B. A. Part-I Outlines of Philosophy Marathi Version PDF

"VdkmZmMr naofm'
~r. E. ^mJ-1 : VdkmZ

d` A``Z nwpVH$m
oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya

( 2008 [mgyZ hm{Um`m [arjmgmR>r)
Hw$bg{Md, {edmOr {dmnrR>, H$mohmnya (_hmamQ>)
W_mdmr : 2007
{Vr` Amdmr : 2008
~r. E. (VdkmZmMr $naofm) ^mJ - 1 H$[aVm
gd hH$ dmYrZ. oedmOr odm[rR>m`m [admZJroedm` H$m{U`mhr H$mamZ{ ZH$c H$aVm `{Uma Zmhr.
Vr : 500
n
H$meH$ :
S>m. amO| X. H$mH$[a`m
Hw$bg{Md,
{edmOr {dmnrR>,
H$mohmnya - 416 004.
n
_wH$ :
lr. E. Eg. _mZo,
^mar AYrjH$,
{edmOr {dmnrR> _wUmb`,
H$mohmnya - 416 004.
n
_wInR> gOmdQ> :
VrH$ {qQ>J gphgog, H$mohmnya.
ISBN-978-81-906236-3-6
Xya oejU H|$ AmoU oedmOr odm[rR> `m]cMr _mohVr [wT>rc [`mda o_iy eH{$c.
oedmOr odm[rR>, odmZJa, H$m{hm[ya - 416 004. (^maV)
Xya oejU [nafX - BoXam JmYr amQ->r` _wV odm[rR>, Zdr oXcr `m`m odH$gZ AZwXmZmVyZ `m gmoh`mMr oZo_Vr H{$cr
Amh{.
(ii)
Xya oejU H|$, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya

n Vk go_Vr n
S>m. amO| X. H$mH$na`m
m. (S>m.) _moUH$amd gmiwI{,
Hw$cgoMd,
Hw$cJw$,
oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.
n
gcmJma go_Vr n
_m. m. (S>m.) E_. E_. gmiwI>{ ,
S>m. amO| X. H$mH$na`m
Hw$cJw$,
Hw$cgoMd,
m. (S>m.) E. E. S>mJ{
lr. ]r. Eg. [mQ>rc
gMmcH$, _hmodmc`rZ odH$mg _S>i,

odm d c{Im AoYH$mar,

lr. E. gr. [m{dma
m. (S>m.) Cm_amd ^m{BQ>{
. [arjm oZ`H$
cmc ]hma emr _mJ, ^maVr` odm[rR>, [wU{.
S>m. E. EZ. Om{er
S>m. ]r. [r. gm]i{,
gMmcH$, oejUem odmemIm,

èdVamd MhmU _hmamQ-> _wV odm[rR>, ZmoeH$.
"AWdgmX' Q>r-3, 32/11, Vmam]mB [mH$, H$m{hm[ya.
S>m. (lr_Vr) dmgVr amg_
lr. O{. Ama. OmYd
AoYR>mVm, gm_moOH$ em{, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.
AoYR>mVm, H$cm odmemIm, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.
S>m. H{$. EZ. gmJi{

AoYR>mVm, oejUem odmemIm,
S>m. Q>r. ]r. OJVm[
m. (S>m.) hr. Eg. [mQ>rc,
m. S>m. (lr_Vr) gr_m `{dc{ (gX` goMd)
AoYR>mVm, dmoU` odmemIm, oedmOr odm[rR>>, H$m{hm[ya.
gMmocH$m,
Xya oejU H|$, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.
AoYR>mVm, odkmZ odmemIm, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.
m. (S>m.) Eg. E. ]mar,

gMmcH$, Xya oejU H$h{`y odm[rR>, H$ZmQ>H$.
n
A`mg_S>i : VdkmZ n
A`j - lr. ZmJa{ H$Uamd ]S>m{]m

g. Jm. _. H$mc{O, H$amS>
l
lr. o[Q>H{$ gwYra _mYd
_wYm{Or H$mc{O, \$cQ>U, oO. gmVmam.

l
VdkmZ AoYod^mJ, [wU{ odm[rR>, [wU{.
lr. dmK_m{S>{ amOmam_ gm{Zm
]idV H$mc{O odQ>m, Vm. ImZm[ya, oO. gmJcr.

l
S>m. Jm{Ic{ [r. [r.

S>m. Om{er ]r. Ama.
10, [mZ_im, amD$V o]pS>J, dXmdZ Zgar Odi, [wU{-30.
lr. aKwZmW gmXmJa ohad{

MV`, 50 odmZJa, èdV H$mcZr, H$amS>, oO. gmVmam.
(iii)
Xya oejU H|$

oedmOr odm[rR>,
H$m{hm[ya
VdkmZmMr [a{fm
A`mg KQ>H$mMo boIH$

gnmXH$/boIH$
KQ>H$ H$_mH$
lr. ZmJao H$Uamd ~S>mo~m

g. Jm. _. H$mcoO, H$amS>, {O. gmVmam.
3d4
lr. {nQ>Ho$ gwYra _mYd

_wYmoOr H$mcoO, \$cQ>U, {O. gmVmam.
1, 2, 5
lr. \$aVmao Ama. hr.

_wYmoOr H$mcoO, \$cQ>U, {O. gmVmam.
9 d 10
lr. dmK_moS>o amOmam_ gmoZm

~idV H$mcoO, {dQ>m, Vm. ImZmnya.
6d7
lr. {hado Ama. Eg.

MV`, 50 èdV H$mcZr {dmZJa, H$amS>, {O. gmVmam
gnmXZ g{_Vr n
m. Ho$. ~r. ZmJao, H$amS>

A`j, VdkmZ A`mg _S>i,
{edmOr {dmnrR>, H$mohmnya
VdkmZ {d^mJ _wI, g. Jm. _. H$mboO, H$amS>
m. Ama. Eg. {hado

_mOr A`j, VdkmZ A`mg _S>i,
{edmOr {dmnrR>, H$mohmnya
{Zdm m`mnH$ d {d^mJ_wI,
N>.{edmOr H$mboO, gmVmam
m. Eg. E_. {nQ>Ho$, g_d`H$

VdkmZ {d^mJ _wI, _wYmoOr H$mboO, \$bQ>U
(iv)
666
VmdZm....?
{edmOr {dmnrR>m`m Xya {ejU H|$ AVJV ~r.E.^mJ1 VdkmZ `m {df`m`m VdkmZmMr naofm `m A`mgH$_mda
AmYm[aV d` A``Z nwpVH$m {dm`m`m hmVr Xo`mV Amhm
gdmg AmZX hmoV Amho. ^maVr` Am{U nmMm` VdkmZmbm gw_mao
2500 dfmMr nanam Amho. `mVrb H$mhr Vddo`m`m Am{U
`m`m {dMmamMm n[aM` H$$Z XoUo hm `m nwpVHo$_mJMm Coe
Amho. n{h`m nmM KQ>H$mV ^maVr` XeZmMm Va nwT>rb nmM KQ>H$mV
nmMm` {dMmadVmMm AmT>mdm KoVbobm Amho.
^maVr` VdkmZmV Y_ Am{U VdkmZ `mMm EH${V {dMma
Ho$bm OmVmo. qhXy Y_, ~m Y_, OZ Y_ `m`m_mJo eH$amMm`,
^JdmZ ~m, ^JdmZ _hmdra `mMo {dMma AmhoV. VgoM nmMm`
VdkmZm~m~V hUVm òV Zmhr. nmMm` VdkmZmV OS>dmX,
{MXdmX, AZw^ddmX Aem {d{dY {dMmaUmbr AmT>iVmV. {dMma
UmbrVrb R>iH$ VdkmMm `m A`mgH$_mV AmT>mdm KoVbobm
Amho.
hr nwpVH$m V`ma H$a`mMo H$m_ `m gd boIH$ _S>itZr
Ho$bobo Amho. nwpVH$m doioV V`ma H$a`mMo lo` gdmZmM Amho.
VgoM {edmOr {dmnrR>mZo `mH$m_r Amhmg gYr {Xbr `m~b
Amhr gd boIH$ {edmOr {dmnrR>mg Y`dmX XoVmo.
666
(v)
AZwH$_{UH$m
KQ>H$ H$_mH$
KQ>H$mMo erfH$
nmZ H$_mH$
KQ>H$ 1
^maVr` VdkmZmMo d$n
KQ>H$ 2
MmdmH$ XeZ
11
KQ>H$ 3
OZ XeZ
18
KQ>H$ 4
~m XeZ
34
KQ>H$ 5
AV doXmV
51
KQ>H$ 6
gmHo${Q>g d coQ>mo
59
KQ>H$ 7
gV Wm_g A{dZmg
72
KQ>H$ 8
aoZo XoH$mV
78
KQ>H$ 9
OmZ cmH$
86
KQ>H$ 10
~H$co
97
(vii)
`{H$ KQ>H$mMr gwdmV CoQ>mZ r hm{Bc

. CoQ>{ oXemXeH$ AmoU [wT>rc ]m]r [Q> H$aUmar
AgVrc.
1. KQ>H$m_`{ H$m` oXc{c{ Amh{.
2. Vw_`mH$Sy>Z H$m` A[{ojV Amh{.
3. odoeQ> KQ>H$mdarc H$m` [yU H{$`mZVa Vwhmcm H$m` _mhrV hm{`mMr A[{jm Amh{.
d` _y`_m[ZmgmR>r Z oXc{c{ AgyZ `mMr A[{ojV Cma{hr X{`mV Amc{cr Amh{V.
`m_wi{ KQ>H$mMm A`mg `m{` oXe{Z{ hm{Bc. Vw_Mr Cma{ ochZ Pm`mZVaM d` A``Z
gmoh`m_`{ oXc{cr Cma{ [mhm. hr Vw_Mr Cma{ (qH$dm dm`m`) Am_`mH$S>{ _y`_m[ZmgmR>r
[mR>dm`Mr ZmhrV. Vwhr `m{` oXe{Z{ A`mg H$amdm, `mgmR>r hr Cma{ "A`mggmYZ' (Study
Tool) hUyZ C[`wV R>aVrc.
`{H$ od^mJm`m [mR>r_mJ{ Or naV [mZ{ R>d{ c{cr Amh{V `mda `m od^mJmMm A`mg
H{$`mda _hdmM{ _w{ AWdm Q>r[m och eH$mc. `m_wi{ KQ>H$mMm gIm{c A`mg Va hm{Bc
M
[U [arj{Mr V`mar hm{D$Z Vw_Mm _m`dmZ d{ihr dmM{c.
(viii)
KQ>H$ - 1
^maVr` VdkmZmMo dn
1.0 C{>o
1.1 mVm{dH$
1.2 {df`{ddoMZ
1.2.1
VdkmZ hUOo H$m`?
1.2.2
^maVr` VdkmZmMo dn
1.2.3
^maVr` XeZmMo dJuH$aU
1.2.4
^maVr` VdkmZmMr g_mZ d{e>o
1.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z
1.4 gmame
1.5 d` A``Z ZmMr Cmao
1.6 gamdmgmR>r dm`m`
1.7 nm[a^m{fH$ eX
1.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$
1.0 C{>o :
`m KQ>H$mV Imcrc Jmo>tMr AmnU _m{hVr H$Z KoUma AmhmoV.
* VdkmZ hUOo H$m` ho gmJVm òBc.
* VdkmZm`m {d{dY `m`m H$aVm òVrc.
* ^maVr` VdkmZmMo dn n> H$aVm òBc.
* ^maVr` XeZmMo dJuH$aU n> H$aVm òBc.
* ^maVr` VdkmZmMr g_mZ d{e>o gmJVm òVrc.
1.1 mVm{dH$ :
VdkmZ {df`mMr AmoiI H$Z KoUo hm KQ>H$mMm Coe Amho. VdkmZ `m {df`m~c gm_m`
cmoH$m_ò H$mhr Jag_O AmhoV. hm {df` H$i`mg AdKS> Amho Aer g_OyV Amho nU hr g_OyV
H$er MwH$sMr Amho ho AmnUmg `m {df`m`m A`mgmZo hmoBc. òH$ am>mcm B{VhmgmV AZoH$ _hmnwf,
1
{dMmadV hmoD$Z Joco.`m`m {dMmamdZ AmnUmg ""VdkmZ'' {df`mMr AmoiI hmoBc. `m _hmZ nwfmZr
Ago H$mhr {dMma {Xco H$s, `m H$mimVrc gm_m` cmoH$mMo OrdZ ~XcyZ Joco.
AmnU VdkmZm_ò A`mg`m OmUm`m {d{dY g_`mMr Cmao AmnU emoYV OmD$ VgVgo
VdkmZ hUOo H$m`? `m ZmMo Cma AmnUmg {_ioc.
VdkmZm`m gX^mV VrZ Z {dMmaVm òVrc. VdkmZ ho H$ohm {Z_mU Pmco? H$go {Z_mU
Pmco? Vo H$moUmH$Sy>Z {Z_mU Pmco? gmYmaU ^maVr` Am{U nmm` VdkmZmMm CJ_ gw_mao 2500
dfmnydu Pmcm. Oohm _mUyg ^modVmcMo OJ H$go {Z_mU Pmco? {dm`m _yimMr A{V_ Vd H$moUVo?
_r Hw$Ry>Z Amcmo? `m OJmMm {Z`Vm, {Z_mVm H$moU Amho? Aem {d{dY mZm Cmao emoYy cmJcm. `mVyZ
VdkmZmMm O_ Pmcm.
^maVr` VdkmZ ho doXH$mimnmgyZ ApVdmV hmoVo. gmYmaU {Vnydu 1500 dfmnydu doXmMr
aMZm Pmcr. ^maVr` VdkmZmMr gw` df_V _mS>Ur gmYmaU B.g.5 do 6 do eVH$mV Pmcr. ^maVr`
VdkmZmMr d{XH$ Am{U Ad{XH$ Aem XmoZ ^mJmV {d^mJUr Ho$cr OmVo. `m`, deo{fH$ , gm`, `moJ,
nyd{__mgm, Cma {__mgm Aer d{XH$ XeZo AmhoV Va MmH$mH , OZ, ~m m Ad{XH$ nanam AmhoV.
^maVr` XeZmV eH$amMm`, ^JdmZ ~m, ^JdmZ _hmdra Ago R>iH$ {dMmadV AmhoV `mZr
^maVr` VdkmZm`m jomV _mocmMr â Q>mH$cr.
nmMm` VdkmZmMo CJ_WmZ Jrg XoemV AgyZ nmm` VdkmZmMo mMrZ- _`_`wJrZAdmMrZ Ago VrZ H$mcIS> nS>VmV ""Wocrg'' hm n{hcm nmm` {dMmadV hmo` `mZo g>rMr {Z{_Vr
H$er Pmcr? `m mcm BamZo {d {Z_mU Ho$co `m mnojm doJio Cma {Xco. `mZo g>rMm O_
OcmVyZ (nm`mVyZ) Pmcm Ago n>rH$aU {Xco Agm `mZo `m H$mimVrc n>rH$aUmnojm doJio
n>rH$aU {X`m_wio `mc nmMm` VdkmZmMm OZH$ hQ>co OmVo. JrH$ {dMmadVmV gmHo${Q>g, coQ>mo
Ago {dMmadV AmhoV mMrZ H$mimnmgyZ Vo AmOVmJm`V nmm` VdkmZmV Am_m, Ba, g>rMr
Cnmr H$er Pmcr? Aem mZm Cmao {Xcr Jocr.
AmnU `m dfu`m VdkmZm`m A`mgH$_mV H$mhr _wI ^maVr` Am{U nmm` VdkmZmMm
n[aM` H$Z KoUma AmhmoV.
1.2 {df` {ddoMZ
1.2.1 VdkmZ hUOo H$m`?
{d{dY `m`m
1. VdkmZ hUOo g_J AZw^dmMo kmZ hmo`. (Philosophy as of Experience as a whole)eX
`wnmr emmV VdkmZ hUOo VV Mo kmZ hmo`. VV hUOo Oo H$mhr ApVdmV Amho Vo hmo ` .
EImm dVyMo gnyU kmZ hmo`mgmR>r `m dVy`m JwUmMo kmZ hmoU Amd`H$ Amho. Ago JwU OmUyU KoUo
qH$dm dVyMo ""gmaVd'' (Essence) hUOo VV hmo`. CXm. EImm nwnmMm AmH$ma, JY, aJ dJao JwU
hUOo nwnVd hmo`. _wZ`mMo _Zw`d. Aem VhoZo gnyU AZw^dmMo kmZ hUOo VdkmZ hmo`.
2
2.
VdkmZ ho emmMo em Amho. (Philosophy as Science of all Sciences.)
mMrZ H$mir Oohm _mUyg S>m|Ja X`mV amhV hmoVm `mdoiog Vmo ^modVmc`m OJm{df`r _m{hVr
KoV Jocm. `mZo Jmoim Ho$coco kmZ IwnM _`m{XV hmoVo. `m kmZmcm `mZo ""VdkmZ'' Ago Zmd {Xco.
hiyhiy `m kmZmMm {dVma EdT>m hmoV Jocm. _mUgmZo dV:`m gmoBgmR>r `m kmZmMr {d^mJUr Ho$cr,
doJdoJir emo {Z_mU Pmcr. CXm. nXmW {dkmZ,agm`Z em, dZnVr em, Ordem B. _mUgm`m
_ZmV ^modVmc`m OJm~amo~aM g_mO{df`H$ kmZmMmhr g_mdoe hmoVmo. `m kmZmVyZ B{Vhmg, g_mOem,
amèm, AWem, _mZgem Aer emo {Z_mU Pmcr. `m gd emmMm CJ_ VdkmZmV Amho
hUyZ VdkmZmcm gd emmMr OZZr (Mother of all sciences) hUVmV.
3
VdkmZ hUOo kmZm~Xc kmZcmcgm, AmnwcH$s ~miJUo, kmZmda o_ H$aUo hmo`.(Philosophy

as love for Wisdom.) Vdk H$moUmcm hUVm òBc? VdkmZ hUOo ehmUm _mUyg (Wise Person) hmo`.
ehmUm _mUyg kmZmda o_ H$aVmo. kmZmMm emoY KoVmo. kmZmMr H$miOr KoVmo. kmZ dmT>rg H$go cmJoc,
`mMo ajU H$go hmoBc? Voo nmhVmo. `m_wio gd jomV gemoYZ H$aUm`m gdmZm Vdk hUyZ g~moYVm
òBc.
4
VdkmZ hUOo A{V_ g`mMm emoY KoUo hmo`. (Philosphy as a search for Ulitimate Reality.)
_mUgmcm ^modVmc`m g>r~c, dV:~c Hw$Vhc {Z_mU Pmco. ho {d H$go {Z_mU Pmco?
Vo H$moU`m VdmnmgyZ {Z_mU Pmco? ho Vd EH$ Amho H$s AZoH$? Ago Ag` {Z_mU Pmco. H$mhr
VdkmZr Ago Cma {Xco H$s EH$_od Aem VdmnmgyZ {d {Z_mU Pmco. ho Vdk EH$ddmXr (Monistic)
hUyZ AmoiIco OmVmV. Va H$mhr VdkmZm`m _Vo {d ho EH$mnojm A{YH$ VdmnmgyZ {Z_mU Pmco.
Ago hUUmao Vdk AZoH$ddmXr (Pluralistic) hUyZ AmoiIco OmVmV. ^maVr` Am{U nmm`
VdkmZmV ho {d H$emVyZ (H$emnmgyZ) {Z_mU Pmco `m mcm XmoZ _wI Cmao {Xcr Jocr. H$mhr
Vdk hUVmV-OS> `mVyZ {d {Z_mU Pmco. `m VdkmZm`m _Vo ""OS>`'' ho A{V_ g` Amho.
(Matter is real.) Va H$mhr VdkmZm`m _Vo Am_VdmnmgyZ (MV` VdmnmgyZ) {d {Z_mU Pmco
Amho. `m`m _Vo Am_Vd ho A{V_ Vd Amho. (Idea is real.) WmoS>`mV OS>dmXr Am{U Am_VddmXr
hr `m mMr XmoZ Cmao AmhoV. Aem VhoZo VdkmZmV A{V_ g`mMm emoY KoVcm OmVmo.
5. VdkmZ hUOo OrdZ OJ`mMm EH$ _mJ hmo`. (Philosophy as a way of life.) _mZdr B{VhmgmV
AZoH$ nmMm` Am{U ^maVr` {dMmadV hmoD$Z Jooco. `mZr OJmdo H$go? `m~c gm_m`mZm _mJXeZ
Ho$co, {dMma {Xcm. `m {dMmam_wio gm_m` cmoH$mMo OrdZM ~XcyZ Joco. ^JdmZ ~m, dm_r
{ddoH$mZX, H$mc _mg, _. JmYr, S>m. ~m~mgmho~ Am~oS>H$a Aem cmoH$mZr EH$ {d{e> OrdZnVr
{Z_mU Ho$cr. `m_wio VdkmZ hUOo OrdZ OJ`mMm _mJ hmo`. Ago hUVm òBc.
6
VdkmZ hUOo gd H$mhr Amho Am{U / gd H$mhr Zmhr.(Philosophy as evertyhing / or Nothing)

VdkmZm_ò gd H$mhr Amho `mMm AW gdM kmZmMm VdkmZmV g_mdoe hmoV AgVmo naVy ZVa`m H$mimV
kmZmMm {dVma Pm`mZo dV emo {Z_mU Pmcr. VdkmZmnmgyZ EH$ EH$ {df` ~mOycm hmoV Joco.
AcrH$S>rc H$mimV g_mOem, _mZgem ho {df` ~mOycm Pmco AmhoV Am{U Vr dV emo ~Zcocr
AmhoV.
AmO`m H$mimV VdkmZm_ò kmZ _r_mgm (Epistemology) Am{U gmmem qH$dm gXdVy
_r_mgm `m (Metaphysics) XmoZ _wI emImMm A`mg Ho$cm OmVmo. kmZ_r_mgoV kmZ hUOo H$m`?
kmZmMo dn, d aMZm AmnUmg kmZ H$go m hmoVo Aem kmZ{df`H$ {d{dY mMm A`mg Ho$cm
OmVmo.Va gXdVy _r_mgoV A{V_ g` H$moUVo? BamMo dn, Am_m, eara, Am_m d earamMm g~Y
Aem {d{dY mMm A`mg Ho$cm OmVmo. `m XmoZ _wI emIm~amo~aM Zr{Vem, gmX` _r_mgm,
VH$em, _y` {gmV, gm_m{OH$ amOH$s` VdkmZ Aem hr VdkmZm`m {d{dY emIm AmhoV.
1.2.2 ^maVr` XeZmMo dn ^maVr` VdkmZmcm XeZem hUyZ g~moYco OmVo. òH$ g_mOmMm OrdZmH$S>o nhm`mMm
>rH$moU VdkmZmVyZ, XeZmVyZ JQ> hmoV AgVmo.
^maVr` XeZo EH$Xa {H$Vr AmhoV?
_mYdmMm`m`m ""gdXeZ gJh'' `m `mV JWmV gmoim XeZmMo {ZnU Ho$coco Amho. `mVrc
_hdmMr ZD$ XeZo AmhoV. `m XeZmMo d{XH$ (Orthodox) Am{U Ad{XH$ (Heterodox) Aem XmoZ
H$mamV dJuH$aU Ho$co OmVo. d{XH$ XeZmZmM ApVH$ XeZo Am{U Ad{XH$ XeZmZm ZmpVH$ XeZo
Agohr hQ>co OmVo. `m{R>H$mUr ""ApVH$'' qH$dm ""Zm{VH$'' `m eXmMm AW ""Bamcm _mZUmao'' d
Z _mZUmao EdT>m _`m{XV ZgyZ doXmZm _mU _mZUmar Am{U doXm_m` ZmH$maUmar Ago ho dJuH$aU
Amho.
d{XH$ XeZo Ad{XH$ XeZo -
1) `m`
2) deo{fH$
3) gm`
4) `moJ
5) nyd_r_mgm 6) Cma _r_mgm (doXmV)
1) MmdmH$
2) OZ
3) ~m
`mVrc AV doXmV `m d{XH$ XeZmMm Am{U

MmdmH$, OZ, ~m `m Ad{XH$ XeZmMm
AmnU A`mg H$aUma AmhmoV. ^maVr` VmpdH$ {dMmamcm doXH$mimnmgyZ ma^ Pmcm. doX aMZoMm
H$mcIS> H$moUVm `m~m~V gemoYH$mV EH$_V Zmhr. gmYmaUnUo {Vnyd 3000 dfo Vo {Vnyd
1500 dfo `m Xa`mZ`m H$mcIS>mV doXmMr aMZm Pmcocr Agmdr. (hUOo gmYmaUnUo 3000 Vo
5000 dfmnydu doXmMr aMZm Pmcocr Agmdr.)
doXdmL>_` mMrZ _mZco OmVo nU `mnojmhr mMrZ Ago B{Ope`Z Am{U ~m{~cmo{Z`Z dmL>_`
Amho. doX hm H$mhr JW Zmhr Va Vmo _m{IH$ dnmV Amho. (AcrH$S>`m H$mimV doX JW dnmV
CncY AmhoV.)mMrZ F$ftZr, _wZtZr doX_w$mMo nR>U, CmaU Ho$co. doX JwH$Sy>Z {e`mH$S>o nanaoZo
Joco. doXmMr nanam hr EoH$`mda, ldUmda AmYm[aV Ag`mZo `mZm "lw{V' hUVmV. doX_mMo nR>U
Ho$co OmVo.
4
doX ho Mma H$maMo AmhoV. 1) F$doX
2) ÒwdoX
3) gm_doX 4) AWddoX
gd Y_ H$nZmMo _yi doXmV AmT>iyZ òVo. doXmMo g{hVm, ~mhUo, Ama`Ho$ Am{U Cn{ZfXo Ago
VrZ ^mJ AmhoV. g{hVo_ò XodXodVmMr VwVr Ho$cocr AgVo Va ~mhU JWmV `k{H$`m H$m H$amdr,
H$er H$amdr WmoS>`mV H$_H$mS>mMo {ddoMZ AgVo Va Cn{ZfXmV doXmVrc VdkmZ AmT>iVo. `m_ò
g>r, Ba, Am_m, A{V_ g` `m gX^mV {dMma _mS>coc AmhoV.
WmZ`r.
Cn{ZfXo, ~hgyo, Am{U ^JdXJrVm `m VrhrVyZ d{XH$ ^maVr` XeZmMm CJ_ Pmcocm Amho
`m_wio `m VrhrZm {_iyZ "WmZ`r' Ago hQ>co OmVo.
1) Cn{ZfXo - Cn{ZfX `m eXmMo \$moS> Cn+{Z+gX Aer H$aVm òBc. Cn hUOo Odi, gX
hUOo ~gUo. Jw`m Odi {Z>mnydH$ ~gUo hmo`. JwH$Sy>Z {e`mZo kmZ JhU H$amdr Aer mMrZ
H$mimVrc nanam hmoVr. JwJhr, Aml_mV {e` ahmV. Jww kmZ XoV, Jw{e` `m`mV momao hmoV,
MMm hmoV. hrM Cn{ZfXo hmoV.Cn{ZfXo hm doXm`m eodQ>r Amcocm ^mJ Amho. Cn{ZfXo EHy$U AH$am
AmhoV. Vr nwT>rc_mUo -Be, Ho$Z, H$R>, _wS>H$, _mS>`, V{V[a`, CVao`, N>mXmo`, ~hXma`H$, ,
doV doVoVa.Cn{ZfXmV Am_m, ~, na~, `mMo dn n> Ho$coco Amho. Am_m Am{U ~U `mMo
nana g~Y B. ~c AZoH$ gyo$ (cmoH$) Cn{ZfXmV AmT>iVmV.
2) ~gyo - ~mXamÙmZr ~hZgymMr aMZm Ho$cr. ~hZ gymZmM doXmVgyo qH$dm em[aarH$ gyo
Agohr hUVmV. ~mXamÙmZr ~hZgym`m ma^rM dV:M ~hZ{df`H$ {dMma _mS>co Va Xwg`m
A`m`m_ò gm`, deo{fH$, ~w Am{X _VmMo IS>Z Ho$coco Amho. `m`m _Vo ~hZ ho OJmMo
Am{XH$maU AgyZ `mVyZ OJ Cn Pmcoco Amho. OJmMo ApVd, cm^hr ~hZmVM hmoVo. Agm {dMma
~mXamÙmZr _mS>cocm Amho.
3) ^JdXJrVm - ""^JdXJrVm'' hr Hw$jomda ^JdmZ lrH$UmZo ""qH$H$V` _yT>'' ~Zco`m
AOwZmcm gm{JVcr Ago _mZco OmVo. nU Vr VodT>mnwaVrM _`m{XV Zmhr. gm_m` _mUgm`m OrdZmV
{der>> gJr H$m` H$amdo? H$go dmJmdo Agm g^_ {Z_mU hmoVmo, Aemdoiog ^JdXJrVm AOwZm_mUoM
gm_m` _mUgmZmhr _mJXeZ H$aVo.
^JdXJrVoMr aMZm gmYmaU {Vnyd ghmdo eVH$ Vo {Vnyd Xwgao eVH$ `m Xa`mZ Pmcocr
Agmdr.^JdXJrVoV _moj hUOo H$m`? Am`mMo Iao dn H$moUVo? Vo H$go OmUyZ `mdo? OrdZmMo
A{V_ ò` H$moUVo Agmdo? Aem {d{dY mMr Cmao {_iVmV. _moj mrgmR>r Agco`m H$__mJ,
^{$_mJ, e{$_mJ `mMo {ddoMZ ^JdXJrVoV AmT>iVo.
òH$mZo Amnco H$V` nma nmS>co nm{hOo. dY_mMo nmcZ Ho$co nm{hOo. "d-Y_' lo> Amho Ago
^JdXJrVm hUVo. H$__mJm~amo~aM ^JdXJrVm ^$sMo _hd {deX H$aVo. ^JdmZ lrH$U hUVmV
_cm _mPo ^$ {` AmhoV. Omo Omo ^$ _m`mH$S>o loZo òVmo, `mMo `mMo _r ajU H$aVmo. `mZo _cm
H$m` AnU Ho$co Amho, nmZo, \w$co, \$io, Oc, YZ `m Jmo>r JmU R>aVmV. lm hr _hdmMr Amho.
5
^JdXJrVoV Am`mMo ~hZmer ZmVo H$go OmoS>mdo, `m `moJ _mJmMo {ddoMZ Amho. Amn`m
{MmdmrMm {ZamoY H$gm H$amdm. pWVk H$go ~Zmdo? `mMo ^JdXJrVoV _mJXeZ Amho. pWV kmMr
cjUo H$moUVr? Vmo H$gm dmJVmo `m~c {ddoMZ Amho. WmoS>`mV ^JdXJrVm hr gm_mÒZmZm _mJXeH$
Agm JW Amho. gnyU OrdZmMo VdkmZ Amho.
1.2.4 ^maVr` VdkmZmMr g_mZ d{eo.
^maVr`m XeZm_ò doJdoJionUm {XgyZ òVmo. hm doJdoJionUm {XgyZ ò`mMr Mma H$maUo gmJVm
òVrc.
1)
{dm_mJrc A{V_ ò {H$Vr d H$moUVr AmhoV?
2)
lw{VMo m_m` _mZmdo H$m`?
3)
BamMo ApVd _mZmdo H$m`?
4)
Am_m A_a Amho H$m`?
{d{Z{_Vr_mJo ~hZ ho EH$_od Vd Amho Ago doXmV _mZVo Va gm` XeZ nwf Am{U H$Vr
Aer XmoZ Vdo _mZVmV. Va `m`, deo{fH$ Am{U OZ Aer XeZo AZoH$ Vdo _mZVmV. AVdmXr
EH$ddmXr hUyZ AmoiIco OmVmV. gm` ho $VdmXr AmhoV Va `m`, d{efH$, OZ ho AZoH$ddmXr hUyZ
AmoiIco OmVmV.
""lw{V'' hUOo doXdm` hmo` ""lw{V'' Zm _mU _mZUmar _r_mgH$, doXmV, gm`, `moJ, `m`
Aer XeZ AmhoV. doX ho Anmfo` AmhoV. Vo Hw$Urhr {Z_mU Ho$coco ZmhrV Ago `mMo hUUo Amho. Va
MmdmH$, OZ, ~m lwVtMo m_m` _mZV ZmhrV. Ba ApVdmV Amho, Vmo {d{Z_mVm Amho Ago
_mZUmar doXmV, `moJ, `m`, deo{fH$ XeZo AmhoV. Va MmdmH$, OZ, ~m, nyd_r_mgm hr Ba Z
_mZUmar XeZo AmhoV. gm` ho BadmXr hr ZmhrV Am{U {ZaradmXrhr ZmhrV.OZ, `m`, deo{fH$,
gm`, `moJ, nyd_r_mgm Am{U doXmV hr Am_m _mZUmar XeZo AmhoV. Va MmdmH$ Am{U ~m XeZo
"Am_m' _mZV ZmhrV. "AZm_dmX' ho Va ~m XeZmMo EH$ _wI d{e>o Amho.Aem VhoZo ^maVr`
XeZmV Oar {d{dYVm {XgyZ òV Agcr Var "MmdmH$' gmoSy>Z BVa gd XeZmV H$mhr g_mZ d{eQ>o
AmT>iVmV.Vr nwT>rc_mUo gmJVm òVrc.
1) H$_{gmV- MmdmH$ gmoSy>Z gd ^maVr` XeZmZr ^maVr` XeZmZr H$_{gmVmMm drH$ma
Ho$cocm Amho. H$_{gmVmcmM "H$_{dnmH$' Agohr Zmd Amho. {dnmH$ hUOo n[aUm_ hmo`. H$_{dnmH$
hUOo H$_mMo \$c m hmoUo hmo`. OJmV`m gd KQ>Zm, m`mZr Ho$cocr H$_o Am{U `mMr \$co `mMm
nanag~Y Amho Ago hm {gmV gmJVmo.
AmO AmnU OJmV`m O_, _`y, AmOmanU, XwH$mi, AnKmV, ^yH$n Aem {d{dY KQ>ZmMr
H$maU_r_mgm emr` nVrZo H$aVmo. nU ^maVr` XeZmZr _m `m H$mir OJmV`m {d{dY KQ>ZmMm
AW cmd`mgmR>r H$_{gmV _mS>cocm Amho. `m`m _Vo g>rVrc òH$ KQ>Zm m mUr Am{U `mMr
H$_o `m_wio KS>VmV. MmJcr H$_o Ho$cr H$s, `mMr MmJcr \$io {_iVmV. dmBQ>, AZ{VH$ H$_o Ho$cr H$s
6
`mMr dmBQ> \$io {_iVmV. EImXm _mUyg AmOmar nS>Vmo, EImXm _mUyg OrdZmV èdr hmoVmo `mMo H$maU
`mZo Ho$cocr H$_} AgVmV.
OJmVrc gd KQ>Zm KS>dyZ AmUUmam H$moUrVar Amho Am{U Vmo Ba Amho. H$_ {gmV Ago gmJVmo
H$s, _mJrc O_mVrc H$_m_wio _mUgmcm AmOMo OrdZ m hmoVo. OrdZmVrc è, Anè, gwI, Xw:I
nyd H$_m_wio m hmoVmo. WmoS>`mV H$_{gmV gmJVmo- _mUgmcm `m`m H$_mZo gwI Xw:I m hmoVo.
Aem VhoZo ^maVr` XeZo g>rVrc KS>m_moS>rMo n>rH$aU H$a`mgmR>r H$_{gmVmMm AmYma KoVmV.
2) nwZO_- MmdmH$ gmoSy>Z gd XeZmZr ""nwZO_'' {gmV pdH$macocm Amho. H$_ Am{U
`mMr \$co `m O_mnwaVrM _`m{XV AgyZ _mJrc OrdZmVrc H$_mMr \$io `m O_mV m hmoVmV Ago
hQ>co Joco Amho. nwZO_ H$moUmg m hmoVmo? ^maVr` VdkmVmV Ord Am{U Am_m m XmoZ [^ JmoQ>r
AmhoV. Am_m hm {Z`, {MaVZ dnr, A{dZmer Agm Amho Va Ord {dZmer Amho. Zme nmdUmam Amho.
Ordmcm nwZO_ m hmoV AgVmo. Ordmcm H$moUVm O_ mV hmoBc, `mcm gwI m hmoBc H$s Xw:I
ho `m OrdmZo _mJrc OrdZmV Or H$_o Ho$cr AmhoV `mda Adc~yZ AgVo.Ordmcm O_- _aU - O_
Aem \o$`mVyZ Omdo cmJVo. ""nwZO_'' H$nZoZwgma OrdmMm O_ m _mJrc O_mVrc H$_mMm nm[anmH$
(n[aUm_) Amho. AmnU `m OrdZmV Oo gwI, Xw:I ^moJV AgVmo Vo _mJrc OrdZmVrc nmn-nw` H$_mMm
n[aUm_ AmhoV Ago nwZO_ _mZVmo. nwT>rc O_r MmJco OrdZ m hmdo `mgmR>r AmO nw` H$_o
H$amd`mMr, nmnH$_o Q>mimd`mMr Agm AmJh Amho. _m O_-_aU ho Ordmcm m hmoV AgVo ""Am_m''
`m gdmnmgyZ AcJ AgVmo. ho OmUyZ KoV`mda OrdmMr O_ _aUm`m \o$`mVyZ gwQ>H$m hmoBc
. `mcm _moj m
hmoBc. MmdmH$ gmoSy>Z gdM XeZmZr Am_XeZmgmR>r _mJ gwM{dco AmhoV.
3) _moj- MmdmH$ gmoSy>Z gd ^maVr` XeZmZr _moj gH$nZoMm drH$ma Ho$cocm Amho. _moj
m H$aUo ho _mZdr OrdZmMo ""na_ mV`'' Amho. Vo m H$Z H$Z KoUo _mZdmMo ò` Amho Ago
òH$ XeZmV gm{JVco Amho. _moj m pWVrcm {d{dY XeZmV Ad~, H d` {ZdmU ~hZr pWVr
Ago {d{dY eX dmnaco AmhoV. òH$ gH$nZoV WmoS>m \$ma ôX Amho. nU _mojmMr _yi H$nZm EH$M
Amho.
_mojmMo {d{dY AW gmJVm òVrc - 1) _moj hUOo Eo{hH$ OrdZmnmgyZ gwQ>H$m H$Z KoUo. 2)
dam`nyU OrdZ OJUo. 3) ~YZmVyZ _w$Vm H$Z KoUo. 4) Am_gmjmH$ma AZw^dUo. òH$ `$sMo
OrdZ dmgZm_` AgVo. BN>m, AmH$mjm, mr, hr gm_m` _mUgmMr òò AgVmV. `m dmgZmnmgyZ
gwQ>H$m H$Z KoUo hUOo ""_moj'' mr hmo`._moj H$gm m H$amdm, _mojmMo dn H$go Amho `mMo
doXmVmV {d{dMoZ Amho Va _moj mr`m _mJmMo {d{dMoZ ""`moJ'' XeZmV Amho. ""OZ'' Am{U ""~m''
XeZmVhr _mojgH$nZm AmT>iVo. OZ VdkmZmV ""_moj na_ m` Amho'' Ago _mZcoco Amho. g`H$
XeZ, g`H$ kmZ Am{U g`H$ M[a `m _mJmZr _moj m hmoBc. `m {Vhr _mJmZm OZ VdkmZmV
""aZ`'' g~moYco OmVo.
~m XeZmV Mma Am` g`mmao Am_kmZ m hmBc Ago hQ>coco Amho. ~m XeZmV _mojmcm
A_VnX (A_VnX) Ago g~mo{Ycoco Amho. ~m XeZmV ""{ZdmU'' hr _mojgH$nZm Amho. {ZdmUmMm
AW emV hmoUo, {dPyZ OmUo Agm Amho.
7
4) nanamdc~Z- ^maVr` XeZmMo EH$ d{e>o Ago gmJVm òBc H$s hr XeZo EH$m_mJyZ
EH$ {Z_mU Pmcocr ZmhrV Va gdmMr dmQ>Mmc EH$mMdoir Pmcocr Amho. ^maVr` {^ {^ XeZm`m
nS>rVm_ò dmX-{ddmX MMm MmcV. EH$mZo Amncr ~mOy _mS>md`mMr, `m`m {damoYH$mZo Vo _V ImoSy>Z
H$mT>m`Mo Aer IS>Z _S>Z nVr Adc[~cr Jocr. ^maVr` XeZmMo d{e>o Ago H$s H$moU`mhr
XeZH$mamZr {VnjmMo _V {dH$V dnmV _mS>coco Zmhr.
`m` - deo{fH$, gm` - `moJ Aer XeZo OmoS>r OmoS>rZo Amcocr AmhoV. `m` XeZmV kmZ
_r_mgm AmT>iVo. Va deo{fH$mZr g>r {Z{_VrMo gmmem {deX Ho$cooco Amho. _r_mgH$mZr eX _mU
_mS>co doXmVmZr Vo drH$maco. gm`mZr nwf - H${V `mVrc ôX gm{JVcm. nwfmcm `m`m _yi
dnmMo kmZ hmoUo ho ò` _mZco Va ho ò` H$go m H$amd`mMo `mMm _mJ `moJXeZmZo {deX Ho$cm.
WmoS>`mV ^maVr` XeZo EH$_oH$mda Adc~yZ AmhoV.
5) _mU MMm - gd ^maVr` XeZm_ò kmZ hUOo H$m`? kmZmMr _mUo H$moUVr? `mMr
MMm AmT>iVo. kmZ mrMo `j Am{U A`j Ago XmoZ _mJ AmhoV. `j kmZ hUOo Br`
gdoXZmmao m hmoUmao kmZ hmo`. MmdmH$mZr Ho$di `j kmZmMmM drH$ma Ho$cm. kmZ mrMo A`j
_mJ hUOo AZw_mZ, eX ho AmhoV. AZw_mZ hUOo `j kmZmda AmYmarV kmZ hmo`. `jmH$Sy>Z
A`jmH$S>o Om`mMr {H$`m hmo`. AZw^dm_H$ kmZmV _aUm_H$ kmZmMmhr gm_mdoe hmoVmo. ` `
Yy_: V V dph: ! {OWo Yya Amho {VWo Ar AgocM ho AZw_mZmMo CXmhaU Amho. `m` XeZmZo Am{U
_r_mgH$mZr "AZw_mZ' _mUmMm drH$ma Ho$cocm Amho.eX _mU hUOo eXmZr Oo VrV hmoVo, n>
hmoVo Vo kmZ hmo`. d{XH$ XeZo doXmVrc XeZmZm _mU _mZVmV. Va ~m XeZo "{{nQ>H$' `m JWmcm
_mU _mZVmV. OZ XeZ Y_ JWmZm _mU _mZVmV. `mZm "AmJ_' Ago g~mo{Yco OmVo.
6) ^maVr` XeZmZr ""ggma Xw:I_` Amho'' Ago hQ>coco Amho. OrdZmVrc Xw:ImMo {VnmXZ
gdM ^maVr` XeZmV Ho$coco Amho. ~m XeZmV Va "gd_ Xw:I_' Ago hQ>coco Amho. Ago Agco
^maVr` XeZmMm Xw:ImH$S>o nhm`mMm X>rH$moU {ZamemdmXr Zmhr. CcQ> Xw:ImMr _r_mgm H$aUo ho
^maVr` VdkmZmMo Cr> Amho. gdM ^maVr` VdkmZmV Xw:ImMo H$maU A{dm, AkmZ Ago g~mo{Yco
Jococo Amho. AkmZ Xya Ho$`mg Xw:ImMm n[ahma H$aUo e` Amho. gdM ^maVr` XeZo `m Xw:ImVyZ
gwQ>H$m H$Z Ko`mMm _mJ gwM{dVmV. Aem VhoZo ^maVr` XeZmMm Xw:ImH$S>o nhm`mMm >rH$moU
AmemdmXr Agm Amho.
1.3 dÀ``ZmgmR>r
A)
EH$m dm`mV Cmao {chm.

