-
Stable-to-unstable transition in quantum friction
Authors:
Daigo Oue,
J. B. Pendry,
Mário G. Silveirinha
Abstract:
We investigate the frictional force arising from quantum fluctuations when two dissipative metallic plates are set in a shear motion. While early studies showed that the electromagnetic fields in the quantum friction setup reach nonequilibrium steady states, yielding a time-independent force, other works have demonstrated the failure to attain steady states, leading to instability and time-varying…
▽ More
We investigate the frictional force arising from quantum fluctuations when two dissipative metallic plates are set in a shear motion. While early studies showed that the electromagnetic fields in the quantum friction setup reach nonequilibrium steady states, yielding a time-independent force, other works have demonstrated the failure to attain steady states, leading to instability and time-varying friction under sufficiently low-loss conditions. Here, we develop a fully quantum-mechanical theory without perturbative approximations and unveil the transition from stable to unstable regimes of the quantum friction setup. Due to the relative motion of the plates, their electromagnetic response may be active in some conditions, resulting in optical gain. We prove that the standard fluctuation-dissipation leads to inconsistent results when applied to our system, and, in particular, it predicts a vanishing frictional force. Using a modified fluctuation-dissipation relation tailored for gain media, we calculate the frictional force in terms of the system Green's function, thereby recovering early works on quantum friction. Remarkably, we also find that the frictional force diverges to infinity as the relative velocity of the plates approaches a threshold. This threshold is determined by the damping strength and the distance between the metal surfaces. Beyond this critical velocity, the system exhibits instability, akin to the behaviour of a laser cavity, where no steady state exists. In such a scenario, the frictional force escalates exponentially. Our findings pave the way for experimental exploration of the frictional force in proximity to this critical regime.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Noncontact frictional force between surfaces by peristaltic permittivity modulation
Authors:
Daigo Oue,
Kun Ding,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
In this study, we reveal noncontact frictional forces between surfaces in the presence of peristaltic permittivity modulation. Our setup comprises a conducting medium, an air gap, and a dielectric substrate on which we have a space-time-modulated grating that emits electromagnetic radiation. The radiation receives energy and momentum from the grating, which is eventually absorbed by the conducting…
▽ More
In this study, we reveal noncontact frictional forces between surfaces in the presence of peristaltic permittivity modulation. Our setup comprises a conducting medium, an air gap, and a dielectric substrate on which we have a space-time-modulated grating that emits electromagnetic radiation. The radiation receives energy and momentum from the grating, which is eventually absorbed by the conducting medium or propagates away from the grating on the dielectric side, resulting in electromagnetic power loss and lateral forces at the surfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023; v1 submitted 24 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Photonics of Time-Varying Media
Authors:
Emanuele Galiffi,
Romain Tirole,
Shixiong Yin,
Huanan Li,
Stefano Vezzoli,
Paloma A. Huidobro,
Mário G. Silveirinha,
Riccardo Sapienza,
Andrea Alù,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Time-varying media have recently emerged as a new paradigm for wave manipulation, thanks to thesynergy between the discovery of novel, highly nonlinear materials, such as epsilon-near-zero materials, and the questfor novel wave applications, such as magnet-free nonreciprocity, multi-mode light shaping, and ultrafast switching. Inthis review we provide a comprehensive discussion of the recent progr…
▽ More
Time-varying media have recently emerged as a new paradigm for wave manipulation, thanks to thesynergy between the discovery of novel, highly nonlinear materials, such as epsilon-near-zero materials, and the questfor novel wave applications, such as magnet-free nonreciprocity, multi-mode light shaping, and ultrafast switching. Inthis review we provide a comprehensive discussion of the recent progress achieved with photonic metamaterials whoseproperties stem from their modulation in time. We review the basic concepts underpinning temporal switching and itsrelation with spatial scattering, and deploy the resulting insight to review photonic time-crystals and their emergentresearch avenues such as topological and non-Hermitian physics. We then extend our discussion to account for spa-tiotemporal modulation and its applications to nonreciprocity, synthetic motion, giant anisotropy, amplification andother effects. Finally, we conclude with a review of the most attractive experimental avenues recently demonstrated,and provide a few perspectives on emerging trends for future implementations of time-modulation in photonics.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2021; v1 submitted 16 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
An Archimedes' Screw for Light
Authors:
Emanuele Galiffi,
Paloma A. Huidobro,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
An Archimedes' Screw captures water, feeding energy into it by lifting it to a higher level. We introduce the first instance of an optical Archimedes' Screw, and demonstrate how this system is capable of capturing light, dragging it and amplifying it. We unveil new exact analytic solutions to Maxwell's Equations for a wide family of chiral space-time media, and show their potential to achieve chir…
▽ More
An Archimedes' Screw captures water, feeding energy into it by lifting it to a higher level. We introduce the first instance of an optical Archimedes' Screw, and demonstrate how this system is capable of capturing light, dragging it and amplifying it. We unveil new exact analytic solutions to Maxwell's Equations for a wide family of chiral space-time media, and show their potential to achieve chirally selective amplification within widely tunable parity-time-broken phases. Our work, which may be readily implemented via pump-probe experiments with circularly polarized beams, opens a new direction in the physics of time-varying media by merging the rising field of space-time metamaterials and that of chiral systems, and may form a new playground for topology and non-Hermitian physics, with potential applications to chiral spectroscopy and sensing.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Čerenkov radiation in vacuum from a superluminal grating
Authors:
Daigo Oue,
Kun Ding,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Nothing can physically travel faster than light in vacuum. This is why it has been considered that there is no Čerenkov radiation (ČR) without an effective refractive index due to some background field. In this Letter, we theoretically predict ČR in vacuum from a spatiotemporally modulated boundary. We consider the modulation of traveling wave type and apply a uniform electrostatic field on the bo…
▽ More
