Research Methods
and
Performance
Analysis
Edited by Mike Hughes, Henriette Dancs, Katalin Nagyváradi, Tibor Polgár,
Nic James, Goran Sporis and Goran Vuckovic.
ISBN 978-963-9871-43-4
Editors: Hughes, M., Dancs, H., Nagyvaradi, K., Polgar, T., James. N.,
Sporis, G., & Vuckovic, G.
Publisher: University of West Hungary
2
3
4
CONTENTS
Page
Sport and Society
11
Sport as cultural product in tourism.
J. Bokor_ Cs. Kocsis,
University of West Hungary, Szombathely, Hungary.
12
Sporting and sports equipment choice habits of the students from Szombathely. 20
T. Polgár and K. Nagyváradi,
West - Hungarian University, Savaria Campus, Szombathely, Hungary.
Factors influencing the sport careers of Hungarian elite volleyball players.
24
K. Biróné Ilics,
NymE SEK Szombathely, Institute of Physical Education, Visual Arts and Music, Hungary.
Sport Pedagogical and Psychological aspects
33
The formation of the personal and professional important skills at the future sports
specialists under the psycho-pedagogical support.
34
Kosobudskaya O. and Ershova, N.
Velikie Luki Sports Academy, Russia.
Comparison of motor performance and social anxiety (SASC) of 10-12-year-old PE class
and music class school children.
41
Szalay, P., Ipach, M., Sipos, K., and Tóth, L.,
Semmelweis University, Faculty of Physical Education and Sport Sciences,
Budapest, Hungary.
The use of the calorimetric system to measure factors related to the competence of
teachers of primary school.
50
S. di Tore,
University of Salerno, Italy
PE project.
H.Ekler Judit,
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Hungary.
56
Canoe sport and positive psychology.
61
A. Szabó,
University of Szeged, Faculty of Art, Graduate School of Educational Sciences, Hungary.
Empowerment, locus of control and professional interests: an action research with Kore
University students.
65
Rosaria Schembri1, Pietro Mango1, Marco Arpino2, Riccardo Tangusso1 and Simona Nicolosi3
5
1
PhD Students in Vocational guidance sciences University of Cassino and Kore University of
Enna, Italy
2
PhD Student in Physical activities and sport sciences in education and high performance,
Kore University of Enna, Italy
3
Researcher, Kore University of Enna, Italy
Physical activities in early adolescence: implications for self-description and interpersonal
perception.
71
Nicolosi, S.*, Schembri, R.**, Sgrò, F.***, Mango, P.** and Lipoma M.*,
* Kore University of Enna, Italy
**Vocational Guidance Sciences, University of Cassino and Kore University of Enna, Italy
*** Research methodology: sport, inclusion, didactic and disability, Kore University of Enna,
Italy
The influence of canistherapy on motoric skills of junior school age children with
mental retardation.
81
Mgr. K. Maria Jindrichova,
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Hungary.
Research into pedagogical impacts on the movement development of crèche children.
84
Emőke Bucsy and Adrienn Bakk Baloghné,
University of West Hungary,
Benedek Elek Faculty of Pedagogy,
Sopron, Hungary.
Sport Physiology
93
Research Trends in Adapted Physical Activity.
Prof. Emmanouil Skordilis,
University of Athen, Greece
94
Effect of special kinetic program for advancement coordinations skills for para-vaulting
training.
112
Mgr. J- Sklenaříková,
Faculty of Sport Studies,
Masaryk Univerzity Brno,
Czech Republic.
Thermographic changes in overloaded muscles of the back for people with sedentary jobs.
120
J.Novotny,
Faculty of sport education, Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic.
Monitoring of physical activity in children living in children's houses with
school.
H.Bednářová,
Czech republic, Palacký University Olomouc, Faculty of Physical Culture.
6
124
Physical Activity preschool children.
L. Miklánková, Erik Sigmund and Milan Elfmark,
Faculty of PhysicalCulture,
Palacky University in Olomouc,
Czech Republic.
131
Secular trend in changes of the subcutaneous fat in the Transdanubian Region among 318-year-old children – unfavourable changes.
136
Cs. Suskovics1 and G.Tóth2 ,
1
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Faculty of Physical Education, Szombathely,
Hungary.
2
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Laboratory for Human Biology Research,
Szombathely, Hungary.
The mental health decrease among the active working age women in Szombathely and its
surroundings depend on physical activity.
146
B. Geosits
West - Hungarian University, Savaria Campus, Szombathely, Hungary.
Performance Analysis – INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP
153
Physical characteristics of elite Serbian female soccer players.
N. Trajkovic1, G. Sporis2, Z. Milanovic1 and M. Jovanovic2
1
Faculty of Sport and Physical Education, University of Nis, Nis, Serbia
2
Faculty of Kinesiology, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia
154
Behaviour patterns of elite coaches working with elite student athletes.
M. Hughes*, B. Archer**, N. James* and G. Vuckovic***
*University of Middlesex, London, UK.
**UWIC, School of Sport, Cardiff, UK.
*** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
162
The effect of match status on attacking strategies in the English Championship. 172
G.Rees1, N. James1, M. Hughes1, J. Taylor2, G. Vučković3
1
London Sport Institute, Middlesex University, UK
2
English Institute of Sport, UK
3
Faculty of Sport, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia
Pace as an influencing factor in basketball.
178
Csataljay, G.1; Hughes, M.2; James N.3 and Dancs H.1
1
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Institute of Sport Sciences, Hungary
2
Middlesex University, London Sport Institute, UK
3
University of Wales Institute, Cardiff, UK
Performance analysis of paddle.
J. Ramon-Llil*, G.Vuckovic**,
*University of Alicante, Spain..
** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
188
7
Tactical and movement analysis of elite racket sports using the Sagit Analysis System.
194
R. Racz*, M. Hughes*, N. James*, G. Vuckovic** and H. Dancs***,
*University of Middlesex, London, UK.
** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
***UWH, Szombathely, Hungary.
The use of zone 14 as a strategic attacking area in the English Championship.
G.Rees1, N. James1, M. Hughes1, J. Taylor2, G. Vučković3
1
London Sport Institute, Middlesex University, UK
2
English Institute of Sport, UK
3
Faculty of Sport, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia
205
The efficiency and ergonomics of different data entry systems in real-time and lapsedtime computer notation systems.
213
M.Hughes*, O. Fuller**, S. Murray***, N. James* and G.Vuckovic****
*University of Middlesex, London, UK.
**PGIR, Bath, UK.
*** EIS, Manchester, UK.
**** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
In search of nexus between attacking game-patterns, match status and type of ball
recovery in European Soccer Championship 2008.
226
D. Barreira1,2, J. Garganta1,2 and T. Anguera3
*Faculty of Sport – University of Porto, Portugal. CIFI2D.
**Faculty of Psychology – University of Barcelona, Spain.
Attacking game-patterns in soccer. a sequential analysis of the winner team of World Cup
2010.
238
Machado, J., Barreira, D., Garganta, J.,
Faculty of Sport – University of Porto, Portugal.
Performance analysis – the future.
Mike Hughes, Nic James, Goran Vuckovic, M.T. Hughes and S. Murray,
University of Middlesex, London, UK.
246
Analysis of physical demands of ballroom dancers in tango and quickstep using the
tracking system SAGIT.
257
Zaletel, P*., Vučkovič, G*., James, N**., Rebula, A*. and Zagorc, M*.
* University of Ljubljana, Faculty of sport, Slovenia.
** University of Middlesex, UK.
The performance development by the flow in the Canoe sport.
Szabó Attila,
West - Hungarian University, Savaria Campus, Szombathely, Hungary.
266
Bodily communication in volleyball.
Raiola, G., Di Tore, S. and Di Tore, A.,
271
8
University of Salerno, Italy.
Teaching , coaching methodology
281
The importance of being earnest – with your data.
Prof. Nic James,
University of Middlesex, London, UK.
282
9
10
Sport and Society
11
Sport as Cultural Product in Tourism
J. Bokor and Csabáné Kocsis,
University of West Hungary, Szombathely, Hungary.
Abstract
Our everyday life is entwined with the material way of thinking present in the
various aspects of society, pushing aside the quality features of life. Quality, as a
philosophic concept is the entirety of essential features that characterise a thing.
Quality represents a certain positive value, and this positive shift makes the
difference between certain ways of life, the way we live
According to the World Health Organisation, by 2022 tourism and the health
industry will have been the largest industries. The available money is increasing in
certain classes, while health and physical wellbeing is becoming a priority to
consumers at the same time. As the number of the elderly is growing, the need for
quality life, for living the everyday life in good health is becoming more relevant.
Tourism products on the supply side change accordingly, they become wider and
more varied. This tendency is good both for health and sport tourism.
The relationship between culture and tourism has gained ground primarily with the
increase of leisure time. The right to rest and leisure (UN General Assembly, 10
December 1948), as well as the need for a change of environment and the facilities
available due to the technical development make the active participation in tourism
possible. In parallel appears our national consciousness, the representation of our
nationality and culture, along with the due respect for and acceptance of the
culture of the destination country. This fact also reflects, that besides its financial
potential, tourism plays an immense role in the representation of the national
culture. In other words: it is becoming a product in the market of tourism.
In our research we were looking for the answer to what extent the conscious
improvement of the mental and physical aspects of health, that is the sport element
of health culture is present in a market segment, namely among the guests of Bük
Spa.
1 Introduction
Our everyday life is entwined with the material way of thinking present in the various aspects
of society, pushing aside the quality features of life. Quality, as a philosophic concept is the
entirety of essential features that characterise a thing. Quality represents a certain positive
value, and this positive shift makes the difference between certain ways of life, the way we
live. This has an outward manifestation, which is normally triggered by the (social, economic,
etc.) environment, and is mostly standardised.
According to the World Health Organisation, by 2022 tourism and the health industry
will have been the largest industries. Thanks to social wellbeing, the available money is
increasing in certain classes, while health and physical wellbeing is becoming a priority to
consumers at the same time. As the number of the elderly is growing, the need for quality life,
for living the everyday life in good health is becoming more relevant. So among this age group
health-consciousness, healthy eating are more present on the demand side of tourism than
before, and they are more interested in activities other than what they normally do, which they
often wish to find in tourism. Tourism products on the supply side change accordingly, they
become wider and more varied. This tendency is good both for health and sport tourism.
12
The quality of life cannot be described merely by economic figures. It is also affected by the
events that take place within the soul, which are often reflected on the people's faces. Onefolded activities deprive this age group from these special experiences, especially from those
they can gain while travelling. Thus their way of life becomes monotone, boring. It is wellknown that our soul also needs new impulses from our environment, which makes us (as said in
sport language) more resistant and less vulnerable. And thus, we already take care of the mental
side of our health. So these new impulses influencing our inner health come from our
environment. The everyday impulses do not have a positive effect on people after a certain
time, but a change of environment, with other words: ’the different’ acts as a catalyst for the
body and makes our everyday activities more effective. Gaining experience with a change of
environment - which is the most basic aspect, the aim of tourism - has an indirect effect on the
tourist’s health. Thus tourism can have, and actually has an immense role in improving the
quality of life. However, it is not influenced only by mental wellbeing, but also by our physical
condition. If we pay attention to the physical components as well, than we have already done a
great deal in order to live a healthier, better quality life, thus enriching our culture, as well as
our material and spiritual values.
2 Culture – body culture – health culture – way of life
Culture is the entirety of our knowledge, our behaviour models, customs, our beliefs, which we
acquire implicitly while living in a family, in a society, so while socialising. Culture thus
becomes part of our personality, and is manifested in our relationship with our environment.
The relationship between culture and tourism has gained ground primarily with the
increase of leisure time. The right to rest and leisure (UN General Assembly, 10 December
1948), as well as the need for a change of environment and the facilities available due to the
technical development make the active participation in tourism possible. In parallel appears our
national consciousness, the representation of our nationality and culture, along with the due
respect for and acceptance of the culture of the destination country. This fact also reflects, that
besides its financial potential, tourism plays an immense role in the representation of the
national culture. In other words: it is becoming a product in the market of tourism.
Body culture is part of our culture. The result of our activities to achieve and maintain
our health defines our body culture, partly our health culture as well, and above all their
quality. The concept and the content of culture change along with humanity. The material and
spiritual sides cannot be separated, so culture includes not only the phenomena of art, science
and spiritual activities, but that of the everyday life. For example the way we live, eat, work, or
the way we spend our free time. The culture of leisure, recreation is a popular topic nowadays,
not only in the life of the individual, but also among scientific researchers. Tourism, as a leisure
activity together with travelling, is an excellent possibility for cultural exchange. We travel to
get to know other cultures, while taking our personal, and in most cases our national culture.
Body culture is part of our culture, which simply means the education of the body. It reflects
our genetic inheritance, and means to keep our body in a good condition, to improve or
eventually to correct it. This can be achieved by various effects, activities. To mention some:
e.g. to make use of the powers of nature, by various sport activities, sport equipment, or with
the knowledge of educating the body, sport sciences.
3 Demographic changes – quality of life – new tendencies in tourism
13
The overage age of people has considerably increased by the 21st century, and the quality of
this longer life is not indifferent. The change of environment due to travel can greatly improve
our quality of life, which is reflected not only in the tourist’s health condition but indirectly
also in society. F. Kennedy said that the power of a democracy lies in the health of its citizens.
So when we speak, think about tourism, we can mention not only its importance in and positive
impact on economy, but also its beneficial effects on health.
Tourism trends are affected by the demographic changes. The changes of the values,
attitudes of people, their way of life result in these new tendencies. These changes are formed
by the growth of population, increasing life expectancy, different household structures, and
expanding migration. This change is traceable in the destinations (where people go from
where), and in the activities at the destinations. As people live longer, they wish to live this
longer life in good health conditions, living a quality life. Thus they are going to live in a more
health-conscious way. The health-conscious way of life includes –among others – a more active
participation in tourism and physical and sport activities pursued at the destination.
There is a considerable number of researches studying the physical activity, healthconscious attitude and way of life of elderly people, and the effect of the above on their health
condition, and as a consequence on the quality of their life. Monitoring and complying with the
activity needs of the growing number of elderly tourists at the destinations, providing services
that could improve their quality of life could be a part of the new tourism tendencies, allowing
an advance for the service provider in the competition.
4 Hypotheses
In our research we were looking for the answer to what extent the conscious improvement of
the mental and physical aspects of health, that is the sport element of health culture is present in
a market segment, namely among the guests of a spa.
We supposed that the vast majority of the surveyed arrived at the spa for recovery and
medical treatment.
We supposed that the approach of the foreign guests to sport activities (frequency in
doing sports, intensity and regularity) is better than that of the Hungarian ones.
5 Methodology
As our primary research method of data collection we have chosen the questionnaire in the
second biggest medicinal spa in Hungary, namely the Medicinal Spa of Bük. The survey by the
questionnaires (filled by the surveyed) was conducted during the winter period (between
November 2008 and March 2009), the participants were chosen by random sampling. There
were both closed and open ended questions. In spite of the considerable efforts of the Medicinal
Spa to counterbalance the seasonal differences by widening the variety of services in the past
few years, there is still remarkable difference between the summer and winter turnout indices.
During the surveyed period services were mostly used by elderly guests looking for more peace
and quite, and by ill people making use of social security coverage. Significant difference can
be traced in the composition of the guests, as two-thirds arrive from foreign countries, a vast
majority of whom come from German-speaking areas (Table 1.). It is a positive tendency that
the number of guest arriving from the Czech Republic is increasing progressively, which must
be taken into consideration in the diversification of supplies.
Data were analysed by SPSS for Windows 17.0 statistical method, as well as with the
help of Excel figures and tables.
14
Table 1. Nationality of the surveyed.
Nationality
Hungarian
German-speaking (German,
Austrian,)
Czech
Total:
number
194
90
96
380
6 Findings
The present findings reflect only the presence of sport activities of the guests during their visit
at the spa and at home in their permanent environment, without the intention of specifying the
sport activities in question. We wished to investigate to what extent the guests participate in
sport activities, which influence the quality of life, thus health culture. Pursuing sport activities
at tourism destinations may bring along a continuation of sport activities at home, thus
improving the quality of life.
When interpreting the findings we must keep in mind the fact that the guests of the
surveyed medicinal spa were participants primarily in health tourism, thus this time they
represented primarily the market segment of health tourism.
In case we wish to examine the sports motivation of those participating in health
tourism, we need to find out ‘how’ the surveyed guest has arrived at the spa.
Concerning the entire Hungarian sample, 51,3% arrived with social security referral, 9,3% with
tourism cheque, and 39,4% were self-financing. (Figure 1.).
Self-financing
9%
39%
Social security
referral
52%
Tourism
cheque
1. ábra/Fig. 1. a magyar vendégek milyen
minőségben érkeztek/ The way of financing the
visit to the spa
n=194
Figure 1. The way of financing the visit to the spa
15
The above proportions projects the activities of the surveyed Hungarian guests during their
stay, as it is less probable that the large number of guests arriving with social security referrals
would seek after sports facilities in the spa. Figure 2. shows that the main reason of the
Hungarian for visiting the spa was recovery.
60.00%
50.00%
magyar
40.00%
cseh
30.00%
osztrák/n
émet
20.00%
10.00%
0.00%
egészségmegőrző
gyógyulás
rekreáció
2. ábra/Fig.2. Gyógyfürdőbe érkezés célja/ Aim of visiting the spa
Figure 2. Reasons for visiting the spa.
Free sport activities for health preservation were the most popular among the Hungarian guests
(Figure 3.), while their number was the smallest in relation to participation in fee-paying sport
programs (4.ábra). The spa unfortunately is unable to meet such demand, as they provide only
one free program, as opposed to the nine fee-paying ones.
51,30%
48,60%
46,40%
60,00%
40,00%
20,00%
részt
vesz
0,00%
-20,00%
nem
vesz
részt
-40,00%
-60,00%
-48,70%
m agyar
-51,40%
cseh
-53,60%
osztrák/ném et
3. ábra/Fig.3. Ingyenes mozgásprogramokon való részvétel
/ Participation in free activities
16
Figure 3. Participation in free sport programs.
58,33%
60,00%
29,41%
44,58%
40,00%
20,00%
részt
vesz
0,00%
-20,00%
nem vesz
részt
-40,00%
-41,67%
-60,00%
-70,59%
-80,00%
magyar
-55,42%
cseh
osztrák/német
4.ábra/Fig.4. Pénzért igénybe vehető
mozgásprogramokon való részvétel/ Participation in feepaid sportprograms
Figure 4. Participation in fee-paying sport programs.
Besides the lack of financial resources, other reasons are also possible for not participating in
the fee-paying programs. As when sport is part of our everyday activities, of our way of life, we
do not mind spending money on it. If it is not, it is easy to resist. Figure 5. shows the guests’
sport activities at home.
66,80%
65,40%
70,00%
60,00%
50,00%
50,00%
40,00%
30,00%
20,00%
10,00%
cseh
0,00%
osztrák,
német
magyar
5. ábra/Fig.5. Sport az állandó lakóhelyen/ Sport at
the permanent places
Figure 5. Sport activities at home.
17
Doing sports for health is maybe more important at an older age, in order to retain our
locomotor mobility, general wellbeing, good physical condition and quality of life. Figure 6.
shows that the majority of the Hungarian surveyed have come for medical treatment. It is true
that we do not do sport when we are ill, however quite a few sport activities can help to cure
illnesses. A health-conscious person seeks the possibility for recovery even with sport
activities.
TB beutaló
100%
Önfinanszírozás
80%
60%
40%
Üdülési csekk
20%
0%
Egészségmegőrzés
Rekreáció/pihenés
6. ábra/Fig. 6. Senior magyar (n=45) minőség-cél összefüggés/ The
reason for visit among senior tourists
Figure 6. The reason for visit among senior tourists
Figure 6. The reason for visits among senior tourists.
7 Conclusions
Participation of the Hungarian guests in sport activities is far below in every respect that of the
foreign guests. The reason for this can be of financial nature or other, but it is very likely that
the Hungarian have a simpler concept of health, how to reach it and by what means. According
to certain figures, the number of health-conscious people has increased lately, yet concerning
sport activities the Hungarian guests are behind the foreign ones based on the findings.
This statistic figure could be improved by a change in the approach, but even tourism,
with its sport elements on the supply side, could implicitly help to change the way of life.
8
References
Bokor, J. (2004). Sportturizmus és sportturisták. Magyar Sporttudományi Szemle, 1. pp.7-10.
Pikó, B. (2006): Életmód, kultúra, egészségtudatosság. In: BARABÁS K. (szerk.) Egészségfejlesztés. Medicina Könyvkiadó Rt., Budapest, pp. 269-281.
18
Sporting and Sports Equipment Purchasing Habits of University Students in
Szombathely.
Tibor Polgár and Katalin Nagyváradi,
West – Hungarian University, Szombathely, Hungary.
Abstract
One of the deciding factor of the effective sport supplements is to measure the
student’s sporting habits, because they are happier to do what they actually like.
It was found from the survey, that the generality of the young adults hike, make a
trip, dance or race-sport very rarely, and only do some leisure sport just once a
week. In addition to the results of those who get exercise daily, only 28,5% of the
students do sports regularly.
From the ranked sport equipments the training shoes and the sportswear are
exceeded. Fitness and swimming pool season tickets got numerous nominations as
well. In point of genders less man choose indoor cycle and sportswear, while
19
significantly more women choose Fitness season tickets. Sportswear and indoor
cycle are not so significant for man as for woman.
Keywords: students, sport, sport equipments
1 Introduction
The issues of healthy lifestyle and workout are occurring more and more frequently nowadays.
Health behaviour and health value are culture-dependent factors so the systems of norms and
values in a society greatly contribute to the formation of them (Ferron, 1997). A regular
physical activities have very good physiological and psychological effects on health. (Brukner
and Brown, 2005).
The topic has a great impact on everybody, since health, which we do not achieve by various
therapies, medical interventions, but by health promotion, is fundamental to our life. The
lifestyle of those young people who regularly do exercise is healthier, than those doing other
activities in their spare time (Burke, 1997). It is estimated that only thirty percent of the 15-85year-old age group take part in physical activity on a regular basis in Hungary and this rate is
significantly decreasing by age. (Gáldi, 2002.)
Realizing the values of a health-conscious lifestyle is essential for taking conscious steps.
As for exercise, we can come to the same conclusions: it is proved that lack of exercise is
detrimental to health, but at the same time we also know the positive effects that regular
exercise can have on health and the quality of life.
As it is known that regular exercise has preventive, maintaining and healing functions, its
importance is indisputable taking into consideration the whole society, including children,
adults and the elderly, of course.
2 Method and subjects
The sample is made up students of the West Hungarian University, Savaria Campus. We’re
using random sampling method, examined sample: 274 students (34% men, 66% women).
We’re using mathematical statistical method. SPSS 15.0 for Windows statistical software.
3 Results and discussion
Sporting Habits
Table 1. The interviewed students had preference for the following leisure activities.
Frequency
Never
Rarely
Monthly
Weekly
Daily
Total
Significance
Hiking
7.8
61.3
25.6
5.1
.2
100.0
p<0.05
Excursion
3.3
57.5
32.1
6.4
.7
100.0
P<0.05
Dancing
18.6
32.7
18.4
25.5
4.9
100.0
p<0.05
20
Competitive Sport
54.9
25.7
5.7
9.0
4.7
100.0
p<0.05
Leisure Time
Sport
2.8
20.5
14.6
38.3
23.8
100.0
p<0.05
A vast majority of the interviewed young people rarely go Hiking (Chi2=752.219), rarely go on
excursions (Chi2=715.211), rarely go Dancing (Chi2=126.543), rarely do Competitive Sports
(Chi2=543.012), and do some kind of Leisure Time Sport on a weekly basis (Chi2=201.920).
Adding up the results of those doing exercise daily (Competitive Sport 4.7%; Leisure Time
Sport 23.8%), it shows that it is only 28.5% of the students who regularly do sport.
Table 2. Popular sports activities done in free time considering independent variables.
Independent
Variables
Girl-Boy
Mother’s
Qualifications
Father’s
Qualifications
Does Sport 0-2
Times/Week
Does Sport 3 or More
Times/Week
Hiking
P<0.05
Excursion
-
Dancing
p<0.05
Competitive
Sport
p<0.05
Leisure Time
Sport
p<0.05
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
p<0.05
-
-
-
-
p<0.05
P<0.05
-
-
p<0.05
-
Except for going on Excursions, there is a significant difference considering the results of each
question. Girls go Hiking less frequently (Pearson Chi2=12.653), they go Dancing more
(Pearson Chi2=61.866), fewer of them do Competitive Sport (Pearson Chi2=81.892), and they
do less Leisure Time Sport activities than boys (Pearson Chi2=65.402). As regards gender, the
results demonstrate that girls are more inactive than boys in case of both Competitive and
Leisure Time Sport. The children of fathers with higher education qualifications do
significantly more Leisure Time Sport than the others (Pearson Chi2=15.813).
Among those doing sport regularly, it is more common that they do activities that are to do
with Competitive Sport, and students who do sport less frequently tend to do activities that are
to do with Leisure Time. The number of students who do Competitive Sport is lower than that
of students who do Leisure Time Sport.
Purchasing Sports Equipment
Table 3. Purchasing sports equipment from gift money.
Sports Equipment
Opted for
Not Opted for
Total
Sports shoes
28.7
71.3
100
Signific
ance
p<0.05
Stationary Bike
7.7
92.3
100
p<0.05
Swimming Pool
Season Ticket
Skateboard
16.1
83.9
100
p<0.05
3.8
96.2
100
p<0.05
Tennis Racquet
4.9
95.1
100
p<0.05
Skis
5.4
94.6
100
p<0.05
Fitness Season
Ticket
Hiking Boots
19.1
80.9
100
p<0.05
7.1
92.9
100
p<0.05
21
Skates
9.2
90.8
100
p<0.05
Sportswear
29.9
70.1
100
p<0.05
Table 4. Heterogeneity test of those having ranked the sports equipment considering gender
and parents’ qualifications.
Sports
Equipment
Sports shoes
Stationary
Bike
Swimming
Pool Season
Ticket
Skateboard
Tennis
Racquet
Skis
Fitness
Season Ticket
Hiking Boots
Skates
Sportswear
Gender
Mother’s
Qualifications
Father’s
Qualifications
Sporting Habits
p<0.05
-
p<0.05
0-2 times a
week
-
3 or more
times a week
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
p<0.05
p<0.05
-
-
-
p<0.05
-
-
-
-
p<0.05
-
-
p<0.05
-
Sports shoes and Sportswear are high on the top of the list of the ranked pieces of sports
equipment. The sum of the percentage that the 2 items amounts to (58.6%) is more than the
total of the other eight pieces of equipment altogether. Having information about their dressing
habits and knowing the percentage of those who do sport, the students presumably purchase
sports shoes and clothing not solely for sporting purposes, but for everyday street use. The two
items that come next on the list are the Fitness Season Ticket (19.1%) and the Swimming Pool
Season Ticket (16.1%).
As for gender, fewer men opt for a Stationary Bike (Pearson Chi2=7.000) and Sportswear
(Pearson Chi2=9.281), while there are significantly more women who will choose a Fitness
Season Ticket. (Pearson Chi2=33.217). Men do not consider Sportswear and Stationary Bikes
as important as women do.
Taking parents’ qualifications into consideration, a student being the child of a mother with a
higher education qualification tends to buy a tennis racquet (Pearson Chi2=6.189), while
Skateboards, showing a considerable difference, would be purchased by students having a
father with higher education qualifications (Pearson Chi2=7.309). As regards the positive value
of choosing a Stationary Bike, it is the children of less educated fathers where there is a
significant discrepancy. (Pearson Chi2=6.319).
4 Conclusions
From the ranked sport equipments the training shoes and the sportswear are exceeded. Fitness
and swimming pool season tickets got numerous nominations as well. In point of genders less
22
man choose indoor cycle and sportswear, while significantly more women choose Fitness
season tickets. Sportswear and indoor cycle are not so significant for man as for woman.
Health is the unity of our physical, mental, intellectual, social and emotional life. Our health is
only complete if we live in harmony with the natural and social environment surrounding us
Since it is more difficult, though not impossible, to start a more health-conscious life at an older
age, the goal would be to start education for a healthy lifestyle at an early age, during
childhood. (Polgár, 2008.)
5 References
Brukner, P.D. & Brown, W.J. (2005).: Is exercise good for you? Medical Journal of Australia,
183, 538-541.
Burke, V., Milligan, R.A.K. and Beilin, L.J.. (1997): Clustering of Health-related behaviors
among 18-year-olds. Australians. Preventive Medicine, 26, 724-733.
Ferron, C. (1997): Body image in adolescence: cross-cultural research – results of the
preliminary phase of a quantitative survey, Adolescence, 38, 289-311
Gáldi G. (2002). Fizikai aktivitás Magyarországon az ezredfordulón. Magyar Sporttudományi
Szemle, 3-4, 16-18.
Polgár T. (2008). Sportolási értéktartalmak hatásmechanizmusa Vas megyei középiskolás és
főiskolás diákok körében, doktori disszertáció, Budapest, 10.
23
Researching factors which influence the sport career among Hungarian elite volleyball
players.
Katalin Biróné Ilics,
NymE SEK Szombathely, Institute of Physical Education, Visual Arts and Music, Hungary
Abstract
Volleyball is in a difficult situation in Hungary. There are only few junior players.
Getting into the sport often happens by chance. The youngster or junior age-groups
often fall into pieces just before they could get into the adult team. This fact is also
proved by research. The aim of the research is to find the answers to the question
whether there is a certain way in Hungary nowadays on which somebody can reach
the front line and can be among the best volleyball players, or not. The research of
our selected men and women volleyball players’ past and present in sport (N=36)
deals with four issues. Details of getting into the team, skills or maybe specialities
needed for playing volleyball, the quality of years spent with playing volleyball
connected to age-group and circumstances of getting into the front-line. The
problem was researched with the help of questionnaires, in which open format
questions and closed format questions (with one or more choices) appeared. It was
found that 63% of the respondents had already done sports before started playing
volleyball (athletics 28%, basketball 21%) or started playing volleyball because
they were encouraged by their parents or P.E. teachers. Of the respondents, 45 %
wanted to be a famous sportsman, or the purpose was just simply recreation. Only
10 % of them started playing this sport because of the chance of earning money
with it. According to our selected players’ opinion, their self-development (59%)
and the presence of their mental abilities (leader-like personality, cooperation,
strength of will) contributed to the fact that they are in the Hungarian National
Volleyball Team today. It can be concluded from the research that deciding on
someone’s suitability or the measurement of the physical and cognitive abilities’
presence is not continuous. It appears typically in the adult age-group, where
coaches apply also combined (psychological and motor) tests. In other countries
(e.g. Italy) their objective selection systems work well, whereas in Hungary the
principle of “the coach’s eye’ is still dominating.
1 Introduction
In the last few years several researches have been made about selection and nursing talented
players. Based on the background literature, the objectives of the surveys were to give some
practical advice and define which factors can influence the realization of the talent. In order to
get closer to the topic within this sport, we have to study the period lasting from the choice of
the sport to the becoming of an elite player. The sport career, which takes at least 10 years, is
influenced by many factors. They are the following: the choice of the sport and the connected
objectives, motivation, the personality of the coach, the spirit of the trainings, experiencing
success or failure, factors from the close social environment (family, friends, school,
profession), unpredicted factors (injury, accident), special psychological factors needed for
volleyball, motor abilities and the existence of physical features (Biróné, 2004: 241-242).
24
Consequently, do those ones who want to be desperately prominent volleyball players,
supported by the family and environment, have proper motor and mental abilities, furthermore
good build and do not get permanent injuries during the sport career become an elite player
surely?
The aim of our research was finding an answer to this question. We analysed the factors which
influenced our elite players’ career from the beginning to the selection. We studied whether all
the top-players went through on the same path until reached the top or not.
Hypotheses
H1: In our opinion, most of the players became a volleyball player consciously and not by
chance.
H2: The selected players mark out from their mates mainly because of their mental abilities.
H3: We think that members of the selected team got on well with the coaches of their agegroups.
H4: We assume that the self-improvement and extra work of the players also contributed to
their success.
2 Method
In our research those men and women volleyball players filled in a questionnaire /N=36/ who
were selected in the years of 2008/2009 and 2009/2010. Those players, who were part of the
selected team in both league years, filled in the questionnaire only in the first year.
The questions deal with the factors which influence the career of the players, abilities which
are needed for players to become selected and chances which help the preparation.
The questionnaire contained one or more-option based closed format questions and openformat questions, as well.
3 Results
In our study we dealt with such factors which could positively or negatively influence a
player’s time and its quality spent at sport. Based on it, we studied the circumstances of
selection, the players’ sports background and their objectives in connection with volleyball. We
analysed the players’ opinion about abilities needed for volleyball and about their own
speciality. Finding out their relationship with their coaches and those processes by which their
competence in elite line could be detected. According to the background literature, starting
playing volleyball is the best between the ages of 9-11 (NÁDORi, 1991: 275). On the average,
our selected volleyball players started the sport at around the age of 10 (Table 1).
Table 1. Time of starting playing volleyball.
Time of starting the
sport
Valid N (listwise)
N
36
Minimum Maximum
5
16
36
25
Mean
10,94
Std.
Deviation
2,777
Certain sports (artistic gymnastics, rhythmic gymnastics, Goliat football) start the children’s
training early. By the ages of 9-11, most of the children have already tried some sports in which
they probably reached success, too. So, directing them towards another sport – at present,
towards volleyball – is the duty and responsibility of parents and experts.
It can be seen on the diagram (Figure 1) that 63 % of the players (23 persons) did some sports
before playing volleyball. Among the sports, athletics, martial arts, swimming and basketball
(Figure 2) appear. These are sports, which opposed to volleyball, offer sport facilities for
kindergarten and primary school students, as well. It is also worth mentioning that most of the
players had played basketball and done athletics before. These sports could serve as good
basics for their later volleyball career.
25
20
15
10
5
0
Doing sports before playing volleyball
Yes
23
No
13
Figure 1. Doing sports before playing volleyball.
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Type of sport before playing
volleyball
Artistic Gymnastik
1
Swimming, Waterpolo
3
Basketball
5
Tennis
2
Martial arts
5
Football
1
Figure 2. Type of sports.
26
In volleyball, the application happens during recruitments, where the children usually appear
not because of their own free will. Basically, their parents’ dedication towards the sport, the
friends or the P.E. teacher’s influence is in the background of their choice.
A further influential factor can be the results of the local volleyball team or spectacular,
exciting matches on TV, as well. It turned out that the choice of the sport had been basically
influenced by the P.E. teachers and parents of the players (Figure 3). According to each
background literature which deals with selection, the role of the P.E. teacher is vitally
important in the process of training junior players. There are several measurements and
observations which help to direct children towards the most proper sport, based on their
aptitude and skills. The children of those parents, who also play volleyball, tend to start this
sport willingly, too.
Many of their parents are still active at the sport or have already finished their sport career but
still love going to volleyball matches and events. Thus, the volleyball court and the proximity
of players seem to mean a straight line towards the love of this sport.
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
The reason for choosing the sport
Affected by the Tv,
radio, newspapers
0
Encouraged by the
P.E. teacher
15
Encouraged by parents
13
Encouraged by friends
5
Affected by having a
role model at sport
1
Others
2
Figure 3. The reason for choosing the sport.
Interest towards the sport is aroused by the movements, the love of playing together, the
novelty and excitement. After a short time, a further motivating factor can be the possibility of
becoming an elite player or making a living with the sport. We received a partly surprising
answer to the question of ‘What was your objective with volleyball?’(Figure 4).
We presumed that players were preparing for their career on a conscious way (H1) and
wanted to become famous players or earn money with the sport. Behind both motivations,
determined ideas and conscious, ambitious behaviour appears which can result in desperate
preparation. Opposed to it, only 17 respondents wanted to become famous sportsmen and a
further 17 respondents said that volleyball was “only” a useful past time activity. One
respondent was motivated by the possibility of earning money with the sport and another one
27
player did not give an answer to this question. So, our hypothesis was not proved but we found
an interesting connection.
Those players, who were motivated to play volleyball by the P.E. teacher, answered in great
numbers (exactly 71 % of them) that the sport is just a pleasure, useful pastime activity for
them; while 69% of those respondents who were motivated by parents, wanted to become
famous sportsmen.
The game has speeded up by the development of techniques, tactics and the modification of
rules. The players can get the better of the opposing team with quick decisions, unexpected,
sudden solutions. For this, they need outstanding aptitude, special abilities. An elite volleyball
player is visibly tall and has long limbs. He endures monotony well but has a little
scoundrelism, as well. We hypothesise that he can work in a good team, so has the ability of
cooperation but is also able to solve the tasks on his own.
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
The aim for choosing the sport
Making new friends
0
Becoming a famous
sportsman/sportswome
n
17
Entertainment,useful
pastime activity
17
Earning money with it
1
Figure 4. The aim for choosing the sport
As the consequence of the momentary ball touches, the player can solve sudden situations,
long rally, and sustained tasks under five-set matches.
In order to be able to analyse which players could be among the elite ones, we have to define
the abilities and features for that.
Based on the background literature (Harsányi, 2000: 106-107, 82-83; Nádori, 1991: 274-293;
TRZAKOMA-BICSÉRDY, 2009: 265; Hancik et al., 1990: 83-85) and our own experiences, the
following abilities and features are important and needed for reaching the elite line: good
physical-, coordination- and conditional abilities, psychological and environmental factors. It
means the followings at volleyball:
1. Physical abilities: high build, long limbs
2. Motor abilities: ball mastery, quickness, flexibility, joint suppleness, strength, stamina,
balance
3. Features of personality, psychological factors: courage, discipline, game-intelligence,
motivation, firmness, ambition, helpfulness, fighting spirit, endurance, long-lasting
attention, tolerance of monotony, sense of space, anticipation, importance of humility,
self-discipline, fast reaction time, power of will, moderation, leading personality, load
ability.
4. Environmental factors: parental background which support the sport.
28
We asked the respondents’ personal opinion about which abilities are needed for volleyball. We
asked them to choose the five most important ones from the list.
Furthermore, they had to write down what they thought about how they could become selected
players, what kind of abilities could help them in it and what their specialities are (Figure 5).
Many (6) of the 8 mostly mentioned factors belong to the mental abilities. Our players think
that physical and build factors are also important, however, the psychical preparedness plays
the most important role in the efficiency of a player /H2/. 65% of them say that their own
mental abilities (leading personality, humility) helped them, too to become selected players in
volleyball. Our second hypothesis /H2/ could be proved, as well. Based on it, the players mark
out from the others mostly by means of their mental abilities. To be the best at volleyball (two
players’ responds were not evaluable), 39% of them did extra trainings, 29% of them did
maximum training work, 17% of them took the coach’s advice and 15% of them prepared
mentally. So, our hypothesis /H4/ was proved.
25
20
15
10
5
0
Abilities needed for playing volleyball
Cooperation
23
Craft in ballgames
21
Submissiveness
19
Quick recognition of
the situation
10
Fightin spirit
13
Willpower
Figure 5. Abilities.
Detecting the abilities and the best knowledge is the role of the coach. A beginner player has
and works with three or even four coaches until he becomes an adult player. The personality
and aptitude of the coach can influence the player’s later career a lot. He is responsible for the
thing that every single factor in the young players’ life should be in harmony: the family, the
career, the company of the peers and free time (SIGURD, 2006: 135-135). The cheer of
trainings, the sufficient number of matches which can uphold motivation, the attention and
proximity of the adult team all help the players to stay in sport and guarantee the continuous
preparation. Most of our elite volleyball players liked and respected their coaches in all the
three age groups. 28 respondents out of 36 had already played volleyball in the child age group.
Twenty subjects (71.5%) had a really good relationship with their coaches, 17.9% of them
accepted the coaches and only 10.6% had changeable relationships with them, that is neither
bad nor good (Figure 6).
29
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Relationship with the coach in child agegroup
Liked, respected
20
Accepted
5
Neutral
0
Changing
3
Figure 6. Relationship with the coach.
The relationship between the coach and players is similarly satisfactory in the puberty age
group, too. 19 out of 35 respondents liked, respected the coach. 12 players (23%) accepted him
or her, 1 player had neutral connection with the coach and 3 people had changeable relationship
with him or her (Figure 7).
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Relationship with the coach in puberty agegroup
Lik ed, respected
19
Accepted
12
Neutral
1
Changing
3
Absolutely Bad
0
Figure 7. Relationship with the coach.
In Hungary each volleyball team (except universities and colleges) is obliged to have a junior
team. It means a problem for almost all the associations. Because there are not enough players,
junior players necessarily get into the adult team many times where they might meet failures
continuously. The personality of the coach and his or her relationship with the players may be
the most important in this case. On the diagram (Figure 8) it can be seen clearly that also in this
age group most of the players had a good relationship with their coach, which fact also
determines the preparation and performance a lot.
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Relationship with the coach in junior age-group
Lik ed, respected
21
Accepted
7
Neutral
1
Changing
4
Absolutely bad
0
Figure 8. Relationship with the coach.
Consequently our hypothesis was proved /H3/. Based on it, most of our players had a really
good relationship with their coaches. During the time of preparation the coaches continuously
monitor their own players and the opponent team’s players; and based on the players’
proficiency and performance they draw conclusions. These conclusions and monitoring are
useful but do not involve the whole personality and complex features of the youths. It can
happen that by neglecting the fact of improvement and early maturity the coaches draw wrong
conclusions. In order to avoid from that, the solution would be a selection based on continuous,
complex measurements. In volleyball, selection is mostly based on the players’ performance on
the matches. Only few coaches apply complex measurement for proving a player’s suitability.
During the career of our elite players, only 19.4% of them were regularly measured (Figure 9).
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Methods for evaluation applied by the
coach
Yes, regularly
7
Yes, but only in my
rising-generation age
7
15
Yes, but only in
adulthood
7
No, never
Figure 9. Selection.
The most common measurement methods are motor tests and height measurement.
31
These methods are applied compulsorily since joining the Herakles program and players are
measured by regional leaders.
Known, but less often applied methods among volleyball players are the psychological tests,
sociometric measurements which measure the character, moral and volitional skills (Hancik et
al., 1990: 83-84).
4 Conclusions
The aim of our study was to find the answer to the question whether there is a certain way in
Hungary on which someone can reach the front line and can be among the best volleyball
players, or not. In our survey we studied the sport career of our selected male and female
volleyball players. It turned out that the answers of the players are very similar and show only
slight differences. More than half of the players have switched to volleyball from another sport
because of their parents or P.E. teachers’ suggestion. The bulk of these encouraged young
players had already known that they wanted to be famous players, so prepared consciously to
their career. Based on the analyses it can be said that those volleyball players who have suitable
motor abilities needed for the sport and regarding the mental field are strong players or have
good or acceptable relationship with the coach, can get into the front-line with good chances
beside sufficient preparation.
5 References
BIRÓNÉ Nagy Edit (2004). Sportpedagógia. Dialóg Campus, Budapest-Pécs.
GOMBOCZ János (2004). A testnevelő tanár és az edző szerepe. In: Biróné Nagy Edit (szerk.).
Sportpedagógia. Dialóg Campus, Budapest-Pécs.
HANCIK Vladimir és mtsai (1990). Röplabdaedzés utánpótlás korú és felnőtt csapatok részére.
Hungaria Sport, Budapest.
HARSÁNYI László (2000). Edzéstudomány I. Dialóg Campus, Budapest-Pécs.
NÁDORI László (1991). Az edzés elmélete és módszertana. Magyar Testnevelési Egyetem,
Budapest.
SIGURD Baumann (2006). Csapatpszichológia. Dialóg Campus, Budapest-Pécs.
TRZASKOMA-BICSÉRDY Gabriella és mtsai (2009). Adatok a birkózók kiválasztásához és
beválásához. In: Bognár József (szerk.). Tanulmányok a kiválasztás és a
tehetséggondozás köréből. Magyar Sporttudományi Társaság, Budapest.
32
Sport Pedagogical and Psychological aspects
33
“Self”- conception formation at future specialists in sphere of physical culture and sport.
O. Kosobudskaya and N. Ershova,
Velikie Luki State Academy of Physical Culture and Sport, Russia.
Abstract
In sphere of physical training and sports many scientists are engaged in a problem of personalprofessional development of the future experts, because now in the course of change of the
higher educational system have increased requirements to quality of preparation. We supposed
that the system of the students’ psycho-pedagogical support is based upon a new students’ and
lecturers’ interaction during educational process. It was revealed that the students trained in
the system of psycho-pedagogical support had the level of the development of communication
skills more than 59%, empathy -52%, tolerance – 59%, reflection – 72%, emotional flexibility –
53%. These indicators are more than 14% higher than at students not involved in the
experiment. The analysis of the received results has allowed to allocate a number of the basic
tendencies of the student’s personal-professional development of sport academy. The analysis
of the received results has allowed to allocate a number of the basic tendencies of the student’s
personal-professional development of high school of physical training.
1 Introduction
In sphere of physical training and sports many scientists are engaged in a problem of personalprofessional development of the future experts, because now in the course of change of the
higher educational system have increased requirements to quality of preparation.
Modern requirements to the specialists make active a task of preparation of the
purposeful, independent, creative person showing high level of culture, structurally overcoming
arising stressful situations in life and activity (Khazova, 2008; Mitina, 2003; Toschenko, 2004).
Many psychologists suggest that the educational process in high school influences much
on developing “self’-conception in the whole. The certain life standpoint and professional
position defining the level of competence of the personality and professional are formed during
the educational process (Byorns, 1986; Khazova, 2008; Mitina, 2003).
However, the result of a traditional professional training in this area is the expert with the
standard thinking, focused on narrow understanding of the problems in the field of optimization
of pupils’ state of health, their physical activity, poorly showing the initiative and creativity in
professional work.
One of possible ways of solving this problem can be purposeful psycho-pedagogical
support of students, providing efficiency of the professional-personal becoming from the point
of view of preparedness for professional work (Ershova, 2004).
We define “support” as complete process of studying, forming, developing and correcting
the person’s professional becoming in the situation of high school training. It is focused on the
change of students’ educational activity. It promotes the creation of conditions of improvement
of educational quality.
2 Method
2.1 Subjects
34
The subjects were 163students of Velikie Luki State Academy of Physical Culture and Sport
(age 17-23). The investigation was based on questionnaires. In the analysis categories were
coded and grouped in themes according to their characteristic features and then non-parametric
statistics were used.
2.2 Purpose
The purpose of our study was to reveal the developed of “self”-conception at the future sports
specialists at different level of studying at high school and to define the organizationalpedagogical conditions promoting its development.
2.3 Tasks
a) To study the students’ ideas their ideal level of developed professionally important
skills necessary for the sports specialists.
b) To study “self”- conception of developed professionally important skills, at sports
specialists at the 1st, 3d, and 5th courses.
c) To reveal the distinctions in developed components of “self”-conception at different
grade levels of the sports academy.
2.4 Methods
2.4.1. Special literature analysis.
2.4.2. Psychodiagnostics methods.
a) The questionnaire for revealing of formation "Self" – concepts at the future
teachers-psychologists.
b) The Technique of revealing of communicative and organizing abilities.
c) The Questionnaire of revealing of communicative tolerance (V.V.Bojko).
d) The Test questionnaire of motivation affiliation measurement (The testquestionnaire of A.Mehrabiana modification).
e) Estimation to stress resistance (Medical center of Boston University).
f) The definition of emotional intelligence (Holl, N.).
2.4.3. Pedagogical experiment.
2.4.4. Methods of mathematic statistics.
3 Results and Discussion
Such qualities as empathy, reflection, tolerance, communicative skills, emotional flexibility,
stress tolerance, affiliation and organization skills were examined. We can see (Fig.1) that the
most significant professional quality for the 1-st year students is objectivity and the least
significant is affiliation. For the students of the 3-d course the most significant is
communicative skills and the lesser is tolerance. Students of the 5th course put on the first
place stress stability and the last place occupies affiliation.
At studying of an image "I"-real (Fig.2) it was revealed, that at students of the 1st course
communicative abilities are the most expressed, the less is tolerance; at the 3-d year students
communicative abilities have 8,95 and the less one is stress stability with 7,1. For the students
of the 5th course the most expressed are such qualities as stress-tolerance and emotional
flexibility 9,1 pts accordingly, and affiliation has only 7,2.
35
1
3
5
Figure 1. The average indices of the “Self”- ideal at students.
Figure 2. The average indices of the “Self”- real at students.
Having studied communicative skills (Fig.3), it was revealed, that at 35 % of students of the 1st
course and 50 % of students of the 3-d course the level of development of these skills are
high. It allows to make the conclusion, that to the 3-d course, they got professional knowledge
helping to come into contacts and to communicate with other people; easy to behave in new
collective; to defend the opinion. Besides they prefer to make independent decisions.
36
Figure 3.The level of communicative skills developed at the 1st and the 3d year students.
One of the basic skills, allowing to solve professional problems, there should be a tolerance. At
diagnosing of a level of tolerance development (Fig.4) it was established, that at 70 % of
examinees of the 1st course the low level of development of the given skill prevails. It testifies
that the dominating part of students does not possess professional abilities to show tolerance.
Figure 4. The level of communicative tolerance developed at students of the 1st course.
Studying stress stability (fig.5), it has been established, that at 60 % of the 3-d year students
this skill is on a low level development, while at 64,3 % of students of the 5th course its level is
high. It is possible to assume, that students by the end of the high school have necessary
professional knowledge and qualities which help them to resist to stressful situations, to
overcome difficulties, to suppress the emotions, to understand human moods.
37
Figure 5. The indices of stress stability at the 3d and the 5th year student.
One of the important qualities for the future sports specialists is the emotional flexibility. The
level of its (Fig.6) development at 64,2 % of examinees of the 5th course is high enough. It
allows to tell about the ability of good understanding of own emotions and emotions of other
people, responsiveness and emotional stability.
Figure 6. The indices of emotion flexibility at students of the 5th course year student.
It was established that the level of formed of components of “self”-conception and
components’ development at different steps of training is unequal and has nonlinear character.
The comparative analysis has shown that there were not reliable distinctions among “I”-ideal
38
and “I”-real estimated at the students of the 1st course; there were reliable distinctions at
students of the 3d course in such skills as: communicative and organizational. As for the 5th
year students there were reliable distinctions between “I”-ideal and “I”-real in all qualities
estimated. These results testify that the students receive necessary professional knowledge, get
some experience greatly influencing on “self”-conception developed.
It was revealed that the students trained in the system of psycho-pedagogical support
had the level of the development of communication skills more than 59%, empathy -52%,
tolerance – 59%, reflection – 72%, emotional flexibility – 53%, stress tolerance 64%, affiliation
55% and Organization skills 58%. These indicators are more than 14% higher than at students
not involved in the experiment.
4 Conclusions
The analysis of the received results has allowed to allocate a number of the basic tendencies of
the student’s personal-professional development of sport academy. The analysis of the received
results has allowed to allocate a number of the basic tendencies of the student’s personalprofessional development of high school of physical training. They are:
- level of the students’ professional-personal development depends on forming its
integrated characteristics;
- process of professional-personal development is caused by a complex of psychopedagogical conditions, main of which the technology of psycho-pedagogical support is;
- technology of realization of the psycho-pedagogical support, including pedagogical and
psychological methods of influence on the student, promote harmonization of students’
personality of high school of physical training, development of their need for self-knowledge,
self-improvement.
Thus, the application of the theoretical seminars, seminar-practical works, problem
lectures, different kinds of games and problem tasks, individual consultations, psychopedagogical support and personal-focused approach promoted the professional becoming in the
sphere of physical culture and sports and as a whole the development of “self”-conception.
The process of purposeful forming and developing of professionally important
qualities, and first of all such as empathy, reflection, tolerance, communicative skills,
emotional flexibility, stress tolerance has direct influence on the process of “self”-conception
development.
5 References
Byorns, E. ( 1986). Development “Self” – conception and education. Moscow: Progress (pp.
30-66).
Cai, Y., Reeve, S., & Robinson, D. T. (2002). Home schooling and teaching style: comparing
the motivating styles of home school and Public school teachers. Journal of Educational
Psychology, 2, 372 – 380.
Ershova, N.G. (2004). Psychological-pedagogical support of vocationally-personal
development of students at high school of physical culture: monograph, Velikie Luki
(pp. 85-140).
Khazova, S.A. (2008). Personal qualities of competitive expert in physical culture and sport.
Teoriya i prektika fizicheskoy kultury, 12, pp. 64-68.
Mitina, L.M. (2003). Psychology of development of competitive personality. Publ. h-se of
Moscow sociopsychological institute. Voronezh: MODEC.
39
Standage, M., Duda, J. & L., Ntoumanis, N. (2003). A model of contextual motivation in
Physical Education: using constructs from self determination and achievement goal
theories to predict physical activity Intentions. Journal of Educational Psychology, 1, 87
– 110.
Toschenco, Zh. (2004). Social paradoxes of higher education in Russia. Alma-mater, 5, 14-16.
Wolters, C. A. (2004). Advancing achievement goal theory: using goal structures and goal
orientation to predict student’s motivations, cognitions and achievement. Journal of
Educational Psychology, 2, 236 – 250.
40
Comparison of motor performance and social anxiety of 10-12-year-old PE class and
music class children.
Piroska Szalay, Marcell Ipach, Kornél Sipos and LászlóTóth,
Semmelweis Univesity,
Faculty of Physical Education and Sports Sciences ,
Health Science and Sports Medical Department, Hungary.
Abstract
Methods/Subjects: motor performance (static hanging with bent elbow/sec, standing log jump
/cm, number of sitting up during 30 sec), and social anxiety measures (social anxiety and
distress in new situations /SADN, fear of negative evaluation/FNE, and social anxiety and
distress in general/SADG) were compared for PE class and music class school children of 1012 year of age (N=132, PE student group=79, music student group = 55). BMI served the
differentiation of slim(G1), average (G2) and overweigh(3) boys and girls according to
Mészáros (2005). Basic statistics, Pearson correlation, ANOVA, and linear regression analysis
had been done with SPSS 15.0 for Windows. Cronbach alpha and part-whole correlation.
The only sex difference was found in BMI. It was significantly higher for boys than girls.
Calendar age correlated only with standing long jump for boys. There was no statistically
significant difference between PE class and music class students neither in the motor
performance tests, nor in social anxiety.
The most significant differences occurred for body weight subgroups with different feature in
boys and girls. ANOVA revealed longer static hanging with bent elbow and more number of
sitting up in group 1 /2 than in group 3 for boys. Standing long jump results differ significantly
for groups ½ form group 3 (boys), and group 1 from group 3 (girls). The regression analysis,
in the groups of boys, supported the casual relation between static hanging with bent elbow
and FNE, and between the calendar age and standing long jump.
It was concluded that the students of different specialized classes do not differ from each
other in motor performance and emotional characteristics.
Key words: motor performance, social anxiety, PE – music class comparison
1 Introduction
The Hungarian law of education § (8) says:
Those schools that have special classes (teaching faculties in higher amount of lessons), can
prepare their own educational program according to the children’s interests, preparedness or
future plans; and with this own program they can teach with a higher level curriculum than in
the normal (non-special class) schools.
Hypotheses:
We assumed that hypothesis number one is that
• H.1. Differences in the emotional test will be found between the two types of classes
As a second hypothesis we supposed that
41
•
H.2. Significant differences in the motor performance will be found between the two
classes
And thirdly we thought that
• H.3. At least one of the measured variables will show that the boys and girls had
significant differences in motor/emotional results
2 Method
In this research we used the SASC (Social Anxiety Scale for Children) test elaborated by A. H.
La Greca. Our motor test came from the Eurofit tests, we used 3 tests of them. We used SPSS
15.0 for data processing.
Children of classes four (4), five (5), and six (6) took part in the examination from the
Elementary School of Music and Physical Education, Budapest (n=134) The number of the
examined pupils was 134.
It was deemed important for the same teacher using the same methods, in both class types.
Other:
SASC test (Social Anxiety Scale for Children) test questions.
42
There are 3 main parts of this test.
SADN – social anxiety and distress in new situations
FNE – fear of negativ evaluation
SADG – social anxiety and distress in general
These are the illustrations of the 3 motor tests we were interested in.
1. Static hanging with bent elbow
2. Standing long jump
3. Sit ups for 30 seconds. (30 sec)
3 Results and Discussion
Table 1. The results of the examined groups can be seen here in the first table, such as hanging,
long jump, sit-ups, body mass index etc.
Descriptive Statistics
DECIM. AGE
HANGING
LONG JUMP
SIT-UPS
BMI
SADNSUM
FNESUM
GSUM
Valid N
(listwise)
N
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
Minimum
9,57
,00
100,00
,00
12,40
6,00
8,00
4,00
Maximum
13,34
62,10
200,00
32,00
32,00
30,00
39,00
17,00
134
40
Mean
11,1840
14,4358
150,4627
21,4478
21,4478
16,6791
18,8731
8,0970
Std. Deviation
,9403
14,3988
22,3794
5,1293
5,1293
4,7424
6,6597
3,2302
Table 2. In the second table we can see the 3 main factors of SASC (Social Anxiety Scale for
Children)test and Chronbach Alfa values in the bottom line, which show validity and reliability
of the test.N= 134.
SADN
FNE
GSUM
MEDIAN
16,68
18,87
8,09
SD
4,74
6,66
3,23
CR α
,62
,80
,58
Table 3. Differences between emotional test results I. Comparison of anxiety indices of the two
classes with a two-way t-test.
SADNSUM
FNESUM
GSUM
1=PE class
2=music class
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
N
Mean
79
55
79
55
79
55
17,2532
15,8545
18,3671
19,6000
8,1392
8,0364
Std.
Deviation
Std.Error
Mean
5,0140
4,2314
6,5284
6,8383
3,1204
3,4100
,5641
,5706
,7345
,9221
,3511
,4598
The results of the SASC (Social Anxiety Scale for Children) test show that there are no
statistically significant differences between the children of PE (Physical Education) and music
classes.
Table 4. Comparison of boys and girls in music class with a two-way t-test.
Decim. age
Hanging
Long jump
Sit ups
Sadnsum
Fnesum
Gsum
gender
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
1,00
2,00
N
24
31
24
31
24
31
24
31
24
31
24
31
24
31
Mean
11,3392
11,3442
15,9042
9,3677
145,5000
137,0645
21,0833
18,8387
14,5417
16,87*
18,6250
20,3548
7,2500
8,6452
Std.
Deviation
1,11205
,89687
17,86825
11,29154
22,82447
16,93701
4,32301
4,45044
4,83627
3,44230
6,84494
6,84859
3,17942
3,50760
Std. Error
Mean
,22700
,16108
3,64734
2,02802
4,65903
3,04198
,88243
,79932
,98720
,61826
1,39722
1,23004
,64900
,62998
p < 0,043 (t= -2,087; df= 53; N =55).
This result is very interesting because in the case of children going to music classes we found
significant difference between boys and girls in Social anxiety and distress in new situations.
(SADN). The result means that girls have greater fear in new situations than boys..
41
Motor differences between BMI groups.
Long jump
150
Hanging
147,2
18
145
15,9
16
140
14
135
12
Long jump
131,5
10
130
Hanging
8
125
5,16
6
4
120
BMI 1
BMI 3
2
0
BMI 1
BMI 3
Figure 1. thin (low weight) group
Figure 2. average group (normal weight
Sit ups
35
28,85
30
25
20
Sit ups
14,65
15
10
6,22
5
0
BMI 1
BMI 2
BMI 3
Figure 3. Overweight group (fatty).
The results were significant in the motor differences, in the diagrams.
Table 5. Comparing the results of the motor and anxiety tests produced by different classes.
DECIM. AGE
HANGING
LONG JUMP
SIT UPS
BMI
CLASS
N
MEAN
1
79
11,0741
2
55
11,3420
,9867
,1330
1
79
15,9785
14,0375
1,5793
2
55
12,2200
14,7487
1,9887
1
79
157,2278
21,5585
2,4255
2
55
140,7455
19,9770
2,6937
1
79
22,5823
5,2614
,5920
2
55
19,8182
4,4973
,6064
1
79
22,5823
5,2614
,5920
42
STD.
DEVIATION
STD.
ERROR
MEAN
,1009
SADNSUM
FNESUM
GSUM
2
55
19,8182
4,4973
,6064
1
79
17,2532
5,0140
,5641
2
55
15,8545
4,2314
,5706
1
79
18,3671
6,5284
,7345
2
55
19,6000
6,8383
,9221
1
79
8,1392
3,1204
,3511
2
55
8,0364
3,4100
,4598
Key: 1=PE class
2=Music class
Comparing the motor and anxiety results of the two classes, we haven’t found statistical
differences.
Results of Motor Tests of the Classes
Means of hanging by class
Means of long jump by class
18
160
16
155
14
12
150
10
Mean of hanging
Mean of long jump
8
145
6
4
140
2
135
0
PE class
PE class
Music class
Figure 4. Comparison of means hanging by
class.
Music class
Figure 5. Comparison means of long jump
by class.
M eans of sit ups by class
23
22,5
22
21,5
21
Mean of sit ups
20,5
20
19,5
19
18,5
PE class
Music class
Figure 6. Comparison of means sit ups by class.
In these figures shows that although there were differences in motor performance between the
two classes, these differences were not remarkable statistically.
44
Table 6. Comparing the results of the motor and anxiety tests by gender.
DECIM. AGE
HANGING
LONG JUMP
SIT UPS
BMI
SADNSUM
FNESUM
GSUM
GENDER
N
MEAN
STD.
DEVIATION
STD. ERROR
MEAN
1
83
11,0902
,9221
,1012
2
51
11,3367
,9587
,1342
1
83
17,2723
15,9638
1,7523
2
51
9,8196
9,9223
1,3894
1
83
157,0602
23,0431
2,5293
2
51
139,7255
16,4792
2,3075
1
83
22,8434
5,1855
,5692
2
51
19,1765
4,1699
,5839
1
83
22,8434
5,1855
,5692
2
51
19,1765
4,1699
,5839
1
83
16,3253
5,3536
,5876
2
51
17,2549
3,5034
,4906
1
83
18,0602
6,7794
,7441
2
51
20,1961
6,3024
,8825
1
83
7,6988
3,1728
,3483
2
51
8,7451
3,2468
,4549
Key : 1=boys; 2=girls
Comparing the results of the motor and anxiety tests by gender, haven’t found any statistically
significant differences either.
Results of Motor Tests of the Classes by Gender
Means of hanging by gender
20
Means of long jump by gender
15
Girls
10
Boys
5
160
Boys
155
150
Girls
0
145
Mean of hanging
Mean of long jump
140
135
130
Mean of long jump
Girls
Boys
Figure 7. Comparison of means hanging by
gender.
Figure 8. Comparison of means long jump
by gender.
44
Means of sit ups by gender
23
22
21
20
Mean of sit ups
19
18
17
Mean of sit ups
Girls
Boys
Figure 9. Comparison of mean numbers of sit ups by gender.
In these figures shows that although there were differences in motor performance between the two
genders, these differences were not remarkable statistically.
Hanging
Figure 10. Correlation of variables.
We applied regression analysis to examine how the variables relate to each other. Variables signed
by stars have effects on each other. This means that if the value of one variable changes, the other
variable’s value changes as well. For instance, the strength of correlation is 0.288 between hanging
and fear of negative evaluation (FNE).
In Figure 10 the correlation between static hanging and fear of negative evaluation (FNE) among
boys. There is a negative correlation between the two variables.
45
Table 7. Relations of the variables (Variables that take effect on each other).
Correlations
DECIM.
AGE
DECIM. AGE
HANGING
LONG JUMP
SIT UPS
BMI
SADNSUM
FNESUM
GSUM
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
Pearson
Correla
tion
Sig. (1tailed)
N
HANG
ING
LONG
JUMP
SADNS
UM
FNESU
M
1,000
-,047
,169(*)
,048
,048
-,003
,093
,021
,
,293
,025
,292
,292
,486
,142
,403
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
1,000
,532(*
*)
,490(**
)
,490(**
)
-,087
134
,288(**
)
-,047
,293
,
,000
,000
,000
,158
,000
,003
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
,169(*)
,532(*
*)
1,000
,581(**
)
,581(**
)
,003
-,111
-,120
,025
,000
,
,000
,000
,484
,100
,083
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
,048
,490(*
*)
,581(*
*)
1,000
1,000(*
*)
-,068
-,165(*)
-,140
,292
,000
,000
,
,000
,217
,028
,053
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
,048
,490(*
*)
,581(*
*)
1,000(*
*)
1,000
-,068
-,165(*)
-,140
,292
,000
,000
,000
,
,217
,028
,053
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
-,003
-,087
,003
-,068
-,068
1,000
,532(**
)
,429(**)
,486
,158
,484
,217
,217
,
,000
,000
134
134
,288(*
*)
134
134
134
134
134
134
-,111
-,165(*)
-,165(*)
,532(**)
1,000
,576(**)
,093
SIT
UPS
BMI
GSUM
-,236(**)
,142
,000
,100
,028
,028
,000
,
,000
134
134
,236(*
*)
134
134
134
134
134
134
-,120
-,140
-,140
,429(**)
,576(**
)
1,000
,021
,403
,003
,083
,053
,053
,000
,000
,
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
134
46
*
Corr
elati
on is
signi
fican
t at
the
0.05
level
(1taile
d).
**
Corr
elati
on is
signi
fican
t at
the
0.01
level
(1-
Figure 11. Correlation of variables II.
This figure (fig. 11.) show that there is negative correlation between hanging and general sum
(GSUM) among boys.
Answers for the hypotheses
Our hypotheses have partly been confirmed.
H. 1: Differences in the emotional test were found between the children of the two different
classes.
H. 2: In case of motor results our hypothesis didn’t prove true, because no significant differences
were found between the children of the two classes.
H. 3: The third hypothesis was verified, because we found significant differences in motor and
emotional results between the two genders.
4 Summary
In the school, which we examined the children of the two classes had quite similar results both in
motor and in emotional tests.
We recommend that the number of schools with special classes should be increased rather than
reduced. The purpose of increasing the number of PE lessons in schools is not just specializing in
sports, but it creates the basis of a healthy way of life. We think that anxiety that appears in
children’s behaviour leads to problematic situations, and the aim of our work is to teach the pupils
to handle these situations without fear.
5
Conclusions
47
Our final conclusion is the following: the personality of the teacher is the determining factor in the
teaching process. Our results show that the same teacher, using the same methods in both class
types, reached similar results.
In the future we are planning to extend the research to other schools, and other classes and we also
want to apply additional motor and emotional tests.
6
References
Greca A.M. Dandes S. k. wick R., Shaw K.,and Stone , W.L. (1988). Development of the social
Anxiety Scale for Children. Reliability and concurent validity . Journal of clinical Child
Psychology, 17. pp. 84-91.
Mészáros János (2003). A gyermeksport biológiai alapjai, [The Biological Basis Of Children's
Sport] Platin - Print Bt., Budapest
Patakiné Sós Mária (1983). Pszichológia, [Psychology] Medicina Könyvkiadó, Budapest
Rákos Etelka (1991). Serdülőkorú tanulók szorongásvizsgálata, különös tekintettel a szociális
szorongásra, Doktori Disszertáció [Examination Of Anxiety In Teenagers Regarding
Especially To Their Social Anxiety, PhD Thesis]
Rókusfalvy Pál (1981). Sportpszichológia, [Sports Psychology] Athenaeum, Budapest Hungary
Sarason, I. G. (1984). Stress anxiety and cognitive interference: Reactions to tests, Journal of
Personality and social Psychology, 46. 929-938.
Sarason, I. G. (1980) Introduction to the study of test anxiety, In: Sarason, I. G. (ed) Test anxiety;
Theory, research, and applications, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N. J. 3-14.
Szmodis Márta, Mészáros János (2003).: A kövér fiúk testzsírja és antropometriai jellemzői,
valamint motorikus teljesítménye közötti kapcsolat, Kalokagathia, 1.sz. pp. 42-64. [The
Relationship Between Body Fat Of Obese Boys And Their Antropometric Characteristics
And Motoric Performance]
48
The use of the calorimetric system to measure factors related to the competence of teachers of
primary school.
Stefano Di Tore *, Paola Aiello * , Antinea Ambretti *, Gaetano Raiola *, Maurizio Sibilio *, Nadia
Carlomagno **
*
Department of Educational Sciences, University of Salerno, Italy.
**
Faculty of Science of Formation, University of Naples, Italy.
Abstract
In Italy the family doctor, who is not necessarily a specialist in sports medicine,
according to the Ministerial Decree of 28.2.1983, is called to certify the state of health
that allows the person to participate in non competitive sports and motor activities. At
school, in Italy is required the practice of motor and sports activities from the first grade
of primary school and the Decree of the President of the Republic n.403 of 20.10.1993 ,
in Article 10, states that the family doctor should authorize with a certificate (valid for
one year) the participation in non-competitive sports activities at school. The medical
examination for children of primary school does not require tests of the reaction of the
cardiovascular system to physical effort during intense physical activity. In this sense,
the physical activities and school sports are configured as light physical activities that
do not require the use of intense effort, not appropriate for students aged from 5 years
and six months to 10 years. The physical and sports activities in the Italian primary
school should therefore be “light” activities to enable pupils to build a true well-being
through the gradual understanding of the impact of the movement, its benefits and
drawbacks of the intense practice during childhood and pre-adolescence in the absence
of adequate health checks. The latest Guidelines of the Italian Ministry of Education
(2007) in the section on "Body, movement and sport”, motor and sports activities
contribute to" ... the knowledge and awareness of the body's identity as well as to the
need to take care of one’s own person and welfare”. In particular, the "wellness recalls
the need that in the curriculum of education shall be included experiences that lead to
healthy lifestyles. The goals for the achievement of the competences stated in the Italian
Ministerial Documents require that the Italian students attending primary school, in the
first three years, acknowledge "some basic principles relating to the mental and
physical well-being depending on the care of his/her body “and in the fourth and fifth
year of school is able to "recognize the relationship between diet, physical exercise and
health, taking appropriate behaviors and healthy lifestyles."
