Integrated Finite Elements Analysis and Design of Structures
Integrated Finite Elements Analysis and Design of Structures
COPYRIGHT
The computer program SAP2000 and all associated documentation are proprietary and copyrighted products. Worldwide rights of ownership rest with Computers and Structures, Inc. Unlicensed use of the program or reproduction of the documentation in any form, without prior written authorization from Computers and Structures, Inc., is explicitly prohibited. Further information and copies of this documentation may be obtained from:
Computers and Structures, Inc 1995 University Avenue Berkeley, California 94704 USA tel: (510) 845-2177 fax: (510) 845-4096 e-mail: support@csiberkeley.com web: www.csiberkeley.com
Copyright Computers and Structures, Inc., 1978-1997. The CSI Logo is a registered trademark of Computers and Structures, Inc. SAP2000 is a registered trademark of Computers and Structures, Inc. Windows is a registered trademark of Microsoft Corporation.
DISCLAIMER
CONSIDERABLE TIME, EFFORT AND EXPENSE HAVE GONE INTO THE DEVELOPMENT AND DOCUMENTATION OF SAP2000. THE PROGRAM HAS BEEN THOROUGHLY TESTED AND USED. IN USING THE PROGRAM, HOWEVER, THE USER ACCEPTS AND UNDERSTANDS THAT NO WARRANTY IS EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED BY THE DEVELOPERS OR THE DISTRIBUTORS ON THE ACCURACY OR THE RELIABILITY OF THE PROGRAM. THE USER MUST EXPLICITLY UNDERSTAND THE ASSUMP-TIONS OF THE PROGRAM AND MUST INDEPENDENTLY VERIFY THE RESULTS.
Table Of Contents
2-D Frame with Static loading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 2-D Frame with Response Spectrum Loading . . . . . . . . . . . 11 2-D Frame with Time History Loading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 2-D Frame Steel Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Toolbar Icon Descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A1
TUTORIAL 1
10
0.1K/ft ROOF 20K 176 LEVEL 7 15K 176 LEVEL 6 12.5K 211 LEVEL 5 10K 211 LEVEL 4 7.5K 257 LEVEL 3 5K 257 LEVEL 2 2.5K 257 GROUND GLOBAL Z 283 257 162 283 162 257 2 @ 13-6" 162 283 162 257 131 257 131 211 131 257 131 211 5 @ 130" 104 211 104 176 104 211 104 176 104 104
30-0"
30"-0"
GLOBAL X
ALL COLUMNS ARE W14S ALL BEAMS ARE W24S MEMBER WEIGHTS ARE INDICATED TYPICAL STORY MASS = 0.49 kip-sec-sec/in MODULUS OF ELASTICITY = 29500 ksi STEEL STRENGTH (fy) = 36ksi
Note: You can change the units you are working with at any time and SAP2000 will handle the conversion. 2. From the File menu select New Model from Template.
3. 4.
Select 2D Frame. Fill in story and bay information. For now use 13 ft for story height and we will edit the first two floors and their grids next.
Editing Model
We are going to edit the framing and the grid at the same time. 1. From the Draw menu select Edit Grid. Hint: Always try to locate your joints at grid intersections. By providing grids you can make inputting, modifying and viewing of your model much easier and faster. 2. 3. 4. Select the Z direction button to change the grids defining the story heights. Select the Glue Joints to Grid Lines option. This will let you edit the joint locations and framing by simply editing the grid. Edit the grid locations and press the OK button to close the form. Hint: When you have finished editing the grid you can right click with the mouse on the columns to find out if the columns are the proper length. This is a very practical way to inquire about any joint or frame member.
Editing Supports
The next step is to change the supports on the structure from the default of pinned to fixed. 1. Select the Pointer Tool icon from the floating tool bar. 2. Draw a box completely around the three joints at the base of the structure Hint: You can always look at the status bar to see what type of elements and how many of them have been selected. 3. Select Assign Joint Restraints icon from the floating tool bar to set the fixed supports. You can also define other Joint properties including the restraint through the Assign menu.
