ECCS Examples To Eurocode 3
ECCS Examples To Eurocode 3
ECCS
CECM
E KS
Examples to Eurocode 3
FIRST EDITION
1993
NO71
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form
or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of the
Copyright owner :
ECCS
CECM
EKS
General Secretariat
Avenue des Ombrages, 32/36 bte 20
8-1200 BRUSSEL (Belgium)
Tel. 3Z2-762 04 29
Fax 3Z2-762 09 35
ECCS assumes no liability with respect to the use for any application of the material and information contained in this
publication.
Introduction
The European Convention for Structural Steelwork (ECCS) has as one of its primary objectives the
promotion of the safe and economical use of steel in structures. ECCS believes that the introduction of
the harmonized Eurocodes has a great value in achieving this objective; accordingly ECCS has set up an
Advisory Committee, AC 5, charged with the task of promoting the introduction and adoption of the
Eurocodes.
The AC 5 Committee have considered how this process could be best achieved and concluded that a
three stage approach was desirable. The first stage was to produce a concise version of the Eurocodes
which can be used for normal every day design; this part has already been issued as ECCS Publication
No. 65.
The second stage is the production of this document which gives design examples to EC 3/1 and E-EC
3 and has been prepared as a design aid to facilitate the use of EC 3/1 for the design of steel buildings
during the ENV period. These examples concentrate on those aspects which are likely to be needed for
daily practical design work.
The third and final stage will be the production of a series of "Design Aids" which will enable the design
process to be made more quickly by using tabulated or graphical values for the various design formula
contained in EC 3/1.
The combination of these three documents will enable practising engineers to more easily adopt to the
use of the new Eurocodes and should have a beneficial help in their speedy introduction.
Scope
These Design Examples to EC 3/1 and E-EC 3 have been prepared by the ECCS Advisory Committee
AC 5 as a design aid in supplement to the complete EC 3/1 to facilitate the use of EC 3/1 for the design
of steel buildings in the ENV-period.
The Design Examples only contains examples to EC 3/1 and E-EC3 that are likely to be needed for daily
practical design work.
The y values used in this document are the values recornmended in EC 3 main document. These values
may deviate from the values recommended in the National Application Documents (NAD) of the member
states.
The ECCS - Advisory Committee 5 is at present composed of the following members:
Aasen, B.
Arda, T.S.
Bock, H.
Danieli, S.
Dowling, P.J.
Falke, J.
Gemperle, C.
Gettins, H.J. (Chairman)
Lequien, Ph.
Lutteroth, A.
Schleich, J.B.
Sedlacek, G.
Lundin, K.
Noway
Turkey
United Kingdom
Italy
United Kingdom
Germany
Switzerland
United Kingdom
France
Germany
Luxembourg
Germany
Sweden
Luxembourg
Luxembourg
Germany
United Kingdom
Also particular thanks are given to the ECCS Technical Committees TC 8 and TC 10 who have contributed
to the work.
References
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Contents
Introduction
Scope
Part 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.1
Load combination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Example
I;:I
Example 1.1.2
n
- a
1,
Example 1.1.3
Example 1.1.4
Crane girder
I/
Example 1.1.5
~~~~~
Page
2093
1.2
Methods of analysis
11
........ ......
Example 1.2.1
............................
. . . . 14
Example 1.2.2
Page
J, I I I
I 1
LT
I I I I I I I I 1 1 1 I
I I I I ~~~=17,9kN/m
Example 1.2.3
Page
Example 1.2.4
J,:
I I I
I l l I I 1 I I l l I 1 I I I
I Lpd=ll.9kWm
18
1.3
Frameanalysis
........................................................
Example 1.3.1
Page
Example 1.3.2
19
Page
20
1.4
Example 1.4.2
. .
26
frame.1
frame.2
Example 1.4.3
Example 1.4.4
28
Page
29
25
Part2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30
Members in compression . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.31
2.1
Example 2.1.1
Example 2.1.2
page
I" /.ir
page
32
Example 2.1.3
page
Example 2.1.4
34
Detail
r6
2.2
Example 2.1.5
Page
Members in bending
........
Example 2.2.1
.....
Page
..................................
Example 2.2.2
38
Example 2.2.3
page
Example 2.2.4
42
1IOP.l"
1700
L.
7700
37
2.3
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Example 2.3.1
Example 2.3.2
..
Page
50
48
I
Example 2.3.3
Page
Column of a frame
Example 2.3.4
Page
Rafter of a frame
56
2.4
~~
~~
Example 2.4.1
Page
J
noo
,I
I1
25
4'
900
1200
II
1 m
Example 2.4.2
page
rd lOU.10
64
Example 2.4.3
Page
i'
Example 2.4.4
Page
65
310111
lOOXI0
Example 2.4.5
~~
~~
Page
~~
69
Part 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71
3.1
Bolted connections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Example 3.1.1
Example 3.1.2
Page
73
r
J
+ '.
' P T T T T
as
Page
a5
72
1:
! , +
.+ +
J
+$
.!
T I P T -
4~'3&Ox16
260x12
75
-;
'
3LOx16
Example 3.1.3
Page
Example 3.1.4
Page
77
Example 3.1.5
Page
81
Example 3.1.7
Example 3.1.8
88
Example 3.1.9
page
t"
.
91
IPE 220
Fe360
fa
Welded connections
3.2
.....................................................
Example 3.2.1
Page
Example 3.2.2
96
Page
2 L 50x5
98
97
F e 360
Example 3.2.3
Page
Example 3.2.4
Page
100
Example 3.2.5
103
Page
i"'"
e,
3.3
.........................
i'-.
- **.=
-(&
pq
105
Pinconnections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . 107
Example 3.3.1
page
Pin connection
l"d
108
AnnexA
..................................................................
109
Part 1
Load combination
Methods of analysis
Frame analysis
Bracing system analysis
1.1
Load combination
These examples demonstrate how the design values of action effects (NSd,,V,, ,M
,
etc) are
determined from the load assumptions. The further steps of design are not treated in this part.
