Journal of Oil Palm Research Vol. 25 (2) August 2013 p. 1400-1400
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE EFFECTS
OF PROCESSING CONDITIONS AND
FORMULATIONS ON THE PHYSICAL AND
SENSORY PROPERTIES OF FROZEN NASI
LEMAK MADE OF PALM-BASED SANTAN AND
COCONUT SANTAN
RAFIDAH ABD HAMID*; NUR IZYANI AHAMAD AZAHARI* and MISKANDAR MAT SAHRI*
ABSTRACT
The objective of the study was to determine the efect of processing conditions on physical characteristics
of frozen nasi lemak. Two types of santan that is, palm-based santan and coconut santan were used in
this experiment. They were tested at three santan to rice ratios i.e. 1/5, 1.5/5 and 2/5 under diferent
freezing rates and thawing processes. The results showed that nasi lemak made of palm-based santan have
lower moisture content compared to that made of coconut santan and fast-freezing followed by immediate
reheating, was able to retain a higher moisture content in both samples. The water activity of frozen nasi
lemak samples ranged from 0.994 to 0.998 at 25.0 ± 0.7°C and was not signiicantly afected by processing
conditions and type of santan. An increase in the amount of santan signiicantly increased the amount
of lipid-amylose complexes formed in frozen nasi lemak which resulted in high Complexing Index (CI)
values. It simultaneously reduced the hardness and increased the stickiness of the rice kernels for both
type of santan. The freezing rate inluenced the stickiness of rice. At 1/5 santan to rice ratio, nasi lemak
made of palm-based santan was comparable to that of coconut santan in its sensory attributes, except for
its colour, odor and overall taste.
Keywords: lipid-amylose complexes, thawing, frozen, nasi lemak, palm-based, santan, coconut.
Date received: 18 July 2012; Sent for revision: 11 September 2012; Received in inal form: 28 February 2013; Accepted: 22 March 2013.
Oil Board (MPOB) developed a palm-based transfree liquid santan in 2008 and it was successfully
commercialised in 2010. It has been proven that
coconut santan contains higher fat and protein
content compared to palm-based santan (Zaida, et
al., 2008).
Foods that contain santan are always perceived
as ‘rich’. Santan gives a unique lavour and taste
to the food. Among the popular local dishes that
contain santan are nasi lemak and curry. Nasi lemak
is one of the most popular Malaysian dishes for
INTRODUCTION
Santan is a Malay term for coconut milk and is
derived from the lesh of coconuts. Due to the
increase in demand for santan, palm-based santan has
been developed. Researchers at the Malaysian Palm
* Malaysian Palm Oil Board,
6 Persiaran Institusi, Bandar Baru Bangi,
43000 Kajang, Selangor, Malaysia.
E-mail: raidah@mpob.gov.my
1
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
breakfast. Two of the main ingredients in nasi lemak
are santan and rice. Recently, instant and frozen nasi
lemak was introduced to the market as a ready-toeat meal in order to cater to the busy life-style of the
urban community, which requires for meals that can
be served fast. Palm-based santan has been tested
in many foods, including nasi lemak. However, the
usage of palm-based santan in nasi lemak has not been
scientiically reported in peer-reviewed journal.
In this study, the physical characteristics of frozen
nasi lemak made of palm-based and coconut santan
were examined. The objective of the study was to
determine the efects of processing conditions on the
physical characteristics of frozen nasi lemak. Four
analyses involved were moisture content, water
activity, complexing index and texture analysis.
Water content, or moisture content, is a
measurement of the total water contained in a food.
On the other hand, water activity is a measurement
of the availability of water for biological reactions.
It determines the ability of microorganisms to grow.
If water activity decreases, microorganisms with
the ability to grow will also decrease. Water activity
can be reduced by freezing, e.g. water is removed in
the form of ice. However, Benson et al. (1992) had
detected increased amounts of malondialdehyde, a
breakdown product of lipid peroxides, in frozen/
thawed rice cells compared to unfrozen controls.
