5-Life-after-Life
5-Life-after-Life
5-Life-after-Life
LifeafterLifeAnAssessmentofElderlyInstitutionalCareinAddisAbabaCityinParticularReferencetoMekedoniaHomefortheElderlyandMentallyDisabled
Strictly as per the compliance and regulations of:
© 2017. Tewodros Habtegirorgis Zikarge. This is a research/review paper, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License http://creative commons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Life after Life: An Assessment of Elderly
Institutional Care in Addis Ababa City (in
Particular Reference to Mekedonia Home for the
Elderly and Mentally Disabled)
Tewodros Habtegirorgis Zikarge
2017
Abstract- Given the economic advancements and well-being circumstances elderly people lose their independent
leading people to live longer, older people living in developing livings (Luppa& Tobias,2009).
Year
nations particularly in Africa are suffering from multi-faceted Nowadays, elderly people are encountered with
problems. One of the possible interventions to curb the various problems this is due to limited government
suffering of the elderly population is an institutional caring
social welfare schemes, weakening of traditional family 41
system. This intervention is of paramount importance in time of
crises like family lose, health complication and poverty driven
and community support. Thus it is common to see
elderly who have the knowledge and skill to help not
-
services to the neediest elders is the foundation goals of the associations suchas Mekedonia Home for the Elderly
institutions. And also understands that the service provision and Mentally Disabled, are assumed to be significant to
has changed the life situation of the resident elders. One of the increase the quality of life of the elderly with good quality
possible interventions to curb the problems of vulnerable of care.
populations (such as elderlies, children and women’s) is an Mekedonia Home for the Elderly and Mentally
institutional care system. This intervention is of paramount Disabled (MHEMD) is an indigenous non-governmental,
importance in time of crises like family lose, health
non-profit charity organization, founded on 7th January
complication and poverty driven street-life.
2010. The purpose of the institution is to support elderly
Keywords: elderly, institutional care, residents.
people and people with disabilities who otherwise have
I. Introduction no means of survival by providing them with shelter,
clothing, food, and other basic services.
M
ost elderly prefer to remain in their homes where Mekedonia is a residential home care unit that
they are able to maintain the integrity of their is more than just a provider of support; it is also the
social network, preserve environmental permanent dwelling place of residents. It has the
landmarks and enjoy a higher quality of life. However, potential, therefore, to in fluence and affect many
due to complex socio-economic and political aspects of the residents’ daily lives beyond health and
Author: Lecturer at Wolaita Sodo University, Department of Sociology.
functional ability. It is important, therefore, that
e-mail: girumfekadu25@gmail.com researchers, policy-makers and other interested parties
recognize and understand the important elements that reduce the sampling error to zero (Yeraswork, 2010,
constitute a good quality of care in elderly home care in p135).
order to put in place mechanisms that will ensure that Sampling was conducted as follows: Firstly, the
this objective is achieved. population was partitioned into homogenous subsets
It is in this regard that this study attempts to i.e. the sampling frame (the roster) was divided between
assess the types of care being provided by Mekedonia that which contains the names of (males and females),
and residents’ rating of the actual care provided, taking (residents with physical disability and the physical
the institution and the elderly care recipients as a frame ability), and then appropriate random samples were
of study. drawn from each of the subsets.
Likewise, according to the statistical figures of
II. Materials and Methods the institution, from the total residents of 850, 320 of
them were mentally disabled hence, they were thought
a) Research Design
as they provide less information for the study; they are
The general principle of research design is that
removed from the sampling frame. Out of the remaining
the research strategy or strategies, and the methods
2017
questions made by the researcher wants to answer residents (using the online sample size calculator) were
(Robson, 1993:39). This study employed, cross- estimated. The selection process was conducted
42 sectional survey design so as to obtain information through random numbers generator in SPSS Version 20)
about the present situation which is related to the issue from each of the sampling categories (i.e. sex and
under study. Data’s were collected at one point in time
Global Journal of Human Social Science ( C ) Volume XVII Issue II Version I
to effectively address different objectives of the Mekedonia. The main services provided for the admitted
research. While survey questionnaire was utilized as elders, includes; Shelter/bed rooms/, food, health care
technique of collecting quantitative data, the qualitative service, hygiene facilities, assisted caring, clothing and
was collected using interview, FGD and observation. funeral ceremonies when they died. The other
supporting services though it is not well enough as itwas
c) Sampling Technique
indicated by the coordinator includes, recreational
For the purpose of achieving the objectives of
facilities such as, TV room facility (four in four meeting
the study, stratified random sampling techniques were halls), and indoor games.
