Irrig Drainage Syst
DOI 10.1007/s10795-007-9029-z
Mapping and assessing water use in a Central Asian
irrigation system by utilizing MODIS remote
sensing products
Christopher Conrad & Stefan W. Dech & Mohsin Hafeez &
John Lamers & Christopher Martius & Günter Strunz
# Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2007
Abstract Spatial and temporal patterns of water depletion in the irrigated land of Khorezm,
a region located in Central Asia in the lower floodplains of the Amu Darya River, were
mapped and monitored by means of MODIS land products. Land cover and land use were
classified by using a recursive partitioning and regression tree with 250 m MODIS
Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) time series. Seasonal actual evapotranspiration (ETact) was obtained by applying the Surface Energy Balance Algorithm for Land
(SEBAL) to 1 km daily MODIS data. Elements of the SEBAL based METRIC model
(Mapping Evapotranspiration at high Resolution and with Internalized Calibration) were
adopted and modified. The upstream–downstream difference in irrigation was reflected by
analyzing agricultural land use and amounts of depleted water (ETact) using Geographical
Information Systems (GIS). The validity of the MODIS albedo and emissivity used for
modeling ETact was assessed with data extracted from literature. The r2 value of 0.6
indicated a moderate but significant association between ETact and class-A-pan evaporation.
Deviations of ETact from the 10-day reference evapotranspiration of wheat and cotton were
found to be explainable. In Khorezm, seasonal maximum values superior to 1,200 and
1,000 mm ETact were estimated for rice and cotton fields, respectively. Spatio-temporal
C. Conrad (*) : S. W. Dech
Remote Sensing Unit, Department of Geography, University of Wuerzburg,
Am Hubland, 97074 Wuerzburg, Germany
e-mail: christopher.conrad@mail.uni-wuerzburg.de
C. Conrad : S. W. Dech : G. Strunz
German Aerospace Center (DLR)–German Remote Sensing Data Center (DFD),
Oberpfaffenhofen, 82234 Wessling, Germany
M. Hafeez
Land and Water Division, Commonwealth Scientific & Industrial Research Organization, CSIRO,
Locked Mail Bag 588, Wagga Wagga NSW 2678, Australia
J. Lamers : C. Martius
Center for Development Research (ZEF),
Walter-Flex-Strasse 3, 53113 Bonn, Germany
comparisons of agricultural land use with seasonal ETact disclosed unequal water consumption in Khorezm. Seasonal ETact on agricultural land decreased with increasing distance to
the water intake points of the irrigation system (972–712 mm). Free MODIS data provided
reliable, exhaustive, and consistent information on water use relevant for decision support
in Central Asian water management.
Keywords Central Asia . MODIS . Time series . Seasonal actual evapotranspiration .
Spatially distributed modeling
Introduction
Water mismanagement, pollution, rapid population growth, and water-related environmental
and ecological problems are major issues in the Aral Sea basin, located in the semiarid and
desert areas of Central Asia (Martius et al. 2004). Although these parts of the desert regions of
Central Asia are associated with high evaporation and infiltration rates, the main reason for
the shrinking of the Aral Sea (Ressl and Micklin 2004) and the resulting ‘Aral Sea Syndrome’
(WBGU 1998) is the human-induced diversion of river water for irrigated agriculture.
Between 1960 and 1990, cotton cultivation in Central Asia expanded from 3 million ha to
8 million ha (Micklin 1991). Since independence from the Soviet Union in 1992, Uzbekistan
has continued the cotton production practices developed under the Soviet planned economy
and in addition introduced a state order for winter wheat from 1995 onwards (Ruzmetov et al.
2003). Presently, Uzbekistan and the other central Asian countries top the list of highest percapita water use (WWF 2002).
Due to the aridity of the climate, agricultural production on more than 90% of the arable
land in Uzbekistan is only feasible with irrigation (Chub 2000). The agriculture-based
economy of the Khorezm region in northwest Uzbekistan highly depends on irrigation from
the Amu Darya River. The development of extensive irrigation schemes but with
improperly working drainage systems caused rising groundwater tables, and consequently
drastically changed the local and regional hydrology (Ibrakhimov 2005). In addition, the
irrigation water-use efficiency is very low (Dukhovny et al. 2004) and there is an urgent
need to find options to “grow more crop per drop.”
One important means to approach this goal may be to increase the low water use
efficiencies, which is feasible when management decisions are based on an analysis of
accurate hydrological information at each scale. Unfortunately, until today water resource
managers in Central Asia face both a paucity of reliable and consistent information (Dukhovny
et al. 2004) and inadequate and inappropriate tools for analysis, especially at the irrigation
system and watershed level (Chemin et al. 2004). The use of appropriate, reliable, and
consistent information at the irrigation system level can improve water management
significantly, e.g., by indicating necessary changes for managing water more beneficially,
negative impacts in downstream areas can be minimized. An important challenge for water
managers is, furthermore, obtaining timely, objective and accurate information on water usage
at each spatial scale. Despite existing land and water regulations from field to basin scale,
major problems in the Central Asia countries remain the inconsistent and incomplete
information about the actual resource usage (Chemin et al. 2004) and the absence of
monitoring or control facilities (Dukhovny et al. 2004). To bridge this gap, spatial and temporal information about the volume of water consumption for the land use classes in the basin
are needed. Recent developments in the remote sensing sciences and their application to
water resources management now allow the provision of accurate spatio-temporal information about land and water use patterns in large basin (Schmugge et al. 2002).
The current research was carried out under the framework of the ZEF/UNESCO project,
which addresses among other concerns the assessment of valid and reliable information
about availability, distribution and usage of water in Khorezm (Martius et al. 2004). To
complement the findings on water use and efficiency on the field level (Forkutsa 2006),
analyses of land and water use patterns for all of Khorezm have been initiated but still
suffer from insufficient information (Schweitzer et al. 2004; Ruecker et al. 2005). The
major objective of this study was to map and assess spatio-temporal water use patterns in
the large scale irrigation system of Khorezm by utilizing MODIS remote sensing data and
GIS to improve decision making. Additional objectives were (1) mapping and validating
accurate land cover and land use based on time series of 8-day, 250 m MODIS MOD09
surface reflectance data and (2) assessing the validity of 1 km MODIS MOD11 land surface
temperature (LST) data for mapping seasonal actual evapotranspiration by using SEBAL
and METRIC.
Remote sensing for irrigation water management
Remote sensing techniques are highly suitable for classifying regional and global scale land
cover, and for delineating irrigated areas (Droogers 2002) or land use patterns in
agricultural regions (Thenkabail et al. 2005; Bastiaanssen et al. 2000). Several approaches
exist to derive land cover and use classes from different types of remote sensing data
(Richards and Xiuping 2005). In particular, high temporal resolution data in combination
with multitemporal classification strategies have been found useful for describing the
temporal dynamics of seasonal vegetation cover and land use in irrigated areas (Thenkabail
et al. 2005).
Until 2000, the only sensor providing daily data with an acceptable spatial resolution of
1 km2 in an operational mode was the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer
(AVHRR) on board TIROS-N and NOAA 8-15 (Jensen 2000). Essential improvements
were obtained with the MODerate resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) on
board the Terra (EOS-AM1) and Aqua (EOS-PM1) platforms launched in 1999 and 2002,
respectively (Savtchenko et al. 2004). The high spectral resolution of 36 bands allowed
improvements in atmospheric correction, which resulted in the reflectance product
(Vermote et al. 1997) as a standardized input parameter of the MODIS land product suite
(Justice et al. 1998). MODIS spatial resolutions of 250 m within the red and near infrared
spectra and of 500 m in the visible and short wave infrared (five bands) spectra increased
the level of detail for classification.
Unsupervised clustering techniques were applied to AVHRR time series of Normalized
Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI; Loveland et al. 2000) or filtered data (Viovy 2000) to
distinguish land cover classes on a continental scale. The results of a cluster analysis of 42
MODIS 500 m 8-day surface reflectance data sets and a complex set of features describing
the location of a class within a feature space were integrated into a decision tree to classify
different crop rotations in the Ganges and Indus River basins (Thenkabail et al. 2005).