3.
Assigning Loads
1.
The first step in entering the loads is to define static load cases. From the Define menu select Static Load Cases. DEAD can be used for the beam vertical loads and keep the Self Weight Multiplier as 1.
2.
Define a static lateral load case called EQ for the earthquake load. Assign the lateral load as a QUAKE type load. This will allow the load combinations for the design features of the program to be calculated automatically. Also set the Self Weight Multiplier to zero. The vertical loads shown in Figure 1-1 can be assigned to the beams by selecting all the beams and using the Assign Frame Span Loads button on the floating tool bar. The static lateral loads need to be entered by selecting each node individually and using the Assign Joint Loads button. Reminder: Make sure that you are adding the loads to the proper load case.
3. 4.
From the Assign menu select Joint Constraints. Select Add Diaphragm from the drop down list box. In the Diaphragm Constraint form give the diaphragm a name like DIA1 for the first floor. Select Z-axis constraint. This defines a diaphragm perpendicular to the Z-axis. Press the OK button.
2. 3. 4.
Press the OK buttons to finish the operation. Repeat the steps for the other floors with a different diaphragm name for each one.
The Story masses are the same on all floors so select one node from each floor. Change the input units to Kip-in since the Typical Story Mass provided in Figure 1-1 is given in those units. From the Assign menu select Joint Masses Enter the story mass in the local direction 1 (which in this case is the global X) direction. All the other values are zero.
5.
Material Properties
The final thing to check before running the analysis is the material properties. 1. 2. From the Define menu select Materials. In the Materials form select STEEL and press the MODIFY/SHOW MATERIAL button. In the Material Property Data form check that the material properties are correct. Remember that the values are reported in the current units.
Running Analysis
Once data has been entered, it is time to run the model and take a look at our results. 1. 2. Save your model. Set the parameters for the analysis run by selecting from the Analyze menu Set Options. In the Analysis Options form select a Plane Frame analysis to reduce the size of the solution and thus reduce the time needed for the analysis. Press the OK button to accept your changes.
3.
Select Run from the Analyze menu to analyze the structure. Note: Once the analysis has finished, you may want to look at the entire analysis results screen before pressing the OK button. This is your first check to see if there are any problems with the model.
Look at the deflection and animate it for both lateral and vertical loads to make sure that the model is behaving as expected. From the Display menu select Show Deformed Shape and select the loading case in which you are interested. Also select the Wire Shadow option, so you can see the undeformed structural shape. See Figure 1-3 and Figure 1-4 for the deformed shapes of the structure. Right click on any joint to see its displacement and rotation. Animate the displayed load by pressing the START ANIMATION button at the bottom of the status bar (A window with the deformed shape will need to be active for the button to show). You can also save the animation as an *.AVI file for later viewing from the File menu. (See online help under Export an AVI file.) Try This: Press the + and buttons next to the Animate button and see what happens to the form with the deformed shape. Press the STOP ANIMATION button when you are finished looking at it.
If these checks show that the input information appears to be correct then we can move to the more advanced checks.
Structural Performance
You will often want to make certain that the structure is within the performance limits, such as stresse ratio, set by the code being used. SAP2000 will do the stress checks automatically when a member is designed. (The design features of SAP2000 will be discussed in more detail in subsequent tutorials.) 1. The structural elements can be designed by simply selecting from the Design menu the Start Design/Check of Structure option. The frame elements will now display colors showing their stress level with the stress ratio level value indicated below the beam. A value of 1 is 100% stressed. Other design and input information can also be displayed by selecting from the Design menu the Display Design Info option.
2.
