-
Effect of high pressure synthesis conditions on the formation of high entropy oxides
Authors:
Solveig Stubmo Aamlid,
Minu Kim,
Mario U. González-Rivas,
Mohamed Oudah,
Hidenori Takagi,
Alannah M. Hallas
Abstract:
High entropy materials are often entropy stabilized, meaning that the configurational entropy from multiple elements sharing a single lattice site stabilizes the structure. In this work, we study how high-pressure synthesis conditions can stabilize or destabilize a high entropy oxide (HEO). We study the high-pressure and high-temperature phase equilibria of two well-known families of HEOs: the roc…
▽ More
High entropy materials are often entropy stabilized, meaning that the configurational entropy from multiple elements sharing a single lattice site stabilizes the structure. In this work, we study how high-pressure synthesis conditions can stabilize or destabilize a high entropy oxide (HEO). We study the high-pressure and high-temperature phase equilibria of two well-known families of HEOs: the rock-salt structured compound (Mg,Co,Ni,Cu,Zn)O including some cation substitutions and the spinel structured (Cr,Mn,Fe,Co,Ni)$_3$O$_4$. Syntheses were performed at various temperatures, pressures, and oxygen activity levels resulting in dramatically different synthesis outcomes. In particular, in the rock salt HEO we observe the competing tenorite and wurtzite phases and the possible formation of a layered rock salt phase, while the spinel HEO is highly susceptible to decomposition into a mixture of rock-salt and corundum phases. At the highest tested pressures, 15 GPa, we discover the transformation of the spinel HEO into a metastable modified ludwigite-type structure with nominal formula (Cr,Mn,Fe,Co,Ni)$_4$O$_5$. The relationship between the synthesis conditions and the final reaction product is not straightforward. Nonetheless, we conclude that high-pressure conditions provide an important opportunity to synthesize high entropy phases that cannot be formed any other way.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Short-range order and local distortions in entropy stabilized oxides
Authors:
Solveig S. Aamlid,
Sam Mugiraneza,
Mario U. González-Rivas,
Graham King,
Alannah M. Hallas,
Jörg Rottler
Abstract:
An idealized high entropy oxide is characterized by perfect chemical disorder and perfect positional order. In this work, we investigate the extent to which short-range order (SRO) and local structural distortions impede that idealized scenario. Working in the entropy stabilized $α$-PbO$_2$ structure, we compare a two-component system, (Ti,Zr)O$_2$, with a four-component system, (Ti,Zr,Hf,Sn)O…
▽ More
An idealized high entropy oxide is characterized by perfect chemical disorder and perfect positional order. In this work, we investigate the extent to which short-range order (SRO) and local structural distortions impede that idealized scenario. Working in the entropy stabilized $α$-PbO$_2$ structure, we compare a two-component system, (Ti,Zr)O$_2$, with a four-component system, (Ti,Zr,Hf,Sn)O$_2$, using a combination of experimental and computational approaches. Special quasi-random structures are used in conjunction with density functional theory calculations to investigate the local distortions around specific elements revealing significant local distortions that are relatively insensitive to the number of chemical constituents. Using finite temperature Monte Carlo simulations, we are able to reproduce the previously experimentally observed SRO and transition temperature for the two-component system. However, ideal configurational entropy is never reached, so SRO is expected even at synthesis temperatures. On the other hand, the order-disorder transition temperature is dramatically lower and experimentally inaccessible for the four-component system, while the configurational entropy is closer to ideal and less sensitive to temperature. Total scattering measurements and pair distribution function analysis of slow-cooled and quenched samples support this view. In general, we demonstrate that SRO effects in high entropy materials are less prevalent as more components are added in, provided the pairwise interaction strengths remain comparable, while local distortions are less affected by the number of components.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Critical Role of Disorder for Superconductivity in the Series of Epitaxial Ti(O,N) Films
Authors:
Fengmiao Li,
Oliver Dicks,
Myung-Geun Han,
Solveig Aamlid,
Giorgio Levy,
Ronny Sutarto,
Chong Liu,
Hsiang-Hsi Kung,
Oleksandr Foyevstov,
Simon Godin,
Bruce A. Davidson,
Andrea Damascelli,
Yimei Zhu,
Christoph Heil,
Ilya Elfimov,
George A. Sawatzky,
Ke Zou
Abstract:
Experimental manipulation of superconductivity is of paramount importance, not only for practical applications but also for identifying the key factors involved in electron pairing. In this work, we have undertaken a meticulous study of the superconductivity in a series of titanium compounds with a rocksalt structure, synthesized as epitaxial films. We find that substituting nitrogen (N) for oxyge…
