Determining Hydrogen Pre-Cooling Temperature From Fueling Parameters
Determining Hydrogen Pre-Cooling Temperature From Fueling Parameters
Determining Hydrogen Pre-Cooling Temperature From Fueling Parameters
ScienceDirect
Article history: Compressed hydrogen storage has a requirement on the temperature: for safety reasons,
Received 24 January 2016 the final gas temperature is not allowed to exceed 85 C during filling. However, due to the
Received in revised form short time and the fast filling rate in practice, the final gas temperature rises sharply. To
4 June 2016 solve the issue, the hydrogen could be pre-cooled sometimes, but setting the pre-cooling
Accepted 8 June 2016 hydrogen temperature becomes a critical problem, we need to know whether the inflow
Available online 30 June 2016 hydrogen needs to be pre-cooled and what the pre-cooling temperature it should be. This
paper proposes a new analytical solution of pre-cooling hydrogen temperature from a
Keywords: simplified lumped parameter model. The effects of initial temperature, initial pressure and
Hydrogen storage the filling time on the inflow hydrogen temperature are studied, and three sets of equations
Refueling are proposed correspondingly. Further we use these equations to fit the published refer-
Fast filling ence data, the fittings show good agreement. The occasions where the hydrogen needs to
Pre-cooling be pre-cooled are presented. We suppose this study not only helps to choose the pre-
Temperature cooling hydrogen temperature, but also ensure the safety during the hydrogen filling.
Safety © 2016 Hydrogen Energy Publications LLC. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
coefficients and the filling time can be also known by the use
Nomenclature of another fitted formula with 48 coefficients.
We developed the numerical solutions for the lumped
af heat transfer coefficient between hydrogen and
parameter thermodynamic models of adsorptive and cryo-
ambient fluid, W/m2/K
adsorptive hydrogen storage systems [12,13]. Based on the
As internal surface area of tank, m2
lumped parameter thermodynamic models, analytical solu-
cp constant-pressure specific heat, J/kg/K
tions are developed for chargeedischarge cycle of compres-
cv constant-volume specific heat, J/kg/K
sion hydrogen storage system [14] and adsorptionedesorption
h specific enthalpy of hydrogen, J/kg
cycle of adsorptive hydrogen storage system [15]. The simple
hin specific enthalpy of inflow H2, J/kg
uniform formula is inspired by the concept of the rule of
hout specific enthalpy of outflow H2, J/kg
mixture and its weighted factors are obtained from the
kp0 kp0 ¼ T=ðT0 pf Þ
analytical solution of lumped parameter thermodynamics
kp0f kp0f ¼ T=T0
model. The analytical solution of the hydrogen temperature in
kpf kpf ¼ Tp0 =T0
the tank is used to fit the experimental temperatures [16,17].
m mass of hydrogen mass in tank, kg
Estimation of final hydrogen temperature from refueling pa-
m0 initial hydrogen mass, kg
rameters based on the rule of mixtures is simple and practical
m_ mass flow rate, kg/s
for controlling the maximum temperature and for ensuring
m_ in hydrogen mass inflow rate, kg/s
hydrogen safety during fast filling process.
m_ out hydrogen mass outflow rate, kg/s
The SAE J2601 establishes the protocol and process limits
p0 initial pressure, MPa
for hydrogen fueling of light duty vehicles, it has been devel-
p0f p0f ¼ p0 =pf
oped to meet the performance objectives under all practical
pf final pressure, MPa
conditions based on a look-up table approach [18,19] and MC
Q_ heat inflow rate, Q_ ¼ af As ðTf TÞ, W
Method [20,21]. The useful hydrogen fueling test data is
t time variable or fill time, s
_ s available at http://www.h2protocol.com/h2-fueling-data/ [22].
t* characteristic time, t* ¼ m0 =m,
These data would be used for further estimation of final
T temperature of hydrogen, K
hydrogen temperature or determination of pre-cooled
T* characteristic temperature, K
hydrogen temperature.
T0 initial temperature in tank, K
In the research of the development of hydrogen storage
Tf temperature of ambient fluid, K
system, in order to meet the requirement of the highest
T∞ inflow or outflow temperature, K
temperature limit (e.g. 85 C), cooling the hydrogen in
u specific internal energy, J/kg
advance has been proved to be an applicable way. However,
Greek symbols setting the pre-cooling hydrogen temperature has become a
a dimensionless heat transfer coefficient, critical problem, which should not only ensure the final
a ¼ af As =cv m_ temperature of hydrogen not to exceed the corresponding
g ratio of specific heats, g ¼ cp/cv limits, but also avoid making the pre-cooling temperature too
m fraction of initial mass, m ¼ m0/m low to waste energy. In this article, we fix the final tempera-
m0 m0 ¼ m1þa ture as the highest temperature limit (e.g. 85 C), express the
t dimensionless time, t ¼ t=t* pre-cooling temperature T∞ as the function of refueling pa-
rameters including initial temperature T0, initial pressure p0
and filling time t under different final pressures. For the three
cases, the deduced equations are used to fit the reference
on the temperature distribution and the temperature rise, data. The fittings show good agreement. Furthermore, the
and a three-parameter formula was proposed [6]. An experi- fitting result can be used for deciding whether the inflow
ment was carried out to investigate the discharge cycle of a hydrogen needs pre-cooling or not and how could it should
type III cylinder and a model was also presented [7]. The ef- be.
