Chapter 3 Structure
Chapter 3 Structure
Chapter 3 Structure
magmatic
arc conjugate fractures
Oceanic
orthogonal
Plate
convergence
Transfer
σ1
Structure
vein accretionary
Continental wedge
Plate
ic Plate
splay Ocean
ting
back arc duc
sub
Figure 3.1 Illustration of three classes of major structures which participate in epithermal-porphyry ore formation in magmatic arc-back
arc environments and described herein.
Bobadah
Trench subduction
Peak Hill
Mineral Hill Fifield Bowdens zone (figure 3.4;
Goonumbla Copper Hill Corbett and Leach,
Tran
Cowal Cadia s v er 1998).
se Z
West Wylong Browns one
Gilm
Gidginbung Creek
o
Dobroyde
re S
Mt Adra
u tu
Adelong
re
Figure 3.3
Corbett Aeromagnetic image of New South Wales, Australia, showing several ore systems localised along the Gilmore suture terrain
SC2012_1371
boundary and Lachlan Transverse Zone. Note the NS trending segments of the Macquarie Arc which host the Goonumbla, Copper Hill
and Cadia districts.
1992 image by NSW and Commonwealth of Australia Departments of Mineral Resources.
3.1.3 Conjugate fractures Deseado Massif, figure 3.5) are equally aligned in
relation to the arc-parallel fractures and display 60°
Conjugate fractures are recognised at much lower separations typical (Price, 1966; Blés and Feuga,
angles to the arc than the arc-normal structures 1986) of conjugate fractures. Variations in the angular
and appear to be best developed within orthogonal relationship may be consistent with brittle or ductile
compressional magmatic arcs (figure 3.1). Some failure (Price and Cosgrove, 1990) and hence crustal
settings host opposing fractures in the one location level of formation. Low angles (to 38°) are recognised
or distributed throughout the arc, while elsewhere at the Batu Hijau, Indonesia (figure **) and very high
one fracture may be dominant. Orthogonal fractures angles (125°) in the deeply eroded crystalline terrain
should not be confused with conjugate elements. of the Pontides in the Eastern Black Sea (Güven, 1993
Although conjugate fractures are interpreted to in Moon et al., 2001; figure **).
have formed during orthogonal compression and
display associated strike-slip senses of movement In northern Chile-Argentina (figure 3.2) the NW
(figure 3.1), vein kinematics suggest many have been conjugate fractures may dominate over NE. Some
reactivated during extension associated with transient important fractures include the NW La Escondida
relaxation of compression. Vein orientations within trend which localises the La Escondida porphyry
the conjugate fractures demonstrate the Batu Hijau district at the intersection with the Domeyko fault
porphyry, Indonesia (figure 3.**) and the Mastra Au system, and the NW Veladero trend which localises
veins, Turkey (figure 3.**) were emplaced during a the Pascua-Lama, Chile-Argentina and Veladero,
relaxation of compression. Argentina high sulphidation epithermal Au deposits.
The El Quevar high sulphidation system is localised
There is considerable variation in the angular by the NW Co. Ricon Azure fracture, which hosts
relationship between the conjugate fractures many volcanic centres, while in northern Chile the
and to the structural grain of the district. Most El Guanaco high sulphidation epithermal Au deposit
conjugate fractures (northern Chile, figure 3.2 and and San Cristobal, low sulphidation Au deposit in are
Peru
Brazil Figure 3.5 Conjugate fractures influence ore formation in the
Bolivia
Deseado Massif, Argentine Patagonia.
A - Regional setting and location, including of figure 3.2 a the top
Chile box and figure 3.5 B as the lower box.
B - Mines and exploration projects within the Deseado Massif.
C - Fractures apparent on a remote sensing image in the Cerro
Moro district (from Climax Mining website). See also section
0 1000km
3.2.3.2.1 and figure 3.4 for discussion of these structures in ore
Argentina
shoot formation.
Subduction-related 144
o
compression Einasleigh
σ1 Forsayth
Cop
Wirra Wirra
Caldera
perfi
eld
t
en
Scotia Plate Mt Borium m
ar
ne
Li
CORBETT ai1681
Kidston X
B
Percyvale
Lochabar
X Ring Dyke
19 00 19 00
o
X
o
Complex
Line
n
rto
arm
lbe
Gi X Christmas Hill
ent
X
Baystow
Ring Dyke
Gilberton X X
Complex
0 100 km
144
o
At prospect scale dilatant fractures control the Orthogonal extension responsible for epithermal
geometry of epithermal veins, especially the vein formation is commonly manifest as sets listric
development of better mineralisation within faults with sub-parallel strike and normal senses of
ore shoots, and these kinematic controls are movement which may define the structural grain of
commonly related to larger scale structures or the district (Sierra Madre, northern Mexico; Great
tectonic movements, such that better mineralisation Basin, US; southern Peru; Argentine Patagonia;
generally occurs in second order structures. Similarly, Gosowong, Indonesia; Hidden Valley, Papua New
many porphyry deposits are localised by dilatant Guinea). Bedding may be reoriented while subsidiary
structures such as splay faults and some of the faults develop in the hanging wall to the principle
best mineralisation may occur in sheeted vein fault with dips towards that structure (figure 3.7).
systems or breccias governed by a dilatant structural Drag on the fault tips during normal movement
setting. Sheeted fractures not only host porphyry provides a curvature to each structure in plan view
mineralisation, but as dilatant fractures, participate in with opposite senses (Arcata, Peru; figure 3.8). Vein
the transport of ore fluids from the magmatic source and lode mineralisation typically exploit the most
at depth to higher crustal levels where mineralisation dilatant portion of the listric (including subsidiary)
deposits under cooler conditions. Polyphasal activity faults and so flat pitching ore shoots dominate in the
accounts for elevated metal grades within banded and steep dipping portion of the listric fault and veins
laminated veins. Wallrock porphyry deposits comprise decline in thickness and Au grade as the listric fault
sheeted veins of porphyry mineralisation which, in flattens (figure 3.7; Corani, Peru; figure 3.9, Corbett in
dilatant settings, extend from the source porphyry into Swarthout et al., 2010; Palmarejo, Mexico, figure 3.10;
the adjacent wall rocks (figure 1.1). Gosowong, Indonesia; figure 3.43 Sleeper, Nevada,
US). Smaller scale parallel tension veins may from
Dilatant settings for the development of epithermal stockwork veins arrays within the wall rocks adjacent
vein mineralisation categorised as orthogonal to listric faults or between listric fault elements
extension, oblique extension and transpression, and (Hidden Valley, Papua New Guinea).