DeFries et al. (1998) applied supervised classification trees to metrics of 8 km AVHRR time
series resulting in 57 nodes for 17 global land cover classes. One year of monthly 1 km
AVHRR data made it possible to distinguish 12 classes by a cascading two-class hierarchy
of classification trees (Hansen et al. 2000). MODIS 500 m reflectance data were combined
with other GIS data in “classification and logistic regression” trees to derive land use and
predict deforestation in Colombia (Etter et al. 2006). Remote sensing techniques also
proved useful for estimating evaporation when solving the energy balance of thermodynamics fluxes at the earth surface. This approach has gained momentum since 1990 due to
the relatively low cost of data collection, which amounts to $0.03/ha for irrigated lands
(Sakthivadivel et al. 1999). Various methods for estimating actual evapotranspiration (ETact)
have been investigated by combining satellite images and ground meteorological data for
large areas (Vidal and Perrier 1989; Choudhury 1994; Granger 1997).
One method for estimating ETact is the Surface Energy Balance Algorithm for Land
(SEBAL) developed by Bastiaanssen (1995, 2000) and Bastiaanssen et al. (1998). SEBAL
is designed for flat terrain in semiarid regions and is based on the calculation of the latent
heat of ET (λET) as a residual from the surface energy balance. In recent years, SEBAL has
been widely used to model seasonal ETact by utilizing remote sensing data (Bastiaanssen
2002). METRIC extends SEBAL for mountainous relief and couples it with reference
evapotranspiration for alfalfa and was used to predict seasonal ETact based on Landsat data
in the USA (Allen et al. 2005). Tasumi et al. (2005) demonstrated the internal calibration of
SEBAL and METRIC showing with sensitivity analyses the independence of atmospheric
influences on the thermal radiation received at the sensor. Verstraeten et al. (2005) analyzed
the suitability of different remote sensing approaches in view of operational estimations of
ET from NOAA data over European forests.
SEBAL was applied in more than 15 case studies to all remote sensing sensors receiving
thermal information (e.g., Landsat TM and ETM, NOAA, ASTER, MODIS, and Meteosat)
and carried out worldwide in different climatic regions (Hafeez and Khan 2006). The
accuracy of SEBAL measured on a field scale by lysimeter, scintillometer, Bowen ratio
towers, or Eddy correlation fluxes varied between 1 and 33% for instantaneous ET and
between 2 and 30% for 10-day ET (Bastiaanssen et al. 2005). At the catchment scale,
accuracies were estimated by the water balance, which led to results of less than 11%.
Description of the study area
Research was conducted in the Khorezm region, located in the northwest of Uzbekistan and
between 60.05 and 61.39 N and 41.13 and 42.02 E of the Greenwich meridian,
approximately 225 km south of the present shores of the Aral Sea. Khorezm is part of
the lower Amu Darya River floodplain (Fig. 1, upper right map). Besides the capital
Urgench, the region encompasses ten administrative districts. Khorezm encompasses an
area of about 5,600 km2, of which 260,000 ha (2,600 km2) can be irrigated.
The climate in the Khorezm Region is extremely continental (Chub 2000). Potential
evapotranspiration exceeds the annual precipitation of about 100 mm between 14 and 16
times (Glazirin et al. 1999). The mean annual air temperature is approximately 13°C and
annually 205 frost-free days are recorded (Glazirin et al. 1999; Chub 2000). The main crops
are cotton, winter wheat, rice and alfalfa, but livestock rearing is rapidly gaining importance
(Mueller 2006).
The water of the Amu Darya River is distributed through six major inlet water
constructions. It is supplied in an extensive, hierarchically constructed network of main,
inter-farm and on-farm irrigation channels with a total length of 16,233 km and a drainage
network of 7,679 km (Fig. 1, main map). Although pumps are used, water flow is overwhelmingly caused by gravity forces. Khorezm receives annually between 3.5 and 5 km3
water, of which about 95% is designated for agricultural purposes (Conrad 2006). Water is
often led to the fields in open, nonlined channels (Ibrakhimov 2005), and losses from evaporation and groundwater discharge are estimated to be 40% or more (Martius et al. 2004).
Fig. 1 The irrigation system within the administrative boundaries of Khorezm oblast, Uzbekistan. The small
map in the upper right corner illustrates the location and dimension of Khorezm within Central Asia
Materials and methods
The study was based on MODIS remote sensing data comprising spectral reflectance (ρ), land
surface temperature (LST) and emissivity (ɛ), surface albedo (α), Normalized Difference
Vegetation Index (NDVI), and Leaf Area Index (LAI). Half-hourly measurements of prime
meteorological data recorded at a meteorological station within the study area were used to
estimate reference evapotranspiration for modelling. After data selection and preprocessing,
the methods applied to derive agricultural land use classes and seasonal ETact are specified.
Subsequently, a plausibility analysis for the validation of the modeling results is presented,
followed by a description of the spatio-temporal analysis using Geographical Information
Systems (GIS).
NASA MODIS products
The large MODIS product suite comprises land surface parameters with daily, 8-day, and
16-day temporal resolutions reprojected and gridded in 250, 500 m, and 1 km spatial
resolutions (Justice et al. 1998). Overpass LST data necessary for the application of SEBAL
(Bastiaanssen et al. 1998) are provided as swath products and needed to be separately preprocessed, which is described below.
Table 1 lists different Terra-MODIS products which were downloaded and preprocessed
for the land cover/land use classification and for SEBAL. Detailed information about
MOD09 surface reflectance products is provided in Vermote et al. (1997). Wan and Li (1997)
describe the retrieval of MOD11 land surface temperature (LST) and emissivity from MODIS
data. The algorithms of the vegetation index (MOD13) and the Leaf Area Index (MOD15)
products are presented by Huete et al. (2002) and Myneni et al. (2002). The computation of
broadband white sky albedo (stored in the MOD43B3 product) by integrating bi-hemispherical
reflectance data modeled over MODIS channels 1–7 (0.3–5.0 μm) is explained in Schaaf et al.
(2002).
All NASA MODIS land products include so called Quality Assessment Science Data Sets
(QA-SDS). Depending on the product, the QA-SDS considers the atmospheric conditions in
Table 1 MODIS data products used to classify land cover/land use and to model seasonal actual
evapotranspiration between the 1st of April and the 31st of October 2004 (DOY 92 to DOY 305)
Data
product
Layer
Spatial
Temporal MODIS QA-SDSa analysis (quality flags
resolution resolution passed)
kmb
kmb
kmb
kmb
km
MOD11_L2 LST
Emissivity
View anglec
Recording time
MOD13A2 NDVI
1
1
1
1
1
MOD15A2
LAI
1 km
8-day
MOD43B3
White sky
albedo
Red
reflectance
NIR
reflectance
1 km
16-day
250 m
8-day
MOD09Q1
a
Overpass
Overpass
Overpass
Overpass
16-day
Linear
interpol.
General quality: good and acceptable LST No
No
errors up to 4 K accepted
No
No
Usefulness: perfect – good
Yes
Mixed clouds: no
General quality: good and acceptable
Yes
Cloud state: clear and assumed clear
General quality: good and acceptable,
Yes
Snow: no
General quality: good
Yes
Clouds: clear
Band quality: highest
Quality Assessment Science Data Sets
b
The swath products were gridded using the MODIS reprojection tool (MRT).
c
The view angles were analyzed to remove effects from scan geometry caused by increasing IFOV towards
the edges of the scan lines.
terms of cloud cover and aerosol content, algorithm choices, processing failures, and error
estimations. The software application ‘Time Series Generator’ (TiSeG, Colditz et al. 2006) was
used to exclude invalid data by analyzing the MODIS QA-SDS. With TiSeG, improved time
series were built from several gridded MODIS land data products by assessing data quantity
against data quality (Conrad et al. 2005). The settings applied are also noted in Table 1. The
albedo and the vegetation products NDVI and LAI were interpolated using temporal linear
interpolation.
