BANKINGOMBUDSMAN
BANKINGOMBUDSMAN
BANKINGOMBUDSMAN
net/publication/353018758
CITATIONS READS
0 478
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sayantan Guha Mazumder on 06 July 2021.
Editor in Chief
I express my considerable appreciation to all the authors of the articles in this book.
These contributions have required a generous amount of time and effort. It is this
willingness to share knowledge, concerns and special insights with fellow beings that
has made this book possible.
We hope “Fusion of Research Thoughts “will become the primary platform for
researchers to share findings and discuss all aspects of their fusion thought of research
in the development of future innovative research that will benefit the international
community. We are now welcoming submissions for future issues of the book. Together,
let’s make fusion of research thought to happen.
Dr Deepchand Dhankher
Editor’s Desk
It gives me immense pleasure to write an editorial message for the book titled 'Fusion
of Research Thoughts’. Fusion of research thoughts, a research-oriented book with
ISBN has indeed provided a great opportunity for academicians, industrialists,
researchers and research students to explore their research ideas, views and thoughts.
The multidisciplinary nature, a distinguishing feature of this book has really helped
academicians, industrialists, researchers and research scholars to expand their
ideology in various segments like agriculture, engineering, health, digital technology,
science, music, banking and finance, and many more.
This book contains collection of research articles from various disciplines or subjects.
Professors, Scholars and professionals have contributed a lot to make this book useful
to not only to the researchers but also to the society. The readers of this book will get
inspiring knowledge. A plethora of topics from various disciplines have made this book
really awesome. This book can be a good source of knowledge to carry out further
research in various areas.
At this juncture, I would like to thank the Editor-in-Chief for his support and guidance
and co-editors for their initiation and continuous support. I also thank all the review
team members and technical support team for their continuous effort and constant
support.
I also thank all the authors who have contributed their research papers and articles for
this book. My sincere thanks to all those who have contributed directly and indirectly
to the benefits of this multidisciplinary research book.
Dr. Prabhuswamy M
From Editor’s Pen
I firmly believe that creative disagreements foster growth. Deviation found in
philosophies controls and navigates progress. In my view point this could be the
simplest definition of a specialization. Imagine a room full of scholars from diverse
backgrounds and experiences, where outcome may have a clash but probability of
getting a flawless outcome is more. Thus, bringing together different types of
philosophers will definitely result in something like a colorful rainbow or a confluence
of rivers, always being soothing and beyond the ordinary.
Marching in the same league the compilation, ‘Fusion of Research Thoughts’ is an
attempt to pool the versatile thoughts and to extract a novelty. Different perceptions
have been clubbed on various issues. This book is a pool of multidisciplinary
outcomes which curtails the monotony and allows the readers to flip their minds. It
is not only an academic outcome that can only be referred by the scholars but it is
also a leisure time knowledge bank.
From corporate-management (e-HRM) to meditation (Sadhna); issues of national-
development (MSME/Banking/Currencies) to human-fitness (physical health); local-
administration to mental-health; ICT to Music and many other diversified
contributions have been made to this book.
For adding worth to this book, I would like to signify my sincere gratitude to the
reviewers for primary screening of manuscripts. A special thanks to the Editor-in-
chief Dr. Dhankher Deepchand for his continuous guidance. Also, I acknowledge
appreciations to Dr. Prabhuswamy and Mr. Karnik Yatin for maintaining the fusion.
Rashmi Singh
EDITOR’S DESK
I shall assure all our readers that our constant and consistent efforts will be aimed
toward increasing the impact, visibility, citations and the overall quality of our book.
Finally, I would like to thank each and every member who have put their tremendous
efforts to publish this book “FUSION OF RESEARCH THOUGHTS” and making a
huge success. Going ahead I look forward to challenging, successful and higher
quality submissions.
