NEW LITERARIAAn International Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies in Humanities
Volume 3, No. 2, August-September, 2022, PP. 86-99
ISSN: 2582-7375
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.48189/nl.2022.v03i2.011
www.newliteraria.com
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with
the Nation: A Study of Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
Merinnage Nelani De Costa
Abstract
Migrant women workers are the main income generators of their families and they contribute
to the Sri Lankan economy as a vital part of the labour force. This research explores their
representations in Sri Lankan English fiction in terms of how they are perceived and negotiate
with their identities. The methodology of this study includes a textual analysis of selected Sri
Lankan English fiction such as Vijita Fernando’s “The Homecoming” (1984), Punyakante
Wijenaike’s “Anoma” (1996) and Jean Arasanayagam’s The Famished Waterfall (2004). This
research aims to scrutinize the representations of migrant women workers within the dominant
ideological framework where women are primarily perceived as the cultural disseminators of
their nation. One of the research questions of this study is to determine the extent to which
migrant women workers are considered transgressive according to the conventional beliefs and
values in the mainstream society where women are symbolically equated to the nation. The
other is to inquire what are the ways in which these workers come to terms with their identities,
interpersonal relationships and negotiations in their journeys from home to host countries. Both
questions are deliberated concerning the representation of migrant women workers in Sri
Lankan English fiction. Therefore, this research concludes that the narratives of migrant
women workers in Sri Lankan English fiction negotiate with their identities, families and
interpersonal negotiations. It also critiques the hegemonic and heteropatriarchal perception of
such domestic workers within the dominant ideological framework of the nation.
Keywords: Migrant Women Workers, Sri Lankan English Fiction, Nation; Representation,
Negotiations.
Introduction
The number of Sri Lankan women migrating to West Asia as domestic workers has grown
gradually since the late 1970s. These women are the main income generators of their families
and they contribute to the Sri Lankan economy as a vital part of the labour force as low-skilled
workers. Their reasons for migrating, the violation of their rights in foreign countries, the legal
protection that they are offered and the negative impact of the absence of women from their
own households have been heavily debated and assessed issues in previous research
(Jayasuriya & Opeskin, 2015; Mahanama & Thennakoon, 2012; Tidball, 2011; Henderson,
2021; Kottegoda et al., 2013).
Even though media reports how the government has tried to improve the migrant
women workers’ rights and their absorption back to their roots, the mainstream Sri Lankan
87
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
media available for the masses, such as newspapers and the television engage in “engendered
national debates [about the] demerits of absentee mothers [on their families which lead to]
unhappy home environments” (de Alwis, 2002, p.678). In my research, I examine the ideology
behind the construction of such a mainstream perception. I observe that this derives from the
age-old and traditional assumption of symbolically equating the woman to the nation. Thus, it
is vital to scrutinize the ideological representations of women migrant workers as they are often
looked upon in terms of their familial ties of being the mother of the family.
The extant research on migrant women workers in general also recognizes the narratives
of women migrant workers. These are scrutinized in terms of examining self-reflections,
interpersonal relations and negotiations between the constructions of their identity (self) and
nation from the homeland of women migrant workers to the host countries they migrate to as
“exilic communities” (Yeoh & Huang, 2000, p.413).
My study further extends the existing research on these workers and delves explicitly
into the identities, reflections, relations, negotiations and larger ideological perceptions of Sri
Lankan migrant women workers in literature. I perceive that analyzing and examining the
representations of these women in literary work is vital as they are mass-cultural productions
which provide an outlook or media through which these identities communicate. Further, the
available research on Sri Lankan migrant women workers is within the parameters of empirical
research comprised of both qualitative and quantitative studies (Jayasuriya & Opeskin, 2015;
Mahanama & Thennakoon, 2012; Tidball, 2011; Henderson, 2021; Kottegoda et al., 2013).
Publications and research on migrant women workers in international fiction include
those by Jansen (2019) who studies the representation of domestic workers in South African
literature. Such work includes research on migrant women workers in Chinese fiction such as
Dooling (2017) who explores these identities in the fiction of Zheng Xiaoqiong and Wang Lili.
Adding to these, Liu (2012) analyses how the experiences of Chinese rural migrant women in
Zhima (2003) by Zhang Kangkang “codes and unfolds female migrants’ changing subjectivities
both in reaction to and within the post-socialist discursive framework of gender, class and
modernity” (p. 511). Despite the rich research on such identities available in South African and
Chinese literature, I have identified a research gap considering the absence of studies exploring
domestic women workers by scrutinizing their representations in Sri Lankan English fiction.
Hence, through this study, I contribute to the enrichment of research by exploring the migrant
women worker in Sri Lankan English fiction.
My objective in this study is to scrutinize the representations of these women to
perceive how they negotiate with their identities and gender where overarching values and
expectations have been ascribed to the perception of the nation. This is particularly significant
as they are primarily perceived within the mainstream media as women who are held
responsible for the degeneration of their own families, whom they leave behind to secure that
‘pot of gold’ in unfamiliar lands. Since antiquity, women have been regarded as the
disseminators of their nation’s cultural values. As such, within the conventional discourse in
mainstream media, women who do not cater to their nation’s dominant ideological expectations
are relegated as transgressive women subjected to humiliation. This premise has enabled me to
formulate the following research questions,
1. To what extent can migrant women workers be considered transgressive in the
mainstream society where women are symbolically equated to the nation?