MOD11_L2 LST and emissivity data was preprocessed in three steps. First, the MODIS
reprojection tool (MRTSwath) was used to transform the swath data into 1 km grids and for
subsetting. Second, the QA-SDS were analysed and all scenes with valid data covering
more than 75% of Khorezm were selected (see Fig. 2). This provided 110 overpasses during
the 214 day vegetation period from April 1st to October 31st, 2004 for analysis. The third
Fig. 2 Daily percentage of valid
pixel values for MOD11A1 data
2004 recorded over Khorezm
preprocessing step required sensor related considerations. MODIS is a whisk broom
scanner recording one complete scan line after another. Due to the Earth’s curvature, the
MODIS detector’s instantaneous field of view (IFOV) at the edge of the scan lines is 2.0
(4.8) times larger in the track (scan) direction than at nadir (Wolfe et al. 1998). The overlap
of the scan lines increases with the scan angle and the same geographic location may be
recorded twice. The MRTSwath (L2G approach, see Wolfe et al. 1998) eliminates this
“bow-tie effect.” However, fitting pixels to a 1 km raster requires the integration of adjacent
observations with an increasing error in off-nadir scans, because the IFOV also increases
with the scan angle. To minimize this impact, pixels with a view angle higher than 30° offnadir were removed. At 30° off-nadir view angles, the IFOV is approximately 1.1 km in the
along-track and 1.25 km in the across-track direction (Wolfe et al. 1998). In addition, the
75% criteria was applied for each overpass. Finally, 62 MODIS LST observations were
considered suitable for analysis of the 214 day vegetation period in 2004. Figure 2 shows
the percentage of valid pixels for each day. The red line indicates the limit of 75%, below
which the complete overpass was taken out of the further modeling process.
Meteorological data
The application of SEBAL according to the METRIC variant requires several types of
meteorological data. Air temperature, relative humidity, wind speed in 2 m height, and net
radiation were recorded half-hourly at a meteorological station located in the center of the
irrigation system (60°37′12″E, 41°39′10″N; Khamzina 2006). Reference evapotranspiration
was obtained by applying the ASCE standardized reference evapotranspiration equation for
alfalfa (ETrs; ASCE-EWRI 2005), as suggested by Allen et al (2005). Therefore, coefficients
given by ASCE-EWRI were used to estimate ETrs on hourly data, whereas ground heat flux
(G) was calculated according to FAO-56 (Allen et al. 1998).
Land cover/land use classification
For classification, temporal signatures of NDVI time series were derived from 46 8-day
250 m surface reflectance data (MOD09Q1, Fig. 3). Mono-modal distributions with one
growing peak in the summer characterize cotton and rice (Fig. 3a, b), whereas the winter
wheat (Fig. 3c) had its maximum in late spring. The crop rotations of wheat with rice,
sunflower, alfalfa, and maize (Fig. 3d) typically showed a bi-modal NDVI development.
Non-modal time series represented the land cover classes desert and permanent water
surfaces (Fig. 3e, f). Water was spatially stratified into water from lakes and water from
river and large channels, because the varying water levels of the rivers generated sudden
shifts of the curve above the soil line and resulted in a signature with higher variances than
shown by water from lakes. In total, the eleven classes included six nonagricultural surface
types (‘desert’, ‘urban settlement’, ‘rural settlement’, ‘trees and gardens’, ‘permanent water
surface’, and ‘rivers and channels’) and five agricultural land use types (‘cotton’, ‘rice’,
‘wheat-fallow’, ‘wheat-rice’, and ‘wheat-other’).
Up to 60 training and validation samples for each of the eleven classes were extracted
from four ASTER scenes acquired on the 17th and 26th of August 2004. They were crosschecked with 120 field samples collected during the summer season of 2004 and with seven
observation sites on large homogeneous cotton and rice areas.
For classification, recursive partitioning and regression trees (Breiman et al. 1984) were
applied to metrics of MOD09 NDVI time series by employing the statistical open source
software R (R Development Core Team 2005). The statistical gini index was used as impurity
Fig. 3 Temporal NDVI signatures from 8-day 250 m MOD09 surface reflectance data, mean values and
standard deviation for cotton (a), rice (b), wheat (c), the crop rotation wheat–rice (d), and the land cover
classes desert (e) and water (f)
measure (split criterion); the minimum number within one observation in one node was set to
5 (stop criterion). The method used in this study resembles the approach presented by Hansen
et al. (2000).
Applying the classification tree to the training samples led to a misclassification error rate
of 3%. Validation samples were used to calculate the overall accuracy and the Kappa coefficient according to Congalton (1991). During post-classification, errors within the settlement
pixels were eliminated by using settlement polygons provided by the ZEF/UNESCO GIS
Center in Urgench.
Modelling seasonal actual evapotranspiration
Basically, the SEBAL model solves the surface energy balance for each pixel, which results
in the latent heat for evapotranspriation (λET). λET is derived by subtracting ground heat
fluxes (G) and sensible heat fluxes (H) from the available energy; the net radiation (Rn).
MODIS LST, α, ɛ, and NDVI data were used to calculate Rn and G according to the formulation of SEBAL (Bastiaanssen et al. 1998; Bastiaanssen 2000). The multitemporal approach and the application of SEBAL to large scale MODIS pixels required modifications for
the modelling of H (Eq. 1), which is explained in the following.
H ¼ ρair cp
dT
rah
ð1Þ
In SEBAL and METRIC (Allen et al. 2005; Tasumi et al. 2005), H usually results from
dividing the gradient of vertical temperatures (dT) by the aerodynamic resistance of heat
transport (rah). ρair is the air density and cp is the specific heat of air. Atmospheric conditions
determine the aerodynamic resistance of heat transport (rah). Unstable conditions initiate an
upward force of air mass; no movement can be registered at neutral conditions, while stable
conditions trigger a downward force of air mass. An iterative process integrating the Monin–
Obhukov length to consider the stability of the atmosphere finally results in H (Bastiaanssen
et al. 2005).
One basic assumption of SEBAL and METRIC is the linear relationship between dT and
land surface temperature (Bastiaanssen et al. 1998; Allen et al. 2005). The linear equation is
computed using two anchor points, where H can be calculated by using the surface energy
balance. For a completely dry (hot) pixel the latent heat of evaporation is zero. Thus H can be
calculated as the difference between Rn and G, immediately resulting in dThot (Bastiaanssen
et al. 1998). Both SEBAL and METRIC characterize hot pixels as nonvegetated dry areas
and at best bare soil located close to the meteorological station (Allen et al. 2002). Completely cold pixels such as water surfaces are presumed to consume all available energy for
evaporation processes, from which dTcold becomes zero (Bastiaanssen et al. 1998).
In METRIC, well-vegetated fields are selected as cold pixels. H at the cold anchor point
(Hcold) is expressed as Rn −G−k×λETrs where ETrs is the standardized reference evapotranspiration for alfalfa (ASCE-EWRI 2005). The k-factor considers well-watered
conditions at the cold pixel which outrange other densely vegetated fields due to higher
surface wetness. Allen et al. (2005) assumed k to be 1.05 and included NDVI corrections of
k for initial and late growing seasons, when well-watered vegetation pixels are absent.
The selection of homogeneous cold and hot pixels over the whole season by using low
spatial resolution remote sensing data sets leads however to uncertainties in heterogeneous
landscapes. One square kilometer pixels identified as well-watered vegetation are at least
partly covered by roads and houses or smaller irrigation and drainage canals. Spatial variations
within the agricultural plots are also possible. Similarly, pure nonvegetated pixels on the 1 km2
scale are only located in the desert, often far away from the meteorological station, whereas
pixels representing nonvegetated land in the irrigated area again often include spots of
vegetation, gardens, parts of vegetated fields and at least small or dry irrigation and drainage
channels. In this study, a second k-factor for the hot pixel and a slightly finer specification of
the k-factor for the cold pixel (Allen et al. 2005) are suggested.
