-
Performance-Aligned LLMs for Generating Fast Code
Authors:
Daniel Nichols,
Pranav Polasam,
Harshitha Menon,
Aniruddha Marathe,
Todd Gamblin,
Abhinav Bhatele
Abstract:
Optimizing scientific software is a difficult task because codebases are often large and complex, and performance can depend upon several factors including the algorithm, its implementation, and hardware among others. Causes of poor performance can originate from disparate sources and be difficult to diagnose. Recent years have seen a multitude of work that use large language models (LLMs) to assi…
▽ More
Optimizing scientific software is a difficult task because codebases are often large and complex, and performance can depend upon several factors including the algorithm, its implementation, and hardware among others. Causes of poor performance can originate from disparate sources and be difficult to diagnose. Recent years have seen a multitude of work that use large language models (LLMs) to assist in software development tasks. However, these tools are trained to model the distribution of code as text, and are not specifically designed to understand performance aspects of code. In this work, we introduce a reinforcement learning based methodology to align the outputs of code LLMs with performance. This allows us to build upon the current code modeling capabilities of LLMs and extend them to generate better performing code. We demonstrate that our fine-tuned model improves the expected speedup of generated code over base models for a set of benchmark tasks from 0.9 to 1.6 for serial code and 1.9 to 4.5 for OpenMP code.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
HPC-Coder: Modeling Parallel Programs using Large Language Models
Authors:
Daniel Nichols,
Aniruddha Marathe,
Harshitha Menon,
Todd Gamblin,
Abhinav Bhatele
Abstract:
Parallel programs in high performance computing (HPC) continue to grow in complexity and scale in the exascale era. The diversity in hardware and parallel programming models make developing, optimizing, and maintaining parallel software even more burdensome for developers. One way to alleviate some of these burdens is with automated development and analysis tools. Such tools can perform complex an…
▽ More
Parallel programs in high performance computing (HPC) continue to grow in complexity and scale in the exascale era. The diversity in hardware and parallel programming models make developing, optimizing, and maintaining parallel software even more burdensome for developers. One way to alleviate some of these burdens is with automated development and analysis tools. Such tools can perform complex and/or remedial tasks for developers that increase their productivity and decrease the chance for error. Until recently, such tools for code development and performance analysis have been limited in the complexity of tasks they can perform, especially for parallel programs. However, with recent advancements in language modeling, and the availability of large amounts of open-source code related data, these tools have started to utilize predictive language models to automate more complex tasks. In this paper, we show how large language models (LLMs) can be applied to tasks specific to high performance and scientific codes. We introduce a new dataset of HPC and scientific codes and use it to fine-tune several pre-trained models. We compare several pre-trained LLMs on HPC-related tasks and introduce a new model, HPC-Coder, fine-tuned on parallel codes. In our experiments, we show that this model can auto-complete HPC functions where generic models cannot, decorate for loops with OpenMP pragmas, and model performance changes in scientific application repositories as well as programming competition solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024; v1 submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Overcoming Challenges to Continuous Integration in HPC
Authors:
Todd Gamblin,
Daniel S. Katz
Abstract:
Continuous integration (CI) has become a ubiquitous practice in modern software development, with major code hosting services offering free automation on popular platforms. CI offers major benefits, as it enables detecting bugs in code prior to committing changes. While high-performance computing (HPC) research relies heavily on software, HPC machines are not considered "common" platforms. This pr…
▽ More
Continuous integration (CI) has become a ubiquitous practice in modern software development, with major code hosting services offering free automation on popular platforms. CI offers major benefits, as it enables detecting bugs in code prior to committing changes. While high-performance computing (HPC) research relies heavily on software, HPC machines are not considered "common" platforms. This presents several challenges that hinder the adoption of CI in HPC environments, making it difficult to maintain bug-free HPC projects, and resulting in adverse effects on the research community. In this article, we explore the challenges that impede HPC CI, such as hardware diversity, security, isolation, administrative policies, and non-standard authentication, environments, and job submission mechanisms. We propose several solutions that could enhance the quality of HPC software and the experience of developers. Implementing these solutions would require significant changes at HPC centers, but if these changes are made, it would ultimately enable faster and better science.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Machine Learning-Driven Adaptive OpenMP For Portable Performance on Heterogeneous Systems
Authors:
Giorgis Georgakoudis,
Konstantinos Parasyris,
Chunhua Liao,
David Beckingsale,
Todd Gamblin,
Bronis de Supinski
Abstract:
Heterogeneity has become a mainstream architecture design choice for building High Performance Computing systems. However, heterogeneity poses significant challenges for achieving performance portability of execution. Adapting a program to a new heterogeneous platform is laborious and requires developers to manually explore a vast space of execution parameters. To address those challenges, this pa…
▽ More
Heterogeneity has become a mainstream architecture design choice for building High Performance Computing systems. However, heterogeneity poses significant challenges for achieving performance portability of execution. Adapting a program to a new heterogeneous platform is laborious and requires developers to manually explore a vast space of execution parameters. To address those challenges, this paper proposes new extensions to OpenMP for autonomous, machine learning-driven adaptation.
