Christmas with the Surplus Girls

Chapter One

September 1922

‘NOW THEN, OUR Nancy,’ said Pa after they had all eaten a slice of cake each. ‘It’s time we had a talk.’

‘What about?’ Nancy licked a fingertip and dabbed her plate, picking up crumbs of sponge and slipping them onto her tongue, savouring the final burst of sweetness. The Pikes didn’t have the wherewithal to splash out on cream, even for a special occasion, but she had baked two thin sponges and smeared a thin layer of jam between them. That was luxury for the Pike family.

Her presents sat on the table, beside them the brown paper in which they had been wrapped, neatly folded now and ready to be used again. A lace-edged hanky embroidered with an N, together with a bar of Cadbury’s Dairy Milk, from Lottie and Emily, who had pooled their saved-up Saturday pennies; and, from Mam and Pa, a cardie knitted by Mam in pale-green wool with big green buttons. That was the thing about being a redhead. You ended up wearing lots of green. Not that Nancy was a redhead exactly. Nothing so glamorous. She was more of an orange-head, only darker. According to Mam, her hair was the colour of copper saucepans. Mam had been in service in her youth, working in a big house over Heaton Mersey way. Nancy wasn’t sure how she felt about having hair the colour of saucepans, but Mam had meant it kindly or she wouldn’t have said it, and at least the saucepans had been in a posh kitchen.

‘That sounds interesting, Pa,’ said Lottie. ‘What’s it about?’

‘Never you mind,’ said Pa. ‘You two go and do the washing up, please.’

‘It’s Nancy’s turn,’ Lottie objected.

‘It’s Nancy’s birthday.’ Emily fetched the tray from the sideboard.

‘And don’t answer Pa back, our Lottie,’ said Mam.

‘I never meant to, Pa,’ Lottie murmured.

It wasn’t unheard of to give Pa backchat without meaning to. He was gentle and mild-mannered, which made him lovely to live with, and was one of the reasons why their flat, for all its drawbacks, had a cosy atmosphere. But it also meant that sometimes, before you knew it, you had overstepped the mark and spoken out of turn. Other girls had fathers who were very much the lord and master, but Pa wasn’t a bit like that. Nancy was aware of her responsibility, as the oldest, to set a good example by treating him with the unquestioning respect he deserved, all the more so because, while other men, other fathers, the heads of other households, were tall and forceful, Pa was… Much as she loved him, she couldn’t escape from the fact that he was rather – well, weedy. He was thin and pale and inclined to stoop. Although the sight of his face softening with love and concern for Mam made Nancy’s heart melt, there were other times when he did that funny thing with his mouth, sucking in his cheek to chew it, that made him look like the world’s worst worrier. There was even anxiety in the way he blinked.

While Lottie and Emily loaded the tray with crockery and cutlery, Nancy put the rest of the sponge in the tin and returned the margarine to the marble slab on the shelf in the corner-cupboard that did duty as their larder. The family lived in two rooms – three, if you counted the alcove at the head of the staircase that served as the girls’ bedroom, but you’d have to be soft in the head to call that a bedroom and hope to get away with it. For cooking, they had the use of the tiny kitchen in the back of the shop downstairs, where the single gas-ring meant that Mam had become an expert at one-pot cooking. Meals were carried upstairs with great care and at the end of each meal, the tray was loaded with dirty dishes, which were taken downstairs to be washed up in the scullery. It was a fag if you were in the best of health, but for poor Mam, with her anaemia, it was sometimes too much to cope with.

Alongside the permanent smell of tobacco from the shop downstairs, the air in the flat was still sweet with the fruity, bready aroma of the tea-cakes she had brought home from the shop. They were yesterday’s tea-cakes that hadn’t sold, but the Pikes didn’t care about details like that. Tea-cakes didn’t have to be fresh from the oven to be a treat.

While Pa gave Mam his arm and helped her from the table to their one and only armchair, Nancy fetched the small brass dustpan and brush, and gave the tablecloth a brisk clean, pretending not to notice as Mam, reaching the chair, dropped into it and then made a fuss of settling herself, smoothing her skirt, as if she had been in perfect control of how she sat down.

