House of Tatas - Group 4
House of Tatas - Group 4
House of Tatas - Group 4
Case Presentation
Submitted By
GROUP 4
Manvendra Gupta - 09927841
Mayur Kumar - 09927875
Mehta Vighnesh Ishverlal - 09927910
Meraiya Harshil Arunkumar - 09927821
Mukesh Kumar - 09927891
Insight – Group Chairman
“ We have two guiding arrows. One Points overseas, where we want to expand markets
for our existing products. The other points right here, to India, where we want to explore
the large mass market that is emerging - not by following but by breaking new grounds in
product development and seeing how we can do something which hasn’t been done
before. “
Ratan Tata
Group Chairman
With Increasing International Revenues and a high Compound Annual Growth Rate of
62.4 % , we could clearly see why a coherent Strategy for Globalisation of Tata
Companies appears must
Way Ahead for 5 Next Years- Recommendations
Analysis Included
Strategic Alliances
• Enter into strategic relationships with various global technology vendors
• Collaborate on joint research leveraging each other’s strengths to research
and to the development of best-of-breed offerings
• Develop solutions with associated services and offer the same as an
integrated business model to customers
Acquisition Strategy
TCS is a firm believer in ‘organic growth’ and acquire only those companies
which are in line with TCS’ strategic long term goals
•Create specific value propositions aimed directly at the relevant stakeholders— and in
the new tech ecosystem, these relevant stakeholders must include business executives,
not just IT personnel
•‘Do not put all eggs in one basket’ – TCS must provide diverse services to refrain from
being over-dependent and increasing exposure to the vulnerabilities of few sectors
/geographies
•TCS should shift focus from Low cost advantage to high quality services commanding a
premium being the pioneer in the industry
•Consolidation and strategic acquisitions are essential for future growth of revenues.
•Quickly adapt and gain customer confidence in high growth markets. TCS should
leverage its success stories to drive the growth in this market.
•TCS has rightly placed SMB (Small and Medium Businesses) as a separate strategic unit,
which should be focused aggressively. They should also focus consulting practice on the
same radar.
India's largest automobile company, with consolidated revenues of Rs. 92,519 cr (USD
20 billion) in 2009-10.
Leader in commercial vehicles segment, and among the top three in passenger vehicles
with winning products in the compact, midsize car and utility vehicle segments.
24,000 employees.
First company from India's engineering sector, to be listed in the New York Stock
Exchange (September 2004).
Tata JLR deal
Opportunities: Threats
• Rising appetite for luxury automobiles • Volatility in market driven by new
in growing markets like India and China products
• Established European brands available • Strong presence of competitors like
at affordable investment Mercedes, BMW, Lexus and Infinity
• Support from Jaguar in Technology, • Receding sales and brand image
Engine, IT, Accounting • Downturn making Investment riskier
• Complete product line with addition of and costlier
luxury brands • 90% of TAMO revenues comes from
• Access to European and American one market alone-India
Market
Strengths: • JLR would give TAMO an in-house R&D • Acquisitions like JLR will help TAMO in
• Tata’s strong management capability and designing capabilities competing with brands like Merc. etc.
• Strong monetary base to invest • Better utilization of cash reserves • Proven Management and brand
• Synergy due to Corus, TACO and TCS available with TAMO building capabilities would facilitate
• Experience in growing market like India • Reduce production cost of JLR by faster JLR turnaround
• New product development and brand synergizing better with other TATA cos • Strong financial muscle will help TAMO
building experience like Corus to invest in R&D and produce new
better products
• Improve risk profile of TAMO with
diversification in different markets
Weaknesses: • JLR experience and designing capability • Leverage experience gained with Tetley
• Inexperience in Handling luxury would help TAMO in improving their and Corus in allaying market
automobile brand existing products in Indian markets. apprehensions about acquisition
• Inexperience in turning around loss • JLR’s strong brand image will ease • Make Jaguar design center as their
making company acceptance of TAMO in international global design HQ
• R & D and designing capabilities markets • Use Jaguar channel to distribute TAMO
• Keeping the existing management team brands without merging the brands
of JLR make turning around easier
Recommendations – Tata Motors
Tata Jaguar
Motors Land Rover
●With Continued Strong Industry ●Continue to grow its presence world
Growth leverage upon Market wide & in the Indian market by opening
additional dealerships throughout.
