Educational Brief: A NASA Recipe For Protein Crystallography
Educational Brief: A NASA Recipe For Protein Crystallography
Educational Brief: A NASA Recipe For Protein Crystallography
Grades 9 - 12
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
Educational Brief
A NASA Recipe For Protein Crystallography
Lysozyme Crystals
Excelsin Crystals
rotein crystals can be very difficult to grow. Even protein crystallographers are often unable to produce crystals of the high quality that is required to determine the molecular structure of many proteins. As part of NASAs educational outreach activities, we have prepared a simple recipe for growing protein crystals from Brazil nuts. Please let us know how your attempts at growing these protein crystals turn out. You may contact us at: microgravitynews@msfc.nasa.gov
For more up-to-date information about NASAs macromolecular crystallography program, see: http://crystal.nasa.gov
Note: all bold face words are referenced in the glossary in the back of this document.
Introduction
any hours of scientific study and investigation are invested in growing protein crystals crystals that, when nearly perfect in form, are very highly prized. The information they reveal about a proteins molecular structure makes them very sought after and important to science. Proteins, macromolecules involved in everyday functions of the body such as transporting oxygen and chemicals in blood, forming major components of muscle and skin, and fighting disease, come in over 100,000 varieties. Active sites on molecules of proteins, when inappropriately triggered or absent, can cause disease or an unwanted function. Scientists seek to locate those active sites so drug designers can understand their function and then, in some cases, work to block them or render them inactive. For example, the anti-inflammatory drug ibuprofen works on a specific protein, which is involved early in the signaling process that tells your body that inflammation should occur. Blocking the active site on this protein prevents or reduces the inflammation.
are so small that humans cant see them individually, let alone find a specific site on a molecule or determine its molecular structure. If one cell in the human body were the size of a football stadium, one protein molecule would be approximately the size of a can of soda, and one of the atoms making up that protein molecule would be about the size of the fine print on the can.
protein crystal is a three-dimensional array of molecules in which every molecule or specific group of molecules has the same orientation and relationship to its neighbors, as long as the chemical environment of the solution surrounding the crystal remains the same. When a protein crystal forms, protein molecules or groups of molecules align to produce a
repeating three-dimensional pattern or array. The effect of bringing these molecules together in this arrangement is called amplification. Amplification can be thought of in this way: imagine a football stadium full of people. If only one person stands up and yells, the sound produced is not easily heard. But if everybody in the stadium stands up, faces the same direction and yells at the same time, that sound can be heard from a great distance. A very similar thing happens during the analysis of a protein crystal. One protein
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
History
structures of an abundance of crystals grown by biochemists. Further, there was a century-long backlog of crystals to be investigated. By the 1970s, however, the X-ray crystallographers had become more selective in determining which proteins needed to be crystallized for analysis, and production of the desired crystals was no longer meeting demand. New
crystallization of a protein was made by F.L. Hunefeld in 1840 at Leipzig University in Germany. While working with hemoglobin, Hunefeld obtained flat, plate-like crystals of this protein when he pressed the blood of an earthworm between two slides of glass and allowed the blood to dry very slowly. In 1851, Otto Funke, another German researcher, published a series of articles in which he described growing hemoglobin crystals by successively diluting red blood cells with a solvent such as pure water, alcohol or ether, followed by slow evaporation of the solvent from the resulting protein solution. Early on, scientists grew crystals solely to purify proteins. Not until the 1930s did researchers begin to focus their attention on crystals as a source of structural information about protein molecules. They turned to X-ray diffraction, a procedure in
methods for growing higher-quality crystals were needed. The inability of scientists to produce crystals useable for successful analysis of some proteins had become a bottleneck in the process of determining the three-dimensional structures of the molecules of many important proteins. Typically a protein crystal must be structurally well ordered and from about 0.2 to 0.5 mm in size. With a high water content, protein crystals are usually quite fragile and somewhat difficult to handle. Protein crystals can be described as "soft" in contrast to a "hard" salt crystal.