*
Stefano Di Tore : Corresponding author. Phd student in “Pedagogical and Didactics and Political-Social Analysis Processes “ at the Department of
Educational Sciences of the University of Salerno.
*
Paola Aiello : Co-author . Didactics Coordinator of the research. Phd student in “Methodology of Educational Research” at the Department of
Educational Sciences of the University of Salerno. She has worked on the didactics and methodological aspects of the research.
*
Antinea Ambretti: Co-author. She has worked on the coherence between the research and the Guidelines of the Ministry of Education. Phd student
in “Pedagogical and Didactics and Political-Social Analysis Processes “ at the Department of Educational Sciences of the University of Salerno.
*
Gaetano Raiola: Co-author: Organizational coordinator of the research. Phd candidate in “Movement Science and Sports” at the University “Foro
Italico” in Rome and Lecturer at the University of Salerno.
*
Maurizio Sibilio - Co-author. He has worked on the methodology of the research. Full Professor of “Methods and Teaching of Sports Activities” at
the Department of Educational Sciences - University of Salerno-Italy.Director of the Interdepartmental Centre of “Health, Sport and Integration
Processes” – University of Salerno-Italy. Responsible of the Handicap Laboratory at the Faculty of Formation Sciences – University of Salerno Italy.
*
Nadia Carlomagno - Scientific coordinator of the research. She is Researcher in Methods and Didactics of Physical Activities at the University "Suor
Orsola Benincasa”, Faculty of Science of Formation in Naples.
49
Italy has progressively tried to meet the expectations of the Italian Ministry of Education
on the safeguarding of health through movement activities with the the training of
primary schools teachers since 1998 setting a four-year course of study at University.
The hypothesis of the research is that the low number of teachers trained in the teaching
of motor activities, which in 2007 was only 6.8% (Sibilio et al.), still affects the practice
of motor and sports activities not satisfying the parameters of safety and not always
related to the category of light physical activities” guaranteed by the medical suitability
for
non-competitive
sports
activities.
To assess these factors it has been chosen to monitor the energy expenditure of primary
school students during the execution of a light physical activity (warm–up activity)
conducted according to the teaching methods freely chosen by the teachers and
consequently comparing the data emerged with the standard classification of the energy
expenditure of physical activities.
1 Introduction
Several studies conducted at the international level in recent years have highlighted the importance
of teachers training in physical and sports activities for the development of healthy and effective
motor habits in children attending primary schoo (Stewart et al., 2004; Faircloughet al., 2006,
Bailey et al., 2009).
It is therefore evident the importance of the didactics of motor activities aimed at the prevention of
diseases.
In response to this need of teachers’ qualification in motor activities, in Italy it has been paid more
attention in motor and sports activities practice. The definition of primary school teachers training
in Italy has in fact followed a long process that began to produce its effects only in 1998. The
Ministerial Decree 26/05/98 (G.U. 3/07/98) no. 153, establishing the Degree course in Sciences of
Primary Education, started the new university formation of teachers targeted, for the first time, to
the academic qualification of infant and primary school teachers creating, at the same time, an
institutionally recognized training dimension of physical education.
The updating of teachers training has not been followed by an updating of the rules to manage this
matter in the school system. If to practice agonistic and professional sports, there are rules to protect
health through medical visits and tests to define the suitability or unsuitability to practice sports, it
is not required any medical certification to practice motor and playful activities in the infant school.
It is only required in primary and secondary schools in the following cases:
1) physical and sports activities planned by School for extracurricular activities;
2) preparation activities for National Students Games. The teacher is then alone to manage many
issues inherent to motor education such as the assessment of the physical activities and the health
of its students.
1.1 Aim
The aim of this research was to assess whether the teaching methodology used by teachers in
primary school during physical education lessons is consistent with the current National Guidelines
of the Ministry of Education and whether they can be included in specific categories of "light
physical activity" whose practice is authorized by the medical certification required by Italian
primary schools. To assess these factors it has been chosen to monitor the energy expenditure of
students during the practice of a light physical activities, specifically warm-up activities using
teaching methods freely chosen by teachers comparing the collected data with the standard
classification of the energy expenditure of physical activities.
50
2
Methods
The methodology used has envisaged the following phases:
Planning of an agreement school-university to share the aim, methods and procedure of the
research.
1. Arrangement of an informative report to collect data on age, weight, height, diets,
or any sports practiced as well as information about students’ lifestyles;
2.
Training to teachers on how to use the portable multi sensor monitoring system
(calorimeter).
3.
Request to perform a warm-up physical activity to the students of a total duration
of 15 minutes;
4.
Required physical activity collecting data of the caloric consumption of each
student;
5.
Analysis and processing of data related to the calorimetric recordings made with
the production of a vertical bar graph showing the average total energy
expenditure and the actual average expenditure for the practiced physical activity.
2.1 Sample
The research was carried out using as a sample students attending the primary school of
Campania Region (Italy) formally agreed with the Department of Educational Sciences of the
University of Salerno for a total of 76 students from 5 classes including 2 year-three classes and
3 four-year classes.
2.2 Standards
According on the intensity and duration of gesture, physical activities can be classified according to
energy expenditure requested. To evaluate the energy expenditure is increasingly being used the
MET unit. MET = O2 consumption per unit of time linked to basal metabolism. The MET is
therefore a measure of the intensity of exercise. 1 MET is approximately equal to oxygen consumed
for basal functions of various organs by a man at rest. Therefore can be considered of mild intensity
physical activities, those activities that have energy expenditure around 3 METs, moderate-intensity
physical activities than those involving energy consumption between 3 and 6 METs, medium and
high intensity physical activity those that cause high energy consumption more than 6 METs. 1
2.3 Instruments
As a calorimetric monitoring system was used the portable metabolic holter BodyMedia that
enables the recording and analysis of accurate data on energy expenditure, physical activity and
lifestyle. The system is made of a clinically validated portable calorimeter, the SenseWear
Armband, and a software for viewing and analyzing data. The Armband continuously records a
series of physiological data of the body. The collected data are then analyzed, graphically
displayed and presented by the software on a report that clearly shows the energy expenditure of
the subject.
3 Results
1
Macchi C, Molino Lova R., Cecchi F.,Sibilio.M (2008),Attività fisica dieta e salute,Firenze:Le Lettere
51
Table 1 shows the standard of energy expenditure for light, moderate and intense physical
activity, and Table 2 shows the effective expenditure of the detected METs.
Table 1. The standard of energy expenditure for light, moderate and intense physical activity.
mild intensity
physical
activities
< 3.0 METs
moderate-intensity
physical activities
3.0-6.0 METs
medium and high
intensity physical
activity
> 6.0 METs
Table 2 shows the effective expenditure of the detected METs.
Height
Weight
Kcal
METs Average
METs Dev.St
Cff var
3a
134,56
34,79
62,50
6,53
0,47
7,14%
3b
131,24
34,36
52,47
5,90
0,47
8,00%
4a
143,29
45,19
75,64
6,26
0,41
6,54%
4b
138,71
37,48
58,43
6,00
0,46
7,67%
4c
137,60
39,33
63,33
6,19
0,80
12,89%
TOT
136,79
38,00
62,09
6,17
0,57
9,24%
Figure 1. The actual consumption
52
As can be seen from Table 2, energy expenditure in detected METs is not in the standards that
define physical activity as light as that of warm-up.
In particular in 100% of examined cases energy expenditure is over 3 METs and in 55% of
energy expenditure observed is over 6 METs falling within the average expected values for
heavy physical activity. The variability of the observed phenomenon expresses a relative
homogeneity in Energy consumption, as shown in Table 2, however, the average energy
expenditure stood at 6.17 METs, exceeding the value of 3 METs requirements for light physical
activity. Figure 1 shows how the actual consumption is relatively homogeneous in each class
and how it exceeds the expected energy expenditure.
Figure 2 shows a comparison between the energy expenditure standards for light activities such
as warm-up and the energy expenditure that was observed, highlighting that the activity
effectively practiced by the pupils can not be considered light physical activity.
Figure 2. A comparison between the energy expenditure standards for light activities.
4 Discussion and conclusions
The collected data show that the teaching methodology used by teachers appear homogeneous but
not suitable to the teaching of “warm-up” physical activities. The data also show that the activities,
even if defined as non-competitive activities, are considered performances that normally require a
further medical examination with "stress test" to determine the suitability to practice competitive
sports.
This highlights the lack of knowledge by teachers about the effects produced by the applied
teaching methods and the proposed activities providing the possibility of a further deep analysis of
the training needs of teachers. Nowadays despite the attention paid to their training at academic
level, it is still very weak in terms of teaching methodology and assessment. The data can also be
interesting to prevent the risks on health stressing the importance of the capacity of teachers to
estimate the energy expenditure and the physical effort required by their proposed motor activities
53
preventing the risk that movement activities considered "light" by teachers are too intense to be
potentially unhealthy for the students.
5 References
Arvidsson D, Slinde F, Larsson S, Hulthén L. (2007). Energy cost of physical activity in children:
Validation of senseware armband. Med Sci Sport Exercise Nov;39 (11):2076-84.
Bailey, R., Armour, K., Kirk, D., Jess, M., Pickup, I. & Sandford, R. (2008). The Educational
Benefits Claimed for Physical Education and School Sport: An Academic Review, Research
Papers in Education, pp. 1-26.
Fairclough, S.J.; Stratton, G. (2006). A review of physical activity levels during elementary school
physical education.’ Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 25(2): 239-257.
Hay P. (2006). Assessment for learning in physical education, in D.Kirk, D. MacDonald & M.
O’Sullivan(Eds) International handbook of research in physical education (London,
UK,Sage), 312-325.
Jakicic U.S., Marcus M., Gallagher K.I., Randall C., Thomas E., Goss FL., Robertson RJ. (2004).
Evaluation of the SenseWear Pro Armband to assess energy expenditure during exercise Med Sci Sports Exercise. 36 (5) pp. 897-904.
Macchi C, Molino Lova R., Cecchi F.,Sibilio.M (2008),Attività fisica dieta e salute,Firenze:Le
Lettere.
Penney D., Brooker R., Hay p., Gillespie L.(2009). Curriculum, pedagogy and assessment: three
message systems of schooling and dimensions of quality physical education. Sport, Educatio
and Society, 14(4), pp.421-442.
INDICAZIONI PER IL CURRICOLO
54
PE project
H. Ekler Judit
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus
hekler@mnsk.nyme.hu;
Abstract
The everyday-like form of the project can be fixed into the education-pedagogical process of P.E.
lessons very well. Firstly, because the arrangement of the material, which is based on project-logic,
deals with a certain topic or curriculum within 3-4-6-week-long periods, is a common practice on
the P.E. lessons. On the other hand, the project can be renewed on the P.E. lessons also from
different aspects. Approaching the chosen topic from different point of views can activate children
to individual, creative work. It makes the measurement possible, more over, inevitable in the
beginning and the end of the project work, which can be used for checking the individual
development and progress. Associating the movement materials of the project topic with other kind
of information can help us with identifying and understanding connections between cause and
effect. So, beyond the actual motivation, it can be the tool of attitude- and lifestyle formation.
Key-words: project, motivation, self-expression, connection with other subjects
1 Introduction
Among the duties of P.E. we can mention the establishment of needs for movements needed for the
healthy- and movement-rich lifestyle and for the good fitness condition (NAT, 2007). Its goal is
reached if all these objectives are fulfilled in the case of every student. However, our students
strongly differ from one another, both physically (Vajda et all, 2010) and psychically, socially
(Mihály, 2007; Németh Gáborné Doktor, 2008). Thus, monitoring the motivation, differentiation
and individual progress period is a more currant issue in P.E. than it used to be.
Increase in the number of P.E. lessons as a positive change can be only effective by reforms of
content and methodology. One possible way is the project-based learning. This kind of learning
requires interdisciplinary approach by which the often isolated curriculum becomes much more
lifelike. Many times the project-oriented learning happens outside school or with the help of private
people, which strengthens further the relation of the learned material and real life. The projects form
the real and natural learning process, so they are suitable for educating the easy-to-handle, talented
children and also for hard-to-handle, so called problematic children within the ordinary educational
frames (M. Nádasi, 2003). Advantages of the project-method can affect the teachers, too as this
kind of learning changes the role of teachers. But they have to be prepared for this role. So, the
methodological material is part of the P.E. lesson project in our Institution which is presented in this
project, as well.
In most of the cases we can hear about big and long projects which deal with more subjects or even
the whole school or at least with one certain grade. Such kinds of projects are connected to many
sports or physical education, for example health week, Olympic project, circus project (Hajagos &
Hamar). However, our experiment deals with shorter projects which aim to renew the methodology
of the P.E. lessons.
2 Method
55
Research period: February 2010 – May 2010
Sample: 32 PE teachers took part in the research. They teach Grades 3-12 and have spent 1-25 years
in teaching so far. They formed 5 groups (3x6 persons, 2x7 persons) in the experiment where
beginner teachers took part in the same rate as teachers with more than 10 years experience.
The objective of the experiment:
- spreading the project-type curriculum processing in Physical Education
- presenting the phases of already tested P.E. projects
- getting to know the opinion of P.E. teachers who lead the project
The process of experiment:
a.) Preparation for the experiment (February 2010): we dealt with basic questions about the theory
and practical side of project teaching on P.E. lessons in the form of consultations. After discussing
it, the participant groups chose project topics. These were: 6:3; Vizes hetes (Wet Sevens); Futsal;
Erdei Zsolt and Testépítés (Bodybuilding). The groups agreed on the starting point and the main
direction of the topic (brainstorming).
b.) Experimental phase (February-May 2010): Teachers, who were involved in the research, carried
out the project in an optionally chosen class of their own school. Common parameters of the
project: setting of the topic, forming the process of the project work based on the students’ ideas,
dividing the tasks, defining the measurements, measuring the level of the starting point, working on
the project (2-4 weeks), final measurement, summary, evaluation. Each P.E. teacher wrote a diary
about the process of the project and also collected own documentation.
c.) Final phase (May 2010): The groups had a final discussion and evaluation with the following
subtasks: making a project map, measurement, evaluation in the project, listing the performed work,
connected subjects and persons.
3 Results
a.) Phases of the Physical Educational project and its characteristics
Project map
Working on most of the topics happened with the help of project maps which were created by
teachers and students together. The project map is a collection of the connected ideas. This is the
basic for defining the project objectives, choosing and dividing the tasks and duties, preparation of
the time schedule.
In the case of a P.E. project it is worth mentioning – during the making of the project map – that
most parts of the project must serve the movement, movement learning, skill development and
practice. We must take care that the rate of the lots of interesting associated areas (other subjects,
extra-curricular programs) and the movement activities should not collapse.
Activities
One of the advantages of the project-based learning is that getting the knowledge, learning and
practice happen throughout activities, with the active participation of students. The 6:3 (the famous
soccer triumph of the Hungarian national team against the British one) project was held up as a
model. In this project such usual, topic-related movement activities can be found as practising the
technical and tactical elements of football on lessons and trainings, and home-made school
competitions.
However, these usual movement activities are surrounded by such circumstances which draw and
maintain attention. These are lessons or trainings with the leadership and participation of football
players, coaches; and school competitions with teams of parents, teachers, and professional players.
Movement activities were supplemented by collection of information about the Golden Team, the
present Hungarian selected team, the rules and officiating. During this work children used diverse
56
information sources. Parts of the information were collected during interview making or
conversations. So, they got in touch with persons connected to the heyday of football or the presentday football. While going to the trainings and football matches, they could become acquainted with
the duties of the masseur and sport doctor. On the one hand, exhibiting and presenting the collected
material and the documents of their own activities helped the interest to be kept alive. On the other
hand, they gave emergence and the experience of success for the smart students in different fields.
Curricular/scientific relations:
During the 6:3 project children got in touch with many kinds of subjects and sciences.
Firstly, we have to emphasise the cognition of training and the theory of P.E. – trainings, warming
up, technique and tactics of football, its rules, etc. – and making it real. Realizing regularities,
relations between cause and effect in movement activities and on trainings can lead the children to
the voluntarily chosen, active lifestyle. Based on the sportsmen’s diet and lifestyle we could gain
biological information and by studying the era’s remnants (material-, written- and film documents)
we could get historical data. Arts also appeared in the projects. Based on the topic, students made
drawings in many classes and their work of art was exhibited. The original record of the 1953 match
was watched in every class which was also interpreted from the point of view of sport and also film.
The famous sport reporter, György Szepesi’s commentary also affected many people greatly and
encouraged the “commentary” of the school matches. Some features about the topic also appeared
in the projects. By watching them, students could see the history of the 1960s. A film and several
photos were also made of the school competition. By making each team individual (creating
emblems, flags, team-song, and battle cry), children could be also creative.
Lastly, I mention informatics as searching on the Internet means almost a routine activity for the
students.
Personal relations:
Getting to know other adults apart from the P.E. teacher during the project work meant a great
experience for the children as specialists within a certain sport (masseur, referee) and their job was
very inspiring for the children.
Becoming acquainted with the active sports participants of the 1960s or collectors of sport relics is
also an interesting program.
The power of sporting with parents is well-known for everybody. Students also got into contact
with teachers of other subjects in new kinds of situations (common sporting, learning information
about subjects based on the students’ questions), which fact could arouse their motivation towards
sport and the given subject.
b.) Measurement, evaluation
There should be a state- or level condition survey in the beginning of the projects in order to
monitor the individual progress. Of course, its methods and devices match to the nature of the
evaluated material. In many cases, the P.E. teacher colleagues who lead the project rely only on
their observations. If it was possible – as for example during the 6:3 project – skill levels and sport
technical tasks were measured in the beginning and end of the project.
Evaluation happened in two ways. Activity and the standard of the concrete movements during the
project activity were usually only positively evaluated. Evaluation happened by marks (5-mark
scale), prizes and also orally in front of the audience (sometimes in front of bigger, out of class
communities).
4 Discussion
57
The objective of the project experiment was to try out the project-based education in the process of
the everyday P.E. education. We aimed to find out whether the small projects which serve as tool
for the curriculum processing, work in physical education or not. Furthermore, we were also
interested how teachers who are used to the traditional teaching methods can take advantage of this
method.
The reaction of those colleagues who took part in the experiment has changed radically during the 4
months. In the beginning of the experiment they did not understand the necessity of it and were
absolutely sceptical. However, changes appeared during their preparation and on group discussions
which were about the project topics. It became clear to every P.E. teacher that certain parts of the
method – 3-6-week-long material separation along with a main material, making biomechanical or
physical regularities in sports movements realized, relation with actual sport events, etc – appeared
also on P.E. lessons so far, though mainly now and then. The real breakthrough in the attitude of
our colleagues happened during operating projects and project processes. The ideas itself, and its
novelty, curiosity, versatility provided motivation for all the students. So, on the final discussion
meeting we could hear the evidently positive opinion of teachers about the project-based
educational on P.E. lessons.
The activity of students undoubtedly increased in the fields of movements and other activities, too.
As other kinds of curricular activities appeared on the P.E. lesson, too, those children also became
active who were not previously. In the case of many types of activities and also in movement
activities, differentiation resulted from itself. So, varied activities of the project proved the
experience of success for many students.
Self-sufficiency, separate work process, cooperative solutions among each other and building of
out-of-school relationships also described the process. However, the autocratic behaviour of
teachers is still needed to be changed on.
The isolation of subjects was dissolved by the project activity. Connecting the coherent parts of
different fields of sciences helps the comprehension, the consciousness and the relation of studies
with the real life.
The less effective part was the measurement/evaluation. Individual placement testing and its userfriendly devices are needed to be created, not only in the field of skills but also about movement
knowledge.
In case of certain projects, the rate of activities which are connected to the movement activities
(performances, visits, drawings, etc.) exceeds the expected norm. We should not forget that the
objective of the project is the Physical Education and the sport.
As individual work and planned work is one of the leading motives of the project, students’
individual work even at home should get more important role. In the case of adequate motivation
and systematic measurement of the individual progress, movement activity can be continued at
home as “homework”. Hereby, we would be much closer to the aim of Physical Education which is
the movement-rich, active, healthy way of life.
5 References
Elbert Gábor (2010). Testnevelési és európai kulcskompetenciák a közoktatásban. Magyar
Sporttudományi Szemle. 11. évf. 41.szám 10-13.
Hajagos László, Hamar Pál: Projektoktatás és cirkuszprojekt I.- II. rész Retrieved August 07, 2010,
from http://mcteka.shp.hu/.../hpc_member.php?...hajagos_hamar;
http://epa.oszk.hu/01400/01461/00002/hajagos.htm
Mihály Ildikó (2007). Differenciáltan. Törekvések a személyre szabott oktatásra. Új Pedagógiai
Szemle. október
M. Nádasi Mária (2003). Projektoktatás. Gondolat Kiadói Kör, Budapest, (Oktatás-módszertani
kiskönyvtár.)
58
NAT (2007). A NAT cél- és követelményrendszere. Oktatási és Kulturális Minisztérium, Budapest.
Németh Gáborné Doktor Andrea (2008). A szociális kompetencia fejlesztésének lehetőségei az
iskolában. Új Pedagógiai Szemle. január
Vajda Ildikó, Batta Klára, Hegedűs Ferenc, Vajda Tamás, Pampakas Polydoros, Bartusné Szmodis
Márta (2010). A testi fejlettség, a relatív testzsírtartalom és a Cooper-próbával jellemzett
állóképesség nemzedékenkénti különbségei általános iskolás fiúknál. Magyar
Sporttudományi Szemle. 11. évf. 41.szám 20-25.
59
Research into pedagogical impacts on the movement development of crèche children.
E. Bucsy and A.Bakk,
Benedek Elek Faculty of Pedagogy, University of West Hungary, Sopron, Hungary.
60
Canoe sport and positive psychology.
A. Szabó,
University of Szeged, Faculty of Art, Graduate School of Educational Sciences, Hungary.
Abstract
In our study we compared the psychology immune competence values of two groups. The
participants are former kayak-canoe sportsmen, and teachers who don’t do any sports. 50
former sportsmen and 50 teachers participated in our study. The participants filled four
questionnaires.
It is very important in the life of a top competitor and his trainer to make a good decision
at the right time. It can be determinant in the later career and can influence private life
too. It concerns of course every field however it is even more important in our profession.
Work of a trainer is about that we are who consider alternatives and determine the right
way instead of the competitor as well. I am sure in one thing that is we can only achieve
our aims if we have enormous humility towards the trainer profession and the sport itself.
It is necessary to indoctrinate our competitors with this ethical attitude in order to they
become world class competitors. Among the several circumstances the most important is
maybe the creation of the training system based on performance, in which the competitor
can belong in and endure the load fitting for his age. I build this system from the tradition
of this sport, experience and the specific training methods. One of the problems concerns
how we can build the talented young competitors in the world famous adult team. Presentday successful trainers often get into a situation like this and in these matters we
absolutely shirk for ourselves. Of course, class competitors are provided with everything
by the Kayak Canoe Association which is necessary for their preparation but this is not the
case with the second line. It is a thankless task to decide who should be promoted for the
future Olympic athletes and this decision is made by trainers. It does not always pleasure
for older aged world class competitors and that is why conflict can arise against a less
experienced but talented young person.
The main goal of my stady was to entrance trainer’s pedagogical profiles. It could be
proved my statistical analyses that profesional sport could help in coping strategies. and
its also important sheto assess the effect of the new method could you measureal.
Antonowsky (1979) has studied that: How be people could healthy in the fall of their
problems? Batta (2004) has found that them are differens in characters of personality
betwen active and non-active people. Csikszentmihályi and Seligman (2000) developed the
possibility to use the psychology of people and talent to strengthem.
61
1 Introduction
The latest trend of coaching is to enhance productivity as well as mental capacity. Therefore this
study is based on two models, that is, the Flow theory of Mihály Csíkszentmihályi and that of
Antonovsky’s.
During training, the body should be strengthened so as to be able to tolerate and bear strains and
stress. A special tailor made training plan will enable competitors to cope with this flow while
preparing sportsmen for competitions. It is evident that this stress and hard work bring about other
personal/individual problems (Csíkszentmihályi , 2009).
Aims
- To map up the protective factors developed by doing sports
- To change trainers’ attitudes on the basis of the outcomes
- To work out methods supporting sportsmen/women to be able to adapt
themselves into civil life.
2 Methods
Population of the research:
- 50 kayak-canoe professional competitors
- Control group with: 50 teachers
To gain data in relation to psychological immune competence the Questionnaire of Psychological
Immune- system ( PIK Oláh 1996) was used. The 16 scales attempt to identify the interviewees’
stress-resistance. Each scale has 5 items and the participants can indicate to what extant they think.
The questions may be relevant for them
- Valid outcome can be gained only in the state
of flow
- Each successful professional has already
experienced flow
- This psychological immune system
strengthened by trainings and competitions
will support the individuals’ life and career.
3 Results
In case of educators there is a significant difference within the feeling of coherence due to the strict
rules of sports. Sports do not support sportsmen/women in the third dimension of education, namely
to acquire skills enabling them to act autonomously . Actually rules will control their life
(Gombócz, 2007). Bearing this fact in our mind indicate that we should develop the educative and
pedagogic strategy of trainings. It is also crucial to make a plan that focuses on enhancing the
awareness of the importance of experiencing FLOW as well positive thinking.
62
scale
sportsmen
Positive thinking 15,36
feeling of
growth
14,91
emotional
control
13,14
feeling of
control
16,05038
feeling of
coherence
14,18148
Self-esteem
15,59645
challenge,
flexibility
15,56575
ability of social
monitoring
14,05276
Inventiveness
14,69425
feeling of self
efficiency
15,1595
ability of social
mobility
14,20229
social creativity 14,85873
the skill of
synchron
14,20444
Stamina
13,76274
Impulse control 14,73597
quick
Figure 1. Outcomes of temper,inhibition 12,5463
teachers
14,84
szign.
-
15,41
-
13,41
-
13,9304919 0,00001
15,4133708 0,035813
14,9512208 15,1545048 13,6325841 14,0734705 15,0455628 14,2191835 13,2407515 0,004537
14,2046364 14,0519058 13,5181567 0,014494
13,1694178 -
Figure 2. Significant outcomes of the 4 factors
63
PIK scale.
Figure 3. The avarage of the survey
4 References
Antonovsky A. (1979) Helth stress, and coping:new perspektives on mental and physical wellbeing. Josef Bass, san Francisko.
Gombócz J. 2007, A sport és nevelés harmadik dimenziója, OSK , Eger.
Oláh A. (2005) Érzelmek, megküzdés és optimális élmény Trefort kiadó , 85-93
Seligman, M.E.P. és Csíkszentmihályi M.(2009) Possitive Psychology: An Introduction
American Psychologist, 55. 5-14
Csikszentmihályi M .(1991) FLOW. A tökéletes élmény pszichológiája.
64
Empowerment, locus of control and professional interests: an action research with Kore
University students
Rosaria Schembri1, Pietro Mango1, Marco Arpino2, Riccardo Tangusso1 and Simona Nicolosi3
1
PhD Students in Vocational guidance sciences University of Cassino and Kore University of Enna,
Italy
2
PhD Student in Physical activities and sport sciences in education and high performance, Kore
University of Enna, Italy
3
Researcher, Kore University of Enna, Italy
Abstract
The aim of our action research was to analyse the different factors playing a role in the
professional choices and chosen career profiles of students at Kore University. To achieve our
goal, we analysed motivational factors, psychological interpersonal adjustment, self empowerment,
locus of control, coping strategies, professional interests and values.
We surveyed a sample of fifty students attending Physical activities and sport sciences and
Architecture courses degrees, gender balanced. The research intervention aimed at helping
students in their professional choices and building all the skills that the job market requires. We
carried out two focus groups for each degree course: 1) Self empowerment; 2) Locus of control. In
each focus group a counsellor supported students in analysing their motivational and choice
awareness process concerning their professional carriers.
After the intervention, it is possible to have a change in the variables already collected. Results
may provide suggestions to design objectives and curricula of Physical activities and sport sciences
degree courses.
1 Introduction
Our research action is based on the social cognitive theory on the observational learning developed
by Albert Bandura, the founder of social cognitive theory (Bandura, 1977). Bandura's researches
broadened the knowledge on the learning process, focusing on the different ways social experiences
play a role in people's personality and their regulation of conduct.
Our research project analysed all the variables linked to the students selection process. The
sample we surveyed was made up for students attending two different degree courses at Kore
University of Enna.
Our project aimed at studying the main variables connected to Physical activities and sport
sciences degree course and Architecture degree course students professional choices during their
education. The collected data have to be considered part of person-environment system where
individuals are retroactively aimed at a possible and aware future, especially because counselling is
considered to be a complex topic.
We provided three workshop activities where we discussed about topics inherent to the studied
variables: empowerment, locus of control and professional interests.
Every workshop activity used the same methodology: participants were given a instrument to
survey variables and, afterwards, the focus group activity took part for two hours for each
workshop.
Students choice concerning their university or professional carrier is the product of different
factors – individual, social and situational ones- which play a role in the final result (Grimaldi,
2005; Grimaldi, Del Cimmuto, 2006).
65
The empowerment process is very complex and is defined as “process centred on a local
community, intentional and continuative, that implies mutual respect, critical consideration,
affection and group participation. By means of it people who did not have these resources in an
appropriate way could perceive their Self better and have a better control of their lives (Rappaport,
1981).
Concerning locus of control (LoC), Rotter differentiated from internal locus of control and
external LoC (Rotter, 1966);“LoC” can be often used in an interchangeable way with self-efficacy.
It is considered to be a personality feature that reflexes how a person perceive all the events that are
under his control (internal locus) or external to it (external locus) (Rotter 1966).
Professional values, involvement and satisfaction are essential components of the complex topic
called “the importance of job” (Super, 1981; Trentini, 1995). They are in a intermediate level
between needs and interests, linked to cultural and environmental factors and closely connected to
individual motivations. They are constantly mediated by internal and external factors, that is why
we can define them as dynamic values (Super, 1970; Boerchi and Castelli, 2000).
Whenever we talk about interests we mean a positive attitude of individuals towards some
activities. People got their interests during a personal and subjective experience where they are
aimed at achieving a certain goal. Interests are the motivational elements that will make individuals
feel able to face situations and activities. During education, students interests can be orientated,
modified for the professional opportunities offered by the territory and the contest. Important
working aspects like satisfaction and realization are up to individuals; they come from the congruity
between professional interests and individual features (Di Nuovo S., 2003).
2 Method
2.1 Instruments
Our project used the following research instruments:
- professional values Scale (Avallone, Farnese, Grimaldi & Pepe, in Grimaldi, 2007);
- perceived skills for the entry in the job market Scale (Farnese, Avallone, Pepe & Porcelli, in
Grimaldi, 2007);
- perceived self-efficacy in job search Scale (Farnese, Avallone, Pepe & Porcelli, in Grimaldi,
2007);
- job market self-perception Scale (Farnese, Avallone, Pepe & Porcelli, in Grimaldi, 2007);
- focus group.
The focus group was used to achieve the following goals:
- to get to know oneself and other group members better in order to create a positive clime and a
common basis for other activities;
- to sound out members' knowledge of the studied subjects;
- to point out the factors that played a role in their professional choices.
We provided three workshop activities to discuss about empowerment, locus control and
professional interests. In the end of each workshop we supplied the focus group activity.
2.2 Subjects
Our research project surveyed a sample of fifty people, thirty students attending Physical activities
and sport sciences degree course and twenty students attending Architecture degree course at Kore
University of Enna.
2.3 Processing data
66
We used T-Lab (F. Lancia) to analyse focus groups data. T-Lab software is an all-in-one set of
linguistic and statistical tools for text analysis for text analysis. We used co-occurrence analysis, as
word associations and concept mapping, expecially the Multidimensional scaling with Sammon's
mapping method.
3 Results and Discussion
The research presentation is on the analysis of the results carried out by the focus groups.
Qualitative analysis of “Empowerment” focus group data
Figure 1. Multidimensional scaling of Empowerment focus group
MDS metodo Sammon; stress=0,0059
67
SITUATION
FORTUNE
Figure 2. - Associations with the concepts group called “control” in both of the degree courses
Word association and multidimensional scaling
The overall conceptual picture outlined by the students is represented in the graphic map realized
through the multidimensional scaling (MDS & Sammon's mapping). Students' representation of the
present is clearly different from their representation of the future (Figure.1). On the right side of the
Figure.1, we mostly have positive concepts related to their university studies (present) and their
professional carriers (future), on the left side we have the ideas linked to the students personal
growth and their possible Selves (Markus & Nurius, 1986).
By means of the analysis of Empowerment focus group data we realized that Physical activities
and sport sciences degree course students see their own Self-representation closely linked to the
study concept (within “study” we can also include concepts as goals, knowledge, competence, etc..,
and values as loyalty and transparency).
The current empowerment analysis showed that Physical activities and sport sciences degree course
students consider their biggest difficulties to be the chance to fail an exam or not be able to achieve
what they could not do already.
The future empowerment is seen in the representation of their future Self. Development, passion,
extroversion and stubbornness are linked to the concept of seriousness of sport
What they consider as difficulties is what they want to improve or to avoid.
Concerning the current empowerment, Architecture degree course students' Self-representations are
characterized by patience, availability and their skills, that seem to be all distinguish features of the
architect profession. Concerning the future empowerment, they consider improvement to be
connected to commitment, responsibilities, determination, realism without abandoning their
dreams/desires and their ambitions.
By means of the results of the analysis of the second workshop focus group we realized the locus
of control was associated to the concept of control related to the possible different situations and to
the fortune (Figure 2).
Physical activities and sport sciences degree course and Architecture degree course students think
that their perception of control over chances is external to their capabilities. All the participants
believe the university environment to be controllable only through strategies not related to their
68
study or preparation. The chance, in their opinion, deals with their relationship with professors and
schoolmates and their emotions, rather than their cognitive processing.
The results we got from analysis of the third workshop activity concerning students' interests and
professional values showed us that love, friendship and family are shared by both degree courses
students. Physical activities and sport sciences degree course students associate to the term
“honesty” the predominant values of commitment and technical competences, while for
Architecture degree course students family is the predominant value, followed by love, friendship,
respect and sincerity. Students of Physical activities and sport sciences degree course link their selfimage to the profession, using general values and referring to a general ethic of work.
Professionalism, honesty, technical competence etc., may in fact be applicable as values to any
profession. Students of architecture, however, introduce in general values, personal ethics of the
professional relationship with the customer and with the works created by the professional.
Overall, a clear fact is the general perception of students on their degree course. The degree
course in Architecture, which has direct access to a professional register with well-defined job
opportunities, appears to establish a clear definition of the profession in the future students.
In contrast, students of Physical activities and sport sciences degree course do not have a clear
vision of the work they will do, but they indicate professions characterized by little or no
consistency with regard to the course undertaken.
The results, obtained by self-rating scales, complete and confirm the overview of personal and
business representation, present and future, constructed by students through focus groups. By
comparisons of degree courses, can be seen differences in work values: an analysis of focus groups
made possible to detect a tendency to conservatism of the students of Architecture and a willingness
to change in students of Physical activities and sport sciences degree course, which is further
confirmed by Professional Values Scale. Other significant differences are found in the job market
self-perception Scale, students in Science of motor and sports activities perceive the labor market as
more dynamic, clearer, more equitable, but also more complex.
4 Conclusions
The results obtained by our research highlighted dissimilar perceptions among students attending
two different degree courses. Differences can be found in students goals and aims, especially in
their current studies and future profession.
Students think the knowledge gotten from their studies is distant to their future job. This is an
extremely important data that requires our attention and intervention.
Another meaningful data is that University is for them the only knowledge institution, while
working stands for the practical part that can not be learnt at university, but only in their future
working life.
A clear data is students perception of their degree courses: students attending a course that will
give them the possibility to work immediately after university with a well-defined profession, such
as Architecture degree course ones, know exactly what they want to do.
Otherwise, Physical activities and sport sciences degree course students do not have clear ideas
about their future profession, as it is shown by their answers to the above mentioned question.
However, the lack of a traditional representation of the future profession and the idea that
however they will try many roads to work, allows students who have chosen sports and physical
activities, to be more open to news and more assertive towards their future work. They are ready
also to the complexity and rapid changes of the job-market.
Probably, this would push Physical Activities course degree students to a state of readiness and
greater flexibility in coping with the unexpected. They feel able to redesign of their competencies
for rapid adaptation to the demands of an ever-changing job world. The perceived self-efficacy in
building their own career plan and interpersonal relationships, should be connected, however, 69
including through professional guidance intervention - in a coherent and realistic knowledge of the
career opportunities in sport and physical activities.
5 References
Bandura A. (1986). Social Foundations of trought and action. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs.
Bandura A.(1977). Social Learnig theory. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Bandura, A. Ianes, D. (a cura di), (1996). Il senso di autoefficacia: aspettative su di sé e azione.
Erickson, Trento.
Boerchi, D., e Castelli, F., (2000). Inventario dei valori professionali, Vita e Pensiero Edizioni,
Padova.
Cornell University Empowerment Group (1989). Networking Bulletin: Empowerment and Family
Support. 1, 1, October 1989.
Corrao S. (2000). Il focus group. Franco Angeli, Milano.
Di Nuovo S. (a cura di) (2003). Orientamento e formazione. Progetti ed esperienze nella scuola e
nell’università. Giunti O.S., Firenze.
Di Nuovo, S. (2000). Percorsi di orientamento educativo. Oasi-Città Aperta, Troina.
Grimaldi A. (a cura di) (2002). Analisi della domanda di orientamento: I bisogni emergenti di
giovani allievi italiani. Franco Angeli, Milano.
Grimaldi A., Ghislieri C. e Montalbano G. (2006). Le dimensioni del coping e dell’attribuzione
causale nell’orientamento: due strumenti. Isfol, Roma.
Grimaldi, A. (2007). Bisogni, valori e autoefficacia nella scelta del lavoro, Isfol Editore, Roma.
Grimaldi, A., Del Cimmuto, A. (a cura di) (2006). Dialoghi sull’orientamento: dall’esperienza ai
modelli, Isfol, Roma.
Grimaldi, A.(Editoriale) (2005). Osservatorio Isfol, anno XXVI, n. 4, Isfol, Roma, 5-11.
Holland J.L. (1985). Making vocational choices. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 2^ ed., NJ.
Markus, H., & Nurius, P. (1986) Possible Selves. American Psychologist, 41, 9, 954-969.
Saks, A. M., & Ashforth, B. E. (1996) Proactive socialization and behavioral self-management.
Journal of Vocational Behavior, 48, 301–323.
Rappaport J. (1981). In praise of paradox: A social policy of empowerment over prevention.
American Journal of Community Psychology, 9,1, 1-25.
Rotter, J. B. (1966). Generalized expectancies for internal versus external control of reinforcement.
Psychology Monographs, 80, Whole n. 609.
Super, D.E. (1970). Work values inventory manual.houghton. Mifflin, Boston.
Super, D.E.(1981). La percezione dell’importanza del lavoro. Psicologia Italiana, 3, 51-58.
Trentini, G. (1995). Manuale del colloquio e dell'intervista. Utet, Torino.
70
Physical activities in early adolescence: implications for self-description and interpersonal
perception.
S. Nicolosi, R. Schembri, F. Sgrò, P. Mango and M. Lipoma,
Kore University of Enna, Italy.
Abstract
Few studies have so far examined the relation between Self (physical and social), the variables
linked to identity construction and physical activity.
The psychological well-being resulting from exercise or sport is now generally accepted both in
scientific literature and common belief. The improvement of mood, energy and body image, greater
stability and confidence in the physical Self perception, greater perceived interpersonal and
physical competence in sport or exercise, are some of the physical, cognitive, emotional and social
correlates in physical activity.
During adolescence, the transitional period from childhood to adulthood, when individuals try
to adapt to all the physical, cognitive and social changes, exercise and sport - especially
‘structural’ ones - can have a very important role in the developmental acquisition of this
particular age. All these changes can make the adolescent experience very strong emotional events
which can lead to a significant reduction of self-esteem. An area of self-esteem that can be mainly
affected during adolescence is the physical self-esteem, which includes both body attractiveness and
physical competence perception. The results of a study by Bowker (2006), showed the mediating
role of physical self-esteem in the relationship between sports participation and global self-esteem.
The study wants to investigate the effects of specific training, based on the physical activity
practice, on Self concept, physical and social self-esteem, self-efficacy and interpersonal
psychological adjustment.
Pre-adolescents from 11 to 14 years of age were involved in physical activities and educational
itineraries. The instruments used were the Interpersonal Adjustment Questionnaire (QAI) for
middle school students; the Physical Self-esteem Scale in the Multidimensional Self-Concept Scale
– MSCS; the Self Image Scale for the investigation of Self-Concept – VIS; the General self-esteem
and Self-efficacy scales; the italian version of the Physical Self Description Questionnaire (PSDQ)
in a single administration in post test.
Results show that physical fitness may provide more positive social feedback and recognition
from peer groups, and this will subsequently lead to improvement in an individual’s self-image and
self esteem.
1 Introductıon
Many studies have shown that physical activity provides a harmonious development of personality
and psychological dimensions of the physical self description (Ciairano, 2008; Fox , 1997; Annesi,
2007; Bowker, 2006; Bandura, 1997; Sonstroem, Harlow e Josephs, 1994). Physical self is the
initial core of the self (Epstein, 1973; Jacobson, 1974; Wallon, 1967) and plays a key role in
childhood and adolescence. During adolescence, bodily changes, combined with individual and
environmental factors, lead to a revision of the physical self, which has a deep impact on global
self, identity and emotion. Fox (1997) considers the bodily self as a “public” self, means the body is
the medium that allows us to show to others. In the Fox’s model, physical self-concept has a critical
mediating role in psychological adjustment processes.
71
The self-description of the body is the ideal bridge between self and others; a connection
through which build relationships with others and, according to James (1890), elaborate the
“characteristics of the self recognized by the other”, contributing to the social self.
Through the social group we develop personal perceptions, judgments and patterns of behavior
(Sherif, 1967). In addition, the acquisition of behavior patterns, through social learning and through
imitation, leads the individual to the formation of expectations on the capabilities of personal
achievement, on sense of self-efficacy (Bandura, 1977; 1995; 1997). The present work aims to link
the studies of physical self to the practice of teaching physical activities, to observe changes in the
descriptive and evaluative aspects of self-perception and interpersonal relationships in a sample of
preadolescents. This research is a part of a longitudinal study that analyzed the reprocessing of the
self concept − expecially of the social and physical selves − in early adolescence, multi-level
cognitive and metacognitive aspects of learning motor skills. During pre-adolescence, the effects of
pubertal development include a focus on the subject's own body and to a deeper reflection on selfschemas of the physical self (Markus, 1977). Within the research, was made an educational
intervention based on group work and on the acquisition of motor skills and cognitive, motor and
social problem-solving. Participation in these activities has improved the perception of self in
interpersonal relationships, enhanced social skills, increased physical and general self-esteem and,
finally, has improved a positive Self-image.
2 Method
2.1 Project Structure
The research is divided into three phases.
The first phase (pre-test) was led to the pre-evaluation of the variables investigated (physical
self and global self image, physical and global self-esteem, self efficacy, interpersonal
psychological adjustment) in a sample of preadolescents aged 11 to 13 years old.
In the second phase, realized in the scholastic year after, the participants involved in physical
activities and structured games aimed at potentiating motor, cognitive and social problem solving.
In the third phase (post-test), at the end of the scholastic year, the final rating of the test scorings
collected.
2.2 Subjects
Have joined the project over 200 preadolescents attending two middle schools in the town of Enna
(Sicily, Italy). Test administered in the same sample, in two different times and scholastic year,
before (Time 1) and after (Time 2) the intervention.
This work will analyse the data concerning a sample of students attending the first and the
second classes of the middle school2. Participants were divided into two groups, 22 students that
have concluded the first year of the intervention (Experimental Group - EG) and 46 students that
were not involved in project (Control Group - CG).
The age of the participants, during the Phase I (Time 1),was between 11 and 13 years (M =
11.33, SD = 0.52, Mdn = 11.00).
More over, in this school year, about 60 subjects, divided in three PE classes, are completing
the phase II of the second edition of the project. A sample of 80 subjects will be the control group.
We attend that the assessment of these groups will confirm this data.
2
In the Italian educational system, the first and the second classes are equivalent to the 6th and 7th
grades of the middle school in United States, whereas to the 7th and 8th grades of the secondary
school in United Kingdom.
72
2.3 Instruments
In the first and third phases of the project, the tools used were:
- the Interpersonal Adjustment Questionnaire (QAI) for middle school students (Di Nuovo, 1998):
the four subscales of QAI − Ambient and Family pressure (A&F), External Locus of control in
relationship engagement (ELC), Tendency to Depression (D) and Tendency to Psychosomatization
(P) − represent the main hurdles in social adjustment;
- the Physical Self-esteem Scale in the Multidimensional Self-Concept Scale – MSCS (Bracken,
1993);
- the Self Image Scale for the investigation of Self-Concept – VIS (Magnano & Di Nuovo, 2010);
- the General self-esteem and Self-efficacy scales (Bandura, 1977; Schwarzer, 1993);
- the italian version of the Physical Self Description Questionnaire (PSDQ) (Marsh, 1996; Meleddu
et al., 2002) in a single administration in post test.
3 Results and Discussion
Results are presented in two sections: Phase I (pre-test) and phase III (post-test). First, we present
preliminary results concerning total group and differences between gender. Second, pre-post test
findings are presented both in sperimental and control groups.
In the Phase I (pre-test), participants presented average levels of physical and general selfesteem, average levels of self-efficacy, a high degree of interpersonal adjustment and a positive
evaluation of self-image. However, in girls there were lower levels of physical self-esteem than
boys. The results show, for what concerns the bodily self, the emergence of a significant gender
difference on the concept and image that people perceive their own body, in line with previous
research (Harter, 1997, cit. in Bowker, 2006).
Comparisons pre-post test with Paired sample T-Test
In the final assessment, the experimental group (EG) has lower average intervention in all the four
subscales of the Interpersonal Psychological Adjustment Questionnaire (QAI). Even if, A&F, ELC
and D are significantly lower in Time 2.
In comparisons between gender, after the intervention, A&F is significantly lower (p=0,04), but
in the girls the A&F scores are significantly higher than boys (p<.001). So, for the girls to obtain the
social consent and to substain the effects is more oppressive than boys. There are significant
differences in Tendency to depression (D), that decreases in boys (p=0,05). More, the Externalism
(ELC) decreases significantly in boys and girls (p<0,001).
Results show that as far as Self Image is concerned, in girls involved in the project, the overall
vision of Self-Concept is better than the beginning (p =0,05). In Physical Self Description (PSDQ),
boys shows a better sense about the weight than girls (p=0,03), in Obesity, a PSDQ factors.
As far as Physical Self, EG-boys perceived their own phisical abilities (p=.05), motor
coordination (p=.03), strength (p=.01) and endurance (p=.01) higher than EG-girls.
In EG, final averages of A&F subscale is significantly lower (p=0,04) than averages of time 1.
Between pre-test and post-test, the self-evaluation of negatives features of Self-image increased
in CG subjects (p=0,03), that reported higher averages than EG. Consequently, Global Self Vision
in Time 2 is significantly lower than Time 1 (p=0,03).
Comparisons between experimental and control groups with the Test U of Mann-Whitney
In comparisons between groups, averages of the CG in the QAI subscales, Tendency to depression
(D) (p=0,03) and Externalism (ELC) (p=0,05), are significantly higher than experimental group.
Global Self-Image in participants group is significantly higher than control group (p=0,04).
73
Table 1. Correlation with Spearman’s Rho in Control group, among Self concept, Self esteem and other variables in environmental and individual
psychological adjustment in Time 1 and in Time 2
Time 2
Time 1
Ambient and family pressure
External Locus of control
tendency to depression
tendency to psychosomatization
Self esteem
Physical Self esteem - MSCS
Self efficacy
VIS - Self-image– negatives aspects (NA)
VIS - Self-image– positives aspects (PA)
G-VIS – Global Self-image
A&F
ELC
D
P
Self
esteem
MSCS
0,78***
0,19
0,44
-0,03
-0,50
-0,20
0,16
0,33
-0,03
-0,37
0,32
0,01
0,44
0,09
-0,40
-0,18
0,16
0,15
-0,09
-0,33
0,29
0,28
0,54
-0,03
-0,26
-0,30
-0,16
0,45
-0,01
-0,37
0,04
-0,08
0,31
0,48
-0,45
-0,34
-0,05
0,31
0,10
-0,25
-0,51
-0,21
-0,58
-0,08
0,68**
0,55
0,30
-0,60*
0,23
0,67
-0,32
-0,03
-0,20
-0,11
0,61
0,60
0,26
-0,18
0,14
0,25
*p<.05 **p<.01 ***p<.001
74
Self
efficac
y
-0,24
-0,05
-0,44
-0,05
0,30
0,41
0,32
-0,51
0,19
0,55
VIS
(NA)
VIS
(PA)
G-VIS
0,35
0,30
0,42
0,17
-0,12
-0,14
-0,18
0,68**
0,15
-0,43
-0,28
0,03
-0,11
0,12
0,35
0,28
0,17
-0,13
0,21
0,28
-0,41
-0,26
-0,41
-0,11
0,29
0,25
0,18
-0,58
-0,01
0,49
Table 2. Correlations with Spearman’s Rho among PSDQ and other variables in environmental and individual psychological adjustment
(Experimental group in Time 2)
Environmental and individual
psychological adjustment
Physical Self Description Questionnaire Factors
Health
Coordination
Physical
activity
Body
fat
Sport
skills
Global
Physical
Appearance
Strength
Flexibility
Endurance
Esteem
0,43
0,39
0,20
0,10
-0,15
0,56*
**
0,47
0,35
0,23
-0,01
0,52
0,33
0,32
0,18
0,63*
**
0,68*
**
0,54
Self-image – VIS
G-VIS – Self Image
0,10
0,09
0,04
0,38 0,22
Intra-personal psychological adjustment
Self-esteem
Physical Self-esteem - MSCS
Self-efficacy
Ambient and family pressure
External Locus
Tendency to depression
Tendency to psicosomatization
0,15
0,18
0,22
0,36 0,24
0,48
0,58
0,72*
0,52
*
**
0,05
0,42
0,30 0,29 0,30 0,32
Inter-personal psychological adjustment
-0,10 -0,06 -0,11
-0,41
0,36 0,23
-0,14 0,21
0,24 0,01
-0,19
0,03
-0,09 -0,03 -0,05
-0,48
0,21 0,30
-0,36 0,09
0,05 0,08 0,16 -0,06
0,13
0,58*
0,36
*p<.05 **p<.01 ***p<.001
75
0,66* 0,63**
**
*
0,30
0,28
-0,27
-0,33
-0,00
0,10
-0,43
0,05
0,07
0,22
0,30
-0,27
-0,29
-0,07
0,04
0,05
-0,48
-0,01
-0,05
0,05
0,15
-0,29
In comparisons by gender, we observed that this finding is attributable to females.
Indeed, the evaluation of Self-Image in EG-girls was higher than CG-girls (p=.05).
Correlations with Spearman’s Rho in control group (Table 1)
Correlations between initial and final assessment in CG confirmed comparisons
findings. From Phase I and Phase III, we observed positives correlations between A&F
(p<0.001) and general self-esteem (p<0.01). In CG preadolescents, there is a positive
correlation between negative Self-evaluation about their own Image from Time 1 to
Time 2 (p<0.01) and a negative correlation between Negative aspects of Self-Image and
General Self-esteem (p<0.05).
Correlations with Spearman’s Rho (Table 2)
Physical Self-esteem of Bracken’s MSCS is significantly related with several subscales
of PSDQ: Coordination, Obesity, Global Physical, Appearance, Strength and Esteem
(see Table 2). As far as Esteem, the PSDQ subscale, there is a positive correlation
among General and Physical Self-esteem (MSCS) and Positive Perception of Self Image
(VIS) (p<.001).
In girls, Physical Self-esteem is related with General Self-esteem (p<.001) and
Positive Perception of Self Image (p<.05); furthermore, general Self-esteem related with
Appearance and Global Physical.
4 Conclusions
Participating in activities linked to sport and problem solving didactic, during
adolescence, can play a protective role in decreased self esteem and help the
development of cognitive and metacognitive processes.
In accordance with previous researches (Marcoux et al., 1999; Sallis et al., 1999), a
program structured on specific physical activities could determine significant positive
changes in interpersonal adaptation, global self-image and specific dimensions of
physical self, which are indispensable aspects in psychological and physical well being
in early adolescence.
The first year of research has produced a first step in two directions: the first is to
establish a planning group for the didactics of Physical Activities and to integrate
learning between universities and schools. The second of the results obtained in the
followed work program, led to significant results in some critical areas of development
in adolescence: interpersonal adjustment, overall vision of self and in some subdimensions of the physical self.
With regard to psychological regulation in interpersonal relationships, there was a
reduction in the factors hindering a balanced and positive adaptation to school
environment and family, and particularly in the pressure perceived in social settings,
control on externalism and a tendency to depression. At the end of the project, the
participants perceived themselves as more assertive, better able to establish positive
relations with others, more aware that they can withstand the environmental pressures
and more able to interact with the environment in an active way. At the conclusion of
the meetings, even the reflections, expressed by the children themselves, showed greater
awareness for relational processes and satisfaction with the route taken.
The overall view of self is enhanced, especially in girls, who initially had lower
body self-esteem than boys. Compared to the beginning of the project, the girls have a
better sense of their body weight, while boys perceived themselves as more coordinated,
with more sports skills, stronger and more resilient.
76
It must, however, dwell on the most critical elements identified in the first year of
research. The findings, though positives, reflect the general approach of the educational
planning. In other words, positive - or no negative - changes have been made in general
in the size of inter- and intra-individual self. However can not find specific evidence in
the individual factors of the physical self. Meleddu & Scalas (2003) pointed out that,
since pre-adolescence, it would seem that interest in the body is different between
genders; previous studies have found that for girls seems to be more important the
physical appearance, while for boys the physical capacity (Lerner, Orlos and Knapp,
1976, cited in Meleddu & Scalas, 2003). We add to this recently (Thornton and
Ryckman, 1991, cited in Meleddu & Scalas, 2003) also the emphasis on physical
performance for both boys and girls. In particular, at the conclusion of the project, with
regard to the description of the physical self, was found in girls a better understanding
of weight while in the boys a better perception of strength, endurance, skills and
coordination.
It wonders, therefore, whether the differences in our sample take such a
configuration, are determined by patterns of gender, female or male, or derived from a
higher concentration in the planning of exercises and activities that privileged strength,
endurance, and flexibility rather than dexterity. Aspects, the latter, where the girls
would probably be more effective and achieve better results. Consistent with gender
differences observed in the studies cited, it could assume that in the absence of a
programming of the body characteristics for gender or of other units of learning related
to the subdimensions of Physical Self, participants were directed towards those aspects
which they considered more important for self-adjustement.
Another limitation is the current sample size that does not yet allow a generalization
of the results.
Despite the limitations exposed, which is believed will be overcome thanks to the
expansion of the sample and to a more specific program of assistance for the second
year of the project, it can finally say that the intervention has helped, in this group of
participants, to face up to some of the psychological processes derived from somatic
changes of adolescence, especially those relating to the physical self in social
relationships and adaptation intraindividual. In general, the instruments and the
modalities of physical activity and sports can be a valuable asset and effectively, in
adolescence, to allow for a positive revision of its physical self and to improve the
climate of relationships in the peer group and with adults in the school environment.
A further consideration concerns, finally, the pedagogical aspects of the project,
which focused on cooperative learning, based on problem solving, in motor activity
which has also enabled links with other disciplines (such as mathematics, geography,
italian literature, music education). This kind of intervention, which is a new practice in
school physical education in Italy, can be a simple and flexible model of teaching although open to improvement - to achieve the “personality formation through
knowledge and awareness of their own corporeal identity” required by the Directions of
the Italian Ministry of Education Curriculum for the Elementary and Middle school of
2007.
5 References
Annesi, J. J. (2007). Relations of age with changes in self-efficacy and physical selfconcept in preadolescents participating in a physical activity intervention during
afterschool care. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 105, 1, 221-226.
77
Bandura A. (1997). Self-effìcacy: exercise of control, New York: Freeman. It. Tr. (2000)
Autoefficacia: teoria e applicazioni, Trento, Italy: Erickson.
Bandura A. (Ed.) (1995). Self-efficacy in changing societies, Cambridge, MA:
Cambridge University Press. It. Tr. (1996). Il senso di autoefficacia. Aspettative
su di sé e azione. Trento, Italy: Erickson.
Bandura, A. (1977) Self-efficacy: Toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioral Change.
Psychological Review, 84, 2,191-215.
Bowker, A. (2006). The Relationship Between Sports Participation and Self-Esteem
During Early Adolescence, Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, 38, 2,
214-229.
Bracken, B.A. (1993). MSCS, Multidimensional Self-Concept Scale, Austin, Texas:
Pro-Ed. Inc. It. Tr. (1993) TMA. Test di valutazione multidimensionale
dell’autostima. Trento, Italy: Erickson.
Ciairano, S. (Ed.) (2008). Le attività motorie e sportive nello sviluppo degli adolescenti.
Roma-Bari, Italy: Laterza.
Di Nuovo, S. (1998). QAI: un test di adattamento interpersonale In Di Nuovo S., Lo
Verso G., Di Blasi M. & Giannone F., Valutare le psicoterapie:la ricerca
italiana (pp. 281-289). Milano, Italy: Franco Angeli.
Epstein, S. (1973). The self-concept revisited or a theory of a theory. American
Psychologist, 28, 404-416.
Fox, K.R. (Ed.). (1997). The physical self: From motivation to well-being. Windsor,
ON: Human Kinetics.
Harter, S. (1997). The development of self-representation. In W.D.Eisenberg (Ed.),
Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 3. Social, emotional, and personality
development (pp. 553–618). New York: Wiley.
Jacobson, E. (1974). Il sé e il mondo oggettuale. Firenze, Italy: Martinelli.
James, W. (1890) The principles of psychology. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Lerner, R.M., Orlos, J.B. & Knapp, J.R.(1976). Physical attractiveness, physical
effectiveness, and self-concept on the late adolescents, Adolescence, II, 313-326.
Magnano, P. & Di Nuovo, S. (2010). Evaluation of Self Image Scale for the
investigation of Self Perception, Enna, Italy: Kore University Press, in press.
Marcoux, M.F., Sallis, J.F., McKenzie, T.L., Marshall, S., Armstrong, C.A. & Goggin,
K.J. (1999). Process evaluation of a physical activity self-management program
for children: SPARK. Psychology & Health, 14, 4, 659-677.
Markus, H. R. (1977). Self-schemata and processing information about the self. Journal
of Personality and Social Psychology, 35, 2, 63-78.
Marsh, H.W. (1996). Physical Self-Description Questionnaire: Stability and
discriminant validity. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport. 67, 249-264.
Marsh, H.W., Hey, J., Roche L.A. & Perry C. (1997). Structure of Physical SelfConcept: Elite Athletes and Physical Education Students. Journal of
Educational Psychology, 89, 2, 369-380.
Meleddu, M. & Scalas, L.F. (2003). La molteplicità del sé. Disagio emotivo, vissuto
corporeo e adolescenza. Roma, Italy: Carocci.
Meleddu, M., Scalas, L.F. & Guicciardi, M. (2002).. Contributo alla validazione italiana
del Physical Self-Description Questionnaire, Bollettino di Psicologia Applicata,
237, 36-52.
Perussia, F. & Viano, R. (2008). Mini Locus of Control Scale. Piccolo manuale, con
Tratti e Tipi, da una Scala psicometrica semplificata. In: Di Nuovo, S. & Sprini,
G. (Ed.) Teorie e metodi della psicologia italiana. Tendenze attuali. Milano,
Italy: Franco Angeli.
78
Sallis, J.F., Prochaska, J.J. & Tayler, W.C. (1999). Correlates of Physical Activity in a
National Sample of Girls and Boys in Grades 4 Through 12, Health Psychology,
18, 410-415.
Schwarzer, R. (1993). Measurement of perceived self-efficacy. Psychometric scales for
cross-cultural research. Berlin, Germany: Freie Universität Berlin.
Shephard, R.J. (1997), Curricular physical activity and academic performance, Pediatr
Exerc. Sci, 9,113-126.
Sherif, M. (1967). Social interaction: Process and products. Chicago: Aldine.
Sonstroem R.J., Harlow L.L. & Josephs L. (1994). Exercise and self-esteem: Validity of
model, expansion and exercise associations. Psychology of Sport and Exercise,
16, 29-42.
Thornton, B., & Ryckman, R.M. (1991). Relationship between physical attractiveness,
physical effectiveness and self-esteem. Journal of Adolescence, 14, 85-98.
Wallon, H. (1967). Psicologia ed educazione del bambino. Firenze, Italy: La Nuova
Italia.
79
The influence of canistherapy on motoric skills of junior school age children with
mental retardation.
Katerina Jindrichova, Masaryk University, Faculty of Sport Studies, Brno, Czech
Republic
Abstract
Research results from the fact, that dogs positively affect human health on the mental,
physical and social part. The therapy is suitable as an additional psychotherapeutic
method for the work with patients who have communication problems, motoric
problems and mental retardation.
Research represented motional and relaxation exercises, which was realised as a part
of the regular lessons for 3 months. The research was designed as case studies.
Participants with similar diagnosis was observed once a week for three months. Part of
the lessons was: positioning, relaxation, training of motoric skills by kinetic cubes,
combing, smoothing, feeding.
In the end was evaluated the changes of the rate of the reactions, punctuality in action
with kinetic cubes.
Progress was notable on social level as progressional closer contact with dog and
better spontaneity. Mental concentration stayed very low.
Canistherapy as a psychotherapeutic method may be supporting in the process of
developing motoric, mental and social skills for children with mental retardation.
Key words: canistherapy, mental retardation, motoric skills, relaxation, positioning
1 Introduction
Canistherapy is composed from words „ canis – dog and therapy – healing“. Dogs
positively affect human health on the mental, physical and social part. The therapy is
suitable as an additional psychotherapeutic method for the work with patients who have
communication problems; it supports the abilities for feeling, thinking and moving.
2 Method
Case studies was realised at ZŠS Ibsenova in Brno. Two participants were observed and
analysed – girl and boy in junior school age between 10 – 11. Participants had similar
diagnosis of mental retardation and psychomotoric retardation F80.
Evaluated were: The changes of the rate of the reactions, punctuality in action with
kinetic cubes.
Research represented motional and relaxation exercises, which was realised as a part
of the regular lessons for 3 months, between September 2009 – December 2009. The
research was designed as case studies.
Two participants were observed individually once a week for three months. Part of the
lessons was:
80
•
•
•
•
•
•
Positioning
Relaxation
Training of motoric skills by kinetic cubes
Combing
Smoothing
Feeding
Positioning is a method based on direct physical contact of the client and the dog
(dogs). Basic conditions are the client’s confidence in the dog, calm and undisturbed
and relaxing atmosphere, what can be complemented with relaxation music etc. In the
research participants was: the physiotherapist (methodic guiding, determination of
positions), the dog handler (deals with the dog), the teacher.
At first the participants saluted the dog, then they practised with kinetic cubes for five
minutes(put them down on the dog body, rise them a put them back to the basic big
cube. Then the physiotherapist choose a position suitable for the client (or the client
could choose it himself), they were lying in positions on a soft mat (on back, on side or
on stomach). Subsequently the dog handler brings the dogs to him so that they get down
closely beside the client - on places determined by the physiotherapist. Other places are
additionally positioned by rehabilitation aids (pillows, rollers, blankets) and free places
are covered so that heat cannot escape. The participant lies in a pleasant undisturbed
atmosphere for individual time duration (30 minutes).
The factors working here are particularly the warming through, the breath stimulation
of the dog, the stimulation by the dog hair, the calm atmosphere, the relationship to the
dog. In this part participants smooth the dog.The impacts discovered are mainly
calming, promoted blood circulation, relaxation, pleasant experiences, warmingthrough. Then they feed the dog by their hands. And finally they train fine motor ability
with kinetic cubes once again after positioning.
3 Results and Discussion
In the end was evaluated the changes of the rate of the reactions, punctuality in action
with kinetic cubes on motoric skills. Progress was notable on social level as
progressional closer contact with dog and better spontaneity. Mental concentration
stayed very low.
Canistherapy as a psychotherapeutic method may be supporting in the process of
developing motoric, mental and social skills for children with mental retardation.
Canistherapy may be supporting in the process of healing children with mental
retardation.
4 References
Galajdová, L.: Pes lékařem lidské duše – aneb canisterapie, 1.vyd. Praha: Grada
Publishing, 1999, ISBN 80-7169-789-3.
Hartl, P., Hartlová, H.: Psychologický slovník, 1. vyd. Praha: Portál, 2004, ISBN 807178-303-X.
Hessler – Kezová, M.: Magická moc zvířat, 1.vyd. Praha: PLOT, 2002,
ISBN 8086523-10-1.
81
Karásková, V., Krausová, A.,: Pes a dítě s mentálním postižením, 1.vyd. Olomouc:
Ediční řada – skripta, 2004, ISBN 80-244-0953-4.
Langmeier, J., Krejčířová d., Vývojová psychologie, 3.vyd. Praha: Grada, 1998, ISBN
80-7169-195-X.
Pes přítel člověka, Praha: Pražská vydavatelská společnost, 2001, ISSN 0231-5424.
Pipeková, J., Vítková, M.: Terapie ve speciálně pedagogické praxi, 2.vyd. Brno: Paido,
2001, ISBN 80-7315-010-7.
Švarcová, I., Vzdělávací program zvláštní školy, Praha: Septima, 1997, ISBN 80-7216025-7.
Valenta, M., Müller, O.: Psychopedie, 1.vyd. Praha: Parta, 2003, ISBN 80-7320-039-2.
Vítková, M.: Integrativní školní (speciální) pedagogika.Základy, teorie, praxe. 1.vyd.
Brno: SMD, 2003, ISBN 80-86633-07-1.
82
Research into Pedagogical Impacts on the Movement Development of Crèche
Children
Emőke Bucsy and Adrienn Bakk,
University of West Hungary, Benedek Elek Faculty of Pedagogy, Sopron, Hungary.
Abstract
In 2008 a new BA major was introduced in Hungarian higher education.
The permission for the establishment of the major of Infant and Early
Childhood Educator was accepted in the branch of Pedagogue Education.
The possibility of attaining a qualification of higher education in this field
can be regarded as a prominent achievement even in international context.
The Benedek Elek Faculty of Pedagogy of the University of West Hungary
obtained the right to launch the above mentioned major in 2009.
Consecutively, education began in correspondent and full time courses.
Instructing the methodology subjects connected to majors classified as part
of the educational branch of Educator on a high level makes the conduction
of researches necessary, which examine the educational impacts on crèche
children.
During the sport-pedagogical study introduced in the poster-lecture we
were searching for an answer to the following questions: How far do the
movement possibilities offered by crèche pedagogues support the optimal
movement development of infants? Does their background knowledge
provide a sufficient basis for planning and conducting PE trainings
professionally? We also examined what expectations the parents formulate
concerning physical education in the crèche as well as how far they
contribute to the efficiency of pedagogical work in this field of education.
Our methods included analysing documents, compiling written
questionnaires and examination. We recorded the data of 54 crèche
educators during our study. The parents’ sample consisted of 29 women and
26 men.
While examining 28 informal PE trainings we came to the conclusion that
structure and content of crèche physical education have individual features.
Our experiences confirmed our hypothesis that there are untapped
possibilities of movement development of small children within the
framework of institutional physical education. This can be primarily
explained with the fact that health care skills of crèche educators are on a
higher level than their pedagogical qualification and that they did not
receive a proper education concerning the methodology of physical
education. We found that parents regard regular playful physical education
significant in the crèche. However, their knowledge is incomplete regarding
the movement forms guaranteeing optimal development for small children
and they are insecure about the content of physical education in crèche.
83
1 Introduction
The traditions of crèche education are going back as far as 1852. Training the
professionals for these institutions has been taking place on intermediate level for a long
time. This level of training, by our days, however, has not secured the prevailing of
pedagogical and psychological research concerning early learning. In infant age and at
early childhood - according to this research - not only nursing, but also education has a
crucial role regarding the development of the nervous system, as well as cognitive and
social improvement. Establishing post secondary vocational training, later on the
launching of the BA major of Infant and Early Childhood Educator emerged as a
professional claim. Higher professional qualification is to secure more thorough
pedagogical preparedness of professionals dealing with infants and small children. This
step can be regarded crucial from the viewpoint of the prestige of the profession as well,
since up till now crèche employees wanting to study were forced to attain a degree in
various different institutions; in the education of kindergarten teachers, primary
teachers, socio-pedagogues, etc. The rocketing of the number of crèche children also
puts a need to the renewal of professional education, to guarantee more thorough
pedagogical preparedness, as the higher headcount puts a higher responsibility on
attendants and educators in crèche. Sharing the task with the parents, they will be in
charge of the education and movement development of more and more infants.
The Benedek Elek Faculty of Pedagogy of the University of West Hungary
obtained the right to launch the BA major of Infant and Early Childhood Educator in
2009. Consecutively, education began in correspondent and full time courses.
Instructing the methodology subjects connected to majors classified as part of the
educational branch of Educator on a high level makes the conduction of researches
necessary, which examine the educational impacts on crèche children. During the sportpedagogical study introduced in the poster-lecture we were searching for an answer to
the following questions: How far do the movement possibilities offered by crèche
pedagogues support the optimal movement development of infants? Does their
background knowledge provide a sufficient basis for planning and conducting PE
trainings professionally? We also examined what expectations the parents formulate
concerning physical education in the crèche as well as in what extent they identify with
the view that regular, planned exercises are already important in the early years.