2. What are the ways in which migrant women workers come to terms with their identities
and interpersonal relationships and negotiations in their journeys from home to host
countries?
Both these research questions are deliberated concerning the identities of migrant
women workers in Sri Lankan English Fiction.
.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with the Nation: A Study of
Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
Women and the Nation
As I explore the representation of migrant women workers by drawing from the theoretical
concepts of women being equated to the nation, it is first of all necessary to study this
phenomenon in detail. De Alwis (2002) explores the role of women in Sri Lanka to state that,
regardless of their ethnicities, women are expected to fulfil the traditional roles as reproducers,
nurturers, disseminators and signifiers of “‘tradition’, ‘culture’, ‘community’ and ‘nation.’” (p.
675) in the dominant discourse. This gendered motif of “woman-as-nation” (Silva, 2004, p. 97)
is constructed upon a binary stage of viewing the male as “the author and subject of the nation,
while the female stands for the nation itself, in need of male protection, the reproducer and
nurturer of future generations and transmitter of cultural values” (De Mel, 2001, p.3).
Thus, within the dominant Sri Lankan discourse, they are expected to conform to the
roles of the “heteronormative roles of docile daughter, chaste wife, nurturing mother, or
sagacious grandmother” (de Alwis, 2002, p.679). Women who subvert these stereotypical roles
and refuse to embody the dominant expectations of the hegemonic society are subjected to
abuse, ridicule and harassment. De Alwis (2002) says that the nation, communities, societies
and families valorize the women who conform to the above-mentioned heteronormative and
heteropatriarchal roles. However, women who do not fall within the parameters of these
stereotypical categories such as migrant women workers, women workers at free trade zones,
war widows and feminists, are considered transgressive women subjected to devaluation,
vilification and marginalization.
Moreover, all three migrant women workers in Fernando’s “The Homecoming”,
Wijenaike’s “Anoma” and Arasanayagam’s The Famished Waterfall are mothers. Thus, I find
it essential to particularly discuss the cultural and theoretical perception of mothers in relation
to the nation. According to De Mel (1996),
Despite [the woman’s] continuing marginalization in patriarchal society, her biological
and historically social function of nurturing Mother for instance, has imbued woman
with the notion of authenticity, permitting her to be used as a channel of culture and
nation-building. It follows that at times of war and socio-political insecurity, the figure
of the Mother becomes a central signifier of racial and cultural values, national pride
and purity (p.170).
I discuss how the motif of equating the woman to the nation, the social function of the
nurturing mother and viewing her as a signifier of cultural values within the dominant discourse
are significant considering the representation of women migrant workers in Sri Lankan English
fiction.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers
Here I discuss the representation of the migrant woman worker in Fernando’s “The
Homecoming” and Wijenaike’s “Anoma”, particularly concerning their role as mothers within
the familial institution. In “Anoma”, I mainly refer to the migrant woman worker’s daughter’s
role who voices her experience to generate an in-depth discussion.
Fernando’s “The Homecoming” critiques the dominant societal perceptions of
considering migrant women as transgressive and blaming the demerits of absentee mothers on
the degeneration of the family. The author realizes this by offering the point of view, grief and
turmoil of the returnee migrant mother. I draw from De Alwis (2002) to contend with this
89
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
critical portrayal as she says that women domestic workers’ prolonged stay overseas has
engendered national debates about the shortcomings and failings of absentee mothers.
Moreover, returnee mothers are perceived in mainstream society as those who are corrupted by
new lives and foreign environments. Furthermore, the absence of mothers is lamented and
discussed as the cause of fissures and fractures in the family, such as the “complications [which
arise from] unfaithful and spendthrift fathers who fritter away their wives’ earnings” (De Alwis,
2002, p.678).
In Fernando’s (2008) “The Homecoming”, the returnee migrant mother’s daughter-inlaw justifies the infidelity and cruel treatment of the mother’s husband by adapting a selfrighteous tone and saying, “[f]ather has had a bad time, you know. Two years is a long time
that you were away. Pushpa [the daughter] doesn’t look after him properly. Anyway, she is too
young to take on her mother’s responsibilities” (p.206). In this story, the hard work, endurance
and dedication of the returnee migrant woman Millie, are utterly devalued by her whole family
and particularly her husband who has squandered and used the three thousand rupees she has
sent every month to provide for the family on buying clothes and gold accessories to his
mistress. Millie’s husband is described as indolent with a fondness for drinking and idleness
and the sons are portrayed as greedy, unwelcoming of her return back home and only concerned
about fighting amongst each other to possess the gifts she has bought from abroad (Fernando,
2008). Moreover, Millie’s daughter-in-law disrespects her years of toil and labour in a foreign
environment in the host country and continues to justify the father’s infidelity on the pretext of
a man being unable to control his sexual desire. She says, “[t]rue, he had money to spend. But
a man wants more than money. After all, Father is not an old man, you know” (Fernando, 2008,
p.207). These encounters only serve to entirely shatter Millie’s expectations of an ideal warm
homecoming and drive her away from her family. Thus, it is evident that the author is able to
make a poignant defence of the migrant woman by depicting how she is disillusioned and jaded
by the hostile reception, greed, carelessness and infidelity of her family.