which a pencil-lead-sized X-ray beam is directed at a crystal. The X-ray beam is scattered by the crystal, producing a signal that results in tiny pinpoints that can be recorded on film. Data from this recorded X-ray diffraction pattern has a direct relationship to the proteins molecular structure and can be used to help reveal the structure of a molecule of the particular protein under investigation. By the 1960s, scientists were investigating the molecular
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
Enter Microgravity
research pioneer and professor of chemistry at the University of Freiburg, Germany, was using a common method of growing protein crystals: placing a salt solution together with the protein solution. When two such solutions come in contact, the salt becomes associated with some of the water molecules in which the protein is dissolved. This causes the protein molecules to move closer together and to begin to crystallize. However, many of the crystals produced by this method are fragile, and small or broken. By 1980, Littke suspected the culprit in his unusable crystals to be convection, or fluid flow, in the solution surrounding the growing protein crystals. This phenomenon occurs in normal gravity,
the clarity with which a crystallographer can "see" the precise position each atom occupies in the three-dimensional structure of the protein molecule. Another adverse effect of gravity on growing crystals is sedimentation. Crystals drift to the bottom of a drop of the solution when they have grown to a mass larger than can be supported by suspension in the drop. When this happens, partially formed crystals fall on top of one another and continue growing into each other. Since X-ray diffraction analysis requires single crystals, sedimentation renders potentially high-quality crystals unusable for data collection. Scientists began to consider the idea that in a microgravity environment, with reduced convection and sedimentation, protein molecules would move together more slowly, primarily by diffusion. It was expected that higher quality crystals could be produced in the microgravity environment, such as that of the orbiting Space Shuttle. But just how do scientists grow a protein crystal in microgravity (or on Earth, for that matter), and what do they do with it once they have grown it? Researchers begin with a protein solution that is supersaturated. A protein solution is prepared by dissolving the protein, also called the solute, in a solvent. Proteins have a solubility, which is a measure of the amount of the protein (solute) that can be dissolved in a given solvent, under specific conditions. Growing a crystal, however, requires supersaturation, which is a less stable condition that results when somewhat more than maximum amount of protein that can be dissolved in a solvent under nominal conditions is, in fact, dissolved in the solvent.
also known on Earth as one-g. Convection takes place during crystal growth in one-g as protein molecules move from the surrounding solution and assemble in an orderly way to become a part of the growing crystal lattice. As protein molecules in the solution move toward a crystal and become a part of the crystal, the solution bordering the crystal then contains a lower protein concentration than the remainder of the solution and, therefore, it has a lower density. This less-dense solution tends to rise, and the denser solution sinks under the influence of gravity, creating fluid flows or convection, next to the crystal. These convective currents can have a negative effect on the quality of the crystal being formed, because they can alter the orientation and position of the protein molecules as they become a part of the crystal lattice. This can cause disorder in the lattice structure of the protein crystal. These imperfections in the crystal lattice, in turn, adversely affect X-ray diffraction analysis results, or
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
of the protein they may be investigating. A researcher tests many different solution conditions by varying such parameters as protein concentration, salt concentration and pH, in order to find the
effectively raising the concentration of the protein in the solution. Under these conditions the protein molecules come together and begin to crystallize.
