Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Occupational Morbidity among Municipal Solid Waste Loaders in Mumbai

Social Science Spectrum
Municipal solid waste loaders collect and load waste into waste carrying compactor from different areas of the Mumbai city. Waste loaders are vulnerable to develop communicable and non-communicable disease due to the nature of work. This paper attempts to understand the occupation related morbidities and health seeking behavior of solid waste loaders. A primary survey was conducted with a total 160 municipal waste loaders in M/East ward of Municipal Corporation of Greatem Mumbai. The waste loaders are found to have high prevalence rate of low back pain, shoulder pain and hip/thigh pain in past 12 months. Almost 75 per cent of them reported eye related problems; two-thirds had breathlessness and 42 per cent workers reported injuries in past six months. The years of working, smoking, alcohol consumption and chewing tobacco significantly contribute for raising the prevalence of morbidities. Loaders with higher age, income and years of working spend more on their health treatment. At the outset waste loaders have higher prevalence of injury/accident, skin disease ,respiratory disease, eye disease and musculoskeletal disorders. The municipal corporation should take preventive measures and hold periodical health camps for minimizing the health risk among the waste loaders....Read more
Social Science Spectrum ISSN 2454-2806 Vol. 2, No. 3, September 2016, pp. 195-202 Occupational Morbidity among Municipal Solid Waste Loaders in Mumbai Pradeep Salve and Dhananjay W. Bansod  Abstract Municipal solid waste loaders collect and load waste into waste carrying compactor from different areas of the Mumbai city. Waste loaders are vulnerable to develop communicable and non-communicable disease due to the nature of work. This paper attempts to understand the occupation related morbidities and health seeking behavior of solid waste loaders. A primary survey was conducted with a total 160 municipal waste loaders in M/East ward of Municipal Corporation of Greatem Mumbai. The waste loaders are found to have high prevalence rate of low back pain, shoulder pain and hip/thigh pain in past 12 months. Almost 75 per cent of them reported eye related problems; two-thirds had breathlessness and 42 per cent workers reported injuries in past six months. The years of working, smoking, alcohol consumption and chewing tobacco significantly contribute for raising the prevalence of morbidities. Loaders with higher age, income and years of working spend more on their health treatment. At the outset waste loaders have higher prevalence of injury/accident, skin disease ,respiratory disease, eye disease and musculoskeletal disorders. The municipal corporation should take preventive measures and hold periodical health camps for minimizing the health risk among the waste loaders. Key words: Municipal waste loaders, occupational morbidity, treatment seeking, health expenditure. I. Introduction Outbursting urbanisation resulted in the monolithic production of solid waste materials in towns and metropolitan cities in India. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) generates on an average of 8,500 metric tons of solid waste per day from its 24 administrative wards. Around 30,000 regular employees are associated with the collection and transportation of this waste along with a fleet of 983 municipal and private vehicles making 1,396 trips each day to dispose the waste on landfill areas (Commissioner, 2012; Davis, 2013). Workers physically handle the decaying carcasses of animals, household garbage, human and animal excreta, gully material, infectious and hazardous medical waste and other toxic wastes with their bare hands, which leads to development of communicable as well as non-communicable diseases and disorders among the loaders. Waste loaders are vulnerable at every step for these diseases due to the exposure they have during waste collection from field, transportation of waste and recycling or disposal of waste during working hours. Past numerous cross-sectional studies in developing countries are evidence that workers associated with solid waste collection were likely to have high risk for development of various chronic health problems such as respiratory tract infection, skin diseases, injuries, strains, contusions, fractures, lacerations and musculoskeletal disorders compared to the general workforce (Aweng & Fatt, 2014; Hansen et al., 1997; Inyang, 2007; Lora, James, Huren, & Bean, 1999; Poulsen et al., 1995; Rushton, 2003; Yang et al., 2001). Similarly, studies conducted in India demonstrated that workers associated with the solid waste collection have potential risk for development of chronic respiratory diseases, anemia, hypertension, injuries, eye diseases, skin Pradeep Salve, Doctoral Fellow, Department of Public Health & Mortality Studies, International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai 400 088. E-mail: pradeep8889@gmail.com, pradeep@iips.net  Dhananjay W. Bansod, Associate Professor, Department of Public Health & Mortality Studies, International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai 400 088. Emai: dhananjay@iips.net The suggestions and comments of anonymous reviewers of this journal greatly helped us to improve this manuscript.