I also draw similarities between the woman migrant worker’s portrayal in “The
Homecoming” and Punyakante Wijenaike’s “Anoma.” Wijenaike presents a dark and
incestuous tale of the migrant woman’s daughter who voices her suffering to the embryo of the
baby growing within her and whom she decides to name Anoma. In the absence of the mother
who travelled to the Middle East as a domestic aid to become the primary wage earner of the
family, the father has sexually violated his 14-year-old daughter who has conceived a baby.
The daughter, an unnamed narrator, talks of her pain of not being able to go to school anymore
and being ignored by her brother who thinks she has “robbed mother of her place with father”
(Wijenaike, 1996, p.30). She also laments over the negligence of the grandmother who has lost
her faculties of hearing and seeing to a significant degree and was unable to protect her from
her father’s unwelcome attentions. She says, “[m]other should have left someone younger in
charge, like mother’s sister, my Punchi Amma, my aunt. Someone who could cope up with
father’s needs. Did she forget father’s needs?” (Wijenaike, 1996, p.30). She lays the blame on
the poverty of the family which created the need to secure the “pot of gold [that] has ruined us”
(Wijenaike, 1996, p.30).
Though the focal character of “Anoma” is not the migrant woman worker but the
daughter, unlike in “The Homecoming”, the daughter lays the blame for her misery on poverty
and the dream of securing better economic prospects. Further, the daughter is deliberately left
as an unnamed first-person narrator by Wijenaike in the story, generalising the girl's
experience, suffering, and anguish. Moreover, Wijenaike voices and critiques taboo incestuous
practices in the society, paedophilia, promiscuity of Sri Lankan men and lack of child
protection. By doing so, it is possible to perceive Wijenaike as contributing to the problematic
mainstream discourse of viewing the mother as being “held responsible for not only what
.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with the Nation: A Study of
Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
befalls them (when they leave home) but what happens to families in their absence” (De Alwis,
2000, p. 679). However, I interpret that Wijenaike critiques these mainstream assumptions of
blaming the absence of mothers for the degeneration of their families and considering them as
transgressive. This is realized by portraying the utter failure of the father who not only sexually
violates his own biological daughter but also shirks from his duties to protect and take care of
the family. Furthermore, I also consider the grandmother who is charged with taking care of
the children being both blind and deaf, as a symbolical critique of the perceptions in mainstream
society.
I interpret that in both “The Homecoming” and “Anoma”, the concept of the mother
being held responsible for the degeneration of the family is critiqued to a certain extent. I
contend that the authors realize this by critiquing conventional societal perceptions and
emphasizing the failure of fathers within the familial institution. I also analyze that this concept
of holding the mother responsible stems from the traditional ideology of considering the
migrant mother as transgressive. This is because she is unable to conform to the role of the
normative mother who acts as the caretaker and nurturer of her family. As previously
mentioned in my study, this assumption results from the age-old patriarchal ideology of largely
perceiving women as the upholders and symbolical disseminators of culture and tradition.
The Demarcations of Respectability
Under this subtitle, I further explain how Fernando critiques the mainstream societal perception
of condemning the migrant woman worker for not catering to the stereotypical expectations of
the normative mother in “The Homecoming.” I realize this by drawing from the theoretical
concepts of Obeyasekere (1984) and de Alwis (1997).
In this story, Millie has left her family back in Sri Lanka to provide for their economic
difficulties. However, she is condemned by her family and society for not conforming to the
hegemonic societal perception of the valorized, conventional and normative mother. Gananath
Obeyesekere says that lajja-baya (shame-fear) is a part of the social conditioning process of
the Sinhala child. He says that, “[b]aya when conjoined with lajja means ‘fear of ridicule or
social disapproval’” (Obeyesekere, 1984, p.504). So, the Sinhalese must not only have a “sense
of shame” but also be “sensitive to the reaction of others who may shame them” (Obeyesekere,
1984, p.504). de Alwis (1997) extends Obeyesekere’s construction of the Sinhala practice of
lajja-baya to respectability. She explores how the subject positions of women are constructed
through the interpellation of lajja-baya. She also says, when performing “public roles” women
are “constantly under surveillance and vulnerable to being sexualized and shamed i.e., being
considered as lajja-baya nati (loose and immoral) and therefore subject to the unmaking and
unmasking of their ‘respectability’” (de Alwis, 1997, p.105).
I extend this notion of respectability to Fernando’s “The Homecoming”, where at one
point, the narrator is insulted by Siripala, her husband. He calls her the obscene and derogatory
term “whore” with “hate and loathing [along with a] gesture of revulsion” (Fernando, 2008,
p.205) accompanying it. He refers to all migrant women workers as “[w]hores, the lot of them
[…] come with their money and their fancy clothes. They and their work, housemaids they are
called” (Fernando, 2008, p.205). The moment he makes this obscene remark Millie feels that
this word was left “unspoken” and “hovered in the air since she came home. All those drunken
orgies celebrated a whore’s homecoming, rich with the spoils of her whoring in some other
land. A whore came home, let’s give her a whore’s welcome” (Fernando, 2008, p.205).
Thus, I interpret that Millie is considered transgressive and deviant by the
heteronormative and heteropatriarchal society. I contend that this is because Millie does not
91
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
contribute to a woman’s traditional role as an upholder and disseminator of culture by being
equated with the ‘nation.’ This makes her open to ridicule, vilification and punishment by the
society as she is perceived to be lacking ‘respectability’ and as a lajja-baya nathi woman since
she has spent her time in a foreign country away from the family. Despite her dedication and
endurance in working to secure that ‘pot of gold’ for her family, she is still seen as a “whore”
(Fernando, 2008, p.205).