best conditions required to promote the formation of usable protein crystals. Once the researcher has defined an optimum range of solution conditions, he or she usually uses one of two methods for actually growing the crystal: vapor diffusion or liquid/liquid diffusion. Both methods involve changing the conditions of a protein solution to supersaturate the solution. In vapor diffusion, the crystallographer places a drop of protein solution in a chamber that also holds a solution called a precipitant solution, typically a salt solution. The salt in the precipitant solution is more concentrated than salt that is in the protein solution. This causes water vapor to diffuse through the air from the drop to the precipitant solution. As water is removed from the drop, the protein becomes more concentrated, causing protein molecules to move closer together and nucleate. In liquid/liquid diffusion, the researcher diffuses a salt solution or some other precipitant solution in one compartment of a two-chamber vial into a protein solution in the other compartment. As the salt concentration increases, some of the water from the protein solution becomes associated with the salt,
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
for dozens of fundamental science experiments growing macromolecular crystals. Since NASAs protein crystal growth program began, principal investigators and their research teams have flown samples of a total of 185 different proteins, RNAs, DNAs and viruses (as of August 1999). The macromolecules these scientists have studied range from insulin to lactate dehydrogenase ( a major enzyme in energy production and an important muscle protein in all animals) to thaumatin (a sweet tasting protein with potential as a sugar substitute.) Most of NASAs protein crystal growth experiments, conducted from 1985 to 1999, have been flown on Space Shuttle missions. The remainder were conducted on the Russian space station Mir. Given the great strides NASAs protein crystal
Earth (1g)
Space (g)
growth program has made since the first protein crystal growth experiments were conducted in microgravity, where is the field headed now? For many, it is to the International Space Station (ISS).
The International Space Station (ISS) will provide a platform for long term microgravity experiments http://spaceflight.nasa.gov/station
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
National Science Education Content Standards (Grades 9-12) supported by the NASA Recipe for Protein Crystallography.
1) Identify questions and concepts that guide scientific investigations 2) Design and conduct scientific investigations 3) Use technology and mathematics to improve investigations and communications 4) Formulate and revise scientific explanations and models using logic and evidence 5) Recognize and analyze alternative explanations and models 6) Communicate and defend a scientific argument 7) Understandings about scientific inquiry 1) 2) 3) 4) Structure of atoms Structure and properties of matter Chemical reactions Motions and forces
Physical Science
Life Science
1) The cell 2) Molecular basis of heredity 3) Matter, energy, and organization in living systems 4) Behavior of organisms 1) Abilities of technological design 2) Understandings about science and technology 1) Personal and community health 2) Science and technology in local, national, and global challenges 1) Science as human endeavor 2) Nature of scientific knowledge 3) Historical perspectives
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
Key Words
Aqueous Clarify Decant Filtrate Dialysis Membrane (or tubing) Centrifuge Opaque Denature Morphology Pellet Dialyze Supernatant
Materials
Funnel Water (distilled preferred) Brazil Nuts (raw, organically grown) Centrifuge Tubes Dialysis Membrane (app. 20 cm in length) 50 ml graduated cylinder 500 ml and 150 ml beakers Small clamp(s) Blender or Coffee Grinder Styrofoam (for bottom of 500 ml beaker) Table Salt (sodium chloride) Glass Rod Cheesecloth, Glass Wool, or Filter Paper Pipette or Medicine Dropper Thermometer Heating Plate Small Centrifuge (up to 3000rpm)(optional) Laboratory Balance
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
Methods
I. Isolation of Excelsin
1) Record the mass of ~ 8 or 9 raw Brazil nuts (preferably organically grown). Grind the nuts to granular size. 1 nut has a mass of approximately 2.8 grams. 2) Prepare a 5% sodium chloride (NaCl) solution by dissolving 10 grams of solid NaCl in 200 milliliters of distilled water. Measure 25 ml of 5% NaCl solution into a graduated cylinder and then pour into a 150 ml beaker. Record the volume of NaCl solution in the beaker. (Reserve remaining 5% NaCl solution for making 1% NaCl solution in Part II.3.) 3) Create a water bath by placing a flat piece of styrofoam (can be cut from the bottom of a styrofoam cup) into the bottom of a 500 ml beaker. Pour approximately 50 ml of water into the 500 ml beaker. Place the smaller 150 ml beaker (that contains the NaCl solution) in the larger 500 ml beaker (that contains the water). Place the beaker assembly on the heating plate and heat until the water is at 50C. Measure the final temperature and record. 4) Add the ground nuts to the NaCl solution in the 150 ml beaker and stir with a glass rod to mix. Continue heating the water bath to maintain the temperature of the NaCl solution and ground nut mixture at 50C to 70C for 20 minutes, stirring occasionally. Record the temperature at regular intervals. (Be careful not to stir vigorously or to heat above the designated temperature range because this may cause the protein to denature or break down). 5) (Caution: Glass wool should only be handled when wearing gloves.) Place 1-2 layers of glass wool (or 10 layers of cheesecloth or filter paper) in a funnel and place over a beaker. Pour the NaCl/nut mixture through glass wool. Measure and record the volume of filtrate. (Note: Filtrate should be opaque.) 6) Option 1 - For classrooms without a centrifuge: Skip steps 7-9 and go directly to the Crystallization of Excelsin in Section II.