fect of mass flow rates and inlet gas temperatures on the end
state of charge was measured by Cebolla et al., then a
conclusion was drawn that the inlet gas temperature played Model for determining hydrogen pre-cooling
an important role on the final state of charge [8]. temperature
Monde et al. [9] took two different ways to deal with the
hydrogen gas and the tank wall, a lumped parameter model General mass and energy balance equations for charge/
was used to describe the thermal behaviors of hydrogen gas in discharge processes of high pressure hydrogen gas into/from a
the tank and a one-dimensional model was used for tank wall. tank are mostly written as [14].
Their simulation results were proved to agree with the gas
temperature profile obtained by BMW-Powertech tests [10]. dm
¼ m_ in m_ out (1)
Monde et al. derived approximate equations to predict the dt
temperature of the pre-cooled hydrogen and the filling
d
time for a practical vessel [11], the pre-cooled hydrogen tem- ðmuÞ ¼ m_ in hin m_ out hout þ Q_ (2)
dt
perature can be predicted by using a fitted formula with 36
16318 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 1 ( 2 0 1 6 ) 1 6 3 1 6 e1 6 3 2 1
_ the solution of
Under constant charge or discharge rate m, T∞ ¼ a bT0 (12)
_ Thus
mass balance equation (3) is simplified as m ¼ m0 þ mt.
Comparing Eq. (12) with Eq. (11), we have
the energy balance equation becomes
1 1þa a m0 1 þ a
du a¼ T Tf ; b ¼ (13)
_
ðm0 þ mtÞ _ ¼ mh
þ mu _ þ a f As T f T (5) 1m g
0 g 1 m0 g
dt
This formula is used to fit the reference data [11], as shown
For the case of constant inflow or outflow hydrogen tem- in Fig. 1. The values of fitted parameters of a and b for four final
perature T∞, the energy equation (5) can be written in the form pressures are shown in Table 1. For simplification, we can
of temperature: assume m0 zm for most cases. The known constants according
to the reference [11] are T ¼ 358.15 K, Tf ¼ 293.15 K. So, there
dT T* T
¼ ð1 þ aÞ * (6) are three unknown parameters in the Eq. (13). We must fix one
dt t þt
of the three parameters in Eq. (13) and then we solve other two
where T* ¼ ðgT∞ þ aTf Þ=ð1 þ aÞ is a characteristic temperature, parameters by using two equations in Eq. (13). Table 2 gives
t* ¼ m0 =m_ is characteristic time, and a ¼ ðaf As Þ=ðcv mÞ
_ is a out the values of parameters m and g when a ¼ 0 and a ¼ 1.
dimensionless heat transfer coefficient which represents the Through the equations, whether the hydrogen need pre-
ratio of heat transfer ability afAs to heat capacity change cv m_ cooling or not could be determined if the real initial temper-
(W/K) of the system during charge and discharge processes. ature, finial pressure and ambient temperature are known. For
Using dimensionless time t ¼ t=t* , solution of Eq. (6) can be example, as shown in Fig. 1, assuming that the ambient
obtained as [14]. temperature is 300 K, when the finial pressure in the tank
reaches 50 MPa, a critical initial temperature T0 can be found
1þa
T* T 1 by ensuring the highest hydrogen temperature is 85 C. If the
¼ (7)
T* T0 1þt real initial temperature T00 is higher than T0, the required
inflow temperature T∞ will be lower than the ambient tem-
Then, the solution can be expressed in the form of “rule of
perature (i.e. the source temperature), so the hydrogen needs
mixtures” [17]:
to be pre-cooled. On the opposite side, the hydrogen doesn't
T ¼ m0 T0 þ ð1 m0 ÞT* (8) need pretreatment.