There is also the ability to see the design information on individual members and to assign alternate sections to them by right clicking on the element. From the screen that appears you can select the DETAILS button to view detailed information on the section for each of the load combinations used in the design. You can also redesign the element after changing its design parameters, effective length, K factor and section properties by pressing the REDESIGN button.
3.
If you have selected a new section and want to use that for your final design you can select from the Design menu the Update Analysis Sections option so the structure can be reanalyzed using the new sections that have been selected. Note: You may need to use the Refresh Window button on the tool bar to update the design information in the active window after changing any of the design parameters.
2. 3.
Final Comments
As you can see, SAP2000 is a powerful structural analysis tool and can be used for a variety of problems. However it is very important to understand the engineering principles on which it is based. Most projects start as feasibility exercises and mature into a full analysis/design project. This makes it very important to decide early on what the proper tool is so there will be no need to change programs during the middle of a project. SAP2000 tries to address as many of the needs that a designer may have during the life of the project. Features that help in the design process include: The ability to design small and large projects without having to learn a new program. The ability to design steel and concrete members within the same program. Fast analysis algorithms allowing time for developing the model and optimizing the design of structural elements. The ability to easily modify and improve the design.
There are probably as many ways to model a structure as there are engineers. However, you may find some of these ideas helpful: Start with a basic model of your structure and try and understand it before adding more detail. It is always easier to fix structural system related problems while the model is still simple. Ensure the structure can be constructed and will behave the way you have modeled it. If it can not be built in such a way, you may need to understand what effect that will have on the structure. Thoroughly document your design including assumptions, areas that need to be reviewed and information that is still required. You can use the User Comments and Session Log text editor under the File menu. This basic text editor is built into the program allowing your notes to be with your model. Experiment with alternative structural systems. SAP2000 was designed to be fast; use the extra time to improve your design. If there is time to do it properly later there should be time to do it properly from the start.
TUTORIAL 2
Description
This tutorial is a continuation of Tutorial 1. In this tutorial we will demonstrate how to add a Response Spectrum analysis to the 2-d frame. The basis for the Response Spectrum will be the UBC94S2 spectrum, which is included in SAP2000.
3.
Alternately, select the Find tab to search for key words in any of the online help topics. If this is the first time that you use Find for the SAP2000 online help, a Find Setup Wizard form will appear. Press the NEXT button to accept the criteria for building the find database. Press the FINISH button to have the database built.
In Area 1 type Response Spectrum In Area 3 you will again find Define Response Spectrum Functions which you can select to get to the help information. Note: You can find more information on using online help, in your windows documentation. You can also run the WINHELP32.HLP file in your C:\WINDOWS\HELP folder.
Defining Response Spectrum Case 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. If the model is locked then use the Lock/Unlock Model button to unlock it so you can make changes to the model. Set the units to Kip-ft. From the Define menu select Response Spectrum Case. Press the ADD NEW SPECTRA button on the Response Spectra form. In the Response Spectrum Case Data form:
Input a Damping of 0.05 (5 %) Select the UBC94S2 for the U1 direction and a Scale Factor of 32.2 ft/sec2. The scale factor is used for the Response Spectrum because UBC94S2 is normalized by the acceleration due to gravity g. The remainder of the default values are acceptable. Press the OK buttons to accept the changes you have made to both forms.
Running Analysis
Once you have made the modifications, it is time to run the model and take a look at the Response Spectrum results. 1. 2. Save your model. Set the parameters for the analysis by selecting from the Analyze menu Set Options. Select the Dynamic Analysis check box. Press the SET DYNAMIC PARAMETERS button and change the Number of Modes used in the solution to 7. The remaining default values are acceptable. Press the OK button on both forms to accept your changes. Note: You have to decide how many modes you will need to consider in your analysis to make the results meaningful. There are many criteria to take into account, but for a structure as simple as ours you can consider the same number of modes as there are floors. 3. Select Run Minimized from the Analyze menu to analyze the structure. Note: The Run Minimized option is extremely helpful when running large models that may take a lot of time to analyze. This option allows SAP2000 to run in the background so you can continue working on other programs. The other advantage to this option is that you get a cancel button that allows you to cancel a run if you need to.