Before we start introducing the research, it is important to define what we mean
by optimal movement development at this age. According to our experience, in our
urbanized world, the movement-deficient lifestyle of adults already affects small
children. A remarkable part of the parents do not pay attention to satisfying the natural
movement-requirements of their children. The cause of this might be lack of time, or
not proper sport-socialization (Bognár et al, 2006). Regarding sporting habits, parental
ambition is determinative in the life of the rising child (Gombocz, 2008). The task of
institutional physical education is the compensation of the harmful effects caused by
inactive lifestyle - using the natural movement-requirements of the children - as well as
forming the habitual system of regular physical education bound to time limits (Bucsy,
2009). A significant part of crèche children is in their early childhood. At the age of 1-3
practicing basic movement forms extensively is the content of physical education, as
the child already knows and uses several various kinds of movements, but the specialdynamic features of these fall behind mature movement patterns (Farmosi, 1999). We
regard the fulfilment of the above mentioned fundamental for undisturbed movement
development. At this early stage children acquire basic movement forms or their simple
combinations via personation and in a playful way (Istvánfi, 2006). The development of
84
some movement forms, the appearance of their diversified forms particularly requires
the help of adults, their movement pattern. For this reason, crèche educators’
pedagogical qualification, methodological knowledge and expertise is an indispensable
element of motoric development.
2 Material and method
2.1 The hypotheses of the research
We set our hypotheses according to the aim of the research.
H1: We presumed that the health care qualification of crèche attendants is higher than
their pedagogical qualification.
H2: We presumed that structure and content of crèche physical education have
individual features, there are untapped possibilities of movement development of small
children within the framework of institutional physical education.
H3: We presumed that parents regard regular playful physical education significant in
the crèche.
2.2 The sample of the research
In the research we recorded the data of 54 crèche educators, who work in four Sopron
crèches carrying out practical training. Students taking part in the post-secondary
vocational training of Infant and Early Childhood attendant and BA major Infant and
Early Childhood Educator students accomplish their practice in these institutions. We
can see the distribution according to age in Figure 1.. The average age of the sample is
40,8 years, the modus is 50. We consider the data of crèche educators in more detail by
the presentation of the results of the research.
25
20
X
Mo
man
15
10
5
0
20-30
31-40
41-50
51-60
age
Figure 1. The distribution of crèche educators according to age.
The parental sample consisted of the parents of the children from the Practice Crèche
No. 1., 29 women and 26 men.
85
From the data regarding the parents’ qualification, income and sporting habits we
drew the conclusion that in both the case of the fathers and the mothers we can speak
about a positive sample. We attached great importance to recording sporting habits
among the features, as the judgement of crèche physical education seriously depends on
the parents’ relationship to exercise.
Table 1. The data of the parental sample.
Average age(years)
Qualification (%)
University, College
Secondary school
Vocational school
Primary school
Standard of living (%)
We are well-off
Average
Not well-off
Pursuing sport regularly (%)
Mother
34,8
Father
36,3
51
21
28
0
35
42
23
0
7
90
3
35
12
76
12
23
2.3 The methods of the research
We used several different methods to verify our hypotheses. We applied document
analysis to examine „ The National Fundamental Programme of Crèche Educationattendance” (2008), the educational programmes of the individual crèches and the week
timetables of crèche groups. We drew up minutes about 28 crèche classes, applying a
‘monitoring technique without coding’. Our observations primarily focussed on the
content of the informally organised physical education trainings. We used the method of
‘eliciting in writing’ about parents’ expectations in connection with the content and
regularity of physical education in crèche.
From the elaborating methods we conducted an elemental examination of the
data, regarding statistical schemes factor analysis applying SPSS.
3 The results of the research
3.1 The personal conditions of physical education in the crèche
By the fulfilment of personal conditions we considered the qualifications of crèche
educators. The column diagrams of Figure 2. exemplify well, that professional
education is not unified in this field. The pedagogical, methodological knowledge and
preparedness connected to each qualification is hard to trace. From the 54 attendants
taking part in the examination 1 is qualified as belonging to category C, which means
she took part in an Infant and Early Childhood Attendant Course which does not require
GSSE. The ones classified as members of category D possess a skill of Infant and Early
Childhood Attendant requiring GSSE, the ones in category D acquired a qualification as
professional attendants. The attendants who accomplished their studies in the above
86
mentioned two school types received first and foremost health care education and had
little possibility to acquire professional methodology knowledge. On the other hand,
they frequently take part in professional trainings organized by the regional
methodological centre. Information brochures covering several educational areas and
methodological letters help daily pedagogical activity. 23 from the attendants taking
part in the research have accomplished the two-year post secondary vocational training
for Infant and Early Childhood Educator-Attendant – which also means classification
into category E. 15 of them had in their curriculum the block of subjects called “ The
Bases and Methodology of Physical Education” for three terms, with theoretical and
practical knowledge. This group of subjects prepares the students for planning,
organizing and conducting physical education in the crèche.
6 of the 54 crèche attendants possess a college degree. They have a qualification
as kindergarten teacher or socio-pedagogue. Their curriculum includes sportprofessional subjects that can osculatorily be connected to crèche physical education.
25
20
15
%
10
5
0
Infant and Early
Professional Attendant
Infant and Early
Childhood EducatorCategory E
Childhood Attendant
Attendant Category E
Category D
(Post Secondary
Vocational Training)
Infant and Early
Childhood Attendant
Course Category D
Figure 2. The qualification of crèche attendants
3.2 The content of crèche physical education
The National Fundamental Programme of Crèche Education-attendance contains the
principles of organising crèche life. The first place of the here formulated educational
tasks is taken by facilitating healthy physical development and forming healthy
lifestyle. In favour of the healthy physical development of infants and small children
possibility for movement development, physical exercise has to be assured by daily
regularity. Documents record the institutional framework of kindergarten physical
education, laying down the number of weekly physical education trainings respectively
physical education classes, and their framework of content. There is no unified
instruction on national level with reference to the institutional framework and content of
crèche physical education.
Before analysing the minutes recording the content of crèche physical education, we
recorded the age of crèche children, which we present in Figure 3.
87
Introducing the age characteristics of the crèche children is crucial considering the
content of physical education lessons. The data recorded in September show that the
average age of the 307 recorded children was 27,5 months. The youngest child was 6,
the oldest 43 months old.
Our observations about the structure and content of crèche physical education took
place in October and November, when the children were mainly inside. At that time the
majority of the children was already two years old. According to our experience, the
structure of the informal 20-25 minute lessons is different from what is common in
physical education lessons in kindergarten and in school. In kindergarten and in school
warm-up exercise are followed by learning the main exercises and physical education
games helping to learn the main exercises, finally, the organism is cooled down.
According to our observations, the preparatory part of crèche physical education
consists of 2-4 beat gymnastic exercises, occasionally complemented by walkingrunning exercises. The fundamental movement forms are practiced in the main part. We
saw no examples of physical education games. As for the proportions, the preparatory
part takes up half of the informal lessons in time. When analysing crèche physical
education we grouped the movement material into gymnastic exercises (Table 2.) and
basic movement forms (Table 3.)
12
10
8
man
Crèche No 1.
Crèche No 2.
6
Crèche No 3.
Crèche No 4.
4
2
0
6 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41
month
Figure 3. The age distribution of crèche children.
Table 2.: The fundamental gymnastic forms observed in the crèche physical education.
Muscle groups
Neck exercises
Arm exercises
Abdominal
exercises
Back exercises
Stretching exercises
neck bending,
neck rotation exercises
finger- and
wrist exercises
arm swing exercise
arm rotation
backward trunk bending
forward trunk bending
88
Strengthening exercises
arm lift
-lowering
arm floating
leg movements in sitting,
lying
forward trunk bending 90
degree,
lying on abdomen
backward trunk bending,
leg lift backwards
Side exercises
Leg exercises
turning trunk sideways
sideways trunk bending
toe- and
ankle exercises
leg swing exercises
heel lift exercises
toe- and
ankle exercises
knee bending - stretch
jumping exercises
The table assembling fundamental gymnastic forms demonstrates well, how rich crèche
physical education is in fundamental gymnastic forms. In the 28 informal lessons we
could on the whole observe exercises stretching or strengthening almost all muscle
groups. The characteristic method of conducting practise was the imitating form, using
nursery rhymes well known by the children. In the composition of the set of exercises
the methodological aspects that have to be taken into consideration for the sake of
general and versatile development of children’s organism were poorly represented.
The wide- range practice of fundamental movement forms in the crèche secures the
movement basis, on which early childhood and at the same time kindergarten physical
education can build. At the age of 4-7 years this is the base of improvement of
movement forms and of the appearance of the first movement combinations (Meinel,
1977:293-410). The versatile practice of basic skills is also important because in the
early childhood movement development takes first place as a coordinative, later on as a
differentiating process (Hirtz-Ludwig,1976:506-510; Israel,1976: 501-506).
Table 3.The fundamental movement forms observed in the crèche physical education
lessons.
Fundamental movement forms
Variations of fundamental movement forms
crawling
crawling on abdomen (with bean bag, on a bench),
crawling on all fours, crabwalk
crawling in 4- point kneeling position, bunny hop,
crawling sitting stretch
walking keeping pace, tiptoeing, walking on heels,
with knee lift,
walking on outer-, inner sole edge, walking changing
pace,
walking with tasks (squatting for a sign),
stepping over a string, balancing walking
running around
vertical jumping, jumping home, jumping over
punching ( balloon), throwing home (horizontal
target), bean bag toss, ball toss, rolling ball in pairs,
walking
running
jumping
throwing
lifting-carrying
dragging-pushing
rolling
hanging, climbing
dragging in sitting with a partner
rolling around longitudinal axle
89
Taking the data of Table 3. into consideration, the principle of versatile movement
practice did not entirely come to fulfilment in the lessons monitored. From fundamental
movement forms we could observe the richest variations in the field of walking.
However, we missed the walking exercises in the various spacial directions (sideways,
backwards) and exercises with diverse gymnastic apparatus. The different types of
crawling are the first dislocation movements of small children. These are the most
important means of forming the biomechanically right posture and developing motoric
skills at this age. Although they came after walking as the second movement form in the
physical education lessons, their use qualitatively and quantitatively still fell behind the
needs of the age group. Running is a preferred movement form of children, they enjoy
performing it. In spite of this, it was carried out few times in the informal lessons;
however developing a running with good technique is an important task of physical
education. Practicing running in the crèche under manifold circumstances - running in
different formations, in pairs, evading objects, etc., - helps more and more secure, better
and better carried out running. The study is not aimed at a detailed analysis of all the
movement forms, as with the help of the table the occurrence of the individual exercises
can clearly be followed. Nevertheless, it is important to note that we have not seen
examples of hanging and climbing. The inevitable movement material serving the
development of trunk musculature might possibly have been ousted from the physical
education exercises- as - with one exception - there are no wall bars in the crèche group
rooms. Hopefully, outdoors gymnastic apparatus and jungle gyms stop this gap in
spring and autumn. We also experienced that informal lessons do not contain physical
education games; crèche educators did not make use of this possibility for practicing
movement forms. Crèche children enjoy running games the most, at the end of early
childhood individual races can also successfully made to be practiced among them. The
advantage of this physical educational game is that it makes the practice of various
movement forms possible; furthermore, children have to adapt few rules.
3.3 Parents’ opinion about physical education in the crèche
Before presenting the results of the questionnaire fact-finding, it is important to mention
that we processed the data of a positive sample considering pursuing sports, as 35 per
cent of the mothers and 23 per cent of the fathers marked on the questionnaire that they
pursued sport at least 2-3 times a week. This proportion exceeds the national average by
far. As a result of the attitude towards sport, 96 per cent of the mothers and 97 per cent
of the fathers considers regular playful physical education important in the crèche. We
also asked questions about the content of physical education in the crèche. We
enumerated the fundamental movement forms; in addition, we asked, the practice of
which they considered significant in the early years. According to the data of Table 4.,
mothers privilege balancing, jumping, crawling and walking. Most of the fathers favour
running, jumping and balancing.
Table 4.: The content of physical education according to the opinion of the parents.
Fundamental movement
forms
Crawling
Walking
Running
Balancing
Mother (%)
45
55
52
83
90
Father (%)
35
50
62
58
Rolling
Throwing
Jumping
Experiments for hanging
28
52
66
35
27
46
58
42
At this age the extensive practice of fundamental movement forms guarantees the
optimal movement development of small children. The answers of the parents indicate
that only few of them are aware of this. Only two parents marked the full scale of all the
movement forms in the relevant question of the questionnaire. The results of the factor
analysis refer that the movement forms does not have a close system in the parents’
thoughts.
4 Conclusions
The research aiming at the study of pedagogical effects influencing the movement
development of crèche children affirmed our hypotheses.
Our hypothesis, namely that the health care qualification of crèche attendants is
higher than their pedagogical qualification, was verified. Only 15 of the 54 attendants
had been prepared in post-secondary vocational training to plan, organize and conduct
crèche physical education. While examining 28 informal PE trainings we came to the
conclusion that the structure and content of crèche physical education have individual
features. It was for example conspicuous
that gymnastic exercises are more stressed than practicing the basic skills, furthermore
PE games did not occur in the informal lessons observed. Our experiences confirmed
our hypothesis that there are untapped possibilities of movement development of small
children within the framework of institutional physical education. In our view more
possibility has to be given to practice fundamental movement forms through applying
toys and games triggering quick and accurate actions.
According to written eliciting, parents regard regular playful physical education
significant in the crèche. However, their knowledge is incomplete regarding the
movement forms guaranteeing optimal development for small children and they are
insecure about the content of crèche physical education.
In view of our research experience so far we think it is expedient to conduct
further studies with reference to crèche education and to employ the results at the BA
major of Infant and Early Childhood Educator at the Benedek Elek Faculty of Pedagogy
of the University of West Hungary.
5 References
The National Fundamental Programme of Crèche Education-Attendance (2008).
Institute for Sociopolitics and Labour. Department for Child Protection.
Bognár, J., Trzaskoma-Bicsérdy, G., Révész, L. & Géczi, G. (2006). The Role of
Parents in Improving Sport Talents. Kalokagathia, XLIV. 1-2. 86-96.
Bucsy, G.-né (2009). The Role of Physical Education in Kindergarten in the
Establishment of Life-time Sport. In: Hughes, Mike- Dancs, HenriettNagyvaradi, Katalin (Eds) Research in Sport Science. Cardiff. ISBN 1 901288
00 13. 41-50.
91
Farmosi, I.(1999). Movement Development. Dialóg Campus, Budapest-Pécs.
Hirtz, P. & Gudrun, L. (1976). Aims, Means and Methods of Coordinative Motoric
Development. Körpererziehung, 11. 506-510.
Israel, S. (1976). Early Developing of Movement Coordination. Körpererziehung 11.
501–506.
Gombocz , J. (2008). Educating Sportsmen. Platin-Print, Budapest.
Istvánfi, Cs. (2006). Learning Movements, Movement Skills, Movement Mastery.
Platin-Print, Budapest.
Meinel, K. (1977). Movement Science. Volk und Wisser Volkseigener Verlag, Berlin,
1977. 293-410.
92
Sport Physiology
93
Research trends in adapted physical activity.
Emmanouil K Skordilis,
Assistant Professor,
Department of Physical Education and Sport Sciences,
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece.
Abstract
Adapted Physical Activity (APA) is a cross disciplinary body of knowledge, with an aim
towards the identification and solution of psychomotor problems throughout the life
span (Hutzler & Sherrill, 2007). In turn, Sherrill (2004) stated that APA incorporates
service delivering, pedagogy, training, coaching etc., and is provided by qualified
professionals to enhance, through physical activity, empowerment and quality of life of
individuals of all ages, with a variety of disabilities and societal restrictions. Using the
above definitions and following the research study of Reid and Stanish (2003), APA was
perceived for the purposes of the present study as a discipline for it’s own sake, with an
existing knowledge base, methodology and terminology. In turn, the hallmark of APA as
a discipline was related to the advancement of theoretical knowledge through research
(Reid & Stanish, 2003). Therefore, the aim of the present study was to examine the
latest research trends in APA. Following previous research studies (e.g. Reid &
Broadhead, 1995; Porretta & Sherrill, 2005; Sherril, 1997; Sherrill & O’Connor,
1999), the 2007-2010 publications in the Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly (APAQ),
a committed international research journal in the field, were reviewed. It was assumed
that the APAQ was representative of the research conducted in the respective field
(Sherrill, 1997). Examination of the 2007-2010 publications revealed information
concerning the researchers involved and countries of origin, scientific focus, disabilities
examined, sampling designs, statistical analyses used, validity and reliability reports,
theories used, etc. The results are discussed in accordance to previous publications, in
an attempt to describe the current research trends in APA.
1 Introduction
According to the Web, trend is considered as the general course or prevailing tendency
or the general direction. In turn, research may be considered as the systematic inquiry or
investigation into a subject in order to discover or revise facts, theories, applications, etc
(Google: http://dictionary.reference.com). According to Sherrill (1997), research may be
perceived also as ‘means by which a body of knowledge is developed’ (citation) (p. 2).
Research trends therefore were defined, for the purposes of the present study, as the
tendency of systematic inquiry in the field of adapted physical activity (APA) providing
the general direction for scientists planning their future research endeavors.
Adapted Physical Activity (APA) is perceived as a cross disciplinary body of
knowledge, directed towards identification and solution of psychomotor problems
throughout the life span. Further, it is a service delivery profession and an academic field
of study that supports an attitude of acceptance of individual differences, advocates
access to active lifestyles and sports and promotes innovation and cooperative service
delivery programs and empowerment systems (Hutzler & Sherrill, 2007; Reid & Stanish,
2003; IFAPA, 2004). According to Sherrill (2004), APA refers to the integration of
94
knowledge from many disciplines in the creation of a distinct, unique body of knowledge
focusing on adaptation, individual differences and physical activity. Information from
different academic disciplines, such as kinesiology, exercise and sport science, recreation
(leisure studies), social studies, special education, general education, counseling,
medicine, law, physical and occupational therapy are shaping therefore the knowledge
base of APA (Sherrill, 2004).
The European Association on Research into the APA field (EARAPA) defined
APA in terms of movement experiences and applications directed towards the needs,
interests and abilities of individuals with impairments, disabilities and handicaps (DollTepper, 1996, p. 598). Definitions of impairment, disability and handicap may be found
in a variety of academic textbooks, such as those of Winnick (2005), Sherrill (2004),
Steadward, Wheeler & Watkinson, (2003), etc. Disability for example, as a target area in
the APA field, was defined by Steadward et al (2003) as ‘any restriction or lack
(resulting from impairment) of ability to perform an activity in the manner or within the
range considered normal for a human being’ (p. 54). According to the International
Classification of Functioning and Health (ICF), disabilities as a general term were
revised as the human experience of activity limitations in their daily living. These
limitations must be severe enough to interfere with activities of daily living, like
dressing, general education, transportation, employment, etc., and are specific to
particular areas of human functioning. Further, definition of impairments was also
provided, while the term handicap is no longer used and substituted from the term
‘restrictions’. Based on the above description, daily activities may be adapted and the
experienced activity limitations can be minimized or even eliminated, providing this way
a less permanent and a more dynamic perspective in the disability term (Sherrill, 2004).
The importance of promoting research in the scientific field of APA stems mainly
from the world wide rising population of individuals with disabilities. Sherrill (2004) for
example stated that approximately 45 million of individuals experience some type of
disability in the USA (16% of the total population). According to the Federal Public
LAW (105-17) in USA, the 13 legally recognized disabilities are: autism, deaf-blindness,
hearing impairment, mental retardation, multiple disabilities, orthopedic impairments,
other health impairments, serious emotional disturbance, specific learning disability,
speech or language impairment, traumatic brain injury, and visual impairment including
blindness. Of this 45 million with disabilities in USA, 10% are children and adolescents,
30% are young and middle aged adults while over 50% are individuals above the age of
65. Further, approximately 10-12% of individuals experience disabilities from birth to
the age of 22 years old, and may benefit from special education services, including APA.
A variety of researchers have evaluated in the past the body of research in the
APA field (Reid & Prupas, 1998; Reid & Stanish, 2003; Sherrill, 1999; Sherrill &
O’Connor, 1999; Hutzler & Sherrill, 2007, Porretta & Sherrill, 2005). Reid and Stanish
(2003) for example examined the APA literature (APAQ and Clinical Kinesiology) in an
attempt to conclude whether APA represents a cross disciplinary knowledge base,
through the advancement of it’s theoretical knowledge from research. Further, Reid and
Stanish (2003) used the knowledge base flowing from academic research as the basic
criterion to evaluate the professional and academic discipline of APA. The researchers
stated that APA has a cross disciplinary knowledge base, borrowing terminology, theory
and methods from a variety of allied fields, such as kinesiology, psychology, sociology,
etc. Sherrill (1997) however, few years earlier had disputed the above conclusion and
opened up the way for researchers to support APA to meet all the necessary criteria and
get recognition as an autonomous academic discipline. Specifically, Sherrill (1997)
stated that ‘the first step in that direction is the publication of theoretically rich research
95
that helps to clarify our domain and seeking answers to vital questions related to a
healthy life style for all individuals involved’ (p. 3). Finally, few years later, Hutzler and
Sherrill (2007) claimed that APA may be perceived as a discipline that prepares
professionals to work in the field of physical activity for individuals with disabilities.
However, whether APA represents a unique discipline or cross discipline is still under
debate among academic scholars in the field (Hutzler & Sherrill, 2007; Sherrill &
DePauw, 1997).
Following the above studies (Reid & Prupas, 1998; Reid & Stanish, 2003;
Sherrill, 1999; Sherrill & O’Connor, 1999; Porretta & Sherrill, 2005), it was decided to
examine the APA literature in an attempt to describe the future trend in the APA research
field. Overall, the ‘major advances in APA over the past years have resulted from a
vigorous application of the scientific method, and this approach holds the greatest
promise as we move into the new millennium’ (Shepherd, 1999, p. 342).
2 Method
The major concern in the present study was to identify the sources where the major body
of research in the APA field may be found. Porretta and Sherrill (2005) stated that
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly (APAQ) and Palaestra are two well-known
scientific journals publicizing exclusively research in the APA field. The above
researchers stated that APA scholars publish in a variety of different journals while the
primary journal in the field is APAQ. The same direction was followed by Sherrill
(1999) who evaluated the first decade of publications in the APAQ, while Reid and
Stanish (2003) reviewed studies from APAQ and Clinical Kinesiology as representative
in the APA field. Finally, Hutzler and Sherrill (2007) stated that since 1994, the
International Federation of APA has selected APAQ as the main international journal
increasing the knowledge base of the field through research. Overall, following the
direction provided above from distinguished scholars in the past, we assumed that the
APAQ is representative of the research in our field, and as such was selected to evaluate
the research trends in APA. The study of Porretta and Sherrill (2005), examining the
APAQ publications during the last two decades, provided the rational for continuing
upon their work and examine the APAQ literature thereafter.
Personal accessibility over the APAQ publications was available since 2007.
Unfortunately, 1 volume during 2009 and 2 volumes during 2010 could not be retrieved.
Further, the last (4th) 2010 volume was not published yet by the time the present study
was conducted. Therefore, 12 APAQ volumes were evaluated, with a total of 56 studies
since 2007. The above studies may be found in Appendix 1.
Accordingly, the 56 studies were evaluated in an attempt to define the research
trends in APA. Following the example of previous researchers, the studies were
evaluated according to the scientific area examined (Porretta & Sherrill, 2005), disability
(Reid & Broadhead, 1995; Porretta & Sherrill, 2005), quantitative vs qualitative method
used (Sherrill & O’Connor, 1999; Bouffard, Strean & Davis, 1999), country authorship
(Porretta & Sherrill, 2005), sampling design (Sherrill & O’Connor, 1999), validity and
reliability reports (Yun & Ulrich, 2002), software for statistical analysis and theories
used (Sherrill, 1997, 1999; Reid & Broadhead, 1995).
Concerning the area, the attempt was to retain those identified by Porretta and
Sherrill (2005), and the respective brief definitions may be found in Appendix 2. The
disabilities identified may be found in Appendix 3. For the quantitative vs qualitative
distinction between studies the definitions of Langdridge (2004) were used (Appendix
96
4), while country authorship was determined by ‘the university/ agency affiliation and
mailing address at time of publication’ (Porretta & Sherrill, 2005, p. 126). In the present
study, authors were counted additionally in case they had published more than once in
APAQ since 2007. Further, the research sampling design, the software used for statistical
analysis and validity and reliability reports were counted to strengthen the evaluation of
research studies in an attempt to detect the research trends in APA (Sherrill & O’Connor,
1999, Sutlive & Ulrich, 1998, Yun & Ulrich, 2002).
Finally, the present study evaluated the theories used in the APA literature, since
2007. According to Slife and Williams (1995) theories may be perceived as formalized
ideas applied to explain different phenomena. Sherrill (1999) stated that theories
constitute a conceptual framework in which inter related knowledge is synthesized in an
attempt to describe, or even predict the phenomena we examine. Further, Sherrill (1999)
stated that in ‘selecting topics for future research, we should be cognizant of their
underlying theories and how they fit together to form the whole that makes up our
knowledge base’ (p. 212). Following the above suggestions, it appeared that the
evaluation of theories publicized in the APAQ were of significant merit for describing
the respective research trends. For the purposes of the present study, we counted the
frequency and content of theories specifically presented into the 56 APAQ publications,
which in turn were either incorporated as separate sub sections or specifically addressed
within the introduction.
3 Results
The 56 studies were evaluated according to the respective area examined, disability,
quantitative vs qualitative method used, country authorship, sampling design, validity
and reliability reports, software for statistical analysis and theories used. Reliability
checking was conducted with a doctorate student in the APA field. The percentage of
agreement obtained between researchers was above 80% (Thomas & Nelson, 2001) and
the results are presented accordingly.
Concerning the scientific areas, the majority of publications since 2007 examined
psychosocial issues (16 studies, 28.57%), measurement/ assessment/ classification (9
studies, 16.07%), motor behavior (8 studies, 14.29%), exercise science/ physical activity
(8 studies, 14.29%) and biomechanics (5 studies, 8.92%). No history studies were
identified and the overall findings are presented in table 1.
Table 1. The areas identified in APA.
Scientific Focus
Frequency
Psychosocial issues
Motor behavior
Exercise science/ physical activity
Inclusion/ programming
Measurement/ assessment/ classification
Research issues
Professional preparation/ issues
Biomechanics
Pedagogy
Other
History
Total
16 (28.57%)
8 (14.29%)
8 (14.29%)
4 (07.14%)
9 (16.07%)
1 (01.79%)
1 (01.79%)
5 (08.92%)
1 (01.79%)
3 (05.35%)
56 (100%)
97
With respect to the disabilities examined, the majority evaluated samples of individuals
with physical (11 studies, 21.15%) and intellectual disabilities (10 studies, 19.23%). The
generic studies were next, with samples of e.g. parents, students without disabilities (7
studies, 13.46%) etc, while no studies were published examining individuals with
hearing impairment, learning disabilities, and at-risk infant-toddlers. The above findings
are presented in table 2.
For the quantitative vs qualitative distinction, 34 studies were evaluated as quantitative,
13 studies were qualitative and 3 studies used mixed quantitative and qualitative
methods. Further, 3 review studies were identified which were not counted as either
quantitative or qualitative.
Table 2. Disabilities identified in the APA literature.
Disability
Frequency
Generic
(13.46%)
Intellectual disability (Mental Retardation)
Multiple sample
(03.85%)
Physical disability
DCD/ awkward/ MI
(07.69%)
Down syndrome
(01.92%)
Neurological impairment
(07.69%)
Hearing impairment
Medical conditions
(01.92%)
Emotional/ behavioral disorders
(05.77%)
Visual impairment
(03.85%)
Learning disabilities
Autism
(03.85%)
Multiple disabilities
(05.77%)
Gerontology
(03.85%)
At-risk infant toddlers
Total
7
10 (19.23%)
2
11 (21.15%)
4
1
4
1
3
2
2
3
2
52 (100%)
Researchers from 19 separate countries appeared in the APAQ since 2007. The
researchers from the USA appeared in 33 studies, with colleagues from Canada (12
studies), Australia (6 studies) and Belgium (5 studies) being next. The respective data
from country authorship may be found in table 3.
The specific sampling design used was introduced in 36 studies. The majority of the
above studies incorporated recruited (11 studies), purposive (9 studies), and convenience
(8 studies) sampling selection methods. In turn, volunteer sampling (3 studies) and
random selection/ assignment (2 studies) were coming next. Single case study,
98
representative sampling selection and invited to participate methods of sampling, were
used in one study each.
Accordingly, validity and reliability reports appeared in 40 studies. A variety of
methods were used to report the validity and reliability evidence, and as such, it was not
feasible to summarize the respective findings, which are presented in table 4.
Interestingly, trustworthiness was the method appeared most often, in 8 separate studies,
and was related to validity methods in studies using qualitative methods of research.
Statistical analyses used mainly an SPSS version (13 studies), with SPSS-14
more often reported (5 studies). Interestingly, the SPSS-15 was the latest version
reported in one study only, although latest SPSS versions are nowadays available for
researchers and statisticians to use (e.g. SPSS-19). The LISREL and PRELIS were
reported in three studies for conducting Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA). Further,
the LISREL 8.54 was reported in one study for reporting CFA results as well. Other
statistical software used was the Strata 9.0 (1 study), the SAS (1 study) and the Statistica
6.0 (1 study).
With respect to the theories used, a total of 35 studies (66.04%) indicated the
exact theory guiding the respective research study. The social cognitive theory of selfefficacy (Bandura, 1997) and the self-determination theory (Wehmeyer, 1998;
Wehmeyer & Gamer, 2003; Deci & Ryan, 1985, 1991) were the most commonly used.
The above results are summarized in table 5.
Table 3. Country authorship.
Country authorship
Frequency
Australia
Belgium
Brazil
Canada
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Hong Kong
Israel
Latvia
Netherlands
Norway
Poland
Puerto Rico
Portugal
Spain
Taiwan
USA
6 studies
5 studies
1 study
12 studies
1 study
1 study
1 study
1 study
2 studies
2 studies
1 study
3 studies
1 study
2 studies
1 study
1 study
2 studies
1 study
33 studies
Country authorship is listed alphabetically and was determined by the affiliation and
mailing address at time of publication
Table 4. Validity and reliability reports.
Method
Frequency
99
Quantitative research method
Reliability
Internal consistency
Intraclass coefficients
Internal consistency – Inter rater reliability
Internal consistency – test retest
Reliability – accuracy
Inter observer agreement
Validity
Construct validity
Content validity
Translation validity
Concurrent validity
Reliability and validity
Test retest – Intraclass – Concurrent validity
Test retest reliability – Convergent validity
Qualitative research method
Trustworthiness
Credibility
Triangulation
3 studies
3 studies
2 studies
2 studies
5 studies
6 studies
2 studies
1 study
1 study
1 study
1 study
1 study
8 studies
2 studies
2 studies
Table 5. Theories used.
Researchers
Theory
Oh & Kozub (2010)
Todd et al (2010)
Sousa et al (2009)
Self-efficacy theory
Self-determination theory
Conception of the lived body
(1996)
Hierarchical model of self-esteem
and self efficacy
Self-efficacy theory
Mazzoni et al (2009)
Kasser (2009)
1986)
D’Hondt et al (2009)
Standal & Jespersen (2008)
Moola et al (2008)
Klavina & Block (2008)
Martin (2008)
Driver (2008)
Pan (2008)
& Ryan
(1985, 1991)
Collumna et al (2008)
(1977)
Citation
Bandura (1997)
Wehmeyer (1998)
Merleau-Ponty
Fox (2000)
Bandura (1977)
Bandura (1977,
Activity-deficit hypothesis
Wall (2004)
Bouffard et al (1996)
Situated learning theory
Social cognitive theory
Contact theory
Social cognitive theory
Self-worth model
Self-determination
Wenger (1998)
Bandura (1977)
Allport (1954, 1979)
Bandura (1977)
Harter (1987)
Wehmeyer & Gamer
(2003); Deci
Ecological model of
Bronfenbrenner
human development
Hutzler & Sherrill (2007)
(2003)
An & Goodwin (2007)
Arbour et al (2007)
Driver (2007)
Social constructionism
Denzin & Lincoln
Disablement model
Peters (1996)
Social identity theory
Turner (1984)
Multidimensional social influence Chogahara (1999)
100
Maiano et al (2007)
(1976)
Hutzler (2007)
Perreault & Vallerand (2007)
1991)
Multidimensional self-concept
Shavelson et al
Systematic ecological
model in APA
Self determination theory
Hutzler (2007)
Deci & Ryan (1985,
4 Discussion
The present study examined the research trends in APA. As such, and following the
example of previous scientific reports (Porretta & Sherrill, 2005; Sherrill 1997) the
APAQ publications since 2007 were selected to serve the present research purpose. A
total of 56 studies were evaluated and the results are presented accordingly.
The most commonly examined subject area included psychosocial issues
(28.57%), followed by measurement/ assessment/ classification (16.07%), motor
behavior (14.29%), exercise science (14.29%) and biomechanics (8.29%). Individuals
with physical disabilities (21.15%) were the most commonly examined, followed by
individuals with mental retardation (19.23%), developmental coordination disorder-DCD
(7.69%) and neurological impairment (7.69%). The generic group, incorporating
individuals without disabilities, was examined in 13.64% of the studies.
The quantitative research methods used were evident in 34 studies, while 13
studies reported qualitative methods and 3 studies used mixed (quantitative and
qualitative) methods. The USA was most commonly seen as country authorship,
followed by Canada, Australia, Belgium and the Netherlands. The common sampling
methods used were either recruited (N = 11), volunteer (N = 3), purposive (N = 9) and
convenience (N = 8). The SPSS was used in 13 studies for data analysis, while
quantitative validity and reliability reports were evident in 28 studies. Twelve more
studies used qualitative reports of validity and reliability evidence, presented as either
trustworthiness, credibility and triangulation.
Comparison of the present figures with those reported by Porretta and Sherrill
(2005) revealed the following, with respect to the scientific area examined: Inclusion
(7.14%) and professional preparation (1.79%) research were less than the 13.38% and
4.46% respective figures of Porretta and Sherrill (2005). In turn, the 8.92% in
biomechanics was higher compared to the respective 2.97% during the last two decades.
No history studies were reported since 2007 which is similar to the previous figure of
0.37%. Overall, it appears that the editors interest for publicizing research from the
biomechanics field has increased lately, while there is a slight drop for inclusion and
professional preparation. The psychosocial, motor behavior, exercise science and
measurement gather the highest research attention and this trend remains invariant across
time.
Concerning the population examined, no studies with at-risk infant toddlers,
individuals with hearing impairment and learning disabilities were published during the
last four years. Individuals with autism (3.85%) and gerontology (3.85%) were more
often examined than the 0.37% and 0.74% figures reported by Porretta and Sherrill
(2005). The DCD group of children retained a similar scientific interest (7.69% since
2007 vs 9.29% during the last two decades). Further, physical disabilities (21.15%),
MR/ID (19.23%) and generic studies (13.46%) gathered the highest research attention
lately. Porretta and Sherrill 92005) reported a 13.75% for physical disabilities, 30.11%
for generic research and 15.24% for individuals with mental retardation (MR/ ID).
101
Overall, physical disabilities and mental retardation still accumulate a wide research
attention, while there is a tendency for a decrease number of research studies in the
generic field.
Authorship from the USA was still the dominant figure (42.86%), although
smaller than the 52.34% reported by Porretta and Sherrill (2005). The present and past
figures from Canada (15.58% vs 14.48%), Australia (6.49% vs 4.45%), and Netherlands
(3.90% vs 3.79%) remained similar, while there was a slight increase in the studies from
Belgium (6.49% vs 3.56%). Surprisingly, no researchers from England appeared in the
APAQ throughout the last four years, compared to the 6.46% reported for the previous
two decades. Further, no publications were reported from New Zealand, Ireland,
Sweden, Singapore, Republic of Korea, China and Jordan (Porretta & Sherrill, 2005),
while new authorship was reported from Brazil, Latvia, Polland and Puerto Rico.
Overall, it appears that the APAQ editors are open to international publications from a
variety of countries. However, authorship from North America (USA and Canada) still
approach almost 60% of the total publications. Therefore, although a variety of
researchers from different countries are welcome to submit their studies in the APAQ,
they have, proportionally, a limited space for their research work to be published.
Finally, researchers in the APA field may also attend other journals to publicize their
studies, besides APAQ, which may be an explanation for the absence of research studies
reported from England lately.
Although not presented as a separate research hypothesis, there was a further
attempt to evaluate the representativeness of male and female researchers in the APAQ,
following the example of Sherrill and O’Connor (1999). The only criterion used in that
case was the researcher’s first name and as such, the results may not be valid enough to
consider. Consultation with a doctorate student revealed several cases where it was not
possible to determine the researcher’s gender and these cases were excluded from
statistical recording. Overall, the percentage of male and female researchers (52.91% vs
47.09%) since 2007 was similar with the 55% vs 45% reported by Sherrill and O’Connor
(1999). Male and female researchers therefore appear to have similar accessibility in the
APAQ. However, the present findings are limited from the method used to analyze our
data and should be considered with extreme caution.
As mentioned above, the dominant sampling design was recruited, purposive,
convenience and volunteer, all counting for 58.49% of the sampling methods used since
2007. Similarly, Sherrill and O’Connor (1999) reported random, purposive, volunteer,
systematic and convenience as the more frequently sampling methods used. In the
present study however, random selection/ assignment was reported for two studies only.
This fact, along with the added tendency for a more qualitative research method used
(reported below) and a lower tendency to report sophisticated statistical software
(reported below), may be indicative for a shift of APA research towards examining
specific samples, an attempt to get more in depth understanding, without a general
tendency to generalize the findings and an overall qualitative tendency for future
researchers in the field.
The quantitative vs qualitative research method used since 2007 revealed 34 and
13 studies respectively, while 3 studies reported mixed (quantitative and qualitative)
methods. Review studies were not counted as either quantitative or qualitative for the
purpose of the present analysis. Therefore, a total of 16 studies used qualitative methods
of research, which represented a respective figure of 32%. The 32% is higher compared
to the 5.26% reported by Sherrill and O’Connor (1999) and indicative for a shift towards
qualitative methods of research in the APA field.
102
The SPSS was the statistical software more often reported for statistical analysis.
Further, a variety of reliability and validity evidence were reported for a total of 40
studies, following the suggestions of Yun and Ulrich (2002). Yun and Ulrich (2002)
however presented mainly methods for sample specific validity and reliability evidence
in quantitative research (construct validity, concurrent validity, internal consistency, inter
observer agreement). The present study revealed that their suggestions were followed in
28 quantitative studies since 2007. Further, 12 qualitative studies followed the
suggestions of Yun and Ulrich (2002) but reported different methods for providing
validity and reliability evidence, such as trustworthiness (8 studies), credibility (2
studies) and triangulation (2 studies). Overall, the general guidelines of Yun and Ulrich
(2002) and other researchers in the field (e.g. Sherrill & O’Connor, 1999) still prevail
since APA researchers need to provide validity and reliability evidence for their findings.
The validity and reliability reports however, may vary, according to the quantitative or
qualitative method used to examine their research hypothesis.
A total of 35 publications (66.04%) reported the theory used to guide the
respective research studies. This figure is in agreement with scholars in the field who
suggested that APA is strongly driven by theory (Sherrill, 1997; Bouffard & Watkinson,
1998; Sherrill, 1999; Sherrill & O’Connor, 1999; Reid & Stanish, 2003; Hutzler &
Sherrill, 2007). According to Slife and Williams (1995), theories may be perceived as
formalized ideas, such as understandings, observations, assumptions, etc., applied in an
effort to understand a variety of phenomena. The theories more often emerging in the
APAQ, since 2007, were the self-efficacy theory (Bandura, 1977) and the selfdetermination theory (Deci & Ryan, 1985, 1991; Wehmeyer, 1998; Wehmeyer & Sands,
1996; Wehmeyer & Gamer, 2003). In brief, Bandura (1997) stated that self-efficacy is
the individual’s belief of his/ her personal capacity to be successful. High levels of selfefficacy result in higher motivation and desire to excel. Individuals with assurance of
their personal abilities tend to focus on challenging goals and persist when facing
difficulties. Individuals, however, with lower self-efficacy, avoid challenging goals and
withdraw easily when facing difficulties (Bandura, 1997). In turn, self-determination
(Deci & Ryan, 1985, 1991) is a life long developmental process. According to
Wehmeyer and Sands (1996), self-determination is leading individuals ‘to act as the
primary causal agent in one’s life, and to make choices and decisions regarding one’s
quality of life, free from undue external influence or interference’ (p. 24). Autonomy,
self-regulated behavior, psychological empowerment and self-realization are the four
main characteristics which must be met for an individual to be self-determined. Finally,
the APAQ publications since 2007 revealed a unique research study introducing an
innovative theory in the APA field (Hutzler, 2007). Specifically, Hutzler (2007)
presented a systematic ecological model for adapting physical activities. This model was
developed as a theoretical frame to guide researchers and practitioners in the APA field
and was not borrowed from allied disciplines (such as psychology and sociology).
5 Conclusions
The purpose of the present study was to detect the research trends in adapted physical
activity (APA). The APAQ publications, since 2007 were examined for that purpose and
the results revealed a decrease in generic research and an emphasis in specific samples
recruited with a variety of sampling methods, other than those commonly used in
experimental research. A wide increase in qualitative methods was reported suggesting
that there is a research trend towards a more specific, qualitative approach in the field.
103
Further, validity and reliability reports were still prominent, while no emphasis was
provided on sophisticated statistical software. Finally, the suggestions of scholars in the
field were kept and the APAQ literature may be perceived as strongly driven by theory.
The present findings are in agreement with Bouffard, Strean & Davis (1998) who
stated that ‘a related trend is to strive from a heavy focus on statistical analysis toward
more emphasis on meaning derived from language, discourse and symbols’ (p. 264).
This trend may be a healthy way to afford more focus upon the individual, at least when
we want an individual level of analysis (Bouffard et al., 1998). Overall, a tendency for
researchers appears in the field to withdraw from aggregating data when working with
individuals, freeing this way themselves from a perceived obligation to legitimize and
validate all information they collect with probability values (Bouffard, 1993).
6 References
Bandura, A. (1977). Social Learning Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Bandura, A. (1997). Self efficacy: The exercise of control. New York: W. H. Freeman &
Company.
Bouffard, M. (1993). The perils of averaging data in adapted physical activity research.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 10, 371-391.
Bouffard, M., Strean, W. B., & Davis, W. B. (1998). Questioning our philosophical and
methodological research assumptions: Psychological perspectives. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 15, 250-268.
Bouffard, M., & Watkinson, J. (1998). Special issue: Questioning our research
assumptions. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 15(3).
Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (1985, 1991). Intrinsic Motivation and Self-determination in
Human Behavior. New York, NY: Plenum Press.
Doll-Tepper, G. (1996). Developments and perspectives of sports with special groups in
a European context. In H. Rieder, G. Huber, & J. Werle (Eds.), Sport with special
groups: A textbook (pp. 595-609). Schorndorf, Germany: Hoffman Verlag.
International Federation of Adapted Physical Activity (IFAPA: 2004). By Laws. Online
retrievable from http://www.ifapa.biz/imgs/uploads/PDF/IFAPA%20ByLaws.pdf.
Google: http://dictionary.reference.com, http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/trend,
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/research.
Hutzler, Y. (2007). A systematic ecological model for adapting physical activities:
Theoretical foundations and practical examples. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 24, 287-304.
Hutzler, Y., & Sherrill, C. (2007). Defining adapted physical activity: International
perspectives. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 24, 1-20.
Langdridge, D. (2004). Introduction to Research Methods and Data Analysis in
Psychology. Boston, MA: Pearson-Prentice Hall.
Porretta, D. L., & Sherrill, C. (2005). APAQ at twenty: A documentary analysis. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 22, 119-135.
Reid, G., & Brodhead, G. D. (1995). APAQ at ten: A documentary analysis. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 11(1), 1-2.
Reid, G., & Prupas, A. (1998). A documentary analysis of research priorities in disability
sport. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 15, 168-178.
Reid, G., & Stanish, H. (2003). Professional and disciplinary status of adapted physical
activity. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 20, 213-229.
104
Shepherd, R. (1999). Postmodernism and adapted physical activity: A new gnostic
heresy? Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 16, 331-343.
Sherrill, C. (1997). Past, present, future. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 14, 1-7.
Sherrill, C. (1999). Disability sport and classification theory: A new era. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 16, 206-215.
Sherrill, C. (2004). Adapted Physical Activity, Recreation and Sport: Crossdisciplinary
and Lifespan (6th ed.). Boston, MA: McGraw Hill Higher Education.
Sherrill, C., & DePauw, K. (1997). Adapted physical activity and education. In J.
Massengale & R. Swanson (Eds.). History of Exercise and Sport Science (pp. 39108). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Sherrill, C., & O’Connor, J. (1999). Guidelines for improving adapted physical activity
research. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 16, 1-8.
Slife, B. D., & Williams, R. N. (1995). What’s Behind the Research? Discovering
Hidden Assumptions in the Behavioral Sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications.
Steadward, R.D., Wheeler, G.D., & Watkinson, E.J. (Eds) (2003). Adapted Physical
Activity. Alberta, BC: Alberta University Press.
Sutlive, V. H., & Ulrich, D. A. (1998). Interpreting statistical significance and
meaningfulness in adapted physical activity research. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 15, 103-118.
Thomas, J., & Nelson, J. (2001). Research Methods in Physical Activity (3rd ed.).
Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
Winnick, J. P. (2005). Adapted Physical Education and Sport (4th ed.). Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics.
Yun, J., & Ulrich, D. A. (2002). Estimating measurement validity: A tutorial. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 19, 32-47.
Wehmeyer, M. L. (1998). Self-determination and individuals with significant disabilities:
Examining meanings and misinterpretations. The Journal of the Association for
Persons with Severe Handicaps, 23, 5-16.
Wehmeyer, M. L., & Gamer, N. W. (2003). The impact of personal characteristics of
people with intellectual and developmental disability on self-determination and
autonomous functioning. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities,
16, 255-265.
Wehmeyer, M. L., & Sands, D. L. (1996). Self-determination across the lifespan:
Independence and choice for people with disabilities. Baltimore, MD: Paul H.
Brookes Publishing Co.
105
Appendix 1
The 12 APAQ volumes, since 2007, with the 56 studies used to evaluate the research
trends in APA
2007 (1)
1) Hutzler, Y., & Sherrill, C. (2007). Defining adapted physical activity: International
perspectives. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 1-20.
2) Hodge, S., Kozub, F., Robinson, L., & Hersman, B. (2007). Reporting gender,
race, ethnicity, and sociometric status: Guidelines for research and professional
practice. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 21-37.
3) An, J., & Goodwin, D. (2007). Physical education for students with spina bifida:
Mother’s perspectives. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 38-58.
4) Van Waelvelde, H., Peersman, W., Lenoir, M., & Smits Engelsman, B. (2007).
Convergent validity between two motor tests: Movement ABC and PDMS-2.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 59-69.
5) Davis, R., Kotecki, J., Harvey, M., & Oliver, A. (2007). Responsibilities and
training needs of paraeducators in physical education. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 1, 70-83.
2007 (2)
1) Block, M., & Obrusnikova, I. (2007). Inclusion in physical education: A review of
the literature. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 2, 103-124.
2) Lahtinen, U., Rintala, P., & Malin, A. (2007). Physical performance of individuals
with intellectual disability: A 30-year follow-up. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 2, 125-143.
3) Arbour, K., Latimer, A., Martin Ginis, K., & Jung, M. (2007). Moving beyond the
stigma: The impression formation benefits of exercise for individuals with a physical
disability. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 2, 144-159.
4) Driver, S. (2007). Psychometric properties and analysis of the physical activity
social influence scale for adults with traumatic brain injuries. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 2, 160-177.
5) Maiano, C., Ninot, G., Morin, A., & Bilard, J. (2007). Effects of sport
participation on the basketball skills and physical self of adolescents with conduct
disorders. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 2, 178-196.
2007 (3)
1) Ray, C., Horvat, M., Williams, M., & Blasch, B. (2007). Kinetic movement
analysis in adults with vision loss. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 209-217.
2) Beets, M., Foley, J., Tindall, D., & Lieberman, L. (2007). Accuracy of voiceannouncement pedometers for youth with visual impairment. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 3, 218-227.
3) Beets, M., Combs, C., Pitetti, K., Morgan, M., Bryan, R., & Foley, J. (2007).
Accuracy of pedometer steps and time for youth with disabilities. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 3, 228-244.
4) Motl, R., Zhu, W., Park, Y., McAuley, E., Scott, J., & Snook, E. (2007).
Reliability of scores from physical activity monitors in adults with multiple sclerosis.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 245-253.
5) Reina, R., Moreno, F., & Sanz, D. (2007). Visual behavior and motor responses of
novice and experienced wheelchair tennis players relative to the service return.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 254-271.
106
2007 (4)
1) Hutzler, Y. (2007). Systematic ecological model for adapting physical activities:
Theoretical foundations and practice examples. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly,
4, 287-304.
2) Perreault, S., & Vallerand, R. (2007). A test of self-determination theory with
wheelchair basketball players with and without disability. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 4, 305-316.
3) Frossard, L., Smeathers, J., O’Riordan, A., & Goodman, S. (2007). Shot trajectory
parameters in gold medal stationary shot-putters during world-class competition.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4, 317-331.
4) Chrysagis, N., Skordilis, E. K., Koutsouki, D., & Evans, E. (2007). Kinesthetic
ability in children with spastic hemiplegia. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4,
332-351.
5) Passmore, S., Burke, J., & Lyons, J. (2007). Older adults demonstrate reduced
performance in a Fitts’ task involving cervical spine movement. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 4, 352-363.
2008 (1)
1) Przysucha, E., Taylor, M. J., & Weber, D. (2008). The nature and control of
postural adaptations of boys with and without developmental coordination disorder.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 1-16.
2) Deconinck, F. J., De Clercq, D., Von Coster, R., Oostra, A., Dewitte, G.,
Savelsbergh, G., Cambier, D., & Lenoir, M. (2008). Sensory contributions to balance
in boys with developmental coordination disorder. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 1, 17-35.
3) Pedersen, S. J., & Surburg, P. R. (2008). Lower extremity movement preparation
and children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 1, 36-48.
4) Moola, F., Faulkner, G., Kirsh, J., & Kilburn, J. (2008). Physical activity and sport
participation in youth with congenital heart disease: Perceptions of children and
parents. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 49-70.
5) Simons, J., Daly, D., Theodorou, F., Caron, C., Simons, J., & Andoniadou, E.
(2008). Validity and reliability of the TGMD-2 in 7-10 year-old Flemish children
with intellectual disability. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 71-82.
2008 (2)
1) Frey, G., Stanish, H., & Temple, V. (2008). Physical activity of youth with
intellectual disability: Review and research agenda. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 2, 95-117.
2) Bryant, L., Curtner-Smith, M. (2008). Impact of a physical education teacher’s
disability on elementary pupils’ perceptions of effectiveness and learning. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 2, 118-131.
3) Klavina, A., & Block, M. (2008). The effect of peer tutoring on interaction
behaviors in inclusive physical education. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 2,
132-158.
4) Hechler, T., Rieger, E., Touyz, S., Beumont, P., Plasqui, G., & Westerterp, K.
(2008). Physical activity and body composistion in outpatients recovering from
107
anorexia nervosa and healthy controls. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 2, 159173.
2008 (3)
1) Giacobbi, P., Stancil, M., Hardin, B., & Bryant, L. (2008). Physical activity and
quality of life experienced by highly active individuals with physical disabilities.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 189-207.
2) Standal, O., & Jespersen, E. (2008). Peers as resources for learning: A situated
learning approach to adapted physical activity in rehabilitation. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 3, 208-227.
3) Columna, L., Pyfer, J., Senne, T., Velez, L., Bridenthrall, N., & Canabal, M.
(2008). Parental expectations of adapted physical educators: A Hispanic perspective.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 228-246.
4) Sit, C., McKenzie, T., Lian, J., & McManus, A. (2008). Activity levels during
physical education and recess in two special schools for children with mild
intellectual disabilities. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 247-259.
2008 (4)
1) Martin, J. (2008). Multidimensional self-efficacy and affect in wheelchair
basketball players. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4, 275-288.
2) Driver, S. (2008). Development of a conceptual model to predict physical activity
participation in adults with brain injuries. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4,
289-307.
3) Pan, C. (2008). School time physical activity of students with and without autism
spectrum disorders during PE and recess. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4,
308-321.
4) Wang, Y., Bernard, R., Cope, C., Chang, L., Limroongreungrat, W., & Sprigle, S.
(2008). Fundamental locomotive activity time efficiency with differently positioning
drive-axis wheelchairs among elders. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4, 322334.
5) Molik, B., Lubelska, E., Kosmol, A., Bogdan, M., Yilla, A., & Hyla, E. (2008).
An examination of the International Wheelchair Rugby Federation classification
system utilizing parameters of offensive game efficiency. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 4, 335-351.
2009 (1)
1) Rossow-Kimball, B., & Goodwin, D. (2009). Self-determination and leisure
experiences of women living in two group homes. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 1, 1-20.
2) D’Hondt, E., Deforche, B., De Bourdeaudhuij, I., & Lenoir, M. (2009).
Relationship between motor skill and body mass index in 5- to 10- year old children.
Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 21-37.
3) Loh, P., Piek, J., & Barrrett, N. (2009). The use of the developmental coordination
disorder questionnaire in Australian children. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1,
38-53.
4) Skowronski, W., Horvat, M., Nocera, J., Roswal, G., & Croce, R. (2009). Eurofit
special: European fitness battery score variation among individuals with intellectual
disabilities. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 54-67.
108
5) Harada, C., & Siperstein, G. (2009). The sport experience of athletes with
intellectual disabilities: A national survey of Special Olympics athletes and their
families. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 1, 68-85.
2009 (3)
1) Seymour, H., Reid, G., & Bloom, G. (2009). Friendship in inclusive physical
education. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 201-219.
2) Kim, S., & Yun, J. (2009). Determining daily physical activity levels of youth
with developmental disabilities: Days of monitoring required. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 3, 220-235.
3) Sousa, A., Corredeira, R., & Pereira, A. (2009). The body in persons with an
amputation. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 236-258.
4) Mazzoni, E., Purves, L., Southward, J., Rhodes, R., & Temple, V. (2009). Effects
of indoor wall climbing on self-efficacy and self-perceptions of children with special
needs. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 259-273.
5) Kasser, S. (2009). Exercising with multiple sclerosis: Insights into meaning and
motivation. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 274-289.
2009 (4)
1) Shields, N., Dodd, K., & Abblitt, C. (2009). Do children with Down syndrome
perform sufficient physical activity to maintain good health? A pilot study. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 4, 307-320.
2) Sit, C., Lau, C., & Vertinsky, P. (2009). Physical activity and self-perceptions
among Hong Kong Chinese. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 4, 321-335.
3) Pitetti, K., Beets, M., & Flaming, J. (2009). Accuracy of pedometer steps and time
for youth with intellectual disabilities during dynamic movement. Adapted Physical
Activity Quarterly, 4, 336-351.
4) Costa, G., Rubio, M., Belloch, S., & Soriano, P. (2009). Case study: Effect of
handrim diameter on performance in a Paralympic wheelchair athlete. Adapted
Physical Activity Quarterly, 4, 352-363.
2010 (3)
1) Cervantes, C., & Porretta, D. (2010). Physical activity measurement among
individuals with disabilities: A literature review. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 3, 173-190.
2) Oh, H., & Kozub, F. (2010). The psychometric properties of the Difficult Behavior
Self-efficacy scale. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 191-207.
3) Mauerberg-deCastro, E., Lucena, C., Cuba, B., Boni, R., Campbell, D., & Moraes,
R. (2010). Haptic stabilization of posture in adults with intellectual disabilities using
a nonrigid tool. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 208-225.
4) Todd, T., Reid, G., & Butler-Kisber, L. (2010). Cycling for students with ASD:
Self-regulation promotes sustained physical activity. Adapted Physical Activity
Quarterly, 3, 226-241.
5) Van Biesen, D., Verellen, J., Meyer, C., Mactavish, J., Van de Vliet, P., &
Vanlandewijck, Y. (2010). The ability of elite table tennis players with intellectual
disabilities to adapt their service/ return. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly, 3, 242257.
Appendix 2
109
The areas identified and their respective definitions to evaluate the research trends
in APA (Porretta & Sherrill, 2005).
Pedagogy: teacher behavior
Inclusion/ programming: activity setting where persons with and without
disabilities participate together
Measurement/ assessment/ classification: psychometric properties of instruments
or focus on disability classification issues
Biomechanics: Kinetics or kinematics of motion
Exercise science/ physical activity: Effects of exercise or activity on human body
Motor behavior: Development, performance, learning and control of movement
Psychosocial: Psychological or sociological perspectives
Research issues: General or specific research methodologies or practices
Professional preparation issues: Preparation of teachers/ coaches or issues driven
by legislation, litigation, innovation, etc.
History: Changes over time
Other: Articles not categorized into one of the above areas
110
Appendix 3
Disabilities identified in the APA literature (Porretta & Sherrill, 2005; Reid &
Broadhead, 1995)
Generic, mental retardation-ID, Down syndrome, physical disabilities, multiple
sample, DCD/ awkward/ MI, learning disabilities, at-risk infant toddlers,
developmental delay (preschool), neurological impairments (cerebral palsy, TBI,
stroke, multiple sclerosis, etc), medical conditions (e.g congenital heart disease),
visual impairment, hearing impairment, emotional/ behavioral disorders,
gerontology, autism, multiple disabilities.
Examples:
Physical disabilities: e.g muscular dystrophy, spinal injury, amputations, etc
Emotional/ behavioral disorders: e.g. depression, anorexia nervosa, hyperactivity
(ADHD), conduct disorder
Multiple disabilities: two or more conditions concurrently
Multiple sample: individuals from different disability categories
Neurological impairments: incorporated TBI, Stroke, multiple sclerosis etc.
Cerebral palsy was incorporated as well and therefore, was not included under
physical disabilities
Appendix 4
Definitions of quantitative and qualitative research
Langdridge (2004)
Quantitative research concerns the quantity of measurements of some
phenomenon. Quantifying phenomena. If we measure things accurately, we can make
claims about the object of study. Hypothetico-deductive approach to knowledge
acquisition. Generalization focus. Large samples.
Qualitative research is concerned with the qualities of some phenomenon. Is
concerned with text and meaning. Inductive approach to knowledge acquisition.
There are no truths about the world. More in depth focus. Limited samples.
111
A special kinetic programme for advancement of coordination skills in
paravaulting training.
Mgr. Jana Sklenaříková, Faculty of Sport Studies, Masaryk Univerzity Brno, Czech
Republic.
Abstract
Paravaulting, or acrobatics on horseback, is one of many rehabilitation
methods based on therapeutic pedagogical-psychological riding, and at
the same time one of discipline sport riding for disabled people.
Coordination skills are basic components of motor training in
paravaulting. The aim of the study was to examine if regular
paravaulting exercises influence coordination skills of disabled
competitors. We performed an experimental examination for selected
group in term of kinetic tests. The intervention program improved basic
skills, supporting this way the research hypothesis. The results are
further discussed in detail.
Keywords: hippo therapy; paravaulting; horse; gymnast; kinetic tests
1 Introduction
Sports and rehabilitation for disabled individuals incorporate newly established
and innovative methods such as the hippo rehabilitation, hippo therapy or paravaulting.
Paravaulting for example allows the opportunity of expression, self-fulfillment and the
development of creative skills. The paravaulting is performed by individuals with
different disabilities, who learn with each other respect and tolerance. Vaulters are
trained and compete together. In addition to the cooperation between them, exercising
on the horseback leads to greater responsibilities, autonomy and physical coordination
(Ježková, Nejezchlebová, 2002).
Paravaulting, or acrobatics on the horse back, is one of the rehabilitation
methods based on therapeutic pedagogical-psychological riding, at the same time it is
also a discipline of sport riding for disabled people. Three-dimensional movement of the
horse can have a beneficial effect on clients with impaired mobility, holding body,
coordination and balance. It is a complex therapeutic method which is intended for a
wide range of clients with physical, mental or educational problems. These sports
disciplines have a high claim to correct technical performance and harmonize
movement with horses. Paravaulting has also specific aims in addition to other forms of
therapeutics horse riding. It means mainly developing and improving motor skills of
disabled individuals (Kulichová et al., 1995). This sport is recommended particularly
for people with special types of handicaps: Cerebral Palsy, Down syndrome, Autistic
behavior or Diabetes mellitus. Handicapped clients (paravaulters/gymnast) performed
acrobatic exercises on the horse with medical attendants.
1.1 Training model of paravaulting
Paravaulting is physically demanding discipline which places heavy demands on
coordination and joint mobility. A gymnast must practice on a relatively small and
constantly moving area, which is the saddle of a horse. The basic physical ability is the
112
dynamic force and an additional static force. Static force is needed during the endurance
exercises. Endurance exercise must be performed for 4 seconds, representing the horses
four beat gait. These four steps are the regular rhythm of the horse, which aids the
exercise (Ježková, Nejezchlebová, 2002).
Paravaulting is rhythmic exercise where the rhythm of horses helps to induce
concentration of the gymnast. Gymnasts should learn to be aware of their body, the
location of body parts, control muscle tone and be able to keep an upright sitting
position. Training unit was formed to match the general requirements for construction
and training tailored to the specificity of work horses and work with disabled vaulters.
For paravaulters is important that the schedule of training remains consistent. Gymnasts,
after a few practice sessions remember what comes next and what their obligations are,
which greatly contributes to a faster and smoother workout.
1.2 Aim
Determining what happens with the selected coordination skills of disabled athletes
through the intervention program.
This is a pilot study to a doctoral dissertation.
Types of training in paravaulting:
• Introduction
• Warm-up
• Intervention program
• Preparing the horse
• Work on the simulator
• Work on riding/paravaulting
• Conclusions
approx. 5 minutes
approx. 20 minutes
approx. 30 minutes
approx. 10 minutes
approx. 30 minutes
approx. 30 minutes
approx. 10 minutes
2 Methods
Gymnastics paravaulting exercises, with regard to growth performance, were
implemented. Gymnastic elements were included in main part of training, especially for
the development of orientation, balance and the overall dexterity.
A total of 4 standards tests were used for the purposes of the pilot study. The
participants were 6 vaulters from one riding club in the Czech Republic. Training was
held in the horse riding club, regularly 3 times per week. First (pre) testing was held in
precompetitions time in March. Second (post) testing was held in postcompetitions time
in November. The intervention program lasted 6 months, from March to November.
2.1 Subjects
Proband 1 – Female, 20 years old, Cerebral Palsy
Central diparesa spastic. Since she was 5 years old went to a section of
hippotherapy. Paravaulting practice since she was 12 years old and rode her first
competition after one year of training. She is one of the first gymnast paravaulting.
113
Currently competing about 8 years and belongs to the category of severe disability.
From the beginning, when she had problems with walking and dexterity, regular
training has achieved several titles Czech champion.
Proband 2 – Male, 19 years old, Cerebral Palsy
Hypotonic form of cerebral palsy, mental defect moderate degree. He is
competing in paravaulting since 2002 in the category of mental handicap. Initially, in
exercise greatly feared, it was necessary to help him. Over time, the fear was removed
and seen great progress. It is difficult to communicate with him, he use mostly sign
language. The basic problem that we must eliminate is the haste and lack of
concentration.
Proband 3 – Female, 13 years old, Cerebral Palsy
Cerebral Palsy, hypotonic form. With paravaulting began in January 2009,
previously not attending any form of hippotherapy. She belongs to the category of
severe disability. She has during the ride a little scared, which over time slowly
degrades.
Proband 4 – Male, 43 years old, Down syndrome
Down syndrome and hips osteoarthritis. He practice paravaulting since 1999.
Previously visitor a hippotherapy. Currently practicing paravaulting for 10 years, but the
first competition was 5 years ago. He was classified as a heavy handicap. Despite of his
reduced intellect is quite separate, mainly due care and access from his father. The
negative impact of the training is his mood.
Proband 5 – Female 15 years old, Epilepsy
3 years attended hippotherapy, due to the improvement started from September
2008 to train paravaulting. The competition was first in the 2009 season in the category
of light handicap. She is very slow, must be stepped up her response so that during
exercise would be better able to respond to any motion changes of horses.
Proband 6 – Female 15 years old, Personality Disorders
Paravaulting in our club devote 2 years in the category light handicap. She has at
her age, very childish behaviour, she is confused and disoriented. Sometimes she hides
and falls asleep.
2.2 Few examples of exercises during the intervention program:
114
Figure 1. Static exercises to strengthen arm muscles. One of the pair in the default
position of kneeling, the other grabs him by the ankles and lifted into the push-up.
Figure 2: Dynamic exercise on leg strength. Gymnast in action is deep forward and
swing his right foot while the rear. The torso and upper limbs are moving down and
right leg up, the axis of motion in the hip joint. The final phase of exercise is a dove in a
standing position.
Figure 3: Dynamic exercises to strengthen leg muscles. Over swing legs over gymnasts
ahead (Wiemers, 1997).
2.3 Kinetic tests
Flexibility: Bending forward in a sitting position. Test the flexibility of the spine and
hamstrings. In contrast, standing forward bend test excludes the influence of gravity
(Neuman, 2003).
Dynamic body rotation and bending forward: Dynamic mobility of the trunk
muscles and hamstrings. Gymnast stands with his back about 30-40 cm from the smooth
wall and leans forward with straight legs and touch the fingertips of both hands between
feet. Then quickly rises and turns the body to touch the wall behind him, turns right and
turns left. Calculates the number of cycles (forward bend and turn) for 20 seconds
(Neuman, 2003).
115
Orientation: Stand on one leg with closed eyes. Tested person stands with closed eyes
on one preferred leg. Other leg is attached to the knee leg stance. Free foot must not
touch the floor. It is measured in seconds (Měkota, 1980).
Burpee test-testing speed and endurance: Testing of speed-endurance ability, in the
same time muscle strength and dexterity in arms and legs. Tested person had to
implement accurately and quickly 10times cycle consisting of four positions: upright
position - squat down - push up (in which the torso and legs form a straight line) - squat
down - upright position. (Neuman, 2003).
3 Results
Graphs from data obtained through kinetic tests are presented.
In the Figures we may see some differences between vaulters, which may be attributed
to differences across gender, age, and severity of disability.
Figure 1. Bending forward in a sitting position.
Generally speaking, the regular intervention program had the greatest influence on the
development of flexibility.
116
Figure 2. Dynamic body rotation and bending forward.
Figure 3. Standing on one leg with eyes closed
The lowest score was obtained from an individual who was afraid to close eyes during
the second test.
Figure 4. Burpee test - speed and endurance.
We could not rehearse and repeat tests like Burpee test and dynamic movement
many times, they rapidly lost condition and after a few attempts were very
uncertain and wobbled. Guidance for the further research is carefully choose the
order of tests. In this pilot study, we confirmed that the more physically
demanding tests we have to choose at the end of testing. On the other hand, use
correct tests at the beginning in which we need to use balance or orientation.
WELL, HERE IS TO DIFFICULT FOR ME TO PROVIDE ANY REVIEW
FEEDBACK (MUST BE WRITTEN AGAIN)
3.1 Analysis of the results of probands
117
Probands 1 - Cerebral palsy: the testing of all the most improved. Despite her strong
will in practice still has a problem with coordination, particularly given the fact that her
disability hinder the further development. Still working hard and it is most visible in the
flexibility test, since there was an improvement by 4 cm during the six months
intervention.
Proband 2 - Cerebral Palsy: During testing there was no substantial improvement of
physical structures. Proband has a problem with joint mobility, but improved in
dexterity and orientation. The performance largely depends on his mood. If he is in a
bad mood, takes development exercises very long and if he feels sure, his performance
increases dramatically up.
Proband 3 - Cerebral Palsy: With paravaulting just starting, it makes less of a problem
to learn a new form of movement. With gymnastics and acrobatics is not yet acquainted.
With regard to hypertonic form of cerebral palsy was published best test of flexibility.
Proband 4 - Down's syndrome: Has not improved significantly, it is necessary to take
into account that he has coxarthropathy. It took him longer to exercise and he had
problems remembering what to train, be it repeated several times. Standing on one leg
managed to try a few times because he was afraid to close his eyes. The negative impact
on his growth performance is the lack of training, which is large due to his moodiness.
Yet for his age and extent of disability is very handy and thanks paravaulting keeps in
shape.
Proband 5 - Epilepsy: she is in good condition, which is reflected in the results of our
experiment. However, due to her disability must exercise great caution. For example, in
deep forward has made very far, then had dizziness about an hour and was not able to
exercise more. This had the effect that the result of second test (stand on one leg with
closed eyes) was weaker than the first test.
Proband 6 - Personality disorders: Problem with more complex coordination
exercises, which is seen on the results of the tests. Small improvement due to inclusion
of the coordination exercises into daily training. She is very slow and slowly
understands new kinetic structures. Her slowness has positively affected the outcome of
test - stand on one leg with closed eyes.
4 Conclusions
This kind of sport riding is very difficult. Training must be well laid out with
regard to individual access. It is not always strictly adhered to the prepared schedule due
to weather or current health status of the gymnasts. Analysis revealed that the regular
training increased across the intervention period.
This pilot study has shown that it is good to be devoted to each individual
gymnast, according to disability. In developing an intervention program is important to
encourage the athletes to learn more difficult exercises. In further research, we must
also choose an appropriate order of kinetic tests to achieve other partial results that can
be used for routine practice.
118
5 References
Hromádková, J. Fyzioterapie, 1.vydání Praha: H&H 1999, 428s. ISBN: 80 -86022 - 45 5
Ježková, A., Nejezchlebová, S. Paravoltiž v kostce. 1. vydání Praha: Česká
hiporehabilitační společnost, 2002. 7s.
