Notes - Effect of Ice Loading
Notes - Effect of Ice Loading
2.7m 5.14m
2.2m
2.2m
2.5m
3.5m
3.6m
3.9m
3.2m
2.9m
3.6m
3.2m
23.6m 26.4m
16m 12m
Ground
3.7m 4.1m
Span Longths :
distributa
is known as span
1he distance bctwccn the two adjacent poles length. It is
denoted by / and spccified in meters.
geae
the profile of the
The location of the supports (towers) depends upon land along
eanal
transmission linc is to be run. This means the span length may not be
When successivc spans are unequal, changes in load or temperature will bring unt
Span Lengths :
distribution atty
The distance between the two adjacent poles is
known as span length. It
is
denoted by T and specified in meters.
The location of the supports
geneTaly
(towers) depends upon the profile of the
transmission line to be run. This means the span length may not be
is land along
which
equal.
When successive spans are unequal, changes in
load or temperature will bring uneayal
changes in tension in the different span.
It is very difficult to
calculate the sag and tension for each and every
make span and then to
adjustment while erecting the transmission line.
Therefore it is necessary to have calculations
between the two tension towers.
assuming uniform tension inthe conductor
It can be shown
mathematically that the variations in the tension with variation in load
or temperature are within
permissible limits.
Hence for preparing asag
calculations, the equivalent span is used.
The equívalent span length can be
calculated as follows.
Equivalent span length L=1,+
Iitl,+l,...
Where l,. b. a are the lengths of the
individual spans between the two tension towers.
It is to be noted that the
method of sag template for locating towers should not be used
for long spans as well as where the
slope of the protile is very steep. In such cases it
is
desirable to make actual calculations for sag and tension.
--I(PU)
System 3-11
Power Mech. Desig. of Over. Lin. &
Under. Cab.
Sag:
PU - May 2012. May 2013
straight distance between the two
The the shortest distance.
poles
gives
Therefore to minimise the length of A
One Imay stretch the
conductor,
Conductorto
make it straight. Conductor
|Sag = S
conductor is stretched
Howeverif the T
much, beyond its safe value, then
too
break due to excessive
conductor may
Ground
tension.
Fig. 3.4.1: Sag inoverhead line
order to permit safe
that conductors are under safe tension. In
important some dip.
Itis very not fully stretched but are allowedto have
conductors, they are conductor is
tension in the and lowest point on the
supports
difference in level points of
Thns the
placed in between two supports
called sag.
two supports and conductor is
and B are
InFig.3.4.1, A
shows the ´sag'.
thedistance S
2012, May2014
of Sag: Dec.
3.5 Calculation PU- May
2010, May2011,
conductor tension is less
way that
adjusted insuch a safetyshouldbe2.
lines, the sag
is minimumfactorof
overhead strength i.ethe
For an ultimate tensile following factors:
its depends onthe
uanDo%oof conductor 3. Iceloading.
The tension onthe Temperaturevariations.
the conductor.
I. Weightof 4.
considerations:
2. Wind effects. two
thereare
sag groundlevel.
While calculating the equal level.
Supports are at ground
(a) When the unequal
Supports are at
(b) When the
Power System -I(PU) 3-12
Mech. Desig. of
3.5.1 Supports are at Equal Ground Level: fOver.Lin, a
PU May 2010, Dec.
Let usconsider. 2011, Dec. 2012.
The two supports 'A'and "B' at equal ground level. De
Conductor is placed between the supports 'A' and 'B'.
The tension at any point on the
conductor acts tangentially.
Refer the Fig. 3.5.1 in which'0' is the lowest point
of the
L = Length of span in metres. conductor sspacing.
W = Weight of the conductor per unit length
T = Tension in the conductor.
Consider any point P on the conductor whose
origin. coordinates are 'x and 'y' if
f the curvature is Ak
small then the
distance 'OP' is nearly equal to 'x Support
There are two forces acting on the
portion 'OP' viz. Wx
() Weight of the portion OP'
acting
downward at a distance x/2 from
origin "0.
Fig. 3.5.1l: Supports are at
(ii) Tangential tension T equal ground level
acting at points O'.
Taking the moments of the above forces
about point '0' we have.
T·y = W.xX X
Wx'
y = 2T ..351)
Here 'y' is the sag at point
'P",Therefore 'S' will be the (maximum) sag atpointB.
Substitutey=Sand x = in Equation (3.5.1) to have maximum sag
:. Equation (3.5.1)
becomes.
W
(U2)
2T
W'
S = 8T Meter.
"..359
rSystem-1(PU)
atUnequal Level :
p p o r ta
sr e
OU-May 2010, Dec. 2010, May 2012, May 2013, May 20O16
geographical conditions such as hilly areas, vallies etc., the supports can
certain ground level.
o unequal
at
rected: the position of lowest points O' of conductor which is not exactly at
3.5.2
shows
e ofdistance
S2
S.