Checking Results
1. Check the modal shapes and periods to see that they are as expected. From the Display menu select Show Mode Shape and select the mode you are interested in. You may also want to select the Wire Shadow option so you can see what the undeformed shape looks like. See Figures 2-1 through 2-4 and note that the mode number and period is shown as the title of the window.
Note: You can look at subsequent mode shapes by pressing the + and buttons that are next to the START ANIMATION button. 2. It is helpful to see the base shear produced due to the Response Spectrum analysis. Using the BASE SHEAR group that was set up in Tutorial 1, look at the base shear for the structure due to the Response Spectrum. You will see that it is substantially larger than the static load case.
3.
You can also check the displacement of a joint due to the Response Spectrum. From the Display menu select Show Deformed Shape. In the Deformed Shape form select the load case for the spectral analysis. Press the OK button.
Right click on a joint at the top level of the structure to see the displacement of the joint in the global X direction.
4.
Check the mass participation to see if enough modes were included in the solution. This will need to be done outside of SAP2000 by looking at the filename.OUT file using a text editor like WordPad. Minimize the SAP2000 program. Start WordPad or another text editor. In WordPad open the file filename.OUT. Where filename is the name of the file you used when saving this tutorial. Find the section titled MODAL PARTICIPATING MASS RATIOS as shown in Figure 2-5. You will find under the CUMULATIVE SUM column that Mode 1 through Mode 7 includes 100% of the mass participation. Which means that the 7 modes included in the analysis were enough.
Final Comments
A Response Spectra analysis introduces another level of complexity, which requires the engineer to further check the analysis results and the assumptions used in the modeling. Things to keep in mind during a Response Spectrum analysis: Completely understand the static behavior of the model before running a dynamic analysis. You will need to completely understand the rationale and applicability of scaling dynamic analysis results to equivalent static base shear before scaling results for any given model. The speed advantages of running a Response Spectrum analysis over a full Time History analysis can be substantial. In design, the Response Spectrum analysis can provide an even greater speed advantage, due to the fact that the design check does not need to be done at each time segment. However, one needs to be aware of the limitations of this method over a full Time History analysis.
TUTORIAL 3
Press the OK button to accept the additions that you have made.
3.
From the Define menu select Time History Cases to define the specifics of the Time History for your model. Select the ADD NEW HISTORY button. Press the MODIFY/SHOW MODAL DAMPING button and enter 0.05 (5%) for all modes and hit the OK button. Enter 500 in Number of Output Time Steps. Enter 0.02 (sec) in Output Time Step Sizes. This will give us 10 seconds of the earthquake time history. Select Linear from the Analysis Type drop down list box. In the Load Assignment area: select ACC DIR1 under Load select ELCENTRO under Function Set the Scale Function to the acceleration due to gravity which is 386.4 in/sec2 if your units are in Kip-in and 32.2 ft/sec2 if your units are in Kip-ft. Set the Arrival Time and Angle to Zero. Press the ADD button to add the load assignments and the OK button to accept the data you just entered.
We have now entered all the information we need for a Time History analysis. Note: It is usually a good idea to run your model every time you make a major change or addition. This will give you a way to catch your mistakes early and save you time in your final design.
Running Analysis
1. 2. Save your model. Set the parameters for the design run by selecting from the Analyze menu Set Options. 3. Check that the Dynamic Analysis settings are the same as for Tutorial 2.