Our solution includes a set of novel language constructs, compiler transformations, and runtime support. We propose a producer-consumer pattern to flexibly define multiple, different variants of OpenMP code regions to enable adaptation. Those regions are transparently profiled at runtime to autonomously learn optimizing machine learning models that dynamically select the fastest variant. Our approach significantly reduces users' efforts of programming adaptive applications on heterogeneous architectures by leveraging machine learning techniques and code generation capabilities of OpenMP compilation. Using a complete reference implementation in Clang/LLVM we evaluate three use-cases of adaptive CPU-GPU execution. Experiments with HPC proxy applications and benchmarks demonstrate that the proposed adaptive OpenMP extensions automatically choose the best performing code variants for various adaptation possibilities, in several different heterogeneous platforms of CPUs and GPUs.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Mapping Out the HPC Dependency Chaos
Authors:
Farid Zakaria,
Thomas R. W. Scogland,
Todd Gamblin,
Carlos Maltzahn
Abstract:
High Performance Computing~(HPC) software stacks have become complex, with the dependencies of some applications numbering in the hundreds. Packaging, distributing, and administering software stacks of that scale is a complex undertaking anywhere. HPC systems deal with esoteric compilers, hardware, and a panoply of uncommon combinations. In this paper, we explore the mechanisms available for packa…
▽ More
High Performance Computing~(HPC) software stacks have become complex, with the dependencies of some applications numbering in the hundreds. Packaging, distributing, and administering software stacks of that scale is a complex undertaking anywhere. HPC systems deal with esoteric compilers, hardware, and a panoply of uncommon combinations. In this paper, we explore the mechanisms available for packaging software to find its own dependencies in the context of a taxonomy of software distribution, and discuss their benefits and pitfalls. We discuss workarounds for some common problems caused by using these composed stacks and introduce Shrinkwrap: A solution to producing binaries that directly load their dependencies from precise locations and in a precise order. Beyond simplifying the use of the binaries, this approach also speeds up loading as much as 7x for a large dynamically-linked MPI application in our evaluation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2022; v1 submitted 22 October, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Using Answer Set Programming for HPC Dependency Solving
Authors:
Todd Gamblin,
Massimiliano Culpo,
Gregory Becker,
Sergei Shudler
Abstract:
Modern scientific software stacks have become extremely complex, using many programming models and libraries to exploit a growing variety of GPUs and accelerators. Package managers can mitigate this complexity using dependency solvers, but they are reaching their limits. Finding compatible dependency versions is NP-complete, and modeling the semantics of package compatibility modulo build-time opt…
▽ More
Modern scientific software stacks have become extremely complex, using many programming models and libraries to exploit a growing variety of GPUs and accelerators. Package managers can mitigate this complexity using dependency solvers, but they are reaching their limits. Finding compatible dependency versions is NP-complete, and modeling the semantics of package compatibility modulo build-time options, GPU runtimes, flags, and other parameters is extremely difficult. Within this enormous configuration space, defining a "good" configuration is daunting.