1)
VdkmZmMm CJ_ Ho$hm Pmcm?
2)
Vdk H$moUmg hUmdo?
3)
OS>dmX {daMZo~m~V H$m` hUVmo?
4)
VdkmZmMo H$moU`m XmoZ H$mamV dJuH$aU Ho$coo OmVo?

8
5)
~)
MmdmH$ nwZO_ H$nZm drH$maVmV H$m?
`mo` n`m` {ZdS>m.

.........................
1) VdkmZ ho
em Amho.
A) gm{h`mMo
~) emmMo
H$) nXmWmMo
.........................emoY KoUo hmo`.
2)
VdkmZ hUOo A{V_
3)
A) g`mMm~) g>rMm
H$) {dkmZmMm
........................._ò Am_m, eara g~YmMr MMm Ho$cr OmVo.
4)
A) kmZ_r_mgm
~) gXdVy_r_mgm
H$) Zr{Vem
.........................ho ZmpVH$ XeZ Amho.
5)
A) doXmV ~) OZ H$) gm`

~hgyo.........................`mZr aMcr.
6)
A) nm{UZr ~) ~mXamÙ H$) eH$amMm`

.........................`mZr AZw_mZmMm _mU hUyZ drH$ma Ho$cocm Amho.
A) `m` ~) ~m H$) MmdmH$
1.4 gmame
VdkmZ ho A{V_ g`mMm emoY KoVo. Ord, ~hZ, Am_m, _moj m VdkmZmVrc _hdnyU gH$nZm AmhoV.
^maVr` VdkmZmMo d{XH$ Am{U Ad{XH$ Aem XmoZ H$mamV dJuH$aU Ho$co OmVo. kmZ _r_mgm d gXdVy_r_mgm m
VdkmZm`m XmoZ _wI emIm AmhoV. d{XH$ VdkmZm`m WmZl`r, CJ_WmZo hUyZ Cn{ZfXo,
~hZgyo Am{U ^JdXJrVm nm{hco OmVo H$_{gmV, nwZO_, _moj, nanamdc~Z Am{U _mUMMm hr
^maVr` VdkmZmMr g_mZ d{eQ>o AmhoV.
1.5 dÀ``Z mMr Cmao
A)
1) B.g. nyd 2500
2) kmZm~c AmWm ~miJVmo Vmo Vdk hmo`.
3) OS>`mVyZ {d {Z_mU Pmco Amho.

4) d{XH$ Am{U Ad{XH$
5) MmdmH$ nwZO_ H$nZm drH$marV ZmhrV.
~)
1) emmMo 2) g`mMm
3) gXdVy_r_mgm 4) OZ
5) ~mXamÙ
6) `m`.
9
1.6 gamdmgmR>r dm`m`.

1) VdkmZm`m {d{dY `m`m gmJwZ `mMo dn n> H$am.
2) ^maVr` XeZmMr g_mZ d{e>o gmJm.
3) ^maVr` XeZmMo dJuH$aU - d{XH$ / Ad{XH$ `mda Q>rn {chm.
1.7 nm[a^m{fH$ eX.
OS>dmX
OS>ò ho A{V_ g` Amho _mZUmam >rH$moU.
{MXdmX
{MXdmX (Am_m) ho A{V_ g` _mZUmam >rH$moU.
EH$ddmX
A{V_ Vd EH$ Amho.
AZoH$ddmX -
A{V_ Vd EH$mnojm A{YH$ AmhoV.
kmZ_r_mgm -
kmZmMo dn n> H$aUmar VdkmZmMr emIm.
gmmem
Am_m, Ba, Ord `mMm {dMma H$aUmar emIm.
d{XH$ XeZo -
doXmcm _mU _mZUmar XeZo.
Ad{XH$ XeZo - doX _mU Z _mZUmar XeZo.

WmZl_r -
d{XH$ XeZo `mda AmYm[aV AmhoV Vo mMrZ JW
nwfmW
^maVr` _y` {df`H$ {dMma
AZw_mZ
`jmda AmYm[aV _mU
1.8 A{YH$ dmMZgmR>r nwVHo$ gd KQ>H$m`m eodQ>r nwVH$mMr `mXr {Xcocr Amho.
666
10
KQ>H$ - 2
MmdmH$ XeZ
2.0
C{>o
2.1
mVm{dH$
2.2
{df`{ddoMZ
2.2.1 MmdmH$mMm kmZ{df`H$ {gmV
2.2.1 OS>dmX
2.2.2 d^mddmX
2.2.3 Am`mMo {ZamH$aU
2.2.4 MmdmH$mMo Zr{V{df`H$ {dMma
2.3
dÀ``ZmgmR>r
2.4
gmame
2.5
dÀ``Z mMr Cmao
2.6
gamdmgmR>r dm`m`
2.7
nm[a^m{fH$ eX
2.8
A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$
2.0
C{>o -
`m KQ>H$mV AmnU ""MmdmH$'' XeZmMr AmoiI H$$Z KoUma AmhmoV. `m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZo
""MmdmH$'' VdkmZm~c Imcrc Jmo>tMr _m{hVr hmoBc.
* MmdmH$ ho ZmpVH$ XeZ Amho.
* MmdmH$mMm kmZ {df`H$ {gmV
* MmdmH$mMm OS>dmX
* MmdmH$mMo Zr{V{dfH$ {dMma
2.1
nmVm{dH$ -
^maVr` XeZmVrc ""MmdmH$'' ho EH$ ZmpVH$ XeZ hUyZ AmoiIco OmVo. ""ZmpVH$'' `mMm
""Bda Z _mZUo "" EdT>mnwaVm AW _`m{XV Zmhr. Va `m`, deo{fH$, gm`, `moJ, doXmV Aem AmpVH$
XeZmZr `m `m Jmo>r drH$maco`m AmhoV `m MmdmH$ ZmH$maVmV. MmdmH$ Ba, Aearar, Am_m,
11
nacmoH$, nwZO_ `m gd Jmo>r ZmH$maVmV. Aem AWmZo ""MmdmH$'' ho ~S>Imoa AmhoV.""MmdmH$'' hr EH$
`$s ZgyZ Vmo AZoH$ `$sMm g_yh Amho. ""~hn{V'' hm `m XeZmMm Am dVH$ _mZcm OmVmo.
""MmdmH$'' `m eXmMr \$moS> Mm + dm`_ Aer H$aVm òBc. ""Mm'' `mMm AW JmoS>. gdgm_m`mZm
JmoS> cmJUmar, AmdS>Umar, nQ>Umar dmò Agm ""MmdmH$'' `m eXmMm AW Amho. ""MmdmH$'' XeZmcm
""cmoH$m`V'' Ago AmUIr EH$ Zmd Amho. cmoH$ + Am`V_ cmoH$ hUOo gdgm_m` cmoH$ Am{U Am`V_
hUOo _mU. gdgm_m` cmoH$mZm _m` hmoUmao _mU hmo`. qH$dm gdgm_m`mV gm[aV Pmcoco qH$dm m
OJmda (Bh cmoH$mda) AmYm[aV Agcoco _V hUOo ""cmoH$m`V'' hmo`. VdkmZmV B. g. 8 `m eVH$mnmgyZ
""MmdmH$'' ho Zmd gamg dmnacoco {XgyZ òVo.
2.2
{df` {ddoMZ
2.2.1 MmdmH$mMm kmZ{df`H$ {gmV ""kmZ'' hUOo Amn`m ^modVmc`m OJm{df`rMr, dV:{df`rMr _m{hVr hmo`. AmnUmg
kmZ H$go m hmoVo? `m nmcm VdkmZmV Cma {Xcoco Amho. `j Am{U A`j Ago kmZ mrMo _mJ
AmhoV. `j kmZ hUOo Amn`m nM kmZ|{`m`m ghm`mZo hmoUmao kmZ hmo`. Va eXkmZ, _aUm_H$
kmZ, AZw^dm_H$ kmZ Ago A`j kmZmMo H$ma AmhoV.MmdmH$ Ho$di `j kmZmMm drH$ma H$aVmV.
`j kmZmcmM Vo n_mU _mZVmV. MmdmH$ ""AZw_mZ'' m kmZ H$mamMm drH$ma H$arV ZmhrV. Vgo
nm{hco Va Amn`m kmZmMm ~amMgm ^mJ AZw_mZmZo `mncocm Amho. `m_wio Ho$di `j hoM _mU hr
""MmdmH$mMr'' ^y{_H$m `mdhm[aH$>m Amn`mcm nadS>Umar Zmhr.~hYm hr AS>MU cjmV KoD$Z ZVa`m
H$mimV ""nwaXa'' `m MmdmH$mZo ""cmoH$ {g'' AZw_mZ, Amhm MmdmH$mZm gwm B> Amho. Aer ^y{_H$m
KoVcr. cmoH$ {g `mMm AW m OJmV {g H$aVm òBc Ago AZw_mZ hmo`. Ago AZw_mZ Amhr
drH$maVmo nU cm{H$H$ _mJm`m ncrH$S>o OmD$Z Oo AZw_mZ H$ BpN>VmV `mMm Amhr {ZfoY H$aVmo Ago
`mZo hQ>coco Amho.gH$V_ò ""cmoH$'' `mMm AW ""Br` {df`'' Agm Amho Am{U {g hUOo
Br`m`m AmYmao {g hmoUmao. MmdmH$mMr hr ^y{_H$m 20 `m eVH$mVrc nmm` VdkmZmVrc Vm{H$H$
`jVmdmXmer {_iVrOwiVr Amho `m_wio MmdmH$mMm {dMma {H$Vr AmYw{ZH$ hmoVm ho cjmV òBc.
2.2.1 OS>dmX ""MmdmH$'' ho OS>dmXr hUyZ AmoiIco OmVmV. OS>dmXr ^y{_H$m Aer Amho H$s ho {d OS>`mVyZ
{Z_mU Pmco Amho. MmdmH$m`m OS>dmXmV VrZ {gmVmMm gm_mdoe hmoVmo.
OS>VddmX
A{V_ g` ho AIoan`V {Q>Hy$Z ahmVo Vo hmo` Oo H$Yrhr Zme nmdV Zmhr. MmdmH$m`m _Vo OS>ò
ho A{V_ g` Amho. ndr, Oc, VoO Am{U dm`y Aem Mma ^yVmMm {H$dm nXmWmMm MmdmH$mZr drH$ma Ho$cocm
Amho. {dmV`m gd dVy, mUr mMr {Z{_Vr m Mma nXmWmnmgyZ Pmcocr Amho. hr Mma A{V_ ò
Amn`m kmZmMm {df` AmhoV. H$mhr MmdmH$mZr ""AmH$meVd'' ho nmMdo Vd (nXmW) drH$macoco Amho.
nU ~hVmer MmdmH$mZr ho Vd ZmH$macoco Zmhr H$maU AmH$me ho `j Jm Zmhr Vo AZw_mZJm Amho.
2.2.2 d^mddmX ndr, Oc, VoO Am{U dm`y `m Mma A{V_ `mnmgyZ {dmV`m gd dVy {Z_mU Pmcoo`m
AmhoV. Oa gd dVy g_mZ Aem OS>`mnmgyZ {Z_mU Pmcoo`m AmhoV Va `m doJdoJ`m H$m AmhoV?
12
`mMo JwUY_ doJdoJio H$m AmhoV? Agm {Z_mU hmoVmo. `m mcm Ba _mZUmao Ago Cma XoVmV H$s,
BamZo {d {Z_mU Ho$coco Amho. ""BamMr BN>m'' ho {d{dYVoMo H$maU Amho. MmdmH$mZm ho _m` Zmhr. Vo
Ba ZmH$maVmV.{dmV`m {d{dYVoMo Cma Vo ""d^mddmX'' {gmVmyZ XoVmV.
""d^mddmX'' hUVmo Oo Oo KS>Vo, Oo Amho Vo Vo `m m`m`m, dVyy`m d + ^mdm_wio KS>V
AgVo. d hUOo g~{YV dVy Am{U ^md hUOo AgUo. H$mo{H$ioMm _Yya Amcmn, _moamMm {ngmam, D$g
JmoS> cmJUo ho `m `m n`mMo, dVyMo d^md AmhoV. `mgmR>r na_oamMr JaO Zmhr. MmdmH$m`m m
_Vmda H$mhr OU Amjon KoVmV- AmnU _mUgo H$mhr hoVy _Zmer ~miJyZ H$Vr H$arV AgVmo. H$mhr Jmo>r
AmnU R>adyZ H$aVmo qH$dm _Zmer R>adyZ H$mhr H$Vr H$a`mMo Q>miVmo.{dmV`m gd dVy, KQ>Zm `m_mJo
H$mhr hoVy, `moOZm Agcr nm{hOo. nU ho MmdmH$mZm _m` Zmhr.
MmdmH$ hUVmV, OS> `m`m {d{e> g`moJmZo ""MV`'' AWdm OmUrd {Z_mU hmoVo. MV`
OS>mnmgyZ [^ Agco Var Vo OS>mMmM {dH$ma Amho. CXm. Jyi, nrR> `m nXmWmV H$\$ AgUmao, Zem
AmUUmao JwUY_ ZgVmV naVy `m`m {_lUmVyZ _ V`ma Ho$co OmVo. H$s `m`m godZmZo Zem òVo.
WmoS>`mV {_lUmZo ZdrZ JwUY_ {Z_mU hmoVmV. {_lUmZo ZdrZ JwUY_ V`ma hmoVmV `mMo Xwgao EH$
CXmhaU XoVm òBc. nmZ, MwZm, H$mV `mVrc H$moUVrM dVy cmcm Zgcr Var `mnmgyZ V`ma Ho$cocm {dS>>m
MKicm H$s cmc aJ {Z_mU hmoVmo.
`m_mUoM ""MV`'' hm OS>mMmM {dH$ma Amho. ""^yVo`: MV`_'' MV` ho OS>mVyZ (^yV_mmVyZ)
{Z_mU hmoVo. WmoS>`mV MmdmH$m`m _Vo ""MV`'' ho dV ` Zho. hm {gmV d^mddmX (Naturalism)
hUyZ AmoiIcm OmVmo.
2.1.2
Am`mMo {ZamH$aU
MmdmH$m`m OS>dmXmV Am`mMo {ZamH$aU m {Vg`m {gmVmMm g_mdoe hmoVmo. Am`mMo dV

ApVd MmdmH$ ZmH$maVmV. OS>`m`m gKmV Agm Omo _mZdr Xoh `m`m {R>H$mUr MV` hm JwUY_
Cn hmoVmo. hmM ""MV` {d{e>> Xoh hUOo Am_m'' Ago MmdmH$ hUVmV.
1)
Xohm`m (earam`m) ncrH$S>o Am`mcm doJio Ago ApVd Zmhr. _r Wyc Amho, _r Jmoam Amho hr
gd d{eR>o Xohmcm cmdcr OmVmV. hmM Am_m hmo` Ago MmdmH$ hUVmV.
2)
`m XohmVyZ {Zamim Agm Am_m (Self) kmZmMm {df` hmoV Zmhr. `m MmdmH$m`m {dMmamer nmm`
AZw^ddmXr w_Mo {dMma {_iVo OwiVo AmhoV. w_ hUVmo- Oohm _r _m`m~c (dd~c) {dMma H$
cmJVmo Vohm {d{e>> OmUrdoMo, gdoXZoMo _cm kmZ hmoVo. WS>-Ja_, COoS>-AYma, o_-Cof, gwI-Xw:I
`m OmUrdm`m dnmV _cm _mPo d _m`m ^modVmc`m n[agamMo kmZ hmoVo. `m gdoXZm{edm`, OmUrdo{edm`
ddmMr OmUrd hmoV Zmhr qH$dm `m OmUrdoncrH$S>o Agcobm ""_r'' hm gdoXZ, OmUrdoZo ~Zcocm Amho.
""_r'' hUOo Br`, Xoh qH$dm Xoh hUOo Am_m Aer ^y{_H$m Ko`m`m MmdmH$mda ""Am_dmXr'' VdkmZr
H$mhr Amjon KoVco. Xohmnojm Am_m dV Agcm nm{hOo Ago MmdmH$m`m {damoYH$mMo hUUo Amho. MmdmH$
{damoYH$mZr H$mhr Amjon KoVco Vo nwT>rc_mUo gmJVm òVrc.
1)
""_r'' hm XohmncrH$S>rc Agcm nm{hOo H$maU XohmV ~Xc hmoV AgVmZm Xoh A{Z` Amho. EH$mZo
AZw^dco Am{U Xwg`mZo _aU Ho$co Ago hmoV Zmhr. _aU H$aUmam d AZw^d KoUmam hm {Z`, EH$M EH$
Agcm nm{hOo. ""Xoh'' {Z` Zho Va ""Am_m'' ho {Z` Vd Amho.
13
2)
gd Br`mMo {df` {^ {^ AmhoV. CXm. Mjw-`, H$mZ-ldU, ZmH$-JY, Or^-Md, dMmne B. `m gd Br` gdoXZmZm EH$ H$aUmam H$moUrVar Agcm nm{hOo Vmo ""_r'' Am_m hmo`.
3)
""_r'' hm _mVm A{dH$mar Agcm nm[hOo hUOo Z ~XcUmam Agcm nm{hOo. ""KQ> a$ Amho.''
(nm`mMm _mR> Vm~S>m aJmMm Amho) `m_ò KQ>mMo Am{U `m`m dUmMo kmZ hmoBn`V EH$M EH$ A{YH$mar
kmVm Agcm nm{hOo. Xoh, ~wr ho {dH$mar (~XcUmao) AmhoV `m_wio ""Am_m'' ho A{dH$mar Vd hUyZ
drH$maco nm{hOo.Am_dmm`m `m AmjonmZm H$Q>miyZ hUm qH$dm {H$MH$Q> dmXmcm H$Q>miyZ MmdmH$mZr Ago
hQ>co H$s eara {OdV Agon`V EH$M EH$ A{YH$mar Am_m Amho Ago _mZ`mg haH$V Zmhr. ""O`V'' hm
gw{g Z`m{`H$ Amn`m ""`m`_Oar'' JWmV Aem MmdmH$mZm ""gw{e{jV MmdmH$'' hUyZ g~mo{YVmo.
XohnmVmZVa (_`wZVa) Am_m {eH$ CaVmo `m _Vmcm _m gw{e{jV MmdmH$mZr H$S>mSy>Z {damoY Ho$cm.Aem
VhoZo OS>VddmX, d^mddmX Am{U Am`mMo {ZamH$aU `m {VhtZr {_iyZ MmdmH$mMm OS>dmX {g hmoVmo.
2.1.4 MmdmH$mMo Zr[V{df`H$ {dMma
Zr{Vem hUOo Amncm Am`w`H$_ `mo` arVrZo H$gm `mdm ho R>ad`mMo em hmo`. Zr (Z`)ZUo `m lmVynmgyZ ""Zr{V'' hm eX `wn Pmcocm Amho. MmdmH$mMm {dMma ""Amho hooM OrdZ'' Agm
Ag`mZo _`wZVa Am`mcm J{V {_ioc H$m` ? AmnUmg (dJcmoH$ H$m ZaH$) H$moUVm cmoH$ m hmoBc
`mMr H$miOr H$ Zò Ago Vo hUV.MmdmH$mMo Zr{Vem Eo{hH$ hmoVo. Mmcy OrdZmer g~{YV hmoVo. Vo nma
cm{H$H$ ZhVo. `m Xohm`{V[a$ Am_m, `m`m H$_mnmgyZ Cn hmoUmao nmn nw` d `mZwgma Am`mMo
nacmoH$ J_Z m gd JmoQ>r `mZr ZmH$maco`m Amho. `mMm {ZfoY Ho$cocm Amho.MmdmH$mZr `j _mUmMm
drH$ma Ho$cocm Ag`mZo AmnmoAmnM Eo{hH$ >r drH$macr. MmdmH$m`m _Vo AW Am{U H$m_ hoM Iao
nwfmW AmhoV. _moj AWdm nmacm{H$H$ gwIm`m _mJo cmJy Zò. _mUgmZo `m cmoH$sM (OJmV) e` hmoBc
VodT>o gwI Cn^moJmdo Agm `mMm {dMma hmoVm.Amnco OrdZ gwI-Xw:I {_{lV Agco Var `mVrc gwI
doMyZ `mdo, gmcrdaMm Vyg H$mTy>Z VmXyi `mdm qH$dm H$mQ>m H$mTy>Z _mgm Imdm AWdm {^joH$`mcm MwH$dyZ
gwJmg (MmJcm Kmg) ^jU H$amdm Ago MmdmH$mMo hUUo hmoVo. `$sZo nwT>Mm _mJMm {dMma H$Z
dV:gmR>r OmVrV OmV gw I {_i{d`mMm `Z H$amdm `m J r H$m `m E{n`w [ aAZ n W m`m
{eH$dUyH$sgmaIoM MmdmH$mMo _V Amho.
""OrdZmV OmVrV OmV gwI {_idm'' m MmdmH$m`m _Vmda Amjon KoVm òBc. H$moUVohr gwI
Cn^moJyZ Pm`mda Vo gnyZ OmVo, {eH$ H$mhr ahmV Zmhr ho MmdmH$mZr cjmV KoVcoco Zmhr. H$maU OodT>m
gwImMm AZw^d AmVm òV AgVmo VodT>oM gwI {eH$ Amho. ~mH$sMo Cn^moJcoco gwI Z> Pmcoco AgVo.
WmoS>`mV òH$mMm gwImMm AZw^d Ago gmJVmo H$s gwI ho {dZmer Amho. `mMm Zme hmoVmo. Ago Zme
nmdUmao gwI OrdZmMo ò` _mZmdo H$m? Agm nS>Vmo.Xwgao hUOo gwI hr A_yV gH$nZm Amho. B>
Jmo>rMr mr Pmcr H$s AmnU gwIr ~ZVmo. {OVHo$ gwI {_idmdo {VVHo$ Ag_mYmZ dmT>V OmBc `m_wio
Ago gwI m H$aUo OrdZmMo ò` H$go drH$maVm òBc?
na_m` hUOo Oo Amn`mcm lo> Ago ò` m H$amd`mMo Amho, {_idmd`mMo Amho Vo
{MaVZ, {MaH$mi (H$m`_dnr) {Q>H$Umao Agco nm{hOo. `m_wio nXar nS>oc VodT>o gwI m H$am m
hU`mcm AW ahmV Zmhr. OrdZmV gwImMr aocMoc Pmcr, ânya _mUmV gwI m Pmco Var ""VV:
{H$_'' gwImZVa H$m` m H$amd`mMo hm CaVmo. B`mXr ImocmV Z {eaVm MmdmH$mZr gm{JVco {OdV
Agon`V _Zw`mZo A{YH$m{YH$ gwI {_idmdo.MmdmH$m`m gwIdmXmMm ~`mM OUmZr {dn`mg Ho$cm. MmdmH$mZr
Ago gm{JVco - dV:Mo gwI nhmdo, dmW nhmdm, BVam`m gwI-Xw:ImMr ndm H$ Zò, nmn-nw`mH$S>o
14
cj Xody Zò, Cm H$m` hmoBc `mMm {dMma H$ Zò `mdmrd gwI OrdoV
F$U H$dm KV {n~oV &
^_r^yV` Xoh`
nwZamJ_Z Hw$V: &&
(Omon`V Am`w` Amho Vmon`V gwImZo OJmdo. H$O} H$mTy>Z Vyn amoQ>r Imdr. EH$Xm Amn`m XohmMr
amI Pmcr hUOo naV H$moU òUma Amho?) `jmV H$O} H$mTy>Z gwIo {_idmdrV, H$O} \o$Sy> ZòV Ago
MmdmH$mZr H$moR>ohr gm{JVco Zmhr. `mZr XoIrc Zr{V AZr{VMm {dMma Ho$cocm Amho. Amnco OrdZ H$go
`VrV H$amdo `m~m~V ""gdXeZ gJh'' `m JWm~m~V MmdmH$mMo _Zm~m~V cmoH$ Amho.
H${f Jmoa`dm{U`XS>Zr`m{X{^ ~wY: &
>aod gXwnm`^mooJmZZw^doX ^w{d &&
MmdmH$m`m _Vo ehm`m _mUgmZo (~wY), eoVr, JmonmcZ, `mnmaCXr_, emgH$s` `dWm `m
gma`m > Agco`m ""gV'' Cnm`mZr ndrdarc {Za{Zamio ^moJ ^moJmdoV.MmdmH$mZr `m _mJmcm
""gV'' _mJ hQ>co Amho Vmo AmOhr gV_mJM AmhoM. `mH$mimV H$_H$mS>, nyOmAMm `mMo IynM Vmo_
_mOco hmoVo `mcm MmdmH$mMm {damoY hmoVm.
Vo hUVmVA{hmo `mo doXmpVXS> ^_JwR>Z_ &
~w{nmfhrZmZm Or{dHo${V ~hn{V : &&
A{hmomMm R>mU _mSy>Z, {H$mi ZmZ g`m, ^_ cmdyZ nmamo{h`m{X _mJmZo CnOr{dH$m H$aUm`mMr
MmdmH$mZr qZXm Ho$cr Amho. ~wr Am{U nmf Zgcoc cmoH$ hm CnOr{dHo$Mm _mJ drH$maVmV Ago MmdmH$mZr
hQ>coco Amho.MmdmH$mZr AW, Zr{V, AZr{V, gV, AgV hm {ddoH$ H$Q>mjmZo nmimdm Ago gm{JVcoco Amho.
\$$ `m`m gV AgV`m H$nZm m `jn_mUmda AmYm[aV Amho. `m_wio doX aMZmH$mamda Vo
nwT>rc_mUo Q>rH$m H$aVmV.
"`modoX` H$Vma:
^S>YyV - {ZemMX: &'
doX aMZm H$aUmao {dXyfH$, YyV, {ZemMa Agco nm{hOoV Agm Vo Amamon H$aVmV.
(`m H$mir amr \$$ Mmoa qhS>V AgV.)
MmdmH$mZr `j _mU _mZ`mZo Amn`m Vo AZw^dmn{cH$S>o g`, gwXa Aem Jmo>r AmhoV ho
_mZmd`mg V`ma ZmhrV. doXmV nma_m{WH$, m OJmncrH$S>`m Jmo>rMr MMm Ho$cocr Amho `m_wio MmdmH$
doXaMZmH$mamda Q>rH$m H$aVmV. Aem VhoZo MmdmH$mMo ZrVr{df`H$ {dMma n> H$aVm òBc.
15
2.3 dA``ZmgmR>r n A) EH$m dm`mV Cmao {chm.

1) MmdmH$ gwIdmXr AmhoV H$m`?
~)
2)
d^mddmX H$moU`m {gmVmV g_m{d> hmoVmo?
3)
MmdmH$mMm Zr{V{df`H$ {dMma H$moU`m OrdZm{df`r Amho?
4)
""MmdmH$'' eXmMr \$moS> H$er H$aVm òBc?
5)
MmdmH$ ""Am_m'' ho dV ` drH$maVmV H$m`?
`mo` n`m` {ZdS>m.

...........................
1)
MmdmH$ ho
AmhoV.
2)
A) OS>dmXr
~) {MXdmXr
H$) EH$ddmXr
...........................
MmdmH$mZr
nXmWmMm drH$ma Ho$cocm Amho.
A) Mma
3)
~) nmM
H$) ghm
...........................
MmdmH$ Ho$di
_mUmMm drH$ma H$aVmV.
A) AZw_mZ
H$) emX
...........................
4)
MmdmH$m`m _Vo MV` hm
5)
A) OS>mMm
~) ~hZmMm
H$) m`mMm
...........................
MmdmH$
`m nwfmWmcm ZmH$maVmV.
A) H$m_ ~) AW
2.4
~) `j
A[dH$ma Amho.
H$) _moj
gmame -
MmdmH$ ho EH$ OS>dmXr, ZmpVH$ XeZ Amho. MmdmH$m`m kmZ{df`H$ {gmVmV OS>VddmX,
d^mddmX Am{U Am`mMo {ZamH$aU `mMm g_mdoe hmoVmo. A{V_ g` OS> dnr Amho Ago OS>ddmXr
hUVmo. Va d^mddmXm`m_Vo g>rVrc KQ>Zm, mUr, njr, `m`mV KS>Umao ~Xc, `mMo d^md ho
{ZgJV:M AgVmV. Vo ~Xc KS>dyZ AmUUmam "Ba' ApVdmV Zmhr. "Ba' gH$nZo~amo~aM MmdmH$
""Am_m hm dV nXmW'' hUyZ ZmH$maVmV.
MmdmH$mMo Zr{V{df`H$ {dMma Eo{hH$ OJm{df`r AmhoV. Vo hUVmV, Amho hoM OrdZ, dJ, nmn,
nw` `mMm {dMma H$ Zò. OJmVrc gd gwIo Cn^moJmdrV. VgoM H$fr, JmonmcZ, `mnma, g_mOH$mamU
Aem {dYm`H$, \$cXm`r H$m`mV _mUgmZo A{YH$m{YH$ cj Kmcmdo. {H$mc ZmZg`m, doXnR>U, `k`mJ
`m_ò doi dm`m Kmcdy Zò. Agm MmdmH$mMm Zr{V{df`H$ {dMma Amho.
16
2.5
d` A``Z mMr Cmao A)

~)
2.6
2.7
2.8
1) hmo`.2) OS>dmX
3) Eo{hH$
4) Mm + dm`_ &
5) Zmhr.
1) OS>dmXr
2) Mma
3) `j
4) OS>mMm
5) _moj
gamdmgmR>r 1 cm.
MmdmH$m`m OS>dmXmMo dn n> H$am.
2 am.
MmdmH$mMo Zr{V{df`H$ {dMma {deX H$am.
nm[a^m{fH$ eX 1) Eo{hH$
`m OJm{df`r
2) nmacm{H$H$
cm{H$H$ OJmncrH$S>Mo
3) cmoH$ {g
Br`mZo {g hmoUmao
4) d^mddmX
Oo KS>Vo Vo {ZgJV:M KS>Vo Ago _mZUmam >rH$moU
5) gwIdmX
gwImda â XoUmar {dMmagaUr
A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$nwVH$m`m eodQ>r `mXr {Xcocr Amho.

666
17
KQ>H$ - 3
OZ XeZ ( Jainism )
3.0 C{>o
3.1 mVm{dH$ - OrdZ dmmV
3.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
3.2.1
OZ nanam
3.2.2
Aqhgm
3.2.3
AZoH$mVdmX
Z`dmX
`mXdmX
3.2.4
Ord Am{U AOrd
3.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z
3.4 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW
3.6 gmame
3.0 C{Q>o :
`m KQ>H$mMm A`mg Ho$`mZVa Amn`mbm *
OZ Y_mMr nanam n> H$aVm òBb.
OZ Y_mMo VdkmZ d {eH$dU dUZ H$aVm òBb.
doVm~a d {XJ~a `m XmoZ nWmMo doJionU {deX H$aVm òBb.
"Aqhgm' `m OZm`m A`V _hdm`m gymMo d$n n> H$aVm òBb.
OZmMr _yi ^y{_H$m- AZoH$mVdmX d{eQ>o gmJVm òVrb.
Ord Am{U AOrd `m XmoZ `mMm Vmb{ZH$ nam_e KoVm òBb.
3.1 mVm{dH$ (OrdZ dmmV) :

qhXy Y_mIoarO ^maVmV OZ, ~m, nmaer, erI, Bbm_, {MZ `m {d{dY Y_m`m VdkmZmbm
d gXm`mZm AZwgaUmao bmoH$ Amho. {hXy Y_mVyZ d ^maVr` Y_nanaoVyZ CH$mV Pmbobo OZ Y_mMo
18
VdkmZ d `mMo H$m` g_OmdyZ KoUma AmhmoV. OZ Y_ ^maVmVrb d{XH$ Y_mBVH$m mMrZ Amho, Ago
A`mgH$ _mZVmV. OZ Y_mMo dVZ, gdYZ Am{U gma `mZr Ho$bm `mZm "VrWH$a' hUVmV. Ago
EHy$U 24 VrWH$a AmhoV. `m VrWH$amZm "{OZ' hUVmV. {OZ hUOo B{ò qOH$Umam. {OZ `m gkod$Z `m
Y_mbm OZ Y_ ho Zmd $T> Pmbo. dY_mZ _hmdra ho 24 do VrWH$a AmhoV.
dY_mZ `mMm O_ dOr O_mVrMr amOYmZr dembr òWo [Vnyd 599 _ò Pmbm. (dembr ho
{R>H$mU {~hma am`mV Amho). dY_mZmMo AmB-d{S>b C Hw$imVrb hmoVo hUOoM Vo j{` hmoVo. `m`m
{n`mMo Zmd {gmW d _mVoMo Zmd {ebm hmoVo. `mMr _mVm EH$ amOH$`m hmoVr. _hmdram`m _mVm{n`mZr `mMo Zmd "dY_mZ' Ago R>odbo hmoVo. _hmdra hr EH$ CnmYr Amho. dY_mZmg hr CnmYr ~oMmirgm`m
dfu mV Pmbr. nU nwT>o `mMm CboI _hmdra `m ZmdmZoM Ho$bm OmD$ bmJbm. _hmdramMm {ddmh èmoXm
{h`mer Pmbm hmoVm. `mZm AUmoOm ZmdmMr EH$ _wbJr hmoVr. _hmdra Vrg dfmMo AgVmZm `mMo _mVm{nVm _`y nmdbo. `m_wio `mMo d{S>b~Yy ZXrdYZ `m`m hmVmV Hw$Qw>~mMm A{YH$ma Ambm. _hmdramZr
Amnbo d{S>b ~Yy d Hw$Qw>~mVrb BVa d{S>bYmar _mUgo `m`mH$Sy>Z OZ Y_m`m {dYrZwgma {Xjm KoVbr.
`mZVa `mZr ~mam df} IS>Va VnM`m Ho$br. n{h`m Voam _{h`mZVa `mZr Amn`m dmMm `mJ
Ho$bm. eodQ>r VnM`}VyZ kmZmVr Pmbr. `mVyZM `mZr Amn`m Y_mMm Mma Ho$bm. VoM hUOo OZ
VdkmZ hmo`. Amn`m Y_mMm gma H$aV Vo d`m`m 72 `m dfu _`y nmdbo.
3.2 {df` {ddoMZ :
3.2.1 OZ nanam :
OZ Y_mMr nanam \$maM OwZr d mMrZ Amho. OZ `m eXmMr `wnmr "{O' `m _yi gH$V
YmVynmgyZ Pmbobr AgyZ `mMm AW qOH$Uo qH$dm dm{_d {_i{dUo Agm Amho. OZ hm Amn`m
dmgZm{dH$mamda, H$moYmda, H$m_mda {dO` {_i{dVmo hUyZ OZ ~ZVmo. amJof `mgma`m eyda {dO`
{_i{d`m_wio dY_mZmbm {OZ qH$dm OoVm hr CnmYr {_imbr. {OZ `m gkod$Z `m Y_mbm OZ Y_ ho Zmd
$T> Pmbo.
VrWH$a :
OZ Y_mMo dVZ, gdYZ Am{U gma `mZr Ho$bm `mZm "VrWH$a' hUVmV. Ago EHy$U 24
VrWH$a AmhoV. VrWH$a hUOo _mJ XmI{dUmam. ggma gmJamVyZ V$Z Om`mg _XV H$aUmam hmo`.
G$f^ZmW ho n{hbo VrWH$a _mZbo OmVmV. G$f^ZmW hm Am VrWH$a Ag`m_wio OZ Y_mV `mg \$ma
AmXa XmI{dVmV. EdT>oM ZmhrVa ~mU Y_mVhr {dUy`m Mmodrg AdVmam_ò G$f^mMr JUZm H$a`mV
òVo. G$f^mZVa hmoD$Z Joobo`m 23 VrWH$amMo {dVV dUZ OZ JWmV nhmd`mg {_iVo. _m 23 do
VrWH$a nmdZmW Am{U 24 do VrWH$a _hmdra ho XmoKo eodQ>Mo VrWH$a {g AmhoV.
OZ Y_mV Oo 24 VrWH$a hmoD$Z JoboV `mMr H$mbmZwH$_o Zmdo _m{hVrgmR>r XoV AmhmoV.
1) G$f^Xod (ZmW) 2) A{OVZmW
3) g^dZmW
5) gw_{VZmW
6) nX_^
7) gwnmdZmW 8) M^
9) nwnXV
10) erVbZmW
11) lo`mgZmW 12) dmgwnw`
13) {d_bZmW
14) AZVZmW
15) Y_ZmW
19
4) A{^ZXZZmW
16) emVrZmW
17) Hw$WwZmW
18) AahZmW
19) _brZmW 20) _w{Zgw~VZmW
21) Z{_ZmW
22) Zo{_ZmW
23) nmdZmW 24) dY_mZ _hmdra
OZ Y_mMm eodQ>Mm hUOo Mmodrgmdm VrWH$a "dY_mZ _hmdra' hmoVm. dY_mZ _hmdra hm _JY
XoemV amhmV Ag`mZo `mZo `m mVm`m AY_mJYr ^mfoV OZ VdmMr _mS>Ur d Mma Ho$bm Am{U Agm
Mma H$aV H$aV d`m`m 72 `m dfu _`y nmdbm. _hmdramZo OZ Y_mgmR>r Eo{Vhm{gH$ H$m` H$$Z OZ
Y_mbm ^mdr ~Z{dbo. OZ Y_ hm EH$ ^maVmMm _wI Y_ ~Z{d`mMo A`V _hdmMo H$m` Ho$`m_wio
OJm`m B{VhmgmV `mbm AT>i WmZ mV Pmbo Amho. Aem H$mao OZ Y_mMr nanam A`V XrKH$mbrZ
Amho.
OZ Y_mVrb nW : {XJ~a, doVm~a
_hmdram`m _`yZVa OZ Y_mV _VôX hmoD$Z `mMo XmoZ nW nS>bo `mZm {XJ~a d doVm~a Ago
hUVmV. VdkmZm`m >rZo `m XmoZ gXm`mV \$magm \$aH$ Zmhr. _m `m`m AmMaUm_ò ôX {XgyZ
òVmo Vmo Agm * {XJ~a hUOo AmH$me hoM A~a. A~a hUOo d. `mCbQ> doVm~a hUOo ew^ d n[aYmZ
H$aUmao hmoV.
* {XJ~a nW hm A{YH$ H$S>H$ dVmMaU d CJ Vn`m H$a`mda â XoVmo Va doVm~a nW _mZdmMo
H$mhr ~m~VrVrb Xm~` _m` H$$Z VnòMr CJVm H$_r H$aVmo.
* {XJ~a nWmMo _Vo, _mZdmZo BVHo$ {ZdmWu d An[aJhr hmd`mg nm{hOo H$s `mZo AJmda dhr
R>odVm H$m_m Zò. VgoM AmH$membmM Amnbo d _mZmdo, OodUmgmR>r gwm nm dmn$ Zò, B`mXr Jmo>tda
â XoVmV. `mCbQ> doVm~a nWr` _wZr ho AJmda ew^ d n[aYmZ H$$Z qhS>VmV.
* WmoS>`mV dY_mZ _hmdram`m _yi AmMmamMo g_WZ H$aUm`m _wZtZr d`mJ Ho$bm Vo {XJ~a
hmoV. `mCbQ> `m _wZtZr d dmnamMo g_WZ H$$Z ew^ do drH$mabr `mZm doVm~a hUyZ AmoiIbo
OmD$ bmJbo.
OZmMo _yb Y_JW :OZ VdkmZmMo JW nwH$i AmhoV. _yb Y_JWmMr g`m 85 âVo. `m_ò 41 gyJW, gw_mao 31
H$sUHo$, 12 {Z`wVr (^m`JW) Am{U 1 _hm^m` Amho. AmMm` ~bXod Cnm`m` `mZr OZ gm{hp`H$
JWmMo dJuH$aU H$a`mgmR>r Mma H$mb {d^mJ Ho$bo AmhoV, Vo Ago- AmJ_JW, Ama^H$mi, _``wJ Am{U
AdmMrZ JwU. OZmMo _yi JW AY_mJYr ^mfoV AmhoV. `m JWmnH$s H$mhr JW _hdmMo _mZbo OmVmV, Vo
Ago- 1) C_mdmVrMo- "VdmWm{YJ_gy' 2) {ggoZ {XdmH$amMo - `m`mdVma 3) Hw$XmHw$XmMm`mModMZgma 4) Zo{_MS>mMo - `gJh 5) _{goZgwarMo- `mmX_Oar. ho JW VmdrH$ d$nmMo AmhoV.
3.2.2
Aqhgm :-
Aqhgm na_mo Y_: - `mMm AW Aqhgm hm gdlo> Y_ Amho. ho OZmMo A`V _hdmMo gy Amho. hm OZ
gXmMmamMm nm`m Amho. Aqhgm `m gH$nZo_ò Imbrb JmoQ>tMm g_mdoe Ho$bm OmVmo.
1) qhgm Z H$aUo H$moU`mhr d$nmV qhgm H$aUo ho OZ Y_mV _hmnmn g_Obo OmVo. H$moU`mhr n[apWVrV H$moUmhr
20
OrdmMr qhgm H$$ Zò, _J Vo Ord H$sS>o, _w`m, S>mg, T>oHy$U, qdMy, gn, dZmVrb mUr (h{aU, ggm,
B`mXr) d _mZd Agbo Var `mMr h`m H$$ Zò. dV:bm Oar {H$Vrhr mg, H$>, YmoH$m {Z_mU Pmbm Var
_wZrZo H$moU`mhr OrdmMr h`m H$aVm H$m_m Zò. `m {Z`_mMo H$gmoerZo nmbZ Ho$bo nm{hOo Aer OZ Y_mMr
AmJhmMr {eH$dU Amho.
Jar~ OZmdamZmhr XòZo dmJdmdo. `mZm K> Xmoa ~mYy Zò, `mMo Ad`d H$mny Zò, `m`mda
â_gmR> AmoPo bmXy Zò, `m`mH$Sy>Z dmOdrnojm A{YH$ H$m_ H$$Z KoD$ Zò. `mZm nwaogo Im`m{n`mg
mdo. `m Jmo>tMr H$miOr KoUo OZm`m AqhgoV g_m{d> Amho. qhgonmgyZ A{bV amhUo `mg "mU{VnmV
{da_U dV' Ago hUVmV. hUOoM _Zw`mZo H$moU`mhr Ord-OVyMr h`m hoVynwana H$$ Zò.
2) qhgoMo XmoZ ôX qhgoMo XmoZ ôX AmhoV. `mZm 1) ` qhgm - m`mMm `j dY H$aUo qH$dm `mg nrS>m XoUo. 2)
^md qhgm - H$moU`mhr m`m`m dYmMm qH$dm nrS>m Xo`mMm _ZmV {dMma H$aUo hmo`.`qhgonojm ^md qhgm
A{YH$ Xmof`wV AgVo. H$maU ^md qhgo_wio _Zw` dV:`m AVaJmMm KmV H$$Z KoVmoM `mCbQ> `qhgm `j
Pmbr Var qhgm XmofmnmgyZ _Zw`mMm ~Mmd hmoD$ eH$Vmo. Vr j` Agy eH$Vo. CXm. aVm ZrQ> nmhZ A`V gmdYnUo
MmbUm`m g`_r _mUgmH$Sy>Z `m`m nmdbmImbr EImm N>moQ>m OrdmMr qhgm Pmbr Var `mMo _Z ew Ag`mZo
Vmo Xmofr R>aV Zmhr. qhgm Xmofm_ò Amnbo _Z H$go Amho. AmMaUmV AqhgoMm `Z {H$Vr Amho ho _hdmMo
Amho. hUOoM _Zw`m`m _mZ{gH$ ewwVoda \$ma â Xo`mV Ambm Amho. OZ _VmZwgma gdM dVm`m
~m~VrV _ZmMr ewVm \$ma _hdmMr _mZVmV. CXm._mVm-{nVm `mZr Amn`m _wbmZm, JwZr Amn`m
{dm`mZm, `m`m{YemZr Anam`mZm bhmZ _moR>m Ho$bo`m {ejm Xmofr _mZ`m OmV ZmhrV H$maU
`m_ò `mMo _Z ew AgVo. `mV `m `m `Vr`m d g_mOm`m H$`mUmMr ^mdZm AgVo.
3) JhWm`m XZ{XZ OrdZm`m _`mXm bjmV KoD$Z qhgoMo Mma H$ma gm{JVbo AmhoV.
A) Ama^r qhgm - CR>Uo, ~gUo, MmbUo, dJao emar[aH$ hmbMmb. PmS>Uo, PQ>H$Uo dJao gm\$g\$mB, Myb
noQ>{dUo, XiUo, B`mXr {H$`m_wio hmoUmar qhgm hr Ama^r qhgm hmo`.
~) CmoJr qhgm - H$fr, XwH$mZXmar, `mnma, CmoJ, YZ {_i{dVmZm Or qhgm hmoVo {Vbm CmoJr qhgm
hUVmV.
H$) {damoYr qhgm - EImm m`mZo Amn`mda hbm Ho$`mg `m`mnmgyZ dV:Mo ajU H$a`mgmR>r
qhgm H$aUoMm g_mdoe {damoYr qhgo_ò hmoVo. hUOoM dOZ, n[aOZ, Y_, Xoe, g_mO, B`mXt`m
ajUmW Ho$bobr qhgm {damoYr qhgm Amho.
S>) gH$nr qhgm - {ZanamY m`mMr ghoVwH$nUo {eH$ma d qhgm H$aUo hr gH$nr qhgm hmo`. _ZmoaOZ
hUyZ, damMm ~Xbm hUyZ, namH$_ XmI{d`mgmR>r hUyZ, qH$dm Hw$R>`mhr H$maMm dmW gmY`mgmR>r
OmUyZ~wOyZ Or qhgm Ho$br OmVo Vr gH$nr qhgm hmo`.
JhWmbm `m MmanH$s n{h`m VrZ nyU Q>miVm òVM ZmhrV. VarnU `m~m~VrV `mZo e`
{VVHo$ A{YH$ {ddoH$erb amhZ {OVHo$ Q>miVm òBb {VVHo$ nhmdo. gH$nr [hgm hrM A`V dmBQ> AgVo.
Vr Q>miVm òUo e` Amho d Vr Q>mibrM nm{hOo Ago OZmMo _V Amho.
21
4)
nmM A{VMma qH$dm Aqhgm AZwdVmMo Xmof -
dYm{edm` A` H$maMr nrS>m XoD$Z qhgm XmofmMo ^mJrXma hmo`mMr AZoH$ H$maUo Agy eH$VmV.
H$R>moa eXmMm dmna Ho$`m_wio Xwg`mMo _Z XwImdbo Jobo Var Vr qhgmM hmoVo. n[aOZ d new dJao`m
~m~VrV nmM H$ma`m Hy$a dVZmbm A{VMma qH$dm Aqhgm AZwdVmMo Xmof hUVmV, ho A{VMma nmM
H$maMo AmhoV Vo Ago A) ~YXmof - H$moU`mhr Ordmbm (m`mbm) ~mYyZ qH$dm H$m|Sy>Z R>odUo, godH$mZm A{YH$ Wm~dyZ
R>odUo, R>abo`m doionojm A{YH$ doi H$m_ H$$Z KoUo, B`mXr {H$`mMm g_mdoe ~YXmofm_ò hmoVmo.
~) dYXmof - Ordo _maUo hm Va dY AmhoM. nU m`mZm _ma XoUo, Am{lV qH$dm ZmoH$a `mZm _ma
XoUo, H$moUm`m bmMmarMm Ja\$m`Xm KoUo, emofU H$aUo Am{U m`mZm BVa Hw$R>brhr nrS>m XoUo B`mXr
dYXmof AmhoV.
H$) N>oX Xmof - m`m`m AJCnmJmbm VmoS>Uo, hUOoM _mUgm`m qH$dm ney`m earambm OI_m
H$aUo, B`mXrMm g_mdoe N>oX Xmofm_ò hmoVmo.
S>) A{V^mamamonU Xmof - ney`m nmR>rda `mbm nobdUma Zmhr BVHo$ AmoPo bmXUo, Hw$UmH$Sy>Z
`m`m VmH$Xrnojm A{YH$ H$m_ H$$Z KoUo, dV:_ò H$m_ H$a`mMr eVr AgyZgwm Xwg`mH$Sy>Z H$m_
H$adyZ KoUo, B`mXtMm g_mdoe A{V^mamamonU Xmofm_ò hmoVmo.
B) AZnmZ {damoY - H$moU`mhr _mUgmbm, m`mbm dm newbm AZnmUr KoD$ Z XoUo qH$dm `m_ò
AS>Wim AmUUo, ZmoH$amZm doioda AZnmUr Z XoUo qH$dm WmoS>o XoUo, B`mXrMm g_mdoe AZnmZ {damoY _ò
g_mdoe hmoVmo.
OZ Y_m`m _Vo darb nmM H$ma`m A{VMma qH$dm XmofmnmgyZ OZ Y_mMo nmbZ H$aUm`m
JhWmbm `m gd A{VMmamnmgyZ Xya am{hbo nm{hOo VaM Vr Aqhgm hmo`.
5)
A{hgm hUOo o_ hmo` -
A{hgm hm eX ZH$mam_H$ Amho nU Aqhgm Vd ZH$mam_H$ Zmhr. Aqhgm hUOo o_. gd

