Substation Composite Insulator Solutions and Application
Substation Composite Insulator Solutions and Application
Substation Composite Insulator Solutions and Application
3 SOLUTIONS
2 CHALLENGES
4 APPLICATION
Background——History Contribution of Substation Porcelain Insulator
Since high voltage transmission started, porcelain insulators had been adopted to outdoor
insulation, and substation porcelain insulators made a historic contribution.
Background——Malignant Accidents of Substation Porcelain Insulator
Huge
maintenance
costs every
year
Background——Manufacture Difficulty of High Voltage Substation Porcelain Insula
Higher voltage, higher requirements for large structure and more difficulties of
manufacture, causing China depends on import insulator.
Background——Environment Influence Of Substation Porcelain Insulator Industrie
Energy consumption
and carbon emissions
are high on
manufacturing process.
Malignant Accidents
Environment Influence
Background——Short Lifespan of Room Temperature Vulcanized ( RTV )
Silicone Rubber Composite Insulator
Low molecular weight , only ( 1-10 ) *104g/mol
Aging in harsh areas, hard to meet the use requirements of the whole life-cycle.
Aging happened on SF6 CT RTV hollow composite insulator manufactured by China, as shown
below.
Background——LSR Composite Insulator Poor Erosion Property and Hi
Low molecular weight,
( 1-10 ) *104g/mol 。
Number of
composite
insulators
Used Time/(year)
!
WE WANT
PERFECT INSULATORS
Contents
1 BACKGROUND
3 SOLUTIONS
CHALLENGES
4 APPLICATION
Application requirements of composite insulators for substation
——Environment
Composite insulators in substations need to face different special environments , such
as some regions with strong ultraviolet , strong sandstorm , large temperature
difference between day and night , coastal salt-fog and so on.
SOLUTIONS
SOLUTIONS
APPLICATION
Bending requirements Internal pressure Torsion requirements Compression
: requirements : SToL , MDToL . requirements :
MML , SML ( hollow ) ; (hollow):
SCoL , MDCoL .
MDCL , SCL ( post ); MSP , SIP .
Deflection requirement
Application requirements of composite insulators for substation
—— Electrical properties
External insulation :
Creepage distance
Insulation level (power frequency, DC withstand ,
impulse withstand, etc.) (altitude, pollution correction)
Internal insulation :
hollow insulator ——sealing.
APPLICATION
post insulators ——insulation level.
Application requirements of composite insulators for substation
—— Special Properties
SOLUTIONS
APPLICATION
The inside liner is resistant to HF Resistance to various types of Eddy current and temperature
and transient high temperature. insulating oil . Such as CVT , oil rise requirement. Such as
Such as LTB , DTB . CT . Reactor .
Challenge of Technology
1 、 Research of shed and sheath materials on substation composite insulator
meet the requirements of application:
Hydrophobicity and hydrophobicity transform resistance performance
Erosion aging resistance performance
Ultraviolet radiation resistance performance
Sand abrasion performance
2 、 Research of FRP materials on substation composite insulator
meet the requirements of application:
Mechanical properties
High temperature arc erosion and HF gas corrosion performance resistance
Oil resistance performance
3 、 Research of sealing structure design on substation composite insulator
4 、 Research of manufacturing process on substation composite insulator
How to make silicone rubber overall compression molding, adequately
vulcanized, reliably bonding with FRP
5 、 Technology supplemental notes
meet the requirements of application:
Salt fog aging resistance performance
Acid rain corrosion resistance performance
Low temperature and temperature difference resistance performance
Effectively prevent bird pecking and rat bite
Contents
1 BACKGROUND
3 SOLUTIONS
2 CHALLENGES
4 APPLICATION
Solutions——Housing Material
Environmental
Electrical Factors
Factor
Arc,
Acid Salt
UV rain
Sand SOLUTIONS
spray
leakage
current
Types of materials
Material formulation
Vulcanizing process
Solutions——Housing Material
3.1.1 Hydrophobicity and hydrophobicity transform performance
Requirements :
Silicone rubber should have excellent hydrophobicity and hydrophobicity transform performance.
Hydrophobicity of composite insulator in service should reach HC6 under Chinese industry standard
DL/T 864.