We tackle this problem using Answer Set Programming (ASP), a declarative model for combinatorial search problems. We show, using the Spack package manager, that ASP programs can concisely express the compatibility rules of HPC software stacks and provide strong quality-of-solution guarantees. Using ASP, we can mix new builds with preinstalled binaries, and solver performance is acceptable even when considering tens of thousands of packages.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Flexible and Optimal Dependency Management via Max-SMT
Authors:
Donald Pinckney,
Federico Cassano,
Arjun Guha,
Jon Bell,
Massimiliano Culpo,
Todd Gamblin
Abstract:
Package managers such as NPM have become essential for software development. The NPM repository hosts over 2 million packages and serves over 43 billion downloads every week. Unfortunately, the NPM dependency solver has several shortcomings. 1) NPM is greedy and often fails to install the newest versions of dependencies; 2) NPM's algorithm leads to duplicated dependencies and bloated code, which i…
▽ More
Package managers such as NPM have become essential for software development. The NPM repository hosts over 2 million packages and serves over 43 billion downloads every week. Unfortunately, the NPM dependency solver has several shortcomings. 1) NPM is greedy and often fails to install the newest versions of dependencies; 2) NPM's algorithm leads to duplicated dependencies and bloated code, which is particularly bad for web applications that need to minimize code size; 3) NPM's vulnerability fixing algorithm is also greedy, and can even introduce new vulnerabilities; and 4) NPM's ability to duplicate dependencies can break stateful frameworks and requires a lot of care to workaround. Although existing tools try to address these problems they are either brittle, rely on post hoc changes to the dependency tree, do not guarantee optimality, or are not composable.
We present PacSolve, a unifying framework and implementation for dependency solving which allows for customizable constraints and optimization goals. We use PacSolve to build MaxNPM, a complete, drop-in replacement for NPM, which empowers developers to combine multiple objectives when installing dependencies. We evaluate MaxNPM with a large sample of packages from the NPM ecosystem and show that it can: 1) reduce more vulnerabilities in dependencies than NPM's auditing tool in 33% of cases; 2) chooses newer dependencies than NPM in 14% of cases; and 3) chooses fewer dependencies than NPM in 21% of cases. All our code and data is open and available.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2023; v1 submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Reliabuild: Searching for High-Fidelity Builds Using Active Learning
Authors:
Harshitha Menon,
Konstantinos Parasyris,
Tom Scogland,
Todd Gamblin
Abstract:
Modern software is incredibly complex. A typical application may comprise hundreds or thousands of reusable components. Automated package managers can help to maintain a consistent set of dependency versions, but ultimately the solvers in these systems rely on constraints generated by humans. At scale, small errors add up, and it becomes increasingly difficult to find high-fidelity configurations.…
▽ More
Modern software is incredibly complex. A typical application may comprise hundreds or thousands of reusable components. Automated package managers can help to maintain a consistent set of dependency versions, but ultimately the solvers in these systems rely on constraints generated by humans. At scale, small errors add up, and it becomes increasingly difficult to find high-fidelity configurations. We cannot test all configurations, because the space is combinatorial, so exhaustive exploration is infeasible.
In this paper, we present Reliabuild, an auto-tuning framework that efficiently explores the build configuration space and learns which package versions are likely to result in a successful configuration. We implement two models in Reliabuild to rank the different configurations and use adaptive sampling to select good configurations with fewer samples. We demonstrate Reliabuild's effectiveness by evaluating 31,186 build configurations of 61 packages from the Extreme-scale Scientific Software Stack(E4S). Reliabuild selects good configurations efficiently. For example, Reliabuild selects 3X the number of good configurations in comparison to random sampling for several packages including Abyss, Bolt, libnrm, OpenMPI. Our framework is also able to select all the high-fidelity builds in half the number of samples required by random sampling for packages such as Chai, OpenMPI, py-petsc4py, and slepc. We further use the model to learn statistics about the compatibility of different packages, which will enable package solvers to better select high-fidelity build configurations automatically.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Scalable Comparative Visualization of Ensembles of Call Graphs
Authors:
Suraj P. Kesavan,
Harsh Bhatia,
Abhinav Bhatele,
Todd Gamblin,
Peer-Timo Bremer,
Kwan-Liu Ma
Abstract:
Optimizing the performance of large-scale parallel codes is critical for efficient utilization of computing resources. Code developers often explore various execution parameters, such as hardware configurations, system software choices, and application parameters, and are interested in detecting and understanding bottlenecks in different executions. They often collect hierarchical performance prof…
▽ More