Nothing can physically travel faster than light in vacuum. This is why it has been considered that there is no Čerenkov radiation (ČR) without an effective refractive index due to some background field. In this Letter, we theoretically predict ČR in vacuum from a spatiotemporally modulated boundary. We consider the modulation of traveling wave type and apply a uniform electrostatic field on the boundary to generate electric dipoles. Since the induced dipoles stick to the interface, they travel at the modulation speed. When the grating travels faster than light, it emits ČR. In order to quantitatively examine this argument, we need to calculate the field scattered at the boundary. We utilise a dynamical differential method, which we developed in the previous paper, to quantitatively evaluate the field distribution in such a situation. We can confirm that all scattered fields are evanescent if the modulation speed is slower than light while some become propagating if the modulation is faster than light.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Calculating spatiotemporally modulated surfaces: a dynamical differential formalism
Authors:
Daigo Oue,
Kun Ding,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Electromagnetic waves in a system with a space and time dependent boundary experience both diffraction and Doppler-like frequency conversion. In order to analyse such situations, conventional methods call for either the eigenmodes or the dyadic Green's function in space and time dependent media. Here, we propose a dynamical differential method which does not require either of them. Our method util…
▽ More
Electromagnetic waves in a system with a space and time dependent boundary experience both diffraction and Doppler-like frequency conversion. In order to analyse such situations, conventional methods call for either the eigenmodes or the dyadic Green's function in space and time dependent media. Here, we propose a dynamical differential method which does not require either of them. Our method utilises a dynamical coordinate transformation in order to simplify the calculation of the optical response of the space and time dependent system. We reveal that the diffraction symmetry is broken in the presence of traveling-wave type spatiotemporal modulation.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
A new mechanism for gain in time dependent media
Authors:
J. B. Pendry,
E. Galiffi,
P. A. Huidobro
Abstract:
Time dependent systems do not in general conserve energy invalidating much of the theory developed for static systems and turning our intuition on its head. This is particularly acute in luminal space time crystals where the structure moves at or close to the velocity of light. Conventional Bloch wave theory no longer applies, energy grows exponentially with time, and a new perspective is required…
▽ More
Time dependent systems do not in general conserve energy invalidating much of the theory developed for static systems and turning our intuition on its head. This is particularly acute in luminal space time crystals where the structure moves at or close to the velocity of light. Conventional Bloch wave theory no longer applies, energy grows exponentially with time, and a new perspective is required to understand the phenomenology. In this letter we identify a new mechanism for amplification: the compression of lines of force that are nevertheless conserved in number.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2021; v1 submitted 25 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Homogenisation Theory of Space-Time Metamaterials
Authors:
Paloma Arroyo Huidobro,
Mario G. Silveirinha,
Emanuele Galiffi,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We present a general framework for the homogenisation theory of space-time metamaterials. By mapping to a frame co-moving with the space-time modulation, we derive analytical formulae for the effective material parameters for travelling wave modulations in the low frequency limit: electric permittivity, magnetic permeability and magnetoelectric coupling. Remarkably, we show that the theory is exac…
▽ More
We present a general framework for the homogenisation theory of space-time metamaterials. By mapping to a frame co-moving with the space-time modulation, we derive analytical formulae for the effective material parameters for travelling wave modulations in the low frequency limit: electric permittivity, magnetic permeability and magnetoelectric coupling. Remarkably, we show that the theory is exact at all frequencies in the absence of back-reflections, and exact at low frequencies when that condition is relaxed. This allows us to derive exact formulae for the Fresnel drag experienced by light travelling through travelling-wave modulations of electromagnetic media.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Wood Anomalies and Surface-Wave Excitation with a Time-Grating
Authors:
Emanuele Galiffi,
Yao-Ting Wang,
Zhen Lim,
J. B. Pendry,
Andrea Alù,
Paloma A. Huidobro
Abstract:
In order to confine waves beyond the diffraction limit, advances in fabrication techniques have enabled subwavelength structuring of matter, achieving near-field control of light and other types of waves. The price is often expensive fabrication needs and the irreversibility of device functionality, as well as the introduction of impurities, a major contributor to losses. In this Letter, we propos…
▽ More
In order to confine waves beyond the diffraction limit, advances in fabrication techniques have enabled subwavelength structuring of matter, achieving near-field control of light and other types of waves. The price is often expensive fabrication needs and the irreversibility of device functionality, as well as the introduction of impurities, a major contributor to losses. In this Letter, we propose temporal inhomogeneities, such as a periodic drive in the electromagnetic properties of a surface which supports guided modes, to circumvent the need for subwavelength fabrication in the coupling of propagating waves to evanescent modes across the light line, achieving the temporal counterpart of the Wood anomaly. We show analytically and numerically how this concept is valid for any material platform and at any frequency, and propose and model a realistic experiment in graphene to couple terahertz radiation to plasmons with unit efficiency, demonstrating that time-modulation of material properties could be a tunable, lower-loss and fast-switchable alternative to the subwavelength structuring of matter for near-field wave control.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2020; v1 submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Casimir induced instabilities at metallic surfaces and interfaces
Authors:
Kun Ding,
Daigo Oue,
C. T. Chan,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Surface plasmons subject to a surface distortion split asymmetrically in energy resulting in a net lowering of zero-point energy. This is because surface plasmon eigenvalues are the square of frequencies, a statement generally true for electromagnetic excitations. We utilize the method based on conformal mapping to demonstrate asymmetric splitting under surface corrugations leading to a decrease i…
▽ More
Surface plasmons subject to a surface distortion split asymmetrically in energy resulting in a net lowering of zero-point energy. This is because surface plasmon eigenvalues are the square of frequencies, a statement generally true for electromagnetic excitations. We utilize the method based on conformal mapping to demonstrate asymmetric splitting under surface corrugations leading to a decrease in zero-point energy of a single corrugated metallic surface contributing to surface reconstructions but too small on its own to drive the reconstruction. However, by introducing a second metallic surface more significant lowering of energy is seen sufficient to drive the instability of a mercury thin film.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Probing Graphene's Nonlocality with Singular Metasurfaces
Authors:
E. Galiffi,
P. A. Huidobro,
P. A. D. Gonçalves,
