Education Reform. MR Samaila
Education Reform. MR Samaila
Education Reform. MR Samaila
Kakuri, Kaduna.
Nursing Education Reform: An X-ray of the Global and National Scheme of Nursing
Education Reforms
To Mr Samaila
GROUP 7 MEMBERS
Abstract
Worldwide because of the link between education and development. What appears
not to have been fully explored in the Nigerian context is the responsiveness of
various professions, especially nursing, to the constantly changing educational
system. Yet innovative advances in the health care system in the twenty-first century
demand that Nursing as a profession should prepare practitioners who are well
equipped to meet the challenges of care within the context of a complex milieu. This
paper, therefore, examines the Nigeria educational system, its reforms and current
status of nursing education in Nigeria. Some of the challenges in the emergence of
professional nursing in Nigeria and the progress made so far to advance
professional as well as university education for nurses are articulated with
propositions of possibilities and the gains for the Nigeria nation.
Introduction
What is nursing education?
Nursing education is a nursing program which prepares a person for initial licensure
to practise Nursing. It will be necessary to identify and analyse the key terms in this
topic before going into the discussion.
Minister (FMOH 2004), the Health Sector reform is a broad based purposeful and
sustainable fundamental change in function, structure and performance of health
system in order to deliver efficient, quality, affordable accessible, effective and
equitable health care services to the population and ultimately improve the health
status of the people.
Rao (2007) stated this basic fact, “there is no educational system in the world that
has not undergone some reforms and restructuring”.
The truth is that the more pragmatic the reforms embarked upon, the more dynamic
the educational system that evolves.
Brief history of Nursing Education in Nigeria reveals that formal Nursing education in
Nigeria started in 1930 (Adelowo, 1988).
This system was bequeathed to the country by the British Colonial Administrators, in
fashion with what was operated in Britain at that time. This was the apprenticeship
type of training obtained from a hospital based on a training post.
This system of Nursing education metamorphosed from the apprenticeship type of
training to tertiary education in hospital – based Schools of Nursing, Midwifery and
Post Basic Nursing programme (Ndatsu, 1999; Adelowo, 1988)
Nursing education in Nigeria is eighty one (81) years old and therefore is overdue for
re-organization and restructuring. The weaknesses of this conventional system of
Nursing education necessitating reforms are as follows:
1. The students are not issued with any academic certificate from
the Nursing educational institutions but only receive their professional
certificates of registration from the Nursing and Midwifery Council of
Nigeria on passing the Council Final Qualifying Examination. This
situation can engender a feeling of inadequacy in the professional
nurses thereby affecting the confidence and output of the practitioners.
of nurses, the labour market and the society, hence the need for Nursing
education reforms.
A well structured Nursing education system will not only eliminate difficulty in
academic progression of nurses but will also promote job satisfaction, build
competence and confidence of practitioners; thereby promoting quality
nursing care delivery.
It is however worthy to note that the goal of nursing education reforms is not
just to produce nursing practitioners with educationally acceptable academic
qualifications, degrees and higher degrees. Higher or nationally accepted
nursing qualifications in itself alone cannot guarantee excellent nursing care.
● The age long ideals, virtues and attitudes that will enable them to render
professional nursing care to patients and clients with a passion.
According to Leininger (1991) care is the essence of nursing while Watson (2003)
describes Nursing as a human science within the major focus being the process of
caring for individuals, families and groups. This means that no nursing reforms will
be complete if it does not translate into better patient care. A successful nursing
education reform should translate into more humane, more caring and more
conscientious nurses.
In all health care settings, the success of care is directly related to the quality of
Nursing care.
Sick people are usually anxious, afraid and suspicious even if they do not show it and
reactions to illness are not always logical or rational.
It takes a skillful and caring nurse to:
Running Head: NURSING EDUCATION REFORM 6
▪ bring to bear the needed inter personal skills required to keep the
patient in a relaxed state for treatment and care.
