code of Ethics
1. A corporate member will, at all times, endeavour to protect the engineering profession
frommisrepresentation and misunderstanding.
2. A corporate member will interact with others in his profession by free exchange of
information and experience. He will contribute to the growth of the institution to
maximum effectivenessto the best of his ability.
3. A corporate member will not offer his professional services by advertisement or
throughany commercial advertising media, or solicit engineering work, trading,
teaching eitherdirectly or indirectly or through agencies/organizations in any manner
derogatory to thedignity of the profession and the institution.
4. A corporate member will not directly or indirectly injure the professional reputation,
work,or practice of another corporate member.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

5. A corporate member will not divulge confidential findings or actions of the council
orcommittee of which he is a member, without obtaining official clearance.
6. A corporate member will not take credit for an activity, professional work,
engineeringproposal when engaged in a team and give due recognition to those where
due.
7. A corporate member will express an opinion only when it is founded on facts and
honestconviction before a forum, court, commission or at an inquiry.
8. A corporate member will exercise due restraint in criticizing the work or professional
conductof another corporate member which would impinge or hurt his character and
reputation.
9. A corporate member will not try to supplant another corporate member in a
particularemployment, office or contract.
10. A corporate member will be upright in all his dealings with person(s), organizations,
inbusiness, contractors, and agencies. He should not take actions that lead to
groupisim, politicalconnotation or unethical conduct in the discharge if his official
powers.
11. A corporate member will not misrepresent his qualification to gain undue advantage
in hisprofession.
12. A corporate member will act with fairness and justice in any office, employment or
contract.
13. A corporate member will not associate in engineering work which does not conform
toethical practices.
14. A corporate member will not compete unfairly with another corporate member by
means,which in the opinion of others, are based on garnering support for personal
gain, enlistinguncalled for sympathy, espousing unjust cases or amounts to use of
unconstitutional methods.
15. A corporate member will act in professional matters as a faithful agent or trustee.
16. A corporate member will not receive remuneration, commission, discount or any
indirectprofit from any work with which he is entrusted, unless specifically so
permitted.
17. A corporate member will not accept financial or other compensation from more than
onesource for the same service or work connected thereto, unless so authorized
18. A corporate member will immediately inform his organisation/institution of any
financialinterest in a business, and engineering work which may compete with,
adversely affect orhamper the growth of parent body.
19. A corporate member will engage or enlist the services of specialist/experts when in
hisjudgement, such services are in the best interest of his employer or to the
profession.
20. A corporate member will endeavour to develop a team among his colleagues and staff
andprovide equal opportunity to them for professional development and advancement.
21. A corporate member will subscribe to the principle of appropriate norms, appreciation
andadequate compensation for those engaged in office, technical and professional
employmentincluding those in subordinate positions.
22. A corporate member, if he considers that another corporate member is guilty of
unethical,illegal, unfair practice, defalcation, will not present such information to the
Council of theInstitution for necessary action, unless armed with substantial proof.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

5.7. Engineers As Consultants

● Consultants are persons who give expert advice in Engineering, business, law etc.
● Consulting engineers generally exercise their consulting activities as independent. The
consulting engineers work in private. There is no salary from the employers. But they
charge fees from the sponsor and they have more freedom to decide on their projects. Still
they have no absolute freedom, because they need to earn for their living. The consulting
engineers have ethical responsibilities different from the salaried engineers, as follows:
1. Advertising
2. Competitive bidding
3. Contingency fees
4. Safety and client needs
5. Provisions for resolution of disputes