used to select sample residents. Stratified sampling is a The table below indicates the number of
sampling design in which separate samples are drawn physically disabled respondents who have been
from different segments of a population in order to provided with aid equipment and are actually using the
ensure the proportionate representation of each of the provided aid equipment. Likewise, all sample
segments in the overall sample (Yeraswork, 2010, respondents were asked to mention the type of aid
p135). equipment’s they use in the institution. Accordingly,
For instance, this study was undertaken on the ramps comes first with 48 frequencies, followed by
elderly & disabled population of institutional care. Thus, walking aid equipment with frequencies of 45 and
disability status and sex are very important variables and handrails with a frequencies of 17 respectively. The
along these two variables thereby it was possible to smallest use of aid equipment wasramps and electric
employ stratified sampling technique which can nearly wheelchairs with a frequencies of 2 and 3 respectively.
Table:-1: Frequency and percentage distribution of physically impaired respondents who commonly use aid
equipment at Mekedonia
Use of aid
Yes No Total
equipment
Walking aid 45 (25.7) 130 (74.3) 175(100)
equipment 48 (27.4) 127 (72.6) 175(100)
Manual wheelchair 3 (1.7) 172 (98.3) 175(100)
Electric wheelchair 17 (9.7) 158 (90.3) 175(100)
Handrails along 2 (1.1) 173 (98.9) 175(100)
corridors 11 (6.3) 164 (93.7) 175(100)
Ramps 7 (4) 168 (96) 175(100)
Special eating
utensils
2017
Special writing
utensils
Year
Source: Researcher’s survey data (2016)
Institutional care has the potential to in fluence facilities at Mekedonia, so that it is possible to 43
residents’ lives either positively or negatively on understand how residents are engaged in meaningful
outcomes that include more than just health. It shapes andentertaining activities. Respondents were asked
Variable No. %
Yes 132 75.4
Was there any entertaining program
provided by Mekedonia? No 43 24.6
As it is seen in the above table (table 3), most of Accordingly, television comes first with 175 frequencies,
the sample respondents’ i.e. 75.4% has mentioned as followed by Video or DVD with frequencies of 140 and
there was entertaining programs produced by Newspapers and magazine with a frequencies if 136
-
Mekedonia. Whereas, 24.6% of the samples has replied respectively.
as there was no entertaining programs provided by It is summarized in the following table below:
Mekedonia.
Sample respondents were also asked about the
availability of entertainment facilities at Mekedonia.
Fair 8 4.6
Provision of health care service Good 71 40.6
Excellent 79 45.1
44 Total 162 92.6
Poor 52 29.1
Global Journal of Human Social Science ( C ) Volume XVII Issue II Version I
Fair 55 31.4
Availability of adequate bed rooms Good 47 26.9
Excellent 21 12
Total 175 100
Poor 53 30.3
Fair 61 34.9
Availability of adequate bath rooms Good 39 22.3
Excellent 22 12.6
Total 175 100
Source: Researcher’s survey data (2016)
All sample residents were asked if they believe sample respondents’, 48.6% has rated the clothing
that there is adequate food service at Mekedonia. And service as good, 33.1% of the samples has rated as
out of the total 175 sample residents, 163(93.1%) of the excellent, whereas, 17.7% has rated as fair and only one
samples believe that there is adequate food service, or 0.6% of the sample respondents’ has rated the
whereas, the remaining 12(6.9%) believe that there is no clothing service as poor. Moreover from the above data
adequate food service at Mekedonia. Furthermore, it is possible to conclude that, even though residents are
respondents were asked to rate the available food not interested with the clothes they are receiving but,
service at Mekedonia. they have a positive outlook for the clothing service.
