-
Theoretical predictions for $b\to s μ^+ μ^-$ decays
Authors:
Nico Gubernari
Abstract:
I review the state of the art of the theoretical calculations for decays mediated by $b\to s \ell^+ \ell^-$ transitions, for $\ell=e,μ$. I focus on the predictions of observables in $B\to K μ^+μ^-$, $B\to K^* μ^+μ^-$, and $B_s\to φμ^+μ^-$ decays, as many of these predictions are in tension with the corresponding experimental measurements. I also briefly discuss the $Λ_b\to Λμ^+μ^-$ decay and prese…
▽ More
I review the state of the art of the theoretical calculations for decays mediated by $b\to s \ell^+ \ell^-$ transitions, for $\ell=e,μ$. I focus on the predictions of observables in $B\to K μ^+μ^-$, $B\to K^* μ^+μ^-$, and $B_s\to φμ^+μ^-$ decays, as many of these predictions are in tension with the corresponding experimental measurements. I also briefly discuss the $Λ_b\to Λμ^+μ^-$ decay and present a new calculation for this channel. Special emphasis is placed on the non-local contributions, as they are the largest systematic uncertainties in these decays. The current theoretical calculations for $b\to s μ^+ μ^-$ decays are not able to explain the tensions with the experimental measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Non-factorisable Contributions of Strong-Penguin Operators in $Λ_b \to Λ\ell^+\ell^-$ Decays
Authors:
Thorsten Feldmann,
Nico Gubernari
Abstract:
We investigate for the first time a certain class of non-factorisable contributions of the four-quark operators ${\cal O}_{3-6}$ in the weak effective Hamiltonian to the $Λ_b \to Λ\ell^+\ell^-$ decay amplitude. We focus on the case where a virtual photon is radiated from one of the light constituents of the $Λ_b$ baryon, in the kinematic situation of large hadronic recoil with an energetic $Λ$ bar…
▽ More
We investigate for the first time a certain class of non-factorisable contributions of the four-quark operators ${\cal O}_{3-6}$ in the weak effective Hamiltonian to the $Λ_b \to Λ\ell^+\ell^-$ decay amplitude. We focus on the case where a virtual photon is radiated from one of the light constituents of the $Λ_b$ baryon, in the kinematic situation of large hadronic recoil with an energetic $Λ$ baryon in the final state. The effect on the suitably defined ``non-local form factors'' is calculated using the light-cone sum rule approach for a correlator with an interpolating current for the light $Λ$ baryon. We find that this approach requires the introduction of new soft functions that generalise the standard light-cone distribution amplitudes (LCDAs) for the heavy $Λ_b$ baryon. We give a heuristic discussion of their properties and a model that relates them to the standard LCDAs. Within this framework, we provide numerical results for the size of the non-local form factors considered.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024; v1 submitted 21 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
$B\to D_0^*$ and $B_s\to D_{s0}^*$ form factors from QCD light-cone sum rules
Authors:
Nico Gubernari,
Alexander Khodjamirian,
Rusa Mandal,
Thomas Mannel
Abstract:
We present the first application of QCD light-cone sum rules (LCSRs) with $B_{(s)}$-meson distribution amplitudes to the $B_{(s)}\!\to\! D_{(s)0}^*$ form factors, where $D_{(s)0}^*$ is a charmed scalar meson. We consider two scenarios for the $D_0^*$ spectrum. In the first one, we follow the Particle Data Group and consider a single broad resonance $D_0^*(2300)$. In the second one, we assume the e…
▽ More
We present the first application of QCD light-cone sum rules (LCSRs) with $B_{(s)}$-meson distribution amplitudes to the $B_{(s)}\!\to\! D_{(s)0}^*$ form factors, where $D_{(s)0}^*$ is a charmed scalar meson. We consider two scenarios for the $D_0^*$ spectrum. In the first one, we follow the Particle Data Group and consider a single broad resonance $D_0^*(2300)$. In the second one, we assume the existence of two scalar resonances, $D_0^*(2105)$ and $D_0^*(2451)$, as follows from a recent theoretically motivated analysis of $B\to Dππ$ decays. The $B\!\to\! D_0^*$ form factors are calculated in both scenarios, also taking into account the large total width of $D_0^*(2300)$. Furthermore, we calculate the $B_s\!\to\! D_{s0}^*$ form factors, considering in this case only the one-resonance scenario with $D_{s0}(2317)$. In this LCSRs calculation, the $c$-quark mass is kept finite and the $s$-quark mass is taken into account. We also include contributions of the two- and three-particle distribution amplitudes up to twist-four. Our predictions for semileptonic $B\!\to\! D_0^*\ellν_\ell$ and $B_s\!\to\! D_{s0}^*\ellν_\ell$ branching ratios are compared with the available data and HQET-based predictions. As a byproduct, we also obtain the $D_0^*$- and $D_{s0}^*$-meson decay constants and predict the lepton flavour universality ratios $R(D_0^*)$ and $R(D_{s0}^*)$.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2023; v1 submitted 18 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Dispersive Analysis of $B\to K^{(*)}$ and $B_s\to φ$ Form Factors
