Colanattaya,+02 Role+of+Local+Government+ (2021!07!05)
Colanattaya,+02 Role+of+Local+Government+ (2021!07!05)
Colanattaya,+02 Role+of+Local+Government+ (2021!07!05)
Abstract
Local Government Authorities (LGAs) possess traditional roles of securing a stable business and
service delivery environment at the community level. Despite the aforesaid roles, the actual
contribution to local economic development (LED) and service delivery remains inconclusive in
Tanzania. This paper aims to explore the role of LGAs in promoting LED and service delivery to
local communities in Tanzania. The study is conducted along Community Economic Development
and Service Support Approach to be used in assessing the role of LGAs in promoting LED and
service delivery at the community level. The approach provides a guideline for LGAs regarding
where to focus in order to become active in playing their role. The study uses documentary review
of reports, books, articles and newspapers. The collected data were analyzed through secondary
data analysis approach. The findings revealed that LGAs promote LED by providing soft loans,
improving business infrastructure and local investment support. Also, LGAs promote service
delivery by ensuring supply of water, supporting electricity supply and school improvements.
Challenges toward playing a more effective role were identified including non-performing loans
and failure to provide entrepreneurship skills. The study urges LGAs to put more effort toward
solving the identified challenges, e.g., addressing non-performing loans, completing unfinished
business infrastructure, and becoming innovative toward service delivery and economic liberation
of local communities.
Keywords
economic development, local community, LGAs, service delivery
CORRESPONDING AUTHOR
Rogers Rugeiyamu, The Local Government Training Institute
P.O. Box 1125, Dodoma, Tanzania. Email: okoth3890@gmail.com
© College of Local Administration, Khon Kaen University. All rights reserved.
Introduction
Local Government Authorities (LGAs) were established under the constitution of the
United Republic of Tanzania of 1977 Articles 145 and 146. The purpose of the LGA is to transfer
authority to the people, empower them to participate, and involve them in the planning and
implementation of development programs within their respective areas. LGAs in Tanzania have
the function of social development and public service delivery, facilitation of maintenance of law
and order and promotion of local development under a participatory process. They are
administered through local councils responsible for overseeing local government activities
(Rugeiyamu et al., 2018, 244).
LGAs in Tanzania passed through a long history. In summary, their evolution can be
traced to a pre-colonial time when people organized themselves in kingdoms/chiefdoms.
Rudimentary forms of LGAs also existed during colonialism, especially during British domination
when chiefs/kings were also used in colonial administration. During independence LGAs were
retained and improved to cope with the environment of that time. In 1972 LGAs were abolished
and replaced by the development committees with central control, and then re-established in
1982. The 1982 re-establishment resulted in the structure of LGAs in Tanzania today (Mmari,
2005, 5).
In relation to Articles 145 and 146 of the constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania,
LGAs are empowered by the Local Government (District Authorities) Act No.7, 1982 establishing
district authorities and Local Government (Urban Authorities) Act No. 8, 1982 establishing urban
authorities. In this regard, LGAs in Tanzania are divided into rural authorities established by Act
No. 7, and urban authorities established by Act No. 8 as identified above (Njunwa, 2005).
The district authority is made up of units including village government, Township
Authorities and District Councils. The village government is composed of the village council
(comprising the village chairperson, village executive officer, and not more than twenty-five
members), and the village assembly in which all members of the village who have reached the
age of 18 years are eligible to participate. A village assembly is called quarterly during the year.
As Tanzania LGAs follow a council committee system, the village has three committees which
are planning/finance/economic affairs, social services, and security. The village council members
are elected every five years.
Again, Township Authorities are for promoting and maintaining an effective and efficient
system of local government in a township area. The township administration is comprised of the
chairman, one elected member from each ward in the area of the township authority, not less
than three members appointed by the respective district where the township resides, members of
parliament residing in the township area, such that the number of women members who are
qualified to be elected to the township authority comprise not less than one quarter of all the
Review of Literature
The Role of LGAs in Promoting LED and Service Delivery
LGAs have to play a significant role to achieve full LED of local communities in Tanzania.
The following empirical studies show what they have been doing so far and the issues they have
been facing toward achieving LED and service delivery outcomes.
