Experience of Managers Upon Handling Neurodiverse Employees
Experience of Managers Upon Handling Neurodiverse Employees
Experience of Managers Upon Handling Neurodiverse Employees
Abstract: The intent of this research is to unfold managers’ and driven by a particularly unique set of forces (Alton,
experiences in handling neurodiverse employees. Managers who 2020). Any manager, or aspiring manager, must understand
help their employees succeed in the organization have how to deal with employees efficiently. Employee
tremendous accomplishments, but among all the tasks that engagement is dependent on relationships with managers and
manager must perform, managing people is by far the most
challenging as each employee is different, unforeseen, and driven
employees (Martic, 2019). You are accountable for the
by the own set of forces. Proponents used a qualitative research improvement of your employees, there will still be challenges
method specifically narrative inquiry and conducted an in-depth or difficult moments along the way. In fact, in 2019, 79% of
interview with semi-structured questions. The following themes employees said they were disengaged from their jobs (Wooll,
revealed in this study are (1) manager’s knowledge and 2021). “Challenge” is a situation to face an obstacle to
involvement in neurodivergent employees at work, (2) overcome and achieve a goal that needs significant effort to be
acknowledging the challenges faced by the managers in handling done successfully and assess the person’s ability (Cambridge
neurodiverse employees, (3) strategies of managers in dealing Dictionary, n.d). If applied to the workplace, it is a problem
with neurodivergent employees, and (4) the influence of that keeps you from achieving success in the workplace or
manager’s positive approach in the welfare of neurodiverse
employees. Therefore, it is concluded that managers have little to
career where even new or seasoned employees face challenges
no challenges in handling neurodiverse employees. Moreover, at work.
these types of employees are above average people in terms of According to Indeed Editorial Team (2021), there are twelve
performance but lack emotional control that leads to anger and
common management challenges and the researchers decided
frustration. In the perspective of the following participants, there
is no perfect strategy in handling neurodiverse employees.
to narrow them down to three which are; performance,
Managers must be diversified and versatile in handling these coordination, and leadership. Pulakos & O’Leary (2011)
types of employees and use strategies that fit in with their needs. explain that employees can’t assume that their managers can
This study was assessed and completed that allows managers, read their minds and need to start a conversation about their
especially the human resource management, to get an performances whenever they meet obstacles or wanted to
informative approach in neurodiverse employees. know about the managers’ opinion. Pulakos & O’Leary
Keywords: strategies/approaches, neurodiversity, leadership, believe that educating both managers and employees about
workplace, condition how performance management plays a significant role in
maximizing performance.
I. INTRODUCTION
Vasilescu (2019) said that leadership influences people
term of neurodiversity in 1990. Neurodiversity is an umbrella study is to create a narrative based on the participant’s
term that refers to individuals with different neurological experiences upon handling neurodiverse employees.
conditions, namely dyscalculia, dyslexia, autism, attention
Manager's Culture and Climate in Workplace
deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and other brain
functions (Disabled World, 2021) or people with diverse ways Patrick and Kumar (2012) state that understanding and
of thinking. The social model of disability influences that appreciating the interdependence of the natural environment,
advocates are adopting this principle would benefit society by humanity, and culture is involved in the conscious practices of
recognizing the talents of these neurodiverse individuals diversity. Managers must adhere to organizational culture
rather than pathologizing them for their weaknesses (Doyle, because it is vital for the growth and success of the
2020). organization (Griffin & Moorhead, 2013). People's feelings
and emotions related to their work environment are referred to
They have a higher probability of being underemployed or
as "climate." Many individuals mix up climate with culture,
unemployed than the wider population which was individuals
believing that climate cannot be handled because it is too
with a common neurological function or development or
broad and set in the organization. The climate is measurable
neurotypicals, Day-Duro et al., 2018 who takes up most
and much flexible to shape, while culture stresses an
employees (Loiacono, 2018) due to the stigma and prejudice
organization's unstated beliefs, which can be more difficult to
of psychiatric disabilities that becomes one of the main factors
change. Great managers understand that the climate can be
of the low prevalence of people with psychiatric conditions
transformed and making proper changes can turn employees
Kosyluk et al., 2013. Though, it does not mean that the talents
from fear to confidence and from isolation to connection. A
and potential of the neurodivergent should be ignored since
positive work environment does not always imply more
some neurodivergent have specific skills that could contribute
enjoyment or leisure; it means setting up conditions in which
to success and show a competitive advantage to an
workers feel productive and extraordinary (Freifeld, 2012).
organization (Brinzea, 2019).