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
7) Option 2 - For classrooms with a centrifuge: Pour filtrate into two centrifuge tubes and weigh to make sure tubes are of equal weight. Record the mass of each centrifuge tube. 8) Centrifuge for 20 minutes at 3000 rpm. Referring to the diagram from the previous page, pipette off the oil (top layer) and discard. Carefully push the pipette through the nut meat
layer into the aqueous layer and decant off the aqueous portion (located above the pellet and just below the oil). Discard the pellet and oil. 9) Centrifuge the supernatant to clarify the solution further. The supernatant should now be a fairly clear brown or brownish-yellow solution. Measure and record the volume of the extracted protein solution.
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
10
Lab Record
Step I(1) I(2) I(3) I(4) I(4) I(4) I(4) I(4) I(5) I(6) I(6) I(8) II(3) II(3) II(3) III(2) III(2) III(3) III(3) Procedure Brazil nut mass (grams) Volume of NaCl solution (ml) Temperature of water bath (C) Temperature of NaCl/nut solution (C) 1st recording Temperature of NaCl/nut solution (C) 2nd recording Temperature of NaCl/nut solution (C) 3rd recording Temperature of NaCl/nut solution (C) 4th recording Temperature of NaCl/nut solution (C) 5th recording Volume of protein filtrate (ml) Centrifuge tube #1 mass Centrifuge tube #2 mass Volume of extracted protein solution (ml) Volume of protein filtrate (ml) Volume of 1% NaCl solution (ml) Volume of 0% NaCl solution (ml) (if required) Volume of 5% NaCl solution added to bag (ml) Volume of 1% NaCl solution added for dialysis (ml) Volume of 5% NaCl solution added to bag (ml) Volume of 1% NaCl solution added for dialysis (ml) Record g ml C C C C C C ml g mg ml ml ml ml ml ml ml ml
Record the size, number and morphology of the final Excelsin crystals produced.
Crystal Excelsin
Morphology (check which box applies) Oily Spherical Platelike Hexagonal Needles Other
Number
Size mm mm mm mm mm mm
11
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
4
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
12
GLOSSARY
Active site Aqueous Clarify Concentration Convection Decant Denature the portion of a molecule that binds with a substrate molecule relating to, similar to, containing, or dissolved in water; watery to make clear by removing impurities or solid matter a measurement of the amount of solute that is dissolved in a given quantity of solvent heat transfer in a gas or liquid by the circulation of currents from one region to another to pour off gently to alter the structure of (a protein), as with heat, alkali, or acid, so that some of its original properties, especially its biological activity, are diminished or eliminated the ratio of the mass of an object to its volume the transfer of dissolved solids (solute) across a semipermeable membrane, which permits or hinders diffusion of molecules according to their size a semipermeable casing used to dialyze a solution
Density Dialysis/Dialyze
Electron density map a graphical representation of the volume of space that an electron is most likely to occupy; the smaller the volume of space occupied, the higher the electron density Filtrate Gravity Hemoglobin the liquid passing through the filter during filtration the natural force of attraction of objects to each other due to their masses an iron-containing protein in red blood cells that carries oxygen from the lungs to the rest of the body
Liquid/liquid diffusion the diffusion of a precipitant solution into a protein solution across their common liquid/liquid interface Macromolecule a very large molecule, such as a polymer or protein, consisting of many smaller structural units linked together an environment in which the apparent weight of a system is small compared to its actual weight (due to gravity) the sum of the weight of all the atoms in a molecule, also called formula weight
Microgravity
Molecular weight
13
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