Kos, B., Žižka, J. Posilovací gymnastika, 2. vydání Praha: nakl. Olympia, 1986. 307 s.
Kubička, J. et al. Vybrané kapitoly z teorie gymnastiky, 1. vydání Praha: vyd.
Karolinum, 1993. 49s.
Kulichová, J. et al. Hiporahbilitace. 2. vydání Praha: Nadace OF, 1995. 101s.
Měkota, K. Měření a testy v antropomotorice IV., 1. vydání Olomouc: rektorát
Univerzity, 1980, 125s.
Neuman, J. Cvičení a testy obratnosti, vytrvalosti a síly, 1.vydání Praha: Portál 2003,
157s.
Wiemers, J. Stretch and strength for young riders, vaulters, and mice. Bainbridge
Island: Island Grown Publications, 1997.
119
Thermographic changes in overloaded back muscles of people with sedentary job.
Jan Novotný, Faculty of sport studies, Masaryk University, Czech Republic
Abstract
The muscles are stressed at work. We have observed the ability of
infrared thermography to see muscles with more and less activity
(temperature). The first meeting with thermal imaging was display calf
(m. gastrocnemius – caput mediale et laterale).
The aim of our research is to determine the activity of the trunk and
head stabilizer for people with sedentary jobs.
In preliminary research, we took 23 shots back of people of
different sex and age. In 11 cases we have seen an increase in muscle
temperature, which are loaded in the seated position (m. trapezius, m.
levator scapulae, m. rhomboideus major et minor, m. seratus posterior,
m. erector spinae, m. splenius capitis). The images were taken with the
Fluke TIR camera.
After tuning the methodology we want to study 20-30 persons aged
25-40 years with a sedentary job. Each person will be examined in the
morning and afternoon during one day. For each area, which will
represent a particular muscle group, will calculated average and
relative temperature. Images will capture the new higher-level system,
SC620 FLIR camera.
The research results will help diagnose congested muscles, the next
output will PhD work and materials in teaching.
1 Introduction
During the work, the muscles are stressed and issue radiation. Kind of camera
can catch and show this radiation like warm. We have observed the ability of infrared
thermography to see muscles with more and less activity (temperature). The first
meeting with thermal imaging was display calf (m. gastrocnemius – caput mediale et
laterale) and then others parts of human body.
Recently works have appeared recommending infrared technique as an auxiliary
diagnostic method in ports physiology. Zaidi et al. (2007) brought the original findings
on the effects of ifferent swimming strokes at the distribution of skin temperature on
competitive swimmers. Furthermore, the Chudecka et al. (2008) dealt with changes of
thermal emission on the arms of handball players before, immediately and 10 minutes
after training. This way I could continue listing other sporting disciplines using
thermography. Thermography is used in the sport long before the layman can imagine.
First began to be used in veterinary medicine for horses, perhaps because the horse can
not talk about their problems and perhaps also because the horses are very much
appreciated. In any case, thermography in horse racing and dressage is still used
(Turner et al 2002 Ciutacu et al. 2006).
Infrared Thermal Imaging in Sports Medicine (ITI) has been shown to be useful
as a diagnostic tool in the differential diagnosis of neuromusculoskeletal injuries and
their prognosis for return to participation and/or competition. Since ITI is noninvasive,
120
risk-free, and relatively portable. ITI not only helps confirm a diagnosis, but can be used
as a gauge to clinically assess progress and treatment response, as well as a prognostic
indicator (Meditherm 2010).
1.1 Aim
Determine muscle activity of the trunk and head stabilizer for people with
sedentary jobs. In the literature there is not enough documented evidence to objectively
identify the thermographic loaded muscles – stabilizers for rigid body in a sitting
position.
2 Method
A total of 23 back-side shots of people of different sex and age were taken. In 11
cases an increase in muscle temperature was observed, in the seated position (m.
trapezius, m. levator scapulae, m. rhomboideus major et minor, m. seratus posterior, m.
erector spinae, m. splenius capitis, m. supraspinatus).
After tuning the methodology, the plan was to examine 20-30 persons aged 2540 years with a sedentary job. Each person would be examined in the morning and
afternoon of the same day.
Differences in muscle temperatures:
1. before job and after job without exercise
2. before job and after job with exercise
3. before job without exercise and after job with exercise
Comparisons will be based on permanent temperature of ear and with enviroment
(relative temperature).
121
3 Results
Thermographic pictures of back:
Plate 1. Before job (without exercise).
Plate 2. After job (without exercise).
Plate 3. Before job (with exercise).
Plate 4. After job (with exercise).
For each area, which will represent a particular muscle group, will calculated average
and relative temperature.
Plate 5. Areas of back muscles – will count average temperature
122
of each areas. Every area has left and right side.
Images will capture the new higher-level system, SC620 FLIR camera. This type of
camera has highest sensitivity and most advanced feature set available on portable
cameras.
Plate 6. SC620 FLIR - front view.
Plate 7. SC620 FLIR – back view.
These research results will help diagnose congested muscles and offer advices for
exercise at work.
4 Conclusion
We assume that everyday short excercise can help to ease overloaded back and neck
muscles.
5 References
Chudecka M. Szczepanowska E, Kempioska A. Changes of thermomission of upper
extremities in female handball players –the preliminary study. Medicina
Sportiva12, 2008, 3: 99-102.
Meditherm company, Digital Infrared Thermal Imaging, link:
http://www.meditherm.com/thermography_page1.htm
Stavratjev M. Infrared thermography and its use in diagnosis. Candidate work. Faculty
of Medicine, J.E. Purkyně University, Brno 1973, 145s.
Turner TA, Pansch J, Wilson J. Thermographic assessment of racing Thoroughbreds,
In: Proceedings of Conference on Equine Sports Medicine and Science, 2002:
207.
Zaidi H, Taiar R, Fohanno S, Polidori G. The influence of swimming type on the skintemperature maps of a competitive swimmer from infrared thermogrypfy. Acta
of Bioengineering and Biomechanics9, 2007, 1: 47-51.
123
Monitoring physical activity of children living in children's houses at school.
Hana Bednářová* and Jana Vašíčková**
*Department of Adapted Physical Activities,
**Centre for Kinanthropology Research,
Faculty of Physical Culture, Palacký University in Olomouc, Czech Republic.
Abstract
The research dealt with the physical activity of children living in
children’s houses within school (CHHS). Children with sociopathological behaviour who were enacted institutional or protecting
education by court are placed into these institutions. The aim of the
present research was to compare weekly physical activity expressed by
the number of steps and skips by the children living in families and
children living in children’s houses with school. An index of PA level
(average daily number of steps) was used for the purposes of the study.
We chose the pedometer ‘Yamax Digi-Walker SW-200’ for monitoring
physical activity, since it has acceptable validity and reliability (Le
Maurier, Sidman & Corbin, 2003). The gadget is not demanding for
carrying and operating. Steps and skips are recorded on electronic
display. The IBM SPSS 18.0 (Chicago, IL, USA) software was used for
data analysis. For comparison of average number of steps, a MannWhitney U-test for two independent sets and an estimation of the effect
size (Cohen’s d) (American Psychological Association, 2002) were used.
The significance of differences for Mann-Whitney test was set at p<0,05
and p<0,01.
The differences in number of steps were most apparent on school days.
The effect of difference was large (Cohen’s d). Middle-size effect was
detected in the difference of average number of steps over the whole week.
There was nearly no difference over the weekend in average number of
steps of the control group of children vs children living in children’s
houses at school. Despite the fact that children live in children’s houses,
the average daily amount of walked steps overreached the
recommendation for PA, which is 10,000 steps a day. We were also
interested whether average number of steps differentiates according to
age. We compared two groups of children. One group of children was of
primary school age (12-14 years old) (general population: n=240 and
CHHS: n=45) and another group of children was 15-16 year old
attending first grade of secondary school (15-16 years old) (general
population: n=141 and CHHS: n=58). An interesting finding is a higher
average number of steps by the 12-14 years old children during weekend
days.
PA of children from CHHS is lower compared to the control group of
children. What matters is the location of school which has a direct effect
of their involvement in walking and physical activity in general. School
attendance is substituted by leisure-time PA.
Key words: physical activities, pedometer, leisure time, children’s houses with school
124
1 Introduction
The research dealt with physical activities of children in the environment of
children’s houses within school (CHHS). Children with socio-pathological behaviour
who were enacted institutional or protecting education by court are placed into these
institutions.
The interest in physical activities among children and the youth is decreasing
dramatically. Children with socio-pathological behaviour are usually enacted
institutional or protecting education. This type of education is carried out in some of the
following school institutions, such as: diagnostic institution, children’s houses,
children’s houses with school and educational institutions. Children’s houses with
school are for children and the youth untill they finish their compulsory school
attendance. Children in children’s houses with school abide a weekly and daily system
within the institution, which is markedly influenced by the educators, by children’s
interests and by material and space conditions of the institution. That is why we assume
that students in CHHS have got quite low range of physical activities in comparison to
children living with their families.
1.1 Aim
The aim of our research was to compare weekly physical activity expressed by
the number of steps and skips by the children living in families (control) and children
living in children’s houses with school. The index of PA level (average daily number of
steps) was used to serve the purposes of the present study.
2 Methods
We chose pedometer Yamax Digi-Walker SW-200 for monitoring physical
activity which has sufficient validity and reliability evidence from previous research (Le
Maurier, Sidman & Corbin, 2003).
Plate 1. Pedometr Yamax Digiwalker SW-200.
125
The gadget is not demanding for carrying and operating. Steps and skips are
recorded on electronic display. The IBM SPSS 18.0 (Chicago, IL, USA) software was
used for data analysis. For comparison of average number of steps, we used MannWhitney U-test for two independent sets and estimation of the effect size was obtained
(Cohen’s d) (American Psychological Association, 2002). The significance for the
Mann-Whitney test was set at p<0,05 and p<0,01 levels.
At the beginning, the research set was made of 127 children aged 12 to 16 form
seven children’s houses within schools in Moravia region (Veselíčko, Šumperk, Horní
Těrlicko, Počátky, Jihlava, Bystřice pod Hostýnem, Moravský Krumlov). After the data
was entered to the database and was processed we used the records of 103 children. The
elimination was carried out on the basis of incomplete or pointless data. For analyses
and comparison, data, received during 2000-2006 through a weekly monitoring by
pedometers in children of common population (n=381) aged 12-16, was used.
Table 1. Basic characteristics of the research group.
CHHS
Common population+
Boys
n=73
Girls
n=30
Boys
n=197
Girls
n=184
M±SD
M±SD
M±SD
M±SD
Age (years)
14,30±1,08
14,80±0,96
14,1±1,3
14,6±1,3
Height (cm)
168,0±10,2
163,3±7,6
164,7±12,6
164,0±7,4
Hmotnost (kg)
57,3±12,3
58,5±8,0
53,8±11,7
51,9±8,3
Key: CHHS – children's houses with school; M – mean; SD – standard deviation; n –
number of children; + Vašíčková, in press
3 Results and discussion
The differences in number of steps were most apparent on school days. The
effect of difference was large (Cohen’s d). Middle-size effect was detected in the
difference of average number of steps over the whole week. There was no significant
difference over the weekend in average number of steps of common population children
and children from children’s houses. Despite the fact that children live in children’s
houses, the average daily amount of walked steps overreached the recommendation for
PA, which is 10,000 steps a day.
We were also interested whether average number of steps differentiates
according to age. We compared two groups of children. One group of children was of
primary school age (12-14 years old) (common population: n=240 and CHHS: n=45)
and another group of children was 15-16 year old attending first grade of secondary
126
school (15-16 years old) (common population: n=141 and CHHS: n=58). An interesting
finding is a higher average number of steps by the 12-14 years old children during
weekend days.
Table 2. The average daily number of steps during the week, on work days and at
weekends of children of common population and children living in children's houses
with school and differences between them.
Average daily number of CHHS
steps
(n = 103)
(steps x day -1)
Comon
population
(n = 381)
M ± SD
z
p
d
M ± SD
Work days
10852 ± 3694
15047 ± 3917
8,48
0,00
0,77
Weekends days
10879 ± 4389
10728 ± 4605
0,41
0,68
0,04
Week
11330 ± 3460
13813 ± 3476
5,60
0,00
0,51
Key: CHHS – children's houses with school; n – number of children; z-body (MannWhitney test); p – level of statistic significance; d – effect size; M – mean; SD –
standard deviation
Table 3. Differences in the average number of steps during school days, weekends and
the whole week according to age groups of common population children and in
children´s houses with school.
Average daily
number of steps
(steps x day -1)
Age groupe
Work days
12 – 14 let
Weekends days
Week
Common
population
M ± SD
CHHS
z
p
D
15479 ± 3815 11373 ± 3962
5,30
0,00
0,63
15 – 16 let
14313 ± 3992 10447 ± 3453
5,85
0,00
0,83
12 – 14 let
10566 ± 4806 11934 ± 4399
1,96
0,05
0,23
15 – 16 let
11004 ± 4244 10060 ± 4240
1,52
0,13
0,22
12 – 14 let
14075 ± 3427 11979 ± 3619
3,03
0,00
0,36
15 – 16 let
13368 ± 3525 10826 ± 3274
4,09
0,00
0,58
M ± SD
Key: CHHS – children's houses with school; z-body (Mann-Whitney test); p – level of
statistic significance; d – effect size; M – mean; SD – standard deviation
4 Conclusions
127
PA of children from CHHS is lower by the children of common population.
What matters is the location of school that is directly in the premises where children do
not have to walk. School attendance is substituted by leisure-time PA. We assume that
12 to 14 years old children reach higher average number of steps at the weekend thanks
to organized program in that institution, which is different from life in common
families. The number is also positively influenced by the pedagogues who organize
their free time and decide about its content. The age matters too because these children
are keen on physical activity more at this age. The interests of older children turn away
from physical activities.
Explanatory: * – statistic significance on the surface p < 0.001
Figure 1. The average number of steps per week for the age group of 12–14 years
children of common population and children's homes with school.
128
Explanatory: * – statistic significance on the surface p < 0.001
Figure 2. The average number of steps per week for the age group of 15–16 years
children of common population and children's homes with school.
5 References
American Psychological Association (2002). Publication manual of the American
Psychological Association. (5th edition). Washington, DC: APA.
Frömel, K., Chmelík, F., et al. (2007). Pohybová aktivita české mládeže: koreláty
intenzivní pohybové aktivity. Česká kinantropologie, 11(4),49-55.
Frömel, K., Formánková, S., & Sallis, J. F. (2002). Physical aktivity and sport
preference sof 10 to 14-year-old children: A 5-year prospective study. Acta
Universitatis Palackianae Olomucensis. Gymnica. 32(1), 11-16.
Kudláček, M. (2008). Physical activity and sport preferences of the secondary school
students. In D. Milanović & F. Prot (Eds.), 5th international scientific
conference on kinesiology – Kinesiology research trends and applications (pp.
833-837), Zagreb: Faculty of Kinesiology
Le Masurier, G.C., Sidman, C.L., & Corbin, C. B. (2003). Accumulating 10,000 steps:
Does this meet current physical aktivity guidelines? Research Quarterly for
Exercise and Sports,74(4), 389-394.
MŠMT, MV. Analýza stavu a dalšího vývoje mladých lidí po opuštění zařízení pro
výkon ústavní nebo ochranné výchovy za období 1995 – 2004. Praha: IKSP,
2007
MŠMT. Statistika počtu dětí umístěných v zařízeních ochranné a ústavní výchovy.
Praha: 2009
Večerka, K., Holas, J., Diblíková, S., Štechová, M. Sociálně patologické jevy u dětí.
Praha: IKSP, 2000
129
Zákon č. 383/2005 Sb., o výkonu ústavní výchovy nebo ochranné výchovy ve školských
zařízeních a o preventivně výchovné péči ve školských zařízeních a o změně
dalších zákonů
http://www.msmt.cz/socialni-programy/statistika-poctu-deti-umistenych-v-zarizenichochranne-a
http://slovnik-cizich-slov.abz.cz/web.php/slovo/socialne-patologicke-chovani
http://www.vzd.cz/node/9
130
Physical Activity of preschool children
Ludmila Miklánková. Erik Sigmund and Milan Elfmark,
Faculty of Physical Culture, Palacky University in Olomouc, Czech Republic.
Abstract
The aim of this thesis was to map and evaluate physical activity (PA) and
environmental stimulus of pre-school kindergarten students. An
experimental group was created with 200 children (96 girls, 104 boys)
from 17 kindergarten in different region of Czech Republic. Mean of age
was 5,71 years. We evaluated PA employing the daily amount of steps
(STEPS: number × day–1) by the pedometer Yamax Digi-Walker SW-200
and active energy expenditure (AEE: kcal × kg–1 × day–1) by the
accelerometer Caltrac. A 7-day survey took place in September and
October in similar climatic conditions. Data were obtained with the
support of the research grant No. MSM 6198959221, ’Physical Activity
and Inactivity of inhabitants of the Czech Republic in the context of
behavioral changes’, which was gained by the Centre Kinanthropology
Research at the Faculty of Physical Culture of Palacky University,
Olomouc. With regard to the children’s low age, parents´ written
approval and approval of Ethical Committee of Faculty of Physical
Culture in Palacký University in Olomouc were sought for realization of
the research.
The level of PA index – AEE (kcal·kg-1·day-1) and STEPS (steps·day-1) –
was nearly equal during the monitored week and it did not show any
significant differences. The exception is the time period of the stay in
nursery school and the time period the children stayed out of nursery
school during the working days, where significant differences (p < 0,001)
were found out between the values.
It is necessary to create conditions for separate and also safe transport
of children by elaborate urbanisation and by creating networks of
footpaths and cycle lanes, which depends a lot on the state policy. It is
important to focus on systematic educating of citizens – future and current
parents – in the area of knowledge about healthy life style and its benefits
for positive development of a child and to create conditions for mutual PA
of parents and children.
Key words: pre-school children, active energy expenditure, amount steps,
accelerometer, pedomete
1 Introduction
Physical activity (thereinafter PA), being integral part of human life, is
currently being examined from various view points. In terms of importance for health
of present-day and future generations it is very important to devote our time to the
youngest age groups. The reason for that is that acquired knowledge about this age
131
group can bring new, more positive approaches to the relationship to physical activities
of children and the young. The future benefits could be expected in increasing the
level of fitness, in responsible approach to one’s own health and in preferring health
life style of the future adult generation. That is why we focused on PA of pre-school
age children. That is the age group which pedagogical effect of the family and school
usually first intervene in. The main target was to map and evaluate PA of pre-school
age girls and boys, who attend kindergarten.
2 Method
The results were measured within the scope of MŠMT ČR investigative project
on the topic “Physical Activity and Inactivity of the Czech Republic Population in the
Context of Behavioural Changes” RP identification code: 6198959221, whose
organizer is Faculty of Physical Culture Palacky University in Olomouc.
For mapping PA of pre-school age children 200 children total composed the
research group (96 girls, 104 boys) whose average age was 5.71 years. The demands of
the observation lay mainly in long-term preparation of the research – written and oral
communication with the school head masters and children’s parents. The participation
on the research was voluntary, without any financial interest of the people concerned
and all data was acquired as anonymous. With regard to the children’s low age, parents´
written approval and approval of Ethical Committee of Faculty of Physical Culture in
Palacký University in Olomouc were sought for realization of the research.
A 7-day survey took place in September and October in similar climatic
conditions. All nursery schools kept at disposition common space conditions (play
room, playground), material conditions meeting the Czech Republic standard and
personal conditions corresponded to the demands on the pedagogical worker’s
qualification at the given kind of school in the Czech Republic. Curriculum in all
nursery schools resulted from valid Framework Educational Programmes for pre-school
education.
For monitoring PA a combination of techniques was used:
1. Pedometer Yamax Digi-Walker SW-200 (Yamax Corporation, Tokyo, Japan),
which records every vertical oscillation stronger than sensitivity threshold of the
instrument (0.35 g). The values (number per day) indicate a number of footsteps
in a time unit.
2. Accelerometer Caltrac (Muscle Dynamics Fitness Network, Torrance,
California), which measures vertical movements and calculates overall and
active energy expenditure out of them. This happens in the context of set data:
calendar age of the measured person, weight, body height, gender. The values
(kcal per minute) represent a value of so called active energy expenditure,
expenditure without standard metabolism.
The instruments were taken off only during children’s sleep and during possible
water contact (personal hygiene, swimming, bathing). The parents carried out the data
record out of the instruments Caltrac and Yamax (including the time of record) to the
individual recording forms. The data records were always carried out in the morning,
before putting it on, and in the evening, as the instruments were taken off before sleep.
Those data records were carried out daily during the whole period of the monitoring,
including weekends. The teachers recorded the values out of both instruments to the
individual recording forms after children’s arrival to school and when they were leaving
the school. The teachers did not record activities, which were not usual in common
132
schedule (visit of a cultural action, all-school academy, school trips, swimming, and so
on). In the afternoon the first monitored day (before a walk) elastic belts with
instruments for PA monitoring were fastened to the children. The instruments were reset
and data necessary for measuring were entered into them in advance. Stiffening was
placed over the buttons of the accelerometer and attached firmly. The recording forms,
including pencils, were put in the “pockets” for the instruments.
The last day the parents delivered the instruments with filled recording forms to
the teachers at kindergarten. Only data of the children was registered who finished the
whole 7-day monitoring, including two weekend days, completed entire program of the
nursery school during working days
Special software (Chytil, 2004) was used for transferring the data from the
individual records. Pearson’s correlating coefficient (rp) was used to find out the
closeness of the relationship between monitored PA indexes reciprocally – active
energy expenditure and number of footsteps. Negativeness of correlating coefficient
was evaluated in accordance with the recommendations of the mentioned author with
regard to logical significance. Statistic significance of the difference between the PA
indexes, which were reached in particular parts of the monitored day (SKaee, LEIaee,
SKsteps, LEIsteps) or monitored week (AEE7, AEE5, AEE2, STEPS7, STEPS5,
STEPS2), depending on gender were found out by means of a single-factor analysis of
variance for dependant measures. Fisher’s LSD test was used as a post-hoc test.
INDICATOR PA
GROUP
GIRLS
BOYS
(n = 200)
(n = 96)
(n =
104)
AEE7
11.89
11.43
12.31
AEE5
11.94
11.50
12.34
3 Results
Table 1. Indicators of Physical Activity – active energy expenditure (kcal·kg-1·day-1)
and number of steps (steps·day-1 )
133
AEE2
11.76
11.25
12.23
SKaee
3.67
3.67
3.68
LEIaee
7.74
7.66
7.82
STEPS7
9322
8785
9866
STEPS5
9384
8876
9866
STEPS2
9337
8718
9925
SKsteps
3051
2930
3173
LEIsteps
6458
6197
6721
Legend: AEE7 – active energy expenditure during the week (kcal·kg-1·day-1 ) ; AEE5 – active energy
expenditure in workweek (kcal·kg-1·day-1 ); AEE2 – active energy expenditure at weekend (kcal·kg1
·day-1 ) ; SKaee active energy expenditure in kindergarten (kcal·kg-1·day-1 ); LEIaee -active
energy expenditure in leisure time after kindergarten (kcal·kg-1·day-1 ); STEPS7 – number of steps during
the week (steps·day-1 ) ;
STEPS5 – number of steps in workweek(steps·day-1 ); STEPS2 – number of steps at weekend (steps·day1
) ; SKsteps – number of steps in kindergarten (steps·day-1 ) ; LEIsteps – number of steps in leisure time
after kindergarten (steps·day-1 ) ; GROUP – monitored group (pre school children)
4 Discussion
Based on the results it could be said that the need of PA for children of preschool age children is high. The level of PA index – AEE (kcal·kg-1·day-1) and STEPS
(steps·day-1) – was nearly equal during the monitored week and it did not show any
significant differences. The exception is the time period of the stay in nursery school
and the time period the children stayed out of nursery school during the working days,
where significant differences (p < 0,001) were found. Average values for the monitored
group maybe found in Table 1.
Last, and also according to current level of researches, I consider necessary:
to map space and material conditions at nursery and primary schools,
examine their quality according to educational process of physical
education and frequency of their use by teachers and public,
to evaluate curriculum at nursery schools and further at primary schools
from the view of physical education and time donation for PA, because
134
the results could lead to strengthening time donation of physical education
teaching mainly at lower levels of schools,
to analyse and restructure studying programs of universities, which
educate future teachers of nursery schools and primary schools in the
Czech Republic, which will lead to deepening of professional level of
teachers teaching physical education the youngest age categories.
I assume that a certain pressure on authorities at nursery and primary schools for
determination of sufficient time for systematically conceived children’s physical
education in curriculum could bring desired effect in keeping the interest in PA for older
age categories. The research enclosures from those areas should be headed to teachers
practice at nursery schools. It is necessary to create conditions for separate and also safe
transport of children by elaborate urbanisation and by creating networks of footpaths
and cycle lanes, which depends a lot on the state policy.
5 Conclusions
It is important to focus on systematic education of citizens – future and current
parents – in the area of knowledge about healthy life style and its benefits for positive
development of a child and to create conditions for mutual participation in PA for both
parents and children.
More attention to economical consequences of civilization diseases, caused by
insufficient PA must be paid. These diseases are present but their effect has not been
expressed numerically yet. That is the reason why we should pay increased attention to
these areas, make a prognosis and at least enumerate approximately economical impact
of those civilization diseases on future generation (according to current health state of
children and the young) and to streamline the system of prevention.
6 References
Chytil, J. (2004). Program PaTj2004-program pro sledování, záznam a hodnocení
pohybové aktivity, vyučovacích, cvičebních a tréninkových jednotek v týdenním
režimu [Computer software]. Olomouc: SoftWareCentrum.
135
Secular trend in changes of the subcutaneous fat in the Transdanubian Region
among 3-18 year old children – unfavourable changes.
Csilla Suskovics1 and Gábor Tóth2 ,
1
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Faculty of Physical Education,
Szombathely, Hungary.
2
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Laboratory for Human Biology
Research, Szombathely, Hungary.
Abstract
The Körmend Growth Study – launched in 1958 and repeated at regular
10-year intervals – has proven the changes in the children’s growth and
maturity, the phenomenon of the secular trend.
Recording the values of biceps, triceps, subscapular, suprailiac,
abdominal and calf skinfolds has been part of the anthropometric
schedule from 1968 on. All extents have been measured with caliper
according to Martin’s technique, taking the recommendations of the IBP
HA into consideration. Different periods of the children’s growth are
characterized by distinct skinfold values, as well. Differences in early
childhood skinfold measures increasing by age –especially in the
truncal region – develop to be a significant indicator of gender
dimorphism by the prepubertal-pubertal age. Secular increasing trend
of truncal skinfold values denote an unfavourable tendency. Changes in
skinfold measure are, in certain extent, due to the alteration of
nutritional conditions and physical activity.
Key words: The Körmend Growth Study, skinfolds, Hungary
1 Introduction
Körmend is a small town in Western Hungary. The Körmend Growth Study –
launched in 1958 and repeated at regular 10-year intervals – has proven the changes in
the children’s growth and maturity, the phenomenon of the secular trend. As it is well
known, growth and maturation of children, influenced by genetic and environmental
factors, is a dynamic process: growth pattern changes from time to time. Therefore, it is
necessary to investigate the somatic developmental status of the children repeatedly
(Eiben, 2002; 2003; Eiben and Tóth, 2000a; 2000b; 20005; Tóth et al, 2009a).
Body mass index is a commonly used measure for the assessment of nutritional
status. However, many publications have demonstrated the unreliability of BMI for
estimating adiposity Using BMI namely, body composition – body fat, lean body mass,
and so on (Ross et al, 1996; Abernethy et al, 1996; Suskovics et al., 2009, Szabó, 2010)
– cannot be estimated dependably. Among body measures reflecting the nutritional
status, skinfold values are the most informative ones (Tóth and Suskovics 2010).
Measuring skinfold values was first used in the 1960s in Hungary, in Körmend.
136
2 Methods
The purpose of the study was to involve all healthy, 3-18 year-old boys and girls
living in the town, i.e. all pre-school and school children. The representation has usually
been over 95%, except in the case of K-98 (76%), and in the case of K-008 (72%).
Exercising their personality rights, several parents refused assisting the investigation in
1998 and 2008. The last cross-sectional study (2008) has been carried out on 1563
children (757 girls and 806 boys).
The anthropometric programme of the KGS is an ample one. Recording the
values of biceps, triceps, subscapular, suprailiac, abdominal and calf skinfolds has been
part of the anthropometric schedule from 1968 on. All measurements have been
conducted with callipers, according to Martin’s technique (Martin and Saller, 1957),
taking the recommendations of the IBP HA into consideration (Tanner et al, 1969).
3 Results and discussion
On the basis of weighted means, the secular changes of body measures
characteristic for the second half of the 20th century have been determined (Tóth and
Eiben, 2004). As for skinfold measures, Hungarian data revealed the following results:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Biceps skinfolds: Weighted means are 6-7 mm in early childhood and there are
no notable differences between sexes. During prepuberty and puberty, there is a
certain increment in values, which, in girls, appears in younger ages than in
boys. After puberty, girls’ means tend to be greater, showing the characteristics
of a female physique, while in boys means decrease with age.
Triceps skinfold values are perhaps the most informative skinfold
measurements. Values of weighted means are greater (about 3 mm) in all age
groups than those of biceps skinfold. Increasing and later decreasing with age in
both boys and girls appear similarly as in case of biceps skinfold. It is worthy to
mention that means of 1980s are the highest, probably because of a temporary
improvement in the living standards.
Subscapular skinfold is another very informative skinfold measurement. Means
of girls are consequently greater than those of the boys.
Suprailiac skinfold means are also greater in girls. In this case, however,
differences increase with age intensively: in prepuberty, they are about 5 mm,
while after puberty about 9 mm. This underpins the development of a roundish
female physique.
The means of abdominal skinfold (a relatively rarely measured characteristic)
can be twice as great in girls than that in boys.
Calf skinfold, measured on the medial side of the calf, shows a moderate excess
in girls before puberty. The means are slightly increasing with age in boys, while
markedly in girls.
•
Until 1998, the Körmend results practically matches Hungarian tendency (Tables 1-6).
According to our studies the growth patterns of children have been changed in both
genders at the turn of the millennium (Tóth et al. 2009b). Therefore comparison of the
skinfold measures of 1998 and 2008 is considered important.
137
In both gender, calf skinfold values are first increasing, than decreasing,
reflecting the characteristic changes in adolescence. This tendency is noticeable when
measuring all skinfold values. It is caused by the changes in energy storage during the
pubertal period. Thereafter, calf skinfold values tend to decrease in boys.
Table 1. Skinfold calf, means and SD (mm) in Körmend boys and girls (1968-2008)
Age
(years)
Boys
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Girls
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
K-68
K-78
K-88
K-98
K-008
10.4
9.9
8.6
8.1
8.3
8.5
9.4
9.8
10.4
10.4
11.0
10.9
10.7
10.3
10.9
9.8
2.3
1.9
1.6
1.9
2.0
1.9
2.7
3.1
3.2
3.8
3.7
3.5
3.4
3.7
3.3
3.1
10.9
10.1
9.3
9.7
9.5
10.4
11.9
11.6
12.6
13.2
13.3
12.7
12.0
11.1
10.3
9.8
2.6
4.1
2.5
5.3
3.8
4.7
5.6
5.8
6.4
6.4
5.9
6.1
4.5
4.3
4.4
3.6
12.7
12.7
10.5
11.4
11.5
12.2
13.0
12.9
14.4
15.8
13.5
13.4
13.8
13.0
13.3
11.7
3.6
4.3
3.0
6.1
4.4
4.9
6.0
6.2
7.3
8.9
6.6
6.3
8.0
5.7
8.9
6.1
9.1
10.1
10.7
10.6
11.3
12.4
12.2
13.2
16.6
15.5
15.7
14.9
11.0
10.1
11.8
9.3
2.7
2.7
3.6
3.8
4.3
6.8
5.7
6.2
8.6
8.1
6.7
7.5
5.5
4.2
6.5
4.3
9.1
8.6
8.4
8.6
8.4
11.8
14.0
13.7
13.0
14.4
14.1
13.3
10.9
9.7
10.0
9.4
2,2
2,8
3,0
3,9
3,5
7,2
6,7
7,1
5,9
7,2
6,7
6,5
7,0
5,2
6,7
6,3
10.1
10.1
8.9
8.9
8.8
10.1
10.1
11.0
11.0
10.9
10.9
11.4
14.2
13.9
14.5
15.1
2.3
1.6
1.2
2.0
2.1
2.5
3.0
3.2
3.3
2.9
3.1
3.6
3.7
5.0
4.7
4.4
12.1
12.0
11.9
11.4
12.2
12.1
14.0
13.3
14.1
16.0
15.7
16.7
17.9
18.6
19.6
18.4
2.6
2.3
3.3
3.6
5.1
4.7
5.3
5.1
4.9
8.2
5.8
6.0
7.6
5.5
5.9
5.9
11.9
14.2
13.0
12.6
13.7
16.5
15.4
17.5
17.7
21.0
19.2
19.9
22.1
22.0
20.3
21.7
2.8
3.4
4.0
4.5
4.8
6.4
4.7
6.3
6.8
7.5
8.8
7.6
9.6
8.1
7.4
7.9
13.0
12.3
12.0
12.0
13.6
14.1
15.1
16.1
17.4
16.5
18.6
18.5
17.1
20.1
17.7
21.6
2.3
3.6
4.0
4.7
5.5
5.3
5.7
6.6
5.8
5.6
6.5
7.0
4.7
5.7
5.2
6.9
9.4
9.8
10.3
11.2
12.7
12.8
14.3
15.5
14.5
16.6
17.1
14.7
15.4
16.9
17.5
17.6
3,0
3,0
3,0
4,6
7,4
5,3
6,2
7,5
6,9
6,9
7,0
4,7
6,3
4,7
10,2
9,1
138
Table 2. Skinfold biceps, means and SD (mm) in Körmend boys and girls (1968-2008)
Age
K-68
K-78
(years)
Boys
3
5.8 1.5 7.4 2.4
4
5.7 1.4 6.8 2.2
5
5.4 1.2 6.8 2.3
6
5.4 1.5 5.9 2.2
7
4.9 1.2 5.2 2.7
8
5.4 1.4 5.3 2.7
9
5.7 2.2 6.3 2.9
10
4.4 1.7 6.4 3.5
11
4.8 1.7 6.8 4.1
12
4.4 1.8 7.0 4.4
13
4.8 2.0 7.0 4.0
14
4.4 1.5 6.4 3.5
15
3.0 1.0 5.5 2.5
16
4.3 1.1 5.3 2.6
17
4.2 2.7 5.1 2.8
18
3.9 0.7 5.2 2.7
Girls
3
5.7 1.7
7.9 2.4
4
5.6 1.4
7.3 2.0
5
5.4 1.2
7.3 2.2
6
5.4 1.5
7.3 2.5
7
4.9 1.2
6.9 3.3
8
5.4 1.4
6.5 3.1
9
5.7 2.2
7.8 2.9
10
6.5 2.1
7.6 3.3
11
6.2 2.5
8.0 3.7
12
6.2 1.9
9.4 4.3
13
6.9 2.3
8.5 3.8
14
7.1 2.2
8.8 3.6
15
8.2 3.0
8.8 4.5
16
8.0 3.1 10.9 4.0
17
7.6 2.4 10.4 3.8
18
8.0 1.9
8.6 3.6
K-88
K-98
K-008
9.7
9.3
8.5
8.2
8.0
8.6
9.3
9.9
10.9
11.5
10.0
9.8
9.4
9.2
8.6
8.6
3.1 5.6 1.7 6.2
3.6 5.6 2.3 6.1
2.6 5.9 2.8 6.1
2.6 5.5 3.0 5.9
3.4 6.0 3.7 6.2
3.8 7.1 5.5 7.6
4.6 6.2 4.3 8.9
4.5 7.2 5.4 8.8
5.0 10.0 7.2 10.0
5.4 8.0 5.6 10.5
4.9 7.4 4.3 9.0
4.5 8.1 6.0 8.3
3.8 5.7 4.1 6.5
4.2 4.7 2.7 5.2
4.2 6.2 4.7 6.4
3.5 4.2 2.3 6.2
1,7
1,9
2,4
2,7
2,7
5,4
5,0
5,1
5,5
6,4
6,3
6,6
4,7
3,8
5,2
5,8
8.6
10.3
9.6
9.9
9.2
9.9
10.6
12.1
12.6
12.2
12.6
13.3
13.8
13.9
12.4
13.2
2.2
2.8
2.8
3.2
3.3
3.6
4.1
4.5
4.4
5.6
4.7
4.5
5.4
4.9
4.1
4.7
2,4
3,4
2,6
3,2
4,7
4,6
4,9
4,7
4,7
6,1
4,5
4,7
4,3
3,1
6,4
6,7
139
7.5
7.5
6.8
6.7
7.6
8.4
9.4
9.0
10.2
9.1
10.8
10.4
9.9
10.6
9.7
11.9
2.9
3.1
3.1
3.3
4.0
4.8
5.0
5.8
5.0
4.6
5.7
5.2
4.7
4.6
3.5
5.6
7.2
7.4
7.3
8.0
8.7
9.3
10.6
11.6
10.5
11.6
10.5
10.4
9.0
9.2
9.5
10.5
Table 3. Skinfold triceps, means and SD (mm) in Körmend boys and girls (1968-2008)
Age
(years)
Boys
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Girls
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
K-68
K-78
K-88
K-98
K-008
10.4
9.2
8.6
8.3
7.3
7.9
7.4
7.8
8.4
7.4
8.0
7.7
7.0
7.1
6.9
6.8
1.6
1.4
1.5
1.7
1.7
1.9
1.7
2.3
2.7
2.1
2.7
1.9
1.9
2.2
1.8
2.1
11.9
10.9
9.7
9.6
9.0
9.5
10.4
10.2
10.5
10.7
10.1
10.1
8.9
8.6
8.1
8.2
2.7
2.9
2.2
2.6
3.2
4.0
4.0
4.5
5.1
5.1
5.2
5.4
3.7
4.0
4.1
3.2
13.4
12.9
11.7
11.3
11.9
12.5
13.4
13.6
14.5
15.5
12.4
12.4
11.9
12.3
11.1
11.1
3.4
3.2
2.6
2.8
3.9
4.1
5.0
5.3
4.9
6.0
4.6
4.8
4.8
5.0
4.5
4.0
10.8
11.6
10.9
10.5
10.7
11.7
11.5
12.7
14.5
13.8
14.3
13.2
9.5
8.7
11.1
8.8
2.4
3.0
3.3
3.5
4.7
5.4
4.7
5.6
5.7
6.6
5.3
5.6
3.9
4.1
5.4
3.5
10.2
10.1
10.1
9.9
9.7
12.4
13.4
12.9
14.2
14.8
12.9
11.7
10.6
9.6
10.4
9.7
1,8
2,1
3,3
3,3
3,4
5,7
5,6
5,7
5,2
6,2
7,2
7,9
6,0
5,3
6,2
5,8
10.1
10.1
8.5
8.6
8.5
9.4
9.3
10.3
10.7
10.0
10.5
10.3
14.6
13.8
13.7
14.7
2.3
1.6
1.1
1.9
2.1
2.2
2.6
3.0
3.0
2.4
2.9
3.0
3.7
4.9
4.2
3.3
12.1
11.6
11.2
11.7
11.8
10.6
12.0
12.1
11.4
12.4
12.9
14.8
14.7
17.2
17.2
15.6
2.6
3.1
2.6
4.4
4.3
3.7
4.1
4.2
3.9
5.3
5.6
5.1
4.9
5.6
5.9
5.0
12.3
14.1
12.9
13.6
13.4
14.0
14.6
16.3
16.3
15.8
16.9
17.8
19.1
19.2
18.2
18.6
1.9
3.0
3.8
3.9
3.9
3.9
4.5
5.4
5.3
5.8
5.9
5.3
6.3
5.4
5.1
5.3
12.6
13.2
12.1
12.3
12.4
13.3
15.0
15.7
16.6
15.0
16.4
16.8
14.8
15.9
15.1
17.5
2.6
3.6
3.7
4.1
4.1
4.2
5.4
6.2
6.0
5.1
5.9
6.5
4.8
4.7
4.4
5.3
10.2
11.9
11.4
12.2
12.7
13.9
14.8
14.7
14.0
14.7
14.8
15.2
15.6
15.2
15.2
16.2
2,9
3,7
3,2
3,9
4,9
4,3
4,4
4,3
5,3
5,6
4,5
5,7
5,5
4,1
6,9
7,2
140
Table 4. Skinfold subscapular, means and SD (mm) in boys and girls (1968-2008)
Age
(years)
Boys
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Girls
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
K-68
K-78
6.2
5.4
5.0
5.1
5.0
4.4
5.3
5.8
6.5
6.1
6.5
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
8.2
1.2 5.9
1.1 6.2
0.9 6.0
1.2 5.9
1.2 5.3
1.3 6.7
1.3 7.0
1.5 7.8
2.3 8.5
2.0 8.9
2.3 9.2
2.4 9.6
1.5 8.8
1.9 9.7
2.0 9.5
1.6 11.3
1.7
2.7
2.1
2.5
2.6
5.2
4.4
5.5
5.8
5.9
6.8
5.9
3.7
4.1
4.3
5.1
9.2
8.2
7.5
7.6
9.0
9.0
10.3
10.5
12.4
14.3
12.6
13.5
14.1
14.9
14.6
15.3
3.5
2.8
2.4
2.6
4.3
4.5
6.4
6.1
8.0
8.5
6.5
5.5
6.6
7.0
5.5
5.7
5.5
5.8
5.8
5.4
6.9
8.0
7.2
8.3
12.1
11.2
10.4
13.4
10.1
9.9
13.3
11.3
2.5
1.9
3.5
3.7
4.2
6.5
4.5
5.9
6.7
6.1
6.1
6.3
5.8
4.9
6.4
4.5
5.7
5.3
6.0
6.0
5.7
8.4
9.3
9.5
10.2
11.6
10.7
10.8
10.0
11.7
12.1
12.8
1,1
1,1
3,3
3,0
2,9
7,0
6,0
6,2
6,7
7,4
7,9
13,7
6,1
7,8
8,6
8,8
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.3
1.5
2.3
2.6
2.5
4.0
2.1
2.9
3.2
3.6
4.2
3.7
4.0
2.5
2.5
2.2
3.1
4.8
5.1
5.3
5.2
6.1
6.1
6.5
6.2
5.9
6.3
6.6
5.3
8.3
9.7
10.0
10.2
10.0
11.1
11.3
14.1
15.6
17.0
17.5
18.9
22.0
22.5
20.4
21.8
2.6
3.5
4.2
4.0
5.4
5.7
5.9
7.5
7.8
8.0
7.7
7.2
8.0
8.2
6.8
8.3
6.9
7.4
6.8
6.8
8.8
10.4
11.4
12.1
13.1
12.9
15.1
16.6
14.7
14.8
14.6
18.5
2.2
4.3
4.5
4.2
4.9
5.8
6.9
7.8
7.5
6.3
7.0
7.9
5.9
5.5
6.1
8.1
7.6
7.5
7.1
7.5
9.2
9.5
10.5
10.6
11.0
12.4
11.3
12.9
12.5
12.9
14.0
16.5
4,7
3,9
2,4
3,7
6,4
5,5
6,3
5,4
6,7
6,5
5,5
6,0
6,6
5,7
9,9
11,1
6.2
6.4
6.1
5.9
5.8
6.8
6.9
8.1
9.2
8.5
9.6
10.9
13.4
13.7
13.3
13.4
7.0
6.5
7.1
7.3
7.7
7.9
9.1
9.4
9.7
11.9
12.4
13.7
13.8
15.1
16.3
14.9
K-88
141
K-98
K-008
Table 5. Skinfold suprailiac, means and SD (mm) in Körmend boys and girls (19682008)
Age
(years)
Boys
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Girls
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
K-68
K-78
K-88
K-98
K-008
6.3
5.5
4.8
4.8
4.7
5.6
5.0
5.5
6.4
6.1
6.7
6.5
6.9
7.2
8.2
6.9
2.6
2.0
2.1
1.4
2.5
2.7
2.1
2.1
2.8
2.7
3.0
2.4
2.5
2.3
3.1
2.1
6.6
6.7
6.7
7.2
6.9
8.8
10.3
11.3
12.8
12.7
13.2
13.3
11.8
12.9
12.1
14.7
1.7
2.8
2.5
3.2
3.8
7.6
7.7
9.0
9.5
9.0
9.9
8.8
6.6
7.4
7.3
7.8
10.1
9.7
9.6
9.9
11.3
11.5
13.5
13.4
16.2
17.3
14.3
15.6
16.8
17.4
17.4
19.1
4.5
3.7
3.7
4.4
6.5
6.0
8.5
8.7
10.4
11.1
8.7
8.0
10.0
9.8
8.4
7.5
6.5
6.8
7.2
8.1
9.6
10.9
10.5
12.7
18.0
16.6
15.5
20.2
15.2
13.5
17.6
15.7
2.0
2.8
4.6
4.6
7.4
8.7
7.1
10.4
12.8
11.9
9.6
13.9
9.2
7.0
9.5
7.9
9.0
7.9
9.5
10.0
9.1
14.1
16.6
16.4
18.8
21.2
21.2
19.4
17.4
19.8
20.4
18.8
2,5
2,8
6,0
6,8
5,2
13,2
10,5
11,8
11,7
14,5
14,3
13,7
12,0
13,5
15,4
12,9
7.3
7.5
7.0
6.7
6.4
7.2
7.7
9.5
9.1
8.8
10.5
10.9
16.1
17.7
15.1
20.6
2.7
2.2
2.7
2.1
3.1
2.5
2.9
3.2
3.3
2.5
3.6
3.2
4.0
4.8
4.4
4.9
7.9
8.1
9.0
9.3
10.3
10.0
12.7
13.1
13.8
16.5
16.4
17.4
17.8
19.2
21.5
18.6
2.6
3.1
3.2
4.0
6.2
6.2
6.6
6.7
7.6
10.0
8.3
8.0
7.5
8.1
8.9
7.0
9.8
11.9
11.8
12.7
12.9
14.3
14.8
17.6
18.7
19.7
19.7
21.7
24.0
24.8
22.0
23.1
3.3
5.0
6.0
5.6
6.0
6.9
8.2
8.6
8.9
9.4
8.9
8.4
9.1
8.8
6.4
7.6
8.8
9.8
9.1
9.7
11.5
13.3
15.9
16.7
18.1
17.7
20.0
21.2
19.8
20.1
20.1
22.9
2.9
5.6
6.0
5.5
5.8
6.2
8.1
9.9
8.5
8.4
9.3
9.7
7.8
7.2
7.1
9.4
10.0
11.5
11.4
13.7
13.8
15.8
18.9
19.5
20.4
24.3
23.6
25.5
23.8
26.8
26.4
26.1
3,9
5,7
5,0
7,0
8,3
8,5
8,7
10,5
12,9
12,3
11,2
10,2
11,9
11,8
15,0
11,7
142
Table 6. Skinfold abdomen, means and SD (mm) in Körmend boys and girls (19682008)
Age
(years)
Boys
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Girls
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
K-68
K-78
K-88
K-98
K-008
8.5
8.3
5.7
6.1
5.3
6.7
6.1
6.7
8.4
7.9
9.2
10.1
9.2
10.2
10.9
11.0
3.3
2.2
1.5
1.8
1.8
3.4
2.5
2.8
4.3
2.8
3.9
3.8
3.1
3.1
4.3
3.1
5.8
6.0
5.4
6.2
5.9
7.3
9.0
10.1
10.4
11.2
11.5
11.8
11.9
12.7
12.0
13.8
2.3
2.9
2.3
3.7
3.9
6.6
7.2
8.6
8.7
9.4
8.8
8.3
6.5
7.2
7.9
8.5
8.6
8.5
7.5
8.1
10.3
10.5
11.9
13.0
16.0
18.2
15.3
15.9
17.7
18.6
17.9
20.3
3.2
3.9
3.2
4.3
6.5
6.1
8.3
9.9
11.5
12.5
9.9
8.6
10.6
11.2
10.2
10.0
6.1
5.9
7.1
6.3
7.4
9.4
10.1
12.3
18.4
15.6
15.6
18.7
13.7
12.0
16.2
13.4
3.4
3.0
6.0
4.0
6.8
6.6
6.3
8.8
9.9
9.6
9.1
9.5
9.5
8.3
9.7
8.1
5.3
5.3
6.6
7.4
6.6
11.8
15.4
13.9
15.8
18.8
17.4
17.6
16.3
18.0
18.5
18.5
1,4
1,3
4,7
6,2
4,2
11,9
12,7
11,2
11,7
14,4
6,7
6,9
13,3
14,2
16,1
14,3
7.3
7.5
6.4
8.1
6.7
8.3
8.8
10.6
10.2
13.3
15.4
18.9
22.1
22.8
17.8
24.3
1.6
3.4
2.3
3.4
2.1
3.2
3.0
3.6
3.4
4.6
4.5
6.0
4.2
5.0
4.6
4.7
8.3
7.2
7.1
8.0
8.5
8.5
11.0
11.2
13.0
15.9
16.6
19.1
19.9
21.6
23.0
19.7
3.6
2.6
3.4
4.1
5.8
5.5
7.4
6.1
7.8
9.5
8.2
8.1
7.8
8.8
9.0
7.3
7.8
9.7
9.9
10.7
11.9
13.2
14.1
18.5
19.9
21.4
23.5
26.6
29.5
31.7
29.0
28.5
2.7
3.9
5.6
6.0
7.1
7.2
9.0
9.8
10.9
12.6
10.4
10.7
11.2
9.6
8.3
9.5
9.2
9.1
7.7
8.7
10.4
12.2
15.6
15.4
17.8
17.5
19.2
19.4
18.9
19.4
17.6
21.9
3.0
5.3
4.9
6.1
6.8
7.3
9.5
9.9
9.5
8.6
9.2
9.9
7.3
8.4
7.6
9.8
6.6
8.5
8.2
9.5
11.6
13.4
16.9
17.9
17.4
20.4
19.0
21.8
21.4
22.6
23.1
25.2
3,0
4,9
4,3
5,3
10,0
9,1
10,5
10,2
13,4
11,2
9,7
10,4
11,6
8,1
14,9
12,2
In girls, however, after stagnating for a while, calf skinfold values tend to increase
again. In both genders the 2008 values (K-008) are exceeded by those of 1998 (K-98).
Biceps skinfold values of boys are, in all age groups, greater in 2008 than in 1998. In
girls, however, after the adolescence changes lower bicipal skinfold values were
measured in 2008 than in 1998.
The values of triceps skinfolds in boys were first slightly lower in 2008 than in 1998.
After the pubertal changes, however, triceps skinfold values of boys proved to be higher
in 2008 than ten years earlier. Recent tricipal skinfold values of girls are, in all age
groups, lower than those recorded in K-98.
143
Subscapular skinfold values of boys in 2008 are first identical to those in 1998;
while in later ages – after a decreasing period – measures tend to exceed the 1998 ones.
In girls, however, K-008 values are, in each cohort, lower than those in 1998. On the
other hand, suprailiac and abdominal skinfolds (both are markers of the truncal region)
tend to increase considerably in all age groups, in both genders. These unfavourable
changes are presumptive predictors of adulthood abdominal type obesity.
4 Conclusions
Different periods of the children’s growth are characterized by distinct skinfold
values. Differences in early childhood skinfold measures are increasing by age –
especially in the truncal region – may be perceived as indicators of gender dimorphism
by the prepubertal-pubertal age. Increasing truncal skinfold values denote an
unfavourable tendency. Secular changes in skinfold measure are, in certain extent, due
to the alteration of nutritional conditions and physical activity.
5 References
Abernethy, P., Olds, T., Eden, B., Neill, M., Baines, L. (1996). Anthropometry, health
and body composition. In: Norton, K. and Olds, T. (Eds.). Anthropometrica.
UNSW Press, Sydney, 171–198.
Eiben, O. G. (2002). The “Körmend Growth Study”: tendencies in generations.
Humanbiol. Bud. 27: 39–46.
Eiben, O. (2003). Körmend ifjúságának biológiai fejlettsége a 20. század második
felében. Körmendi Füzetek, Körmend.
Eiben, O. G., Tóth, G. (2000a). Half-a-Century of the "Körmend Growth Study". Coll.
Antropol. 24 (2): 431–441.
Eiben, O. G., Tóth, G. (2000b). Secular changes of sexual differences in height during
puberty. In: Bodzsár, É. B., Susanne, C., Prokopec, M. (Eds.): Puberty:
variabilty of changes and complexity of factors. Eötvös University Press,
Budapest. 177–181.
Eiben, O. G., Tóth, G. A. (2005). A Hungarian case of secular growth changes: the
Körmend Growth Study. Ind. J. of Phys. Anthrop. and Hum. Gen. 24(2): 99–
108.
Martin, R., Saller, K. (1957). Lehrbuch der Anthropologie I. G. Fischer, Stuttgart.
Ross, W. D., Leahy, R. M., Marshall, G. R., Carroll, G. W. (1996). The BMI: a parody
of science and common sense. In: Sidhu, L. S. and Singh, S. P. (Eds.). Human
biology. USG Publ. And Distrib., Ludhiana, 39–60.
Suskovics Cs., Geosits B., Fügedi B., Nagyváradi K., Tóth O., Kocsis Cs. (2009).
Szombathely és vonzáskörzetében élő nők tápláltsági állapotának elemzése. In:
Mesterházy B. (Ed). 8th International Conference on Applications of Natural-,
Technological- and Economical Sciences, Presentations. CD. Szombathely.
Szabó, S. A. (2010). Alkalmas-e a BMI a sportolók tápláltságának jellemzésére?
Magyar Sporttud. Szle 11(4): 24–28.
Tanner, J. M., Hiernaux, J., Jarman, S. (1969). Growth and physique studies. In:
Weiner, J. S. and Lourie, J. A. (Eds.). Human biology. A guide to field methods.
IBP Handbook 9. Blackwell Scientific Publishers, Oxford–Edinburgh.
144
Tóth, G. A., Eiben, O. G. (2004). Secular changes of body measurements in Hungary.
Humanbiol. Bud. 28. Plantin, Budapest.
Tóth, G., Suskovics, Cs., Buda, B. (2009a). A gyermekek növekedésének szekuláris
trendje: Körmend 1958-2008. Magyar Sporttud. Szle 10(2): 56–57.
Tóth, G., Suskovics, Cs., Buda, B. (2009b). “Körmendi Növekedésvizsgálat 2008” Előzetes eredmények. In: Mestreházy B.. (szerk.): VIII. Természet-, Műszaki- és
Gazdaságtudományok Alkalmazása Nemzetközi Konferencia, Összefoglalók.
CD. Szombathely.
Tóth, G., Suskovics Cs. (2010). 3–18 éves gyermekek bőrredő értékei a NyugatDunántúlon (1968–2008). Népegészségügy 88(3): 197.
Acknowledgements: MSTT, MTA VATT, NyME SEK, Szombathely Sport Association
145
Mental health decrease among active women in Szombathely and relationship to
physical activity.
Beatrix Kiss-Geosits1, Katalin Nagyváradi1, Csabáné Kocsis2 and Csilla Suskovics2
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus
1
Institute of Health Promotion
2
Institute of Sport Sciences
e-mail: geosits.beatrix@mnsk.nyme.hu
Abstract
Mental health is part of the general health. Its state is influenced
by personal (biological and psychological), social, and cultural factors.
Data, which show the high occurrence of different mental health
problems worldwide, draw the attention to the importance of mental
health’s study. According to the WHO’s report from 2001, the collective
short-term prevalence of mental disorders is between 15-20% within the
scope of adult population. The life prevalence rate is between 30-50%.
The mental health shows a close correlation with other health problems.
The connection between somatic diseases and depression was detected
inversely, too. There is also a strong relationship between mental health
and the subjective health condition.
In our research mental health was interpreted within the frame
of the functional health model. According to the model, mental health
problems can also cause functionality decrease which could imply such
health problems which do not exhaust the diagnostic criteria. Similarly
to the OLEF2000 and OLEF2003 researches, the GHQ-12
questionnaire was used in the present study in Szombathely, as an
indicator of mental health. The questionnaire is a self-estimator scale
which is used for estimating the mental health problems in the
population. Furthermore, the complex questionnaire had a part
referring to the judgment of mental state and the degree of physical
activity.
The basis of our study is a mental health condition survey from
2008, which was carried out among people aged between 23-65 in
Szombathely and its surrounding. 123 women’s data got into the
purified sample. Our aim was to collect data concerning the prevalence
of mental health decrease and to compare the mental health condition of
active working age women living in Szombathely and its surroundings,
and the relationship with data from a national sample. We anticipated
that the positive effect of physical activity may be detected among rates
of mental health decrease and subjective health condition.
Keywords: mental health, psychic health decrease, GHQ 12, subjective health
condition, physical activity
146
1 Introduction
The mental health is part of the general health. Its state is influenced by
personal- (biological and psychological), social-, and cultural factors. One significant
factor within the field of mental health protection is the regular physical activity which
entails with health consciousness. The physically active lifestyle has favorable psychic
and psychosocial effects, makes you feel well, helps fighting against distress and
depression. Furthermore, it improves self-confidence and assists the formation of
positive thinking. The protective factors or also called social immunogenic factors
operate as psychosocial buffers, neutralize the harmful stress effects and help in health
preservation and in the maintenance of the balance. The regular physical activity
ensures a richer life in vitality and health, which makes you feel better, consequently the
opinion about the own health condition improves.
Data, which show the high occurrence of different mental health problems
worldwide, draw the attention to the importance of mental health’s study. According to
the WHO’s report from 2001, the collective short-term prevalence of mental disorders is
between 15-20% within the scope of adult population. The life prevalence rate is
between 30-50%.
The mental health shows a close correlation with other health problems. The
connection between somatic diseases and depression was detected inversely, too. There
is also a strong relationship between mental health and the subjective health condition.
In our research mental health was interpreted within the frame of the functional health
model. According to the model, mental health problems can also cause functionality
decrease which could imply such health problems which do not exhaust the diagnostic
criteria.
Similarly to the OLEF2000 and OLEF2003 researches, GHQ-12 questionnaire
was used in the research in Szombathely as one of the indicators of mental health. The
questionnaire is a self-estimator scale which is used for estimating the mental health
problems in the population. It concentrates on the global components of psychiatric
morbidity (especially on mental health problems which entail symptoms of distress and
emotional disorders). However, a concrete diagnosis can not be established with it. The
questionnaire is widely-used, both in population research and within the frame of the
basic health service. It was translated into more than 35 languages. The questionnaire is
valid and reliable. The complex questionnaire had a part referring to the judgment of
mental state and the degree of physical activity, as well.
1.1 Hypotheses
1. The degree of mental health decrease is lower among working age women in
Szombathely than the rates of the national representative study.
2. The positive effects of sporting and physical activity can be shown among the
rates of mental health decrease.
3. The opinion about the health condition (subjective element) shows
correspondence with the degree of mental health decrease (objective element).
2 Method
147
The basis of our study is a mental health condition survey from 2008, which was
carried out among people aged between 23-65 in Szombathely and its surrounding. The
data of 123 women were in the purified sample. 10 yearly age groups were created for
the analysis (Table 1). The applied research methods had two parts.
Questionnaire method
It contains the motivation background which basically determines the health
behaviour, the physical activity, the eating habits, abilities for dealing with stress,
addictive behaviour and social background. Part of the questionnaire was adapted, that
is the GHQ-12 questionnaire (OLEF 2000 and OLEF 2003), while another part was
based on the target group. The reliability of the scale was assessed in a pilot study
(Cronbach α = 0.748).
2.1 Method for analysing the biological and health conditions
Studying the body composition and Cardiovascular indices.
Table 1: Distribution of the sample based on age groups
Group
23-33 years
34-43 years
44-53 years
54-65 years
Sum
Average
28,77
38,93
48,38
56,52
43,19
Distribution
3,161
3,116
2,589
3,530
9,585
N
22
40
40
21
123
Percentage
17,9
32,5
32,5
17,1
100,0
3
Results and discussion
1. The degree of mental health decrease is lower among working age women in
Szombathely than the rates of the national representative study.
148
Figure 1. The degree of mental health decrease among working age women in
Szombathely.
47,5% of the active, working age women in Szombathely have absolute mental health,
which reached 0 point. In 2003 it was 56,8% of the Hungarian representative survey. It
reached at least 5 points on the GHQ-12 questionnaire, so 11,7% of women could be
described with mental functionality decrease in the national survey. Significant mental
decrease was found among 20,4% of the women in Szombathely.
The changing of mental health decrease in different ages increases with age according
to the Hungarian health survey. In the case of women who took part in the Szombathely
survey, 22% of the respondents from the younger generation (23-33 years) show
significant mental health decrease. In the other age groups this rate has decreased
(18,86%, 20%, 19,23%). On the whole, regarding the age group of 34-65 years, 19,37%
is the rate (see Table 2. and Figure 2.).
Table 2. Significant mental health decrease distributed according to age groups, based
on the study of OLEF 2003.
GHQ-12 value shows significant mental health
decrease (higher than 5 points)
18-34 years 35-64 years 65+ years
sum
9,0
11,3
16,4
11,7
Figure 2. The degree of mental health decrease in different age groups among women
from the Szombathely sample.
2. The positive effects of sporting and physical activity can be shown among the rates of
mental health decrease. On Figures 3, 4, 5 the rate of mental health decrease can be seen
in connection with sporting. The connection is significant (0,012) between sporting and
mental health. At the same time, regarding the frequency of sporting, the differences can
not be seen (Figure 6).
3. The opinion about the health condition (subjective element) shows correspondence
with the degree of mental health decrease (objective element).
149
It was proved that those people who do some sports are able to define their own mental
health condition in an elaborated way as their choice ranged from the very bad to the
very good categories. However, those people who do not do any sports chose only the
average category.
Figure 3. The appearance of absolute mental health related to the sporting activity.
Figure 4. Slight mental health decrease related to the sporting activity
Figure 5. Significant mental health decrease related to the sporting activity
150
Figure 6. The degree of mental health decrease related to the frequency of the sporting
activity.
The connection is obvious (0,002) between the existence of mental health and the
evaluation of the subjective health condition, both in the sample of sporting and no
sporting. (Figures 7, 8).
Figure 7. The judgement of health condition among respondents doing sport.
151
Figure 8. The judgement of health condition among respondents not doing sports.
4 Conclusions
Except the first hypothesis, the second and third ones were proved. It is worth
thinking about the reason why the degree of mental health decrease is so significant
among active age women in Szombathely. The relation between sporting and the mental
health is evident. The primer nuovum of the Szombathely research is that the GHQ-12
questionnaire, which measures the mental health decrease and preferred by the WHO
and the European Union, has not been published in the relationship with physical
activity and sporting yet.
152
Performance Analysis – INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP
153
Physical characteristics of elite Serbian female soccer players.
Nebojsa Trajkovic1, Goran Sporis2, Zoran Milanovic1 and Mario Jovanovic2
1
Faculty of Sport and Physical Education, University of Nis, Nis, Serbia
2
Faculty of Kinesiology, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia
Abstract
The main aim of this study was to describe physical performance
characteristics of top Serbia female soccer players. In addition, the aim of
the study was to examine positional differences in this sample of athletes.
Research was performed on a sample of 22 elite female soccer players
from Serbian A-national team (aged 23.95±4.52, body height 168.82±7.19
cm, body weight 61.4±6.0 kg). The following tests were used for
measurement of speed and agility with and without the ball: 10-m Sprint
(S10), Flying 20-m Sprint (LS20), 30-m Sprint (S30), Zigzag Test (CC),
Zigzag With the Ball (CCL). For the estimation of the explosive strength of
lower extremities three tests have been used: Squat jump (SJ), counter
movement jump (CMJ) and counter movement jump with arm swing
(CMJZ). Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test level 1 (YYIRL1) was used for
measuring the physical match performance. The values of physical
performance of the Serbian female soccer players are lower than those in
some other studies that included high level players. In addition, their
physical performance do not significantly differ depending of the position
in the team.
Key words: female, performance, differences, position
1
Introduction
Female soccer has become one of the fastest growing sports with over 26 million
participants around the world (Andersson, 2010). Germany has over one million
registered female soccer players, while both Sweden and Denmark have approximately
60,000 registered players (Andersson, 2010). Traditionally the number of female soccer
players is limited when compared to other sports played by femailes. However, the
number of young girls deciding to professionally take up soccer is nevertheless
increasing in Serbia. The general characteristics of female soccer players have been
extensively described in the literature (Andersson, 2010). These studies showed that
average range in height, weight, VO2max, vertical jump performance and 20-m sprint
time vary among players in the various levels of competition and the different positions
of players in the field (Krustrup et al., 2005; Mohr et al., 2008; Polman et al., 2004;
Siegler et al., 2003; Stølen et al., 2005; Tumilty and Darby, 1992). More recent studies
stated that total distances covered in a game by female soccer players amounts to
around 10 km per game (Gabbett and Mulvey, 2008; Hewitt et al., 2007; Krustrup et al.,
2005; Mohr et al., 2008). The requirements of women’s soccer, in this respect, appears
to be similar to those of the men’s game (Krustrup et al., 2005; Mohr et al., 2003b;
Mohr et al., 2008), but differs from elite male players in high intensity running. It has
been shown that top international female players covered an average of 1.7 km of high
intensity running during a game (Mohr et al., 2008). The total distance includes a large
amount of walking and jogging (>50%). Therefore, the distance covered in high
154
intensity running has been suggested to be a better indicator of the physical stress
during a game (Andersson, 2010). The amount of high intensity running performed by
female soccer players is related to the competition level and may range between 0.7-2.0
km during a game (Krustrup et al., 2005; Mohr et al., 2008). It has also been reported
that the same female player covered a longer distance of high intensity running when
playing an international game than when playing a domestic league game (Andersson et
al., 2010; Gabbett and Mulvey, 2008). Krustrup et al. (2005) concluded that YYIRTL1
(Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test level 1) is a good predictor of elite female soccer
player’s ability to perform high-intensity running throughout competitive matches and it
can be used as an indicator of physical match performance. In addition, it has been
shown that power has great impact in soccer and can contribute directly to winning
possession of the ball and to scoring or conceding of goals (Chamari et al., 2008;
Matkovic et al., 2003). Agility is very important when it comes to soccer players (Miller
et al., 2006; Thomas et al., 2009). Not only do they use it to outmaneuver the opposition
but it also helps in preventing injuries (Jovanovic et al., 2010).
A number of field tests are often used to evaluate physical performance. The
assessment of physical performance is commonly used to identify talent, monitor
training interventions and observe normal growth and development patterns (Vescovi et
al., 2009). Various physical performance tests have been used in soccer in order to make
the difference between levels of play (Reilly et al., 2000; Franks et al., 1999) as well as
to classify positional differences for male soccer players (Reilly et al., 2000; Franks et
al., 1999; Matkovic et al., 2003). Specifically, it has been found that the midfielders
have the highest aerobic capacity (Reilly et al., 2000; Matkovic et al., 2003). It has also
been reported that vertical jumping ability is greater in forwards and defenders
compared to midfielders (Wisloff et al., 1998). In addition, goalkeepers and defenders
are taller and have greater body mass compared to midfielders and attackers (Reilly et
al., 2000; Franks et al., 1999). There are several factors that could influence the female
level of fitness. The nature of the annual soccer calendar and the fact that most female
soccer players mainly train and play on a part-time basis could be one of the factors
according to Polman (2004). In order to effectively use this small amount of time it is
essential to know more about the performance of female soccer players.
The main aim of this study was to describe physical performance characteristics of top
Serbia female soccer players. In addition, aim of the study was to examine positional
differences in this
sample of athletes.
2 Method
2.1 Subjects
Research was performed on a sample of 22 elite female soccer players from Serbian Anational team (aged 23.95±4.52, body height 168.82±7.19 cm, body weight 61.4±6.0
kg). The subjects were the following: 2 goalkeepers, 4 attackers, 8 midfielders and 8
defenders (Table 1).
Testing was performed during the preparation of national team, in February 2009.
Before testing, subjects gave their approval for this research. The protocol of the study
was approved by the Ethical Committee of the Faculty of Sport and Physical Education,
University of Nis, according to the revised Declaration of Helsinki. The study protocol
was held for every subject. Beside the results, the basic anthropometric parameters
155
(body height-TV and body weight-MT) and the age of the players were registered in the
study protocol. Power and endurance tests were held at the same day.
Table 1. Subject characteristics.
Mean±SD Goalkeepers Attackers Midfielders Defenders
(n=22)
(n=2)
(n=4)
(n=8)
(n=8)
Age (years)
Body weight (kg)
Body height (cm)
23.9±4.5
61.4±6.0
168.8±7.2
23.0±1.4
59.5±10.6
172.5±3.5
24.5±2.6
59.7±2.9
164.7±5.0
26.2±6.3
62.7±7.7
168.7±8.7
21.6±2.2
61.37±5.2
170.0±7.2
2.2 Testing procedure
Body height and body weight were measured according to the instructions of the
International Biological Program–IBP (Weiner and Lourie, 1969). The body height was
measured with a GPM anthropometer (Siber & Hegner, Zurich, Switzerland ) to the
nearest 0.1cm. Body weight was obtained by TANITA BC 540 (TANITA Corp.,
Arlington Heights, IL) to the nearest 0.1 kg.
The tests for the linear speed and agility were performed from a standing start and
measured by means of infrared photocells Uno Lux (The Republic Institute for Sports,
Belgrade, Serbia). The following tests were used for measurement of speed and agility
with and without the ball: 10-m Sprint (S10), Flying 20 m Sprint (LS20), 30-m Sprint
(S30), Zigzag Test (CC), Zigzag With the Ball (CCL). Flying 20 m Sprint test assessed
the sprinting ability over a short distance, which should be of particular importance for
soccer (Hoff and Helgerud, 2004). The running time along 20 m following the 10 m
maximal acceleration was measured. As a consequence, the subjects were instructed to
run with maximal speed over 30 m, and both the 10 m and the 20 m tests were obtained
from the same trial. The Zigzag Test assessed running agility from changes in direction.
