Issue Guide 1
Issue Guide 1
Issue Guide 1
Addicted to Education:
The Power of Knowledge
in Drug Prevention
Deliberation Issue
Guide
INTRODUCTION
The Issue
Drug abuse in America is hardly a niche issue, with how romanticized and
wide scale it currently is it's rare to watch a day of news go by without at least
one drug related headline.
This epidemic of drug abuse has caused damage to communities across the
country. When a community member begins to abuse drugs the impact
extends beyond the user and the burden is shared by everyone. Drugs
abusers can tear apart families, cause strain on the criminal justice system,
and be gateways for greater problems. The epidemic produced a plethora of
shocking statistics that show its true scale and how it has affected many
aspects of the U.S. The opioid and drug crisis has even caused the majority of
students to not be raised by their parents in some counties of West Virginia.
In addition, according to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, a staggering 45% of all
current prisoners that are incarcerated are charged for drug offenses. While
these statistics are shocking in their own right, they don’t mention the 91,799
drug overdose deaths that occurred in 2020, with around 75% of those deaths
being opioid related. Considering the scale of this issue, it's easy to see why
solutions to this crisis have been endlessly debated and deliberated.
Background
Approach Overview
Approach 1
This approach focuses on educating high school students on not only the
dangers of drugs, but also how to be safe regarding drug use. Currently,
students are taught to simply abstain from drugs, but that isn’t a sustainable
method of preventing drug use or abuse. This approach changes that by
suggesting that high school students be exposed to open and honest
conversations regarding drugs.
Approach 2
This approach will focus on educating current drug users and people in rehab
on harm reduction. Some ways to help save drug users lives are teaching and
providing Narcan, fentanyl test strips, clean needles, and more. This education
would focus on opiates more than other types of drugs (such as psychedelics)
since opiates are highly addictive and a drug of choice for many users.
Approach 3
APPROACH 1:
Education of High Schoolers
VALUES: TRANSPARENCY AND DIRECTNESS
Abstinence VS Safety
Most students begin learning about drugs and alcohol in middle school. From
the very beginning, they are told to “just say no”; however, the drug epidemic
cannot be solved with that simple saying. Rather than preaching absolute
abstinence in high school, schools should teach students how to be safe
around substances.
According to The National Center for Drug Abuse Statistics, 62% of high
school seniors have abused alcohol and 50% of all teenagers have misused
drugs at least once in their life. The diagram pictured to the right shows the
breakdown of drug abuse
among college students,
whose abuse is even more
common than high school
students. Because of these
disturbingly high statistics,
school boards should begin
to rethink their current ways
of preventing drug use and
addiction.
As mentioned previously, these types of “just say no” programs don’t solve all
of the problems related to drug use. One way that these programs especially
fall short is by not providing students with the necessary resources to make
6
Implementation
Changes must be made to the material that students are taught in school in
order to appropriately inform them about the risks associated with drug use.
Presently, the Pennsylvania State Academic Standards for Health, Safety, and
Physical Education place more of an emphasis on teaching children how to
avoid dangerous situations and how to refuse to participate in dangerous
activities.
Pros Cons
Students will be exposed to the Parents will most likely be
realities of the drug crisis in a unapproving of this method of
controlled setting. prevention.
Being taught how to use safely will Being taught how to use may
prevent overdoses. encourage students to try drugs.
Since abuse rates increase in college, Not all schools will be comfortable
educating before that may decrease with teaching this.
the rates.
Giving reasons other than “just say Organizations like D.A.R.E. might
no” might be more useful in avoiding fight back against this method of
drug abuse. education.
Framing Questions:
● Should we provide more educational opportunities for teenagers in
high schools to teach drug safety rather than abstinence?
● Will teenagers be more likely to abuse drugs if they are taught how to
use safely in school?
● How can we encourage schools to implement this style of education
into their curriculum?
9
APPROACH 2:
Education of Drug Users
VALUES: SELF RESPECT AND SAFETY
Once a person becomes addicted to a drug, they will struggle to stop using it
despite the harmful effects it may have on them, their families, or their
friends. The continuous use of drugs causes those with SUD to need larger
doses to get the same effects, and, depending on the drug, they will
experience withdrawal symptoms if they go too long without the drug.