1. Advertising
✔ The consulting engineers are directly responsible for advertising their services, even if
they employ other consultants to assist them. But in many organizations, this
responsibility is with the advertising executives and the personnel department.
✔ They are allowed to advertise but to avoid deceptive ones. Deceptive advertising such as
the following are prohibited:
a) By white lies.
b) Half-truth, e.g., a product has actually been tested as prototype, but it was claimed
to havebeen already introduced in the market. An architect shows the photograph
of the completedbuilding with flowering trees around but actually the foundation
of the building has beencompleted and there is no real garden.
c) Exaggerated claims. The consultant might have played a small role in a well-
known project.
d) But they could claim to have played a major role.
e) Making false suggestions. The reduction in cost might have been achieved along
with thereduction in strength, but the strength details are hidden.
f) Through vague wordings or slogans.
2. Competitive Bidding
✔ It means process of offering of prices at an auction or in business, and get
something in return for the service offered. The organizations havea pool of
engineers.
✔ The expertise can be shared and the bidding is made more realistic. But
theindividual consultants have to develop creative designs and build their
reputation steadily and carefully,over a period of time.
✔ The clients will have to choose between the reputed organizations and
provenqualifications of the company and the expertise of the consultants.
Although competent, the youngerconsultants are thus slightly at a disadvantage.
3. Contingency Fee
✔ This is the fee or commission paid to the consultant, when one is successful in saving the
expenses forthe client. A sense of honesty and fairness is required in fixing this fee.
✔ The NSPE Code III saysthat the engineers shall not propose or accept a commission on a
contingent basis where their judgmentmay be compromised.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

✔ The fee may be either as an agreed amount or a fixed percentage of the savings realized.
But inthe contingency fee-agreements, the judgment of the consultant may be biased.
✔ The consultant may betempted to specify inferior materials or design methods to cut the
construction cost. This fee maymotivate the consultants to effect saving in the costs to the
clients, through reasonably moral andtechnological means.
4. Safety and Client’s Needs
✔ The greater freedom for the consulting engineers in decision making on safety aspects,
and difficultiesconcerning truthfulness are the matters to be given attention.
✔ For example, in design-only projects, theconsulting engineers may design something and
have no role in the construction. Sometimes, difficultiesmay crop-up during construction
due to non-availability of suitable materials, some shortcuts inconstruction, and lack of
necessary and adequate supervision and inspection.
✔ Properly-trained supervisionis needed, but may not happen, unless it is provided. Further,
the contractor may not understandand/or be willing to modify the original design to serve
the clients best.
✔ A few on-site inspections by the consulting engineers will expose the deficiency in
execution andsave the workers, the public, and the environment that may be exposed to
risk upon completion of theproject.
✔ The NSPE codes on the advertisement by consultants provide some specific regulations.
Thefollowing are the activities prohibited in advertisement by consultant:
1. The use of statement containing misrepresentation or omission of a necessary fact.
2. Statement intended or likely to create an unjustified expectation.
3. Statement containing prediction of future (probable) success.
4. Statement intended or likely to attract clients, by the use of slogans or sensational
languageformat.
5. Provision of resolution of disputes
✔ Since large engineering projects require responsibilities from different values within
the organization representing owner, the consulting engineer and the construction
company, therefore it is obvious that there may be chances for overlapping
responsibilities, misplaced control, indecision, delays and inability to solve disputes
quickly
✔ Filling litigation cases against consulting engineers has increased considerably
✔ As these cases are time consuming, costly and laborious process, therefore the
consulting engineer should be prepared to have contractual provisions to resolve
conflicts

5.8. Engineers As Expert Witness

✔ Frequently engineers are required to act as consultants and provide expert opinion
and views in manylegal cases of the past events.
o They are required to explain the causes of accidents, malfunctions andother
technological behaviour of structures, machines, and instruments, e.g.,
personal injury whileusing an instrument, defective product, traffic accident,
structure or building collapse, and damage tothe property, are some of the
cases where testimonies are needed. The focus is on the past.
o Public planning, policy making that involves technology.
✔ Usually engineers are hired by one adversary in the dispute. These engineers
releases special ethical concerns
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

✔ It is desired that without becoming hired guns, engineers can function as advocates
for attorneys and their clients, for public officials, or for private organisation that
hire them
5.8.1. Engineers As Expert Witness In The Courts
✔ The dependent in civil or criminal cases may hire an engineer to serve as an
expert witness
✔ Some engineers may serve as experts and some may specialist in forensic
engineering. Forensic engineering means the application of engineering skills
and knowledge in criminal investigation to aid judicial system
✔ Engineers may act as witness in a wide variety of cases such as concerning
defective products, personal injury, damage to properties, traffic accidents and
airplane crashes
✔ Engineer’s evidences are considered seriously while awarding compensatory damages
for injuries, loss of property or violation of rights
✔ The functions of eye-witness vs. expert-witness