Through this, I perceive that Fernando is able to lodge a complaint against the
hypocritical perception of the migrant woman worker’s husband and critique the blindness of
the patriarchal society. She realizes this by depicting how Siripala and by extension the
patriarchal society consider Millie as transgressive, deviant, licentious and promiscuous and as
a woman who has been subjected to the “unmaking and unmasking of [her] ‘respectability’”
(de Alwis, 1997, p.105).
[E]very word Siripala shouted would have been heard all over the shanty garden. Those
filthy words would have found their way to every nook and crevice, penetrated into
every sleeping hovel, obtruded into every sleeper’s brain, woken the babies and
disturbed the fitful sleep of the sick. She knew it only too well (Fernando 206).
In this quotation, it is evident that this is not only in the problematic perception of the
husband but the whole family as well as Millie’s entire community. Therefore, I observe that
devaluing Millie by considering her as a woman without respectability further solidifies how
women are equated to the nation as its cultural disseminator. It also reveals how the migrant
woman worker is insulted for not fulfilling the cultural expectations of a normative woman
within the patriarchal society.
The ‘Choiceless Choice’ of Migrant Women Workers
Here I deliberate the way Arasanayagam represents the crisis migrant women workers face in
Sri Lankan fiction in English. To analyse this, I first explore Langer’s (1980) concept of the
“choiceless choice” (p.224) and Ladegaard’s (2019) extension of it to analyze the choice of
domestic workers in the fiction to migrate. I depict how this choice can be seen concerning the
reasons Erandathi, the protagonist and migrant woman worker in Arasanayagam’s The
Famished Waterfall gives for her choice to undertake that journey to migrate to Kuwait.
Langer (1980) refers to the concept of a choiceless choice to identify the crisis
individuals face when life choices do not reflect options between “life and death, but between
one form of ‘abnormal’ response and another, both imposed by a situation that was in no way
of the victim's own choosing” (p.224). Ladegaard (2019) extends this to the struggle which the
migrant woman worker faces to state that a migrant woman does not have a real choice in
deciding to leave her familiar roots and family to take that crucial decision to become a migrant
worker in a foreign country. By narrating stories of returnee migrant women which she
gathered via interviews Ladegaard (2019) further says that, “[i]f staying at home means not
being able to provide for the children’s basic needs, migration becomes a necessity, not a
choice” (p.293).
I draw from this concept to analyse Erandathi’s choice to migrate in Arasanayagam’s
story. Erandathi says that her choice was due to her husband’s lack of responsibility in
providing for the family and the children being young. She further states that,
“They [my children] needed food, clothes shelter and education. It was now my
responsibility to provide them with what they needed to live from day to day […] I had
.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with the Nation: A Study of
Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
to depend on my own resources, my inner strength and whatever skills I had, to even
offer myself for employment in the Middle East” (Arasanayagam, 2004, p.39).
I further observe that this narrative largely corresponds with the widely-known reasons
and the push and pull mechanisms that research states for mother migration in Sri Lanka. These
can include push factors like,
Lack of employment opportunities, poverty, poor education, lack of livelihood support,
alcoholism of the husband, domestic violence, extra marital affairs of the husband, to
provide for children, to pay off debt, to build a house, to save enough money to have a
better future, to achieve economic and social freedom, vicious cycle of early marriage,
husbands not having job opportunities and to save children’s future dowry (Perera &
Rathnayaka, 2013, p.10).
Within the globalized context of the modern society, this push-and-pull mechanism
would involve “pushing poor migrant workers from poverty and unemployment in their home
countries and pulling them towards affluent societies with promises of job, better pay and the
prospects of upward social mobility” (Ladegaard, 2019, p.289). Migration has been prompted
due to the needs of the family, children, and the mobility of working overseas offering them,
“the only livelihood option, and the only way to earn an income” (Sylvie, 2006, p.32). Thus,
the reasons why women decide to undertake these journeys are strongly inclined by being a
part of a familial network and relations. These reasons significantly impact the choice migrant
women make to pursue financial stability by working as foreign domestic aid. In this study, I
identify that such explanations are reflected in the struggle of the migrant women workers in
the selected fiction.
Migrant Journeys and Negotiations
Under this subtitle, I explore the journeys of migrant women workers in the selected fiction by
examining their negotiations with their self/identity, gender and nation from their perspectives
from their homeland to the host country to which they migrate.
In The Famished Waterfall Erandathi develops her will and determination to undertake
the journey to Kuwait, to an unfamiliar environment with the sole objective of becoming the
primary wage earner for her children. Her own expectations of pursuing that ‘pot of gold’
involves rebuilding “[her] home, fill[ing] it with comfortable furniture […] changing the lives
of [her] family, give [her sons] the best education that could be had” (Arasanayagam, 2004, p.
39). She dreams about them attending good schools and colleges, learning English, and entering
universities to give her children the opportunity to access academic dreams that she could not
pursue due to the abusive marriage she was emotionally coerced into by her husband. However,
she communicates her uncertainty about this situation by saying, “I would find a place to work
in but I knew nothing of the people I would work with, the families whom I would have to
work for. There was only hope but no certainty” (Arasanayagam, 2004, p.39). Though she feels
a sense of freedom from travelling overseas and determination to fulfil her dreams for her
family, in terms of her negotiations with her ‘home’ and ‘host’ countries, there is always a
constant longing to return to familiarity. “I longed to return to my home, my country, to the
familiar sights, sounds, surroundings that made me feel safe and secure” (Arasanayagam, 2004,
p.51).
