Letters to the Editor
women are over-reporting vaginal discharge because of
the deep cultural meanings of the symptom. This is
leading to inappropriate treatment of women with
antibiotics, with all its attendant consequences.
This issue needs urgent attention. The syndromic
approach to the treatment of STDs is costly, and in the
setting of South Asia, it is clearly not an appropriate use
of scarce resources.
K Trollope-Kumar MD PhD
West End Health Associates, 1827 Main Street West, Hamilton,
Ontario L8SlH6, Canada
E-mail: trolloak@mcmaster.ca
References
2
Nichter M. Idioms of distress: alternatives in the expression of
psychosocial distress: a case study from South India. Culture
Med Psychiatry 1981;5:379-408
Hawkes S, Morison L, Foster S, et al. Managing reproductive
tract infections in women in low-income, low-prevalence
situations: an evaluation of syndromic management in
Matlab, Bangladesh. Lancet 1999;354:1776-81
Resurgence of schistosomiasis mansoni in Oman
The Sultanate of Oman is currently promoting tourism as
part of its strategy for economic growth. An increasingly
popular destination is the coastal town of Salalah, located
in southern Dhofar province, the original source of
frankincense, which is the only region in the Arabian
Peninsula to be affected by the summer mosoon. (An
added attraction for overseas tourists is its vicinity to the
fabled 2000-year old 'lost city of Ubar', referred to by T E
Lawrence as the 'Atlantis of the Sands'.) Daily rain and
mist occur during this cool period (mean daily temperature 28°C), and the surrounding mountains become lush
with green vegetation'. In the foothills are numerous
springs and freshwater pools, ideal for picnics, reached by
a short drive from Salalah.
Unfortunately, Schistosoma mansoni was detected for
the first time in 1979 in this region, appearing first in
irrigated farmland/. Suitable vector Biomphalaria arabica
snails had been present in the district since 18963, and it
was suspected that the parasite had been recently
introduced by Egyptian farm labourers or Omanis of
East African origin. Control measures, including identification and treatment of patients, and an extensive search
for snail vectors and mollusciciding, were immediately
instituted, but a further study in 1989, indicated that low
level transmission was continuing'', The control programme was intensified and by 1994, the disease appeared
to have been eradicated'. However, regular mollusciciding
and surveillance of eight known snail-infested sites
continued. Warning signs in Arabic and English, advised
that snails were present, that swimming was dangerous,
and that contamination of water with faeces or urine was
prohibited. Farmworkers and schoolchildren living near
these sites had annual stool examination, but in 1999, no
cases were identified". Unfortunately, there is recent
evidence that schistosomiasis has been reintroduced to
one of the freshwater springs, and several residents of the
district have developed acute infection.
Case 1
In June, 1999, a 9-year-old village boy from the Salalah
hills had bloody diarrhoea, 4 weeks after bathing in
freshwater springs at Wadi Sahanout, a well-known
Tropical Doctor
July 2001, 31
locality for B. arabica snails (a wadi is a watercourse).
Apparently, some unknown person or persons had
removed the warning notice at the pool. Six weeks later,
he developed acute Katayama syndrome with fever, with
progression to acute, areflexic, flaccid paraplegia, with a
sensory level at TIO, and with impaired bladder and bowel
sphincter function. His white blood count was 37.0 x 109 /
L, with 27.0 x 109/L eosinophils. His stool contained
abundant S. mansoni ova, and examination of the
cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) showed 50 lymphocytes/mm',
protein 0.9 g/I, and normal glucose level. Unfortunately,
anti-schistosomal antibodies were not measured in the
first CSF sample, and the father refused to allow a second
lumbar puncture. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
scan revealed oedema of the spinal cord from the first
thoracic vertebral level to the conus medullaris.