▽ More
Experimental manipulation of superconductivity is of paramount importance, not only for practical applications but also for identifying the key factors involved in electron pairing. In this work, we have undertaken a meticulous study of the superconductivity in a series of titanium compounds with a rocksalt structure, synthesized as epitaxial films. We find that substituting nitrogen (N) for oxygen (O) in titanium monoxide (TiO) with the stoichiometry close to TiO$_{0.6}$N$_{0.4}$ leads to superconductivity with a transition temperature (T$_c$) of ~2.6 K, about five times higher than that of TiO at ~0.5 K and half as high as the T$_c$ of ~6 K in titanium nitride (TiN). However, Eliashberg theoretical calculations predict similar Tc in TiO, Ti oxynitride and TiN. The analysis of electron mean free path suggests the presence of significant disorder in TiO and a remarkable reduction in the impact of disorder in oxynitrides. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that disorder decreases the coherence of electronic states for non-zero momenta, which would degrade the influence of electron-phonon. Our findings demonstrate the disorder and superconductivity depend strongly on the N/O ratio, highlighting the critical role of disorder for superconductivity in this series of Ti(O,N) materials.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Phase stability of entropy stabilized oxides with the $α$-PbO$_2$ structure
Authors:
Solveig S. Aamlid,
Graham H. J. Johnstone,
Sam Mugiraneza,
Mohamed Oudah,
Jörg Rottler,
Alannah M. Hallas
Abstract:
The prediction of new high entropy oxides (HEOs) remains a profound challenge due to their inherent chemical complexity. In this work, we combine experimental and computational methods to search for new HEOs in the tetravalent $A$O$_2$ family, using exclusively $d^0$ and $d^{10}$ cations, and to explain the observed phase stability of the $α$-PbO$_2$ structure, as found for the medium entropy oxid…
▽ More
The prediction of new high entropy oxides (HEOs) remains a profound challenge due to their inherent chemical complexity. In this work, we combine experimental and computational methods to search for new HEOs in the tetravalent $A$O$_2$ family, using exclusively $d^0$ and $d^{10}$ cations, and to explain the observed phase stability of the $α$-PbO$_2$ structure, as found for the medium entropy oxide (Ti, Zr, Hf, Sn)O$_2$. Using a pairwise approach to approximate the mixing enthalpy, we confirm that $α$-PbO$_2$ is the expected lowest energy structure for this material above other candidates including rutile, baddeleyite, and fluorite structures. We also show that no other five-component compound composed of the tetravalent cations considered here is expected to form under solid state synthesis conditions, which we verify experimentally. Ultimately, we conclude that the flexible geometry of the $α$-PbO$_2$ structure can be used to understand its stability among tetravalent HEOs.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Understanding the role of entropy in high entropy oxides
Authors:
Solveig S. Aamlid,
Mohamed Oudah,
Jörg Rottler,
Alannah M. Hallas
Abstract:
The field of high entropy oxides (HEOs) flips traditional materials science paradigms on their head by seeking to understand what properties arise in the presence of profound configurational disorder. This disorder, which originates from multiple elements sharing a single lattice site, can take on a kaleidoscopic character due to the vast numbers of possible elemental combinations. High configurat…
▽ More
The field of high entropy oxides (HEOs) flips traditional materials science paradigms on their head by seeking to understand what properties arise in the presence of profound configurational disorder. This disorder, which originates from multiple elements sharing a single lattice site, can take on a kaleidoscopic character due to the vast numbers of possible elemental combinations. High configurational disorder appears to imbue some HEOs with functional properties that far surpass their non-disordered analogs. While experimental discoveries abound, efforts to characterize the true magnitude of the configurational entropy and understand its role in stabilizing new phases and generating superior functional properties have lagged behind. Understanding the role of configurational disorder in existing HEOs is the crucial link to unlocking the rational design of new HEOs with targeted properties. In this Perspective, we attempt to establish a framework for articulating and beginning to address these questions in pursuit of a deeper understanding of the true role of entropy in HEOs.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