-
As shown in the table above, all respondents The researcher was also interested to know
were asked to rate the level of food service despite their whether the provided clothes fulfill the interest of
differential outlook about the presence of adequate food residents (i.e. residents were asked if the provided
service at Mekedonia. Likewise, 54.3% of sample clothes were distributed based on their needs). Thus, it
respondents’ had rated the food service as good, 36.6% is 41.7% of the total sample respondents’ that are
has rated the food service as excellent, whereas, 6.9 interested in the provided clothes, whereas, 58.3% of
and 2.3 percent has rated the food service as poor and the sample respondents’ replied as they are not
fair respectively. Therefore, from the above data it is interested in the given clothes. Accordingly, from the
possible to conclude that respondents’ had a positive above data we can understand that though all of the
outlook for the food service at Mekedonia. residents are benefited from the provided clothes but
Respondents’ were asked whether the there is disparity in terms of their specific needs for the
institution provide them clothes. Likewise, all the provided clothes. Hence the clothes are acquired from
respondents’ 175(100%) has replied as they are volunteer personalities it might not fulfill their specific
provided with clothes. In addition, respondents were needs. As such, most of them are not interested with the
asked whether the provided clothes fulfill their interests provided clothes.
(i.e. residents were asked if the provided clothes are Mekedonia is serving residents in four
distributed based on their needs). compounds, one owned and three rented compounds.
As such, all sample respondents were asked to The bed rooms inhibit between eight and forty (in
rate the clothing service at the institution. Most of the temporary shelters) residents. There are bed rooms
© 2017 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Life after Life: An Assessment of Elderly Institutional Care in Addis Ababa City (in Particular Reference to
Mekedonia Home for the Elderly and Mentally Disabled)
constructed with metal sheets used as temporary believe that there is adequate bath rooms at Mekedonia.
residences to receive the needy elders whose Out of the total 175 sample respondents 100 samples
admission couldn’t be delayed until the construction of (57.1%) has believed that there is no adequate bath
regular residence. Beds in Mekedonia are double stairs. room at Mekedonia. Whereas, the remaining 75(42.9%)
Elders are assigned to the ground bed and younger of the samples has believed that there is adequate bath
elders are assigned to sleep on the upstairs beds. As it rooms. Furthermore, respondents were also asked to
is indicated in the table above, all sample residents were rate the available bath rooms.
asked if they believe that there is adequate bed rooms As it is visible in the above given data, all
at Mekedonia. And out of the total 175 sample sample respondents were asked to rate the available
respondents 118 samples (67.4%) believe that there is bath room facility regardless of their differential outlook
no adequate bed room at Mekedonia whereas, the about the adequacy of the bath rooms. Likewise, 34.9%
remaining 57(32.6%) of the samples believe that there is of sample respondents’ had rated the available bath
adequate bed rooms. rooms as fair, 30.3% has rated as poor. It is, 22.3 and
Furthermore, respondents were also asked to 12.6 percent of the sample respondents who has rated
2017
rate the available bed rooms. Despite respondents’ the available bathe rooms as good and excellent
Year
differential response about the adequacy of bed rooms, respectively. Therefore, from this data, it is possible to
all sample respondents were asked to rate the available conclude that residents had unfavorable outlook for the
bed rooms. Likewise, 31.4% of sample respondents’ existing bathe rooms, this is because most of them
had rated the available bed rooms as fair, 29.7% has (57.1%) believe that there is no adequate bathe rooms 45
rated as poor, whereas, 26.9 and 12 percent has rated and the existing bathe rooms lack quality which is nearly
-
It’s important to combine and discuss about the respondents’ who had been benefited from the available
respondents’ past and present sleeping situation in clinic, were asked to rate the available health care
order to come up with a clear understanding of the service. As it can be seen from the data, 92.6% of the
resident’s rating of the available bed rooms at respondents’ have been treated or benefited from the
Mekedonia. As it is indicated in table, 31.9 and 29.7 available health care service. Whereas, 7.4% of the
percent of the respondents has leveled the situation of respondents’ has never been benefited. Consequently,
bed rooms at Mekedonia as fair and poor respectively out of 92.6% of sample respondents, who has been
which is more or less unfavorable outlook. Whereas, benefited from it, 48.8% of the sample respondents’ has
majority of i.e. 68 and 12 percent of the respondents has rated the available health care service as, it is excellent,
replied as they were living on the streets and in church 43.8% of the sample respondents’ has rated as it is
yards respectively which is nearly 80 percent. Therefore, good. Whereas, 4.9% rated as it is good and only four or
from this data, in particular and from the two data’s in 2.5% of the sample respondents’ has mentioned as it is
general, it is possible to conclude that even though, poor. Moreover, from the data provided we can
residents had come up from the worse sleeping conclude that, most of the residents are more satisfied
situation still the existing sleeping rooms are not by the health care service provided by Mekedonia.
