2 - Overview of Properties of Exploration Fields
2 - Overview of Properties of Exploration Fields
By
Dr. Islam Nagy El-Nekhiely
Assistant Professor of Applied Geophysics
Suez Canal University
Geological and thermogeological properties
of thermal and subthermal sources
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 3
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 4
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 5
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 6
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Mudpots
• Mudpots are surface features that occur when limited
amounts of geothermal water is mixed with mud and clay.
Acid and bacteria in the water can dissolve surrounding
rock forming viscous pools of bubbling mud.
3/4/2024 8
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 9
Overview of properties of exploration fields
3/4/2024 10
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• Cap rocks need to play role as in any subsurface fluid system; to stop
vertical and steep oblique migration (movement).
11
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The objective of geothermal exploration is to obtain adequate information about the properties and
features of a prospective geothermal system before embarking on drilling. Most of the information
include but not limited to:
1. Identify areas with potential geothermal energy.
2. Estimate equilibrium reservoir temperatures.
3. Characterize thermal fluids.
4. Define the geometry (shape, size and depth) of the resource.
5. Rank the prospect areas in order of development priority.
6. Develop a conceptual model.
7. Locate suitable drilling targets.
12
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• This exploration program consists of several phases, which are described as follows:
13
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The application of physical theories and measurements to discover the properties of the Earth.
• Geophysical surveys provide the only means of delineating deep subsurface features, other than drilling. They can
be used to cover large areas in a short time and at much lower cost when compared to drilling.
14
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Geophysical
Methods
Seismic
Electromagnetic Electrical Gravity Magnetic
reflection
Depth to Depth to
MT Sometimes VES (basement) (basement)
source of heat source of heat
Depth to the
Curie point
3/4/2024 15
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• Magnetotellurics (MT) is a passive geophysical method which uses natural time variations of
the Earth's magnetic and electric fields to measure the electrical resistivity of the sub-
surface.
• Resistivity distribution could be obtained from depth of few 10s of meters, down to several
hundred kilometers
Why resistivity?
• Fluid (Amount - Nature (liquid or vapor phase, other liquids and gases – Salinity))
3/4/2024 16
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The equipment generally consists of four current electrodes and three magnetometers.
• Electric field (E) and magnetic field (H) are measured along two perpendicular directions
(x and y)
3/4/2024 17
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Geophysical Exploration
Magnetotelluric
• Magnetotellurics (MT) is a passive geophysical method which uses natural time variations of
the Earth's magnetic and electric fields to measure the electrical resistivity of the sub-surface.
• The equipment generally consists of four current electrodes and three magnetometers.
• Electric field (E) and magnetic field (H) are measured along two perpendicular directions (x
and y)
3/4/2024 18
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• Source of current - changes in the Earth’s magnetic field caused by solar particles
and atmospheric phenomena (e.g. lightning charges)
• These occurrences induces electric current flow in the subsurface, and current
flow depends on conductivity of rocks.
• Subsurface structures have the role of conductors, and the amplitude and phase
of magnetic field and induced electric field depend on the rocks conductivity
3/4/2024 19
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• Time change of the Earth’s magnetic field are of period from 10-3 s to 105 s (frequency 103 do 10-5 Hz)
• frequency (f)
• Skin depth – the relative measure of the depth to which electromagnetic waves penetrate (the depth at which
the amplitude of the electromagnetic wave decreases to 1/e of the amplitude on the surface
3/4/2024 20
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 21
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 22
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Gravity method
• The gravity method exploits the density contrasts among different rock formations to map subsurface
structure, delineate faults and intrusive bodies below the surface and determine the thickness of
alluvium in sedimentary basins.
• In the context of geothermal prospecting, gravity surveys are used to define lateral density variation
related to deep magmatic body, which may represent the heat source.
Magnetic method
• Also, the idea of using magnetic anomalies for the exploration of geothermal energy is based on
calculating the depth to the basement rocks which is believed to be one of the heating sources of the
ascending meteoric or intrusion water.
• One of the most important applications for using the geophysical magnetic data is not only to delineate
the regional subsurface structures but also to calculate the depth to the Curie point, the thermal gradient
and the heat flow.
23
Deep Geothermal Engineering
24
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Corrected TF
43700
43650
43600
43550
43500
43450
43400
43350
43300
43250
3227000 3228000 3229000 3230000 3231000 3232000 3233000
Sedimentary rocks
Basement rocks
4 March 2024
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The Earth’s lithospheric magnetic field originates from the magnetism of rocks in the crust and upper
mantle with a temperature lower than the Curie point.