Health care reform, regardless of the specific proposal ultimately accepted, calls for
changes in baccalaureate nursing education to prepare students for
community-based practice. These changes include a shift toward the community as
Running Head: NURSING EDUCATION REFORM 9
the primary setting for clinical practice; greater emphasis in the curriculum and more
extensive clinical experiences in health promotion and prevention of illness;
integration of primary health care within different levels of the curriculum; more
interdisciplinary experiences in the delivery of care; expanded knowledge and skills
for care of mothers, children, the aged, and critically ill patients in varied settings;
and the reexamination of teaching strategies for preparing students with these
expanded competencies. As nursing faculty consider the impact of health
care reform, they are called upon to reexamine the curriculum and clinical
experiences provided within their programs to prepare students for practice in
community-based systems.
Results: The project provided faculty and baccalaureate nursing students with an
opportunity to implement a community outreach education project addressing
Safe Sleep. Students learned cultural assessment, teaching, and communication
skills, and community members benefited from learned knowledge of health
promotion programs.
Review question/objective: The overall aim of this systematic review is to identify the
appropriateness and meaningfulness of maternal-child simulation-based learning for
undergraduate or pre-registration nursing students in educational settings to inform
curriculum decision-making.
Running Head: NURSING EDUCATION REFORM 10
Brown and Hartrick Doane propose that nurses need to draw on a range of
knowledge that enhances the nurse's "sensitivity and ability to be responsive in
particular moments of practice". Theoretical or decontextualized knowledge becomes
a "pragmatic tool" used to improve nursing practice. Simulation has been identified
as a promising pragmatic educational tool for practice learning that can be integrated
with theoretical knowledge from nursing and other disciplines. Bland, Topping and
Wood conducted a concept analysis and defined simulation in nursing education as:
"simulated learning is a dynamic concept that deserves empirical evaluation not
merely to determine its effects but to uncover its full potential as a learning
strategy". Simulation usually involves student(s) providing nursing care to a
simulated patient who might be a manikin or actor based on a standardised scenario.
Following the experiential learning opportunity the scenario is debriefed
and the clinical situation analysed with opportunities for reflection on
performance. In nursing education, simulation is usually used in a way that
complements learning in practice settings. However simulation has also been
used: to make up some clinical practice hours, to provide opportunities to practise
and assess particular clinical skills, and for remedial learning when students
encounter difficulties in practice settings. In addition simulation provides the
opportunity to focus on quality and safety competencies (QSEN) that have been
identified for nurses. New forms of simulation are being developed with multiple
patients so that nursing students can learn to prioritise care needs and delegate
care to other team members.Nurse educators have identified several advantages
for learners using simulation, including: providing a safe environment to improve
nursing competence, allowing learners to become more comfortable with
receiving feedback about their clinical performance, providing consistent and
comparable experiences for all students, and learning a mix of technical and non-
technical skills including communication, teamwork and delegation. Within the
Canadian context, students and instructors have reported positive learning
experiences with simulation, particularly in understanding complex patient care
scenarios, multidisciplinary team scenarios, team-based learning, and reflective
debriefing. Furthermore, simulation technology has been proposed as a strategy
for developing clinical reasoning skills, enhancing nurses' abilities to build upon
previous knowledge and past experiences, and manage new or unfamiliar
situations. Simulation has previously been integrated into nursing curricula in a
"piecemeal" fashion that lacks an integrative pedagogy or theoretical approach.
More recently a number of theoretical and pedagogical frameworks and best
practice standards have been published. In April 2014 a preliminary search of
literature (in CINAHL, Medline, Academic Search Complete and Web of Science)
Running Head: NURSING EDUCATION REFORM 12
was conducted with guidance from our library specialist to test the search
strategy and ensure that there would be enough qualitative findings to include in
the systematic review. A preliminary scan of the abstracts from these searches
demonstrated that many experiential case reports with qualitative findings were
missed with the use of research limiters (including our search strategy specifically
constructed to retrieve qualitative research) so the decision was made to err on
the side of caution by searching more broadly and review a larger number of
abstracts for inclusion in the study. However, a number of reports with qualitative
findings were identified. For example, from a review of the abstracts from a CINAHL
search dated April 17, qualitative research papers (including two
dissertations), 12 evaluation study reports, six mixed methods studies and nine
case reports with qualitative findings were identified. It is timely then to review
qualitative studies to better understand the meaningfulness and appropriateness
of integrating maternal-child simulation-based learning activities in undergraduate
nursing education programs.A search of both the Cochrane Library of Systematic
Reviews and the Joanna Briggs Institute Database of Systematic Reviews and
Implementation Reports have been conducted. No systematic reviews of qualitative
studies of maternal-child simulation-based learning for undergraduate or pre-
Registration of nursing students in educational settings is evident in the literature.