compression, influence the geometry of ore shoots
(figure 3.7), either separately or combined. Ore shoots, In many exploration examples vein thickness and
defined earlier as containing the widest and highest precious metal grades have declined as the dip of
metal grade vein portions, are most easily identified listric faults shallowed. Variations of just a few degrees
using gram x metre plots, typically on long section dip of the listric fault may account for the limitation
data. of ore shoots with depth. This is well illustrated in
the exploration data for Palmarejo, Mexico where on
the long section vein
steep flat
portions steeper
C
A splay A sheeted veins than 55° dip hosted
B
blind COMPRESSION ore shoot metal
bedding
ORE SHOOTS sector grades (figure 3.10),
jog or
link
collapse
C
although in many
σ 1 OBLIQUE A A
reverse systems inflection
EXTENSION
fault point is steeper
A
flexure B (66° for Kupol in
thrust C
pull-apart eastern Russia).
cros
s acid
basin σ 1 Consequently, some
faul
t sulphate AB high C listric
cap sulphidation fault exploration projects
hanging B
arc
parallel
may host significant
B
exposures of flat
*
wall splay vein
C
listric dipping listric faults
refraction fault
C arc with extensive
Figure 3.7 Model illustrating the three main structural settings in which mineralised epithermal veins occur, (Corani, Peru, figure
showing the ore shoot geometry for each (from Corbett, 2012). 3.9).
fluid mixing
hanging
* principal
listric fault
wall splay
felsic
domes
CORBETT ai1682
C D E
A B
D E
F
Figure 3.10 Listric fault at Palmarejo, Mexico.
A - View of Palmarejo during exploration with drill roads on the ore shoots.
B - Conceptual cross section.
C - Long section aligned along the La Prieta structure of the Rosario-Tuscon
clavo as >50 gram x metre vein portion restricted to the > 55° dip fault
segment.
D - Map showing the location of ore shoots and long section section (adapted
from Masterman et al., 2005)
E - Legend
F - La Prieta listric fault in underground workings.
M
L
C D
E F
Figure 3.11 Listric fault hosted mineralisation at Ladolam, Lihir Is., Papua New Guinea.
A - 1984 view of the Luise Caldera shows the yet undiscovered Minifie (M) as well as Lienetz (L) and Coastal (C) Zones under exploration.
B - Composite onshore slide looking radar and off shore bathometric map of Lihir island showing detritus derived from sector collapse
(from Corbett, 2005b)
C - Conceptual model for sector collapse of the Luise volcanic ediface.
D - Listric faults facilitated Mt St Helens-style sector collapse for comparison.
E - A Minifie zone cross section showing steepening of the listric fault which cuts the earlier porphyry event and is exploited by the
epithermal mineralisation.
F - Steep dipping Minifie fault in the open pit (2004) which hosted elevated Au grades.
Peruk
Jez lode N
Rambari
ne
ma
Ro
Roamane ult
Fa
II
eV
Zon
structure
Calc-shale
C N S Bleached sediments
0 500m
Tawisakali
from Corbett (1980) CORBETT ai1685
0 100m
Roamane
Fault
calc-shale
bleached sediments
augite-hornblende diorite
hornblende diorite
feldspar porphyry
CORBETT ai1686
Figure 3.12 Hanging wall splay fault at Porgera, Papua New Guinea.
A - View of Porgera about 1991 from the south in part B, with the Waruwari carbonate-base metal Au mineralisation to the left, two
adit levels and the line of drill sites in the hanging wall to the Romane fault at the base of the hill, in which each peak represents a
resistive intrusive.
B - Porgera geology showing augite hornblende diorite stocks, adjacent bleached sediments and some structural elements stock
(adapted from Corbett unpubl. map 1980 and other sources).
C - Cross section 22,410N through the Roamane fault showing the feldspar porphyry which locally exploits the hanging wall splay (from
Porgera Joint Venture data 1989).
D - Roamane fault underground in about 1991.
E - Bonanza Au grade roscoelite breccia in the immediate hanging wall to the Roamane fault about 1991.
vein
6 m @ 15.72 g/t Au
volcanics
10 m @ 17.31 g/t Au
1600m
B
5.3 m @ 48.38 g/t Au
5.5 m @ 48 g/t Au
0 50m 1500m
metamorphics
CORBETT ai1690
controlling structures
0 2km
Figure 3.19 Analysis of fractures associated with an earthquake at Dasht-e Baȳaz, Iran, 31 August 1968 from Tchalenko and Ambraseys
(1970), showing a fault jog which hosts dilatant subsidiary fractures developed where strike-slip movement has crossed from one
fracture to another.
Coromandel
Peninsula
Havre
Trough
Taupo
Volcanic N
Zone
Coromandel
Whitianga
0 100 km Thames -
Ohio Creek - Monowai
Lookout Rocks
district Ohui
coast line
Neavesville
Ohio Creek
Hauraki porphyry
Waihi
Graben
m
St
Karangahake
ru
ra
0 20km
Ta
Tui
Ha
Tin
k
ur
Gu
lly
i
Hau
re e
Ag
u
fF
lt
FAULT JOG
ar
o en
rak
s
nP
Hauraki d
on l
Go tari-ria N
i
S
be
Graben
ai b
Ru
W m
Mo Ca
an
Ohio Creek ata Horseshoe
ri
porphyry
tension vein Thames
Lookout Rocks F
formation bonanza veins
alteration zone
TIM
Hauraki
Gulf Thames
E
Fault
Goldfield m Jupiter
e St
Nap Una Hill
Ha
ur
ak
i
Fa
u 0 2km
N lt
0 10 km
CORBETT ai1582
Figure 3.20 The Thames-Lookout Rocks district, New Zealand showing development of a regional scale fault jog in the Hauraki fault and
development the quartz-sulphide tension vein lodes which link the Ohio Creek porphyry and Thames goldfield.