• The depth at which the Earth’s magnetic minerals lose their ferromagnetic property is known as Curie
point depth (CPD).
• A Curie point isothermal surface (called a Curie surface) is created by ferromagnetic minerals in
crustal rocks becoming a paramagnetic interface when the temperature reaches the Curie point.
• The depth to the curie point depth is extremely important when exploring for geothermal energy.
27
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The areas which have shallow depths to the curie point are characterized by high temperature gradient
which is considered the main heating source for the groundwater, forming geothermal reservoir.
• Magnetic mineral that is very common in igneous rocks have different Curie temperatures,
(The temperature of Curie isotherm is 550 °C ± 30 °C).
• Several geothermal reservoirs got their heat from this point which is believed to be the depth for
geothermal source.
• The Curie surface varies from region to region, depending on the regional geology, the geothermal flow,
and the mineral content in rock
3/4/2024 28
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• Nwankwo et al. [2009] observed that different minerals which are ferromagnetic have different Curie
temperatures, magnetic mineral that is very common in igneous rocks is within the range of a few hundreds
to 580 °C.
• The depth at which the Earth’s Fe–Ti oxide minerals lose their ferromagnetic property is known as Curie
point depth (CPD).
• The temperature of Curie isotherm is 550 °C ± 30 °C.
• Several geothermal reservoirs got their heat from this point which is believed to be the depth for geothermal
source.
• The degree of growth in temperature per unit depth in the Earth owing to the outflow of heat from the centre
is known as the geothermal gradient.
• The Curie point depth is the theoretical surface with a temperature of approximately 580oC and can be
considered as an index of the bottom of a magnetic source, due to the converting of the ferromagnetic
minerals to paramagnetic minerals (Hsien et. al., 2014).
• The Curie surface varies from region to region, depending on the regional geology, the geothermal flow, and
the mineral content in rock
3/4/2024 29
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• To calculate the Curie point depth in a specific area, we need to analyze the magnetic intensity data
(Aero-magnetic maps).
• Thereafter, the estimation of the temperature gradient and heat flow values becomes an easy target.
• Its disadvantage is that it cannot directly measure the geothermal parameters at a relatively large
depth.
• There are many factors that affect the depth of a Curie surface, including the surface heat flow, the
geothermal gradient, the rock heat generation rate, mantle heat flow, fault activity, and the composition
of rock physical properties.
3/4/2024 30
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• Aeromagnetic surveys are often flown at relatively low heights; thus, the magnetic fields caused by the
surface sources suppress the signals coming from the deep crust.
• The power spectrum analysis of magnetic anomalies to estimate the depth of the Curie surface (Maden,
2010; Saibi et. al., 2015; Tanaka et. al., 1999) was used in this technique.
• In the calculation process, we first divide the study area into windows of equal size.
• The size of the window should be at least 4–6 times the depth of the Curie surface (Dimitriadis et. al.,
1987; Nwobgo, 1998).
3/4/2024 31
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The area required to estimate the depth of the Curie – temperature isotherm should not less than few
hundred kilometers (Maus et. al., 1997).
• (Okubo et. al., 1985) suggested that centroid depth (Zo) estimation could be derived from data windows
as small as 40 × 40 km.
Calculation methods
3/4/2024 32
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The Curie point depth and the measurements of temperature gradient and
heat flow values can be estimated using the spectral analysis and technique
through these steps:
1. Calculate the upper boundary depth of the magnetic source (Zt) by fitting a straight line
through the high wave number part of a radially averaged power spectrum.
2. Calculate the centroid of the magnetic source (Zo) by fitting a straight line through the
low wave number part of the radially averaged frequency scaled power spectrum.
3. The Curie point depth (Zb), which is considered the lower boundary of the magnetic
source, can be calculated from the following relation (Okubo et. al., 1985 ; Tanaka et.
al., 1999):
Zb = 2Zo – Zt ,
3/4/2024 33
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• The Curie point depth and the measurements of temperature gradient and
heat flow values can be estimated using the spectral analysis and technique
through these steps:
4- The geothermal gradient (dT/dZ) between the earth's surface is calculated from the
following relation:
dT/dZ = 580oC/Zb ,
5- Moreover, the heat flow (q) will be a valuable tool in studying the geothermal energy and
can be derived from the geothermal gradient as follows:
q = λ (dT/dZ) = λ 580oC/Zb ,
Where: (λ) is the thermal conductivity of the prevailing rocks. Thus, the Curie point depth
is inversely proportional to heat flow
3/4/2024 34
Deep Geothermal Engineering
• In each block the total field anomaly data were Reduced to the
Magnetic pole (RTP) and tapered at boundaries.