September 2016 Social Science Spectrum 196 diseases, nail infections and musculoskeletal disorders compared with the general population (Akolkar et al., 2012; Hambach et al., 2012; Jariwala & Christian, 2013; Jayakrishnan, Jeeja, & Bhaskar, 2013; Neghab, Khodaparast-Kazerouni, Hassanzadeh, & Ahmadzadeh, 2013; Sabde & Zodpey, 2008). Municipal solid waste collectors are not only vulnerable to communicable diseases due to lack of education, poor housing condition and non-availability of proper diet but their daily substance use habits like tobacco consumption, smoking and regular drinking of alcohol also affect their immune system. Previous studies suggested that substance use such as smoking and alcohol consumption is higher among solid waste collectors and drainage cleaners (Mudalige & Dharmathilake, 2000). In developing countries not only health affects the human production capacity but at the same time treatment seeking behaviour leads to financial burden due to high out of pocket expenditure fot treatment. For instance, a majority of population in developing countries pays for hospital care facility through out-of-pocket expenses (OPE) which push them into poverty and OPE is one of the leading factors that causes the burden of health expenditure on an individual/family. To cope with these expenditures, individuals borrowed money from friends and relatives or sold/mortgaged their assets (Bhojani et al., 2012; Saksena & Evans, 2011). The solid waste collectors have a higher burden of health expenditure due to their continuous health problems and risky profession. Workers adopt a combination of savings, selling/mortgage assets or borrow money from available sources as coping strategies. Limited studies have been conducted with municipal solid waste collectors to assess the occupation related morbidities and health seeking behaviour among municipal solid waste loaders in India. Therefore, the present study assesses the waste loading associated morbidities and health seeking behaviours of solid waste loaders in Mumbai. II. Methods and materials The primary survey was conducted with 160 waste loaders working in M/East ward of Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai. For in-depth understanding, five in-depth interviews were conducted with workers who had more than ten years of work experience.The municipal waste loaders are those who collect and load solid waste into waste carrying compactors from assigned areas throughout the 24 municipal wards in the city. During the eight working hours, waste loaders have to collect and load the solid waste from nearly 10 to 15 waste collection spots such as public markets, community dustbins of slums, residential areas, hotels and industrial zones. The data was collected with the help of semi-structured questionnaire which covered the information on demographic, socio-economic and occupational characteristics of waste loaders. Specifically, it included information on morbidities, treatment seeking behaviour, expenditure on health and information related to the protective measures. The interviews were conducted during the working hours at the reporting places of workers (Chowkis) during February to March 2013. The data entry and analyses were in STATA12 (StataCorp, 2015). The multivariate analyses were performed to identify the confounders that lead to raising the morbidities. Permission to conduct the primary survey was obtained from the MCGM and the respondents were assured that the information would be confidential. III. Results The results show that 59 per cent waste loaders working in M/East ward were less than 30 years of age. With regard to education, 63 per cent were educated up to secondary school and 14 per cent were uneducated. Traditionally the cleaning occupation is mainly dominated by socially weaker categories of people in India. They were systematically forced to perform this menial work from generation to generation (Ramaswamy, 2005). It was seen that 82 per cent waste loaders in this study belonged to the scheduled and other backward castes (Table 1). Alcohol consumption was found to be very high among waste loaders. Almost two-thirds of the waste loaders consumed alcohol with smoking (51 per cent) and chewing tobacco (44 per cent).