Optimizing the performance of large-scale parallel codes is critical for efficient utilization of computing resources. Code developers often explore various execution parameters, such as hardware configurations, system software choices, and application parameters, and are interested in detecting and understanding bottlenecks in different executions. They often collect hierarchical performance profiles represented as call graphs, which combine performance metrics with their execution contexts. The crucial task of exploring multiple call graphs together is tedious and challenging because of the many structural differences in the execution contexts and significant variability in the collected performance metrics (e.g., execution runtime). In this paper, we present an enhanced version of CallFlow to support the exploration of ensembles of call graphs using new types of visualizations, analysis, graph operations, and features. We introduce ensemble-Sankey, a new visual design that combines the strengths of resource-flow (Sankey) and box-plot visualization techniques. Whereas the resource-flow visualization can easily and intuitively describe the graphical nature of the call graph, the box plots overlaid on the nodes of Sankey convey the performance variability within the ensemble. Our interactive visual interface provides linked views to help explore ensembles of call graphs, e.g., by facilitating the analysis of structural differences, and identifying similar or distinct call graphs. We demonstrate the effectiveness and usefulness of our design through case studies on large-scale parallel codes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Preserving Command Line Workflow for a Package Management System using ASCII DAG Visualization
Authors:
Katherine E. Isaacs,
Todd Gamblin
Abstract:
Package managers provide ease of access to applications by removing the time-consuming and sometimes completely prohibitive barrier of successfully building, installing, and maintaining the software for a system. A package dependency contains dependencies between all packages required to build and run the target software. Package management system developers, package maintainers, and users may con…
▽ More
Package managers provide ease of access to applications by removing the time-consuming and sometimes completely prohibitive barrier of successfully building, installing, and maintaining the software for a system. A package dependency contains dependencies between all packages required to build and run the target software. Package management system developers, package maintainers, and users may consult the dependency graph when a simple listing is insufficient for their analyses. However, users working in a remote command line environment must disrupt their workflow to visualize dependency graphs in graphical programs, possibly needing to move files between devices or incur forwarding lag. Such is the case for users of Spack, an open source package management system originally developed to ease the complex builds required by supercomputing environments. To preserve the command line workflow of Spack, we develop an interactive ASCII visualization for its dependency graphs. Through interviews with Spack maintainers, we identify user goals and corresponding visual tasks for dependency graphs. We evaluate the use of our visualization through a command line-centered study, comparing it to the system's two existing approaches. We observe that despite the limitations of the ASCII representation, our visualization is preferred by participants when approached from a command line interface workflow.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
xSDK Foundations: Toward an Extreme-scale Scientific Software Development Kit
Authors:
Roscoe Bartlett,
Irina Demeshko,
Todd Gamblin,
Glenn Hammond,
Michael Heroux,
Jeffrey Johnson,
Alicia Klinvex,
Xiaoye Li,
Lois Curfman McInnes,
J. David Moulton,
Daniel Osei-Kuffuor,
Jason Sarich,
Barry Smith,
Jim Willenbring,
Ulrike Meier Yang
Abstract:
Extreme-scale computational science increasingly demands multiscale and multiphysics formulations. Combining software developed by independent groups is imperative: no single team has resources for all predictive science and decision support capabilities. Scientific libraries provide high-quality, reusable software components for constructing applications with improved robustness and portability.…
▽ More
Extreme-scale computational science increasingly demands multiscale and multiphysics formulations. Combining software developed by independent groups is imperative: no single team has resources for all predictive science and decision support capabilities. Scientific libraries provide high-quality, reusable software components for constructing applications with improved robustness and portability. However, without coordination, many libraries cannot be easily composed. Namespace collisions, inconsistent arguments, lack of third-party software versioning, and additional difficulties make composition costly.
The Extreme-scale Scientific Software Development Kit (xSDK) defines community policies to improve code quality and compatibility across independently developed packages (hypre, PETSc, SuperLU, Trilinos, and Alquimia) and provides a foundation for addressing broader issues in software interoperability, performance portability, and sustainability. The xSDK provides turnkey installation of member software and seamless combination of aggregate capabilities, and it marks first steps toward extreme-scale scientific software ecosystems from which future applications can be composed rapidly with assured quality and scalability.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