Managers serve as a link between the vision of leadership and
Various theories have been led to the experiences of managers
the harsh realities of the front lines. They are often the most
in the workplace. In the perspective of Situational Leadership
dedicated workers, as well as your greatest critics, offering
Theory, this study tries to understand the experiences and
valuable feedback that propels the company ahead while
challenges of managers in handling employees. In relation to
avoiding barriers and blind alleys. Managers support their
the rationale of this study, this will serve as a basis to unfold
leaders in making better decisions, while also educating
the experiences of managers and to know what approaches
employees about organizational dynamics and making them
managers will take, especially the Human Resource
feel like important contributions to an essential goal. (Wigert
Management (HRM) could apply in handling neurodiverse
& Maese, 2019)
employees. The theory of Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard
(1997) which is Situational Leadership aims to find different Factors that affect Manager's Performance
managers' approaches toward their staff. In this theory, leaders
are evaluated in terms of their leadership styles based on their The main reason to employ a manager is to help the
team members' situations and developmental stages. This organization to achieve its goals as part of the manager’s
responsibility is to make their employees act both effectively
notion will aid them in successfully adjusting to their work
and efficiently. According to Purnama (2014) that the
environment and the people they supervise. (Wolf, 2021). It is
manager’s performance includes four characteristics such as
the manager’s responsibility to oversee the success and
manage their employees (Perkbox, 2021) and to know how to knowledge, skills, emotional maturity, and attitude which she
find and address the challenges of supervising the teams that concluded are the qualities that managers need to perform
their responsibilities. In addition, Aini (2018) study implies
are often facing difficulties in productivity and
the model of competency-performance showed that the role of
communications (Indeed Editorial Team, 2021).
organizational culture, leadership, commitment, and
Hence, dealing with neurodiversity in an organization is more competence improves the manager’s motivation. With the
complex and requires careful planning and assessment. In lack of management theories to apply, Hosmer-Jolley (2018)
other words, Human Resource Management (HRM) personnel believes that it limits managers from familiarizing themselves
face many challenges in handling neurodiversity employees with an effective behavior to lead their employees to do their
(Austin & Pisano, 2017). Practices that support their workers best at work and without enough knowledge it results using
to fulfill their potential rather than approaches that do not the wrong approach that decreases productivity.
consider the advantages that each employee can contribute are
The Emergence of Neurodiverse Employees
beneficial for all staff, especially the neurodivergent. (Bewley
& George, 2016). Based on reports from the World Report on Disability shows
There is a paucity of research on how managers should 15% of the world’s population has some sort of disability
(The World Bank & World Health Organization, 2011). A
approach dealing with neurodiverse employees in the
billion people around the world have some form of disability
Philippines. Proponents assume that it is significant when
and neurodivergent takes up over 10% of the population. 1 in
viewed in this manner. Therefore, the primary goal of this
68 people are diagnosed with Autism (ASD) and in the workplace is unpleasant at the current company. (Siddiqui,
Philippines. It is estimated that 1 in 500 Filipinos total 2014).
population has autism spectrum disorder (Autism Care Act,
Managers have an overall performance of an organization,
2017).
which is likely the most significant of any role in the
The decline in employment of individuals with disabilities, workplace. Managers have the greatest potential for having an
like other minorities, is due to the prejudice from supervisors immediate impact on how they handle the employees under
and coworkers, affecting their work experiences and skill their direct supervision. They are tasked with the duty of
development. A Danish software executive, Thorkil Sonne, guaranteeing that the achievements of both their department
encourages companies to employ disabled people out of a and the personnel working within it are in line with the overall
sense of goodwill. As 75% of his workers are people with goals of the company. So, managers and the employees are
Asperger’s syndrome, and some other form of ASD. Society the ones who play an extremely key part in the formation of
has slowly begun to accept neurodiversity. However, Balilan the company's culture (Foster, 2017).
