English Education &

Applied Linguistics
Journal

POLITENESS STRATEGIES USED BY STUDENTS IN

CLASSROOM INTERACTION
Muhamad Luthfi

Institut Pendidikan Indonesia Abstract.

Garut, West Java, Indonesia In education, such as classroom teaching and learning,
Email: Luthfiiix@gmail.com politeness is very important. Students communicate
with the teacher during the teaching and learning
Article History process using various sayings that demonstrate
Submitted 15 July 2022 politeness strategies. Considering politeness consists of
Revised 1 August 2022 methods to create appropriate politeness in
Published 19 August 2022 communication between students and teachers. But
when students use politeness strategies in giving
feedback on the teacher's response, not all students can
know a good speech. Therefore, this study was
conducted to determine the politeness strategies used
by students and teachers for classroom interaction.
There are four politeness strategies based on Brown
and Levinson's theory. There are bald on record, off
record, positive politeness, and negative politeness.
Researcher used qualitative descriptive methods to
describe the results. The participants of this study were
students and teachers in English classes. Researcher
used two research instruments, namely interviews and
observations. The Data were analyzed by undergoing
several processes such as reading, analyzing,
interpreting, and inferring. The results showed that the
most dominant politeness strategy used by students is
positive politeness. Thus, this study is expected to
contribute to students choosing the suitability of
politeness strategies when classed.

Keywords: politeness strategies, classroom

interaction, bald on record, off record

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 128
INTRODUCTION
Humans communicate in order to send messages and form social bonds. People require
a medium, typically language, to undertake social contact. Language is a means of
communication between people (Nurmawati & Weda, 2019). When communicating with
others, one must consider the politeness approach because it appears to be a key idea
and a necessary part of interpersonal communication, including communication between
teachers and pupils in a classroom (Heriyawati et al., 2019). Politeness is a broad phrase
that refers to language standards in everyday communication.

Politeness is a pervasive social phenomenon seen as a moral standard in human

communication and social relationships. It is one of the most fundamental aspects of
human contact (Lestari et al., 2018). In education, such as classroom teaching and
learning, politeness is vital. During the teaching and learning process, the instructor
communicates with the pupils using a variety of utterances that demonstrate a politeness
strategy. Considering politeness consists of a strategy to make politeness appropriate in
communication among students and teachers (Purandina et al., 2014).

However, until this point, students might not necessarily act in an impolite manner to be
rude, and they may not have a strategic purpose in mind when doing so. Even though
they are in a school setting, kids occasionally act solely on their thoughts (Purnomo,
2019). Disrespectful behaviour in class or among students is described as disrespectful
comments or acts that disturb the learning environment (Yrisarry et al., 2019). In
classrooms, uncivilized behaviour is becoming more widespread. This type of behaviour
is frustrating for the instructor and can also be detrimental to the other students in the
class. In other words, many pupils can still not conduct themselves appropriately in class.

In relation to this, many studies have been conducted. Some of them focus on classroom
interaction by the teacher (Heriyawati et al., 2019)(Darong, Kadarisman, & Basthomi,
2020), (Purandina et al., 2014). Examining the manners of courtesy employed by male
and female educators (Ningrum et al., 2018), (Lestari et al., 2018). And analyze the
implications of using politeness strategies in teaching and learning (Risal & Tambunan,
2021).

Following the lines of the research, the present study attempts to extend the scope of
politeness research by investigating the politeness strategies used by the English
students when joining some feedback sessions with their teachers. The results of the
research are expected to shed light on the literature of politeness in the context of EFL
learning.

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 129
LITERATURE REVIEW
A language is a communication tool that helps people speak with one another and define
their goals to continue interacting and presenting new ideas (Marpaung, 2019).
Language, society, and culture are inextricably linked terms that cannot be separated or
ignored. It has long been a source of fascination and debate among sociolinguists, both
in the past and now (Ningrum et al., 2018). Pragmatic understanding refers to the
capacity to utilize language appropriately. Pragmatic knowledge is the ability of language
users to match utterances to contexts in which they are appropriate. Pragmatics consists
of several scopes, one of which is politeness (Purnomo, 2019).