Tendrils of late summer sunshine slid through the window, bestowing a golden shimmer on their ancient oak sideboard and almost returning it to its glory days before it was bruised and scuffed and adorned with an unfortunate burn mark. The glowing light lent a silvery edge to the stack of faded piano music and turned the lace doilies to twinkling gossamer; though all it did for the bare floorboards was make them look drab and bland, and never mind the elbow grease that went into scrubbing and polishing them every week, while the corners seemed curtained by inky shadows.

‘Come and sit down, Nancy.’

Pa took a ladderback chair from the table and placed it beside Mam’s armchair. How many men would do that? Not many, that was for sure, but Pa was a sweetheart. So what if every other man would insist upon sitting on the carver chair at the table, because it was the one chair in their mismatched set that had arms? Pa was happy for Mam to have it, to help her be comfortable, the same as he wanted her to have the armchair. Pa might not be tall and imposing like other men, but he was the most considerate person Nancy had ever met.

She paused in the act of pulling the tablecloth towards her. ‘I haven’t taken the cloth off yet.’

‘Leave it for now,’ said Pa.

They never gave up on a task. Living in a small flat, you had to be tidy and organised. It made Mam’s life easier an’ all. Half smiling, half frowning, she glanced at Mam.

‘Don’t look at me,’ said Mam. ‘I don’t know what this is about.’

Nancy picked up the oval-backed wooden chair from the table and carried it across.

‘It sounds serious.’

She didn’t mean it. She only said it to make Pa say no, it wasn’t. She smiled at him, giving him a second chance to say it. Pa smiled back, but his smile was tight, not a real smile at all. Nancy’s skin prickled.

Pa looked at Mam. ‘Our Nancy is nineteen now. We ought to discuss her future.’

‘My future?’ It came out as a squeak. ‘Is this about me not wanting to marry Henry? He’s a nice lad and I’m fond of him, but only as a friend. I – I couldn’t marry someone I didn’t love.’

‘You’re a lovely girl and you’ll meet someone one day, I’m sure,’ said Mam.

‘Let’s hope so,’ said Pa. ‘Since the war, there are lots of girls who have been left high and dry without husbands. But, just in case, we need to talk about your job, our Nancy.’

‘What about it? I love it. I know it’s an early start, and I’m on my feet all day, but I love serving the customers and I’m good at it. You – you haven’t had a complaint about me, have you?’

‘Of course not.’

‘We know you work hard, love,’ said Mam. ‘You’re a grafter. What’s this about, Percy?’

‘Serving in the pie shop doesn’t pay that well,’ said Pa.

He didn’t, he couldn’t, want her to leave the pie shop – could he? Nancy leaped in before he could utter the fatal words.

‘If it’s the money, the twins turn twelve after Christmas. They can go half-time at school and get afternoon jobs. That’ll bring in a bit more.’

‘Percy.’ Mam’s gaze darted his way. ‘We’re managing, aren’t we? I know we’re hard up, but we always get by.’

Pa patted her hand. ‘It’s our Nancy I’m thinking of, and her future. She can do more than work in a pie shop.’

‘There’s nowt wrong with working in the pie shop.’ Did that sound defiant? ‘I’m sorry, Pa, but there isn’t.’

‘I never said there was, but you could do more.’ He sounded almost jovial, but pretend-jovial, like his smile earlier had been a pretend-smile.

‘I don’t want to. I’m happy there.’

‘You’re a good girl,’ said Pa. ‘Amenable. Helpful. I’m sure you could be happy doing summat else.’

‘You mean a different kind of shop?’

Imagine working in one of the posh department stores in town. She might like that. But no, starting there at the grand old age of nineteen would make her stand out like a sore thumb when all the others would have gone there straight from school at thirteen or fourteen. Oh aye, straight from school at thirteen…and straight from the pie shop at nineteen. She would be a laughing-stock.