B C
Figure 3.21 The Umuna Lode, Misima gold mine, Papua New
Guinea.
A - Graphic illustrates the development of the lode as a 2 km
long link structure constrained between controlling structures
with a dextral sense of movement.
B - Open pit mine aligned along the lode in 1990 at the early
stage of development.
C - Banded quartz-MnO oxidised ore.
B C
structural
pretation grain
ter
in
co
nju
ga
dilation
te
fra
ctu
re
El Indio
Argentina
Chile
0 5km
Figure 3.23 Localisation of El Indio within a regional scale cross over of dextral fault movement.
A - Remote sensing image in which major structures are apparent as drainage anomalies.
B - Line diagram showing the dilatant link zone formed by the transfer of dextral strike-slip movement from the NE to SW major
structures.
mine hosts ore within a sigmoidal loop (Caddy in mineralisation is only likely to be localised within
Jannas et al., 2000) apparent as a fault flexure which the short limb faults of the rhomboid which display
hosts early banded pyrite-enargite veins and quartz- dilatant down-drop and activation as growth faults,
gold veins, while the individual ore shoots at the whereas the long limb strike-slip faults tend not to
Viento vein to the east also occur within flexures be dilated and mineralised. Multiple mineralised
formed by the same dextral sense of movement growth faults are common in many pull-apart basins
(figure 1.13 & 3.28) (Gympie goldfield, Australia; Corbett and Leach,
1998) and structures with more dilation display both
.3.2.2.3 Pull-apart basins greater growth fault down-drop and better later vein
development. Consequently, exploration targets might
Pull-apart basins are recognised as rhomboidal down- emerge within steeper portions of growth faults, from
dropped blocks formed by normal fault movement on stratigraphic analyses of volcanic successions.
the rhomboid short dimension normal faults, dilated
by strike-slip activation of the controlling structures Pull-apart basins are commonly discernible at the
which host the rhomboid long limbs and do not surface by recognition of the rhomboidal shape of
B C
Figure 3.24 The Kelian pull-apart basin hosted, low sulphidation epithermal carbonate-
E
base metal Au deposit.
A - Setting within a compressional magmatic arc which provides a dextral sense of
movement to the NS conjugate fracture.
B - Sheeted quartz-pyrite Au veins.
C - Carbonate-base metal breccia mineralisation formed by increased dilation of the
sheeted veins. Figures from Corbett and Leach, 1998 and references therein.
D - Mine area in the NW corner of the pull-apart basin showing the Burung normal
and West Prampus strike-slip faults, andesite domes, diatreme-flow dome complex and
sheeted veins grading to breccias with increased deformation.
E - Disconformities in the epiclastic sediments.
were readily silicified to facilitate the formation of 3.2.2.3.2 The Ocampo, low sulphidation polymetallic
fracture-controlled mineralisation, whereas the shale Ag-Au deposit lies in Sierra Madre region of northern
basement and diatreme breccia rocks which underwent Mexico, characterised by extensional tectonism
ductile deformation did not fracture and so are barren. on parallel listric faults (figure 3.25 A). While vein
Continued strike-slip movement created increased mineralisation typically occurs in the steeper portions
dilation on sheeted fractures with quartz-sulphide Au of listric faults, the Plaza de Gallos pitching ore shoot
mineralisation (figure 3.24 D) and so facilitated the is developed within a fault jog localised by an offset
transition to open space breccias with higher Au grade between two fault segments with a component of
carbonate-base metal Au mineralisation (figure 3.24 E; strike-slip fault movement derived from the curvature
section 7.2.1.2). of the listric fault system (figure 3.25 B). The fault jog
link structures have been activated as normal growth
faults to result in development a localised pull-apart
basin (figure 3.25 C).
F 0 200m
F 11,000N
Con
ico
Ve F
i n
El Rajo Teodora
Str
P
trendG E
d
Refugio Arroyo 3
Vein F
45 Picacho
Arroyo 1
F
Plaza 50 10,000N
de Gallos Arroyo 2
F
Clay alteration
62
CORBETT ai1692
B
Volcaniclastic sediments
fill pull-apart basin
Expansion breccia
40
silicified fault
pull-apart basin
on fault jog
50
D controlling structures
dip to west
D
50 0 100m
19600m 19800m
CORBETT ai1693
A Thailand C
14N
Cambodia
Vietnam
10N
EURASIAN PLATE
6N
Malay
Penninsula
2N D
Borneo
Sumatra
2S
Su
nd
aT
Indian Ocean
ren
ch
4S Java
B
N
SU
MA
TR
AN
FA
U LT Talang Santo
PRETATIO
TER N
IN
Way Linggo
ZO
strike-slip dilation NE
structures
0 10km
CORBETT ai1691
Figure 3.26 The Way Linggo district hosts low sulphidation epithermal Au veins within the dilatant fractures formed in a several pull-
apart basin terrain associated with dextral movement on the Sumatran Fault system.
A - Tectonic setting of the Way Linggo district.
B - Remote sensing image with an overlay of structure.
C - View of pull-apart basin about 1993.
D - Way Linggo banded low temperature opal-bearing vein identified during exploration about 1993.
E - Banded chalcedony-ginguro ore mined in the 2011-17 era.