(2019) said that the society's perception in neurodiverse is still
It is crucial for both the company and the individual that
a mixture of both positive and negative due to the
managers and employees are engaged. The provisions of
misconceptions about them.
contract agreements could be used by employees to obstruct
There are positive perceptions about neurodivergent the manager's position has gotten more challenging in terms of
individuals, and the most common belief is that they are defining which organizational cultures to adapt to and which
incredibly gifted where they excel in specific fields to prevent the company's aims from being met. Any
(Maddocks & Hughes, 2019). Organizations should establish successful company needs executives that can take advantage
new norms and encourage HRM to design and adjust their of employee engagement efforts. (Hammoud, 2017).
practices if they want to provide support to neurodivergent Employees are the ones who are directly accountable for
employees and applicants. Human resource management carrying out an organization's goal, which is one of the
practices are often catered for the neurotypicals, it is primary reasons why employees are so vital to the success of a
suggested that the organization has a foundation that supports company (Peek, 2022).
neurodiversity and their inclusion in the workplace (Valpone
II. METHODS
et al., 2022).
This study used a qualitative research design specifically the
The Struggles of Managers in Handling Neurodiverse
narrative inquiry as it gives an opportunity to allow
Employees
participants to express themselves freely and publicly (Austin,
Managers must be prepared to respond to the specific Zubin; Sutton & Jane, 2014), allows researchers to understand
challenges that Neurodiverse Employees bring to the how participants create stories using a narrative structure
workplace. This includes management of time, interacting based on their own experiences (Limpaecher, 2022) and
well with people around, committing careless errors, eventually to interpret them and any resulting themes to aid in
impetuous actions, mood swings and antisocial actions (Pitts, understanding the topic being examined (Sargeant, 2012).
Mangle, & Asherson, 2015). Managers are sometimes hesitant
Researchers conduct an in-depth interview with semi-
to engage with neurodiverse staff, not because they believe
structured questions to gather information that goes beyond
they are less talented or intelligent, but because they are
the initial answers and answers on a more superficial level
unsure how to speak with them. “Can they ask questions about
(Macfarlan, 2020) and allowing the interviewer to make up
a person’s disability?”, “Will they be labeled as ignorant,
follow-up questions in response to the participant’s answers
mean or ‘politically incorrect’ if they do?”, “What happens if
(from Hardon, Rubin & Rubin, Polit & Beck [as referenced in
a neurodivergent employee is insulted by the question?”,
Kallio et al., 2016]) and giving them a room to express
“What questions are managers legally prohibited from
themselves verbally (RWJF, 2008).
asking?”. Many managers ask themselves these critical
questions but are often afraid to ask (Loiacono, 2018). They This study's participants are the managers who handle
occasionally assert that taking part in programs to promote neurodiverse employees selected using the purposive
neurodiversity at work "improves them as managers." (Austin sampling method due to the limited mobility of the
& Pisano, 2017). Employers may find it challenging to know researchers in this time of pandemic.
how to best recruit and support mental health service users
Saturation is referred to as the golden standard or the rule that
within their organizations due to the ambiguous legal status
influences the size of the purposive sample and it was used to
(Wheat et al., 2010).
discontinue the collection of data when it is figured out that
Handling Employees is Pivotal for Organizational Success there are no more other data gathered from the participants
(Saunders, et al., 2017).
Finding the cultures that their firms ought to adopt and those
that they ought to reject has become more difficult for Participants are the three (3) managers from the companies of
managers to undertake. There is a risk that an employee will selected cities in the National Capital Region (NCR),
switch companies in quest of a better work environment if the
particularly in Quezon City and Manila that meet these the two participants, the issues fall into the superior’s end.
following criteria: These superiors who were handling these neurodiverse
employees needed to be more knowledgeable and empathic on
• Currently employed in any company within the NCR handling these types of employees. On the other hand, all
• At least at the age of 20 to 60 years old participants said that they are above average when it comes to
• Have at least two (2) years of working experience as performance level. However, P1 and P3 added that usually
a manager neurodiverse employees lack emotional control and are prone
• Have at least six (6) months of working experience in to anger and frustration.
handling neurodivergent employees
• The participants are open to any gender. Austin & Pisano (2017) said that managing the stress of
neurodiverse staff is another difficulty and to keep everything
The instruments used in the study before the collection of data under control you must keep them under their feet, you must
were interview guide questionnaires, audio and video record, gently help them and make them aware by explaining to them
and transcription prepared by researchers has Ethical where these emptions came from or how to release it.
