Review Paper NFSU (2 Kud)
Review Paper NFSU (2 Kud)
Review Paper NFSU (2 Kud)
Introduction
Mindfulness is a state of active, open attention to the present. When we are mindful, we are fully
present, aware of our thoughts, feelings, and sensations. (Brown and Ryan 2003)
It is the practice of delicately focusing your awareness on the present moment repeatedly. It
involves concentrating on sensations to become fully aware of your body in the here and now.
We can't expect our minds to be present in the moment at all times, as it is the nature of the mind
to think and analyze things. Its attention jumps from one thing to another, so it is hard to stay
focused on the present moment. Therefore, we should practice this while meditating and during
daily life activities such as cooking, cleaning, walking, bathing, etc. It also involves embracing
your thoughts and feelings without judging them.
The Shapiro model of mindfulness was developed by Dr. Shauna Shapiro in 2006. It focuses on
three core elements that are important for mindfulness practice:
1.Intention- This refers to the reason or motivation behind the practice. The intention is to
develop awareness, presence, and compassion. It is about wanting to be present in the moment
and acknowledging things as they are, without judging them.
2. Attention- This refers to the ability to focus on the present moment, paying attention to what
is happening right now. It involves being aware of our thoughts, feelings, and bodily sensations
without getting absorbed in them. Practicing attention means noticing everything that is going on
without reacting or trying to change it.
3. Attitude - This refers to the approach we take while practicing mindfulness. It includes
qualities such as patience, curiosity, non-judgment, and openness. It is about being gentle with
ourselves and others, accepting situations as they are, and letting go of the desire to fix
everything or the need to control things.
Anxiety is a feeling associated with worry, nervousness, or fear about something that may or
might not happen in the future. It's a pretty natural response to things that seem uncertain or
difficult. Though everyone feels anxious sometimes - like right before an important exam or job
interview - anxiety becomes a problem if the feelings are too intense or last too long, making it
hard to focus or enjoy the more mundane daily events. In extreme conditions, anxiety is felt to be
overwhelming and at times causes sleep, concentration, and overall well-being to be affected.
The chief symptoms of anxiety include speedy breathing, irritability, restlessness, muscle
tension, difficulty in focusing, increased heart rate, etc. The DSM-5-TR contains many specific
anxiety disorders such as GAD, Panic disorder, Agoraphobia, Social anxiety disorder, etc.
A study by Jilian Haydicky, Judith Wiener, and colleagues (2012) evaluated a mindfulness-based
intervention (MMA) for adolescents with learning disabilities (LD) and co-occurring ADHD and
anxiety. This study included 60 adolescents: 28 in the MMA and 32 in the wait-list control
group. Results were found to clearly show results in alleviating anxieties, as well as to improve
social skills and behaviors. But the study recommended that further research be conducted on
techniques that will enhance participant motivation and retention to maximize interventions for
youth struggling with co-occurring disorders and to ensure long-term efficacy.
A study conducted by Teresa M. Edenfield and Sy Atezaz Saeed (2012) reviewed the
effectiveness of mindfulness meditation (MM) as a self-help treatment for anxiety and
depression. The authors' review of mindfulness-based interventions, such as MBSR and MBCT,
showed that MM is highly effective in anxiety reduction and improvement of psychological
well-being compared to their counterparts among subjects with histories of anxiety disorders. A
positive relationship between increased mindfulness and reduced anxiety was observed in the
study. However, it pointed to areas of research gaps, particularly the need for strong studies that
would investigate mechanisms, optimal constituents, and dose-response relationships of MBIs.
A study conducted by Cicero (2013) assessed the impact of mindfulness exercises on anxiety and
coping strategies in elementary school children using a six-week intervention.Anxiety was
decreased, and coping skills became effective to the extent that teachers reported improvements
in behavioral and academic performance. The study highlights potential benefits from
mindfulness to young children, yet the effectiveness and applicability of long-term mindfulness
programs in diversified school populations need further research.
A study by Jose Gallego, Jose M. Aguilar-Parra, and Adolfo J. Cangas (2014) assessed the
impact of an 8-session mindfulness program on university students' anxiety, stress, and
depression. Using pre- and post-intervention assessments. Since it gathers data both prior to and
after intervention, the research demonstrated reduced anxiety levels against the control group,
which consequently suggests an underlying effect as well. However, the study has a small sample
size, measures had not followed up the individuals after treatment, and there is a failure to use
specific mindfulness-related assessments with respect to the effect in the long run and possibly
optimal mindfulness techniques for anxiety reduction.