Magigi (2013, 174) citing Kigoma and Coastal regions as a case study revealed that the
LED strategy was introduced in 2009 under partnership modalities between the governments of
Tanzania and Belgium under the Belgian Technical Cooperation (BTC). The latter provided
Methodology
Study Approach
The study uses the ‘Community Economic Development Support’ approach to explore
the role of the LGA. This is an approach proposed by Rugeiyamu, Shayo, Kashonda and Mohamed
to study the role of LGAs in promoting economic development and service delivery to the local
community. The approach belongs to the family of Community Development Support
Approaches which focuses on the funding, capacity building, investments and increased
empowerment to the local community, thereby fostering economic development (Clay & Jones,
2009).
Data Analysis
This study used a secondary data analysis approach. Secondary data analysis is analysis
of data that was collected by someone else for another primary purpose. Hakim (1982) defines
Provision of Loans
The approach insists on the provision of loans by the LGAs to the community for
the aim of boosting the economic development at the community level. The review of LGA
documents revealed that LGAs are providing soft loans to community groups. For instance, on
the aspect of youth and women, LGAs in Tanzania under Women and Youth Development Fund
Guidelines and Directives issued by the government, each LGA is required to contribute ten
percent of its own revenue to a women & youth revolving fund for the aim of enabling women
and youth to access loans and engage in various economic activities (Mmari and Katera, 2018).
The review of LGA documents revealed that LGAs are trying to contribute ten
percent of their own revenue for the women & youth development fund. Table 1 (which has been
extracted from the Controller and Auditor General [CAG] report of LGAs for 2017/2018) shows
data for LGAs with outstanding contributions to women and youth from 2014/2015 to
2017/2018. In this aspect, it can be argued that this is a good indication of how LGAs play a role
in the economic development of community groups especially women and youth as they have
been able to use loans to engage in entrepreneurial activities to raise their income, living
standards and contributing to the GDP.
However, the CAG General report of LGAs for 2017/2018 revealed some weaknesses
of LGAs on the aspect of contributing ten percent to the development of women and youth. After
assessing the implementation of women & youth development fund directives, it was found that
143 out of 185 LGAs did not contribute ten percent of their own revenue to the women & youth
development fund, in the amount of TZS 40, 377,882, 284. In this aspect, it can be argued that
the issue of LGAs not contributing ten percent of their own revenue to the women & youth
development fund, retards the efforts toward liberating community groups economically.
The LGA budget draws upon local revenue (contributing almost nine to ten percent
of the total budget), intergovernmental transfers (contributing 90 percent) and donor funding
(one percent). The ten percent to be contributed by LGAs is from the LGAs own revenue. Own-
source revenue includes money received from fees, fines and penalties, license fees, building
permits and other sources specified in their by-laws. For instance, during Fiscal Year 2017/2018,
185 LGAs managed to collect a total of TZS 566,729,291,189 from own source revenue against
the approved budget of TZS 677,965,549,714, resulting in an under-collection of TZS
111,236,258,525, equivalent to 16% of the total revenue estimated to be collected. Of the total
budget, 60 percent is allocated for development and 40 percent is allocated for expenditures.
Again, the intergovernmental transfers are allocated for expenditure and personal emoluments.
Also, the donor funding is used for development purposes. It is in the development part of the
budget that loans for women and youth, business infrastructure, and local investment dwell. It
should be born in mind that the budget funding is not uniform, and it varies from one LGA to
another and from year to year due to the differences in revenue collection. The business
infrastructure support is funded by both own sources and intergovernmental transfers. For water
supply, the responsibility has been shifted to RUWASA which cooperates with LGAs to ensure
service provision.
Also, the CAG General report of LGAs for 2017/2018 revealed that, in 90 LGAs, the
loans issued to women and youth were not recovered. Loans were not recovered due to ineffective
control, as LGAs were not following up on the returns of loans from beneficiaries. It was revealed
that, out of TZS 17,009,608,283 loaned, only TZS 6,965,154,627 were recovered, leaving a
balance of TZS 10,044,453,656, equivalent to 59 percent. Table 2 (as extracted from CAG General
Table 2. Trend of Unrecoverable Women and Youth Loans for Four Consecutive Years
Debatably, the non- recovered loans may lead to the failure of the fund intentions
of liberating community groups economically. The study authors are of the view that the fund
has good intentions of improving the economic performance of community groups. However,
proper management of these funds from LGAs need to be ensured so that they can help
individuals at the community level to develop economically as they will be able to use the
provided funds to open new business.