N. A. Mortensen,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Singular graphene metasurfaces, conductivity gratings realized by periodically suppressing the local doping level of a graphene sheet, have recently been proposed to efficiently harvest THz light and couple it to surface plasmons over broad absorption bands, achieving remarkably high field enhancement. However, the large momentum wavevectors thus attained are sensitive to the nonlocal behaviour of…
▽ More
Singular graphene metasurfaces, conductivity gratings realized by periodically suppressing the local doping level of a graphene sheet, have recently been proposed to efficiently harvest THz light and couple it to surface plasmons over broad absorption bands, achieving remarkably high field enhancement. However, the large momentum wavevectors thus attained are sensitive to the nonlocal behaviour of the underlying electron liquid. Here, we extend the theory of singular graphene metasurfaces to account for the full nonlocal optical response of graphene and discuss the resulting impact on the plasmon resonance spectrum. Finally, we propose a simple local analogue model that is able to reproduce the effect of nonlocality in local-response calculations by introducing a constant conductivity offset, which could prove a valuable tool in the modelling of more complex experimental graphene-based platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2019; v1 submitted 25 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Broadband Nonreciprocal Amplification in Luminal Metamaterials
Authors:
E. Galiffi,
P. A. Huidobro,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Time has emerged as a new degree of freedom for metamaterials, promising new pathways in wave control. However, electromagnetism suffers from limitations in the modulation speed of material parameters. Here we argue that these limitations can be circumvented by introducing a traveling-wave refractive index modulation, with the same phase velocity of the waves. We show how the concept of "luminal g…
▽ More
Time has emerged as a new degree of freedom for metamaterials, promising new pathways in wave control. However, electromagnetism suffers from limitations in the modulation speed of material parameters. Here we argue that these limitations can be circumvented by introducing a traveling-wave refractive index modulation, with the same phase velocity of the waves. We show how the concept of "luminal grating" can yield giant nonreciprocity, achieve efficient one-way amplification, pulse compression and frequency up-conversion, proposing a realistic implementation in double-layer graphene.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2019; v1 submitted 19 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Nonlocal effects in singular plasmonic metasurfaces
Authors:
Fan Yang,
Yao-Ting Wang,
Paloma Arroyo Huidobro,
John B Pendry
Abstract:
A local model of the dielectric response of a metal predicts that singular surfaces, such as sharp-edged structures, have a continuous absorption spectrum and extreme concentration of energy at the singularity. Here we show that nonlocality drastically alters this picture: the spectrum is now discrete and energy concentration, though still substantial, is greatly reduced.
A local model of the dielectric response of a metal predicts that singular surfaces, such as sharp-edged structures, have a continuous absorption spectrum and extreme concentration of energy at the singularity. Here we show that nonlocality drastically alters this picture: the spectrum is now discrete and energy concentration, though still substantial, is greatly reduced.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
A transformation optics approach to singular metasurfaces
Authors:
Fan Yang,
Paloma A. Huidobro,
John B. Pendry
Abstract:
Surface plasmons dominate the optical response of metal surfaces, and their nature is controlled by surface geometry. Here we study metasurfaces containing singularities in the form of sharp edges and characterized by three quantum numbers despite the two-dimensional nature of the surface. We explore the nature of the plasmonic excitations, their ability to generate large concentrations of optical…
▽ More
Surface plasmons dominate the optical response of metal surfaces, and their nature is controlled by surface geometry. Here we study metasurfaces containing singularities in the form of sharp edges and characterized by three quantum numbers despite the two-dimensional nature of the surface. We explore the nature of the plasmonic excitations, their ability to generate large concentrations of optical energy, and the transition from the discrete excitation spectrum of a non-singular surface to the continuous spectrum of a singular metasurface.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Van der Waals force assisted heat transfer for vacuum gap spacings
Authors:
Karthik Sasihithlu,
John Brian Pendry,
Richard V. Craster
Abstract:
Phonons (collective atomic vibrations in solids) are more effective in transporting heat than photons. This is the reason why the conduction mode of heat transport in nonmetals (mediated by phonons) is dominant compared to the radiation mode of heat transport (mediated by photons). However, since phonons are unable to traverse a vacuum gap (unlike photons) it is commonly believed that two bodies s…
▽ More
Phonons (collective atomic vibrations in solids) are more effective in transporting heat than photons. This is the reason why the conduction mode of heat transport in nonmetals (mediated by phonons) is dominant compared to the radiation mode of heat transport (mediated by photons). However, since phonons are unable to traverse a vacuum gap (unlike photons) it is commonly believed that two bodies separated by a gap cannot exchange heat via phonons. Recently, a mechanism was proposed by which phonons can transport heat across a vacuum gap - through Van der Waals interaction between two bodies with gap less than wavelength of light. Such heat transfer mechanisms are highly relevant for heating (and cooling) of nanostructures; the heating of the flying heads in magnetic storage disks is a case in point. Here, the theoretical derivation for modeling phonon transmission is revisited and extended to the case of two bodies made of different materials separated by a vacuum gap. Magnitudes of phonon transmission, and hence the heat transfer, for commonly used materials in the micro and nano-electromechanical industry are calculated and compared with the calculation of conduction heat transfer through air for small gaps.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Transformation optics: a time- and frequency-domain analysis of electron-energy loss spectroscopy
Authors:
Matthias Kraft,
Yu Luo,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) and Cathodoluminescence (CL) play a pivotal role in many of the cutting edge experiments in plasmonics. EELS and CL experiments are usually supported by numerical simulations, which, whilst accurate, may not provide as much physical insight as analytical calculations do. Fully analytical solutions to EELS and CL systems in plasmonics are rare and difficult…
▽ More
Electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) and Cathodoluminescence (CL) play a pivotal role in many of the cutting edge experiments in plasmonics. EELS and CL experiments are usually supported by numerical simulations, which, whilst accurate, may not provide as much physical insight as analytical calculations do. Fully analytical solutions to EELS and CL systems in plasmonics are rare and difficult to obtain. This paper aims to narrow this gap by introducing a new method based on Transformation optics that allows to calculate the quasi-static frequency and time-domain response of plasmonic particles under electron beam excitation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Harnessing transformation optics for understanding electron energy loss and cathodoluminescence
