doiSerbia

Efficiency in managing peer-review of scientific manuscripts - editors’ perspective

Nedić Olgica (Institute for the Application of Nuclear Energy - (INEP), Belgrade)
Drvenica Ivana (Institute for Medical Research, Belgrade)
Ausloos Marcel (University of Leicester, School of Business, Leicester, United Kingdom + Group of Researchers for Applications of Physics in Economy and Sociology (GRAPES), Angleur, Belgium)
Dekanski Aleksandar (Institute of Chemistry, Technology and Metallurgy, Department of Electrochemistry, Belgrade)

The purpose of this paper is to introduce a model for measuring the efficiency in managing peer-review of scientific manuscripts by editors. The approach employed is based on the assumption that the editorial aim is to manage publication with high efficiency, employing the least amount of editorial resources. Efficiency is defined in this research as a measure based on 7 variables. An on-line survey was constructed and editors of journals originating from Serbia regularly publishing articles in the field of chemistry were invited to participate. An evaluation of the model is given based on responses from 24 journals and 50 editors. With this investigation we aimed to contribute to our understanding of the peer-review process and, possibly, offer a tool to improve the “efficiency” in journal editing. The proposed protocol may be adapted by other journals in order to assess the managing potential of editors.

Keywords: survey, editorial experience, Parsimonious model