Defence Life Science Journal, Vol. 3, No. 2, April 2018, pp. 172-176, DOI : 10.14429/dlsj.3.12573
2018, DESIDOC
Evaluation of Physiological Parameters in Response to Endurance Exercise of
Zanskar Ponies Adapted to High Altitude of Ladakh Region
Saket Kumar Niranjan#, Ranjit S Kataria#, Monika Sodhi#, Vijay K Bharti$, Bhuvnesh Kumar$,
Ajay Garg!, MC Yadav@, Ankita Sharma#, Prince Vivek$, Arup Giri$ and Manishi Mukesh#,*
#
ICAR-National Bureau of Animal Genetics Resources, Karnal-132001, Haryana, India
DRDO-Defense Institute of High Altitude Research, Leh-194101, Jammu and Kashmir, India
!
RVS, HQ14 CORPS, Jammu & Kashmir, India
@
16 MFVH, Zanskar Ponies Breeding Unit, Partapur, Jammu & Kashmir, India
*
E-mail: mmukesh26@gmail.com
$
ABSTRACT
Zanskar pony, a native horse breed of Ladakh mainly used for transportation in Trans-Himalayan region of India,
is well adapted to high altitude hypobaric hypoxia environment. Due to extreme conditions of the Ladakh region,
better endurance of these ponies under hypoxic and extreme cold conditions is of utmost concern for their recruitment
in Indian Army. In the present study, 12 young trained Zanskar ponies were evaluated during endurance exercise at
an altitude of 3292 m above mean sea level. The animals were subjected to carriage transport with 65-70 kg load
or riding on a track of 5-6 km. Physiological parameters viz., pulse rate (PR), heart rate (HR), rectal temperature
(RT), respiratory rate (RR) and oxygen saturation (SaO2) were recorded in Zanskar ponies during pre-exercise
(T0), post- exercise (T1) and post recovery (T2, 2 h post resting) stages. Results showed marked increase in PR, HR,
RR and RT post exercise time points. The mean values of PR increased from 49.83±4.62 to 73.67±21.54 per min,
HR from 48±13.60 to 75±15.82 beats/min, RR from 37.83±9.70 to 57.67±13.48 per min and RT from 99.62±0.34
101.04±0.53 °F from pre stress to post endurance stress. The mean SaO2 level reduced significantly (88.58±6.75
at T0 versus 64.00±18.70 at T1 and 54.42±14.79 at T2) post exercise. This indicated limited availability of arterial
oxygen for tissues which could be vital factor for adverse change in some of physio-biochemical parameters. Though
the trend of physiological response was similar for all the 12 animals, still variation at individual animal level was
observed during endurance stress. In future, some of these physiological parameters along with biochemical and
molecular parameters could be evaluated as potential biomarkers in selecting ponies with superior endurance trait
specifically under hypoxic conditions.
Keywords: Zanskar pony; Endurance; Physiological response; Hypoxia; High altitude adaptation; Ladakh
1.
INTRODUCTION
Ladakh, one of the world’s highest inhabited regions, is
located at the northern most Trans-Himalayan part of India.
It is a cold-arid desert at over 3000 meters mean see level
(MSL), having very harsh climate characterised by extreme
temperature (-40 oC in winter and 35 oC in summer); low
relative humidity, precipitation (80-300 mm) and oxygen level
(nearly 60-70 percent of the oxygen concentration at sea level);
high UV radiations and wind erosion. To have survival and
adaptability at cold as well as hypobaric hypoxic conditions,
the human and other species inhabiting such harsh environment
have developed certain unique physiological adaptation
including comparatively higher aerobic performance, low
hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstrictor response, better levels
of oxygen saturation, high hemoglobin (Hb) level, increased
flow of oxygen carrying blood and higher oxygen diffusion
from blood to tissues/cells1-3. Positive selection and selective
Received : 16 May 2017, Revised : 18 December 2017
Accepted : 25 December 2017, Online published : 20 March 2018
172
sweeps at certain candidate genes related to hypoxic pathway,
Hb phenotypes and other blood characteristics is the probable
genetic basis of high altitude adaptation in human and other
species4-9. Through constant evolutionary pressure and natural
selection, human and several other species get well adapted to
cold hypobaric hypoxic conditions10-12.