Note: You can also view the Time History plot of the base shear by selecting Add Group Summation Forces instead of Add Base Functions and selecting the base shear group that was defined in Tutorial 1. 2. You can also check the displacement of a joint due to the time history. Select a joint and from the Display menu choose the Show Time History Traces option. Press the DEFINE FUNCTIONS button and in the Time History Functions form select the joint name from the list and press the MODIFY/SHOW TH FUNCTION button. In the Time History Joint Function form select the DISPL Vector Type and UX Vector Direction. Press the OK button to accept the changes. Press the OK buttons to go back to the Time History Display Definition form. Add the joint from the List of Functions to the Plot Functions list box and remove the Base Shear X function. Press the DISPLAY button to see the joint displacement with respect to time. See Figure 3-3.
You can also define a joint function directly in the Time History Display Definition form without selecting it first. In the Time History Display Definition form press the DEFINE FUNCTIONS button and in the Time History Functions form select Add Joint Disps/Forces. In the Time History Joint Function form enter the Joint ID. Select the Vector Type and Vector Direction. Press the OK buttons to go back to the Time History Display Definition form where you will find the new joint function in the List of Functions list box.
Note: The scale factor is used to normalize the Response Spectra. The Time History that is being used to produce the Response Spectra has been scaled by g so we need to divide by the same number to get back to normalized values. Under the Period tab select the Default and Structural frequencies, which are used in the generation of Response Spectrum. Default frequencies are a set of built-in frequencies, typically of interest in structures. Structural frequencies are the structures natural frequencies. Under the Damping tab keep only the .05 Damping Value. As the structure is assumed to have 5% damping, we will not need any other values. Press the DISPLAY button when you finish.
4.
You will see a plot of a response spectrum for the El Centro earthquake at 5% damping. See Figure 3-4.
5.
In the Response Spectrum Curves form select from the File menu the Print Tables to File option. This will make a file that has two columns. The first one is the Period and the second is the PSA for each period. Save the file under the name RS-ELCEN.TXT
Editing Table
The next step is to do some minor editing on the RS-ELCEN.TXT text file so it is in a format that SAP2000 can read. When the file is made, there is some extraneous information that is added to help you understand the content of the file. This extra information needs to be deleted. 1. Open RS-ELCEN.TXT in a text editor like WORDPAD or NOTEPAD. 2. Select all the text that is shown highlighted in Figure 3-5 and delete it. Save RS-ELCEN.TXT as a text file using the same name.
Now that the file only has the Period and the PSA columns, it is in a format that SAP2000 can read.
3.
In the Response Spectrum Functions form press the Add Function from File button. Name the spectra RSELCEN Press the Open File button and pick the RS-ELCEN.TXT file from the Pick File form. Keep the Number Of Points Per Line to 1 as there is only one set of response data on each line. Select the Period and Acceleration Values option. Press the OK buttons to close the forms.
4. 5.
From the Define menu select Response Spectrum Cases. In the Response Spectrum form press the ADD NEW SPECTRA button. Set the Modal Damping to 0.05. In the Input Response Spectra area select RSELCEN for the U1 direction and give it a scale factor of 32.2 ft/sec2. The remaining default values are acceptable. Press the OK buttons to close the forms.
Running Analysis
Once you have made the modifications, it is time to run the model and take a look at our results. 1. 2. Save your model. Select Run Minimized from the Analyze menu to analyze the structure.
Checking Results
The first thing to do is check the maximum deflection at the top of the structure and the base shear due to the Time History and the Response Spectrum. This will show how well the outlined method works. At the end of this section you will find the results of the static lateral load, Response Spectrum and Time History analysis. Response Spectrum Deflection 1. From the Display menu select Display Deformed Shape. 2. In the Deformed Shape form select the load case for the spectral analysis. Press the OK button.
Right click on a joint at the top level of the structure to see the displacement of the joint in the global X direction.
Response Spectrum Base Shear Using the BASE SHEAR group that was set up in Tutorial 1, look at the base shear for the structure due to the Response Spectrum. Time History Deflection and Base Shear 1. 2. Using the method outlined in the first part of this tutorial, plot the deflection at the top of the structure. Now remove the joint from the Plot Functions list and plot the Base Shear X direction by selecting it from the List of Functions in the Time History Display Definitions form.