They suggested that freezing injury can promote
lipid peroxidation. Later, Yu et al. (2010a) found
that high quality cooked rice can be produced
by combined rapid freezing with frozen storage.
They reported that rapid freezing combined with
−18°C frozen storage can efectively retard starch
retrogradation and maintain the textural properties
of cooked rice for at least seven months. Another
inding suggested that cooked rice chilled with
slower cooling rate retrograded faster than chilled
with rapid cooling rate (Yu, et al., 2010b).
The texture of a cooked rice is described by
the hardness and stickiness values. The textural
properties of a cooked rice is afected by the
processing conditions and chemical characteristics of
the raw kernel (Mestres, et al., 2011). These chemical
characteristics may include amylose, protein and
arabinoxylan contents. Xie et al. (2008) discovered
the hardness and adhesiveness of cooked rice of
non-waxy cultivars were due to protein hydration.
The cooking method applied in this study
was based on the common rice cooking method of
households in Malaysia which is boiling followed
by slow heating. Another method is by stewing.
Ghasemi et al. (2009) reported that stewing of rice
grains by steam after boiling in excess water can
be used for cooking rice perfectly. It reduced the
hardness and increased the adhesiveness of rice
grains signiicantly, which means that it produced
better gelatinisation and more expansion of starch
granules compared to non-stewed rice.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
White rice (Super Special Jasmine, Selangor,
Malaysia) was purchased from a shop. Palm-based
santan (Khalis, Premium Food Corporation Sdn
Bhd, Selangor, Malaysia) and coconut santan (Ayam
Brand, Selangor, Malaysia) were purchased from a
nearby supermarket. Ginger, shallots, pandan leaves
(screwpine) and salt were bought from a wet market.
Filtered tap water was used for cooking.
Methods
Preparation of frozen nasi lemak. Several
formulations were tested as listed in Table 1. All
ingredients were put into an automatic rice cooker
(Model 18GXN, 1.8L, 220V, 50Hz, Panasonic, Shah
TABLE 1. FORMULATIONS FOR ALL LEVELS OF TREATMENTS
Santan to
rice ratio
1/5
Rice (500 g)
Water (1000 ml)
Palm-based
santan (100ml)
Ginger (5 g)
Shallots (5 g)
Salt (2 g)
Ingredients
Pandan leaves
(2 pcs)
1.5/5
2/5
1/5
1.5/5
Rice (500 g)
Water (1000
ml)
Palm-based
santan
(150ml)
Ginger (5 g)
Shallots
(5 g)
Salt (2 g)
Pandan
leaves
(2 pcs)
Rice (500 g)
Water (1000
ml)
Palm-based
santan
(200ml)
Ginger (5 g)
Shallots (5 g)
Salt (2 g)
Pandan
leaves
(2 pcs)
Rice (500 g)
Water (1000
ml)
Coconut
santan
(100ml)
Ginger (5 g)
Shallots (5 g)
Salt (2 g)
Pandan
leaves (2 pcs)
Rice (500 g)
Water
(1000 ml)
Coconut
santan
(150ml)
Ginger
(5 g)
Shallots
(5 g)
Salt (2 g)
Pandan
leaves
(2 pcs)
2
2/5
No santan
Rice (500 g) Rice (500 g)
Water (1000 Water
ml)
(1000 ml)
Coconut
santan
(200ml)
Ginger (5 g)
Shallots
(5 g)
Salt (2 g)
Pandan
leaves (2
pcs)
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
Alam, Malaysia) and cooked for about 26 min.
Cooked samples of 100 g were transferred into
labelled 350 ml square microwavable polypropylene
plastic container. Every set has seven containers.
These containers were labelled A, B, C, D, E, F and
G (Table 2). These samples were then subjected to
diferent processing conditions, as speciied in Table 2.