A zigzag course consisted of 4-5 m sections set out at 100º angles. Zigzag With the Ball
is the ability to control the ball while changing direction was assessed. Subjects were
instructed to run with the ball as fast as possible along the same zigzag path used in the
previous test. Time was recorded in 100ths of a second, and the average value from 3
sprint attempts was taken into consideration as a final result. Before each testing the
subjects performed a standard 25 minute warm-up. During the test air temperature
ranged from 22°C to 25°C. It began at 10 am and finished by 1 pm. All sprint tests were
performed on a grass sports field, and the players wore soccer shoes to replicate the
playing conditions.
For the estimation of the explosive strength of lower extremities three tests have been
used: Squat jump (SJ), counter movement jump (CMJ) and counter movement jump
with arm swing (CMJZ). Ergotester jump system (Globus, Italy) was used to estimate
vertical jump height in SJ, CMJ and CMJZ. The tests on the contact platform were done
twice with adequate rest between attempts and for further analyses better result was
taken. Ten minutes after this tests, physical match performance was measured.
Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test level 1 (YYIRL1) was used for measuring the physical
match performance (Bangsbo et al., 2008).
2.3 Processing the data
156
The Statistical Package for Social Studies SPSS (v17.0., SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL) was
used for statistical analysis. Descriptive statistics were reported as mean ± SD for all
measures with special analysis for positions in team. A one-way ANOVA was used to
examine if differences exist between four positions: attackers, midfielders, defenders
and goalkeepers. The statistical significance was set at p<0.05.
3 Results and Discussion
Table 2. General descriptive parameters of the sample.
X±SD
(n=22)
SJ (cm)
26.4±3.5
Goalkeeper
s
(n=2)
24.4±5.8
Attackers
(n=4)
Midfielders
(n=8)
Defenders
(n=8)
25.9±5.3
26.1±2.6
27.5±3.3
CMJ (cm)
30.2±3.5
29.3±3.2
30.5±5.9
28.6±2.5
31.8±2.9
CMJZ (cm)
35.7±4.2
33.4±4.0
37.5±4.2
32.9±3.3
38.3±3.6
YYIRL1 (m)
892.7±197.6 780.0±84.8 900.0±200.0
930.0±239.8 880.0±190.0
S10 (s)
1.93±0.08
2.00±0.05
1.90±0.14
1.94±0.07
1.91±0.05
LS20(s)
1,41±0.05
1,43±0.06
1.39±0.09
1.40±0.02
1.43±0.04
S30(s)
3,34±0.12
3,43±0.01
3.30±0.23
3,38±0.10
3,31±0.07
CC(s)
5.68±0.20
5.62±0.15
5.66±0.36
5.72±0.17
5.66±0.21
CCL(s)
7.56±0.39
7.43±0.76
7,40±0.44
7.47±0.34
7.74±0.35
SJ - Squat jump, CMJ - Countermovement jump, CMJZ - Countermovement jump with
arm swing, YYIRL1 - Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test level 1; S10- Sprint 10 m;
LS20- Sprint 20 m; S30- Sprint 30 m; CC- Zigzag; CCL- Zigzag with ball
Descriptive statistics showed no significant deviation in body height and weight among
tested players depending on the positions in the team (Table 1). The goalkeepers were
the tallest in the team with mean value of 172.5 ±3. 5 cm, while the attackers (164.7 ±
5.0 cm) and the midfielders (168.7 ± 8.7 cm) were the smallest. The height of the
players in this research are similar with the values of elite Croation (Sporis et al., 2007)
and Danish (Krustrup et al., 2005) female soccer players. The major difference is that
they possess greater body mass (61.41 ± 6.07 kg) in comparison to the other researches
(Mujiki et al., 2009; Krustrup et al., 2005). Table 2 shows descriptive statistics of tested
variables. The YYIRL1 test’s results have shown that all positions have similar value
within range of 880-930 m. The deviation is noticed within the goalkeepers whose
average value was 780.0 ± 84.8 m. The average values of the YYIRL1 test 892.7 ±
197.6 m are much smaller than the values found in the Danish (1379 m) and the Spanish
(1224 ± 255 m) Premier League (Krustrup et al., 2005). The explanation could be found
in the fact that during this research the female players were not physically well prepared
since the research was carried out during the transition period.
The average values of the height of the vertical jump which are of the lower values
than at the Mujiki et al. (2009). Greater body mass could cause the subtraction of the
values of the leg’s explosive power of the women involved in the research, which was
confirmed by the results (Table 2). Linear sprint speed is considered an essential
element for successful performance in sports requiring athletes to guard an opposing
player or being able to receive a pass (Vescovi et al., 2007). Moreover, a recent study
reported that 96% of sprint bouts during a soccer game are shorter than 30 m, 21 with
157
49% being less than 10 m (Wisløff et al., 2004). Linear sprint times are shown in Table
2. Because of the different protocols and distance during testing the authors could not
compare the results with other studies.
Table 3. Results of one-way ANOVA.
F
p
SJ (cm)
,479
,701
CMJ (cm)
1,149
,356
CMJZ (cm)
3,588
,034*
YYIRL1 (m)
,292
,831
S10 (sec)
,865
,477
LS20(sec)
1,134
,362
S30(sec)
1,041
,398
CC(sec)
,179
,909
CCL(sec)
,919
significant difference between defenders and midfielders
,453
*
SJ - Squat jump, CMJ - Countermovement jump, CMJZ - Countermovement jump with
arm swing, YYIRL1 - Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test level 1; S10- Sprint 10 m;
LS20- Sprint 20 m; S30- Sprint 30 m; CC- Zigzag; CCL- Zigzag with ball
Nevertheles, the research has shown that elite players who were faster (15 and 30
meters), could jump higher, had better agility, and were more aerobically fit (Vescovi et
al., 2006), so we could speculate that our results in sprint and agility tests were lower
than those in other studies with elite female soccer players. However, in recent study,
vertical jump height was shown to be significantly related to short sprint performance in
well-trained elite soccer players. (Chamari et al., 2008). In contrary, Little and
Williams’ (2005) results suggest that straight speed and agility training methods
produce specific gains in performance that have limited transfer to the other
performance mode. A one-way ANOVA has shown no significant differences among
positions for linear sprinting tests, agility tests with and without the ball and Yo-Yo
intermittent recovery test level 1 (YYIRL1). In addition, there were no significant
differences among positions for SJ and CMJ tests. The only significant difference
among positions was in counter movement jump with arm swing (CMJZ test).
Difference was found between defenders and midfielders which may be the result of the
fact that defenders are being involved in more frequent bursts of acceleration. In
addition, Wisloff et al. (1998) stated that vertical jumping ability is greater in forwards
and defenders compared to midfielders.
4 Conclusions
Physical characteristics of elite Serbian female soccer players do not significantly differ
depending of their position in the team. The values of their physical performance are
lower than those in some other studies that included professional players. These days,
the importance of having good physical fitness is essential for elite sport. This is
158
especially important for soccer. The ability of a player to be quick, powerfully and with
great endurance plays a significant role in successful soccer performance.
By examining a variety of performance characteristics, which are believed to be
advantageous for competition, and the conditioning training of elite female soccer
players, we may be able to enhance ability of selection of the best possible soccer
players for the athletic team or to determine the physiological demands of female
soccer. Ideally, this would lead to enhanced conditioning and training strategies and
improved performance. Several researches has come to conclusion that with intensive
SAQ (speed, agility, quickness) training, improvement in the player’s power
performance could be achieved. Many coaches do not use the SAQ training in their
training process because they are afraid of overtraining and injuries. One of the reasons
why overtraining occurs in soccer is too much nonspecific endurance and power
training (Jovanovic et al., 2010).
A limitation for this study is that no identification of training status was obtained
before testing and that the research was carried out during the transition period. So, it
was speculated that all participating athletes demonstrated peak performance. Within
the constraints of these limitations the findings in the current study indicate little
positional variations for elite Serbian female soccer players.
5 References
Andersson, H. (2010). The physiological impact of soccer on elite female players and
the effects of active recovery training. Örebro University: Heinz Merten
Andersson, H., Randers, M., Heiner-Møller, A., Krustrup, P. & Mohr, M. (2010). Elite
female soccer players perform more high-intensity running when playing in
international games compared to domestic league games. Journal of Strength
and Conditioning Research, 24, 912-9.
Chamari, K., Chaouachi, A., Hambli, M., Kaouech, F., Wisloff, U. & Castagna C.
(2008). The five-jump test for distance as a field test to assess lower limb
explosive power in soccer players. Journal of Strength and Conditioning
Research, 22, 944-50.
Davis, J.A. & Brewer, J. (1993). Applied physiology of female soccer players. Sports
Medicine, 16, 180-189.
Gabbett, T. & Mulvey, M. (2008). Time-motion analysis of small-sided training games
and competition in elite women soccer players. Journal of Strength and
Conditioning Research, 22, 543-552.
Hewitt, A., Withers, R. & Lyons, K. (2007). Match analyses of Australian international
female soccer players using an athlete tracking device. In Science and Football
IV ( edited by T. Reilly, F. Korkusuz), pp. 224-234. London: Routledge.
Hoff, J. & Helgerud, J. (2004). Sports Medicine, 34, 165-16.
Franks, A.,Williams, A.M., Reilly T. & Nevill, A. (1999).Talent identification in elite
youth soccer players: physical and physiological characteristics. Journal of
Sports Sciences,17, 812.
Jensen, K. & Larsson, B. (1992). Variations in physical capacity among the Danish
national soccer team for women during a period of supplemental training.
Journal of Sports Sciences,10, 144-145.
Jovanovic, M, Sporis, G, Omrcen, D, and Fiorentini, F. Effects of speed, agility,
quickness training method on power performance in elite soccer players. Journal
of Strength and Conditioning Research, 24, 000–000 (In press).
159
Krustrup, P., Mohr, M., Ellingsgaard, H. & Bangsbo, J. (2005). Physical demands
during an elite female soccer game: importance of training status.
Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 37, 1242-1248.
Little, T. and Williams, A.G.. (2005). Specificity of acceleration, maximum speed, and
agility in professional soccer players. Journal of Strength and Conditioning
Research,19(1), 76–78.
Matkovic, B.R., Misigoj-Durakovic, M., Matkovic, B., Jankovic, S., Ruzic, L., Leko, G.
& Kondric, M. (2003). Morphological differences of elite Croatian soccer
players according to the team position. Collegium Antropologicum, 27(Suppl. 1),
167-74.
Miller, M., Herniman, J., Ricard, M., Cheatham, C. & Michael, T. (2006). The effects
of a 6-week plyometric training program on agility. Journal of Sports Science
and Medicine, 5, 459–465.
Mohr, M., Krustrup, P., Andersson, H., Kirkendal, D. & Bangsbo, J. (2008). Match
activities of elite women soccer players at different performance levels. Journal
of Strength and Conditioning Research, 22, 341-349.
Mohr, M., Krustrup, P. & Bangsbo, J. (2003b). Match performance of highstandard
soccer players with special reference to development of fatigue. Journal of
Sports Sciences, 21, 519-528.
Mujika, I., Santisteban, J., Impellizzeri, F.M. & Castagna, C. (2009). Fitness
determinants of success in men's and women's football. Journal of Sports
Sciences, 27(2), 107-14.
Reilly, T., Bangsbo, J. & Franks, A. (2000a). Anthropometric and physiological
predispositions for elite soccer. Journal of Sports Sciences,18, 669—83.
Reilly, T., Williams, A.M., Nevill, A. & Franks, A. (2000b). A multidisciplinary
approach to talent identification in soccer. Journal of Sports Sciences, 18, 695—
702.
Polman, R., Walsh, D., Bloomfield, J. & Nesti, M. (2004). Effective conditioning of
female soccer players. Journal of Sports Sciences, 22, 191-203
Rhodes, E. & Mosher, R. (1992). Aerobic and anaerobic characteristics of elite female
university players. Journal of Sports Sciences, 10, 143-144.
Siegler, J., Gaskill, S. & Ruby, B. (2003). Changes evaluated in soccer-specific power
endurance either with or without a 10-week, in-season, intermittent, highintensity training. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,17, 379-387.
Stølen, T., Chamari, K., Castagna, C. & Wisløff, U. (2005). Physiology of soccer: an
update. Sports Medicine, 35, 501-536.
Tamer, K., Gunay, G., Tiryaki, G., Cicioolu, I. & Erol, E. (1997). Physiological
characteristics of Turkish female soccer players. In Science and Football III
(edited by T. Reilly, J. Bangsbo & M. Hughes), pp. 37-39. London: E & Spon.
Todd, M., Scott, D. & Chisnall, J. (2002). Fitness characteristics of English female
soccer players: an analysis by position and playing standard. In Science and
Football IV (edited by W. Spinks, T. Reilly & A. Murphy), pp. 374-381.
London: E & Spon.
Thomas, K., French, D. & Hayes, P.R.. (2009). The effect of two plyometric training
techniques on muscular power and agility in youth soccer players. Journal of
Strength and Conditioning Research, 23, 332–335.
Tumilty, D. & Darby, S. (1992). Physiological characteristics of female soccer players.
Journal of Sports Sciences, 10, 144.
160
Vescovi, J.D., Brownb, T.D. & Murrayc, T.M. (2007). Descriptive characteristics of
NCAA Division I women lacrosse players. Journal of Science and Medicine in
Sport, 10, 334—340.
Wisloff, U., Helgerud, J. & Hoff, J. (1998). Strength and endurance of elite soccer
players. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 30, 462—7.
Chamari, K., Chaouachi, A., Hambli, M., Kaouech, F., Wisløff, U. & Castagna, C.
(2008). The five-jump test for distance as a field test to assess lower limb
explosive power in soccer players. Journal of Strength and Conditioning
Research, 22(3), 944-50.
Hoff. J. & Helgerud, J. (2004). Endurance and strength training for soccer players:
physiological considerations. Sports Medicine. 34(3), 165-80.
161
Behaviour patterns of elite coaches working with elite student athletes.
Mike Hughes*, Ben Archer**, Nic James*, Michael Hughes*** and Goran
Vuckovic****
*University of Middlesex, London, UK.
**UWIC, School of Sport, Cardiff, UK.
***PGIR, Bath, UK.
**** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Abstract
Jones (2006) proposed that “coaching remains an ill defined and under
theorised field”. Of the studies that have been produced they mostly come
from America, little is known about British coaches. The aim of this work
was to analyse the behaviour of elite coaches and add to the theory and
knowledge in Britain and enable the comparison of their behaviour
patterns.
The analysis of four elite coaches involved in football, basketball, pole
vaulting, and squash working with elite athletes in university was
performed through four hours of recording the coaches in their training
sessions. The investigation used a combination of the behaviours used by
More and Franks (1996) and Tharp and Gallimore (1976) and after hand
notating the recordings total amounts of time for each behaviour were
calculated and then compared against each other.
The results showed the coaches performing consistently throughout
their four sessions, and surprisingly there were no significant differences
(p<0.05) between the behaviours of the four coaches. Instruction,
organisation, positive demonstration, and praise were the behaviours that
were consistently used more by all coaches. From the findings it was able
to produce times for a set behaviour pattern for elite coaches as shown in
Table7.
Although the statistical tests showed no significant differences between
the coaches, diversity was seen throughout the data sets, suggesting how
coaches may be different and universal behaviour sets are not possible.
The results stimulate many questions for discussion and further research,
including, why coaches are similar, why they are not, how testing
procedures many affect the findings and how future research should be
performed.
1 Introduction
Sports’ coaching, as a scientific discipline, has grown over recent years and has been
recognised as an important process where all stages are linked together rather than a
random collection of separate learning environments (Lyle, 2002). A sports coach when
giving instruction needs a wide range of skills that vary from planning and organisation
of training to the presentation of instruction and feedback information (More & Franks,
1996).
162
Effective instruction is essential in the quest for the best sporting performance. To be
able to have more effective instruction would mean the more the coach’s role will
benefit an athlete’s performance (Franks et al, 2001).
Coaches should be able to know if they are effective or ineffective (Pyke, 2001) and,
although most coaches don’t perform in or have the measures to evaluate their own
skills and abilities, analysis of coach behaviour can be very productive (More & Franks,
1996). If a coach was able to review data analyses of their own behaviours, they would
be able analyse if they perform in the correct way and hence decide where and how they
need to change their behaviours to become more effective and a higher standard coach.
Although a variety of sports and levels have been studied, they have mostly come from
America, (Millard, 1996; Miller, 1992; Claxton, 1988) little is known about British
youth coaches (Cushion, 2001, cited in Smith & Cushion, 2006).
To be able to provide quantitative analysis of such coaches in the instructional process
(providing information, coaching) it would help highlight the objective assessment of
instructional behaviour and would give information on variables believed to be
important in determining effectiveness (Hughes & Franks, 1997).
Therefore the aim of this research was to analyse the behaviours of elite level coaches
in Britain, and compare the respective behavioural patterns from both an inter-coach
and intra-coach perspective, irrespective of their different sports.
2 Methodology
2.1 Instruments/Apparatus
The scoring sheet used to transcribe the information collected was a hand notated tally
system which compromised a list of the performance indicators being analysed. This list
of behaviours and their definitions were produced by the investigator selecting what
they perceived to be important performance indicators from the behaviours used in
previous research of More and Franks (1996) and Tharp and Gallimore (1976). A
definition of each behaviour is shown below:
Table 1. Behavioural category sets and their operational definitions.
Individual
Group
Skill Related
Instruction
Correct
Incorrect
Before
During
Stopped
After
Demonstration
Positive demonstration
Negative demonstration
Questioning
a single person.
two or more people.
how performance should be performed.
saying why performance was good.
saying why performance was wrong.
comments made pre-performance/task.
while the performance/exercise is being carried out.
the coach interrupts performance (stops it) to
comment.
performance/exercise is finished.
performance is re-enacted by coach or someone
else.
demonstration of a correct performance.
demonstration of an incorrect performance.
asks the athlete about performance, e.g. what are
the four principles of play when defending in
football?
163
Non Skill Related Praise
Scold
Hustle
Organisation
Non specific
Behaviour
Silence
Behaviours not categorised Other
Unrecordable –
verbal/non verbal compliments relative to
performance.
verbal/non verbal behaviours of displeasure
towards a performance.
comments of encouragement, or effort, e.g. hurry
up, let’s go.
detail of how to function, e.g. start over there,
change positions.
comments not related to performance/the training
session.
refers to the athletes conduct.
when no comments are being said, e.g. when none
of the other behaviours are being used.
comments that are not related to the behaviours
above, this could range from humour, questions not
related to performance, comments when refereeing
a game situation, giving definitions, describing
situations etc.
comments that were not coded, this could be from
not being able to hear the comments, possibly from
equipment faults, unable to understand the coach,
unsure of what was meant.
The recording equipment used to gather the data included a Sony HDR-HCIE digital
camera and a Sennheiser EW500 microphone.
Reliability was performed by using an intra-operator re-test method. By analysing the
two sets of data it was possible to calculate percentage error (Hughes et al., 2002) to
show the margin of difference possible due to operator error. The difference between
the two pilot tests when the intra-operator test was applied on a 60 min coaching
session, resulted in 15 seconds of difference, this was a small difference between the
two, and was put down to observer error. The percentage error test, ( i.e. % error = [(V1V2)/VM]*100, (where VM is the mean of the 2 tests) ), gave a result of 0.054. This is a
small error margin, which would suggest the data gathering methods were reliable.
2.2 Participants
The investigation involved four coaches, three of the subjects were male, along with one
female. The sports being analysed were two from team sports and two from individual
sports, to be able to get a range of data collected to investigate the comparison between
coaching within the different sports. The sports involved were basketball, squash, pole
vault, and football. The analysis of the four elite coaches was performed on four hours
of video recording of the coaches regular coaching/training sessions.
Time was an issue within the investigation therefore affecting the amount of subjects
able to use and the time eligible to collect data from them, e.g. data would have to be
collected from a small section of the season instead of having data spread from a range
of sessions throughout the season, e.g. beginning, middle and end. And, very
importantly, the 4 sessions for each coach were randomly collected - no chance to
organise homogeneity of intent in the sessions.
Due to the restriction of easily accessible subjects available to the investigation, the
study could only provide a small population. The investigation used coaches that were
164
available from one university; therefore other elite coaches from around the country
were not taken into consideration. This is also the case for the athletes whom they were
coaching; all athletes although being of high standard (nationally ranked or equivalent),
were from the same university so a range of subjects from different areas was not
possible.
2.3. Procedure
Once the consent of the coaches and their athletes had been obtained, a pilot test was
performed to enable practice time with the hand notation system The data were
collected over a four week period by recording the coaches in their normal coaching
environment, with the digital camera and microphone, during the training sessions of
the athletes for a total of four hours each, broken down into one hour sessions at a time,
although the squash recording had one half an hour session and a hour and a half
session as part of its data collection. Once all information was collected the data
analysis was performed by replaying the video footage and notating the data onto the
tally sheets to find the results of the experiment.
2.4. Design and Analysis
When viewing the recorded information, the investigator recorded how long each
behavior was performed along with if it is used in a group or individual situation before,
during, after or when a performance is stopped onto the scoring sheet. This information
was then calculated in the Microsoft Excel to gain a total amount of time for each
behaviour, as well as being described as a percentage of the overall session in relation to
the other performance indicators. The results of each coach was placed into the software
package SPSS to perform a non parametric independent Kruskal-Wallis test to see if
there was a significant difference with the results. Then the coaches were compared
against each other, using the percentages from the behaviours in relation to the whole
14400 seconds of recording to see if there was a relationship between each coach and
their coaching behaviours.
3 Results and Discussion
3.1 Variation within
3.12 Coach A
Coach A (basketball) had large differences between the total percentages of the
behaviours used. When examining the individual data for each session it can be seen
there are differences in each behaviour, this is reflected in the p values from a Friedman
significance test shown in Table 6. Instruction for example was used for 707 seconds in
one session and only 356 seconds in another. Questioning was another behaviour were
differences were apparent, having 33 seconds between the highest and lowest
recordings. Praise, scold, correct and other also showed differences in one behaviour
through the four sessions. Similarities were also found however, e.g. hustle, incorrect,
behaviour, all show that their use was kept the same during the sessions. These are
shown in the standard deviation scores in table 2, with some producing scores over 100
and others below 10.
165
3.12 Coach B
The results of coach B (pole vault) again showed differences in their data; however it
was different behaviours that produced the differences. Instruction was kept consistent
as were praise, scold, and organisation. Negative demonstration, correct, questioning all
show areas of difference. Differences were also seen where correct and incorrect were
used more compared with other coaches.
3.13 Coach C
The football coach had two behaviours that were far apart from the others, instruction
(17.5%) and organisation (6.1%) were used a lot more than the others that all produced
percentages around 2% or below. Despite this instruction and organisation still showed
variation in its use, both showing standard deviation results of 100 or more. The other
behaviours were more consistent, with their standard deviations being a lot less.
3.14 Coach D
Significant differences within the data were apparent (Table 6). Instruction, positive
demonstration, organisation and praise, all had large differences noticed between the
four training sessions. These were attributed to the very different intentions expressed
by the coach in the aims of each of his sessions. A few standard deviations scores would
suggest that some behaviours were less fluctuating, including correct, negative
demonstration, and scold.
3.2 Variation between coaches
Table 2. Times the basketball coach spent using each behaviour.
Behaviour
Basketball
Time on each session (secs)
Overall total secs)
instruction
correct
incorrect
Positive demonstration
negative demonstration
organisation
hustle
praise
scold
non specific
behaviour
questioning
unrecordable
other
silence
410
18
29
213
27
168
21
83
21
0
0
9
28
164
2409
356
2
24
160
13
168
27
26
7
0
0
18
5
50
2744
406
5
27
54
23
127
27
101
1
0
0
3
273
91
2462
707
26
52
251
31
224
24
83
2
2
0
36
139
82
1941
1879
51
132
678
94
687
99
293
31
2
0
66
445
387
9556
Total (not including silence)
Total (including silence)
1191
3600
856
3600
1138
3600
1659
3600
4844
14400
Totals (%)
13.0
0.4
0.9
4.7
0.7
4.8
0.7
2.0
0.2
0.0
0.0
0.5
3.1
2.7
66.4
All coaches showed differences in their own data, and when the coach’s data were
compared against the others, differences were still noticeable. The mean score for the
166
basketball coach when giving praise was shown as 73 seconds (table 2); this is very
different to the pole vault coach who had a score of 173 seconds. Other examples are
apparent where there seems to be big differences between coaches, e.g. instruction, pole
vault = 338, basketball = 470, football = 630. Many of the standard deviations also have
a large range, e.g. the football coach has a deviation of 100 for organisation, and
basketball has 160 for instruction, this demonstrates how the coach’s performance of
that behaviour could change by that number either up or down, meaning there is a large
range of time where the use of the behaviour could be.
Table 3. Times the Pole Vault coach spent using each behaviour.
Behaviour
Pole Vault
Time on each session (secs)
Overall total (secs)
instruction
correct
incorrect
Positive demonstration
negative demonstration
organisation
hustle
praise
scold
non specific
behaviour
questioning
unrecordable
other
silence
336
60
48
96
15
132
22
133
3
4
0
48
77
68
2558
304
77
65
61
6
185
9
163
4
6
0
18
0
113
2589
271
44
112
92
9
99
17
131
7
25
0
22
20
61
2690
439
42
149
107
8
144
23
122
0
8
2
13
55
80
2408
1350
223
374
356
38
560
71
549
14
43
2
101
152
322
10245
Total (not including silence)
Total (including silence)
1042
3600
1011
3600
910
3600
1192
3600
4155
14400
Totals (%)
9.4
1.5
2.6
2.5
0.3
3.9
0.5
3.8
0.1
0.3
0.0
0.7
1.1
2.2
71.1
Jones (2002) examined the timing of instruction when performing their case study on a
single coach; they found that 61% of comments made were during a performance of the
athletes, second was by stopping an exercise with 30% and after an exercise was
performed only 9% on instruction was given. The coaches used in the present
investigation produced different results compared to Jones (2002) as well as different
results to each other. The basketball coach gave most instruction before an exercise
(41.2%), the pole vault coach gave 61.7% of their instruction after exercise, and the
football coach gave most during (32.5%), while the squash coach gave the majority of
their instruction before exercise (49.5%). This is an area that would warrant further
research into why comments happen when they do.
Borrie (1996, pp 246) stated that “it is now widely accepted that there is no one single
personality that is ideal for coaching”, (pp 248) “it is now accepted that there is no
universal behaviour pattern that provides optimal coaching effectiveness in all
situations”. Borrie (1996) claimed that research shows that the characteristics of an
athlete, e.g. age, maturity, experience, and ability control the type of coaching
behaviours produced by the coach. As the present investigation involved athletes all
167
within two to three years of each other, all playing at a high standard, this could explain
why results were similar, as Borrie’s literature would suggest they all want/need the
same type of coaching.
Table 4. Times the football coach spent using each behaviour.
Behaviour
instruction
correct
incorrect
Positive demonstration
negative demonstration
organisation
hustle
praise
scold
non specific
behaviour
questioning
unrecordable
other
silence
Total (not including silence)
Total (including silence)
Football
Time on each session (secs)
702
0
47
68
0
299
61
41
17
3
18
32
6
79
2227
1373
3600
734
0
33
144
2
308
49
39
31
13
11
26
14
71
2125
1475
3600
575
2
23
58
0
171
47
66
10
0
44
19
286
70
2229
1371
3600
Overall total (secs)
509
0
16
44
2
104
19
43
8
5
3
36
52
62
2697
903
3600
Totals (%)
2520
2
119
314
4
882
176
189
66
21
76
113
358
282
9278
5122
14400
17.5
0.0
0.8
2.2
0.0
6.1
1.2
1.3
0.5
0.1
0.5
0.8
2.5
2.0
64.4
Table 5. Times the squash coach spent using each behaviour (normalised).
Behaviour
Squash
Time on each session (secs)
Overall total (secs)
instruction
correct
incorrect
Positive demonstration
negative demonstration
organisation
hustle
praise
scold
non specfic
behaviour
questioning
unrecordable
other
silence
434
4
18
38
10
42
28
124
4
0
0
2
18
94
2784
139
10
9
29
0
48
11
32
2
0
0
6
5
54
3254
328
13
40
105
10
90
8
86
2
0
0
18
0
120
2780
511
18
32
116
18
228
16
19
14
4
2
39
59
102
2422
1412
45
99
288
38
408
63
201
22
4
2
65
82
370
11240
Total (not including silence)
Total (including silence)
816
3600
346
3600
820
3600
1178
3600
3160
14400
168
Totals (%)
9.8
0.3
0.7
2.0
0.3
2.8
0.4
1.4
0.2
0.0
0.0
0.5
0.6
2.6
78.1
Table 6. The p values from a Friedman significance test when the coaches four sessions
are compared against themselves and when the four coach’s data were compared against
each other.
basketball
N
14
pole vault
N
14
Chi-square
11.390
Chi-square
1.147
df
Asymp.
Sig.
3
.010
df
Asymp.
Sig.
football
N
3
.766
14
Chisquare
df
5.776
Asymp.
Sig.
.123
3
squash
N
Chi-square
df
Asymp.
Sig.
14
17.885
3
.000
3.3 Similarities between coaches
However in each of the coach’s results, many similarities were provided as well. The
first comparison was that silence was the most used behaviour by every coach (66.4%,
71.1%, 64.4%, 79.7%), this would be where the coach is watching/monitoring the
athletes when they are performing in exercises/drills. As the sessions being recorded
were the athletes training sessions then it would seem normal that they were performing
in many exercises, therefore right for the coach to be watching these, to be able to
analyse the performances. As this seems obvious it is the other behaviours that the
coach performs around the exercises that should be looked at with interest as these are
what affect the athlete and overall performance of the session/skill. Without including
silence therefore, the percentages of skill related and non skill related comments were
calculated. The data showed that skill related comments were the most common by
every coach roughly by a 60 – 40 split. Although similar for the coach in this
investigation it was not for Jones (2002), she found that the majority of the comments
were non skill related (57%), this would show a difference between elite level coaches.
The most common, and regularly used behaviour with all coaches, was instruction.
This set of data is similar to those of Jones (2002), as the highest skill related comment
was instruction with the majority of 33% of the 43% skill related comments; Tharp and
Gallimore (1976) also found that the majority (over half) of comments made by their
coaches were instructional, where the coaches in their experiment were predominantly
engaged in instruction. As a lot of previous research has also found results similar to
these where instruction is a large part of the coaching behaviours, then it would seem
that these results help prove that elite coaches use and need a lot of instruction in their
coaching to help the athletes. This is supported by Hodges and Franks (2004), who
claim that it appears decisive that coaching includes comments of informational content.
However Harris-Jenkins and Hughes (1995) discovered different results, showing
organisation was the largest behaviour used, although these differences in the data can
be rationalised as the coaches were working with youngsters (other research was with
the elite) who may need treating differently and just need to be set up ready to play
(organisation) as not so much detail in performance is needed.
All coaches produced demonstrations during their sessions and again of similar
numbers, this information would therefore suggest that to help athletes and be a good
169
coach positive demonstration is required when in a coaching environment. Negative
demonstration was not used much by any of the coaches (0.7% being the highest and
0% the lowest). This is thought to be due to coaches only reinforcing correct
performance, and getting the athletes to model that. Negative demonstration was mainly
used to help the coach describe and show the athlete how they went wrong, therefore
helping to correct performance.
The results showed the coaches performing consistently throughout their four
sessions, and surprisingly there were no significant differences (p<0.05) between the
behaviours of the four coaches. Instruction, organisation, positive demonstration, and
praise were the behaviours that were consistently used more by all coaches. From the
findings it was able to produce aggregate times for a model set of behaviour patterns for
elite coaches as shown in Table 7.
Table 7. Summary analysis of the behaviour patterns of the coaches.
Behaviour
% used
instruction
correct
incorrect
positive demonstration
negative demonstration
organisation
hustle
praise
scold
non specific
behaviour
questioning
other
silence
12.4
0.6
1.3
2.5
0.3
4.4
0.7
2.2
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.6
2.4
70.0
4 Conclusions
It was found that 2 elite coaches had no significant differences within their training
sessions, 2 elite coaches had significant differences within their training sessions, but
overall they were producing consistent behaviour patterns across the 14400 seconds of
coaching.
The coaches had some significant differences between their behaviour patterns when
compared against each other, showing significant difference between the coaching of
team and individual sports.
Instruction, organisation, positive demonstration, and praise were the most common
and frequently used behaviours.
These results suggest that elite coaches would perform in a similar manner within
themselves and against each other when presented with the same type of athlete and
environment with the same behaviours emerging the most.
Future Directions
170
The experiment could be developed to help provide more results and results that have
more meaning and plausibility; this could be done in many ways.
Firstly to have more sessions in which the coaches would be analysed, this would help
provide more data therefore having a bigger collection of the coach’s behaviours which
would produce more accurate stats on their performances.
If time permitted this could be done so the sessions recorded were stretched out over
the length of a sporting season therefore seeing the coach at different times and how
possible differences in their actions instead of just over a four week period. More
coaches could be used within the investigation, again this would help in the clarity of
the results as more data would be collected, seeing if it really is the same for all
coaches.
This is also the case for having a larger variety of coaches, having coaches from
others sports, and/or more than one coach from a single sport to see if there is a
relationship.
5 References
Borrie, A. (1996). Coaching process; In Reilly, T; Science and Soccer. London; E + FN
Spon, pp 43-258.
Claxton, B. (1988). A systematic observation of more and less successful high school
tennis coaches. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 7, 302-310.
Franks, I.M., Hodges, N. and More, K. (2001). Analysis of coach behaviour.
International journal of performance analysis of sport, 1, 27-36.
Harris-Jenkins, E., Hughes, M. (1995). A computerised analysis of female coaching
behaviour with male and female athletes. In Science and Racket Sports (edited
by Reilly, T., Hughes, M., Lees, A.), pp238-243. Cambridge; E+FN Spon.
Hughes, M., Franks. I.M. (1997). Notational Analysis of sport. London; E & FN Spon.
Hodges and Franks (2004),
Hughes, M., Cooper, S-M. and Nevill, A. (2002) Analysis procedures for nonparametric data from performance analysis. International Journal of
performance Analysis in Sport, 2, 6 – 20.
Jones, R.L. (2006). How can educational concepts inform sports coaching?, in R.L.
Jones, (ed.) The sports coach as educator: Reconceptualising sports coaching,
London: Routledge.
Lyle, J. (2002) Sports coaching concepts, London: Routledge.
Millard, L. (1996). Differences in coaching behaviors of male and female high school
soccer coaches. Journal of Sport Behavior, 19, 19 – 31.
Miller, A. W. (1992). Systematic observation of behaviour similarities of
various youth sport soccer coaches. Physical Educator, 49, 136 – 143.
More, K.G., Franks, I. (1996). Analysis and modification of verbal coaching behaviour:
Usefulness of a data driven intervention strategy. Journal of Sports Sciences. 14,
523-543.
Pyke, F.S. (2001). Better Coaching 2nd Ed: advanced coaching manual. Australia;
Human kinetics.
Smith. M., & Cushion, C. J. (2006). An investigation of the in-game behaviours of
professional, top-level youth soccer coaches. Journal of Sport Sciences, 24(4), p.
355-366.
Tharp, R.G., Gallimore, R. (1976). What a coach can teach a teacher. Psychology
Today. 25, 75-78.
171
The effect of match status on attacking strategies in the English Championship
Gethin Rees1, Nic James1, Mike Hughes1, Joe Taylor2, Goran Vučković3
1
London Sport Institute, Middlesex University, UK
2
English Institute of Sport, UK
3
Faculty of Sport, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia
Abstract
Jones, James and Mellalieu (2004) found that the duration of possession
was related to successful performance in the English Premier league and
suggested this was primarily a function of skill level as opposed to strategy
differences. Similar to Lago and Martin (2007) they also found that,
independent of team level, teams had longer possessions when winning than
when losing. Twelve matches from the 2010/11 season involving four
English Championship teams (one league lower than the Premier) were
analysed to assess whether strategy differences could be discerned between
teams deemed as successful and unsuccessful. Two teams were classified as
successful as they were in the top six league positions throughout data
collection and two teams as unsuccessful as they occupied positions within
the bottom six. Successful teams had longer possessions than unsuccessful
teams when winning (mean = 18.21 seconds cf. 12.44 seconds; Mann
Whitney U = 6911.5, p < .001) and drawing (mean = 20.50 seconds cf.
14.21 seconds; Mann Whitney U = 4323.0, p < .01). The sample did not
contain periods when the successful teams were losing preventing this
comparison although similar to previous research the unsuccessful teams
had longer duration possessions when losing (mean = 14.09 seconds) in
comparison to winning (Mann Whitney U = 5125.0, p < .05). The method of
getting the ball into the final third differed between the successful and
unsuccessful teams (chi square = 22.99, df = 2, p < .001) with the successful
teams preferring to use a pass to feet rather than an aerial pass which was
the preferred method of the unsuccessful teams (Fig. 1). Both successful and
unsuccessful teams did not alter their style of play in relation to match
status. It therefore appears that ball entries into the final third appears to
discriminate between successful and unsuccessful Championship teams with
patterns of play maintained irrespective of match status. However the small
sample analysed here may mean that these results only reflect these teams’
performance.
1 Introduction
Since Reep and Benjamin’s seminal work in the 1960’s (Reep and Benjamin, 1968) on
passing frequencies leading to goal scoring, much scientific research has centred itself
around team strategies and how best to score goals. Subsequent research has seemingly
172
created two contrasting schools of thought, namely those who advocate ‘possession’
football (e.g. Hook and Hughes, 2001; Grant, Williams and Reilly, 1999), characterised
by patient build up of play, and those who advocate the direct approach to goal or ‘long
ball game’, which suggests that getting the ball into the opposition penalty area as
quickly and as often as possible will create more goal scoring opportunities (e.g. Bate,
1988).
More recently, research has attempted to describe team behaviours in response
to match events or variables, as final score line by itself is insufficient in describing how
a team has performed and is often influenced by chance (Lago, 2005). One such
variable which can potentially affect performance is ‘evolving score line’. This refers to
how the score changes through a match. For instance does a team have more possession
of the ball when winning, as opposed to drawing or losing, or likewise increase the
number of penalty area entries when in winning positions. A more detailed analysis of
performance therefore allows a manger/coach a better understanding of how their team
reacts to different situations in competitive conditions.
Jones, James and Mellalieu (2004) used evolving score to evaluate possessions
for successful and unsuccessful teams. Their definition of evolving score was ‘all
possessions that were categorised as taking place in a ‘drawing’ status and continue as
such until a goal is scored.’ Their results suggested that successful teams had
significantly longer possessions than unsuccessful teams irrespective of match status.
Furthermore, both successful and unsuccessful teams had longer durations of possession
when losing. Lago and Martin (2007) showed similar findings with possessions of
Spanish La Liga teams (2003-4) having significantly longer possessions when in losing
positions, as opposed to drawing or winning. Findings also suggested that match venue
was linked with possession; with home teams having an average of 6% more possession
than their opponents. The authors acknowledged that this may have been dependent on
opposition strength.
The following investigation will analyse English Championship teams in an
attempt to analyse whether any strategic differences could be detected between those
teams deemed successful and unsuccessful. Specifically, attacking strategies will be
looked at to determine if there are any fundamental differences in how these teams
attempt to enter into the oppositions final third. Evolving score will be used to examine
if behaviours change as a result of match status, e.g. longer passing sequences leading to
final 1/3 entry when winning. Unlike, Jones, James and Mellalieu (2004) who excluded
possessions of under 3 seconds, all controlled possessions which enter into the
oppositions final third will be included for analysis. This is based on the findings by
Horn, Williams and Ensum (2002) who found that 64% of possessions within zone 14
(the area directly in front of the penalty area) came from possessions of between 0.5 –
2.5 seconds. Also 46% of off target attempts from zone 14 were from possessions of
just one second. If possessions of under 3 seconds were excluded then all of such
possessions would be lost from any subsequent analysis. Indeed, these possessions may
well be indicative of a ‘high press’ strategy to win the ball in advanced positions.
2 Method
Digitally captured match footage was transferred onto Focus X 2
(www.elitesportsperformance.com) analysis package. During analysis footage was
played back at a rate of 75% of normal match play speed to make identification of
analysis criteria easier to record, i.e. eliminate miss keys. If the analyst was unsure of
173
an event then the footage was rewound and played back to ensure that coding was
performed reliable (playback rate speed could also be altered to a slower speed at the
analysts discretion).
2.1 Coding
The point at which the analysed team gained possession was recorded along with the
area in which this event occurred (using pitch schematic illustrated in Fig. 1). Once the
area start button was pressed, the time of the match would automatically be recorded.
Footage was then played to the conclusion of the possession. If the possession passed
into the attacking final third footage was played back with the method of ball transfer,
from which area did the transfer occurred and the number of passes in the possession all
recorded.
Figure 1. Pitch divided into 18 zones (attacking third highlighted).
2.2 Reliability
To ensure that data collection depicted a true representation of the events recorded a
reliability study was performed to ensure consistency within the analysts coding
process. One match was selected at random from the 12 available. This match was
coded on two separate occasions, with a 3 week period between each event to negate
any learning effect on the analyst. On completion the two data sets were compared
using Bland and Altman limits of agreement ( ) to detect any significant differences in
the coded results.
2.3 Statistical Analysis
Since the data was primarily frequency data non parametric statistics were used. The chi
square test of independence was used to assess differences between successful and
unsuccessful teams.
3 Results
174
Possessions which resulted in the ball being under control within the final (attacking)
third of the pitch lasted on average 16.26 seconds (Fig. 2) with possession durations
being skewed in favour of lower duration possessions.
Figure 2. Frequency histogram of possession durations.
Successful teams had significantly longer duration possessions than unsuccessful teams
when in drawing (U = 4323.0, p < .01) and winning (U = 6911.5, p < .001) positions
(Fig. 3). No data was available for successful teams in a losing situation.
Figure 3. Possession durations for successful and unsuccessful teams for winning,
drawing and losing situations.
Successful teams preferred to use a pass to feet rather than an aerial pass whereas the
unsuccessful teams tended to play similar amounts of each pass (chi square = 22.99, df
= 2, p < .001; Fig. 4).
175
Figure 4. Method of ball entries into the final third by successful and unsuccessful
teams.
Neither successful (chi square = 0.05, df = 2, p = .97) or unsuccessful (chi square =
3.78, df = 4, p = .44) teams altered their method of getting the ball into the final third in
relation to match status (Fig. 5).
Figure 5. Method of ball entries into the final third by successful and unsuccessful
teams for winning, drawing and losing situations.
4 Discussion
The current investigation showed that successful teams had significantly longer
possessions than unsuccessful teams when in both drawing and winning positions. This
replicates findings by Jones, James and Mellalieu (2004) and Lago and Martin (2007).
A lack of available data made any conclusions on successful team’s behaviours winning
in losing positions impossible to make. Jones, James and Mellalieu (2004) state that
including equal numbers of matches where successful and unsuccessful teams are in
winning losing and drawing positions may not portray a true reflection of a successful
team. For this reason the current data set picked matches for teams which were met the
criteria for successful and unsuccessful at random. Jones, James and Mellalieu (2004)
also suggested that successful teams kept possession better than unsuccessful teams
when in winning positions and that this may be a tactic both to create scoring chances
and prevent opposition chances. It appears that this is replicated in Championship
teams.
Successful teams were shown to prefer to use passes to feet as opposes to aerial passes.
Unsuccessful teams tended to play similar amounts of each type of pass. It may be
concluded that this is due to the successful teams’ ability to impose their style on match
play, whereas unsuccessful teams were forced into more hasty aerial passes. It could
also be suggested that it this attacking style that determines if a team is successful or
not.
Neither successful nor unsuccessful teams changed their methods of ball transfer into
the final third in relation to score line. This suggests that Championship teams play to
their pre defined tactics and try to implement them irrespective of match situations.
176
5
References
Bate, R. (1988) Football chance: Tactics and strategy. In T. Reilly, A. Lees, K. Davids
and W. Murphy (Eds.). Science and Football. E. & F.N. Spon, London, 293301.
Available at: http//www.elitesportsperformance.com
Grant, A.G., Williams, A.M. and Reilly, T. (1999). An analysis of the successful and
unsuccessful teams in the 1998 World Cup. Journal of Sports Sciences, 17,827.
Hook, C. and Hughes, M.D. (2001). Patterns of play leading to shots in ‘Euro 2000’.
Pass.com. Cardiff: UWIC, 295-302.
Horn, R., Williams. R. and Ensum, J. (2002). Attacking in Central Areas: A Preliminary
Analysis of Attacking Play in the 2001/ 2002 Premiership Season. Insight. 3,5,
28-31.
Hughes, M., Cooper, S-M. and Nevill, A. (2002) Analysis procedures for nonparametric data from performance analysis. EIJPAS International Journal of
Performance Analysis Sport (Electronic), 2, 6 – 20.
Jones, P., James, N. & Mellalieu, S.D. (2004). Possession as a Performance Indicator in
Soccer. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 4, 1, 98-102.
Lago, C. & Martin, R. (2007). Determinants of possession of the ball in soccer. Journal
of Sports Sciences, 25, 9, 969-974.
Reep, C. and Benjamin, B. (1968), Skill and Chance in association football. Journal of
the Royal Statistics Society, Series A, 131, 581-585.
Lago, C. (2005). To win or to lose in soccer: A matter of performance or chance?
European Journal of Human Movement, 14, 137 – 152.
177
Pace as an influencing factor in basketball
Csataljay, G.1; Hughes, M.2; James N.2 and Dancs H.1,
1
University of West Hungary, Savaria Campus, Institute of Sport Sciences, Hungary.
2
Middlesex University, London Sport Institute, UK.
Abstract
The purpose of the current study was to identify the critical performance
indicators that distinguish between winning and losing performances in
three different clusters based on the game pace (fast, average and slow
rhythm), and to find the characteristic features of winning performances
from different paced periods of basketball games.
Post event data analysis of all 26 games played by a Hungarian 1st
division basketball team (Falco KC Szombathely) during the regular season
in 2007/2008 was undertaken on shooting performance, rebounding
performance, steals, turnovers, assist passes, shot blocks and suffered fouls.
Types of offense were also recorded, as well as the type of defensive
pressure on the shooting player. Data analysis was undertaken separately by
quarters in order to consider the fluctuation of pace within matches. Based
on the average number of team’s ball possessions (Min = 15; Max = 24; m
= 19.33; SD = 1.62), quarters were classified into three groups (low,
average and high paced quarters) by using k-means cluster analysis. A series
of Wilcoxon signed ranks tests were used for 29 variables to identify the
indicators that differentiated between winning and losing performances at three
different types of quarters. Kruskal Wallis H test was used to identify significant
differences between the game related statistics of winning team performances at
fast, average and slow paced quarters, and a series of Bonferroni adjusted
Mann Whitney U post hoc tests were employed where there were significant
differences between the three samples.
Winning and losing team performance in high paced quarters indicated that
winning teams could be described as having better shooting performance, more
effective defensive performance through steals and defensive rebounding as well
as having more easy scoring opportunities from fast breaks. For average paced
periods, 3 point shooting and domination in offensive and defensive rebounding
differentiated winning and losing performance. During low paced periods
winning teams had higher 3 point shooting percentages, scored more effectively
from close distance and had significantly higher number of suffered fouls
followed by more successful free throw performance than losing teams.
Kruskal-Wallis tests indicated significant differences for winning
performances at fast, average, and slow paced periods for the number of
steals, the number of shooting opportunities under minimal defensive
pressure, the number of fast breaks and the amount of scored points. Post
hoc testing of differences between individual pairs of samples revealed that
slow periods can be distinguished from fast and average paced quarters for
all of the four performance indicators, but no significant differences were
found for winning performances between fast and average paced quarters.
178
The results of the study indicated that for different paced periods,
different sets of performance indicators distinguished winning teams from
losing ones. The differences between winning team performances at high,
average and low paced periods could be attributed to indicators related to
fast break situations.
1 Introduction
The purpose of the current study was to identify the critical performance indicators that
distinguish between winning and losing performances in three different clusters based
on the game pace (high, average slow rhythm) and to find the characteristic features of
winning performances from different paced periods of basketball games.
Basketball is a time-dependent, goal throwing invasion game (Hughes and Bartlett,
2002), where duration of each ball possessions is limited by strict rules. Teams are
forced to accomplish their offences by shooting attempts within the shot clock limit.
Duration of ball possessions used up for offences are influenced by several factors such
as offensive and defensive style of teams (Oliver, 2004), game situations at an actual
score advantage or disadvantage …etc. One of the most important indicators that may
extend the duration of pall possessions is the offensive rebound. Getting an offensive
rebound means that the shot clock is restarted and the ball is kept in offence; therefore
teams have another scoring opportunity. The rhythm of play during a period can be
determined based on the frequency of ball possession changes. The pace of play often
changes within teams and within basketball games. Similarly to pace, score difference is
also fluctuates and winning teams do not always win all the quarters, despite the
eventual victory (Choi et al, 2006). Therefore in the current research, determination of
game rhythm and data gathering of winning and losing performances was undertaken
separately by quarters.
However crucial indicators that determine success in basketball were published by
several authors (Akers et al, 1991; Choi et al, 2006; Dezman et al, 2002; Ibanez et al,
2003; Ittenbach et al, 1992; Ittenbach and Esters, 1995; Jukic et al, 2000; Mendez and
Janeira, 2001; Reano et al, 2006a, 2006b; Sampaio and Janeira, 2003; Sampaio et al,
2010; Tirinic et al, 2002; Tsamourtzis et al, 2002) only few of these papers considered
the importance of fluctuation of play within games. In a study of Choi et al (2006),
analysis of performance variability relies on the fluctuation of outcome scores by
quarters. Obtaining data from archival datasets that contain accumulated performance
indicators of whole matches does not allow researchers to analyse the variability of
performances within games. Moreover, those publications that process datasets of all
the games from a whole championship, often use data normalization in order to hide
differences occurred in game rhythm (Sampaio and Janeira, 2003; Reano et al, 2006a,
2006b) and do not consider pace as an influencing factor in basketball. Oliver (2004)
also suggested applying data normalization when analysing score sheets so that longer
term performances of several teams could be compared. However measuring
performance per ball possession is an appropriate technique for the process of
identifying winning and losing performances, this technique ignores pace differences
within and between games and it is not necessary to use for comparison of data from
single games. In a study of Sampaio et al (2010) the dominance of Team USA at the
Beijing Olympic Games (2008) was analysed from the aspect of game pace. Pace was
179
described by the amount ball possessions per quarters. The researchers examined the
game-related statistics that discriminate between fast- and slow-paced games played by
USA’s team, and key performance indicators relating to point differentials were also
identified, but differences between winning and losing performances at different paced
periods were not analysed. It was concluded by the authors that at fast-paced games,
Team USA were able to made more interceptions that were followed by effective fieldgoal shooting.
Reviewing the research literature in basketball exposed that different game types
based on the pace as an influencing factor has not been considered so far when
distinguishing indicators between winning and losing team performances were
analysed.
The rationale of the study is to provide important findings for coaching process in
basketball. Based on the results, coaches will be able to obtain usable information in
order to work out the winning strategy for those special score advantageous and
disadvantageous situations when the rhythm of play has to be increased or decreased.
2 Methods
2.1 Subjects and equipments
Post event data gathering was undertaken from all 26 games played by a Hungarian 1st
division basketball team (Falco KC Szombathely) during the regular season in
2007/2008. Focus X2 performance analysis software was used for data collection that
was made separately by quarters in order to consider the fluctuation of pace within
matches. Winning performances were determined based on the results of quarters.
Performance data were collected from shooting performance (2 point successful and
unsuccessful shots divided into shots from close distance and from far distance;
successful and unsuccessful 3 point shots and free throws), rebounding performance in
offence and in defence, steals, turnovers, assist passes, shot blocks, and suffered fouls.
Types of offenses were also observed (fast break, offense against unsettled defence and
against set defence), as well as the type of defensive pressure on the shooting player
(without pressure, half or maximum pressure). Additionally, shooting percentages and
offensive and defensive rebounding rates were calculated.
2.2 Processing the data
Data of winning and losing performances from 104 quarters were organized into SPSS.
18. statistical package, in order to find differences that distinguish between two team
performances while considering the fluctuation of rhythm within basketball games.
Based on the idea of Sampaio et al (2010), pace of the quarters were determined by
the average number of ball possessions of the two opponents. The number of ball
possessions can be estimated from standard statistical data (Oliver, 1991, 2004;
Sterbenz, 2006) with the following equation:
Ball possessions = Field Goal Attempts + (Free Throw Attempts x 0.4) + Turnovers –
Offensive Rebounds
Offences terminate with either free throws or field goal attempts or turnovers. Oliver
(1991, 2004) found that about 40 percent of free throw attempts end possession.
Offensive rebounds are considered as part of ball possessions; therefore, have to be
180
deducted from the formula. Deviate from the suggestions of Oliver, the occurrences of
free throw situations were precisely counted from the event list of the gathered data.
Based on the average number of team’s ball possessions (Min = 15; Max = 24; M =
19.33; SD = 1.62), quarters were classified into three groups by using k-means cluster
analysis. The final cluster centres are 17.4 ball possessions per team at slow paced
quarters (n = 28), 19.2 at average paced (n = 46) and 21.3 at fast paced quarters (n =
30). Data from 4 average paced quarters in which the outcome score was tied were not
considered while performance differences were tested between winning and losing
performances.
Table 1. Analysis of fast paced and average paced quarters.
Performance Indicators
Fast paced quarters
(n=30)
Winners
Losers
(mean+SD) (mean+SD)
Average paced quarters
(n=42)
Winners
Losers
(mean+SD) (mean+SD)
Successful 3 point shots
3 point attempts
%successful 3 point
attempts
Successful far 2 point
shots
Far 2 point attempts
%successful far 2 point
attempts
Successful close 2 point
shots
Close 2 point attempts
%successful close 2 pt
attempts
Successful free throws
made
Free throw attempts
%successful Free throws
Offensive rebounds
Defensive rebounds
Total rebounds
Offensive rebounding %
Defensive rebounding %
Steals
Turnovers
Assist passes
Blocked shots
Suffered fouls
Shots under min. def.
pressure
Shots under half def.
pressure
Shots under max.
defensive press
2.9+1.6**
6.3+1.9
44.7+23.5*
1.7+1.2
5.3+2.3
31.4+24.1
3.0+1.7**
6.6+2.1**
44.2+20.9**
1.7+1.3
5.2+2.1
31.0+20.1
1.0+1.1*
0.5+0.9
1.1+1.1
0.8+1.0
2.9+1.7
32.5+32.7*
2.3+1.9
15.0+23.3
2.5+1.6
38.1+36.1
2.3+1.3
31.5+35.8
5.3+2.3
4.9+2.2
4.7+2.3
4.0+1.7
7.8+2.7
68.9+19.4*
8.6+2.6
56.7+18.2
7.7+2.6
60.5+18.5
7.5+3.0
55.7+21.1
6.4+4.1*
4.4+3.1
4.7+2.7
3.6+2.7
7.5+4.3
82.8+19.4**
2.5+1.6
7.6+2.1***
10.2+2.2**
29.4+13.9
76.6+16.3*
2.5+1.6*
3.4+1.6*
4.2+2.2**
0.6+0.6
6.4+2.5
6.7+2.8*
6.5+4.2
65.8+22.6
2.4+2.2
5.3+1.9
7.8+3.2
21.8+17.0
64.7+18.0
1.6+1.2
4.4+1.9
2.4+1.6
0.4+0.6
6.1+2.5
5.1+2.3
6.0+3.3
74.3+25.7
3.2+1.7**
7.0+2.1***
10.2+2.9***
35.8+15.5***
76.3+16.7**
2.1+1.3
3.0+1.6*
3.4+1.5**
0.8+0.9
5.8+1.8
5.9+2.8
5.1+3.6
66.4+29.8
2.0+1.3
5.3+1.9
7.2+2.2
21.6+13.6
62.2+15.8
1.5+1.2
3.7+1.4
2.3+1.6
0.6+0.8
5.3+2.2
5.0+2.0
2.8+1.9
2.7+1.6
3.1+1.4
2.4+1.4
7.3+2.5
8.4+2.7
7.9+2.3
1.5+2.6
181
Fast breaks
Offenses against unsettled
def
Offenses against set
defence
Scored points
3.1+1.9*
1.3+1.2
2.2+1.3
0.9+1.3
2.3+1.4
0.9+1.0
1.7+1.1
0.7+0.8
15.6+3.4
15.6+3.2
16.0+2.5*
14.8+2.1
27.7+4.5***
20.2+4.8
25.1+4.6***
18.4+3.3
A series of Wilcoxon signed ranks test were used for 29 variables to identify the crucial
indicators that differentiate between winning and losing performances at three different
types of quarters. The level of significance was set at p < 0.05.
Kruskal Wallis H test was used to identify significant differences between the game
related statistics of winning team performances at fast-, average-, and slow-paced quarters.
The level of significance was determined at p < 0.05 when Kruskal Wallis H tests were
used. Application of Kruskal Wallis H test in SPSS does not provide any post hoc tests.
Therefore, a series of Bonferroni adjusted Mann Whitney U tests were employed
(recommended by O’Donoghue, 2010) to find differences between individual pairs of
samples where there were significant differences between the three samples. In order to
avoid type I error, the Bonferroni adjusted level of significance was determined at p < 0.017
by dividing the threshold p value (0.05) by the number of pairs of groups (n=3).
3 Results
Table 2. Analysis of low paced quarters.
Performance Indicators
Successful 3 point shots
3 point attempts
%successful 3 point attempts
Successful far 2 point shots
Far 2 point attempts
%successful far 2 point attempts
Successful close 2 point shots
Close 2 point attempts
%successful close 2 pt attempts
Successful free throws made
Free throw attempts
%successful Free throws
Offensive rebounds
Defensive rebounds
Total rebounds
Offensive rebounding %
Defensive rebounding %
Steals
Turnovers
Assist passes
Blocked shots
Suffered fouls
Shots under min. def. pressure
Slow paced quarters
(n=28)
Winners (mean+SD)
2.6+1.4
6.0+2.6
47.1+23.1**
1.0+1.1
2.5+1.7
36.0+34.0
4.0+1.9*
6.4+2.0
63.4+23.0**
5.1+2.8**
6.2+3.2**
83.4+16.3*
2.7+1.8
7.1+2.0***
9.7+2.6*
32.6+18.7
69.2+16.8
1.2+1.0
2.5+1.5
3.0+1.1
0.5+0.7
5.9+1.6**
4.7+2.1
182
Losers (mean+SD)
2.0+1.4
6.6+2.0
27.7+17.3
0.9+0.9
2.3+1.6
36.3+35.9
3.0+1.8
6.7+2.4
43.6+20.5
3.0+2.1
4.2+2.1
64.7+33.1
3.0+2.0
4.8+1.5
7.8+2.4
28.2+16.5
64.3+18.4
1.2+1.4
2.8+1.4
2.7+1.6
0.4+0.7
4.7+1.6
4.7+1.8
Shots under half def. pressure
Shots under max. defensive
press.
Fast breaks
Offenses against unsettled
defence
Offenses against set defence
Scored points
2.9+1.6
7.3+2.5
3.0+1.7
7.9+2.4
1.4+1.1
0.9+0.6
1.2+1.2
0.6+0.8
15.0+2.6
23.5+4.4***
15.7+2.4
16.6+3.4
For average paced quarters, Wilcoxon signed ranks test expanded 11 performance
indicators that distinguished winning and losing teams. Table 1 shows that the number of
defensive rebounds, the amount of total rebounds and the offensive rebounding rate were
the most important ones (p < 0.001).
Analysis of slow paced periods showed that there were 9 discriminative performance
indicators that differentiated successful and unsuccessful performances (Table2). The
highest level of difference can be seen at the number of defensive rebounds (p < 0.001).
Kruskal-Wallis test disclosed significant differences between winning performances at
fast-, average-, and slow-paced periods for the number of steals (p < 0.01), the number
of shooting opportunities under minimal defensive pressure (p < 0.05), the number of
fast breaks (p < 0.01) and for the amount of scored points (p < 0.01). Testing differences
between individual pairs of samples did not reveal any distinguishing indicators when
winning performances from fast- and average-paced quarters were compared. The
Bonferroni adjusted Mann Whitney post hoc test exposed significant differences for the
number of steals (U = 345.0, z = - 3.0, p < 0.05), the number of easy shots under
minimal defensive pressure (U = 329.0, z = - 3.1, p < 0.05), the number of fast breaks
(U = 277.5, z = - 3.8, p < 0.05) and for the scored points (U = 381.5, z = - 2.5, p < 0.05),
when average-paced and slow-paced winning periods were analysed. Post hoc testing of
differences between fast- and slow-paced quarters showed that the number of steals (U
= 218.5, z = - 3.2, p < 0.05), the number of shooting opportunities under minimal
defensive pressure (U = 181.5, z = - 3.7, p < 0.05), the number of fast breaks (U =
143.5, z = - 4.4, p < 0.05) and the scored points (U = 184.0, z = -3.7, p < 0.05) all
distinguished between the two samples.
Table 3. Comparison of winning team performances from fast paced, average paced and
slow paced quarters.
Winning team performances
Performance Indicators
Fast paced
quarters
(n=42)
(mean+SD)
Successful 3 point shots
3 point attempts
%successful 3 point attempts
Successful far 2 point shots
Far 2 point attempts
%successful far 2 point
attempts
Successful close 2 point shots
2.9+1.6
6.3+1.9
44.7+23.5
1.0+1.1
2.9+1.7
32.5+32.7
5.3+2.3
183
Average
Slow paced H values
paced
quarters
of
quarters
(n=20)
Kruskal
(n=38)
Wallis H
(mean+SD) (mean+SD)
test
3.0+1.7
2.6+1.4
0.6
6.6+2.1
6.0+2.6
0.9
44.2+20.9
47.1+23.1
0.4
1.1+1.1
1.0+1.1
0.2
2.5+1.6
2.5+1.7
1.4
38.1+36.1
36.0+34.0
0.4
4.7+2.3
4.0+1.9
4.1
Close 2 point attempts
%successful close 2 point
attempts
Successful free throws made
Free throw attempts
%successful Free throws
Offensive rebounds
Defensive rebounds
Total rebounds
Offensive rebounding %
Defensive rebounding %
Steals
Turnovers
Assist passes
Blocked shots
Suffered fouls
Shots under min. defensive
press
Shots under half defensive pres
Shots under max. defensive
press
Fast breaks
Offenses against unsettled
defence
Offenses against set defence
Scored points
7.8+2.7
68.9+19.4
7.7+2.6
60.5+18.5
6.4+2.0
63.4+23.0
5.4
2.8
6.4+4.1
7.5+4.3
82.8+19.4
2.5+1.6
7.6+2.1
10.2+2.2
29.4+13.9
76.6+16.3
2.5+1.6
3.4+1.6
4.2+2.2
0.6+0.6
6.4+2.5
6.7+2.8
4.7+2.7
6.0+3.3
74.3+25.7
3.2+1.7
7.0+2.1
10.2+2.9
35.8+15.5
76.3+16.7
2.1+1.3
3.0+1.6
3.4+1.5
0.8+0.9
5.8+1.8
5.9+2.8
5.1+2.8
6.2+3.2
83.4+16.3
2.7+1.8
7.1+2.0
9.7+2.6
32.6+18.7
69.2+16.8
1.2+1.0
2.5+1.5
3.0+1.1
0.5+0.7
5.9+1.6
4.7+2.1
3.2
2.0
2.6
3.3
2.3
0.6
2.8
3.8
13.2**
3.9
5.1
3.3
1.1
7.0*
2.8+1.9
7.3+2.5
3.1+1.4
7.9+2.3
2.9+1.6
7.3+2.5
1.1
1.4
3.1+1.9
1.3+1.2
2.3+1.4
0.9+1.0
1.4+1.1
0.9+0.6
14.9**
2.0
15.6+3.4
27.7+4.5
16.0+2.5
25.1+4.6
15.0+2.6
23.5+4.4
1.7
10.0**
4 Discussion
The results of the current study revealed that for different paced periods, different sets
of performance indicators distinguished winning teams from losing ones. Winning and
losing team performance in high paced quarters indicated that winning teams could be
described as having better shooting performance, more effective defensive performance
through steals, forced turnovers and defensive rebounding as well as having easier scoring
opportunities without defensive pressure from fast breaks. Previous researchers agreed
that winning teams create more fast break situations as a consequence of successful
defence, moreover, outnumbering fast breaks enhance the efficiency of shooting
performance (Ibanez et al, 2003; Sampaio and Janeira, 2003; Tsamourtzis et al, 2002;
Tsamourtzis et al, 2005). For average paced periods, mainly 3 point shooting and
domination in offensive and defensive rebounding differentiated winning and losing
performance. During low paced periods winning teams had higher 3 point shooting
percentages, scored more effectively from close distance and had significantly higher
number of suffered fouls followed by more successful free throw performance than losing
teams. The more effective shooting performance from close distance and the higher number
of suffered fouls mean that during low paced periods winning teams in offence dominated
the area under the basket either with post plays or with penetrations.
For each type of quarter, the number of defensive rebounds was identified as the
most critical discriminative indicator between winning and losing performances. The
184
importance of getting rebounds both in offence (Dezman et al, 2002; Oliver, 2004) and
in defence (Akers et al, 1991; Ittenbach et al, 1992; Ittenbach and Esters, 1995; Mendes
and Janeira, 2001; Trninic et al, 2002; Tsamourtzis et al, 2002) was highlighted by
previous researchers. One of the most important findings of the current research was
that the interpretation of the amount of rebounds as critical performance indicators
could be misleading when winning and losing team performances are compared.
Because the higher the shooting percentage of a team, the lower the number of
opportunities for getting offensive rebounds and the lower the chance for getting
defensive rebounds for the opponent. The analysis of fast paced quarters identified
significant differences between winning and losing performances for the number of
defensive rebounds (p < 0.001), but the level of significance was lower when defensive
rebounding rate was considered (p < 0.05). At average paced periods the level of
significance was different between the amount of rebounds and the rebounding rate both
in offence and in defence. The most conspicuous difference was occurred at the results
of slow paced quarters. The identification of critical performance indicators between
successful and unsuccessful teams showed high level of significance when the number
of defensive rebounds was analysed (p < 0.001). But there was not significant difference
identified for the defensive rebounding rate (p > 0.05). Therefore, the number of
rebounds always should be related to rebounding opportunities both in offence and in
defence.
The differences between winning team performances at high, average and low paced
periods could be attributed to indicators related to fast break situations. Similarly to the
findings of Sampaio et al (2010), winning team performances between fast, average and
slow paced quarters can be distinguished by the number of steals that can referred to the
efficiency of defensive performance. Due to the higher number of interceptions, the
number of fast break situations was increased when the rhythm of play was higher.
Creating outnumbering fast breaks accompany effective scoring opportunities without
defensive pressure; therefore, the amount of scored points could be increased.
5 Conclusions
The results of the current research proved that the intensity of play took influencing
effect on basketball performance. The variability of pace within games accompanied the
changing performance of basketball teams, because different sets of critical
performance indicators were found for fast, average and slow paced periods. The
differences between winning team performances at different paced periods could be
connected to indicators referred to fast break situations. The number of defensive
rebounds was identified as the most important performance indicator that distinguished
between winning and losing team performances for each type of quarters. However,
interpretation of the amount of rebounds without considering the rebounding
opportunities could be misleading. Therefore, rebounding rates should be counted both
in offence and in defence, instead of measuring only the number of rebounds.
6 References
Akers, M. D.; Wolff, S. and Buttross, T. (1991). An empirical examination of the
factors affecting the success of NCAA Division I College Basketball teams. The
Journal of Business and Economic Studies, 1(2), 14-21.
185
Choi, H.; O’Donoghue, P. and Hughes, M.D. (2006). A study of team performance
indicators by separated time scale real-time analysis techniques within English
national league basketball. In: Dancs, H.; Hughes, M.D. and O’Donoghue, P.:
World Congress of Performance Analysis of Sport VII – Proceedings. 138-141..
Dezman, B.; Erculj, F.; and Vuckovic, G. (2002) Differences between winning and
losing teams in playing efficiency. Acta Kinesiologiae Universitatis Tartuensis,
7, (Supplement), 71-74.
Hughes, M.D. and Bartlett, R. (2002). The use of performance indicators in
performance analysis. Journal of Sport Sciences. 20, 739-754.
Ibáñez, S. J.; Sampaio, J.; Sáenz-López, P.; Jiménez, J. and Janeira, M. A. (2003).
Game statistics discriminating the final outcome of junior world basketball
championship matches (Portugal 1999). Journal of Human Movement Studies,
74, 1-19.
Ittenbach, F.; and Esters, I. G. (1995). Utility of team indices for predicting end of
season ranking in two national polls. Journal of Sport Behaviour, 18(3), 216224.
Ittenbach, F.; Kloos, T. and Etheridge, J. D. (1992). Team performance and national
polls: The 1990-91 NCAA Division 1 basketball season. Perceptual and Motor
Skills, 74, 707-710.
Jukic, I.; Milanovic, D.; Vuleta, D. and Bracic, M. (2000). Evaluation of variables of
shooting for a goal recorded during the 1997 European Basketball
Championship in Barcelona. Kinesiology (Zagreb), 32(2), 51-62.
Mendes, L. and Janeira, M. (2001). Basketball performance - multivariate study in
Portuguese professional male basketball teams. In Hughes, M.D. and Tavares, F.