For the hot pixel (Eq. 2) vegetation cover is considered in the case that the NDVI excels
the average values of the sandy surface of the surrounding desert (0.15). The factor khot is
defined as a function of NDVI, with khot =NDVI−0.15 if the NDVI is greater than 0.15, and
khot =0, otherwise.
Hhot ¼ Rn
G
khot ðNDVI Þ 1ET ref
ð2Þ
METRIC uses a soil water balance to account for possible effects of antecedent precipitation
at the hot anchor point, which is not reflected by the NDVI. However, in the vegetation period
2004 total precipitation only reached 48 mm. Consequently, influences of soil moisture were
assumed to be negligible. In addition, the introduced automated selection process of the anchor
points screened all parts of the investigation area, where the probability to find effectively dry
pixels is always high due to the patchiness of precipitation in arid regions. Corrections for soil
moisture which are part of METRIC were therefore omitted in this approach due to local
weather conditions in Khorezm.
For the computation of Hcold at the climax of the vegetation period (NDVI≥0.65) kcold
was implemented as 1.05 for the same reasons given by Allen et al. (2005): the probability
to find pixels within the 240,000 ha sized irrigated network surpassing other pixels with
comparably dense and well watered vegetation due to surface wetness was presumed to be
high. Adjustments were applied to kcold using the NDVI to account for low vegetation cover
during initial and vegetative crop stages or after harvest (kcold =1.05−(0.65−NDVI)/2). In
addition rice, water, and other nonagricultural land cover were expected to be absent at the
cold anchor point on the 250 m subpixel scale. Thus, Hcold is a written as function of NDVI
and the actual land cover (Eq. 3):
Hcold ¼ Rn
G
kcold ðNDVI; landcoverÞ 1ET ref
ð3Þ
To apply the model on daily data, automated selection of the hot and the cold pixels was
necessary to reduce processing time. The presented automated selection process employed
remotely sensed information on vegetation density and water conditions when assessing the
pixels. Vegetation density can be biophysically related to the leaf area index (LAI, Huete
et al. 2002). The land surface temperature (LST) describes the skin temperature of soil and
vegetation cover, on which ET has a cooling effect (Verstraeten et al. 2005). For the
automated calculation of ET over European forests using NOAA data, Verstraeten et al. (2005)
suggested a combination of NDVI and LST as an indication of the vegetation cover and water
conditions of a single pixel. LST and LAI were preferred for selecting the hot and cold pixels
by Allen et al. (2002). In the presented approach, low LAI values and high land surface
temperature characterize hot pixels; high LAI values describe dense vegetation, which in
combination with relatively low surface temperatures indicates high ET values (Table 2).
Additionally, the land cover and land use classification is included. Both pixels should
originate from the agricultural area in order to discard lakes, desert or settlement pixels
from the analysis. Rice fields were unsuitable for the automation process, firstly because
they are initially completely covered with water while METRIC requires vegetated areas,
and secondly because the literature on the later growing stages gives inconsistent values for
the actual water consumption of rice fields (see Mohan and Arumugam 1994).
Table 3 depicts the bi-monthly result of the automated selection process for each of the
two model computations. Here, NDVI and LST reflect the introduced k-factors at the cold
and hot anchor points. Due to the lack of well watered conditions and the absence of full
vegetation cover within one entire MODIS pixel, kcold of less than 1 were found in the early
vegetation period. The increase of khot demonstrates the difficulty in finding 1 km2 with
completely dry conditions in Khorezm during the cotton season, which made adjustments
necessary.
Finally, 1ET transformed to daily ETact by using ETref as suggested by Tasumi et al.
(2005) resulted in amounts of seasonal ETact. The relation ETact/ETref was interpolated
linearly to close gaps caused by missing data. Accordingly, the data gaps in single overpasses
resulting from omitting invalid MOD11_L2 data could be filled, except for minor errors
owing to the scan angles, as mentioned before.
Table 2 Suggested rules to automate the selection of cold and hot pixels
Cold pixel
Hot pixel
Verbal formulation
Computation rule
Verbal formulation
Computation rule
Agricultural area
Select from land use classes
Agricultural area
Select from land use
classes
No water surface
Actual land use ≠ ‘rice’,
actual land cover ≠ ‘water’
Maximum (LAI)
Low green
vegetation density
Assumed low
evapotranspiration
Actual land use≠‘fallow’
minimum (LAI)
Maximum (LST)
High green
vegetation density
Assumed high
evapotranspiration
Minimum (LST)
Table 3 Environmental situation at the anchor points automatically selected from remote sensing data and
resulting k-factors for each two computations of SEBAL per month
Date
08.04.2004
22.04.2004
08.05.2004
20.05.2004
09.06.2004
20.06.2004
06.07.2004
20.07.2004
08.08.2004
21.08.2004
08.09.2004
22.09.2004
08.10.2004
17.10.2004
Cold anchor pixel
Hot anchor pixel
LST
NDVI
kcold
LST
NDVI
khot
294.88
294.30
306.38
307.20
307.34
309.62
305.36
305.54
302.56
304.24
297.86
298.44
292.26
289.78
0.36
0.39
0.43
0.52
0.40
0.36
0.35
0.46
0.62
0.64
0.74
0.63
0.49
0.56
0.90
0.92
0.94
0.98
0.93
0.91
0.90
0.95
1.04
1.04
1.05
1.04
0.97
1.01
301.18
299.10
310.68
313.42
317.80
320.92
314.64
315.96
309.64
312.28
302.82
304.22
297.34
293.22
0.20
0.20
0.21
0.20
0.17
0.20
0.31
0.23
0.29
0.34
0.43
0.36
0.33
0.24
0.05
0.05
0.06
0.05
0.02
0.05
0.16
0.08
0.14
0.19
0.28
0.21
0.18
0.09
Validation of ETact
Due to absent lysimeters (Tasumi et al. 2005), scintillometers, Bowen ratio towers, or eddy
covariance systems (Bastiaanssen et al. 2005) often used for validation, a stepwise plausibility analysis was carried out to validate the SEBAL modeling results. To account for possible
errors caused when using MODIS data, in a first step, albedo and emissivity were compared
with the biophysical values of cotton, rice and wheat taken from secondary sources. Secondly, class-A pan evaporation (Epan) was measured in close vicinity of the meteorological station in central Khorezm, which allowed comparison with ETact over water surfaces. The land
use classification was used to obtain pixels from water surfaces within a 15 km circle around the
location of the class-A pan (9 pixels). In a third step, ETact over vegetated areas was opposed to
crop-specific reference evapotranspiration (ETcrop) calculated as follows:
ETcrop ¼ Kc ETOS
Crop coefficients (Kc) and the cropping calendar of wheat and cotton for the Khorezm region
were obtained from the Central Asian Scientific Research Institute of Irrigation (SANIIRI;
Table 4). ASCE standardized reference evapotranspiration for small crops (ETos) similar to
grass with an approximate height of 0.12 m was computed from daily meteorological data
(ASCE-EWRI 2005). This formula for reference evaporation is equal to that presented in
FAO-56 (Allen et al. 1998) and therefore valid for the correct derivation of ETcrop according
to the FAO manual. The comparisons were made for each 10-day period.
Practical application: spatio-temporal GIS analysis
Water use patterns in Khorezm were analysed in two steps. First, agricultural land use was
compared with agricultural water consumption (ETact) to investigate seasonal variations in
water distribution. Second, the inventory of agricultural land use and ETact for the Water
User Associations (WUAs) was related to their absolute distance to the intake points of the
Table 4 Growing stages and crop coefficients of winter wheat and cotton for the Khorezm region
Crop
Duration of growing stage (days)
Crop coefficients
Initial stage Crop development Midseason
Winter 20
wheat
Cotton 60
Lateseason
Initial stage Midseason
Lateseason
185
30
25
0.3
1.15
0.25
50
60
55
0.35
1.2
0.7
Source: Oral communication with SANIIRI, Tashkent.
irrigation system to assess upstream–downstream trends in water distribution. For the latter,
pixels covering more than 75% agricultural land were included.