Solutions :
We selected one kind of HTV whose molecular mass was 720 thousand g/mol, and developed a
reasonable formula.
silicone CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3 CH3
molecule hydrophobicity
Si Si Si Si Si groups
O O O O O O
HTV material
Solutions——Housing Material
3.1.1 Hydrophobicity and hydrophobicity transform performance
Experiment :
Results :
Hydrophobicity lose under corona
and recover to initial level after 2 hours.
Conclusion :
Hydrophobicity and hydrophobicity
transform performance meet the
requirements of application.
Hydrophobicity loss and recovery under corona
Solutions——Housing Material
Requirements :
Chinese industry standard DLT 376-2010: tracking and erosion test requirement of composite
insulators with outer insulation material is TMA4.5.
Solutions :
Experiment:
HTV silicone
Item
rubber
Tracking and erosion
TMA4.5
resistance
Results:
Erosion trace is only 1mm , much
smaller than standard of 2.5mm 。 1.00mm 0.87mm 0.80mm 0.91mm 0.84mm
Solutions :
CH2=CH Si O Si O Si O Si CH=CH2
CH3 CH3 n CH3 m CH3
n=5000~10000,m=10~20
不会使硅橡胶出现结构性损伤
HTV structural formula The silicone rubber structure won't be damaged
by the ultraviolet radiation.
Solutions——Housing Material
3. 1.3 Ultraviolet radiation resistance
Experiment :
The amount of ultraviolet radiation of test is equivalent to the total amount of the strongest
ultraviolet region of the Northwest's radiation in 40 years through the 5000h UV aging test .
Requirements :
1. The depth of silicon rubber abrasion by sand is less than 2mm.
2. Hydrophobicity of composite insulator after abrasion reaches HC4 at least .
Solutions :
●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●
●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●
●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●
●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●
●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●
reinforced material :
nano-sized fumed silicon dioxide
Solutions——Housing Material
3. 1.4 Sand abrasion resistance
Experiment :
Sand blowing test of shed material is took according to GJB150. The sand used in the experiment is wind-blown sand
from desert, the content of silicon dioxide is more than 95%, and half of the sand’s diameter is bigger than
300μm. Parameters as shown in table
Temperature Relative Wind Sand Time
℃ humidity speeds concentration duration
% m/s g/m3 h
24℃ 30% 29m/s 2.2g/m³ 3h
M4 sand dust test chamber Silicone rubber properties change before and after test
Results : Properties DL/T376-2010 Before After △
Thickness mm / 2.04 1.95 0.09
Hardness shA ≥50 64 65 1
Tensile strength
≥4.0 5.37 5.13 0.24
MPa
Elongation at
≥150 355 341 14
break%
Hydrophobicity after sand abrasion
Tear strength
( left : 0h ; right : 48h ) ≥10.0 15.33 14.64 0.69
Conclusion : kN/m
Substation composite insulators using HTV house with reasonable formula can meet
the requirements of sand abrasion resistance for application .
Solutions——Housing Material
3.1. 5 Salt fog aging
Requirement :
Salt fog itself can`t corrode silicone rubber, but when attached to composite insulator, surface charge develop as
well as corona aging and erosion happen. So it is necessary to pay attention to salt fog aging in use, which benefit
from excellent electrical aging resistance performance
Experiment :
1000h salt fog test is made by Xi`an High Voltage Apparatus Research Institute, which is to simulate the salt fog
condition and evaluate the corrosion resistance.
Condition :
Standard: IEC 61462
Voltage: 19.5kV ,
Duration: 1000h 。
Results :
No over-current and shed
breakdown, no tracking and
erosion to the core.
Conclusion :
Able to tolerate salt fog test.
Solutions——Housing Material
3.1. 6 Acid rain aging
Requirement :
Acid rain consists of SOX, NOX, and other acidic material in air which became sulfurous acid
and nitrogen acid after immersed in rain. Acidic material react with reactive pressed on the
surface and damage the stability.
The PH of normal rain is 5.6, while acid rain is less than 5.6. So acid rain resistance
performance is required.
Solutions :
Excelent hydrophobicity
Results :
No mechanical and electrical performance decline after acid rain immersion, better than
standard DL/T376-2010.
Solutions——Housing Material
3. 1.6 Acid rain aging
Experiment :
Hydrophobicity change before and after acid rain accelerating aging test : A little decrease and
still stay at a high level.