m`m`m ~m~VrV X`m^md d __Vm^md AgUo hrM Iar Aqhgm hmo`._bm H$mQ>m ~moMbm H$s doXZm hmoVmV,
_bm H$moUr {edr {Xbr H$s Xw:I hmoVo VgoM Xwg`mghr doXZm hmoVmV, Xw:I hmoVo. _bm Oer OJ`mMr Vrd
BN>m hmoVo VerM BVa gd m`mZm Amho. `m ^mdZm gVV _ZmV ~miJUo hUOo Iao A{hgm-dV hmo`.
Aqhgm ^mdZm Oohm I`m AWmZo {dH${gV hmoVo Vohm _Zw`mbm eyXoIrb {_M dmQ>VmV. {_mda H$moUrhr
o_ H$aob nU eydahr o_ H$amd`mg nm{hOo, ho Aqhgm dVmMo _yb_ Amho. `m`mOdi emVVm, o_,
ghmZw^yVr, g_^md AgVmo Vmo o_i AgVmo. WmoS>`mV Aqhgm hUOo o_ hmo`.
6)
{dd H$`mUmgmR>r Aqhgm -
`VrZo gwerb, gXmMmar d g_mO{hVdmXr hmdo `mM~amo~a A{Z> dmrnmgyZ Xya ahmdo. Aqhgm
VdmMo nmbZ Ho$`mZo nanam_Yrb o_ dmT>ob. {df_Vm d {nidUyH$ Wm~ob. Ym{_H$, gm_m{OH$, Am{WH$,
amOZ{VH$ jomV AqhgoMm dmna H$aVm òBb. Vgo Pm`mg `wo Q>iVrb. am>mam>mV emVVm d AmnwbH$sMr
^mdZm $Oob, gmao AmZX_` d gwI_` hmoBb. AemH$mao {dd H$`mUmgmR>r Aqhgm ho dV Cn`wV
hmoBb.
22
3.2.3 AZoH$mVdmX :OZ_V hm EH$ Y_ Amho. VgoM Vo EH$ VdkmZ (XeZ) Amho. Y_ `m >rZo nmhVm Aqhgm hm `mMm
Am_m (mU) Amho. VdkmZ `m >rZo nmhVm "AZoH$mVdmX hm `mMm nm`m Amho. AZoH$mVdmX hm OZ
XeZmVrb EH$ {gmV ZgyZ OJmH$S>o nmh`mMm EH$ >rH$moZ Amho. Aqhgm `m _yb^yV oaUoVyZ AZoH$mVdmXmMr
C^maUr Pmbobr Amho. Aqhgm hUOo h`m Z H$aUo, Xwg`m Ordmda o_ H$aUo, _Z CXma H$aUo, Vohm
~m{H$ nmVirda Aqhgm qH$dm {^Z _V g{hUwVm hUOoM AZoH$mVdmX hmo`.H$moU`mhr dVyMo kmZ
mV H$aVmZm {V`m gnyU ~mOyMm {dMma H$aUo hUOo AZoH$mVdmX hmo`. Hw$R>`mhr Jmo>rg~Yr EH$mJrH$nUo
_V Z ~Z{dUo hUOo AZoH$mVdmX hmo`.AZoH$mVdmXmVrb AV hUOo H$S>, eodQ> qH$dm {ZpMV {ZU` hmo`
Am{U EH$mV hUOo EH$M EH$ {ZU` hmo`. hUyZ AZoH$mVdmX hUOo H$moU`mhr Jmo>rg~Yr EH$mJrnUo
{dMma Z H$aUo qH$dm _V Z ~Z{dUo hmo`. H$maU H$moU`mhr dVwbm AZoH$ ~mOy AgVmV. hUyZ H$moU`mhr
dVyMm {dMma H$aVmZm {V`m gnyU ~mOyMm {dMma H$aUo hUOo AZoH$mVdmX hmo`.
dVy AZVY_m_H$ AgVo H$moU`mhr JmoQ>rMm {dMma EH$m >rH$moZmVyZ H$aVm H$m_m Zò Aer OZ Y_mMr _w` {eH$dU Amho.
`m JmoQ>rMm {dMma H$amd`mMm `mZm BVa H$mhr ~mOy AmhoV qH$dm ZmhrV `mMm {dMma hmoUo Amd`H$
AgVo. H$moUmhr `VrMm n[aM` hmo`mgmR>r {VMm Xoe, OmV, d`, Y_, g_mO, Zmd, Hw$Qw>~, B`mXr OmUyZ
KoUo Amd`H$ Amho. _Z_mohZ `m `VrMo JwU Vmo ^maVr`, qhXw, JmadU, ~mU, BV`m CMrMm, d`mMm,
A_yH$ {ejU KoVbobm EdT>oM g_OyZ MmbUma Zmhr Va `mM~amo~a Vmo `wamo{n`, Am{\$H$Z, {MZ Y_u`
Zmhr Ago {ZfoYm_H$ kmZ hmd`mg nm{hOo. `m_mUo OZ_VmZwgma òH$ dVy hr dn`m` d nan`m`
`mMm g_wM` AgVo.
dVy AZVY_m_H$ AmhoV. `mMm {dMma Zoh_r gmnojVoZo Ho$bm nm{hOo. AmnU {H$Vrhr `Z Ho$bm
Var dVyMo AmnUmg hmoUmao kmZ d {VMo gnyU d$n `m_ò AVa amhUmaM. H$maU AmnU dVyMo kmZ
H$$Z KoVmZm Hw$R>bm Var EH$M AV qH$dm eodQ> nH$S>rV AgVmo. AmnU Ago hQ>bo H$s, ho Q>o~b bmH$S>mMo
Ho$bobo Amho. AWmV ho {dYmZ Iao Amho. nU `m`m IaonUmg _`mXm nS>VmV. Vo Hw$R>`mhr bmH$S>mMo Zmhr
Va gmJdmZ `m OmVr`m bmH$S>mMo Amho. Vmo gmJdmZhr A_yH$ EH$ H$maMm Amho. Vo A_yH$ EH$m gwVmamZo
~Z{dbo Amho. B`mXr Jmo>r g~YrMo kmZ H$$Z `mdo bmJob. WmoS>`mV H$moU`mhr dVyMo kmZ H$$Z
Ko`mgmR>r `m`m gd ~mOyMm {dMma H$$Z _m{hVr `mdr. H$maU Hw$R>brhr dVy hr AZVY_m_H$ AgVo.
OZm`m `m _Vmg AZoH$mVdmX hUVmV.
Z`dmX d `mXdmX AZoH$mVdmX hm EH$ >rH$moZ Amho. hm >rH$moZ dVy d$nm`m kmZm`m AnojoZo dmna`mg
`mVyZ Z`dmX {ZnZ hmoVmo d `mdoir {dYmZm`m AnojoZo dmna`mg `mVyZ `mXdmX {ZnZ AgVmo.
Z`dmX Am{U `mXdmX hr AZoH$mVdmXmMrM XmoZ no AmhoV.
Z`dmX * Z` hUOo Ae, AJ qH$dm nmhUm`mMm {d{e> A{^m` hmo`.
* Z` hUOo H$moU`mhr dVyMo {V`mg~Yr`m {d{eQ> >rH$moZmVyZ Pmbobo kmZ hmo`. Z` hUOo
OmUUm`m `VrMm EH$ {d{e> >rH$moZ hmo`. Vmo Agm H$s AZoH$ JwUY_ AgUm`m dVy`m EImmM
23
JwUY_mda bj H|$rV Ho$bo OmVo d `m JwUm~b {dYmZ Ho$bo OmVo. `mMm AW Agm H$s, H$moU`mhr dVy`m
AZoH$ JwUmnH$s EH$mdoir EH$mM JwUmda bj H|$rV H$aUo hUOo Z`dmX hmo`. gm_m` _mUgo EH$mdoir
nXmWmMm Ho$di EH$M JwUY_ OmUy eH$VmV. `m_wio `m `VrMo kmZ Aen (H$_r) AgVo. Aem `m
Aen kmZmbm OZmZr Z` hQ>bo Amho.
Z`dmX H$ma Z`
`Z`
1) ZJ_Z`
2) gJhZ`
4) G$OwgyZ`
n`m`Z`
3) `dhmaZ`
5) eXZ` 6) g_{^T> Z`
7) Ed^yVZ`
Z`mMo _w` H$ma XmoZ nS>VmV. `mZm `Z` d n`m`Z` Ago hUVmV. Z`mMo EHy$U H$ma gmV
nS>VmV.
`Z` H$moU`mhr dVy`m {R>H$mUr Agm {Z` Ae AgVmoM H$s `m`moJmZo VrM hr dVy Amho Ago kmZ
hmoVo, `mg `Z` hUVmV. CXm.1) H$mngmMm doiy H$$Z `mMo gyV H$mTy>Z `mnmgyZ H$mnS> ~Z{dbo Var
`mVrb H$mnyg ho ` VoM amhVo `mbmM `Z` hUVmV.
CXm. 2) _mVr ho ` Amho. Vr {ÔdyZ {V`m Jmo`mnmgyZ {Vbm AmH$ma XoD$Z KQ> V`ma Ho$bo
OmVmV d Vo H$aVmZm _mVr doJdoJir $no KoVo. Vr ^mObr H$s aJ ~XbVmo. AmYr H$mim aJ AgVmo d _J
^mO`mda Vm~yg ~ZVmo. nU {H$Vrhr ~Xb Pmbo Var _mVr ho ` amhVoM. gmo`mMohr CXmhaU AgoM
Amho. gmoZo VmndyZ `mnmgyZ {d{dY H$maMo AbH$ma V`ma Ho$bo OmVmV nU `mVrb gmoZo ho ` H$m`_
amhVoM. WmoS>`mV `m `m dVyMm Vmo Vmo {d{e> JwU VmoM amhVmo. CXm.gmo`mMo {ndionU, {_R>mMo ImaQ>nU,
gmIaoMo JmoS>nU, H$m`mMo H$Sy>nU, ~\$mMo WS>nU, B`mXr.
`Z`mMo H$ma `Z`mMo VrZ H$ma nS>VmV. `mZm 1) ZJ_Z` 2) gJhZ` 3) `dhmaZ` Ago hUVmV.
1)
ZJ_Z` -
H$moU`mhr dVy~b {dMma H$a`mMr Or nVr AgVo {Vbm ZJ_Z` hUVmV. òH$ dVybm
qH$dm KQ>Zobm gm_m` d {deof Ago JwU AgVmV. `m nVr_ò dVyMo gm_m` JwU d {deofJwU bjmV
KoVbobo AgVmV. hUOoM dVyMm gm_m`JwU d {deofJwU `mV \$aH$ Ho$bobm ZgVmo. CXm.`mdoir AmnU
Am_dj Ago hUVmo. `mdoir `m_ò djmMo gm_m`JwU d {deofJwU g_m{d> AgVmV. djmMo gm_m`JwU
hUOo _wio, ImoS>, \$mm, nmZo, {hadonUm AgUo ho hmoV. Am_djm`m ~m~VrV `mMm {deof JwU hUOo
nmZmMm {d{e> AmH$ma, `mbm Ambobm _mohmoa d `m _mohmoambm Am~o bmJUo Agm Amho. gm_m` d {deof ho
EH$_oH$mV {_gibobo AgVmV d Xmohr {_iyZ H$moUVrhr Jmo> hmoV AgVo. AemH$mao ZJ_Z`mV gm_m` d
{deofJU bjmV KoVbo OmVmV.
24
2)
gJhZ` -
`m_ò H$moU`mhr dVy`m gm_m` JwUmMmM {dMma Ho$bobm AgVmo. (EH$m {d{e> OmVrV Agbo`m
gd `Vr_ò Oo JwU g_mZ AgVmV Vo gm_m`JwU hmoV) `m Z`mZwgma, H$moU`mhr dVyMo {deofJwU `m
dVy`m gm_m` JwUmnojm doJio ZgVmV. CXm.Oa djM ZgVo Va Am_djM ApVdmV am{hbm ZgVm.
hUOo Am_djm`m {R>H$mUr AgUmao {deof JwU ho `m Am_djm`m gm_m` JwUmnmgyZ doJio amh eH$V
ZmhrV Ago gJhZ` hUVmo.
3)
`dhmaZ` -
`dhmaZ`m_ò H$moU`mhr dVy`m {R>H$mUr AgUmao {deofJwUM bjmV KoVbo OmVmV. (Oo JwU
Ho$di `m {d{e> `VrVM AmT>iVmV `mZm {deof JwU hUVmV). `m {deof JwUm`m `{V[aV gm_m`
JwUmMo ApVd AgV Zmhr Ago _mZbo OmVo. CXm.Oohm EImXm _mUyg EImm `Vrbm KQ> AmUmd`mg
gmJVmo, Vohm Vr `Vr H$mim qH$dm bmbgaM KQ> AmUVo. H$maU aJhrZ KQ>H$ Agm ApVdmVM
ZgVmo.`m Z`m_ò dVyH$S>o nmh`mMm `mdhm[aH$ >rH$moZ AgVmo d Vmo B{` AZw^dmda AmYmabobm
Amho. AmnU Oohm dVyer `dhma H$aVmo Vohm Vmo {d{e> dVyer AgVmo, `m dVy`m OmVrer qH$dm
dJmer ZgVmo.
n`m`Z` dVyMm {Za{Zam`m AdWmZm OZ ^mfoV n`m`Z` hUVmV. dVy`m d$nmMo kmZ H$$Z Ko`mgmR>r
{V`m {R>H$mUr AgUm`m {d{dY n`m` Z`mMm dmna Ho$bm OmVmo. n`m`Z`mMo nwT>rb ^mJ nS>VmV - 4)
G$OygyZ` 5) eXZ` 6) g_{^$T> Z` 7) Ed^yV Z`
4)
G$OwgyZ` -
G$Oy hUOo gai d gy hm dMZm`m AWmZo dmnabobm eX Amho. `m Z`m`m _VmZwgma H$moU`mhr
dVy`m ^yVH$mimMm qH$dm ^{d`H$mimMm {dMma Z H$aVm Vr dVy dV_mZH$mimV H$er Amho `mMm {dMma
Ho$bm OmVmo. hUOoM H$moU`mhr dVy`m dV_mZ pWVrMmM {dMma Ho$bm OmVmo. H$moU`mhr dVy`m
^yVH$mi d ^{d` pWVrer Amn`m XZ{XZ `dhmamMo H$V` ZgVo. Amnbm g~Y \$V dVy`m
dV_mZ pWVrerM AgVmo, Ago G$OwgyZ` nQ> H$aVmo. CXm.EImmbm `m`m nw`H$_m_wio nydO_r
dJbmoH$ {_imbm Agob naVw Vo nw` gn`m_wio Vmo `m O_r _mUyg Pmbm Agob Va nydu`m dJbmoH$s
OrdZmMm `mbm dV_mZH$mir H$mhrhr Cn`moJ Zmhr. òWo \$V Vmo g pWVrV H$gm Amho `mMm {dMma Ho$bm
OmVmo.hm Z` \$V {d{e> jUr dVyMo Agbobo $n bjmV KoVmo. CXm.`m jUr gwI Amho. `m AZw^dmV Vmo
\$V `m jUr AgUm`m gwImMmM {dMma H$aVmo. Cm H$m` hmoBb `mMm {dMma H$aV Zmhr.
5)
eXZ` -
eXZ`mMm >rH$moZ hm eX d `mMo AW `m`mer g~YrV AgVmo. H$moUVmhr eX {d{e> dVy,

{df`, JwU, g~Y qH$dm {H$`m Xe{dUmam AgVmo. eX ho EH$ Zmd qH$dm gkm AgVo. Vmo eX CMma`mda
Amn`m _Zmg_moa EImXr dVy, JwU, g~Y, KQ>Zm C^r Ho$br OmVo. òH$ eXmbm AW AgVmo. {^Z
eX EH$M dVy {ZX}e H$$ eH$VmV. CXm.XJS>, nmfmU, A_m ho eX XJS> hr dVy XmI{dVmV. amOm
A{YnVr, ^w, Zaoe, B`mXr eX amOm gwM{dUmao AmhoV. nZr, ^m`m, O`m, B`mXr eX nZr gwM{dUmao
AmhoV.
25
6)
g_{^T>Z` -
EH$mM dVyMm qH$dm `VrMm {ZX}e H$a`mgmR>r Cn`moJmV AmUbo`m {Za{Zam`m g_mZmWH$
eXm`m gmmZo `mMm {ZX}e Ho$bm OmVmo Vohm `mg g_{^T>Z` Ago hUVmV. CXm.{n, hpVZ,
H$[aZ ho JO{ZX}eH$ (hmr) eX AmhoV. {n hUOo Xmohm|Zr gmoS> d Vm|S> `mZr {nUmam Agm AW hmoVmo.
hpVZ hUOo hV AgUmam òWo `mMr Vm|S> hmM `mMm hmV H$pnbobm Amho. H$[aZ `m eXmVrb _yi
H$nZm hUOo `mMr gm|S> hmM `mMm H$a (hmV) Aer Amho. Aem H$maoo g_mZmWH$ eX dmn$Z
g_{^T>Z` `V Ho$bm OmVmo.
7)
Ed^yVZ` -
`m `m dVy`m qH$dm `Vr`m `m `m pWVrbm AZwg$Z `m `m dVybm qH$dm `Vrbm

Oohm Zmd {Xbo OmVo Vohm `m {dMmanVrbm Ed^yVZ` Ago hUVmV. CXm.Zaqgh ho Zmd `mdoir EImXm
nwf qghmgmaIo dVZ H$aV Agob `mdoir XoVmV. Jm `m eXmMm AW {\$aUmam mUr Agm Amho. qhS>Umar,
{\$aUmar Jm` hUOo "Jm' naVw Oohm Vr Jm` pWa d dW ~gbr Agob Vohm {Vbm "Jm' hUVm òUma
Zmhr. pWa pWVrV Agbo`m JmBMo dUZ H$a`mgmR>r Xwgam EImXm eX emoYmd`mg nm{hOo. Jm`H$
hUOo JmUmam nU hm Z` `mbm Zoh_r Jm`H$ hUyZ pdH$maUma Zmhr. Vr `Vr JmV Agob VohmM `mMm
Jm`H$ hUyZ drH$ma H$aob.
`mXdmX (gV^JrZ`) {dYmZm`m AnojoZo `mdoir AZoH$mVdmX pdH$mabm OmVmo `mdoir `mVyZ `mXdmX {ZnZ hmoVmo.
`mX `mMm eXH$mofmVrb AW - H$Xm{MV g^dV: H$W{MV Ago AmhoV. nU òWo `mX `mMm AW EH$m
n[aZo qH$dm {d{e> gX^mV Agm Amho.
EImm dVyg~YmZo AmnU {ZpMVnUo H$mhr gmJy eH$V Zmhr qH$dm `m dVy`m gX^mV {ZpMVnUo
H$mhr ZmH$m$ eH$V Zmhr. dVy`m AZV Aem JwVmJwVr_wio H$mhr {ZpMV {dYmZ H$aVm òV Zmhr. EImXr
dVy qH$dm {VMm Y_ `m`m g~Yr H$mhr {dYmZ Ho$bo Va Vo EH$m {d{e> gX^mVM Iao AgVo. naVw gX^
~Xbbm Va Zo_Ho$ `m`m{d$ {XgUmao {dYmZ ho {VV`mM g_WnUo _mS>Vm òBb Ago `mXdmXmMo
Vmn` Amho. gX^ ~XbyZ Hw$R>`mhr Jmo>rg~Yr {dYmZ H$a`m`m EH$Xa gmV nVr AmhoV `m Aem 1) `mX ApV &
2) `mX ZmpV &
4) `mX AdV`_ &
5) `mX ApV AdV`_ &
6) `mX ZmpV AdV`_
7) `mX ApV ZmpV A`V`_
3) `mX ApV ZmpV &
Aem H$mao `m gmV {dYmZmMr {_iyZ Or aMZm V`ma hmoVo {Vbm gV^Jr Z` Ago hUVmV. darb
gmV {dYmZmMr _m{hVr Imbrb_mUo XoVm òBb.
1)
`mX ApV &
Ago Agy eHo$b. hm {dYmZ H$a`mMm n{hbm H$ma Amho. H$moUVrhr dVy `mMo `, jo, WmZ,
H$mb d ew `m >rZo {dMma H$aVm Vr dVy hUyZ ApVdmV AgVo. CXm.KQ> hm _{VHo$ nmgyZ (`) V`ma
Pmbobm Amho hUyZ _m`m ImobrV (WmZ) Amho. VgoM `m jUr (H$mb) Amho Am{U A_yH$ EH$m _mnmMm
26
Am{U AmH$mamMm ($n) Amho hUyZ ApVdmV Amho.

2)
`mX ZmpV &
Ago Zgy eHo$b. Xwg`m EImm dVy`m gX^mVrb `, WmZ, H$mb Am{U n `m`m >rZo
nmhVm n{hbr dVy ApVdmV ZgVo. CXm.`mX ApV _ò AmnU EH$Xm KQ> _mVrMm Amho Ago hQ>bo
Amho. Vgo òWo KQ> YmVyMm (`) ~Z{dbobm Amho. Vmo Xwg`m {R>H$mUr Amho. VgoM Vmo doJ`m doir Amho
Am{U doJ`m AmH$mamMm Amho `m AWmZo ApVdmV Zmhr.
3)
`mX ApV ZmpV &
Ago Agy d Zgy eHo$b. EH$M dVy XmoZ {^Z >tZr nm{h`mg EH$Xm AgVo Am{U EH$Xm ZgVo Ago
hUVm òD$ eHo$b. `m {Vg`m H$mamV H$moUVr dVy H$er Amho VgoM Vr H$er Zmhr `mMmhr {dMma Ho$bm
OmVmo.
4)
`mX AdV`_ &
dUZ Z H$a`mgmaIo Agob. `mX AdV`_ hUOo XmoZ {damoYr JwU EH$mM dVy`m {R>H$mUr
AgVmV, Am{U hUyZ `m dVyMo Zo_Ho$ d$n H$go Amho ho R>a{dUo Ae` ~ZVo. CXm.ndr hr hQ>bo Va
pWa Amho d hQ>bo Va pWa Zmhr, hUyZ Vr Zo_H$s H$er Amho Vo gmJVm òV Zmhr. Aem AWmZo Vr
AdUZr` (AdV`_) Amho.
5)
`mX ApV AdV`_ &
Agy eHo$b nU dUZ H$a`mgmaIo Zgy eHo$b. hUOo ndr Amho, pWa Amho Am{U Varhr {VMo
Zo_Ho$ d$n H$go Amho Vo gmJUo H${R>U Amho. Vo g_O`mgmaIo Zmhr. hUyZ `mbm AdV`_ hQ>bo
Amho.
6)
`mXZmpV AdV`_ &
Ago Zgy eHo$b d dUZ H$a`mgmaIo Zgy eHo$b. hUOo EImXr dVy Aer Zmhr Am{U `mM~amo~a
Vr AdUZr` Amho. CXm.ndr {\$aV Zmhr Ago {XgVo. nU `mM~amo~a {VMo d$n AdV`hr Amho.
7)
`mX ApV ZmpV AdV`_ &
Agy, Zgy d AdUZr` Ago eHo$b. `mX ApV ZmpV AdV`_ hUOo EImXr dVy Aer Amho,
Aer Zmhr, Am{U Varhr Vr AdUZr` Amho. hUOo ndr EH$m AWmZo pWa Amho, EH$m AWmZo {\$aV Amho.
Am{U Varhr {VMo Iao d$n AmH$bZr` Zmhr d hUyZ Vo AdUZr` (AdV`_) Amho Agm `mMm AW
Amho.
AemH$mao kmZ {_i{d`m`m `m {^Z {^Z gmV ~mOy AmhoV. gmVhr EH$ hmoD$Z AmnUmg
dVyMr gnyU H$nZm XoVmV. Z`dmX d `mXdmX `m`m AmYmao OZmZr Amnbm AZoH$mVdmX darb_mUo
n> Ho$bobm Amho.
27
3.2.4 Ord Am[U AOrd Vdo :JwU Am{U n`m` `mZr `wV Ago Oo ` nXmW AmhoV Vo ` nXmW Ord Am{U AOrd `m XmoZ _wI
H$mamV {d^mJbobo AmhoV. hUOoM Ord Am{U AOrd hr Xmohrhr ò hmoV hUOo Vr JwU Am{U n`m`mZr
`wV AmhoV.OZ VdkmZmZwgma `m {ddmMr XmoZ A{V_ VdmV {d^mJUr Ho$bobr Amho d Vr hUOo Ord
Am{U AOrd hmo`. hr Xmohr Vdo {Z` d emdV AgyZ Vr nanamhZ dV AmhoV Am{U Varhr `mMo
ghApVd Amho. Ord hm ^moVm Amho Va AOrd hm ^mo` {df` Amho. Ordmbm OmUrd (~moY) qH$dm kmZ
AgVo Am{U AOrd ho Mma B{`mZm ne, $Mr, JY d >r `m`m_m\$V VrV hmoVo. Ord MoVZ AgVmo
Am{U AOrd AMoVZ AgVmo. hUOoM Ord {OdV d mUdmZ AgVmV Am{U AOrd mUa{hV [H$dm OS> d
^m{VH$ d$nmMo AgVo. Ord d `mMo H$ma Am{U AOrd d `mMo H$ma `mMr _m{hVr nwT>rb_mUo Amho Ord OZ Y_mV Ord hm eX doJdoJ`m H$mao dmnabm Jobm Amho. Ord hUOo mUVd, Am_m d OmUrd
Agohr hQ>bo Amho. `mbm MoVZm Amho Vmo hUOo Ord hmo`. Oo Vd OmUVo, {dMma H$aVo Am{U gdoXZerb
AgVo Vo Vd hUOo OrdVd hmo`. kmZ, gdoXZm, {dMma Am{U gH$n `m Jmo>r H$moU`mVar Vdmer
g~{YV AgVmV Vo Vd hUOo OrdVd hmo`. Ordm_wio qH$dm mUm_wio earambm {OdVnU bm^Vo.kmZ
AWdm OmUrd hm OrdmMm Y_ Amho. OrdmMm Y_ Am{U dV: Ord `m {^Z Jmo>r ZmhrV. CXm.`moVrMm
H$me hm `moVrhZ {^Z ho Iao Amho nU H$mea{hV `moV H$er Agy eHo$b? Am{U `moVr{edm` H$me
H$gm Agob? `m_mUo OmUrd hr OrdmhZ {^Z ho Iao Amho. nU OmUrda{hV Ord H$gm Agob d
Ordm{edm` OmUrd H$er Agob ?
OrdmMo JwU Ord Oohm `m`m ew emdV pWVrV AgVmo Vohm `mMo AmR> JwU gm{JVbo AmhoV Vo Ago 1)
AZV kmZ - A_`m{XV Ago kmZ
2)
AZV XeZ - A_`m{XV Aer lm AWdm gmjmH$ma
3)
A`m~mY - gwIXw:ImnmgyZ _wVr
4)
g`H$d - g`H$ kmZ, g`H$ XeZ, g`H$ AmMaU
5)
Aj` pWVr - emdV AdWm
6)
A$nr - AmH$mahrZVm AWdm $nhrZVm
7)
AJwbKy - pWVrMr g_mZVm, \$ma CM Zmhr qH$dm \$ma ZrM Zmhr Aer pWVr
28
8)
AZV-dr` - A_`m{XV {H$`merbd
OrdmMo H$ma Ord

ggmar Ord
Wmda Ord
Wyb Ord
gy_ Ord
1) dZnVr
2) ndrH$m`
_wV Ord
gOrd
{gOrd
rq`
t{`
VrWH$a Ord
MVw[a{`
nMo|{`
g_ZH$
3) ObH$m`
4) A{H$m`
5) dm`wH$m`
OrdmMo _w` H$ma XmoZ nS>VmV `mZm 1) ggmar Ord d 2) _wV Ord Ago hUVmV.
1)
ggmar Ord -
ggmar Ord hUOo EH$m O_mVyZ Xwg`m O_mV doe H$aUmao qH$dm OmUmao Ord hmo`. `m ggmar
OrdmMohr XmoZ H$ma nS>VmV `mZm A) g Ord d ~) Wmda Ord Ago hUVmV.
A)
g Ord -
g hUOo WbmVa H$aUmao Ord hmoV. hUOoM EH$m OmJoH$Sy>Z Xwg`m OmJoH$S>o OmUmao Ord hmoV.
Aem `m g OrdmMo nmM CnH$ma nS>VmV `mZm 1) t{` 2) t{` 3) MVw[a{` 4) nM|{` 5)
g_ZH$ Ago hUVmV.
1)
t{` Ord -
r-B{` Ord CloUrMo AgVmV. `m m`mZm Ho$di ne d agZm Aer XmoZM B{ò AgVmV
`mZm r-B{` Ord hUVmV. `m OrdmZm ghm mU AgVmV. ag, ne, eara, dgZeVr, OrdZH$mb
Am{U dmH$ (MmbUo) Ago ho ghm mU AmhoV. `m_ò OV, qen`mV amhUmao gy_ Am`mgmaIo Ord,
JmSw>io, Oidm, gwadQ> ho mUr AgVmV. `mMm OJ`mMm H$mbmdYr 12 dfmhZ A{YH$ ZgVmo.
29
2)
t{` -
`m m`mZm ({H$Q>H$mZm) Ho$di ne (dMm), agZm (Or^) d JY (ZmH$) Aer VrZ r-B{` Ord
Ago hUVmV. `m dJmV Vm~S>m, nmT>`m d H$m`m _w`m, T>oHy$U d nVJ `mgma`m m`mMm g_mdoe
hmoVmo. `mMm OJ`mMm H$mbmdYr 49 {Xdgmnojm A{YH$ ZgVmo.
3)
MVw[a{` -
`m m`mZm ne, agZm, JY d Mjy (S>moio) Aer Mma B{ò AgVmV `mZm MVwa-B{` Ord
hUVmV. `m dJmV qdMy, S>mg, JmYrb_mer, {MbQ>o, _mem, \w$bnmIao, Q>moi `mgma`m m`mMm `m dJmV
g_mdoe hmoVmo. `mMm OJ`mMm H$mbmdYr ghm _{h`mnojm A{YH$ ZgVmo.
4)
nM|{` -
`m m`mZm ne, agZm, JY, Mjy d ldU Aer nmM B{ò AgVmV `mZm nM|{` Ord Ago
hUVmV. `m dJmV KmoS>m, Jm`, dmK, qgh `mgma`m m`mMm g_mdoe hmoVmo.
5)
g_ZH$ Ord -
_Zw` mUr `m H$mamV òVmoo. _Zw`mbm nMkmZ|{ò (ne, agZm, JY, Mjy d ldU) d _Z Am{U
{dMma H$a`mMr eVr AgVo. BVa m`mnojm _Zw` hm mUr `m_wioM doJim Amho. `m{edm` _Zw`m_ò
dmMm (~mobUo) Amho. `m_wio Vmo Amnbo {dMma `V H$$ eH$Vmo. _Zw`mMm OJ`mMm H$mbmdYr gamgar
100 df}n`V AgVmo.
~)
Wmda Ord -
Wmda Ord ho EH$ B{` AgUmao Ord AgVmV. `mZm \$V ne ho EH$M B{` AgVo. `m EH$B{` OrdmZm Mma mU AgVmV. ne, eara, dgZeVr d OrdZH$mi ho Vo mU hmoV. ho Wmda Ord XmoZ
H$maMo AmhoV `mZm 1) Wyb Ord d 2) gy_ Ord Ago hUVmV.
1)
Wyb Ord d 2) gyy_ Ord -
`m EH$-B{` OrdmMo H$_ Wyb AgVo Vo Wyb EH|${` Ord hmoV. ho Wyb EH|${` Ord H$mhr
{Z`{_V Wir AgVmV. `m Wyb Ordm_ò {d{dY H$ma`m dZnVtMm g_mdoe hmoVmo.
`mCbQ> `m EH|${` OrdmMo H$_ gy_ AgVo, `mZm gyj EH|${` Ord hUVmV. `m gy_
Ordm_ò ndrH$m`, ObH$m`, A{H$m` d dm`wH$m` `mMm g_mdoe hmoVmo.
2)
_wV Ord -
_wV Ord hUOo nyUnUo _moH$io Pmbobo Ord hmoV. _wV Ord Eo{hH$ Jmo>tnmgyZ A{bV AgyZ C
A`mp_H$ AdWoV Jobobo AgVmV. _wV Ord ho _wV ({Z$nmYr) AgVmV. H$maU Vo ew ApVd
Am{U AZV OmUrd `m`m AdWoV AgVmV. `mZm AZVkmZ, AZV XeZ, AZV dr` Am{U AZV gwI
mV Pmbobo AgVo. `m _wV OrdmMr {d^mJUrgwm XmoZ H$mamV hmoVo. `mZm Wyb Ord d VrWH$a Ord
Ago hUVmV. Wyb Ord ho ggmar Ordm`m gwIXw:Img~Yr CXm{gZ AgVmV. VgoM Wyb Ord ho
30
nyUdmg nmohmoMbobo AgVmV. Vo gd H$_mnmgyZ _wV Pmbobo AgVmV. VrWH$a Ordgwm _wV AgVmV.
ggmar OrdmZm H$mhr H$mi `mZr _mJXeZ Ho$bobo AgVo Ago Ord VrWH$a Ord AgVmV.
AOrd OrdmZVaMo Xwgao Vd hUOo AOrd hmo`. AOrd hm AMoVZ AgVmo. hUOo AOrd mUa{hV qH$dm
OS> d ^m{VH$ d$nmMm AgVmo. MoVZoMm A`V A^md AgUmam nXmW hUOo AOrd hmo`. AOrd hm ^mo`
{df` Amho. AOrd ho Mma B{`mZm hUOo ne, $Mr, JY d >r `m`m _m\$V VrV hmoVo. Ago ho AOrd
Vd nmM H$mamV {d^mJbo OmVo.
AOrd H$ma 1) nwXJb
2) Y_ (J{V)
4) H$mb
5) AmH$me
3) AY_ (pWVr)
nwXJb * nwXJb ho n{hbo AOrd ` hmo`. `m nXmWmbm eX, ne, ag, JY d dU ho JwU AgVmV Vmo
nXmW hUOo nwXJb hmo`. B{`mZm `mMo kmZ hmoVo Vr dVy, B{ò, OrdmMr earao, Wyb _Z, H$_}, B`mXr
AmH$ma Agbo`m Jmo>r AgVmV `mZm nwXJb Ago hUVmV.
* `m`m bhmZ _moR>m gKmVmZr OJmVrb {Za{Zamio AMoVZ nXmW ~Z{dbobo AmhoV `m AUyZm
nwXJb hUVmV. nwXJbm`m {R>H$mUr eX, g`moJ, _wbm`_nUm, WybVm, AmH$ma, {d^mJ, VoO d CUVm
Am{U $n `m {d{H$`m AgVmV.
* ` qH$dm nXmW ho A{dZmer AmhoV. ` H$moUVohr $n KoD$ eH$Vo Am{U H$moUVohr JwU `mV Agy
eH$VmV. ` qH$dm nXmW ho hmbMmbtMo H|$ Amho. `mbmM nwXJb Ago hUVmV.
* nwXJbm`m g~YmVrb JVr XmoZ H$maMr Amho. `mZm gmYr nanX JVr d n[aUm_ JVr Ago
hUVmV. n[anX JVr hUOoM ZwgVrM hmbMmb hmo`. n{aUm_ JVr hUOo JwUmV d n`m`mV ~Xb hmoUo
hmo`.
2) d 3) Y_ d AY_ Y_ Am{U AY_ `mMo Zoh_rMo AW hUOo gXmMma hmo`. nU OZ XeZmV hm AW KoVbobm Zmhr.
VgoM `mMm AW nw` d nmn [H$dm Z{VH$ gXJwU Agm ZgyZ {ddmV JVr d pWVr `m`m_wio e`
hmoVmV Aer XmoZ Vdo AmhoV. Y_ d AY_ {XgV ZmhrV, naVw OJmV JVr (hmbMmb) d pWVr (pWaVm)
`mMo n>rH$aU H$aVm ò`mgmR>r `m ghm`H$ {H$`m hUyZ OZ XeZmV JhrV Yabo`m AmhoV.Y_ `
J{V ghm`H$ Amho. hUOo dV: Vo CXmgrZ AgyZ JVrg CnH$maH$ Amho. CXm.nm`m_wio _membm BH$S>o
{VH$S>o {\$aUo e` hmoVo nU nmUr _membm dV: T>H$bV Zmhr. Y_mMohr VgoM Amho hUyZ Y_m_wio J{V
CnZ hmoV Zmhr Va Vo JVrg ghm`H$ R>aVo.AY_ ` ho pWaVoMo CXm{gZ H$maU Amho. Ogo djmMr
N>m`m dmQ>g$bm ~ioM amoIyZ YaV Zmhr Va WH$bobm dmQ>g$ djm`m N>m`m_wio djmImbr {dlmVrg
Wm~Vmo. AY_ `mMo H$m` `mM H$maMo Amho.
31
4)
H$mb -
H$mbmMo bjU AgUo ho Amho. Vmo ` AgyZ AZV AgVmo. Vmo {XgV Zmhr. H$mhr OZ Vdk H$mbmMo
XmoZ H$ma _mZVmV. `mZm {ZM`H$mi d `dhmaH$mi Ago hUVmV. {ZM`H$mi hm AZmXr d AZV
AgVmo. `mdhm[aH$ H$mbmbm g_` hUVmV. `mMr {d^mJUr jU, Vmg, {Xdg, _{hZo, df} `mV H$aVm
òVo.
5)
AmH$me -
AmH$me ho XoemMo ~Zbobo Amho. EH$m nwXJb na_mUw_wio OodT>m AS>Wim {Z_mU hmoVmo VodT>mg EH$
Xoe hUmd`mMo. BVa ` nXmWmZm AdH$me H$$Z XoUo d `m`m hmbMmbrg ghm`^yV hmoUo ho
AmH$memMo H$m` Amho. AmH$memMo bmoH$mH$me d AbmoH$mH$me Ago XmoZ ^mJ _mZbo AmhoV. AbmoH$mH$memV
H$mhrM Zmhr. Vr ZwgVr AIS> nmoH$ir Amho. `mV Y_ Am{U AY_ hr ò Zg`mZo `mV nXmWm`m
JVrMr Am{U hmbMmbrMr e`Vm ZgVo. Ord, nwXJb, Y_ d AY_ ho ~hXoe`mnr Ag`mZo `m`m
{dVmamgmR>r AmH$me `mMo ApVd g` _mZUo Amd`H$ R>aVo.
3.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z :A)
Jmibo`m OmJm âm.