To analyze ETact on the MODIS 1 km scale, the 250 m pixels assigned to agricultural land
use (cotton, rice, and wheat rotations) were counted within each 1 km2 pixel [=agricultural
land use density (%)]. According to the cropping calendar (see Table 4) five configurations of
agricultural land use density were extracted (Table 5). Until the first half of April, the only
crop is winter wheat; from the middle of April, cotton is seeded, and rice growing usually
starts from mid-May onwards. Wheat harvest occurs from the beginning of June, whereas rice
is usually harvested by the end of September. Thus, cotton is the only crop remaining until
the end of October.
The GIS data used to calculate the upstream–downstream situation included the irrigation
canal network of Khorezm, the Amu Darya River, and the administrative boundaries of the
Water User Associations (WUAs). Intersections with the canal system were applied to identify
the intake points of the WUA subsystem boundaries. The heads of those parts of the Khorezm
irrigation system close to the Amu Darya River were digitized manually. Then, the reticular
distance between each Khorezm system intake location and each WUA distribution point was
calculated. The distances were averaged for WUAs having more than one subsystem intake
point.
Results and discussion
Land cover and land use classification
For the validation of the land cover and land use classification, at best 30 homogeneously
covered MODIS pixels were extracted visually for each class from high resolution ASTER
data as validation samples. The overall accuracy was 89% and the Kappa coefficient, 0.88.
Incorporating inhomogeneous pixels (dominated by more than one class) into the assessment decreased these accuracy indicators.
Table 5 Relevant configuration changes in detectable land use classes during the 2004 vegetation period
Period
Fallow
Wheat
April 1st–April 15th
April 16th–May 15th
May 16th–June 15th
June 16th–September 30th
October 1st–October 31st
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Cotton
Other
Rice
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
The classification results (Fig. 4) showed a clear view of distribution and patterns of
actual land use in Khorezm. About 49% of the study area was classified as irrigated land
(IL). Agricultural land expansion is mainly delineated by the desert and settlements. As
expected, the dominating agricultural crops were cotton (124,000 ha, ∼54% of IL) and rice
(73,500 ha, ∼32% of IL), particularly found in the vicinity of the Amu Darya River. Rice fields
covered large parts of the northern rayon Gurlen (see GUR, Fig. 1), which historically is
known for rice cultivation. The homogeneity of the agricultural landscape decreased with
distance to the river. Concurrently, an increase in crop rotation with winter wheat was
identified (54,899 ha, ∼24% of IL). Trees and gardens were scattered throughout the entire
oblast. Even though settlements could be extracted from the GIS layer, the classes ‘rural’ and
‘urban settlements’ indicate a relation between green and impervious portions within a pixel.
Detailed GIS analysis of the classification results allows a comprehensive discussion,
which is presented below, including spatio-temporal patterns of water consumption (ETact).
The following estimations of ETact are based on these results of the land use classification.
Mapping seasonal actual evapotranspiration (ETact)
Comparisons with biophysical values for wheat, cotton, and rice taken from secondary
sources indicated the validity of the input parameters albedo and emissivity (Table 6).
Averaged MODIS emissivities overestimated the values found in literature, while in general
0.97 is suggested for modeling emissivity of nonmetal surfaces (Campbell and Norman
1998). However, simulations showed that overestimations in emissivity of 0.01 increased
the available energy budget at the earth surface by less than 1%.
The r2 value of 0.6 (n=52 applications of SEBAL) indicated a moderate but significant
correlation between ETact over water surfaces averaged for each overpass and daily
measured Epan. The resulting trend (Epan =1.04 ETact) showed smaller ETact than Epan
because in contrast to the class-A pan, radiation deeply penetrates a natural water body,
which makes less energy available for evaporation. Even though physical conditions of
evaporation differ widely between water bodies and agricultural crops and SEBAL was
Fig. 4 Spatially distributed land cover and agricultural land use in Khorezm 2004
designed for land rather than for water surfaces, the correlation between ETact and Epan
indicates that the model output is plausible.
ETcrop was calculated for winter wheat and cotton to compare ETact over the irrigated
land of Khorezm. ETcrop and ETact summarized for each 10-day periods and standard
deviations of ETact are depicted in Fig. 5.
In early April, 10-day ETact overestimated ETcrop for winter wheat between 3% and 11%.
Underestimations between 18% and 32% were found during the ripening stage (Fig. 5a).
The 105% deviation of ETact from ETcrop in the wheat harvest stage can be explained by
initial leaching and initial growth stages of a second crop (on the sub-pixel level). When
excluding the last 10-day period, the coefficient of variation (CV) of ETact ranged between
15 and 21%.
In the initial cotton phase, ETact exceeded ETcrop by more than 50% (Fig. 5b), most
likely due to high soil evaporation after the leaching period, when high groundwater tables
were recorded (Ibrakhimov 2005). In the beginning of July, ETact tends to be lower than
expected. Forkutsa (2006) explained similar results from field level by inadequate irrigation
within the vegetative growing stage of cotton. During the intensive irrigation phases (July
until September), ETact virtually equaled ETcrop. Late-season leaching for field preparation
explains the higher overestimations (68 and 78%) during harvest time, usually starting at
the end of September. CV for 10-day ETact varied between 30 and 44% in April and
between 12 and 26% throughout the later growing phases.
Figure 6 shows the spatial distribution of total ETact in the period from 1st of April until
the 31st of October, including late leaching and the entire vegetation period. ETact was
lowest in desert margins and urban settlements (0–300 mm) and increased in agricultural
land to over 1,200 mm. As expected, there were high values for the lakes in southern
Khorezm, also because of noise in the input data which occurred at the southern border to
Turkmenistan. In central Khorezm (Khonka rayon, KHO, Fig. 1) and in the most northern
rayon, Gurlen, (GUR, Fig. 1), minimum seasonal ETact was 700 mm. Well watered locations were also detected south of central Khorezm, where a large branch of the irrigation
system is feeding a large fish farm with water (Fig. 6).
Table 6 Emissivity, albedo and surface roughness (z0 m) of wheat, cotton, and rice used as input parameters
for modeling ETact compared to literature values
Emissivity
Albedo
a
Crop
μ
σ
Literature biophysical values
Wheat
Cotton
Rice
Wheat
Cotton
Rice
0.980
0.981
0.980
0.182
0.178
0.176
0.005
0.005
0.005
0.014
0.010
0.013
0.981–0.986a; 0.976b
0.96 (for cotton leaves)c
0.97–0.85d
0.14–0.22e; 0.16–0.22c, 0.16–0.23f
0.21f
0.17–0.22e; 0.25g, 0.12f
Chen and Zhang (1989)
b
Huband and Montheith (1986)
c
Campbell and Norman (1998)
d
Coll et al. (2004)
e
Allen et al. (2002)
f
Halstead et al. (1957)
g
Mohan and Arumugam (1994)
Fig. 5 Comparison between total amounts of ETcrop and ETact, for wheat (a) and for cotton (b)
Crop specific statistics were derived by intersecting the aggregated land cover and land
use map with seasonal ETact. Mean values and standard deviations of ETact were 768 and
248 mm on cotton fields, and 798 and 300 mm on rice fields, respectively. On wheat-rice
crop rotations, where rice seedlings are commonly transplanted from the nursery to the rice
paddies in mid-June, slightly lower average values (739 mm) were modeled.
The results for cotton compare well with the ETact of 706 mm measured in 2004 in an
irrigation experiment with furrow-irrigated cotton fields near Tashkent (Ibragimov et al.
2007). Howell et al. (2004) reported an ETact of approximately 750 mm from cotton fields
in the arid Texas High Plains.