-X
unequalground level
Fig. 3.5.2 : Supportsare at
refore
support at lower level (support A)from lowest point '0'.
is the distance of (support B) from lowest point 0.
support at higher level
is the distance of
Tis span length = X1 + X
is tension on conductor.
2Th
WI
2x, = l 2Th
WI
ie. I Th
X =
WI
Adding Equations (3.5.3) and (3.5.4)
2T h
WI
2Th
2x, = l+ WI
Th
WI
Using Equations (3.5.5) and (3.5.6), values of X, and x, can be found out. Further ,
S, can be easily calculated.
Catenary curve :
B
|Sags
Wind W;
(Ww+ Wi)
(b) (c)
(a) pressure on conductor
Fig. 3.6.1: Ice loading and wind
sag we have to consider the equivalent weight of the
Therefore while calculating
conductor which is given by W,
W yw +W,' +(w)'
=
= density of icex nt (d + t)
W, = wind force per unit length
= wind pressure per unit area x
projected a
= wind pressure x ((d +2t) x 1] area per unit
lengh
3.7 Sotved Examples:
Ex. 3.7.1: An overhead transmission line has a span of 160m of
Tension T = 2100 kg
Windfotce /mlength Wy =1.6 kg
Secificgravity of conductor material = 9.7 gm/cm.
Sag= S
Tofind:
'ktof conductor / mlength W = specific
gravityX volume of Im conductor
W =9.7 x2x 100 =
1940 gm
=1.94 kg
Total weight of 1metre length of conductor is.
W, =/w'+ w W
W
W, =V1.94)' +(1.6)
W, =2.515 kg
W W,
Sag, S =
W,r 2.515 x(170 Fig. P. 3.7.2
8T 8 x 2100
S =4.33 m
This sag is a slant sag at an angle with vertical plane.
Wy 1.6 =0.825
tan = 1.94
W
.. 0 = 39.510
cos(39.51°)
.. Vertical sag = Scos =4.33 x
Vertical sag = 3.34 m
conductor
Ek, 3733 eead line has a span of 120 m between level Supports. Thekg/cm and
2.5 cm. The ultimate strength is 5200 The wind
has a cross sectional area of
gravity of the material is 8.9 gm/cc. level if
safety factor is 5. The specific
ofthe conductor above ground
pressure is 1.7 kg/m. Calculate the height
minimum clearance of Zm is required.
3-18
Power System - I (PU)
Mech. Desig. of
Over.
Soln. :
Given : Span length = 120m
Cross section area of conductor = 2.5 cm
LIn.&Un
Ultimate Strength = 5200 kg/cm
Safety factor = 5
Specific gravity of material = 8.9 gm/cc
Wind pressure = 1.7 kg/m
To find :
W, =Ve.225) +(1.7'
W, =2.80 kg
Slant sag = W,
8T
S = 2.00 x(120
8x 2080
W
S = 2.423 m
tan W
W
1.7
2.225
= 0.764
0 = 37.38° Fig.P.3.7.3
Vertical sag = S Xcos
3-19 Mech. Desig. of Over. Lin. & Under. Cab.
(PU)
-/
System
Powerr = 2.423 × cos (37.38)
= 35 m
Height of support A
iren
: 95 m
Height of support B
=
Spanlength 500m
Tension T 1650 kg
kg/m.
Weight of conductor W= 1.6
The minimum clearance between water and conductor.
ofind :
l= 500m
95 m
35 m
Fig. P. 3.7.4
Xy - X =
247.5 m
= 500
. Xy t X,
2475
+ Xy- X, =
2x, = 747.5
.. X, = 373.75 m
.. X, = 500373.75 = 123.25 m
OR
= +
Th
W!
500 1650 x 60
2 1.6 x 500
Xy = 373.75 m
2
.. S, = Wx
2T
1.6 x(126.25)
2x 1650
S, = 773 m
Therefore minimum clearance between water and conductor is =Height of :SupportA-SagS
= 35-7.73
C= 27.,27 m
Ex. 3.7.5: TWo towers of height 40 m and 30 m respectively support atransmission
line conductor at water crossing. The horizontal distance between thetowers
is 300 m. If the tension in the conductor is 1590 ka. Find the Clearanceofthe
the
conductor at lowest
towers are at equal point. Weight of
basesof
support A = 40m
Height of
support B = 30m
Heightof
Spanlength / 300m
Tension T
= 1590 kg.
conductor W= 0.8 kg/m
Weight of
Minimumclearance C.
two levels = 40- 30 = 10 m=h.
Difference between
Equations(3.5.5) and(3.5.6)
From Th l= 300m
+
X1 WI
h
300 1590× 10 S
+
0.8 × 300
40 m
= 213.24 m
30 m
=l- X1
=300-213.25
X = 83.75 m
S = 11.76 m
Clearance C = 40- 11.76
C = 28.23 m.