Harm Reduction
One common education that is given to people suffering from substance use
disorder is harm reduction education. This type of education focuses on
giving the necessary knowledge to current drug users to provide physical,
mental, and social help to prevent overdose. Many of these organizations
combat substance abuse by designing recovery, prevention, and treatment
pathways based on where users are in their recovery. Harm reduction
education addresses common health and social issues among people with
substance use disorders through policies, programs, and practices.
According to the CDC, there have been over 100,000 overdose deaths from
May 2020 to April 2021, which is a 29% increase from the previous year. Harm
reduction services offer humility and empathy to drug users and addresses
substance use disorder as a learning process.
Figure 2. National Drug Overdoses Through Various Ages and Genders, From
Years 1999 - 2021
With these numerous benefits, many people argue that supplying a safe
space to do drugs promotes further drug usage and leads to an increase in
drug users. When individuals with substance use disorders are criminalized
and stigmatized, it creates a hazardous environment that endangers their
safety. Additionally, it deters them from seeking the necessary assistance and
treatment services, resulting in increased occurrences of overdoses and
transmission of infectious diseases.
Implementation
Pros Cons
Abstinence only may not be realistic Teaching harm reduction may cause
for some people with addiction, but some people with addiction to
reducing drug use could be. continue using when they otherwise
may have quit.
Framing Questions:
● To what extent will harm reduction benefit drug users?
○ Do you think it can also be implemented with educating family
and friends of users?
● How can we realistically integrate harm reduction strategies into the
daily routines of individuals who are hesitant to seek treatment for their
substance use disorders?
○ How do we advertise?
● How do we make harm reduction education and services more
approachable?
13
APPROACH 3:
Education of the Public
VALUES: COMMUNITY AND PROGRESS
Public Education
Programs
Drug abuse violations constitute the majority of public order arrests in the
United States. In 2020, 1,155,610 arrests were made for drug law violations;
1,001,913 of those were related to drug possession alone.
Legalization allows the crisis to be handled through the public health system.
This means that the public’s money goes to rehabilitation programs as
opposed to incarceration, therefore putting less strain on the criminal justice
system. On the other hand, decriminalization focuses on harm reduction.
While no criminal penalties are faced for drug use or abuse, users are subject
to civil penalties. Civil penalties typically result in a fine or drug education
and/or treatment.
15
Effect of Media
The tobacco industry has
been known to target
the public, and some
argue that the alcohol
industry does the same
by paying for their
products to be shown in
movies, TV shows, and
books. Young people are
especially influenced by
the media because they
care a lot about how they
look and who they are. This makes them more likely to be influenced by flashy
or exciting things like animations, quick camera cuts, and loud music. The
exact same way, some media portrayals of drugs can glamorize drug use,
making it appear exciting or cool. There are some steps that can be taken to
deal with this issue, including:
Implementation
There are many ways to implement drug education. With the purpose of
educating parents and educators on drug misuse prevention, early
intervention, and treatment, workshops can be held. As a result of legislative
laws that can be implemented, drug education can be taught in the
workplace. This ensures that every adult receives the same amount of
information about drugs, their consequences, and measures to avoid drug
misuse. Drug education campaigns might be subsidized by policies. This
ensures that programs have adequate resources and can reach the greatest
number of people. Policies encouraging collaboration among healthcare
providers, community organizations, and educational institutions can be
implemented. As a result, drug education might adopt a more collaborative
and effective prevention strategy. Authorities can explore legalizing or
decriminalizing specific drugs to reduce the negative consequences of drug
use, such as overdose deaths and drug user imprisonment. Agencies can
work with other countries to tackle international drug trafficking and
demand. It should be highlighted that no single strategy is guaranteed to be
beneficial, and that when it comes to legalization or decriminalization, a
combination of strategies may be required to minimize drug usage and its
associated repercussions.
Pros Cons
Framing Questions
● How can the general public receive accurate and current information
on drugs? What role does it play in effective drug education?
● What are some major drug education program examples from
throughout the globe, and what can be inferred from their execution?
● Is it ethical to use fear tactics in drug education campaigns, such as
graphic images or scare stories, to deter people from using drugs?
● Is it fair to customize drug education programs to specific populations,
such as minority communities, or does this risk perpetuating
stereotypes or discrimination?