ISSN 2454-2806 Social Science Spectrum Vol. 2, No. 3, September 2016, pp. 195-202 Occupational Morbidity among Municipal Solid Waste Loaders in Mumbai Pradeep Salve and Dhananjay W. Bansod Abstract Municipal solid waste loaders collect and load waste into waste carrying compactor from different areas of the Mumbai city. Waste loaders are vulnerable to develop communicable and non-communicable disease due to the nature of work. This paper attempts to understand the occupation related morbidities and health seeking behavior of solid waste loaders. A primary survey was conducted with a total 160 municipal waste loaders in M/East ward of Municipal Corporation of Greatem Mumbai. The waste loaders are found to have high prevalence rate of low back pain, shoulder pain and hip/thigh pain in past 12 months. Almost 75 per cent of them reported eye related problems; two-thirds had breathlessness and 42 per cent workers reported injuries in past six months. The years of working, smoking, alcohol consumption and chewing tobacco significantly contribute for raising the prevalence of morbidities. Loaders with higher age, income and years of working spend more on their health treatment. At the outset waste loaders have higher prevalence of injury/accident, skin disease ,respiratory disease, eye disease and musculoskeletal disorders. The municipal corporation should take preventive measures and hold periodical health camps for minimizing the health risk among the waste loaders. Key words: Municipal waste loaders, occupational morbidity, treatment seeking, health expenditure. I. Introduction Outbursting urbanisation resulted in the monolithic production of solid waste materials in towns and metropolitan cities in India. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) generates on an average of 8,500 metric tons of solid waste per day from its 24 administrative wards. Around 30,000 regular employees are associated with the collection and transportation of this waste along with a fleet of 983 municipal and private vehicles making 1,396 trips each day to dispose the waste on landfill areas (Commissioner, 2012; Davis, 2013). Workers physically handle the decaying carcasses of animals, household garbage, human and animal excreta, gully material, infectious and hazardous medical waste and other toxic wastes with their bare hands, which leads to development of communicable as well as non-communicable diseases and disorders among the loaders. Waste loaders are vulnerable at every step for these diseases due to the exposure they have during waste collection from field, transportation of waste and recycling or disposal of waste during working hours. Past numerous cross-sectional studies in developing countries are evidence that workers associated with solid waste collection were likely to have high risk for development of various chronic health problems such as respiratory tract infection, skin diseases, injuries, strains, contusions, fractures, lacerations and musculoskeletal disorders compared to the general workforce (Aweng & Fatt, 2014; Hansen et al., 1997; Inyang, 2007; Lora, James, Huren, & Bean, 1999; Poulsen et al., 1995; Rushton, 2003; Yang et al., 2001). Similarly, studies conducted in India demonstrated that workers associated with the solid waste collection have potential risk for development of chronic respiratory diseases, anemia, hypertension, injuries, eye diseases, skin  Pradeep Salve, Doctoral Fellow, Department of Public Health & Mortality Studies, International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai 400 088. E-mail: pradeep8889@gmail.com, pradeep@iips.net  Dhananjay W. Bansod, Associate Professor, Department of Public Health & Mortality Studies, International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai 400 088. Emai: dhananjay@iips.net The suggestions and comments of anonymous reviewers of this journal greatly helped us to improve this manuscript. September 2016 Social Science Spectrum diseases, nail infections and musculoskeletal disorders compared with the general population (Akolkar et al., 2012; Hambach et al., 2012; Jariwala & Christian, 2013; Jayakrishnan, Jeeja, & Bhaskar, 2013; Neghab, Khodaparast-Kazerouni, Hassanzadeh, & Ahmadzadeh, 2013; Sabde & Zodpey, 2008). Municipal solid waste collectors are not only vulnerable to communicable diseases due to lack of education, poor housing condition and non-availability of proper diet but their daily substance use habits like tobacco