Static Lateral Max Deflection Max Base Shear 1.6 in 72.5 Kips
Final Comments
As you have seen the Time History analysis is much more time consuming than a Response Spectrum analysis. The Response Spectrum and Time History analysis results can give similar results. However it is very important for the engineer to understand the strengths and limitations of each method so they can be effectively used.
TUTORIAL 4
0.1K/ft ROOF 20K COLUMN LEVEL 7 15K COLUMN LEVEL 6 12.5K COLUMN LEVEL 5 10K COLUMN LEVEL 4 7.5K COLUMN LEVEL 3 5K COLUMN LEVEL 2 2.5K COLUMN GROUND GLOBAL Z COLUMN COLUMN BEAM COLUMN COLUMN BEAM 2 @ 13-6" BEAM COLUMN COLUMN BEAM BEAM COLUMN COLUMN BEAM BEAM COLUMN COLUMN BEAM 5 @ 130" BEAM COLUMN COLUMN BEAM BEAM COLUMN COLUMN BEAM BEAM BEAM
30-0"
30"-0"
GLOBAL X
ALL COLUMNS ARE W14S ALL BEAMS ARE W24S TYPICAL STORY MASS = 0.49 kip-sec-sec/in MODULUS OF ELASTICITY = 29500 ksi STEEL STRENGTH (fy) = 36ksi
Materials
First thing to do is set the material properties. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Check that the units are set to Kip-in. From the Define menu select Materials. Select the STEEL Material type and press the MODIFY/SHOW MATERIAL button. Set the Steel Yield Stress fy to 36 Ksi. Set Modulus of Elasticity E to 29,500 Ksi. Press the OK buttons to accept the changes and close the forms.
Loads
1. In Tutorial 1 you assigned a set of point and uniform loads as DEAD load and included the member self weight. (See Figure 4-2 for the new Static Loads Case list.) In this tutorial we will assign a load case for the live load and one for the self weight of the members. Including a load case for the self weight of the structure is a good way to keep track of the structural weight for design optimization purposes. The loads are separated into dead, live and lateral earthquake load cases so the design part of SAP2000 can automatically generate load combinations. 2. For the DEAD load case set the Self Weight Multiplier to 0. Add a load case SELF of Type DEAD for the member self weight and set Self Weight Multiplier to 1. Add another static load case named LIVE and assign it as Type LIVE.
Add the same loads that are in the DEAD load case to the LIVE load case. This will mean that each beam in the structure has identical dead and live loads. (See Tutorial 1 for instructions on entering loads.)
Remember: You will not be able to delete a section that is in use. This feature is a way for the program to insure that all the members are assigned to existing sections. 4. From the Frame Section form add an Auto Select section which will be at the bottom of the Add drop down list box. Change the Auto Section Name to COLUMN. In the Auto Selections list box select and remove using the Remove button all the sections except the W14s. This will mean that any frame member assigned a COLUMN section will be designed from the list of W14 sections in the Auto Selections list box. (See Figure 4-3.)
5.
Using the instructions outlined in steps 2 through 4: Import all the sections between W24x55 and W24x162. Assign an Auto Selection group called BEAM with only the W24 sections in it.
6.
Finally, select all the vertical frame members and assign the COLUMN section to them. Then select all the horizontal frame members and assign the BEAM section to them. (See Tutorial 1 for instructions on assigning sections to frame members.) Note: You can of course select a specific section for both the analysis and design instead of using an Auto Select section . You simply need to assign the frame member a steel section and design it as outlined in Tutorial 1. The steel section can either be a user-defined section or a section from the Section Property file.