5.8.2. Abuses of Engineers As Expert witness

✔ The engineers, who act as expert-witnesses, are likely to abuse their positions in
the following manners:
✔ Hired Guns
o Mostly lawyers hire engineers to serve the interest of their clients. Lawyers
are permitted and requiredto project the case in a way favorable to their
clients. But the engineers have obligations to thoroughlyexamine the events
and demonstrate their professional integrity to testify only the truth in the
court.
o They do not serve the clients of the lawyers directly. The hired guns
forward white lies and distortions,as demanded by the lawyers. They even
withhold the information or shade the fact, to favor theirclients.
✔ Money Bias
o Consultants may be influenced or prejudiced for monitory considerations,
gain reputation and make afortune.
✔ Ego Bias
✔ The assumption that the own side is innocent and the other side is guilty, is
responsible for this behavior.
✔ An inordinate desire to serve one’s client and get name and fame is another reason for
this bias.
✔ Sympathy Bias
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

✔ Sympathy for the victim on the opposite side may upset the testimony. The
integrity of the consultantswill keep these biases away from the justice.
✔ The court also must obtain the balanced view of bothsides, by examining the
expert witnesses of lawyers on both sides, to remove a probable bias.
✔ Duties
1. The expert-witness is required to exhibit the responsibility of confidentiality just as
they doin the consulting roles. They can not divulge the findings of the investigation
to the oppositeside, unless it is required by the court of law.
2. More important is that as witness they are not required to volunteer evidence
favorable to theopponent. They must answer questions truthfully, need not elaborate,
and remain neutraluntil the details are asked for further.
3. They should be objective to discover the truth and communicate them honestly.
4. The stand of the experts depends on the shared understanding created within the
society. Thelegal system should be respected and at the same time, they should act in
conformance withthe professional standards as obtained from the code of ethics.
5. The experts should earnestly be impartial in identifying and interpreting the observed
data,recorded data, and the industrial standards. They should not distort the truth, even
underpressure. Although they are hired by the lawyers, they do not serve the lawyers
or theirclients. They serve the justice. Many a time, their objective judgments will
help the lawyerto put up the best defense for their clients.
5.9. Engineers As Expert Advisors
5.9.1. Advisors In Planning And Policy
Making Advisors
● The engineers are required to give their view on the future such as in planning,
policy- making, whichinvolves the technology. For example, should India expand
nuclear power options or support traditionalenergy sources such as fossil fuels or
alternative forms like solar and wind energy? In the recent past,this topic has created
lot of fireworks, in the national media.
Various issues and requirements for engineers who act as advisors are:
1. Objectivity
The engineers should study the cost and benefits of all possible alternative means in objective
manner,within the specified conditions and assumptions.
2. Study All Aspects
They have to study the economic viability (effectiveness), technical feasibility (efficiency),
operationalfeasibility (skills) and social acceptability, which include environmental and ethical
aspects, beforeformulating the policy.
3. Values
Engineers have to possess the qualities, such as (a) honesty, (b) competence (skills and
expertise),(c) diligence (careful and alert) (d) loyalty in serving the interests of the clients
and maintainingconfidentiality, and (e) public trust, and respect for the common good,
rather than serving only theinterests of the clients or the political interests.
4. Technical Complexity
The arbitrary, unrealistic, and controversial assumptions made during the future planning that
areoverlooked or not verified, will lead to moral complexity. The study on future is full of
uncertaintiesthan the investigations on the past events. On the study of energy options, for
example, assumptions onpopulation increase, life style, urbanization, availability of local fossil
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

resources, projected costs ofgenerating alternative forms of energy, world political scenario,
world military tensions and pressuresfrom world organizations such as World Trade
Organisation (W.T.O.) and European Union (EU) mayincrease the complexity in judgment
on future.
5. National Security
The proposed options should be aimed to strengthen the economy and security of the
nation, besidessafeguarding the natural resources and the environment from exploitation
and degradation.