18
Conclusion
Multiple Approaches
There are multiple options on how to tackle the issue, but what is most
important is that action is taken. As learned in the first approach, many U.S
high school students will encounter illicit drugs during their high school
years. Despite the best intentions and hard work of those educating high
school students about the ills of drugs, Substance Use Disorder is still
extremely prevalent in this country.
In the first approach, when it comes to drug and alcohol education in schools,
many programs rely on a "just say no" approach that emphasizes abstinence
above all else. However, with over half of high school seniors and half of all
teenagers having misused drugs or alcohol at least once, this approach may
not be enough to effectively prevent substance abuse. Programs such as
DARE have been criticized for not providing practical resources to help
students make safe decisions around drugs and for causing some students to
become wary and dismissive of adult warnings. Instead, some organizations
are adopting a harm reduction approach that supplements traditional drug
education with strategies for reducing risk and staying safe. For example, the
Drug Policy Alliance's "Safety First: Real Drug Education for Teens" program
teaches students how to recognize and respond to drug-related emergencies,
avoid laced drugs, and access resources for mental health issues. While some
may object to this approach, arguing that it may encourage drug use, harm
reduction advocates believe that providing students with the knowledge and
tools to stay safe is a more effective way to combat drug addiction.
In the third and final approach, public education programs, such as those
offered by the FDA, were shown to be a powerful tool to raise awareness
about the effects of drug abuse. Community-based naloxone programs are a
valuable tool in reversing opioid overdoses, and increasing access to naloxone
through various channels can help save lives. Legalization and
decriminalization offer distinct approaches to addressing drug abuse, with
legalization prioritizing rehabilitation programs and decriminalization
emphasizing harm reduction strategies. However, drug education campaigns
may unintentionally promote drug use by glamourising or sensationalizing it,
and inaccurate or outdated information may lead to misunderstandings.
Despite this, drug education can help prevent drug abuse, reduce stigma,
and break stereotypes about addiction.
20
Works Cited
Introduction and Conclusion
Blackford, Meghan. “‘Just Say No’ and the D.A.R.E Program.” FHE Health –
Addiction & Mental Health Care, 8 June 2015,
https://fherehab.com/news/just-say-no-and-the-d-a-r-e-program/.
“Death Rate Maps & Graphs.” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2 June 2022,
https://www.cdc.gov/drugoverdose/deaths/index.html.
Young, Graham. “About the 1980's Just Say No Campaign.” Paz Packs, 1
Feb. 2022,
https://pazpacks.com/blogs/blogposts/about-the-1980s-just-say-no-
campaign.
21
Approach 1
Academic Standards for Science and Technology - State Board of
Education. The Pennsylvania Department of Education, 18 July
2002,
https://www.stateboard.education.pa.gov/Documents/Regulations
%20and%20Statements/State%20Academic%20Standards/Science
andTechnologyStandards.pdf.
“Safety First: Real Drug Education for Teens.” Drug Policy Alliance, 8 Oct.
2019,
https://drugpolicy.org/resource/safety-first-real-drug-education-tee
ns.
“Teenage Drug Use Statistics [2023]: Data & Trends on Abuse.” NCDAS, 1
Jan. 2023, https://drugabusestatistics.org/teen-drug-use/.
“Top 10 Reasons to Say No to Drugs Poster.” The Bureau for At-Risk Youth,
https://www.at-risk.com/products/top-10-reasons-to-say-no-to-drug
s-poster.
22
Approach 2
“Alcohol and Drug Abuse Statistics (Facts about Addiction).” American
Addiction Centers, 21 Oct. 2022,
https://americanaddictioncenters.org/rehab-guide/addiction-stati
stics.
Lipari, Rachel N., et al. “America's Need for and Receipt of Substance
Use Treatment in 2015.” SAMHSA, 29 Sept. 2016,
https://www.samhsa.gov/data/sites/default/files/report_2716/Short
Report-2716.html.
Approach 3
“Addiction Myths vs. Facts.” Www.shatterproof.org,
www.shatterproof.org/learn/addiction-basics/myths-versus-facts.
“Advocacy about Drugs | 5 Major Drug Advocacy and Use Policy Groups.”
Alleva, 5 June 2017,
helloalleva.com/5-major-drug-use-policy-and-advocacy-groups.