Running Analysis
Once data has been entered, it is time to run the model and take a look at our results. 1. 2. Save your model. Set the parameters for the design run by selecting from the Analyze menu Set Options. In the Analysis Options form select a Plane Frame analysis to reduce the size of the solution and thus reduce the time needed for the analysis. Select the Include P-Delta check box. Press the SET P-DELTA PARAMETERS button to set the analysis parameters. Set Maximum Iterations to 10. Include the two dead load cases DEAD and SELF in the P-Delta load combination with a factor of 1. Include the LIVE load case with a factor of 1.
Note: The load factors that you use need to be the load factor for the design load combo that includes lateral loads and has the largest vertical load on the structure. 3. The remaining default values are acceptable. Press the OK buttons to accept the changes and close the forms.
Select from the Analyze menu the Run option to analyze the structure. Note: Because we have assigned groups of sections and not specific sections for our design, SAP2000 will take suitable section properties to calculate the stiffness matrix and any other properties it may need. Once the first analysis and design has been performed, the program can be instructed to use the designed sections for analysis.
Designing Sections
Once you have run the analysis and checked the analysis results, you can set the parameters needed for steel design.
Selecting Code
The information in the analysis run is used to do a code check on the frame elements. 1. From the Options menu select Preferences.
2.
In the Preferences form under the Steel tab, select the steel code you want to use. In this case lets use AISC-ASD-89. Use the same Section Properties file that was used for importing the steel sections.
Once you have selected the code you will be using to design the members, you need to check the load combinations that will be used for the design. 1. 2. The first thing to do is make sure that under the Design menu the Steel Design item has a check mark on it. This will tell SAP2000 to design the steel sections. From the Design menu choose Select Design Combos. Look at the automatically created combos in the Design Combos list box by selecting the combo and pressing the SHOW button. If you find that there are other load combos that you want to use in your design, you can add them. Simply define the combo from the Define menu and then in the Select Design Combos form add the combo to the Design Combos list.
3.
Run the Design/Check from the Design menu by selecting Start Design/Check of Structure. Each of the elements will be designed with the most efficient section from its Auto Selection section group. SAP2000 will automatically display on the active window the percent of maximum stress below each of the elements. The elements will also be color coded for convenience with a stress ratio color key located at the bottom of the window.
Note: If you just want to check the design for a limited number of frame members, you can select those members and then choose Start Design/Check of Structure.
Overwrite Allowable Stresses used for the design. This is a value in the current units for the allowable stress of the section. When you have finished modifying the design parameters press the OK button. Note: Changing any of the information in the ReDesign form will make SAP2000 automatically recalculate the design stress ratios for that new information and update the Steel Stress Check Information form. See the Re-Analyzing section for instructions on updating the analysis sections.
5.
To use the ReDesign section in the next analysis you will need to select from the Design menu the Update Analysis Sections option. This will replace the sections used to build the stiffness matrix so that a more accurate design check can be made.
6.
You can also look at various design results on the graphics screen by selecting from the Design menu the Display Design Info option. These results will be plotted on the bottom and to the right of frame members. Note: The sections used for the analysis are shown at the top and to the left of the frame members. All the design information is shown at the bottom and to the right of the frame members.
7.
You can also Print out the design results by selecting from the File menu Print Design Tables. To print results on a limited number of members, select the members and then selecting from the File menu Print Design Tables.
3.
You will now see that the beam members are smaller. Hint: You can get a group load joint sum report on the Base Shear group to find what the self-weight of the structure is. This is a quick way to see if your changes have produced a more efficient structure. You can also get the total weight of the structure from the filename.EKO file.
Re-Analyzing
The first analysis run used approximate section properties to develop the stiffness matrix. So the model will need to be run again as an iterative process to make sure that the analysis is done using the selected sections. 1. Once you have finished modifying the structural sections you will need to use, from the Design menu select the Update Analysis Sections option. Then rerun the analysis to use the selected member properties for the stiffness matrix. Then rerun the design to see which members have changed. Once you are satisfied with the sections selected, from the Design menu choose the Replace Auto w/ Optimal Sections option. This will permanently replace the auto sections with the current design sections. This effectively makes the design section the analysis section and therefore replaces the BEAM and COLUMN analysis sections with the optimal or user selected sections.