(eds) Notational Analysis of sport - IV, Cardiff: UWIC, pp. 103 - 111.
O’Donoghue, P. (2010). Research methods for sport performance analysis. Routledge.
Oliver, D. (1991). New measurement techniques and a binomial model of the game
basketball. Journal of Basketball Studies. http://www.rawbw.com/~deano/
Oliver, D. (2004). Basketball on paper – Rules and tools for performance analysis.
Washington, D.C.: Brassey’s Inc.
Reano, G. M. A.; Calvo, L. A. and Toro, O. E. (2006a). Differences between winning
and losing under-16 male basketball teams. In: Dancs, H.; Hughes, M.D. and
O’Donoghue, P.: World Congress of Performance Analysis of Sport VII –
Proceedings. 142-149.
Reano, G. M. A.; Calvo, L. A. and Toro, O. E. (2006b). Performance differences
between winning and losing teams in elite Spanish male and female basketball.
In: Dancs, H.; Hughes, M.D. and O’Donoghue, P.: World Congress of
Performance Analysis of Sport VII – Proceedings. 180-184.
Sampaio, J. and Janeira M. (2003). Statistical analyses of basketball team performance:
understanding teams’ wins and losses according to a different index of
ballpossessions. Electronic International Journal of Performance Analysis in
Sport, 3.1. 40-49.
Sampaio, J.; Lago, C. and Drinkwater, E.J. (2010). Explanations for the United States of
America's dominance in basketball at the Beijing Olympic Games (2008).
Journal of Sport Sciences. 28, 147-152.
Sampaio, J.; Godoy, S.I. and Feu, S. (2004). Discriminative power of basketball gamerelated statistics by level of competition and sex. Perceptual and Motor Skills,
99, 1231-8.
Sterbenz, T. (2006). The rational game. FIBA Assist Magazine, 20. 20-21.
186
Tavares, F. and Gomes, N. (2003). The offensive process in basketball - a study in high
performance junior teams. International Journal of Performance Analysis in
Sport, 3(1), 34-39.
Trninic, S.; Dizdar, D. and Luksic, E. (2002). Differences between winning and
defeated top quality basketball teams in final of European club championship.
Collegium Antropologicum, 26(2), 521-31.
Tsamourtzis, E., Karypidis, A. and Athanasiou, N. (2005). Analysis of fast breaks in
basketball. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 5(2), 17-22.
Tsamourtzis E., Salonikidis K., Taxildaris K. and Mawromatis G. (2002). Technic and
tactical characteristics of winners and losers in basketball. Leistungssport, 1, 5458.
187
Players’ covered distance according playing level and balance between teams: A
preliminary analysis in paddel.
Jesus Ramón-Llin*, Jose F. Guzmán*, Goran Vučković**, Salvador Llana* and Nick
James***,
*University of Alicante, Spain.
** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
*** University of Middlesex, London, UK.
Abstract
Paddle has achieved great circulation in South America and Spain, where
its practice has become a question of social interest called “paddle
phenomenon”. Nevertheless very little is known about performance
characteristics. This study analysed distance covered by players along the
game, and how playing level and balance between teams were related with
it. Fifteen matches (5 for each level: recreational, medium, and high) were
analyzed with SAGIT system.
Total distance covered by players varied between 2588.6 m and 4035.3.
Players’ covered distance by game ranged between 130.2 m to high level
and 175.4 to medium level. A balance coefficient was calculated as the ratio
games/set. Values equal or higher than 9 were considered balanced, and
lower than 9 unbalanced. Covered distance in balanced games was 170.8
m,
meanwhile
in
unbalanced
games
was
140.
Playing level and balance between teams seem to be related with players’
covered distance in paddle. Balanced games could produce higher covered
distance, because teams would need to promote adversary displacements
before winning each point. On the other hand, medium level could be
related with higher covered distance in each game because at this level
players would not fail as much as beginners but still would not have enough
skills to perform an efficient attack.
1 Introduction:
Paddle is a young sport with similar characteristics to tennis in aspects as regulation,
technology and tactics, but with differences that confer it singularity. The main
differences are that the court is smaller, 20 x10m, the walls are part of the game (ball
can rebound on them) and a paddle is used instead of a racquet to hit the ball.
Paddle was devised in Mexico in 1969 and invented by Enrique Corcuera. It has
become very popular in Spain and South America (Hoyo, Corrales & Paez, 2008; Moon
& Arazuri, 2008). Paddle International Federation was established in Madrid in 1991,
and the professional tournament circuit Padel Pro Tour, where the most famous and best
players of the world play.
Some reasons to explain the growing popularity of this sport may be that it is: (1)
more profitable than other racquet sports. The paddle court is 200 square meters
meanwhile the tennis court is near 400. (2) Easier to learn, due to the shorter court and
the help of walls, paddle may be practiced with success very early in the initiation
process, game characteristics changing according player’s technical and tactical
improvements. (3) Requires a lower level of physical condition than other sports. With
regard to tennis and squash, paddle requires less cardiovascular effort. The heart rate
average in paddle is about 148 beat/min (Hoyo et al., 2008) meanwhile in tennis is
of158 beats/min (Torres 2004) and in squash 170 beats/min (Alvero 2006). The VO2
188
consumption in competition is very similar to what is found in tennis (Hoyo et al.,
2008).
Although some studies have analysed paddle, the studied variables are still very
limited and the findings need to be explored. The objective of this study was to
calculate and compare the covered distance of 3 different levels of paddle players (low
or recreational, intermediate, and high-elite levels). Our hypotheses were: First that elite
players would cover greater distances due a faster pace. Second, that balanced matches
would lead to higher covered distances at any level of performance. This study was
based on squash studies of covered distances. In one Hughes & Franks (1994) obtained
than losers ran more distance, meanwhile in other Vuckovik (2004) found opposite
results.
2 Methods
2.1 Sample
15 paddle matches were recorded in an indoor court. 2 paddle experts classified 5
matches as recreational level, 5 as intermediate and finally another 5 as high- elite level.
2.2. Procedure
A digital version of the match was recorded, placing cameras in transverse beams to the
court at seven meters height. To set up the cameras in the beams we used a lift platform,
and fixed the camera to the beam through a demountable and adjustable tripod called
"goril-la".
The cameras were placed in a transverse beams to the court, and were at seven
meters height. To set up the cameras in the beams we used lift platform, and fixed the
camera in the beam through a demountable, adjustable tripod, whose name is"goril-la".
After each match it was calculated a balance coefficient (BC = games / sets) to split
sample in balanced and unbalanced matches. If one match got a value equal or higher to
9 it was considered as a balanced match. 8 matches were classified as balanced and 7
matches were classified as unbalanced.
2.2 Instruments.
We used two Bosch Dinion IP 455 video cameras. The video format of the cameras
was mpeg-4. We used Bosch software to convert mpeg-4 format to Windows media
video format. Afterwards with a normal video converter we made the change to mpeg-2
format.
These format changes were necessary because the software, called “SAGIT”, which
we used to track automatically the players path, only accepted MPEG-2 format. In the
context of tracking players' movements in sport games the SAGIT tracking system is
essentially a measurement system and it has been tested to estimate its errors of
measurement (Pers et al., 2002). The SAGIT system was specified by their authors like
we describe below:
Calibration module
The calibration module is used to calibrate each video to the same court coordinate
system. During the calibration process, the start and end points of the game in the
189
video and the type of the game are manually specified and then a small number of key
points are placed along the court boundaries following the computer's instructions. In
this way, the computer can determine the correspondence between the image and court
coordinates. (Vuckovic 2002).
Tracking module
The tracking module is used to obtain reasonably accurate data about a player's
movements around the court. The maximum RMS error of the obtained data varies from
0.3 m under the camera to 0.5 m along the court boundaries (Perš et al., 2002). Players
are initialized manually by clicks of the mouse, and then the automatic processing of the
video starts. (Vuckovic 2002).
Annotation module
The annotation module is used to enter manual expert annotations about the events
observed on the court. These annotations can then be used to produce high-level game
statistics about the number and positions of different elements of the game such as
passes, shoots, screens etc. They are perfectly aligned since they are recorded in the
same framework as the player motion data. (Vuckovic 2002).
Presentation module
The presentation module is used to view, export and print the results obtained with the
help of the tracking and annotation modules. It can be used to produce appealing visual
presentations of the obtained data. (Vuckovic 2002).
3 Results
We calculated the average distance covered by players in each game. Players of
intermediate level covered more distance in each one (M=170.40; SD = 30.84). Players
of low level covered less distance (M=153.16; SD = 24.69) than intermediate level but
more than elite level (M=145.68; SD = 19.66). T tests between elite and intermediate
level did not showed significant differences (t= -1.51; p= .17). The same happened
between elite and recreational level (t = -.53; p = .53), and between intermediate and
recreational (t = .98; p = .36).
On the other hand, balanced matches showed higher covered distance in each game
(M=170.78; SD = 21.92) than unbalanced matches (M = 140.00; 20.39). T tests between
balanced and unbalance matches showed significant differences (t= 2.80; p= .015).
4 Discussion
Although we did not find significant differences in the distance players’ covered in each
game between playing levels, descriptives showed a tendency that could be verified in a
higher sample. In it we hypothesized that the intermediate level would cover more
distance in each game than the elite and recreational level. This hypothesis is supported
by the idea that at recreational level players would perform more mistakes and
consequently games would finish early. On the other hand at elite level players would
have more ability to finish points with winner shots, shortening the length of games. At
intermediate level players would not fail as much as at recreational level, and moreover
players would not be able of finishing with winner points as easily as at elite level,
190
consequently the length of games being higher and the covered distance in each one
increasing.
Balance between teams was related with players’ covered distance in each game. We
thought that in balanced games teams need more ball shots to get enough advantage to
finish the point, because the ability of one team to attack was compensated by the
ability of the other to defend. Meanwhile in unbalanced games, points finished earlier
by mistake of winner shot, due to the ability of one team to attack was higher than the
ability of the other to defend.
More research is necessary to analyse this hypothesis with higher sample. Also
would be necessary to analyse covered distance by winners and losers, and also to
analyse speed.
191
Table 1. Study’s results.
Level
Elite
Medium
Low
Match
1 (3 sets, 34 games)
2 (3 sets, 27 games)
3 (2 sets, 17 games)
4 (2 sets, 22 games)
5 (2 sets, 19 games)
1 (3 sets, 27 games)
2 (3 sets, 32 games)
3 (3 sets, 22 games)
4 (2 sets, 18 games)
5 (2 sets, 16 games)
1 (2 sets, 15 games)
2 (2 sets, 16 games)
3.(2 sets, 17 games)
4 (2 sets, 17 games)
5 (2 sets, 18 games)
Balance
coefficient
(Games/sets)
1>=9
Balanced
Balanced
Unbalanced
Balanced
Balanced
Balanced
Balanced
Unbalanced
Balanced
Unbalanced
Unbalanced
Unbalanced
Unbalanced
Unbalanced
Balanced
Balanced
Unbalanced
M
Distance
(m)
M
Distance/game
(m/game)
M
Time
(min)
5084
3807.2
1996.1
3788.2
2818
4887.2
6351.2
3791.4
3280.5
1866.5
2103
2239.1
2710.6
2409
3481.7
149.5
141
117.4
172.2
148.3
181
198.5
172.3
182.3
117.9
131.4
139.9
159.4
141.7
193.4
170.78 (21.92)
140.00 (20.39)
108.63
72.93
36.96
70.94
48.92
92.97
133.99
79.98
64.32
37.94
42.23
43.39
60.24
41.39
69.91
192
M (SD)
Distance
(m)
M (SD)
Distance/game
(m/game)
3498.70 (1163.30)
145.68 (19.66)
4035.36 (1689.83)
170.40 (30.84)
2588.68 (548.34)
153.16 (24.69)
5 References
Alvero, J.R., Barrera, J., & Mesa, A. (2006). Correlations of physiological responses
in squash players during competition. Proceedings of the IV World Congress
of Science and Racket Sports. Alcoy: Alto Rendimiento.
CSD (2011). http://www.csd.gob.es/csd/estaticos/asoc-fed/Licenciasclubesfederados.pdf
De Hoyo Lora, M., Corrales, B.S., & Páez, L.C.(2008). Demandas fisiológicas de la
competición en pádel. [Physiological demands of paddle competition]
RICYDE, 3 (8) 53-58
Hughes M., & Franks. I.M. (1994). Dynamic patterns of movement of squash players
of different standards in winning and losing rallies. Ergonomics, 37 (1):23-29.
Luna, V.M., & Arazuri E.S. (2008) Promoción del pádel de competición en las
primeras etapas deportivas (6-12años). Un proyecto de intervención [paddle
promotion in first stages of sport initiation (6-12 years), an intervention
project]. Retos. Nuevas tendencias en Educación Física, Deporte y Recreación
, 13, 46-49.
Pers, J .,Vuckovic, G., Dezman, B., & Kovacic, S.,(2001). A low-cost real-time
tracker of live sport events. In Proceedings of the 2nd international
symposium on image and signal processing and analysis in conjunction with
23nd int'l conference on information technology interfaces, pages, 362-365,
Pula, Croatia,
Torres, G., Cabello, D., & Carrasco, L. (2004). Functional differences between tennis
and badminton in young sportsmen. In A. Lees, J.F. Khan, I.W. Maynard
(Eds.). Science and Racket Sports III (185-189). Oxon: Routledge.
Vuckovic, G., Dezman, B., Erculj, F., Kovacic, S., & Pers, J (2002). Computer
tracking of players at squash matches. Acta kinesiol. 7:216-220.
Vuckovic, G., Dezman, B., Erculj, F., Kovacic, S., & Pers, J. (2004). Differences
between the winning and the losing players in a squash game in terms of
distance covered. In A. Lees, J.F. Khan, I.W. Maynard (Eds.). Science and
Racket Sports III (202-207).
193
Tactical and movement analysis of elite racket sports using the Sagit Analysis
System.
Robert Racz*, Mike Hughes*, Nic James*, Goran Vuckovic** and Henriette
Dancs***,
*University of Middlesex, London, UK.
** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
***UWH, Szombathely, Hungary.
Abstract
Movement analysis of different sports has enabled a deeper
understanding of the demands of each sport both across the sport and
also within differences between positions in team sports. The definitive
motion analysis of soccer, using hand notation, was by Reilly and
Thomas (1976), who recorded and analysed the intensity and extent of
discrete activities during match-play. They went on to define fitness and
training demands for the different positions in soccer. This template of
research has been repeated in most sports. In racket sports there has
been little work of this nature, Hughes and Franks (1991) developed a
tracking system for squash, which enabled accurate measures of
distances travelled, velocities and accelerations. Movements specific to
different sports have been analysed (Pereira, Wells and Hughes, 2001;
Hughes and Moore, 1998).
A major influence on the tactics in racket sports is to dominate the
court movement patterns, forcing over-exertion to the opponent.
Movement is vital due to the speed and pace of the different games.
Pearson (1999) stated that good movement stems from reading the game
and watching the ball at all times. Players should never commit
themselves to a shot unless they are certain what direction the ball will
move in.
A full review of recent research will be presented and analysed,
demonstrating the needs for this study. The methodology employed will
be the SAGIT Observation System (Perš et al., 2001), which will be
presented and explained. The aims of the research are:
1. To conduct a reliability study on the SAGIT system used for
tennis.
2. A tactical analysis of shot types played by tennis, squash,
badminton and real tennis players.
3. Compare the shot selections used by players of different
standards playing in a competition situation.
4. Compare the distances and velocities covered by players of
different standards.
5. Analysis of the position of the opponent at the moment the
ball is hit (by the opposite player).
6. Movement assessed is relation to ball hitting (movements to
and from the ball strike).
The analyses of the data will be discussed and likely outcomes proposed.
194
1 Introduction
Movement analysis of different sports has enabled a deeper understanding of the
demands of each sport both across the sport and also within differences between
positions in team sports.
General, rudimentary and unsophisticated forms of notation have existed for
centuries. Hughes and Franks (1997) suggested that research shows that the earliest
recorded form of music notation was conceived in the eleventh century, although it
did not become established as a uniform system until the eighteenth century.
Historical texts give substantial evidence pointing to the emergence of a crude form of
dance notation much later, in about the fifteenth century. They also stated that the
early attempts at movement notation may well have `kept step' with the development
of dance in society, and as a consequence the early systems were essentially designed
to record particular movement patterns as opposed to movement in general.
It would seem natural, therefore, that dance notation actually constituted the
`starting base' for the development of a general movement notation system. Arguably
the greatest development in dance notation was the emergence of the system referred
to as `Labanotation' or `Kinetography-Laban', so-called after its creator, Rudolph
Laban in 1948. Laban highlighted three fundamental problems encountered in the
formulation of any movement notation system:1.
Recording complicated movement accurately.
2.
Recording this movement in economical and legible form.
3.
Keeping abreast with continual innovations in movement.
As already mentioned, the development of Labanotation represented a major factor in
the evolution of notation. The next `step' in the development of movement notation
came in 1947 with the conception of another form of dance notation, Choreology,
published in 1956, by Jean and Rudolph Benesh. In this form of notation, five staves
formed the base or matrix for the human figure.
i.e.
____________________
____________________
____________________
____________________
____________________
Top of Head
Top of Shoulder
Waist
Knees
Floor
All notation was completed on a series of these five line grids with a complex
vocabulary of lines and symbols.
The major underlying disadvantage of both the Benesh and Laban methods of
notation in terms of sport is that they are both primarily utilized for the recording of
patterns of movement rather than its quantification. Movement notation systems,
developed primarily in the field of expressive movement, gradually diversified into
game analysis, specifically sport.
195
2 The need for objective evaluation
Forms of objective feedback could be qualitative or quantitative. Qualitative
information such as ‘good’ or ‘bad’ is not as precise as quantitative. ‘Missed by 25
cm’ would be more quantitative feedback. Both of them depend on the knowledge of
performer and lead the learner to the correct response or movement.
In those universities that deliver degrees in sport, it is taught that there are three
“simple” components in the elite career life of an athlete to reach their best. These are
firstly, long-term preparation (many years hard training), secondly, cutting edge
performance by the athlete (provided in competitions), and thirdly, evaluation.
Hughes and Franks (2004) have examined different perspectives of performance
analysis. This discipline existed already, but they were the pioneers who expanded the
area and gave it a new meaning. They defined performance analysis as “an objective
way of recording performance so that key elements of that performance can be
quantified in a valid and consistent manner” (Hughes and Franks, 1997). They
suggested that the main issue of performance analysis is reliable, objective evaluation,
and that not only athletes need this form of objective feedback but also coaches.
Notational analysis has been identified by Franks (1983) as one of the best forms of
quantitative analysis. Franks et al (1983a, cited by Hughes and Franks, 1997)
maintained that:"'if it can be measured - it is fact, if it cannot be measured - it remains
opinion', also applies to the coaching arena." (1983b: 77)
Athletes and coaches use notational analysis as a source of feedback to improve their
performance. Notational analysis was developed to provide an objective method of
assessing sports performance, thereby attempting to eliminate subjective bias and
ensure coaching observations are both reliable and accurate. Franks and Miller
(1986) provided evidence for the observational deficiencies of coaches, and therefore
a method for the collection of reliable and objective performance data would seem
important. The weaknesses identified, were; highlighting, memory and using
subjective data, leniency error and the halo effect.
The research has also found inconsistencies with subjective analysis. Coaches in
Canada remembered correctly 30% of performance (Franks and Goodman, 1983). A
soccer study by Franks and Miller (1986) showed that international coaches could
only recollect 42% of key factors during a match that determined successful
performance. Franks (1993) carried out a study in gymnastics and found that
experienced gymnastics coaches were not significantly better than novice coaches at
recognising key differences in gymnastics.
3 The development of sport-specific notation systems
The first published research in Notational Analysis was by Fullerton (1912), a
mathematical paper, which explored the combinations of players batting, pitching and
fielding in baseball, and the probabilities of success. Probably one of the first attempts
to devise a notation system specifically for sport analysis was that of Messersmith and
Corey (1931), who attempted to notate distance covered by specific basketball players
during a match.
196
Reep and Benjamin (1968) collected data from 3,213 matches between 1953 and
1968. These matches included 9,175 goals, the passes leading to these goals, how
possession was gained and the position of these actions were all recorded. It was
found that 80% of goals resulted from a sequence of three passes or less. Fifty percent
of all goals came from possession gained in the final attacking quarter.
Bate (1988) explored aspects of chance in football and its relation to tactics and
strategy in the light of the results presented by Reep and Benjamin (1968) and data
from unpublished research collected by C.F.Hughes in 1987. Bate claimed that goals
are not scored unless the attacking team gets the ball and one, or more, attacker into
the attacking third of the field. The greater the number of possessions a team has the
greater chance it has of entering the attacking third of the field, therefore creating
more chances to score. The higher the number of passes per possession, the lower will
be: the total number of match possessions, the total number of entries into the
attacking third, and the total chances of shooting at goal. Thus Bate rejected the
concept of possession football and favoured a more direct strategy. He, in conjunction
with Reep and Charles Hughes, concluded that to increase the number of scoring
opportunities a team should:
1. Play the ball forward as often as possible.
2. Reduce the square and back passes to a minimum.
3. Increase the number of forward passes and forward runs with the ball of 40
yards or more.
4. Play the ball into space as often as possible.
These tactics had a profound effect on British football, as they form the basis of the
‘long ball’ game, and it spread throughout the British coaching community because
the positions occupied by Hughes and Bate.
The first publication of a comprehensive racket sport notation was not until some
time later, when Downey (1973) developed a detailed system which allowed the
comprehensive notation of lawn tennis matches. Detail in this particular system was
so intricate that not only did it permit notation of such variables as shots used,
positions, etc., but it catered for type of spin used in a particular shot. The Downey
notation system has served as a useful base for the development of systems for use in
other racket sports, specifically badminton and squash.
Although some sports have little notational research published, it does not mean that
systems do not exist or are not used in these disciplines. For purposes of clarity and
reference the following section has been sub-divided into specific sports, even though
in some areas there is not a great deal of information to report.
4 Tennis
Publishing tennis research with complex hand system was developed by Downey,
(1973). This lawn-tennis notation system, established a foundation for the
development of other racket sports such as squash and badminton. Notational analysis
research in tennis has since diversified into investigation of a variety of different
variables, including movement analysis of serve and volley players (Hughes and
197
Moore, 1998), investigation of timing factors between serves, points and games
(O’Donoghue and Liddle, 1998a) and more detailed analysis of areas such as levels of
aggression on strokes (Hughes and Tillin, 1994) and causes of players approaching
the net (O’Donoghue and Ingram, 2001a). Furlong (1995) analysed the service
effectiveness in lawn tennis at Wimbledon and in clay at the French Open in 1992 as
a comparison. Furlong (1995) notated both men’s and women’s, singles and doubles
events to standardise for the fastest and slowest surface. The results showed that the
service in doubles was the most effective because most serves were slower to
compensate for accuracy so that a strong attacking position at the net could be
achieved, which would help in scoring more points.
Hughes and Taylor (1998) compared the patterns of play between six top
British U18 players in comparison to six top U18 European and three top U18
American / Canadian elite performers. The hand notation system recorded data using
symbols based in four positional zones of the court, data gathering was performed
post-event from video. These researchers analysed two tournaments just before the
1996 Wimbledon, which are perceived as ‘Warm Up’ tournaments. These
tournaments were Imber Court, London and I.T.F. Group one tournament held in
Roehampton, London, both of a grass surface. Eight matches were recorded over the
two venues and the following conclusions were generated:
• U18 British players made more unforced errors from the back of the court.
• Europeans seem to ht more attacking shots from the back of the court.
• U18 British players made more defensive shots from the back of the court.
• U18 British players won more points at the net, where Europeans won more at the
back of the court.
• U18 British players executed a low number of winning passing shots in
comparison to both Europeans and Americans / Canadians.
Most research has been focused around the serve and the differences between patterns
of play. Research into the analysis of movement patterns began within the sports of
squash and football, nevertheless there has yet to be a transfer of these techniques to
the field of tennis.
5 Squash
Several systems have been developed for the notation of squash, the most prominent
being that by Sanderson and Way (1977). Most of the different squash notation
systems possess many basic similarities. The Sanderson and Way method made use of
illustrative symbols to notate seventeen different strokes, as well as incorporating
court plans for recording accurate positional information. The major emphasis of this
system was on the gathering of information concerning `play patterns' as well as the
comprehensive collection of descriptive match data. Sanderson felt that `suggestive'
symbols were better than codes, being easier for the operator to learn and remember,
and devised a code system. These were used on a series of court representations, one
court per activity, so that the player, action and position of the action were all notated.
In addition, outcomes of rallies were also recorded, together with the score and the
initials of the server. The position was specified using an acetate overlay with the
courts divided into 28 cells. The system took an estimated 5-8 hours of use and
practise before an operator was sufficiently skillful to record a full match actually
198
during the game. Processing the data could take as long as 40 hours of further work.
Sanderson (1984) used this system to gather a data-base and show that squash players
play in the same patterns, winning or losing, despite the supposed coaching standard
of `....if you are losing change your tactics'. It would seem that the majority of players
are unable to change the patterns in which they play.
Most of the data that Sanderson and Way presented was in the form of frequency
distributions of shots with respect to position on the court. This was then a problem of
presenting data in three dimensions - two for the court and one for the value of the
frequency of the shots. Three dimensional graphics at that time were very difficult to
present in such a way that no data were lost, or, that was easily visualised by those
viewing the data. Sanderson overcame this problem by using longitudinal and lateral
summations. Not only were the patterns of rally-ending shots examined in detail, but
also those shots, (N-1), that preceded the end shot, and the shots that preceded those,
(N-2). In this way the rally ending patterns of play were analysed. The major pitfall
inherent in this system, as with all long-hand systems, was the time taken to learn the
system and the sheer volume of raw data generated, requiring so much time to process
it.
All the research carried out on playing patterns in squash have observed male
subjects only, apart from a recent study by Hughes, Wells and Matthews (2000) who
analysed female squash players. The aim of the study was to define models of patterns
of play at different levels in squash for women and analyse the demands placed on
players as they ascend through these levels. An additional aim was to define a
'normative profile' and explore how much data were required to reach a 'normal
playing pattern'. Using a computerised notation system (Brown and Hughes, 1995)
post-event analysis for elite (N=20), county (N=20), and recreational (N=20) were
analysed. A dependent t-test was used to establish whether a normative profile had
been reached, the profiles of 8 matches were compared with those of 9 and 10
matches, for each of the categories of players. Analysis of variance and chi-squared
analysis were used to test for differences in the overall match totals and distributions
of shots.
The results produced in this study have clearly distinguished between the playing
patterns of women at the different levels of play. It was discovered that elite and
county players did establish a playing pattern that could be reproduced reasonably
consistently. The recreational players did not produce a normal playing pattern due to
lack of significance at a suitable level. Hughes, Wells and Matthews (2000) felt that a
normative playing pattern is only achieved when a player plays at top level, the
subsequent differences of the recreational player exist because they do not posses a
fixed pattern. Their differences were not caused by chance but by the fact that they
have no fixed pattern of play. As players work their way up the different standards of
play set patterns emerge. The county playing standards showed a set pattern forming,
but this will not be fully achieved until that county playing standard reaches the top
level of squash, elite level. (Hughes et al., 2000, p91.
Significant differences were produced on a number of key elements of play across
the three standards. There was a significant difference in the total number of shots
played per match, (p<0.05) and standards of play. Also significant differences
(p<0.05) were found between all three groups for the total number of shots per rally.
The conclusions drawn from this study have similarities to that of Hughes (1986) on
his work concerning male subjects. The elite players employed an 'all-court' game,
using more complex tactics creating more pressure, due to their higher levels of
fitness, covering ability, speed and skill levels. County players showed a consistent
199
attempt on hitting the ball into the back of the court and predominantly on the
backhand side. Their shots were less accurate than the elite players, but significantly
more accurate than the recreational player. Recreational players adopted a 'hit and run'
game due to their inability displaying tactics. They were erratic with their distribution
of shots, hitting a high percentage loose to the middle of the court. These studies by
Hughes (1986) and Hughes et al. (2000) distinguish between playing patterns of both
standards of genders, they are not representative of the junior game in any way. This
is due to the differing physiological factors that exist between the two subject areas,
for instance being able to retrieve the ball, and also other factors that might contribute
to the variance in playing patterns, such as quality of coaching.
Armed with this information the coach can then analyse any technical
deficiencies of their players when playing in these particular areas of the court or
when playing a certain shot. This in turn will inform the player of tactical
considerations of shot sequences. This can be done live in training, or with use of
video feedback. Seeing technical faults in the past has been quite difficult on video
due to the frame rates. However with introduction of high-speed cameras for feedback
purposes, technical analyses of the racket swings and individual player movement can
now be scrutinised to the minutest detail.
The definitive motion analysis of soccer, using hand notation, was by Reilly and
Thomas (1976), who recorded and analysed the intensity and extent of discrete
activities during match-play. They went on to define fitness and training demands for
the different positions in soccer. This template of research has been repeated in most
sports. In racket sports there has been little work of this nature, Hughes and Franks
(1991) developed a tracking system for squash, which enabled accurate measures of
distances travelled, velocities and accelerations. Movements specific to different
sports have been analysed (Pereira, Wells and Hughes, 2001; Hughes and Moore,
1998).
A major influence on the tactics in racket sports is to dominate the court movement
patterns, forcing over-exertion to the opponent. Movement is vital due to the speed
and pace of the different games. Pearson (1999) stated that good movement stems
from reading the game and watching the ball at all times. Players should never
commit themselves to a shot unless they are certain what direction the ball will move
in.
6 Badminton
Full time notational analyst for the Badminton Association of England, Steve Evans
has developed various hand notation systems to provide information on badminton
play patterns, work to rest ratios and movement analysis. Using the 1998 ladies
singles final of the All England Championship, Evans (1998b) analysed rally-ending
situations so as to provide tactical match plans for future training sessions. Within the
study it was noted that a low winner to error ratio was apparent. The players also
showed an increased amount of errors when playing the clear in comparison to other
shots. This could have been due to the surrounding environment or increased
pressure, it is usually expected that a clear will produce a low winner to error ratio.
The smash though will usually have a winner to error ratio greater than one (in men’s
singles the ratio is 2.2:1, Evans, 1998a). Within this study only one match was
analysed therefore care must be taken when interpreting the data. Evans (1998)
outlined that ideally a good player profile can be established by using a collection of
200
five matches, ‘the more matches one can notate the more accurate an emerging
pattern will be,’ Evans (1998, p.9).
7 Movement analysis
Based upon the work conducted by Reilly and Thomas (1976), on movement duration
and intensity in soccer, Hughes, Franks and Nagelkerke (1989) designed a tracking
system for squash. The tracking system was designed to be used post-match from
video at match speed. A ‘Power Pad’ was used to gather the positional data along
with the time base (Hughes, 1998). Accurate tracking was enabled by training a video
camera on the ‘Power Pad’ and mixing the image from the camera with the footage of
the match and transferring it to a single VDU screen. The image of the representation
of the playing area on the ‘Power Pad’ was aligned to exactly meet the dimensions of
the court on screen. This allowed the operator to be able to focus upon where they
were tracking and where the player was moving at the same time. This was shown to
be an accurate and reliable method of gathering information regarding player
velocities and accelerations.
This system was utilised by Hughes and Franks (1994) in a study comparing
the motions of squash players of differing standards. They recorded the distances
moved, the average velocities and the accelerations during rallies of four different
standards of players ranging from club level to elite internationals. The mean distance
travelled by recreational and regular club players was only 12m, which raised some
questions about the type and specificity of the training that these players were
performing. The study also showed that the then number 1 player in the world,
Jahangir Khan, had a physiological advantage over the other top players in the world.
It was found that when the data for Jahangir Khan were compared to that of the top
six players, including his own data, his acceleration during a rally was 50% greater
than that of his opponents.
Hughes and Moore (1998) analysed the patterns of movement concerned with
serve and volley tactics in tennis. They indicated that certain types of movement, like
skip-check, combined with the ready position were used almost universally, however,
some movements, such as running or jumping through a shot, placed pressure on the
player often resulted in them losing the rally. They also suggested that losing players
exhibited a higher number of post impact steps away from the midline of the court.
Richers (1995) also conducted a study regarding movement and physiological
profiling of single tennis. She used a time-motion analysis combined with an
assessment of sets and repetitions of continuous foot movements. The research
suggested that elite tennis players primarily utilise anaerobic metabolic pathways
(ATP-PC and Lactic Acid pathways), and also noted that players took similar
repetitions of steps across hard, clay and grass surfaces per set, but significantly
higher numbers of sets on both hard and clay surfaces, largely owing to the
significantly longer duration of each point on those surfaces.
Liddle & O’Donoghue (1998) investigated rally and rest times for each
discipline of badminton (apart from mixed doubles) and found mean rest durations to
be longer than mean rally durations for all forms of the game. In men’s singles, mean
rally duration was found to be 9.15 ±0.43s, whilst the mean rest time was 13.84
±1.16s. These figures differ greatly from those found by Coad et al.(1979) and
Docherty (1982) (cited in Hughes, M. G., 1994). They found rally length to be
around five seconds with five to ten seconds of recovery in between, but did state that
the rally length would be expected to be longer at the elite level. However, the study
201
by Liddle and O’Donoghue (1998) was limited in that only four of each men’s and
ladies’ singles, five men’s doubles and four ladies doubles matches were notated.
This meant that a restricted study size was examined for each discipline. The analysis
(Liddle & O’Donoghue, 1998) was performed live using computer notation during
matches. This will have removed inaccuracies that arise from post match analysis,
caused by such events as stretching of the videotape due to repeated viewing.
Conclusions were drawn from the research that training should be specific to the
discipline in which performers participate. This is reinforced by the fact that the
Badminton Association of England have appointed specialist singles and doubles
coaches in recent times.
Pereira et al. (2001) indicated the importance of movement within the game of
squash, a concept that is re-iterated by many tennis professionals, even given the
differences in reported rally time, intensity, and rest ratios between the two sports.
The principle aim of the research undertaken by Pereira et al. (2001) was to link
movement patterns form different areas of the court, to establish a normative
movement profile. Within the study, movements were operationalised into categories
according to the discrete movements of the sport, and later inter-linked during the
data analysis. This enabled different movements, from the initial movements, those to
the ball, and those at the time of ball striking to be linked together, and when
combined with data on the rally outcome, determine the normative movement patterns
of winning and losing squash players. Although the outcomes of the research are not
directly comparable to tennis, the methodology used represents a new approach in the
analysis of patterns of movement. Wells and Hughes (2001) also conducted a similar
study in squash, however their methodology differed to Pereira et al (2001) due to the
division of front, back, and middle areas of the court, and further sub-divisions on
both the forehand and backhand side. This enabled a more specific and relevant
analysis of the movement patterns to be established, and served as an accurate tool for
future coaching. Such profiles of movement are not currently available in the field of
tennis, and if a reliable and valid measure for these movements in tennis could be
produced, it would serve as a valuable resource for both coaches and players alike.
Movement analysis in racket sports has enabled a better understanding of the
physical demands of the sports and, as a result, the creation of specific training drills
to better prepare the players for matchplay. This information can also be used to help
strengthen junior players who are currently finding the transition from the junior
game to the senior (professional) sport difficult due to the greater physicality of the
senior game (Pearson, 1999).
7 Aims of the study
The aim of this study is to compare patterns of play of players to establish if
differences exist in movement patterns. It is also an aim of this study to attempt to
establish a normative profile for elite male tennis players. The study also aims to add
to the framework of current notation research used to aid coaching and teaching
relevant on a practical level.
The general aim is to investigate movement patterns and shots played as dependant
variables to infer the "decision making" of different levels of tennis players using the
SAGIT analysis system.
Tactics will be assessed from shot data i.e. the selection of shots played under
different conditions can provide evidence of tactical decision making, e.g. at present
202
no reliable information has been collected regarding the time available to play shots,
this is possible using the SAGIT system.
The review of recent research demonstrates the needs for this study. The
methodology employed will be the SAGIT Observation System (Perš et al., 2001),
which will be presented and explained. The aims of the research are:1. To conduct a reliability study on the SAGIT system used for tennis.
2. A tactical analysis of shot types played by tennis, squash, badminton and
real tennis players.
3. Compare the shot selections used by players of different standards playing
in a competition situation.
4. Compare the distances and velocities covered by players of different
standards.
5. Analysis of the position of the opponent at the moment the ball is hit (by
the opposite player).
6. Movement assessed is relation to ball hitting (movements to and from the
ball strike).
8 References
Bate, R. (1988) Football chance: tactics and strategy. In T.Reilly, A.Lees, K.Davids &
W.Murphy (Eds.), Science and Football. London: E. & F. Spon.
Hughes, C. (1990). The winning formula : Soccer skills and tactics. U.K.: Collins
Downey, J.C. (1973). The Singles Game. London: E.P. Publications, London.
Hughes, M.D. and Franks, I.M. (1997). Notational Analysis of Sport. E. and F.N.
Spon. London.
Hughes, M.D. & Franks, I.M. (1991) A time-motion analysis of squash players using
a mixed-image video tracking system. Ergonomics, 37, 23-29.
Pereira, A., Wells, J. and Hughes, M. (2001). Notational analysis of elite women’s
movement patterns in squash. In (eds. M. Hughes and I.M. Franks) pass.com,
Cardiff: CPA, UWIC, pp. 223 – 238.
Fullerton, H.S, (1912) The inside game: the science of baseball. The American
Magazine, LXX, 2-13.
Hughes, M. and Moore, P. (1998). Movement Analysis of Elite Level Male Serve
and Volley Tennis Players. In A. Lees, I. Maynard, M. Hughes and T. Reilly
(eds) Science and Racket Sports II. London: E. & F.N. Spon, pp. 254-259.
Messersmith, L.L. and Corey, S. M. (1931) Distance Traversed by a Basketball
Player. Research Quarterly. 2(2) 57-60.
Pearson, D (1999). Movement is the key.
http://uksquash.hypermart.net/movement.htm
Reep, C. and Benjamin, B. (1968) Skill and chance in association football. Journal of
the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 131, 581-585.
Reilly, T. & Thomas, V. (1976). A motion analysis of work-rate in different
positional roles in professional football match-play. Journal of Human
Movement Studies, 2, 87- 97.
Robertson, K. (1999) Observation, Analysis and Video, Leeds: NCF.
Sanderson, F.H. (1983). A notation system for analysing squash. Physical Education
Review, 6, 19-23.
203
Sanderson, F.H. & Way K.I.M. (1977). The development of an objective method of
game analysis in squash rackets. British Journal of Sports Medecine, 11, 188.
Sharp, C. (1995). Physiological demands of racket sports. In: T. Reilly, M. Hughes &
A. Lees (Eds.) Science of Racket Sports, London, E. & F. Spon, pp. 7 - 23.
Perš, J., Vučković, G., Kovačič, S. & Dežman, B. (2001). A Low-cost Real-time
Tracker of Live Sport Events. In ISPA 2001 (edited by S. Lončarić and H.
Babić), pp. 362-365. Pula, Croatia.
204
The use of zone 14 as a strategic attacking area in the English Championship
Gethin Rees1, Nic James1, Mike Hughes1, Joe Taylor2, Goran Vučković3
1
London Sport Institute, Middlesex University, UK
2
English Institute of Sport, UK
3
Faculty of Sport, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia
Abstract
Whilst research in performance analysis of soccer has often investigated strategies
for success, relatively little attention has been devoted to the so called ‘zone 14’
which seems popular within coaching, particularly in the UK. This area of the pitch is
located centrally, directly in front of the 18 yard box (see Fig. 1). Research suggests
that successful teams play more passes into this attacking area than unsuccessful
teams (Grant, Williams, Reilly and Borrie, 1998) and that the majority of attempts at
goal result from assists from this area (Horn, Williams and Grant, 2000).
Furthermore, passes played from zone 14 into the penalty area produce four times the
number of goals than passes laterally from wing positions (Horn, Williams and
Ensum, 2002). Previous research related to zone 14 has been limited to international
and English Premier League teams. This paper analysed 12 matches involving four
English Championship teams during the 2010/11 season. Two teams were classified
as successful as they were in the top six throughout data collection, the two classified
as unsuccessful were in the bottom six. The analysed teams had 280 possessions in
zone 14 (45.1% of attacks) suggesting Championship teams have an average of about
23 possessions in zone 14 per game (Horn et al. 2002 found Premier League teams
averaged 30 per game). Whilst successful teams had slightly less possessions in zone
14 than unsuccessful teams (n=134 vs. 146 respectively), they converted more of them
(43.2% vs. 28.8% respectively) into critical incidents (shots) (chi square = 4.12, df =
1, p < .05). This suggests that how possessions are used in zone 14 rather than the
frequency of possessions in this area is a performance indicator in English
Championship soccer.
1 Introduction
Performance analysis in soccer provides coaches/managers with both technical and
tactical information from which future training sessions, formations and line ups can
be decided upon. Much of the published research in soccer has centred itself around
the effectiveness of attacking strategies, i.e. the best way to create and convert goal
scoring chances. Initially such published data advocated a direct approach to goal
(Reep and Benjamin, 1967) which has created much debate and rebuttal for those who
suggest possession as a key indicator of success (Hughes and Franks, 2005).
Recent trends have moved towards producing a more ‘finer grained’ analysis
of performance where authors have attempted to describe performance, not as a whole
i.e. final match result, but by elements of match play, such as final third entries,
penalty box entries or possession in the opposition half. Much of this research is
often developed via analysis of elite teams, such as World Cup, Premier League or
UEFA Champions League on the basis that knowing what aspects of these
performances contribute most to success potentially account for success in general.
205
Of particular recent interest within coaching circles is the influence that
controlling a particular area of the field within the attacking third, named ‘zone 14’,
can have upon a match. This area of the pitch is located centrally, directly in front of
the 18 yard box (see Fig. 1). For instance, Grant, Williams, Reilly and Borrie (1998)
compared successful (defined as teams reaching the semi-finals) and unsuccessful
teams (defined as those who went out in the group stage) on a number of performance
outcomes. Analysis was performed on 30 matches played in the 1998 World Cup,
with the pitch split into 18 zones of equal size in an attempt to describe more fully
activities of match play (for pitch zones see Fig.1). Successful teams were seen to
create more goal attempts from possessions with a greater number of passes and for
longer durations (>15 seconds) than unsuccessful teams, advocating a patient passing
game. Most attempts at goal came from possessions gained in the attacking quarter
for both classifications of teams, seemingly advocating a high pressing game for
regaining possession. More interestingly successful teams made more passes within
zone 14, particularly to ‘danger areas’ zone 16, 17 and 18. Zone 14 was therefore
highlighted as an area of critical importance, which if utilised fully could potential
increase the number of attempts at goal and thus the chances of scoring a goal.
Figure 1. Soccer pitch with 18 zones of equal size
Using the same pitch schematic, Horn, Williams and Grant (2000) performed a
detailed analysis of France in the 1998 World Cup and 2000 European Championship,
to which they were eventual champions in both. Again zone 14 was highlighted as an
area of particular strategic influence with results illustrating that passes from this area
created the highest proportion of goals (passes from zone 10 created 1 goal, zone 13
- 1 goal, zone 14 - 7 goals, zone 16 - 1 goal, zone 17 - 6 goals and zone 18 - 1 goal).
Furthermore, the majority of attempts on target also came from possessions gained
within zone 14.
Horn, Williams and Ensum (2002) concentrated specifically on zone 14 with
attempts made to show what percentage of entries into zone 14 resulted in an attempt
at goal, using English Premier League teams 2001-2002. Attempts were also made to
establish optimal time periods for possession in zone 14, what were the most
successful methods of ball entry to zone 14 and was this linked with successful
outcomes. All entries into zone 14 were analysed in 10 Premiership matches, with the
duration of each possession, method of ball entry (i.e. long aerial pass, short floor
pass etc.), action within zone 14, destination of the ball when leaving zone 14 and the
final outcome of the possession being recorded. Results suggested that there were on
206
average 30 possessions per team, per game within zone 14, 26% of which resulted in
an attempt at goal. However, the authors suggested that there was a relative low
strike rate from shots from zone 14 (goals: attempts ratio) suggesting that chances
were not necessarily of a high quality. Transferring the ball from zone 14 to zone 17
(penalty area) resulted in the largest % of goals created from zone 14. This seems
logical as moving the ball closer to goal (into the penalty area) maybe hypothesised as
making goal chances easier or inhibit defences from making challenges in fear of
conceding a penalty. No possession within zone 14 exceeded 15 seconds (n=600),
with 64% of them only lasting between 0.5 and 2.5 seconds. This indicated that the
area is of primary concern to defences who will attempt to put pressure on the ball in
an attempt to stop it entering the penalty area. Conversely, regaining possession in
zone 14, along with dribbling, was the most successful form of ball transfer into the
area, suggesting that attacking teams will try to press the opposition high up the field.
From the available literature zone 14 appears as an area of strategic
importance for both defence and attacking. Exploiting the area in attack is linked to
goal scoring and creating shooting opportunities, which in turn highlights the need for
a well organised defence to protect the area. Available literature can however be
criticized for a variety of reasons. Operation definitions are often omitted or at least
unavailable to the reader, e.g. what constitutes a successful tackle? Perhaps more
importantly results are often presented in the absence of a robust reliability study,
which has been suggested to leave any results and conclusions with limited validity
(Hughes, Cooper & Nevill, 2002). Research is often performed on ‘one off, winner
takes all’ international tournaments and therefore may not represent the wider
footballing community. When analysis has been performed within league
tournaments data collection process has been skewed towards analysis of elite teams.
For instance, Horn, Williams and Ensum, (2002) analysis of 10 Premiership games
included 6 matches which included teams who placed in the top 3 in the final league
standings.
In light of such limitations the following paper analysed 12 matches involving
four English Championship teams during the 2010/11 season with attempts made to
explore the influence and use of zone 14. By doing so attempts will be made to
compare results obtained to that of the previous research, and where possible suggest
what implications such findings have for coaches and managers. Finally
recommendations for future research on zone 14 will be made.
2 Method
Digitally captured match footage was transferred into the Focus X2 analysis package
(ref). During analysis footage was played back at a rate of 75% of normal match play
speed to make identification of analysis criteria easier to record, i.e. eliminate miss
keys (see Fig. 2 for an example of the analyst window). If the analyst was unsure of
an event then the footage was rewound and played back to ensure that coding was
performed reliably (playback rate speed could also be altered to a slower speed at the
analysts discretion).
207
Figure 2. Example of Analyst Coding Window
2.1 Coding
The point at which the analysed team gained possession was recorded along with the
area in which this event occurred (using pitch schematic illustrated in Fig. 1). Once
the area start button was pressed, the time of the match would automatically be
recorded. Footage was then played to the conclusion of the possession. This allowed
the analyst to know if the possession had moved through zone 14 or to any other final
1/3 area. Footage was then played back with the method of ball transfer, the area
from which the ball transfer occurred, the final third area which the possession was
passed into i.e. penalty area, zone 14 or other, and the final outcome of the possession
(for a full list of operational definitions see Appendix 1.)
2.2 Reliability
To ensure that data collection depicted a true representation of the events recorded a
reliability study was performed to ensure consistency within the analysts coding
process. One match was selected at random from the 12 available. This match was
coded on two separate occasions with a 3 week period between each event. This was
to ensure that no significant learning process effected results. On completion the two
data sets were compared using the techniques advocated by Hughes Cooper Neville (
200?). An initial comparison revealed no difference in the length of the data sets.
Each coding category was analysed separately and no errors greater than 3.8% were
found.
208
2.3Statistical Analysis
Since the data was primarily frequency data non parametric statistics were used. The
chi square test of independence was used to assess differences between successful and
unsuccessful teams.
3 Results
There were 280 possessions in zone 14 (Fig. 3), which accounted for 45.1% of the
attacks analysed. This suggests that English Championship teams have about 23
possessions in zone 14 per game.
Figure 3. Frequency of ball entries into the final third.
Figure 4. Frequency of ball entries into the final third by successful and unsuccessful
Championship teams.
Successful teams had slightly less, but not significantly (chi square = 0.48, df = 2, p =
0.79) possessions in zone 14 than unsuccessful teams with successful and
209
unsuccessful teams exhibiting very similar proportions of ball entries into the final
third (Fig. 4).
The majority of critical incidents were from possessions that used zone 14 with no
significant difference between successful and unsuccessful teams (chi square = 5.77,
df = 2, p = .06; Fig. 5).
Figure 5. Proportion of critical incidents by final third entry for successful and
unsuccessful Championship teams.
Although there was very limited data it seemed that zone 14 appeared to produce
more goals than the wide areas of the final third (Fig. 6).
Figure 6. Goals scored from zone 14 and wide areas of the final third.
210
4 Discussion
The current investigation suggested that Championship teams had on average 23
possessions within zone 14 per game. This accounted for 43.1% of possession within
the final third of the pitch. Horn et al. (2002) suggested that Premier League teams
had on average of 30 possessions within the same zone per game. This difference
may potentially be a reflection of differences in strategy or skill between the Premier
and Championship teams. When teams were categorised as successful or
unsuccessful, results suggested that successful teams had fewer, although not
statistically significant, number of possessions within zone 14 than their unsuccessful
counterparts. This finding advocates quality over quantity within zone 14, seemingly
rejecting the use of the direct method of ball transfer commonly known as the ‘long
ball game’. This suggestion is supported by the finding that successful teams
converted significantly more possessions in zone 14 into shots at goal. Such findings
contradict those of Grant, Williams, Reilly and Borrie (1998) who suggested that
successful teams play more passes into zone 14. As Grant et al., (1998) research was
performed over 10 years ago it may be feasible to suggest that behaviours within
Championship teams have changed as a result of such research, combined with an
increase in attention given to scientific research by football coaches and management.
Horn et al. (2000) suggested that assists from zone 14 created the highest
proportion of goals in France’s World Cup and European Championship winning
teams than the other 13 zones. The current investigation supported this finding with
possessions using zone 14 producing more goals than wider areas (zone 13, 15, 16
and 18).
Although the current investigation furthered understanding on the importance
of zone 14, future research should attempt to explore other facets of match play which
may possibly affect behaviours regarding entry into and behaviours once in
possession of the ball in zone 14. Several studies have investigated the effect of
scoreline on aspects of soccer performance by comparing play in the period where the
score was level with play in the period where a team was winning or losing (Jones,
James and Mellalieu, 2004; Lago and Martin, 2007).
The current investigation included possessions which started within final third
zones as ‘dead ball’ situations, such as corners and free kicks. Future investigations
may develop a better understanding of attacking strategies if possessions in final third
zones were separated into final third entries that develop from open play and final
third entries which start from dead ball situations.
5 Conclusions
Similar to previous studies (Grant, Williams, Reilly and Borrie, 1998; Horn, Williams
and Grant, 2000; Horn, Williams and Ensum, 2002), the current investigation
highlighted zone 14 as an area of strategic attacking importance within English
Championship teams. Results highlighted the importance of the quality of possession
within zone 14 over the frequency of entry into the zone.
211
6 References
Grant, A., Williams, A.M., Reilly, T. and Borrie, A. (1998) Analysis of the successful
and unsuccessful teams in the 1998 World Cup. Insight. 2, 1, 21-24.
Horn, R., Williams. R. and Ensum, J. (2002). Attacking in Central Areas: A
Preliminary Analysis of Attacking Play in the 2001/ 2002 Premiership Season.
Insight. 3,5, 28-31.
Horn, R., Williams. R. and Grant. A. (2000). Analysis of France in World Cup 1998
and Euro 2000. Insight.4,1, 40-43
Hughes, M. and Franks, I. (2005). Analysis of passing sequences, shots and goals in
soccer, Journal of Sports Sciences. 23,5, 509 – 514.
Jones, P., James, N. & Mellalieu, S.D. (2004). Possession as a Performance Indicator
in Soccer. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 4, 1, 98102.
Lago, C. & Martin, R. (2007). Determinants of possession of the ball in soccer.
Journal of Sports Sciences, 25, 9, 969-974.
Reep, C. and Benjamin, B. (1968). Skill and Chance in association football. Journal
of the Royal Statistics Society, Series A, 131, 581-585.
Available at: http//www.elitesportsperformance.com
212
The efficiency and ergonomics of different data entry systems in real-time and
lapsed-time computer notation systems.
Mike Hughes*, Ozzie Fuller**, Michael Hughes**, Stafford Murray***Nic James*
and Goran Vuskovic****
*University of Middlesex, London, UK.
**PGIR, Bath, UK.
*** EIS, Manchester, UK.
**** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Abstract
Computerised notational analysis is now widely used in the sports industry.
Most, if not all, professional sports teams or individuals use some form of
video analysis through a computer and software packages. However there
is little research into the efficiency of match analysis systems, furthermore,
the areas of human-computer interaction and artificial intelligence in match
analysis systems have also been neglected.
Human-computer interaction is the study of the relationship, which exists
between human users and the computer systems they use in the performance
of their various tasks (Faulkner 1998). Whilst there are many definitions of
artificial intelligence, it is first important to understand intelligence. There
are very many definitions of intelligence; Negnevitsky (2001) defined
intelligence as, ‘The ability to learn and understand, to solve problems and
make decisions. The definition offered by Lapham and Bartlett (1995) was,
‘The faculty of understanding’; ‘the action or process of understanding’.
Negnevitsky considered artificial intelligence to be a science that aims, ‘To
make machines do things that would require intelligence if done by
humans’. Lapham and Bartlett expressed the concept as, ‘The capacity of a
machine to simulate or surpass intelligent human behaviour’.
This paper therefore investigates and discusses the efficiency and
ergonomics of selected squash match analysis systems. The three systems
analysed were Focus X2 manual system using a mouse, Focus X2 Voice
Interactive system and the SWEAT (Murray and Hughes, 2001) system
using keyboard data entry. The three systems were analysed in real time
match analysis and lapsed time analysis using winner and error analysis. 4
matches were analysised in lapsed time and real time for each analysis
system. Whilst the analysis procedure was being completed, video recording
of the data entry were recorded. The study investigated data inputs per
minute and analysis time, in lapsed time analysis. Whereas in real time
analysis the paper examined the analysis times, errors made, error
corrections, error correction times and total analysis time. A training study
was conducted prior to the efficiency analysis to enable the researcher to
gain sufficient learning of systems and prevent bias. A percentage difference
calculation stated by Hughes et al. (2002) was used to perform an intraoperator reliability investigation in real time analysis and lapsed time
analysis, overall highest errors being 3.9%, which were deemed
satisfactory.
From the results, it found that the Focus X2 manual system was the most
efficient in both lapsed time and real time analysis. The efficiency profiles of
213
the analysis highlight the strengths and weakness of the human computer
interaction of the analysis systems. The findings of the study also concluded
that from the three-match analysis systems there were significant ergonomic
characteristics that affected the operator in the case of repetitive injuries.
Furthermore, discussions into the development of technology to enhance the
efficiency and ergonomic characteristics of match analysis software and
computers. It was found from the study that more research into human
computer interaction is required and also to research the use of artificial
intelligence and the application to performance analysis.
1 Introduction
As new technology is developing, sports can benefit through the application of
performance analysis to provide detailed information during and after the
performance. Furthermore, performance analysis and analysts can benefit through the
improvements in Human Computer Interaction (HCI). Human-computer interaction is
a discipline concerned with the design, evaluation and implementation of interactive
computing systems for human use and with the study of major phenomena
surrounding them (Baecker et al., 1992). From a computer perspective, the focus is on
interaction and specifically on interaction between one or more humans and one or
more computational machines. It should be clear that the role of HCI in system design
is to enhance the quality of the interaction between human and computer systems.
(Preece, 1994). Furthermore, it can be said that artificial intelligence has a part to play
in the development of performance analysis data efficiency through computer
systems.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is concerned with the design of intelligent computer
programs, which simulate different aspects of intelligent human behaviour. In
particular, the focus has been on representing knowledge structures that are utilised in
human problem solving. AI knowledge and methods, such as the use of production
rules, have been applied to HCI in connection with the development of tutoring and
expert systems with intelligent user interface. However, the relationship of AI and
HCI is mainly concerned with user interaction with an intelligent interface (Preece
1994).
The implementation of ergonomics in system design should make the systems work
better by eliminating aspects of system functioning that are undesirable, uncontrolled
or unaccounted for, such as inefficiency, fatigue, user difficulties and apathy.
The aim of this study was to build efficiency profiles of the three match analysis
systems:Focus X2 manual (mouse),
SWEAT (keyboard) system and
Focus X2 Voice Interactive system
to enable efficient and reliable data to be completed in Lapsed time and real time
analysis and identify ergonomic positive or negative characteristics for the operators
usage of squash match analysis systems.
This paper therefore investigates and discusses the efficiency and ergonomics of
selected squash match analysis systems. The three systems analysed were Focus X2
manual system using a mouse, Focus X2 Voice Interactive system and the SWEAT
(Murray and Hughes, 2001) system using keyboard data entry.
214
2 Method
2.1 Introduction
The three systems were analysed in real time match analysis and lapsed time analysis
using winner and error analysis. 4 matches were analysised in lapsed time and real
time for each analysis system. Whilst the analysis procedure was being completed,
video recording of the data entry were recorded. The study investigated data inputs
per minute and analysis time, in lapsed time analysis. Whereas in real time analysis
the paper examined the analysis times, errors made, error corrections, error correction
times and total analysis time. A training study was conducted prior to the efficiency
analysis to enable the researcher to gain sufficient learning of systems and prevent
bias. The same researcher conducted all match analysis. To provide valid and reliable
results a training study was conducted using all three systems in lapsed time and real
time until the researcher’s learning continuum curve ‘plateaued’ to indicate that the
learning phase was over (figure 1).
Figure 1. Graphical depiction of the three stage learning curve.
From the training study an intra-observer reliability test was conducted to deem this
study valid and reliable. Following the completion of the training study and reliability
test the researcher, and acceptable results from these, the research then progressed to
the main study. In the analysis of efficiency and ergonomic characteristics 4 matches
were analysed using each system in lapsed time and real time analysis, which meant
each match will be analysed 6 times. To prevent the researcher memorising the match
play and affecting the results of the study, the matches were randomised to improve
validity and reliability.
215
To analyse ergonomic characteristics of the match analysis systems data entry
procedure, video recording of the procedures were recorded. These video recordings
enabled the researcher to identify ergonomic positives and negatives such as
repetition stress on wrist whilst inputting data. Furthermore, the video enabled the
researcher to identify areas of analyses that added increasing time to the analysis
procedure and finally error
correction and correction time.
From the lapsed time efficiency analysis method the results investigated the time
taken to analyse the matches (broken-down into games), data entries per minute, shot
statistics, court positioning and game statistics. Subsequently, the real time analysis
investigated analysis times (per game), errors made, error corrections, error correction
time, total analysis time, game statistics, court positioning and shot statistics. To
analyse efficiency times between rallies for all matches were recorded to further the
investigation in data input efficiency.
2.2 Equipment
Hardware
Sony Vaio Laptop
Microphone Head set
Stopwatch
Panasonic Wide Lens HD Camcorder
Tripod
Software
Excel
Focus X2 manual Analysis System
Focus X2 Voice Interactive Analysis System
Squash 2000 Analysis System
2.3 Data Collection System
Three analysis systems Focus X2, Focus X2 Voice Interactive and Squash 2000
systems were investigated during ‘real time’ and ‘lapsed time’ match analysis using
the same individual analyst. From the completion of the training study, 4 matches
were analysed ‘real time’ using the three software packages. During the analysis the
analysts was videoed to enable indications of errors made and timely areas of data
entry. This same procedure was conducted using the ‘lapsed time’ software.
To prevent the analyst becoming too familiar with the match play, randomisation of
the order of matches being analysed changed during each software package analysed.
For each software package a similar performance indicator template was devised to
produce consistency of the study.
The performance indicators used in the study had operational definitions set to
provide specific indications of all actions of performance to enable reliability in
analysis (Table 1). The squash court was divided into a 4 x 4 cell, labelled 1 – 16
(figure 2, this was the same as that used by Murray and Hughes (2001).
‘Real Time’ Analysis Procedure
Before the commencing of the analysis a Panasonic Wide Lens Camcorder was set
up, to video the match analysis procedure, and was stopped at the completion of the
216
data entry. In the use of the two Focus systems the matches were captured onto the
computer before commencing the analysis.
Due to the analysis being conducted real time the match duration was taken as the
analysis time. However, if error corrections had to be completed after the match
finishes a stopwatch was started and stopped on completion. Then the two times were
added together to give overall analysis time. The analyst commenced the analysis on
the start of the game.
This procedure was completed for all the real time analysis systems investigated
within this study.
Figure. 2, The squash court divisions (Murray and Hughes, 2001)
Table, 1. Definitions of squash terminology
Skill
Boast
Volley Boast
Back wall boast
Reverse Boast
Definition
A shot, which strikes the sidewall before hitting the front wall.
A shot which is hit before the ball has bounced, and hits the sidewall
before hitting the front wall
A shot which strikes the back wall before hitting the front wall
A shot, which strikes the opposite wall, than you are playing the shot
from and then strikes the front wall.
Triple boast
Drive
Like a boast, but played at the front of the court.
A shot, which is hit straight to the back of the court.
Cross Drive
A shot, which is hit cross the court to the back of the court.
Cross Volley
Drive
Volley
A shot that is hit before the ball has bounced and is hit cross the court
landing in the back of the court.
A shot that is hit before the ball has bounced
Drop
Volley drop
Cross Volley Drop
A shot hit with great touch so that it dies close to the front wall
A shot that is played to the front of the court before the ball bounces.
A shot that is played cross to the front of the court before the ball
217
Kill
Volley Kill
Lob
Serve
Let
Stroke
bounces.
A shot, which is hit hard and short on the court.
A shot, which is hit hard and short on the court before the ball bounces.
A shot hit upward and softly on the front wall that arcs high off the front
wall and comes down deep in the backcourt
A shot that starts of the rally by being hit onto the sidewall above the
service line and lands in the opponents side within the back of the court.
A situation in which a point is replayed
Where interference occurs and yourself or opponents wins the rally
‘Lapsed Time’ Analysis Procedure
Before the commencing of the analysis a Panasonic Wide Lens Camcorder was set
up, to video the match analysis procedure. As the match analysis starts, a stopwatch
was started to measure the time taken to complete process. In the use of the two Focus
systems the matches were captured onto the computer before commencing the
analysis.
The analysts commenced the match analysis, using the template devised for each
system. During the lapsed time match analysis the analysts was able to use the power
of pause and rewind to enable correction and justification of shots and positioning.
When the data entry was completed the stopwatch was stopped and the time taken
was recorded. Following this the video camcorder was stopped.This process was then
completed for all the analysis systems being investigated in the lapsed time match
analysis study.
2.4 Training Study/Reliability
To enable the analyst to have an equally efficient knowledge of the use of these
analysis systems, a training period was set up to enable improvements in using each
of these systems. During the training period a single match was analysed, then every
other day the match was re-analysed until the time in which it took to analyse the
match stabilised and errors reduced to an acceptable level, which was deemed 10%
for this study (Hughes et al, 2002). This was conducted for all the real time and lapsed
time match analysis systems. A percentage difference calculation, suggested by
Hughes et al. (2004), was used to perform an intra-operator reliability investigation in
real time analysis and lapsed time analysis, overall highest errors being 3.9%, which
were deemed satisfactory (Howells, 2006).
2.5 Data Population
The actual data population used in this study was not deemed very important, but as
most analysis is of elite athletes, then this was thought appropriate. The data
population were matches of international standard professionals, all ranked within the
top ten in the world rankings. The matches were taken from 2004-2008 season
tournaments around the world. The broadcast coverage is public domain information
that the subjects give permission to be broadcast. This was a condition of their entry
to the tournaments. Nevertheless, player identities were kept confidential.
218
3 Results and discussion
3.1 Training Study/Reliability
The training studies enabled the investigation of the ergonomics and efficiency of
performance analysis systems. This training allowed the investigator to complete an
inter-observer reliability study. The variables that were central to this investigation,
and their reliability, were examined using an intra-operator percentage difference
calculation. The three specific variables were, whether the player hit a winner or
error, let or stroke, shots played and finally rally number.
Table 2. Times taken for data gathering in real and lapsed time .
LAPSED TIME
Lapsed time Analysis (Focus x2 Manual) Training Study
Test 1
Test 2
Analysis
Time
18 mins 30 secs.
14 mins 47
secs
Lapsed time Analysis (Focus Voice Interactive) Training Study
Analysis Time
20 mins 12
18 mins 35
secs
secs
Lapsed time Analysis (SWEAT) Training Study
Analysis Time
19 mins
16 mins
52 secs
18 secs
Test 3
Test 4
Test 5
10 mins 16
secs
7 mins 34
secs
7 mins
36 secs
14 mins 28
sces
12 mins 31
secs
11
mins
54
secs
13 mins
42 secs
12 mins
37 secs
12 mins
36 secs
12
mins
27
secs
REAL TIME
Match Analysis (Squash SWEAT system) Training Study ‘real time’
Test 1
Test 2
Test 3
Analysis Time
10 mins 32
10 mins 32
10 mins
secs
secs
32 secs
Test 4
10 mins 32
secs
Test 5
10mins
32 secs
Real Time Match Analysis (Focus x2 Voice Interactive) Training
Study
Analysis Time
7 mins 36
7 mins 36
7 mins 36
secs
secs
secs
7 mins 36
secs
7 mins
36 secs
Real Time Match Analysis (Focus x2 Voice Manual) Training
Study
Analysis Time
11 mins 10
11 mins 10
secs
secs
11 mins 10
secs
11
mins
10 secs
219
11 mins 10
secs
Table 2, Lapsed time analysis training study using the 3 systems.
Test 1
No. of Rallies
W’s Played
Errors Played
Drives
Boasts
B Wall Boasts
Cross Drives
Cross VDrives
Volley Drive
Drop
Volley Drop
Cross V Drop
Kill
Volley Kill
Lob
Cross Lob
Lets
Strokes
17
9
7
5
2
0
0
0
2
6
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
Focus x2 Manual
Test 2
Test 3
17
8
8
5
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
17
8
8
5
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
Test 4
Test 5
Test 1
Test 2
17
8
8
5
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
17
8
8
5
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
21
10
6
8
3
0
2
1
1
3
1
0
1
0
0
1
3
2
21
10
6
8
4
0
1
1
1
3
1
0
1
0
0
1
4
1
SWEAT
Test 3
Test 4
21
10
6
8
4
0
2
1
1
2
1
0
1
0
0
1
4
1
Test 5
Test 6
Test 1
21
10
6
8
4
0
2
1
1
2
1
0
1
0
0
1
4
1
21
10
6
8
4
0
2
1
1
2
1
0
1
0
0
1
4
1
21
10
6
8
4
0
2
1
1
2
1
0
1
0
0
1
4
1
18
9
8
2
2
0
3
1
1
4
3
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
Test 4
Test 5
Test 1
173
12
4
4
2
3
0
1
3
2
3
0
0
0
0
0
1
173
12
4
4
2
3
0
1
3
2
3
0
0
0
0
0
1
17
7
9
5
2
0
0
0
0
5
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
Focus Voice Interactive
Test 2
Test 3
Test 4
18
8
9
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
3
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
18
8
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
3
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
18
8
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
3
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
Table 3. Real Time Training Study using 3 systems.
Test 1
Total Shots
W’s Played
Errors Played
Drives
Boasts
Cross Drives
Cross VDrives
Volley Drive
Drop
Volley Drop
Cross V Drop
Kill
Volley Kill
Lob
Cross Lob
Lets
Strokes
18
9
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
3
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
Focus x2 Manual
Test 2
Test 3
18
9
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
4
0
0
1
0
0
0
18
8
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
4
0
0
1
0
0
0
Test 4
Test 5
Test 1
Test 2
18
8
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
4
0
0
1
0
0
0
18
8
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
4
0
0
1
0
0
0
178
12
4
5
2
4
0
0
3
1
2
0
0
0
0
0
1
183
12
4
4
2
3
0
1
2
3
2
1
0
0
0
0
1
SWEAT
Test 3
172
12
4
4
2
3
0
1
3
2
3
0
0
0
0
0
1
220
Focus Voice Interactive
Test 2
Test 3
Test 4
17
8
8
4
2
0
0
0
0
5
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
17
8
8
4
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
17
8
8
4
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
Test 5
17
8
8
4
2
0
0
0
1
6
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
Test 5
18
8
8
3
2
0
3
1
0
4
3
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
Reliability study:
Table 4. Lapsed time reliability results.
Rallies
Type of shot
Volley Drop
T1 v T2
%
0
1.9
3.9
T2 V T3
%
0
0
0
T1 v T2
%
0
3.7
0
T2 V T3
%
0
0
1.8
Table 5. Real time reliability results.
Rallies
Type of shot
Volley Drop
4.4 Efficiency Study Results:
4.41 Lapsed Time Efficiency
La pse d Tim e An a lysis Tim e M a t ch 2
La p se d Tim e An a ly sis Tim e s M a t ch 1
Minut es/ Seconds
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24
23
22
21
20
19
18
17
16
15
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Minut es/
Seconds
Foucus X2 Manual
SWEAT
Focus X2 Voice I nt er act ive
56
54
52
50
48
46
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Foucus X2 Manual
SWEAT
Focus X2 Voice I nt eract ive
Gam e 1
Gam e 1
Gam e 2
Gam e 3
Gam e 2
Gam e 3
Gam e 4
Tot al
Analysis
Tim e
Tot al
Analysis
Tim e
Figure.4. Graphical model of Lapsed
time Analysis Time Match 2.
Figure. 3. Graphical model of Lapsed
time Analysis Time Match 1 .