In the story, Arasanayagam depicts the course of self-development of the protagonist.
The climactic point of Erandathi’s development becomes evident after her final journey to
Kuwait as a domestic maid. Her journey as a migrant worker comes to a standstill after
93
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
experiencing the fear, horror and intensity of war in the 1990s invasion of Kuwait. She faces
an economic loss of not being paid for her labour. Thus, her negotiation with the host country
to which she had hereto before taken several journeys to work as a domestic maid becomes
ultimately and utterly inhospitable. She says, “I returned like an exile. Moreover, I was in a
state of shock, badly shaken by all the suffering I had undergone during the war”
(Arasanayagam, 2004, p.88). The sense of weariness and the unpredictability of the journeys
made her disillusioned about being “spellbound by romantic dreams of that pot of gold.”
However, after all these journeys, experiences and suffering, the protagonist finally comes to
terms with her identity or sense of self and no longer feels like the completely depleted and
diminished ‘famished waterfall.’ The narrative ends with the protagonist’s reflection: "I had
lost that waterfall with my going away. I would search it out again” (Arasanayagam, 2004,
p.88).
However, the negotiation of Millie with her identity in the geopolitical spaces of home
and host countries in Fernando’s “The Homecoming” reflects a few differences from that of
Erandathi in Arasanayagam’s The Famished Waterfall. In “The Homecoming”, Millie wishes
to tell Sumithra, the mistress of her husband that the humiliation, suffering, fear and indignities
she experienced in the host country were not endured for the “money”, but for “[t]he dream of
coming home [which] had been alive during the two years” (Fernando, 2008, p.199). However,
this dream of the happy family reunion as she happily gazed across the “emerald green of her
homeland” (Fernando, 2008, p.199) shatters as she experiences the bitter reality of the
unwelcome homeland, surrounded by abject poverty and misery, that constrains, restraints and
suffocates her.
The mud walls of the shanty shut her in. In those dark moments before the dawn she
felt them closing in, closing in, strangling her. The mosquitoes added their bit with
their chanting and singing. The heat stifled her. Added to all this was the drunken
snoring of her husband, his nightly tirade at last silenced (Fernando, 2008, pp.199200).
However, I perceive that her negotiations with not only the host country as a migrant
woman worker but also in the homeland as a returnee domestic aid are alienated and estranged.
She constantly refers to the host country as a “distant”, “far away” and “strange” land, filled
with the “babel of foreign tongues [..] that makes no sense” (Fernando, 2008, p. 209). Her
internal monologue further reflects how she had to constantly deal with unwelcome and hostile
glances and encounters due to her race, class and gender in the host country. Nevertheless,
after returning to her home country, her attempts to maintain and strengthen the imagined ties
of a happy family reunion fail. As a result, her presence is considered a loathsome existence by
her family who devalues her role as a mother. Also, as stated earlier, I interpret that Millie is
degraded in the homeland for not catering to the expectations imbued upon her as a
disseminator of the nation. Based on how she is wholly disregarded by the entire family and
regarded as an absentee mother, I argue that Fernando depicts how the patriarchal society
perceives her as a transgressive mother. Thus, she is rejected as she cannot fulfil the traditional
role of the mother of constantly caring for her husband and nurturing children, which is
symbolically equated to the nation in the conventional discourse of the patriarchal society.
Such devastating experiences only serve to complicate Millie’s negotiations with the home
country as a returnee migrant woman worker.
In this story, I contend that both the host and home countries become hostile places for
Millie who suffers from a sense of rootlessness and lack of belonging in both spaces. Thus, it
is with an emotional tone that Fernando narrates how Millie hugs her ticket and passport to her
chest with the dream of returning home when she was a domestic maid, but after her
.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with the Nation: A Study of
Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
disillusionment as a returnee maid, she caresses the return ticket and passport to go back to the
host country with a sense of tenderness, yearning and longing. Despite this yearning to return,
I perceive that the story ends on a jaded note. This is because as readers, we are aware of the
suffering she has already encountered and will be experiencing again in the host country.
Familial Networks and ‘Transnational Motherhood’
Under this subtheme, I analyze interpersonal relationships and negotiations with familial
networks that migrant women workers share by engaging in an in-depth analysis of their
experiences within the framework of a family in both home and host countries in The Famished
Waterfall and “Anoma.” I also draw from Hondagneu-Sotelo &Avila’s (1997) concept of
“transnational motherhood” (p.548) to further analyze the role of a mother the migrant woman
worker plays in relation to two geopolitical spaces of the home and host countries.
Transnational motherhood refers to the ways the definitions of motherhood are
rearranged to accommodate separations caused by differing geopolitical spaces and times. To
perform domestic duties and the rearing and nurturing of children, transnational mothers
“radically break with deeply gendered spatial and temporal boundaries of family and work”
(Hondagneu-Sotelo &Avila, 1997, p.552). I draw from this concept to analyze Erandathi’s role
as a mother in The Famished Waterfall. The protagonist looks back at the dreams and hopes
she had for her family with nostalgia in this story. With the bonds and love she has in rearing
her own children back home, she does not imagine the possibility of them growing distant from
her due to separation when she was preparing to migrate.