2. 3.
LRFD Design
The method used for LRFD design is essentially the same as that used for ASD. The combos and checks made on the frame members will be performed using the LRFD code so the results and information reported are different. To run an LRFD Design/Check you will need to change some of your input parameters. 1. 2. 3. Enter new load factors for the P-Delta analysis. Select from the Preferences form the AISC-LRFD93 steel code. Redesign the steel sections.
Advanced Features
Defining Frame Element Groups
Sometimes you may find it helpful to design using frame member groups. This will force all the members in the group to be designed with the same section. The advantage of this method is that it will reduce the various number of sections used in the design. For example you can group two or three floors as one group when designing them. This will then provide you with one section that works for all the columns and one section that works for all the beams in that group. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Reassign the Auto Selection sections to the frame members. Assign all the frame sections at level 3 and below to a group name BOTTOM. Assign all the frame elements between Level 5 and Level 3 to a group name MIDDLE. Assign the remaining elements to a group name TOP. Rerun the analysis on the model. From the Design menu choose the Select Design Group option. This is where one can have the program design a group of members and assign all of them with the lightest section that satisfies the stresses in all of them. Include in the Design Groups list box only the member groups TOP, MIDDLE and BOTTOM. This will mean that each frame element group is designed with the most efficient section from the Auto Selection group. Note: If there are no groups in the Design Group list box then all the members will be designed individually. 3. When you press the OK button, SAP2000 will automatically design the steel sections and display the results in the active window.
Compare the results from the first design run and the group design run to see how that will affect the selected sections.
End Offset
This structure is designed to be a moment frame system with members that have no cross sectional dimensions for analysis purposes. However, even though this is not a bad assumption, SAP2000 allows a more accurate way of modeling this problem. By setting Member End Offsets, you can define a region about the beam column connection where the members can not bend. This essentially produces a rigid zone at that connection. The area can be as large as the user wants, but it is usually taken as the depth of the member that is framing into it, at that joint (or a fraction thereof). 1. 2. Select all the frame elements. From the Assign menu select Frame End Offsets. In the End Offset form select the Update Lengths From Current Connectivity option. This will make the program automatically calculate the end offset from the sections coming into each joint. Enter 1 for Rigid Zone Factor. This means that 100% of the potential End Offset length should be taken as rigid in the analysis run. Press the OK button.
3.
If you set the Element Shrink option on from the Set Elements form and look at the active graphics window, you will see that there are lines at each joint that show the assigned End Offsets. Remember: You will need to reset End Offsets every time the frame sections are changed. Note: The moment and shear values on the beams and columns will be slightly different than with no rigid End Offsets. This is because the rigid End Offset assignment reduces the flexible length of the members.
Final Comments
The steel design tools in SAP2000 are very helpful in designing the frame members. However there are a few things to keep in mind: 1. Make sure that all the design data for the sections are correct. The default values that the program uses for design may not be correct due to various methods you may have used to model your structure, e.g. K and Unbraced Length Ratios. You can use the Display Design Results form to view this information on the framing. For convenience, you can also view the analysis sections at the same time as the design information. Check that the design combos the program has provided are correct and sufficient for your particular structure. If they are not, add your own to the list used in design. Check the final design results at key locations to make sure they are the results you expect.
2. 3.
4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Check that the load factors used for the P-Delta analysis are correct. Redesign the structure whenever you make changes to the model. This will give you a way to see if the members are still acceptable. Use a group to help find the total weight of the structure. (See Tutorial 1 for instructions on how to do this.) Use groups for your design to reduce the different number of sections that are in your model. The filename.EKO file contains the total weights for each section used. This information can be used for initial cost estimations.
Appendix A
Appendix B