Authors:
Nico Gubernari,
Méril Reboud,
Danny van Dyk,
Javier Virto
Abstract:
We propose a stronger formulation of the dispersive (or unitarity) bounds à la Boyd-Grinstein-Lebed (BGL), which are commonly applied in analyses of the hadronic form factors for $B$ decays. In our approach, the existing bounds are split into several new bounds, thereby disentangling form factors that are jointly bounded in the common approach. This leads to stronger constraints for these objects,…
▽ More
We propose a stronger formulation of the dispersive (or unitarity) bounds à la Boyd-Grinstein-Lebed (BGL), which are commonly applied in analyses of the hadronic form factors for $B$ decays. In our approach, the existing bounds are split into several new bounds, thereby disentangling form factors that are jointly bounded in the common approach. This leads to stronger constraints for these objects, to a significant simplification of our numerical analysis, and to the removal of spurious correlations among the form factors. We apply these novel bounds to $\bar{B}\to \bar{K}^{(*)}$ and $\bar{B}_s\to φ$ form factors by fitting them to purely theoretical constraints. Using a suitable parametrization, we take into account the form factors' below-threshold branch cuts arising from on-shell $\bar{B}_s π^0$ and $\bar{B}_s π^0 π^0$ states, which so-far have been ignored in the literature. In this way, we eliminate a source of hard-to-quantify systematic uncertainties. We provide machine readable files to obtain the full set of the $\bar{B}\to \bar{K}^{(*)}$ and $\bar{B}_s\to φ$ form factors in and beyond the entire semileptonic phase space.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2024; v1 submitted 10 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
On the contribution of the electromagnetic dipole operator ${\cal O}_7$ to the $\bar B_s \to μ^+μ^-$ decay amplitude
Authors:
Thorsten Feldmann,
Nico Gubernari,
Tobias Huber,
Nicolas Seitz
Abstract:
We construct a factorization theorem that allows to systematically include QCD corrections to the contribution of the electromagnetic dipole operator in the effective weak Hamiltonian to the $\bar B_s \to μ^+μ^-$ decay amplitude. We first rederive the known result for the leading-order QED box diagram, which features a double-logarithmic enhancement associated to the different rapidities of the li…
▽ More
We construct a factorization theorem that allows to systematically include QCD corrections to the contribution of the electromagnetic dipole operator in the effective weak Hamiltonian to the $\bar B_s \to μ^+μ^-$ decay amplitude. We first rederive the known result for the leading-order QED box diagram, which features a double-logarithmic enhancement associated to the different rapidities of the light quark in the $\bar B_s$ meson and the energetic muons in the final state. We provide a detailed analysis of the cancellation of the related endpoint divergences appearing in individual momentum regions, and show how the rapidity logarithms can be isolated by suitable subtractions applied to the corresponding bare factorization theorem. This allows us to include in a straightforward manner the QCD corrections arising from the renormalization-group running of the hard matching coefficient of the electromagnetic dipole operator in soft-collinear effective theory, the hard-collinear scattering kernel, and the $B_s$-meson distribution amplitude. Focusing on the contribution from the double endpoint logarithms, we derive a compact formula that resums the leading-logarithmic QCD corrections.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Improved Theory Predictions and Global Analysis of Exclusive $\boldsymbol{b\to sμ^+μ^-}$ Processes
Authors:
Nico Gubernari,
Méril Reboud,
Danny van Dyk,
Javier Virto
Abstract:
We provide improved Standard Model theory predictions for the exclusive rare semimuonic processes $B\to K^{(*)}μ^+μ^-$ and $B_s\toφμ^+μ^-$. Our results are based on a novel parametrization of the non-local form factors, which manifestly respects a recently developed dispersive bound. We critically compare our predictions to those obtained in the framework of QCD factorization. Our predictions prov…
▽ More