An action is a force (load) applied to the structure or an imposed deformation (e.g. temperature
effects or settlements). Characteristic (unfactored) values of these actions are specified in ENV
1991 Eurocode 1 or other relevant loadings codes. These values of actions shall be multiplied by
relevant safety factors and combination factors, see chapter "Combinations of actions" in ENV
1993 Eurocode 3 or Table 2.1 in the Essentials of Eurocode 3 to determine the design values of
the effects of actions. The following examples show the method of determination of the maximum
effects of actions. Not all possible combinations of actions are presented nor are relevant
combinations worked out. In practice, one will collect experience to easily find out which load
combination is decisive for verification of the structures.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 1.1.1:
Example 1.1.2:
Example 1.1.3:
Example 1.1.4:
Example 1.1.5:
!I
Ual
e
c
c
.c
c
L
a
cn
c
6
s
cn"
r
Tu!
F
*?
U
C
'5
CI
n
W
DI
E
b
C
0
e
-n6
C
->
6
0
e
C
6
W
-9
Q)
E!
Q)
r
Q)
".
m
Ei
II
I1
0)
ul
2J
(D
8C
Q)
5
c
Q)
v)
.-0
c
-0
c
!?
Q
E
U
v)
C
al
-s
0
E
E
E
U
f
Q
n
E
0
0
+
-
-i
?
z
Q
.-m
s
.-C
C
0)
.al
?!
5P
Q
v)
U
al
al
5
c
=
c
(
I
.-z
.c
C
._
n
E
6Q
Q
cn
I1
e0
U-
"
.c
-m3
c
.-
"
C
-aml
.->2
0
U
Y
U)
0
"
0
$
-E
a,
n!
c:
c)
1.2
Methods of analysis
These examples demonstrate on continuous beams how the design values of action effects are
determined using either plastic global analysis or elastic global analysis and plastic or elastic
stress distribution. All of the methods of analysis presented may also be applied on frames.
The further steps of design are not treated in this part.
Note:
For plastic global analysis special requirements specified in 152.7, 5.3.3 and 3.2.2.21 shall
be satisfied.
1.2.1:
1.2.2:
1.2.3:
1.2.4:
14
-. -.
+--I-+
Ea xa
{3
VI
N
Lu
1
m
VI
U
C
._
"!
e3
P
O-
TE
U)
U)
.:
5
+-
.-
m
p?
ln
E
n
E
E
II
2
0
cu
0
II
z
0
0
cu
w
a,
0.
fj
a,
A=
I1
II
<
1.3
Frame analysis
The first example demonstrates the application of the criterion "sway - non sway" and how the
second order effects in the sway mode are included using first order analysis with amplified sway
moments. The second example demonstrate how frame imperfections are determined.
The further steps of design are not treated in this part.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 1.3.1:
Example 1.3.2:
19
H
H
a
9.
Q
U)
..
.-
U)
-mc
5.
U)
-E:
E
U)
(U
0
E
ci
N
(U
CV
C
C"
C
.-
t-
P
U
.-
2
m
2
e
5
II
II II
II
+
n
+
f
C
m
m
5
9
c?
v)
.-
mC
f
a
-r
f
3
?
f
.-
v)
v)
v)
-.--e
0
0)
51
>
W
m
a
I
S
-
m
b
-m
e
.-X
m
m
I
.c
-
N
P
'
c
.-c
1.4
25
al
n
>
aa
z
E
8
8
9
0
I1
1'
..
r
U
!
r
'c5
0.
0
P
8
Q
E
s
E
(U
(U
0-
.. (
..
8
11
i5
c
.e
+
c
.c
cv
U)
aeo
I1
-10
II
I1
v)
-d
cy
$.
m-
I?
"0
-7
cu
cu
X
\
I1
!i
c
Q
5
0
Fi
I5
ut
Part 2
Members in compression
Members in bending
Combined loading - Bending and compression
Local stresses
30
2.1
Members in compression
These examples demonstratethe verification of members in compression assuming design values
of action effects N
(),
which have been calculated by an analysis of the structure and these values
, etc.
already include ~ r yF
The results presented in the examples are rounded values. For the purpose of easy re-calculation
each formula and each check is calculated with the rounded values.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 2.1.1:
Example 2.1.2:
Example 2.1.3:
Example 2.1.4:
Example 2.1.5:
31
kr
.-
U)
C
G
c
Q)
5
e
.-
U)
Pm
U)
I
0
8
II
m
d
cici
E
0
L".
m
I1
0
a
x
.U
al
cz
>
L
Q
c
.-c
EE
zi
m
c
U)
a
0
0
.c
m
c
.-
a
a
r
a
L
5
8
N
Q)
.-cO
-a
G
'4
0)
0
0
i
U
m
II
II
II
v1
Ea
z
E
n
'*
m
0
ul
N
I1
E
11
In
0
i?
A
+
ul
m
0
II
+
v)
m0
II
L n
:
a
C
.c
ln
m
E
0
0
01
m
II
zJI
A
..
e0
0)
.-0VI
VI
Ins
II
I.+
3
ei
r/
0052
I I I I
- -
n" 2
2.2
Members in bending
Examples 1, 2 and 3 demonstrate the verification of members in bending assuming design values
of action effects V
,(,
M
,, etc) which are calculated by an analysis of the sub-structure.
Example 4 demonstratesthe veriiication of members in bending assuming design values of action
effects V
,(,
M, etc) which have been calculated by an analysis of the structure and these values
already include 9 , yF etc.
The results presented in the examples are rounded values. For the purpose of easy re-calculation
each formula and each check is calculated with the rounded values.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 2.2.1:
Example 2.2.2:
Example 2.2.3:
Example 2.2.4:
37
0
8
gr=
sll
II
II
0II
%
w
0
..L
>
Q
c
C
8
C
ia
E
o?