T = 1500kg
conductor and ground
Under.Ca
lowest point of
find : Clearance between the
To
between the towers,
Vertical distance sin 0
h = S, = Q
m
= 350 (1/20) = 17.5
P S 22 m
i20.5
m
22 m
20.5 Y
Fig. P. 3.7.6
= V(350)-(17.5) =349.56
350 m
..()
= X + Xy
h = S,-S,
2 2
W W
2T 2T
0r W
h =7, +x) (x, - x)
2Th 2x 1500x 17.5
= W( +x,) 1x350 ..2)
Xy- X = 150 m
1(PU) 3-23 Mech. Desig, of Over. Lin,&Under. Cab.
-
System
Power
Equations( )and (2)
Solving X, + XË = 350
+ X- X = 150
2 Xy = 500
= 250 m
X = 350
250= 100 m
2
Wx, 1x (250) = 20.83 m
Sag S, = 2T2x 1500
20.5 + 17.5=38m
R, = Rs +S,=
Now,
from the groundis.
O
point -UV=R,-S,-UV
Clearanceoflowest ZV- S, (100x0.05)
OU = 17.17- =
38-20.83 - x,tan (0)
=
= 12.17m
2 cm and weights
of
an effective diameterbetween two adjacent
cm
conductor has Thedistance thicknessis 1.27the
transmission line strength is 9000 kg.coatingofradial Calculate
Ex3.7.7: A
The ultimate conductorhasice projectedarea.
0.9 kg/m. 300m. Ifthe of
pressure of 3.6gm/cm´
factorofsafetyis2.
Supportis wind and
subjectedtoa oficeis0.91gm
and C.C.
weightof1
sagif kg/m
W = 0.9
Soln. :
cm safety = 2
d = 2 Factorof cm
Given : kg t = 1.27
9000
U.S. =
1= 300 m
9000/2=4500kg
.. T = V(W+W)+(W)
S =? W, =
To Find : Sag W
W, W
WFig.P.3.7.7(a)
3-24 Mech.
-I(PU)
Desig. of Over.
Power System conductor.
meterlength of
Volume oficeper = tt(d+ t) x 100 cm
Conductor
Ice coating
-d
Fig. P. 3.7.7(b)
100
. Volume of ice /meter = T X 1.27 X(2+ 1.27)x
3
= 1304.67 cm
conductor,
.. Weight of ice / meter length of
W, = 0.91 x 1304.67 = 1187.25 gm
= 1.187 kg
Wind force/ meter length of conductor,
W., = [wind pressure] x [(d + 2t) x 1001
=3.6 x [(2 + 2x 1.27) x 100)
= 1634.4 gm
=1.634 kg
.. Total weight of conductor / meter length,
W, =y(w+ W)+ (W,)'
V0.9+1.187)' +(1.634)
= 2.65 kg
W,I 2.65 x 300
Sag S=
8T 8x4500
S =3.626 m
Ex. 3.7.8 : kg, Spar
If weight ofconductor is 0.35 kg/m, maximum allowable strength is800colanery
length is 160 mand safety factor is 2. Find the minimum point of
Supports are at 70 m and 65 m.
Soln.:
Given :
Weight of conductor W= 0.35 kg/m
Maximum allowable strength = 800 kg
3-25
n- I
System
(PU) Mech. Desig. of Over. Lin. &
Under. Cab.
Factor of safety = 2
Power
T= 800 /2 = 400 kg
Span length = 160 m
70 m
Height of support A
65m
Height of supportB
find:Sag=? -l=1 80m
S1
70 m
65 m
Fig. P. 3.7.8
|between supports,
Difference inlevel
h =70m 65m = 5m
KË + X = l60m
2 2
W x Wx
Now Sag S, = 2T
and S, = 2T
2 2
Wx Wx
h =S- S, = 2T 2T
2
W
S =2T ( X-
S = (X1 - X) (X1+ x, )
5x2x 400
5x2T
(Xj X) = w(X +X) 0.35 (160)
= 71.43 m
71.43
X1 - Xy =
160
XË + Xy =
2x, = 231.43
X = 115.71 m
3-26
Power System - I (PU) Mech.
160 -
Desig. of Over.