In difficult terrain of Ladakh region (high altitude, cold
and arid conditions), where land resources are meager, animal
wealth plays an important role in the life of the local people.
Common livestock genetic resources in Ladakh area include
cattle, sheep, goat, horse, donkey, double hump camel and
yak. These livestock species are well adapted to hypoxia, low
temperature, high ultra violet exposure and survival during
scarce nutrition in lean period. The native animals have
developed certain physical changes like small stature, large
hair fur, and thick skin so as to combat with tough environment.
Most of these animals have unique circulatory adaptability with
enlarged lungs, heart and larger concentration of red blood cells
to accommodate the hypobaric-hypoxic environment. Amongst
the livestock species, ponies along with mules hold special
NIRANJAN, et al.: DEF. LIFE SCI. J., VOL. 3, NO. 2, APRIL 2018, DOI : 10.14429/dlsj.3.12573
significance as these are the main pack animals for the local
people and the troops in this region. Zanskar, a recognised pony
breed of the India, is distributed mainly in Zanskar valley lying
between 3500 m to 7000 m MSL altitudes in Ladakh region.
These ponies are well adapted to hypobaric-hypoxia conditions
at high altitude. Over the years these ponies are known for
their sure footedness, ruggedness, ability to withstand extreme
cold climates, work tirelessly, and carry loads on hilly tracks.
These ponies are better suited than mules for snow-bound
high-altitude areas and can carry 50-60 kg load. The Zanskar
ponies are well-built, with medium height (120-140 cm),
predominant eyes, heavy and long tail, and uniform gait. The
body hairs are fine, long and glossy. These ponies are highly
docile, resistant to diseases and can survive on local feed and
fodder, in case of emergencies, can be deployed immediately
without any acclimatisation13. Further, these ponies require
least management practices and have less feed consumption.
Although Zanskar ponies are very important for the
region, the population of the Zanskar ponies is showing
decline in recent few years and is in the category of endangered
breed. The current population of Zanskar ponies is only nine
thousands in Ladakh (National livestock census, 2012). The
Zanskar ponies seem to be evolved and adapted over the years
under harsh conditions of Ladakh and are resource for unique
genes or gene combinations. These ponies have developed
functional and structural adaptations/ acclimatisation
like development of muscle mass, a high proportion of Table 1.
muscle fibers, high densities of mitochondria, ability to
increase oxygen-carrying capacity of blood, buffering
Animal
and transport capacity for CO2, intramuscular storage
No.
of energy substrates (in particular glycogen), lactate
YS-032
depletion capacity of the liver and muscles, and efficient
ZP-065
14,15
use of evaporation for thermoregulation . Loss of
ZP-078
Zanskar ponies could result in loss of these gene(s)
ZP-082
forever. The deployment of these ponies as pack animals
ZP-083
for the army logistic support in Trans Himalayan region
ZP-086
will help in revival of this breed in the region. It will also
ZP-088
lead to significant saving to the state since movement
ZP- 089
of pack animals from plains is a costly affair and not
ZP-090
advisable because they not only require special feed and
ZP-091
management but need time to get acclimatised to harsh
conditions of Ladakh.
ZP-092
Hence, selection of Zanskar ponies with efficient
ZP-093
load carrying capacity and high endurance would be
useful for meeting the demands of army and local
people, conservation of important livestock resource with
adaptation to cold hypoxic conditions, survival at minimum
feed and fodder, and low management cost. Therefore, present
study was undertaken to investigate the physiological responses
to endurance stress and load carrying ability of Zanskar ponies
so as to understand their performance traits at higher altitude.