0
m
I1
IB
m
C
7
a
a
c
.c
e
.-0
0
C
e
E
U?
0
I1
0
11
II
0-
In
m
m
I1
ii
3
0
C
m
0
-m
a
0
cull
In
E
L-
al
"15
U
's
2.3
47
-c
U
0&=
0
0
0
0
U
&
*
I
OOOL
00%
00%
+-
m
C
?
5
("
0
v 2
'9
/P
IF
c3
'9
I1
..
(U
II
'4
0
E
0
II
x'
ln
II
0-
?
c
-Y
.J
.-VI
2
zf
c
B
E
.-Um
C
C
0)
m
c
.-
!iE
8
Q)
0
E
2!Q)
rc
Q)
.-c0
-a
Q
d
Ji
cn
a
2
In
E
E
eQ
c
E
!iE
0
2a
U
ln
..
C
0
.c
.-0
a3
0
f%
%"
.-
..
(v
m
C
cz
a.
-2
ul
C
+
t
:
0
I1
+
c"
(Y
0
._
e
Q)
v)
Q!
Q!
m
L.
c
v!
8
II
"E
E
n
U)
P)
II
0)
cu
0
?
eo
90
cu.
cu
b
I
I
U)
B
Q
5
al
U
5a
5
11
I1
29
0
II
x'
{
0
Q)
C
.-
4
0
n
m
C
.U)
..
.-
U)
ul
0
r
U
2.4
Local stresses
These examples demonstrate the verification of load introduction problems assuming design
values of action effects N
(,, , V
,
M, etc) which have been calculated by an analysis of the
structure and these values already include ~ r yF
, etc.
The results presented in the examples are rounded values. For the purpose of easy re-calculation
each formula and each check is calculated with the rounded values.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 2.4.1:
Example 2.4.2:
Example 2.4.3:
Example 2.4.4:
Example 2.4.5:
61
i?
E
U
C
m
II
M0-
If
5aa, -f'4 2
C
.?
ln
f
U
c
m
I1
0
- 3
01
0
A
F!
m
u)
>
e
I
I
8
E
r
Q)
U
J
T=
0
I1
E
9
0
A
.-2
=I
U
?!
.c
c
..-0
a
5
U)
U-
0
CD
ri
"E
-=
.-CC
s
0
"!
W
(9
U!
c)
9 9
aSS
sc
I1
2-+
/
=I
+
xI1
6
r
+
(3
8
I1
11
E a
E E
EZ
3%
1
I1
.. ..
E
E
\
N
T:
c.
P)
0)
n
P
Q)
C
U)
C
.E
z
n
1
v)
%Nc
eo
s
I
Part 3
Bolted connections
Welded connections
Pin connections
71
3.1
Bolted connections
These examples demonstrate the verification of bolted connections assuming design values of
action effects (Nu, , ,V M
,, etc) which have been calculated by an analysis of the structure and
these values already include ~ r yF
, etc.
The results presented in the examples are rounded values. For the purpose of easy re-calculation
each formula and each check is calculated with the rounded values.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 3.1.1 :
Example 3.1.2:
Example 3.1.3:
Example 3.1.4:
Example 3.1.5:
Example 3.1.6:
Example 3.1.7:
Example 3.1.8:
Example 3.1.9:
72
Em
v e
= U )
!r$
m
C
z
C
.-0
n
U)
a,
A
VI
m
0
.v
0
a,
C
8
U
a,
e
B..
-6al
z
(II
J.
....
I1
I1
v)
t
II
8C
Q
.-
c
U)
U)
E
E
i
E
A
n
E
E
5
0
-I'
6'
r.
yc
hi
e0
5
A
Ej
II
R
m
II
2
!
(0
P
e
0
al
c
C
0
a
l
-
P..
'?
r
in
0
.e
0
..
U
W
.5
3
W
C
.-
..
v)
v)
wo
suf
W
..
0
c a..l
m
- e
.'" m
0"
0
.-C
z
2
.-
z
2
'
.r
v!
1 s
II
II
II
II
Vn
Q
ii
n
3
CO
0
E
E
In
z
II
"
e
+
"
In
Ic
<
II
+
N
<
>
rn
4C
.m
II
I1
II
I1
.U)
??
E
8
.-
U)
E
E
I1
i
J
3
0
(U
m
m
OD
I1
01
.
:
In
m
r
c
al
e
0
al
;i,
Pm
-3
-m0
c
.U)
8c
.U)
U)
2
u)
.-c
2
0
8E
c
Q)
Q
II
>3,
-EL
.-0
U
al
C
0
n
I
-ci
Q
e
0
X
al
D
Ea
U
al
-m
c
0
m0
.8c
U)
U)
.U)
a,
.-c
1
e
n
e
r
I-
I
.-
0
I1
-5
0
\
(0
0
II
P
U0
5
a.
._
(0
04
I1
UT
ai
ai
c\!
o!
y!
(D
0 0
m
m
H
Y
.
r
U)
-m
0
II
Q
Q
al
5
0
m
(D
E
E
9
ln
N
II
- --
-0
n
e
'?
I-
0
-
5
c
C
al
C
C
8
0
-m
C
CD
.U
C
Q
.al
-mQ
0
5
"0
C
0
.-c
-m
-20
E
E
E
E
0
RPO
-
v)
-0
c
cu
.r
3
R
c
'?
I-
al
n
c
0
Q
e
-m
.-
5
C
0
.c
.-C
ii
a,
5
0
I1
11
0
II
II
I,
In
E
E
8
0
II
o
c
0
6
In
..a
2
C
0
.In
o
C
c
m
.In
e
0
J
I1
z
U-
9
b
II
a
0
I1
2
\
P;
e
Y
0
II
cu
v\
"*rn'
!!E
E
0
cu
0
P)
f?
r
5
c
0
EC
m
U)
v)
It
I1
li-
11
It
It
1
4
I1
4
Li-
I1
-IE
.U)
w
L
al
11
..
al
C
.-0
U)
U)
a3
w
z
aC
f!