Lee Redstone (2015) investigated the impact of mindfulness meditatio combined with
aromatherapy on reducing anxiety in hospitalised patients with mood disorders. Results came
from a 5-month intervention and revealed a reduction of 32.6% for anxiety. Although promising,
this study indicates a need for more research to understand the long-term effects, applicability
across different populations, and what mechanisms are involved in this intervention.
A study conducted by Mayorga, de Vries, & Wardle (2016) on the impact of mindfulness
behavior on anxiety included a mindfulness meditation program for students. The authors found
a significant negative correlation between mindfulness and anxiety; therefore, mindfulness
behavior appears to result in reducing anxiety. There were no benefits to mindfulness awareness.
A call for more research into the mechanisms driving mindfulness and anxiety and better
methodologies to evaluate mindfulness interventions is put forward.
Hong Ye (2017) conducted a randomized trial examining MBSR’s effect on student social
anxiety, finding notable anxiety reductions. However, the study only considered anxiety and
excluded more general ramifications such as perfectionism and life satisfaction. Chang et al.
(2016) also established that maladaptive perfectionism is related with lower levels of life
satisfaction but did not incorporate longitudinal analysis, whereas Frost and Marten (2015)
pointed that opposite stress effects exist wherein perfectionism is divided into types and left life
satisfaction out of scope. The current systematic review synthesizes available knowledge on the
correlation between perfectionism and life satisfaction and articulates pathways for further
research.
A study conducted by Michele F. Rodrigues, Antonio E. Nardi, and Michellee Levitan (2017)
reviewed the effectiveness of mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) like MBSR and MBCT
for treating anxiety disorders. This study, under the methodology of a literature review, declares
that mindfulness meditation significantly reduces anxiety in people with GAD. However, it is
still lacking in the mechanism by which mindfulness achieves efficacy and its versatility within
various therapeutic protocols. Future studies need to explore these aspects more to complete this
development in clinical settings.
A study conducted by Hoge et al. (2018) explored the impact of mindfulness meditation on
biological stress responses in individuals with Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD) through a
randomized controlled trial. Mindfulness meditation significantly lowered levels of
anxiety-related biological markers such as cortisol and ACTH. The present study lends support
to the utility of mindfulness as a treatment for GAD but clearly indicates that more research is
needed to optimize protocol intervention and examine long-term psychological and physiological
benefits of mindfulness in anxiety disorder treatment.
A study conducted by Liu, Gao, and Hou (2019) assessed the effects of mindfulness-based stress
reduction (MBSR) combined with music therapy on anxiety, pain, and sleep quality in
osteosarcoma patients through a randomized controlled trial. As a part of this objective, a
randomized controlled trial was designed, and results were presented based on which anxiety
levels, pain, and sleep quality improved in subjects exposed to combined therapy. Conclusion
The study proved the effectiveness of combined mindfulness and music therapy in the
management of cancer-related symptoms, though long-term implications and applicability of this
combined approach for other medical conditions will require further research.
A study by Amir Dana, Vesal Alipour Shahir, and Saeed Ghorbani (2022) examined the effects
of mindfulness and mental skills protocols on competitive anxiety in athletes. In their study, they
included 45 experienced shooters allocated to either a mindfulness intervention group, a mental
skills training group, or to the control group. Both interventions reduced and uplifted athletic
performance markedly but had no significant difference between them. The study calls for
further research in greater detail on specific mechanisms of these interventions and how best they
can be integrated to yield the maximum.
A study conducted by Priebe & Kurtz-Costes (2022) on the effect of mindfulness interventions
on test anxiety in college students included a random assignment of participants to three groups:
six-week mindfulness, three-week mindfulness, and six-week sham mindfulness. Results showed
that mindfulness interventions resulted in a significant decrease in test anxiety for all groups, but
the most pronounced decreases were seen in the six-week and three-week mindfulness groups. A
gap in research has been identified concerning the long term outcomes of mindfulness training as
well as comparisons in effectiveness between differences in length of mindfulness interventions.