adequate and the situation of the bed rooms are Also as the information gained from in depth
uncomfortable for residents as it is expected to be. interview, there is referral system for the patients in need
The other service provided by Mekedonia was of extra medications, the patient will get referred to other
bath room and all sample residents were asked if they government hospitals like Zewditu, Menelik II,
© 20 17 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Life after Life: An Assessment of Elderly Institutional Care in Addis Ababa City (in Particular Reference to
Mekedonia Home for the Elderly and Mentally Disabled)
TekurAnbessa, Zenebework, Yekatit 12, and St. Paulos. home. They were not discomforted with their stay rather;
The institution has special agreement with these they were enjoying their communal living. As a result, of
hospitals. Volunteer medical doctors will also come to institutional living they are able to enjoy and connect to
the clinic on Tuesday, Thursday and Sunday and give the community regardless of gender, class, and
services to those who need medication. Saturday religious differences.
morning psychiatrists came to the clinic and give
b) Recommendation
psychological services to mentally ill care recipients.
One of the health care givers has explained that Institutional care recipients, especially those who
most of the care recipients have poor health and usually are suffering from frailty want to be addressed in a
visit the clinic. Some other nurses has also added, as polite, friendly and appropriate manner and treated
causes of frequent health problems are age related. with respect for their personal privacy, hygiene and
It was also revealed that most of the older appearance, choice of clothes and furnishings and
persons are facing sight, mobility and hearing problems, access to appropriate care and assistance with
some of them gastritis and others suffered mental eating, drinking, washing, toilet and other daily
2017
illness. These illnesses were treated by the medium activities are required.
clinic in the institution and by the referral hospitals. As institutional elders are the most segregated and
Year
found enjoying their institutional life. The findings of the 2. Ara, S. 1995. “Old Age Homes-The Last Resort”,
survey have indicated that, residents are made to Research and Development Journal. Help Age
receive services such as shelter, food, clothes and India, Vol. 2, No.1p 3-10.
health care services. They spent their spare time by 3. Babbie, Earl. 2008. The basis of social research.
playing card games, chatting with friends, watching T.V Thomson Wadsworth. Fourth edition. Belmont, USA.
and having discussions among themselves. Except with 4. Bailey, C. 2004. Extending social security coverage
some problems associated to care such as; inadequate in Africa. (Working Paper, ESS No. 20). Geneva,
bathe and bed rooms and communal recreational Switzerland: International Labor Office.
facilities, decreased care givers attention on the process 5. Botev, N. 1999. Older persons in countries with
of care giving activity, insufficient physical space for economies in transition. In Population Ageing,
residents to care for and living together with mentally Challenges for Policies and Programmes in
disabled patients, most beneficiaries expressed their Developed and Developing Countries. United
opinion that they are living a better life than their living Nations Population Fund and CBGS, pp. 85-100.
arrangement before admission. New York and Brussels.
In developed countries it is considered that old 6. Brodsky, J., Habib, J., & Hirschfeld, M. 2003. Long-
age homes as the last resort and staying there as term care in developing countries: ten case studies.
equivalent to being thrown in a dustbin. But, that was World Health Organization (http:///www.who.int/
not true in the case with the residents of these old age ncd/long_ term_care/index.htm).
2017
Psychosocial care and support for older carriers.
Year
Retrieved 02/09/2015: (http://www.Helpage.org/)
11. Help Age International Ethiopia and Cordaid. 2011.
A study of older people’s livelihoods in Ethiopia.
Retrieved 02/09/2015: (http://www.Helpage.org/) 47
12. Help Age International Ethiopia (HAIE). (2013). The
-
Unpublished Master’s Thesis, Addis Ababa
University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
17. Years work Admassie. 2010. Social Research
methods: survey research, Addis Ababa University
press, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.