C
-"c
0
0
.-
U)
0
c
al
5
c
0
Q)
-"
Q)
U)
.-.-Em
c
U)
z
P
35
0
al
-d
Y)
L
L
m
9)
6
Y
CI
II
3.2
Welded connections
These examples demonstrate the verification of welded connections assuming design values of
action effects (NW,V, ,M
, etc) which have been calculated by an analysis of the structure and
these values already include q r , yF etc.
The results presented in the examples are rounded values. For the purpose of easy re-calculation
each formula and each check is calculated with the rounded values.
The following examples are included in this chapter:
Example 3.2.1 :
Example 3.2.2:
Example 3.2.3:
Example 3.2.4:
Example 3.2.5:
96
=a
C
ln
2
al
.->
C
U
FJ
.-ln
U
U
9
al
b
m
0
-alm
C
m
C
.5
0
.E
a,
.-%
U
U
m
-0
m
.-c
$
ln
m
2.
n
e
C
a,
5,
Eal
--ma
tl
II
E
E
al
m
0
9
U)
0
al
5
0
0)
C
e
.-
U)
U)
2
C
.C
E
U)
P
?-' mI
P
x
0)
c
0
al
5
al
.c
E,:
2m a2l
c::
m
L
m $
a
m
0 0 0
2aa
999
U
C
al
ga
al
n
c
al
c
.0
.I1
n'$
'"
d
a,
U)
.c
.-0
U)
n
.c
.-U)
L
U)
U)
2
0
.-e
e
U)
U)
E
E
E
E
I1
I,
3
3
mm
69
v)
t
c
Q
E
c
E
E
U)
3
0
.5
3
C
0
.-c
o
0
C
o
0
c
-5
0
z
n
U
a,
TI
2..
Q)
E
Q
X
+In
*fn
C
.-0
e
5
C
0
0
W
5
E
$
8
mm
a 0
u
u
eQ
C
Q
-5
U)
.5
E
z
Y
Y
z
,B
52
II
..
C
0
c
U
a,
C
C
0
U
a,
5
0
-m
C
C
al
p . ro"
0
3.3
?in connections
This example demonstrates the verification of pin connections assuming design values of action
effects N
(,, , ,V ,M
,
etc) which have been calculated by an analysis of the structure and these
values already include qr, yF etc.
The results presented in the examples are rounded values. For the purpose of easy re-calculation
each formula and each check is calculated with the rounded values.
Example 3.3.1:
Pin connection
107
E
E
4;:
E
E
It
II
..
C
W
c
0
0
.U
cl
a
c
0
.5
.. zw
72
n
+AN
Annex A
Values of the reduction factor x for
the appropriate non-dimensional slenderness A.
of buckling curves a,,, a, b, c, d
are given in the following tables
109
x
-
( a = 0.13)
0,oo
0.01
0,02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0,07
0.08
0.09
1,0000
1,0000
1,0000
0,9859
0,9701
0,9513
1.0000
1.0000
0.9986
0,9845
0,9684
0,9492
1,0000
1.0000
0,9973
0,9829
0,9667
0,9470
1,0000
1,0000
0,9959
0.9814
0,9649
0,9448
1,0000
1.0000
0.9945
0,9799
0,9631
0.9425
1,0000
1,0000
0.9931
0,9783
0,9612
0,9402
1,0000
1,0000
0,9917
0,9767
0,9593
0,9378
1,0000
1,0000
0,9903
0,9751
0,9574
0,9354
1,0000
1,0000
0,9889
0,9735
0,9554
0,9328
1,0000
1,0000
0,9874
0.9718
0.9534
0,9302
0,00
0,9276
0.8961
0.8533
0,7961
0,7253
0.9248
0,8924
0.8483
0.7895
0,7178
0,9220
0,8886
0.8431
0.7828
0,7101
0,9191
0.8847
0.8377
0,7760
0.7025
0.9161
0.8806
0.8322
0,7691
0,6948
0.9130
0.8764
0.8266
0,7620
0,6870
0,9099
0,8721
0,8208
0,7549
0,6793
0,9066
0.8676
0.8148
0,7476
0,6715
0,9032
0,8630
0,8087
0,7403
0,6637
0.8997
0,8582
0.8025
0,7329
0,6560
0.60
0.70
0.80
0.90
0,6482
0.5732
0.5053
0,4461
0,3953
0.6405
0,5660
0,4990
0,4407
0.3907
0,6329
0,5590
0,4927
0.4353
0,3861
0,6252
0,5520
0,4866
0.4300
0.3816
0.6176
0.5450
0,4806
0.4248
0.3772
0,6101
0,5382
0,4746
0.4197
0,3728
0,6026
0,5314
0,4687
0,4147
0,3685
0,5951
0,5248
0,4629
0,4097
0,3643
0,5877
0,5182
0,4572
0,4049
0,3601
0.5804
0,5117
0,4516
0,4001
0,3560
1,10
1,20
1,30
1.40
1.50
1.60
1,70
1,80
1.90
2.00
0,3520
0,3150
0 2833
0.2559
0.2323
0,3480
0,3116
0,2804
0,2534
0,2301
0,3441
0,3083
0,2775
0,2509
0,2280
0,3403
0.3050
0.2746
0.2485
0,2258
0,3365
0.3017
0.2719
0,2461
0.2237
0,3328
0.2985
0.2691
0.2437
