This document summarizes a study on the treatment of clavicle nonunion using compression plate fixation and bone grafting. 15 patients were treated for clavicle nonunion using an operative technique involving excision of the nonunion site, compression of the clavicle fragments together using a plate, and packing the area with cancellous bone graft. All patients achieved bone union by 10 weeks on average and returned to full function and activities with pain relief and no limitations. The technique provided stable fixation while allowing early mobilization and minimizing morbidity.
This document summarizes a study on the treatment of clavicle nonunion using compression plate fixation and bone grafting. 15 patients were treated for clavicle nonunion using an operative technique involving excision of the nonunion site, compression of the clavicle fragments together using a plate, and packing the area with cancellous bone graft. All patients achieved bone union by 10 weeks on average and returned to full function and activities with pain relief and no limitations. The technique provided stable fixation while allowing early mobilization and minimizing morbidity.
This document summarizes a study on the treatment of clavicle nonunion using compression plate fixation and bone grafting. 15 patients were treated for clavicle nonunion using an operative technique involving excision of the nonunion site, compression of the clavicle fragments together using a plate, and packing the area with cancellous bone graft. All patients achieved bone union by 10 weeks on average and returned to full function and activities with pain relief and no limitations. The technique provided stable fixation while allowing early mobilization and minimizing morbidity.
This document summarizes a study on the treatment of clavicle nonunion using compression plate fixation and bone grafting. 15 patients were treated for clavicle nonunion using an operative technique involving excision of the nonunion site, compression of the clavicle fragments together using a plate, and packing the area with cancellous bone graft. All patients achieved bone union by 10 weeks on average and returned to full function and activities with pain relief and no limitations. The technique provided stable fixation while allowing early mobilization and minimizing morbidity.
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 14
Nonunion of Fracture Clavicle;
Treatment by Compression Plate
and Bone Graft Shabir, M. Et Durrani, Z. Journal reading Introduction Fracture of Clavicle One of most common bony injury Rarely require open reduction Usually caused by fall on shoulder or outstretched hand Classified on basis of fracture location Can lead to complication, particularly nonunion Introduction Nonunion Normal process of fracture repair is thwarted and bone fails to unite Divided into 2 types: Hypertrophic nonunion Atrophic nonunion introduction Causes of Nonunion Distraction and separation of fragments Excessive movement at fracture line A severe injury that renders local tissues nonviable Poor local blood supply Infection Introduction Major contributing factors to nonunion Severe initial trauma Marked initial displacement Shortening Refracture Open fracture Polytrauma Inadequate initial immobilization Introduction Option of management of symptomatic nonunion of clavicle Excision of the site Interosseous wiring with a bone graft Intramedullary fixation Interfragmentary screw fixation and dynamic compression platting with combination of cortical or cancellous auto graft Material and Methods They studied 15 patients treated for nonunion of clavicle since desember 2001 to desember 2003 All of patients were interviewed, examined in detail (ROM, grip and pinch strength, and width of shoulder girdle) They used DASH questionnaire to allow to record upper-limb fuction Operative Technique Incision made parallel with and just distal to clavicle Periosteum incised and elevated with periosteum elevator The site of nonunion was completely excised down to the bleeding bone The cut ends of the clavicle are compressed together Operative Technique (cont) Four to six hole dynamic compression plate is then contoured to fit the upper surface of clavicle Area around the nonunion is packed with cancellous bone graft from illiac crest The wound is closed over the drain Result The average time to union was ten weeks, and all patiens returned to full function and employment All had full pain relief and none had limitation of activities No patients was disstatisfied with his/her appearance None of patient had narrowing of shoulder girdle Result (cont) The range of shoulder movement was equal on both side Pinch-grip strengths were only slightly reduce on the operated side The DASH questionnaire confirm that no patient had any difficulties with shoulder- related activities Discussion Most closed fracture of clavicle are managed conservatively and often unite with some shortening Painless nonunion rarely requires treatment, unless neurovascular symptoms are present Partial removal of clavicle has been described for nonunion associated with a thoracic outlet syndrom and local pain Discussion (cont) Intramedullary pinning may be combined with cancellous bone or onlay illiac crest grafting, but this is difficult Intraosseous wiring with illiac crest bone graft not gives full stability
Conclusion The technique of this research respect AO principles for the treatment of nonunion, allows early postoperative mobilization of adjecent joints, and minimize morbidity The lack restoration of the shoulder width has proved to be cosmetically acceptable and gives excellent function