Authors:
Yu Luo,
Matthias Kraft,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
As the continual experimental advances made in Electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) and cathodoluminescence (CL) open the door to practical exploitations of plasmonic effects in metal nanoparticles, there is an increasing need for precise interpretation and guidance of such experiments. Numerical simulations are available but lack physical insight, while traditional analytical approaches are r…
▽ More
As the continual experimental advances made in Electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) and cathodoluminescence (CL) open the door to practical exploitations of plasmonic effects in metal nanoparticles, there is an increasing need for precise interpretation and guidance of such experiments. Numerical simulations are available but lack physical insight, while traditional analytical approaches are rare and limited to studying specific, simple structures. Here, we propose a versatile and efficient method based on transformation optics which can fully characterize and model the EELS problems of nanoparticles of complex geometries. Detailed discussions are given on 2D and 3D nanoparticle dimers, where the frequency and time domain responses under electron beam excitations are derived.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Bianisotropy and magnetism in plasmonic gratings
Authors:
Matthias Kraft,
Avi Braun,
Yu Luo,
S. A. Maier,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We present a simple design to achieve bianisotropy at visible wavelengths: an ultrathin plasmonic grating made of a gold grating covered by a thin flat layer of gold. We show experimentally and through simulations that the grating exhibits magneto-electric coupling and features asymmetric reflection and absorption, all that with a device thickness of a tenth of the operating wavelength. We compare…
▽ More
We present a simple design to achieve bianisotropy at visible wavelengths: an ultrathin plasmonic grating made of a gold grating covered by a thin flat layer of gold. We show experimentally and through simulations that the grating exhibits magneto-electric coupling and features asymmetric reflection and absorption, all that with a device thickness of a tenth of the operating wavelength. We compared the spectral results and retrieved the effective material parameters of different polarizations and devices. We show that both asymmetry and strong coupling between the incoming light and the optically interacting surfaces are required for obtaining asymmetric optical behavior in metasurfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Graphene, plasmons and transformation optics
Authors:
Paloma A. Huidobro,
Matthias Kraft,
Ren Kun,
Stefan A. Maier,
John B. Pendry
Abstract:
Here we study subwavelength gratings for coupling into graphene plasmons by means of an an- alytical model based on transformation optics that is not limited to very shallow gratings. We consider gratings that consist of a periodic modulation of the charge density in the graphene sheet, and gratings formed by this conductivity modulation together with a dielectric grating placed in close vicinity…
▽ More
Here we study subwavelength gratings for coupling into graphene plasmons by means of an an- alytical model based on transformation optics that is not limited to very shallow gratings. We consider gratings that consist of a periodic modulation of the charge density in the graphene sheet, and gratings formed by this conductivity modulation together with a dielectric grating placed in close vicinity of the graphene. Explicit expressions for the dispersion relation of the plasmon po- laritons supported by the system, and reflectance and transmittance under plane wave illumination are given. We discuss the conditions for maximising the coupling between incident radiation and plasmons in the graphene, finding the optimal modulation strength for a conductivity grating.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Harvesting Light with Transformation Optics
Authors:
Yu Luo,
Rongkuo Zhao,
Antonio I. Fernandez-Dominguez,
Stefan A. Maier,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Transformation optics (TO) is a new tool for controlling electromagnetic fields. In the context of metamaterial technology, it provides a direct link between a desired electromagnetic (EM) phenomenon and the material response required for its occurrence. Recently, this powerful framework has been successfully exploited to study surface plasmon assisted phenomena such as light harvesting. Here, we…
▽ More
Transformation optics (TO) is a new tool for controlling electromagnetic fields. In the context of metamaterial technology, it provides a direct link between a desired electromagnetic (EM) phenomenon and the material response required for its occurrence. Recently, this powerful framework has been successfully exploited to study surface plasmon assisted phenomena such as light harvesting. Here, we review the general strategy based on TO to design plasmonic devices capable of harvesting light over a broadband spectrum and achieving considerable field confinement and enhancement. The methodology starts with two-dimensional (2D) cases, such as 2D metal edges, crescent-shaped cylinders, nanowire dimers, and rough metal surfaces, and has been well extended to fully-fledged three-dimensional (3D) situations. The largely analytic approach gives physical insights into the processes involved and suggests the way forward to study a wide variety of plasmonic nanostructures.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Surface Plasmons and Nonlocality: a Simple Model
Authors:
Yu Luo,
A. I. Fernandez-Dominguez,
Aeneas Wiener,
S. A. Maier,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Surface plasmons on metals can concentrate light into sub-nanometric volumes and on these near atomic length scales the electronic response at the metal interface is smeared out over a Thomas-Fermi screening length. This nonlocality is a barrier to a good understanding of atomic scale response to light and complicates the practical matter of computing the fields. In this letter, we present a local…
▽ More
Surface plasmons on metals can concentrate light into sub-nanometric volumes and on these near atomic length scales the electronic response at the metal interface is smeared out over a Thomas-Fermi screening length. This nonlocality is a barrier to a good understanding of atomic scale response to light and complicates the practical matter of computing the fields. In this letter, we present a local analogue model and show that spatial nonlocality can be represented by replacing the nonlocal metal with a composite material, comprising a thin dielectric layer on top of a local metal. This method not only makes possible the quantitative analysis of nonlocal effects in complex plasmonic phenomena with unprecedented simplicity and physical insight, but also offers great practical advantages in their numerical treatment.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Rotational Quantum Friction
Authors:
Rongkuo Zhao,
Alejandro Manjavacas,
F. Javier García de Abajo,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We investigate the frictional forces due to quantum fluctuations acting on a small sphere rotating near a surface. At zero temperature, we find the frictional force near a surface to be several orders of magnitude larger than that for the sphere rotating in vacuum. For metallic materials with typical conductivity, quantum friction is maximized by matching the frequency of rotation with the conduct…