A study conducted by Maharana, Goswami, and Behera (2023) examined the effects of
mindfulness on anxiety, stress, and depression among university students in Odisha using a
multimodal survey. The result showed a significant reduction in level of anxiety and that the
variance in the anxiety level explained by mindfulness was around 14.9%. While the study
reports into the auspiciousness of mindfulness interventions, it still requires further exploration
into the other forces that contribute to mindfulness and its wider implications towards mental
health in the education domain.
A study conducted by Malik and Parveen (2023) explored the relationship between mindfulness,
anxiety, and cognitive emotion regulation among university students using survey methods. A
significant negative correlation between mindfulness and anxiety was found, and the variance in
anxiety was explained by 14% due to mindfulness. The study also emphasized adaptive emotion
regulation strategies in alleviating anxiety. However, it shows that future studies should look
further into how maladaptive emotion regulation strategy interacts with mindfulness and
influences the outcome of anxiety. Liu, Gao, and Hou conducted a randomized controlled trial,
assessing the impact of mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) combined with music
therapy upon osteosarcoma patients concerning anxiety, pain, and sleep quality.
A study conducted by Skolzkov and Efremova (2023) on the effects of brief mindfulness training
on first-year psychology students at Ural Federal University used a pre- and post-test design.
The results indicated that mindfulness training was related to marginally lower levels of anxiety,
although the difference failed to reach statistical significance (p = 0.06). Although the study
implicated potential benefit of mindfulness in increasing subjective happiness and decreasing
anxiety among students, in the future, studies involving larger samples with longer interventions
will be necessary to reliably establish efficacy in reducing anxiety and improving subjective
happiness.
Methodology
This systematic review synthesizes data from fifteen studies on the performance of MBIs in
reducing anxiety across different populations, reviewing their effectiveness. The design
integrates both qualitative and quantitative findings to assess outcomes and explore mechanisms.
The inclusion-exclusion criteria for the selection process were clear: studies included focused on
MBIs, such as MBSR and MBCT, in populations suffering from anxiety, including students,
athletes, and clinical patients for whom quantifiable data existed before and after the
intervention. The following were excluded from consideration for use in the review: those
lacking focus on mindfulness or anxiety reduction, or control group, or quantitative outcomes. A
purposive sampling technique captures studies from multiple databases to ensure broad
representation of findings across settings and demographics. Data collection will include using
standardized anxiety measures to compare before and after the intervention; qualitative data that
captures participant feedback, author insights, and so forth, which can reveal themes regarding
the effectiveness of the intervention. The systematic coding of data across intervention type,
target population, duration, outcome measures, and effect size ensured the possibility of
structured comparisons. Summary study characteristics were conducted through descriptive
analysis, whereas appropriate meta-analytic techniques were employed to obtain an overall effect
size of MBIs on anxiety reduction, and thematic analysis of qualitative data provided insight into
underlying mechanisms, long-term impacts, and limitations. This holistic approach provides for
an extremely informative understanding of the efficacy, applicability, and potential benefits of
MBIs for anxiety management in diverse populations.
Results
Sr
Authors Title Year Result Conclusion
No.
1.
Jilian Evaluation of 2012 the results indicated that MMA shows promise for
Haydicky, a adolescents with clinically youth with LD and
Udith Mindfulness- elevated anxiety symptoms co-occurring disorders.
Wiener based who participated in the Participants improved in
et.al Intervention MMA program reported externalizing behavior and
for significant improvements in social skills. Mindfulness
Adolescents self-reported anxiety levels. training helps manage
with This suggests that behavioral and emotional
Learning mindfulness practices can difficulties. High retention
Disabilities effectively reduce anxiety in rates indicate program
and this population. This acceptability among
Co-occurring highlights the effectiveness adolescents. Further research
ADHD and of the mindfulness is needed to enhance
Anxiety intervention in addressing motivation for completion.
anxiety issues among
participants.
2.
Teresa M An update on 2012 The results indicate that Mindfulness-based
Edenfield, mindfulness MBIs are moderately interventions show promise
meditation as effective in improving for anxiety treatment. More
Sy Atezaz a self-help anxiety symptoms, with a research is needed on
Saeed treatment for calculated effect size of mechanisms of change. Effect
anxiety and Hedges' g = 0.63. In clinical sizes indicate moderate
depression populations diagnosed with effectiveness of mindfulness
anxiety disorders, interventions. Improvements
mindfulness interventions in symptoms are maintained
showed even more over time.
substantial improvements,
with effect sizes of Hedges'
g = 0.97 for anxiety
symptoms.