Politeness is viewed as a language representation of saving someone's face during

transmission regarding its coverage (Darong et al., 2020). In any language, being nice is a
difficult task. It is challenging to learn because it requires knowledge of the language and
the community's social and cultural values. Two types of speech are commonly employed
in communication and daily conversation: polite and everyday speech. In general, polite
speech is utilized in social circumstances such as conversations between strangers or
acquaintances (Nurmawati & Weda, 2019).

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research utilized qualitative case studies. A qualitative case study is a research
methodology that aids in the exploration of a phenomenon within a specific context
using a number of data sources (Yin, 2018). The exploration is done through a variety
of lenses in order to highlight the phenomenon's many features. A real-time
phenomenon is examined in a case study within its naturally occurring setting with
the understanding that context will make a difference.

Researchers chose topics based on their experience in teaching practice. Many

teachers complain that their students are less able to speak politely in class because
students previously studied online, resulting in less of their attitude education.
Students have difficulty and lack of understanding how to speak good and correct
words. It was proven when researchers do teaching practice there are still many
students who do not understand how to be polite to the teacher and they do not
know what speech can be categorized well to say to the teacher.

This study was conducted at a Senior High School in Garut, West Java. The samples
of this study were 2 English teachers and 73 students in 2 classes. Seventy-three
students were selected based on their ability to use English, especially their mastery
of English speaking and vocabulary. Several factors led to the selection of this
institution, i.e., choosing a public school can get students from various regions. These

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 130
schools previously did online learning, resulting in students not knowing each other
and not being very familiar with their teachers.

Observation and interviews are employed as research instruments. In terms of

observation, participant observation is used to monitor the actual and factual
conditions of classroom learning interaction. Observation tells researchers about the
fundamental significance of behavior. First, the researcher examined two distinct
high school classes. Second, the researcher gathered information about the teaching
and learning process in the classroom and interviewed the instructors of both
courses. Finally, the researcher assessed their politeness strategy.

The researcher used several steps to collect data. First, the researcher prepared 20
questions for the interview and a checklist observation table that would be used as
a research instrument. Second, after all is ready, researcher asks permission from the
school that will be used as research places. The following day, after receiving
permission from the school, the researcher began observing the first class. When the
observation was carried out, the researcher used an audio recorder as a tool to
transcribe data. Then the researcher also used cell observation to observe students
' politeness toward the teacher.

After the observation had been completed the next day, the researcher continued
his research by interviewing two teachers on the topic of discussion of student
politeness strategies to teachers. This interview also used an audio recorder for ease
for researcher transcribing data. Finally, after all the observation and interview data
had been obtained, the researcher identified and transcribed the data.

THE RESEARCH FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS

The researcher explains the research findings of this study based on the objectives
mentioned in Chapter 3, the research instruments used by teachers are observation and
interview. It is used to collect as detailed information as possible from the participants to
get a better answer to the student's politeness strategy to the teacher. The researcher
selected the teachers who taught English in different classes as study participants. There
are 10th and 11th-Grade high schools.

Moreover, before the researcher explains the research findings, the researcher would
like to review the research objectives revealed in Chapter 1. The research problem is
"How do students implement the politeness strategy in the classroom?” According to the
research question, this study aimed to investigate what kind of politeness strategies that
are used by the students and to find out how the politeness of the students in the
classroom to the teachers. The researcher conducted observations in class on April 20

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 131
until 21, 2022. And for the interviews were conducted on June 10, 2022, with the
teachers directly at the school.

Based on observations, it can be explained that the students’ politeness strategy to the
teachers when interacting in the classroom. The tenth Grade used positive politeness
strategies such as in-group identify markers, asserts knowledge of H's wants, and
intensifies interest in H in class. For negative politeness in the form of questions, hedge
and give respect. In contrast to the eleventh Grade, using positive politeness strategies
such as using the group identifies markers, being optimistic, giving or asking for a reason,
jokes, and negative politeness strategies such as using questions, hedge, and apologies.
Therefore, it can be said that students emphasize using politeness strategies in class in
teaching and learning English, such as getting grades, praise, and appreciation,
apologizing, and others.

In addition, the outcomes of interviews with 10th and 11th-grade instructors are
intended to yield the results that teachers desire so that students can use their civility in
the classroom. The 10th-grade teacher, who became an English instructor, observed the
students' courtesy beginning with their facial expressions and tones of voice. This teacher
advised the student to pay attention to his tone of voice when speaking to her. Students
are expected to be courteous and participate more actively in class. Students are
expected to understand the limits of acceptable speech, including what can and cannot
be said. For instance, raising hand before questioning or responding to the material. The
most important thing for students to remember is to eliminate those behaviors they
consider warm outside but not in school. Teachers always pay close attention to their
students in class. When counseling students, teachers focus on the development of their
conduct. This matter must be addressed concerning students' application of classroom
courtesy.