2. MATERIAL AND METHODS
2.1 Location and Animals
Under the study, 12 Zanskar ponies maintained at Zanskar
Ponies Breeding Unit of Siachen Vets, Remount Veterinary
Services (RVS), Partapur (Leh) at an altitude of 3292 m above
MSL were subjected to endurance exercise. Parental lines of
these ponies were taken over from DIHAR Zanskar research
section, Leh for further breeding through continuous selection.
Permission for conducting the experiment was obtained from
RVC wing of Indian Military. A total of 12 ponies -5 males
and 7 females based on their age, similar body size, physical
fitness and temperament were selected for the experimentation
(Table 1). All of the ponies, except twoYS-032 and ZP-065
were young, about 3 years of age. The selected animals were
examined for their sound health, physical fitness and any injury.
All of the ponies were moderately built and docile. However,
male ponies were slightly larger in body size compared to
females. The typical Zanskar pony animals are depicted in Fig.
1. These ponies were under the training with medium regimen
for load carriage in high altitude driven hypoxic conditions for
about 6 months. The experiment was conducted at noon in the
month of August 2015, characterised by comfortable ambient
temperature in day time of 30-32 0C and moderate air velocity.
The ambient temperature and humidity were also recorded
at an interval of 30 mins during endurance test using digital
hygro-thermometer.
2.2 Exercise Regimen
Out of these 12 animals, 5 animals were given endurance
exercise with 60 kg of loads, 6 animals were subjected for
riding stress with a rider weighing about 70 kg. One pony- YSDetails of Zanskar ponies included in the experiment at Siachen
Vets of Remount Veterinary Services, Partapur
Sex
Stage
Birth
Male
Female
Male
Male
Female
Female
Female
Female
Male
Female
Female
Male
Geld (castrated adult)
Mare (adult)
Colt (Young)
Colt (Young)
Filly (Young )
Filly (Young)
Filly (Young)
Filly (Young)
Colt (Young)
Filly (Young)
Filly (Young)
Colt (Young)
16.04.2010
25.05.2011
28.03.2012
19.04.2012
30.04.2012
18.05.2012
28.06.2012
19.07.2012
22.07.2012
22.07.2012
31.07.2012
25.08.2012
Endurance
Exercise
Without load
Rider
Rider
Rider
Load
Rider
Load
Load
Load
Load
Rider
Rider
Figure 1. Depiction of facial features of typical Zanskar
ponies.
173
NIRANJAN, et al.: DEF. LIFE SCI. J., VOL. 3, NO. 2, APRIL 2018, DOI : 10.14429/dlsj.3.12573
032 was allowed to travel with no loading stress, as a control.
Animals were allowed to travel in group of two at an interval of
10 min between the groups and were allowed to return back in
same order and nearly at the same interval. None of the animal
showed any discomfort during loading or riding and completed
the trip without any interruption. All the animals were allowed
to travel on a track of 5 km in hilly terrain with slightly uphill
slope (track meant for endurance exercise), which took about
50 min to travel to and fro journey.
2.3 Physiological Parameters
Various physiological parameters pulse rate (PR), heart
rate (HR), rectal temperature, (RT), respiratory rate (RR) and
oxygen saturation (SaO2) were recorded in Zanskar ponies
just before initiating the exercise regimen (pre-endurance
stress, T0), immediately after completion of exercise (postendurance stress, T1) and 2 h after exercise (post recovery
period, T2). Oxygen saturation was taken by holding the pulse
oximeter (Masimo RAD-9 model, Massimo make) on the ear
tip, whereas, pulse rate was recorded by palpating coccygeal
artery at the base of the tail. Respiration rate was recorded by
observing the movement of belly and thorax for one min. Heart
rate was measured by placing a stethoscope against the chest of
the horse under the elbow (olecranon) for a min and recording
the value as beats/min. Rectal temperature was measured by
inserting the tip of digital thermometer into the rectum until it
gave the beep sound.
2.4 Data Analysis
Means and standard error were calculated for each of
the parameter. Statistical difference for each parameter was
determined by Analysis of variance 1 (ANOVA1) followed by
Tukey’s multiple comparison tests.