1)
{OZ `m eXmMm AW ----------- Agm hmoVmo.
2)
OZ Y_mMo n{hbo VrWH$a ----------- AmhoV.
3)
OZ Y_mMo Mmodrgmdo VrWH$a ----------- AmhoV.
4)
OZ Y_mMo ----------- Am{U ----------- ho XmoZ R>iH$ nW AmhoV.
5)
----------- hm OZ gXmMmamMm nm`m Amho.
6)
----------- hUOo Ae, AJ qH$dm nmhUm`mMm {d{e> A{^m` hmo`.
7)
----------- Am{U ----------- hr AZoH$mVdmXmMrM XmoZ no AmhoV.
8)
`mbm MoVZm Amho Vmo hUOo ----------- hmo`.
3.4 n[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW :1) VrWH$a - OZ Y_mMo dVZ gdYZ Am{U gma `mZr Ho$bm `mZm VrWH$a hUVmV.
2) {OZ : B{ò qOH$Umam
3) {XJ~a : AJmda d Z R>odVm qhS>Umao
4) doVm~a : ew^ d n[aYmZ H$aUmao
5) Aqhgm na_mo Y_m: : Aqhgm hm gdlo> Y_ Amho.
6) Z` : Ae, AJ, nmhUm`mMm {d{e> A{^m`
7) G$Oy : gai
32
8) `mX : EH$m AWmZo, EH$m narZo, {d{e> gX^mV

9) g : WbmVa H$aUmao
3.5 d` A``Z ZmMr Cmao :1) qOH$Umam
2) G$f^ZmW
4) {XJ~a d doVm~a
3) ^JdmZ _hmdra
5) Aqhgm
6) Z`
7) Z`dmX Am{U `mXdmX
8) Ord
3.6 gmame :OZ XeZ ho EH$ Ad{XH$ (ZmVrH$) XeZ Amho. OZ XeZmMm gma d gdYZ `mZr Ho$bm `mZm
VrWH$a Ago hUVmV. Ago EHy$U 24 VrWH$a hmoD$Z JoboV. `mnH$s G$f^ZmW ho n{hbo VrWH$a AmhoV.
dY_mZ _hmdra ho Mmdrgmdo VrWH$a AmhoV. OZ XeZmW {XJ~a d doVm~a Ago XmoZ R>iH$ nW {XgyZ
òVmV. {XJ~a hUOo AJmda d Z R>odVm qhS>Umao d doVm~a hUOo ew^ d n[aYmZ H$aUmao hmoV.
OZmMo _ybJW AY_mJYr `m ^mfoV {b{hbo AmhoV. Aqhgm hm OZ gXmMmamMm nm`m Amho. OZmMo A`V
_hdmMo gy Amho. H$moU`mhr H$maMr qhgm Z H$aUo hm OZmMm _yb_ Amho. AZoH$mVdmX hm `mMm
_hdmMm {gmV Amho. AZoH$mVdmXmVyZ Z`dmX d `mXdmX hr XmoZ no {Z_mU hmoVmV. Z` hUOo Ae,
AJ qH$dm nmhUm`mMm {d{e> A{^m` hmo`. Z`dmXmMo _w` H$ma XmoZ nS>VmV `mZm `Z` d n`m`Z`
Ago hUVmV. `Z`mMo VrZ H$ma d n`m` Z`mMo Mma H$ma Ago {_iyZ Z`dmXmMo EHy$U gmV H$ma
nS>VmV `mZm ZJ_Z`, gJhZ`, `dhmaZ`, G$OygyZ`, eXZ`, g_{^$T>Z` d Ed^yVZ` Ago hUVmV.
`mXdmXmMohr gmV H$ma nS>VmV.
OZ VdkmZm_ò Ord Am{U AOrd Vdo _hdmMr AmhoV. Ord ho MoVZVd Amho d AOrd ho AMoVZ
Vd Amho. OrdmMo _w` H$ma XmoZ nS>VmV. `mZm ggmar Ord d _wV Ord Ago hUVmV. AOrdmMo EHy$U
nmM H$ma nS>VmV `mZm nwXJb, Y_, AY_, H$mb d AmH$me hUVmV.
3.7 gamdmgmR>r dm`m` :1)
OZ Y_mMr nanam {deX H$am.
2)
OZmMm AZoH$mVdmX n> H$am.
3)
OZm`m Aqhgm `m VdmMr _m{hVr m.
4)
OrdmMo H$ma CXmhaUmgh n> H$am.
5)
AOrdmMo H$ma n> H$am.
3.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$ :gd KQ>H$m`m eodQ>r nwVH$mMr `mXr {Xbr Amho.
666
33
KQ>H$ - 4
~m XeZ
( Buddhism )
4.0 C{>o
4.1 mVm{dH$ (OrdZdmmV)
4.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
4.2.1
Mma Am`gò
4.2.2
A>mJ _mJ
4.2.3
j{UH$dmX (A{Z`VmdmX)
4.2.4
AZm_dmX
4.2.5
{ZdmU gH$nZm
4.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z
4.6 gmame
4.0 C{Q>o :`m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZVa Amn`mbm * ~m Y_mMr {eH$dU g_Oob.
* OrdZ Xw:I_` Amho `mMr _m{hVr hmoBb.
* Xw:ImMr H$maUo g_OVrb d Xw:I {ZamoYmMo _mJ {_iVrb.
* AmnU AZw^drV AmhmoV Vo gwI jU{Odr Amho ho H$iob.
* _moj _mJ g_Oob.
4.1 mVm{dH$ (OrdZdmmV) :^JdmZ JmV_~w hm ~m XeZmMm gWmnH$ Amho. `mMm O_ {Vnyd 7 `m eVH$mV Pmbm
Amho. hUOoM `mMm O_ [I.ny.563 `m dfu {h_mb`m`m nm``mer H${nbdVy `m ehamOdirb
bw{~Zr `m JmdmV Pmbm. `m`m AmBMo Zmd _m`mXodr d d{S>bmMo Zmd ewmoXZ Ago Amho. ewmoXZ hm j{`
Hw$imVrb AgyZ Vmo EH$ AmXe amOm hmoVm. JmV_m`m O_mZVa `mMr AmB _m`mXodr {hMo 7 {XdgmZr
34
{ZYZ Pmbo. `mZVa JmV_mMr _mder JmV_r {hZo `mMo nmbZnmofU Ho$bo. `mMo _yi Zmd {gmW Ago hmoVo.
{gmWmbm bhmZnUmnmgyZ qMVZmMr gd` hmoVr. Vmo gdgm_m` _wbm_mUo Ioi`mV a_V Zgo. Vmo
VmgZVmg `mZ_Z AdWoV Ago. `mMo {Mm ggmamV a_mdo hUyZ `m`m d{S>bmZr `mMm {ddmh j{`
amOHw$_mar èmoYam {hMo ~amo~a 16 `m dfu bmdyZ {Xbm. `mg EH$ _wbJm Pmbm. Varhr `mMo _Z
ggmamV a_oZm. _Z ggmamV a_mdo hUyZ `m`m d{S>bmZr Iyn `Z Ho$bo nU eodQ>r Vo `W R>abo.
EHo$ {Xder Vmo aWmVyZ ~mhoa OmV AgVmZm `mbm {Za{Zam`m doir VrZ ò {Xgbr. Vr Aer 1) dmY`mZo dmH$bobm, aV d _mg H$_r Pm`mZo eara ewH$ Pmbobm, XmV nS>bobm, Ho$g {nH$bobm,
EoH$m`bm Z òUmam Agm EH$ OI hmVmam `mZo nm{hbm. 2) Xwg`m {Xder a`mda H$$U dmUrZo
AmH$moe H$aUmam EH$ amoJJV _mUyg `mZo nm{hbo. 3) {Vg`m {Xder H$U AmH$moe H$aUm`m kmVr
~mYdmZr doT>bobo EH$ oV `mZo nm{hbo. hUOoM earam`m dmY`, amoJJVVm d _`y `m VrZ AdWm
`m`m >rg nS>`m. Aem Xw:Ir `mZr `m`m _Zmda Imob n[aUm_ Pmbm.
Jh`mJ :gmar H${nbdVy {Zo`m AYrZ Pmbr AgVmZm Amn`m H$WH$ `m bmS>`m KmoS>mda dma hmoD$Z
N>XH$ `m gma`mbm ~amo~a KoD$Z _àmr Vmo ~mhoa nS>bm. WmoS>m dmgmZVa `mZo KmoS>mbm d gma`mbm
aOm {Xbr. `mZo XmT>r d S>mo`mMo _wT>Z Ho$bo Amnbr amOdo EH$m {eH$m`mbm XoD$Z `mMr _{bZ do
n[aYmZ Ho$br. eodQ>r Vmo nmQ>`m`m X{jUog Agbo`m C$dobm òWo Ambm. VoWo `mbm AmUIr nmM
gmYH$ ôQ>bo. earambm ZmZm H$mao boe XoD$Z na_mVrgmR>r Vo `Z H$aV hmoVo. `m`m_mUo Vmo
Cnmg-Vnmg H$$ bmJbm. `m_wio `mMo eara ApWnOa Pmbo. `mdoionmgyZ JmV_mZo R>a{dbo H$s,
na_mVrgmR>r eara nrS>m hm _mJ Zho. H$Vr dm`mgmR>r `mo` Amhma Ko`mMm `mZo {ZU` KoVbm.
Cdobm `m IoS>mOdirb {ZOZ ^mJmV Vmo EH$m qnnim`m PmS>mImbr `mZ bmdyZ ~gbm (`mbmM
AmnU ~moYrdj hUVmo). `m {R>H$mUr `mbm Am_gmjmH$ma Pmbm d `mbm ~wd mV Pmbo. kmZ mV
Pmbo. `m kmZmVr`m doir, nwZO_m`m \o$`mVyZ hmoUmar n[a^_Uo, Xw:ImMo _yi H$maU Am{U `m
Xw:ImMm g_yi Zme H$aUmam Cnm` `mMr `mbm OmUrd Pmbr. `mVyZM `mbm na_~moY Pmbm. AmnUmg
mV Pmbobo kmZ BVamZm Xo`mgmR>r Vmo ~mhoa nS>bm. VoWyZ Vmo ~Zmag òWo Ambm. VoWo `mg nydu gmoSy>Z
Jobobo Vo nmM {^jwH$ ôQ>bo. dV: Oo kmZ mV Pmbo hmoVo `m`mg~Yr n{hbo dMZ `m nmM Vn`m`m
g_moa {Xbo. `m n{h`m dMZmg "Y_MH$ dVZ' Ago hUVmV. ~wmbm `m g`mMm gmjmH$ma Pmbm Vo
hUOo, "`m OJmV Oo Oo hUyZ H$mhr Amho Vo gd A{Z`, j{UH$ d ZmedV Amho. `m {ddmV gd KQ>Zm
{Z`_mZwgma KS>VmV. Bda dJao H$moUrhr {ddmMm d _mZdmMm H$Vm d {Z`Vm Zmhr. ho OJ gVV ~XbUm`m
dmhmgmaIo Amho. `mV {Z`, emdV Ago H$mhrM ZgVo. _mZdmMo gd {dMma, ^mdZm, BN>m d AmgVr
`m`m Xw:Imbm H$maUr^yV AgVmV d `mnmgyZ _mZdmbm _wV hmoVm òVo d Vmo `mnmgyZ _wV Pmbm Va
VrM AIS> emVr ({ZdmU) AgVo. Aem H$ma`m mV Pmbo`m kmZmMm CnXoe `mZo O_â Ho$bm.
eodQ>r {Vnyd 483 _ò d`m`m 80 `m dfu `mMo {ZYZ Pmbo. `mbm Oo kmZ mV Pmbo `mbm
Am`gò hUVmV. hoM JmV_mMo VdkmZ hmo`.
4.2 {df` {ddoMZ
4.2.1 Mma Am`gò ~wmZo Or Mma gò gm{JVbr Vr Mma Am`gò hUyZ AmoiIbr OmVmV. gmaZmW òWrb n{h`m
35
dMZmV ~wmZo Mma Am`g`mMm CnXoe Ho$bm. Vr Mma Am`gò nwT>rb_mUo AmhoVA) gd Xw:I_ ~) Xw:I H$maU_ H$) Xw:I {ZamoY S>) Xw:I {ZamoYmMo _mJ
A)
gd Xw:I_ -
Xw:I ho n{hbo Am`g` Amho. ~wmZo _mZdr OrdZmMo {ZarjU d qMVZ Ho$bobo hmoVo. `m qMVZmVyZ
`mZr Agm {ZH$f H$mT>bm H$s, _mZdr OrdZ Xw:I_` Amho. Xw:Im~b ~wmZo Amnbo _V nwT>rb_mUo
_mS>bo Amho *
OJmV gd Xw:I âbobo Amho.
O_, Oam, `mYr Am{U _`y hr gJir Xw:Io hmoV.
O_m~amo~a Xw:I AgVo.
{ddg hm Xw:IXm`r AgVmo.
gwIXm`H$ Jmo>rnmgyZ ApbV hmoUo Xw:IXm`H$ AgVo.
BN>o_mUo Z hmoUo qH$dm Z {_iUo ho Xw:I hmo`.
A{ZN>mnydH$ Hw$R>`mhr Jmo>rer g~Y òUo Xw:IH$maH$ AgVo.
A{`mMm g`moJ hmoUo d {`mMm {d`moJ hmoUo ho Xw:I Amho.
Xw:I ~moMVo, Q>moMVo, gbV amhVo hUyZ Xw:I ho Am`g` Amho.
~)
Xw:I H$maU_ -
Xw:Imbm H$maU Amho ho Xwgao Am`g` Amho. `m {ddmV {ZH$maU H$moUVrhr KQ>Zm KSy> eH$V Zmhr.
AH$maU EImXr KQ>Zm KS>br Ago hmoUo e` Zmhr, Ago ~wmMo n> _V Amho. gmh{OH$M Xw:I hr KQ>Zm
Ag`m_wio {hbm gwm H$maU ho AgboM nm{hOo. BN>m d O__`yMr oaUm hr XmoZ _hdmMr Xw:I H$maUo
~wmZr gm{JVbobr AmhoV.
nwhm nwhm CnZ hmoUmar Am{U AZoH$ {df` Cn^moJmV aJyZ d $VyZ ~gUmar BN>m hrM Xw:ImMr
OZZr Amho. `m BN>obm ~w VUm Ago hUVmV. hUyZ ~w hUVmV, gd H$maMr VUm hr Xw:ImMo _yi
qH$dm H$maU Amho. VUm VrZ H$maMr AgVo 1)
H$m_VUm - gwI Cn^moJmgmR>r bmJbobr VUm.
2)
^dVUm - ApVdmgmR>r bmJbobr VUm.
3) {d^dVUm - ^d Zmhrgo H$a`mMr VUm (YZmMr BN>m d Eod` `m VUm _mZdmbm Hw$R>bohr
H$m` H$a`mg dm H$aVmV Am{U `mVyZ Xw:I {Z_mU hmoVo.) m VUmM gd Xw:ImMo Am[U O__`yMohr
H$maU AmhoV.
gd Xw:ImMo _yi H$maU A{dm _mZbo Amho. A{do_wio gH$ma, gH$mam_wio {dkmZ, {dkmZm_wio
Zm_n, Zm_nm_wio fS>m`VZo (nmM kmZ|{ò d _Z), fS>m`VZm`m `moJo ne, nem_wio doXZm, doXZo_wio
VUm, VUo_wio CnmXmZ, CnmXmZ_wio ^d, ^dm_wio OmVr qH$dm O_, O_m_wio Oam-_aUm{XH$ Xw:Io Aer
~mam H$maUmMr _m{bH$m ~wmZo gm{JVbobr Amho. `m H$maU nanaobmM "{V`g_wnmX' Ago hQ>bo Amho.
36
VgoM `m _m{bHo$Vrb òH$ Xw`mbm "{ZXmZ' hUyZ g~mo{Ybo Amho. `mM_mUo `m ~mam Xw`m`m
nanaobm "mXe {ZXmZ' ho Zmd {Xbobo Amhoo. `mMr g{dVa _m{hVr Imbrb_mUo Xw:ImMr ~mam H$maUo (mXe {ZXmZ) 1)
A{dm -
Xw:ImMo _yi H$maU A{dm hmo`. A{doMm CJ_ AhH$mamVyZ {Z_mU hmoVmo. AhH$ma hUOo _r Am{U
_mPo (__d) `mMm CJ_ Agbobr Am_H$nZm hUOo A{dm hmo`.Mma Am`g`mg~YrMo AkmZ hUOo
A{dm Agmhr AW gm{JVbobm Amho. A{doMr H$maUo hUyZ nmM {ZdmaUo {Xbobr AmhoV. {ZdmaU hUOo
AmN>mXZ qH$dm nS>Xm hmo`. Vr Aer - H$m_mN>X, `mnmX, Am`, Hw$w$, `moZ{_. `mMo n>rH$aU
nwT>rb_mUo1)
H$m_mN>X - hUOo {df` Cn^moJmMr _Zmbm bmJbobr MQ>H$ qH$dm Am`{VH$ AmdS> hmo`.
2)
`mnmX - hUOo ZmdS>`m dVw{df`r qH$dm `Vr{df`r dmQ>Umam of hmo`.
3)
Am` - hUOo {MmmMr MMbVm Agm AW KoVbobm Amho.
4)
Hw$w$M - hUOo _ZmMr Mwi~wi. AmnU H$arV AmhmoV Vo ~amo~a Amho H$s MyH$ Amho Aem ge`mV
nS>`mMr ImoS> hmo`.
5)
`moZ{_ - hUOo _ZmMm OS>nUm Am{U AmiernUm hmo`.
hr nmM {ZdmaUo eara, dmUr Am{U {dMma `m`m mam Ho$bo`m nmnmZr nwQ> Ho$br OmVmV. B{ò
Vm`mV Z R>odUo, dmBQ> gH$mamMm A{JH$ma H$aUo, Y_mMr {eH$dU Z EoH$Uo, {^jyMm AmXa Z H$aUo Aer Vr
nmno hmoV. Aem H$mao A{doVyZ Xw:I {Z_mU hmoV AgVo.
2)
gH$ma :-
A{dm ho gH$mamMo H$maU AgVo. hUOoM A{donmgyZ gH$ma {Z_mU hmoVmV. gH$ma hUOo
{Za{Zam`m {df`m`m g~YmZo CnZ hmoUmao gy_ d$nmVrb amJ, of, _moh ho {dH$ma AmhoV. `mVyZ
Xw:I {Z_mU hmoVo.
3)
{dkmZ :-
`m gmIirVrb {Vgam Xwdm hUOo {dkmZ hmo`. gH$ma$nr {dH$mamVyZ (amJ, of, _moh) ApVdmMr
OmUrd {Z_mU hmoVo. _r Amho AWdm nXmW AmhoV Aem `m OmUrdoMo d$n AgVo. `m ApVdm`m OmUrdog
{dkmZ hUVmV. `mVyZ Xw:I {Z_mU hmoVo.
4)
Zm_n :-
`m gmIirVrb MmWm Xwdm hUOo Zm_n hmo`. {dkmZm_wio Zm_n ho H$m` KS>Vo. Zm_ hUOo
_Z:qnS> d n hUOo earaqnS> hmo`. _Z:qnS> hm kmVm (OmUUmam) AgVmo Va earaqnS> hm ko` {df`
AgVmo. kmVm IoarO ko` ho AWhrZ R>aVo. hUyZ Zm_n d {dkmZ ho nanamda Adb~yZ AgVo. {dkmZ ho
dVnUo ApVdmV Agy eH$V Zmhr `mbm AmYmamgmR>r Zm_nmMr Amd`H$Vm AgVo.
37
5)
fS>m`VZ :-
Zm_nmVyZ hUOo _Z:qnS>mVyZ d earaqnS>mVyZ nwT>o ghm H$maMr kmZ|{ò d `mMr ghm H$m`joo {Z_mU
hmoVmV. `m_ò nMkmZ|{ò (S>moim, H$mZ, ZmH$, Or^ d dMm) d _Z `mMm g_mdoe hmoVmo.
6)
ne :-
S>moim, ZmH$, H$mZ, dMm d Or^ ({Ohm) Am{U _Z `m ghm B{`mMm `m`m $n (nmhUo), EoH$Uo,
JY, ag, ne d Y_ `m {df`mer hmoUmam g`moJ hUOo ne hmo`. kmZ{H$òV ne hm \$ma _hdmMm
Amho. H$maU `m_wio ~m OJV d `m OJmVrb dVy `mMm fS>`VZmVrb B{`mer g~Y òVmo. WmoS>`mV
B{`, `mMm {df` d `m B{`m_m\$V H$m_ H$aUmao {dkmZ `m {VhtMr gJVr hUOo ne hmo`.
7)
doXZm :-
doXZm hUOo gwIXw:ImMm AZw^d òD$ bmJUo hmo`. ~m OJVmVrb dVyer g~Y Am`mZVa
doJdoJ`m H$ma`m doXZm {Z_mU hmoVmV. `m doXZm gwIH$maH$ d Xw:IH$maH$hr AgVmV. hUOoM doXZoVyZ
gwIXw:ImMm AZw^d òD$ bmJVmo. `m doXZo_wio `Vr hr OJVmer A[YH$m{YH$ EH$$n hmoD$ bmJVo.
8)
VUm :-
VUm hr doXZoVyZ {Z_mU hmoVo Am{U hr VUm OJVmVrb Xw:ImMo _wI H$maU ~ZVo. doXZonmgyZ VUm
{Z_mU hmoD$ md`mMr H$s Zmhr ho `m `Vr`m hmVmV AgVo. `m VUo_wioM _Zw` OJVmVrb òH$
Jmo>t`m _mJo _yImgmaIm bmJVmo. VUo_wio _Zw` Am_m d Bda `mgma`m Jmo>t`m emoYmV amhVmo.
VUm hr EH$gmaIr dmT>V amhVo. `m VUm VrZ H$ma`m AgVmV (H$m_VUmm, ^dVUm, {d^dVUm)
`mMm CboI _mJo òD$Z JobobmM Amho. Oohm VUoda AmnU {dO` {_i{dVmo `mdoir gd Xw:Io Zmhrer
hmoVmV. `m_mUo H$_bnwnmdarb Xd d[aV JiyZ nS>Vmo `m_mUo VUodaVr {ZÙ R>od`mZo gd Xw:Io
d[aV Zmhrer hmoVmV.
9)
CnmXmZ :-
* CnmXmZ ho VUoMoM EH$ n Amho. VUoMr Am`{VH$ AdWm hUOo CnmXmZ hmo`. CnmXmZ hUOo
A{VVUm. CnmXmZmMm AW AmgVr Agmhr Ho$bm OmVmo. ApVdmgmR>r bmJbobr VUm hUOohr CnmXmZ
hmoVo.
* Or gwIo mV Pmbobr AmhoV Vr gwIo H$Yrhr ZQ> hmoD$ ZòV, qH$~hZm `mnojm A{YH$ _mUmV
gwIo mV hmdrV hm h`mg hUOo CnmXmZ hmo`.
* VUmZr hm CnmXmZm`m BYZmZo d{bV hmoVo Ago ~w EHo$ {R>H$mUr hUVmo. `m `m {R>H$mUr
A{ `m `m {R>H$mUr BYZ ho AgVoM Am{U hUyZ `m `m {R>H$mUr VUm AgVo `m `m {R>H$mUr CnmXmZ
AgVo. `m CnmXmZm_wio Ord ~m dVyV A{YH$m{YH$ Jwa\$Q>V OmVmo. ~YZmg nm R>aVmo `mgmR>r CnmXmZmnmgyZ
dV:hZ _wV Pm`mIoarO `Vrg _moj {_iV Zmhr.
* CnmXmZmMo Mma H$ma _mZVm òVmV Vo Ago. 1) H$m_ CnmXmZ 2) >r CnmXmZ 3) erbdV
CnmXmZ 4) Am_dmX CnmXmZ.
1) H$m_ CnmXmZ - B{` Cn^moJm~b Agbobr AmgVr hm n{hbm H$ma hUOo H$m_ CnmXmZ. ho
I`m AWmZo VUm hmo`. BVa VrZ H$ma AkmZmVyZ {ZKmbobo AmhoV.
38
2) >r CnmXmZ - nmIS>r _Vm~b`m AmdS>rZo Ambobr AewMr AmgVr hUOo >r CnmXmZ hmo`.
3) erbdV CnmXmZ - nmIS>r bmoH$mZr Amn`m ò` mVrgmR>r A{JH$mabobo AmMmaY_ d dVdH$ò
`m~bMr AmgVr hUOo erbdV CnmXmZ hmo`.
4) Am_dmX CnmXmZ - Am`m`m ApVdmda Agbobm {ddmg hUOo Am_dmX CnmXmZ hmo`.
10) ^d :AmgVr _YyZ nwZO_mg H$maUr^yV R>aUmao Oo H$_ KS>Vo `mg ^d Ago hQ>bo Amho. ^d hm
CnmXmZmVyZ {Z_mU hmoVmo. ^dmMm n[aUm_ hUyZ nwhm nwhm O_ `mdm bmJVmo Am{U `mVyZ hmVmanU,
amoJ Am{U _`y hr Xw:Io ^moJmdr bmJVmV.
11) Om{V :^d _YyZ OmVr {Z_mU hmoVo. Om{V hUOo O_. ^dm`m H$_m_wioM mUr O_mg òVmo. ho O_mg
òUo hUOoM Om{V hmo`. Omon`V _Zw` O_ _`y`m MH$mV AS>H$bobm AgVmo Vmon`V Vmo _mojmnmgyZ
A{bV amhVmo.
12) Oam - _aU :Oam `mMm AW dmY` Agm eXem AW KoVbm OmVmo. nwZO_ ho Xw:ImMo H$maU AgVo. EH$Xm O_
_`y`m MH$mV _Zw` AS>H$bm H$s `mbm hmVmanU d _`y `m ~m~r AmnmoAmnM òD$Z {MH$Q>VmV. `mVyZ
_Zw`mbm nwhm nwhm O_ `mdm bmJVmo d nwZO_mZo Xw:I ^moJmdo bmJVo.
^dMH$ :`m ~mam {ZXmZmMr VrZ O_mV {d^mJUr Ho$bobr Amho. hUyZ `mbm O_` Ago hUVmV. `m
O_`mbm `mnUm`m `m ~mam {ZXmZm`m _m{bHo$bm ^dMH$ hUVmV.
mXe - {ZXmZmMr {Vbmo_ H$_mZo _mS>Ur :mXe - {ZXmZmMr CbQ>m H$_mZo hUOo {Vbmo_ H$_mZo _mS>Ur H$aUo g_O`m`m >rZo A{YH$
gw~moY R>aVo. Vr Aer H$aVm òVo - 12) Amnbm O_ hm dmY`, _`y, amoJ `m_wio Xw:I_` ~ZVmo
(Oam_aU). 11) AmnUmg Xw:I ^moJmdo bmJVo H$maU AmnU O_mbm òVmo (Om{V) 10) _r O_mbm òVmo
H$maU _r `m OJmV AgVmo (^d) 9) _r `m OJmV OJVmo H$maU _bm `m OJm{df`r AmgVr, o_ dmQ>Vo
(CnmXmZ) 8) _r OJVmo H$maU _bm AZoH$ BN>m d dmgZm AgVmV (VUm) 7) _bm BN>m hmoVmV H$maU
_bm gdoXZ hmoV AgVo (doXZm) 6) _bm gdoXZ hmoVo H$maU _mPm OJmer g~Y òVmo (ne) 5) _mPm `m
OJmer g~Y òVmo H$maU _bm ghm B{Xò AgVmV (fS>m`VZ) 4) _mPm `m OJmer g~Y òVmo H$maU ho
Zm_nmMo OJ AgVo (Zm_n) 3) _r EH$ OmUUmar `Vr Ag`mZo _mPm Zm_$nm_H$ OJmer g~Y
òVmo. _bm OmUrd Ag`mZo ho OJ _bm g_Oy eH$Vo ({dkmZ) 2) ho {dkmZ qH$dm hr OmUrd nydO_r`m
gH$mam_wio {Z_mU hmoVo (gH$ma) 1) `m gdmMo _yi H$maU _bm _mPo dV:{df`rMo Ag`kmZ qH$dm
AkmZ AgVo (A{dm).
H$)
Xw:I{ZamoY :-
~wmZo gm{JVbobo ho {Vgao Am`g` hmo`. `mV `mZo Xw:ImMm gnyU Cne_ (Zme) H$amdm Ago
gm{JVbo Amho. Xw:ImMm gnyU Cne_ H$amdm hUOoM dmgZm, VUm, Am_o_ `m gd JmoQ>r Z> H$amd`mg
39
nm{hOoV. VUoMm Zme Pmbm hUOo gd Xw:ImMm AV hmoD$Z {ZdmU mV hmoBb. VUm ZmemZo _Zw` gd
Xw:ImVyZ _wV hmoVmo. O__`y`m MH$mVyZ gwQ>Vmo Am{U kmZ mV hmoD$Z AIoa {ZdmUV OmVmo.
AhH$ma Z> Ho$`mZo d g`{df`H$ o_ R>od`mZo Xw:ImMm Zme hmoVmo. amJ, of, ge` `m gdmMm
`mJ Ho$`mZo {ZdmUV OmVm òVo. {ZdmU AdWoV dmgZm gXoh, B{` gwIo, B`mXtMm Zme Pmbobm
AgVmo. `m AdWobm ~w ew`mdWm hUVmo. ew`mdWoV EH$ H$maMr emVr {_iVo.
S>)
Xw:I {ZamoYmMo _mJ :-
ho MmWo Am`g` hmo`. Xw:I {ZamoY hm hmoD$ eH$Vmo. BVHo$M Zho Va `m Xw:I_mJmnmgyZ Amnbr
gwQ>H$mhr H$$Z KoVm òVo. Xw:I {ZamoY H$a`mMm Omo _mJ ~wmZr gm{JVbm `mbmM Xw:I {ZamoY _mJ Ago
hUVmV. `mbmM Am` A>m{JH$ _mJ qH$dm _`_ {VnX Agohr hUVmV. `mMr _m{hVr nwT>rb_mUo
Amho.
4.2.2 A>mJ _mJ :Xw:I {ZamoY H$a`mMm Omo _mJ ~wmZr gm{JVbm `mbm Am` A>m{JH$ _mJ hUVmV. JmV_ ~wmZr
Amn`m n{h`m dMZmV gd _mZd OmVr`m H$`mUmgmR>r gXmMmamMm _mJ H$WZ Ho$bm. `mMr AmR> AJo
Ag`mZo `mbm A>m{JH$ _mJ Ago hUVmV.~wmZo Ho$di Xw:ImMr H$maUo gm{JVbr ZmhrV Am{U OrdZmH$S>o
Ho$di Xw:I_` ^y{_Ho$VyZM nm{hbo Zmhr Va `m Xw:ImMm Zme hmo`mgmR>r Am{U OJmH$S>o AmemXm`r >rH$moZmVyZ
nmh`mgmR>r ~wmZo Xw:I {ZamoYmMo AmR> _mJ gm{JVbo AmhoV. `mbm A>m{JH$ _mJ qH$dm _`_ {VnX
Ago hUVmV. `mMr AmR> AJo nwT>rb_mUo AmhoV 1) g`H$ Q>r
2) g`H$ gH$n
3) g`H$ dmMm
4) g`H$ H$_mV
5) g`H$ AmOr{dH$m
6) g`H$ `m`m_
7) g`H$ _Vr
8) g`H$ g_m{Y
1) g`H$ >r :* g`H$ eXmMm AW "`mo`' Agm KoVbm OmVmo. g`H$ >r hUOo `mo` (MmJbr) >r hmo`.
g`H$ >r hUOo Mma Am`g`mMo kmZ hmoUo hmo`. dV _Z Am{U {dMma g`H$ >rbm Amd`H$
AmhoV.
* `m {ddmV Oo Oo H$mhr KS>Vo `mMr Cnmr hmoVo. Vo EH$gmaIo ~XbV amhVo d gnw>mV òVo. hr
{ZgJmMr {H$`m Amho. hr AerM MmbV amhVo d MmbV amhUma d hUyZ H$emMmhr emoH$ dmQy>Z Ko`mZo
Xw:Im`{V[aV H$mhrhr hmVr òUma Zmhr. `mMr Imr hmoUo ho g`H$ >rZoM e` hmoVo. {ZgJ {Z`_m{d$
H$moUVrhr Jmo> hmoV Zmhr ho bjmV R>odmdo.
* g`H$ >r AYlobm Xya gm$Z _mUgm`m {dMmamZm ~wrnm_m`dmXr diU bmdVo. gmamgma
{ddoH$ ~miJyZ, Hw$R>bohr Q>moH$ Z JmR>Vm g_Vmob gmYUmam dVZ `dhma gmY`mda òWo â {Xbobm Amho.
* g`H$ >rMo A`V `mnH$ d$nmV "g_m{X{>gwmm' _ò gm[anwmmZo Vnerbdma dUZ Ho$bo
Amho. ~amo~a H$m` Amho d MwH$sMo H$m` Amho ho H$go g_Om`Mo `m{df`r {ddoMZ H$aVmZm Ago hQ>bo Amho
H$s, qhgm H$aUo, Mmoar H$aUo, b{JH$ `{^Mma, Ag` ^mfU H$aUo, qZXm H$aUo, H$R>moa dmJUo, H$S>m
{nH${dUo, bmo^ ~miJUo, {VaH$ma H$aUo, ^_mV amhUo ho XwJwU AmhoV. `m gdmMo _yi bmo^, of, _moh ho
40
AmhoV d `m`mnmgyZ gd XwJwUmMm CX` hmoVmo. hUyZ Aem XwJwUmMm bmon Pm`mZVa `m H$Vr Ho$`m
OmVmV `m {ZXm}f amhVmV d `m H$Vr gXJwUm`m AgVmV ho H$iUo hUOo g`H$ >r hmo`.
2)
g`H$ gH$n :-
* g`H$ gH$n hUOo `mo` ò`, C{MV AmH$mjm R>oD$Z `mZwgma dmQ>Mmb H$aUo hmo`. òH$mZo
ew^H$m_Zm, ew^ AmH$mjm, m`m{df`r o_ ^mdZm, ew hoVy `mMm gH$n H$amdm Am{U `mZwgma Amnbo
AmMaU R>odmdo.
* g`H$ >r Agbo`m gmYH$mMm {ZdmU mV H$$Z Ko`mMm T> {ZM` hUOo g`H$ gH$n
hmo`.
* g`H$ >r {dH${gV H$arV AgVmZm {dMmamZm gH$nm`m gmmZo ZrQ> {Xem XoD$Z `m`mV
g_d` KS>{dUo Amd`H$ AgVo. dmWunUm _ò AmS>dm Z AmUVm gH$nm`m gmmZo {dMmam_ò
gwgdmX KS>dyZ AmUmd`mg nm{hOo.
3)
g`H$ dmMm :-
* g`H$ dmMm hUOo `mo` ^mfU hmo`. hUOoM ImoQ>o Z ~mobUo, A{` Z ~mobUo, naqZXm Z H$aUo,
H$Qy> eX Z ~mobUo, `W ~S>~S> Z H$aUo, B`mXtMm g_mdoe g`H$ dmMm _ò òVmo.
* EH$mZo Xwg`m{df`r dmBQ> ~moby Zò. gdmer AmnwbH$sZo d gmO`mZo ~mobyZ g`H$ dmMm _mJmMo
nmbZ H$amdo.
* òH$mZo `mo` Am{U g` ~mobmdo. AneX`wV qZXmZmbVr Q>mimdr. hm _mJ g_mO dm`mgmR>r
A`V CnH$maH$ Amho.
4)
g`H$ H$_mV :-
* g`H$ AmMaUmgmR>r "g`H$ H$_mV' hm eX `moObm Amho. `m_ò Xwg`mMo mU Z KoUo, Mmoar
Z H$aUo, B{`mda g`_ R>odUo `m JmoQ>r òVmV.
* g`H$ H$_mV `m eXmMm AW `mo` dVZ Agm hmoVmo. òH$mZo Xwg`mMo hH$ Am{U ^mdZm
`mMm AmXa amIyZ H$Vr H$amdr.
* OrdZm`m _yb^yV {Z`_mer gwgJV dVZ hUOo g`H$ H$_mV hmo`. g_mO YmaUobm nmofH$
Agm hm _mJ Amho. gH$_mMo H$m`rH$, dm{MH$ d _mZ{gH$ Ago H$ma AmhoV. WmoS>`mV Hw$H$_mnmgyZ
òH$mZo Xya am{hbo nm{hOo.
* gdgm_m` _mUgmgmR>r d gdgm_m` `dhmamgmR>r ~wmZr H$mhr {Z`_ gm{JVbo AmhoV Vo Ago
1) AmB d{S>bmZr Amn`m _wbmZm nmnr AmMaUmnmgyZ namdm H$amdo Am{U `m`m_ò A{YH$m{YH$ MmJbo
JwU H$go òVrb `m>rZo `Z H$amdoV. {ejU gn`mda hUOo `mo` d`mV Am`mda `mMm {ddmh H$amdm. _wbmZrhr
dmnH$mir Amn`m AmBd{S>bmMr d nmbH$mMr `mo` H$miOr `mdr.
2) {dm`mZo Jw{df`r AmXa R>odmdm. `m`m Amkm nmim`mV d `m`m JaOm nyU H$am`mV. Jw
`m_mUo gmJob `m_mUo A``Z H$amdo. JwZohr {dm`mer o_nydH$ `dhma H$amdm. `mZm em,
H$bm, B`mXr_ò nmaJV H$amdo. `m`m_ò MmJ`m MmJ`m gd`r {Z_mU H$a`mMm `Z H$amdm.
41
3) nVrZo nZrer AmXa^md ~miJmdm d {V`mer EH${Z> ahmdo. {V`m gd H$`mUmMr O~m~Xmar
`mdr. nZrZohr nVrer o_nydH$ dVZ Ho$bo nm{hOo. KamMr gnyU H$miOr KoVbr nm{hOo. gd A{VWtMm
`mo` g_mZ Ho$bm nm{hOo.
* `m{edm` gmYwbmoH$mZrhr g`H$ H$_m~m~V H$mhr {Z`_ nmiUo Amd`H$ Amho Ago ~w _mZVmo.
`m`m _Vo gmYw bmoH$mZr Amhma, {dhma, gm_m{OH$ gKf, gmX`mMr H${_ gmYZo dmnaUo, XmJXm{JZo,
gmoZo, e`mgmo~V B`mXrnmgyZ A{bV am{hbo nm{hOo.
5)
g`H$ AmOr{dH$m :-
* g`H$ AmOr{dHo$g "g`H$ {Zdmh' Agohr hQ>bo Amho. AmnU `mo` _mJmMm Adb~ H$$Z
Amnbr CnOr{dH$m Mmb{dUo hUOo g`H$ AmOr{dH$m hmo`.
* òH$mZo Amnbr CnOr{dH$m H$moUmdahr A`m` Z H$aVm, `mo` _mJmZo YZmVr H$$Z Am{U
Z{VH$Vm nmiyZ H$amdr. òH$mbm {OdV amh`mgmR>r YZmVrMr Amd`H$Vm AgVo. Mmoar, {eH$ma,
^>mMma `mgmaIr Hw$H$_} H$$Z YZ {_i{dUo `mo` Zmhr.
* AmOr{dH$m `m`nyU d g_mO_m` Agbr nm{hOo hUOoM g`H$ AmOr{dH$m hm Z{VH$VoZo
OJ`mMm _mJ Amho.
6)
g`H$ `m`m_ :-
* _ZmVrb Xw{dMma H$mTy>Z Q>mHy$Z `m {R>H$mUr ew^{dMmamMr WmnZm H$a`mgmR>r gVV `Zerb
amhUo hUOoM g`H$ `m`m_ hmo`.
* g`H$ `m`m_mMr Mma CnmJo AmhoV Vr Aer 1)
Amn`m AJmV Agbobo XwJwU Kmb{dUo.
2)
Amn`m AJmV Zgbobo gXJwU gnmXUo.
3)
Kmb{dbo XwJwU nwZ: Amn`mV òD$ Z Xo`mMm `Z H$aUo.
4)
gnmXZ Ho$bo`m gXJwUmMr OmonmgZm H$aUo.
* `mM~amo~a Am_{ZÙ, B{` gwImon^moJmMm `mJ H$aUo, dmBQ> BN>m _ZmV Z AmUUo, gnyU
H$`mUmgmR>r ew^{dMmamMr _ZmV n`ZnyydH$ {V>mnZm H$aUo, B`mXtMm g_mdoe hmoVmo.
* MmJ`m {dMmamda qMVZ H$aUo, H$VrMo n[aUm_ MmJbo H$s dmBQ> `mMm A`mg H$aUo, dmBQ>
{dMmamMr H$maUo emoYUo, _Zmda {ZÙ R>odUo `mgma`m ~m~tMm g_mdoe g`H$ `m`m_mV hmoVmo.
7)
g`H$ _Vr :-
* g`H$ _Vr hUOo gd Xw:I_` Amho. j{UH$ Amho, "_r' ZmdmMm H$moUr pWa nXmW Zmhr, dJao
Jmo>rMo gVV _aU R>odUo hmo`.
* {Mm pWa R>odyZ `mMr Mb{~Mb hmoD$ Z XoUo hUOo g`H$ _Vr hmo`.
* _ZmVrb XwQ> dmgZmda I~ra nhmam R>odUo, dmBQ> {dMmamMr hH$mbn>r H$aUo Am{U _Z gXd
OmJV R>odUo hUOo g`H$ dmr hmo`.
42
* gH$_mMo AmH$fU Am{U XwH$_mMm {VaH$ma Ho$`m_wio g`H$ `m`~wr {Z_mU hmoVo d `m_wio
_mZdr OrdZ {ZdmU nX mVrbm nm hmoVo, Agm {ddmg `m _mJmVyZ `V hmoVmo.
8)
g`H$ g_m{Y :-
* g`H$ g_m{Y hr A>mJ _mJmMr n[aUVr hmo`. `mZm`m Mma {Za{Zam`m AdWmVyZ Jo`mda
{MmmV Omo na_emVrMm (_Z:emVrMm) AZw^d òVmo `mbm g_m{Y AdWm hUVmV.
* `mZm`m Mma AdWm 1) n{h`m AdWoV Mma Am`gò d ~wmMr {eH$dU `mda emV {MmmZo `mZ H$amd`mMo AgVo
Am{U AZmgV {dMma {Z_mU H$$Z A{Vr` d$nmMm AmZX {Z_mU H$amd`mMm AgVmo.
2) Xwg`m AdWoV {dMma ho AZmd`H$ R>aVmV. hr _mUgmMr {dMmaa{hV AdWm AgVo. ge`mMo
{ZYmaU hmoD$Z Mma Am`g`mdarb lm ~iH$Q> hmoVo. koVyZ ZdrZ CmamMr {Z{_Vr hmoV AgVo. hr
AdWm mV Pm`mZVa {MmmV EH$ H$maMr emVVm d emdVVm {Z_mU hmoV AgVo.
3) `m AdWoV AmZX d {Mm EH$M AmhoV `mMr {MVr òVo. `m AdWoV {Mm ho EH$mJ hmoV AgVo.
4) gnyU emVrMr AdWm Mm`m AdWoV mV hmoVo. `mdoir gd H$ma`m gwIXw:ImMm Zme
Pmbobm AgVmo. VgoM _Zm`m gd dmr d C_u Z> Pmbo`m AgVmV. `m AdWoV nyUd, emVr AZw^yVrg
òVmV. `mVyZ {ZdmU mV hmoVo.
* g`H$ g_mYr `m eXmMm AW {MmmMr EH$mJVm Agm hmoVmo. _Zmbm MmJ`m Jmo>rMm {dMma
H$a`mMr gd` bmdUo, MmJbo diU bmdUo hUOo g`H$ g_mYr hmo`. {MmmMr Mb{~Mb Wm~{dUo hUOo
g`H$ g_mYr hmo`. Vr gm` H$a`mgmR>r AmYr gm{JVbo`m gmVhr _mJmMo `Wmo{MV AmMaU JmV_
~wmZm A{ôV Amho.
* EH$Xm `WmW Q>r mV Ho$br hUOo `WmW {ZM` H$aVm òVmV. `m_wio dm^m{dH$nUo `WmW
dmUr, `WmW H$_, `WmW H$_gmYZo `m`m{df`r OmJ$H$Vm {Z_mU hmoVo. `WmW qMVZ Am{U `Z `mMo
OmoS> {_imbr hUOo _mUyg g`H$ g_mYrbm nm hmoVmo. `m _mJmV B{` {ZJh Am{U _mZ{gH$ EH$mJVm `m
Jmo>rda â Xo`mV Ambobm Amho. `m`m_wio VUoda {dO` {_i{dVm òVmo. `mVyZ g`H$ g_mYrbm _mUyg
nm hmoVmo.
* YZmMm A`mg Mmby AgVmZm Mma H$ma`m ^mdZm _wm_ dqJV H$am`mV Ago gm{JVbo
Amho. `m Mma ^mdZm hUOo _r, H$Um, _w{XVm d Cnojm `m hmoV. mUr_mmda o_ H$amdo (_r) `mMr
Xw:Io bjmV KoD$Z `m`m{df`r X`m ~miJmdr (H$Um), `m`m gwImZr AmZXyZ Omdo (_w{XVm) d Ago
H$arV H$arV OJm{df`r Amn`m _ZmV Cnojm ~wr T> H$amdr, hUOoM {Mm pWa H$amdo (Cnojm) `mbmM
g_mYr Ago hUVmV.
4.2.3 j{UH$dmX (A{Z`dmX) :AW - ho OJ d `m OJmVrb gd dVy d KQ>Zm n[adVZerb (~XbUm`m) AmhoV. `m OJmVrb
òH$ Jmoo> {VjUr ~XbV AgVo. `m OJmV H$mhrhr pWa, {Z`, emdV, {Q>H$mD$ qH$dm A_a ZgVo.
Agm ~wmMm _hdmMm {gmV Amho. `mbmM j{UH$dmX qH$dm A{Z`dmX Ago hUVmV.
* ~m XeZmZwgma gd Y_ A{Z` AmhoV. EH$m jUmbm EH$ Y_ CnZ hmoVmo d Zme nmdVmo. `m
43
_Vmbm j{UH$dmX Ago hUVmV.