▽ More
We investigate the frictional forces due to quantum fluctuations acting on a small sphere rotating near a surface. At zero temperature, we find the frictional force near a surface to be several orders of magnitude larger than that for the sphere rotating in vacuum. For metallic materials with typical conductivity, quantum friction is maximized by matching the frequency of rotation with the conductivity. Materials with poor conductivity are favored to obtain large quantum frictions. For semiconductor materials that are able to support surface plasmon polaritons, quantum friction can be further enhanced by several orders of magnitude due to the excitation of surface plasmon polaritons.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2012; v1 submitted 21 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
A DC magnetic metamaterial
Authors:
F. Magnus,
B. Wood,
J. Moore,
K. Morrison,
G. Perkins,
J. Fyson,
M. C. K. Wiltshire,
D. Caplin,
L. F. Cohen,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Electromagnetic metamaterials are a class of materials which have been artificially structured on a subwavelength scale. They are currently the focus of a great deal of interest because they allow access to previously unrealisable properties like a negative refractive index. Most metamaterial designs have so far been based on resonant elements, like split rings, and research has concentrated on…
▽ More
Electromagnetic metamaterials are a class of materials which have been artificially structured on a subwavelength scale. They are currently the focus of a great deal of interest because they allow access to previously unrealisable properties like a negative refractive index. Most metamaterial designs have so far been based on resonant elements, like split rings, and research has concentrated on microwave frequencies and above. In this work, we present the first experimental realisation of a non-resonant metamaterial designed to operate at zero frequency. Our samples are based on a recently-proposed template for an anisotropic magnetic metamaterial consisting of an array of superconducting plates. Magnetometry experiments show a strong, adjustable diamagnetic response when a field is applied perpendicular to the plates. We have calculated the corresponding effective permeability, which agrees well with theoretical predictions. Applications for this metamaterial may include non-intrusive screening of weak DC magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2007; v1 submitted 5 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Non-local effective medium of metamaterial
Authors:
Jensen Li,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the effect of spatial dispersion on a double-lattice metamaterial which has both magnetic and electric response. A numerical scheme based on a dipolar model is developed to extract the non-local effective medium of the metamaterial. We found a structure-induced bianisotropy near the resonance gap even if the artificial particles are free from cross-coupling. A cross…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate the effect of spatial dispersion on a double-lattice metamaterial which has both magnetic and electric response. A numerical scheme based on a dipolar model is developed to extract the non-local effective medium of the metamaterial. We found a structure-induced bianisotropy near the resonance gap even if the artificial particles are free from cross-coupling. A cross-coupled resonance also results from spatial dispersion and it can be understood using a Lorentz frequency dispersion model. The strength of the cross-coupled resonance depends on the microstructure and it is larger at a higher normalized frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
A spherical perfect lens
Authors:
S. Anantha Ramakrishna,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
It has been recently proved that a slab of negative refractive index material acts as a perfect lens in that it makes accessible the sub-wavelength image information contained in the evanescent modes of a source. Here we elaborate on perfect lens solutions to spherical shells of negative refractive material where magnification of the near-field images becomes possible. The negative refractive ma…
▽ More
It has been recently proved that a slab of negative refractive index material acts as a perfect lens in that it makes accessible the sub-wavelength image information contained in the evanescent modes of a source. Here we elaborate on perfect lens solutions to spherical shells of negative refractive material where magnification of the near-field images becomes possible. The negative refractive materials then need to be spatially dispersive with $ε(r) \sim 1/r$ and $μ(r)\sim 1/r$. We concentrate on lens-like solutions for the extreme near-field limit. Then the conditions for the TM and TE polarized modes become independent of $μ$ and $ε$ respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
Focussing Light Using Negative Refraction
Authors:
J. B. Pendry,
S. Anantha Ramakrishna
Abstract:
A slab of negatively refracting material, thickness d, can focus an image at a distance 2d from the object. The negative slab cancels an equal thickness of positive space. This result is a special case of a much wider class of focussing: any medium can be optically cancelled by an equal thickness of material constructed to be an inverted mirror image of the medium, with, $ε$ and $μ$ reversed in…
▽ More
A slab of negatively refracting material, thickness d, can focus an image at a distance 2d from the object. The negative slab cancels an equal thickness of positive space. This result is a special case of a much wider class of focussing: any medium can be optically cancelled by an equal thickness of material constructed to be an inverted mirror image of the medium, with, $ε$ and $μ$ reversed in sign. We introduce the powerful technique of coordinate transformation, mapping a known system into an equivalent system, to extend the result to a much wider class of structures including cylinders, spheres, and intersecting planes and hence show how to produce magnified images. All the images are perfect in the sense that both the near and far fields are brought to a focus and hence reveal sub wavelength details.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
-
Imaging the Near Field
Authors:
S. Anantha Ramakrishna,
J. B. Pendry,
M. C. K Wiltshire,
W. J. Stewart
Abstract:
In an earlier paper we introduced the concept of the perfect lens which focuses both near and far electromagnetic fields, hence attaining perfect resolution. Here we consider refinements of the original prescription designed to overcome the limitations of imperfect materials. In particular we show that a multi-layer stack of positive and negative refractive media is less sensitive to imperfectio…
▽ More
In an earlier paper we introduced the concept of the perfect lens which focuses both near and far electromagnetic fields, hence attaining perfect resolution. Here we consider refinements of the original prescription designed to overcome the limitations of imperfect materials. In particular we show that a multi-layer stack of positive and negative refractive media is less sensitive to imperfections. It has the novel property of behaving like a fibre-optic bundle but one that acts on the near field, not just the radiative component. The effects of retardation are included and minimized by making the slabs thinner. Absorption then dominates image resolution in the near-field. The deleterious effects of absorption in the metal are reduced for thinner layers.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2002;
originally announced July 2002.