‘Anyroad,’ she said, ‘I like the pie shop.’

She more than liked it. She loved it. She had never been obstinate in her life before, but now she folded her arms and pressed her lips together. She felt defensive. She felt…no, Pa would never make her feel like that. Not threatened. Not Pa. It wasn’t possible.

Yes, it was. Oh, crikey.

Chapter Two

SATURDAY WAS NANCY’S favourite day of the week. She loved every day in the pie shop, surrounded by golden pastry and the enticing aromas of mince-and-onion and cheese-and-onion and the homely scent of meat-and-potato. They sold sweet pastries as well, lardy cakes loaded with sultanas and mixed spice, with sugar twinkling on the top; plump crumpets, good enough to make marge taste like the creamiest butter; and Eccles cakes, packed with the juicy currants that made children call them squashed flies cakes. Plenty of adults called them that an’ all, but Nancy wasn’t allowed to, because of working in the shop.

It was a grand job. She had started here the morning after she finished school and never once been sorry or wished for summat different. Saturday was the best day of all, because of the mill girls. That was what they were called, mill girls, no matter how old they were. The mill was up the road from the pie shop and it was shut over the weekend, but on Saturdays some of the mill girls topped up their earnings by doing half a day’s cleaning. Just after midday, they would burst through the shop door, cheerful at the prospect of being off work until Monday, their tummies rumbling after four hours of solid graft. Nancy didn’t kid herself about them. She knew they were bone-tired from the mixture of mill work and domestic responsibilities; but their Saturday visit to the pie shop made the place crackle with energy and good humour and something inside her responded, sometimes with eagerness, other times with a trickle of ice down her spine. Mam would never be in fine fettle like this.

Was that why Pa wanted her to earn more? To provide Mam with a more comfortable life?

Today she was to meet Pa after work and attend an interview for joining a business night-school. Night-school! Her! She had never shone at school and the thought of returning to the classroom made her heart tie itself in a knot, but Pa was determined. She couldn’t understand it. He had never suggested anything of the kind before.

The Turners, who owned the shop, started work in the bakehouse at half past four each morning and Nancy arrived in time for the shop to open at half-six. Monday to Friday, the shop stayed open for as long as the stock lasted, though Nancy finished at four. On Saturdays, the shop shut early, at three. Nancy spent the next hour washing the shelves and the counter and mopping the floor before helping to clean the ovens in the bakehouse. Usually she performed these tasks cheerfully, glad of an early finish, but today she felt more like climbing inside one of the cooling ovens and pulling the door to behind her.

‘When you catch the bus, ask for Chorlton Office,’ Pa had instructed. ‘That’s the terminus, so you needn’t worry about getting off at the wrong place.’ He had made it sound as if she wanted to go, as if alighting at the wrong stop would have been a disaster.

Normally she would have taken an interest in the unfamiliar roads, but on today’s journey she didn’t see anything of what she passed. At last, the bus swung around a wide hairpin bend and entered the open-air terminus, and there was Pa, approaching her window. Too late to duck down and pretend she wasn’t here.

‘Good. You’re on time,’ Pa greeted her as she stepped down from the platform. ‘It’s a five-minute walk to Wilton Close. I’ve already been to have a look.’

No chance of getting lost, then, and missing the appointment.

From the terminus, they walked along a street with houses on both sides, partway down which a vast tree overhung the pavement and road.

‘That’s a beech tree,’ said Pa, ‘and this is Beech Road.’

They passed through the tranquil shade cast by the tree, a golden-tongued breeze shifting through the leaves.

‘Round this corner,’ said Pa. ‘On the other side of that hedge across the road is the recreation ground; and Wilton Close is…here.’

He paused at another corner, but if he had stopped for her to admire Wilton Close, he was wasting his time… No, he wasn’t. She might be in turmoil, but she couldn’t help admiring the short cul-de-sac. There were two pairs of smart semidetached houses on either side, and a lone semi at the top, each with a front garden and a side-passage leading, no doubt, to a rear garden, not a back yard. The rich-green leaves and pale-pink blooms of a lace-cap hydrangea nodded over a garden wall on this side of the road and a mass of white roses, as delicate as tissue-paper, tumbled over a wall on the other side.