(Y_ hUOo `m H$emg "Amho' hUVm òBb
Vo, `mMm `` òVmo Vo, Oo dbjUmZo {d_mZ Amho Vo)
* OJmV Oo AZw^yVrg òVo Vo jUâM {Q>H$Vo. OJmV {Z` Ago H$mhrhr ZgVo. ~m XeZmV `mbm
gd j{UH$_ qH$dm gd_ A{Z` Ago hQ>bo Amho.
* OJmV gd dVy j{UH$ AmhoV, {Z` Ago H$mhrhr Zmhr (j{UH$dmX) ho gmJ`mgmR>r nwT>rb
`w{$dmX ~m XeZmV H$a`mV Ambobo AmhoV - 1) AW{H$`mH$m[ad `w{$dmX 2) AZw^dmYm[aV `w{$dmX.
1)
AW{H$`mH$m[ad `w{$dmX :-
OJmV Oo ApVdmV Amho, gV Amho nU Vo jUâM {Q>H$Vo (jUâ {Q>H$Vo `mMm AW òH$ Jmo>
{VjUr ~XbV AgVo Agm KoVbm Amho). EImXr Jmo> ApVdmV Amho `mMm AW `m Jmo>rV AW{H$`mH$m[ad
Agbo nm{hOo. ""AW{H$`mH$m[ad hUOo H$mhrVar KS>dyZ AmU`mMo gm_` hmo`. `mbmM H$m`monmXZ
j_Vm Ago hUVmV.'' (`m`m `moJo H$mhrM KS>V Zmhr Vo Agbo H$m` Am{U Zgbo H$m` Xmohrhr Jmo>r
gma`mM). {O`mmao H$mhrVar KSy>Z òVo hUOoM {O`mV AW{H$`mH$m[ad Amho VoM gV hmo` Am{U Vo
{VjUr ~XbUmao Amho, A{Z` Amho, jU^Jya Amho.
H$mhrVar KSy>Z òVo hUOo n{hbr Jmo> Z> hmoVo Am{U `mVyZ ZdrZ Jmo> {Z_mU hmoVo. {Z_mU Pmbobr
ZdrZ Jmo> jUâ {Q>H$Vo, Vr Z> hmoVo Am{U `mVyZ ZdrZ Jmo> {Z_mU hmoVo.
CXm.Oohm ~rOmVyZ AHy$a \w$Q>Vmo Vohm ~rO Z> hmoVo d AHy$a V`ma hmoVmo. H$mhrVar CnZ Ho$`m{edm`
ApVd Zmhr. nU Xwgao CnZ hmo`mgmR>r nyduMo Z> hmoUo Amd`H$ Amho. `mMmM AW Agm H$s, gd Y_
j{UH$ AmhoV.
Amjon - `mda H$mhrOU Agm Amjon KoVmV H$s, Hw$U`mV R>odbo`m {~`m`m {R>H$mUr AHw$amonmr ho
H$m` KS>dyZ AmU`mMo gm_` Amho. nU AHy$a {Z_mU Z H$aVm XoIrb {H$VrVar doi (jU) Vo ~rO VgoM
{Q>Hy$Z amhVo. Vo AHy$a {Z_mU H$aV Zmhr. Vo ~r ApVdmV Zmhr Ago hUVm òUma Zmhr. `m`m {R>H$mUr
H$m` KS>dyZ AmU`mMo gm_` Amho nU `mg j{UH$ hUVm òUma Zmhr.`m Amjonmg ~mmMo Cma gm_` Agob Va H$m` VH$mi KSy>Z AmboM nm{hOo. A_yH$ EH$ H$mbn`V Vo gm_` dmQ> nhmV amhVo Ago
_mZVm òUma Zmhr. H$maU A_yH$ EH$ H$mi bmoQ>bm ho `m gm_`mbm H$iUma H$go ? Vmo H$mi EdT>m qH$dm
VodT>m Ago hUVmM òUma Zmhr. Vgo hU`mgmR>r H$mhrVar KS>mdo bmJob. hUyZ nXmW `m jUmnmgyZ `m
jUmn`V ApVdmV Amho `mMm AW _`Var H$mhrVar KS>bo Amho AgmM hmoBb. Oohm H$mhr KS>Vo Vohm
nydjUrMm nXmW Z> hmoD$Z `m`m {R>H$mUr Xwgam CnZ Pmbm AgoM hUVm òBb. ho {dYmZ Hw$R>`mhr
jUmg~Yr H$aVm òVo. WmoS>`mV Oo gV Amho `m`m {R>H$mUr AW{H$`mH$m[ad Amho Am{U hUyZ Vo j{UH$
Amho. (gV --- AW{H$`mH$m[ad ---j{UH$Vm Agm `wVrdmX hmo`.)
2)
AZw^dmYm[aV `w{$dmX :-
* j{UH$Vog~YrMm Xwgam `w{$dmX _mS>VmZm ~w AZw^dmMm AmYma KoVmo. `m`m _Vo Amn`m
AZw^dmg òUm`m gdM Jmo>r ZmedV AmhoV. hUOoM `m jU^Jya AmhoV. `m OJmVrb gd dVy d KQ>Zm
n[adVZerb AmhoV. `m OJmVrb òH$ Jmo> {VjUr ~XbV AgVo, `m OJmV H$mhrhr pWa, {Z`,
emdV d {Q>H$mD$ Zmhr, Agm AZw^dmda AmYm[aV {gmV ~wmZo _mS>bm Amho. `mgM j{UH$dmX Ago
hUVmV.
44
* CXmhaUmXmIb ~w Ago hUVmo H$s, g_moaMm ndV XoIrb H$mhr bmI dfmZr ZQ> hmooUma Amho.
Vmo AJXr EH$m jUmV Z> hmoVmo Ago Zmhr Va Amn`m AZw^dmg Z òVm XoIrb Vmo ~XbV AgVmo. `m_ò
H$mhrVar XajUr \$aH$ nS>V AgVmo. hUOoM òH$jUr `m ndVmg Hw$R>bmgm-Hw$R>bmVar ~Xb Pmbobm
AgVmo. hm ~Xb hUOo n{hbm ndV Z> hmoUo d `mOmJr Xwgam ndV {Z_mU hmoUo ho hmo`. {Z` Agm ndV
H$moUmbmhr AZw^dmg òV Zmhr. WmoS>`mV OJmVrb H$moU`mhr dVyV H$mbmVamZo ~Xb hmoV amhUma ho
AZw^dmMo g` Amho.
Amjon - ~wm`m `mdarb _Vmda H$mhtZr Amjon KoVbm Amho Vmo Agm :
""{ZgJmMo {Z`_ ho _m j{UH$ d A{Z` ZgVmV. {ZgJmMo {Z`_ ho emdV d {Z` AgVmV. nU
`m {Z`_m_mUo hmoUm`m {d{e> KQ>Zm _m n[adVZerb d gVV ~XbV AgVmV. Vohm {Z`Vm d
A{Z`Vm `m XmoZ Jmo>r _m` H$am`m bmJVmV. Amn`m m _Vm`m nQ>rH$aUm gmR>r `mZr H$mhr
CXmhaUo nwT>rb_mUo {Xbobr AmhoV.
CXmhaU 1) nimnimZo {Xdg dmT>V AgVmo. nhmQ>, Cf:H$mb, gH$mi, Xwnma, {Vgam ha, g`mH$mi,
am, _àm, nwhm nhmQ> Ago {Xdg-amrMo MH$ A`mhVnUo {\$aV AgVo.
CXmhaU 2) g_wmbm âVr-AmohmoQ>r òVo. g_wm`m nm`mda Mgy`mMo AmH$fU H$m` H$arV
AgVo. g_wmMo nmUr dmT>Vo, _moR>_moR>m bmQ>m CgiyZ {H$Zm`mH$S>o YmdV òVmV, _moR>r JOZm H$aVmV d
nmUr \w$JVo `mbm âVr òVo hUVmV. âVr gnVmM AmohmoQ>r gw$ hmoVo d AmohmoQ>r gnVmM âVr gw$ hmoVo.
{XdgmVyZ XmoZXm âVr d XmoZXm AmohmoQ>r òVo. EH$doi KS>mi MwHo$b nU âVr-AmohmoQ>r`m doim MwH$V
ZmhrV.CXmhaU 3) dfmMr {d^mJUr ghm G$VyV Ho$bobr Amho. EH$ G$Vy gnVmM Xwgam G$Vy gw$ hmoVmo d
`mbm R>am{dH$ doir AV òVmo. òH$ G$VyMm H$mi XmoZ _{h`mMm AgVmo. dgV, Jr_, dfm, eaX, ho_V
d {e{ea ho G$Vy `mM H$_mZo Z MwH$Vm gmV`mZo hOmamo df} hmoV Ambobo AmhoV. CXmhaU 4) OrdmMr
{Z{_Vr, dmT>, O_ hmoUo d O_mZVa eed, ~m`, H$m_m`, `mdZ (Vm`), mT>d, dmY` d eodQ>r AV
hmoUo ho MH$ _mZd Y$Z gd {OdV m`mV Mmby AgVo.WmoS>`mV - {ZgJmMo {Z`_ gmV`mZo H$m` H$aVmV
d `mMo {Z`_ MH$ A`mhVnUo ([Z`{_V) {\$aV amhVo. `m OJmV n[adVZ gVV Mmby AgVo hm òH$mMm
AZw^d Amho. {ZgJmMo {Z`_ ho _m j{UH$ d A{Z` ZgVmV.
`m Amjonmg ~mmMo Cma - ~wmZo _m `mVrb n[adVZm`m ^mJmda Omoa {Xbm. `m OJmV gdM
~XbUmao, n[adVZerb d A{Z` AgVo. Aem {ddm`m J{V_mZVoMm _hdmMm {gmV _mS>bm Amho.
hUOoM "gd j{UH$_, gd A{Z`_ &' Amho Agm `mMm _yb^yV {gmV Amho.~w `mgmR>r CXmhaU XoVmo
Vo Ago - `moV OiV AgVo Vohm òH$ jUr Zdr `moV AgVo. Vr EH$M d pWa dmQ>V Agbr Var
òH$ jUr doJir d Zdr `moV V`ma hmoV AgVo. òH$ jUr Zdo H$U OiyZ `mVyZ H$me ~mhoa òV
AgVmo.VgoM ZXrMm dmhVm dmh Oar VmoM {XgV d dmQ>V Agbm Var `mVrb nmUr AIS>nUo dmhV
Ag`mZo `mV {Z` ZyVZVm AgVo. òH$ jUmbm ZdrZ nmUr dmhV d nwT>o gaH$V AgVo. WmoS>`mV
ZXrMo dmhVo nmUr qH$dm {X`mMr OiVr `moV Oar EH$M d VrM {XgV Agbr Var Vmo ^mg AgVmo d `mMo
{VjUr ~XbUmao $n hoM Iao AgVo Ago ~w hUVmo. hUOo ~wm`m _Vo n[adVZerbVm ho g` AgVo
Am{U {Z`Vm Ag` d ^mg_mZ AgVo, Agm AZw^dmYm[aV `w{$dmX _mS>bm Amho.
45
4.2.4 AZm_dmX :~m _V - dV: JmV_ ~w Am{U gd ~mY_u` ho Am_m _mZV ZmhrV. gd ~m nWmZm g_mZ
AgUmao AmUIr EH$ Vd hUOo AZm_dmX hmo`. `mbmM Theory of Nonsoul Ago hUVmV.AWmV ~w
hm Am_m _wirM _mZrV Zmhr Ago Zmhr, Va Vmo Am_m ZmdmMo {Z`, emdV, A{dH$mar, An[adVZr`
A{dZmer ` Amho ho drH$maV Zmhr. {ddmVrb òH$ Jmo>, dVy d KQ>Zm j{UH$, {VjUr ~XbUmar
Ag`mZo Am_mhr n[adVZm`m {Z`_mbm AndmX Zmhr. Am_mhr gVV ~XbUmam Amho Ago ~wmMo hUUo
Amho.
doXmVr _V - doXmVr _VmZwgma, Am_m hm EH$ pWa nXmW qH$dm ` Amho Ago _mZbo Amho. hUOoM
`m {R>H$mUr Am_m `mMm AW Ho$di gOrd nXmWm`m {R>H$mUr _mZbm OmUmam Am_m (self, soul) EdT>mM
Zmhr Va Am_m hUOo `m {Za{Zam`m Y_mMm AWdm JwUmMm AmnUmg `` òV amhVmo `mZm AmYma^yV
Agbobm EH$ pWa nXmW AWdm ` Agm Amho.
CXm. \y$b ho ` `m. `m_ò JY, aJ, ne, B`mXr JwUY_ amhVmV. hUOoM \w$bmMm AmnUmg
JY òVmo, aJ {XgVmo, ne OmUdVmo. nU `m JwUY_mZm AmYma^yV Agbobo \y$b ZmdmMo ` doJioM
AgVo. JwUY_ WmoS>o~hV ~XbVmV qH$dm n[adVuV hmoVmV. VarXoIrb hr n[adVZo `m`m Aml`mZo hmoVmV
Vo ` pWa amhVo Am{U `mbm \y$b Ago hUVmV. `mVrb \y$b ho ` hmo` d ho {Z` AgVo. `m_mUo
\y$b ho ` {Z` AgVo, `m`m AmYmamZo JwUY_ ~XbV AgVmV `m_mUo Am_m ZmdmMm EH$ {Z`
nXmW AgVmo d `m`m AmYmamZo amJ, of, B`mXr ^mdZm ~XbV AgVmV Ago doXmVr gmJVmV.
~m _V - ~mmZm {Z` Ago ` ZmH$mamd`mMo Amho. _J Vo OS> Agmo AWdm MoVZ Agmo. JY, aJ,
ne B`mXr JwUY_mhZ doJim Agm \y$b ZmdmMm H$mhr ` nXmW Zmhr. H$maU `mMm AmnUmg AZw^d
Zmhr Ago `mMo hUUo Amho. aJ, JY, ne, B`mXr Y_ Oa H$mTy>Z Q>mH$bo Va \y$b ZmdmMm nXmW
ApVdmV XoIrb amhUma Zmhr. `m {d{dY Y_mMm gKmV hUOo \y$b ho ` hmo` Am{U ho ` {Z` Ago
ZgVo. Omon`V JwUY_ {Q>Hy$Z AmhoV Vmon`V Vo AgVo.Or Jmo> \y$bmgma`m AMooVZ nXmWmMr VrM Jmo>
"_r', "Vy', XodXm `mgma`m MoVZ nXmWmMr AgVo. {VjUr {Z_mU hmoUm`m amJ, of, BN>m, gwI, Xw:I,
B`mXr {MmY_mZm AmYma^yV Aem EH$m pWa nXmWmMr AmnU H$nZm H$aVmo d `mg Am_m hUVmo. nU
{Za[Zam`m {MmY_m`m g_wX`mMm gKmV hUOo Am_m hmo` Ago ~wmMo _V Amho.
CXm. `m gX^mV JrH$ amOm {_btX d {^jy ZmJgoZ `mMr Jmo> {g Amho. Vr Aer, {_btX amOm
ôQ>md`mg Ambm AgVm ZmJgoZmZo Z {dMmabm, _hmamO AmnU H$go AmbmV ? amOm hUmbm, aWmVyZ
Ambmo. ZmJgoZ hUmbm, Zo_Ho$ aW H$emg hUmd`mMo ? aWmMr MmHo$ hUOo aW H$s H$Um hUOo aW H$s KmoS>o
hUOo aW B`mXr. aW hUOo Ho$di MmHo$, H$Um, KmoS>o `mnH$s H$moUVohr EH$ qH$dm `mMr ~oarO ZgyZ `m
gdmZm {_iyZ aW Ago hUVmV Ago {_btX amOm`m bjmV AmUyZ {Xbo.
`m_mUo _mUgmMo hmV, nm`, ZI, Ho$g, S>moHo$, S>moio, Vm|S>, B`mXr Ad`dm`m gKmVmhZ {^Z
Agm _mUyg (Am_m) H$moUrhr Zmhr. Am_m ZmdmMo {Z` Ago H$mhrhr Zmhr. `m_mUo OS> dVy`m Y_mZm
Hw$R>bohr AmYma ` Zmhr `m_mUo MoVZ dVy`m Y_mZm Hw$R>bohr AmYma ` Zmhr. Oo Amho Vo Y_mMo
(JwUmMo) gKmV d `m gKmVmMo gVmZ hmo` `m _Vmg AZm_dmX Ago hUVmV.
* Hw$R>bmhr Y_ Xwg`m Y_mda Adb~yZ AgVmo, Xwgam {Vg`mda, {Vgam Mm`mda Agm `m_ò
H$_ AgVmo. g_wmVrb EH$ bmQ> Xwg`m bmQ>og O_ XoVo, Xwgar {Vgarg `m_mUo Vr EH$ AIS> {H$`m
46
Mmby AgVo. `m_mUo EH$ Y_ Xwg`mg O_ XoVmo, Xwgam {Vg`mg O_ XoVmo. `m nmR>r_mJo d Agm
H$moUrhr ZgVmo `mbmM AZm_dmX Ago hUVmV.
* Iao nmhVm Cn{ZfXmV gm{JVbobm {Z`, pWa, emdV, A{dH$mar, `n qH$dm ~ Agm
Am_m Amho ho ~wmZo nyUnUoo ZmH$mabo AgyZ Vmo nwhm nwhm gmJVmo H$s, {MaH$mb {Q>H$Umam, {Z`, emdV,
{ZJwU d {ZamH$ma Am{U AZoH$ O_ KoUmam Agm Am_m Zmhr. AmnUmg Omo Am_m hUyZ dmQ>Vmo Vmo Ho$di
{VjUr ~XbV amhUmam "nMH$YmMm' gKmV Amho. `mnojm A{YH$ doJio H$mhr Zmhr. (nMH$Y - n,
doXZm, gkm, gH$ma d {dkmZ)
4.2.5 {ZdmU gH$nZm :{ZdmU hm ~mmMm _hdmMm {gmV Amho. ~wmZo `m Xw:I_` OJmnmgyZ _wV hmo`mMo ò` A{V_ d
gdm} Amho Ago gmJyZ Vo mV H$$Z Ko`mgmR>r Am` A>mJ_mJ gm{JVbm. {hXy Y_mV _moj qH$dm _wVr
ho A{V_ d na_moM ò` d AmXe g_Obm OmVmo. VgoM ~m Y_mV {ZdmUmbm na_moM WmZ Amho.
_mZdmZo gd {_idm`Mo kmZ, H$amd`mMo H$_, AmMamd`mMo Vn, AJrH$ma`Mr gmYZm, H$amd`mMo `mZ `m
gdmMo EH$_od C{> hUOo {ZdmUmVr Amho. {ZdmUm_ò na_emVr, na_gwI, na_ AmZX, na_ {dlm_
`mMm AZw^d òVmo Ago hQ>bobo Amho.
{ZdmU hUOo H$m` ?
1) {ZdmU `m eXmMm _yi AW {dPUo qH$dm {dP{dUo, emV qH$dm WS> hmoUo, gd H$mhr AVJV hmoUo
Agm Amho.
2) [ZdmU `m eXmMr `wnmr {Zg+a+dm `m YmVynmgyZ {Xbr OmVo. `mMm AW Agm KoVbm Amho
H$s, {X`mMr `moV AmnU Oer \w$Hy$Z {dP{dVmo Vgo {dPdyZ Q>mH$Uo Agm Amho. {ZdmUmgmR>r `mo` Pmbm
AgVm, gd EImm {X`mgmaIm {dPyZ OmVm. {Xdm {dPbm AgVm ZVa `mMm _mJ_yghr amhV Zmhr, Vgo
{ZdmUmVr Pmbo`m gdmMo ApVd ahmV Zmhr Am{U Vmo nwhm O_mbm òV Zmhr.
3) {ZdmU `m eXmMm AW {Xdm AWdm `moV {dPUo, emV hmoUo Agm KoVbm Amho. OrdZmg `moVrMr
Cn_m ~m XeZmV dmadma òVo. OrdZ `moV emV hmoUo, OrdZm`m VmnmMm Cne_ hmoUo hUOo {ZdmU hmo`.
4) ~m Y_mZohr Eo{hH$ ApVdmnmgyZ emdV _wVr ho _mZdr Am`w`mMo A{V_ ò` R>a{dbo Amho.
`mg {ZdmU ho Zmd {Xbo Jobobo Amho.
5) O_, Oam, _`y Am{U Am`w`mV Zoh_r òUmar Xw:Io `mnmgyZ _wVVm hUOo {ZdmU hmo`.
6) {ZdmU hUOo Xw:I-a{hV na_ AmZX ({ZdmU na_ gwI_) hmo`. {ZdmU hoM A{V_ gwI Amho.
7) {ZdmUmMo n, AmH$ma, H$mb_mZ, B`mXr{df`r _m{hVr XoVm òV Zgbr Var `m`m JwUmMo dUZ
_m Ambobo Amho, Vo Ago * [ZdmU ho dmBQ> gH$mamZr Xw{fV Pmbobo ZgVo. CbQ> dmBQ> gH$mamnmgyZ hmoUmam Vmn Vo emV
H$aVo.
* {ZdmU ho nm{d`, kmZ Am{U _moj `m`m nwwnmZr ~habobo AgVo. Xw:I Am{U gH$Q>o `m`mnmgyZ
_wVVm nmdyZ emVr, AmZX Am{U nm{d` `m`mmam {ZdmU AZw^{dVm òVo.
47
8) ~mam {ZXmZmMo ahmQ>JmS>Jo H$m`_ Mmby ahmV AgVo. naVw `mnmgyZ ~mOybm amhUo qH$dm _wVVm
{_i{dUo hUOo {ZdmU hmo`.
9) {ZdmU gH$nZoMm ^mdn AWhr H$aVm òVmo. `{$dmMm {dZme hUOo ApVdmMm {dZme
Zho Ago hUVm òBb. nMH$Ynr `{$d {d$Z OmBb nU OoWyZ `mZo AmH$ma KoVbm Vo AIS> ApVd
C$Z amhrb Aer H$nZm H$aVm òVo. Aer {ZahH$mar Am{U hUyZ Ho$di gm{jdmMr pWVr AZw^dVm òVo.
ho ^maVr` Am`mp_H$ nanaoMo _wI gy Amho.
gamodamV bmQ> CR>Vo Am{U {O$Z OmVo. bmQ> Z> Pmbr Var gamoda em~yVM amhVo Am{U bmQ>oMo Iao
d$n gamoda hoM Amho. {ZdmU `mMm hm AW KoV`mg Vmo Cn{ZfXmVrb AIS> AmZX_` A_Vdm`m
H$nZoer OwiUmam Amho.
10) {ZdmUmMm Agmhr EH$ AW KoVbm OmVmo H$s, _`yZVa VWmJVmMo (ApVdmMo) H$m` hmoVo ? Vmo
ApVdmV amhVmo H$s Zmhr ? `m ZmMo Cma Xo`mg JmV_ ~wmZo ZH$ma {Xbm. `md$Z AmnU hUy eH$Vmo
H$s, {ZdmU hUOo Aer AdWm H$s {O`m g~Yr H$gboM {dYmZ H$aVm òV Zmhr. Vr EH$ A{ZX}`,
A{Zdm` pWVr Amho. {ZdmU `mMm hm AWgwm doXmVmVrb A{ZdMZr` d$nm`m _moj H$nZoer
OwiUmam Amho.
`m~m~VrV EH$ gdmX {Xbobm Amho. H$mogbMm amOm goZ{OV d {dVo~b {g Aer {^jwUr
Io_m `m`m_Yrb gdmX ~K`mgmaIm Amho.
amOm goZ{OV {^jwUrbm {dMmaVmo H$s, _`yZVa VWmJV (ApVdmV) CaVmo qH$dm Zmhr. `mdoir
Vr {^jwUr n>nUo Cma XoV Zmhr, H$maU VWmJVmZrM Vo n> Ho$bobo Zmhr. amOm {Vbm nwT>o Ago {dMmaVmo
H$s, VWmJVmZr ho H$m n> Ho$bo Zmhr ? `mda Vr {dmZ {^jwUr amOmbm CbQ> {dMmaVo H$s, ho amOZ,
Vw`mH$S>o Agm H$moUr {hemo~ H$aUmam I{OZXma Amho H$m` H$s Omo JJo`m H$mR>mdaMr dmiy {~ZMyH$nUo
_moOyZ XmIdrb ? qH$dm g_wmMo nmUr `dpWV Am{U `mo` [aVrZo _moOyZ XmIdrb ? amOmbm AWmVM Zmhr
hUUo ^mJ nS>Vo. {^jwUr `mbm nwT>o hUVo H$s, Ogm _hmg_w A_`mX Am{U AJmY Amho `m_mUo
VWmJV (ApVd) A_`mX Am{U AJmY Amho. `m Aem H$ma`m Cmamd$Z, OoWo {dMma Am{U dmUr _yH$
~ZVo Ago na_nX hUOo {ZdmU hmo`.
11) ~wmMm CnXoe Z{VH$ d$nmMm hmoVm ho bjmV KoD$Z, {ZdmU `mMm Agmhr EH$ AW KoVbm
Amho, Vmo Agm H$s, gd Z{VH$ JwUmMr H$_mB H$$Z nyUmdWoV nmohMbo`m _ZmMr gZ, J^ra Am{U emV
AdWm hUOo {ZdmU hmo`.
12) {ZdmUmV H$mhr {_idm`Mo ZgVo Va _mZdm`m gd BN>m, VUm, {dH$ma, AmH$mjm, jwYm d
`mVyZ {Z_mU hmoUmao _mZdmMo gjmo^, qMVm, AdWVm, Xw:I `mMm b` hmd`mMm AgVmo. `m`m _Vo
{ZdmU hUOo OrdZmVrb gd Xw:IH$maH$, Aew^ Jmo>tMm AV hmoUo, BN>m`m dmbmZr doT>bo`m OmJmnmgyZ
gwQ>H$m hmoUo hUOoM gd BN>m, VUm, AmgVr, of, _moh `mnmgyZ _wV hmoUo hmo`.
4.3 dÀ``ZmgmR>r Z :A)
Jmibo`m OmJm âm.

1)
-------- ho ~m Y_mMo gWmnH$ AmhoV.

48
~)
2)
-------- ho Xw:ImMo _yi Amho.
3)
B{` Cn^moJm~b Agbobr AmgVr hUOo -------- hmo`.
4)
Xw:I {ZamoY H$a`m`m _mJmbm -------- hUVmV.
5)
~m XeZmV -------- bm na_moM WmZ Amho.
Imbrb ZmMr òH$s EH$m dm`mV Cmao m.

1)
Mma Am`g`mMr Zmdo m.
2)
A>mJ _mJmMr `mXr H$am.
3)
j{UH$dmX hUOo H$m` ?
4)
`mnmX hUOo H$m` ?
5)
{ZdmU hUOo H$m` ?
4.4 n[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW :1)
XeZ
VdkmZ
2)
A{dm:
3)
doXZm
gwI Xw:ImMm AZw^d
4)
VUm
BN>m
5)
OmVr
O_
6)
^d
AmgVr_YyZ nwZO_mg H$maUr^yV R>aUmao H$_
7)
g`H$ :
8)
fS>m`VZ
AkmZ
`mo`, MmJbm
:
nMkmZ|{` d _Z
4.5 d` A``Z ZmMr Cmao :A)
~)
Jmibo`m OmJm âm - Cmao

1) JmV_~w
2) VUm
4) A>mJ _mJ
5) {ZdmU
3) H$m_ CnmXmZ
EH$m dm`mV Cmao m : Cmao

1)
gd_ Xw:I_, Xw:I H$maU_, Xw:I {ZamoY, Xw:I {ZamoYmMo _mJ
2)
g`H$ >r, g`H$ gH$n, g`H$ dmMm, g`H$ H$_mV, g`H$ Am{O{dH$m,
g`H$ `m`m_, g`H$ _Vr, g`H$ g_mYr
3)
`m OJmVrb òH$ Jmo> {VjUr ~XbV AgVo. `m OJmV H$mhrhr pWa, {Z`, emdV
ZgVo hUOo j{UH$dmX hmo`.
49
4)
ZmdS>`m dVw{df`r qH$dm `{${df`r dmQ>Umam of hmo`.
5)
Eo{hH$ ApVdmnmgyZ emdV _wVr ho A{V_ ò` hUOo {ZdmU hmo`.
4.6 gmame :^JdmZ JmV_~w hm ~m XeZmMm gWmnH$ Amho. ~m XeZ ho Ad{XH$ (ZmVrH$) XeZ Amho.
JmV_ ~wmbm ~moYrdjm`m Imbr Oo g`mMo kmZ mV Pmbo `mbm Mma Am`gò hUVmV. gd Xw:I_,
Xw:I H$maU_, Xw:I {ZamoY d Xw:I {ZamoYmMo _mJ hr Vr Mma Am`gò AmhoV. Xw:I {ZamoY H$a`mMm Omo _mJ
~wmZr gm{JVbm `mbm AQ>mJ _mJ Ago hQ>bo Amho. g`H$ >r, g`H$ gH$n, g`H$ dmMm, g`H$
H$_mV, g`H$ AmOr{dH$m, g`H$ `m`m_, g`H$ _Vr d g`H$ g_mYr ho A>mJ_mJ AmhoV. Xw:ImMm
Zme hmo`mgmR>r `m A>mJ _mJmMm Cn`moJ hmoVmo. g`H$ eXmMm AW `mo` Agm KoVbm OmVmo. g`H$ >r
AYlobm Xya gm$Z _mUgm`m {dMmamZm ~wr m_m`dmXr diU bmdVo.o _ZmVrb Xw{dMma H$mTy>Z Q>mHy$Z
`m {R>H$mUr ew^ {dMmamMr WmnZm H$a`mgmR>r gVV `Zerb amhUo hr g_mYrH$S>o Om`mMo _mJ AmhoV.
JmV_ ~wmZo Amn`m VdkmZm_ò j{UH$dmX, AZm_dmX, {ZdmU gH$nZm `mMr g{dVa _m{hVr
{Xbobr Amho. ho OJ d `m OJmVrb dVy d KQ>Zm n[adVZerb (~XbUm`m) AmhoV Agm j{UH$dmX
_mS>bm Amho. JmV_ ~wmZo Am_m _mZbobm Zmhr. `mgmR>r AZm_dmXmVyZ `mMr _m{hVr {Xbobr Zmhr.
{ZdmU hm ~mmMm _hdmMm {gmV _mZbm OmVmo. {ZdmUm_ò na_emVr, na_gwI, na_ AmZX, na_
{dlm_ `mMm AZw^d òVmo Ago hQ>bo Amho.
~m VdkmZmMr Mma Am`gò n> H$am.
2)
Am` A>mJ_mJ `m{df`rMr g{dVa _m{hVr m.
3)
j{UH$dmXm{df`rMo ~mmMo _V `V H$am.
4)
~mmMm AZm_dmX n> H$am.
5)
~mmZr _mS>bobr {ZdmU gH$nZm n> H$am.
4.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$ :JWm`m eodQ>r `mXr {Xbr Amho.

666
50
KQ>H$ - 5
AV doXmV
5.0 Cr>o
5.1 nmVm{dH$
5.2 {df` {ddoMZ
5.2.1
~ZMo dn
5.2.2
OJmMo ^mg_` dn
5.2.3
_m`mdmX
5.2.4
_mojmMo dn
5.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r
5.4 gmame
5.5 dÀ``Z mMr Cmao
5.7 nm[a^m{fH$ eX
5.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$.
5.0 Cr>o `m KQ>H$mMm A`mg Ho$`mda AmnUmg Imcrc Jmo>tMr _m{hVr {_ioc.
*
eH$amMm`m`m AV doXmVmMr AmoiI hmoBc.
~ZMo dn nQ>nUo g_Ooc.
OJmMo ^mg_` dn H$go Amho ho cjmV òBc.
_m`mdmXmMo n>rH$aU hmoBc.
Ord Am{U ~ `m`mVrc ZmVo cjmV òBc.
AV doXmVmMr ""_moj gH$nZm'' OmUyZ KoVm òBc.
5.1 mV{dH$ ^maVr` VdkmZmV eH$amMm`m`m AV doXmVmcm gdm{YH$ cmoH$_m`Vm {_imcocr Amho. cmoH$
_mZgmV VdkmZ = doXmV = AV doXmV Ago g_rH$aU hmoD$Z ~gcoco Amho.
51
""doXmV'' `m eXmMo XmoZ AW gmJVm òVrc1)
doXmMm {ZH$f qH$dm gma
2) doXmMm AV AgUmar Cn{ZfXo
F$doX, Òwd}X, gm_doX, AWddoX Ago Mma doX AmhoV. Cn{ZfXo, ~gyo Am{U ^JdrVm hr
^maVr` VdkmZmMr CJ_WmZo AmhoV. hUyZ `mZm ""WmZl`r'' hUyZ g~moYco OmVo. ~mXamÙmZr
"~gyo' aMcr. `mZmM ""doXmVgyo'' Agohr hUVmV. doXm`m {dMmamMr ewVm `m CJ_mer òD$Z
nmaIcr OmVo. {Za{Zam`m AmMm`mZr WmZl`rda ^mò Ho$cocr AmhoV.
1)
eH$amMm` {. 788 Vo 820 - Ho$dcmV~mX
2)
am_mZwOmMm` {. 1056 Vo 1137 - {d{e>mVdmX
3)
_dmMm` {. 1199 Vo 1278 - VdmX
4)
d^mMm` {. 1481 Vo 1533 - ewmVdmX
5)
qZ~mH$mMm` (13 do eVH$) - VdmX (ôXmôX) dmX
lr_X Am eH$amMm` M[a Am{U H$mÀm eH$amMm` ho mMrZ lo> Aem n{S>VmnH$s EH$ _mZco OmVmV. `mMm O_ B.g. 788 _ò
Pmcm Va _`y B.g. 820 _ò Pmcm. Ad`m 32 dfm`m H$mcIS>mV `mZr Ho$coco H$m`, coIZ \$maM
MS> dnmMo Amho. `mZr qhXy Y_mMr nwZWmnZm Ho$cr. qhXy Y_m`m gmamW Xoeâ ^_U Ho$co Am{U
nmM nrR>mMr WmnZm Ho$cr.eH$amMm`m_ò EH$ H${d, ^$ Am{U Xme{ZH$ Aem VrphMmhr gwaoI gJ_
Pmcocm {XgyZ òVmo. `mZr CnXoeghr, eVcmoH$s Ago JW X{jUm_yVu, AmZXchar Aer H$mò Va
fQ>nXr Vmo_ & mXenm[aH$m Vmo_ & Aer Vmoo aMcr. doXmVgyo, Cn{ZfXo Am{U ^JdXJrVm Aem
WmZl`rda `mZr Ho$cocr ^mò gw{g AmhoV.eH$amMm` ho AV doXmVr hUyZ AmoiIco OmVmV.
AV `mMm AW EH$_odm{Vr` Agm Amho. A{V_ g` ho EH$_od Amho. `m g`mcm Vo ""~'' `m ZmdmZo
g~mo{YVmV.
EH$m Ow`m gw^m{fVH$mamZo A`m cmoH$mV nyU AV doXmV gmJwZ Q>mH$cocm Amho.
~h_ g`, OJp_`m, Ordmo~hZd Zmna: &
~h_ ho EH$_od g` Amho. OJ {_`m Amho. Ord ~h_mnojm doJio Zmhr.
5.2.1 ~hZmMo dn :
~h_ g` - AV doXmVm`m _Vo ~h_ ho EH$_od g` Amho. AXV doXmVmV ~h_mMo dn
nwT>rc_mUo n> Ho$coco Amho- ~h_ hUOo OmUrd hmo`, MV` hmo`. AV doXmVr gV (Amho) Am{U {Mm
(OmUrd) EH$M _mZVmV. `m Xmohr Jmo>rMr gddr Aô Aem AmhoV. Vmo AmZXmMm Vmo Amho.~h_ H$go
Amho? `m mMo Cma AXV doXmVr ""~h_ ho gV {MV d AmZXdnr Amho'' Ago XoVmV. Aem `m
g{ZmZX dnr ~h_m{df`r VrZ {dYmZo H$aVm òVrcH$) ~h_ ho gmjrMV` Amho.
I) ~h_ ho ôXa{hV Am{U {ZJwU Amho.
52
J) ~h_ {Z` Amho.