the shape of a crystal to gather, as about a nucleus or center impenetrable by light; neither transparent nor translucent a small, solid or densely packed mass a measure of the acidity or alkalinity of a solution, numerically equal to 7 for neutral solutions, increasing with increasing alkalinity and decreasing with increasing acidity; the pH scale commonly in use ranges from 0 to 14 a solution which causes the formation of a precipitate a solid or solid phase separated from a solution any of a group of complex organic macromolecules composed of one or more chains of amino acids; proteins are fundamental components of all living cells and include many substances, such as enzymes, hormones, and antibodies, that are necessary for the proper functioning of an organism a region, often the exposed part of a membrane protein, that binds a substance but does not catalyze a reaction in the chemical it binds the material that settles to the bottom of a liquid the settling of materials to the bottom of a liquid; this settling is due to gravity the dissolved substance in a solution; in salt water, salt is the solute a homogeneous or uniform mixture of two or more substances a substance used to dissolve a solute to form a solution; in salt water, water is the solvent the clear fluid floating above a sediment or precipitate the state of a solution when it contains more solute (dissolved substance) than it can theoretically hold a process of diffusion in which a drop of protein solution is suspended above a precipitant and sealed from the air, resulting in equilibration through the vapor phase the scattering of x-ray beams by crystal atoms, producing a diffraction pattern that yields information about the structure of the crystal
Receptor site
Supernatant Supersaturated
Vapor diffusion
X-ray diffraction
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
14
ASA's Central Operation of Resources for Educators (CORE) was established for the national
and international distribution of NASA-produced educational materials in audiovisual format. Educators can obtain a catalogue and an order form by one of the following methods:
NASA CORE
Lorain County Joint Vocational School 15181 State Route 58 Oberlin, OH 44074-9799 Phone: (440) 775-1400 Fax: (440) 775-1460 E-mail: nasaco@leeca.org Home Page: http://core.nasa.gov
Please contact:
NASA Educator Resource Center Mail Stop 253-2 NASA Ames Research Center Moffett Field, CA 94035-1000 Phone: (650) 604-3574 FAX: (650) 604-3445 http://ccf.arc.nasa.gov/dx/basket/trc/trchome.html
NASA Educator Resource Center NASA John H. Glenn Research Center at Lewis Field 21000 Brookpark Rd., MS 8-1 Cleveland, OH 44135 Phone: (216) 433-2017 FAX: (216) 433-3601 http://www.grc.nasa.gov/WWW/PAO/html/edteacher.htm
15
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
Connecticut Delaware District of Columbia Maine, Maryland Massachusetts Pennsylvania New Hampshire New Jersey New York Rhode Island Vermont Colorado Kansas Nebraska New Mexico North Dakota Oklahoma South Dakota Texas
NASA Educator Resource Laboratory Mail Code 130.3 NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Greenbelt, MD 20771-0001 Phone: (301) 286-8570 FAX: (301) 286-1781 http://pao.gsfc.nasa.gov/gsfc/educ/trl/welcome.html
Space Center Houston NASA Educator Resource Center for Johnson Space Center 1601 NASA Road One Houston, TX 77058 Phone: (281) 244-2129 FAX: (281) 483-9638 http://www.jsc.nasa.gov
NASA Educator Resource Center Mail Code ERC NASA Kennedy Space Center J.F. Kennedy Space Center, FL 32899 Phone: (321) 867-4090 FAX: (321) 867-7242 http://www/ksc.nasa.gov Virginia Air and Space Center Educator Resource Center for NASA Langley Research Center 600 Settlers Landing Road Hampton, VA 23669-4033 Phone: (757) 727-0990 Ext. 75 FAX: (757) 727-0898 http://www.vasc.org/erc/
U.S. Space & Rocket Center Educator Resource Center for NASA Marshall Space Flight Center One Tranquility Base Huntsville, AL 35758 Phone: (256) 544-5812 FAX: (256) 544-5820 http://www.msfc.nasa.gov/education/erc
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
16
Mississippi
NASA Educator Resource Center NASA Stennis Space Center Building 1200 Stennis Space Center, MS 39529-6000 Phone: (228) 688-3220 FAX: (228) 688-2824 http://education.scc.nasa.gov/htmls/trc/trc.htm NASA JPL Educator Resource Center Village at Indian Hill 1460 East Holt Avenue, Suite 20 NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory Pomona, CA 91767 Phone: (909) 397-4420 Fax: (909) 397-4470 http://learn.jpl.nasa.gov
NASA Educator Resource Center for NASA Dryden Flight Research Center 45108 N. 3rd Street East Lancaster, CA 93535 Phone: (661) 948-7347 Fax: (661) 948-7068 http://www.dfrc.nasa.gov/trc/
The Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) serves inquiries related to space and planetary exploration and other JPL activities.