A B
pitch varies if an oblique fault movement is combined Quartz-gold breccias (figure 13.D) were therefore
with normal or reverse movement (section 3.2.4). As derived from progressive mixing of the south to north
discussed above dilatant fractures join the tails of migrating evolved magmatic ore fluid with increased
arrows which illustrate the movement direction on ground waters (sections 1.2.2.4 & 7.5). The flexure
faults, whereas compressional restraining bends which shape evidences the dextral sense of movement and
join the arrow heads are likely to develop as reverse of the northerly pitch of the ore shoots is derived from
thrust faults (figure 3.16). a combination of this dextral strike-slip and west
block up movement, discernible from slickensides
Explorationists should be aware that in many vein (figure 3.28). The presence of abundant quartz is
systems all meaningful mineralisation is restricted indicative of transition along strike from high to
to flexure-hosted ore shoots, while the intervening lower sulphidation epithermal mineralisation (section
vein portions may be essentially barren or sub- 1.2.2.4).
economic (figure 3.29 A). Consequently, careful
geological mapping is required in order to design drill
programmes to correctly evaluate the flexures. This
may necessitate not using traditional grid arrays.
ore in dilational
adjacent link
structures shoot 3
NE structures
localise fault jog
link structures
C
up down
Viento veins
4200 RL
4100 RL
shoot shoot
4000 RL 2 3 shoot
4
Figure 3.28 Flexures in the Viento vein El Indio
3900 RL district (figure 3.22), Chile.
3800 RL shoot 1 A - The Viento vein system, from figure 1.13,
vertical control to
3700 RL high grade gold showing a series of flexures which account for
0 200m the moderately north pitching ore shoots in long
section. A detailed model in plan view, derived
12387
3.2.2.4.2 At Vera Nancy, in the Pajingo Mining host (section 3.2.1.3), although Mustard et al., (2005)
District of North Queensland Australia, steep pitching suggest structural complexities restrict definition of
ore shoots viewed in long section are localised along a the stratigraphy. Simms (2000) interpreted the veins to
major NW trending structure, described as a regional dip steeply within the ore shoots also apparent on the
scale rift (figure 3.29; Butler, 2004; Hoschke and data of Mustard et al. (2005). It is common for several
Sextan, 2005). Although younger sandstone cover factors to contribute towards the development of ore
obscures the structure at the surface, underground shoots (section 3.2.4).
mapping has demonstrated that each ore shoot lies
within a flexure where the structure deviates from
NW toward EW, locally apparent on geophysical A
data (Simms, 2000). Indeed other ore systems in that
district (Scott Lode, Anne, Cindy) are also hosted by
EW vein portions (see Mustard et al., 2005). In long
section the ore zones bottom at a shallow SE pitching
zone (figure 3.29), possibly due to a combination of
the flattening of the host structure (as a listric fault)
at the base of the ore zone, and the confinement of
mineralisation to a competent portion of the east
dipping Mt Janet Andesite host rock. There may
also be dilation due to a component of refraction
of the major structure upon entering the competent
The exploration implication is that the host as en echelon vein arrays, this terminology might
structure between the ore shoots hosts only very low also include many other variably termed dilatant
grade mineralisation varying to essentially barren, and fractures and veins such as link structures, cross overs
so it is important to plan drill programs to attempt to developed within fault jogs, fissure veins and larger
intersect the flexures and not rely on grid drilling. lodes, localised in a negative flower structure setting
between the near surficial pull-apart basin and a
3.2.2.5 Tension veins deeper splay fault (figure 3.17). McKinstry (1948) also
notes an association with horse tail (splay) faults which
Tension or extension fractures develop by the places tension veins in the central portion of negative
application of a shear component to a brittle rock flower structures (figures 3.17). Therefore tension
and these fractures transition to veins as the open veins represent an important site of epithermal vein
space becomes filled by hydrothermal minerals. While mineralisation development and local normal fault
clusters of tension veins are commonly grouped activity.
Corbett Short Course Manual Section 3 27
Tension vein geometry is apparent from analyses of amounts of vein material and so commonly represent
modern analogies (figure 3.19) and exposures from ore shoots.
outcrop (figure 3.27) to mine (figures 1.13) and district
(3.19, & 3.22) scale. Tension veins develop as fractures At the Thames goldfield, New Zealand (figure 3.20)
initiate at angles in the order of 45° (see Price and large scale tension veins within the Thames fault
Cosgrove, 1990) to the controlling strike-slip structure, jog become more prominent and vary from NNE
and progressively widen as tension gash rotates in trending at the Day Dawn mine, to the corridor of
response to continued movement on the controlling NE trending tension veins extending from the Sons
strike-slip structures (figure 3.30). The wider gash of Freedom to the Jupiter veins, and then the EW
continues to fill with hydrothermal minerals to form trending Thames bonanza veins. The fluid flow model
a tension vein. At an angle of just past 90° to the (Corbett and Leach, 1998) suggested magmatic ore
controlling structures, the rotated portion of the fluids migrated from the vicinity of the Ohio Creek
existing tension gash vein becomes anti-dilational porphyry-Lookout rocks alteration zone, along NW
and a new vein initiates in the vicinity of 45° to the tension veins, which host low Au grade quartz-
controlling structures and the process continues. sulphide Au mineralisation, to deposit bonanza Au
Importantly, the wider reoriented tension veins host grade at the intersection with flinties in the Thames
higher precious metal grades in addition to the greater bonanza Au field. Normal fault down-drop on these
large scale tension veins in plan view resulted in the
A
development intervening tension veins in cross section
(specimen leaders) as bonanza Au grade ore shoots
(figure 3.30 D) described by Fraser (1910) as “richly
gold-bearing ... highly pyritised quartzose veinstone”.
cL
ea between NS trending dextral strike-slip
dom
M
faults, include the prominent Martha
Free
specimen
leaders
wall veins (Corbett and Leach, 1998;
200m
Braithwaite et al., 2006 and references
C therein each). Well banded veins have
been deposited by regular opening of
this dilatant structural setting controlled
by country scale fault movement and
tension regular deposition of rapidly cooling
vein
100m and boiling hydrothermal fluids. Veins
in the more dilatant settings, such as the
0 50m
near EW Martha vein tend to host more
banded quartz (chalcedony) deposited
CORBETT ai1723
Figure 3.31 Structure of the Waihi mine New Zealand (modified from Corbett and Leach, 1998 and references therein) showing NS
controlling structures recognised from air photo interpretation and mapped in underground workings, while the cross section shows
development of the tension veins as a listric fault (Martha Vein) and hanging wall splays (Empire and Royal Veins). The Correnso veins
are oriented in a much less dilatant setting than the main NE portion of the Martha vein.