12 ml test tube. The sample was then homogenised
using a vortex mixer (Barnstead Thermolyne,
Dubuque, USA) for 2 min and centrifuged (Model
80-2, Jiangsu, China) for 15 min at 3000 rpm. The
supernatant (500 µl) was transferred into a cuvette
and iodine solution was added before made up
to 2 ml with distilled water. The iodine solution
used for this analysis was freshly prepared by
dissolving 2 g of potassium iodide (KI) (Systerm,
Shah Alam, Malaysia) and 1.3 g iodine (I2) (Systerm,
Shah Alam, Malaysia) in 50 ml of distilled water.
This solution was allowed to stand for about 2 hr
before the inal volume was made up to 100 ml with
distilled water. The absorbance was measured using
spectrophotometer (Aquamate, Minnesota, USA) at
690 nm. The absorbance represents the portion of
starches that formed complexes with iodine. Pure
potato starch (98%) was used as control. CI was
calculated using the following equation.
Storage of frozen nasi lemak. Samples C, F, and G
from all treatments were stored at -20°C, straight
away after cooking. While, samples B, D and E were
frozen using a blast freezer (at -40°C for 2 hr) before
storage at -20°C. Samples were stored overnight
before further analyses were carried out.
Reheat of frozen nasi lemak. On the day of the
analysis, samples D and F were directly reheated
in the microwave without thawing. Whereas,
samples E and G were thawed for 15 min (at room
temperature) before they were reheated in the
microwave for 5 min. Reheated samples were used
for all analyses.
CI (%) =
Moisture content. The moisture content was
determined according to the AOAC International
Method 926.08 (AOAC 2007). The 3 g sample was put
in a crucible before it was left in an oven (Memmert,
Schwabach, Germany) overnight at 105°C. Then
it was transferred into an electronic dessicator
(Eureka, Taipei, Taiwan) for cooling down before
weighing. Total moisture content was calculated
using formula:
% Moisture content =
b - (c – a)
b
(Absorbance of control – Absorbance of sample)
Absorbance of control
x 100
Water activity. The sample was placed in a water
activity (Aw) meter (AquaLab, Pullman, USA). This
instrument has selectable internal temperature
control which enables temperature-controlled
water activity determination under a temperaturestable sampling environment, without the need of
an external waterbath. The measurement was taken
directly from the instrument.
Textural analysis. The texture of the frozen nasi
lemak was determined using a Texture Analyser (TA.
XT21, Texture Technologies, Corp, UK) with a 36 mm
cylinder probe by using a 5 kg load cell. The analyser
was linked to a computer that recorded the data by
a software program called Texture Expert Excede
version 1.0 (Stable Micro Systems Software, Surrey,
UK). A compression force versus time program was
used to compress the samples till 90% of the original
kernel thickness was achieved. A 36 mm cylinder
probe was used to compress three kernels, with pretest speed and test speed of 0.5 mm s-1, and posttest speed 10.0 mm s-1. The texture was expressed as
x 100
where, a is weight of empty crucible (g);
b is weight of sample (g); and
c is weight of inal sample with crucible (g)
Complexing index. Complexing index (CI) was
determined using method developed by Gilbert
and Spragg (1964). Sample of 2 g was mashed into
paste and mixed with 10 ml distilled water in the
TABLE 2. LABELLING OF NASI LEMAK SAMPLES FOR DIFFERENT PROCESSING CONDITIONS
Sample A: freshly prepared nasi lemak.
Sample B: freshly prepared nasi lemak – fast freezing (-40°C).
Sample C: freshly prepared nasi lemak – slow freezing (-20°C).
Sample D: freshly prepared nasi lemak – fast freezing – immediately reheated (5 min).
Sample E: freshly prepared nasi lemak – fast freezing – thawed (15 min) prior to reheat (5 min).
Sample F: freshly prepared nasi lemak – slow freezing – immediately reheated (5 min).
Sample G: freshly prepared nasi lemak – slow freezing – thawed (15 min) prior to reheat (5 min).
3
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
hardness (peak force of the irst compression) and
stickiness (maximum –ve force) of the samples. At
least four readings were taken for every sample.