Consideration and Informed Consent approved by the Branch Managers must be quick in responding and resolving the
Research Ethics Board (BREB) of PUPQC given and signed situation so that it will not escalate.
by the participants.
Despite the difficult features associated with various kinds of
The data collected on the in-depth online interview, neurodivergence, it is vital to recognize that they also have
particularly in “Google Meet” focuses on the experiences of beneficial traits such as hyperfocus, tenacity, visual-spatial,
managers in handling neurodiverse employees. This online loyalty, lateral thinking, creativity, and more. However, not all
interview happened in June 2022. neurodivergent people are gifted, but they all have strengths
In data analyzation, proponents included the procedure of and unique combinations of qualities linked with their
transcription, familiarization with the interview, coding, and illnesses (Bewley & George, 2016).
thematic analysis. Transcription, coding, and thematic Theme 3: The Influence of Manager’s Positive Approach on
analysis are used for analyzing the information gathered Welfare of Neurodiverse Employees
through interviews to extract the participants’ leadership
approaches toward their neurodiverse employees. The This is encouraging to hear through interviews among the
questions that are asked during the interview reflect the participants’ answers that they use a positive approach at work
Situational Leadership Theory, which evaluates the manager’s on handling neurodiverse employees. It is also notable that
leadership styles based on situations and developmental they care for the welfare of these types of employees, boosting
stages. Thematic analysis was used for interpreting and their morale and ending discrimination present at the
finding the repeated patterns found in the experiences of the workplace. The participants are really devoted to promoting a
participants (Braun & Clarke, 2006). positive environment and it is important to acknowledge the
power of influence that a manager could bring forth for the
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION betterment of the workplace.
Theme 1: The Manager’s Knowledge and Involvement in Whether they are aware of it or not, managers have a lot of
Neurodiverse Employees at Work influence especially their behavior over the employee under
This theme tackles the overall knowledge and involvement of their care. In addition to helping workers understand and
the three (3) participants who are managers. It is notable to appreciate their value within the team and company, they can
see that these participants have enough knowledge and more decide career advancement, and development possibilities
than a year of involvement in handling neurodiverse (Knuth, 2022).
employees. P1 stated that neurodiverse refers to someone who Managers taking regards of a clear understanding of their
acts differently from the majority. P2, however, said that employee’s conditions and effective interaction guidelines can
neurodiversity is not profound and there are times that their have a positive effect in the employee, industry, and in the
attitudes cannot be controlled so managers should let organization (Holley-Jolley, 2018). Managers who had gone
themselves be more involved in the matter. through proper training allows them to recognize and use their
It also affirms the statement of Indeed Editorial Team, 2019 neurodiverse employees’ strength and allow them to
that great managers have the ability and knowledge to help understand what to expect from them, in terms of needing to
their employees whatever the situation, especially when make accommodations and differentiation of management
dealing with neurodiverse employees. styles, thus resulting in new ways for support and better
productivity as well as creating a better environment where
Theme 2: Acknowledging the Challenges Faced by the employees and managers can have an open conversation
Managers in Handling Neurodiverse Employees (Orduna, 2019; Austin & Pisano, 2017; Loiacono & Ren,
This theme pointed out that there are little to no challenges at 2018).