as a growth fault prior to mineralisation. A series of east dipping bedding in the Waipupu Formation host-
steep dipping veins (Union, Amaranth, Gladstone and rock andesite, (below the flat dipping post-mineral
Favona) extend for about 3.5-4 km SE in the hanging Whakamoehau andesite of Simpson et al., 2001,
wall of the Martha normal fault (figure 3.31) towards previously termed Omahine andesite by Corbett and
the Waihi Basin described (Bromley and Braithwaite, Leach, 1998), led Begbie et al. (2007) to suggest the
1991) as a possible collapse caldera. Some workers Empire Vein originally dipped east and the now flat-
have speculated the Martha structure might represent lying stockwork veins on the eastern side developed as
a regional scale listric fault with extension to the SE steep dipping hanging wall splay faults. Post-mineral
related to the down drop at the Waihi caldera, from normal fault are offset by Steep-dipping bedding-plane
where the ore fluids may have been derived. faults. If this post-mineral clockwise rotation in the
order of about 70° is removed, then the Golden Cross
fissure vein might have dipped in the order of 65° east
and the stockwork veins steep west (approx. 82°).
A B
co
str ntro
wi uctu llin
g
str thin re
of uctu
dis ra
tri l g
ct ra
in
progressive development
of wider reorientated
tension veins with
higher Au grades
C
soil geochemical
anomaly
tension vein
forms
ore shoot
drill hole bored
normal to soil anomaly
and structural grain
parallels the tension veins
CORBETT ai1740
B C D
Figure 3.33 Tension vein mineralisation and drill direction, Mt Kasi, Fiji.
A - Sketch (from Corbett and Taylor, 1994) illustrates the development of tension veins at a high angle to the elongation of the old open
pit, soil anomaly and structural grain of the district which an early unsuccessful drill program bored directly across.
B - Looking long the old open pit and the structural grain with the Waidamudamu dome in the background.
C - Fractures and tension veins at a high angle to the open pit wall, Geoff Taylor for scale.
D - Detail of the mineralised tension vein breccias in drill core.
drill hole
banded sulphides in structure
open space
breccia infill
vein fragments in breccia C
shear
sh formation
n ga
nsio
Te
tension veins
(droppers)
increased
quartz vein with normal fault
shear sulphides parallel movement
to core
shear
CORBETT ai1680
Figure 3.34 Sigmoid veins aligned along the drill core axis and constrained by small scale shears, are common marginal to mineralised
normal faults.
A - Graphic to illustrate the relationships discussed herein
B - Core-parallel sigmoidal tension vein limited by shears, Palmarejo, Mexico.
C - Core-parallel sigmoidal tension vein limited by shears, Drake goldfield, Australia.
by continued normal fault movement on the parallel localise porphyry intrusions, particularly as stock-like
fractures, in order to develop mineralised tension veins apophyses to larger deeply buried magmatic source
at high angles to the controlling faults and commonly rocks. Sheeted veins which transport ore fluids from
parallel to the drill core axis. Consequently, irregular the magmatic source into the overlying stock are
Au grades may occur outside the main ore envelope of aligned along the dilatant splay fault orientation.
the normal fault-hosted fissure vein (figure 3.34). Prior to the classification of porphyry deposits,
Lindgren (1933), Bateman (1950), McKinstry (1948)
The exploration implication of this model explains all describe horsetail faults as mineralised fissure veins
the presence of locally elevated Au grades within small mostly citing the example of Butte, Montana, as a
core-parallel stockwork veins which, during resource clearly dilatant mineralised vein array. Splay faults
calculations, must be taken into account as not part therefore participate in the creation of the space
of the main fissure vein but a marginal stockwork. required for porphyry emplacement within essentially
Elsewhere the recognition of these veins supports any compressional magmatic arcs and later mineralisation
N Radomvo
Tomic
Fault
F
az
ga
7540000
ro
Za
s
q ue
Estan s
nco
Figure 3.35 Horsetail fault array as the termination of this Bla
structure, El Indio, Chile.
of the stock drawing fluids from the deeper magmatic
Bal m aceda
source.
Chuqui
3.2.2.6.1 The Chuquicamata porphyry lies within porphyry INTERPRETA
a continuous zone of mineralisation up to 22 km 7535000 T
IO
long from Radomiro Tomic in the north and the
N
Toki cluster in the south as shown in recent mapping
(Rivera et al., 2012). The Chuquicamata porphyry
is localised at the intersection of NS trending Falla
Oeste (West Fault), as a local element of the Domeyko
fault corridor, and splay faults discernible as the NNE splays
West
veins
FRI
ED
A FA
FRIEDA ULT
Camp
Cu-Au
porphyry
0 5 km
LEONARD-SCHULTZ FAULT
silica-alunite ledges
Figure 3.38 Frieda-Nena localised by a splay in the Fiak-Leonard Schultz fault, Papua New Guinea and development of the dilatant
Frieda-Nena structural corridor. See figure 3.4 for location.
A - View of the Frieda-Nena structural corridor looking NW towards Nena.
B - Interpretation of the Frieda structural elements.
C - Side looking radar image for the Frieda region. See figure 2.31 for SE view of Frieda-Nena structural corridor.
0 20km
P
Dizon
PI
Longos
NE
Taysan
Marcopper
Samar
FA
UL
T
Panay 11°00’
Palawan Atlas Leyte
Negros
Bulawan
Hinoban Placer
Maricalum Siana
N
Mindanao From Corbett & Leach, 1998
Amacan
Tampakan 20 Ohm/m
King King resistivity
Mines Deep well
Prospects Shallowwell
10°30’
0 400km
CORBETT ai1688
elements of
0 2km the Philippine
Fault
124°30’ 125°00’ CORBETT ai1784
D E
Figure 3.39 Splay faults along the Philippine Fault localise ore
systems.