Theoretically, slow freezing will result in
signiicant lower moisture content than initial
value due to the structural damage of the rice
which promotes drip when the product is thawed
(Redmond et al., 2005). However, in this experiment,
samples that went through slow freezing before
they were thawed and reheated (sample G) had a
higher content of moisture compared to sample that
undergone fast freezing (sample E). Most probably
the drip loss during thawing was re-absorbed into
the kernel during reheating since the packaging was
kept intact during thawing.
The moisture content of samples E and F were
about the same. Fast freezing followed by thawing
and reheating seems not to have much efect
compared to slow freezing followed by immediate
reheating in these frozen nasi lemak samples.
It was generally observed that the moisture
content of nasi lemak increased as the ratio of santan
to rice was increased from 1/5 to 1.5/5. An addition
of santan reduces relative water content because
the components in santan which are mainly oil
would lower the water activity of the cooked rice
(El-Bassiouny and Bekheta, 2005). However, at
two-ifth santan to rice ratio, the moisture content
dropped slightly. This applies to both types of santan
as shown in Figure 1.
Overall, nasi lemak made of palm-based santan
has lower moisture content compared to that made
of coconut santan, due to the fact that moisture
content of palm-based santan is lower than coconut
santan. The moisture content for palm-based santan
is 63.1%, while that for coconut santan is 65.3%
(Zaida et al., 2008).
When the data were analysed using the General
Linear Model (GLM), it was observed that the value
of R2 of each single factor was just 51.4% and this
gave an indication that the single factors (type of
santan, santan to rice ratio, freezing rate and reheating
condition) did not signiicantly afect the moisture
content of frozen nasi lemak. But, the R2 of the
interactions of these factors was very high (99.84%).
The interactions of these factors signiicantly
inluenced the moisture content of samples. The
interactions between freezing rate and thawing
condition have the highest value of Sequential Sum
of Squares (Seq SS) which meant that this interaction
highly inluenced the moisture content of frozen nasi
lemak.
Sensory evaluation. Sensory evaluation was
conducted by 32 untrained panellists. Panellists
were randomly selected from the Malaysian Palm
Oil Board (MPOB) staf and students, without any
speciic priority in selection. They were asked to
evaluate two samples; 1) nasi lemak made from palmbased santan; and 2) nasi lemak made from coconut
santan. Evaluation was based on six attributes
that included colour, odour, hardness, stickiness,
oiliness and overall taste using a nine-point scale.
Scale 1 indicates the least acceptable sample while
9 indicated the most acceptable sample. Samples of
frozen nasi lemak made of palm-based santan and
coconut santan were immediately reheated in a
microwave before they were served to the panellists.
Nasi lemak was served warm with hot savoury. Only
nasi lemak with one-ifth santan to rice ratio was used
in the sensory evaluation.
Statistical analysis. Data were evaluated using the
analysis of variance (ANOVA) and General Linear
Model (Minitab Version 14). Signiicance was
established at a level of p < 0.05.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Moisture Content
Moisture content is an important criteria that
has a signiicant efect on the freshness and quality
of the food. Rice is considered as fully cooked
when the inal moisture content is in the range of
58% to 64% (Zheng and Lan, 2007). Figure 1 shows
the signiicant diference in moisture content of
samples between diferent processing conditions.
Samples B and C were not analysed. In sample A,
where nasi lemak was freshly prepared and did not
undergo any freezing treatment, the lowest value of
moisture content was recorded, regardless of type
or any santan to rice ratio, due to moisture loss to
the surrounding atmosphere during the process of
cooling down.
Sample D, regardless of type or any santan
to rice ratio, has the highest moisture content.
Obviously, fast freezing and immediate reheating
have signiicant efects on the moisture content of
the frozen nasi lemak. Fast freezing formed very
small ice crystals in food structure, which provide
less damage to the cellular structure when the frozen
product is thawed (Ernest, 1999). Thus, water
remains within the kernel after reheating.