Business Infrastructure
The business infrastructure entails the basic facilities, structures, and services
including transportation, water, electricity, and markets. Infrastructure development presumably
triggers economic development. In this aspect, the approach contends that LGAs need to ensure
that such infrastructures are accessed by the local community for the aim of boosting their
economy. The study found that the LGAs have been playing a role in the construction of
infrastructure to hasten the economic development of people at the local level. Regarding
markets for instance, through own-source revenue, the Bagamoyo DC is constructing a modern
fish market costing TZS1,415,910,550, the Namtumbo DC constructed a modern commercial
market costing TZS1,600,793,853 (CAG General Report of LGAs for 2019/2020), and Dodoma City
Council constructed a modern market (Job Ndugai market) costing TZS14 billion financed by a
World Bank loan. For the Dodoma City aspect, the market has a place for petty traders so that it
can help boost the local economy (The Guardian, 2019 March, 23). Moreover, it was found that,
in some LGAs, there is ongoing construction of a modern commercial market such as at the
Namtumbo District Council and construction of Luganga market at Kilolo District Council (DC).
Concerning bus terminals, Dodoma City constructed a bus terminal at a cost of
TZS24 billion whereby, among other issues, it provides priority to small traders within the city to
engage in business to improve the local economy (The Guardian, 2020 May, 28). Dar es Salaam
City constructed a bus terminal at a cost of US$22 million which has provided several
opportunities to citizens including accommodating 3,000 buses per day, booking offices, banking,
pharmaceutical services, canteens, fast food, spare parts shops, a gym, vending machines and
ATMs. Also, there is an ongoing construction of a bus stand in Iringa DC among other
infrastructure projects (John, 2020). It can be conjectured that, when these and the like projects
are completed, these actions will boost the economic development of the local community as
individuals can establish businesses in the completed marketplaces and bus stands. This is
expected to boost the economic development of the local community. Again, these actions are
a good move toward service delivery because community members will gain access to bus stand
services and market services and household products.
Entrepreneurial Skills
This approach calls upon LGAs to provide and ensure that people at the community
level are informed of the essential skills of entrepreneurship so that they can be innovative in
establishing new businesses to boost their economy. In this aspect, it can be demonstrated that
Schools Service
Schools are one of the education facilities where people can learn and improve skills
that can help to boost the economy through employment. Since 2008, the administration of
primary and secondary education was transferred to the formerly-named Prime Minister Office
Regional Administration and Local Government (currently re-named as Ministry in the President’s
The results above reflect the great efforts of LGAs toward liberating individuals
economically and promoting service delivery. This is because access to school gives youth the
ability to be liberated and become more innovative. Education facilitates self–employment and,
hence, boosts economic development. Nevertheless, LGAs have to maintain their efforts to
ensure that other facilities are provided in schools including textbooks, teachers, and laboratories.
References
Bank of Tanzania. (2018). Annual report 2017/2018. Dar es Salaam: Bank of Tanzania.
Binswanger, H. B. & Swaminanthan, S. A. (2003). Scaling up Community-Driven Development. World
Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3039. Washington, DC: World Bank.
http://econ.worldbank.org.Retrieved 21 May, 2021.
Clay, R.A., Jr., & Jones, S. R., 2009. A Brief History of Community Economic Development. Journal of
Affordable Housing, 18(3), 257-267.
Controller and Auditor General. (2019). Annual general report on the audit of Local Government
Authorities (LGAs) for Fiscal Year 2017/2018. Dar es Salaam: National Audit Office.
Controller and Auditor General. (2020). Annual general report on the audit of Local Government
Authorities (LGAs) for Fiscal Year 2018/2019. Dar es Salaam: National Audit Office.
Daily News. (2019, August 29). Tanzania: second Batch of 1,700 students join form five education.
Dijk, V.T. (2019). Pathways in Local Economic Development in Tanzania: Institutionalization of
Collective Action: The Case of Mbulu and Karatu Districts. Doctoral dissertation, Erasmus
University, Rotterdam.