0.2217
0,3291
0,2954
0,2664
0,2414
0,2196
0,3255
0,2923
0,2637
0.2390
0,2176
0,3219
0,2892
0,2611
0.2368
0,2156
0,3184
0,2862
0,2585
0.2345
0,2136
1.60
1,70
1,80
1.90
2.00
2.10
2.20
2.30
2.40
2.50
0.2117
0.1937
0.1779
0.1639
0,1515
0.2098
0.1920
0,1764
0,1626
0,1503
0,2079
0,1904
0,1749
0,1613
0,1491
0,2061
0,1887
0,1735
0.1600
0.1480
0,2042
0,1871
0,1721
0,1587
0,1469
0.2024
0.1855
0,1707
0,1575
0,1458
0,2006
0.1840
0,1693
0,1563
0,1447
0.1989
0.1824
0,1679
0,1550
0,1436
0,1971
0,1809
0,1665
0,1538
0,1425
0.1954
0.1794
0.1652
0,1526
0.1414
2.10
2.20
2,30
2.40
2,50
2.60
2.70
2.80
2,90
3.00
0,1404
0.1305
0,1216
0,1136
0,1063
0,1394
0,1296
0,1207
0,1128
0,1056
0,1383
0,1286
0,1199
0,1120
0.1049
0,1373
0,1277
0,1191
0,1113
0,1043
0,1363
0.1268
0.1183
0,1106
0,1036
0,1353
0,1259
0,1175
0,1098
0,1029
0,1343
0,1250
0,1167
0,1091
0,1023
0,1333
0,1242
0,1159
0.1084
0,1016
0,1324
0,1233
0,1151
0,1077
0,1010
0,1314
0.1224
0,1143
0.1070
0,1003
2.60
2.70
2.80
2,90
3,lO
3.20
3,30
3.40
3,50
0,0997
0,0937
0,0882
0,0832
0,0786
0,0991
0,0931
0,0877
0,0828
0.0782
0,0985
0.0926
0.0872
0,0823
0.0778
0,0979
0,0920
0.0867
0.0818
0.0773
0.0972
0,0915
0.0862
0.0814
0,0769
0.0966
0,0909
0,0857
0.0809
0,0765
0,0960
0,0904
0,0852
0.0804
0,0761
0.0955
0,0898
0,0847
0.0800
0,0756
0.0949
0.0893
0.0842
0.0795
0,0752
0,0943
0,0888
0.0837
0,0791
0.0748
3,10
3.60
0.0744 0,0740 0,0736 0.0732 0,0728 0.0724 0,0720 0,0717 0.0713 0.0709
0,oo
0.10
0.20
0.30
0,40
0,50
0,60
0,70
0,80
0.90
1,oo
1,lO
110
0,10
0.20
0,30
0.40
0.50
1,00
1.20
1,30
1,40
1,50
3,00
3,20
3,30
3,40
3.50
3.60
Reduction f a c t o r s
f o r b u c k l i n g curve a
(U =
0,Ol
0,02
0,03
0.04
1.0000
1,0000
0.9978
0,9751
0.9501
0.9211
1,0000
1,0000
0.9956
0.9728
0.9474
0.9179
1,0000
1,0000
0,9934
0,9704
0,9447
0,9147
1.0000
1,0000
0,9912
0,9680
0,9419
0,9114
0.8823
0,8382
0,7841
0,7206
0,6516
0,8783
0,8332
0,7781
0.7139
0,6446
1,lO
1,20
1,30
1,40
1.50
0,5960
0,5300
0,4703
0.4179
0,3724
0,5892
0,5237
0.4648
0,4130
0.3682
0.5824
0,5175
0.4593
0,4083
0.3641
1.60
1.70
1.80
1.90
2,oo
0,3332
0,2994
0,2702
0,2449
0.2229
0,3296
0,2963
0,2675
0.2426
0,2209
0.3261
0.2933
0,2649
0,2403
0.2188
0,21)
0.06
0,07
0,08
0.09
1,0000
1.0000
0,9889
0,9655
0,9391
0,9080
1,0000
1.0000
0.9867
0.9630
0,9363
0,9045
1,0000
1,0000
0.9844
0,9605
0,9333
0,9010
1,0000
1,0000
0,9821
0.9580
0,9304
0,8974
1,0000
1,0000
0,9798
0,9554
0,9273
0.8937
0.00
0,10
0.8742
0,8282
0.7721
0,7071
0,6376
0,8700
0,8230
0,7659
0,7003
0,6306
0.8657
0,8178
0.7597
0,6934
0,6236
0.8614
0,8124
0,7534
0,6865
0,6167
0,8569
0,8069
0.7470
0,6796
0.6098
0,8524
0.8014
0,7405
0,6726
0,6029
0.60
0.70
0,80
0.90
1.00
0,5757
0,5114
0,4538
0.4036
0.3601
0,5690
0,5053
0,4485
0.3989
0.3561
0,5623
0,4993
0,4432
0,3943
0.3521
0,5557
0,4934
0.4380
0.3898
0.3482
0,5492
0,4875
0,4329
0,3854
0,3444
0,5427
0,4817
0.4278
0,3810
0,3406
0,5363
0,4760
0,4228
0,3767
0,3369
1.10
1.20
1.30
1.40
1.50
0,3226
0.2902
0.2623
0,2380
0.2168
0,3191
0.2872
0,2597
0.2358
0,2149
0,3157
0,2843
0.2571
0,2335
0.2129
0.3124
0.2814
0,2546
0,2314
0,2110
0,3091
0,2786
0,2522
0,2292
0,2091
0,3058
0,2757
0,2497
0,2271
0,2073
0,3026
0,2730
0,2473
0,2250
0,2054
1,60
1.70
1.80
1.90
2.00
0,1966
0,1805
0.1663
0.1536
0.1424
0,1949
0.1790
0,1649
0.1524
0,1413
0.1932
0.1775
0.1636
0.1513
0,1403
0,1915
0,1760
0,1623
0,1501
0,1392
0,1899
0.1746
0,1610
0,1490
0,1382
0.1883
0.1732
0,1598
0.1478
0.1372
2.10