Water Activity
It was observed that the range of Aw of nasi
lemak samples was from 0.994 to 0.998 at 25.0
± 0.7°C. Water activity is the range of 0 to 1. The
values near to 1 indicated that nasi lemak is classiied
under the perishable food category. Theoretically,
4
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
Palm-based santan
Coconut santan
No santan
Figure 1. Means ± standard deviation of moisture content of nasi lemak made of palm-based and coconut santan under
diferent processing conditions.
the range of Aw that for perishable food is 1.00 to
0.95. Perishable food needs to be handled with
extra care since it can easily be spoilt by microbial
contamination due to high water availability. Aw is
a very useful parameter to determine the possibility
for microbial growth (Subramaniam, 2000). As the
Aw gets higher, shelf-life would become shorter.
Perishable food should be kept hot (>70°C) or cold
(<5°C) to ensure it is safe for consumption. Results
showed that there were no signiicant diferences in
water activity of all samples. Thus, santan to rice
ratio and the rates of freezing and reheating method
do not signiicantly inluence the Aw of frozen nasi
lemak.
On the other hand, there was a slight diference
in Aw of rice cooked without an addition of santan,
where the Aw was lower compared to other samples.
The addition of santan increased the Aw of the rice
kernel.
Complexing Index
Figure 2 shows the means and standard deviations
for complexing index (CI) of samples. CI gives the
indication of how much starches (i.e. amylose) have
formed complexes with lipid in nasi lemak samples.
In this context, amylose was from rice, while lipid
was from santan that was added in during the
preparation of nasi lemak. Amylose helices occupied
by lipid reduced its capacity to attach to iodine,
and will have a lower absorbance than starch alone
Figure 2. Means ± standard deviation of complexing index of nasi lemak made of palm-based and coconut santan under
diferent processing conditions.
5
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
when mixed with iodine. Thus, the CI will increase
as the iodine binding capacity decreases (Tang and
Copeland, 2007). The control starch used in this
analysis is the amylose from potato starch (>98%)
and its absorbance was determined to be 0.982.
From the results shown in Figure 2, the efect of
diferent processing conditions (freezing rate and
thawing condition) on CI was negligible. However,
there was a clear pattern when the amount of santan
was increased. The CI progressively increased when
the amount of santan added was increased. This
applies to both palm-based and coconut santan.
This means that when more santan was added, more
amylose-lipid complexes were formed leaving only
small amount of free amylose helices that could
bind with iodine. Thus, the amount of santan added
inluenced the CI value.
A higher CI value indicates that there are more
lipid-amylose complexes formed and fewer amylose
formed complexes with iodine. Theoretically, rice
without the addition of santan should have the
lowest CI values in all treatments. However, the CI
values of sample cooked without santan remained
relatively low in all treatments except for B, D, E
and G. Rate of freezing afects the CI as well. Fast
freezing has resulted in lower CI compared to slow
freezing, as indicated by sample B, D and E. The
efect of rate of freezing on CI is very signiicant.
Immediate reheating resulted in higher CI value
compared to thawing prior to reheating as indicated
by sample G.
When the data were analysed using the GLM, it
was observed that the single factors (type of santan,
santan to rice ratio, freezing rate and reheating
condition) did not have a high impact on the CI
of nasi lemak. The value for R2 was just 53.88%.
However, the interactions between these factors
having R2 of 99.66% really inluenced the CI values.
The interaction between type of santan, freezing rate
and thawing condition had given the highest impact
on CI of frozen nasi lemak.
the higher the amount of leached amylose, the
harder the inal cooked rice texture. This could
explain why rice cooked without santan (sample
G) that has undergone slow freezing has higher
hardness values compared to that of fast freezing.
Slow freezing caused more rupture to cells and more
leaching components is released. But this situation
could only be noticed easily in rice cooked without
santan. When santan was added during cooking
and cooked samples were freezed and reheated
at diferent conditions, this theory could not be
applied. The efect of diferent freezing rates and
thawing conditions were not very clear in frozen
nasi lemak regardless of the type of santan used.
