Nepalese Vet. J. 35:1-8
Effectiveness of Different Hormonal Treatment Protocols on
Treatment of Postpartum Anoestrus in Cross-Bred Dairy Cows
P. K. Rana1, G. Gautam1*, B. Devkota1, S. K. Shah1, S. Barsila2 and I. P. Kadariya 3
1
Department of Theriogenology, Agriculture and Forestry University, Rampur, Chitwan, Nepal.
2
Department of Animal Nutrition, Agriculture and Forestry University, Rampur, Chitwan, Nepal.
Center for Biotechnology, Agriculture and Forestry University, Rampur, Chitwan, Nepal.
3
*Corresponding author: gogautam@afu.edu.np
ABSTRACT
Postpartum anoestrus (PPA) is one of the major factors causing prolonged calving
interval & that leading to decreased annual milk production. Hormonal treatments can
be effective tools for treatment of PPA when nutritional & environmental management
are good. So, objective of this study was to know the comparative effectiveness of
different hormonal protocols on treatment of PPA in cross-bred dairy cows. Used
protocols were: single dose of GnRH, Ovsynch with TRIU-B and single dose of PGF2α
injection which were used in three different groups, each containing ten animals.
GnRH and Ovsynch with TRIU-B were used in postpartum true anoestrus cattle with
inactive ovaries while PGF2α was used in postpartum silent oestrus condition having
palpable corpus luteum and the condition were identified through rectal palpation
and history record. Cows treated with Ovsynch+TRIU-B showed higher oestrus
expression rate within one week (80%) than cows treated with GnRH (10%) and
PGF2α (50%). Ovulation rate was also comparatively higher in Ovsynch+TRIU-B
group (100%) than GnRH (90%) and PGF2α (70%). But the pregnancy rate, checked
after 45 days of first AI through rectal palpation, was comparatively higher in GnRH
group (40%) than in Ovsynch+TRIU-B (30%) and PGF2α (20%). Among treated
cows, pregnancy rate was found to be significantly higher (P=0.02) in cows with
≥100 days duration of postpartum anoestrus (53.84%) than in cows with 100 days
duration (0%). In conclusion, ovsynch with intravaginal progesterone (p4) releasing
device was more effective at inducing oestrus and synchronizing ovulation than the
single GnRH injection. However, single GnRH injection was as effective as ovsynch
with intravaginal p4 releasing device for pregnancy outcomes in anoestrous crossbred dairy cows in a commercial dairy farm where formulated concentrate ration is
daily fed.
Keywords: hormonal protocols; oestrous synchronization; pregnancy rates; silent
estrus; true anoestrus
1
Nepalese Vet. J. 35:1-8
INTRODUCTION
In Nepal infertility/anoestrus problem in crossbred and exotic cattle has been
reported to be the most prioritized problem in dairy pocket areas in the country (Jha,
2000). Fertility and breeding efficiency of dairy animals play a pivotal role in dairy
economics (Peter et al., 2009). Cows are regarded as physiologically anoestrous for
a few days following parturition, whereas, lack of oestrus after 60 days postpartum
is considered pathological anoestrus or extended postpartum anoestrus (Islam et
al., 2013). In general, a calving interval of about 1 year is considered economically
optimal for dairy cows (Schmidt, 1989). To achieve such a calving interval, a postpartum cow has to resume ovarian activity, to be observed in heat, to be mated, and
to conceive within 85 days after calving (Lamming, 1981). It has been suggested that
in high-yielding dairy herds, there is increased incidence of anoestrous (Berger et al.,
1981). However, factors such as limited energy intake, lower body reserves, hormonal
imbalance and postpartum diseases can also delay the return to cyclicity (Opsomer et
al., 2000). As it is known that follicle maturation, ovulation or ovarian cyclicity are
energy as well as hormonal dependent process, negative energy balance and hormonal
insufficiency frequently cause inactive ovaries i.e. postpartum true anoestrus for long
time period. Similarly, sometime although there is ovulation timely after calving, the
animal can’t express heat; called as postpartum silent oestrus (Opsomer et al., 2000).