consumption, smoking and regular drinking of alcohol also affect their immune system. Previous studies suggested that substance use such as smoking and alcohol consumption is higher among solid waste collectors and drainage cleaners (Mudalige & Dharmathilake, 2000). In developing countries not only health affects the human production capacity but at the same time treatment seeking behaviour leads to financial burden due to high out of pocket expenditure fot treatment. For instance, a majority of population in developing countries pays for hospital care facility through out-of-pocket expenses (OPE) which push them into poverty and OPE is one of the leading factors that causes the burden of health expenditure on an individual/family. To cope with these expenditures, individuals borrowed money from friends and relatives or sold/mortgaged their assets (Bhojani et al., 2012; Saksena & Evans, 2011). The solid waste collectors have a higher burden of health expenditure due to their continuous health problems and risky profession. Workers adopt a combination of savings, selling/mortgage assets or borrow money from available sources as coping strategies. Limited studies have been conducted with municipal solid waste collectors to assess the occupation related morbidities and health seeking behaviour among municipal solid waste loaders in India. Therefore, the present study assesses the waste loading associated morbidities and health seeking behaviours of solid waste loaders in Mumbai. II. Methods and materials The primary survey was conducted with 160 waste loaders working in M/East ward of Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai. For in-depth understanding, five in-depth interviews were conducted with workers who had more than ten years of work experience.The municipal waste loaders are those who collect and load solid waste into waste carrying compactors from assigned areas throughout the 24 municipal wards in the city. During the eight working hours, waste loaders have to collect and load the solid waste from nearly 10 to 15 waste collection spots such as public markets, community dustbins of slums, residential areas, hotels and industrial zones. The data was collected with the help of semi-structured questionnaire which covered the information on demographic, socio-economic and occupational characteristics of waste loaders. Specifically, it included information on morbidities, treatment seeking behaviour, expenditure on health and information related to the protective measures. The interviews were conducted during the working hours at the reporting places of workers (Chowkis) during February to March 2013. The data entry and analyses were in STATA12 (StataCorp, 2015). The multivariate analyses were performed to identify the confounders that lead to raising the morbidities. Permission to conduct the primary survey was obtained from the MCGM and the respondents were assured that the information would be confidential. III. Results The results show that 59 per cent waste loaders working in M/East ward were less than 30 years of age. With regard to education, 63 per cent were educated up to secondary school and 14 per cent were uneducated. Traditionally the cleaning occupation is mainly dominated by socially weaker categories of people in India. They were systematically forced to perform this menial work from generation to generation (Ramaswamy, 2005). It was seen that 82 per cent waste loaders in this study belonged to the scheduled and other backward castes (Table 1). Alcohol consumption was found to be very high among waste loaders. Almost two-thirds of the waste loaders consumed alcohol with smoking (51 per cent) and chewing tobacco (44 per cent). 196 Salve & Bansod Table 1: Background characteristics of waste loaders Characteristics Per cent Age Less than 30 58.7 More than 30 41.3 Mean age 31.8 Education Non-educated 14.4 Up to secondary 62.5 Secondary and above 23.1 Marital status Currently married 85.6 Never married 14.4 Religion Hindu 36.9 Neo-buddhist 50 Others# 13.1 Caste SC/ST/OBC 82.5 Others 17.5 Years of working Less than 5 years 33.1 More than 5years 66.9 Mean 8.2 Income in Rs. Less than 17,000 46.3 Above 17,001 53.7 Mean 15066.9 Household size Less than 4 35 More than 4 65 Mean 5.1 Substance Use Smoking 51.2 Tobacco 44.4 Alcohol 65.6 Total 100.0 Municipal Waste Loaders Number 94 66 23 100 37 137 23 59 80 21 132 28 53 107 74 86 56 104 82 71 105 160 #Others-Muslim and Christian. SC-Scheduled