Hardness is generally related to the level of the
amylose content. Generally, high amylose rice has
high hardness and tensile values (Lu et al., 2009). In
this experiment, the same type of rice is used in all
samples. Therefore, the diference in hardness values
is not due to the diference in amylose content. The
addition of santan may contributed to the changes in
hardness. According to Kaur and Singh (2000), the
addition of fatty acids into food that contains starch
will alter the physical and chemical properties of
food since starchy food will tend to form complexes
between amylose and lipids. These complexes
afect the hardness value. Cameron and Wang
(2005) reported that protein and crude lipid contents
have a negative correlation with hardness of cooked
rice. Generally, results in Figure 3 indicate that as
the amount of santan increased, the hardness of rice
gradually decreased.
It is observed that type and amount of santan
added afected the hardness of nasi lemak. However,
the efect of using diferent types of santan only had
a smaller impact on the hardness of the samples.
Data analysis using the GLM showed that type
of santan, amount of santan, the interaction between
the rate of freezing and thawing condition, and
the interaction between type, amount and rate of
freezing have a signiicant efect on the hardness of
frozen nasi lemak.
Hardness
Stickiness
The rice kernels were analysed for its hardness
at an ambient temperature and the results are shown
in Figure 3. Hardness is related to the hydration
process which takes place in starch granules. During
cooking, rice granules absorb moisture and swell
which provide the increase in volume of cooked
rice. While the granule expands, cells will rupture
and cause amylose leaching. This may afect the rice
texture.
Cameron and Wang (2005) reported that the
cooked rice texture has strong correlation with the
amount of insoluble amylose than did the apparent
amylose or leached amylose. They concluded that
Stickiness is another important criteria when it
comes to cooked rice. Amylose content is not directly
related to the stickiness but when the amylose
content was high, the stickiness will be low (Ayabe
et al., 2009). Figure 4 shows the mean and standard
deviation of stickiness of samples. Negative (-ve)
sign indicates the stickiness, as measured by the
Texture Analyser (TA.XT21, Texture Technologies,
Corp, UK). Rice without santan has the lowest
stickiness value followed by frozen nasi lemak made
of palm-based santan and frozen nasi lemak made of
coconut santan. The stickiness of rice was increased
6
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
Palm-based santan
Coconut santan
No santan
Figure 3. Means ± standard deviation of hardness of nasi lemak made of palm-based and coconut santan under diferent processing conditions.
Palm-based santan
Coconut santan
No santan
Figure 4. Means ± standard deviation of nasi lemak made of palm-based and coconut santan under diferent processing conditions.
7
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
as more santan was added. The amount of santan
signiicantly inluenced the stickiness. This applied
to both types of santan.
The rate of freezing also has signiicant efect
on the stickiness of samples. Slow freezing resulted
in samples which were less sticky compared to fast
freezing and unfrozen rice. Immediate reheating
resulted in stickier samples compared to thawing
prior to reheating.
The stickiness of the rice was not greatly afected
by the processing conditions as shown in Figure 4.
The trend was not very clear. According to Syamsir
et al. (2011), the deformation of the grain and exposed
endosperm after the grain splitting sharply changed
stickiness values. The addition of santan during
cooking and the processing conditions (freezing
and thawing) caused some deformations to the rice
kernels that vary its stickiness values. However,
frozen samples (B and C) had low stickiness values
in all formulations. The stickiness value was the
highest in samples formulated with two-ifth
santan to rice ratio that had undergone fast freezing
followed by immediate reheating.
The R2 value for the single factor analysis was
64.53%, whereas, in the interactions analysis the
R2 value was higher (98.87%). This indicates that
interactions between factors (type of santan, santan
to rice ratio, freezing rate and reheating condition)
has a signiicant efect on the stickiness of nasi
lemak. The type and amount of santan have the
highest value of sequential Seq SS, thus indicating
that these two factors have very signiicant impact
in the stickiness of nasi lemak.
one-ifth santan to rice ratio is suicient to cook a
nasi lemak, and it applies to both types of santan.