3.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The endurance exercise regimen carried out
during the experimentation resulted in modulation of
various physiological parameters in Zanskar ponies
at different stages. Various physiological responses
like pulse rate (PR), heart rate (HR), respiration rate
(RR), rectal temperature (RT) and oxygen saturation
(SaO2) during pre and post stress of endurance test
for individual animal were recorded. Except for SaO2,
there was marked increase in various physiological
parameters from pre stress (T0) to post stress (T1) stages
in all the 12 animals included in the study. As expected,
changes in physiological parameters were least in
control animal as it was allowed to travel without
any load carriage. Interestingly, the physiological
responses were not sex specific, as animals of both of
the sexes showed similar trend and extreme values for
the observed parameters specifically PR, HR and RR.
While accounting for all the animals together,
there was significant (p<0.05) increase in mean values
of various physiological parameters (PR, HR, RT
and RR) except SaO2 during post endurance exercise
(Fig. 2). The mean value of PR during pre-stress state
across 12 animals was 49.83±4.62 per min while
174
immediately post stress, the mean PR increased to 73.67±21.54,
and returned to 52±6.34, close to the pre-stress range after 2 h
of resting period (Fig. 2 (a)). The mean value of PR increased
significantly (p<0.05) by ~1.5 times at T1 as compared to T0,
indicating the effect of endurance stress in the animals.
Similar trend was observed for HR values with significant
(p<0.05) increase in mean values from 48±13.60 beats/
min in pre stress stage to 75±15.82 beats/min in post stress
stage and returned to 49.67±5.51 beats/min in post recovery
stage (Fig. 2 (b)). The mean values of HR also increased by
~ 1.5 times at T1 as compared toT0. RR mean value increased
from 37.83±9.70 per min at T0 to 57.67±13.48 per min at T1
and 49.33±5.21 per min at T2 (Fig. 2c). The RT values also
increased significantly (p<0.05) during post endurance stress
with values of 99.62±0.34 at T0, 101.04±0.53 at T1 and
100.03±0.43 at T2 time points (Fig. 2d). On the other hand,
the mean SaO2 level reduced significantly (p<0.05) after post
endurance stress. Its value decreased from 88.58±6.75 at T0,
to 69.81±18.70 at T1 and further to 54.14±14.79 at T2 time
points (Fig. 2(e)). The reason for increase in physiological
parameters post stress could be explained by the fact that
during exercise there is increase in body core temperature
resulting in enhanced blood flow towards periphery including
skeletal muscle, so as to dissipate heat through skin to meet
the enhanced energy requirements. Hence, HR, RR and other
physiological parameters get enhanced during post stress. In
Zanskar ponies, the increase in HR, PR and RR post exercise
may indicate the increased requirement of blood oxygen to the
tissues under hypoxic conditions.
The resting values of RT and HR in Zanskar ponies were
within the normal range of 99.5-101.5ºF and 26-42 beats/min
for equines as suggested by Evans and Rose16. However, the
resting stage mean value of Zanskar ponies showed tangible
differences with exotic horses reported in one of the previous
study17. In Zanskar ponies, the mean value of HR rate at
Figure 2. Physiological parameters of Zanskar ponies (ZP) during pre and
post stress; and post endurance stress recovery. a) Pulse rate, b)
heart rate, c) respiration rate, d) rectal temperature and e) oxygen
saturation. Values are expressed as means± SE. Different letters
indicate significant differences (P<0.05).
NIRANJAN, et al.: DEF. LIFE SCI. J., VOL. 3, NO. 2, APRIL 2018, DOI : 10.14429/dlsj.3.12573
resting stage was 48±13.60 beats/min whereas in exotic
horses, the mean value was 37.3±6.1 beats/min. Similarly,
RR mean values in Zanskar ponies was 37.83±9.70 per min,
while in exotic thoroughbred horse the mean RR value was
42.9±16.7 per min. Further, mean RT values of Zanskar ponies
(99.62±0.34) at resting stage were also different from that of
exotic high thoroughbred horse (101.0±1.3). This difference in
basic physiological parameters between the two horse types
could be due to their genetic differences or due to the distinct
environments to which they are adapted.