Pa guided her over the road and opened the gate belonging to the house adjoining the one with the roses. Inside was a neatly edged lawn that could do with a spot of water, and shallow beds of marigolds, their hues ranging from palest lemon to rich gold, the trumpet-blooms of petunias, and scarlet dahlias standing tall above ink-dark leaves.

‘…and this must be your daughter.’

‘Nancy!’ Pa gave her a discreet nudge.

‘Oh.’ Heat streamed into her cheeks. ‘I’m so sorry. I didn’t hear the door open. I was too busy admiring your garden. It must be like living in a park.’

Of all the stupid things to say – but the lady didn’t look contemptuous. In fact, she didn’t look capable of contempt. Older than Mam and Pa, she was thin and pale. At first glance, she was nowt special. Her mid-calf-length dress might be suitable for her years, but it cemented the rather dull impression. But that was before you noticed the kindness in the light-blue eyes, the lines at the sides of her mouth that suggested that smiles came more naturally than frowns, and the gentle way she moved her hands. Nancy warmed to her. Drat! That wasn’t meant to happen. She was all geared up for this afternoon to be the last word in unpleasantness. She hadn’t anticipated liking anyone or anything.

‘This is my daughter, Nancy.’ Pa removed his tired old trilby, gripping its brim in both hands.

‘I’m pleased to meet you, Miss Pike,’ said the lady. ‘My name is Patience Hesketh and you should call me Miss Patience. My sister is Miss Hesketh. Won’t you come in?’

Nancy had been in houses with hallways, but she had never seen a hall like this. Hallways were meant to be dark and narrow, with a row of coat-pegs on the wall and a poky staircase of bare treads that went straight up. Here, the stairs were carpeted up the centre, and after a dozen treads turned a corner and disappeared. A dark-wood bench, all fancy carving, stood beside the staircase and – was that? Yes, it was – a small cloakroom, with shelves and pegs, sat in an alcove opposite the foot of the stairs. An actual cloakroom – in a house! The last time Nancy had seen a room devoted to coats and hats had been at school.

Miss Patience opened a door and led them into a sitting room. By, it was grand! Fancy having a bay window. Mam would love that. If only Mam could have a bay window where she could look out at a pretty garden, instead of being stuck in grimy Bailiff’s Row in a measly flat in which the cloying, fusty whiff of stale tobacco was inescapable.

‘Prudence, this is Miss Pike. Miss Pike, allow me to introduce my sister, Miss Hesketh.’

Nancy started to smile, but stopped halfway. Instead of a second gentle, appealing lady, this one was – well, dress her in black, stick a pointy hat on her head and you could call her a witch. Her features were sharp – everything about her was sharp, from the set of her shoulders to the criticism in her glance. Her posture was upright, her manner austere. And yet she had the same grey hair and light-blue eyes as Miss Patience, the same thin build, the same slender hands; but what was soft and gentle in one was severe and unyielding in the other.

‘How do you do?’ said Miss Hesketh. ‘Please sit down. So you hope to be accepted for our business school?’

‘Well…’ What could she say?

‘We usually start an interview by inviting the applicant to tell us about her current position.’

‘I work in a pie shop.’

‘What do you do there?’

‘I sell pies.’ Did that sound impertinent? ‘And pastries. And I clean up at the end of the day on Saturdays.’

‘It doesn’t sound very interesting.’

‘Oh, but it is.’ Nancy sat up straighter. ‘I know all the customers by name and who their children are, and which ones are working hard at school and who got the cane for being naughty; and who’s engaged and who’s expecting. I know everyone’s favourite pies and what size pie they need for their family. And I know all the commercial travellers, even the ones who visit our part of the world only once a quarter. I know where they stay and what they travel in.’

‘Well, that certainly makes it sound more interesting,’ said Miss Patience. Was she being kind?