Results from the sensory evaluation shows
that frozen nasi lemak made of coconut santan had
higher scores compared to frozen nasi lemak made
of palm-based santan for all attributes except for
oiliness, hardness and stickiness, where they are
not signiicantly diferent, as shown in Table 3.
Signiicant diferences were observed for colour,
odour and overall taste between the samples. Only
eight out of 32 panellists prefered the frozen nasi
lemak made of palm-based santan. The majority of
the panellists prefered frozen nasi lemak made of
coconut santan.
Figure 5 further illustrates the values showed in
Table 4. From the results it can be concluded that
some eforts could be made to improve the colour,
odour and overall taste of nasi lemak made of palmbased santan. The performance of palm-based
santan should be improved so that it is comparable
or better than coconut santan in frozen nasi lemak. By
doing this, consumer demand and preferences for
palm-based santan can be increased.
Sensory Evaluation
Nasi lemak is a common food among Malaysians
especially for breakfast. Therefore, the use of
untrained panellists in this sensory study was
suicient to meet the purpose. Only nasi lemak
with 1/5 santan to rice ratio was used in the sensory
evaluation because results from the previous
physical analyses of this experiment showed that
Figure 5. Mean values of hardness, stickiness, oiliness, colour, odour
and overall taste of frozen nasi lemak made of palm-based
and coconut santan.
TABLE 3. MEAN ± STANDARD DEVIATION OF SENSORY ATTRIBUTES OF NASI LEMAK MADE OF
PALM-BASED AND COCONUT SANTAN
Hardness
Stickiness
Oiliness
Colour
Odour
Overall Taste
Preference
Coconut santan
6.7813 ± 1.3616a 6.6563 ± 1.3102b
6.5625 ±
1.2165c
7.2813 ±
0.9583d
7.4063 ±
1.1876f
7.5937 ±
0.9108h
24
Palm-based
santan
6.4688 ± 1.7410a 6.4375 ± 1.2936b
6.5625 ±
1.1622c
6.3438 ±
1.4505e
6.0938 ±
1.6136g
6.6563 ±
1.4505i
8
Note: Mean values in the same column with diferent letters are difer signiicantly (p<0.05).
8
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
El-BASSIOUNY, H M S and BEKHETA, M A (20050.
Efect of salt stress on relative water content,
lipid peroxidation, polyamines, amino acids and
ethelyene on two wheat cultivars. International
journal of Agriculture and Biology, 7(3): 363-368.
CONCLUSION
The ratio of palm-based santan to rice of one-ifth is
suicient in providing the texture to a frozen nasi
lemak. However, nasi lemak made of palm-based
santan has a lower moisture content compared to
one made of coconut santan. The rate of the freezing
and thawing process inluences the moisture
content and texture properties of frozen nasi lemak.
Fast freezing followed by immediate reheating
without thawing resulted in less sticky, irm texture.
The water activity of frozen nasi lemak was very
high (0.994 to 0.998 at 25.0 ± 0.7°C) and was not
signiicantly afected by processing conditions and
type of santan. The formation of lipid-amylose
complexes was enhanced by increasing the amount
of santan and this applies to both types of santan.
Increasing of santan to rice ratio led to the reduction
of hardness but an increase in the stickiness of the
rice kernels, regardless of the type of santan. Nasi
lemak made of palm-based santan was comparable to
that of coconut santan in its sensory attributes except
for colour, odour and overall taste when tested at
one-ifth santan to rice ratio.
ERNEST, R V (1999). Elementary Food Science. Fourth
edition.. Springer-Verlag,New York, LLC. p. 177.
GHASEMI, E; MOSAVIAN, M T H
and
KHODAPARAST, M H H (2009). Efect of stewing
in cooking step on textural and morphological
properties of cooked rice. Rice Science, 16(3): 243-246.