Although a systematic review of the meaningfulness and appropriateness of using
human patient simulation manikins as a teaching and learning strategy in
undergraduate nursing education had been planned and a protocol registered in
October 2009, we learned from contacting the lead author that this systematic
review was not completed. Currently little is known about how nursing students
and/or educators have experienced maternal-child simulation or their
understandings of the appropriateness and meaningfulness of particular
simulation-based learning practices. Our proposed systematic review therefore
fulfils all requirements for the PROSPERO database.
Definitions: For this review we will use the definition of "simulation-based learning
experience" adopted by the International Nursing Association for Clinical
Simulation and Learning (INACSL):We will include any use of simulation in an
educational setting (with pre-registration or pre-licensure or undergraduate
nursing or health professional students) with a focus relevant for maternal-child
nursing. Maternal-child nursing has been variously defined in literature to include
maternity care and paediatric nursing. For the purposes of this review, we will
include perinatal, neonatal and paediatric contexts of care that focus on families
with children under the age of five. We will exclude studies that focus on school
age children, adolescents and/or youth.We have adapted an earlier definition of
"appropriateness" as the "best conditions under which simulation can be
integrated into undergraduate nursing education". In this review "meaningfulness"
refers to the experiences and reflections of undergraduate nursing or health
professional students and educators as presented in the studies reviewed. The
research was retrieved from abstracts with qualitative reports on the
Running Head: NURSING EDUCATION REFORM 13
experience and reflections which this article above calls “meaningfulness” missed
and although the review fails to depict the usefulness of the review on simulation-
based protocols in the enlightenment of nursing students, it proved useful in
giving them the opportunity to put to use their nursing skills, assessing nursing
procedures and allowing learners to become more comfortable with receiving
feedback about their clinical performance, providing consistent and comparable
experiences for all students. Therefore this attempt to improve community
approach delivery of nursing care based on the initial education reform was a
success in showing its role in innovatively achieving community centred practice
for clinical practice.
In the terms of education reform, the curriculum is currently and constantly under
changes due to the shift from the theoretical to evidence-based literature in
nursing strengthened by collaboration with other health professionals.
It would be tempting to declare that transformation of nursing education in the
current context of faculty shortages and other scarce resources as Mission
Impossible. But I believe that the opposite is true. It is my sense that the rapid
changes in healthcare, the shifting population needs and the acute nursing
shortage have catalysed fundamental change, perhaps the most profound in the
50 year history of WIN. The first steps of that transformation are becoming
increasingly apparent as nursing faculty begin to challenge their long-standing,
taken-for-granted assumptions; as they set aside differences and their internecine
warfare of the entry-into-practice debates; as they begin stronger and deeper
collaborations with their clinical partners. We won't see the evidence of these
changes in the literature for a while, because they are just getting started. There's
not a lot to report yet. Here are some examples of the changes afoot: The Oregon
Consortium for Nursing Education has resulted from unprecedented collaboration
between community college and university faculty, with an eye to develop a
standard, competency-based curriculum to prepare the "new" nurse, and to
improve access to a seamless baccalaureate curriculum. The first students were
enrolled in nursing courses in fall, 2006 on 8 campuses- the four campuses of
OHSU and 4 community colleges, with additional community college campuses
admitting students in '07 and '08. In this curriculum, fundamentals of nursing have
been redefined as evidence-based practice, culturally sensitive and relationship-
centred care, leadership and clinical judgement, with these concepts and others
introduced early and spiralled throughout the curriculum. Through a 2-year faculty
development program, faculty leaders in the OCNE partner programs have taken
to heart the many lessons about learning, intentionally attending to content
selection that will help reduce the volume while focusing on the most prevalent.
Running Head: NURSING EDUCATION REFORM 14
Conclusion
The quality of nursing is dependent on the quality of education given to nursing
students. A poorly educated nurse cannot provide the quality health care needed for
the highly technological health care system and complex society of today. It is on this
note that the Nursing and Midwifery Council of Nigeria is committed to
implementation of the Nursing education reforms. This will surely not only promote
excellence in Nursing practice but will stimulate the much needed growth and
development of the Nursing profession in Nigeria.
References