According to the definition of m (m ¼ m0/m), the value of it is
where m0 ¼ m1þa ¼ ðm0 =mÞ1þa is the weighted factor. Inserting supposed to be less than one and more than zero, and the
the characteristic temperature T* ¼ ðgT∞ þ aTf Þ=ð1 þ aÞ into higher the final pressure, the less the value of it. The
Eq. (5), we obtain
T ¼ m0 T0 þ g0 T∞ þ a0 Tf (9) 320
310 pf=35MPa
where g0 ¼ gð1 m0 Þ=ð1 þ aÞ, a0 ¼ að1 m0 Þ=ð1 þ aÞ. So we can
express the hydrogen pre-cooling temperature as 300
50MPa
Inflow temperature (K)
1 290
T∞ ¼ 0 T a0 Tf m0 T0 (10)
g 70MPa
280
i.e. 87.5MPa
270
260
1 1þa a m0 1 þ a
T∞ ¼ T Tf T0 (11) 250
1 m0 g g 1 m0 g
In the case of reference data [11], Tf ¼ T0, so Eq. (10) or Eq. (11) than the source temperature, so there is no need for us to pre-
can be simplified as cool the hydrogen. Otherwise, if the real initial pressure is
lower than the critical initial pressure, the inflow hydrogen
1þa 1 m0 þ a needs to be pre-cooled.
T∞ ¼ T T0 (14)
1 m0 g 1þa
According to the equation of state for ideal gas, for initial Determining from filling time and final pressure
state and end state, we have p0V ¼ n0RT0 and pfV ¼ nRT, then
we can obtain p0/pf ¼ n0T0/(nT). We define m ¼ m0/m ¼ n0/n, so As in Section Determining from initial pressure and final
we get m ¼ Tp0/(T0pf). We can further have m ¼ kp0 p0 , where pressure, we have m0 zm ¼ Tp0 =ðT0 pf Þ, we assume m ¼ kpf/pf,
kp0 ¼ T=ðT0 pf Þ, or m ¼ kp0f p0f , where kp0f ¼ T=T0 and p0f ¼ p0 =pf . where kpf ¼ Tp0/T0 ¼ 12.21. For the case of reference data [11],
For simplification, we also use m0 zm in Eq. (14). T ¼ 358.15 K, T0 ¼ 293.15 K, p0 ¼ 10 MPa, so kpf ¼ Tp0/T0 ¼ 12.21.
We use T ¼ 358.15 K, T0 ¼ 293.15 K to fit the data which We also assume the dimensionless heat transfer coefficient as
comes from the reference [11]. Fig. 2 shows good agreement. a ¼ ktt. Then Eq. (14) becomes:
The values of the corresponding fitting parameters are shown
in Table 3. In Fig. 2, the horizontal line represents the envi- . !
ronment temperature is 300 K. In order to achieve a certain 1 þ kt t 1 kpf pf þ kt t
T∞ ¼ . T T0 (15)
final pressure (for example, 35 MPa), a critical initial pressure 1 kpf pf g 1 þ kt t
p0 can also be obtained. According to the curve of 35 MPa,
when the real initial pressure p00 is higher than the critical Rearranging Eq. (15) gives the inflow temperature as a
initial pressure p0, the required inflow temperature is higher linear function of time:
16320 i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 1 ( 2 0 1 6 ) 1 6 3 1 6 e1 6 3 2 1
.
kt ðT T0 Þ T T0 kpf pf
T∞ ¼ . t þ . (16) Acknowledgments
g 1 kpf pf g 1 kpf pf
We wish to thank the National Natural Science Foundation of
However, the data given in Fig. 3 show nonlinear behavior. China (NSFC Project No.51476120) and the Natural Sciences
So this formula has to be modified to well fit the reference and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) for their
data. Given that the reference data increase lower than the financial supports and Mr. Benjamin Angers for his technical
linear model, a fractal exponent on the time t is used for ex- assistance on the OriginPro 2015 software.
press the dimensionless heat transfer coefficient a ¼ kt t1=2 . For
the reference data [11], the fitted parameters are shown in
Table 4, and the fitted results are shown in Fig. 3. As it’s
shown, the fittings agree very well. references
In Fig. 3, the horizontal line represents the environment
temperature is 300 K. In order to achieve a certain final pres-
sure (for example, 35 MPa), a critical filling time t can be ob- [1] Suryan A, Kim HD, Setoguchi T. Comparative study of
turbulence models performance for refueling of compressed
tained. According to the curve of 35 MPa, when the real filling
0 hydrogen tanks. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2013;38:9562e9.
time t is less than the critical filling time t, the required inflow
[2] Monde M, Mitsutake Y, Woodfield PL, Maruyama S.
temperature is lower than the source temperature, so the Characteristics of heat transfer and temperature rise of
hydrogen needs pre-cooling. Otherwise, the hydrogen can be hydrogen during rapid hydrogen filling at high pressure. Heat
filled without pretreatment. Transfer Asian Res 2007;36:13e27.