-
Limitations on Sub-Diffraction Imaging with a Negative Refractive Index Slab
Authors:
D. R. Smith,
D. Schurig,
Marshall Rosenbluth,
S. Schultz,
S. Anantha Ramakrishna,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Recently it has been proposed that a planar slab of material, for which both the permittivity and permeability have the values of -1, could bring not only the propagating fields associated with a source to a focus, but could also refocus the nonpropagating near-fields, thereby achieving a subdiffraction image. In this work we discuss the sensitivity of the subwavelength focus to various slab par…
▽ More
Recently it has been proposed that a planar slab of material, for which both the permittivity and permeability have the values of -1, could bring not only the propagating fields associated with a source to a focus, but could also refocus the nonpropagating near-fields, thereby achieving a subdiffraction image. In this work we discuss the sensitivity of the subwavelength focus to various slab parameters, pointing out the connection to slab plasmon modes. We also note and resolve a paradox associated with the perfect imaging of a point source. We conclude that subwavelength resolution is achievable with available technology, but only by implementation of a critical set of design parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
Near Field Lenses in Two Dimensions
Authors:
J. B. Pendry,
S. Anantha Ramakrishna
Abstract:
It has been shown that a slab of materials with refractive index = -1 behaves like a perfect lens focussing all light to an exact electromagnetic copy of an object. The original lens is limited to producing images the same size as the object, but here we generalise the concept so that images can be magnified. For two dimensional systems, over distances much shorter than the free space wavelength…
▽ More
It has been shown that a slab of materials with refractive index = -1 behaves like a perfect lens focussing all light to an exact electromagnetic copy of an object. The original lens is limited to producing images the same size as the object, but here we generalise the concept so that images can be magnified. For two dimensional systems, over distances much shorter than the free space wavelength, we apply conformal transformations to the original parallel sided slab generating a variety of new lenses. Although the new lenses are not `perfect' they are able to magnify two dimensional objects. The results apply equally to imaging of electric or magnetic sub wavelength objects in two dimensions. The concepts have potential applications ranging from microwave frequencies to the visible.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
Optical gain removes absorption and increases resolution in a near-field lens
Authors:
S. Anantha Ramakrishna,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
A recent paper showed how to construct a lens that focuses near field radiation and hence produce resolution unlimited by wavelength. The prescription requires lossless materials with negative refractive index: finite loss cuts off the finer details of the image. In this paper we suggest compensating for losses by introducing optical gain media into the lens design. Calculations demonstrate a dr…
▽ More
A recent paper showed how to construct a lens that focuses near field radiation and hence produce resolution unlimited by wavelength. The prescription requires lossless materials with negative refractive index: finite loss cuts off the finer details of the image. In this paper we suggest compensating for losses by introducing optical gain media into the lens design. Calculations demonstrate a dramatic improvement in performance for a silver/gain composite medium at optical frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
The asymmetric lossy near-perfect lens
Authors:
S. Anantha Ramakrishna,
J. B. Pendry,
D. Schurig,
D. R. Smith,
S. Schultz
Abstract:
We extend the ideas of the recently proposed perfect lens [J.B. Pendry, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 85}, 3966 (2000)] to an alternative structure. We show that a slab of a medium with negative refractive index bounded by media of different positive refractive index also amplifies evanescent waves and can act as a near-perfect lens. We examine the role of the surface states in the amplification of the…
▽ More
We extend the ideas of the recently proposed perfect lens [J.B. Pendry, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 85}, 3966 (2000)] to an alternative structure. We show that a slab of a medium with negative refractive index bounded by media of different positive refractive index also amplifies evanescent waves and can act as a near-perfect lens. We examine the role of the surface states in the amplification of the evanescent waves. The image resolution obtained by this asymmetric lens is more robust against the effects of absorption in the lens. In particular, we study the case of a slab of silver, which has negative dielectric constant, with air on one side and other media such as glass or GaAs on the other side as an `asymmetric' lossy near-perfect lens for P-polarized waves. It is found that retardation has an adverse effect on the imaging due to the positive magnetic permeability of silver, but we conclude that subwavelength image resolution is possible inspite of it.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
Comment on "Left-Handed Materials Do Not Make a Perfect Lens"
Authors:
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
In a recent Physical Review Letter [1] Garcia and Nieto Vesperinas (GNV) dispute the claim of perfect lensing made in [2]. The thrust of the GVN paper is that the solutions proposed in [2] imply infinite energy density and are therefore inadmissible. They claim that finite absorption leads to catastrophic collapse of the amplifying solutions vital to focussing and that no useful effect can be ac…
▽ More
In a recent Physical Review Letter [1] Garcia and Nieto Vesperinas (GNV) dispute the claim of perfect lensing made in [2]. The thrust of the GVN paper is that the solutions proposed in [2] imply infinite energy density and are therefore inadmissible. They claim that finite absorption leads to catastrophic collapse of the amplifying solutions vital to focussing and that no useful effect can be achieved. In this Comment I show that, on the contrary, careful consideration of absorption results in solutions that are always well behaved and evolve smoothly and continuously to perfect resolution in the limiting case of zero absorption.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
Theory of extraordinary optical transmission through subwavelength hole arrays
Authors:
L. Martin-Moreno,
F. J. Garcia-Vidal,
H. J. Lezec,
K. M. Pellerin,
T. Thio,
J. B. Pendry,
T. W. Ebbesen
Abstract:
We present a fully three-dimensional theoretical study of the extraordinary transmission of light through subwavelength hole arrays in optically thick metal films. Good agreement is obtained with experimental data. An analytical minimal model is also developed, which conclusively shows that the enhancement of transmission is due to tunneling through surface plasmons formed on each metal-dielectr…
▽ More
We present a fully three-dimensional theoretical study of the extraordinary transmission of light through subwavelength hole arrays in optically thick metal films. Good agreement is obtained with experimental data. An analytical minimal model is also developed, which conclusively shows that the enhancement of transmission is due to tunneling through surface plasmons formed on each metal-dielectric interfaces. Different regimes of tunneling (resonant through a ''surface plasmon molecule", or sequential through two isolated surface plasmons) are found depending on the geometrical parameters defining the system.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2000;
originally announced August 2000.
