John Hallagan

A critical evaluation of the available information demonstrates that reactions to natural color additives are rare. Studies of turmeric and carotenoid pigments administered in mixtures with other food colorings failed to definitely identify reactions to either color additive. For carotenoids, the one case report of an adverse reaction was not conclusive. An anaphylactic reaction to saffron does suggest an IgE-mediated reaction, but the high use of saffron as compared with this single report of an adverse reaction suggests that sensitivity to saffron is extremely rare. Numerous reports of reactions to grapes or grape products have been reported in the literature, but no reports of sensitivities to grape skin extract or grape color extract were found. In rare cases, annatto dye may provoke a severe, adverse reaction in individuals with an uncommon hypersensitivity, and may aggravate the symptoms of patients suffering from recurrent urticaria. In its long history of use, there has been only one reported case of anaphylaxis resulting from the ingestion of annatto. Studies designed to investigate the role of annatto in recurrent urticaria sufferers were limited due to the absence of double-blind challenge and placebo controls. A number of cases of adverse reactions to carmine following ingestion have been reported in the literature. These adverse reactions suggest an IgE-mediated hypersensitivity. In many of the reported cases, the cause of sensitization to carmine was topical exposure from the use of carmine-containing cosmetics or occupational exposure to carmine and not from ingestion of carmine-containing foods and beverages. Following sensitization, affected individuals would be sensitive to carmine and the amounts present in foods and beverages could elicit allergic reactions. It is not known whether all individuals with carmine sensitivity induced through topical use are sensitive to the ingestion of carmine in foods. However, reactions to carmine solely because of ingestion are likely to be exceedingly rare due to the low use levels of carmine in foods and beverages. Despite their widespread use in food products, few reports of allergic reactions following ingestion have been reported for the majority of natural color additives. It is concluded that the ingestion of natural color additives presents a very low risk of provoking adverse reactions.

After nearly ten years of civil war Zimbabwe now has more elephants than at any time since at least the 1940s: the bush was simply too dangerous for the poachers. Much wildlife management too had to be suspended during the war. Now in the Wankie National Park there is considerable elephant damage as a result of the population pressure, and some culling has been done.

In 1995 we published a review describing the scientific and legal bases for the GRAS assessment program for flavor ingredients sponsored by the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association of the United States (FEMA) [Hallagan, J.B., Hall, R.L., 1995. FEMA GRAS - A GRAS assessment program for flavor ingredients. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 21, 422]. This review provides new information related to flavor safety assessment and regulation and is intended to complement our previous report. The FEMA GRAS assessment program is the most extensive and longest running industry-sponsored GRAS program and has established a sound record of scientific rigor and transparency. In this review, in addition to providing general information on the topics of flavor safety assessment and regulation, we explore the effects of recent developments on the four pillars of the FEMA GRAS assessment program: (1) general recognition; (2) among experts qualified by scientific training and experience to evaluate safety; (3) through scientific procedures; (4) under the conditions of intended use in food. We conclude that developments since our last review in 1995 have further strengthened the FEMA GRAS assessment program allowing it to maintain its global leadership role in the safety assessment of flavor ingredients.