Castes, ST-Scheduled Tribes, OBC-Other Backward Castes. In the present study, prevalence rates of injury/accident, skin disease, respiratory disease, eye disease, gastrointestinal and musculoskeletal disorders were found high among waste loaders (Table 2). Workers reported pain in nine defined anatomical areas due to continuously physical activities of pulling, pushing, lifting and loading community dustbins into waste carrying compactors. Nearly nine out of ten waste loaders reported musculoskeletal disorders in past 12 months. Pain in low back, shoulder and hip/thigh were higher than the other anatomical parts. Similarly, due to direct exposure to the collection of solid waste causes higher prevalence of injury/accident in the past six months. The injury/accident was reported high particularly of laceration (80.6 per cent) due to needles and glass material, fracture (17.6 per cent) and contusion (40.6 per cent) in this period. Additionally, waste loading occupation led to the incidence of skin diseases, respiratory problems and eye infections due to contact with stagnant water, handling waste with inadequate protective measures, exposure to organic dust containing micro-organism, vehicles’ exhaust, and irritant gasses during work. The prevalence of respiratory problems was high among the waste loaders compared with the skin and eye diseases. Specifically, more than 197 September 2016 Social Science Spectrum two-thirds of the waste loaders reported breathlessness (67.5 per cent) and continuous watering (60 per cent) of eyes during the past six months. Table 2: Prevalence of disease/disorder by sub-category among waste loaders during past six months Prevalence Morbidities Number (per cent) Injuries/Accident 87.5 140 Fracture 17.6 28 Laceration* 80.6 129 Contusion 40.6 65 Skin disease 73.1 117 Rashes/Infective 52.5 84 Fungal infection 51.6 82 Respiratory disease 78.8 126 Dust allergy 8.8 14 Asthma 8.8 14 Chronic cough 26.3 42 Running nose 42.5 68 Breathlessness 67.5 108 Eye disease 71.9 115 Eye soreness 12.5 20 Redness 53.1 85 Watering 60.0 96 Itching 46.3 74 Gastrointestinal infections 45.0 72 Loose motion 2.5 4 Gastroenteritis 41.9 67 Leptospirosis 1.9 3 Worm infection 3.1 5 Musculoskeletal disorders# 89.4 143 Neck 26.9 43 Upper back 26.9 43 Shoulder 66.2 106 Elbow 22.5 36 Wrist and hand 23.1 37 Low back 71.2 114 Hip/thigh 61.9 99 Knee 33.1 53 Ankle 30.0 48 Total 160 * Laceration with needles and glass material, #reference period past 12 months. The multivariate logistic regression shows that years of working had significant impact on development of morbidities among workers (Table 3). Workers working more than five years as waste loaders five-time (OR=5.06; p<0.01) are more likely to have injury/accident compared with those worked for less than five years. Similarly, workers working for more than five years are likely to have four times (OR=4.46; p<0.05) and two times (OR=2.27; p<0.05) higher musculoskeletal disorders and skin diseases respectively than those working for less than five years. Substance use among loaders significantly increase the probabilities of morbidness. Workers who consumed alcohol were fourtimes (OR= 4.32; p<0.01) more likely to have injury/ accident compared with non-alcoholic workers. Similarly, waste loaders with smoking habit were three times (OR=3.39; p<0.01) more likely to have eye problems. Chewing tobacco also significantly increased the respiratory, eye and musculoskeletal disorders among waste loaders. 198 Salve & Bansod Municipal Waste Loaders Table 3: Odds ratio showing association between major morbidities and background characteristics among waste loaders Injury/ GastroCharacteristics Skin Respiratory Eye MSDs# accident intestinal Years of working Less than 5® More than 5 5.06*** 2.27** 2.06* 1.65 4.46** 1.48 (1.43-17.84) (0.97-5.29) (0.52-5.13) (0.68-3.99) (0.69-28.60) (0.67-3.25) Years of schooling Less than 10® 10 and above 1.00 1.12 1.31 1.07 0.78 1.35 (0.32-3.08) (0.49-2.52) (0.54-3.13) (0.46-2.48) (0.16-3.72) (0.66-2.74) Smoking No® Yes 2.32 1.91* 1.81 3.39*** 2.85 0.99 (0.66-8.11) (0.84-4.36) (0.74-4.40) (1.47-7.82) (0.37-21.59) (0.49-1.96) Alcohol No® Yes 4.32*** 1.07 1.15 1.66 2.77 1.21 (1.30-14.33) (0.46-2.47) (0.47-2.80) (0.73-3.74) (0.46-16.36) (0.58-2.51) Tobacco No® Yes 1.72 2.03* 2.33** 1.91* 7.49*** 1.54 (0.55-5.31) (0.92-4.45) (0.99-5.49) (0.86-4.22) (0.82-68.45) (0.79-2.97) Family size <4® members >4 members 0.50 0.84 0.96 2.27** 2.47 1.45 (0.14-1.66) (0.36-1.89) (0.40-2.28) (1.02-5.05) (0.48-12.65) (0.71-2.95) # Musculoskeletal disorders in past 12 months; the model additionally adjusted for sge, marrital status and caste. Workers were not only vulnerable for developing occupational morbidities but at the same time burdened by out of pocket expenditure while seeking treatment. Table 4 provides treatment seeking behaviour and mean expenditure of waste loaders by socio-economic and occupational characteristics. The mean health expenditure of workers was positively associated with age, years of working, income and household size. For seeking health treatment at the young age workers prefer to visit private health facilities but with increase in age their place of treatment changes. For instance, more than 50 per cent workers aged less than 30 years visited private health facility compared with the 47 per cent workers of more than 30 years. The expenditure on health treatment increases with increase of age. Similarly, with increase in working years, waste loaders prefer the government facility for seeking treatment compared with the private facility. Waste loaders working for more than five years in the solid waste department spend three times higher for treatment seeking compared with those who had less than five years of working experience. The analysis also shows that among workers who had above Rs. 17,000 of monthly salary, 53.5 went to private facilities and spent more than Rs. 3,000 on treatment in the past six months. No difference was found while considering the health expenditure of loaders who were habitual to substance use. IV. Discussion In the present study, the mean age of waste loaders was 32 years along with mean eight years of working experience. Majority of the workers were educated upto the secondary education, whereas about 15 per cent were non-literate. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai has institutionlized the age-old practice of cleaning where selected castes were enforced to do this menial cleaning. This system is sustained form generation to generation due to the caste based process of recruitment as a municipal worker. In the present study, more than 80 per cent of waste loaders were belong to the scheduled castes. The work of solid waste loading is highly associated 199 September 2016 Social Science Spectrum with the substance use. The alcoholism and smoking habits are found to be more common, and they work as anesthesia during the working hours. Due to the exposure of waste loading work, workers were vulnerable to the developemnt of communicable as well as non-communicable diseases/disorders. Table 4: Treatment seeking behaviour and mean health expenditure of waste loaders by socio-economic and occupational characteristics. No Govt. Private Mean expenditure Characteristics Number treatment (per cent) (per cent) Rs. (SD) Age Less than 30 years 8.5 39.4 52.1 1543 (2384) 94 More than 30 years 3.0 50.0 47.0 4201 (10982) 66 Education Non-educated 0.0 60.9 39.1 3682 (7807) 23 Up to secondary 7.0 44.0 49.0 2989 (8472) 100 Secondary & above 8.1 32.4 59.5 1045 (1326) 37 Marital status Currently married 5.1 44.5 50.3 2887 (7894) 137 Never married 13.0 39.1 47.8 1161 (2217) 23 Religion Hindu 8.5 40.7 50.8 2158 (4338) 59 Neo-Buddhist 6.2 45.0 48.7 3225 (9648) 21 Others# 0.0 47.6 52.4 1761 (2641) 80 Caste SC/ST/OBC 7.6 43.1 49.2 2827 (8005) 132 Others 0.0 46.4 53.6 1757 (2854) 28 Years of working Less than 5 years 11.3 35.8 52.8 1050 (2056) 53 More than 5years 3.7 47.6 48.6 3426 (8807) 107 Income Less than Rs. 17,000 9.5 44.6 45.9 1699 (4081) 74 Above Rs. 17,001 3.5 43.0 53.5 3448 (9270) 86 Household size Less than 4 members 5.4 46.4 48.2 1865 (2768) 56 More than 4 members 6.7 42.3 50.9 3056 (8906) 104 Substance use No addiction 15.4 30.8 53.8 2869 (6461) 26 Any one 9.7 51.6 38.7 2037 (3805) 31 Two and above 2.9 44.7 52.4 2763 (8373) 103 Total 6.3 43.7 50 160 #Others-Muslim and Christian; SD-Standard Deviation; Substances- Tobacco, Smoking and Alcohol; SC-Scheduled Castes, ST-Scheduled Tribes, OBC-Other Backward Castes, Govt.