We provide improved Standard Model theory predictions for the exclusive rare semimuonic processes $B\to K^{(*)}μ^+μ^-$ and $B_s\toφμ^+μ^-$. Our results are based on a novel parametrization of the non-local form factors, which manifestly respects a recently developed dispersive bound. We critically compare our predictions to those obtained in the framework of QCD factorization. Our predictions provide, for the first time, parametric estimates of the systematic uncertainties due to non-local contributions. Comparing our predictions within the Standard Model to available experimental data, we find a large tension for $B\to Kμ^+μ^-$. A simple model-independent analysis of potential effects beyond the Standard Model yields results compatible with other approaches, albeit with larger uncertainties for the $B\to K^*μ^+μ^-$ and $B_s\to φμ^+μ^-$ decays. Our approach yields systematically improvable predictions, and we look forward to its application in further analyses beyond the Standard Model.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2022; v1 submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
$B\to D_1(2420)$ and $B\to D_1'(2430)$ form factors from QCD light-cone sum rules
Authors:
Nico Gubernari,
Alexander Khodjamirian,
Rusa Mandal,
Thomas Mannel
Abstract:
We perform the first calculation of form factors in the semileptonic decays $B\!\to\! D_1(2420)\ellν_\ell$ and $B \to D_1^\prime (2430)\ell ν_\ell$ using QCD light-cone sum rules (LCSRs) with $B$-meson distribution amplitudes. In this calculation the $c$-quark mass is finite. Analytical expressions for two-particle contributions up to twist four are obtained. To disentangle the $D_1$ and…
▽ More
We perform the first calculation of form factors in the semileptonic decays $B\!\to\! D_1(2420)\ellν_\ell$ and $B \to D_1^\prime (2430)\ell ν_\ell$ using QCD light-cone sum rules (LCSRs) with $B$-meson distribution amplitudes. In this calculation the $c$-quark mass is finite. Analytical expressions for two-particle contributions up to twist four are obtained. To disentangle the $D_1$ and $D_1^\prime$ contributions in the LCSRs, we suggest a novel approach that introduces a combination of two interpolating currents for these charmed mesons. To fix all the parameters in the LCSRs, we use the two-point QCD sum rules for the decay constants of $D_1$ and $D_1^\prime$ mesons augmented by a single experimental input, that is the $B \to D_1(2420)\ellν_\ell$ decay width. We provide numerical results for all $B\to D_1$ and $B\to D_1^\prime$ form factors. As a byproduct, we also obtain the $D_1$- and $D_1'$-meson decay constants and predict the lepton-flavour universality ratios $R(D_1)$ and $R(D_1')$.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2022; v1 submitted 16 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
EOS -- A Software for Flavor Physics Phenomenology
Authors:
Danny van Dyk,
Frederik Beaujean,
Thomas Blake,
Christoph Bobeth,
Marzia Bordone,
Katarina Dugic,
Eike Eberhard,
Nico Gubernari,
Elena Graverini,
Martin Jung,
Ahmet Kokulu,
Stephan Kürten,
Domagoj Leljak,
Philip Lüghausen,
Stefan Meiser,
Muslem Rahimi,
Méril Reboud,
Rafael Silva Coutinho,
Javier Virto,
K. Keri Vos
Abstract:
EOS is an open-source software for a variety of computational tasks in flavor physics. Its use cases include theory predictions within and beyond the Standard Model of particle physics, Bayesian inference of theory parameters from experimental and theoretical likelihoods, and simulation of pseudo events for a number of signal processes. EOS ensures high-performance computations through a C++ back-…
▽ More
EOS is an open-source software for a variety of computational tasks in flavor physics. Its use cases include theory predictions within and beyond the Standard Model of particle physics, Bayesian inference of theory parameters from experimental and theoretical likelihoods, and simulation of pseudo events for a number of signal processes. EOS ensures high-performance computations through a C++ back-end and ease of usability through a Python front-end. To achieve this flexibility, EOS enables the user to select from a variety of implementations of the relevant decay processes and hadronic matrix elements at run time. In this article, we describe the general structure of the software framework and provide basic examples. Further details and in-depth interactive examples are provided as part of the EOS online documentation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Lepton-flavour non-universality of $\bar{B}\to D^*\ell \barν$ angular distributions in and beyond the Standard Model
Authors:
Christoph Bobeth,
Marzia Bordone,
Nico Gubernari,
Martin Jung,
Danny van Dyk
Abstract:
We analyze in detail the angular distributions in $\bar{B}\to D^*\ell \barν$ decays, with a focus on lepton-flavour non-universality. We investigate the minimal number of angular observables that fully describes current and upcoming datasets, and explore their sensitivity to physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM) in the most general weak effective theory. We apply our findings to the current data…