1. Positive Politeness
Positive politeness is a practice aimed to bring a smile on the listener’s face. To establish
rapport with individuals, the speaker expresses his gratitude, approval, interest, and
acquaintance with them. Using FTA, speakers offer the sense that they share the same
desire as the other speaker, demonstrating their friendliness. Typically, this approach
draws closer to someone by expressing familiarity and approbation. In reality, there are
fifteen sub strategies of politeness. However, the study identified just four sub-strategies
adopted by students, namely use in-group identify markers, assert’s knowledge of H’s
wants, give or ask for reasons, and jokes. Here are descriptions of the four sub strategies
employed by pupils:
1) Use in-group Identity Marker
Teacher: Assalamualaikum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatuh.
Students: Waalaikumsalam warahmatullahi wabarakatuh.

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 132
 (Students employed their group's customary greeting phrase to demonstrate that
they are Muslim.)
2) Give or ask for reason
Teacher: Yeah, it is the same idea. Any else?
Students: Because if she says honestly to the classmate or teacher, she will get
attention and special treatment to solve her difficulty so that can be easy
to learn or to study again.
3) Jokes
Teacher: What do you propose since Sania doesn't want to help her mother? I want
to hear your most brilliant recommendation, so tell me?
Students: Sania will help her mom if she can, but if she can't, well, huh I don't know,
hehe.
(The student made a joke by providing Sania the option of helping her mother or not.
Sania was responsible.)
4) Notice, and attend to the hearer (his interest, wants, needs, goods)
Teacher: What Is Simple present tense? Do you know what the simple Present tense
is?
Students: To explain at the present time, Mrs.
2. Negative Politeness
Negative Politeness is a tactic aimed at appeasing the heare’s negative attitude
about respect conduct and avoiding imposing on the hearer. In this method, the speaker
should emphasize the relative power of the listener to maintain social distance. There
are ten sub-strategies of negative politeness, but the researcher identified only three
sub-strategies employed by students: conventionally indirect, using a question, and
hedging.
1) Use question or hedge
Teacher: “So, what solution do you propose for this issue?”
Students: “I think she should not adopt the lifestyle of her wealthier friends. She
must prudently manage her pocket money.”
2) Be conventionally indirect
Teacher: “So, what do you propose?”
Students: “In my opinion, she should work hard at school, not be shy, and
not waste her time.”
3) Apologies
Teacher: “Hemat is judgement? Really?”.
Students: “Oh… sorry, perhaps her parents have to ask her to be economical, and
her parents have to ask her not to be extravagant, and try to be grateful
for her money.”
3. Bald on Record
The term ‘bald on record’ refers to a statement in which the speaker states simply,
plainly, and immediately what they want or intend. The speaker states or speaks the
truth, avoiding saying less or more than is necessary, being pertinent to the matter at
hand, and avoiding ambiguity. It is meant to minimize misunderstanding and achieve
efficiency, but it poses the greatest harm to the face of the hearer. For the example:
Teacher : “Like watching Youtube?”

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 133
Students : “Yes and watching movie.”

CONCLUSION
In the findings part, the researcher provides a brief summary of the study's results,
whereas in this section, he or she will provide a detailed explanation of the results. This
section deals with how students implement politeness strategies in the classroom. Yule
(1983), said that modesty is an attitude that shows an awareness and public self-
consideration image of others. Thus, this study is expected to determine the politeness
of language and actions taken by students in class interaction. This study is expected to
help students to behave politely toward their teachers in the classroom.

As we know that student is a child who develops according to their stage of development,
so they must find many politeness strategies to make the teacher enjoy the class and get
good grades from the teacher. To be a polite student is certainly not easy. They must
know how to be a good student in the eyes of their teachers. From the interview results,
the teacher advised his students to speak politely, experiment, and pay attention to their
tone. According to Yule (1983), it specifies that a face threatening act (FTA) is anything
that threatens the self-esteem expectations of others, while a face-saving act (FSA) is
something that is viewed as a threat to the faces of others. However, the speaker tries to
mitigate the danger. Students are expected to understand the limits of acceptable
speech, including what they can and cannot say. Apart from that, teachers’ pay attention
to not only the students ' speech but also their appearance is assessed politeness by the
teacher. Appearance following the rules applied by the school can be evaluated as
politeness by the teacher. Therefore, the results of students who apply politeness in class
can be rated as good behaviour by their teachers.