In commercial farms where they use commercial feeds to overcome energy deficit, in
this condition hormonal imbalance and high lactation/ production stress may cause
temporary cessation of hypothalamus-hypophysial axis leading to inactive ovaries
or sub-active ovaries. In such cases treatment with appropriate hormonal protocols
can be effective tools to resume the cyclicity in postpartum anoestrus dairy cows or
make them conceived. In Nepalese context, there was very few research works have
been performed in dairy cattle reproduction; there are no well documented reports
on treatment of postpartum anoestrus cows using hormonal protocols. Therefore, this
study was designated to evaluate the efficacy of different oestrus synchronization
protocols using hormones to overcome this postpartum anoestrus problem in dairy
cattle of Nepal.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study was conducted in a commercial dairy farm located in chitwan district and
105 postpartum cows were selected as study samples, that had not shown oestrous
behaviour upto 60 days postpartum and had not mated yet, using their history record.
Among all the postpartum anoestrus cattle, some were selected randomly and
examined by trans-rectal palpation of genital organs. They were classified as true
anoestrus (having no palpable CL and small follicles i.e. < 5mm) and silent oestrus
2
Hormonal Treatment Protocols Postpartum Anstrus
(having palpable CL and large follicles). Among true anoestrus cattle 10 were treated
with single GnRH injection (day 0 Gynarich inj. 5ml i.e. 20μg Buserelin acetate I/M
was given, waited for oestrous expression and AI was done) and 10 were treated
with Ovsynch with TRIU-B/progesterone impregnated intravaginal device (day 0
Gynarich 5ml I/M and vaginal insertion of TRIU-B for 7 day, at day 7 Lutalyse inj
5ml I/M i.e. 25mg Dinoprost tromethamine was given and TRIU-B was removed, at
day 9 Gynarich 5 ml was given and at day 10 FTAI was done). Among silent oestrus
cattle 10 were treated with single PGF2α injection (day 0 lutalyse 5ml I/M was given
and waited for oestrus expression and AI was done). The research activities are
shown in detail in figure 1.
Fig. 1: Comparative Effectiveness of different hormonal treatment protocols on
postpartum anoestrus.
Chi-square test and Fisher’s exact test in IBM SPSS Statistics version 20 were utilized
to know the success rate of different treatment protocols on postpartum anoestrous.
Similarly, MS-EXCEL-2007 was used for data entry and making different diagrams.
RESULTS AND DISSCUSSION
Effect of different hormonal treatment protocols on postpartum anoestrus
The oestrous expression rate within one week was found to be significantly higher
in Ovsynch-TRIU-B treated cows (80%vs 10%) than in single GnRH inj. treated
cows (P=0.003). Resumption of cyclicity or ovulation rate within two week and
oestrous expression rate within one month was found to be very similar between
cows treated with GnRH, TRIU-B and PGF2α i.e. 90%, 100% and 70% respectively.
Pregnancy rate was found to be comparatively higher in GnRH treated cows than
3
Nepalese Vet. J. 35:1-8
Ovsynch+TRIU-B treated and PGF2α treated cows i.e. 40%, 30%, 20% respectively.
The detailed data was presented in Table 1.
Table 1: Effect of different treatment protocols on postpartum anoestrus.
Treatment group
Parameters
True anoestrus
GnRH
Ovsynch
group
with TRIU-B P value
(n=10)
(n=10)
Total
Silent oestrus
PGF2α
Group
(n=10)
(n=30)
8 (80)
0.003
5 (50)
14 (46.7)
Resumption of
9 (90)
ovarian cyclicity
within 2 wk (%)
10 (100)
0.5
7 (70)
26 (86.7)
Oestrus
expression
within 1 month
and AI done (%)
9 (90)
10 (100)
0.5
7 (70)
26 (86.7)
Pregnancy rate
after first AI (%)
4 (40)
3 (30)
0.5
2 (20)
9 (30)
Oestrus
expression
within 1 wk (%)
1 (10)
GnRH=Gonadotropin Releasing Hormone; TRIU-B = Progesterone Impregnated
Intravaginal Device manufactured by Virbac company; PGF2α = Prostaglandin
F2α or its analogue; P value = Degree of association between GnRH group and
Ovsynch+TRIU-B group; wk= week; AI=Artificial Insemination
In case of GnRH, Islam et al (2013) found 75% oestrous expression rate and Shah and
Nakao (2010) found 100% oestrous expression rate with single injection of GnRH in
dairy cows and in buffalo respectively which are significantly higher than this finding
(10%). Similarly, Islam et al., (2013) and Wiltbank et al., (1997) found 76.5% and
85% ovulation rate within one month with single injection of GnRH which are very
similar to this finding (90%).