▽ More
We analyze in detail the angular distributions in $\bar{B}\to D^*\ell \barν$ decays, with a focus on lepton-flavour non-universality. We investigate the minimal number of angular observables that fully describes current and upcoming datasets, and explore their sensitivity to physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM) in the most general weak effective theory. We apply our findings to the current datasets, extract the non-redundant set of angular observables from the data, and compare to precise SM predictions that include lepton-flavour universality violating mass effects. Our analysis shows that the current presentation of the experimental data is not ideal and prohibits the extraction of the full set of relevant BSM parameters, since the number of independent angular observables that can be inferred from data is limited to only four. We uncover a $\sim4σ$ tension between data and predictions that is hidden in the redundant presentation of the Belle 2018 data on $\bar{B}\to D^*\ell \barν$ decays. This tension specifically involves observables that probe $e-μ$ lepton-flavour universality. However, we find inconsistencies in these data, which renders results based on it suspicious. Nevertheless, we discuss which generic BSM scenarios could explain the tension, in the case that the inconsistencies do not affect the data materially. Our findings highlight that $e-μ$ non-universality in the SM, introduced by the finite muon mass, is already significant in a subset of angular observables with respect to the experimental precision.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Non-local matrix elements in $B_{(s)}\to \{K^{(*)},φ\}\ell^+\ell^-$
Authors:
Nico Gubernari,
Danny van Dyk,
Javier Virto
Abstract:
We revisit the theoretical predictions and the parametrization of non-local matrix elements in rare $\bar{B}_{(s)}\to \lbrace \bar{K}^{(*)},φ\rbrace\ell^+\ell^-$ and $\bar{B}_{(s)}\to \lbrace \bar{K}^{*}, φ\rbrace γ$ decays. We improve upon the current state of these matrix elements in two ways. First, we recalculate the hadronic matrix elements needed at subleading power in the light-cone OPE usi…
▽ More
We revisit the theoretical predictions and the parametrization of non-local matrix elements in rare $\bar{B}_{(s)}\to \lbrace \bar{K}^{(*)},φ\rbrace\ell^+\ell^-$ and $\bar{B}_{(s)}\to \lbrace \bar{K}^{*}, φ\rbrace γ$ decays. We improve upon the current state of these matrix elements in two ways. First, we recalculate the hadronic matrix elements needed at subleading power in the light-cone OPE using $B$-meson light-cone sum rules. Our analytical results supersede those in the literature. We discuss the origin of our improvements and provide numerical results for the processes under consideration. Second, we derive the first dispersive bound on the non-local matrix elements. It provides a parametric handle on the truncation error in extrapolations of the matrix elements to large timelike momentum transfer using the $z$ expansion. We illustrate the power of the dispersive bound at the hand of a simple phenomenological application. As a side result of our work, we also provide numerical results for the $B_s \to φ$ form factors from $B$-meson light-cone sum rules.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2021; v1 submitted 19 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
A puzzle in $\bar{B}_{(s)}^0 \to D_{(s)}^{(*)+} \lbrace π^-, K^-\rbrace$ decays and extraction of the $f_s/f_d$ fragmentation fraction
Authors:
Marzia Bordone,
Nico Gubernari,
Tobias Huber,
Martin Jung,
Danny van Dyk
Abstract:
We provide updated predictions for the hadronic decays $\bar{B}_s^0\to D_s^{(*)+} π^-$ and $\bar{B}^0\to D^{(*)+} K^-$. They are based on $\mathcal{O}(α_s^2)$ results for the QCD factorization amplitudes at leading power and on recent results for the $\bar{B}_{(s)} \to D_{(s)}^{(*)}$ form factors up to order ${\cal O}(Λ_{\rm QCD}^2/m_c^2)$ in the heavy-quark expansion. We give quantitative estimat…
▽ More
We provide updated predictions for the hadronic decays $\bar{B}_s^0\to D_s^{(*)+} π^-$ and $\bar{B}^0\to D^{(*)+} K^-$. They are based on $\mathcal{O}(α_s^2)$ results for the QCD factorization amplitudes at leading power and on recent results for the $\bar{B}_{(s)} \to D_{(s)}^{(*)}$ form factors up to order ${\cal O}(Λ_{\rm QCD}^2/m_c^2)$ in the heavy-quark expansion. We give quantitative estimates of the matrix elements entering the hadronic decay amplitudes at order ${\cal O}(Λ_{\rm QCD}/m_b)$ for the first time. Our results are very precise, and uncover a substantial discrepancy between the theory predictions and the experimental measurements. We explore two possibilities for this discrepancy: non-factorizable contributions larger than predicted by the QCD factorization power counting, and contributions beyond the Standard Model. We determine the $f_s/f_d$ fragmentation fraction for the CDF, D0 and LHCb experiments for both scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2020; v1 submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Heavy-Quark Expansion for $\bar{B}_s\to D^{(*)}_s$ Form Factors and Unitarity Bounds beyond the $SU(3)_F$ Limit