This study aims to investigate how students implement politeness strategies in the
classroom. After analyzing the data in the previous chapter, conclusions can be drawn.
The study found sayings containing politeness strategies used by students. There are four
positive politeness strategy sayings (use in-group identity mark up or ask for a reason,
jokes, Notice, and attend to the listener), three negative politeness strategy sayings (use
question or hedge, be conventionally indirect, apologies), and bald on record strategy
sayings. Students favored positive politeness tactics above other strategies, according to
the data. Then, researcher found negative politeness strategies in communicating with
teachers in the classroom as a form of respect furthermore, bald on record politeness
strategy speech in class when students briefly answer questions from the teacher.

In essence, the application of politeness methods is determined by the requirements.

The findings of the study revealed that students employ various politeness tactics in this
situation. It is not a huge concern because the pupils have not studied pragmatics or

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 134
English politeness methods; therefore, they were unaware that their utterances
contained a particular type of politeness strategies.
Based on the conclusions, the study suggests that the teaching of pragmatics in which
the concept of politeness is introduced should be incorporated in the curriculum
coverage. Considering the importance of the pragmatic knowledge in both
communication and language proficiency, thus, the teachers should make sure that the
pragmatics is taught explicitly. In addition to practice, the study also suggests future
research to investigate the influence of such an explicit teaching of pragmatics
knowledge including politeness strategies on students’ pragmatic competence in
general.
REFERENCES
Darong, H. C., Kadarisman, A. E., & Basthomi, Y. (2020). POLITENESS MARKERS IN
TEACHERS’ REQUEST IN CLASSROOM INTERACTIONS. Journal of Literature and
Language Teaching, 217–233.
Heriyawati, D. F., SIba, S. Y., & Sulistyo, T. (2019). LECTURERS. In POLITENESS
STRATEGIES IN EFL CLASSROOM WITH MULTICULTURAL BACKGROUNDS. LITERA
(pp. 447–4462).
Lestari, Y., G., I., Seken, K., Putra, & Jaya, I. N. (2018). Politeness strategy preference of
male and female teachers in classroom interaction during English classes. EDP
Sciences.
Marpaung, T. I. (2019). Politeness Strategy Among Teachers And Students In EFL
Classroom. IOSR Journal Of Humanities And Social Science, 51–55.
Ningrum, R. F., Suharsono, & Suwono. (2018). Gender’s Politeness Strategies of Making
Requests and Giving Compliments in Classroom Setting Sociopragmatic
Perspective. TechMind Research Society, 765.
Nurmawati, H., & Weda, S. (2019). An Analysis of Positive Politeness Strategies to
Promote Effective Interaction in The Classroom. ELS Journal on Interdisciplinary
Studies on Humanities, 171.
Purandina, I. P., Seken, I. K., & Budasi, I. G. (2014). POLITENESS IN EFL CLASSROOM
INTERACTIONS AND ITS IMPLICATIONS TOWARD EFL TEACHING-LEARNING IN SMP
NEGERI 2 TABANAN IN ACADEMIC YEAR 2013/2014. e-Journal Program
Pascasarjana Universitas Pendidikan Ganesha. 2–12.
Purnomo, A. W. (2019). POLITENESS STRATEGIES IN TEACHER-STUDENT INTERACTION
IN EFL CLASSES. Lang Edu Journal, 1.
Risal, H., & Tambunan. (2021). An Analysis of Politeness in Teacher’s Utterances in an
English Classroom. Journal of Language Education and Educational Technology,
27–35.
Yin, R. K. (2018). Case study research and applications: Design and methods. In SAGE
Publications. https://doi.org/10.1177/109634809702100108
Yrisarry, N., Neuberger, L., & Neville, A. M. (2019). Instructor Response to Uncivil
Behaviors in the Classroom: An Application of Politeness Theory. Journal of the
Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 32–42.
Yule, G. (1983). Pragmatics. Oxford university press.

English Education and Applied Linguistic (EEAL) Journal Vol. 5 No. 2 135