‘It sounds,’ said Miss Hesketh, ‘like one long round of gossip, which makes you unsuitable for our business school. We train girls in office work. We would never train a known gossip.’

‘I’m sure our Nancy isn’t a gossip, miss,’ said Pa.

‘I’m not,’ said Nancy. ‘It’s only chat, not gossip. I would never pass on anything that someone has told me. Having a chat is part of the job. It’s called knowing your customer. Folk are pleased if you remember what they had last time.’

‘So you know how to be discreet,’ said Miss Hesketh.

‘Yes.’ She said it with conviction. This was her good name in question. ‘My customers know they can pass the time of day with me without it being passed on to all and sundry.’

‘And you must have a good memory,’ said Miss Patience.

‘For things like what my customers want, yes; but I didn’t have a good memory at school. I can never remember all the capital cities, or which country produces which goods, or any dates apart from 1066.’

‘It sounds as if you didn’t do well at school,’ said Miss Hesketh.

‘Not at subjects like that, but I was good at the practical things – sewing, cooking, housework. The school I went to had a nursery attached, so we had proper mothercraft lessons. I enjoyed those.’

Pa cleared his throat. ‘She’s good at totting up prices in her head and giving change – aren’t you, Nancy?’ He looked at her almost pleadingly. Why did he want this for her?

‘So you’re good at shop work and good with people.’ Miss Patience looked at her sister. ‘That’s not a bad start, and she’s the right sort of age.’

‘The right age to train for office work?’ Nancy asked.

‘The right age for a surplus girl,’ said Miss Patience.

Nancy frowned. ‘Surplus girl?’

‘The term refers to all the girls who now won’t find husbands because so many men were killed in the war.’

‘I know about the unmarried girls, of course,’ said Nancy. ‘Everyone does. But I didn’t know there was an official name for them. We call them perpetual spinsters round our way.’

She bit her lip, realising belatedly that she was addressing two maiden ladies who weren’t exactly spring chickens. She saw them glance at one another. She hadn’t meant to be unkind, but would an apology make it worse, make it even more obvious she had put her foot in it? Then she remembered something.

‘When I left school in 1916, mine was the last year of girls to do mothercraft. They weren’t going to teach it any more. Was that because they knew they were going to have a generation of – of surplus girls on their hands?’ Her fingers curled round palms that suddenly felt clammy. It was a scary thought.

‘We believe,’ said Miss Hesketh, ‘that it is the responsibility of every surplus girl to make the best of herself. Our pupils tend to be girls who became office juniors when they left school. They come to us to broaden their range of skills.’

‘But we also want to help girls from other backgrounds, if we can,’ said Miss Patience. ‘Not just the middle-class girls or the ones who did better at school.’

‘You may not know the kings and queens of England,’ said Miss Hesketh, ‘but you appear to be a willing worker and that’s important. Are you proficient in the three Rs?’

‘I think so.’

‘Come now.’ This was said with asperity: her sister would have said it encouragingly. ‘Either you are or you aren’t.’

Nancy looked Miss Hesketh directly in the eye. ‘Yes, I am; and I go to the library. I like novels and poems.’

‘Poetry, eh? Do you have a favourite poem?’

Her mind went blank. It was like being at school all over again. ‘I used to read The Owl and the Pussy-Cat to my sisters when they were little.’

‘Really?’ Miss Hesketh’s politeness was enough to rip your heart out.

At last, too late, she remembered. ‘Thomas Hardy. I like his nature poems.’

Miss Hesketh nodded, just once. ‘I’m interested in you, Miss Pike.’ She looked at Miss Patience and there was a moment of silence as Miss Patience returned her look. ‘But I do need to be sure that your written English is of a sufficient standard, so you shall be required to write a letter of application.’

‘What do you think you might say in it?’ Miss Patience asked encouragingly. ‘What makes you a good employee?’