Yatin R. Karnik
Research Papers/Articles/Chapters
1. STUDIES ON AM FUNGI ON THREE DIFFERENT ECO-HABITATS
FROM LATERITIC SOUTHWEST BENGAL 1
37. jksx çfrjks/kd {kerk dh o`f) esa lgk;d & çk.kk;ke 255
39. Hkkjrh; ok| laxhr esa rcys dh mRifRr]fodkl ,oa orZeku oknu&”kSfy;kW 266
Mayuri Bhattacharjee
M.Phil Research Scholar,
Department of Commerce,
Dibrugarh University
Abstract
Today’s world revolves around customer satisfaction. Customers are becoming more
sensitive in every aspect. Customer complaints are part of every organization
specifically service organizations. This applies to the banking system as well. With time,
the banks are getting bombarded by customer complaints despite their best efforts.
Thus, to maintain a good relationship with the customers, solutions for such complaints
have become a need of the hour. This resulted into the introduction of a scheme named
as The Banking Ombudsman Scheme by the RBI in 1995. The prime objective of the
Banking Ombudsman Scheme is to redress the various complaints as filed by the
customers relating to the loopholes in the services provided by the banks. The present
study aims at making an evaluative assessment regarding the performance and
progress of the scheme with respect to its effectiveness and efficiency from the financial
year 2015-16 to 2019-20. Moreover, the various modes of receiving the complaints and
the grounds on which such complaints have been filed have also been analyzed along
with the time and cost incurred in handling those complaints. The study reflected that
the OBOs had performed remarkably well over the years and were able to effectively
cater to their set objectives to a huge extent, but, a good scope of improvement lies in
the cracks to be developed yet. Both cost and time factors have been managed in the
best possible way over the years. Few OBOs performed way better than others, showing
less uniformity throughout the country, which is the area of development as per the
present study. Thus, it can be said that for improving the banking sector in India, fully
effective and efficient performance of BANKING OMBUDSMAN SCHEME is desirable
and also the need of the hour.
Introduction
Banks are the backbone of an economy. Banks are known for providing various banking
and Para banking services which are needed not only for the normal operations of an
economy but have also served as a great aid for pursuing normal life activities in this
scenario of pandemic. The advent of digital India, various government schemes like
Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana which aims at financial inclusion and the upsurge of
COVID19 has increased banking operations manifold over the last five financial years.
With increased customer base, along with the increase in the banking transactions, there
has been a rise of various deficiencies in the related field as well. In the present era
142
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
where customers are the king, redressing those customers for those deficient services is
the only option which can keep banks up and running. RBI, well known as the bank of
banks, has taken this initiative and launched a scheme well known as Banking
Ombudsman Scheme in 1995 to eliminate the deficiencies in the best possible way.
Presently, the Banking Ombudsman Scheme, 2006 is in operation. Now, customers of
any bank can complaint about any deficiencies starting from traditional banking
operations to the newly formed e-services. Banking Ombudsman is a quasi-judicial
authority which is determined to resolve the complaints of customers of banks relating
to shortcomings on the part of the banks. Although, the Banking Ombudsman Scheme
came into being with a positive motive, but, at the same time, it is a reflection of the
darker side of the operations of the banks. Hence, it can be said that Banking
Ombudsman is the customer care cell of the banking industry as a whole. For improving
the banking sector in India, fully effective and efficient performance of The Banking
Ombudsman Scheme is desirable and also the need of the hour.
Research Objectives
1. To study and analyse the performance of Banking Ombudsman Offices throughout
the last 5 financial years.
2. To study other attributes of OBOs, like awareness level, sources, cost structure,
mode of receipt and so on.
Research Methodology
For conducting the study, firstly, Banking Ombudsman Schemes as provided in the
official website of RBI (www.rbi.org.in), the objectives of the scheme etc. have been
studied in details, to understand the backdrop which led to the formation of such a
scheme and the base of its working. Secondly, for analyzing the performance, the
annual reports of Banking Ombudsman Scheme from 2015-16 to 2019-20 has been
studied as provided in the official website of RBI. Various parameters have been
studied to evaluate the performance of OBOs in terms of efficiency and effectiveness.
Data related to the number of complaints received, mode wise receipt of complaints,
population wise categories, number of complaints disposed and pending etc. have been
established and presented in tabular form, for understanding the trend of such
parameters over the period of study. Even the impact of nation-wide Digitalization
(DIGITAL INDIA CAMPAIGN-2015) and COVID-19 pandemic has been
acknowledged in increased banking operations, which redefined the role of Banking
Ombudsman again.