-Government The study furhter highlights the high prevalence rate of occupation associated morbidities among waste collectors in given reference period. Mainly waste loaders were more vulnerable to the development of musculoskeletal disorders due to the continuous physical activities. Almost 90 per cent workers reported pain in nine defined anatomical areas during past 12 months. Specifically, pain in the low back (71.2 per cent), shoulder (66.2 per cent), and hip/thigh (61.9 per cent) were higher than the other musculoskeletal regions. Similarly, almost nine out of ten waste loaders suffered with injury/accident in past six months. Laceration due to needles and glass material dumped in open community dust bins were found to be common among waste loaders than fracture and contusion. Manul handiling of solid waste and exposure of various pollutants causes skin disease, respiratory problems and eye infection among workers. The problem of breathlessness was observed to be very high among waste loaders compared with the other health concerns. This may be due to the direct exposure to toxic gasses released from the garbage 200 Salve & Bansod Municipal Waste Loaders compactors while loading and compressing waste. While loading the solid waste into garbage compactors, a loader has to stand behind the vehicle closely where compactor constrict the waste material which emits various gasses. This process causes various problems including redness, itching and continuous watering of eyes. The multivariate logistic regression analysis shows that the years of working and substance use had significant impact on development of morbidities among workers. As the prevalence of morbidities were high among waste loaders, the expenditure on the health seeking involved financial burden. The health expenditure was increasing with age, years of working, income and household size of waste loaders. For instance, waste loaders working for more than five years in the solid waste department tend to spend higher on treatment compared with those who had less than five years of working experience. There are studies to show that municipal workers associated with solid waste collection and disposal tend to develop higher morbidities compared with the general population. The survey conducted among solid waste collectors in Ghana studied the pre- and post- effect of joining work in the solid waste department and suggested that in the post joining period 88 per cent reported neck pain and 79 per cent developed the low back pain compared with the 12.4 per cent and 21per cent respectively (Friedrich, Cermak, & Heiller, 2000). Likewise, the cross-section study conducted with 313 solid waste workers in Kerala highlighted that the higher prevalence of accident (22 per cent), injury (73.2 per cent), respiratory and eye diseases (ranged from 21 per cent to 47 per cent) (Jayakrishnan et al., 2013). Initially the mechanization of solid waste management department helps to reduce the workload of workers, but at the same time it increases the risk of accident and injuries among them. The non-service vehicles like garbage compactors and mini-trucks were one of the main reason for injuries and accidents according to the waste loaders. The finding suggests that,as waste loaders were more habitual for substance use like alcohol consumption, smoking and chewing tobacco, the municipal corporation must take the initiative to reduce the substance use through taking preventive measures and introducing awarness programmes. Additionally, the municipal corporation may provide mobile medical service at the work places throughout the 24 municipal wards in Mumbai which can help to increase the accessibility of the treatment seeking behaviour. At the outset, the Municipal Corporation has to develop some policies and programmes to minimize the health risk and to improve the life standard of waste loading workers. The health of municipal workers continuously deteriorated after the service which leads to the long-term disability in post-retirement age causing premature death. In addition, further research may extend to explore the issues of out-source workers in solid waste collection work. Compared to the formal municipal employees, the heath of contract workers is worse. Out-sourced workers are mainly from Non-Government Organization (NGOs) working without job security at low wages. While hiring the out-source labours, the Municipal Corporation leaves out the responsibilities for providing necessary services such as protective measure, medical care and minimum salary for contract workers. Limitations of the study In this study, diseases and morbidities are mainly self-reported which may have been overor under-reported. There may be a seasonal variation in the prevalence rate of morbidities as the nature of waste loading occupation changes according to the seasons.The survey was conducted in one out of 24 municipal wards in Mumbai and hence the result may be generalised with caution. References Akolkar, A., Padmavathi, S. R. R., Sankar, S., Vijayalakshmi, P. R. T., Subhashini, A., & Kalpana, B. (2012). Respiratory functions of conservancy workers working in solid waste management sector of Chennai, India. F1000Research, 1:67. Aweng, E. R., & Fatt, C. C. (2014). Survey of Potential Health Risk of Rubbish Collectors from the Garbage Dump Sites in Kelantan, Malaysia. Asian Journal of Applied Sciences, 2(1), 36–44. 