Table 2: Effect of duration of postpartum anoestrus on treatment response against
postpartum true anoestrus in dairy cows.
4
Hormonal Treatment Protocols Postpartum Anstrus
Parameters
Categories
Duration of 100 days
anoestrous
≥ 100 days
P value
Total
no.
Oestrus
expression
within 15 days
Oestrus
expression
wihin 30 days
Conception
rate after first
AI
7
5 (71.43%)
6 (85.71%)
0 (0%)
13
9(69.23%)
13 (100%)
7 (53.84%)
0.66
0.35
0.02
Similarly, Islam et al., (2013) found 64.7% and Shah and Nakao (2010) found
90.9% conception rate with single injection of GnRH in dairy cows and buffaloes
respectively which are comparatively higher than this finding (40%). Thus, present
study has demonstrated that a single injection of GnRH analogue had positive effect
on induction of oestrus and conception in anoestrus cows. GnRH and its agonist
act on ovarian follicular development and CL formation indirectly via the induced
release of pituitary LH and FSH. Administration of GnRH causes the large follicles
to ovulate and induces emergence of a new follicular wave within 3 to 4 days after
treatment at any stage of the oestrous cycle in cattle.
In case of PGF2α, very similar findings was obtained by Rasaili et al., (2002) who
found 60% oestrous expression rate and 20% conception rate with first injection of
PGF2α in stall-fed dairy herd in Lumle. But Islam et al., (2013) and Shah and Nakao
(2010) found comparatively higher oestrous expression rate i.e. 73.9% and 100%
respectively. Similarly, they also found higher conception rate i.e. 52.1% and 86.4%
respectively with single injection of PGF2α in dairy cows and buffaloes respectively.
PGF2α and its analogue act on CL, formed on ovary which cause temporary cessation
of oestrous cycle. So lysis of CL cause beginning of new oestrous cycle within 1
week.
In case of Ovsych with TRIU-B protocol, same findings was obtained by Ramakrishnan
et al., (2012) i.e. 100% oestrous expression rate and 33.3% conception rate in first
time AI with Ovsynch CIDR protocol. Similar result was also found by Zabeel et
al., (2009) and Bhoraniya et al., (2012) in buffaloes and Kankrej cows, respectively
i.e. 100% oestrous expression rate. In contrary, Tauck et al., (2007) and Cevik et
al., (2010) found 43% to 83% oestrous expression rate which was lower than this
finding. Similarly, Martinez et al., (1998) found 60%, Cevik et al., (2010) found
53.3% and Tauck et al., (2007) found 69% conception rate with Ovsynch CIDR
protocol in dairy cows which are higher than this finding. Better oestrus response
5
Nepalese Vet. J. 35:1-8
and conception rate in TRIU-B group could be due to progesterone priming through
TRIU-B, establishment of proper endocrine harmony/ synchrony and FTAI. While
difference in conception rate in different findings might be due to quality of semen,
experience of technician etc.
Duration of anoestrous and treatment response against postpartum true
anoestrus in dairy cows
It was found that cows with more than 100 days postpartum duration showed
comparatively higher oestrous expression rate (100%vs 85.71%) and significantly
higher conception rate (53.84%vs 0%) within 30 days of treatment than cows with
less than 100 days postpartum duration. The detailed was given in table 2. It might be
due to overcome/resumption of negative energy balance and reproductive cyclicity
after 100 days of postpartum, so that hormones have worked properly and conception
was not lost.
CONCLUSION
This study found no significantly difference in Conception rate on treatment of
postpartum anoestrus with these three hormonal protocols (GnRH, PGF2α and
Ovsynch with TRIU-B), however GnRH and PGF2α injection can be used efficiently
in small herd size where oestrous detection is not a problem and it is less costly
also while Ovsynch with TRIU-B was found to be better for large commercial
farms where oestrous detection always seems a problem. Similarly, success rate of
hormonal protocols was found to be more in > 100 days postpartum cows than <
100 days postpartum. So, postpartum reproductive rest up to 3 months is required to
increase oestrous expression rate as well as conception rate.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We are grateful to the Nepal Academy of Science and Technology (NAST) for providing
financial support for conducting this research. We would like to acknowledge National
Agriculture Research Development Fund (NARDF) Sinhadarbar plaza, Kathmandu,
Nepal, for providing MVSc fellowship Thesis grant to P. Rana. Laliguras Dairy
cattle farm, Chitwan, Nepal was acknowledged for providing us their well-managed
dairy cattle farm to conduct this research. AFU second batch Theriogenology group
members, Dr. Shatrughan Shah, Dr. Ram Chandra Sapkota and Dr. Bidur Prasad
Gautam are also acknowledged for their cooperation.