On rice fields seasonal ETact varies with climatic conditions and vegetation period. In subhumid India ETact of 596 mm (815 mm) were measured for the 90-day (125-day) period of
dry (wet) season rice growth, whereas ETos achieved 470 mm (623 mm; Mohan and
Arumugam 1994). Hafeez (2003) reported seasonal ETact of 569 mm (452 mm) for 118 days
(130 days) during the dry (wet) season in the Upper Pampanga River Integrated Irrigation
System of the Philippines in 2001. In rice growing areas of New South Wales in Australia
ETact from 685 to 1,350 mm were measured during the 150 day rice growing season over
32 years (1962–1994), whereas ETos ranged between 960 and 1,412 mm (Humphreys et al.
1994). For rice field in semiarid environments of West Africa, Hendrickx et al. (1986)
measured seasonal ETact of 706 mm (443 mm) for a 123 day (92 day) period during two
Fig. 6 Seasonal actual evapotranspiration (mm) integrated
for parts of the leaching season
and covering the whole
summer vegetation period in
Khorezm 2004
different cropping seasons, whereas ETos was 665 mm (525 mm). The vegetation period for
rice in arid Khorezm lasts 135 days.
The assumption of constant weather conditions for the entire irrigation system possibly
caused errors especially for the southern parts near the desert. Due to missing reliable
meteorological data, the quantification of deviations is yet to be accomplished. In the neighborhood to the desert, ETrs is expected to be higher than in the center of the irrigation system
and underestimations of ETact can be a result. On the other hand, this transition zone was
assumed to be small because the numerous lakes indicate increased humidity and decreased
air temperature also affecting the outer boundaries of the irrigation system. The installation of
a small network of meteorological stations could allow these spatial variations to be taken
into account.
SEBAL is a worldwide validated model. By selecting MODIS data with scan angles close
to nadir the total number of suitable overpasses decreased but potential errors resulting from
high IFOV was minimized. In addition, the plausibility analysis confirmed the reliability of
the study findings and the comparisons with field experiments also demonstrated the reliability of the presented SEBAL variant. However, for applications in irrigation management
in Central Asia, significant optimizations are lacking.
Another relevant aspect for the implementation of this SEBAL variant is the dependence
on the actual land use and land cover, which is essential for the selection of the anchor points
in the presented approach. Here, reasonable considerations are required to overcome the
situation of having a post seasonal land use classification derived from annual time series.
Pre-season or early-season land use information would allow intra-seasonal derivations of
ETact useful for operational irrigation management.
Spatio-temporal patterns of land and water usage
Multitemporal analysis of the land cover and land use classification result disclosed seasonal
variations of water distribution in Khorezm. Figure 7 contrasts the temporal development of
agricultural land use density with seasonal ETact. In spring, the homogeneous distribution of
winter wheat caused an intermediate land use density throughout the study area, which
increased with the seeding of cotton in the last decade of April. The highest density of nonfallow agricultural land occurred between mid-May and mid-June, and decreased slightly
after wheat harvest. However, most wheat fields were used to produce a second crop. The
map for October showed homogenous cotton distribution in Khorezm.
The ETact map for the first half of April mainly highlights patterns of leaching. Water
seemed to be distributed homogeneously over all of Khorezm in the initial cotton growing
period, which substantiates the assertion that even in the outer rayons ETact achieve average
values. With increasing dominance of rice fields, ETact maps indicated higher water allocations, in particular in the central parts of the irrigation system and in the rice dominated
northern irrigation system. Also in the late season, when initial leaching was carried out, the
water distribution pattern appeared constant.
Figure 8 summarizes agricultural land use density (a) and ETact on agricultural areas (b)
for the entire cropping season resulting from the GIS analysis of the irrigation canal network (Fig. 9). The density of agricultural land within a WUA ranges between 35 and 65%
and averages 49%, independent of the location of the WUA within the irrigated area. The
low agricultural land use density close to the heads of the irrigation systems was mainly
caused by a desert branch reaching deep into the irrigated land. A lower concentration of
settlements close to the Amu Darya River explains the peak in the distance class “25–35 km”.
Most WUAs within the “45–55 km” distance occur in the surroundings of Urgench (URG,
Fig. 7 Actual land use density versus (left column) seasonal ETact (right column) summarized for the
configurations according to the cropping calendar (Table 5). The a–e opposite these variables for the period
from 1.4.2004–15.4.2004, 16.4.2004–15.5.2004, 16.5.2004–15.6.2004, 16.6.2004–30.9.2004, and 1.1.2004–
31.10.2004, respectively
Fig. 8 Relating agricultural land use density and ETact to the reticular distance between WUAs and intake
heads within the irrigation system
Fig. 1), which are dominated by settlements. Seasonal ETact used for agriculture indicate a
negative upstream–downstream trend of water availability. From class ‘<15 km’ to class ‘35–
45 km’ ETact achieved average values between 891 and 975 mm, whereas in the outer reach
(class ‘>95 km’) ETact averaged 712 mm.
The classification substantiated the well-known (Mueller 2006), very intensive agricultural
use even in regions bordering the desert. The land and water distribution in Khorezm is
characterized by high land use density, also in the tail end regions of the irrigation system
where low ETact was recorded during the vegetation period. In contrast, high water
availability is reported for the downstream parts of the canal network of Khorezm (Mueller
2006; Conrad 2006).
The increase of heterogeneity in crop production in central and downstream Khorezm is
evident; the reasons are speculative and may be related to informally driven water allocation and supply strategies, as recently postulated (Wegerich 2004). Intensive crop rotations with winter wheat might be used to optimize income, to fulfill the state order for
wheat, to reduce risk, or as a strategy to cope with seasonal droughts. The heterogeneous
environmental settings in Khorezm may also be caused by soil texture, and by the level and
salinity of groundwater, any of which may provoke large variations in crop water demands.
Fig. 9 Average distances (km) between the WUAs and the system intake points of Khorezm
Time series of remotely sensed crop coefficients derived on the field level where the environmental settings are representative and well known, as recently demonstrated by Tasumi and
Allen (2007), would make exhaustive and expensive hydrological measurements during the
season unnecessary when assessing irrigation performance.
Conclusions
MODIS land products (Justice et al. 1998) provided insights into land and water distribution in Khorezm. Excellent atmospheric conditions in the central Aral Sea basin allowed the
generation of nearly gapless time series of remote sensing parameters, especially throughout
the vegetation period from April to October. Time series of the 250 m 8-day MODIS
MOD09 surface reflectance product contained relevant features to classify and validate all
important agricultural land use classes.
Furthermore, modelling ETact became possible for 62 of 214 days between the 1st of
April and the 31st of October 2004. Here, extensive preprocessing and pixel selection of
1 km MODIS MOD11_L2 LST/emissivity swath data was necessary to fulfill the
requirements of the SEBAL model where overpass records are requested for. As soon as
collection 5 of daily MODIS level 3 LST products is available for 2004 (Wan 2007), this
time-consuming preparation of level 2 data can be omitted. Interpolation between two
overpasses made collection 4 LST data useless for SEBAL in middle and higher latitudes.
The presented results for the Khorezm region show the potential of remote sensing to
overcome the lack of reliable, objective, exhaustive, and consistent information on water
management issues of Central Asia at a regional scale. With a denser network of meteorological stations permitting better consideration of climatic variations in the irrigation
system and in-situ validation facilities for optimizing the model parameterizations, ETact
modeled on daily MODIS data and integrated to a monthly product could provide decision
support for system-wide operational water management issues.