• The spectral analysis technique was applied for each square, and the
above-mentioned parameters were identified to estimate the Curie
depth point and the temperature gradient as well as the heat flow
values for the study area .
3/4/2024 35
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Overview of properties of exploration fields
Case study (the Gulf of Suez region and surroundings (Sinai Peninsula & Eastern desert).)
Total intensity aeromagnetic map of the Gulf of Suez region and Reduced to the pole magnetic map of the Gulf of Suez region and
surroundings (Sinai Peninsula & Eastern desert). surroundings (Sinai Peninsula & Eastern desert).
3/4/2024 36
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Overview of properties of exploration fields
Case study (the Gulf of Suez region and surroundings (Sinai Peninsula & Eastern desert).)
37
Examples of using of spectral analysis technique to estimate the depth To the Curie point in blocks 1, 15, and 30.
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Overview of properties of exploration fields
Case study (the Gulf of Suez region and surroundings (Sinai Peninsula & Eastern desert).)
Depth to Geothermal
Square Depth to top Curie depth Heat Flow
Centroid gradient
No. Zt(km) Zb(km) mW/m2
Table : Obtained results of Curie Z0(km) ̊C/km
depth, Geothermal gradient, and
Heat flow values 1 4.80 11.24 17.68 31.12 77.79
2 5.27 11.96 18.65 29.50 73.74
3 5.42 10.91 16.41 33.53 83.81
4 5.55 8.17 10.80 50.95 127.37
5 5.13 12.82 20.50 26.82 67.06
6 4.61 14.36 24.11 22.81 57.03
7 4.53 15.19 25.84 21.29 53.22
8 5.53 10.78 16.04 34.29 85.73
9 5.01 9.28 13.54 40.62 101.54
10 4.70 9.30 13.91 39.53 98.83
11 4.44 9.20 13.96 39.39 98.48
12 4.78 12.65 20.53 26.80 66.99
13 5.31 14.02 22.73 24.20 60.49
14 5.01 13.12 21.22 25.92 64.79
15 5.17 10.85 16.53 33.28 83.20
38
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Overview of properties of exploration fields
Case study (the Gulf of Suez region and surroundings (Sinai Peninsula & Eastern desert).)
Curie point depth map of the Geothermal gradient map of the Gulf of Suez Heat flow map of the Gulf of Suez region and
Gulf of Suez region and surroundings. region and surroundings. surroundings.
3/4/2024 39
Deep Geothermal Engineering
40
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 42
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 43
Deep Geothermal Engineering
3/4/2024 44
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Geophysical Exploration
Reflection seismic method
• Although, reflection seismic methods have been very successfully used in exploration for oil and the
theory and field procedures are well established, their use in deep geothermal reservoir exploration has
been rather limited
• The physical property of seismic methods is the density or elastic
constants.
45
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Geophysical Exploration
Seismic methods (Seismic sources)
Geophones:
• The receivers used on land.
Hydrophones:
• Seismic receivers at sea.
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Geophysical Exploration
Seismic methods (Seismic reflection)
• Seismic reflection maps the structure of subsurface formations by measuring the times required for a
seismic wave to return to the surface after reflection from interface between formations having different
physical properties.
• Reflection seismic method is more commonly used in the geothermal explorations because it can give clear
information about deep subsurface tectonic configuration and identify the possible pathways for the
ascending thermal waters (Chandrasekharam et. al., 2015).
S = Source
R = Receiver or
Geophone S R S R
Deep Geothermal Engineering
Geophysical Exploration
Seismic methods (Seismic reflection)
Two-way-time (TWT)
Deep Geothermal Engineering
TRACE
Geophysical Exploration
Seismic methods (Seismic reflection)
-750
-1000
-1250
-1500
In addition, attribute
Coherence the eastern is margin
an edge of the Gulf of
detection
attribute that highlightsbygeologic
Suez is characterized a majorfeatures that
rift border
have
fault, abrupt
which has boundaries. Due to throw
a considerable its ability to
(+5000
image
m.) and discontinuities, coherence
gets the Miocene andis Pre-Miocene
applicable to
many types
sections in ofjuxtaposition
structural andwith
stratigraphic events
the basement
(Abdel-Fattah
complex. and Alrefaee, 2014).