3.
Stephanie The Impact 2013 The mindfulness group Stress and anxiety negatively
Skroman of demonstrated a significant impact students' performance
Cicero Mindfulness reduction in perceived and self-esteem. Mindfulness
on Anxiety anxiety levels among techniques positively affect
and Coping participants. This aligns with anxiety and coping strategies.
Strategies in existing literature that Participants showed decreased
Children: A suggests mindfulness can anxiety and increased coping
Quantitative help in recognizing anxious effectiveness. Teachers
Study thoughts and reducing supported and encouraged
harmful behaviors mindfulness program
associated with anxiety. continuation. More research is
Both teachers and students needed for diverse samples
expressed positive reactions and longer studies.
to the mindfulness program.
Teachers noted
improvements in students'
academic functioning and
behavior, indicating that
mindfulness not only helps
with anxiety but also
contributes to a better
learning environment.
4.
Jose Effect of a 2014 the mindfulness group Mindfulness training reduces
Gallego, Mindfulness exhibited a statistically anxiety in students.Physical
Jose M Program on significant decrease in education also helps reduce
Aguilar-P Stress, anxiety levels compared to anxiety.
arra, Anxiety and the control group. This
Adolfo J Depression in indicates that participants
Cangas University who engaged in mindfulness
et.al Students practices experienced lower
anxiety after the
intervention. The
mindfulness program
significantly reduced anxiety
levels among university
students.
5.
Lee Mindfulness 2015 The study found that there Aromatherapy-enhanced
Redstone Meditation was 32.6% reduction in mindfulness meditation is
and feasible for anxiety reduction.
anxiety level. It also found a
Aromatherap It may be a cost-effective
y to Reduce strong correlation between therapeutic intervention.
Stress and mindfulness meditation and Significant reductions in
Anxiety anxiety levels were observed.
reduction of anxiety among
Further research is needed to
participants. understand its full impact.
Results warrant consideration
by mental health
professionals.
6.
Mary Mindfulness 2016 The study found a The paper concludes that
Mayorga, Behavior and significant inverse mindfulness meditation (MM)
Sabina de Its Effects on relationship between anxiety is an effective self-help
Vries,Eliz Anxiety and mindfulness. This treatment for reducing anxiety
abeth Ann means that students who symptoms. It highlights the
Wardle exhibited higher levels of positive correlation between
mindfulness tended to have increased mindfulness and
lower levels of anxiety, and improved psychological
vice versa. This correlation well-being, emphasizing that
was supported by MBIs can significantly
correlational data indicating alleviate anxiety and enhance
that as anxiety levels emotional regulation.
increased, mindfulness However, the authors call for
levels decreased. A Pearson further research to clarify the
Product-Moment correlation mechanisms of change and
analysis revealed a moderate address methodological
negative correlation (r = limitations in existing studies.
-0.553) between anxiety
levels and mindfulness
attention awareness levels.
This suggests a clear
relationship where increased
anxiety is associated with
decreased mindfulness
awareness. The findings
support the hypothesis that
there is a correlation
between anxiety and
mindfulness, with higher
anxiety levels linked to
lower mindfulness. the study
provides evidence of a
negative correlation between
anxiety and mindfulness,
indicating that mindfulness
practices may help reduce
anxiety levels among
students, although they may
not necessarily enhance
mindfulness awareness
itself.
7.
Hong Ye Impact of 2017 The MBSR group MBSR significantly reduces
Mindfulness experienced a notable anxiety in students with social
–Based Stress decrease in anxiety levels, anxiety. Non-MBSR groups
Reduction with a post-program mean experienced increased anxiety
(MBSR) on score of 2.79 (SD = 0.36), and avoidance symptoms. The
Students compared to an increase in MBSR group showed
Social the non-MBSR group, which improved stress reduction
Anxiety : A had a mean score of 3.31 compared to the non-MBSR
Randomized (SD = 0.94) after the group. Mindfulness enhances
Controlled program. This indicates that self-regulation and coping
Trial mindfulness practices can skills in social situations.
effectively lower anxiety
symptoms in students with MBSR is effective as a
social anxiety The results treatment for social anxiety.
indicate a strong negative
correlation between
mindfulness practices
(MBSR) and anxiety levels.
