Judicial Gatekeeping
2 Followers
Recent papers in Judicial Gatekeeping
The improper bending of scientific opinion by outside influences has been a concern of scholars and commentators for decades. The interference of outside influences with scientific analysis pushed Arthur Kantrowitz in 1967 to propose a... more
Since Daubert, courts have faced difficulty with screening cutting-edge scientific evidence for relevance and reliability under Federal Rule of Evidence 702. In a series of cases following Daubert, courts faced the challenge of... more
Daubert and its progeny may have given judges clear substantive standards for deciding challenges to expert reliability, and great discretion to do so, but the effect of those changes has not been entirely clear. In the decade after... more
While the Daubert case and its progeny provided detailed guidance to judges on the substantive standard for expert gatekeeping, the court spent little time explaining the procedures to use to achieve that gatekeeping review. Justice... more