221
La pse d Tim e Ana lysis Tim e M a t ch 3
Minut es/
Seconds
58
56
54
52
50
48
46
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Re a l Tim e Ana ly sis Er r or Count
16
14
Foucus X2 Manual
12
SWEAT
Focus X2 Voice I nt eract ive
10
Er r or s
Focus X2 Manual
8
SWEAT
Focus X2 Voice I nt eract ive
6
4
Gam e 1
2
Gam e 4
0
Mat ch 1
Figure. 5, Graphical model of Lapsed
time Analysis Time Match 3
Mat ch 2
Mat ch 3
Mat ch 4
Average
Figure. 8, Graphical model of Real
Time Analysis Error Count
La pse d Tim e Ana ly sis Tim e s M a t ch 4
Rea l Tim e Er r or Cor r ect ion Tim es
Minut es/
Seconds
60
58
56
54
52
50
48
46
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
7
6
5
M inut es/
Seconds
Foucus X2 Manual
4
Focus X2 Manual
SWEAT
3
Focus X2 Voice I nt eract ive
SWEAT
Focus X2 Voice I nt eract ive
2
1
0
Mat ch 1
Gam e 1
Gam e 2
Gam e 3
Gam e 4
Figure. 6, Graphical model of Lapsed
time Analysis Time Match 4
12
10
8
Focus X2 Manual
M in u t e s/
Se con d s
SWEAT
I n pu t s
Focus X2 Voice
I nt eract ive
2
0
Mat ch 1
Mat ch 2
Mat ch 3
Mat ch 4
Mat ch 4
Average
Re a l Tim e Tot a l An a ly sis Tim e
D a t a I n pu t s pe r m in u t e
4
Mat ch 3
Figure. 9, Graphical model of Real
Time Analysis Error Correction Time
Tot al
Analysis
Tim e
6
Mat ch 2
Average
58
56
54
52
50
48
46
44
42
40
38
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Focus X2 Manual
SWEAT
Focus X2 Voice I nt er act ive
Mat ch
1
Figure. 7, Graphical model of Data
Inputs per minute
Mat ch
2
Mat ch
3
Mat ch
4
Figure. 10, Graphical model of Real
Time, Total Analysis Time
222
4.42 Real Time Efficiency
Focus X2 Manual system
The results produced from this investigation highlighted that the Focus X2 manual input
through a mouse is the most efficient in the study. This is witnessed through both the lapsed
time analysis and real time match analysis. This could be suggested to be due to the
researcher having previous usage experience of this system. However, to reduce bias in the
study there was significant training on the SWEAT system and Voice interactive system that
enabled valid and reliable results.
The times shown in the lapsed time tests show the greatest efficiency rating (Figures 3, 4,
5, 6). The lapsed time analysis times 28 mins 33 secs match 1, 45 mins 58 secs match 2, 51
mins 57 secs match 3, and match 4 54 mins 58 secs do not show much of a difference to that
of the real time analysis times 25 mins 38 secs match 1, 41 mins 27 secs match 2, 48 mins 08
secs match 3, and match 4, 54 minutes 58 seconds, highlighted efficiency.
From the lapsed time tests the results furthered the suggestion of the efficiency of the
Focus X2 system, through the number of data inputs completed ever minute with an average
of 9 (inputs a minute) - in comparison SWEAT system produced an average data input a
minute of 7.8 (inputs a minute) and voice interactive 7.9 (inputs a minute) retrospectively
(Figure 7).
The real time match analysis results showed the systems efficiency through the error count
being continuously lower than that of the corresponding analysis system. The Focus X2
manual average error count was 4, whereas the SWEAT system had an average of 8, and the
voice interactive average also being 8. However, due to the two Focus X2 systems, manual
and Voice Interactive, having similar error correction times.
SWEAT system
On the completion of the tests the results showed that the SWEAT system required the most
training, (see Table 2), 6 tests required. This could be a consequence of the researcher having
minimal contact with this system before the study, unlike in the two corresponding systems
where the researcher had previous experience. The difference between the SWEAT system
and the Focus X2 Manual and Voice Interactive is the ease of immediate use. Both the mouse
and the microphone are easier to pick up and use than the keyboard with short cut keys. This
reiterates the importance of training, to train the use of short cut keys and the coordination of
processing inputted data. A study by Debaere et al (2003) investigated changes in brain
activation during the acquisition of a new bimanual coordination task and it was observed
that activation changes account for the transition from highly attention-demanding task
performance, involving processing of sensory information and corrective action planning, to
automatic performance based on memory representations and forward control. This shows
that through training the brain in task performance can improve human memory of task and
coordination, this is also demonstrated in the training study results.
The real time analysis results produced some findings that were opposite to the
expectations. The hypothesis stated the real time analysis to be the most efficient system but
the results showed this was not the case. Analysis times produced from the tests showed that
in real time analysis SWEAT system was the second faster system (Figure 10) with times of
28 minutes 56 seconds (match1) compared to 26 minutes 50 seconds (match1) using Focus
X2 Manual. However, the results did highlight that the analysis conducted using the SWEAT
system produced the most amount of errors in match 1: 8 and match 2: 7 input errors (figure
8). This could be a result of a slip of a finger by the operator, in addition when using SWEAT
system one would had to scroll to find performance indicator required in the short period of
time between the rallies. The most efficient characteristic of the SWEAT system was the time
223
in which it took to edit the errors made. The editing facility is very quick as all the operator
had to do was highlight the error and key the correct statistic into the data timeline.
From the lapsed time analysis of the SWEAT analysis system it was shown that there was
a great difference between the Focus X2 manual system (figures 3, 4, 5, 6). and the SWEAT
system. Though this wasn’t expected from the results at the beginning of the study, the
researcher found that the time was taken in the lapsed time analysis from the system not
having the footage as part of the system. As a DVD player was required, it meant that every
time a rally ended the DVD player had to be paused, data had to be inputted and if required,
footage rewound and then the DVD being started again. Whereas, on the Focus X2 manual
system and the Voice interactive system the video is on the software allowing quick pause
and rewind and data can be inputted there and then. These results announce that the SWEAT
analysis system is most efficient as a statistical system used in real time analysis to allow the
athlete to gain game data to help improve performance. Nevertheless, if video footage feature
would be added to the SWEAT system then the efficiency and feedback characteristic would
be enhanced. This would allow a coach to use the video footage as a tool for player
development in the review stage after the performance to back up statistics with actual
footage this was view in a study by Brown et al (2008) into Split Screen System to Analyse
Coach Behaviour: In a Case Report of Coaching Practice, it was found that the coach found
the video sequence feedback to be more useful than the quantitative information produced.
This backs up what is suggested in this study that the SWEAT system requires a video input
device to improve feedback to player and will enhance efficiency of analysis. Allowing the
athlete to visualise corrections required and new tactical profiles on opponents.
Focus X2 Voice Recognition system
Through the investigation it has been shown that the results from the Focus X2 Voice
Interactive system are the least efficient in winner and error match analysis in squash real
time analysis. This is witnessed through the error count being largest in match 3 and 4
(Figure 8) 8 and 16 input errors retrospectively. Nevertheless, it has been calculated and, the
average error count for the study was Voice Interactive 8 errors inputs SWEAT 8 (error
inputs) and Focus X2 Manual 4 (error inputs). This shows identical error inputs to that of the
SWEAT system, however, from analysing the error correction times the Voice Interactive
System has the largest average correction time (3 minutes 50 seconds) than that of the
SWEAT system (2 minutes 56 seconds). This highlighted the Voice interactive system as
being the least efficient system in real time winner and error squash match analysis.
However, from the results of the Lapsed time match analysis the Voice Interactive system
is suggested to be the second most efficient system of the study. This is illustrated from the
systems data input per minute capabilities.leading to an average of 7.9 data inputs a minute
which is larger than that of the SWEAT systems average 7.8 data inputs a minute, though
smaller than Focus X2 manual 9 data inputs a minute. Whilst the Voice Interactive system
had a larger data entry average, the actual analysis times seen in the results show some
anomalies to the suggestion that the Voice Interactive system is second most efficient. In
match 1 games 2 (10 minutes 36 seconds) and 3 (13 minutes 41 seconds) (Figure 3) it can be
seen that the actual analysis times are larger than that of the SWEAT analysis times (Figure
3). Nevertheless, as game 1’s time was smaller this created the Voice Interactive system
having the larger data input a minute statistic. Further anomalies were found in the results
data for match 4 game 3 where the analysis times were greater in the Voice Interactive
analysis, this is suggested to be because of error whilst rewinding footage leading to
enhancing of time causing the anomaly.
224
4 Conclusions
From this investigation it can be concluded that there are revealed differences in the
efficiency profiles of the three squash match analysis systems analysed. This is evident by
the indication of the Focus X2 manual (mouse) system being most efficient in real time and
lapsed time analysis. Furthermore after conducting the comparative case study on the threematch analysis systems, indications of ergonomic characteristics, positive and negative,
occurred through the usage of these systems.
This study confirms that future technological development can influence the efficiency and
ergonomics of squash match analysis systems.
Finally it is suggested that the application of artificial intelligence be investigated for the
extending the automation of data entry in performance analysis as conducted in
athlete/coaching analysis, as suggested by Bartlett (2004) to optimise performance and
human computer interaction of match analysis systems.
5 References
Baecker, R., J. Grudin, W. Buxton, and S. Greenberg (1995), Readings in Human-Computer
Interaction: Toward the Year 2000, 2nd edition San Francisco, CA: Morgan
Kaufmann Publishers, Inc.
Bartlett, R. (2004). Artificial Intelligence Analysis – Past, Present and Future, School of
Physical Education, University of Otago, PO Box 56, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Debaere, F., Wenderoth, N., Sunaert, S., Van Hecke, P., Swinnen, S. P. (2004). Changes in
brain activation during the acquisition of a new bimanual coordination task.
Neuropsychologia, 42:855-867.
Faulkner, C. (1998). The Essence of Human-Computer Interaction. Essex,
Prentice Hall.
Hughes, M., Cooper, S-M. and Nevill, A. (2002). Analysis procedures for non-parametric
data from performance analysis. eIJPAS, 2, 6 – 20.
Lapham, A. C., & Bartlett, R. M. (1995). The use of artificial intelligence in the analysis of
sports performance: a review of applications in human gait analysis and future
directions for sports biomechanics. Journal of Sports Sciences, 13(3), 229-237.
Murray, S. and Hughes, M. (2001). Tactical performance profiling in elite level senior
squash. In (eds. M. Hughes and I.M. Franks) pass.com, Cardiff: CPA, UWIC, pp. 185
– 194.
st
Negnevitsky M. (2002). Artificial Intelligence: A Guide to Intelligent Systems; 1 Edition,
Pearson Education Limited, England, UK.
Preece, J., Rogers, Y., Sharp, H., Benyon, D., Holland, S. & Carey, T. (1994). HumanComputer Interaction. Essex, England: Addison-Wesley Longman Limited.
225
In search of nexus between attacking game-patterns, match status and type of ball
recovery in European Soccer Championship 2008.
D. Barreira1,2, J. Garganta1,2 and T. Anguera3
1
Faculty of Sport, University of Porto, Portugal.
Centre of Research, Education, Innovation and Intervention in Sport, Portugal.
3
Faculty of Psychology, University of Barcelona, Spain.
2
Abstract:
The current study aimed to identify patterns of the successful attacking phases
according to the type of ball possession recovery and match status (winning,
drawing or loosing) of winning teams participating in the EURO 2008.
This is a lag-log study, according to a follow-up, nomothetic and
multidimensional design, matching field formats with a system of categories. After
outlining the protocol and determining the observation reliability (Cohen’s
Kappa>0.88), seven matches (fourteen observations) of the EURO 2008 were
coded.
Using the Software for Visualization and Registration of the Offensive Phase in
Soccer (Barreira et al., 2010), 761 attacks, 10007 multievents and 38846 events
were recorded and analysed by the SDIS-GSEQ Software (Version 5.0.77,
October, 1, 2010, Bakeman & Quera, 1995). All the periods without full
observation, and exceeding the regular time, were excluded.
The goals scored, shots on target and wide shots (n=1.7%; n=4.4%; n=10.0%,
respectively) showed the tendency to occur from an indirect ball recovery. Corner
kicks induced a high probability (z=3.87) of causing wide shots, attesting that this
type of behaviour probably bring on a marked unbalance in the opponent
defensive dynamics. Unsuccessful attacks (ball out of the field or intervention of
the opponent goalkeeper) showed the tendency to occur after a defensive action
followed by pass, goal kick or free kick (z=2.77; z=3.67; z=4.36, respectively).
When loosing (n=103), the teams showed the tendency to improve ball possession
in mid offensive zones (z=2.00). When winning (n=108), teams frequently
performed defence/attack transition behaviours to get closer to the opponent goal.
While drawing (n=540), teams tended to vary the offensive methods to score a
goal. In all the contexts of match status considered, the central offensive zone
tended to be the most used to shoot.
Key-words:
Observational Methodology; Sequential Analysis; Soccer match analysis;
European Championship 2008
1 Introduction
Soccer matches have been mostly studied from a dichotomous perspective, related to attack
and defence game phases. As these two opposite circumstances occur simultaneously, they
involve the confrontation between order, organization and safety, while defending, and
disorder, creativity and risk, while attacking (Silva et al., 2005).
226
Actually, it is unanimous that the moments of changing ball possession involve behaviours,
which meaning to the match needs to be known. After ball recovery, and inversely after ball
lost—transition moments—both teams compete to get advantage in time and space,
developing individual and collective behaviours to improve their own organization levels,
and to decrease the opponent team’s balance. Although Romero Cerezo (2000) referred that
transitions are moments with no organization, including chaotic behaviours, Barreira and
Garganta (2007), and Barreira et al. (2010) observed that transitions could be trained to
improve the patterns of play and probably reduce the game uncertainly and improve this
attitude-changing efficacy.
In the current study, the Organization Model of the Soccer Game, proposed by Barreira and
Garganta in 2007 was used (Figure 1), to systematize the offensive and defensive phases of
the game, including the transitions. In this model, two types were proposed: interphase
transition, and state transition, depending on the way the ball is recovered, indirect or direct,
respectively.
Figure 1. Organization Model of the Soccer Game (Barreira & Garganta, 2007).
According to Hughes and Bartlett (2002), Soccer is a “goals game”. However, the variance of
the match score is not on a sufficient amount that allows identifying statistical determinants,
due to the low number of goals scoring in matches (Lago & Martín, 2006).
This means that it might be more difficult to discriminate the match play patterns
performed by winning teams when compared with defeated teams. Regarding the overall
statistics of the World Cups, the average of goals scored per game has been decreasing, e.g.,
from Uruguay 1930 to Germany 2006, there was a reduction of 1.66 goals per game in
average (3.89 to 2.23, respectively) (Castellano Paulis, 2009). Therefore, most studies
considered that score opportunities (shots) and time of ball possession are the main tactical
performance indicators to succeed in Soccer (Hughes & Bartlett, 2002).
Ball possession has been considered one of the most frequently used performance indicator
in Soccer (Garganta, 2000; Hughes & Bartlett, 2002; Hughes, 2003; McGarry & Franks,
2003). One of the forceful evidences is the correlation observed between the ability to
maintain the ball possession for long-standing periods of time and the success of attacking
sequences (Bate, 1988; Jones et al., 2004). In fact, Grant et al. (1999), and Hook and Hughes
(2001) reported that the most successful teams in both the World Cup 1998 and the Euro
2000 tended to maintain ball possession for longer periods than unsuccessful teams. Also, in
the English Premier League, Jones et al. (2004) observed that the duration of ball possession
was related to successful performance, while Bate (1988) added that the more ball
possessions a team had, the greater the chance of entering the attacking third of the field, and
227
consequently more goal-scoring opportunities were created. Griffiths (1999) studied the
winning team of the World Cup 1998—France—and found that the team was able to create
more shots on goal than the opponent teams, and had the ability to retain ball possession for
long periods. The author added that the French team attacked preferably through the wings,
creating significantly more crosses than their opponent teams. Barreira et al. (2010), also
investigating a specific team—Spain, the Euro 2008 champion—similarly observed that the
team preferred the utilization of crosses from the left to the central path of the offensive
sector, in contexts of numerical superiority, suggesting that in modern Soccer successful
teams tend to attack preferably from wings. However, other studies found that crosses did not
maintain positive relationship with finalization behaviours, as shot on goal (Hughes et al.,
1988; Silva et al., 2005).
The behaviours carried out by Soccer players during matches seem to be affected by
variables such as match location, match status and quality of the opposition (Taylor et al.,
2008). Some authors concluded that the final match score states only the team who won the
match, but no complementary indicators to assess the performance of one player or team can
be obtained (Hughes & Bartlett, 2002; Ensum et al., 2005). For instance, when considering
the match outcome as a win (e.g., a 1–0 win) for a team that scored a goal in the 85th minute,
no account would be taken of the fact that for 95% of the match the teams were drawing.
Therefore, the present study intended to state the influence of the match status (winning,
drawing, and loosing) on the attacking patterns of the most successful teams participating in
the Euro 2008. Accordingly, Taylor and Williams (2002) studied the World Cup 2002
winning team, and observed a relationship between the end of the offensive phase and the
type of ball possession recovery, suggesting that the ball possession recovery in the defensive
area resulted in more attempts on goal than for the other teams of the tournament.
Because Soccer game is a tactical wholeness, the offensive game-patterns evidenced by a
team are closely associated with defensive patterns, and vice-versa, behaving the
cooperation-opposition context, as the individual and collective constraints. Soccer game is
characterized by its successive alternation of states of order and disorder, stability and
instability, uniformity and variety (Garganta, 2001). However, it is also possible to observe,
even only by the intuition or empirical experiences, behaviours that occur with unambiguous
frequency and sequentially all over the match(es). Consequently, a model of analysis that
achieves the specific complexity of the Soccer game in natural contexts has been proposed
for match analysis—the Observational Methodology, in particular the Sequential Analysis—.
This method enables the inclusion of the temporal constraints of the Soccer game, with a
continuous analysis of the team(s), match event(s), and/or player(s), etc. More than a
quantification of actions, this model permits the qualification of the quantities, establishing
relations of the behaviours in the context they occur.
The present study focused on attacking phase—moments when teams had ball possession—
. Accordingly, the defence/attack transition-state was defined to start from the attack
scenarios preceded by a direct ball possession recovery, and to finish when the attacking
player took the ball out of the pressure zone, maintaining the context of interaction without
opponent pressure.
2 Method
2.1 Design
In the present investigation, eight teams were observed. In each match, two teams were
followed all over the match time, regarding their interdependence and interaction, with one of
228
the teams being particularly registered and analysed, consequently demonstrating
heterogeneous responses to the match events. Thus, this study was included in the quadrant
IV: a follow-up, nomothetic and multidimensional study (F/N/M) (Anguera, 2001). The
adoption of this F/N/M design led to a series of decisions being made regarding the type of
data, structure of the observation instrument, data quality control, and data analysis.
2.2 Sample
All the teams that reached the play-off of EURO 2008 were observed from the quarter- to the
final phase, and data were registered. Both teams were studied separately in each match,
amounting two observations per match, e.g., a total of 14 observations (761 offensive
sequences), with an average of 54 attacks per game, as shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Number of offensive sequences per match in the EURO 2008 play-off.
EURO 2008
play-off phase
Quarter final
Quarter final
Quarter final
Quarter final
Quarter final
Quarter final
Quarter final
Quarter final
Semi-final
Semi-final
Semi-final
Semi-final
Final
Final
Observation Unit /
Observed
Match
Team
1. Portugal vs. Germany
Portugal
2. Portugal vs. Germany
Germany
3. Holland vs. Russia
Russia
4. Holland vs. Russia
Holland
5. Spain vs. Italy
Italy
6. Spain vs. Italy
Spain
7. Croatia vs. Turkey
Turkey
8. Croatia vs. Turkey
Croatia
9. Russia vs. Spain
Russia
10. Russia vs. Spain
Spain
11. Germany vs. Turkey
Turkey
12. Germany vs. Turkey
Germany
13. Germany vs. Spain
Germany
14. Germany vs. Spain
Spain
Offensive Sequences: Total / Average
Final
Result
2-3
2-3
1-1
1-1
0-0
0-0
1-1
1-1
0-3
0-3
3-2
3-2
0-1
0-1
Number of offensive
sequences
40
40
49
54
47
82
41
50
49
76
56
46
62
69
761 / 54 per game
Matches—observation units—were observed and analysed in the regular time (90 minutes),
and excluded the offensive sequences without full observation. Additionally, the offensive
sequences were divided according to the evolving match status: winning, drawing, or loosing.
Therefore, while loosing, there were registered sequences in five matches, resulting in 108
attacks, 1411 multievents, and 5436 behaviours. While drawing, 550 attacks were distributed
for 14 matches, corresponding to 7614 multievents, and 29559 behaviours. While winning,
attacks were observed in five matches, corresponding to 103 attacks, 1267 multievents, and
4917 behaviours.
Reliability was assessed using the EURO 2008 final match, with the respective inter-observer
agreement. The first 30 minutes of the match Germany versus Spain were coded, with the
reliability evaluated by the function “compute Kappa” of the SDIS-GSEQ software (version
5.0.77, October, 1, 2010, Bakeman & Quera, 1995). Bakeman & Gottman (1989) preconized
that to have stability in the observations, Kappa value has to be superior to 0.75 in all the
instrument’s criteria. In this study, Kappa values recorded from 0.88 to 0.98, with the lowest
value (k=0.88) in criterion 6—Centre of the game—and the highest in criterion 1—Start of
the offensive phase— and criterion 4–Patterns of field space position— (k=0.97 and k=0.98;
respectively).
229
2.3 Instruments
2.31 Observation instrument
One basic requirement to use the Observational Methodology is to create an ad hoc
instrument (Hernández Mendo et al., 2000). In the present study, field formats were
combined with a system of categories simultaneously to answer a theoretical agreement and
to follow the study particularities (Anguera, 1991). The instrument had seven criteria and a
total of 80 behaviours, each of them represented by a different code:
1. Start of the offensive phase;
2. Development of defence/attack transition-state;
3. Progress of ball possession;
4. Finishing of the offensive phase;
5. Patterns of field space position (Garganta, 1997) (Figure 2.) (E/ME);
6. Centre of the game/Ball position (Barreira & Garganta, 2006) (E/ME);
7. Spatial patterns of teams’ interaction, including position of the players with the ball
and opponents (Castellano Paulis, 2000) (E/ME).
The first four criteria represented the behaviours, and the fifth was a structural criterion,
dividing the field in 12 zones/categories (Garganta, 1997; Figure 2). The sixth and seventh
criteria characterized the interactional contexts, regarding the relations of opposition and
cooperation between teams and players.
DS – Defensive Sector
DMS – Defensive Mid Sector
OMS – Offensive Mid Sector
OS – Offensive Sector
Figure 2. Patterns of field space position divided in twelve zones/categories (adapt. Garganta,
1997).
Criteria 5, 6, and 7 respected the conditions of exhaustiveness and mutual exclusivity
(E/ME). For the other criteria (1 to 4), it was possible to incorporate other categories to the
instrument to optimize the quality and the reliability of the observation process and final
product. Thus, all the behaviours that occurred in the match were possible to register,
although each behaviour corresponded only to one category and code (Table 2).
Table 2. Observation Instrument (Barreira et al., 2010)
230
2.32 Recording and Analysing instruments
The Software for Visualization and Registration of the Offensive Phase in Soccer (Barreira et
al., 2010) was created to reduce time spent in the observation process and errors when
compared with the hand notation system. Consequently, it could improve the study reliability.
Before registering the sequence, the observer categorized the match status, the competition
phase, and match time. Registration software followed the analysis software language—
SDIS-GSEQ software (Sequential Data Interchange Standard - Generalized Sequential
Querier; Version 5.0.77 , October, 1, 2010, Bakeman & Quera, 1995). Data were exported
to one Excel database, and then to the analysis software. The recording instrument included a
Coding Manual, which incorporates the definitions of the codes that governed its use.
Data were submitted to a descriptive and a sequential analysis. Sequential analysis
technique allows verifying the probability of significant associations (positive and negative)
between the different behaviours on the Soccer game. Thus, achieving the z value, it is
permitted to find out the strength of the relations between the behaviours and its sequentially.
3 Results and Discussion
231
3.1 Ball possession recovery
To analyse the associations between ball possession recovery and the end of the attack, a
retrospective analysis was used, which did not follow the conventional rules of Sacket (1979)
to find out the behaviours’ patterns max-lag. To increase the significance level of the results
and thus determine the associations between categories with 99% of certainty, values of
z≥2.58 or ≤-2.58, to p≤0.01 or p≥-0.01, respectively, were considered.
Wide shot game-patterns showed a positive relation with ball recovery by interception
(z=2.82) in lag -11. Wide shots were also verified after a ball recovery by corner kick (IIc) in
lag -10 (z=2.70; Figure 3) and in lag -2 (z=3.03). As illustrated in figure 4, an intervention by
the opponent goalkeeper occurred after a ball possession recovery by corner kick. Then, a
throw-in of the observed team in zone 10 was performed, succeeding a cross in the same
zone, with an intervention of an opponent player that originated another corner kick. This was
performed in zone 10, with the ball reaching the zone 11 in context of attacking line versus
the opponent’s rear line. There, a shot was made, and the final wide shot occurred after a
rebound, in context of no pressure in numerical equality in the centre of the game.
Figure 3. Attacking game-pattern resulting in a wide shot.
In the EURO 2008 play-off matches, the inside shot game-patterns showed a positive relation
with ball recovery by throw-in, foul and opponent interception. The regaining by interception
occurred immediately before the shot on goal in zone 8 or 11 (z=3.56 and z=2.59;
respectively), showing that once a team recovered the ball in central offensive zones, it might
have caused inside shots without scoring a goal.
A probability of goals being preceded by a throw-in was observed (z=2.58; Figure 4). After
this action, it was verified a ball progression (z=4.11) in the same lateral wing, from zone 7 to
10 (z=3.00), with a cross to the central offensive zone in interactional contexts of exterior
zone versus rear line (z=3.35). On the central offensive zone, it was created a situation of
attacker(s) against goalkeeper (z=6.67), which resulted in a shot with no goal scored. In the
rebound, the goal was scored in a relative numerical superiority and a situation of attacker(s)
against goalkeeper.
Figure 4. Goal game-pattern after a throw-in ball recovery (IILL).
232
Also, it was found the probability of goals being preceded by an indirect free kick on zone 10
(z=4.86) in lag -2. Then, this set piece was performed in two ways (Figure 5): (i) passing to
zone 10, followed by a cross (z=6.10); and (ii) pass to the central offensive zone, where a
shot with no goal was performed (z=4.50). In both situations, the attack ended with a goal on
zone 11 (z=6.19) in situations of attacker(s) against the opponent goalkeeper, with relative
numerical superiority (z=2.77).
Figure 5. Goal game-patterns succeeding an indirect free kick.
In the EURO 2008 play-off, a probability of a goal to occur in the central offensive zone (11),
in interactional contexts of relative numerical superiority (SPr), and in situations of
attacker(s) against goalkeeper (ADV) was observed.
Unsuccessful attacks (ball out of the field and intervention of the opponent goalkeeper)
showed the tendency to occur after a defensive action followed by pass (z=2.77), goal kick
and free kick (z=3.67 and z=4.38, respectively). It was observed that the end of the attack
caused by error of the player with the ball or the opponent intervention (exception for the
goalkeeper) (Fbad) was probably inhibited by ball recovery by the goalkeeper and throw-in
(z=2.70 and z=2.60; respectively).
There were found relations between the types of ball possession recovery and the zones
where it occurred (Figure 6). In the beginning of the offensive phase (lag 0), it was verified a
tendency of a direct ball possession recovery to be performed in the mid-defensive zones,
when compared with the defensive ones. Thus, it was observed a higher probability of a
direct ball recovery by tackle (z=2.94), and by defensive action followed by pass (z=3.00)
made in the central mid-defensive zone (5), while there were found inhibitory relations
between zone 2 and recovery by tackle (z=-4.58) and interception (z=-4.06). However, the
central defensive zone (2) was positively associated with the goalkeepers’ behaviours (IEgr,
z=13,70; IIpb: z=13,64). The lateral defensive zones tended to be associated with a ball
recovery by tackle (1: z=3.12), which can be explained by the higher frequency of 1x1
situations in the offensive lateral zones, respecting the binomial risk versus safety. Throw-ins
were performed homogeneously all over the lateral wings, though the more probability of
occurrence in zones 4 and 9 (z=4.68 and z=5.98; respectively).
233
Direction of the attack
Figure 6. Associations (positive in yellow; negative in red) between field zones and type of
ball possession recovery, regarding z values in the moment of ball recovery.
Consequently, teams probably assumed a defending strategy in which teams performed their
defending behaviours in the mid-defensive zones, in particular in the central zone (5),
opposing the defensive ones (2).
3.2 Match Status
When the teams were winning (n=103, observed in 5 matches), the tendency was to use
behaviours of defence/attack transition after recovering the ball in defensive and middefensive zones. Accordingly, wide shots (figure 7) tended to be preceded by a long pass
from mid-defensive zones to the left offensive one (10: z=2.62) in defence/attack transition.
An opponent performed unsuccessfully and the ball carrier dribbled one opponent, and
performed a positive cross to the central offensive zone (11: z=2.60), where the wide shot
was performed.
However, it was found an exception to the goal patterns (figure 8). Goals tended to be
preceded by an attack carried out with behaviours of development of ball possession in the
left lateral wing (4: z=2.62; 7: z=2.70). A cross (z=2.59) in zone 10 was performed, resulting
in an unsuccessful shot. In the rebound, the goal was scored in a situation of attacker(s)
against goalkeeper.
Figure 7. Wide shot pattern when teams
were winning.
Figure 8. Goal pattern when teams were
winning.
When loosing (n=108, observed in 5 matches), teams tended to use behaviours of
development of ball possession to get near to the opponent goal, except for the end of the
234
attack with goal. In contrary to those of the winning teams, the wide shot patterns of the
loosing teams (Figure 9) tended to be characterized by the use of development of ball
possession behaviours. Teams tended to use the central mid-offensive zones to reach the
opponent’s goal and, probably because of the numeral inferiority in these zones, the attack
ended with no success.
On the other hand, opposing to the goal patterns found in the moments when teams were
winning, the loosing moments were characterized by defence/attack transition behaviours.
There were found two patterns of scoring goals, both finishing in the central offensive zone
(11: z=3.15). The first pattern—illustrated with red arrows in figure 11—showed the
utilization of the left wing, and the goal was performed after a positive cross. The second
pattern—blue arrow in figure 10—presented the use of the central path, with the individual
behaviours (DTcd: z=4.86; DTd: z=4.93) being chosen to reach the opponent goal.
Figure 9. Wide shot pattern when
teams were losing.
Figure 10. Goal pattern when teams
were losing.
While drawing (n=550, observed in 14 matches), teams tended to vary the offensive method
to score a goal, performed positive crosses in transition state (z=5.33), and kept ball
possession (z=4.57) once the ball reached the left offensive zone (z=2.23).
In these contexts of match status (winning, loosing and drawing), the zone 11 tended to be
used to shoot (z=2.57; z=3.15; z=4.09, respectively).
Regarding the occupation of the field, the loosing teams tended to play mainly in zone 8
(z=4.67), and finished the majority of the attacks with a shot without goal scored. On the
other hand, the winning teams frequently used the offensive zones in the moments that
preceded the shot, getting advantage of the opponent’s lower defensive balance. The
tendency seemed to be that the team with a score disadvantage had a relative unbalance when
attacking, allowing the opponents to penetrate in the defensive zone with transition
behaviours. However, this study confirmed that the winning team tried not to allow the
loosing team to enter in the defensive zone, pushing their offensive players to midfield zones.
4 Conclusions
The attempts to shot (goal scored, inside and outside shot) seem to be related with indirect
ball possession recovery, in particular the free kick and throw-in. The direct recovery by
interception appears to be linked to short duration attacks. Unsuccessful attacks occurred
predominantly after a defensive action followed by pass, goal kick, or free kick.
It seems that the attacking patterns of successful teams participating in the EURO 2008
play-off were constrained by the match status. When defeated, the teams might become more
offensive, even neglecting the defensive organization; whereas when winning, the foremost
235
aim might consist in not allowing the opponents to get near the goal, and then using short
duration attacks to achieve the opponent defensive zones.
In the EURO 2008 play-off games, the teams tend to assume a defending strategy and tried
to perform their defending behaviours in the mid-defensive zones, in particular in the central
zone (5). This tendency was mainly observed when the teams were winning, by moving
defensive lines backwards, and by performing short duration attacks. Thus, teams tend to
increase the aggressiveness when the opponent players achieve the mid defensive zones,
trying to recover directly the ball to perform defence/attack transitions.
5 References
Anguera, M.T. (1991). Introducción. En M.T. Anguera (Ed.) Metodología observacional en
la investigación psicológica (pp. 25-28). Barcelona: P.P.U.
Anguera, M.T.; Blanco, A.; Losada, J.L. (2001). Diseños observacionales, cuestión clave en
el proceso de la metodología observacional. Metodología de las Ciencias del
Comportamiento, 3 (2), 135-160.
Bakeman, R.; Gottman, J.M. (1989). Observación de la interacción: Introducción al análisis
secuencial. Madrid: Ediciones Morata, S.A.
Bakeman, R.; Quera, V. (1995). Analyzing Interaction: Sequential Analysis with SDIS and
GSEQ. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Barreira, D.; Garganta, J. (2007). Padrão sequencial da transição defesa-ataque em jogos de
Futebol do Campeonato Português 2004/2005. Atas do 1º Congresso Internacional de
Jogos Desportivos: Olhares e Contextos da Performance. Da iniciação ao rendimento.
Porto: Centro de Estudos dos Jogos Desportivos, Faculdade de Desporto da
Universidade do Porto [em CD-ROM].
Barreira, D.; Ribeiro, R.; Garganta, J.; Anguera, M.T. (2010). Book of Abstracts of the IV
European Congress of Methodology: 27th Biennial Conference of the Society for
Multivariate Analysis in the Behavioural Sciences - EAM-SMABS 2010 -, Potsdam,
Germany.
Bate, R. (1988). Football chance: Tactics and strategy. In T. Reilly, A. Lees, K. Davids, & W.
Murphy (Eds.), Science and football (pp. 293–301). London: E. & F.N. Spon.
Castellano Paulis, J. (2009). Conocer el pasado del fútbol para cambiar su futuro.
Acciónmotriz, Revista Digital, 2, Enero/Junio. [em linha]
http://www.accionmotriz.com/.
Ensum, R.; Pollard, R.; Taylor, S. (2005). Applications of logistic regression to shots at goal
in association football. In T. Reilly, J. Cabri, & D. Araújo (Eds.), Science and football
IV (pp. 211–218). London: Routledge.
Garganta, J. (1997). Modelação táctica do jogo de Futebol. Estudo da organização da fase
ofensiva em equipas de alto rendimento. Dissertação de Doutoramento (não
publicada). Porto: FCDEF-UP.
Garganta, J. (2000) Análisis del juego del fútbol. El recorrido evolutivo de las concepciones,
métodos e instrumentos. Revista de Entrenamiento Deportivo, XIV, 2, 6–13.
Garganta, J. (2001). Futebol e Ciência. Ciência e Futebol. Lecturas Educación Física y
Deportes. Revista Digital, Ano 7, 40. [em linha] http://www.efdeportes.com/.
Grant, A.G.; Williams, A.M.; Reilly, T. (1999). Analysis of the goals scored in the 1998
World Cup. Journal of Sports Sciences 17, 826-827. Sport III. Ed: Hughes, M.D.
Cardiff, UK: UWIC. 155-162.
Griffiths, D.W. (1999) An analysis of France and their opponents at the 1998 Soccer World
Cup with specific reference to playing patterns. PhD thesis. University of Wales
236
Institute Cardiff.
Hernández Mendo, A.; López, J.; Villaseñor, A.; Anguera, M.T. (2000). La metodología
observacional en el deporte: conceptos básicos. Lecturas Educación Física y
Deportes. Revista Digital, Ano 5, 24. [em linha] http://www.efdeportes.com/.
Hook, C., Hughes, M.D. (2001). Patterns of play leading to shots in Euro 2000. In: Pass.com.
Ed: CPA. Cardiff: UWIC. 295-302.
Hughes, M.D. (2003). Notational analysis. In T. Reilly & M. Williams (Eds.), Science and
Soccer (pp. 245–264). London: Routledge.
Hughes, M.D.; Bartlett, R.M. (2002) The use of performance indicators in performance
analysis, Journal of Sports Sciences 20, 739-754.
Jones, P. ; James, N. ; Mellalieu, S.D. (2004). Possession as a Performance Indicator in
Soccer. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 4, 1, 98-102.
Lago, C.; Martin, R. (2006). Determinants of possession of the ball in Soccer. Journal of
Sports Sciences, 25, 9, 969-974.
McGarry, T.; Franks, I. (2003). The science of match analysis. In V (Eds.) Science and
Soccer (pp. 265 – 275). London: Routledge.
Romero Cerezo, C. (2000). Hacia una concepción más integral del entrenamiento en el
fútbol. Lecturas Educación Física y Deportes. Revista Digital, Ano 5, 19. [em linha]
http://www.efdeportes.com/.
Sackett, G.P. (1979). The lag sequential analysis of Contingency and Cyclicity in behavioural
interaction research. In J.D.: Osofsky (eds.), Handbook of infant development (pp.
623-649). New York: Wiley.
Silva, A.; Sánchez Bañuelos, F.; Garganta, J.; Anguera, M.T. (2005). Patrones de Juego en el
Fútbol de alto rendimiento. Análisis secuencial del proceso ofensivo en el
Campeonato del Mundo Corea-Japón 2002. Cultura, Ciencia e Deporte, 2 (1), 65-72.
Taylor, S.; Williams, M. (2002) A Quantitative analysis of Brazil’s performances. Insight 3,
28-30.
Taylor, J. B.; Mellalieu, S. D.; James, N.; Shearer, D. (2008). The influence of match
location, quality of opposition and match status on technical performance in
professional association football. Journal of Sports Sciences, 26, 885–895.
237
Attacking game-patterns in Soccer. A sequential analysis of the World Cup 2010 winner
team
J. Machado1, D. Barreira1,2 and J. Garganta1,2
1. Faculty of Sport, University of Porto, Portugal
2. Centre of Research, Education, Innovation and Intervention in Sport, Portugal
Abstract
The present study aimed to account tactical behaviours performed by Spain
national Soccer team during the World Cup 2010.
To set the observation and data gathering, field formats were combined with a
system of categories, according to seven criteria: Start of the offensive phase;
Development of defence/attack transition; Progress of ball possession; Finishing
of the offensive phase; Patterns of field space position; Centre of the game / Ball
position; Spatial patterns of teams interaction, including position of the players
with the ball and opponents.
After outlining the protocol and determining the observation reliability (Cohen’s
Kappa>0.90), four matches of the World Cup 2010 were coded (1/8 finals; ¼
finals; ½ finals and final - four observations). Using the Software for
Visualization and Registration of the Offensive Phase in Soccer (Barreira et al.,
2010), 42 positive attacks and 802 multievents were recorded and analysed using
the GSEQ Software, Version 5.0.77(Bakeman & Quera, 1995).
The goals scored were mainly preceded by behaviours in zones near the
opposite goal (left and central offensive), and elapsed from the development of
ball possession through a corner kick and defence/attack transition-state through
shooting. Successful finishing of the offensive phase—shot on target— tended to
be preceded by a context of interaction of absolute and relative pressure, both in
left mid-offensive zone. Wide shots tended to occur in central mid-offensive zone
in a context of numerical equality without pressure.
Key-words:
Sequential Analysis; Soccer match analysis; World Cup 2010; Spain national team
1 Introduction
Soccer can be characterized by the permanent relations of cooperation and opposition
between players and teams. Hedergott (1978), Teodorescu (1984) and Bayer (1987) suggest,
in soccer, two phases: the offensive and the defensive. If the team has the ball possession,
means that they are attacking, and if the team doesn’t have the ball, means that they are
defending, to Bayer (1994) that is the difference between those two phases.
This study focused on the offensive phase, stated by Teodorescu (1984) as the moment(s)
when a team has ball possession and tries to score a goal, without violating the laws of the
game. Lago and Anguera (2002) state that the attack is the most important phase in Soccer
game because it allows the team to be victorious in the matches and consequently in the
competitions.
The Organization Model of the Soccer Game, proposed by Barreira and Garganta in 2007
was used (Figure 1) to systematize the offensive and defensive phases of the game, including
238
the transitions. In this model, two types were suggested: Interphase transition, and State
transition, depending on the way the ball is recovered, indirect or direct, respectively.
Figure 1. Organization Model of the Soccer Game (Barreira & Garganta, 2007)
Castellano Paulis (2000) defined ball possession as the moment when a player/team
maintains the ball under control and has the possibility to develop or end the attack.
While attacking, team players may coordinate their behaviours to maintain their organization
levels and, simultaneously, to create unbalance in the opponent's defense. According to
Castelo (1996) one of the most complex problems in Soccer is to preserve the relations
between the players in relation to an organized level—teams global organization— what
depends on the way as the players develop their relations with their teammates.
The competitive level currently evidenced in Soccer has increased for players and teams.
One of the ways used to understand and scrutinize individual and collective performance in
Soccer is Match Analysis. The purpose of this study is to report the offensive tactical
behaviors performed by Spain national soccer team during the World Cup 2010, using the
Observational Methodology and, particularly, the Sequential Analysis technique.
2 Method
2.1 Design
In the present analysis, the World Cup 2010 winner team—Spain— was followed all over the
matches’ regular time. Tactical behaviours were registered and analysed, demonstrating
heterogeneous responses to match events. The current idiographic and multidimensional
study complies an intensive diachronic design (Anguera, 1997, 2001). The adoption of this
design leads to a series of decisions being taken according to the type of data, the structure of
the observation instrument, the data quality control and data analysis.
2.2 Sample
Four Spain matches were observed from the 1/8 finals to the final phase, and data were
registered. Positive attacks—ending with a shot— were registered from a total 42 positive
offensive sequences, as shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Number of Spain positive attacks per match in the Word Cup 2010 play-off.
239
WORLD CUP
2010 play-off
1/8 finals
¼ finals
½ final
Final
Observation Unit /
Match
Spain vs. Portugal
Spain vs. Paraguay
Germany vs. Spain
Netherlands vs. Spain
Final
Result
1x0
1x0
0x1
0x1
Number of positive
attacks
9
9
12
12
The sample sequences were observed and analysed in the regular time (90 minutes), and all
the situations without full observation were excluded.
Reliability was assessed through the observation of the WC 2010 final match, with the
respective intra-observer agreement. The first 30 minutes of the match Spain versus
Netherlands were coded two times by the same observer, with an interval of 15 days. The
function “compute Kappa” of the SDIS-GSEQ software, version 5.0.77 was used (Bakeman
& Quera, 1995).
Bakeman & Gottman (1989) stated that to have stability in the observations, Kappa value
has to be higher than 0.75 in all the instrument’s criteria. In the current study, Kappa values
recorded from 0.91 to 0.96, with the lowest value (k=0.91) in criterion 6—Centre of the
game—and the highest in criterion 1—Start of the offensive phase— and criterion 4–Patterns
of field space position—(k=0.95 and k=0.96; respectively).
2.3 Instruments:
2.31 Observation instrument
Field formats were combined with a system of categories in order to answer a theoretical
agreement and to follow the study particularities (Anguera, 1991).
The instrument combines field formats with a system of categories and includes seven criteria
and 80 behaviours, each of them represented by a different code:
8. Start of the offensive phase;
9. Development of defence/attack transition-state;
10. Progress of ball possession;
11. Finishing of the offensive phase;
12. Patterns of field space position (Garganta, 1997a) (Figure 2.) (E/ME);
13. Centre of the game/Ball position (Barreira & Garganta, 2007) (E/ME);
14. Spatial patterns of teams’ interaction, including position of the players with the ball
and opponents (Castellano Paulis, 2000) (E/ME).
The first four criteria represented the behaviours, and the fifth was a structural criterion,
dividing the field in 12 zones/categories (adapt. Garganta, 1997a; Figure 2). The sixth and
seventh criteria characterized the interactional contexts, regarding the relations of opposition
and cooperation between teams and players.
DS – Defensive Sector
DMS – Defensive Mid Sector
OMS – Offensive Mid Sector
OS – Offensive Sector
240
Figure 2. Patterns of field space position divided in twelve zones/categories (adapt. Garganta,
1997a).
Table 2. Observation Instrument (Barreira et al., 2010).
Criteria 5, 6, and 7 comply with the conditions of exhaustiveness and mutual exclusivity
(E/ME). For the other criteria (1 to 4), it was possible to incorporate further categories in the
instrument in order to optimize the quality and the reliability of the observation process and
the outcome. Therefore, match behaviours were registered each one corresponding to a single
category and code (Table 2).
2.3.2 Recording and Analysing instruments
The Software for Visualization and Registration of the Offensive Phase in Soccer (Barreira et
al., 2010) was created to reduce errors and the time spent in the observation process.
Registration software followed the analysis software language—SDIS-GSEQ software
(Sequential Data Interchange Standard - Generalized Sequential Querier; Version 5.0.77 ,
October, 1, 2010, Bakeman & Quera, 1995). Data were exported to an Excel database, and
241
subsequently to the analysis software. The recording instrument includes a Manual with the
code definitions.
Data were submitted to a descriptive and a sequential analysis. Sequential analysis
technique allows verifying the probability of significant associations (positive and negative)
between different behaviours of the Soccer game. After determining the z value, it was
feasible to identify the extent of the relations between the behaviours and its sequentiality.
3 Results and Discussion
In contrast with other team sports, e. g. Basketball and Handball, in Soccer only 1% of the
attacks per game in average ends with a goal (Dufour, 1993). According to Szwarc (2004)
and Lago-Peñas et al. (2010) winning teams in Soccer tend to have more effective attacks
than the opponents. Accordingly, attacks ending with goal scoring (Fgl), shot on target (Frd),
wide shot (Frf) and shot stopped by the opponent (Frad) were considered as successful
finishing of the offensive phase.
Wide shot was frequently performed in zone 8 (z=2.78), with numerical equality without
pressure in the centre of the game (SPi: z=2.88) (Figure 3), while the shot into the target
without goal—shot on target— (Figure 4) tended to be preceded by a numerical equality with
pressure (Pi: z=3.19). Also, shots on target rarely occurred in numerical equality without
constraints in the centre of the game (SPi: z=-2.20), concluding that shooting into the goal
was performed with constraints, opposing the wide shot game-patterns.
It was found an inhibitory relation between wide shots and the central offensive zone (11:
z=-2.74), showing in moments preceding wide shots behavior players were far from the goal
when compared with goal patterns.
Figure 3. Wide shot game-pattern
Figure 4. Inside shot game-pattern
Shot stopped by the opponent (Figure 5) was probably preceded by a player running with the
ball (z=3.41) in zone 7 (z=2.56), between the mid line of the observed team and the
opponent’s rear line (z=5.48). It was also verified interactional contexts of absolute
pressure—observed team has three or more players less than the opponent in the centre of the
game (z=2.80).
Figure 5. Shot stopped by the opponent game-patterns
It was observed the major exploitation of the left mid-offensive wing to reach upper offensive
zones. Thus, the players running with the ball moved the centre of the game from the left to
242
the central wing, whereas there was numerical inferiority probably inducing the shot stopped
by the opponent.
The conclusions of the work carried out by Castellano Paulis et al. (2008) were confirmed
in the present study. The decrease of number of goals scored since World Cup 1930 was
extended to the World Cup 2010 by Spain, the winner team, showing only four goals scored
in play-off games, winning all the matches by 1-0. We added that Spain’s goal against
Holland in the final match was not analyzed because Holland was playing with one player
less, being this sequence excluded.
According to Hughes and Franks (2005), 80% of goals scored in Soccer matches were
performed in short duration attacks, with players touching the ball in a maximum of four
times. Garganta et al. (1997b) found that 93% of the behaviours leading to a goal were
preceded by attacks with no more than three passes. This was confirmed by goal patterns
found on Spain, occurring predominantly after shooting in a development of defence/attack
transition (DTr: z=2.23) (Figure 6), in contexts of confrontation between attacker(s) and
opponent’s goalkeeper (ADV: z=3.81) or after corner kicks (DPc: z=2.23) (Figure 7).
Griffiths (1999) found similar results when analyzing France, world champion 1998, reaching
a high number of goals from corner kicks and crosses into the opponent’s area.
Fig. 6. Goal game-patterns after rebound. Fig. 7. Goal game-patterns after corner kick.
Hughes (1990) suggested a direct style of play in Soccer as the most productive method and
some researchers (Garganta et al., 1997b) state that a direct style of play can lead to a higher
goal-scoring percentage. However, team’s efficacy seems to depend mainly on their capacity
to change the rhythm of the game, to vary the attacking methods and to apply different styles
of play to surprise the opponent (Garganta, 1997a).
The goal pattern of Spain team (Figure 6) started with a dribble (z=3.31) in lag-5 in left
offensive zone (10: z=2.16), in a context of relative pressure—observed team has one or two
players less than the opponent in the centre of the game (Pr: z=2.07)— and with the
confrontation between the exterior zone of the observed team and the opponent’s rear line
(EAT: z=2.12). Then, predominantly by dribble or cross into the opponent’s central defensive
zone (11: z=2.76), a shot was performed (DTr: z=2.23) and the goal occurs mainly after a
rebound in situation of attacker(s) versus goalkeeper (z=3.81).
Goal game pattern after corner kick occurred in defence/attack transitions (Figure 7)
frequently started with an opponent’s unsuccessful intervention (z=3.31) in left offensive
zone (10: z=2.16) with relative pressure (Pr: z=2.07) and with the confrontation between
exterior zone of the observed team and the opponent’s rear line (EAT: z=2.17). The relative
pressure in the left offensive zone tends to lead to a corner kick (DPc: z=2.23), resulting in a
goal.
243
4 Conclusions
Attacks performed by the Spanish national team in 1/8 finals, quarter finals, ½ final and final
matches resulting in a goal were frequently preceded by individual behaviours (1x1 or
running with the ball) and crosses, in offensive zones (10 and 11). Offensive sequences
tended to start thought the lateral wings, progressing with the predominant use of individual
behaviours (1x1 or running with the ball) to achieve the opponent’s central defensive zone
and score the goal. Moreover, goal happened after corner kicks.
Shots made in mid-offensive zones tended to be less effective than shots in offensive
zones, probably because of numerical inferiority by the team who has the ball. When the ball
reaches the opponent’s defensive zone, the interactional context became favourable to the
attackers. Thus, the shots in zone 11 tend to reach the target.
5 References
Anguera, M.T. (1991). Introducción. En M.T. Anguera (Ed.) Metodología observacional en
la investigación psicológica (pp. 25-28). Barcelona: P.P.U.
Anguera, M.T. (1997). From prospective patterns in behavior to joint analysis with a
retrospective perspective. Methodologie d’analyse des interactions sociales. Paris:
Université de la Sorbonne.
Anguera, M.T.; Blanco, A.; Losada, J.L. (2001). Diseños observacionales, cuestión clave en
el proceso de la metodología observacional. Metodología de las Ciencias del
Comportamiento, 3 (2), 135-160.
Bakeman, R.; Gottman, J. M. (1989). Observación de la interacción: Introducción al análisis
secuencial. Ediciones Morata, S. A. Madrid.
Bakeman, R.; Quera, V. (1995). Analyzing Interaction: Sequential Analysis with SDIS and
GSEQ. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Barreira, D.; Garganta, J. (2007). Padrão sequencial da transição defesa-ataque em jogos de
Futebol do Campeonato Português 2004/2005. Actas do 1º Congresso Internacional de
Jogos Desportivos: Olhares e Contextos da Performance. Da iniciação ao rendimento.
Porto: Centro de Estudos dos Jogos Desportivos, Faculdade de Desporto da
Universidade do Porto [em CD-ROM].
Barreira, D.; Castelão, D.; Freitas, P.; Costa, I.; Brito, J.; Pinto, J.; Garganta, J. (2009).
Offensive playing methods of Spain Football national team during EURO 2008. Book
of Abstracts of the ISPAS Workshop 2009, Lincoln, UK.
Barreira, D.; Ribeiro, R.; Garganta, J.; Anguera, M.T. (2010). Book of Abstracts of the IV
European Congress of Methodology: 27th Biennial Conference of the Society for
Multivariate Analysis in the Behavioural Sciences - EAM-SMABS 2010 -, Potsdam,
Germany.
Bayer, C. (1987). La enseñanza de los juegos deportivos colectivos. Barcelona: HispanoEuropea.
Bayer, C. (1994). O ensino dos desportos colectivos. Lisboa: Dinalivro.
Castellano Paulis, J. (2000). Observación y análisis de la acción de juego en el fútbol. Tesis
Doctoral. Vitoria-Gasteiz. Universidad del País Vasco-Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea.
Castellano Paulis, J., Rodríguez, A. & Hernández Mendo, A. (2008). Análisis de la evolución
del fútbol a lo largo de los mundiales. Psicothema, 20 (4), 928-932.
Castelo, J. (1996). Futebol: A Organização do Jogo. Lisboa: Edição do Autor.
Dufour, W. (1993). Computer-Assisted Scouting in Soccer. In T. Reilly, J. Clarys & A.
Stibbe (eds.), Science and Football II (pp. 160-166). London: E. & F.N. Spon.
244
Garganta, J. (1997a). Modelação táctica do jogo de Futebol. Estudo da organização da fase
ofensiva em equipas de alto rendimento. Dissertação de Doutoramento (não
publicada). Porto: FCDEF-UP.
Garganta, J., Maia, J., & Basto, F. (1997b). Analysis of goal-scoring patterns in European top
level soccer teams. In T. Reilly, J. Bangsbo & M. Hughes (eds.), Science and Football
III. Proceedings of the Third World Congress of Science and Soccer (pp. 246-250). E &
FN Spon. London.
Griffiths, D.W. (1999). An analysis of France and their opponents at the 1998 soccer World
Cup with specific reference to playing patterns. PhD thesis. University of Wales
Institute Cardiff.
Hedergott, K. H. (1978). Fútbol: del aprendizaje a la competición, Buenos Aires: Kapelusz.
Hughes, C. (1990). The Winning Formula. Collins, London.
Hughes, M. & Franks, I. (2005). Analysis of passing sequences, shots and goals in soccer.
Journal of Sports Sciences 23(5): 509-514.
Júlio, L. & Araújo, D. (2005). Abordagem dinâmica da ação tática no jogo de futebol. In
Araújo, D. (2005). O contexto da decisão : A ação tática no desporto – pp. 159-177 Lisboa. Portugal.
Lago, C. y Anguera, M.T. (2002). Evaluación y análisis del rendimiento en el fútbol.
Aplicaciones de la metodología observacional. Metodología de las Ciencias del
Comportamiento, vol.especial, 327-330.Lago-Peñas, C., Lago-Ballesteros, J., Dellal, A.
& Gómez, M. (2010). "Game-related statistics that discriminated winning, drawing and
losing teams from the Spanish soccer league." Journal of Sports Science & Medicine,
9(2): 288-293.
Teodorescu, L. (1984). Problemas de teoria e metodologia nos jogos desportivos. Lisboa:
Livros Horizonte.
Sackett, G. P. (1987). Analysis of Sequential Social Interaction Data: Some Issues, Recent
Developments and a Causal Inference Model. In: J. D. Osofsky (ed.), Handbook of
Infant Development. Wiley, New York, pp. 855–878.
Szwarc, A. (2004) Effectiveness of Brazilian and German teams and the teams defeated by
them during the 17th Fifa World Cup. Kinesiolgy, 36(1), 83-89.
245
Performance analysis – the future
Mike Hughes*, Nic James*, Michael Hughes**, Goran Vuckovic*** and Henriette
Dancs****,
*London Institute of Sport, Middlesex University, UK.
**PGIR, Bath, UK.
*** University of Ljubljana, Slovenia.
**** University of West Hungary, Szombathely, Hungary.
Abstract
“Know your enemy as you know yourself and you need not fear one hundred
battles;
know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also
suffer a defeat;
know neither the enemy nor yourself and you will succumb in every battle.”
Sun Tzu, 652.
The demands and skills are defined by the different roles that the
Performance Analyst can take the role of: Consultant, Researcher or
Teacher. The most recent developments in hardware and software will be
explored and proposals for their application be made, for example, see
Figure 1.
Future of Performance Analysis
Live Data
Recording
SportsCode®
Object
Occasional immediate
post match feedback
Motivational
Video
Feedback
Post
Match
Analysis
Statistics
And Video
Detailed
Analysis by
Coaches
Players
Pre-match
Briefing
Stream Video
Sequences
Internet,
SportsPlan
and email
Squad
Training
Pre-training
Discussion
Communication
About video
clips
Figure 1. Example of applied analyses and feedback using computerized
analyses (Mayes, O’Donoghue, Garland & Davidson, 2009).
Hughes (2004) suggested that the main skill required by consultant
Performance Analysts are:
Performance Indicators,
Reliability,
Discriminate between PI’s,
246
Empirical Profiling,
Comparing data, and
Modelling and Prediction.
The current advances in research will be reviewed in these areas and
suggestions for future work discussed.
1 Introduction
Vision is perhaps our greatest strength.. it has kept us alive to the power
and continuity of thought through the centuries; it makes us peer into the
future and lends shape to the unknown.- Li Ka Shing .
Performance
Analyst
Teaching
Research
Consultancy
Figure 2. The roles and careers of a performance analyst.
The possible roles for a performance analyst are shown in Figure 2. The role of the consultant
is driven by the demands of the coach, and the hardware and software available to the analyst.
Current developments in hardware and software will be reviewed, but, as always, these
reviews will be out of date before this paper is in press. The important message is that
whatever the technology available, good analysis depends upon the skill and experience of
the analyst and their communication skills in getting the messages across to the coaches and
players.
Research informs the teaching process, and ultimately, drives the consultancy work. But not
always, there are examples of analysts working in the field extending and developing
techniques beyond those of the researchers. The latter are usually at the disadvantage of more
limited resources.
Recent research has reformed our ideas on reliability, performance indicators and
performance profiling in notational analysis – also statistical processes have come under
close scrutiny, and have generally been found wanting. These are areas that will continue to
develop to the good of the discipline and the confidence of the sports scientist, coach and
247
athlete. If we consider the role of a notational analyst (Fig. 1) in its general sense in relation
to the data that the analyst is collecting, processing and analysing, then there a number of
mathematical skills that will be required to facilitate the steps in the processes:1. defining performance indicators,
2. determining which are important,
3. establishing the reliability of the data collected,
4. ensuring that enough data have been collected to define stable performance profiles,
5. comparing sets of data,
6. modelling performances.
The recent advances made into the research and application of the mathematical and
statistical techniques commonly used and required for these processes will be discussed and
evaluated in this paper.
2 Academic and research
Figure 3. Linear relationships in data gathering and feedback
When I first started working in sports science, the relationship between the scientist, the
research data and the consultancy data was linear. Research data were often used to prescribe
to the coach the training, tactical and technical strategies to be used with their athletes. As
performance analysts became more experienced and more skilful, and often an integral part
of the coaching and feedback processes with coaches and athletes, they tended to develop
systems that were capable of providing in-event and post-event analyses of performance for
the coach and the athlete. This also coincided with the introduction and development of
computerised data gathering systems, the analogue nature of which inhibited, in some ways,
the data analysis and presentation to the clients, it did aid the process in other ways.
Figure 4 presents a schematic of how analysts worked in the mid-80’s through to the late
90’s. Feedback loops from the coach/athlete teams to the separate analysts, when they
existed, were separate – the sports science support teams of these times rarely talked to each
other. The analysts in their separate disciplines collected the data, invariably they did all the
videotaping themselves. The analogue VHS video cameras were unwieldy and bulky, so they
were not generally used as leisure tools – so even operating video cameras was not a common
248
skill amongst coaches and athletes in the late eighties/early nineties. Analysing the video,
with either commercial software (there was not a lot) or specifically designed systems,
precluded the coach and athletes. Processing the data and presenting them in forms that the
coach and athletes could understand was another problem area – it was only in the late
eighties that PC’s began to include colour screens and graphic capabilities. Commercial
graphics packages arrived in the early 90’s. The analyses of the data were yet another
interface between the performers, the coaches and the analysis of performance. No matter
how educated and enlightened the coach, the interpretation of these outputs (and the
performance) was in the hands of the respective analysts. So, consciously or unconsciously,
the analyst acted as a ‘filter’ on the interpretation of the data twice – many analysts attempted
to involve the coaching teams in the design of these filter systems, but this was not always
possible.
Figure 4. The role of the performance analyst using early analogue video and computer
systems to gather and process performance data for the coach.
249
Figure 5. A digital systems approach to the data sharing that the interactive commercial
systems have enabled for performance analysts working with coaches and athletes (from
Hughes, 2004).
Notational analysis has changed radically with the introduction of digital technology.
Coincidental with this new technology was the availability of the first commercial data
gathering systems, and much more user-friendly computerised video-editing systems. The
introduction of digital video cameras not only enhanced the quality of the recordings and the
access to instant recall of any part of a performance (when accessed from digital storage not
tape), but they immediately invaded the leisure market. In a couple of years everybody could
operate video cameras. In recent years, computerised interactive analysis software, available
commercially, improved step by step. These systems have become more and more easy to use
and a lot of the mystery has been removed from producing edited videotapes of a
performance. This means that coaches and athletes are now becoming more and more
comfortable with handling the hardware and the software and can then take a more informed
position in the partnership of the performance analysis team. This means the ‘data mining’
process can be one in which the whole team can be involved, it no longer means that the
analyst is the only one understanding the process and the output. Inevitably the analyst will
do the major part of the work, but performance data are best gathered and analysed as a
product from a performance team – a combination of analysts from different disciplines,
coaches and athletes, sharing as much information as they can (Fig. 5.). Digital technology
makes this process so much easier now as the process becomes easier for all to assimilate.
The software houses have not yet grasped the nettle of providing generic quantitative data
analysis systems, in any depth or sophistication, integrated with their data gathering, but that
cannot be far off. The data made available from these systems can then be easily interpreted.
Therein lies a host of dangers for the coaches and athletes.
3 Consultancy
250
The working practise of notational analysts embraces most sports utilising a spectrum of
software packages, together with the occasional application of a hand notation system. All
systems of data collection, such as Focus or Sportscode, are carefully tested for reliability
using clearly defined operational definitions, and statistical techniques applied to ensure that
enough data has been collected to define stable profiles of performance. These will be used
by coaches with their own players, to explore their strengths and weaknesses in technique,
tactics and movement. Edited videotapes will then highlight the work that will need to be
done to eradicate weaknesses and maintain their strengths. The same methods of analyses
will be used on possible opponents, to examine best tactical strategies to employ against
them. Movement analyses can explore fitness levels and/or movement technique,
fundamental to success in many match play sports. Qualitative biomechanical analysis
systems, such as Silicon Coach, Quintic and Dartfish, can be used in conjunction with the
coach to explore technical problems, using still frame or slow motion analyses. Some
analysts are finding high speed video cameras (400 fps) particularly rewarding, in this way,
with racket sports coaches and players. Analysts spend half their time now editing videotapes
for feedback, feed forward purposes for players and teams, motivation tapes, education tapes
and coach analysis tapes. So in that way, their modus operandi has undergone a huge change
over the last ten years. These new systems do aid that process immensely. There are now
generic tracking and action analysing systems that can yield an immense amount of data of a
whole team performance. Prozone is one commercial example of this (used by England RU,
and a number of Premier Division Clubs in England). These are expensive in terms of capital
outlay for the equipment and software, but they do yield huge databases of information,
which in turn will demand expensive amounts of time to analyse them appropriately.
Figures 6a and 6b. Examples of recent developments in ‘Autotracking’ by Quintic.
Figures 7a, 7b and 7c. Examples of recent developments in ‘Timewarp’ by SiliconCoach.
251
Voice recognition technology with Focus X2 has been empirically shown to be accurate
and reliable for the live and post match coding of football at championship level (Court,
2007). Taylor and Hughes (1988), in an early piece of research, suggested voice activated
coding will be a natural extension for any current computing hardware system, and
expected that the use of voice activated coding with sport analysis systems would be the
next big step forward for the sport science community. Surprisingly the improvements in
the hardware and software have been slow. Elite Sports Analysis have recently brought
out Focus X2 (Figures 8a and 8b), with voice interactive software, the testing of which is
presented in this volume (Hughes et al., 2011)
Figures 8a and 8b. Examples of recent developments in voice interactive software by Elite
Sports Analysis.
Figure 9. Performance Analysis driving a video-based Knowledge Management with the
Dartfish software packages.
Dartfish, as well as all the other software companies, has added different tools enabling the
Performance Analyst to manage the knowledge of their organizations: online web platform
directly linked to the traditional software applications; very easy quantitative data integration
on video, and ‘easytag’ PDA application.
ProZone are concentrating on
252
Real-time - greater emphasis on instant access and objective intervention during
matches, allowing coaches to make informed decisions immediately
Online access – as coaches and managers become more familiar with web
applications. E.g. ProZone Dashboard, which is ProZone’s first online application
giving users online access to performance information from anywhere in the world!
Increased usage of performance analysis in the media and amongst the consumers
(the fan); e.g. ‘real-time’ data access and gaming interactions. These opportunities
also pose a threat to the performance analysis industry in terms of the accuracy,
reliability and depth of information being broadcast via these portals.
Various GPS Units
Movement analysis, particularly in-event, has progressed rapidly in individual and team
sports through the use of GPS units. Hughes (PGIR) has been very innovative in pioneering
their application with the GB Cycling team in their build-up to, and during, the Beijing
Olympics, when working with the EIS. He is now using these with England Rugby, and they
are in use throughout the soccer Premiership.
1.
2
2
GPS Sports
5Hz (Claims 15Hz on the way)
(Team Sports, cycling)
Catapult
5Hz
(Team Sports, including Everton!)
Garmin
5Hz
(Cycling, outdoor recreation)
The 1st two are the main 2 competitors for team sports and have the lions share of the market
and are used extensively in Aussie rules and Rugby League for the last 5 years in matches as
well as training (in Rugby Union this year). Garmin produces more for individual sports and
for cars, has some very nice online facilities for tracking your rides and runs and producing
reports.
253
Figures 10a, 10b, 10c and 10d. Exemplifying the application of GPS units in tracking cyclists
in race (10a); videoing the road race course (10b) while monitoring the altitude and heart
rates (10c) and replicating these conditions back in the training laboratories in Manchester
(10d).
From a team sports perspective GPS Sports and Catapult offer very little differences
Both provide 5Hz monitoring, a similar level of accuracy, coverage of satellites and size and
weight. Both suffer from the same problems though, fairly lengthy downloads times for
multiple units. But, very badly designed software for producing reports of training sessions,
no database management facility to build up profiles of athletes over time, faulty
synchronizing of the data with video and poor support due to their offices being based in
Australia, are all disadvantages of these units.
Figure 11. The Apple ‘iPad’.
Another technological innovation that is proving very popular is the ‘iPad’, particularly with
players and athletes as a way of sending and watching edited videos. The iPad has an
excellent mix between portability and an easily viewed screen, and with great resolution and
clarity, it means it is ideally suited for video feedback during training or matches. In addition
it has wireless facilities to receive video and data and can be connected directly to a projector
for presentations. On the other hand it has no USB ports for transferring information, so you
have to use ‘iTunes’ software or other applications, and it has limited memory size of 64Gb
means it soon fills up if using a lot of video. It is thought that the second or third generation
of these appliances will be far better.
254
4 Research
It has been suggested that the processes necessary for a Notational Analyst working either as
a consultant or an academic researcher are as follows (Hughes, 2004) :1. defining performance indicators,
2. determining which are important,
3. establishing the reliability of the data collected,
4. ensuring that enough data have been collected to define stable performance profiles
(performance profiling),
5. comparing sets of data,
6. modelling performances.
It was concluded that recent research has demonstrated: clear methods for determining which performance indicators are relevant and which
are more important,
simple absolute measures of reliability need to be used together with accepted nonparametric measures of variance,
that if performance profiles of teams or individual athletes are being applied, then
some measures of confidence in the stability of these profiles need to expressed,
the comparison of sets of data in notational analysis needs to be considered carefully,
as the data are usually non-parametric and conform most likely to Poisson and
Binomial distributions. The use of x2 seems to be a simple answer, however, as soon
as more complex models and higher-order comparisons are required, the approach
based on log-linear models is shown to be more effective,
the sensitivity of these x2 and log-linear models to the small differences in
performance, that differentiate between winning and losing at the elite level, is open
to question,
that there are many techniques used to model sport, some of these are providing the
greatest challenges to notational analysts and mathematicians alike.
It is clear that the working notational analyst must have a broad set of mathematical and
statistical skills and be prepared to maintain and extend those skills just as the research in this
area develops the knowledge base. Further research is urgently needed in some of these
areas: How do we define performance indicators in a general and generic sense? At the
moment they are arbitrarily defined for each sport depending upon the subjective
opinions of the analyst and/or coach.
The statistical methods that we use are improving, but more work needs to be done on
making the more sophisticated systems more transparent, in terms of how they relate
to the experimental aims of the comparisons, and also the basic practical demand of
them being easier to apply.
255
The sensitivity of the tests needs to be examined – how can we determine the
significant differences in performance when the increments of comparison are very
small?
More research in modelling in performance analysis is vital as we extend our
knowledge and databases into those exciting areas of prediction.
Using the word prediction in the same phrase as sport almost certainly creates a form of an
oxymoron, because of the inherent nature of sport. Nevertheless, working towards the
extended aims of modelling, and therefore forecasting, must be the most exciting of the ways
to further develop performance analysis.
5 References
Court, M. (2007). Voice recognition software for soccer analysis. In Dancs, H., Hughes, M.
and O’Donoghue, P. (eds) Notational Analysis of Sport - VII , Cardiff : UWIC, p. 87.
Hughes, M.D. (2004). Performance Analysis – a mathematical perspective. EIJPAS,
International Journal of Performance Analysis Sport (Electronic), 4, 2, 97 - 139.