Literature Review
Singh [1] in his research paper evaluated the performance of the Banking Ombudsman
in India. The researcher found that the number of complaints increased consistently
increased over the years, specifically on the grounds of credit card, indicating
increasing faith among the customers in the scheme. The results of the study revealed
that more than ninety-nine percent of the complaints were disposed by mutual
settlement and the duration for pending cases also declined indicating the efficiency of
the performance of the scheme.
Devi and Sound Aravalli [2] investigated the role of Banking Ombudsman to redress the
grievances of the customers. The researchers used the statistical tools of ANOVA and
t-test to analyse their performance. The study showed that the number of complaints
received from the customers are increasing at the same time bankers are taking due
143
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
Saraswathy [3] in his research paper attempted to ascertain the awareness level of bank
customers regarding complaints, its procedure, awareness about banking ombudsman
scheme and satisfaction level of the customers on complaints. The research was
conducted with the help of both primary data in the form of responses from bank
customers and secondary data collected from various official and non-official sources.
The researcher concluded that regardless of the present efforts of the banks, the
expected level of awareness among the customers of banks regarding complaints and
Banking Ombudsman Scheme is either partial or significant. Moreover, there is no
complete satisfaction among various bank customers regarding handling of complaint
procedure and their source of information is very low.
Trilochan and Joshi [4] in their research paper tried to determine level of awareness of
banking ombudsman scheme in bank customers in small cities such as like Halwani.
The study revealed that out of the selected 100 respondents, only 28 of them were aware
about the scheme. This shows that the awareness level among the customers is too low
and hence, banks should conduct awareness programmes for the customers so that they
can use the benefits of the scheme if required.
Malyaia and Sirisha [5] analysed the success of the Banking Ombudsman Scheme. The
researcher used secondary data to evaluate the performance of the scheme confined to
10 years from 1999-2000 to 2009-2010. The study so conducted produced conclusions
in favour of the scheme. The researcher opined that the Ombudsman scheme is a boon
and a very important channel for redressal of grievances by the general public against
banks and banking services.
Gousia [6] in his research paper analysed the various modes of receipt of complaints by
the Ombudsman, its disposal mechanism and basis for rejection of complaints by the
scheme. The researcher stated that the Ombudsman has developed itself as a primary
forum of customer redressal and has effectively started to outreach their activities in
order to create awareness among customers. The researcher asserted that the scheme
can perform better if the banks follow corporate governance and education of the
customers.
Research gap
The quantity of literature available for Banking Ombudsman Scheme is less. Studies
relating to the Ombudsman Scheme focus mainly on the performance and success of
the Ombudsman Scheme and also the awareness level among the bank customers
regarding the scheme. However, a specific study on the analysis of the performance and
efficiency of the scheme as per the current 22 OBOs has not been made from the time
period 2015-16 to 2019-20.
144
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
Interpretation: It can be seen from the analytical table that the number of complaints
consistently showed an upward trend since the last 5 years mainly due to the
enlargement of the scheme. This shows that, on a positive side, there has been an
increasing awareness among the people regarding the grievance redressal. However,
the increasing number of complaints defeats the efficiency of the functioning of the
Banking sector. As compared to the other OBOs, the Delhi office of Ombudsman
received the highest number of complaints constituting 13.95% of the total complaints
over the years.
145
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
Interpretation: The table shows that maximum complaints were received via. E-mail
(378856), followed by post/courier/hand delivery methods (261814) and lastly
complaints were filed online (261332). Although both Email and online complaints
grew over the years but the offline modes are consistent with their contribution. The
use of offline modes are significant to the fact that may be most of the population are
unaware of the other substitute (online) which is more time and cost efficient option. It
can be also assumed that the rural population are still not availing internet facility to its
full.