As soon as schistosomiasis was diagnosed, he was given
praziquantel (40 mg/kg), and treated with methyl prednisolone 400 mg daily for 3 days, followed by a
diminishing dose for 6 weeks. He began to recover
motor function within a few days of treatment, and
could walk with support after 2 weeks, but sensory
recovery was delayed, and at 3 months, he had persisting
bladder and bowel sphincter impairment with inability to
pass urine and incontinence of faeces.
Case 2
The patient's father, aged 38 years, had bloody diarrhoea
4 weeks after bathing on the same day in June 1999, in the
same springs. He reported that other village children
bathing at the same time had also had bloody diarrhoea.
He was asymptomatic when evaluated in August, but
stool examination revealed light infection, and he was
treated with praziquantel.
Case 3
A 22-year-old woman who swam at Wadi Sahanout in
August, 1999, developed severe swimmer's itch. She
remained otherwise well, but in April 2000, was referred
from Salalah for evaluation of persistent eosinophilia. The
history of exposure to freshwater and subsequent
swimmer's itch was obtained (for the first time), and
stool examination revealed light infection with S. mansoni.
She was treated with praziquantel. The patient reported
that other people including children, were bathing at the
same time, and that no warning notice was present.
Comment
The presentation of acute, flaccid paraplegia in association with Katayama syndrome in our first patient, is an
unusual but well-recognized complication of early schistosomiasis. This is attributed to the immunological
response to maturing Schistosoma adults and egg antigens
in the mesenteric or vesical veins, and it is usually selflimiting. (In established schistosomiasis, myelopathy is
caused by granuloma formation around ectopic egg
deposition, often involving the conus mcdullaris/.) The
cellular response in the CSF may be lymphocytic or
eosinophilic, and immunological tests for Schistosoma in
the CSF are likely to be positive. Presumably, in this
patient the inflammatory reaction in the conus proceeded
to patchy ischaemia and infarction.
Following report of these new cases, the public health
authorities replaced the warning notice at Wadi Sahanout
freshwater springs, and intensified mollusciciding. Local
185
Letters to the Editor
villagers, particularly children, are being screened for
evidence of infection. Clearly, an unknown infected
individual had recently contaminated the springs with
faeces. This could have been a local resident who was
undetected and untreated at the time of the intensive
eradication programme 10 years ago (S. mansoni adults
can survive for as long as 37 years"), We have recently
detected two residents of Salalah with persisting, active
schistosomiasis, who reported exposure to freshwater
springs a decade ago: the first was a 55-year-old man with
hepatosplenic schistosomiasis and portal hypertension,
and the other was a 32-year-old man, who presented with
anaemia (Hg 9.8 g/dl), thrombocytopenia (platelet count
(23 x 109/L), and splenomegaly). Both patients received
praziquantel. Infection might also have been introduced
expatriate: we have encountered many
by an. infect~
expatnates With untreated schistosomiasis, particularly
Egyptian patients.
The resurgence of schistosomiasis in the Salalah district
of southern Oman is a source of serious public health
concern. This popular tourist destination is generally free
of serious infectious disease risks. Contrary to widespread
belief, expressed in many popular travel guide books? the
risk of malaria in southern Oman is almost non-existent:
the prevalent anopheline mosquito Anopheles custiani a
day-biting mosquito, is not anthropophilic. However, a; in
other regions endemic for schistosomiasis, tourists visiting
southern Oman should be advised to avoid all skin contact
with freshwater pools or springs, and this information
should be included in all guide books to Oman. This new
outbreak of schistosomiasis emphasizes the fact that
wherever schistosome infection has been present, as long
as vector snails persist, vigilance can never be relaxed, and
control measures must continue indefinitely.