2
115.71 =44.28 m
S, = 2T (0.35 x115.71
2x 400
and S,
2
(0.35 x44.28)
=5.86 m
2T 2x 40O
Èx, 3.7,9: Àtransnmission line has a span of 120 mbetween
=0.85 m
inlevel
has a cross-sectional area of 3 cm The
tension thesupports, The
sag. Also calculate the vertical wiconduct o r
the specific gravity of the conductor is 9.9 gm/cm and
length, calculate the nd
sag. pres ure is 15
Soln. :
Span length, l = 120m
DllDec. 2010,8 Mar
Working Tension, T = 2000 kg
Wind force/length of conductor W, = 1.5 kg
Weight of conductor/m length,
W = Specific Gravity x Volume of
= 9.9 x3X 100 gm
Im conductor
= 2970 gm = 2.97 kg
Total weight of 1m length of conductor
W, =/w+w
V(2.97)' +(1.5) =3.327 kg
=w
3.327 x(120) m =2.9943 m
:. Sag, S 8T 8x 2000
This is the value of slant sag in a direction making an angle with the verticle.
the figure,
W
1.5
tan WJw =0.5050
2.97
9 = tan
= 26.796° W
W
700
tofconductor 700 kg/ km = 1000 =0.7 kg per meter.
Safety factor = 2
strength = 3000 kg;
ate Ground clearance = 8 m
250m;
ength = Ultimate Strength 3000
Working Tension = 1500 kg
Safety Factor 2
H =11.645 m
B
t..
S=3.645m
11.834m
8m
250m
Fig.P. 3.7.10
conductO
span of 180 between level suppots. Line
m
ransmission line has a
cm and it weighs 1 kg/m. If the breaking
orOSS-sectional area of 13 the maximum sag for a satery
Caculate projected
Conductor is 4000 ka/cm of 100 kg/m of the 6 Marks
pressure
factor of 4 Assumne a maximum wind PU- Dec, 2011,
Suriace
2
|= 120 m, 1.3 cm ,
2
d = 0.643 cm, B.S = 4000 kg/cm,
W W,= 10O kg/m
lkg/m, S.F=4,
3-28 Mech. Desig. of
-1(PU)
PowerSystem
B.S4000=
4
1000
Over.LIn,
xProjectedarea=100 x([d] x 1)
Wa = W,
0.64) xl = 0.64kg/m
= 100x 100
+W=V1+0.64= 1.189 kg
W,
w,r L189 x(120) = 2.14 m
SagS = 8x 1000
8T
kg
Total W, = w+ w = V(2.225)+ (1.5)'= 2.68
W, (2.68) (150 60,300 = 3.015 m
Sag = 8T 8(2500) 20,000
Theconcueb
between level supports.2000kg.Ihe
Ex. 3.7.13 : Atransmission line has a span of 150 m conductor 0s pressues
has cross-sectional of2cm, The tension in the
gm/em and wind
specifio gravity of the conductor material is 9.9 Mart
calculate the sag. What is vertical sag ? 2013,8
1.5 kgimlength, 2012, May.
PU- Dec.
Soln.:
Span length l= 150 m, Working Tension T=2000 kg
Wind forcelm length of conductor, O, = 1.5 kg
weight of conductor/m length
3-29 Mech. Desig. of
(PU) Over. Lin. & Under. Cab.
-
SSI•M
13.
P.3.7.
Fig.
Referto 1.5 =0.76 0 = 37°
tan
1.98
=3.48 × cos 37° = 2.77 m
Sag = S cos
V'ertical 200 meters, the line conductor weights 0.7 kg
overhead line has a span of in the
S7.14: An meter. Calculatethe maximum Sag. If the maximum allowable tension
per
1400 kg. Prove the formula used,
ine is 35.1.
derivationRefer section
t.:For = 0.7 kg/m
1= 200 m
T = 1400 kg
o 0.7 x(200 =2.5 m
Sag = 8T 8x 1400
Fig. P. 3.7.15
Power System - I(PU) 3-30
Mech.
h = S,-S
Desig. of Over.
2
Sag, S,
Sag, S, = 2T h
2T
= 15 m
n.&hdex
Tension, T = Ultimate strength 8000
safety factor 5 =1600
= 600 m
h =
-) =2(K4+X)(K4 X)
1kg
From equation (ii)
1
15
2x 1600 o00 (x - X)
Az-K = 80 m
From Bquation (i) and (i)
X, = 340 m
X1 = 260 m
vertical sag, S, = S, Cos 0
Since, = 0°
S, = S, Cos 9
Cos = 1
Vertical sag S, = 2T = 2x 16O0
1x (260) = 21.125 m
2
2T
1x340x 340 = 36.125 m
2× 1600 ..AnS
3.8
Sag Template and
3.8.1 Sag Template :
Stringing Chart:
Before erecting a
of proposed route of
line.
transmission
line, initial planning is
required which consists ofsurve
This helps in drawing the
Use is made of estimated line
sag templates drawn to profile.
the
Asag
template is avery convenient way ofsame scaletheas the linein profile.
Sag template is locating towers the field.
As shown in Fig.prepared celluloid or tracing cloth.
on
3.8.1, the upper
curve (curve
The middle curve (curve B) represents a uniform vertical distance conductor.
the lineequaltothedesite
A) represents
minimum vertical clearance to
ground which depends on the line voltage.