Requirement :
Used in extremely cold area, reliable shed performance is necessary.
Solutions :
HTV silicone rubber is macromolecular and very smooth, glass-transition temperature low to -60
℃ , and high to 250℃. Extremely high and low temperature resistance performance, and can be
used in extremely cold area.
Experiment :
Low temperature brittleness test according to DL/T376-2010.
Results :
Glass-transition temperature is -66~-67 ℃ 。
Conclusion :
Substation composite insulators using HTV house with reasonable formula can
adapt to extremely low temperature and ensure the safety of power grid.
Solution——FRP Materials
3.2 Structure, Formula and Technology Design of FRP Tube
How to design a FRP tube?
Geometric Materials
Construction Formula
Modulus of
Kind Product specifications Tensile strength/MPa
elasticity /Gpa
Twaron
3000-5000 80-160
Aramid fiber Kevlar
TM 2500~2900 88~92
High strength HT 3100~3500 92~98
and modulus Vipro 2700~2800 88~89
fiber glass
HS 4020~4600 83~86
Solutions——FRP Materials
3. 2.1 Designable mechanical properties
Designable ply scheme research——elastic parameter theoretical calculation
E1 , E2 , E3 —— elasticity modulus
G12 , G13 , G23 —— shear modulus ;
12 , 13 , 23 —— Poisson’s ratio
Material parameters :
Vf —— fibre volume fraction ;Vm —— substrate volume fraction ;
E f 1 —— fibre longitudinal modulus of elasticity ;
E f 2 —— fibre transversal modulus of elasticity ;
Em —— substrate modulus of elasticity ; f 12 , f 23 —— fibre Poisson’s ratio ;
m —— substrate Poisson’s ratio ; Gf —— fibre shear modulus ;
Gm —— substrate shear modulus
Solutions——FRP Materials
3. 2.1 Designable mechanical properties
Reliable mechanical properties——insulator bending simulation calculation
Solutions——FRP Materials
3. 2.1 Designable mechanical properties
Flange
Silicone rubber shed
lining
FRP tube
Solutions——FRP Materials
3. 2.2 High temperature arc erosion and HF acid corrosion resistance
Requirement :
Hollow composite insulator used in transformer, bushing and oil-immersed CT, should
meet the requirement of oil resistance performance.
Solutions :
Dielectric oil:
aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons
non-polar material
no active reaction group
No solvation
Insulation tube:
epoxy resin No reaction
polar FRP inwall
Solutions——FRP Materials
3. 2.3Oil resistance performance
Experiment : Gas composition content and dielectric loss angle change after contact with
insulating oil in certain circumstances, refer to IEC 60599
results : Gas composition content far less than IEC standard after immersed.
Gas composition content of casting after immersed in insulating oil
25#transfo 45#transfor Nynas Methyl IEC
Test item PXE oil C101 oil
rmer oil mer oil Petroleum silicone oil standard
H2 38.57 28.1 88.1 7.43 41.28 50.55 ≤300
C2H6 0 0 0 0 0 0 ≤50
C2H2 0 0 0 0 0 0 ≤2
Insulator inwall FRP casting, choose 25# transformer oil and Nynas petroleum to test dielectric
loss angle refer to GB/T 5654, test conditions as above.
Results : Dielectric loss angle change is slight when immersed, meet the standard.
Conclusion : Hollow composite insulator inwall incompatible with transformer oil, meet the
requirement of oil resistance performance
Conclusion :
Substation composite insulators with suitable sealing material, reasonable sealing structures can
meet the requirements of sealing property for application.
Solutions——Manufacturing process
Requirement :
The maximum diameter is 1 meter, and height is 10 meters. Silicone rubber shed should be one-time injected
under the condition of high temperature of 160℃ and the high pressure of 150MPa so that the shed can full
cure and adhere to the FRP tube reliably.
Solutions :
1. Self-develop hollow composite insulator vacuum injection molding process technology
2. Cooperate with supplier and develop 16 cooling runner injection machine
3. Self-develop injection mold and winding mold fitting the machine to manufacture all kinds of hollow composite
insulators
Conclusion :
HTV silicon rubber vacuum cooling runner injection molding makes the composite
insulators’ house vulcanized completely, stick reliably with FRP tube and no bubbles, and
the silicone rubber sheds are one-time injection.