Euan M Scrimgeour FRACP
R Koul MRCP
J Sallam PhD
M A Idris PhD
Department of Medicine, Sultan Qaboos University,
PO Box 35, AI-Khod (Muscat), Oman
Correspondence to: Dr E M Scrimgeour
E-mail: scrim@squ.edu.om
References
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
186
Thesiger W. Arabian Sands. London: Penguin Travel Library
1999:47-8
'
Shaban MMA. Role of organisational cooperation in
schistosomiasis eradication in Dhofar Governorate. Oman
Med J 1995;12:17-19
Wright CA, Brown DS. The freshwater molluscs of Dhofar. J
Oman Stud 1980;2:97-102
Idris MA, Ruppel A, Numrich P, Eschilbeck A Shaban MA
Diesfeld HJ. Schistosomiasis in the southern re~ion
of Oman~
vector snails and serological identification of patients in
several locations. J Trop Med Hyg 1994;97:205-10
Scrimgeour EM, Mehta FR, Suleiman AJM. Infectious and
tropical diseases in Oman: a review. Am J Trop Med Hyg
1999;61:920-5
Datta D. Schistosomiasis in Oman. Commun Health Dis
Surveillance Newsl (Oman) 1999;7:1-5
Scrimgeour EM, Gajdusek DC. Schistosoma mansoni and S.
hae.matobium infection of the central nervous system: a
review, Brain 1985;0:23~
Chabasse D, Bertrand G, Leroux JP, Gauthey N, Hocquet P.
A case of Schistosomiasis mansoni detected 37 years after
infection. Bull Soc Pathol Exot FilI985;78:643-7
Robinson G. Arab Gulf States. Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman.
Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.
Melbourne: Lonely Planet, 1993:122-60
Could cultural scarification contribute to the high
prevalence of HIV in central Africa?
The practice of scarification is widespread within African
culture. While the details of these incisions vary between
subcultures, the indications for their administration fall
broadly into two categories, medicinal or cultural. In
Malawi, the term 'Mphini' is used to describe these
scarifications. Mphini are administered by tribal herbalists using razor blade incisions at sites determined by the
patient's complaint, in a distribution akin to acupuncture.
We researched the incidence of scarification on a cohort
of the Malawian population. Subjects were in-patients at
the Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, Blantyre, Malawi.
Each subject underwent a clinical examination to establish
~he
site, quant!ty and size of any Mphini. Using an
mterpreter, a history was taken to determine the reason
for their administration. Examining 246 patients (149
males, 97 females) revealed that 54.5% of patients in this
sample population displayed Mphini, the majority of
these being administered for pain relief. It was also noted
that our cohort was sourced in an area of relative
urbanization, with two hospitals and numerous pharmacies in the area. It is probable that this practice is even
more widespread in areas with less access to pharmacological analgesics.
During our research we also witnessed the administration of the scarifications by the 'herbalists'. The procedure
was seen to 'draw blood' and we witnessed the same razor
blade being used on more than one patient, with no form
of sterilization between patients.
HIV prevalence in Malawi has been estimated at 35%.
Over the past 10 years the Malawian government and
international health organizations have allocated many
resources to HIV education and the promotion of 'safe'
medical practice and sex. This education has not
addressed this widespread practice of cultural scarification.
While the serological effects of cultural tattooing have
not been reported, the potential risks were noted
previously when considering the epidemiology of other
blood borne infections'. With the high prevalence of
tattooing found in this study it is our view that these
procedures should be addressed when considering the
transmission routes of HIV.
5 E Gwilym MBBS BSe'
5 R Linnard MBBS'
C Lavy FRCS2
, Royal Free & University College London Medical School,
London, UK; 2Malawi Against Polio, Malawi
Correspondence to: Dr Stephen Gwilym, Department of Surgery,
Middlesex Hospital, Riding House Street, London NWl 3AA, UK
E-mail: s..gwilym@yahoo.com
Reference
Olumi~e
EA. The distribution of hepatitis B surface antigen
m. Af~lca
and the tropics: report of a population study in
Nigeria, Int J EpidemioI1976;5:279-89
Anthropometric measurements in children with
congenital heart disease
Congenital heart disease (CHD) is often associated with
malnutrition and failure to thrive, the prevalence being as
high as 64% in developed countries of the world I. The
Tropical Doctor
July 2001, 31