5.9.2. Normative Models of Advisors

For the advisors on policy making or planning, a shared understanding on balancing the
conflictingresponsibilities, both to the clients and to the public, can be effected by the
following roles or models:
1. Hired Gun
The prime obligation is shown to the clients. The data and facts favourable to the clients are
highlighted,and unfavourable aspects are hidden or treated as insignificant. The minimal level
of interest is shownfor public welfare.
2. Value-neutral Analysts
This assumes an impartial engineer. They exhibit conscientious decisions, impartiality i.e.,
withoutbias, fear or favour, and absence of advocacy.
3. Value-guided Advocates
The consulting engineers remain honest (frank in stating all the relevant facts and
truthful in interpretationof the facts) and autonomous (independent) in judgement and
show paramount importance to thepublic (as different from the hired guns).
5.9.3. Core Qualities Required for an Expert Advisors
According to Rosemarie Tong, an engineer should have following virtues
● Honesty – the quality of being truthfulness
● Competence – the thorough Knowledge of the work they undertake to do
● Diligence – to carry out the given tasks carefully and promptly
● Loyalty – the quality of being true and faithful in one’s support

5.10. Moral Leadership

Engineers provide many types of leadership in the development and implementation of
technology, asmanagers, entrepreneurs, consultants, academics and officials of the
government. Moral leadership isnot merely the dominance by a group. It means adopting
reasonable means to motivate the groups toachieve morally desirable goals. This
leadership presents the engineers with many challenges to theirmoral principles.
5.10.1. Moral creative Leaders
● The success of corporation is to a greater extent is influenced by the quality of leadership
● According to Barnard “Leadership refers to the quality of the behaviour of the
individuals where by, they guide people on their activities in organized effort”
● Moral leadership is essentially required for the engineers, for the reasons listed
as follows:
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

1. It is leading a group of people towards the achievement of global and objectives. The
goalsas well as the means are to be moral. For example, Hitler and Stalin were leaders,
but onlyin an instrumental sense and certainly not on moral sense.
2. The leadership shall direct and motivate the group to move through morally desirable
ways.
3. They lead by thinking ahead in time, and morally creative towards new applications,
extensionand putting values into practice. ‘Morally creative’ means the identification of
the mostimportant values as applicable to the situation, bringing clarity within the groups
throughproper communication, and putting those values into practice.
4. They sustain professional interest, among social diversity and cross-disciplinary
complexity.They contribute to the professional societies, their professions, and to their
communities.
● Moral leaders are those who direct, motivate, organize, manage or in other ways take
groups towards morally valuable goals
● Frederick Taylor, the father of scientific management, have pointed out that engineers
and technologists were best qualified leaders to govern because of their technical
expertise, logical, practical and unprejudiced minds
5.10.2. Participation in professional societies
● Moral leadership within engineering is clearly demonstrated by playing a significant
role in professional bodies like IEEE, ASME, NSPE etc
● The moral leadership in engineering is manifested in leadership within the
professionalsocieties. The professional societies provide a forum for communication,
and canvassing forchange within and by groups.
● Engineers have to resolve the conflicts of interest, disagreement, moral dilemmas and
other issues among themselves through these professional societies
● The engineers have to share the moral activity through these societies
● Engineers as moral leaders can help through these professional societies in sponsoring
ethics workshops, conducting surveys on matters of concern , informing their
members about recent development related to ethics and technology and encouraging
educational institutions to work forward in it
5.10.3. Voluntary services
● In past engineering code of ethics have discouraged voluntarism in the
engineering field. “engineers shall not undertake nor agree to perform any
engineering services on free basis”
● Another important avenue for providing moral leadership within communities,by
the engineers is to promote services without fee or at reduced fees (pro bono) to
theneedy groups.
● The professional societies can also promote such activities among the
engineers.This type of voluntarism (or philanthropy) has been in practice in the
fields of medicine,law and education.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