Nancy swallowed. She wasn’t used to blowing her own trumpet. ‘I’m punctual and polite and I’m honest – I’ve never tried to short-change anybody. I don’t mind what I’m asked to do, because I know it’s important to help out. And – and I’m good around the home. My mam isn’t well and I’ve always run errands and done the shopping and the cleaning.’

‘Even when you were at school?’ asked Miss Patience.

‘Oh, yes. I looked after the twins an’ all when they were little, but they can see to themselves now. I know it’s nowt to do with going out to work, but I try to make my mam’s life easier.’

‘She’s a big help to her mother,’ said Pa.

‘That’s something to be proud of,’ said Miss Patience.

Was it? It was only what any loving daughter would do.

‘It shows you’re capable of organising yourself and your tasks,’ said Miss Hesketh. ‘Subject to a satisfactory application, we should like to offer you a place with us. I believe we could make something of you.’

‘Thank you,’ said Pa.

Thank you? These middle-class ladies wanted to make something of her – and Pa said thank you. What was wrong with her the way she was?

‘Say thank you, Nancy,’ Pa murmured.

‘I think you’re wrong, Miss Hesketh.’ Nancy died a thousand deaths at the sound of the others’ combined intake of breath, but she ploughed on. ‘I don’t think I’m cut out for office work.’ There! She had said it.

Miss Patience sat forward. ‘I assure you that our school is a relatively small concern and there is nothing of the classroom about it. Next week my sister will begin a book-keeping course for a group of five experienced office girls, and that is the largest group we’ve had. When we opened our doors in the spring, all our teaching was on a one-to-one basis. Now each of us has two or sometimes three pupils at a time; but, where appropriate, we should always offer one-to-one tuition, for example if a pupil lacks confidence.’

‘That sounds just right, miss,’ said Pa.

Tears built up behind Nancy’s eyes. They were going to make her do this. Between them, they were going to make her. She turned to Pa.

‘What about paying for it?’ she whispered. ‘We could never afford it.’

‘We’ll manage,’ Pa murmured.

‘How?’ she hissed. She knew how hard up they were.

Pa spoke without moving his lips. ‘Not now, Nancy.’ He smiled a shade too brightly at the two ladies. ‘There’s another thing I’m interested in, if I may make so bold. I understand you sometimes take in a pupil as your lodger—’

‘Pa!’ The word burst out. Nancy’s pulse stopped beating and went to a long skid.

‘I’d like to register my Nancy as a pupil-lodger, if you please.’

There was a silence as Miss Hesketh and Miss Patience exchanged glances.

‘You are correct, Mr Pike,’ said Miss Hesketh. ‘We do have a maximum of two places for pupil-lodgers.’

Please say both places are taken, please, please, thought Nancy.

‘We have one pupil-lodger at present. The other young lady left us in July.’

‘And she got married in August,’ Miss Patience added with undisguised happiness. ‘She is Mrs Abrams now. Dear Molly.’

‘So you have a place free?’ Pa said with an eagerness that made Nancy cringe.

‘I’m afraid,’ said Miss Hesketh, ‘that, owing to family circumstances, we are unable to accept another pupil-lodger at present.’

Nancy had recently read a library book in which the heroine felt dizzy with relief and she had thought it rather over-written, but now she knew just what the author meant.

‘At present, you say?’ Pa edged forwards in his seat. ‘Then at a later date, perhaps…?’

‘Pa,’ Nancy whispered. What was going on? It wasn’t like Pa to be pushy. He was the politest, most accommodating person you could imagine. Besides, ‘family circumstances’ could be a polite way of saying no. She willed Pa to stop talking.

‘We’ll see,’ said Miss Hesketh.

‘Only I would especially like our Nancy to live in,’ said Pa.

‘Live in?’ Miss Hesketh’s thin eyebrows climbed up her forehead. ‘Living in is what servants do. Our pupil-lodgers, sir, are our paying guests for the duration of their tuition.’

‘Of c-course.’ Pa was ruffled. That slight stammer was a dead giveaway. ‘I meant no offence. It’s just that I see it as an important part of Nancy’s professional education that she should live with quality and learn refinement.’