[3] ISO/DIS 15869, Gaseous hydrogen and hydrogen blends e
land vehicle fuel tanks. https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/#iso:std:
52871:en. cited 2016-6e1.
Conclusions [4] Liu Y, Zhao Y, Zhao L, Li X, Chen H, Zhang L, et al.
Experimental studies on temperature rise within a hydrogen
(1) Based on the thermodynamics of the compressed cylinder during refueling. Int J Hydrogen Energy
hydrogen storage system, a lumped parameter model is 2010;35:2627e32.
i n t e r n a t i o n a l j o u r n a l o f h y d r o g e n e n e r g y 4 1 ( 2 0 1 6 ) 1 6 3 1 6 e1 6 3 2 1 16321
[5] Hosseini M, Dincer I, Naterer GF, Rosen MA. Thermodynamic adsorptive hydrogen storage system. Int J Hydrogen Energy
analysis of filling compressed gaseous hydrogen storage 2012;37:13400e8.
tanks. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2012;37:5063e71. [14] Xiao J, Pierre B, Richard C. Charge-discharge cycle
[6] Dicken CJB, Me rida W. Measured effects of filling time and thermodynamics for compression hydrogen storage system.
initial mass on the temperature distribution within a Int J Hydrogen Energy 2016;41:5531e9.
hydrogen cylinder during refueling. J Power Sources [15] Xiao JS, Benard P, Chahine R. Adsorption-desorption cycle
2007;165:324e36. thermodynamics for adsorptive hydrogen storage system.
[7] Guo J, Yang J, Zhao Y, Pan X, Zhang L, Zhao L, et al. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2016;41:6139e47.
Investigations on temperature variation within a type III [16] Xiao JS, Benard P, Chahine R. Estimation of final gas
cylinder during the hydrogen gas cycling test. Int J Hydrogen temperature in compressed hydrogen vehicle refuelling. In:
Energy 2014;39:13926e34. The 1st international conference on modern auto technology
[8] Cebolla RO, Acosta B, Miguel ND, Moretto P. Effect of and services (ICMATS2014), Wuhan, China; October 24e26,
precooled inlet gas temperature and mass flow rate on final 2014.
state of charge during hydrogen vehicle refueling. Int J [17] Xiao JS, Benard P, Chahine R. Estimation of final hydrogen
Hydrogen Energy 2015;35:4698e706. temperature from refueling parameters. Int J Hydrogen
[9] Monde M, Woodfield PL, Takano T, Kosaka M. Estimation of Energy 2016. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2016.05.213.
temperature change in practical hydrogen pressure tanks [18] Fueling protocols for light duty gaseous hydrogen surface
being filled at high pressures of 35 and 70 MPa. Int J Hydrogen vehicles. SAE standard J2601_201407, http://standards.sae.
Energy 2012;37:5723e34. org/j2601_201407/, cited 2016-05-18.
[10] Monde M, Kosaka M. Understanding of thermal [19] Schneider J, Meadows G, Mathison SR, Veenstra MJ, Shim J,
characteristics of fueling hydrogen high pressure tanks and Immel R, et al. Validation and sensitivity studies for SAE
governing parameters. SAE Int J Alt Power 2013;2(1):61e7. J2601, the light duty vehicle hydrogen fueling standard. SAE
http://dx.doi.org/10.4271/2013-01-0474. Int J Alt Power 2014;3(2):257e309. http://dx.doi.org/10.4271/
[11] Monde M, Tanaka S, Takano T. Prediction of filling time and 2014-01-1990.
temperature of precooled hydrogen during filling of [20] Mathison S, Harty R, Cohen J, Gupta N and Soto H.
hydrogen into a high-pressure tank. SAE Technical Paper Application of MC method-based H2 fueling. SAE Technical
2010-32-0127, http://dx.doi.org/10.4271/2010-32-0127. Paper 2012-01-1223, http://dx.doi.org/10.4271/2012-01-1223.
[12] Xiao JS, Zhou ZQ, Cossement D, Be nard P, Chahine R. [21] Mathison S, Handa K, McGuire T, Brown T, Goldstein T,
Lumped parameter model for charge-discharge cycle of Johnston M. Field validation of the MC default fill hydrogen
adsorptive hydrogen storage system. Int J Heat Mass Transf fueling protocol. SAE Int J Alt Power 2015;4(1):130e44. http://
2013;64:245e53. dx.doi.org/10.4271/2015-01-1177.
[13] Xiao JS, Li Q, Cossement D, Be nard P, Chahine R. Lumped [22] The hydrogen data e sharing site. http://www.h2protocol.
parameter simulation for charge-discharge cycle of cryo- com/h2-fueling-data/, cited 2016-05-18.