-
Transmission resonances on metallic gratings with very narrow slits
Authors:
J. A. Porto,
F. J. Garcia-Vidal,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
In this paper we show how transmission metallic gratings with very narrow and deep enough slits can exhibit transmission resonances for wavelengths larger than the period of the grating. By using a transfer matrix formalism and a quasi-analytical model based on a modal expansion, we show that there are two possible ways of transferring light from the upper surface to the lower one: by the excita…
▽ More
In this paper we show how transmission metallic gratings with very narrow and deep enough slits can exhibit transmission resonances for wavelengths larger than the period of the grating. By using a transfer matrix formalism and a quasi-analytical model based on a modal expansion, we show that there are two possible ways of transferring light from the upper surface to the lower one: by the excitation of coupled surface plasmon polaritons on both surfaces of the metallic grating or by the coupling of incident plane waves with waveguide resonances located in the slits. Both mechanisms can lead to almost perfect transmittance for those particular resonances.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
Interface modes of two-dimensional composite structures
Authors:
J. M. Pitarke,
F. J. Garcia-Vidal,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
The surface modes of a composite consisting of aligned metallic wires with square cross sections are investigated, on the basis of photonic band structure calculations. The effective long-wavelength dielectric response function is computed, as a function of the filling fraction. The dependence of the optical absorption on the shape of the wires and the polarization of light is discussed, and the…
▽ More
The surface modes of a composite consisting of aligned metallic wires with square cross sections are investigated, on the basis of photonic band structure calculations. The effective long-wavelength dielectric response function is computed, as a function of the filling fraction. The dependence of the optical absorption on the shape of the wires and the polarization of light is discussed, and the effect of sharp corners analyzed. The effect of the interaction between the wires on the localization of surface plasmons is also addressed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 1998;
originally announced September 1998.
-
Order N photonic band structures for metals and other dispersive materials
Authors:
J. Arriaga,
A. J. Ward,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We show, for the first time, how to calculate photonic band structures for metals and other dispersive systems using an efficient Order N scheme. The method is applied to two simple periodic metallic systems where it gives results in close agreement with calculations made with other techniques. Further, the approach demonstrates excellent numerical stablity within the limits we give. Our new met…
▽ More
We show, for the first time, how to calculate photonic band structures for metals and other dispersive systems using an efficient Order N scheme. The method is applied to two simple periodic metallic systems where it gives results in close agreement with calculations made with other techniques. Further, the approach demonstrates excellent numerical stablity within the limits we give. Our new method opens the way for efficient calculations on complex structures containing a whole new class of material.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 1998;
originally announced July 1998.
-
Silver Filled Carbon Nanotubes used as Spectroscopic Enhancers
Authors:
F. J. Garcia-Vidal,
J. M. Pitarke,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We analyse from a theoretical point of view the optical properties of arrays of carbon nanotubes filled with silver. Dependence of these properties on the different parameters involved is studied using a Transfer Matrix formalism able to work with tensor-like dielectric functions and including the full electromagnetic coupling between the nanotubes. We find these structures exhibit very strong l…
▽ More
We analyse from a theoretical point of view the optical properties of arrays of carbon nanotubes filled with silver. Dependence of these properties on the different parameters involved is studied using a Transfer Matrix formalism able to work with tensor-like dielectric functions and including the full electromagnetic coupling between the nanotubes. We find these structures exhibit very strong linear optical response and hence could be used as spectroscopic enhancers or chemical sensors in the visible range. Very localised surface plasmons, created by the electromagnetic interaction between the capped silver cylinders, are responsible of this enhancing ability. Enhancements of up to $10^6$ in the Raman signal of molecules absorbed on these arrays could be obtained.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 1998;
originally announced May 1998.
-
Effective electronic response of a system of metallic cylinders
Authors:
J. M. Pitarke,
F. J. Garcia-Vidal,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
The electronic response of a composite consisting of aligned metallic cylinders in vacuum is investigated, on the basis of photonic band structure calculations. The effective long-wavelength dielectric response function is computed, as a function of the filling fraction. A spectral representation of the effective response is considered, and the surface mode strengths and positions are analyzed.…
▽ More
The electronic response of a composite consisting of aligned metallic cylinders in vacuum is investigated, on the basis of photonic band structure calculations. The effective long-wavelength dielectric response function is computed, as a function of the filling fraction. A spectral representation of the effective response is considered, and the surface mode strengths and positions are analyzed. The range of validity of a Maxwell-Garnett-like approach is discussed, and the impact of our results on absorption spectra and electron energy-loss phenomena is addressed.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
-
Calculating photonic Green's functions using a non-orthogonal finite difference time domain method
Authors:
A. J. Ward,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
In this paper we shall propose a simple scheme for calculating Green's functions for photons propagating in complex structured dielectrics or other photonic systems. The method is based on an extension of the finite difference time domain (FDTD) method, originally proposed by Yee, also known as the Order-N method, which has recently become a popular way of calculating photonic band structures. W…
▽ More
In this paper we shall propose a simple scheme for calculating Green's functions for photons propagating in complex structured dielectrics or other photonic systems. The method is based on an extension of the finite difference time domain (FDTD) method, originally proposed by Yee, also known as the Order-N method, which has recently become a popular way of calculating photonic band structures. We give a new, transparent derivation of the Order-N method which, in turn, enables us to give a simple yet rigorous derivation of the criterion for numerical stability as well as statements of charge and energy conservation which are exact even on the discrete lattice. We implement this using a general, non-orthogonal co-ordinate system without incurring the computational overheads normally associated with non-orthogonal FDTD.