A - The Philippine fault and location of some Philippine ore
systems.
B - Geological interpretation showing the setting of the
Tongonan geothermal field on the island of Leyte, from Corbett
and Leach, 1998, hosted within in a fault jog in the Philippine
Fault where splay faults, which localise greatest fluid flow in
geothermal wells at depth, are similar to mineralised fissure
veins, from Auelio et a. (1993).
therein).
C - The buried Far South East porphyry is localised at the
D - Philippine strike-slip fault adjacent to the Tongonan
intersection of the Lepanto splay fault and elements of the
geothermal field in a non-dilatant portion of the structure.
sinistral Philippine fault, while the Lepanto high sulphidation
E - The dilatant surficial pull-apart basin formed between in
epithermal Au-Cu mineralisation, also projected to the surface,
two segments of the Philippine Fault which hosts the Tongonan
is located at the intersection of the dilatant Lepanto fault and a
geothermal field as a site of intrusion-related geothermal
diatreme margin (from Corbett and Leach, 1998 and references
activity.
Corbett Short Course Manual Section 3 35
a diatreme breccia pipe (section 4.4.5), and displays a In settings of orthogonal compression veins may
fluid evolution trend consistent with models that ore develop parallel to the direction of principle stress
fluids were bled from the Far South East environment and hence normal to the arc (figure 3.7) as steep
at depth (Corbett and Leach, 1998 and references dipping fissure veins. Movement on conjugate
therein). The Didipio porphyry district in Northern fractures which are common these settings during
Luzon is constrained by NS trending fault segments orthogonal compression (section 3.1.3) may promote
formed parallel to the Philippine Fault. Here the the development of ore shoots by rotation of the arc
Dinkidi porphyry hosts NW trending sheeted veins normal fractures as tension veins (figure 3.39)
developed as tension veins in response to sinistral
movement on those NS structures (Corbett, unpubl. 3.2.3.1.1 The El Guanaco high sulphidation
reports; Garrett, 1996). The sheeted veins not only epithermal gold deposit in northern Chile hosts
host mineralisation but are interpreted to have bled both structurally controlled feeder structures,
ore fluids from the magmatic source at depth to a within competent andesites, and larger bodies of
higher crustal level of mineral deposition in cooler lithologically controlled mineralisation, within fiamme
conditions. On the island of Leyte the intrusion- tuffs (section 8.4.1.7). The ore system occurs as a
related Tongonan commercial geothermal field is several km long, roughly EW-ENE trending, steep
located within a fault jog, discernible as a surficial dipping, structural corridor of veins, formed at a
pull-apart basin, developed as a cross-over between very high angle to the NS trending structural grain of
segments of the sinistral Philippine Fault (figure 3.39; the district, and constrained between both conjugate
Corbett and Leach, 1998). Highest (intrusion-related) fractures and reverse faults developed as part of the
geothermal fluid flow in 1-2 km deep drill holes is structural grain (figure 3.40). Limited components of
associated with splay faults which might therefore strike-slip movement during orthogonal compression
be analogous to mineralised epithermal fissure veins on the NE-SW and NW-SE trending conjugate
developed as part of a negative flower structure below fractures discernible on remote sensing imagery, have
the surficial pull-apart basin. locally deformed and dilated the EW veins to result in
the development of steep pitching ore shoots within
There is an exploration implication in the flexures (figure 3.40).
recognition that splay faults or link structures formed
within structural corridors with oblique sense of 3.2.3.2 Conjugate fractures
movement represent sites for the localisation of
porphyry Cu-Au intrusions or epithermal veins. Conjugate factures described above develop at
Once the sense of strike-slip movement is estimated variable angles to the orientation of compression
on such a corridor of individual structures, defined from the order of 30° in epithermal-porphyry terrains
using geological mapping, remote sensing or magnetic to as much as much as 60° in deeply eroded crustal
imagery, an inspection for cross overs could easily levels such as the Pontides of NE Turkey (section
identify exploration targets. Link structures in one 3.1.3). Although these structures are interpreted to
orientation will be dilatant releasing bends (figure 3.16) have formed in response to orthogonal compression,
and in the other orientation represent anti-dilational transient relaxation or changes in the orientation
restraining bends. of compression may trigger their involvement
in ore formation. It is common for one of the
3.2.3 Orthogonal compression conjugate fractures to become more dominant. The
development of mineralisation under conditions of
Orthogonal compression is an uncommon setting orthogonal compression is considered here.
for mineralisation, despite the overall compressional
nature of subduction-related magmatic arcs which
host epithermal vein deposits and porphyry intrusions.
Several settings for the development of mineralised
veins and ore shoots include steep dipping structures
normal to the structural grain and parallel to
compression, conjugate fractures and arc-parallel
reverse faults or thrusts. Reverse faults host flat
pitching ore shoots best within flatter dipping fault
portions (figure 3.7), described below.
3.2.3.1 Arc-normal veins
A B
horsetail of
splay veins
link vein
sigmoid vein
fault
σ1 jog
σ1
flexure
flexure
CORBETT ai1701
a
V. V ulem
a ng V. Z
ua
rdi
a
F. V
an
gu
ard
ia
N.
F. V
an
gu
V.
ard
O.
ia
S.
D
iez
0 20m
N
0 2km
CORBETT ai1700
Figure 3.41 Mineralised veins and ore shoots related to conjugate fractures.
A - Model based upon conjugate fractures in the Deseado Massif of Argentine Patagonia features NW dominant over NE conjugate
fractures, each with components of strike-slip deformation during EW orthogonal compression. Dilatant veins include: EW link
structures developed between NW fracture/veins and splay veins, flexures sigmoid loops, which feature the progression to wider veins
with higher metal grades as veins rotate (from NW to WNW and EW) during progressive deformation.