The oxygen saturation level measured across T0, T1 and T2
stages is another important physiological parameter especially
at higher altitude where atmospheric pressure remains low. The
mean SaO2 level showed significant reduction post exercise
(88.58 at T0 versus 64.00 at T1 and 54.42 at T2), indicating
limited availability of arterial oxygen. It is interesting to
note that PR, HR and RT at post recovery stage were not
significantly higher than pre-stress condition. However,
RR was significantly higher than pre-stress condition. This
phenomenon is coupled with significantly lowest SaO2 level
indicates that two hours period for recovery from stress induced
condition is not sufficient. Since, oxygen saturation is one of
the critical parameters indicating various changes in physiobiochemical markers in animals experiencing endurance stress,
under hypoxic conditions. Therefore, it would be interesting
to conduct further research by including more number of
animals to evaluate the association of HR, RR, PR, RT and
SaO2 with endurance fitness in ponies working at high altitude
hypoxic conditions. Further, efforts are underway to generate
biochemical, hematological and molecular data (identify
candidate genes and associated pathways) in order to evaluate
various parameters and understand the overall mechanism of
endurance stress in Zanskar horses.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
REFERENCES
1. Gilbert-Kawai, E.T.; Milledge, J.S.; Grocott, M.P.
& Martin, D.S. King of the mountains: Tibetan and
Sherpa physiological adaptations for life at high
altitude. Physiology, 2014, 29(6), 388-402.
2. Wu, T. & Kayser, B. High altitude adaptation in
Tibetans. High Alt. Med. Biol., 2006, 7, 193-208.
Beall, C.M. Two routes to functional adaptation:
Tibetan and Andean high-altitude natives. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci., 2007, 104(Suppl 1), 8655-60.
3. Suzuki, K.; Kizaki, T.; Hitomi, Y.; Nukita, M.;
Kimoto, K.; Miyazawa, N.; Kobayashi, K.; Ohnuki,
Y. & Ohno, H. Genetic variation in hypoxia-inducible
factor 1alpha and its possible association with high
altitude adaptation in Sherpas. Med. Hypotheses,
2003, 61, 385-9.
4. Simonson, T.S.; Yang, Y.; Huff, C.D.; Yun, H.; Qin,
G.; Witherspoon, D.J.; Bai, Z.; Lorenzo, F.R.; Xing,
J.; Jorde, L.B.; Prchal, J.T. & Ge, R. Genetic evidence
for high-altitude adaptation in Tibet. Science, 2010,
329, 72-5.
5. Beall, C.M.; Cavalleri, G.L.; Deng, L.; Elston,
R.C.; Gao, Y.; Knight, J.; Li, C.; Li, J.C.; Liang,
Y.; McCormack, M. & Montgomery, H.E. Natural
14.
15.
16.
selection on EPAS1 (HIF2alpha) associated with low
hemoglobin concentration in Tibetan highlanders.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 2010, 107, 11459-64.
Yi, X.; Liang, Y.; Huerta-Sanchez, E.; Jin, X.; Cuo,
Z.X.P.; Pool, J.E.; Xu, X.; Jiang, H.; Vinckenbosch,
N.; Korneliussen, T.S. & Zheng, H. Sequencing of
50 human exomes reveals adaptation to high altitude.
Science, 2010, 329, 75-8.
Peng, Y.; Yang, Z.; Zhang, H.; Cui, C.; Qi, X.; Luo,
X.; Tao, X.; Wu, T.; Chen, H.; Shi, H. & Su, B.
Genetic variations in Tibetan populations and high
altitude adaptation at the Himalayas. Mol. Biol.
Evol., 2010, 28, 1075-81.
Qiu, Q.; Zhang, G.; Ma, T.; Qian, W.; Wang, J. &
Ye, Z. The yak genome and adaptation to life at
high altitude. Nat. Genet., 2012, 44: 946-9.