We present results for local densities of states calculated using this method for a number of systems. Firstly, we consider a simple one dimensional dielectric multilayer, identifying the suppression in the state density caused by the photonic band gap and then observing the effect of introducing a defect layer into the periodic structure. Secondly, we tackle a more realistic example by treating a defect in a crystal of dielectric spheres on a diamond lattice. This could have application to the design of super-efficient laser devices utilising defects in photonic crystals as laser cavities.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
-
Electromagnetic forces in photonic crystals
Authors:
M. I. Antonoyiannakis,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We develop a general methodology for numerical computations of electromagnetic (EM) fields and forces in matter, based on solving the macroscopic Maxwell's equations in real space and adopting the Maxwell Stress Tensor formalism. Our approach can be applied to both dielectric and metallic systems of frequency-dependent dielectric function; as well as to objects of any size and geometrical proper…
▽ More
We develop a general methodology for numerical computations of electromagnetic (EM) fields and forces in matter, based on solving the macroscopic Maxwell's equations in real space and adopting the Maxwell Stress Tensor formalism. Our approach can be applied to both dielectric and metallic systems of frequency-dependent dielectric function; as well as to objects of any size and geometrical properties in principle. We are particularly interested in calculating forces on nanostructures. We find that a body reacts to the EM field by minimising its energy, i.e. it is attracted (repelled) by regions of lower (higher) EM energy. When travelling waves are involved, forces can be additionally understood in terms of momentum exchange between the body and its environment. However when evanescent waves dominate, the forces are complicated, often become attractive and cannot be explained by means of real momentum being exchanged. We study the EM forces induced by a laser beam on a crysta! l of dielectric GaP spheres. We ob serve effects due to the lattice structure, as well as due to single scattering from each sphere. In the former case the two main features are a maximum momentum exchange when the frequency lies within a band gap; and a multitude of force orientations when the Bragg conditions for multiple outgoing waves are met. In the latter case the radiation couples to the EM eigenmodes of isolated spheres (Mie resonances) and very sharp attractive and repulsive forces occur. Depending on the intensity of the incident radiation these forces can overcome all other interactions present (gravitational, thermal and Van der Waals) and may provide the main mechanism for formation of stable structures in colloidal systems.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 1998;
originally announced February 1998.
-
The Theory of SNOM: A Novel Approach
Authors:
A. J. Ward,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
In this paper we consider the application of electromagnetic theory to the analysis of the Scanning Near-field Optical Microscope (SNOM) in order to predict experimentally observable quantities such as the transmission or reflection coefficients for a particular tip-surface configuration. In particular we present the first application of a transfer matrix based calculation to this challenging pr…
▽ More
In this paper we consider the application of electromagnetic theory to the analysis of the Scanning Near-field Optical Microscope (SNOM) in order to predict experimentally observable quantities such as the transmission or reflection coefficients for a particular tip-surface configuration. In particular we present the first application of a transfer matrix based calculation to this challenging problem by using an adaptive co-ordinate transformation to accurately model the shape of the SNOM tip.
We also investigate the possibility of increasing the transmitted light through the SNOM tip by introducing a metal wire into the centre of the tip. This converts the tip into a co-axial cable. We show that, in principle, this can dramatically improve the transmission characteristics without having a detrimental effect on the resolution.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 1997;
originally announced July 1997.
-
Mie resonances and bonding in photonic crystals
Authors:
M. I. Antonoyiannakis,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
Isolated dielectric spheres support resonant electromagnetic modes which are analogous to electronic orbitals and, like their electronic counterparts, can form bonding or anti-bonding interactions between neighbouring spheres. By irradiating the system with light at the bonding frequency an attractive interaction is induced between the spheres. We suggest that by judicious selection of bonding s…
▽ More
Isolated dielectric spheres support resonant electromagnetic modes which are analogous to electronic orbitals and, like their electronic counterparts, can form bonding or anti-bonding interactions between neighbouring spheres. By irradiating the system with light at the bonding frequency an attractive interaction is induced between the spheres. We suggest that by judicious selection of bonding states we can drive a system towards a desired structure, rather than rely on the structure dictated by gravitational or Van der Waals forces, the latter deriving from the zero point energy population of a state.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 1997; v1 submitted 28 May, 1997;
originally announced May 1997.
-
Effective medium theory of the optical properties of aligned carbon nanotubes
Authors:
F. J. Garcia-Vidal,
J. M. Pitarke,
J. B. Pendry
Abstract:
We present an effective medium theory in order to analyze the reported optical properties of aligned carbon nanotube films (W.A. de Heer et al., Science 268, 845 (1995)). This methodology is based on photonic band structure calculations and allows treatment of complex media consisting of particles that interact strongly. We also develop a simple Maxwell-Garnett type approach for studying this sy…
▽ More
We present an effective medium theory in order to analyze the reported optical properties of aligned carbon nanotube films (W.A. de Heer et al., Science 268, 845 (1995)). This methodology is based on photonic band structure calculations and allows treatment of complex media consisting of particles that interact strongly. We also develop a simple Maxwell-Garnett type approach for studying this system. In comparing the results of both mean field theories, we demonstrate that the inclusion of the full electromagnetic coupling between the nanotubes, as our numerical scheme does, is necessary for a complete explanation of the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 1997;
originally announced May 1997.