Authors:
Marzia Bordone,
Nico Gubernari,
Martin Jung,
Danny van Dyk
Abstract:
We carry out a comprehensive analysis of the full set of $\bar{B}_q \to D_q^{(*)}$ form factors for spectator quarks $q=u,d,s$ within the framework of the Heavy-Quark Expansion (HQE) to order $\mathcal{O}(α_s, 1/m_b, 1/m_c^2)$. In addition to the available lattice QCD calculations we make use of two new sets of theoretical constraints: we produce for the first time numerical predictions for the fu…
▽ More
We carry out a comprehensive analysis of the full set of $\bar{B}_q \to D_q^{(*)}$ form factors for spectator quarks $q=u,d,s$ within the framework of the Heavy-Quark Expansion (HQE) to order $\mathcal{O}(α_s, 1/m_b, 1/m_c^2)$. In addition to the available lattice QCD calculations we make use of two new sets of theoretical constraints: we produce for the first time numerical predictions for the full set of $\bar{B}_s \to D_s^{(*)}$ form factors using Light-Cone Sum Rules with $B_s$-meson distribution amplitudes. Furthermore, we reassess the QCD three-point sum rule results for the Isgur-Wise functions entering all our form factors for both $q=u,d$ and $q=s$ spectator quarks. These additional constraints allow us to go beyond the commonly used assumption of $SU(3)_F$ symmetry for the $\bar B_s\to D_s^{(*)}$ form factors, especially in the unitarity constraints which we impose throughout our analysis. We find the coefficients of the IW functions emerging at $\mathcal{O}(1/m_c^2)$ to be consistent with the naive $\mathcal{O}(1)$ expectation, indicating a good convergence of the HQE. While we do not find significant $SU(3)$ breaking, the explicit treatment of $q=s$ as compared to a simple symmetry assumption renders the unitarity constraints more effective. We find that the (pseudo)scalar bounds are saturated to a large degree, which affects our theory predictions. We analyze the phenomenological consequences of our improved form factors by extracting $|V_{cb}|$ from $\bar B\to D^{(*)}\ellν$ decays and producing theoretical predictions for the lepton-flavour universality ratios $R(D)$, $R(D^*)$, $R(D_s)$ and $R(D_s^*)$, as well as the $τ$- and $D_q^*$ polarization fractions for the $\bar B_q\to D_q^{(*)}τν$ modes.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2020; v1 submitted 19 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
$B\to P$ and $B\to V$ Form Factors from $B$-Meson Light-Cone Sum Rules beyond Leading Twist
Authors:
Nico Gubernari,
Ahmet Kokulu,
Danny van Dyk
Abstract:
We provide results for the full set of form factors describing semileptonic $B$-meson transitions to pseudoscalar mesons $π$, $K$, $\bar{D}$ and vector mesons $ρ$, $K^*$, $\bar{D}^*$. Our results are obtained within the framework of QCD Light-Cone Sum Rules with $B$-meson distribution amplitudes. We recalculate and confirm the results for the leading-twist two-particle contributions in the literat…
▽ More
We provide results for the full set of form factors describing semileptonic $B$-meson transitions to pseudoscalar mesons $π$, $K$, $\bar{D}$ and vector mesons $ρ$, $K^*$, $\bar{D}^*$. Our results are obtained within the framework of QCD Light-Cone Sum Rules with $B$-meson distribution amplitudes. We recalculate and confirm the results for the leading-twist two-particle contributions in the literature. Furthermore, we calculate and provide new expressions for the two-particle contributions up to twist four. Following new developments for the three-particle distribution amplitudes, we calculate and provide new results for the complete set of three-particle contributions up to twist four. The form factors are computed numerically at several phase space points using up-to-date input parameters, including correlations across phase space points and form factors. We use a model ansatz for all contributing $B$-meson distribution amplitudes that is self-consistent up to twist-four accuracy. We find that the higher-twist two-particle contributions have a substantial impact on the results, and dominate over the three-particle contributions. Our numerical results, including correlations, are provided as machine-readable ancillary files. We discuss the qualitative phenomenological impact of our results on the present $b$ anomalies.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2020; v1 submitted 2 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