H$) ~h_ gmjrMV` Amho- ~h_ ho ~XcV AgUm`m AV:H$aUm`m dmtZm gmjr ahmV AgVo. Vo
dmhr Zmhr Va pWa Amho, {Z` Amho. `mcm AV doXmVr ""Hy$Q>W {Z`'' Ago g~mo{YVmV. ""Hy$Q>W
{Z`'' hUOo Ago H$s `m`mda H$emMmhr {dH$ma KS>V Zmhr n[aUm_ KS>V Zmhr ""Hy$Q>'' `m eXmMm
gH$V eXmMm EH$ AW ""ndV{eIa'' Agm Amho. EoaUrda R>odyZ R>moH$co`m dVyV ~Xc KS>VmV, EoaU
VerM amhVo.
Amn`m _Zmodmr pWa ZgVmV. `mV ApWaVm AgVo _Zm_ò AZoH$ {dH$ma, {dMma AgVmV
(gwI, Xw:I) Ogo nm`mZo âco`m ^mS>mV MmMo {Vq~~ nS>coco Amho, nmUr hcco H$s MmMo {Vq~~hr
hcVo. `jmV M pWa AgVmo. `m_mUooM ~hZ ho gmjrMV` AgVo.
AV doXmVr dmrMV` Am{U gmjr MV` Agm ôX H$aVmV.
I)
~h_ ho ôXa{hV d {ZJwU Amho-
~h_ ho {ZJwU Amho H$maU JwU ho ôXmda AmYm[aV AgVmV. eX, ne, JY, ag, n `m`m
ghm`mZo AmnUmg JwU OmUdVmV.
~h_o ho ôXa{hV Ag`m_wio Vo {ZJwU Amho. Vo JwUmZr ~ Zmhr. ~mYcoco Zmhr.
J)
~hZ {Z` Amho-
Ordm`m OmJVmdWm, dZmdWm Am{U gwfw{ (JmT> Pmon) m VrZ AdWm Amho. nU ~h_ ho m
Vrph AdWmnmgyZ A{c Amho. Vo {dm`m Ama^mnmgyZM Amho. OJmV`m gd BVa Jmo>tZm Am{X AV
Amho. `mMm ma^ hmoVmo, eodQ> hmoVmo. `m gd Jmo>r n[adVZerc (~XcUm`m) OJmVrc Amho Va ~hZ ho
{Z` Amho, pWa Amho.
gJwU ~h_ Am{U {ZJwU ~h_
~h_mMo gJwU ~h_ Am{U {ZJwU ~hZ Ago XmoZ H$ma AmhoV. Ago ~hZmMo XmoZ H$ma H$a`mMr H$m`
JaO Amho `mMo AV doXmVmV nwT>rc_mUo n>rH$aU {Xco OmVo-gJwU ~hZ hUOo _mò`m CnmYrghrV
drH$macoco ~h_ hmo`. gm_m` _mUgmZm CnmgZm e` hmdr hUyZ gJwU ~hZ Amd`H$ Amho. AV
doXmVm`m _Vo Ba hUOo gJwU ~hZ hmo`.{ZJwU ~hZ hUOo A{V_, {Znm{YH$ g` hmo`. `mg
na~hZ hUVmV. na hUOo lo> ""g` kmZ AZV ~hZ'' Ago ~hZmMo dn cjU Amho. ~hZ gV,
{MV, AmZX dnr Amho Ago _mZco OmVo naVy ~hZmMo dn ZH$mam_H$ nVrZo n> Ho$co OmVo. ""Zo{V
Zo{V'' & (Z+B{V), ho Zmhr, hohr Zmhr Ago.
""~mH$cr '' Zmdm`m {e`mZo ~mhd F$ftZm {dZ{dco, _cm ~hZ hUOo H$m` Vo gmJm? ~mhd F$fr
"gmJVmo' Ago hUmco d emV am{hco. Ago XmoZ VrZXm Pmco. ~mH$cr hUmcm, AmMm` Vwhr _cm ~hZmMo
dn H$go Amho ho gmJVmo hUmcmV, nU gmJV H$m Zmhr? `mda ~mhd eodQ>r ~mXd hUmco, _r Vwcm
gmJVM hmoVmo nU Vy cjmV KoVco Zmhrg. ""~h_ ho emVdn Amho.''~hZ ho Wyc Zmhr, gy_ Zmhr.
hd Zmhr, XrKhr Zmhr. Vo AUynojm chmZ d _moR>mnojmhr _moR>o Ago Amho. Aer ~hZmcm nana{damoYr
cjUo cmdcr OmVmV. Va OoWo Z nmohmoMVmM dmUr Am{U _Z naV òVo Vo ~hZ Agohr ~hZmMo dUZ AmT>iVo.
AWmV ho {ZJwU ~hZ hmo`, na~hZ hmo`.
53
5.2.2 OJmMo ^mg_` dn

AV doXmVm`m _Vo ""~h_'' ho EH$_od g` Amho. _J AmnU Oo OJ AZw^dVmo Vo H$go Amho? Vo
g` Zmhr H$m`? OJmMo n>rH$aU AV doXmV ""{_`m'' Ago dUZ H$aVmo {_`m hUOo ImoQ>o Ag`
Zho. ""OJ {_`m Amho'' `m AV doXmVm`m {gmVm~c ~aoM Jag_O AmhoV.Amn`mcm OmUdUmao
OJ, `mdhm[aH$ OJ {_`m Amho nU Vo EH$m {d{e> nmVirda, Vm[dH$ nmVirda {_`m Amho. `m gX^mV
EH$ H$Wm gm{JVcr OmVo- EH$ doXmVr AmMm`, dZm_ò Amn`m {e`mZm {eH$drV AgVmV, ~hZ g`
Amho, OJ {_`m Amho. `mdoiog {VWo EH$ dmK òVmo. dmKmcm nhmVmM AmMm`, Am{U {e` XmoKohr {VWyZ ni
H$mT>VmV. gwa{jV {R>H$mUr Am`mda {e` JwZm {dMmaVmo - AmMm`, AmnU OJ {_`m Amho Aer
{eH$dU XoVm _J dmK Amcm ho nm{h`mda AmnU niyZ H$m Amcmo? `mda AmMm` CmaVmV (Cma XoVmV)
""~Q>mo, ncm`Z_{n {_`m &'' ho {e`m, Amnco niUo XoIrc {_`m Amho. AmMm`mMo Cma {dMma H$a`mgmaIo
Amho.
gmm` {gmVAV doXmVmV gmoMm {{dY {gmV _mS>cocm Amho. `m`m _Vo gmm (g`) m VrZ H$ma`m
AmhoV. `mdhm[aH$ gmm, m{V^m{_H$ gmm, Am{U nma_m[WH$ gmm `m VrZ gmm hmoV.`mdhm[aH$ nmVirda
dmK {XgUo, AmnU niyZ OmUo ho g` Amho. `mdhm[aH$ gmoV ""AZw^d'' hm _mU _mZcm OmVmo. `m`m
AmYmao OrdZ`dhma gmYcm OmVmo. Amnco OJUo KS>V AgVo Va m{V^m{gH$ gmoV Xmoar`m {R>H$mUr gmn
nhmUo, qeno`m {R>H$mUr no nmhUo hmo`. `m Jmo>rMm g_mdoe hmoVmo AYmamVyZ OmV AgVmZm a`mV Xmoar
nS>cocr AgVo {Vcm AmnU gmn g_OVmo qH$dm g_w{H$Zm`mcm qenco nS>coco AgVmV Vo ChmV M_H$VmV
`m_wio Vo MmXr_mUo dmQ>VmV. dVyV: `m Xmohr Jmo>r ^mgdn AmhoV. Amn`mcm OmUdUmao OJXoIrc
AgoM Amho. Va nma_m{WH$ gmm hUOo A{V_ g` ""~h_'' `mMo kmZ hmoUo hmo`. `m kmZmrgmR>r
`mdhm[aH$ g`mMm `mJ H$aUo Amd`H$ Amho.`mdhm[aH$ OJ (g`) ho {X>H$ H$mcmZo ~ Amho. Voo `
dnmMo (Br`mZm OmUdUmao) Amho. OS> dnmMo Amho. nma_m{WH$ gmoMo kmZ Pm`mda, ~hZmMo kmZ
Pm`mda `mdhm[aH$ OJ {_`m Amho `mMr OmUrd hmoVo."{_`m' `m eXmMm AmUIr EH$ AW Amcm Amhoo
H$s {dH$mar, ~XcUmao hmo`. Amn`mcm OmUdUmao OJ ho {dH$ma>r, ~XcUmao Ago Amho. Amn`mcm OJ
g`> H$m ^mgVo? ~XcUm`m {dH$mar OJmMo n>rH$aU H$a`mgmR>r eH$amMm` ""_m`mdmX'' {gmV
_mS>VmV.
5.2.3 _m`mdmX
`mdhm[aH$ OJmMo n>rH$aU H$a`mgmR>r AV doXmV ""_m`mdmXmMm'' {gmV _mS>Vo ~hZ Oa
MoVZ {M_` Amho Va `mnmgyZ {Z_mU hmoUmao OJ OS>dnr H$m Amho? EH$mM ~hZ VdmnmgyZ Oa OJ
Cn Pmcoco Agoc Va OJmV ZmZm ôX H$m AmhoV? Aem mMr Cmao Xo`mgmR>r eH$amMm`mZr ""_m`mdmX''
qH$dm ""{ddVdmX'' _mS>cocm Amho.OJmMm AmYma ~h_ Amho. ~h_ ZgVo Va OJ ^mgcoM ZgVo. AV
doXmV hUOo OJ hm ~hZmdma Ho$cocm ""A`mg'' Amho. A`mg hUOo W_ nm{hco`m dVyMo Xwg`m
dVy`m {R>H$mUr hmoUmao _aUm`m dnmVrc kmZ hmo`. A`mgmMo dn n> H$a`mgmR>r aOy gn, [encm-aOV Aer CXmhaUo dmnacr OmVmV. amr AmnU Xmoarcm gmn g_OVmo, `j gmn ZgVmo
nU nydu AmnU nm{hco`m gmnmMo AmnUmg _aU hmoVo hUyZ AmnU Xmoar`m {RH$mUr gmn nhmVmo. qH$dm
g_w{H$Zm`mda Chm_ò qenco M_H$VmV Vohm Vo `mgmaIo, MmXrgmaIo dmQ>VmV. dVyV: Vgo Vo
ZgVmV.
54
~h_mda AmnU OJVmMm A`mg (Ama>mon) H$m H$aVmo? Va A{do_wio, AkmZm_wio hUOo _m`mdmXmMo
_yi A{doV Amho. OJmMo _m{c`, (Xy{fVnUm) OS>Vm ~hZmcm Xw{fV H$aV Zmhr. amy-gn g~YmV gn ho
amyMo H$m` Amho. nU H$m` hUOo n[aUm_ Zho gn hUOo {ddV Va aOy ho {ddVmMo H$maU hmo`.
`m{R>H$mUr {df_ XOmMr gmm AgVo `mcm {ddV hUVmV. Vohm CnmXmZ H$maU Am{U `mMo H$m` `mMr
gmm (g`d) gmaIo AgVo Vohm `mg n[aUm_ hUVmV. CXm. ~\$ Am{U nmUr. naVy amy-gn `m`mV
{df_ XOmMr gmm AgVo `m_wio `mcm {ddV hUVmV. qencm ho H$maU d aOV ho H$m` `m CXmhaUmVhr
KS>Um`m H$m`mg ""{ddV''hUVm òBc.
~h_ ho gZmVZ Amho Va OJ ho A`V Amho, {ddV Amho. Aem VhoZo OJmcm ""_m`m'' hQ>co Amho.
""_m`m'' hUOo A{dmH$pnV Zm_no hmoV. Or Ag`hr ZmhrV nU nyUnUo g`hr ZmhrV. hrM `mdhm[aH$
gmm hmo`.
Zm_nm_H$ OJ `mdhm[aH$ Q>m g` Amho naVy nma_m[WH$ >m g` Zg`mZo `mcm {_`m
hUmd`mMo, _m`m hUmd`mMo _m`m gVhr Zmhr Am{U AgVhr Zmhr. _J _m`m H$er {Z_mU hmoVo? A{do_wio
_mòMm Cd hmoVmo. A{do_wio gVydX (~hZmda) Zm_nmMm A`mg H$ocm OmVmo. hr Zm_no hUOo
_m`m hmo`.
Aem VhoZo _m`mdmXmMm n>rH$aU H$aVm òBc.
5.2.4 _mojmMo dn
AV doXmVm`m _Vo _moj m H$aUo ho OrdZmMo A{V_ ò` Amho. Oohm Ord Am{U ~hZ `m`mVrc
Eo`mMo (EH$dmMo) kmZ hmoVo Vohm _moj m hmooVmo. ^JdXJrVoV hQ>coco Amho, ""`mZo ~hZ OmUco Vmo
~hZ_` hmoVmo'' AkmZmMm Zme hmoUo hUOo _moj m hmoUo hmo`._moj H$moUmcm m hmoVmo? AV doXmVm`m
_Vo Ordmcm _moj m hmoVmo. OJ {_`m Amho, ~hZ hoM g` Amho. Vo g{XmZX dnr Amho. Vo Hw$R>o Amho?
Va doXmV hUVo, ""Ah ~hZmp_'' & _rM ~hZ Amho. Ord hmM ~hZ Amho. ~hZ ho Hy$Q>W {Z` Amho.
`mMm CoI "gmjrMV`' Agmhr Ho$cm OmVmo. Ord Am{U ~hZ `mV Zo_H$m \$aH$ H$moUVm Amho? Ord
Am{U ~hZ `mV Eo` H$go gmYVm òBc `mMo Cma AV doXmV ""_moj gH$nZoVyZ'' XoVo.Ord Am{U
~hZmVrc \$aH$ gmJVm òBc. Ord hm kmZmMm {df` Amho Va Am_m qH$dm ~hZ ho kmZm`m ncrH$S>Mo
Amho. Ord gwIr qH$dm XwIr hmoVmo. Va ""Am_~hZ'' hm gwI Xw:Im`m ncrH$S>Mo AgVo.Ho$di ""Am_m''
g` AgVmZm Ord H$moRy>Z Cn hmoVmo? `m mMo AV doXmVr Ago Cma XoVmV, ""CnmYr_wio Am`mg
Ordd m hmoVo.'' CnmYr hUOo Amnco JwU Xwg`mV C_Q>{dUmam nXmW hmo`. CXm. \${Q>H$meoOmar
OmdXrMo \y$c R>od`mg \${Q>H$ "a$dU' cmc aJmMm ^mgVmo. \${Q>H$ hm nmaXeu AgVmo. Vmo a$dUu
ZgVmo naVy ""OmdXrMo \y$c'' `m CnmYrZo `mcm a$dUd m hmoVo. Am`m~m~V VgoM KS>Vo.A_`H$moam,
mU_` H$moe, _Zmo_` H$moe, {dkmZ_` H$moe Am{U AmZX_` H$moe Aem nMH$moemghrV Am_m hUOo
""Ord'' hmo`. Am`mcm Amn`m I`m nmMr OmUrd hmoUo hUOo _moj hmo`. Agm Am_m Am{U ~hZ
EH$M EH$ hmo`._moj m H$gm H$amd`mMm? OrdmMo ~hZmer ZmVo OmoS>`mZo _moj m hmoBc. Ho$di
AkmZm_wio A{do_wio Ord Am`mhZ {^ ^mgVmo. hm ^_ Xya H$a`mgmR>r kmZnr H$me Amd`H$
R>aVmo. AV doXmVm`m _Vo Ho$di kmZ_mJmZoM _moj m hmoVmo. (kmZmZ Ed _moj:)
_moj hm ^$s qH$dm H$_ Aem Cnm`mZr {_iUma Zmhr Va Vmo kmZmZoM m hmoBc Agm AV
doXmVmMm AmJh Amho. ""kmZ hUOo gmjmV AZw^d hmo`'' _r ~hZn Amho `mMr Ordmcm OmUrd hmoUo
55
hUOo Am_kmZ hmo`. ho kmZ hmd`mMo Agoc Va {Mmewr Pmcr nm{hOo. {ZH$m_ H$_ Am{U ^$s `mZr
{Mmewr hmoVo.{Mm ewrgmR>r doXmVmZo ""gmYZ MVw>'' Mma gmYZo gm{JVcocr AmhoV. hr gmYZo
nwT>rc_mUo1) {Z`m{Z`dVy{ddoH$- Am_m hrM {Z` dVy Amho. ~mH$s gd dVy A{Z` AmhoV hm {dMma
gVV _ZmV KmoidV R>odcm nm{hOo.
2) Bhm_wmW\$c ^moJ {damJ - `m OJmVrc qH$dm A` OJmVrc (cmoH$mVrc) Or gwIo {_iUo e`
Amho `mnmgyZ namdm hmoUo, {da$ hmoUo hmo`.
3) e_X_Zm{XgmYZgnX - e_ hUOo _ZmMm Br`dmrda AmVyZ {ZJh H$aUo, X_ hUOo
Br`m`m ~mhoZ {ZamoY, CnaVr hUOo {d{Y`w$ g`mg KoUo hmo`, {V{Vjm hUOo erV-CU, gwIXw:I EH$mM dmrZo ghZ H$aUo hmo`. g_mYmZ hUOo {Mm EH$mJ R>odUo Va lm hUOo doXmV{gmVmda
{Z>m R>odUo hmo`.
4) _w_wjd - hUOo _moj mr g~Yr O~aXV BN>m ~miJUo hmo`.
gmYZMVwA`mMr nyVVm Pm`mda gmYH$mZo ""Vd_{g'' "~hZ doX ~hZod ^d{V' Aer Cn{ZfXmVrc
dmò ldU H$aUo, `mMo _ZZ H$aUo. _Zmda R>g{dUo Am{U {Z{X`mg H$aUo hUOo {MmmV Vmo {dMma gVV
Kmoi{doUo hmo`.
Aem VhoZo gmYZ MVw>, {Z{X`mgmZo _mojmr hmoBc._mojmr Pm`mda Am_m gV, {Mm, AmZXmMm
gmjmH$ma AZw^dVmo, Vmo ~hZ_` ~ZVmo.
5.3 dÀ``ZmgmR>r n
A)
EH$m dm`mV Cmao {chm.

1)
""~h_gyo'' H$moUr aMco?
2)
~h_mMo dn H$go Amho?
3)
eH$amMm` H$moU`m {gmVm`m AmYmao OJmMo n>rH$aU H$aVmV?
4)
_mojmrMo VrZ _mJ H$moUVo?
5)
AV doXmVm`m ^_{df`H$ {gmVmMo Zmd gmJm.
~) `mo` n`m` {ZdS>m.

...........................
1)
eH$amMm` ho
doXmVr hUyZ AmoiIco OmVmV.
2)
(AV / {der>mV / V)
...........................
`m gwfwr, OmJVr d dZ m VrZ AdWm AmhoV.
(~h_ / Ord / OJV)
3)
Xmoar`m {R>H$mUr gmn nhmUo
...........................
(`mdhm[aH$ / m{V^m{gH$ / nma_m{WH$)

56
gmoMo CXmhaU Amho.
...........................
4)
Am`mdarc AmdaUo hUOo
hmo`.
5)
(nMH$moe / A{dm / _m`m)

...........................
gmR>r gJwU ~hZ Amd`H$ R>aVo.
(mWZogmR>r / CnmgZogmR>r / kmZmgmR>r)
5.4 gmame
eH$amMm` Amn`m AV doXmVmV ~hZmMo dn nQ> H$aVmV. `m`m _Vo ~hZ ho gmjmoMV`,
{ZJwU Am{U {Z` Ago Amho. Vo OJmMo {_`m Ago dUZ H$aVmV. OJ ho ~XcUmao n[adVZr` Ago Amho
`m`m _wimer ~hZ Amho. OJmMo n>rH$aU H$a`mgmR>r eH$amMm`mZr ""_m`mdmX'' _mS>cocm Amho.
A{do_wio AmnU ~hZ `m A{V_ gXdVyda OJmMm A`mg (Amamon) H$arV AgVmo.Ord Am{U Am_m `mVrc
g~Y n> H$aVmZm eH$amMm` hUVmV, nMH$moem_wio Am`mcm Ordd m hmoVo. Am`mcm Oohm `mMo Iao dn
m hmoVo Vohm `mcm _moj m hmoVmo. ""_moj'' hUOo Am`mcm `mMo Iao dn m hmoUo. _moj mrMo kmZ,
H$_, ^$s Ago VrZ _mJ Amho naVy AV doXmVm`m _Vo ""kmZ'' _mJ hm gdlo> _mJ Amho.
5.5 dÀ``Z mMr Cmao
A)
1) ~mXamÙ 2) gV+{MV+ AmZX g{XmZX
3) _m`mdmX 4) kmZ, H$_, ^$r 5) A{ZdMZr` `m{VdmX
~)
1) AV
2) Ord
3) m{V^m{gH$
4) nMH$moe 5) CnmgZogmR>r
5.6 gamdmgmR>r dm`m`.
1)
AV doXmVm`m ""~hZ'' Mo dn n> H$am.
2)
"OJ ^mg_` Amho' H$go Vo {deX H$am.
3)
_m`mdmXmMm {gmV n> H$am.
4)
_mojmMo dn n> H$am.
5.7 nm[a^m{fH$ eX
1)
gmjrMV` -
2)
gmm`mMm {gmV - VrZ gmm- `mdhm[aH$ - m{V^m{gH$ - nma_m{WH$ {ddoMZH$aUmam

{gmV
3)
A`mg
~Xcmcm gmjr AgUmao MV` (~hZ)
Amamon
57
4)
{ddV - H$m` Am{U H$maU `m`mVrc {df_ XOmMr gmm
5)
nMH$moe - Am`mdarc nmM AmdaUo.
6)
A{dm- Am`mMo Iao dn OmUyZ KoUo ho AkmZ.
5.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$.

nwVH$m`m eodQ>r `mXr {Xcocr Amho.
666
58
KQ>H$ - 6
gmHo${Q>g d coQ>mo ( Socrates and Plato )

6.0 C{Q>o
6.1 mVm{dH$ (OrdZdmmV)
6.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
6.2.1
gmHo${Q>gMr nVr
6.2.2
gmHo${Q>g - Z{VH$ {eH$dU
6.2.3
boQ>moMr kmZ{df`H$ Cnnmr
6.2.4
boQ>moMr H$nZm Cnnmr
6.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z
6.6 gmame
6.0 C{Q>o :`m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZVa Amn`mbm * gmHo${Q>g`m A`mg nVrMo d$n g_Oob.
* gmHo${Q>gMr Z{VH$ {eH$dU bjmV òBb.
* boQ>moMr kmZ{df`H$ Cnnmr g_OyZ òBb.
* boQ>mo`m H$nZm CnnmrMo d$n H$iob.
6.1 mVm{dH$ :gmHo${Q>g VdkmZm`m B{VhmgmV JrH$ VdkmZ A{VmMrZ _mZbo OmVo. Ama^r`m VdqMVH$mZr _w`V:
{dd_r_mgm ho VdkmZmMo H$m` g_Obo Amho. mMrZ JrH$ VdkmZ Wo{bg nmgyZ A[aQ>mQ>b n`VMo
_mZbo OmVo. gmHo${Q>g nydr`m VdqMVH$mZr {ddm`m _ybH$maUmMm Z hm VdkmZmMm _w` Z
_mZbobm hmoVm. Wo{bg, AZpP_S>a, AZpP_o{Zg, nm`WmJmoag `mZr Vd_r_mgobm Ama^ Ho$bm.
59
`mZVa`m nm_}Zm`{S>O `m VdqMVH$mZo gVVdmMm (Theory of Being) {dMma _mS>bm. `wng d S>o_m{H$Q>g
AUwdmXm`m ghm`mZo {dd_r_mgm Ho$br d gy_ AUy hoM {ddmMo A{V_ KQ>H$ hmoV Ago {VnmXZ Ho$bo.
JrH$ VdkmZmV _mZdr g_mO`dWm, am``dWm `mda VdqMVZ H$aUmam W_ VdqMVH$
gmHo${Q>g R>aVmo. gmHo${Q>gZo nydu`m VdqMVH$mnojm {^Z {df` {ZdSy>Z Amnbo {dMma _mS>bo. AmnU `m
g_mOmV OJVmo `m g_mOmMo d$n, `mMm dMm[aH$ AmYma, gmH${VH$ AmYma ho gmHo${Q>g`m >rZo
_hdmMo {df` AmhoV. g_mOmVrb emgZ nVr d bmoH$_mZg AmXedmX _mZUmar Zgob Va g_mOmMm
hmg AQ>i Amho Ago gmHo${Q>gbm dmQ>Vo. hUyZ gmHo${Q>gZo ^m{VH$ `m`m ghm`mZo VdqMVZ H$a`mEodOr
g_mOH|$r d _Zw`H|$r VdkmZmMm drH$ma H$$Z Vd_r_mgm Ho$br.
gmHo${Q>gMm O_ B.g. nyd 470 _ò AWog ehamV Pmbm. `mMo dS>rb {enH$ma hmoVo d AmB
J{hUr hmoVr. `mMo {ejU d OrdZm`m gw$dmVr`m H$mim{df`r {deof _m{hVr CnbY Zmhr. Vmo AWog
ehamMm A{^_mZr Ag`mZo `mZo Amnbo gnyU Am`w` AWog_ò `[VV Ho$bo. AWog`m bH$ar
_mo{h_oV `mZo ^mJ KoVbm hmoVm. OdiOdi 30 df} `mZo VdqMVZmMo H$m` Ho$bo. gmHo${Q>gMm H$mbIS>
Y_{Z> {dMmamMm ^md _mZUmam hmoVm. naVw Y_m`m ZmdmImbr Jrg_ò gm_mÒZmMr Or {nidUyH$
hmoV hmoVr {Vbm {damoY H$aUmam gmHo${Q>g hm n{hbm VdqMVH$ R>aVmo.
gmHo${Q>g am>r` XodVmMm Ahoa H$$Z dV:Mr XdVo {Z_mU H$aVmo, AWog_Yrb `wdH$mZm amOgmo`m
{d$ ^S>H$mdyZ `mZm dm__mJmbm bmdVmo Ago AWog`m amOdQ>rZo gmHo${Q>gda Amamon R>odbo. AWog`m
`m` `dWooZo gmHo${Q>gda R>odbobo Amamon Iao AmhoV Ago _mZyZ gmHo${Q>gbm dhVo ho_bmH$ ZmdmMo
mUKmVH$ {df meZ H$a`mMr {ejm gwZmdbr. `m`XodVoMm Amn`mda A`m` H$aUmam AmXoehr gmHo${Q>gZo
{eagd _mZyZ `m`gô_òM ho_bmH$ {df meZ H$$Z gmHo${Q>gZo Xoh`mJ Ho$bm.
boQ>mo :mMrZ JrH$ VdkmZm_ò VdqMVZmbm gw`dpWV d$n Xo`mMm n{hbm `Z boQ>moZo Ho$bm.
boQ>moMm O_ B.g.nyd 427 _ò AWog_Yrb EH$m ImZXmZr Kam`mV Pmbm. boQ>moMo Iao _yi Zmd
A[aQ>mopbg hmoVo. _m Jrg_Yrb VH$m{bZ WoZwgma gd VUmZm ânya `m`m_ H$$Z Cm_ eara
gnXm mV H$amdr bmJV Ago. boQ>mo `mbm AndmX ZhVm. `mZo ânya `m`m_ H$$Z ~bXS> eara`>r
H$_mdbr hmoVr. `m`m âXma d $X N>mVrd$Z `mMo Zmd boQ>mo Ago nS>bo Amho. _m nwT>o VdkmZm`m
B{VhmgmV Vmo boQ>mo `m ZmdmZoM {g Pmbm.
boQ>mo d`m`m 20 `m dfu gmHo${Q>g`m gnH$mV Ambm d gmHo${Q>g`m _`yn`V gmHo${Q>gMm
{e` hUyZ am{hbm. `mZo gmHo${Q>gMr {eH$dU Am_gmV Ho$br. AWog_Yrb bmoH$emhrda A{Y{>V
am``dWoZo `mMo Jw gmHo${Q>gbm ImoQ>m Amamonmd$Z XohmVmMr {ejm {Xbobr hmoVr. gmHo${Q>gdarb
amJ `mdoiMr JrH$_Yrb bmoH$emhr `m`m AZw`m`mda H$mT>rb `m ^rVrZo boQ>mo AWog eha gmoSy>Z {ZKyZ
Jobm. _oJag, gmàrZ, B{OV, BQ>br, {g{gbr dJao XoemZm ôQ>r XoD$Z d`m`m 40 `m dfu boQ>mo
AWogbm naVbm. AWog òWo `mZo EH$ AH$S>_r - kmZ{dmb` (AmO`m n[a^mfoV `mg {dd{dmb`
hUVm òBb) WmnZ Ho$bo d VoWo A`mnZ d boIZ H$$ bmJbm. boQ>mo`m `m JwHw$bmV OJâmVyZ
{dmWu òD$ bmJbo. qH$~hZm boQ>mo`m AH$S>_r_ò {ejU KoUo OJâmV {V>oMo _mZbo OmD$ bmJbo.
60
Amn`m Jwbm AWog`m bmoH$emhrZo XohmVmMr {ejm {X`m_wio boQ>mo bmoH$emhr am``dWMm
{VaH$ma H$$ bmJbm. am``dWo`m gX^mV Vmo hUV Ago H$s, am`H$V} {dMmadV, kmZr, gwgH$V
d {ddoH$mbm _mZUmao Agbo nm{hOoV. `m`m `m {dMmamVyZM "Vdk am`H$V}' (Philosopher King) hr
H$nZm CX`mg Ambr. am``dWoMo Am|Ji d _yV d$n ~XbyZ `mbm ZrVr d A`m_mMm nm`m {Xbm
nm{hOo Aer `mMr nH$s Imr nQ>br d `m`m Aem {dMmamVyZ [anpbH$ The Republie hm AmXedmXr
JW CX`mg Ambm.
boQ>moZo gd JWboIZ gdmX $nmZo Ho$bobo Amho. `m`m ~hVoH$ JWm_ò Amnbm Jw gmHo${Q>gbm
dVm Ho$bobo Amho. `m`m gdmXmMo VrZ JQ> nS>VmV. n{hbm JQ> boQ>moZo gmHo${Q>g`m h`mVrV gmHo${Q>g`m
hmVmImbr {e` hUyZ AgVmZm Ho$bo`m gdmXmMm `m JQ>mV Imbrb gdmXmMm g_mdoe hmoVmo 1)
bm`{gg (hm gdmX _rg~Ym{df`r Amho).
2)
AnmbmOr (Apology) - `m gdmXmV gmHo${Q>gZo Oo dVZ Ho$bo `mMo boQ>moZo g_WZ Ho$bo Amho. 3)
{H$Q>mo - hm gdmX gmHo${Q>g`m H$m`Xm nmbZmg~Yr Amho.
3)
{H$`mo - hm gdmX gmHo${Q>g`m H$m`Xm nmcZmg~Yr Amho.
4)
moQ>Jmoag - `m gdmXmV boQ>moZo gmo{\$> VdkmZmda Q>rH$m Ho$bobr Amho.
5)
bHo$g - `m gdmXmV Y` `m gXJwUmda MMm Ho$bobr Amho.
6)
H$ma_m`{S>g - `m gdmXmV g`_ `m gXJwUmMr MMm Ho$bobr Amho.
7)
`w{W\$mo - hm gdmX gmHo${Q>g`m Y_{Z>og~YrV Amho.
boQ>mo`m gdmXm`m Xwg`m JQ>mV boQ>moMo dV:Mo VdkmZ Ambobo AmT>iVo. `m gdmXmda B{b`m{Q>H$
`m AV _mZUm`m {dMmamMm ^md {XgVmo. `m JQ>mV Imbrb gdmX _moS>VmV 8)
Jm{OAmg - gXJwUm`m dVw{Z>VoMo VdkmZ.
9)
{W`{Q>Q>g - g`m`m dVw{Z>VoMr MMm.
10) gmo{\$> - kmZ, gV, AgV `mg~YrMr MMm.

11) Q>oQ>g_Z - amOm, amOmZo nmimd`mMr Z{VH$ Vdo.
12) nm_}Zm`{S>O - AVdmX
13) _oZmo - ggH$nm{df`r {dMma
14) `w{W{S>_g - gmo{\$>m`m hodm^mgmg~Yr {dMma
15) nm{b{Q>g - amOZr{VemmMo _ybJm_r {ddoMZ
16) Ho${Q>bg - gmo{\$>m`m ^mfmemmdarb {Q>H$m
gdmXm`m {Vg`m JQ>mV boQ>mo`m {dMmaJ^ VdkmZmMo XeZ KS>{dUmao gdmX g_m{d> AmhoV.
17) {gnmo{PA_ - boQ>moMr ggH$nZmdarb ^Vr
18) \$m`br~g - gdmX Zr{VemmMo {dVV {ddoMZ H$aVmo
61
19) {Q>{_Ag - nXmW{dkmZ {df`H$ VdkmZmMm nam_e

20) [anpbH$ - boQ>moMo amOZr{V, {ejU, gm{h`, H$bm, A`m_, dJao {df`mdarb VdkmZ
21) \$sS>mo - Am`m`m A_admg~YrMo VdkmZ
22) {\$S>g - am`mVrb {ejUH$_mg~YrMo VdkmZ
23 d 24) {H${Q>Amg d bmO - boQ>moMr ZVaMr amOZr{V{df`H$ _Vo
6.2. {df` {ddoMZ 6.2.1 gmHo${Q>gMr nVr :gmHo${Q>gZo {d{e> Ago VdkmZ qH$dm VdkmZmMm gXm` {Z_mU Ho$bm Zmhr. VdkmZm`m ZVa`m
B{VhmgmV AZw^ddmX, ~w{dmX `mgmaIo VdkmZmMo gXm` {Z_mU Pmbo. `mgma`m gXm`mMo {ddoMZ
`mZo Ho$bobo Zmhr. H$maU EImm gXm`mMo {ddoMZ d g_WZ H$aUo hUOo VdqMVZmbm _`mXm KmbUo
hmo`. gmHo${Q>gMo VdkmZ VdkmZmVrb gd gXm`mZr drH$mabo `mVyZ gmHo${Q>g`m Vd>rMo >onU
n> hmoVo.VdqMVZ Aja~ hmo`mgmR>r `m VdqMVZmbm {d{e> eX`moJmZo g~moYbo nm{hOo. `m>rZo
gmHo${Q>g`m {dMmamZm gdmX nVr hUyZ g~moYbo OmVo. gmHo${Q>gMr ^y{_H$m Ho$di VdqMVZ H$Q>nUo
gmJUo EdT>mnwaVr _`m{XV ZhVr. VdqMVZ hUOo EImm {dMmadVmZo, A{YH$mar nwfmZo qH$dm OmUH$mamZo
g_mOmVrb gm_m` _mUgm`m `mdhm[aH$ g_`mda Ho$bobo {dMma d `m g_`mda gwM{dbobo Cnm`
hmoV.gmHo${Q>gMr A`mg nVr gdmXm_H$ hmoVr. gdmX nVrV EImm ZmMo, g_òMo ZwgVo Cma
gwM{dUo Ano{jV ZgyZ `m Zm{df`r, g_ò{df`r g_moa`m `Vrbm {dMma dm H$aUo Ano{jV
AgVo. CXm.MmJbo emgZ hUOo H$m` ? `m ZmMo gdmX nVrmao bmoH$mH$Sy>Z OZVoMo Z gmoS>dUmao,
OZVo`m AS>MUtMo {ZdmaU H$aUmao, OZVoMo OJUo gwg H$aUmao d OZVobm Amnbo dmQ>Umao Ago emgZ
ho Cma gmHo${Q>gbm A{ôV Ago.
gdmX nVrmao gmHo${Q>g AWog_Yrb emgZm`m CUrdmMo bmoH$m_ò ~moYZ H$arV Ago. `m
~moYZ H$m`mgmR>r `mZo AWog_Yrb gmdO{ZH$ {R>H$mUo CXm.ehamVrb _hdmMo MmH$, ~mOmaVi d BVa
JO~Obo`m {R>H$mUmMr {ZdS> Ho$bobr AmT>iVo. `mMo H$maU hUOo VoWo bmoH$mer gdmX gmY`mgmR>r bmoH$
ghOnUo CnbY hmoV AgV.gmHo${Q>g`m gdmX nVrMm _w` hoVy hUOo bmoH$mZm OrdZmVrb `mdhm[aH$
Zm{df`r,Wm{ZH$ emgZm{df`r {dMma dm H$aUo hm hmo`. gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo dV: {dMma H$a`m{df`r`m
CXm{gZVoVyZ `{$JV d gm_m{OH$ Z dmT>V OmVmV. gmHo${Q>gZo Amn`m gdmX nVrV VU {nT>rbm
mYm` {Xbo hmoVo. AWog eha d JrH$ ZJa am`m_ò emgZm~m~V Oo Ag_mYmZH$maH$ {M {XgV
hmoVo. `mMo _hdmMo H$maU hUOo bmoH$OmJVr ZgUo ho hmo`. {dMma_WZm~m~V AWog _ò Or gm_gy_
{XgV hmoVr `m_wio am`H$Vo A{Z~YnUo d A`m`H$maH$nUo ^>mMma H$arV hmoVo. AWog`m am`H$`m{d$
~S> H$a`mgmR>r gmHo${Q>gZo VU {nT>rbm hmVmer Yabo. Amn`m gdmX nVrMm Cn`moJ H$$Z AWog_ò
bmoH$ ~moYZ H$a`mMo _hdmMo H$m` gmHo${Q>gZo Ho$bo.
gmHo${Q>g`m gdmX nVrMr d{eQ>o :1)
ge`dmX gmHo${Q>g`m nVrV ge`dmX (Scepticism) AgVmo. ge`dmXmV EImm V`m{df`r, Jmo>r{df`r
62
gw$dmVrbm eH$m CnpWV Ho$br OmVo, ge` `V Ho$bm OmVmo. CXm. "ho' gmoZo Iao Amho H$m` ? hUOo
Amn`m g_moa`m gmo`m`m IaonUm{df`r W_ ge` `V H$amd`mMm. `m gmo`m`m Iao-ImoQ>onUm{df`r
OmUH$ma gwdUH$mamMo _V `md`mMo, {d{e> agm`Z dmn$Z gmo`mbm {hadQ> aJ òVmo H$m` Vo nhmd`mMo.
`m amgm`{ZH$ {MVrZVahr AmYrMo gmoZo [hadQ> Z nS>Vm {ndio Y_H$M amhV Agob Va gmoZo IaoM Amho
Agm {ZH$f H$mT>md`mMm. hUOo ge`mMm eodQ> g`m`m emoYm_ò H$amd`mMm. `md$Z gmHo${Q>gMm
ge` hm g`mdofU H$aUmam hmoVm Ago hQ>bo nm{hOo.
2)
g^mfUm_H$ -
gmHo${Q>g EImm Jmo>r{df`r AZoH$ bmoH$mer MMm H$arV Ago. MM}_ò AZoH$mMr AZoH$ _Vo Agy
eH$VmV. òH$ `Vr Amn`m dMm[aH$ Hw$dVrZwgma AZw^dmVrb dVy{df`r, Zm{df`r Amnbo _V
~Z{dV AgVo. dVyMo kmZ {_i{dVmZm dVy{df`r {^Z _Vo AgVrb. _m AJXrM {^Z _V Agob Va Vo
{dMmamV Z KoVm `mMo dOZ H$amd`mMo. AZoH$mnH$s Oo _V "gmYmaU' Agob, hUOo `m{df`r AZoH$mMo
EH$_V hmoD$ eH$Vo Vo drH$mamd`mMo. Aem [aVrZo g^mfU nVr dmn$Z gmHo${Q>g kmZ{ZpMVr H$arV
Ago. gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo kmZ{dVmamgmR>r, {dMmam`m {dH$mgmgmR>r g^mfU nVr A{YH$ Cn`wV Amho.
H$maU `m nVrV gdgmYmaU {dMmaj_Vm Agbo`m `VrnmgyZ Vo {deofkmn`V gdm`m gh^mJmMm
Cn`moJ H$$Z KoVm òVmo.
3)
`m`mZm_H$ d gH$nZm_H$ -
gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo dVy`m _wb^yV d {ZpMV kmZmgmR>r `m `m dVy`m `m`m H$aUo Amd`H$
AgVo. `m gX^mV `m`m hUOo H$m` ? `m ZmMo Cma W_ nmh. eXmZm, H$nZmZm AZoH$ AW Agy
eH$VmV. Oohm AWm`m ~m~VrV AZoH$ n`m` AgVmV Vohm Zo_H$m H$moUVm AW drH$mamd`mMm hm Z
CnpWV hmoVmo. `m`m hUOo EImm nXmMm, eXmMm {ZpMV D$ Zo_H$m d gd_m` hmoBb Agm AW
gmJUo hmo`. VdkmZm`m n[a^mfoV EImm nXmMr `dN>oXH$ bjU gmJUoo, Zo_H$m AW gmJUo hUOo
`m`m hmo`. nXmMm AWdm eXmMr `m`m Ho$`mda Vo nX AWdm eX BVamnmgyZ H$go {^Z AmhoV ho
n> hmoVo. gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo `mò{edm` kmZmMm {dVma e` ZgVmo. `m`m H$aVmZm `mòo` dVyMo
gmd{H$ d$n n> hmoVo.
gmHo${Q>gZo Amn`m nVr_ò `m`, ehmUnU, Y` `mgma`m gH$nZm`m `m`m {ZpMV
Ho$bo`m {XgyZ òVmV. Amn`m g^mfU nVrmao `m` `m gH$nZobm `mo` Jmo> H$aUo, Agm EH$ AW
Ho$bm. CXm.H$OXmamZo AmnU KoVbo`m H$OmMr doioda naV\o$S> H$aUo `m`mMo Amho, `mo` Amho. òH$mZo
Amnbo Zo_yZ {Xbobo H$V` m_m{UH$nUo nma nmS>Uo hUOo `m` hmo`. boQ>moZo Amn`m "[anpbH$' `m
JWm_ò gmHo${Q>gZo "`m`' `m eXmMm Omo AW gm{JVbm Vmo _mU _mZbobm Amho. `md$Z gmHo${Q>g
eXmMo {H$Vr AMyH$ AW {ZpMV H$arV Ago ho nQ> hmoVo. gmHo${Q>gZo ehmUnU, Y` `mgma`m gH$nZm`m
`m`m {ZpMV Ho$bo`m AmhoV.
4)
AZw^dmda AmYm[aV d {dJm_r :-
VdkmZmVrb {dMma Ho$di H$mn{ZH$ AgUo `mo` Zmhr. VmpdH$ {dMma gdgm_m` _mUgmbm
g_Obo nm{hOoV `mgmR>r VdqMVZmbm bm{H$H$ `dhmamVr AZw^dmMm AmYma Agbm nm{hOo. gmHo${Q>gZo
AWog ZJa am`mVrb emgZmMm dV: AZw^d KoVbm hmoVm d `m AZw^dmd$Z `mZo Amnbo am`
`dWo~bMo {dMma `V Ho$bo hmoVo. gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo OJVmZm _mUgmZo doJdoJio AZw^d _J - Vo gwIX
63
AgmoV dm Xw:IX AgmoV -KoVbo nm{hOo d Amn`m AZw^dm`m AmYmao Amnbo {dMma nHo$ Ho$bo nm{hOoV.
Amn`m {dMmamMm AZw^d hm AmYma Agbm nm{hOo Ago gmHo${Q>g AmJhnydH$ {VnmXZ H$aVmo.
{dJm_r nVr hUOo H$m` ?
VdkmZ d VH$emm`m A`mgmV {dJm_r nVr hr EH$ _m`Vm nmdbobr nVr Amho. Amn`m
g^modVr`m {ddmVrb gdM KQ>ZmMo kmZ AWdm AZw^d Amn`mbm ZgVmo. VWm{n AZw^dmVrb H$mhr
_moO`m KQ>Zm`m AmYmao Amn`mbm H$mhr {ZH$f H$mT>Vm òVmV. {dJm_r nVrV {d{e> CXmhaUo
{dMmamV KoD$Z `m`m AmYmao VemM H$ma`m gd CXmhaUm{df`r EH$ `mnH$ {ZH$f H$mT>bm OmVmo.
CXm. "j' hr H$>miy `Vr Am`w`mV èdr Pmbr. "`' hr H$>miy `Vr Am`w`mV èdr Pmbr.
hUyZ gd H$>miy `Vr Am`w`mV èdr hmoVrb. `m {ZH$fmMm AW Agm H$s Omo Omo H$moUr Amnmn`m
jomV H$> H$arb Vmo èdr hmoBb Agm gm_m` {ZH$f H$mT>Vm òVmo. {dJm_r nVrV {d{e> CXmhaUm`m
ghm`mZo gm_m` {ZH$f H$mT>bm OmVmo _m hm {ZH$f g^m` _mZbm OmVmo. g^m` {ZH$fmMo IS>Z
H$aUo e` AgVo, `mMm ~mY hmoD$ eH$Vmo. AmYw{ZH$ emr` kmZmMm {dH$mg hr {dJ_Z nVrMr èdr
\$b{Znmr _mZbr OmVo.
5) {ZJm_r :gmHo${Q>gMr nVr {ZJm_r d$nmMrhr (Deductive) Amho. VdkmZ d VH$emm`m A`mgmV
{dJm_r nVr_mUoM {ZJm_r nVrhr {deof _hdmMr Amho. `m XmoZ nVtMm Cn`moJ H$$Z kmZ{dVma
e` AgVmo. Oohm EImm `mnH$ Vdm`m AWdm {Z`_m`m AmYmao Vo Vd AWdm {Z`_ `m jombm
bmJy nS>Vmo `m jomVrb gd dVy`m{df`r AZw_mZ H$aUo hUOo {ZJm_r nVr hmo`. {ZJm_r nVrMo
d$n Imbrb `wVrdmXmd$Z n> H$$ 1) gd ^m{VH$ dVy JwdmH$fUm`m {Z`_mZo ~ AmhoV.
2) XJS> hr ^m{VH$ dVy Amho.
hUyZ XJS> JwdmH$fUm`m {Z`_mZo ~ Amho. `m `wVrdmXmMm {ZH$f AmYma {dYmZmd$Z hUOo
nwam`m`m {dYmZmd$Z {ZnZ Pmbm Amho. VH$emmVrb AZw_mZmMm Ame` Agm AgVmo H$s Oa AmYma
{dYmZo g` AgVrb Va {ZH$f g`M Agbm nm{hOo. {ZJm_r nVrZo mV Pmbobo {ZH$f g~i
nwam`mda AmYm[aV Ag`mZo `mMo IS>Z H$aVm òV Zmhr qH$dm `mMm ~mY hmoV Zmhr.
6.2.2 gmHo${Q>gMr Zr{V{df`H$ {eH$dU (Moral Teachings of Socrates) :JrH$ VdkmZm`m B{VhmgmV gmHo${Q>gbm Oo _hdmMo WmZ mV Pmbo Vo _w`V: `m`m Zr{V{df`H$
VdkmZm_wio hmo`. gmHo${Q>gZo VdkmZ{df`H$ {d{e> {dMma gXm` gm{JVbobm Zgbm Var `m`m
VdkmZmMr VdkmZm`m B{VhmgmV Or Zm|X KoVbr Jobr Vr m_w`mZo `mZo gm{JVbo`m d gd_m`
Pmbo`m Zr{V{df`H$ >rH$moZm_wio. gmHo${Q>g EH$ _hmZ Zr{V{ejH$ hmoVm. AmOhr Z{VH$Vo`m ~m~VrV
""_mUyg H$gm Agmdm'' Agm Z {dMmabm Va ""gmHo${Q>ggmaIm Ago '' Cma mdo bmJVo. AWog `m
mMrZ JrH$ ZJa am`m_ò gmHo${Q>gnydu gmo{\$> ZmdmMm VdkmZmVrb EH$ gXm` hmoD$Z Jobm. gmo{\$>
gXm`mVrb {dMmadV _moR>o Vdn{S>V hmoVo. Vo dmX{ddmXmV A`V nQ>mBV Ag`mZo `j MM}_ò
Amn`m {Vnjmbm {dMmam`m nmVirda Zm_moha_ H$arV AgV. gmo{\$>m`m dmX{ddmX ebr_wio gnyU
Jrg_ò VdkmZmMo _hmZ {ejH$ hUyZ `mZr bm{H$H$ {_i{dbm. gmo{\$> `dhmadmXmMo g_WH$ Ag`mZo
64
`j `dhmamV OJVmZm òUm`m ZmMo `dhmadmXr Cma emoY`mg `mMo mYm` hmoVo. gmo{\$>m`m
`dhmadmXr {eH$dUr_wio Jrg_ò `dhmadmXr Zr{V_mm (Practical Morality) _mZbr OmD$ bmJbr.
`j `dhma d Zr{V_mm `mMm _oi ~gUo H$R>rU hmoD$ bmJ`mZo ew Z{VH$ OrdZmMm nm`m S>i_irV
hmoD$ bmJbm. H$moU`mhr _mZdr g_mOmMr dMm[aH$ d Z{VH$ ~R>H$ ^H$_ Agob VaM Vmo g_mO OrdZm`m
bT>mV XrKH$mi Q>rH$mdm Y$ eH$Vmo.gmHo${Q>gZo Jrg_Yrb gmo{\$> {dMmadVmZr g_mOmbm Oo `mdhm[aH$
Zr{V_moMo YS>o {Xbo d `m_wio JrH$ ZJaam`mMm hmg H$gm Pmbm `mda n>nUo ^m` H$amd`mg ma^
Ho$bm. òH$ _mZdr g_mOmMo d{eQ> hUOo `mMr C^maUr emdV, {MaVZ d AmXe Vdmda Pmbr
nm{hOo, Aer gmHo${Q>gMr YmaUm hmoVr. gmo{\$>m`m Z{VH$ {eH$dUr_wio g_mOm_ò Or dmW bmobwnVm,
_y`hrZ, AmXembm Z _mZUmar dmr {Z_mU Pmbr Vr amoI`mgmR>r C`m _mUyg OmVrbm _mJXeH$ R>aob
Aer AmXe Z{VH$ {eH$dU gm{JVbr.
gmHo${Q>gMr Z{VH$ {eH$dU :gmHo${Q>gMr Z{VH$ {eH$dU d `mMo gnyU Zr{Vem nwT>rb VrZ Vdmda AmYm[aV Amho - 1)
gXJwU hUOo kmZ 2) gXJwUmMr {eH$dU XoVm òVo. 3) gXJwU EH$d$nr Amho.
darb òH$ VdmMo {dVmamZo n>rH$aU H$$ :
1) gXJwU hUOo kmZ (Virtue is Knowledge) :gXJwU hUOo `VrZo hoVwV: mV H$$Z `md`mMr Jmo>. `Vr`m AJr Agbobo AmXe JwU
hUOo gXJwU hmo`. nmMrZ H$mimnmgyZ g`_ qH$dm ghZerbVm (Patience), `m` (Justice), Y`
(Courage) d ehmUnU (Wisdom) `mZm gXJwU hUyZ g_mO_m`Vm {_imbr Amho. gmHo${Q>gZo `m Mmahr
gXJwUmMo Amn`m Z{VH$ {eH$dUr_ò {ddoMZ Ho$bo Amho. gmHo${Q>g`m _VmZwgma H$moU`mhr _mUgmbm
g`_mZo dmJ`m{edm`, namH$moQ>rMr ghZerbVm XmI{d`m{edm` èdr hmoVm òUma Zmhr. g`_ hUOo
Amn`m dVZmda, H$Vrda, H$m`mda dV: {ZÙ R>odUoo hmo`. Amnbr H$Vr Amn`m {ZÙmV Agob Va
H$Vr H$a`mV MyH$ hmoUma Zmhr d Vr H$Vr qH$dm H$m` BVamZm _mJXeH$ Aer hmoBb. g`_/ghZerbVm `m
gXJwUmMm Xwgam AW hUOo mV n[apWVrda _mUgmbm _mV H$aVm Ambr nm{hOo. n[apWVr AZwHy$b
Agmo dm {VHy$b Agmo Vr pWa _ZmZo nM{dVm Ambr nm{hOo.
"`m`' `m gXJwUmMm AW n> H$aVmZm gmHo${Q>g hUVmo H$s, EImXr H$Vr `mo` [aVrZo H$aUo hUOo
`m` hmo`. `mgmR>r `Vrbm `mo` H$m` A`mo` H$m` ho g_Obo nm{hOo. `m` hUOo `m `m `Vrbm
`Vr`m gm_m{OH$ WmZm_mUo dmJUyH$ XoUo hmo`. `m` hUOo gdmZm g_mZ dmJUyH$ XoUo Ago hU`mV
darb Ame` `V hmoVmo. CXm.EImm gm_m` AHw$eb H$m_Jmamg C nXW A{YH$m`mBVHo$ doVZ XoUo
hUOo `m` Zho, Va `m XmoKmZm `m`m `mo`Vo_mUo doVZ XoUo hUOo `m` hmo`. `m` `m eXmMm
AmUIr EH$ AW hUOo "g_mZ n[apWVrV AgUm`mZm g_mZ dmJUyH$ XoUo'. hUOo gmHo${Q>g gXJwU d
kmZmbm EH$M _mZVmo. Vohm kmZ hUOo kmZ{df`mMo R>m_ AmH$bZ, g`mMm gmjmH$ma d Xdr _y`mMo
`mo` agJhU Agm AW gmHo${Q>gbm A{ôV Amho. gXJwU OmUUo hUOo darb gXJwUmZw$n dmJUo hmo`.
Amn`mbm `m Jmo>rMo kmZ ZgVo `m Jmo>r Amn`m hmVyZ KS>`m_wio MwH$m hmoVmV. hUyZ AkmZ ho gd
_mXmMo (MwH$mMo) CJ_WmZ hmo`. gXdVZ Ho$di `moJm`moJmZo H$YrM KS>V Zmhr.
65
2)
gXJwUmMr {eH$dU XoVm òVo (Virtues can be taught) :-
gmHo${Q>g ZwwgVm nwVH$s nS>rV ZhVm. g_mOmVrb òH$ _mUgm`m AJr AmXe, _yò ho JwU
Agbo nm{hOoV. `mZo AWog_Yrb gm_m{OH$ OrdZmVrb Xmof dV: AZw^dbo hmoVo. gmHo${Q>g`m darb
{dYmZmVyZ "`Wm amOm VWm Om' `m bm{H$H$ {dYmZmMm `` òVmo. gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo g_mO AZwH$aUerb
d^mdmMm AgVmo. `mZm g_mO JwWmZr _mZVmo, AmXe _mZVmo `m`m òH$ H$VrVyZ g_mO H$mhrVar
{eH$V AgVmo. kmZr _mUgmnmgyZ g_mO kmZmVrMm _mJ {eH$V AgVmo. draMH$ YmaH$mH$Sy>Z Y` hm JwU
KoVbm OmVmo. gmHo${Q>gZo gm{JVbobo darb gXJwU H$go AJr ~mUmdoV `mMr g_mOmbm {eH$dU XoUo e`
Amho. AmnU ^maVr` _mUgo amQ>{nVm _hm_m JmYrnmgyZ g`_, Y`, ehmUnU d `m` `m gXJwUmMr
{eH$dU KoVmo.
3)
gXJwU EH$d$nr Amho (Virtue as a whole) :-
Amn`m AZw^dmVrb {df` H$_r OmV d$nmV g` Agy eH$VmV. EImXr dVy BVHo$ Q>Ho$
MmJbr Amho nU {VVHo$ Q>Ho$ MmJbr Zmhr Ago Amn`m AZw^dmV Agy eH$Vo. gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo dVy_mUo
A{eH$ g`mMr ^mfm gXJwUm~m~V dmnaVm òV Zmhr. hUOo ehmUnU hm gXJwU 70 Q>Ho$ `mo` d 30
Q>Ho$ A`mo` Ago `m gXJwUm`m ~m~VrV hUVm òV Zmhr. `m gX^mV gmHo${Q>g hUVmo H$s _mUyg
ehmUm Agob AWdm ehmUm Zgob, _mUyg Y`dmZ Agob AWdm Y`dmZ Zgob. hUOo `m` hmo`. CXm. A
Am{U ~ XmoKohr H${Z> boI{ZH$ AgyZ XmoKmMrhr godm g_mZ dfmMr Agob Va `m XmoKmZmhr g_mZ doVZ XoUo
hUOo `m` hmo`.
ehmUnU `m gXJwUmMo {ddoMZ H$aVmZm gmHo${Q>g hUVmo, H$s ehmUnU d ~w{_mm `mMr JbV
H$$ Zò. ehmUnU hUOo _mUgmMr gmamgma {dMma~wr. Amn`m gmamgma ~wrMm Cn`moJ H$$Z
gJmZwgma, n[apWVrZwgma Omo `mo` VmoM {ZU` KoVmo, `mo` VrM H$Vr H$aVmo Vmo ehmUm hmo`. CXm. "j'
hm ~w{_mZ nmobrg A{YH$mar Amho. `m`mda g_mOmVrb H$m`Xm d gw`dWm amI`mMr H$m`Xoera
O~m~Xmar Amho. `mg Amd`H$ Vohm Jmoir~ma H$a`mMm A{YH$ma AgVmo. `m`m H$m`mb`mda OZVoMm
_mooMm Am`mda Vmo A{YH$mar Jmoir~mamMm AmXoe XoD$ eH$Vmo d _moMm nmJdy eH$Vmo. _m _moM}H$ar Zo`mer
gmhmXnyU MMm H$$Z, OZVo`m ^mdZm bjmV KoD$Z gm_O`mZo Vmo _moM}H$`mZm emV H$aVmo. `m CXmhaUmV
nmobrg A{YH$m`m`m ~w{_monojm `mMo ehmUnU A{YH$ Cn`wV R>aVo. hUyZ gmHo${Q>gMm Agm AmJh
hmoVm H$s g_mOmbm ehm`m _mUgmMr A{YH$ JaO Amho. ehmUnUmV kmZ {df`mMr nwaoer JhU j_Vm,
nwaonya AmH$bZ d mg{JH$ {ZU` j_Vm `mMm g_mdoe Agbm nm{hOo Ago gmHo${Q>gMo _V Ago.
Y` hUOo `Vr`m AJr Agbobr YmS>gmMr dmr. gJmbm gm_moao Om`mMr dmr, n[apWVr
nmgyZ nbm`ZdmX Z drH$maVm `m n[apWVrbm OmUrdnydH$ gVH$VoZo Vm|S> XoUo hUOo Y` hmo`. gmHo${Q>gMo
_Vo eyamMm JwU hUOo Y`. gmHo${Q>g g_mOmbm Z{VH$VoMo {ejU XoV AgVmZm g_mOmVrb òH$mZo
OrdZmVrb Y` hm gXJwU AJr ~mUbmM nm{hOo `m~m~V AmJhr Ago. g_mOmVrb ôH$S>m`m \$mOonojm EH$
eyadra Ho$hmhr lo> R>aVmo. gXJwUm~m~V Am{eH$ g` hr H$nZm MwH$sMr R>aVo.
gmHo${Q>g`m Z{VH$ {eH$dUrV `mZo Mm[a`mMm {dMma Ho$bm Amho. `mMo _Vo _mUyg d mUr `mV
_mUyg eVnQ>rZo lo> Amho Vmo Mm[a`m`m H$nZo_wio. `mMo dmJUo `m`, ZrVr, gm_m{OH$ AmXe, _yò
`mZm AZwg$Z AgVo Agm _Zw` Mm{a`dmZ hmo`. OrdZmV BVa Jmo>r {_iVrb d OmVrb nU Mm[a` _m
gnmXZ H$amdoM bmJob. Mm[a`m{edm` _Zw` hr H$nZmM H$adV Zmhr. hUyZ _mUgmZo gj_ Mm[a`
66
gnmXZ H$amdo. Mm[a`dmZ _mUgo XrKH$mi g_mOm`m _aUmV amhVmV.