B - Magnetic data for Cerro Moro which illustrates the NW-SE and NE-SW conjugate fractures along with many prospects along with
the most prospective EW trending Escondida vein group in the bottom left, from Perkins and Williams, 2007.
C - Ore shoot formation at Veta Osvaldo Diez, Cerro Vanguadia, from Zubia et al. (1999).
compression, has facilitated the formation of dilatant Figure 3.42 Second order compressional structures formed in a
sites which host ore shoots characterised by wider setting of oblique fault movement, showing development of an
ore shoot in a flatter dipping portion of a reverse fault developed
and higher metal grade vein portions. Dilatant sites in a restraining bend.
formed by strike-slip movement in response to
orthogonal compression include EW link structures slickensides formed normal to the dip of the fault,
locally developed within fault jogs between veins and which hosts vein mineralisation, indicate movement
including splay veins and flexures developed as dilatant has been either orthogonal dip-slip or reverse.
bends in throughgoing veins. Both groups may display Comparison of the dip angles of the host structure
sigmoidal shapes as veins grade to wider forms with and Au content (as gram-metres) indicates best
higher metal grades as the angular relationship to mineralisation occurs in the flatter dipping fault
the master fault increases (figure 3.41 A). At Cerro portions contoured in figure 3.43. Consequently,
Vanguadia ore shoots with wider veins and higher Au the Kencana mineralisation is interpreted to have
grades are discernible as dilatant flexures within the developed within a reverse fault. The 90° divergence
throughgoing veins (figure 3.41 C). Many ore systems in strike between the mineralised Kencana reverse
also feature a change kinematic conditions of NE structures to the Gosowong extensional listric fault is
extension discussed below (section 3.5.2). consistent with these two divergent ore systems having
formed in the same kinematic environment. Whereas
3.2.3.3 Restraining bends and thrust-related ore shoots have been identified in the flatter dipping
mineralisation. portions of the Kencana reverse faults, Gosowong
vein ore shoots are hosted by the steep dipping fault
Whereas figure 3.16 illustrates dilatant second order portion (figure 3.43). The Kencana veins, which are
structures, compression results if the second order blind at the surface were identified during step out
structures are oriented at 90° those fractures, or if drilling from the Gosowong vein (Richards et al.,
there is the opposite movement on the controlling 2005).
strike-slip structures. In that case, restraining bends
develop at compressional flexures, while folds and
domes are common within anti-dilational jogs, locally
developed as positive flower structures prospected
as as oil traps (figure 3.42). Reverse faults which
take up compressional movement locally host vein
mineralisation, within ore shoots that are most
prevalent in the flatter dipping portions, which might
therefore be blind at the surface and pitch flatly in
the plane of the fault (figure 3.7). Combinations of
reverse and strike-slip movement provide an inclined
pitch to ore shoots.
te
ep
Au in gram x metres 20
str
re
uc
ctu
tu
Link structures stru
re
link RL
Gosowong
σ1
0 4800
A 20
North 20
20 4700
0
C
40
30 4600
B
0
4500
20
Gosowong
19200 19300 19400 19500 19600 19700
CORBETT ai1703
1000N
15.5m @ 41 g/t Au
11.7m @ 17 g/t Au
8.0m @ 11 g/t Au
3.4m @ 5.6 g/t Au
K-1
Kencana 2.4m @ 21 g/t Au
σ1
100mRL
K-2
11m @ 140 g/t Au
2.5m @ 15 g/t Au
0 50m
B
Vein Mudstone Ignimbrite Andesite Volcaniclastics
plunge ho
riz
on
ta
l
up
e
p lan pitch
ult wn
fa do pitching
up n oreshoot
w
do
listric
faults
flat dip
CORBETT ai1537
Figure 3.45 The orientation of an ore shoot formed in the steep dipping portion of a listric fault by the combination of strike-slip and
dip-slip movement showing the position of pitch and plunge.
Gu
NW
ad
pitching
alu
ore shoot 3028000
pe
Str
e o ox
lin ppr
f
a
n
io
ct
40
se
Guadalupe
55
3027000
45
An
im
Clay bloom as
St
Historic mine r
0 500m
761000 762000
CORBETT ai1705
A B
Red Rock
Mt Carrington
White Rock
C
limit of
Drake Magnetic
Quiet Zone
0 5 km
Diorite
CORBETT ai1699
ground water
andesite sill
sheeted
or flow
veins
O2 tuff mineralised bedding
stockwork
fluid sand plane shears
mixing ston Figure 3.48 Mineralised bedding plane shears
e
tuff
at the Drake Caldera.
high angle A - Caldera collapse structure with locally
ande vein interpreted
site mineralised resurgent felsite domes, from
link collapse Cumming unpubl reports and Cumming et al.
tuff structure (2013).
B - Red Rock mine showing mineralised
cross bedding plane.
structure
speculated
C - Mineralised bedding plane shear, Hampton
intrusion workings, 5.1 g/t Au.
D - Conceptual model for development of
bedding plane shear and tension vein (figure
3.34) mineralisation, from Corbett, unpubl.
CORBETT ai1712 report and Cumming et al. (2013).
3.2.5.4 Flat-moderate dipping bedding planes Wallrock porphyry Cu-Au deposits host metals within
may be reactivated within folded rock sequences the wall rocks away from any obvious intrusion source
during compression within magmatic arcs and host and are typically characterised by dilatant sheeted vein
stockwork vein mineralisation which extends into arrays which have facilitated metal transport (figures
the wall rock (Kelian, Indonesia; Cowal, Australia; 3.16, 3.49 E & F). Most porphyry deposits feature
Corbett, pers. observ.). some continuation of mineralisation from intrusions
into the adjacent wall rocks.