GSFC/Wallops Flight Facility NASA Educator Resource Center Building J-17 Wallops Island, VA 23337 Phone: (757) 824-2298 FAX: (757) 824-1776 http://WFF.nasa.gov
egional Educator Resource Centers offer more educators access to NASA educational materials. N A S A has formed partnerships with universities, museums, and other educational institutions to serve as regional ERCs in many states. A complete list of regional ERCs is available through CORE, or electronically via NASA Spacelink at http://spacelink.nasa.gov/ercn/ ASA's Education Home Page serves as a cyber-gateway to information regarding educational programs and services offered by NASA for the American education community. This high-level directory of information provides specific details and points of contact for all of NASA's educational efforts, Field Center offices, and points of presence within each state. Visit this resource at the following address: http://education.nasa.gov
17
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
Check the Internet for program listings at: http://www.nasa.gov/ntv For more information on NTV, contact: NASA TV NASA Headquarters Code P-2 Washington, DC 20546-0001 Phone (202) 358-3572 NTV Weekday Programming Schedules (Eastern Times) Video File NASA Gallery 12-1 p.m. 1-2 p.m. 4-5 p.m. 7-8 p.m. 10-11 p.m. 3-4 p.m. 6-7 p.m. 9-10 p.m. Education File 2-3 p.m. 5-6 p.m. 8-9 p.m. 11-12 p.m.
resources specifically developed for the educational community. Spacelink is a "virtual library" in which local files and hundreds of NASA World Wide Web links are arranged in a manner familiar to educators. Using the Spacelink search engine, educators can search this virtual library to find information regardless of its location within NASA. Special events, missions, and intriguing NASA websites are featured in Spacelink's "Hot Topics" and "Cool Picks" areas. Spacelink may be accessed at: http://spacelink.nasa.gov NASA Spacelink is the official home to electronic versions of NASA's Educational Products. A complete listing of NASA Educational Products can be found at the following address: http://spacelink.nasa.gov/products
ASA Television (NTV) features Space Shuttle mission coverage, live special events,
How to Access Information on NASA's Education Program, Materials, and Services EP-1999-06-345-HQ. This brochure serves as a guide to accessing a variety of NASA materials and services for educators. Copies are available through the ERC network, or electronically via NASA Spacelink.
interactive educational live shows, electronic field trips, aviation and space news, and historical NASA footage. Programming has a 3-hour block Video (News) File, NASA Gallery, and Education File beginning at noon Eastern and repeated five more times throughout the day. Live feeds preempt regularly scheduled programming.
Online Evaluation
Please take a moment to evaluate this product at http://ehb2.gsfc.nasa.gov/edcats/educational_brief Your evaluation and suggestions are vital to continually improving NASA educational materials.
EB-2000-10-183-MSFC
18