201 September 2016 Social Science Spectrum Bhojani, U., Thriveni, B., Devadasan, R., Munegowda, C., Narayanan Devadasan, P. K., & Criel, B. (2012). Out-of-pocket healthcare payments on chronic conditions impoverish urban poor in Bangalore, India. BMC Public Health, 12(1), 1–14. BioMed Central. Commissioner, M. (2012). Administration Report of Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai: CitySuburbs and Exteded Suburb. (Municipal Printing Press Mumbai.). Davis, B. (2013). Solid waste management in Mumbai. In Mukherjee, N. (Ed.) Understanding our civic issues. Mumbai. Friedrich, M., Cermak, T., & Heiller, I. (2000). Spinal troubles in sewage workers: epidemiological data and work disability due to low back pain. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health, 73(4), 245–254. Hambach, R., Droste, J., François, G., Weyler, J., Soom, U. V., Schryver, A. D., Vanoeteren, J., et al. (2012). Work-related health symptoms among compost facility workers: a cross-sectional study. Archives of Public Health, 70(1), 1–5. Hansen, J., Ivens, U. I., Breum, N. O., Nielsen, M., Würtz, H., Poulsen, O. M., & Ebbehøj, N. (1997). Respiratory Symptoms among Danish Waste Collectors. Ann Agric Environ Med, 4, 69–74. Inyang, M. P. (2007). Health and safety risks amongst the municipal solid waste collectors in Port Harcourt Metropolis of the Niger delta region of Nigeria. International Conference “Waste Management, Environmental Geotechnology and Global Sustainable Development.” Slovenia. Jariwala, N. D., & Christian, R. A. (2013). A Study of Prevalance of Morbities in Door to Door Waste Collecting Workers of Surat City, Gujarat. Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, 4(4), 123–127. Jayakrishnan, T., Jeeja, M., & Bhaskar, R. (2013). Occupational health problems of municipal solid waste management workers in India. International Journal of Environmental Health Engineering, 2(1), 42. Lora, F., James, E., Huren, A., & Bean, J. (1999). Occupational health and safety amongst municipal solid waste workers in Florida. Waste Management & Research, 17(5), 369–377. Mudalige, O. M. D. C. S., & Dharmathilake, A. D. (2000). Health problems among Colombo Municipal Council workers. Faculty of Medicine,. University of Colombo. Neghab, M., Khodaparast-Kazerouni, F., Hassanzadeh, J., & Ahmadzadeh, F. (2013). Assessment of Respiratory Symptoms and Lung Functional Impairments among a Group of Garbage Collectors. International Journal of Occupational Hygiene, 5(2), 76–81. Poulsen, O. M., Breum, N. O., Ebbeh, N., Hansen, M., Ivens, U. I., Lelieveld, V., Malmros, P., et al. (1995). Collection of domestic waste. Review of occupational health problems and their possible causes. The Science of the total environment, 170(1–2), 1–19. Ramaswamy, G. (2005). India stinking: Manual scavengers in Andhra Pradesh and their work. Chennai: Navayana. Rushton, L. (2003). Health hazards and waste management. British Medical Bulletin, 68(1), 183–197. Sabde, Y. D., & Zodpey, S. P. (2008). A study of morbidity pattern in street sweepers: A cross-sectional study. Indian Journal of Community Medicine, 33(4), 224–228. Saksena, P., & David B. Evans. (2011). Impact of out-of-pocket payments for treatment of noncommunicable diseases in developing countries:: A review of literature, Discussion, 2(9). World Health Orgnization. StataCorp. (2015). Stata Satistical Software: Release 14. College Station: TX: StataCorp LP. Yang, C. Y., Chang, W. T., Chuang, H. Y., Tsai, S. S., Wu, T. N., & Sung, F. C. (2001). Adverse health effects among household waste collectors in Taiwan. Environmental Research, 85(3), 195–199. 202
Keep reading this paper — and 50 million others — with a free Academia account
Used by leading Academics
Madhusudan Subedi
Patan academy of health sciences
Garumma T Feyissa
Drexel University
Trias Mahmudiono
Universitas Airlangga
Werner Soors
Institute of Tropical Medicine, Antwerp