3.3 STRUCTURES ASSOCIATED WITH
Isotropic wall rocks or intrusions exhibit no preferred
PORPHYRY DEPOSITS
grain as a control to vein formation, whereas
anisotropic wall rocks may host a cleavage or
Porphyry stockwork and sheeted quartz-sulphide
volcanic/sedimentary layering as a control to fracture/
veins which host and locally transport most Cu-Au-
vein formation. In some volcanic sequences only the
Mo mineralisation represent the main structures
competent lavas host wallrock porphyry veins, while
associated with porphyry Cu-Au deposits, commonly
incompetent intervening lapilli tuffs and breccias do
developed within stocks or vertically attenuated spine-
not fracture to facilitate vein formation, especially if
like intrusions, which overlie more major magmatic
these permeable rocks become clay altered. Breccia
sources of metals and volatiles, and locally extend into
pipe environments are commonly associated with
the adjacent wall rocks (see section 5). The dilatant
concentric veins (below).
settings which localise porphyry intrusions influence
vein orientations which are considered (Corbett and
Stress characteristics which control porphyry
Leach, 1998) in order to:
emplacement are provided by the analyses of
• Understand the 3 dimensional form of the
vein directions, assuming the two are relatively
porphyry intrusion to guide drill tests and
coeval, as orthogonal compression-extension or
resource determinations.
oblique convergence, while vein directions are also
• Develop an exploration model to explore for
influenced by the level in the porphyry system under
more porphyry intrusions in any district.
consideration and host rock characteristics (Heinrich
and Titley, 1982; Titley, 1990; Corbett and Leach,
3.3.1 Some definitions
1998).
Stockwork veins comprise multi-directional vein arrays
Concentric structures such as ring dykes, sheeted cone
with either no preferred orientation, or with multiple
fractures, or veins, may develop as circular arrays of
directions derived from the intersection of conjugate,
fractures within the wall rocks overlying the outside
orthogonal or other orientations, either developed
of a buried intrusion or breccia pipe. These fracture
as one event or the result of multiple overprinting
patterns are interpreted (Phillips 1973, 1974) to
events, the latter locally related to repeated porphyry
have developed in response to the upward force of
emplacement (figure 3. 49 A & B).
retrograde boiling and may be enhanced by collapse
following evacuation of volatiles from the top of
Sheeted veins form as arrays of parallel veins which
a magma chamber (section 4.4.4.1). Mineralised
reflect the stress conditions active at the time of
concentric, locally sheeted fracture-veins are well
vein development, and as dilatant features, facilitate
developed in breccia pipes with interpreted significant
Corbett Short Course Manual Section 3 45
components of collapse (section 4.4.4.6), and locally Radial veins and lodes are common within wall
kink around pipe margins (Kidston, Australia; figure rocks outboard of the upward projection of source
4.17). intrusions in settings of dominantly upward intrusion
emplacement without significant collapse (figure 3.51
& 3.52; Cargo, Eastern Australia; San Juan, Safford
District, Arizona, Heidrick and Titley, 1982).
A B
C D
E F
Figure 3.50 Stages in the development of mineralised porphyry quartz veins discussed herein.
pull-apart basin at
porphyry structural high crustal level
veins grain &
localising
lodes structure eliptical
intrusion splay
fault
concentric σ1 σ1
fractures
tension sheeted
veins veins strike-
slip
fault
stockwork
radial quartz
concentric veins
fractures
resulting
from σ1
collapse
CORBETT ai1577a
Figure 3.51 Different quartz vein configurations formed in varying structural settings. The sheeted veins in the transpressional setting
may rise above the porphyry environment to form wallrock porphyry deposits.
A B
Zn
Au
Cu Mo
ad
ro
lode
propylitic phyllic
potassic
TN MN
C 0 500m
CORBETT ai1375
calc-silicate
D F
0 100m sheeted
quartz veins
CORBETT ai1709
E
Tjuna (dark diorite) - biotite-clinopyroxene-monzonite
Bugoy breccia
Calc-silicate 1711
Figure 3.54ai1713
CORBETT Structural control to the Browns Creek Au skarn
using data in figure 6.17.
600000 E D
C
transfer
A
Nash’s
structures
Hill
635000 N
Tenandra
Structural Corridor
0 20 km
CORBETT ai1714
B D
C D
E
SE NW
LOOKING SOUTHWEST
18 m @ 1.8 g/t Au
sandstone 23 m @ 2.0 g/t Au
2800 m 19 m @ 1.0 g/t Au
and 5 18 m @ 1.4 g/t Au
siltstone 32 m @ 3.1 g/t Au
27 m @ 3.3 g/t Au
mudstone
puggy breccia 31
29
28
r ust
44 Th
mudstone
3 0 50 m
2700 m
4
Corbett 1447
Figure 3.58. Thrust erosion of the top of speculated to now occur as Mt Kare.
F
A - Slide looking Radar image shows Porgera within a coincident topographic
and magnetic circular interpreted (Corbett et al., 1995) to reflect a buried
intrusion source for the outcropping stocks at Waruawri (figure 3.13).
B - Felsite dyke with clast of an earlier carbonate-base metal vein.
C - Thrust in the Waruwari open pit.
D - Double thickness of Dari Limestone at Mts. Paim and Kajende, from
Waruwari, 1980.
E - Mt Kare cross-section.
F - Coarse grained augite hornblende diorite from a stock within in the early
Waruwari open pit mine.
A B C D
σ1 σ1
σ1
link
zone dilation compression
CORBETT ai1717
Figure 3.59 Formation of dilatant ore-hosting sites by the activation of cross structures during transient changes in the nature of
convergence.
A – Typical structural scenario characterised by a major structure, here an arc-parallel terrain boundary with a reverse sense of
movement, and conjugate-style cross structures in conditions of arc subduction-related compression.
B – Offset of the major structure by cross fracture and development of a link zone during compression.
C – Transient change to oblique convergence, here suitably oriented to facilitate reactivation of the former reverse faults and strike-slip
structures and development of a dilatant site in the link zone suitable of hosting porphyry or vein emplacement.
D – Non-suitably oriented convergence results in the development of anti-dilatant sites which might be manifest as folds, domes or
thrusts with lesser potential to host mineralisation than C.