Acknowledgements This study was funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF;
project number 0339970C). We are especially grateful to Dr. Gerd Ruecker from the German Aerospace Center
(DLR) and Omonbek Salaev from the GIS Center in Urgench, Uzbekistan, for preparing and providing field
training samples of land use and essential meteorological and GIS data. We also would like to thank Dr. Tobias
Landmann, Department of Geography, University of Wuerzburg, and Susan Giegerich and René Colditz,
German Aerospace Center, for their useful comments. The MODIS data used in this study were acquired as part
of NASA’s Earth Science Enterprise. The algorithms were developed by the MODIS Science Teams. The data
were processed by the MODIS Adaptive Processing System (MODAPS) and Goddard Distributed Active
Archive Center (DAAC), and are archived and distributed by the Goddard DAAC. We are grateful for the
valuable comments from two anonymous reviewers on an earlier version of this manuscript.
References
Allen RG, Pereira LS, Raes D, Smith M (1998) Crop evapotranspiration. Guide-lines for computing crop
water requirements. In: FAO irrigation and drainage paper 56, Rome
Allen RG, Waters R, Tasumi M, Trezza R, Bastiaanssen WGM (2002) SEBAL – Surface Energy Balance
Algorithm for Land – Idaho implementation – Advanced training and users manual. Idaho, USA
Allen RG, Tasumi M, Morse A, Trezza R (2005) A Landsat-based energy balance and evapotranspiration
model in Western US water rights regulation and planning. Irrig Drain Syst 19:251–268
ASCE-EWRI (2005) The ASCE standardized reference evapotranspiration equation. Report by the Task
Committee on Standardization of Reference Evapotranspiration, Environmental and Water Resources
Institute of the ASCE
Bastiaanssen WGM (1995) Regionalization of surface flux densities and moisture indicators in composite
terrain. A remote sensing approach under clear skies in Mediterranean climates. Report 109, Agricultural
Research Department, Wageningen, The Netherlands
Bastiaanssen WGM (2000) SEBAL-based sensible and latent heat fluxes in the irrigated Gediz Basin, Turkey. J
Hydrol 229:87–100
Bastiaanssen WGM (2002) Satellite surveillance of evaporative depletion across the Indus Basin. Water
Resour Res 38(12):1273
Bastiaanssen WGM, Menenti M, Feddes RA, Holtslag AAM (1998) A remote sensing surface energy
balance algorithm for land (SEBAL). 1. Formulation. J Hydrol 212–213:198–212
Bastiaanssen WGM, Molden DJ, Makin IW (2000) Remote sensing for irrigated agriculture: examples from
research and possible applications. Agric Water Manag 46:137–155
Bastiaanssen WGM, Noordman EJM, Pelgrum H, Davids G, Thoreson BP, Allen RG (2005) SEBAL model
with remotely sensed data to improve water-resources management under actual field conditions. J Irrig
Drain Eng 131:85–93
Breiman L, Friedman JH, Olshen RA, Stone CJ (1984) Classification and regression trees. CRC Press, New York
Campbell GS, Norman JM (1998) An introduction to environmental biophysics. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg
New York
Chemin Y, Platonov A, Ul-Hassan M, Abdullaev I (2004) Water depletion assessment at administrative and
irrigation levels. Case Study of Ferghana Province using public remote sensing data. Agric Water Manag
64(3):183–196
Chen J-M, Zhang R-H (1989) Studies on the measurements of crop emissivity and sky temperature. Agric
For Meteorol 49:23–34
Choudhury BJ (1994) Synergism of multispectral satellite observations for estimating regional land surface
evaporation. Remote Sens Environ 49:264–274
Chub EV (2000) Climate change and its impact on natural resources potential of the repubic of
Uzbekistan. Tashkent, Uzbekistan, Main Administration on Hydrometeorology under the cabinet of
Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Central Asian Hydrometeorological research institute named
after V.A. Bugayev
Colditz RR, Conrad C, Wehrmann T, Schmidt M, Dech S (2006) Generation and assessment of MODIS time
series using quality information. In: IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium,
July 31–August 04 2006, Denver, Colorado, USA
Coll C, Valor E, Caselles V, Niclòs R, Rivas, R, Sánchez JM, Galve JM (2004) Evaluation of the Envisat-AATSR
land surface temperature algorithm with ground measurements in the Valencia test site. In: Proceedings of
the 2004 Envisat & ERS Symposium (ESA SP-572). 6–10 September 2004, Salzburg, Austria
Congalton RG (1991) A review of assessing the accuracy of classifications of remotely sensed data. Remote
Sens Environ 37:35–46
Conrad C (2006) Remote sensing based modeling and hydrological measurements to assess the agricultural
water use in the Khorezm region (Uzbekistan). PhD Dissertation. University of Wuerzburg (in German)
Conrad C, Colditz RR, Petrocchi A, Ruecker GR, Dech S, Schmidt M (2005) Time-series-generator – a
flexible software module to generate and assess time series from NASA MODIS data products. 17.
Symposium und Fachmesse für Angewandte Geoinformatik (AGIT). July 6th–8th 2005, Salzburg,
Austria (in German)
DeFries RS, Hansen MC, Townshend JRG, Sohlberg RA (1998) Global land cover classifications at 8 km
spatial resolution: the use of training data derived from Landsat imagery in decision tree classifiers. Int J
Remote Sens 19(16):3141–3168
Droogers P (2002) Global irrigated area mapping: overview and recommendations. Working Paper 36.
International Water Management Institute. Colombo, Sri Lanka
Dukhovny VA, Sokolov V, Ziganshima D (2004) Some ideas about IWRM implementation in Central Asia.
Seminar on the role of ecosystems as water suppliers. Genava, UNECE
Etter A, McAlpine C, Wilson K, Phinn S, Possingham H (2006) Regional patterns of agricultural land use
and deforestation in Colombia. Agric Ecosyst Environ 114:369–386
Forkutsa I (2006) Modeling water and salt dynamics under irrigated cotton with shallow groundwater in the
Khorezm region of Uzbekistan. In: Vlek PLG (ed) Ecology and development series 37. Goettingen
Glazirin GE, Shanicheva SC, Shub VE (1999) Brief description of Uzbekistan climate. Tashkent
Granger RJ (1997) Comparison of surface and satellite-derived estimates of evapotranspiration using a
feedback algorithm. In: Application of remote sensing in hydrology. Proceedings of the Third
International Workshop, NHRI Symposium No. 17, NASA, Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt,
MD NHRI, October, 1996
Hafeez MM (2003) Water accounting and productivity at different spatial scales in a rice irrigation system: a
remote sensing approach. In: Vlek PLG (ed) Ecology and development series No. 8. Göttingen
Hafeez MM, Khan S (2007) Spatial mapping of actual crop water use in ground water dominant irrigation
system. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research (in press)
Halstead MH, Richman RL, Covey W, Merryman JD (1957) A preliminary report on the design of a
computer for micrometeorology. J Atmos Sci 14(4):308–325
Hansen MC, DeFries RS, Townshend JRG, Sohlberg RA (2000) Global land cover classification at 1 km
spatial resolution using a classification tree approach. Int J Remote Sens 21(6–7):1331–1364
Hendrickx JMH, Vink NH, Fayinke T (1986) Water requirement for irrigated rice in a semi-arid region in
West Africa. Agric Water Manag 11(1):75–90
Howell TA, Evett SR, Tolk JA, Schneider AD (2004) Evapotranspiration of full-, deficit-irrigated, and
dryland cotton on the Northern Texas High Plains. J Irrig Drain Eng 130(4):277–285
Huband NDS, Monteith JL (1986) Radiative surface temperature and energy balance of a wheat canopy. Part
I: comparison of radiative and aerodynamic canopy temperature. Boundary-Layer Meteorol 36:1–17