Solution——Experiments
Shemar composite insulators pass rigorous and comprehensive experiments
KEMA test report ( 5000h multi-stress aging test, IEC61109 ) , Tsinghua University test
report ( 5000h multi-stress aging test, IEC62217 ) , DARMSTADT test report ( 1000h AC salt
fog test, IEC60099 ) , Sweden ABB test report ( South Africa seaside aging test ) , France
Alstom test report ( long-term thermal aging )
3 SOLUTIONS
2 CHALLENGES
APPLICATION
APPLICATIONS
SHEMAR tested the 500kV hollow composite insulator used for more than 15 years Shemar
cooperated with equipment manufacturer to carry back a hollow composite insulator which has
been running for 15 years and has been replaced from 500kV Minfeng substation in Loudi, Hunan
province. Then we shipped it back to the factory for overall test and component material test. The
results showed that the product performance was basically unchanged.
Mechanical and electrical properties before and after operation
Items New product Running 15years
Maximum offset at the top of the 4kN
6mm 6.4mm
bending load (mm)
Maximum offset at the top of the 36kN
12mm 11.6mm
bending load (mm)
Intrinsic pressure(1.6MPa , 5min ) No leakage No leakage
Seal test (annual leakage rate) 0.001 0.0012
Power frequency withstand voltage ( kV) 680 680
Performance of silicone rubber before and after operation
Items New product Running 15 years
Hardness ( HSD ) 62 63 Minfeng substation put into operation at
the end of 1995. When it expanded in 2002
Tensile strength ( MPa ) 5.1 4.9
it used SF6 current transformer produced by
Elongation at break ( % ) 282 268
Hunan power electric porcelain electrical
Hydrophobicity HC1 HC1~HC2 appliance factory which used hollow
Tracking resistance 1A4.5 1A4.5 composite insulator produced by SHEMAR
Flame resistance FV-0 FV-0 and has been worked well so far.
APPLICATIONS
SHEMAR electric power carries on the experiment to the Qinghai-Tibet project composite
insulators shed material :
The Qinghai Tibet 750kV/±400kV AC and DC interconnection project was commissioned in 2011.
The total length of the line is 1038km, with a maximum altitude of 5231 meters, with an average
altitude of 4650 meters. Up to now, this is the largest DC transmission project built at the highest
altitude in the world. Most of the line composite insulators are provided by SHEMAR. From 23 to
25 in September 2017, during the blackout of the line, SHEMAR changed the line insulators on the
#636 and #637 two towers, and obtained 16 samples that had been running for more than 6 years,
and then tested the shed material performance.
Performance of silicone rubber before and after operation
Items New product Running 6 years
Hardness ( HSD ) 68 71
Tensile strength ( MPa ) 4.3 4.15
Elongation at break ( % ) 336 301
Tear strength , kN/m 15 13
Hydrophobicity HC1 HC2
Tracking resistance 1A4.5 1A4.5
Flame resistance FV-0 FV-0
Application of composite insulators in substation for SHEMAR since 2011
GIS 、 Pass
Oil CT
Bus-bar supporting
Optical instrument
transformer
DTB
CVT
Capacitor
Cable terminal
Reactor
Transformer
Arrester
SF6 CT
Application of composite insulators in substation —— UHV projects
500kV Substation in
Xiangtan Hunan
It was in operation in
2006 and has been in
operation for 11 years .
500kV Substation in
Datang Lusi power plant ,
Jiangsu
It was in operation in
2010 and has been in
operation for 7 years .
750kV substation in
Riyue mountain ,
Qinghai
It was in operation in
2011 and has been in
operation for 6 years .
It is in the strong
sandstorm area .
Application of composite insulators in substation —— Sandy areas
750kV Substation in
Shazhou
It was in operation
in 2013 and has
been in operation
for 4 years .
It is in strong
sandstorm area .
64
Application of composite insulators in substation —— Strong ultraviolet region
750kV Substation in
Guanting , Qinghai
It was in operation
in 2008 and has
been in operation
for 9 years .
It is in a strong
ultraviolet region .
Shemar substation composite insulator servicing more than 90% of the global power
transmission equipment manufacturers
Thanks!