6
Hormonal Treatment Protocols Postpartum Anstrus
REFERENCES
Berger BJ, Shanks RD, Freeman AE, Laben RC (1981). Genetic aspects of milk yield
and reproductive performance. J Dairy Sci 1981; 64:114–22.
Bhoraniya, H.L., Dhami, A.J., Naikoo, M., Parmar, B.C. and Sarvaiya, N.P (2012).
Effect of estrus synchronization protocols on plasma progesterone profile and
fertility in postpartum anestrous Kankrej cows. Trop. Anim. Health Prod.,
44(3): online, DOI 10.1007/s11250-011-0057-1.
Cevik, M., Selcuk, M. and Dogan, S. (2010). Comparison of pregnancy rates
after timed artificial insemination in Ovsynch, Heatsynch and CIDR-based
synchronization protocol in dairy cows. Kafkas. Univ. Vet. Fak. Derg; 16(1):
85-89.
Jha, V.C. (2000) Study on infectious causes of infertility in crossbred & exotic cattle
in Nepal. Annual Report (1999/2000), Animal Health Research Division,
Tripureswor: 19-23.
Lamming GE, Wathes DC, and Peters AR (1981). Endocrine patterns of the postpartum cow. J Reprod Fertil 1981; 30: 155-70.
M. R. Islam, N. S. Juyena1*, M. M. U. Bhuiyan, M. M. Rahman and R. N. Ferdousy,
(2013). Treatment outcomes in postpartum anoestrus cows Guided by
transrectal ultrasonography. Progress. Agric. 24(1 & 2): 93 – 100, 2013.
Martinez, M.F., Kastelic, J.P., Adams, G.P., Janzen, E., Olson, W. and Mapletoft, R.J.
(1998). Alternative methods of synchronizing estrus and ovulation for fixed
time insemination in cattle. Theriogenolgy, 50: 350.
Opsomer G, Grohn YT, Hertl J, Coryn M, Deluyker H, de Kruif A (2000). Risk
factors for post-partum ovarian dysfunction in high producing dairy cows in
Belgium: a field study. Theriogenology 2000; 53:841–57.
Peter, A.T., Vos, P.L. and Ambrose, D.J. (2009). Postpartum anoestrus in dairy cattle.
Theriogenology, 71: 1333–1342.
Ramakrishnan, A., Dhami A.J., Naikoo, M., Parmar, B.C., And Divekar, B.S., (2012).
Estrus induction and fertility response in postpartum Anestrus gir cows.
Indian Journal of Animal Reproduction 33 (1): June 2012
Rasali, D.P. et al., (2002). An attempt to synchronize oestrus in on-station and onfarm local cows for mass insemination in the western mid hills. Nepalese Vet.
7
Nepalese Vet. J. 35:1-8
Journal – 2002, Nepal Veterinary Association (NVA). Pages; 34-42.
Sah and Nakao, (2010). A clinical study of anoestrous buffaloes in southern Nepal.
Journal of Reproduction and Development, Vol. 56, No. 2, 2010.
Schmidt GH, (1989). Effect of length of calving intervals on income over feed and
variable costs. J Dairy Sci 1989; 72: 1605-11.
Tauck, S.A., Wilkinson, J.R.C., Olsen, J.R. and Berardinelli, J.G. (2007). Comparison
of using 7- or 14-d CIDR treatments in an estrous synchronization protocol
that included PGF2á, timed A I and GnRH in primiparous, suckled beef cows.
Proc. Western Section, Am. Soc. Anim. Sci., 58: 271-273.
Wiltbank, M. C. 1997. How information on hormonal regulation of the ovary has
improved understanding of the timed breeding programs. In: Proceed. Annual
Meeting of Society for Theriogenology, Montereal, Canada. 83-97.
Zabeel, S.M., Hegab, A.O., Montasser, A.E. and El-Sheikh, H. (2009).
Reproductive performance of anestrous buffaloes treated with CIDR.
8