2,20
2,30
2.40
2.50
0,OO
0,oo
1,0000
0.10 1,0000
0,20 1,0000
0,30 0,9775
0,40 0.9528
0,50 0.9243
0.05
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
2,60
2.70
2.80
2,90
3,OO
0.1362
0.1267
0,1182
0,1105
0.1036
0.1352
0.1258
0,1174
0,1098
0,1029
0.1342
0,1250
0,1166
0,1091
0,1022
0,1332
0.1241
0.1158
0,1084
0.1016
0,1323
0,1232
0,1150
0,1077
0,1010
0,1313
0,1224
0,1143
0.1070
0,1003
0,1304
0,1215
0,1135
0,1063
0,0997
0,1295
0,1207
0,1128
0,1056
0,0991
0,1285
0,1198
0,1120
0,1049
0,0985
0,1276
0,1190
0,1113
0,1042
0.0978
2.60
2.70
2.80
2,90
3.00
3,lO
3.20
3,30
3.40
3.50
0,0972
0,0915
0,0862
0.0814
0.0769
0,0966
0,0909
0,0857
0,0809
0,0765
0,0960
0,0904
0,0852
0.0804
0.0761
0,0954
0.0898
0,0847
0,0800
0,0757
0,0949
0.0893
0.0842
0.0795
0,0752
0,0943
0,0888
0,0837
0,0791
0.0748
0.0937
0.0882
0,0832
0.0786
0,0744
0,0931
0,0877
0,0828
0,0782
0,0740
0,0926
0.0872
0,0823
0.0778
0,0736
0,0920
0,0867
0,0818
0,0773
0,0732
3.10
3.20
3.30
3.40
3.50
0,0728 0,0724 0,0721 0,0717 0,0713 0,0709 0,0705 0.0702 0,0698 0,0694 3.60
3,60
111
( a = 0.34)
0.00
0.01
0,02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0,06
0,07
1,0000
1,0000
1.0000
0,9641
0,9261
0,8842
1,0000
1,0000
0,9965
0.9604
0.9221
0,8798
1,0000
1.0000
0.9929
0,9567
0,9181
0,8752
1,0000
1.0000
0,9894
0,9530
0,9140
0.8707
1,0000
1,0000
0,9858
0,9492
0,9099
0.8661
1,0000
1,0000
0,9822
0,9455
0,9057
0.8614
1,0000
1,0000
0.9786
0,9417
0,9015
0.8566
1.0000
1,0000
0,9750
0,9378
0,8973
0,8518
1.0000 1.0000
1,0000 1,0000
0.9714 0,9678
0,9339 0,9300
0,8930 0,8886
0.8470 0,8420
0,70
0.80
0,90
1.00
0,8371
0,7837
0,7245
0,6612
0.5970
0.8320
0,7780
0,7183
0,6547
0.5907
0,8269
0,7723
0,7120
0,6483
0,5844
0,8217
0,7665
0,7058
0.6419
0,5781
0.8165
0,7606
0,6995
0.6354
0,5719
0,8112
0.7547
0,6931
0,6290
0,5657
0,8058
0,7488
0.6868
0.6226
0.5595
0,8004
0.7428
0,6804
0,6162
0,5534
0,7949
0,7367
0,6740
0.6098
0,5473
0,7893 0,60
0,7306 0,70
0.6676 0.80
0,6034 0,90
0.5412 1.00
1.10
1,20
1.30
1,40
1.50
0,5352
0.4781
0,4269
0.3817
0,3422
0,5293
0,4727
0,4221
0,3775
0,3386
0,5234
0,4674
0,4174
0,3734
0,3350
0,5175
0,4621
0,4127
0.3693
0,3314
0,5117
0,4569
0.4081
0,3653
0,3279
0,5060
0,4517
0,4035
0.3613
0,3245
0,5003
0,4466
0,3991
0,3574
0,3211
0.4947
0,4416
0,3946
0,3535
0,3177
0.4891
0.4366
0,3903
0,3497
0,3144
0.4836
0,4317
0.3860
0,3459
0,3111
1.10
1.20
1.30
1.40
1,50
1.60
1.70
1,80
1,90
2,oo
0,3079
0,2781
0.2521
0.2294
0.2095
0,3047
0.2753
0,2496
0,2272
0,2076
0,3016
0,2726
0,2473
0,2252
0,2058
0,2985
0,2699
0,2449
0,2231
0.2040
0,2955
0,2672
0,2426
0,2211
0,2022
0,2925
0,2646
0,2403
0,2191
0,2004
0.2895
0,2620
0,2381
0,2171
0,1987
0,2866
0,2595
0.2359
0,2152
0,1970
0,2837
0,2570
0,2337
0,2132
0.1953
0,2809
0,2545
0,2315
0,2113
0,1936
1.60
1.70
1.80
1.90
2,00
2.10
2,20
2.30
2,40
2.50
0.1920
0.1765
0,1628
0.1506
0,1397
0,1903
0,1751
0.1615
0,1494
0,1387
0.1887
0.1736
0,1602
0,1483
0,1376
0,1871 0,1855
0,1722 0,1708
0,1590. 0,1577
0.1472 0,1461
0,1366 0,1356
0,1840
0,1694
0.1565
0,1450
0,1347
0.1825
0.1681
0.1553
0,1439
0,1337
0,1809
0,1667
0,1541
0.1428
0.1327
0.1794
0,1654
0,1529
0.1418
0,1318
0.1780
0,1641
0,1517
0,1407
0.1308
2.10
2.20
2.30
2,40
2.50
2.60
2.70
2.80
2.90
3,OO
0.1299
0.1211
0.1132
0,1060
0.0994
0,1290
0.1203
0.1124
0,1053
0,0988
0,1281
0,1195
0,1117
0.1046
0,0982
0,1272
0,1186
0,1109
0,1039
0.0976
0.1263
0.1178
0.1102
0.1033
0,0970
0.1254
0,1170
0,1095
0,1026
0,0964