all in handling neurodiverse employees. In fact, according to
Participants also mentioned being diversified and versatile in Managers may find it time-consuming and distracting to
handling these types of employees, using a strategy that fits in understand and value people with neurodivergent problems at
with their needs or to what is needed. We must look for a work, as well as adapting their leadership style to each
strategy that could fit in with the types of personality because employee's demands, caused by the failure to apply their
this is important that one strategy may not apply to the rest of abilities and comprehend strategies. (Hosmer Jolley, 2018)
the employees or to everybody. So, we must use mixed or which is why it’s crucial to educate future managers about
different strategies. such conditions to guarantee that they do not contribute to the
emerging cycle of ignorance or inability to be supportive
The action that needs to be taken to help neurodiverse (Coetzer, 2016). In addition, Ortiz (2020) said that industry
employees or coworkers is to educate oneself on the minor leaders claimed that the initiative to reform human processes
adjustments every worker can make to the working so that neurodiverse skills are accessible is producing better
environment to make it more approachable and accessible for managers because of their increased dedication to using all
everyone (Meehan, 2020). Seek someone different from you their employees' talents and having immense sensitivity to
when you are managing and recruiting employees since they individual needs. Overall, managers can benefit from more
will give you a broader and more developed feel of the knowledge, and employees benefit from more training
environment you are working in. (Austin & Pisano. 2017) (Knows & Styles, 2020).
The findings under this theme suggest that a manager can use IV. CONCLUSION
strategies to deal with employees who have neurodivergent
conditions. As a result, the Theory of Situational Leadership Handling employees that have neurodivergence condition in
developed by Ken Blanchard and Paul Hersey (1977), can be an organization is not a snap of a finger. First, there will be
used in knowing the best approach they can do to deal with adjustments to be made not only by their superior but also by
different performances and behaviors of neurodivergent the other employees around the workplace to meet their needs.
employees as the theory itself is all about the manager being It takes time but with frequent discussions, training and
flexible in adapting their strategy based on their employees’ mentoring by a manager, eventually all employees within the
needs (Rabarison, 2013). company will understand and help them out to cope up with
their emotions, adapt to their work environment, perform
ordinary tasks, and interact with ordinary people.
This study particularly focused on experiences of managers on
handling neurodiverse employees manage to get the
standpoint of the participants successfully creating a narrative [6] Cockayne, A. (2019). An examination of the experiences of line
managers who manage employees with Asperger syndrome,
on how managers handle these types of employees. This
exploring how these are shaped by contemporary HRM policies.
research also shows different stories on how managers Retrieved from
identify neurodiverse employees, facing different challenges http://irep.ntu.ac.uk/id/eprint/37628/1/Final%20Thesis%20Anne%
and how to overcome them. Furthermore, the participant's 20Cockayne.pdf
[7] Coetzer, G.H. (2016.) Researching Autism Spectrum Disorder in
experiences revealed that these different strategies were useful
the Workplace: Lessons Learned from Researching the
in handling neurodiverse employees. Relationship between Adult Attention Deficit Disorder and
Organizational Behavior. Retrieved from
It is also notable that the following participants have more http://gebrc.nccu.edu.tw/JBM/pdf/volume/2201/JBM-vol-2201.pdf
than a year of experience and enough knowledge of how to [8] Kallio, H, Pietila, A, Johnson, M and Kangasniemi, M (2016)
handle these types of employees. This gives space to Systematic methodological review: developing a framework for a
managers, especially human resource management, to acquire qualitative semi-structured interview guide Retrieved from
https://usir.salford.ac.uk/id/eprint/39197/1/jan13031
an informative approach in neurodiverse employees. [9] Hosmer-Jolley, J. (2018). Understanding the Needs of
Neurodiverse Employees in the Workplace. Retrieved from
This research also shows that neurodiverse employees are the https://www.proquest.com/docview/2090790089?fromopenview=t
above average in terms of performance level but lack control rue&pq-origsite=gscholar
of their emotional ability making them prone to anger and [10] Indeed Editorial Team. (2022). 12 common management
frustration. The participants also discuss that the only challenges and how to overcome them. Retrieved from
https://www.indeed.com/career-
challenges they face are in how their colleagues treat these advice/careerhttps://www.indeed.com/career-advice/career-
types of employees. There are lots of reflections in this study development/management-challengesdevelopment/management-
that neurodivergent employees are not that hard to handle. challenges
[11] Knowles, L. & Styles, J. (2020). From Academia to Industry: C-
Moreover, the following participants agree that managers Suite Contributors to Perspectives on Neurodiversity in the
should create a positive environment, influencing the Workplace. Retrieved from
workplace whilst preventing discrimination. Yet there is “no https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jason-
Styles/publication/339004745_From_Academia_to_Industry_C-
perfect fit for all” strategy in handling them, it is just a matter Suite_Contributors_to_Perspectives_on_Neurodiversity_in_the_W
of how their managers are trained and knowledgeable to find orkplace/links/5fc9a89ca6fdcc697bdb84c8/From-Academia-to-
an effective approach and strategy to manage them. Industry-C-Suite-Contributors-to-Perspectives-on-Neurodiversity-
in-the-Workplace.pdf
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS [12] Knuth, S. (2022) How open managers can talk to neurodivergent
teammates about performance Retrieved from
The authors of this research would like to emphasize their https://opensource.com/open-organization/22/1/open-managers-
deepest gratitude to their thesis adviser Prof. Sheryl R. neurodiversity-performance
[13] Krzeminska, A., Austin, R. D., Bruyère, S. M., & Hedley, D.