My children? Not to live under the same roof together? I didn’t think then that
separation would make us strangers to each other in every way […] Yes what hopes,
dreams, ambitions I had. All for my family. I was physically small but I felt a new
strength enter my body. That my children would grow away from me, I never thought
of for a moment. I would not see them for years. I would have to survive in a new
environment I knew nothing of. I would discover that true loneliness was with the
separation when it came, from my parents and three sons (Arasanayagam, 2004, pp.4243).
This estrangement and isolation, she feels from living away without her own children
in an unfamiliar land led her to foster feelings and emotional attachments towards the
employers and their children in the host country. Hondagneu-Sotelo &Avila (1997) say that
transnational mothers “do not necessarily divert their mothering to the children and homes of
their employers but instead reformulate their own mothering to accommodate spatial and
temporal gulfs” (p.552). I argue that this can be seen with Erandathi in The Famished Waterfall
due to the spatial restrictions of distance considering the geopolitical landscape and temporal
boundaries of time in terms of the years she lost in playing a significant part in her own
children’s childhood.
Moreover, she tangibly feels the distance this gulf has created between herself and the
familial bond she shares with her own children. This can be seen when she ponders,
When I returned to the island, to my home, rediscovering the familiar things of the past
I found that my children were growing up, growing away from me. I felt the beginnings
of loneliness within me. I was becoming more of a visiting relative to them, a nenda,
an aunt. They had to prepare themselves for my departure. Each time I had to pack up
and go away journeying many times between Kuwait and Sri Lanka (Arasanayagam,
2004, pp.54-55).
95
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
I interpret that the distance associated with Erandathi being perceived as a nenda (an
aunt) by her own children whom she loves, leads her to reconfigure the negotiations between
herself or identity and sense of motherhood in relation to the journeys that she undertakes to
the migrant country. I argue that due to this geographical and temporal separation, the
protagonist reformulates her mothering towards the host family by developing an emotional
bond with baba and mama (father and mother, her host employees) and their children. These
attachments are particularly strong towards the baby of the host family whom she lavishes with
maternal love, care and attention. She says, “[h]e was now three months old and I was all in all
to him. He never left my side. He always slept beside me every night […] How much he loved
me. I needed him too. He filled me with the passionate feeling of maternal love”
(Arasanayagam, 2004, pp.66-67).
When considering the notion of motherhood in Wijenaike’s “Anoma”, I perceive that
the unnamed narrator has a nostalgic longing and desire to go back to the past before her mother
went on the journey to the Middle East to become a domestic worker. She recollects her
memories of those days by saying, “I remember mother before she went away. She used to
comb my hair, wash my face clean and starch my one and only white school uniform”
(Wijenaike, 1996, p.30). Then immediately afterwards she says, “[n]ow I don’t need my white
uniform anymore because I no longer go to school. My brother still goes to school. He is eleven
years old but he does not miss mother the way I do because I wash his school clothes for him
and cook his lunch” (Wijenaike, 1996, p.30).
In interpreting the above quotation, I argue that in the absence of the mother who
migrated to another country to relieve the economic difficulties of the family, the daughter is
forced to carry the burdens of nurturing and caring for the family. The concept of home in this
story is entirely distorted by the sexual abuse and incestuous desires of the father. The father
has forced the daughter to be over-burdened by the misery, guilt, suffering, and dread of the
mother's return to discover the bitter truth. “What will mother say, what will mother do when
she finds out? I have to do something before she returns and finds out” (Wijenaike, 30).
I contend that this further emphasizes how the woman is symbolically associated with
the nation. This is because the story portrays an under-aged girl-child wracked with guilt over
being raped by a deviant adult who is her father and exploited by her own family. I believe that
the shame and vilification that the girl feels, is a disturbing revelation of the hypocrisy of the
society. I perceive that this exposure leads Wijenaike to critique dominant societal perceptions
and by extension, the notion of viewing the woman as the cultural disseminator of the nation.
The author realizes this by portraying how the girl has normalized patriarchal beliefs of the
conventional mainstream society, which would expect her to conform to the heteropatriarchal
expectations of being the chaste, pure and docile daughter.
The Politics of Identity in terms of ‘Self’, ‘Other’ and ‘Discipline’
Here I discuss the identity politics in the negotiations between the woman domestic worker and
her host family. These include the identity crisis the woman migrant worker faces and
deliberations on the conceptualization of self and other, discipline, self-discipline and docile
bodies concerning the selected fiction in this study. I refer to Yeoh & Huang’s (2000) and
Michel Foucault’s (1979) concepts and theoretical insights to further scrutinize the abovementioned concepts.