As mindfulness increased
through the MBSR program,
anxiety and avoidance
behaviors decreased
significantly among
participants. This correlation
suggests that engaging in
mindfulness can lead to
improved emotional
regulation and reduced
anxiety symptoms,
supporting the effectiveness
of mindfulness as a
therapeutic approach for
social anxiety
8.
Michele F Mindfulness 2017 The review indicates that Mindfulness is effective for
Rodrigues in mood and mindfulness-based anxiety disorders. Mindfulness
, Antonio anxiety interventions, such as can be integrated into various
E Nardi , disorders: a Mindfulness-Based Stress therapeutic protocols.
Michellee review of the Reduction (MBSR) and
Levitan literature Mindfulness-Based
Cognitive Therapy (MBCT),
are effective in reducing
symptoms of anxiety. These
approaches help patients
manage their anxiety by
promoting awareness and
acceptance of
present-moment
experiences. The review
reported that mindfulness
meditation training
significantly reduced anxiety
symptoms in patients
diagnosed with Generalized
Anxiety Disorder (GAD).
9.
Elizabeth The effect of 2018 The research highlights that Mindfulness meditation
A Hoge, mindfulness successful treatment of reduces biological stress
Eric Bui, meditation anxiety disorders like GAD reactivity in GAD
Sophie A training on through mindfulness may patients.Findings support
Discussion
Palitz et.al biological improve psychological mindfulness as a low-stigma
acute stress health.Results of this study
This review of 15 research studies highlights the effectiveness of mindfulness-based
interventions (MBIs) for anxiety in different populations: students, clinical anxious participants,
and athletes. Consistency runs everywhere throughout the findings of these studies that MBIs,
such as MBSR and MBCT, significantly reduce symptoms of anxiety. In particular cases, MBIs
also facilitated greater social and academic behaviors, improved emotional regulation, and even
physiological indices in some of the studies on stress-related topics. These results lend further
support to the use of MBIs as a developing non-invasive technique for managing anxiety that
would be beneficial for different populations.
However, there are still gaps in research. Many studies did not have longitudinal follow-up,
leaving open the question of how long the anxiety reductions induced by MBIs would last.
Although several mechanisms were shown to be associated with changes like improved
emotional regulation and reductions in stress markers, the pathways through which MBIs lead to
anxiolytic effects are insufficiently explored. Also, inconsistencies in interventions used make it
hard to isolate what the most appropriate structure and "dose" of MBIs is toward maximizing
impact and sustainability. Missing too in the investigation is a consideration of the varied cultural
and demographic backgrounds that would generally confound the generalization of findings.
Future research should be conducted in the form of longitudinal studies to determine the
extended outcomes for MBIs on the reduction of anxiety over time. Further study on the specific
psychological and physiological mechanisms would help refine MBI protocols for enhanced
effectiveness. Further benefits would be the standardization of intervention lengths and methods,
along with increasing the base to more heterogeneous and cross-cultural populations to
understand applicability, which is needed further to build evidence that would strengthen the
argument for including MBIs in the treatment of anxiety disorders.
Conclusion
This review of 15 studies concluded that mindfulness-based interventions, such as MBSR and
MBCT, do indeed reduce anxiety across diverse populations, from students and clinical patients
to athletes. The interventions caused substantial decreases in the symptoms of anxiety and
promoted improvement in social, academic, and emotional regulation, thus confirming MBIs as
promising non-invasive techniques for enhancing mental health. But important and potentially
useful for future research are the research gaps left open: The long-term follow-up needed to
determine how long anxiety gains are maintained by MBIs, and more detailed exploration of the
psychological and physiological mechanisms through which MBIs work may well refine such
interventions. Standardizing such things as the structure, duration, and "dose" of MBIs can help
maximize their impact and sustainability. In addition, the generalization and cross-cultural
applicability of the findings will be maximized by taking into account more diverse cultural and
demographic backgrounds while conducting further studies. This also adds to the argument on
including MBIs in anxiety treatment protocols.