Share Gains. ●Should collaborate with Tata Motors for
●Introduce more products from
joint product development ( May be in
pipeline(Aria, Magic Iris, India or at a Foreign R&D Centre)
●Continue with the cost reduction
Venture, Prima Range)
●Exporting Nano to other Asian
initiatives & use the extra money to
Invest in Emerging Markets
Countries (ex. Indonesia) / ●Continue to invest in new product &
• JLR was over priced and the balance sheet of TATA was not in a
position to absorb more.
• Ford purchased JLR at $5 bn and sold at almost half the price to
TATA after operating it for losses for few years.
• As the market would have recovered from recession the valuation
would have increased since there would have been growth in the
demand of JLR thus creating more problems for TAMO.
• Tata would not have been able enter into the premium segment
(>10 lakhs) in India.
• TAMO would have lacked in robust designing capabilities.
• Above all, at that time no other major automobile brand was
available for acquisition with such designing and R&D capabilities.
JLR-Business Rebound
Tata Motors-Business Performance
Financial Performance(consolidated)
Tata Motors
TATA Steel
131.3
100.0
75.4
60.3
45 45.2 42.4 80.0
30.3 32.8 33.5
40.0
78%
63% 64%
42% 45%
34%
27% 21%
19% 17% 20% 20%
15%
TISCO SAIL AM JFE Baoshan Nippon POSCO
TATA Corus impact
60.00%
Tata Steel - Corus : Projected capacity 55.7 50.00%
4% 3%
40.00%
Corus Group (in UK and The
9% Netherlands) EBITDA/Turnover
30.00%
Tata Steel - Jamshedpur PBT/Turnover
34% Return on Avg. Capital
20.00%
11% Tata Steel - Jharkhand Employed
Tata Steel - Orissa 10.00% Return on Avg. Net
Worth
Tata Steel - Chattisgarh 0.00%
NatSteel – Singapore
22% Millennium Steel – Thailand
18%
Sharp decrease in profitability
Increased D/E ratio after Corus deal
3
2.5
EPS
2
200
1.5
Gross Block to Net 150
1 Block 100
0.5 Net Debt to Equity
50
0
0
10 09 08 07 06 2009-10 2008-09 2007-08 2006-07
0 9- 8- 7- 6- 5- -50
0 0 0 0
20 20 20 20 20
EPS
Recommendations
GPM
Cause of concern as operating GPM
85%
costs are still very high for Indian 31%
56% 59%
36%
Hotels however its ROA is the
highest at 8% which suggests that
financing costs and other
inefficiencies not present
*Projected figures based on past historical data and then compared with industry averages
Recommendations
• Geographical presence build up with case by case
acquisition.
• Continue Expansion as profit margin is industry
comparable. At present at least 38% of the new hotel
projects in India are Taj projects. IHC have 50
projects on the design board and development stage.
• No problem in raising money from Debt if EBIT
settles around 33% industrial average
• By opportunity if IHC can integrate hotel chain for a
lower price, it’ll add to profitability of IHC.
TATA Tea
24
Tata... 6
Tata tea ROA and ROE low •Heavy investment done in 2007 for
expansion reflected in b/s
Nestle
HUL
Again concept of EVA can be applied in the global context ( However Suitable
Bargaining/ concessions must be available from the foreign government for doing
so)
4. Strategies for Successful Global
Operations
Strategies for Successful Global Operations
PROMOTING GROUP VALUES AMONG ‘GLOBAL’ EMPLOYEES: By Promoting Group
Values like Integrity, Understanding, Excellence, Unity & Responsibility among global
employees, Tata’s would be able to Bring Different Operational Methods Together
and dissolving cultural differences to a great extend. This will Lead to Global Success
in the future.
THINK REGIONAL, ACT LOCAL: A holistic approach to developing several strategies
for different regions (eg European/African), but simultaneously Fulfilling the Needs
of the LOCAL REGULATIONS of the country of concerned Operations
BUILDING TATA BRANDS GLOBALLY: In order to win Big Orders Globally, TATA Group need
to Build its Brand Awareness. ( one possible ex. of doing so is to Grant Funds for building
TATA Memorials at various Global B Schools, which provide Business Education to
Executives. In turn Awareness among business Leaders will be Benefit Tata Brand)