An identity crisis which domestic workers face can be identified as the “rapid reduction
of ‘self’ to immigrant (as well as ethnic, classed, and gendered) ‘other’ in the host-nation”
(Yeoh &Huang, 2000, p.424). This devaluation, estrangement and marginalization resulting
.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with the Nation: A Study of
Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
from being a woman, a domestic aid and an immigrant of an unfamiliar country can irrevocably
damage self-esteem and generate debates on identity politics (Yeoh & Huang, 2000). I interpret
that this is evident in Arasanayagam’s The Famished Waterfall as migrant women workers are
distinctly othered from the host country’s inhabitants as they bear the distinct label of being
referred to as a housemaid. As a domestic worker, Erandathi is considered disempowered in a
foreign land due to the possibility of having to face various “dangers and uncertainties” [even]
assault, rape, murder” (Arasanayagam,2004, p.50). She constantly reminds herself that the
host country is a “temporary home [for her as she always feels like] someone who belonged to
a nomadic tribe that pitched a tent for as long as it was necessary and then moved on”
(Arasanayagam,2004, p.68). The protagonist thus suffers from this inability to feel a sense of
belonging and sorrow as her dedication and love towards the host family's children will be
easily forgotten after her prolonged absence.
Erandathi also deals with an identity crisis by having her sense of self reduced to that
of the other by the employees of another host family. This particular host family is suspicious
of Erandathi and constantly scrutinizes her covertly. I contend that Erandathi’s actions are
surveilled, controlled and monitored by the host family to discipline her. She is thus othered
by the host family who makes her feel suffocated and stifled as they continue to keep a “secret
watch” on her and “did not want [her]even to talk to anyone and listened to whomever [she]
was speaking [to]” (Arasanayagam,2004, p.71). She says that “I felt sometimes that my very
soul did not belong to me. That my every breath was measured by Mama and Baba”
(Arasanayagam,2004, p.71). To further interpret this, I refer to the theoretical insights of
Foucault (1979) who states that discipline can transform individuals into docile bodies that are
spatially enclosed, partitioned, and ranked to maintain order and discipline. Foucault (1979)
further says that “the notion of ‘docility’ [which joins the] analyzable body to the manipulable
body” (p.136) can be regulated and controlled according to the power dynamics which are
pervasive within social institutions. Thus, a docile body “may be subjected, used, transformed
and improved” (Foucault, 1979, p.146) according to the rules and regulations in place within
social institutions.
I draw from this to analyze the host family in The Famished Waterfall as they monitor
Erandathi to discipline, control and manipulate her actions to reduce her to a docile body. This
is specifically seen when Erandathi refers to all the incidents where they have ordered her not
to speak to any Sri Lankan domestic maids when they visit their relatives. However, the
protagonist longs for these conversations as she dearly misses talking in her native tongue and
exchanging news. However, she is restrained from using her voice and agency as they curb her
conversations by asking “[h]ave you finished speaking? […] You have been speaking for such
a long time now. What have you got to say to each other? I hope you are saying good things
about us, that you are happy with us” (Arasanayagam, 2004, p.71). This makes her feel that
she is subjected to the process of othering and not treated as a thinking, feeling and rational
human being. The extent to which such experiences have damaged her emotionally can be seen
when she says, “[t]hey had their friends. They spent hours talking, eating and enjoying their
company. Did they think that I had no feelings, no emotions?” (Arasanayagam, 2004, p.71).
Erandathi’s experiences are similar to Millie’s experience in “The Homecoming”,
where she also refers to this sense of dehumanization she is subjected to in the host country.
Millie reveals that she years for a “friendly smile, a known tongue, the eagerness to see a face
that smiled at [her] as if [she was] a human being.” (Fernando, p. 210). She further painfully
narrates how she is treated as a “piece of dirt to be used and made more dirty” (Fernando 210).
The reader tangibly feels the objectification she feels with these emotive words.
97
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
Both Millie from “The Homecoming” and Erandathi from The Famished Waterfall are
subjected to the process of othering as they tragically narrate the degradations and humiliations
they were subjected to in the host country as women migrant workers. Thus, I interpret that
both these characters feel that this discipline they face in their negotiations with the host family
reduces their identity or sense of self as they are constantly subjected to monitoring,
surveillance and the process of docility.
Conclusion
Through this study, I engage in a textual examination of women migrant workers in Sri Lankan
English fiction via a critical and analytical engagement with Vijitha Fernando’s “The
Homecoming”, Punyakante Wijenaike’s “Anoma” and Jean Arasanayagam’s The Famished
Waterfall.
I predominantly study the identities of these domestic workers by drawing from the
overarching and ubiquitous motif of ‘women-as-nation.’ I realize this by focusing the
discussion on how these women are perceived as transgressive and deviant in terms of their
chosen occupation according to mainstream societal expectations as they do not cater to the
stereotypical expectations of a normative woman. In the selected fictional work, the migrant
women workers are represented by the authors as mothers who choose to pursue that pot of
gold to secure mobility and solve their families' economic difficulties.
I explore the politics and demarcations of lajja-baya (shame-fear), how migrant women
workers are considered as lajja-baya nathi (loose and immoral) women and subjected to the
unmaking and unmasking of respectability according to conventional beliefs and values. I
contend that this devaluation occurs as these domestic workers do not conform to the traditional
and conservative roles expected of them within the hegemonic discourse in the
heteropatriarchal society.
Moreover, I explore the choiceless choice of migrant mothers who decide to migrate
for their families. I analyze their journeys and negotiations in relation to their sense of self or
identity and the home and host countries to which they migrate. I further examine the familial
networks regarding women migrant workers’ engagement with their families at home and
employers' families in host countries. I also engage with the concept of transnational
motherhood and the spatial and temporal gulfs and boundaries associated with it in selected Sri
Lankan English fiction. Finally, I elaborate on the identity crisis, sense of belonging and
reduction of self-migrant mothers in the selected literature are subjected to as a result of the
process of othering and discipline in host countries.