Hughes, M. and Bartlett, R.(2002). The use of performance indicators in performance
analysis. Journal of Sports Science, 20, 739 – 754.
Hughes, M., Evans, S. and Wells, J. (2001). Establishing normative profiles in performance
analysis. eIJPAS, 1, http://ramiro.catchword.com/vl=68509314 – 27.
Mayes, O’Donoghue, Garland & Davidson, (2009).
Taylor, S. & Hughes, M.D. (1988) Computerised notational analysis: a voice interact8ve
system. Journal of Sports Sciencess. 6, 255.
256
Analysis of physical demands of ballroom dancers in tango and quickstep using the
tracking system SAGIT.
P. Zaletel*, G. Vučkovič*, N. James**, A. Rebula* and M. Zagorc*
* University of Ljubljana, Faculty of sport, Slovenia
** University of Middlesex, UK
Abstract
The tracking system SAGIT was used to study the physical demands placed
on a sample of six qualitatively different ballroom (BR) dance couples (3
higher (PRO) and 3 lower (JUN)-quality) in the tango and quickstep.
All the couples danced two BR dances at the same time (tango and
quickstep). Dancers were recorded directly to DVD with one camera at a
frequency of 25 frames per second. Recordings were analyzed using the
SAGIT tracking system to determine the distance covered and the average
speed of movement of the dancers.
Comparison of PRO and JUN couple’s trajectories showed that the
younger and less experienced dancers were still using the basic
choreographic form through the circle while the top dance couples were
looking for a way in the inner space of the dance floor, not just on the
outside edge of a dance circle.
The results show that the dynamics of movement decreases as the quality of
the dancing couple decreases PRO couples covered longer distances on
average (about 30m) and their average movement speed was also
approximately 0.3 m/s higher. This increase in speed was not at the cost of
the movement characteristics. Consequently this finding confirms the
commonly held belief that softness and speed are key for success in BR
dance choreography and technique.
1 Introduction
Sport dancing in Slovenia has a long-standing tradition, as well as many great international
successes in sport dancing competitions. Bigger national and international competitions
demand more precision, systematic and professional work from young dancers and a more
holistic, interdisciplinary approach to improve performance in this sport. Kinesiological
science thus intertwines with other sciences and theirs methods that research the possibilities
of improving sport results.
Sport dance is still a »young« sport discipline, which started to develop around 1920.
It is a monostructure, complex, conventional sport discipline which emphasises energy and
information components on the one hand and aesthetics of movement on the other. Sport
dancers are very expressive in their dance, often undertaking aesthetic movements (Zaletel,
Tušak, Tušak, & Zagorc, 2005). Of course, dancers have to be physically well prepared to
achieve the status of a top dancer and to execute moves beautifully, achieve harmony in
movement, precision, synchronisation with music etc. Artistic or, even better, aesthetic
preparation is one step above physical preparation yet all three are merging together.
Dance in its superb form combines virtuosic mastery of the body in a certain rhythm
and the simultaneous compliance with her/his partner (Zagorc, 2000).
257
Dance is an art that has developed in space and in time (Da Silva in Bonorino, 2008),
expressing sensibility through the physical movement, in a harmonious way or not, according
to the interpretation and the aesthetics of expression (Dantas, 1999). It is a sequence of
gestures, steps and physical movements with musical rhythm that expresses affectionate
states (Catarino, 2002) and, as closer to the perfection the dance becomes, less we distinguish
its elements (effort, gravity, body, muscular strength, objects, sound) (Zucolloto in Freire,
2003).
Sports dance consists of five ballroom (BR) and five Latin American dances (LA).
Dance couples can compete in a combination of ten dances or in each group separately.
Choreography for competitors take place over a relatively long time of 1min 40sec.
BR dances (English waltz, tango, Viennese waltz, slow foxtrot and quickstep) have
been developed in Europe, where the English created a distinctive natural and easy style. BR
dances have more subdued character and they use closed dance position. The dance partners
are in constant contact with each other while dancing around a virtual circle around the room,
in an anti-clockwise direction. Movement in BR dances is current, still fast, emphatic periods
in music (at the beginning of each cycle) are followed by extended and emphasized steps,
which seems to be the ability of dancers for a correct interpretation of the characteristics of
movement in a particular dance.
Time and space are two essential parameters of a dancer’s expressiveness (MinvielleMoncla, Audiffren, Macar and Vallet, 2008). Accuracy in timing motor activities is a major
asset in choreographic production both with and without a partner. Dancers often adapt their
movement timing to the accompanying music and to their partner’s motion and
displacements. Speed of executed steps, movement structures and dance figures is extremely
important for success in dance.
In order to achieve excellence in sport dance there are various tests, which give some
relevant information to dancers, trainers and researchers, so that further improvements can be
made in future training. So far, we have carried out several studies of connection and
dependence of different dimensions of psychosomatic status of dancers and the
environmental impact on their success: a study of morphological and motor skills of sport
dancers, the study of the psychological dimensions of sport dancers in comparison with other
top athletes (personality, motivation, values, self-concept, interpersonal skills) (Zagorc and
Zaletel, 1996; Zaletel, Zagorc and Tušak, 2004; Zaletel, Tušak and Zagorc, 2007).
In addition to the aesthetic movement and morphological characteristics (Da Silva and
Bonorino, 2008, Claessens, Nuyts, Lefevre and Wellens, 1987), for sport dancers there are
many other important skills and characteristics (Brown, Martinez, and Pearsons, 2006;
Zagorc, 2000 ). For example, studies show a high physiological load for sport dancers (Jaray
and Wanner, 1984, Hollmann and Hettinger, 1990; Zagorc, Karpljuk and Friedl, 1999;
Zagorc and Kanduč, 2009).
The study of physical demands in complex sports is important in terms of appropriate
physical, technical and tactical preparation. Therefore, the scientific literature is offering
many studies whose primary purpose was to examine the physical effort of athletes in soccer
(Bangsbo, Mohr and Krustrup, 2006), basketball (Ben Abdelkrim, El phase and El Ata,
2007), rugby (Deutch, Kearney and Rehrer, 2007), handball (Sibila, Vuleta and Pori, 2005),
volleyball (Mauthner, Koch, Tilp and Bischof, 2007) and squash (Hughes, Franks and
Nagelkerke, 1989). Despite the remarkable popularity of dance, the research literature is
deficient in the area of investigation of the dancer’s movement through the space and the
range and speed of movement in two-dimensional space. In the present study we examined
the workloads of qualitatively different dance couples in selected BR dances. We also wanted
to determine the possible differences in distance covered and speed of movement between
dancers of different quality.
258
2 Methods
2.1 Subjects
The group sample consisted of 6 BR dance couples (6 females, 6 males), who differed in
quality of their dance. There were 3 competitive dance couples, who dance professionally and
are training every day (PRO), and 3 junior couples, who have potential to be very succesful,
but their quality is lower (JUN).
Participants were 16 to 24 years old (PRO couples: M=23.8; SD=2.2; JUN couples
M=16.5; SD=3.4). In 2010 all the top-level athletes were members of respective (junior
and/or senior) national teams; some of them are also World Champions.
All the couples danced tango and quickstep at the same time.
2.2 Equipment
The study took place in the sports hall in Ljubljana. Dancers were recorded directly to DVD
with one camera (Ultrak KC CCD Color CP 7501, Japan) at a frequency of 25 frames per
second. The camera was secured on the ceiling of the hall which enabled the recording of a
rectangular projection on the dance area. By using a wide-angle lens (Ultrak KL2814IS,
Japan) the entire dance area was in view.
2.3 Processing the data
The footage was later transferred to a PC and analyzed with the SAGIT tracking system,
which is a human tracking measurement system based on computer vision technology (Perš,
Bon, Kovačič, Šibila and Dežman, 2002). This software provides the methods and algorithms
that serve to obtain useful information from the digital images. The system was successfully
used on several occasions to study the physical demands of athletes in handball (Bon, 2001),
basketball (Erčulj, Vučković, Perš, Perše and Kristan, 2007), squash (Vučković, Perš, James
and Hughes, 2010) and tennis (Filipčič, 2008).
The aim of present study was to analyze distance covered and the average speed of a
dancer’s movement in the selected BR dances.
3 Results
Motion trajectory of JUN couples in quickstep showed a wide movement around the space in
the direction of the circle, this was not found for PRO couples. Their path, in addition to
dancing on the outer edge of the circle, involved continuing within the interior of the dance
floor (Figure 1).
Tango is a specialty of BR dances and contains quite a few differences: posture is more
firm, there are no rises and descents like in other BR dances, foot technique is more
pronounced and complex. Trajectory of movement in tango shows that the tango is typically
characterized by a circular movement, but more rhythmically sharp, cut off. Figure 3 and 4
also show the sharp corners when changing directions, which are also characteristic of the
tango.
259
Table 1. Details of the distance covered and speed of movement of PRO and JUN couples in
quickstep and tango.
JUN1
JUN2
JUN3
AVERAGE
JUN
PRO1
PRO2
PRO3
AVERAGE
PRO
1.3
1.45
1.31
1.35
1.53
1.62
1.64
1.60
quickstep speed
(m/s)
quickstep distance
(m)
tango speed (m/s)
112
124
112
116
139
148
149
145.33
0.82
0.84
0.8
0.82
1.18
1.07
1.11
1.12
tango distance (m)
76
78
75
76,33
115
104
109
109.33
Legend: JUN - junior dance couples of lower quality and PRO - top level dancers, the highest quality dance couples
Figure 1. Paths of three PRO dance couples in quickstep.
260
Figure 2. Paths of three JUN dance couples in quickstep.
Figure 3. Paths of three PRO dance couples in tango.
261
Figure 4. Paths of three JUN dance couples in tango.
Comparison of PRO and JUN couple’s trajectories showed that the younger and less
experienced categories were still using the basic choreographic form through the circle, while
the top dance couples were looking for a way inside the dance floor.
The results show that the dynamics of movement decreases by the quality of the dancing
couple. PRO couples covered on average about 30m longer distance and also their average
movement speed was 0.3 m/s higher.
4 Discussion
The movement of BR dance couples has its meaning in the space - to create an image of
softness, rhythm, travel, power, passion, game. By changing the speed of movement dancers
are trying to create the illusion of lightness, aesthetic perfection, both for the viewer as well
as for an empire.
A pilot study analysing the workloads of dance couples during selected BR and LatinAmerican dances using the SAGIT tracking system (Zaletel, Vučković, Rebula and Zagorc,
2010) discovered that both female and male dancer had almost identical movement
trajectories and also speed trends were very similar. BR dancers dance in a closed position so
dance partners are traveling together on the same path and can be considered as one object.
Also, their speeds are the same as they must operate as one, move through the space easily,
giving the impression of controlled movement. Technical requirements dictate holding the
correct body positions in various motor actions, which in BR dances include the proper foot
technique, lifts, drops, swings, body rotations in all directions, performed at the rhythmic
musical accompaniment.
262
In quickstep, path of PRO dance couple is focused on every corner of dance space, where
the couple does not delay too long, but continues in a diagonal across the dance floor. This
way the dancers can string together a series of typical quickstep figures and show precise
control of theirs foot technique. PRO dancers, so much more so than JUN colleges, present
effortless movement actions and rhythmic contrast, sudden stops, sudden changes of direction
and fast movements in complex structures that are specific to the quickstep.
Because of the speed of dance there is a danger that the dance couples collide with each
other so it is wise to choose space in the interior dance floor as found for the PRO dancers
(see Figure 1). They thus have a better view of the dance floor and have enough time to avoid
unpleasant situations. A similar situation was found for the tango (Figure 3).
The emphasis in tango is on speed and sharpness on the one hand and the softness and
reticence on the other side. Circular movement in tango is rhythmically sharp and cut off so
that the dancer can achieve a certain edge when moving through the dance floor.
PRO couples are looking for a way inside the dance floor, therefore they’re using more
space to perform the complex dance figures and avoid the crowd on the outskirts of the dance
circle since in competitions more than one dance couple is on the floor at the same time.
Collisions of dance couples especially in high speed quickstep are therefore inevitable.
Dance is multi-directional and involves the use and coordination of different muscle groups
at varying times. Increased movement dynamics call for greater control and coordination of
the torso muscles of dance partners, which have been shown in previous studies (Zaletel,
Tušak and Zagorc, 2006).
Dance of JUN couples therefore appears to be more monotonous compared to PRO couples
as they do not explore the dance floor as a whole. This might be described as less
choreographed in terms of use of space and thus explains the less distance being covered by
JUN dancers. Qualitatively better couples also move faster than their younger colleges, but
increase in speed was not at the cost of the movement characteristics.
5 Conclusions
Excellence of BR dance couple is that they seem to be one - as a whole, and move through
the dance floor in accordance with character of specific dance. In the last decade, BR dances
promoted to the complexity of choreography and performance of individual elements. Each
dance bears different content, wants to communicate to viewers, empires, not least to dance
partner. The choreography combines character of each dance with music, dancer’s expression
only amplifies the story. However, the top control of the body in various dance figures is the
key of the best dancers, what is certainly visually (by dancing judges) influenced by speed of
the movement.
It turns out that a tracking system SAGIT shows satisfactory path and speed of the
dancers and gives us numerous parameters about their workload during the dance. However,
in future research it would be beneficial to analyze individual dance elements and fine
movements with hands, head, etc. Consequently a notational module of the SAGIT tracking
system should be applied (Vučković, Dežman and Pers, 2006). Thus, it will be possible to
determine not only the frequency of occurrence of these elements, but also their sequence. It
would also be interesting to find out what is the dynamics of the female and male dancer
whilst implementing aesthetically perfect figures of each dance. Although some dance actions
are often occurring on the site, they still represent a significant portion of the final assessment
of the dancer’s performance.
263
6 References
Abdelkrim, B.N., El Fazaa S., & El Ati J. (2007). Time-motion analysis and physiological
data of elite under-19-year-old basketball players during competition. British Journal
of Sports Medicine, 41, 69-75.
Bangsbo, J., Mohr. M., & Krustrup, P. (2006). Physical and metabolic demands of training
and match-play in the elite football player. Journal of Sports Sciences, 24 (7), 665674.
Bon, M. (2001). Kvantificirano vrednotenje obremenitev in spremljanje frekvence srca
igralcev rokometa med tekmo [Quantified evaluation of effort and monitoring heart
rate of male players during a team handball match]. Doctoral dissertation. Ljubljana:
Faculty of Sport.
Brown, S., Martinez, M.J., & Pearsons, L.M. (2006). The neural basis of human dance. Life
sciences & medicine, Cerebral Cortex. 16(8), 1157-67.
Catarino, M. (2002). Historia da danca, http://gape.ist.utl.pt , accessed October 11th, 2010.
Claessens, A.L., Nuyts, M.M., Lefevre, J.A., & Wellen, R.I. (1987). Body structure,
somatotype, maturation of adolescent and professional classical ballet dancers. J
Sports Med Phys Fitness. 29, 157-62.
Da Silva, A.H., & Bonorino, K.C. (2008). BMI and flexibility in ballerinas of contemporary
dance and classical ballet. Fit Perf J. 7(1), 48-51.
Dantas, E.H.M. (1999). Flexibilidade: alongamento e flexionamento. 4th ed. Rio de Janeiro:
Shape.
Deutsch, M.U., Kearney, G.A., & Rehrer, N.J. (2007). Time -motion analysis of professional
rugby union players during match-play. Journal of Sports Sciences, 25, 461-472.
Erčulj, F., Vučković, G., Perš, J., Perše, M., & Kristan, M. (2008). Establishing basketball
players’ velocity and distance covered during a basketball match with the sagit
computer tracking system. Journal of Coimbra network on excercise sciences, 4, 5059.
Filipčič, T. (2008). Igralne značilnosti gibalno oviranih v tenisu na vozičku in njihov vpliv na
uspešnost igranja [Playing characteristics of physically impaired and their influence
on success in wheelchair tennis]. Doctoral dissertation. Ljubljana: Faculty of Sport.
Hollmann, W., & Hettinger, T. (2000). Sportmedizin, Grundlagen für Arbeit, Training und
Präventivmedizin. Stuttgart: Schattauer Verlag. 4. Auflage, p. 339, 477.
Hughes, M., Franks, I.M., & Nagelkerke, P. (1989). A video-system for the quantitative
motion analysis of athletes in competitive sport. Journal of Human Movement Studies,
17, 217-227.
Jaray, F., & Wanner, H.U. (1984). Heart rate and dance rhythm during dance tournament.
Schweiz Z Sportmed. 32(2), 44-48.
Mauthner, T., Koch, C., Tilp, M., & Bischof, H. (2007). Visual Tracking of Athletes in Beach
Volleyball Using a Single Camera. Int J Comp Sci Sport, 6, 21-34.
Minvielle-Moncla, J., Audiffren, M., Macar, F., & Vallet, C. (2008). Overproduction timing
errors in expert dancers. Journal of Motor Behaviour, 40(4), 291-300.
Perš, J. (2001). Sledenje ljudi z metodami računalniškega vida. [Tracking people with the
methods of the computer vision.] Unpublished master thesis. Ljubljana: Faculty of
electrical engineering.
Perš, J., Bon, M., Kovačič, S., Šibila, M., & Dežman, B. (2002). Observation and analysis of
large-scale human motion. Human Movement Science, 21, 295-311.
Šibila, M., Vuleta, D., & Pori, P. (2004). Position-related differences in volume and intensity
of large-scale cyclic movements of male players in handball. Kinesiology, 36, 1, 5868.
264
Vučković, G., Perš, J., & Dežman, B. (2006). Razvoj avtomatskega sledenja gibanj igralcev
na tekmah in obdelave zbranih podatkov. [The development of automatic tracking of
movements of athletes and methods of editing gathered data]. Sport, 54, 27-30.
Vučković, G., Perš, J., James, N., & Hughes, M. (2010). Measurement error associated with
the SAGIT/squash computer tracking software. European Journal of Sport Science,
10 (2), 129-140.
Zagorc, M. (2000). Družabni in športni ples. [Social and sport dance]. Ljubljana: PZS,
ZPVUT.
Zagorc, M., Karpljuk, D., & Friedl, M. (1999). Analysis of functional loads of top sport
dancers. V: Milanović (Ed.), Kinesiology for the 21th century. Proceedings book,
Dubrovnik, (str. 240-244). Zagreb, Fakultet za fizičku kulturu.
Zagorc, M., & Zaletel, P. (1996). Primerjava nekaterih morfoloških značilnosti in motoričnih
sposobnosti plesalcev in plesalk športnega plesa in akrobatskega rock'n'rolla.
[Comparison of some morphologic and motor dimensions of female and male sport
dancers]. Ljubljana: Plesna zveza Slovenije.
Zaletel, P., Tušak, M., & Zagorc, M. (2006). Plesalec – športnik in umetnik: znanstvena
monografija. [Dancer - an athlete and an artist]. Ljubljana: Faculty of Sport and&
ARRS.
Zaletel, P., Tušak, M., Tušak, M., & Zagorc, M. (2004). Pomen medsebojnih odnosov v
športnem plesu. [The importance of social interactions in sport dance]. Anthropos. 36,
1/4, 73-88.
Zaletel, P., Vučković, G., Rebula, A., & Zagorc, M. (2010). Analiza obremenitve plesnih
parov pri izbranih standardnih in latinskoameriških plesih s pomočjo sledilnega
sistema SAGIT [Analysis of dance couples` loading during selected ballroom and
Latin-American dances using the SAGIT tracking system]. Šport, 58 (3/4), 85-91.
Zucolotto, A., & Freire, A.L.G. (2003). A divina danca, www.idance.com.br , accesed
October 11th, 2010.
265
The performance development by the flow in the Canoe sport.
Szabó Attila,
West - Hungarian University, Savaria Campus, Szombathely, Hungary.
Abstract
In our study we compared the psychology immune-competence values of two
groups. The participants are former kayak-canoe sportsmen, and teachers who
don’t do any sports. 50 former sportsmen and 50 teachers participated in our
study. The participants filled four questionnaires.
Keywords:
Flow, health education, Increasing of performance,
1 Introduction
It is very important in the life of a top competitor and his trainer to make a good decision at
the right time. It can be determinant in the later career and can influence private life too. It
concerns of course every field however it is even more important in our profession. Work of
a trainer is about that we are who consider alternatives and determine the right way instead of
the competitor as well. I am sure in one thing that is we can only achieve our aims if we have
enormous humility towards the trainer profession and the sport itself. It is necessary to
indoctrinate our competitors with this ethical attitude in order to they become world class
competitors. Among the several circumstances the most important is maybe the creation of
the training system based on performance, in which the competitor can belong in and endure
the load fitting for his age. I build this system from the tradition of this sport, experience and
the specific training methods. One of the problems concerns how we can build the talented
young competitors in the world famous adult team. Present-day successful trainers often get
into a situation like this and in these matters we absolutely shirk for ourselves. Of course,
class competitors are provided with everything by the Kayak Canoe Association which is
necessary for their preparation but this is not the case with the second line. It is a thankless
task to decide who should be promoted for the future Olympic athletes and this decision is
made by trainers. It does not always pleasure for older aged world class competitors and that
is why conflict can arise against a less experienced but talented young person. Unfortunately
the young coming from the nature of their age does not endure the everyday duplicate
trainings based on performance and the stressful situations coming from the determinant
personality of the class competitor. The outcome: they give up competition!
In sport competitive like feature is a very important and attractive motive. Sport can be one of
the most effective activities of the improvement of physical abilities and addresses and it sets
all-absorbing problems from the point of view of Pedagogy, Psychology and Sociology as
well. Competitive feature in exponent sport involves more and more problems because
achievements and results are continuously rising, which put to the trainers to start the regular
trainings in younger and younger age. According to my survey children at the age of 12
266
kayak 2-3 hours a day. These exaggerated training quantum involve the possibility of the
psychic and physical overburden and the impairment of health. This is one big dilemma of
our days and then we haven’t mentioned the appearance of dopes and the more and more
wide-ranging spread of them, which are dangerous for certain sports. These arguments put to
the outstanding representatives of sport science to try to analyse those possibilities in a more
and more complex way (Pedagogy, Biology and Psychology) and with the help of these the
effect of the negative factors can be removable or at least reducible.
We started our analysis because of the above-mentioned recognitions and in it we
analyse the effect of the competition sport on personality from pedagogical aspect. The
training courses can be such stages of the educational process where the personality
development and together with it the attitude- and the activity framing can come true
measurably. This is important because in kayak sport schooling already starts at the age of 10
and the sportsman spends 2 later 3-6 hours a day in close work contact with its trainer.
According to Bábosik: “we can consider only such operations as functional parts of the
educational process, therefore concrete educational operation, which provide the framing of
the attitude and activity 3. It’s important that the sport activity in this case the attendance of
the kayak training be determined by inner motivation impetus.
These arguments put me to analyse the educational effect of kayak sport and at the same time
my personal inspiration was that I belonged to the crack of this sport for 15 years. This
survey can bring out such hot and promising results, which can give valuable information to
the trainers and competitors of kayak-canoe sport for the development of the effectiveness of
their educational work and besides it in the initiation of a more successful competitor and
trainer career.
The latest trend of coaching is to enhance productivity as well as mental capacity. Therefore
this study is based on two models, that is, the Flow theory of Mihály Csíkszentmihályi and
that of Antonowsky’s.
During trainings the body should be strengthened so as to be able to tolerate and bear strains
and stress. A special tailor made training plan will enable competitors to cope with this flow
while preparing sportmen/women for competitions. It is evident that this stress and hard
work bring about other personal/individual problems.
3
Bábosik: Egy optimális nevelési modell körvonalai M. A modern nevelés elmélet. Szerk: Bábosik I. Telosz
Kiadó Bp. 255p.
267
2 Methods
Subjects:
- 50 kayak-canoe professional competitors
- Control group with: 50 non professionals ?
To gain data in relation to psychological immune competence the Questionnaire of
Psychological Immune- system ( PIK Oláh 1996) was used. The 16 scales attempt to identify
the interviewees’ stress-resistance. Each scale has 5 items and the participants can indicate to
what extant they think.
Aims
- To map up the protective factors developed by doing sports
- To change trainers’ attitudes on the basis of the outcomes
- To work out methods supporting sportsmen/women to be able to adapt
themselves into civil life.
The questions may be relevant for them:- Valid outcome can be gained only in the state of flow
- Each successful professional has already experienced flow
- This psychological immune system strengthened by trainings and competitions will
support the individuals’ life and career.
3 Results and d iscussion
Figure 1. Outcomes of PIK scale.
268
On this diagram, we can see the 4 dimensions where there is significant differences between
the professional sportsmen and the control group. In the case of feeling of control, social
creativity and impulse control the professional sportsmen achieved better result and int he
case of feeling of coherence the teachers had higher scores.
Figure 2. Significant outcomes of the 4 factors .
On the 2nd diagram we can see the differences between the sportsmen and non active
teachers. As not expected, sportsmen achieved worse results in feeling of coherence. To me it
highlights that with a special treatment I can except an improvement of the performance.
Figure 3. The avarage of the survey .
On the 3 diagram we can see the assessment of the answers for all the questions. We can see
the positive effect of the sport to the mental health.
rd
269
4 Conclusions
In case of educators there is a significant difference within the feeling of coherence due to
the strict rules of sports. Sports do not support sportsmen/women in the third dimension of
education, namely to acquire skills enabling them to act autonomously . Actually rules will
control their life (Gombócz, 2007). Bearing this fact in our mind indicate that we should
develop the educative and pedagogic strategy of trainings. It is also crucial to make a plan
that focuses on enhancing the awareness of the importance of experiencing FLOW as well
positive thinking.
5 References
Antonovsky A. (1979) Helth stress, and coping:new perspektives on mental and physical
well-being. Josef Bass, san Francisko.
Gombócz J. 2007, A sport és nevelés harmadik dimenziója, OSK , Eger.
Oláh A. (2005) Érzelmek, megküzdés és optimális élmény Trefort kiadó , 85-93
Seligman, M.E.P. és Csíkszentmihályi M.(2009) Possitive Psychology: An Introduction
American Psychologist, 55. 5-14
Csikszentmihályi M .(1991) FLOW (Az áramlat ) A tökéletes élmény pszichológiája.
270
Bodily communication in volleyball.
Raiola, G., Di Tore, S. and Di Tore, A.,
University of Salerno, Italy
Keywords bodily communication, tactical, function, diagnostic.
Abstract
The actual coaching formation of volleyball training theory, tactics of game
play, knowledge of biomechanics, automatism of sport gesture techniques,
and the functional mechanisms to recruit energy. The formative itineraries
give rise to the acquisition of the psychological bases of competence that
regulate the dynamics of a group in the diverse phases of a game, but there
was not a thorough study of the function of signs and gesticulation. So, the
aim of this research was to define the first inventory of signs (gestures) most
frequently used in volleyball.
The study method is complex and integrated. Complex because it consists
of the basic research methodology of the humanities, its Philosophy,
Pedagogy and Psychology and the testing of descriptive research. Integrated
because it combines several theoretical aspects of pure study, deductive
arguments related to different knowledge: epistemology, education,
psychology, physiology. Thus it explains and justifies the phenomenon with
the results of descriptive research in the field to evaluate the body
communication performance.
Integrated because it utilizes empirical approach, both related to the field
approach for the human science by ecological vision. An observers’ group
analyzes three fast volleyball skills to evaluate the type of phenomenon by the
following four steps:
1)
study of specialized literature
2)
observation
3)
investigation
4)
focus group
The subjects, that made the specialized group, are three coaches of major
level of the observed team. The group is integrated by six athletes of the
observed volleyball team that participate to focus group.
It was concluded that during the last years at the professional level, many
trainers have dedicated time to these aspects of nonverbal communication, to
their codes, and to their technical-tactical uses of gesture, but often
undervaluing the scientific aspects that subtend body language. Therefore, it
is necessary to provide an educated course for technicians and coaches that
teaches and speaks about the subjects. Education in the field of corporeal
and body language requires interactive methodologies like cooperative
learning, role playing, and the experimentation of multiple types of
simulations. It needs to make an appropriate framework inside university
studies that includes the basis of the functions of gestures, signs and
mimicking in order to construct the competence of gestures required to
become expert coach of volleyball or specialist performance analyst.
271
1 Introduction
The actual coaching formation of volleyball training theory, tactics of game play,
knowledge of biomechanics, automatism of sport gesture techniques, and the functional
mechanisms to recruit energy. The formative itineraries give rise to the acquisition of the
psychological bases of competence that regulate the dynamics of a group in the diverse
phases of a game, but there was not a thorough study of the function of signs and
gesticulation. A more detailed analysis of the diverse actions connected to the phases of a
game (sport) can provide evidence for the strategic role of body language and its
conditioning ability on performance and results. The cause of this conditioning probably
draws on two interdependent traditions of research: the first on the form of nonverbal
communication in team sports, and the second one, on the neurobiological mechanisms that
connect action and cognition. Contest description: Volleyball is a very fast sports game in a
very narrow and little court (81 square meters per team) whose technical characteristics,
tactics and logistics constantly favour nonverbal communication between the players on
the court. Furthermore the motor control system theories has got a significant influence to
deep the phenomenon.
Bodily communication has got its own epistemological frame and into which the
message follows a process of coding, transmission and decoding. It establishes relations
and contacts that become real thanks to the elaboration of data and to the evaluation of the
content of the message. It is also the relationship in sociality (Shannon and Weaver, 1949)
where people collaborate in a common target, it exchanges inside of itself the roles to make
effective the function, it shares the meaning using facial expressions (Ekman, 2001), signs,
symbols (Argyle, 1988) and spaces (Hall, 1966) also with the paradoxes of body as regards
to the meaning of word (Watzlawick, 1967). Bodily communication in social context also
allows the building of the phenomenon through the process of subjectivity among people
(Husserl, 1935) and perception also contributes to this process (Merleau Ponty, 1945). It is
the spaces and the relations body and bodies in the spaces according to proxemics theory
(Hall, 1966). It is also a dynamic flow formed by five basic elements: context, sender,
receiver, channel, code (Jakobson, 1956) and it is enriched by some other elements of
ethnic and social knowledge as in the case of relationships among individuals belonging to
different cultures (Meharabian, 1972) where coding and decoding are different but the
process is the same. The identifying of the source and the destination of the message are
fundamental phases to intercept the code in the channel of communication and to proceed
to the decoding. By “code” we mean a shared system for the organization and the use of
specific signs both linguistic and physical. The relation between mind theories such as
Behaviourism (Skinner, B. F., 1969; Mackenzie, B. D., 1977), Gestalt psychology (Kohler,
1947), Cognitivism and Phenomenology and bodily communication help to enlarge the
horizons around the body to a best understanding of the phenomenon in an educational
psychology vision. The neuropsychological aspects contribute to widen the knowledge of
the mechanisms of bodily communication according to the laws of movement (Latash,
2004) of motor control (Adams, 1975; Schmidt, 1985) and to the abstract processes of
particular nervous structures and they describe the wide complexity of them.
There is new scientific evidence on the brain on some nerve cells that are activated when it
272
sees, hears or perceives through touch but does not produce a movement or act. These nerve
cells are defined by the properties to reflect movements of the others or imagine it remaining
in stop position. They do not contribute to the practical execution of the movement but they
will receive only information (Rizzolatti, Iacoboni, Welsh, Fogassi, Fadiga et al., 1996). They
can be seen by sophisticated brain-imaging equipment such as trans-cranial magnetic
stimulation and functional magnetic resonance imaging.
The focus of this study is the application of bodily communication theories and to construct
an interactive process to aim a new scientific paradigm on bodily communication by
integrative vision. So the aim of the study is to collate the distinct interfaces of the same
knowledge and even to study together and with details the qualitative aspect into the
environment. Furthermore the objective is to identify the types of bodily communication in
volleyball. So, the research wants to define the first inventory of signs (gestures) most
frequently used in volleyball, according to:
• The scientific principles of corporeal communication based on the theoretical
model of Dr. Michael Argyle, Professor of Social Psychology at Oxford University
and Fellow of the Wolfson College for his work published in the book “Bodily
Communication” (1988) pp. 5-12,22-25,48-68,118-131.150-153,165-181,199-209.
This way study is integrated by other authors on nonverbal language such as
Shannon, Weaver, 1949, Watzlawick, 1967, Ekman 2001, Jakobson, 1956,
Meharabian, 1972, Hall, 1966.
• The aspects of perceptive senses according to the research of Alain Berthoz,
published in the book “Le Sens du Mouvement” (1997) pp. 1-41, 103-122. This
way study is integrated by other authors on motor control theories system such as
Jack Adams, 1975 and Richard Scmidth, 1985.
• The neurobiological implications based on the findings of the research of mirror
neurons by Giacomo Rizzolatti published in the book “So Quel Che Fai” (2006) pp.
113-135 and by Marco Iacoboni M. Mirroring People. The new science of how we
connect with others (2008) pp. 134-180.
2 Method
The study method is complex and integrated. Complex because it consists of the basic
research methodology of the humanities, its Philosophy, Pedagogy and Psychology and the
testing of descriptive research. Integrated because it combines several theoretical aspects
of pure study, deductive arguments related to different knowledge: epistemology,
education, psychology, physiology. Thus it explains and justifies the phenomenon with the
results of descriptive research in the field to evaluate the body communication
performance.
Integrated because it utilizes empirical approach, both related to the field approach for the
human science by ecological vision. An observers’ group analyzes three fast volleyball skills
to evaluate the type of phenomenon by the following four steps:
5) study of specialized literature
6) observation
7) investigation
8) focus group
The subjects, that made the specialized group, are three coaches of major level of the
observed team. The group is integrated by six athletes of the observed volleyball team that
participate to focus group.
273
3 Results
3.1 Theoretical Results
Bodily communication, according to the authors Argyle, Meharabian, Watzlawick and Ekman
Hall has its own epistemological framework where the non-verbal message is empirically
investigated in the process of decoding and encoding. Communicating means to establish a
relationship, a contact among people and implies the transfer of a message from one
individual to another, communication is not just transmission of information through a
channel where the beginning is the source of the bodily signs or issuer and the arrival or
receiving the same in the form of Shannon and Weaver which addresses to logicalmathematical aspects. In the relational approach, communication is the foundation of
sociability and socialization where it planned cooperation, exchanges of roles (issuer /
receiver), sharing among multiple actors in a same context surrounding the provision for the
existence of common symbols that replace or accompany the use of language.
Communication is social because it is composed of behaviors that help the socialization
through the construction of subjectivity meanings among people. The individual, through the
natural development and evolution in the interaction with the socio and cultural context,
acquires a set of norms, values and behavior characteristic patterns of that particular cultural
reality. They are learned and, therefore, are evaluated and varied from context to context and
only from the context, because the decoding of messages from outside the body is difficult
due to the lack of specific knowledge elements of the signs, symbols, signals, movements and
spaces of that context. Another context has other items, for example the sport is different
from the other context for dynamics, rules, elements.
The communication process takes into account these variables, a dynamic flow where there
are several elements: the context, sender, recipient, channel, code (Jakobson). Knowledge of
the factors of communication does not guarantee the success of the communication. In the
case of relations among individuals belonging to different contexts is necessary to remove
the obstacles against which the communication would not be effective. If you are able to
identify immediately the issuer the message, the one who produces it, and the recipient, who
must decode the message or the recipient to whom the message is directed, the context, the
channel and the code may be incomprehensible. Code means a shared system for the
organization of signs that refers to a linguistic code, due to a different language the message
is decoded by the absence or difference in code where code is the same as spoken language; if
channel means the physical medium through which the communicative act takes place, a nonverbal channel for example can cause misunderstandings in relation to cultural beliefs and
customs, the environment, understood as physical or psychological scenario in which
communication events occur, may interfere with the communication process when the code
of an issuer is understood by the recipient but the meaning is distorted for ideological
reasons.
It is quite obvious that, for those who do not speak a language code, physical contact or
rather non-verbal language represents the first real form of communication between the two
subjects. It is not often given appropriate emphasis to this approach that can generate some
real misunderstandings if you do not know the habits of the interlocutor.
Some aspects of nonverbal communication are universal, others are adopted by different
cultures and contexts and these differences in the area of non verbal communication
represents the cause of "a major source of antagonism, misunderstanding and conflict
between cultural and ethnic groups" (Argyle, 1988 ). The smile, facial expression and a
symbol according to different contexts, cultures and places, is widely interpreted as a sign of
274
contentment considered the studies of eleven different cultures. In Japan, the smile is used as
a mask that can hide embarrassment or reserve . The face, facial expression, is the first
element to be analyzed in a first approach followed by the postures, movements and bodily
attitudes. The facial expressions that communicate emotions are very similar in different
cultures and in different contexts. If Ekman and Friesen's studies reveal that the facial
expressions reveal emotions, feelings and moods, no less importance must be given to
gesture, "is the aspect that seems to change more in the context of different cultures" (Argyle,
1988). He defines nonverbal emblems acts that have a direct verbal translation, as do the nod,
the beckon and the pointing at. The origin of these movements is derived from basic human
experiences or symbols that describe actions or natural persons. If this final gesture is
considered universal and then the same in all cultures, it is not the gesture of the head that in
many cultures as in northern Europe is shaken to indicate "no", while in Greece the rapid
movement of the head is a sign of denial. The same sign with thumb and forefinger to form a
closed ring is a sign of approval in the United States and northern Europe to mean "OK" but
in southern France indicates something worthless recalling zero. It should not be neglected
the contribution of sign language in its purest form were developed by groups of people who
cannot make use of words such as deaf.
The visual interaction varies considerably within different cultures. The Arabs, South
Americans and southern Europeans in a survey conducted by Watson in 1970 on a sample of
110 foreign students of the University of Colorado, looking more than students from other
cultures where physical contact is limited. Just as American blacks look less white, giving the
impression of a lack of attention or understanding, if combined with a slight head movements
during listening. While African-Americans would look directly at a higher index of equal
status, so they are reluctant to do so because their action would be interpreted as a lack of
respect (Hanna,, 1984).
The spatial behavior must be duly considered in the relationship between individuals and
groups. The proxemics theory (Hall, 1 966) gives the answer on the relation among object
and people and between persons within the past relation. It defines the current definition of
distance space and its effect of verbal language .Anthropologists often distinguish between
cultures with frequent physical contacts and cultures with no or very limited physical
contacts. Individuals from cultures with frequent physical contact (Arabs, Latin Americans,
southern Europeans) are closest, are often opposite each other, touch each other and they look
more at each other, they also speak louder than people from cultures of non-contact as Asians,
Indians, Pakistanis and northern Europeans. The Arabs, for example, when greeting you take
your hands for a certain period of time or they can embrace and kiss the hands, face or beard
in formal occasions; Arab men, in conversation, touch each other on the upper arm with their
right hand and playfully slapped their right hand, against the Arab females are not touched at
all in public. Most likely the differences in spatial behavior may result from differences in the
structure of the physical environment, such as the size of the houses and the degree of
crowding. Instead, we are likely to interpret the spatial behavior in a very simplistic way:
who gets too close is considered invasive in contrast to those who approach too little that are
considered cold and aloof. There are significant cultural differences concerning the number
and type of contact. The Arabs also have a forward leaning posture, an angle of the body
most directly aimed at the contact, while the Japanese bow (even up to 45 °) are only a sign
of respect. Another characterization of ethnic groups is the use of voice tone and vocal
intensity as not to associate with the verbal communication that is the absolute transmission
through the contents of the word. The inhabitants of the West Indies do not mark the end of
sentences with a rising tone of voice appearing rude to the English culture, in addition they
utilize high tones to emphasize what they say, wrongly interpreted as sudden outbursts of
anger. The Arabs use a very high tone of voice compared to most cultures that could be seen
275
as assertive and speak up is synonymous with sincerity. The Japanese instead change their
vocal style to sex gender and social status of their partner, Morsbach has distinguished eight
separate tones of voice.
This analysis opens the scene of bodily communication in physical education and sport and
its specific aspects related to the individual situation of sports both individual and group, with
common roots and different endings, with general characterizations and specific details. The
confrontation between adversaries is also with the help of bodily communication and the
effects in the context at that particular time and place. Particular arguments revolve around
the feint, manifest intention of achieving a goal through the initial implementation of a plan
with specific motor signs, postures, attitudes, etc., which then are carried out in completely
different versions of those originally deduced. In this case, the psychological foundations of
the movement related to the perception and motor control on the theoretical framework,
according to the authors Adams (1975) and Schmidt (1985), affect the performance. In
addition, the motor system according to the theory of mirror neurons (Rizzolatti et al, 1996)
is a new ecological vision more and more associated with the current Phenomenology of
Perception, Merleau Ponty (1945), with the current ecological visual perception of the mind
(Gibson, 1978) and with the current movement sense (Berthoz, 1998). So, explaining how the
brain works only from the biological point of view may be limited, the same may apply if it
deals with the matter only from the philosophical point of view. The new scientific findings
bring into the question of body communication and the theories of motor control are the
principal field of research. It distinguishes the temporal phase of the afferent perception and
efferent movement enforce the reflection according to two scientific paradigms. The first
scientific evidence that the perception occurs first and then occurs the movement and so
constantly in a continuous pathway, where the feedback helps continuously the movement by
adjustments and corrections of motor execution. The adjustments and corrections are
compared by the scheme already in motor memory. It is called in motor system theory
“closed-loop” (Adams, 1975). The second one is when the movements are in the motor
memory in a wide repertory of motor scheme and they are executed without the help of
feedback for the adjustments and the corrections of errors. It cannot be adjustment and
corrected because the feedback comes up to the 200 milliseconds and the brain do not process
the data. It is called in motor system theory (Schmidt, 1985). There is new scientific evidence
on the brain on some nerve cells that are activated when it sees, hears or perceives through
touch but does not produce a movement or act. These nerve cells are defined by the properties
to reflect movements of the others or imagine it remaining in stop position. They do not
contribute to the practical execution of the movement but they will receive only information
(Rizzolatti, Iacoboni, Welsh, Fogassi, Fadiga et al, 1996 et al) They can be seen by
sophisticated brain-imaging equipment such as trans-cranial magnetic stimulation and
functional magnetic resonance imaging.
The phenomenon of activation occurs continuously, in processes of the mind related to the
movement of its own or that of others, thus opening a new scenario on learning related to the
movement by imitation and teaching based on simulation. New discoveries about the brain
suggests that some sort of order mixing action perception in a single process where
perception and execution are together without sequential order. It is described in motor
imagery. Which means that action and perception carries out in a single moment without the
phases of afferent sensory or perception, motor development of the idea, motion planning and
execution of actions
In conclusion it would open a new way to concern the body and its movement in
accordance to a complex approach and an ecological vision. The partial study nowadays do
not help the total phenomena of the body language. There are no studies in physical education
and sport literature on body language, although there is an interest in the field of investigation
276
and the consequences that the appropriate use of the findings and mechanisms of encoding
and decoding of the message body may have some proficiency in fundamental gestures of
the sport in variable contexts. It might be useful for the analysis and evaluation of
performance of the athlete. It checks the inference on the behavior, to observe the
associations among the observed variables and possibly identify pathways that helps to
regulate the educational training to enhance the performance. To identify the components of
bodily communication relating the epistemological, psycho-pedagogical and technical
evaluation could be useful to collect the all aspects around the question.
3.2 Empirical Results
They are three types: Tactical, Functional, Diagnostic.
The decoding of the signs or of the gesticulation may be: Tactical when the gesture or the
action simulates a game intention to solicit a reaction of the adversary who helps their own
team. Bodily and nonverbal communication of the athletes is expressed through 4
different typology:
•
•
•
•
dominate when an athlete dominates the area of game thanks to his high athletic
and/or technical ability works.
hostile or adverse when in the adverse phases, the technical-athletic ability
works in conjunction with the facial signs and the body pantomime which
communicate aggressiveness).
friendly (during training when the actions of the game are finalized to improve
on the plans of attack and defence. In this case, the players of the same team split
into 2 separate (rival) teams).
subjected or mastered (when the offensive abilities of a team are obviously
higher)
The decoding of the signs or of the gesticulation may be: Functional when it refers to the
same team and it is involved the communication between the game companions or that
between trainer and athletes on the tactical intentions, the strategies and the problems of
game.
In volleyball, for example, the setter uses conventional prearranged signs to
communicate to the other players the plans of the game (hand gesture):
index finger meaning the ball will be set (tossed) in front of the player (setter)
for a very rapid spike centred on the net by the attacking player;
2. middle and index finger meaning the ball will be set (tossed) behind the player
(setter) for a very rapid spike on the right side of the net by the attacking player;
3. thumb and index finger meaning the ball will be set (tossed) away and in front
of the player (setter) between the left side and the centre of the net for a very rapid
spike by the attacking player;
4. thumb and little finger meaning the ball will be set away and behind the player
(setter) between the right side and the centre of the net for a very rapid spike by the
attacking player.
1.
277
1
2
3
4
Figure 1. The setter uses conventional prearranged signs to communicate to the other
players the plans of the game (hand gesture).
The decoding of the signs or of the gesticulation may be: Diagnostic
when it is possible to analyze the diverse forms of nonverbal communication of the
opposing team, the signs of the athletes and of the trainer, who anticipate or solicit actions
of the game. This sign language between players is based on (M. Argyle, 1986 - E.T. Hall,
1966):
• close contact and a glance (distance between the players of two teams, visual
contact through the net);
• expressive ability (facial expressions and corporeal (bodily) gestures that
preceed, continue, and follow the actions of play);
• significant difference between signs (difference between corporeal signals,
conventionally coded, prearranged, or personal);
• rituals (gestures, facial expressions, or attitudes that mark the behaviour of the
athlete);
• symbolic presentation of oneself (utilization of the body and of gestures to
express one’s own needs or demands).
4 Conclusions
During the last years at the professional level, many trainers have dedicated time to these
aspects of nonverbal communication, to their codes, and to their technical-tactical uses of
gesture, but often undervaluing the scientific aspects that subtend body language.
Therefore, it is necessary to provide an educated course for technicians and coaches that
teaches and speaks about the following subjects:
•
•
Neurobiological knowledge on the mechanisms of regulation of the various types
and ways of imitation, learning, and gestural communication according to the
research on mirror neurons;
Knowledge of the mechanisms of perception and on the sense of movement or
kinaesthesia which studies the types of simulations and anticipations of motor
278
•
•
•
actions;
Knowledge of the mechanisms of imitation in the different phases of training; i.e.,
the phenomenon called “covert’’ or “implicit imitation” or the chameleon effect;
Knowledge of the rule of the emotion in the sports effect described as an emotional
contact;
Acquaintance and meaning of non-verbal communication, of the interpersonal
motor attitudes, of spaces and body in the spaces, of posture, of facial expressions,
of contact, of proceeding, and of the glance.
Education in the field of corporeal and body language requires interactive methodologies
like cooperative learning, role playing, and the experimentation of multiple types of
simulations.
It needs to make an appropriate framework inside university studies that includes the basis
of the functions of gestures, signs and mimicking in order to construct the competence of
gestures required to become expert coach of volleyball or specialist performance analyst.
5 References
Argyle, M., (1988). Bodily Communication. Second edition, London: Metheun & Co Ltd.
Berthoz, A. (2002). The Brain’s Sense of Movement. Boston, USA:Harvard University Press.
C. E. Shannon, (1948). A mathematical theory of communication, Bell System Technical
Journal, 27, pp. 379-423 and 623-656, July and October, 1948
Ekman, P. (2001). Giù la maschera, Los Angeles USA.
Gallimard. Husserl, D. (1936). Die Krisis der europaischen Wissenscaften und Die
transzendentale Phanomenologie, Belgrado: Philosophia.
Gardner, H. (2002). Frame of the mind, the theory of multiple intelligences. New York, USA:
Basic Books,
Gibson, J.J. (1979). The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Boston: Houghton
Mifflin
Hall, T. E. (1966). The Hidden Dimension. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday. USA
Iacoboni M. (2008). Mirroring People. The new science of how we connect with others. ,
L.A. USA: Farrar Straus & Girox.
Chapman, A., E., (2009). Biomechanical Analysis of Fundamental Human Movements.
Champaign, Ill.: Human Kinetics.
Jakobson R. and Halle, M. (1956). Fundamentals of Language. Gravenhage : Mouton, USA.
Kohler, W. (1947). Gestalt Psycology. New York, USA: Liveright.
Latash M. (2008). Neurophysiological Basis of Movement. Champaign, Ill.: Human
Kinetics.
Mackenzie, B. D (1977). Behaviourism and the limits of scientific method. London:
Routledge.
Meharabian, A. (1972). Nonverbal communication, Library of Congress Catalog Number
USA.
Merleau Ponty, M. (1945). Phenomenologie de la perception, Paris: Libraire.
Rizzolatti, G. (2006). So quel che fai. Il cervello che agisce e i neuroni specchio. Raffaello
Cortina Editore, Milano, Italia.
Schmidt, R., A. and Wrisberg, G., A. (2008). Motor Learning and Performance. Champaign,
Ill.: Human Kinetics.
Shannon, Claude E. & Weaver, Warren (1949). The Mathematical Theory of Communication.
The University of Illinois Press, Urbana.
279
Skinner, B. F., (1969). Contigencies of Reinforcement. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Watzlawick, P., Beavin, J.H. & Jackson, D.D. (1967). Pragmatics of Human
Communication-A Study of Interactional Patterns, Pathologies and Paradoxes. New
York: Norton. USA.
Wrisberg, G. A., (2009). Sport Skills for Coaches. Champaign, Ill.: Human Kinetics.
280
Teaching , coaching methodology
281
The importance of being earnest – with your data.
Nic James,
London Sport Institute, Middlesex University, UK.
Abstract
Reliability, in terms of performance analysis, pertains to the extent to
which the event codes (data) reflect what happened in the game (James,
Taylor and Stanley, 2007). In many other areas of research the value used
to represent the quantity being measured is slightly different to the actual
value, if direct measurement was possible, this is known as measurement
error. However, having ensured, by suitable reliability testing, that data
collection methods were satisfactory, this does not signal the start of
inference or correlation testing.
This paper discusses the extremely important intermediate stage of
analysing the data prior to applying any statistical procedures. Hence
graphical procedures (histogram, stem and leaf plot, scatterplot, box plot,
probability plots) to identify any unusual values and trends in the data will
be presented along with guidance on what to do when the unexpected
happens. The types of data collected (nominal, ordinal, interval, ratio) as
well as the shape of the distribution (normal, skewed) are important
determinants of how the data should be subsequently described and
analysed. Hence appropriate measures (mean, median, standard
deviation, interquartile range, skewness, kurtosis) and techniques for
different data types will be presented along with statistical procedures to
determine the type of distribution (e.g. Kolmogorov-Smirnov). The
procedures presented in this paper will enable researchers to analyse
their data correctly and identify any interesting features that need to be
discussed.
1 Introduction
Having collected reliable data, ascertained by suitable reliability testing (James, Taylor and
Stanley, 2007) this does not signal the start of inference or correlation testing. Rather the data
needs to be analysed prior to applying any statistical procedures. This is achieved by carrying
out a visual inspection of the data i.e. by using graphical procedures such as a stem and leaf
plot, as well as obtaining statistical measures to ascertain the type of distribution, appropriate
measures of central tendency and dispersion and the presence of outliers. The decisions
necessary for selecting the most appropriate methods for achieving these goals are
determined by the type of data collected as well as the type of research being carried out. This
paper will present solutions for common research paradigms in sports science.
For the purposes of this paper research will be categorised as either experimental,
where the researcher manipulates things to assess the effect of an intervention (independent
variable) on some performance (dependent variable) or correlation research, where the
researcher simply measures things and assesses whether there is a relationship between these
measures.
282
2 Correlation research
An experimenter measured counter movement and squat jumps performed by young soccer
players belonging to age category squads (U10, U12, U14, U16 and U18). These vertical
jumps are typically used to assess leg power. The countermovement jump (with arm swing)
starts from an upright standing position; a preliminary downward movement is instigated by
flexing the knees and hips, immediately followed by an extension of the knees and hips to
jump vertically off the ground. The squat jump starts in a stationary semi-squatted position
and does not employ a preliminary downward phase (the countermovement). Skilled
performers of these jumps usually jump about 4 cm higher when using the countermovement
although the opposite may be true when unfamiliar with the countermovement jump.
Since the jumps were measured in centimetres the data was classified as ratio (Field,
2009) implying that parametric statistical methods may be appropriate. Parametric methods
refer to the methods of calculation used when determining averages, dispersion etc. In this
instance the actual values for each item of data can be used as they are real numbers and
consequently any numerical differences apparent accurately reflect true differences.
When assessing the relationship between two variables it is necessary to view the data
to determine whether there are any unusual values (these could be due to input errors or
exceptionally poor or good performances). When these values are found a decision needs to
be made whether to remove or amend the data or to simply leave the data alone. Whilst this
sounds rather unhelpful in that all possible scenarios are presented as applicable in reality the
decision is determined by the explanation for the unusual value. For example if an input error
was detected (e.g. typing 99 instead of 9) then it is obvious that the error would be corrected.
On the other hand if the unusual value was as a result of an exceptionally poor or good
performance then the decision is not so straight forward. Suppose a participant slipped during
a running test resulting in a very slow time, should the data be included or removed, or the
running test re-taken? The answer is down to the experimenter who needs to be able to justify
the decision. Suppose the running test was not able to be re-taken then the argument for
removal or otherwise of the data might be determined by the degree to which the test result
had been affected, e.g. a very minor slip may be included on the basis that small slips are
common on this type of test, other researchers tend to include this data and therefore times
which include small slips are valid data. Equally the research may determine that the slip was
sufficient to make the time totally unrepresentative of performance for this type of participant
and remove the data altogether. Both decisions can be justified logically and are therefore
acceptable.
To visually see the relationship between two variables it is common to produce a
scatterplot. In PASW (formerly known as SPSS) this can be achieved using the chart builder
(in the graphs pull down menu). In the chart builder dialogue box the Scatter Dot chart type
needs to be selected and if the individual group membership needs to be identified, as in this
example, the coloured selection selected and dragged into the chart area (Figure 1).
The resultant scatterplot (Figure 2) shows the general relationship between the
countermovement and squat jumps with performance on both tending to increase with age
although some overlap between age groups is evident. Critically the relationship between the
two variables can be assessed visually by drawing an imaginary line around the data points.
In Figure 2 this imaginary line has been drawn to exemplify. The strength of the relationship
is determined by the width of the shape, in this case it is quite thin suggesting a good
relationship. However the main purpose of visually looking at the data is to determine if there
are any unusual values (points that are a distance from the other points) and to see if a
different relationship other than a linear one exists e.g. a curved shape of points suggests an
exponential relationship. In this example a linear relationship exists and one participant
283
appears to have performed better on the squat jump than his countermovement jump
performance would predict (highlighted by red circle on Figure 2).
Figure 1: Chart builder dialogue box
The actual strength of the relationship is given by the correlation coefficient. In PASW this is
calculated using the Analyze, Correlate, Bivariate pull down menu. This enables the Pearson
(parametric) and Spearman (non-parametric) correlations to be calculated. In this case the
Pearson coefficient was 0.938 and based on 79 pairs of data was shown to be significant (p
<.001). It is important to recognise that the significance value does not suggest the strength of
the relationship (this is determined using the correlation coefficient) but rather the certainty
that the correlation coefficient is an accurate measure, as such is more related to the sample
size.
Figure 2: Scatterplot of counter movement and squat jump performances by age
group soccer players
In this example the correlation coefficient of 0.938 is strong as this value ranges from -1 to 1
where 0 signifies no relationship and 1 a perfect relationship. The sign simply designates the
direction of the relationship where a positive value indicates that high values of one variable
are associated with high values of the other. Conversely a negative value simply indicates
that high values of one variable are associated with low values of the other. To ascertain the
extent to which the two variables are related to each other the correlation coefficient should
be squared, this can be done in the chart editor (double click on chart) and inserting a linear
fit line which also adds the R2 value as shown in Figure 2. In this case (0.88) suggests that
88% of the motor skills recruited by the countermovement and squat jumps are the same and
12% are different.
284
3 Experimental research
Experimental research is where the researcher manipulates independent variable(s) to assess
whether there is any effect on some performance (the thing you measure – the dependent
variable). In this situation it is usual to have more than one group of data between which
comparisons are made to assess the impact of the independent variable(s). When comparing
groups of data there are some requirements that need to be considered to enable you to select
the correct statistical procedure for the comparison test.
The first consideration is whether the distribution of values in each group are broadly
speaking similar. This is assessed as an equality of variances test and the appropriate methods
for each test are built into the options for the test in PASW.
A second consideration is the type of data (this is relevant for dependent variables)
that has been collected. This question refers to how powerful the data is and thus how the
data can be used. There are four types of data scale:• Nominal. Categorical data i.e. no implied relationship between categories e.g. male,
female (you will notice that data i.e. dependant variables, generally are not in this form, it
is more likely that the independent variables are of this type).
• Ordinal. When there is an implied order to the named categories. Here a ranking is
typically applied to the categories such as 1=strongly agree, 2=agree etc. Whilst there is an
order in these ranking you cannot say that the difference in magnitude between “strongly
agree” and “agree” is the same as “agree” and “disagree” since different subjects may
subjectively assign appropriate ranks but you cannot be certain that different subjects use
the same process for assigning ranks. This implies non parametric techniques although
many researchers conveniently ignore this fact! It is worth reading an editorial devoted to
this topic (Nevill and Lane, 2007).
• Interval. Here the difference between categories is relative. The most common interval
scale in psychology is the intelligence scale. This is only interval data (and not ordinal)
because of the great deal of effort taken to standardise these tests. However the point is
that the difference between 90 and 100 is the same as between 110 and 120. There is more
justification for using parametric approaches with this type of data but it is rare to have
this sort of data in sports science research.
• Ratio. This is the most powerful scale which extends from the interval scale to include a
true zero. This allows the assignment of ratios to the data. For example if two times were
recorded for a cross country run where one runner’s time was 104% of the winner’s time
compared to another of 108% you could say that the first runner did twice as well as the
second in terms of relative performance to the winner. This type of data suggests a
parametric approach.
If parametric tests are to be used then some assessment of the distribution of the data is also
necessary to determine if the data is normally distributed (if data is normal then most values
tend to cluster around the average value for the distribution and a frequency plots look like an
inverted U). Performance analysis data of frequency counts of events tend to be skewed
distributions with large frequencies of low values and increasingly less frequent occurrences
of higher values (often Poisson or binomial distributions; Nevill et al., 2002).
Another consideration of the data is whether there are outliers (unusually large or
small values) present. This is more important for parametric tests as these tests use the
numerical value of the data to determine differences. Hence very large or very small values
have a disproportionate influence on the statistical test.
285
In order to demonstrate appropriate techniques a series of examples will be used to
show both the output and an explanation of why the procedure was necessary and what is
showed.
3a Two groups of data
The first example research design involved collecting shot to shot times for elite squash
players (time taken from a starting point when the opposing player hit the ball to the point in
time when the return shot was played). Since the data is time taken (contains a real zero) the
dependent variable is on the ratio scale implying parametric techniques. Parametric
techniques use the actual values of the data and compare each data point with the average
(arithmetic mean) for the group. The sum of all of the differences between each data point
and the average is used in the assessment of difference between groups. Consequently this
sort of test requires that each group is normally distributed and of similar variance. So before
carrying out a parametric significance test these two data features need to be checked.
An ideal method for this is to use the Explore command in PASW (analyse,
descriptive statistics, explore). Within this command there are some useful options to select.
Select the plots button (Figure 3) and select stem-and-leaf, histogram and normality plots
with tests.
Figure 3: Plots option with the Explore command
The output from the Explore command with these settings is extensive but very informative
although depending on the data some will be more informative than others. Each output will
be discussed in terms of what can be good indicators.
The first output is the descriptive statistics (Table 1). Some general principles can be
considered although these are not always informative, particularly if the values are small or
similar in value. In a normal distribution the mean and median are the same so for player 1
the values are 1.44 and 1.36 and for player 2 1.49 and 1.40. The decision whether the scores
are different or not is not particularly obvious but maybe made simpler by considering the
difference as a proportion of the magnitude of the mean 5.746% for player 1 and 6.099% for
player 2. Since normality is never clear cut this is perhaps not too informative!
More informatively the skewness and kurtosis values are measures of the tendency for
the data to have more low values than high (skewness values greater than 0) or for there to be
more data around a central point (kurtosis values greater than 0). For a normal distribution,
both skewness and kurtosis statistics are zero. A skewness value more than twice its standard
error is taken to indicate a departure from symmetry, as is the case for both players here.
Fortunately much of the guesswork is removed by the ability to perform normality
tests (as we selected earlier). When we selected the normality plots option we also gained the
Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic, with a Lilliefors significance level for testing normality, in
286
this example (Table 2) the times for both player 1 and player 2 departed from normal as the
significance level was less than 0.05 (.000 should be reported as p<.001).
Table 1: Descriptive statistics for time taken between shots (PASW output).
Descriptives
Hitter
Player 1
Statistic
Mean
1.4429
95% Confidence Interval for
Lower Bound
1.4090
Mean
Upper Bound
1.4769
5% Trimmed Mean
1.4277
Median
1.3600
Variance
.01728
.181
Std. Deviation
.42513
Minimum
.52
Maximum
2.76
Range
2.24
Interquartile Range
.68
Skewness
Kurtosis
Player 2
Std. Error
Mean
.497
.099
-.434
.198
1.4909
.01688
95% Confidence Interval for
Lower Bound
1.4578
Mean
Upper Bound
1.5241
5% Trimmed Mean
1.4779
Median
1.4000
Variance
.175
Std. Deviation
.41864
Minimum
.56
Maximum
2.72
Range
2.16
Interquartile Range
.64
Skewness
Kurtosis
.469
.099
-.391
.197
Table 2: Tests of Normality (PASW output)
hitter
Kolmogorov-Smirnov
Statistic
Df
a
Shapiro-Wilk
Sig.
Statistic
Df
Sig.
time taken to travel from
Player 1
.098
605
.000
.967
605
.000
start point to finish area
Player 2
.088
615
.000
.974
615
.000
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
287
The normality plots (Figure 4) confirm the above finding since for a normal
distribution the points on the graph would fall on the straight line.
Figure 4: Normality Plots for player 1 and 2
In a similar manner the detrended plots (Figure 5) should exhibit no discernable
pattern for a normal distribution, whereas in this example they do.
Figure 5: Detrended Normality Plots for player 1 and 2
The conclusions drawn from this examination of the data, which was ratio and
therefore suitable for parametric statistics, was that the non normal distributions suggest non
parametric approaches or a transformation of the data to normalise.
Although we have determined that in this case the data was not normal this would not
always be the case. In the case of finding normal distributions in the data we also need to
identify whether there are any extreme values (outliers). These, as discussed earlier, require
consideration as to whether anything needs to be done. In any case the other plots produced
in the explore command are very useful for this purpose and will be presented using different
data.
3b A single data set
The data presented next is the proportion of time 21 basketball players walked at speeds of up
to 1.4 m/s (velocity class 1 (VC1) in Vučković et al., 2010) during 3 matches between two
288
teams during the final stages of the Slovenian National Championship (2004/05). The same
explore command (with previously selected options) was used.
Table 3 suggests a relatively normal distribution as the mean (69.12) is similar to the
median (69.43), the difference being 0.45% (as a proportion of the magnitude of the mean).
Furthermore the skewness value (-0.314) is not twice its standard error (0.18). The kurtosis is
near to 0 (0.655) also suggesting normality.
Table 3: Descriptive statistics for proportion of time spent walking (PASW output)
Descriptives
Statistic
VC1
Mean
Std. Error
69.120
95% Confidence Interval for
Lower Bound
68.223
Mean
Upper Bound
70.017
5% Trimmed Mean
69.187
Median
69.428
Variance
37.589
Std. Deviation
6.1310
Minimum
46.9
Maximum
85.1
Range
38.2
Interquartile Range
.4545
7.6
Skewness
Kurtosis
-.314
.180
.655
.358
The opinion that the data was normally distributed was reinforced by the significance
level of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic (p=0.20; Table 4).
Table 4: Tests of Normality (PASW output)
Kolmogorov-Smirnov
Statistic
VC1
.056
df
a
Shapiro-Wilk
Sig.
182
Statistic
*
.200
.987
df
Sig.
182
.104
a. Lilliefors Significance Correction
*. This is a lower bound of the true significance.
The normality plot (Figure 6) is less clear as for a normal distribution the points on
the graph should fall on the straight line. However extreme values (outliers) tend to affect
these plots with the dot highlighted indicative of an extreme value.
289
Figure 6: Normality Plot for proportion of time spent walking
In a similar manner the detrended plot (Figure 7) should exhibit no discernable pattern
for a normal distribution, which in this example is not the case. At this point it should be
noted that the issue of normality is not as straight forward as to say a distribution is or is not
normal. There are few examples of perfectly normal distributions and many distributions are
relatively normal i.e. they display normal characteristics but contain more or less data in one
or more areas of the distribution. Hence the assessment of normality is to determine if the
data is “normal” enough to allow parametric analyses. Up to this point the evidence has
suggested the data is normal but the presence of extreme values (one is clear on this plot and
highlighted) also determines the validity of using parametric testing.
Figure 7: Detrended Normality Plot for proportion of time spent walking
The final three plots (histogram, scatterplot and boxplot) are useful for determining outliers
and the shape of the distribution although each can be more useful than the others on
occasion. Hence it is recommended that all are viewed to collect the necessary information.
The first plot (histogram) in this example has the advantage that a normal curve can be drawn
290
on it. As with all charts in PASW the chart needs to be double clicked to open the chart
editor. The button highlighted in Figure 8 allows this to be achieved.
Figure 8: Chart editor for Histogram highlighting button for drawing normal curve
Whilst PASW offers alternative curves to fit to the data the default selection is the normal
curve (Figure 9) and in this instance the curve drawn looks normal in that it is pretty close to
symmetrical to the data.
Figure 9: Histogram of proportion of time spent walking
The stem-and-leaf plot (Figure 10) is constructed by splitting each score into a stem
(the leading digit(s)) and a leaf (the trailing digit). The plot then represents a normal
distribution laid on its side. A big advantage of this plot is that the number of extreme values
are clearly identified (in this case 3 very low values of less than or equals 54 and 2 very high
values of greater than or equals 85).
291
VC1 Stem-and-Leaf Plot
Frequency
Stem &
3.00 Extremes
1.00
5 .
1.00
5 .
9.00
5 .
12.00
6 .
10.00
6 .
15.00
6 .
19.00
6 .
26.00
6 .
24.00
7 .
22.00
7 .
21.00
7 .
12.00
7 .
2.00
7 .
.00
8 .
3.00
8 .
2.00 Extremes
Stem width:
Each leaf:
Leaf
(=<54)
5
6
888999999
000001111111
2222333333
444444555555555
6666666777777777777
88888888888888888999999999
000000000000011111111111
2222222222222223333333
444444444444455555555
666666677777
99
223
(>=85)
10.0
1 case(s)
Figure 10: Stem-and-leaf plot of proportion of time spent walking
The last plot is the boxplot (Figure 11) which has the added advantage of
summarising the distribution. The box is determined by the median (the black line through
the middle), the 25th percentile (lower boundary line) and the 75th percentile (upper
boundary line). This means that 50% of cases will fall inside the box with the length of the
box telling you about the spread of the data.
Figure 11: Boxplot of proportion of time spent walking
If the median is closer to the bottom of the box (not in this case) it means that the data
is positivley skewed. Lines are drawn from the box to values which are the highest and
lowest values that aren’t outliers. You will also notice outlying values are plotted. The
292
numbers represent case numbers (in the PASW data sheet) and when preceded by an o are
outliers (between 1.5 and 3 box-lengths from the upper or lower box edges) whilst values
preceded by an * are extreme values (over 3 box-lengths from the upper or lower box edges).
The 5 outliers identified in this distribution may make you consider a non-parametric
approach with this data although this is not necessarily the case. If using a parametric
approach it would be wise to consider the effect these outliers might have on the subsequent
results (outliers have more effect than non-outliers). If a more conservative non-parametric
approach was used then the box plot is a very useful method of presenting the data (see a side
by side boxplot example in James and Rees, 2008).
4 Conclusion
The techniques presented here have demonstrated the important intermediate stage of
analysing the data prior to applying any statistical procedures. Each procedure offers
advantages over the other techniques and so a comprehensive approach to viewing your data
should be adopted. The key decision to be made concerns whether you adopt a parametric or
non-parametric approach to your data analysis. Convention determines that if you adopt a
parametric approach then mean and standard deviation values should be used to describe your
data. If a non-parametric approach is used then the median and interquartile range are more
suitable although some researchers are resistant to this presumably thinking that the mean and
standard deviation are generally better understood measures.
5 References
Field, A. (2009). Discovering Statistics using SPSS. (3rd Ed). Sage: London.
James, N. & Rees, G.D. (2008). Approach shot accuracy as a performance indicator for US
PGA Tour golf professionals. Annual Review of Golf Coaching 2008, 145-160.
(Also available in a supplement volume of the International Journal of Sports Science
and Coaching, 3, 1, 145-160.)
James, N., Taylor, J. & Stanley, S. (2007). Reliability procedures for categorical data in
Performance Analysis. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 7, 1,
1-11.
Nevill, A., Atkinson, G., Hughes, M.D. & Cooper, S-M. (2002). Statistical methods for
analysing discrete and categorical data recorded in performance analysis. Journal of
Sports Sciences, 20, 10, 829-844.
Nevill, A. & Lane, A. (2007). Why self-report ‘‘Likert’’ scale data should not be logtransformed. Journal of Sports Sciences, 25, 1, 1-2.
Vučković, G., Dežman, B., Perše, M., Kristan, M., Perš, J., Kovačič, S., & James, N. (2010).
An automatic tracking analysis of the movement velocities of national level basketball
guards, forwards and centres. In V. Koprivica and I. Juhas (Eds.), Zbornik radova,
Beograd: Fakultet sporta i fizičkog vaspitanja, pp. 97-101.
293