GILBERT, G A and SPRAGG, S P (1964). Iodimetric
determination of amylose. Methods in Carbohydrate
Chemistry (Whistler, W L ed.). Vol. 4. Academic
Press, New York. p. 168-169.
KAUR, K and SINGH, N (2000). Amylose-lipid
complex formation during cooking of rice lour. Food
Chemistry, 71(4): 511-517.
LU, Z H; SASAKI, T; LI, Y Y; YOSHIHASHI, T; LI,
L T and KOHYAMA, K (2009). Efect of amylose
content and rice type on dynamic viscoelasticity of
a composite rice starch gel. Food Hydrocolloids, 23(7):
1712-1719.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors thank Dr Abd Gapor Mohd Top and Ms
Mahani Rifaeh in the Agro Product Unit, MPOB, for
their technical assistance in the vitamin E analysis.
MESTRES, C; RIBEYRE, F; PONS, B; FALLET, V and
MATENCIO, F (2011). Sensory texture of cooked
rice is rather linked to chemical than to physical
characteristics of raw grain. J. Cereal Science, 53(1):
81-89.
REFERENCES
REDMOND, G A; GORMLEY, T R and BUTLER, F
(2005). Efect of short- and long-term frozen storage
with MAP on the quality of freeze-chilled lasagne.
Lebensmittel Wissenchaft und Technologie, 38 (1): 81-87.
AOAC INTERNATIONAL (2007). Oicial Methods
of Analysis. 18th edition. Association of Oicial
Analytical
Chemists
(AOAC)
International,
Gaithersburg, MD.
SUBRAMANIAM, P (2000). The Stability and ShelfLife of Food.. Woodhead Publishing Limited. 28 pp.
AYABE, S; KASAI, M; OHISHI, K and HATAE, K
(2009). Textural properties and structures of starches
from Indica and Japonica with similar amylose
content. Food Science and Technology Research. 15(3):
299-306.
SYAMSIR, E; SUHARTONO, M T and VALENTINA,
S (2010). Efect of time-temperature and amylose
content of rice on the color and texture of rice-based
emergency canned food. Proc. of the International
Seminar of Current Issues and Challenges in Food Safety.
Bogor Agricultural University, Indonesia.
BENSON, E E; LYNCH, P T and JONES, J (1992).
The detection of lipid peroxidation products in
cryoprotected and frozen rice cells: consequences
for post-thaw survival. Plant Science, 85(1): 107-114.
TANG, M C and COPELAND, L (2007). Analysis
of complexes between lipids and wheat starch.
Carbohydrate Polymers Journal, 67 (1): 80-85.
CAMERON, D K and WANG, Y J (2005). A better
understanding of factors that afect the hardness
and stickiness of long-grain rice. Cereal Chemistry.
82(2): 113-119.
XIE, L; CHEN, N; DUAN, B; ZHU, Z and LIAO, X
(2008). Impact of proteins on pasting and cooking
9
JOURNAL OF OIL PALM RESEARCH 25 (2) (AUGUST 2013)
J. Cereal
behaviour of cooked rice during storage. J. Food
Engineering, 96(3): 416-420.
YU, S; MA, Y and SUN, D W (2010a). Efects
of freezing rates on starch retrogradation and
textural properties of cooked rice during storage.
LWT - Food Science and Technology, 43(7): 1138-1143.
ZAIDA, Z; SHUID, A A; WAN, R A I; NOR, A I and
AZMAN, I (2008). Palm-based trans-free liqiud
santan. MPOB Information Series No. 391.
properties of waxy and non-waxy rice.
Science, 47(2): 372-379.
ZHENG, X and LAN, Y (2007). Efects of drying
temperature and moisture content on rice taste
quality. Agricultural Engineering International: the
CIGR Ejournal, Vol. IX.
YU, S; MA, Y; LIU, T; MENAGER, L and SUN, D
W (2010b). Impact of cooling rates on the staling
10