0.1245
0.1162
0.1088
0,1020
0.0958
0.1237
0.1155
0,1081
0,1013
0.0952
0,1228
0,1147
0,1074
0,1007
0,0946
0,1219 2.60
0,1139 2,70
0.1067 2.80
0,1001 2.90
0,0940 3.00
3,lO
3,20
3,30
3.40
3,50
0,0935
0,0880
0,0831
0.0785
0,0743
0,0929
0.0875
0,0826
0,0781
0,0739
0,0924
0.0870
0,0821
0,0776
0.0735
0,0918
0.0865
0,0816
0,0772
0.0731
0.0912
0,0860
0,0812
0.0768
0.0727
0.0907
0,0855
0,0807
0,0763
0,0723
0,0902
0,0850
0,0803
0,0759
0.0719
0,0704 0.0700 0.0697 0,0693 0,0689 0.0686 0,0682 0.0679 0,0675 0.0672
0,oo
0,lO
0.20
0,30
0,40
OS0
0,60
3.60
0.08
0,09
0.00
0,10
0.20
0.30
0,40
0,50
3,60
7
112
Reduct i o n f a c t o r s y, f o r b u c k l i n g curve c
0,Ol
0,02
0.03
( a = 0.49)
0,OO
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
1,0000
1,0000
1,0000
0.9491
0.8973
0.8430
1,0000
1,0000
0.9949
0.9440
0.8920
0.8374
1.0000
1,0000
0,9898
0,9389
0,8867
0.8317
1.0000
1,0000
0.9847
0,9338
0.8813
0.8261
1,0000
1,0000
0,9797
0,9286
0,8760
0,8204
1,0000
1,0000
0.9746
0,9235
0,8705
0.8146
1,0000
1,0000
0,9695
0.9183
0,8651
0,8088
1,0000
1,0000
0,9644
0,9131
0,8596
0,8030
1,0000
1,0000
0.9593
0.9078
0.8541
0.7972
1.0000
1,0000
0,9542
0,9026
0,8486
0,7913
0,oo
0,60
0,70
0,80
0,90
0.7794
0,7185
0,6559
0,5937
0,5342
0.7735
0,7123
0,6496
0,5876
0,5284
0,7675
0,7060
0,6433
0.5815
0,5227
0,7614
0,6998
0,6371
0,5755
0,5171
0,7554
0,6935
0,6308
0,5695
0,5115
0,7493
0,6873
0,6246
0,5635
0,5059
0,7432
0,6810
0.6184
0,5575
0,5004
0,7370
0,6747
0.6122
0.5516
0,4950
0,7309
0,6684
0,6060
0,5458
0,4896
0.60
0.70
1,oo
0.7854
0,7247
0,6622
0,5998
0,5399
1,lO
1.20
1.30
1,40
1,50
0,4842
0.4338
0.3888
0,3492
0,3145
0,4790
0,4290
0.3846
0.3455
0.3113
0,4737
0,4243
0,3805
0,3419
0,3081
0,4685
0,4197
0.3764
0,3383
0.3050
0,4634
0,4151
0,3724
0,3348
0,3019
0,4583
0,4106
0.3684
0.3313
0.2989
0,4533
0,4061
0.3644
0,3279
0.2959
0,4483
0,4017
0,3606
0,3245
0,2929
0,4434
0,3974
0.3567
0,3211
0,2900
0,4386
0,3931
0,3529
0,3178
0,2871
1,lO
1,20
1,30
1,40
1.50
1,60
1,70
1,80
1,90
2,oo
0.2842
0,2577
0.2345
0.2141
0,1962
0.2814
0,2553
0,2324
0,2122
0.1945
0,2786
0,2528
0,2302
0,2104
0,1929
0.2759
0,2504
0.2281
0.2085
0,1912
0,2732
0.2481
0,2260
0,2067
0,1896
0.2705
0.2457
0.2240
0,2049
0,1880
0.2679
0,2434
0.2220
0,2031
0,1864
0,2653
0,2412
0,2200
0,2013
0,1849
0.2627
0.2389
0,2180
0,1996
0.1833
0,2602
0,2367
0,2161
0,1979
0.1818
1.60
1.70
1.80
1.90
2.00
2.10
2,20
2.30
2.40
2,50
0.1803
0,1662
0,1537
0.1425
0.1325
0,1788
0.1649
0,1525
0.1415
0.1315
0,1774
0,1636
0,1514
0,1404
0.1306
0,1759
0.1623
0.1502
0,1394
0.1297
0,1745
0,1611
0,1491
0,1384
0.1287
0,1731
0,1598
0,1480
0,1374
0,1278
0,1717
0.1585
0.1468
0,1364
0,1269
0,1703
0,1573
0,1457
0,1354
0.1260
0,1689
0,1561
0,1446
0,1344
0,1252
0,1676
0,1549
0,1436
0,1334
0,1243
2.10
2,20
2,30
2,40
2.50
2.60
2.70
2.80
2,90
3,OO
0,1234
0,1153
0,1079
0,1012
0,0951
0,1226
0.1145
0,1072
0,1006
0,0945
0,1217
0.1137
0,1065
0,0999
0,0939
0,1209
0,1130
0.1058
0,0993
0,0934
0.1201
0,1122
0.1051
0.0987
0.0928
0,1193
0.1115
0.1045
0,0981
0,0922
0,1184
0,1108
0,1038
0,0975
0,0917
0,1176
0,1100
0.1031
0.0969
0,0911
0,1168
0,1093
0,1025
0,0963
0.0906
0,1161
0,1086
0,1018
0,0957
0,0901
2,60
2,70
2.80
2,90
3.00
3.10
3,20
3,30
3,40
3,50
0,0895
0,0844
0,0797
0,0754
0,0715
0,0890
0,0839
0,0793
0.0750
0,0711
0,0885
0,0835
0,0789
0.0746
0,0707
0,0879
0,0830
0.0784
0,0742
0,0703
0,0874
0,0825
0,0780
0,0738
0,0700
0.0869
0,0820
0,0775