_mZdm`m ^m{VH$ JVr~m~V gmHo${Q>g hUVmo H$s, Ho$di ~m-^m{VH$ JVrd$Z _mZdr g_mOmMo
_moR>onU _moObo OmV Zmhr Va _mZdr g_mO AmV[aH$Q>m {H$Vr g_mYmZr Amho ho A{YH$ _hdmMo Amho.
_mUyg {dMma, H$nZm, gXJwU, g_mOerbVm, kmZbmbgm, am>r` Ap_Vm `m~m~V {H$Vr g_ Amho
`md$Z `mMo gwI-g_mYmZ _moObo nm{hOo. Z{VH$ OrdZ _mZdm`m >rZo {H$Vr lo> Amho `m~m~V gmHo${Q>g
hUVmo H$s, ""^m{VH$ g_mYmZmZo VV Agbo`m newnojm Ag_mYmZr {dmZ Ho$hmhr lo> hmo`.'' (It is
better to be a man dis-satisfied than to be a pig satisfied.)
Zr{V_moMo lo>d gmJVmZm gmHo${Q>g hUVmo H$s, _mUgmVyZ Zr{V_mm dOm Ho$`mg {ebH$ amhVmo
Vmo ney. gmHo${Q>g`m >rH$moZmVyZ gXJwUm~ahHw$_ AmMaU H$aUo, òH$ H$VrJ{UH$ `m`-Zr{V `mMm
Adb~ H$aUo hrM _mZdr Am`mMr Iar {gr hmoo`.
gmame :mMrZ JrH$ VdkmZmV {ddmg~Yr {ddoMZ Ho$bo. _m gmHo${Q>g hm n{hbmM VdqMVH$ H$s `mZo
_mZdH|$r - _mZdr OrdZmg~Yr _hdm`m {df`mZm ne Ho$bm. gmHo${Q>gbm Ago A{ôV hmoVo H$s, _mZdr
g_mO {MaVZ d AmXe _y`mda AmYm[aV Agbm nm{hOo. `m g_mOmbm emdVVoMo A{Y>mZ AgV Zmhr
`m g_mO OrdZmMr dmVmhV hmoVo. `mMo R>iH$ CXmhaU hUyZ gmHo${Q>gZo AWog JrH$ ZJa am`mMm hmg
ho {Xbobo Amho. Z{VH$ {dMmamMo g_WZ H$aVmZm `mZo ^m{VH$mbm JmU WmZ {Xbobo Amho. g_mOmMo lo>d
g_mOmVrb ^m{VH$ gwYmaUmda Adb~yZ ZgyZ g_mOmVrb Mm[a`dmZ, Zr{V_mZ _mUgmda H$go Adb~yZ
Amho ho XmIdyZ {Xbo Amho. gmHo${Q>gZo VdkmZm`m B{VhmgmV ge` nVrbm _mZmMo WmZ {_idyZ {Xbo.
_m `mMr ge`nVr ge`mgmR>r ge` Aer ZgyZ g`mdofU- g`mMm emoY KoUmar ge` nVr
Amho, kmZ {dVma H$aUmar nVr Amho.
6.2.3 boQ>moMr kmZ{df`H$ Cnnmr (Plato's Theory of Knowledge) :boQ>monydu gmo{\$> VdkmZm_ò moQ>Jmoag `m gmo{\$> VdqMVH$mZo "gdoXZ nVrbm' kmZmMr Cnnmr
hUyZ _m`Vm {Xbr hmoVr. moQ>JmoagMo _Vo Amn`mbm ^m{VH$ dVyMm gdoXZm`m nmVirda Omo AZw^d
òVmo Vo Amnbo dVy{df`H$ kmZ hmo`. òH$ km`mbm òUmam AZw^d hUOo `mMo kmZ hmo`. `md$Z
"_Zw` hmM gd Jmo>tMm _mnXS> hmo`' (Man is the measure of all things) hmM kmZmMm {ZH$f
_mZbm. gdoXZ hoM kmZmMo _mU gmYZ hmo`, nVr hmo`. kmZ ho gdoXZmVyZ O_mbm òVo d gdoXZ hmM
kmZmMm AmYma hmo` Agm moQ>JmoagZo >rH$moZ drH$mabm hmoVm.
Amnbr kmZ|{ò Amn`m AZw^dmVrb kmZ{df`mMo AZw^d KoVmV, `m AZw^dmMo JhU hmoVo d `m
AZw^dmVyZ Amn`mbm kmZmVr hmoVo Ago moQ>JmoagZo n> Ho$bo Amho. gmo{\$>m`m gdoXZO` kmZmMo
boQ>moZo Amn`m "moQ>Jmoag' `m gdmXmV IS>Z Ho$bo Amho. ho IS>Z hUOoM boQ>moMr kmZ Cnnmr hmo`.
boQ>mo`m kmZ CnnmrV moQ>Jmoag`m darb {gmVmda Imbrb Amjon KoVbobo AmhoV 1) boQ>moMo _Vo Amnbo B{`mZw^d gmaIo ~XbV Ag`m_wio B{`mZw^dm_wio EImm kmZ {df`mMo
{d_mZ kmZ ^{d`H$mbrZ kmZmnojm {^Z Agy eHo$b.
2) EH$mM dVyMr gdoXZo {^Z H$maMr Agy eH$VmV. CXm.H$mdri Pmbo`m `Vrg g_moa`m
gdM dVy {nd`m {XgVmV. _J dVy Zo_H$s H$er _mZmd`mMr ? {nm `mYrZo JV Agbo`m `Vrbm
67
gmIahr H$Sy> bmJVo. _J gmIa H$Sy> _mZmd`mMr H$m ?

3) gdoXZ CnnmrZwgma òH$ `VrMo gdoXZ d AZw^d {^Z Ag`m_wio "gm_m`kmZ {gmV'
H$YrM ApVdmV òD$ eH$Uma Zmhr.
4) g`m{df`r moQ>Jmoag hUVmo H$s, `mbm `mbm {^Z Jmo>r g` dmQy> eH$VmV `mda boQ>moMo
{VnmXZ Ago H$s, moQ>JmoagMm g`mMm {ZH$f _mZbm Va "gm_m` g`' H$YrM gmJVm òUma Zmhr.
5) Amn`mbm òUmam AZw^d hm Ho$di B{`mmao mV hmoV Zmhr. òUm`m AZw^dmMm AW bmd`mMo
_hdmMo H$m` ~wrMo Amho.
6) kmZ {H$òV gmo{\$>mZr ~wr `m KQ>H$mH$S>o nyUnUo Xwbj Hoo$bo Amho.
7) gmo{\$> VdkmZmV kmZ d _V `mV \$aH$ Ho$bobm Zmhr. EImm Jmo>r~m~V AmnU _Vo (Opinions) ~Z{dV AgVmo. H$mbMo _V AmO ~Xby eH$Vo. _V dadaMo XoIrb Agy eH$Vo. _m kmZm`m ~m~VrV
Ago Agy eH$V Zmhr. hUOoM moQ>Jmoag d gmo{\$>mZr kmZ CnnmrMm `mnH$ Ame` d AW bjmV
KoVbobm Zmhr Ago {XgyZ òVo.
6.2.4 boQ>moMr H$nZm{df`H$ Cnnmr (Plato's Theory of Ideas) :boQ>mo`m VdkmZmVrb _hdmMr Cnnmr qH$dm {gmV hUOo boQ>moMr H$nZm Cnnmr hmo`. Amn`m
AZw^dmV AZoH$ `Vr, dVy Agy eH$VmV. CXm. {hadm M|Sy>, {ndim M|Sy>, Vm~S>m M|Sy> `m gd CXmhaUmV
MoSy> VrZ AmhoV - dVy VrZ AmhoV. `m VrZhr M|Sy>Mo aJ {^Z AmhoV Var `m gdm_ò "M|Sy>' hr H$nZm
EH$M Amho. `mMr H$nZm Cnnmr hUOo _mZdr {dMmamZm dmV{dH$ AZw^dm`m nmVird$Z dMm[aH$
nmVirda ZoUo hmo`.
boQ>mo`m H$nZm {gmVmZwgma H$nZmMr d{eQ>o Imbrb_mUo 1) H$nZm `m_H$ AmhoV (Ideas are Substances). Oo H$emdahr Adb~yZ ZgVo, dV:M
{ZYm[aV AgVo `mg ` hUVmV. CXm._mUyg hm Ord hdm, AZ, nmUr `mda Adb~yZ Amho. nU
"_Zw`' hr H$nZm `mnH$s H$emdahr Adb~yZ Zmhr.
2) H$nZm gmdXo{eH$ AgVmV (Ideas are Universal). `mMm AW H$nZm gd AgVmV. H$nZmZm
WbH$mbmMo ~YZ ZgVo. CXm.H$moU`mhr Jmd`m, Xoem`m _mUgm_ò _Zw` hr H$nZm AgVo. EImXm
AZmoiIr _mUyg ôQ>bm Var `mbm AmnU _mUygM hUVmo. H$nZm ^yVH$mimV hmo`m, AmO dV_mZH$mir
AmhoV d ^{d`H$mimVhr AgVrb.
3) H$nZm nXmW n qH$dm dVy$n ZgyZ {dMma$n AgVmV (Ideas are not things but they are
thoughts). AZw^dmVrb dVyMo AWdm nXmWmMo ApVd ho ^m{VH$ ApVd AgVo. dVyMm kmZ|{`mZm
AZw^d KoVm òVmo. _m dVy`m H$nZm kmZ|{`m`m H$joV òV ZmhrV Va {dMmamZoM g_Oy eH$VmV.
CXm.gwXa dVy S>mo`mZm {XgVo nU gwXa dVyVrb gmX` {dMmamZrM g_Oy eH$Vo.
4) H$nZm Eo`$n AgVmV (Ideas are Unitary). `mMm AW dVy AZoH$ Agy eH$VmV nU `m
AZoH$ dVyVrb H$nZm EH$M AgVo. CXm._mUgo CM, _`_, ~wQ>H$s, dmWu, m_m{UH$, b~mS> Aer Agy
eH$VmV nU `m gdmVrb "_Zw`' hr H$nZm _m EH$M AgVo. `mbmM {Z`_ EH$_ AZoH$mZwJV_ (one
among many) Ago hUVm òBb.
68
5) H$nZm n[adVZr` AgVmV (Ideas are unchanging). AZw^dmVrb dVy_ò gmaIo n[adVZ
hmoV AgVo. dVyMo d$n gmaIo ~XbV AgVo. CXm. _mVrnmgyZ Hw$^ma KQ> ~Z{dVmo. AmOMm KQ> H$mhr
dfmZr doJim dmQ>ob d ZVa \w$Qy>Zhr OmBb. _m KQ> \w$Q>bm hUyZ KQ>mMr H$nZm Z> hmoUma Zmhr.
6) òH$ H$nZm ho nyUd AgVo (Every Idea is a perfection). AZw^dmVrb dVy_ò Va-V_d
AgVo hUOo dVy bhmZ-_moR>m Agy eH$VmV. dVy bhmZ Agmo dm _moR>m AgmoV `md$Z bhmZ dVyVrb
H$nZm bhmZ, _moR>m dVyVrb H$nZm _moR>r Ago _m Agy eH$V Zmhr. CXm.ndV bhmZ Agmo dm
{h_mb`mgmaIm _moR>m Agmo "ndV' hr H$nZm nyUV: AgVo.
7) H$nZm \$V ~wrZoM OmU`m OmD$ eH$VmV (Ideas are known by reason alone). H$nZm
d$nmZo ^m{VH$ dVygma`m Zg`mZo `mMm B{` gdoXZmZo `` òD$ eH$V Zmhr. CXm.Jm`r Amn`mbm
B{` gdoXZmZo {XgVmV nU Jm`t_ò Oo "Jmod' AgVo Vo \$V {dMmamZo qH$dm ~wrZoM g_Oy eH$Vo.
6.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z :1)
A)
`mo` n`m` {ZdSy>Z {dYmZo nyU H$am.

1)
gmHo${Q>gMr nVr ------------ Amho.

( gdmXm_H$ / AZw^dm_H$ / m_m`m_H$ )
2)
gmHo${Q>gMo _Vo ------------ hUOo kmZ.

( gXJwU / gdoXZ / AVkmZ )
3)
gmHo${Q>gMr nVr ------------ Mm emoY KoUmar Amho.

( g`m / Ag`mMm / b~mS>rMm )
4)
boQ>moMo VdkmZ ------------ Amho.

( AmXedmXr / OS>dmXr / AZw^ddmXr )
5)
AmXe am`H$ma^mamg~Yr boQ>moZo ------------ hm JW {b{hbm.

( [anpbH$ / {\$S>mo / nm{b{Q>g )
6)
gmo{\$>m`m kmZ {gmVmMo IS>Z boQ>moZo -------- `m gdmXmV Ho$bobo Amho.

( moQ>Jmoag / `w{W\$mo / Ho$Q>mo )
~)
Imbrb ZmMr EH$m dm`mV Cmao m.

1)
gmHo${Q>gZo H$moUVo gXJwU gm{JVbo AmhoV ?
2)
gmHo${Q>gbm H$moUVo {df meZ H$a`mMr {ejm {Xbr Jobr ?
3)
AWog òWo boQ>moZo WmnZ Ho$bo`m kmZ H|$mMo Zmd H$m` ?
4)
H$nZmMr gmdXo{eH$Vm hUOo H$m` ?
69
5)
boQ>moZo JWboIZ H$moU`m d$nmV Ho$bo Amho ?
6)
boQ>moZo g`m`m dVw{Z>VoMr MMm H$moU`m gdmXmV Ho$br Amho ?
6.4 nm[a^m{fH$ eX :gdmX
nanam_Yrb g^mfU
Vd_r_mgm
EImm {dMmamMo {ddoMZ qH$dm MMm
gVVd
ApVd{df`H$ Vd
^m{VH$ {dd
Amn`m g^modVrMo OJ
AH$S>o_r
kmZH|$
gdoXZ
kmZ|{`mZr hmoUmao kmZ
6.5 d` A``Z ZmMr Cmao :1) A)

~)
1) gdmXm_H$
2) gXJwU
3) g`mMm
4) AmXedmXr
5) [anpbH$
6) moQ>Jmoag
1) g`_erbVm, `m`, ehmUnU d Y` ho Mma gXJwU gm{JVbo AmhoV.

2) gmHo${Q>gbm "ho_bmH$' {df meZ H$a`mMr {ejm {Xbr hmoVr.
3) AWog òWo boQ>moZo "AH$S>o_r' ho kmZ H|$ WmnZ Ho$bo hmoVo.
4) H$nZm gd AgUo hUOo H$nZmMr gmdXo{eH$Vm hmo`.
5) boQ>moZo JWboIZ gdmXm_H$ d$nmV Ho$bo Amho.
6) g`m`m dVy{Z>VoMr MMm boQ>moZo {WA{Q>Q>g `m gdmXmV Ho$br Amho.
6.6 gmame :mMrZ JrH$ VdkmZmV {ddmg~YrMo {ddoMZ Ho$bo Jobo Amho. _m gmHo${Q>g hm n{hbmM VdqMVH$
H$s `mZo _mZdH|$r - _mZdmg~Yr, am` `dWog~Yr _hdm`m {df`mZm ne Ho$bm. gmHo${Q>gbm Ago
A{ôV hmoVo H$s, _mZdr g_mO {MaVZ d AmXe _y`mda AmYm[aV Agbm nm{hOo. `m g_mOmbm
emdVVoMo A{Y>mZ AgV Zmhr `m g_mOmMm hmg hmoVmo ho AWog`m CXmhaUmd$Z XmIdyZ {Xbo Amho.
g_mOmMr nS>PS> amoI`mgmR>r g_mOmbm Z{VH$ {eH$dU XoUo JaOoMo Amho Ago AmJhmZo Vmo gmJVmo.
g_mOmMo lo>d g_mOmVrb Zwg`m ^m{VH$ gwYmaUmda Adb~yZ ZgVo Va g_mOmVrb Mm[a`dmZ,
Zr{V_mZ _mUgmda H$go Adb~yZ Amho ho XmIdyZ Xo`mgmR>r gXJwUmMo g_WZ Ho$bo Amho. gmHo${Q>gZo
gèmoYZmgmR>r ge` nVrbm _hdmMo WmZ {_idyZ {Xbo.
boQ>moZo Amn`m VdkmZmV AmXe am`mMr H$nZm n> Ho$br Amho. kmZm`m jomV Umbr~
VdkmZ gmJUmam boQ>mo hm n{hbm VdqMVH$ R>aVmo. amOZr{V, {ejU, gm{h` Aem AZoH$ {df`mda `mZo
AmXedmXr Q>rH$moZ gm{JVbo. gmo{\$>m`m gdoXZ {gmVmMr g{_jm H$$Z kmZ{gmVmMr WbH$mb
70
{ZanojVm {VnmXZ Ho$br. boQ>moMr H$nZm Cnnmr hUOo _`m{XV Aem AZw^dm`m OJmn{bH$S>o nmh`mMm
~w{dmXr >rH$moZ hmo`. H$nZm Cnnmrmao `mZo Amn`m AZw^dmMo ~m{H$sH$aU Ho$bo Amho.
gmHo${Q>g`m gdmX nVrMo d$n {deX H$am.
2)
gmHo${Q>g`m gXJwUmMr MMm H$am.
3)
gmHo${Q>gMr Z{VH$ {eH$dU n> H$am.
4)
EH$ _hmZ {ejH$ hUyZ gmHo${Q>gMo H$m` gmJm.
5)
boQ>moMr kmZ Cnnmr n> H$am.
6)
boQ>mo`m H$nZm CnnmrMo d$n n> H$am.
6.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$ :H$n`m JWm`m eodQ>r gyMr nhm.

666
71
KQ>H$ - 7
gV Wm_g A{$Zmg ( St.Thomas Acquinas )

7.0 C{Q>o
7.1 mVm{dH$
7.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
7.2.1
Bdaem d VdkmZmMm g~Y
7.2.2
lm d ~wr
7.2.3
BdamMo d$n d
Bdam`m ApVdmg~YrMo nwamdo
7.3 d`-A``ZmgmR>r Z
7.6 gmame
7.0 C{Q>o :`m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZVa Amn`mbm * Bdaem d VdkmZmMm g~Y g_Oob.
* lm d ~wr `m`mVrb g~Y n> hmoBb.
* BdamMo d$n d Bdam`m ApVdm`m nwam`mMr _m{hVr hmoBb.
7.1 mVm{dH$ :_``wJrZ H$mbIS>m`m Ama^mnmgyZ Vo ~moYZ H$mimn`V `wamon_ò Y_gmoMm OrdZm`m gd
jomda {deof ^md hmoVm. Y_ VdkmZ hoM OrdZmMo VdkmZ _mZbo OmV Ago. Y_gmo`m ^mdH$mimVM
gV Wm_g A{$ZmgMo OrdZ Jobo. A{$ZmgMm O_ B.g.1224-25 _ò EH$m Hw$brZ Kam`mV Pmbm.
`mMo dS>rb A{$Zmo òWo H$mD$Q> hmoVo. A{$ZmgMo ma{^H$ {ejU H${gZmo`m {MZ Y_ _R>mV (Abbey
of Mante Cassino) Pmbo. A~Q> {X JoQ> `m {MZ Y_ n{S>Vm`m ghdmgmV amhZ `mZo 1252 n`V
{dm``Z Ho$bo.
72
Wm_g A{$ZmgZo Summa Cantra Gentiles d Summa Theologiae ho XmoZ _hdmMo JW

{b{hbo. `m Xmohr JWm_ò `mZo {MZ Y_ VdkmZ d BdaemmMo {dVV {ddoMZ Ho$bo Amho.
7.2 {df` {ddoMZ :7.2.1 Bdaem d VdkmZmMm g~Y Wm_g A{$Zmg Y_ VdkmZmMm {deof A`mgH$ Ag`mZo `mZo Y_VdkmZ d VdkmZmMm g~Y
XmIdyZ {Xbm Amho. `mMo _Vo Y_VdkmZ hm _mZdr OrdZmMm A{d^m` ^mJ Amho. Y_Vdm`m AmYmao
_mZdmbm Y_m_mUo AmMaU H$am, BVamMm of H$$ ZH$m, nanamda o_ H$am, nmnmMo AmMaU H$$ ZH$m,
gXd Iao ~mobm `mgma`m CXmm VdmMr {eH$dU {Xbr OmVo. Bdaem hm Y_emmMm EH$ Cn{d^mJ
AgVmo. BdaemmZwgma {ddmV Bda gdlo> Amho. AmnU Oo H$m_ H$aVmo Vo Bdam`m BN>oZwgmaM
H$arV AgVmo. ApdZmgZo Y_emo, JrH$ VdkmZ d {MZ VdkmZmMm A`mg H$$Z `mVrb Bda,
Am_m `m _hdm`m H$nZm {ZdS>`m. Bdaem hm Y_emmMm mU Amho. `m {ddmV Oo Oo H$mhr
KS>Vo Vo Bdam`m BN>oZwgmaM KS>Vo Aer `mMr lm hmoVr.A{$ZmgZo BdaemmMo Oo g_WZ Ho$bo Amho
Vo A[aQ>mQ>b`m gmmemmVrb Bda {dMmamMoM H$Q>Z Amho. Bdaem _mZdr g_mOmbm Am`mp_H$
~R>H$ mV H$$Z XoVo. Bdaem VddmXmer {MH$Qy>Z amhUmao Ag`mZo BdaemmV _mZdr {dMma
dmV`mbm \$maer _w^m ZgVo. BdaemmV {d (Trinity), AdVma H$nZm (Incarnation) d H$m{bH$
gOZVm (Temporal Creation) `m H$nZmZm {deof _hd AgVo.
VdkmZ _mZdr OrdZmMm gd ~mOyZr {dMma H$aVo. A{$ZmgMo _Vo VdkmZ hUOo gnyU _mZdr
OrdZmbm `mnyZ Q>mH$Umam {dMma hmo`. VdkmZmV Y_em-Bdaem, gH$Vr, _yèm d {dkmZmMmhr
g_mdoe hmoVmo. Bdaem d VdkmZmMm g~Y XmI{dVmZm Vmo hUVmo H$s, Bdaem OrdZm`m Am`mp_H$
AJmMm {dMma H$aVo. `mV BdamMm {dMma d Bdam`m Amkm hm _w` ^mJ AgVmo. Bdaem _mZdr
AmMaUm`m ewVobm lo> _mZVo. BdaemmZwgma _mZd H$moR>o O_bm `md$Z Vmo lo>-H${Z> R>aV Zmhr
Va Vmo H$em H$maMo AmMaU H$aVmo `md$Z _mZdmMr lo>Vm-H${Z>Vm R>a{dbr OmVo. VdkmZ _mZdr
ApVd, Z{VH$Vm, gH$Vr, {dMma nVr CXm.AZw^ddmX, ~w{dmX, Bdaem `m gdM AJmMm {dMma
H$aVo. VdkmZmMo A`mgjo \$maM `mnH$ AgVo. Bdaem d VdkmZ ho Xmohrhr _mZdr ApVdmgmR>r
Amd`H$ Ag`mZo `m`mV {damoY Agy eH$V Zmhr. `m Xmohm|V g~Y Amho Ago gmJ`mMm hoVy hUOo
{MZY_ d A[aQ>mQ>bMo Y_em d VdkmZ{df`H$ {dMmamV `mbm _oi ~gdmd`mMm hmoVm.
7.2.2 lm d ~wr
(Faith and Reason)
:-
{MZ Y_ VdkmZmV Y_dMZmZm {deof _hd Amho. `m VdkmZmV g`, Aqhgm, o_, H$Um,
emVr, X`m `mZm OrdZmMr emdV _yò _mZbo Amho. `m OrdZ _y`mZm _mZdr OrdZmV CM WmZ Agbo
nm{hOo. A{$ZmgMo _Vo lm hUOo Bdamda AT>i {ddmg AgUo, Bdam`m ApVdm{df`r {ddmg, Bdam~b
na_ AmXa AgUo hUOo lm hmo`. lm hr _mZdr OrdZmMr Am`mp_H$ ~mOy Amho. lo_ò `{${Z>Vm AgVo.
òH$ `VrMr Bdamda lm AgUo Amd`H$ Amho. _``wJmV òH$ Jmo>rMo {ZÙ H$aUmao Vd hUyZ BdamH$S>o
nm{hbo OmV Ago. `mVyZM Bdalm T> Pmbr. Amnbo H$V` BdamnU ~wrZo H$amdo hUOoM Amn`m H$V`mda
lm AgUo hmo`.A{$ZmgZo _``wJmVrb Bdar H$no`m OJmbm ^m{VH$ OJmMr OmoS> {Xbr. `mMo _Vo lm
d ~wr `m EH$mM gnyU ApVdm`m XmoZ nmV`m AmhoV.
~wr - _mZdm`m emar[aH$ {H$`m CXm.MmbUo, nmhUo, EoH$Uo d AmV[aH$ {H$`m Aem XmoZ H$ma`m {H$`m
73
AgVmV. H$nZm H$aUo, {dMma H$aUo, _aU H$aUo `m AmV[aH$ {H$`m hmoV. `m AmV{aH$ {H$`mnojm C
nmVirda ~wrMo H$m` MmbVo. ~wr {ddoH$erb d {d_eerb (Reflective) AgVo. `mo` H$m` A`mo` H$m`
ho R>a{dUo {ddoH$~wrMo H$m` AgVo d `mo`-A`mo` H$m` ho R>a{d`mZVa `mo` VoM H$aUo hUOo {d_eerb
~wr hmo`. ~wr KQ>ZmMo, {dMmamMo AW bmdVo, {dbofU H$aVo. gXd {dMma H$aUo ho ~wrMo d{eQ> hmo`.
A{$ZmgMo _Vo ~wr Ho$di AZw^dmVrb gdo dVyMo kmZ H$$Z XoV Zmhr Va Vr gnyU ApVdmMm
{dMma H$aVo. ~wr Am`mbm {dm`m Am{XVdmH$S>o di{dVo. lm d ~wrMm g~Y n> H$aVmZm
A{$Zmg hUVmo H$s, `m XmohrV {damoY Agy eH$V Zmhr. lm hr `{$JV ~m~ Amho. _mZdr ~wr loMr
{M{H$gm H$$ eH$Vo. lm hr Am`mp_H$ _mUgmMr JaO AgVo Va {dMmar _mUgmbm {d_eH$ ~wrMr
JaO AgVo. kmZ gnmXZmgmR>r lm d ~wr `m XmohrMrhr JaO AgVo. "lmdmZ b^Vo kmZ_' hr CVr
{gM Amho. lo{edm` ~wr H$moaS>r R>aVo Va ~wr{edm` lm AmYir R>aVo.
7.2.3 BdamMo d$n d `m`m ApVdmMo nwamdo {MZ Y_ VdkmZmV BdamMo ApVd _mZbobo Amho. gV AmJQ>mBZ, gV Ago_ `mZr Bdar
^y{_Ho$Mm CKS> nwaH$ma Ho$bm Amho. `m VdkmZmV Bdam{df`r "Xdr H$nZm' (Divine Idea) drH$mabr
Amho. _mZdr B{VhmgmV {Vm`m $nmZo BdamMo EH$ H$Q>Z - AdVma Pmbm Amho Aer `m VdkmZmMr
lm Amho. Wm_g A{$Zmg BdamVrgmR>r MM ho EH$ _m`_ _mZVmo. MMMr _XV Z KoVm Ho$di
dV:`m `Zm`m ~imZo _mZd Bdamn`V nmohmoMy eH$V Zmhr. MMH$Sy>Z {_iUm`m Ym{_H$ gH$mamMr
BdamVrgmR>r JaO Amho.
A{$Zmg`m VdkmZmZwgma Bda qH$dm _mZdr Am_m `{da{hV (Matterless) AgVmV. ^m{VH$
`mZm Ago qH$dm Vgo {d{e> AmH$ma AgVmV _m Bda `{da{hV AmH$ma (Pure Form) Amho. Bda hm
ew AmH$ma Amho, ew gmjmVVm (Pure Actuality) , {ddmVrb gd dVy_Yrb ôX BdamV {dbrZ hmoVmV,
Vmo A{Vr` (unique) Amho. Bda hm "na_OmVr' (Absolute Genus) Amho. `mZoM {ZgJ, _mZdr Am_m d
XodXyV {Z_mU Ho$bo AmhoV.
BdamMo ApVd {g H$a`mgmR>r A{$ZmgZo nwamdo hUyZ Imbrb `wVrdmX gm{JVbo AmhoV 1)
AMb MmbH$mMm `wVrdmX (Agrument of Unmoved Mover) :-
A{$ZmgMm hm `wVrdmX A[aQ>mQ>b`m "AMb MmbH$' {dMmamgmaIm Amho. Amn`m AZw^dmVrb

gd dVy n[adVZr` AmhoV, JVr_mZ AmhoV. `m gd dVyZm JVr XoUmar EH$ eVr Agbr nm{hOo. BVa
dVyVrb eVr hiyhiy H$_r hmoV OmVo. _m gd dVyZm JVr d eVr XoUmao Vd gXd eVr_mZ Agbo
nm{hOo. `m_mUo dmhZ MmbH$ dV: AMb amhZ dmhZ Mmb{dVmo VgoM `m {ddmMo Agbo nm{hOo. hUyZ
`m {ddmMm MmbH$ Agbobm Bda hm dV: AMb Agbm nm{hOo. OJm`m ma^r AgUmao d OJmMo oaH$
Vd hUOo BdaM hmo`.
2)
{Z{_m H$maUmMm `wVrdmX (Agrument of Efficient Cause) :-
gOZm`m {H$òV òH$ dVybm {d{e> H$maU AgVo. R>am{dH$ H$maUmnmgyZ R>am{dH$ H$m` {Z_mU
hmoVo. hUOo dVy m dV:Mo H$maU Agy eH$V ZmhrV. H$maU ho H$m`m`m AmYr Agmd`mg hdo. òH$
H$maUmMo H$maU _mZmdo bmJVo d `m H$maU nanaoV _mJo OmV-OmV Oo Ama^rMo H$maU Agob Vo _yi H$maU
Bda Agbm nm{hOo. A{$Zmg Bdambm OJmMo {Z{_m H$maU _mZVmo.
74
3)
A{Zdm` ApVdmMm `wVrdmX
(Argument of necessary Existence)
:-
OJmV dVy, mUr ApVdmV òVmV d {ZgJH$_mV Z>hr hmoVmV. Aem ApVdmbm Z{_{mH$
ApVd Ago hUVmV. `m H$mhr H$mimnwaVoM ApVdmV Agbo`m dVyZm H$mhrVar A{Zdm`- Amd`H$
Ago ApVd JhrV YamdoM bmJVo. H$Yrhr Zme Z nmdUmao ho A{Zdm` ApVd hUOoM Bda hmo`.
4)
gdmoMVoMm `wVrdmX (Agrument of Supremaly) :-
`m OJmV dVy bhmZ-_moR>m, nyU-AnyU, gwXa-Hw$n AmhoV. hUOoM AZw^dm`m OJmV VaV_d AmT>iyZ òVo. _m VaV_^mdmZo Oo gdmV lo>, A{YH$m{YH$ n[anyU d nyUV_ Ago H$mhrVar Agbo
nm{hOo d Oo gdmV n[anyU AgUmao gdm} ApVd (Maximens) hUOo BdaM hmo`. A{$ZmgMm gdmo
ApVdmMm hm {dMma gV AmJQ>mBZ d gV Ago_ `m`mhr VdkmZmV AmT>iyZ òVmo.
5)
`moOZdmXr `wVrdmX
(Teleological Agrument)
:-
`m OJmVrb òH$ {Z{_Vrbm hoVy AgVmo. AmnU dVy {Z_mU H$aVmo `m g_mOm`m Cn`moJmgmR>r
dVyZm dV:Mo C{> ZgVo. ~w{_mZ mUr Amn`m hoVygmR>r - `mdhm[aH$ JaOmgmR>r dVyMm Cn`moJ
H$aVmV. Bdambm _m dV:Mm H$moUVmhr hoVy ZgVmo. Bda hm `m OJmMm {Z`Vm, {enH$ma, Am`moOH$
(Designer) Agbm nm{hOo. Bdam`m {grMm hm `wVrdmX ZVa H$mQ>`m VdkmZmVhr drH$mabobm
AmT>iVmo.
WmoS>`mV A{$ZmgMm Bda nyU, {Zad`d, kmZr, AZV, A{dZmer Agm Amho.
7.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z :1)
`mo` n`m` {ZdSy>Z Imbrb {dYmZo nyU H$am.