Therefore, I engage with the narratives of migrant women workers by scrutinizing their
representations in Sri Lankan English fiction. In analyzing these representations, I study their
negotiations and interpersonal relations with their sense of self, nation, family, home and host
countries.
References
Arasanayagam, J. (2004). The Famished Waterfall. S. Godage & Sons.
de Alwis, M. (1997). The Production and Embodiment of “Respectability”: Gendered
Demeanours in Colonial Ceylon. In Michael Roberts (Ed.) Collective Identities
Revisited. Marga.
.
Representation of Migrant Women Workers and their Negotiations with the Nation: A Study of
Selected Sri Lankan English Fiction
de Alwis, M. (2002). The Changing Role of Women in Sri Lankan Society. Social Research,
vol. 69, no. 3, 675–691. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/40971569.
De Mel, N. (1996). Static Signifiers: Metaphors of Women in Sri Lankan War Poetry. In
Kumari Jayawardena and Malathi De Alwis (Eds.), Embodied Violence:
Communalising Women’s Sexuality in South Asia, Kali for Women.
De Mel, N. (2001). Women and the Nation’s Narrative: Gender and Nationalism in
Twentieth Century Sri Lanka. Social Scientists’ Association.
Dooling, A. (2017). Representing Dagongmei (Female Migrant Workers) in Contemporary
China. Front. Lit. Stud. China 2017, 11(1), 133–156. https://doi/10.3868/s010‐006‐
017‐0006‐9.
Fernando, V. (2008). The Homecoming. In Rajiva Wijesinha and Dinali Fernando (Eds.).
Modern Sri Lankan Short Stories in English. International Book House (Pvt) Ltd.
Foucault, M. (1979). Discipline and Punish. Random House Inc.
Henderson, S. (2021). The legal protection of women migrant domestic workers from the
Philippines and Sri Lanka: an intersectional rights-based approach, International
Journal of Care and Caring, 5(1), 65-83.
https://bristoluniversitypressdigital.com/view/journals/ijcc/5/1/article-p65.xml
Hondagneu-Sotelo, P. & Avila, E. (1997). ‘I’m here, but I’m there’: The meaning of Latina
transnational motherhood. Gender & Society, 11 (5), 548–571.
Jansen, E. (2019). Like Family: Domestic workers in South African history and literature.
Wits University Press.
Jayasuriya, R.& Opeskin, B. (2015). The Migration of Women Domestic Workers from Sri
Lanka: Protecting the Rights of Children Left Behind, Cornell International Law
Journal: Vol. 48: No. 3, Article 3.
Kottegoda, Sepali, et al. (2013). Transforming Lives: Listening to Sri Lankan Returnee
Women Migrant Workers. Women and Media Collective.
Ladegaard, H. J. (2019). Reconceptualising ‘home’, ‘family’ and ‘self’- identity struggles in
domestic migrant worker returnee narratives. Language and Intercultural
Communication, 19(3), 289-303. https://doi/10.1080/14708477.2018.1509984.
Langer, L.L. (1980). “The dilemma of choice in the deathcamps.” Centerpoint, 4, 222–231.
Liu, X. (2012). The Representation of Rural Migrant Women and the Discourses of
Modernity in Contemporary China- A Study of Zhang Kangkang’s Novel Zhima.
Front. Lit. Stud. China, 6(4), 511–525. https://doi/10.3868/s010-001-012-0029-4.
Mahanama, C. & Thennakoon, T. M. S. P. K. (2012). Problems of Migrant Workers in the
Middle East A Case Study of Return Female Migrants in Sri Lanka. International
Conference on Humanities and Social Sciences, vol 1.
99
NEW LITERARIA, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2022
Obeyesekere, G. (1984). The Cult of the Goddess Pattini. University of Chicago Press.
Perera, N.& Rathnayaka, M. (2013). Sri Lanka’s Missing Mothers: A working paper on the
efforts of Mother Migration on Children. Colombo: Save the Children Sri Lanka.
Silva, N. (2004.) The Gendered Nation: Contemporary Writings from South Asia. New Delhi:
Sage Publications India Pvt Ltd.
Silvey, R. (2006). Consuming the transnational family: Indonesian migrant domestic workers
to Saudi Arabia. Global Networks, 6(1), 23–40.
Tidball, S. (2011). Migration of Sri Lankan Women as Housemaids to the Middle East. Third
Annual Interdisciplinary Conference on Human Trafficking.
Wijenaike, P. (1996). Anoma. Wasafiri, 12(24), 30-31.
Yeoh, B.S.A., & Huang, S. (2000). ‘Home’ and ‘Away’: Foreign Domestic Workers and
Negotiations of Diasporic Identity in Singapore. Women’s Studies International
Forum, 23(4), 413–429.
Bio-note
Merinnage Nelani De Costa is a lecturer at the Department of English and Linguistics,
University of Sri Jayewardenepura. She completed her MA in Gender and Women’s Studies at
the Faculty of Graduate Studies, University of Colombo and obtained a BA (Hons.) in English
from the Department of English and Linguistics, University of Sri Jayewardenepura. Her
research interests include gender studies, queer literary studies, Sri Lankan English and SouthAsian literary studies, film studies, dystopian literature and the absurd in literature.
Email Id: mn.decosta@sjp.ac.lk
.