Learn refinement? As if she was a back-street fishwife. Nancy swallowed hard and her throat bobbed.

‘Miss Pike has pretty manners, from what I can see,’ said Miss Patience.

‘But you do work on a girl’s social graces, don’t you?’ Pa sounded almost desperate. ‘So I’ve been told.’

‘Certainly we do,’ said Miss Hesketh. ‘An office girl must conduct herself with due decorum. Tutoring in that area is my sister’s speciality.’

‘And living with you as your paying guest,’ said Pa, ‘would help this decorum rub off on our Nancy, wouldn’t it?’

Nancy had never felt so small in her life, and for Pa to make her feel that way was horrible. She could hardly hold her head up, and, when it was time to leave, she said her goodbyes in a strangled whisper.

‘Well, our Nancy,’ Pa said as they walked back to the terminus, ‘what do you think?’

‘Are you trying to get rid of me? Don’t you want me at home any more?’

‘Eh, Nancy, eh, lass.’ Pa stopped, but she couldn’t look at him. ‘Of course not.’

‘You want to send me away.’

‘Just for a time. Just to help prepare you for office work. You heard what the lady said. Due decorum.’

‘Oh aye,’ Nancy answered bitterly. ‘There’s none of that in the pie shop, is there, what with me doing the can-can on the counter and showing off next week’s washing.’

‘Now then, our Nancy.’

‘And how am I to be a pupil-lodger? Where’s the money coming from? That’s board and lodging on top of teaching fees.’

Pa started walking again. ‘Aye, well, I’ve got a bit put by.’

Nancy hurried to catch up. ‘Then you should spend it on Mam. Take her to the seaside so she has summat nice to look at out of the window and buy her proper food and lots of it, instead of her looking out at sooty old Bailiff’s Row and drinking rusty-nail water every day.’

‘It will be spending it on Mam if you go to the business school,’ said Pa. ‘Think how it’ll help her if you bring more money in. That’s what this is about, lass, helping Mam.’

Helping Mam. Nancy’s resistance crumpled. A better life for Mam – she wanted that more than anything.

Chapter Three

‘WELL, ’ SAID PRUDENCE when Patience returned from seeing Mr and Miss Pike out.

‘You said that in your significant voice.’ Patience resumed her seat.

‘My what? Really, Patience, you do talk twaddle at times.’

Prudence wasn’t going to admit it, but she was well aware that, on occasion, she employed a particular tone of voice in her place of work that had her junior colleagues frantically double-checking their spelling before she laid eyes on it. There was something about Mr Pike that had elicited that response from her.

‘I’m glad you like Miss Pike,’ said Patience. ‘It will be good for her to leave the pie shop and move into a better kind of work.’

‘Assuming we can lick her into shape.’

‘The poor child. She’d undoubtedly much prefer to remain where she is. Mr Pike was most determined that we should accept her as a pupil-lodger, wasn’t he? He must have saved very hard to be able to afford it.’

Prudence frowned. ‘I wonder what he was saving for originally. It can’t have been for this. We only opened our doors earlier this year and we didn’t start taking pupil-lodgers immediately. A man from that rank of life couldn’t have saved up that quickly.’

‘He must be using the family’s long-standing rainy-day fund for Nancy’s training.’

‘Nancy, is it?’ Prudence raised her eyebrows. ‘I can see that, in your head, you’ve already got her installed in the old box-room.’

‘And why not? I should like to help her. She seemed a sweet girl.’

‘You think they’re all sweet girls,’ said Prudence.

‘What if I do? Don’t pretend you don’t like some of them more than others. You can’t deny you’ve grown fond of Vivienne. You call her by her first name and that’s something I never thought you’d do with one of our p.g.s.’

Vivienne.

Prudence’s heartbeat picked up speed, sending warmth coursing through her into every corner of her being. Vivienne – her daughter.

‘Vivienne is a dear girl.’

It was as much as Prudence could trust herself to say. It hurt more and more to deny the relationship that had changed her life. It