Morales who guided the researchers in this project. We would
(2019). The advantages and challenges of neurodiversity
also like to acknowledge the time and effort of the participants employment in organizations. Journal of Management &
who partake in this study. The authors would like to give Organization, 25(4), 453-463. Retrieved from
special thanks to the help and reinforcement provided by Mr. https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-
core/content/view/E00D823A30F04CA4EA502014329C1CE9/S1
Erickson Raquiño. Moreover, they would like to thank their 833367219000580a.pdf/div-class-title-the-advantages-and-
families and friends who constantly gave support and challenges-of-neurodiversity-employment-in-organizations-div.pdf
understanding during this study. Lastly, to the Almighty God [14] Limpaecher, A. (2022). What is narrative analysis in qualitative
that always give guidance, strength, knowledge and wisdom research? Delve. Retrieved from
https://delvetool.com/blog/narrativeanalysis
to the researchers. [15] Loiacono, E., & Ren, H. (2018) Building a Neurodiverse High-
REFERENCES tech Workforce. Retrieved from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329458841_Building_a_
[1] Austin, R., & Pisano, G. (2017) Neurodiversity as a Competitive Neurodiverse_High-
Advantage Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2017/05/neurodiversity- tech_Workforce?fbclid=IwAR0CkKRBwca5QG65dLCCTGsBFX
as-a-competitive-advantage99 WGLCp0rIvvnWlTJxeywg8ky-jWAd30TBo
[2] Austin, Zubin; Sutton, Jane (2014). Qualitative Research: Getting [16] Macfarlan, A. (2020) In-depth Interviews Retrieved from
Started. The Canadian Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 67(6), –. https://www.betterevaluation.org/en/evaluation-options/in-
doi:10.4212/cjhp.v67i6.1406 depth_interviews
[3] Balcik, B., Beamon, B. M., Krejci, C. C., Muramatsu, K. M., & [17] Martic, K. (2021, June 11). 10 reasons why your employees are
Ramirez, M. (2010). Coordination in humanitarian relief chains: disengaged at work. Semos Cloud. Retrieved from
Practices, challenges and opportunities. Retrieved from https://semoscloud.com/10https://semoscloud.com/10-reasons-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2009.09.008 why-your-employees-are-disengaged-at-work/reasons-why-your-
[4] Bewley, H. & George, A. (2016). Neurodiversity at work. employees-are-disengaged-athttps://semosclou d.com/10-reasons-
Retrieved from https://www.tourettes- why-your-employees-are-disengaged-at-work/work/
action.org.uk/storage/downloads/1482243777_Neurodiversity_at_ [18] Meehan, L. (2020) How Neurodiversity in the workplace can help
work_0916-(1).pdf business Retrieved from https://www.cpl.com/blog/2020/05/what-
[5] Braun, V & Clarke V. (2006) Using thematic analysis in is-neurodiversity-and-how-does-it-benefit-
psychology Retrieved from business?source=google.co.uk
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235356393_Using_them [19] Oesch, T. (2020). Autism at work: Hiring and training employees
atic_analysis_in_psychology on the spectrum. SHRM. Retrieved from
https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/behavioral-