0,0734
0.0696
0.0864
0,0816
0,0771
0,0730
0,0692
0,0859
0,0811
0,0767
0,0726
0,0689
0.0854
0.0806
0,0763
0,0722
0,0685
0,0849
0,0802
0,0759
0,0719
0.0682
3,lO
3,20
3.30
3,40
3.50
3.60
0,0678 0,0675 0,0671 0,0668 0,0664 0,0661 0,0657 0,0654 0,0651 0,0647
3,60
0.04
~~~~~
0,05
~~
0.06
~~~
0,07
0,08
~~~~~~
0.09
~~~~~~
0.10
0,20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0,80
0,90
1,OO
(a =
0.76)
0.00
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.10
0,20
0,30
0.40
0,50
1.0000
1.0000
1,0000
0,9235
0,8504
0,7793
1,0000
1,0000
0.9921
0,9160
0,8432
0,7723
1,0000
1,0000
0.9843
0.9086
0,8360
0,7653
1.0000
1,0000
0.9765
0,9013
0,8289
0,7583
1.0000
1,0000
0,9688
0.8939
0,8218
0.7514
0.9611
0,8866
0,8146
0,7444
0,9535
0,8793
0,8075
0,7375
0,9459
0,8721
0,8005
0,7306
0,9384
0,8648
0,7934
0,7237
0,9309
0,8576
0,7864
0.7169
0.10
0.20
0.30
0,40
0,50
0,60
0,70
0.80
0,90
1.00
0,7100
0,6431
0.5797
0,5208
0.4671
0,7032
0.6366
0,5736
0,5152
0,4620
0,6964
0,6301
0,5675
0,5096
0.4570
0,6897
0,6237
0.5615
0,5041
0,4521
0,6829
0,6173
0.5556
0.4987
0,4472
0,6762
0,6109
0.5496
0,4933
0.4423
0,6695
0,6046
0,5438
0,4879
0,4375
0.6629
0,5983
0,5379
0,4826
0,4328
0.6563
0,5921
0,5322
0,4774
0,4281
0,6497
0,5859
0.5265
0.4722
0.4235
0,60
0,70
0.80
0.90
1.00
1.10
1,20
1,30
1.40
1.50
0.4189
0.3762
0.3385
0,3055
0.2766
0.4144
0,3722
0,3350
0,3024
0,2739
0.4099
0.3683
0,3316
0,2994
0,2712
0,4055
0,3644
0,3282
0.2964
0,2686
0,4012
0.3605
0,3248
0,2935
0,2660
0.3969
0,3568
0.3215
0.2906
0,2635
0,3926
0,3530
0,3182
0,2877
0.2609
0,3884
0,3493
0,3150
0.2849
0,2585
0,3843
0,3457
0,3118
0,2821
0.2560
0.3802
0,3421
0,3086
0,2793
0.2536
1.10
1,20
1,30
1.40
1.50
1.60
1.70
1,80
1,90
2.00
0.2512
0.2289
0,2093
0,1920
0.1766
0,2488
0.2268
0,2075
0.1904
0.1752
0.2465
0.2248
0.2057
0.1888
0.1738
0,2442
0,2228
0,2039
0,1872
0,1724
0,2419
0.2208
0,2021
0,1856
0,1710
0.2397
0,2188
0,2004
0,1841
0.1696
0,2375
0,2168
0,1987
0,1826
0,1683
0,2353
0,2149
0.1970
0,1810
0.1669
0,2331
0,2130
0,1953
0,1796
0,1656
0,2310
0,2112
0,1936
0.1781
0,1643
1.60
1,70
1,80
1.90
2.00
2.10
2.20
2.30
2,40
2,50
0.1630
0,1508
0.1399
0.1302
0,1214
0,1617
0,1497
0,1389
0,1292
0.1205
0,1604
0,1486
0,1379
0,1283
0.1197
0.1592
0,1474
0.1369
0,1274
0.1189
0,1580
0,1463
0.1359
0,1265
0,1181
0.1567
0,1452
0,1349
0.1257
0,1173
0,1555
0,1442
0,1340
0,1248
0,1165
0,1543
0,1431
0,1330
0,1239
0.1157
0,1532
0,1420
0.1320
0,123i
0.1149
0.1520
0.1410
0;1311
0.1222
0.1142
2.10
2.20
2.30
2.40
2,50
2,60
2.70
2,80
2,90
3,OO
0,1134
0,1062
0.0997
0.0937
0.0882
0,1127
0,1055
0,0990
0,0931
0,0877
0,1119
0,1048
0,0984
0,0926
0,0872
0.1112
0,1042
0,0978
0,0920
0,0867
0.1104
0,1035
0,0972
0,0914
0,0862
0,1097
0,1029
0,0966
0,0909
0.0857
0,1090
0,1022
0,0960
0,0904
0,0852
0.1083
0,1016
0,0954
0,0898
0,0847
0,1076
0,1009
0,0948
0,0893
0,0842
0.1069
0,1003
0,0943
0,0888
0,0837
2.60
2,70
2,80
2.90
3.10
3,20
3.30
3,40
3,50
0,0832
0,0786
0,0744
0.0705
0.0669
0,0828
0.0782
0,0740
0,0702
0.0666
0.0823
0.0778
0,0736
0,0698
0,0663
0.0818
0,0773
0,0732
0,0694
0,0659
0,0814
0,0769
0,0728
0,0691
0,0656
0,0809
0,0765
0.0724
0,0687
0,0652
0,0804
0,0761
0,0721
0,0683
0,0649
0,0800
0,0757
0,0717
0,0680
0,0646
0,0795
0,0752
0.0713
0,0676
0,0643
0.0791
0,0748
0,0709
0,0673
0,0639
3,20
3.30
3,40
3.50
0,0636 0.0633 0,0630 0,0627 0,0624 0,0620 0,0617 0.0614 0,0611 0,0608
0,oo
3,60
0.05
0,06
0.07
0.08
0.09
114
0.00
3,00
3,10
3.60