Yan, Y.B.; Huang, W.W. & Zhang, D. New evidence
for human occupation the northern Tibetan plateau,
China during the late Pleistocene. Chin. Sci. Bull.,
2007, 52, 2675-9.
Wu, T. The Qinghai-Tibetan plateau: how high do
Tibetans live? High Alt. Med. Biol., 2001, 2, 48999.
Beall, C.M. Human adaptability studies at high
altitude: research designs and major concepts during
fifty years of discovery. Am. J. Hum. Biol., 2013,
25, 141-7.
Venkatesan, G.; Deshmukh, P.B.; Biswas, A.; Bharti,
V.K. & Srivastava, R.B. Zanskar ponies: Packers
and movers on the rugged terrain. In Innovations in
Agro Animal Technologies, edited by R.B. Srivastava
& W. Selvamurthy. Satish Serial Publishing House,
Delhi, India. 2011. pp. 234-45.
Hodgson, D.R.; Davis, R.E. & McConaghy, F.F.
Thermoregulation in the horse in response to exercise.
Br. Vet. J., 1994, 150, 219-34.
Rivero, J.L. & Henckel, P. Muscle biopsy index
for discriminating between endurance horses with
different performance records. Res. Vet. Sci., 1996,
61, 49-54.
Evans, D.L. & Rose, R.J. Cardiovascular and respiratory
responses in thorough bred-horses during treadmill
exercise. J. Experimental Biol., 1988, 134, 397408.
Hulugalla, W.M.S.W.; Perera, E.R.K. & Wijayagunawardane,
M.P.B. A study on basic physiological parameters and
their response to exercise of exotic horses (Equas
cabellus) kept under Sri Lankan Conditions. Trop.
Agri. Res., 2012, 23(4), 309-18.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Authors are thankful to Zanskar Ponies Breeding Unit of
Siachen Vets, Remount Veterinary Services (RVS), Partapur
(Leh) for all logistic support to conduct this study. Authors are
also thankful to Defense Institute of High Altitude Research
(DRDO), Ministry of Defense, Govt. of India for the financial
support.
175
NIRANJAN, et al.: DEF. LIFE SCI. J., VOL. 3, NO. 2, APRIL 2018, DOI : 10.14429/dlsj.3.12573
CONTRIBUTORS
Dr Manishi Mukesh, Principal Scientist and ICAR National
Fellow at Animal Biotechnology Division, ICAR-NBAGR,
Karnal.
He has conceived the study, executed the experimental plan,
and prepared the manuscript.
Dr Saket Kumar Niranjan, Senior Scientist in Division of
Animal Genetics and Breeding NBAGR, Karnal.
He has contributed in endurance trial and in collection of
physiological data.
Dr Ranjit S Kataria, Principal Scientist and Head, Animal
Biotechnology Division, NBAGR, Karnal.
He has contributed in animal trial and in collection of physiological
data.
Dr Monika Sodhi is Principal Scientist at Animal Biotechnology
Division, ICAR-NBAGR, Karnal.
She has contributed in planning of experiment and manuscript
preparation.
Dr Vijaya K Bharti is Scientist D in DIHAR-DRDO, Leh.
He has helped in planning and coordinating the animal trial.
Dr Bhuvnesh Kumar, Ex-Director DIHAR-DRDO, Leh.
He has coordinated and provided all facilities for the study.
Mr Ajay Garg, Director RVS, HQ14 CORPS, C/o-56 APO.
He has contributed in planning and execution of animal
trial.
Mr M.C. Yadav was posted at Zanskar breeding unit,
Partapur.
He has helped in execution of animal trial.
Ms Ankita Sharma, Research Associate at ICAR-NBAGR,
Karnal.
She has helped in analysis of data and manuscript
preparation
Mr Prince Vivek, Research Fellow at DRDO-DIHAR, Leh.
He has assisted in animal experimentation.
Mr Arup Giri, Research Fellow at DRDO-DIHAR, Leh.
He has assisted in animal experimentation.
176