● But many of the engineers are not self-employed as in the case of physiciansand
lawyers. The business institutions are encouraged to contribute a percentage of
theirservices as free or at concessional rates for charitable purposes.
5.10.4. Community service
This is another platform for the engineers to exhibit their moral leadership.The engineers
an help in guiding, organising, and stimulating the community towardsmorally- and
environmentally-desirable goals. The corporate organizations have come forwardto adopt
villages and execute many social welfare schemes, towards this objective.
The Codes of Ethics promote and sustain the ethical environment and assist in
achieving theethical goals in the following manner:
1. It creates an environment in a profession, where ethical behavior is the basic criterion.
2. It guides and reminds the person as to how to act, in any given situation.
3. It provides support to the individual, who is being pressurized or tortured by a superior
oremployer, to behave unethically.
4. Apart from professional societies, companies and universities have framed their own
codesof ethics, based on the individual circumstances and specific mission of the
organisations.
These codes of conduct help in employees’ awareness of ethical issues, establish, and
nurturea strong corporate ethical culture.
5.11. Corporate Social Responsibility
The term "corporate social responsibility" became popular in the 1960s and has
remained a term used indiscriminately by many to cover legal and moral responsibility more
narrowly construed.[10]
CSR as "A company’s sense of responsibility towards the community and environment (both
ecological and social) in which it operates. Companies express this citizenship (1) through
their waste and pollution reduction processes, (2) by contributing educational and social
programs and
(3) by earning adequate returns on the employed resources."
Scope:
Initially, CSR emphasized the official behavior of individual firms. Later, it expanded to
include supplier behavior and the uses to which products were put and how they were
disposed of after they lost value.
Incidents like the 2013 Savar building collapse pushed companies to consider how the
behavior of their suppliers impacted their overall impact on society. Irresponsible behavior
reflected on both the misbehaving firm, but also on its corporate customers. Supply chain
management expanded to consider the CSR context. Wieland and Handfield (2013)
suggested that companies need to include social responsibility in their reviews of component
quality. They highlighted the use of technology in improving visibility across the supply
chain.
There are a few broad categories of social responsibility that many of today's businesses are
practicing:
1. Environmental efforts: One primary focus of corporate social responsibility is the
environment. Businesses regardless of size have a large carbon footprint. Any steps they can
take to reduce those footprints are considered both good for the company and society as a
whole.
 UNIT V GLOBAL ISSUES

2. Philanthropy: Businesses also practice social responsibility by donating to national and local
charities. Businesses have a lot of resources that can benefit charities and local community
programs.
3. Ethical labor practices: By treating employees fairly and ethically, companies can also
demonstrate their corporate social responsibility. This is especially true of businesses that
operate in international locations with labor laws that differ from those in the United States.
4. Volunteering: Attending volunteer events says a lot about a company's sincerity. By doing
good deeds without expecting anything in return, companies are able to express their concern
for specific issues and support for certain organizations.

Functions:
CSR policy functions as a self-regulatory mechanism whereby a business monitors
and ensures its active compliance with the spirit of the law, ethical standards and national or
international norms. With some models, a firm's implementation of CSR goes beyond
compliance and engages in "actions that appear to further some social good, beyond the
interests of the firm and that which is required by law."
The binary choice between 'complying' with the law and 'going beyond' the law must
be qualified with some nuance. In many areas such as environmental or labor regulations,
employers can choose to comply with the law, to go beyond the law, but they can also choose
to not comply with the law, such as when they deliberately ignore gender equality or the
mandate to hire disabled workers.
There must be a recognition that many so-called 'hard' laws are also 'weak' laws, weak
in the sense that they are poorly enforced, with no or little control and/or no or few sanctions
in case of non-compliance. 'Weak' law must not be confused with Soft law .
The aim is to increase long-term profits and shareholder trust through positive public
relations and high ethical standards to reduce business and legal risk by taking responsibility
for corporate actions. CSR strategies encourage the company to make a positive impact on
the environment and stakeholders including consumers, employees, investors, communities,
and others.