Huete A, Didan K, Miura T, Rodriguez EP, Gao X, Ferreira LG (2002) Overview of the radiometric and
biophysical performance of the MODIS vegetation indices. Remote Sens Environ 83(1–2):195–213
Humphreys E, Meyer WS, Prathapar SA, Smith DJ (1994) Estimation of evapotranspiration from rice in
southern New South Wales: a review. Aust J Exp Agric 34(7):1069–1078
Ibrakhimov M (2005) Spatial and temporal dynamics of groundwater table and salinity in Khorezm (Aral Sea
Basin), Uzbekistan. Göttingen, Germany
Ibragimov N, Evett SR, Esanbekov Y, Kamilov BS, Mirzaev L, Lamers JPA (2007) Water use efficiency of
irrigated cotton in Uzbekistan under drip and furrow irrigation. Agric Water Manag 90:112–120
Jensen JR (2000) Remote sensing of the environment: an earth resource perspective. Prentice Hall, Upper
Saddle River, NJ, USA
Justice CO, Vermote EF, Townshend JRG, DeFries RS, Roy DP, Hall DK, Salomonson VV, Privette J, Riggs
G, Strahler AH, Lucht W, Myneni R, Knjazihhin Y, Running S, Nemani R, Wan Z, Huete A, van
Leeuwen W, Wolfe RE, Giglio L, Muller J-P, Lewis P, Barnsley M (1998) The moderate resolution
imaging spectroradiometer (MODIS): land remote sensing for global change research. IEEE Trans
Geosci Remote Sens 36:1228–1249
Khamzina A (2006) The assessment of tree species and irrigation techniques for afforestation of degraded
agricultural landscapes in Khorezm, Uzbekistan, Aral Sea Basin. In: Vlek PLG (ed) Ecology and
development series 39. Goettingen, Germany
Loveland TR, Reed BC, Brown JF, Ohlen DO, Zhu Z, Yang L, Merchant JW (2000) Development of a
global land cover characteristics database and IGBP DISCover from 1 km AVHRR data. Int J Remote
Sens 21(6–7):1303–1330
Martius C, Lamers JPA, Wehrheim P, Schoeller-Schletter A, Eshchanov R, Tupitsa A, Khamzina A,
Akramkhanov A, Vlek PLG (2004) Developing sustainable land and water management for the Aral Sea
Basin through an interdisciplinary research. In: Seng V, Craswell E, Fukai S (eds) Water in agriculture,
ACIAR Proceedings No. 116 Canberra, Australia
Micklin PP (1991) The water management crisis in Soviet Central Asia. The Carl Beck Papers in Russian
and East European Studies. University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
Mohan S, Arumugam N (1994) Irrigation crop coefficients for lowland rice. Irrig Drain Syst 8:159–176
Mueller M (2006) Sectoral and economy-wide effects of different land and water use reforms. University of
Bonn, Germany
Myneni RB, Hoffman S, Knyazikhin Y, Privette JL, Glassy J, Tian Y, Wang Y, Song X, Zhang Y, Smith GR,
Lotsch A, Friedl M, Morisette JT, Votava P, Nemani RR, Running SW (2002) Global products of
vegetation leaf area and fraction absorbed PAR from year one of MODIS data. Remote Sens Environ 83
(1–2):214–231
R Development Core Team (2005) R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation
for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria
Ressl R, Micklin PP (2004) Morphological changes in the Aral Sea: satellite imagery and water balance
model. In: Nihoul JCJ, Zavialov PO, Micklin PP (eds) Dying and dead seas: climatic versus anthropic
causes: proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop Liège, Belgium, 7–10 May, 2003. Nato
Science Series: 4. Earth and Environmental Sciences 36
Richards JA, Xiuping J (2005) Remote sensing digital image analysis. An introduction. Springer, Heidelberg,
Germany
Ruecker G, Shi Z, Conrad C, Martius C, Lamers J, Strunz G, Vlek P, Dech S (2005) Site-specific cotton yield
estimation by multi-temporal remote sensing data and agro-meteorological model applied to the
Khorezm region, Aral Sea Basin. Paper presented in INTAS, International Association for the promotion
of co-operation with scientists from the New Independent states of the former Soviet Union. Aral Sea
Basin Water and Food Conference – Managing Water and Food Quality and Security in Central Asia, 1–4
September 2005, Almaty, Kazakhstan
Ruzmetov B, Rahimov Z, Rudenko I (2003) Analysis of farmer enterprises and agricultural markets. ZEF
Working papers for Sustainable Development in Central Asia. Center for Development Research (ZEF).
Bonn, Germany
Sakthivadivel R, Thiruvengadachari S, Amerasinghe U, Bastiaanssen WGM, Molden DJ (1999) Performance
evaluation of the Bhakra irrigation system, India, using remote sensing and GIS techniques. Research
report 28. International Water Management Institute (IWMI)
Savtchenko A, Ouzounov D, Ahmad S, Acker J, Leptoukh G, Koziana J, Nickless D (2004) Terra and Aqua
MODIS products available from NASA GES DAAC. Adv Space Res 34(4):710–714
Schaaf CB, Gao F, Strahler AH, Lucht W, Li XW, Tsang T, Strugnell NC, Zhang XY, Jin YF, Muller JP,
Lewis P, Barnsley M, Hobson P, Disney M, Roberts G, Dunderdale M, Doll C, d’Entremont RP, Hu BX,
Liang SL, Privette JL, Roy D (2002) First operational BRDF, albedo nadir reflectance products from
MODIS. Remote Sens Environ 83:135–148
Schmugge TJ, Kustas WP, Ritchie JC, Jackson TJ, Rango Al (2002) Remote sensing in hydrology. Adv
Water Resour 25(8–12):1367–1385
Schweitzer C, Rücker GR, Conrad C, Bendix J, Strunz G, Dech S, Göttingen 2004 (2004) Knowledge-based
land use classification combining expert knowledge, GIS, multi-temporal Landsat 7 ETM+ and MODIS
time series data in Khorezm, Uzbekistan. Proceedings of 1st Göttingen GIS & Remote Sensing Days.
Environmental Studies, Goettingen, Germany
Tasumi M, Allen RG (2007) Satellite-based ET mapping to assess variation in ET with timing of crop
development. Agric Water Manag 88(1–3):54–62
Tasumi M, Trezza R, Allen RG, Wright JL (2005) Operational aspects of satellite-based energy balance
models for irrigated crops in the semi-arid US. Irrig Drain Syst 19(3–4):355–376
Thenkabail PS, Schull M, Turral H (2005) Ganges and Indus river basin land use/land cover (LULC) and
irrigated area mapping using continuous streams of MODIS data. Remote Sens Environ 95:317–341
Vermote EF, El Saleous NZ, Justice CO, Kaufman YJ, Privette J, Remer LC, Tanre D (1997) Atmospheric
correction of visible to middle infrared EOS-MODIS data over land surface, background, operational
algorithm and validation. J Geophys Res 102(14):17131–17142
Verstraeten WW, Veroustraete F, Feyen J (2005) Estimating evapotranspiration of European forests from
NOAA-imagery at satellite overpass time: towards an operational processing chain for integrated optical
and thermal sensor data products. Remote Sens Environ 96:256–276
Vidal A, Perrier A (1989) Analysis of a simplified relation used to estimate daily evapotranspiration from
satellite thermal IR data. Int J Remote Sens 10(8):1327–1337
Viovy N (2000) Automatic Classification of Time Series (ACTS): a new clustering method for remote
sensing time series. Int J Remote Sens 21(6–7):1537–1560
Wan Z (2007) Collection 5 changes in the V5 PGE16. In: NASA Goddard Space Flight Center: MODIS land
collection 5 changes. http://landweb.nascom.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/QA_WWW/newPage.cgi?fileName=
MODLAND_C005_changes. Cited January 5, 2007
Wan Z, Li Z-L (1997) A physics-based algorithm for retrieving land-surface emissivity and temperature from
EOS/MODIS Data. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 35:980–996
WBGU (1998) Worlds in transition. Ways towards sustainable management of fresh water resources.
Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Wegerich K (2004) Informal network utilisation and water distribution in two districts in the Khorezm
Province, Uzbekistan. Local Environ 9(4):337–352
Wolfe RE, Roy DP, Vermote EF (1998) MODIS land data storage, gridding, and compositing methodology:
level 2 grid. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 36:1324–1338
WWF (2002) Living planet report. World Wide Fund for Nature