146
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
Interpretation: Cost includes both working capital needs as well as fixed capital needs,
which are imperative for the running of the Ombudsman. This cost is borne by RBI as
a facilitator of banking and para banking operations. Although, the total cost has
increased in absolute terms but the average cost of handling the complaint has reduced
over the years, which is a sign of effectiveness. In 2015-16, Kolkata absorbed highest
per complaint cost, followed by Jammu over the years. Whereas, New Delhi’s cost
operations remained minimum over the years with respect to per complaint cost. New
Delhi and other central parts of India showed better cost effectiveness as compared to
the poles of the country.
147
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
Interpretation: The above table reflects that a good proportion of complaints handled
(pending at the beginning of the year + received during the year) have been disposed
off. From the analysis, it can be observed that on an average, over the 5 years, the
success level of disposing the complaints of the Ombudsman Office of Chandigarh was
the highest i.e. 99.72% approximately. This shows that Chandigarh has been an
efficient disposer of grievances over the years as compared to the other OBOs. On the
contrary, the performance of the Ombudsman Office of Mumbai-II in terms of
disposing off the complaints was not up to the mark implying less efficiency of the
office. Moreover, Ahmedabad was able to dispose 100% of its complaints from 2015-
16 to 2017-18; Bengaluru (2017-18) and Chennai (2017-18) and so on. This is
reflecting the fact that it is possible for the OBOs to dispose off 100% of the complaints
within the year which would in fact be a good indicator of their performance in terms
of efficiency and effectiveness.
148
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
years with increased awareness of the scheme as well as increasing role of the banking
sector in our economy. It has been witnessed that the numbers of complaints have been
showing a continuous upward trend in the last 5 years. This is an indicator of the fact
that Ombudsman has been successful in reaching its target to a great extent. But, only
22 Ombudsman offices are available in India which is again a huge limitation looking
at the population and banking regions of India.
Most of the complaints are developed from urban and metropolitan areas but even the
rural areas have reported a significant growth in the number of complaints implying
that they are also getting involved in banking transactions and are being aware of this
particular scheme. It may also be a contribution of the present COVID scenario in the
country due to which people are resorting to more of banking transactions and trying to
avoid cash transactions as much as possible. The complaints are being received from
various sources or modes. The most common being the email. But, even today people
are using fax, courier, hand delivery methods etc. which are the traditional methods
extensively showing that even though the online mode is cheaper but the infrastructure
is not so developed which can tap its need. Pending cases has shown an uneven trend
throughout the years. Even a single pending case can be detrimental to the objective of
the Ombudsman looking at the fact that they want to solve the issue. Even the cost
factor has increased over the years but the average or the per complaint cost has
decreased which is a very good indicator of OBOs performance. Central regions of the
country have lower per complaint cost as compared to the poles of the country which
is again an area needing special attention. Mostly, it can be said that banking
ombudsman has definitely improved over the years but there is still a huge scope of
improvement looking at certain areas of inefficiencies which are basically hindering
their core area of operations. Moreover, the data present in the Banking Ombudsman
Annual Reports have shown some discrepancy regarding the calculations which has
served as a major limitation regarding the study. A proper data will not only help
researchers to understand the working of Banking Ombudsman but at the same time
will also help the Ombudsman itself to understand and analyse the performance which
is needed for their better future.
Although the analysis and interpretation reveal that the awareness level of the scheme
and the performance of the Ombudsman Offices is consistently improving indicating
the scheme’s bright future, but, a rise in the number of complaints is defeating the
efficiency of the banking services. It can be considered as two sides of the same coin
being mutually exclusive. The efficiency of the Banking Ombudsman Scheme in terms
of disposal of complaints is putting a scratch on the efficiency of the services provided
by the banking sector in India. Thus, best measures should be adopted to balance both
the sides and convert it into a win-win situation for the Banking Industry as far as
possible.
References
1. Singh, D. T. (2011). Redressal Of Customers’ Grievances In Banks: A Study Of
Bank Ombudsman’s Performance In India. International Journal Of Researchi in
Commerce And Management , pp 84-90.
2. Dr. D. Sasikala Devi, D. P. (2020). A Study On The Performance Of Banking
Ombudsman Scheme In India. Aegaeum Journal , pp 478-485.
149
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2
150
ISBN: 978-93-5473-562-2