1)
A{$ZmgZo ------- `m Y_n{S>Vm`m ghdmgmV A``Z nyU Ho$bo.

( A~Q> {X JoQ> / Agog / AmJQ>mBZ )
2)
------- hm A{$ZmgMm Y_emmdarb JW Amho.

( Summa Theologiae / Republic / Politics )
3)
lm d ~wr `m`mV ------- Agbm nm{hOo.

( gwgdmX / {damoY / `mKmV )
4)
Bda hm ------- AgVmo.

( na_OmVr / dVw$n / AmH$man )
5)
Bda hm ------- Amho.

( AMb MmbH$ / J{V_mZ / MMb )
6)
BdamMo ApVd ------- ApVd Amho.

( A{Zdm` / Z{_{mH$ / AnH$mbrZ )
75
2)
Imbrb ZmMr EH$m dm`mV Cmao m.

1)
A{$ZmgMo ma{^H$ {ejU H$moR>o Pmbo ?
2)
A{$ZmgZo Bdaemmda H$moUVo JW {b{hbo ?
3)
BdaemmV H$moU`m VrZ H$nZm _hdm`m AmhoV ?
4)
gnyU ApVdmMo kmZ H$em_wio hmoVo ?
5)
{d_eerb ~wr hUOo H$m` ?
7.4 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW :{_d
{nVm, nw d n{d Am`mMo EH$rH$aU
lm
na_odamda {ddmg R>odUmar ~wr
Bdaem
Bdam`m ApVdmda lm R>odUmao em
gOZVm
Zdo {Z_mU H$a`mMr eVr - j_Vm
_y`
OrdZmV _mZmd`mMr d nmimd`mMr Vdo
Xdr H$nZm
AZw^dmn{bH$S>rb H$nZm
`moOZ
hoVy
gdm} ApVd
`m ApVdmnojm Xwgao lo> ApVd ZgVo.
7.5 d` A``Z ZmMr Cmao :1)

2)
`mo` n`m` -
1) A~Q> {X JoQ>
2) Summa Theologiae
4) na_OmVr
5) AMb MmbH$
3) gwgdmX
6) A{Zdm`
EH$m dm`mV Cmao :

1)
A{$ZmgMo ma{^H$ {ejH$ H${gZmo`m {MZ Y_ _R>mV Pmbo.
2)
A{$ZmgZo Bdaemmda Summa Cantra Gentile d Summa Theologiae ho JW {b{hbo.
3)
BdaemmV {_d, AdVma d H$m{bH$ gOZVm `m VrZ _hdm`m H$nZm AmhoV.
4)
gnyU ApVdmMo kmZ ~wr hmoVo.
5)
{d_eerb ~wr - mJ{VH$ d dVnUo {dMma H$aUmar ~wr hUOo {d_eerb ~wr hmo`.
7.6 gmame :gV Wm_g A{$Zmg {MZ Y_VdkmZmMm _hmZ CnmgH$ hmoVm. `mZo Amn`m VdkmZmV
Y_VdkmZmMr _mZdr OrdZmVrb JaO {deX Ho$br. _Zw`mUr Ho$di ^m{VH$ OrdZm`m AmYmao OJy eH$V
Zmhr. `mbm Am`mp_H$ kmZmMrhr JaO AgVoM. _mZdr OrdZmV lm _hdmMr Amho. Vd, {dMma,
H$m`-H$V` `m`m nyVVogmR>r loMr Amd`H$Vm Amho. lm d ~wr `mMm OdiMm g~Y Amho. `m`mV
{damoY Zmhr ho `mZo AmJhnydH$ {VnmXZ Ho$bo Amho. `m {ddm`m _wimer EImXo A^m{VH$ Vd Agbo
76
nm{hOo. `m loVyZ `mZo Bda{df`H$ {dMma n> Ho$bo. BdamMo ApVd OS> dVy`m ApVdmnojm {^Z
Amho d ho ApVd `wVrdmXm`m AmYmao {g H$a`mMm `Z `mZo Ho$bm Amho.
BdaemmMr JaO n> H$am.
2)
lm d ~wr `mMo d$n {deX H$am.
3)
Bdaem d VdkmZmMm g~Y n> H$am.
4)
A{$Zmg BdamMo ApVd {g H$a`mgmR>r H$moUVo `wVrdmX (nwamdo) XoVmo ?

JWm`m eodQ>r {Xbobr gyMr nhmdr.
666
77
KQ>H$ - 8
aoZo XoH$mV ( Rene Descartes )

8.0 C{Q>o
8.1 mVm{dH$
8.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
8.2.1
ge` nVr
8.2.2
_r OmUVmo hUyZ _r Amho
8.2.3
eara _ZmMo V
8.2.4
Bdam`m ApVdmMo nwamdo
8.3 d`-A``ZmgmR>r Z
8.6 gmame
8.0 C{Q>o :`m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZVa Amn`mbm * AmYw{ZH$ VdkmZmMo d$n bjmV òBb.
* aoZo XoH$mV`m VdkmZmVrb ge` nVrMo d$n g_Oob.
* "_r' `m ApVdm{df`r _m{hVr hmoBb.
* eara-_ZmMm g~Y n> hmoBb.
* Bdam`m ApVdm{df`rMo nwamdo g_OVrb.
8.1 mVm{dH$ :aoZo XoH$mVMo VdkmZ AdmMrZ (AmYw{ZH$) VdkmZmMm ^mJ _mZbo OmVo. AdmMrZ `wJmMm ma^
B.g.1453 nmgyZ _mZbm OmVmo. AdmMrZ VdkmZ m_w`mZo _mZdr ~wrMo ghm`mZo {ZgJ d _mZdr
OrdZmVrb g`mMm emoY KoUmao Amho. `m VdkmZmV VdkmZmVrb _hdm`m gH$nZmMo AZw^d d ~w{{Z>
d$nmMo {dbofU H$a`mMm `Z AmT>iVmo.
78
_``wJrZ H$mbIS>mZVa VdkmZm`m B{VhmgmV AZw^ddmX, ~w{dmX `mgmaIo {dMmadmh CX`mg

Ambo. H$maU _``wJmV {dMmam`m jomV, kmZm`m jomV VdkmZmMo (Dogmatism) d Y_VdmMo m~`
{Z_mU Pmbo hmoVo. `m_wio dV _mZdr {dMmamZm _hdM Cabo ZhVo.aoZo XoH$mVMm O_ 31 _mM 1596
amoOr Pmbm. aoZo XoH$mV ~w{dmm`m nanaoVrb Am VdqMVH$ _mZbm OmVmo. XoH$mV J{UV VdkmZmMm
nwaH$Vm hmoVm. XoH$mVZo Meditations on First Philosophy hm VdkmZmdarb n{hbm JW {b{hbm. {ZgJ
{dkmZmMm A`mg H$$Z `mda `mZo Le Mande ZmdmMm JW {b{hbm. XoH$mV hm AdmMrZ VdkmZmMm
OZH$ (Father of Modern Philosophy) Amho Ago _mZbo OmVo. H$maU XoH$mV`m {dMmamZo VdkmZm_ò
gw`dpWVnUm, VH$ewVm d dVw{Z>Vm {Z_mU Ho$br.
8.2 {df` {ddoMZ :8.2.1 ge` nVr (Method of Doubt) :XoH$mV`m ~w{dmXr VdkmZmV `mZo ge`nVr dmnabr Amho. `m nVrbm H$mQ>}{e`Z nVr
(Cartesian Method) Agohr hQ>bo Amho. _mZdr _Zm`m H$mhr j_Vm AgVmV CXm.kmZ {df`mMm AW
bmdUo, `mMo JhU H$aUo, Vo _aUmV R>odUo. XoH$mVMr nVr _Zm`m dm^m{dH$ H$bm_mUo kmZ {_i{d`mg
_XV H$aVo. `m`m nVrV _Zm`m XmoZ H$mèVr _mZ`m AmhoV. `m H$mèVr hUOo AVkmZ
(Intuition) d {ZJ_Z (Deduction) `m hmoV.
1) {ZJm_r - Oohm H$moU`mhr kmZ _m`_m{edm` (CXm.S>moim, ZmH$, B.) Amn`mbm kmZ {_iVo
Vohm `mg AVkmZ Ago hUVmV. AVkmZmV AdYmZnydH$ d {Z:g{XY Aer ge`{da{hV gH$nZm
AgVo. AVkmZ hr ~wrMr {H$`m AgyZ ~wrbm hmoUmao n> kmZ AgVo. `mda ge` KoVm òV Zmhr.
XoH$mV`m nVrV {ZJ_ZmMmhr g_mdoe Amho. {ZJ_ZmV nmàr-nmàrZo {ZH$f H$mT>bm OmVmo. CXm.J{UVmVrb
EImXo CXmhaU gmoS>{dVmZm nmàr-nmàrZo {ZH$f hUOo Cma {_i{dbo OmVo. XoH$mVMo _Vo kmZmMo n{hbo
qH$dm Am Vd AVkmZmZo {_iVo d kmZmVrb {ZH$f {ZJ_ZmZo {_iVmo.XoH$mV`m nVrMo _hdmMo d{eQ>
hUOo Amn`m _ZmV `m H$nZm AgVmV, Amnbo Oo {ddmg nHo$ Pmbobo AgVmV `mMr N>mZZr H$aUo
qH$dm {M{H$gm H$aUo ho hmo`. XoH$mVMr ^y{_H$m ~w{dmXr Amho ho `md$Z n> hmoVo. Amnbr g`m{df`rMr
Or ^y{_H$m AgVo Vr Zoh_r VnmgyZ KoVbr nm{hOo. hUOoM g`m{df`rMr ^y{_H$m `j Agbr nm{hOo.
2) _m{bH$ d$nmMr - XoH$mVMr ge`nVr VdkmZmV A`V _m{bH$ nVr _mZbr OmVo.
XoH$mV`m ge`mbm EH$ dV WmZ Amho. XoH$mVMr ge`nVr gm_m` _mUgmMr ge`nVr Zho.
gm_m` _mUgm`m ge`mbm V`mMm AmYma AgobM Ago Zmhr. CXm.EImXr `Vr A{daVnUo H$>
H$aVo, OrdZmMr H$meò mV H$aVo d Am`w`mV Cm_ è {_i{dVo. gm_m` _mUgmbm `m èmV
H$mhrVar H$mio~oao {XgVo. hUOo `mMm ge` amV dmQ>V Zmhr.
VmpdH$ d$n - XoH$mVMm ge` hm "VmpdH$ d$nmMm (Philosophical Doubt) ' Amho. Ho$di
ge`mgmR>r ge` KoUo Ago ZH$mam_H$ d$n `m`m ge`dmXmV Zmhr. EImm Jmo>r`m {ZpMV kmZmg
OmD$Z nmohmoMUo `m`m ge`mMo C{> Amho. `m ge` nVrZwgma _ZmVrb gd {dMma, EImm Jmo>r`m
g`m{df`rMr _Vo, {ddmg, _mZdm`m lm `m`m g`Vo{df`r W_ ge` `V H$amd`mMm, `mg
nwam`mMm AmYma md`mMm. Oa nwam`mZVa "g`' ho g`M amhmV Agob Va Vo g` IaoM hmo` d
g`mda AmnU Omo ge` KoVbobm AgVmo Vmo ge`M ImoQ>m hmo`.
79
4) {M{H$gH$ - XoH$mVMm ge` emr`, {M{H$gH$ d gèmoYZ H$aUmam Amho. `mV MmJ`mda
{MIb\o$H$ Zmhr qH$dm Ag`mbm g` hUyZ pdH$maUohr Zmhr. XoH$mV`m H$mbIS>mV nmpM_m`
Xoem_ò ~w{dmXmMo Oo dMm[aH$ dmao dmhV hmoVo `mMm ^md ge`nVrda nS>bobm AmT>iVmo. ~w{dmXr
VdkmZ _mZdr _Zmbm {M{H$gH$ ~Z{dVo, òH$ Jmo>rMr {M{H$gm H$$Z Vr drH$ma`mMm AmJh YaVo.
VmpdH$ kmZmbm h>mJhdmXm`m (Dogmatism) ^mdmVyZ _wV H$aUo XoH$mV`m ~w{dmXmMo bjU Amho.
8.2.2 _r OmUVmo hUyZ _r (ApVdmV) Amho
(Cogito Ergo Sum)
:-
XoH$mV`m VdkmZmV `m`m ge`dmXmbm AZ`gmYmaU _hd Amho. ge`dmXmZwgma Amn`m

g^modVr`m H$moU`mhr Jmo>rMr g`Vm W_XeZr ge`mnX Agy eH$Vo. Amnbo {dMma, {ddmg, lm,
AmZw^{dH$ g` `m gdm{df`r ge` Agy eH$Vmo. `m JmoQ>ro`m g`Vo~m~V AmnU CnpWV Ho$bo`m eH$m
nwam`m`m / _mUm`m AmYmao ImoSy>Z H$mT>Vm òVmV. hUOoM H$moU`mhr Jmo>r`m ge`mMo {ZamH$aU
qH$dm dOZ Ho$bo H$s {ZIi g` hmVr bmJbo. {dkmZmVrb {MVr VdmMm Cn`moJ H$$Z ge` ImoQ>m
R>a{dVm òVmo.XoH$mVMo "_r OmUVmo hUyZ _r Amho' ho Vd hUOo `m`m VdkmZmVrb Am_ VdmMm {dMma
Amho. "_r' Mo ApVd Amn`m òH$ AZw^dmV n> hmoV AgVo. _r gwaob JrV EoH$bo, Ago Oohm AmnU
hUVmo Vohm Vo JrV Amn`m H$mZr nS>bo, Vo gwaob Amho Ago AmnUmg AmH$bZ Pmbo. `m gd {H$`m_ò
Amnbo ApVdmV AgUo W_ Amd`H$ Amho. Amn`m AZw^dmVrb kmZ {df`mMo d$n Ago Amho qH$dm
Vgo Amho `m{df`r AmnUmg ge` òD$ eHo$b. nU ge` KoUmam ApVdmV Ag`m{edm` ge` ZmdmMr
{H$`m Agy eH$V Zmhr. {dMma Ag`mgmR>r {dMma gmJUmam, {dMma H$aUmam ApVdmV AgbmM
nm{hOo. hUOo {dMma gmJUm`mda ge` ZmdmMr {H$`m MwH$sMr R>aVo. ge` Agob Va Vmo H$embm Var
Agob d H$moUmMm Var Agob `md$Z Ago hUVm òBb H$s ge`md$Z "ge` KoUmam' `{OV hmoVmo (Doubt
implies Doubter). VH$emm`m gab n[a^mfoV Ago hUVm òBb H$s Oa ge` Agob Va ge`m`m
AmYr ge` KoUmam ApVdmV Agbm nm{hOo. `m gX^mV XoH$mV hUVmo H$s, "_r OmUVmo hUyZ _r Amho (I
think therefore I am) ' ho _m`m VdkmZmMo Am Vd Amho.XoH$mVMo "_r OmUVmo hUyZ _r Amho' ho {dYmZ
Ho$di AZw_mZm_H$ Zmhr Va OmUUmam "Oo' Amho `mMo ApVd hr EH$ dmV{dH$Vm Amho. AmnU OmUV
Ag`mVM Amnbo ApVd AV^yV Amho. Amn`m ApVdmMr OmU`mIoarO A` H$moU`mhr nwam`mZo
{gVm Xo`mMr JaO Zmhr. "_r OmUVmo hUyZ _r Amho' ho A`V n> d d`{g g` Amho Am{U ho Vd
Vd_r_mgoMm Ama^{~Xy Amho.
darb {ddoMZmd$Z ho n> hmoVo H$s, XoH$mV`m VdkmZmMm nm`m "Am`mMo ApVd' hm Amho.
Amn`m ge` Ko`m_òhr Am`mMo ApVd AgVoM. Amn`m kmZ|{`m`m gmhm`mZo Am_VdmMr
{MVr KoVm òV Zmhr. `j B{` AZw^dm`m nmVirda ^m{VH$ dVy_mUo `mMo ApVd {g H$aVm
òV Zmhr. Am`m`m ApVdm{edm` "OmUrd' qH$dm kmZ hmoUo e` Zmhr. Am_m hUOo Amn`mbm
hmoUm`m kmZmMr A{Zdm` Aer nyd CnmYr (necessary precondition) Amho. Am`mMo ApVd ZmH$ma`mVhr
Am`mMo ApVd AgVoM. Am`mg~Yr "Ho$Z' Cn{ZfXmV hQ>bo Amho H$s, Oo S>mo`mZr {XgV Zmhr nU
`m`m gmhm`mZo S>moio nmhVmV, Oo H$mZmZr EoH$Vm òV Zmhr nU `m`m gmhm`mZo H$mZ EoH$VmV Vgm
Am_m {XgV Zmhr. Amn`m OmUrdnydH$ `m `m {H$`m hmoVmV `m gdm_ò Am_m CnpWV AgVmo.
ge` KoUmar, {dMma H$aUmar, H$nZm H$aUmar, H$nZm ZmH$maUmar, AmH$bZ hmoUmar, _aU hmoUmar Or
"AdWm' Amho Vr "_r' hr Amho.
80
"_r OmUVmo hUyZ _r Amho' `m Vdm`m AmYmao XoH$mV ~w{dmXm`m WmoS>o nwT>o OmVmo Ago _mZmdo
bmJob. H$maU ~wrda AmYm[aV gd {H$`m_òhr "_r' hUOoM Am`mMo ApVd _m` H$amdoM bmJVo.
`md$Z XoH$mV hUVmo H$s, Am_Vd hUOo _mZdr kmZmMo W_ JhrVdM hmo`.
8.2.3 eara_ZmMo V
(Dualism of Body and Mind)
:-
XoH$mV`m VdkmZmV eara-_Z g~Ymda _hdnyU MMm Ho$bobr AmT>iVo. XoH$mVMo VdkmZ ~w{dmXr
VdkmZ Ag`mZo `mZo eara-_Z g~YmMr MMm ~w{dmXr >rH$moZmVyZ Ho$br Amho. XoH$mVZo eara d
_Zmbm dV ò _mZbo AmhoV. Vo dV AgyZ EH$_oH$mhZ {^Z AmhoV. {dVma hm earamMm JwU _mZbm
Amho Va {dMma hm _ZmMm JwU _mZbm Amho. hUOo earambm Ago qH$dm Vgo CXm.geV, gS>nmVi Ago
n[a_mU Amho. eara OmJm `mnVo. hUOo ^m{VH$ `mMo JwU earamV {XgyZ òVmV. Va _Zmbm ^m{VH$
`m_mUo {dVma Zmhr. hr XmoZ ò nana {^Z (`mdVH$) AmhoV ho `m`m d$nmd$Z gmJVm òVo.
CXm. earambm n[a_mU Amho (hUOo _mPo dOZ 55 {H$bmo J_, 60 {H$bmoJ_ Amho Ago hQ>bo OmVo)
_Zmbm BVHo$ qH$dm {VVHo$ n[a_mU Zmhr. eara OmJm `mnVo, _Zmbm OmJm bmJV Zmhr. eara >r gdoXZmZo
H$iVo _Z >rgdoXZmZo H$iV Zmhr.
XoH$mV eara-_Z VdmXmV Ago {VnmXZ H$aVmo H$s, Oar eara-_Z d$nV: {^Z Agbo Var
`m`mV A`V {ZH$Q>Mm g~Y Amho. CXm.Amn`mbm VhmZ^yH$ bmJbr Va Ord H$mgmdrg hmoVmo. Amn`m
H$m`mda Amnbo bj bmJV Zmhr. earambm ~m Jmo>t_wio AWdm earamVJV ~Xbm_wio OI_ Pmbr Va
_Zmbm doXZm hmoVmV, Amnbm Ord {dhiVmo. EImXm {ZgJa` XoImdm nm{hbm, H$U_Yya gJrV EoH$bo Va
_Z Ch{gV hmoVo. hUOoM darM H$ma`m emar[aH$ {H$`m KS>`m Va _Zmbm gwIX AWdm Xw:IX
AZw^d òVmV. `mMm AW earamV hmoUmao ~Xb d emar[aH$ {H$`m_wio _Zmda AmKmV hmoD$Z _ZmV ~ao-dmBQ>
~Xb KS>dyZ AmUVmV. darb {ddoMZmVyZ earamVrb ~XbmMo qH$dm {H$`mMo _Zmdarb n[aUm_ n> hmoVmV.
`mM_mUo _ZmV hmoUm`m ~Xbm_wio earamda n{aUm_ hmoVmo. Amnbo _Z `m H$nZm H$aVo `m
H$nZmZm AZwg$Z H$m` H$a`mg eara gO hmoVo. CXm._r Am`w`mV èdr hmd`mMo Aer {Vkm
Ho$br Va Am`w`mV èdr hmo`mgmR>r H$am`m bmJUm`m òH$ H$Vr-H$m`mgmR>r eara gO hmoVo.
XoH$mVMo _Vo _mZd hUOo eara d _ZmMo g`wJ Amho. eara d _ZmMo Amho. eara-_ZmMm g~Y OhmO
d `mMm H$VmZ `m`m g~YmgmaIm ZgVmo hUOoM `m{H$ d$nmMm ZgVmo. Amn`m _ZmMm earamer
{ZH$Q>Mm g~Y ZgVm Va Amn`mbm ^yH$ bmJ`mda AmnU `mHw$i Pmbmo ZgVmo. earambm gJmZwgma
hmoUm`m doXZmZr AmnU Xw:Ir, AmZXr AWdm amo_m{MV Pmbmo ZgVmo.
eara d _Z hr Xmohr ò dV d {^Z Agbr Var `m`mV Eo` Pmbobo AgVo d `m XmoKmMohr
ApVd dVnUo n> hmoV AgVo. eara d _Z `m`mV AmVa{H$`m KS>V AgVmV. AmVa{H$òV XmoKmMm
EH$_oH$mer gVV g~Y òV AgVmo. eara d _Zm_ò KS>Um`m AmVa{H$`m H$maU - d$nm`m AgVmV.
H$m`H$maUm_ò Ogo H$maUmV ~Xb Pmbm Va H$m`mVhr ~Xb KS>Vmo `m_mUo earamV hmoUm`m ~XbmMm
_Zmda n[aUm_ hmoVmoM. AmVa{H$`mdmXmZwgma Am`mMm earamer Omo g`moJ hmoVmo `mMm _w` AmYma
hUOo _|XyVrb {n{Z`b JWr hm hmo`. {dVma d {dMma ho AZwH$_o eara d _ZmMo Oo JwUY_ AmhoV `mMo
EH$rH$aU _|XyVrb {n{Z`b JWr_ò hmoVo. {n{Z`b JWr_ò Or nXZo (hmbMmb) {Z_mU hmoVmV Vr
_ZmZo gH${_V hmoVmV. _Zmbm Oohm EImXr {H$`m H$a`mMr BN>m hmoVo Vohm W_ {n{Z`b JWrV nXZo
{Z_mU hmoVmV d `mmao earamV Vr {d{e> {H$`m H$a`mgmR>r hmbMmbr hmoVmV. `md$Z Ago n> hmoVo
81
H$s, eara d _ZmMm g~Y H$maU VdmZwgma òVmo d `m XmohmoV {H$òZwgma `mo` `m hmbMmbr KS>`mg
{n{Z`b JWrMm _m`_ hUyZ Cn`moJ hmoVmo. XoH$mV`m darb {ddoMZmbm AmVa{H$`mdmX (Interactionism)
Agohr hQ>bo OmVo.
`mVrb ^yVmMr H$nZm (The Ghost in mechine) - XoH$mV Amn`m VdkmZmV Ago n>
H$aVmo H$s Oar eara-_Z dV ò Agbr Var `mVrb EH$mMm Xwg`mer g~Y bmd`m{edm` _mZdr
ApVdmMm AWM bmdVm òV Zmhr. XoH$mVMo _Vo eara d _ZmMm g~Y `mVrb ^yVm`m H$nZo_mUo
Amho. `mVrb ^yVmMr H$nZm hUOo `mVrb H$m` H$aUmar eVr Zo_H$s `m`m H$moU`m ^mJmV AgVo
ho R>m_nUo gmJVm òV Zmhr. `m_mUoM eara d _ZmMm Zo_H$m g~Y H$moR>o òVmo ho XoIrb gmJVm òV Zmhr.
XoH$mV`m `mVrb ^yVm`m H$nZoZo VdqMVH$mZm g^_mV Q>mH$bo Amho. H$maU ^yVm`m Ag^d H$nZoMm
_mZdr ~wrbm nQ>Umam AW gmJVm òV Zmhr. 20 `m eVH$mVrb mo.{Jb~Q> amBb `m`mgma`m
{dmZmbmhr XoH$mV`m darb H$nZoZo g^_mV Q>mH$bo Amho. mo.amBb `mMo _Vo eara d _Z `m dV d
nana {^Z `mZm EH$ AmU`mMm XoH$mVZo VH$emmV Z ~gUmam g~Y AmUbm Amho d hr XoH$mVMr
MyH$ Amho. XoH$mV`m `m ^y{_Ho$bm "nXmWmVa _mX' (Category Mistake) Ago hQ>bo OmVo.
WmoS>`mV XoH$mVZo eara-_Z VdmXmV eara d _ZmMo d$n n> H$$Z `m`mV Agbobm d
`j _mZdr AZw^dmV òUmam g~Y XmI{d`mMm `Z Ho$bm Amho.
8.2.4 Bdam`m ApVdmMo nwamdo (Proofs for the Existence of God) :XoH$mV hm ~wrdmXr nanaoVrb VdqMVH$ hmo`. ~w{dmXr VdkmZmMr nanam {dkmZm`m {dH$mgm~amo~a
A{YH$ gH$s` Pmbobr AmT>iVo. ~w{dmXr VdqMVH$mZr {dkmZmVrb `jdmX, AZw^ddmX _mZbm Agbm
Var "Bda' `m gH$nZoMo OmoaXmanUo g_WZ Ho$bobo AmT>iVo. ~w{dmXmZwgma AZw^d J`Vm d ~w{J`Vm
`mV {damoY Ag`mMo H$maU Zmhr.
XoH$mVnydu gV Agoc_, gV AmJQ>mBZ `m Y_-VdqMVH$mZr BdadmXmMo (Theism) {VnmXZ
Ho$bobo AmT>iVo. XoH$mVZo 17 `m eVH$mV BdadmXmMm nwaH$ma Ho$bm `mda _``wJrZ H$mbIS>mVrb
Y_VdmMm ^md OmUdVmo. XoH$mVMm Bdam{df`rMm >rH$moZ Ho$di VH$mda AmYm[aV Zmhr Va ApVddmXr
d$nmMm Amho. XoH$mV CnOV H$nZmMo ApVd _mZVmo. `mMo _Vo Amn`mbm O_V:M AZoH$ H$nZm
mV AgVmV. CXm.dVyMo {hado, {ndionU Amn`mbm Z {eH${dVm H$iVmV. `mAWu {hado, {ndio
`m{df`r`m H$nZm O_OmV AmhoV Ago Vmo R>m_nUo gmJVmo. nwT>o Vmo Agohr hUVmo H$s, BVa H$nZm_mUoM
_bm _m`m _ZmV "Bda' hr H$nZm gmnS>br. Vr ~mho$Z H$moUr _m`mda bmXbobr Zmhr. hUOo _m`m
_ZmV hr H$nZm ~mho$Z gdoXZ AWdm BVa kmZ _m`_mVyZ Ambobr Zmhr. `md$Z Bda ApVdmV
Agbm nm{hOo Ago _mZ`mV Vm{H$H$ {dgJVr {XgV Zmhr. XoH$mVZo Amn`m VdkmZmV BdamMo ApVd
{g H$a`mgmR>r Imbrb nwamdo/`wVrdmX {Xbobo AmhoV.
1) H$maU `w{$dmX (Agreement of Causation ) :H$m`H$maUmMm {dMma H$aVmZm XoH$mV hUVmo H$s, H$maU ho H$_rVH$_r H$m`mBVHo$ Var _moR>o Agbo
nm{hOo. VgoM Amn`m AZw^dmVrb H$moUVrhr Jmo> n[anyU Zmhr. Oo dV:M n[anyU Zmhr Vo `m`mnojm
A{YH$ n[anyU Agbo`m Jmo>rbm H$go {Z_mU H$arb ? _r d _mPo ApVd ho n[anyU Zmhr. _mPr d
Amnbr n[anyU hmo`m`m >rZo dmQ>Mmb Mmby Amho. `md$Z XoH$mV Ago {VnmXZ H$aVmo H$s, Amn`mnojm
n[anyU Ago Bdam{edm` H$mhrhr Agy eH$V Zmhr. n[anyUVo_ò ApVd AV^yV AgVo. ho ^m{VH$ {dd
82
A`V `mnH$ Amho, _moR>o Amho. `m A`V `mnH$ Aem {ddmMo H$maU Bdam{edm` Xwgao H$moUVohr Agy
eH$V Zmhr. hUyZ Bda ApVdmV Agbm nm{hOo Ago _mZmdoM bmJVo.
2)
gmV- AZV g~Y (Finite-Infinite Relation) :-
XoH$mVMo _Vo Amn`m AZw^dmVrb H$moUVrhr dVy _`m{XV Amho. gmV hUOo `mbm AV Amho,
_`mXm Amho Ago. Oa AmnU n[anyU AgVmo Va AmnU dV:bm nm{hOo Vgo ~Zdy eH$bmo AgVmo. Amn`mbm
kmZ, eVr `m~m~V _`mXm AmhoV ho AmnU OmUVmo. `mMm AW Amn`mnojm H$mhrVar A_`mX Amho, AZV
Amho. `md$Z Vmo hUVmo H$s, Amn`m ApVdm`m VwbZoV Oo AZV Amho Vo BdaM Agbo nm{hOo.
3)
{Z{_Vr{df`H$ `w{$dmX (Argument of Creation) :-
XoH$mVMo _Vo Amn`m AZw^dmVrb òH$ dVy hr {Z_mU Pmbobo H$m` Amho. H$maU Vdm`m
_r_mgoZwgma òH$ {Z{_Vrbm, H$m`mbm H$maU AgboM nm{hOo. H$maU ey`mVyZ H$emMrhr {Z{_Vr hmoD$
eH$V Zmhr. ey` AgUo hUOo ZgUo d Oo ZgVoM Vo H$embmhr O_ XoD$ eH$V Zmhr. {dd ho {Z{_V H$m`
_mZbo Va `mMo H$maU H$mhrVar AgboM nm{hOo. _J `m H$maUmnmgyZ ho {dd {Z_mU Pmbo Agob `mMohr
AmUIr {VgaoM H$maU _mZmdo bmJob d Ago H$maUmMo H$maU emoYV AmnU _mJo _mJo Jobmo Va eodQ>r Oo
H$maU hmVr bmJob `mMo H$maU H$moUVo hm Z amhVmoM. Aem [aVrZo `m {ddmMo Zo_Ho$ H$maU AmnUmg
gmnS>UmaM Zmhr `m gJmbm VdkmZmV "AZdWm gJ' Ago hUVmV. hUyZ XoH$mV hUVmo H$s, {dd
{Z{_Vr {H$òV gdmV eodQ>r AmnU OoWo Wm~Vmo Vmo BdaM Agbm nm{hOo.
{MZ Y_ VdkmZmV gV Ago_ d gV AmJQ>mBZ `mZrhr Bdam{df`r AgmM `wVrdmX
Ho$bobm Amho.
4)
{Zanoj Bda (Absolute God) :-
{ddmVrb òH$ ApVd H$emer Var {ZJS>rV Amho. òH$ ApVdmbm AmH$ma, d$n Amho d
EH$ ApVd Xwg`mnojm {^Z Amho. Aem ApVdmbm gmnoj ApVd Ago hUVmV. Bdambm {d{e>
AmH$ma, H$ma AWdm `{$_d Zmhr Va Bda {Zanoj `m_H$ Amho. {Zanoj `mMo ApVd d`{ZYm[aV
AgVo, d`^y AgVo, Xwg`mda Adb~yZ ZgVo. Oo ApVdmgmR>r H$emdahr Adb~yZ ZgVo. Vo ApVdmV
ZgVo Ago _mZUo hUOo Am_`mKmV drH$maUo hmo`. hUyZ XoH$mV hUVmo H$s, {Zanoj `m_H$ Bda
ApVdmM AgbmM nm{hOo. XoH$mV Bdambm n[anyU, gd`mV, gdk, {MaVZ d dV:M dV:Mo H$maU
Agbobm d `m {ddmMo _Jb_` erdVd (Goodness of the world) hUyZ _mZVmo.
8.3 d` A``ZmgmR>r Z :A)
`mo` n`m` {ZdSy>Z {dYmZo nyU H$am.

1)
XoH$mVZo _Zm`m AVkmZ d ------------ `m XmoZ H$mèVr _mZ`m AmhoV.

1) {ZJ_Z
2)
2) {dJ_Z
3) AZw^d
XoH$mVMm ge` ------------ Amho.

1) CWi
2) VmpdH$
83
3) ^mfmemr`
3)
ge`md$Z ge` KoUm`mMo ApVd ------------ hmoVo.

1) `{OV
4)
2) ~m{YV
XoH$mV`m eara-_Z VdmXmbm ------------ Agohr hUVmV.

1) AmVa{H$`mdmX
5)
2) g_mVadmX
2) AZw^ddmXr
3) AV:kmdmXr
XoH$mV`m `mVrb ^yVm`m H$nZobm ------------ hUVmV.

1) nXmWmVa _mX
~)
3) ^mS>dbdmX
XoH$mVMo VdkmZ ------------ Amho.

1) ~w{dmXr
6)
3) I{S>V
2) H$mn{ZH$
3) AmZw^{dH$
EH$m dm`mV Cmao m.

1)
XoH$mV`m XmoZ JWmMr Zmdo H$moUVr ?
2)
kmZmMo AmVd H$emZo {_iVo ?
3)
h>mJhdmX hUOo (Dogmatism) H$m` ?
4)
XoH$mV`m BdamMo d$n H$go Amho ?
5)
XoH$mVMo _Vo eara-_ZmMm g~Y H$em_wio òVmo ?
6)
nXmWmVa _mX hr H$nZm H$moUr gm{JVbr ?
8.4 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW :VdmX (Dualidm)
XmoZ Vdo _mZUmam
h>mJhdmX
Amn`mM Vdmbm {MH$Qy>Z amhUmam
VmpdH$ ge`dmX
EImm Jmo>rMo {dMmam`m nmVird$Z gèmoYZ

H$aUmar _Zmodmr
`{OV hmoUo
{ZnZ hmoUo
{Zanoj Bda
{ZJwU Bda
(Dogmatism)
8.5 d` A``Z ZmMr Cmao :A)
`mo` n`m` - 1) {ZJ_Z

4) AmVa{H$`mdmX
2) VmpdH$
3) `{OV
5) ~w{dmXr
6) nXmWmVa _mX
84
~)
EH$m dm`mV Cmao 1)
Meditations on first philosophy and Le Mande.
2)
kmZmMo AmVd AVkmZmZo {_iVo.
3)
Amn`mM ^y{_Ho$bm, Vdmbm qH$dm {dMmambm {MH$Qy>Z amhUo.
4)
XoH$mV`m BdamMo d$n {Zanoj `m_H$ Amho.
5)
eara-_ZmMm g~Y {n{Z`b JWr_wio hmoVmo.
6)
mo.{Jb~Q> amBb `mZr nXmWmVa _mX hr H$nZm gm{JVbr.
8.6 gmame :XoH$mVMo VdkmZ ho ~w{dmXr VdkmZ Amho. XoH$mVZo AmYw{ZH$ VdkmZmMm nm`m KmVbm.
`m_wio `mg AmYw{ZH$ VdkmZmMm OZH$ _mZbo OmVo. ~w{dmXr >rH$moZmVyZ `mZo ge`dmXmMo {ddoMZ
Ho$bo d Vo VH$ew {aVrZo {g Ho$bo Amho. VdkmZmVrb AVkmZ, {ZJ_Z d {ZXeZm_H$ nVtMm dmna
H$$Z `mZo ge`dmXmMo n>rH$aU Ho$bo Amho. "_r' Mo hUOoM Am`mMo ApVd {g H$aVmZmhr `mZo
VH$em, VdkmZ d {dkmZdmXr >rH$moZmV {damoY Agy eH$V Zmhr ho XmIdyZ {Xbo. eara-_Z g~Y{df`H$
VdmX gmJyZ `mMm nanag~Y H$gm XmI{dVm òVmo ho `mdhm[aH$ AZw^dm`m AmYmao XmIdyZ {Xbo
Amho. Bda H$nZm _m` H$$Z ~w{dmX hm AZw^dmn{bH$S>rb g`mMo ~w{{Z> d gd_m` hmoD$ eHo$b
Ago n>rH$aU H$$ eH$Vmo ho XmIdyZ {Xbo Amho. BdamMo ApVd {g H$aVmZm _``wJrZ Y_n{S>Vm`m
_Vmer ~w{dmXmMm {damoY Agy eH$V Zmhr ho m_m{UH$nUo n> Ho$bo Amho.
8.8 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$ :JWm`m eodQ>r gyMr nhmdr.
666
85
KQ>H$ - 9
OmZ bmH$ ( John Locke )

9.0 C{Q>o
9.1 mVm{dH$ - M[a, H$m` d VdkmZ
9.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
9.2.1
O_OmV H$nZm
9.2.2
H$nZmMr Cnmr d H$ma

- gm`m d g{_l H$nZm
9.2.3
kmZ{gmV
- kmZmonmr
- kmZmMo d$n d H$ma
9.2.4
A_yV H$nZm
9.2.5
d` A``ZmgmR>r Z
9.3 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW, B`mXr

9.4 d`-A``Z ZmMr Cmao
9.5 gmame
9.0 C{Q>o :
*
`m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZo Amn`mbm AZw^ddmXmMm OZH$ - OmZ bmH$`m OrdZ M[amVrb

R>iH$ KQ>ZmMr, VgoM `m`mdarb gH$ma (^md) Am{U `mMr VdUmbr `m {df`rMr
_m{hVr {_iob.
bmH$`m VdkmZmMo d$n, _wI {gmV d gH$nZm `m{df`rMo kmZ {_iob.
O_OmV H$nZmMo `mZo H$go IS>Z Ho$bo Amho Vo g_OyZ _mZdr kmZmMo d$n, H$ma, H$nZmMr
Cnmr d A_yV H$nZm `m{df`rMr {M{H$gH$ {__mgm nQ> hmoD$ eHo$b.
9.1 mVm{dH$ - M[a, H$m` d VdkmZ :

OmZ bmH$ hm AZw^ddmXr VdkmZmMm OZH$ _mZbm OmVmo. `mMm O_ 29 E{b 1632 _ò
{~Q>bOdi [aQ>Z `m Jmdr EH$m _`_dJu` Hw$Qw>~mV Pmbm. bmH$Mo dS>rb H$m`XonS>rV hmoVo. O_mZo Vmo
86
`yarQ>Z nWmMm hmoVm. `yarQ>Z nWr` {dMmaUmbrMm `m`mda IynM ^md nS>bobm hmoVm. `mVyZM nm{d`,
XyaXeunUm, m_m{UH$Vm, CmoJerbVm, dmdb~Z Am{U dmV` o_ `m Jmo>r Vmo {eH$bm hmoVm.
1646 Vo 1652 n`V `mMo {ejU bS>Z òWrb doQ>-{_{ZQ>a {dmb`mV Pmbo. 1652 _ò
Amg\$S> {dmnrR>mV mBQ> MM H$mboO_ò `mZo doe KoVbm. 1659 n`V VoWo `mZo A``Z Ho$bo.
Amg\$S> {dmnrR>mVrb `mMo A``Z VdkmZmnwaVo _`m{XV Z amhVm `mZo nXmW{dkmZ, agm`Zem
Am{U dH$em `mMmhr A`mg Ho$bm. 1660 Vo 1666 `m H$mimV bmH$Zo Amg\$S> {dmnrR>mV A`mnZmMo
H$m` Ho$bo. 1674 _ò `mZo dH$emmVrb nXdr gnmXZ Ho$br d dH$s` `dgm`mMm nadmZm {_i{dbm.
1685 _ò BbS>_Yrb amOH$s` n[apWVr_wio `mbm BbS> gmoSy>Z hmbS>bm Omdo bmJbo. hmbS>_ò Vmo
AkmVdmgmV am{hbm. `m H$mimV Ho$bo`m qMVZmVyZ bmH$Zo "Essay Concerning Human Understanding"
hm {g JW {b{hbm. 1689 _ò Vmo BbS>_ò naV Ambm. `mZo {d{dY {df`mda boIZ Ho$bo. 1704
_ò `mMo {ZYZ Pmbo.
bmH$ hm {d{dY A{^$Mr Agbobm {dMmadV (Man of many interests) hmoVm. gw$dmVrg `mbm
Bda_r_mgm emm~b (Theology) AmH$fU dmQ>V hmoVo. nU ZVa Vmo dH$emmH$S>o dibm. `mZVa
nXmW{dkmZ d agm`Zemm`m A`mgm{df`r `mMr A{^$Mr dmT>br. `m{edm` `mZo Ym{_H$ d amOH$s`
g_`mMm A`mg Ho$bm. XoH$mV`m ~w{dmXr VdUmbrMm ^md bmH$da {XgyZ òVmo. VgoM `m`m
H$mimVrb {g agm`Zemk ~ob Am{U {d`mV earaemk {gS>Zoh_ `m`mer bmH$Mo d`{$H$ _rMo
g~Y hmoVo. `m`mH$Sy>Z `mZo AZw^d{Z> nVrMm AJrH$ma Ho$bm. VgoM `mbm AZw^ddmXr {dMmamMr oaUm
{_imbr. {edm` `yQ>Z`m J{UVr {gmVm_wio bmH$`m H$nZmeVrg MmbZm {_imbr. {dMmam`m _wb^yV
d gdm}M VdmZm AmhmZ XoD$Z `mZo kmZm`m jomVrb JmoYi, g{XYVm Xya H$a`mMm `Z Ho$bm.
_mZdr _ZmVrb O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmg~Yr Q>rH$m H$$Z bmH$Zo Amn`m VdkmZmMr _mS>Ur Ho$br.
`mZo kmZ{gmV qH$dm kmZ{__mgm `mH$S>o {deof bj H|$rV Ho$bo. OrdZm`m òH$ jomV AZw^dmMm AmYma
KoD$Z _mZdr _yò emoY`mMm bmH$Zo `Z Ho$bm. "AZw^dmg òBb VoM g`' Am{U "gd kmZ ho AZw^dO`
AgVo' `m ^y{_Ho$Mm `mZo nwaH$ma Ho$bm. VdkmZm`m jomV AZw^ddmXr {dMmaUmbrMo ~rOmamonU bmH$Zo
Ho$bo d kmZemr` AZw^ddmX {VnmXZ Ho$bm. hUyZM `mbm "AZw^ddmXmMm OZH$' Ago hQ>bo OmVo.
bmH$ZVa AZw^ddmXr ^y{_Ho$Mm {dVma ~H$bo Am{U y_ `mZr Ho$bm. AemH$mao {~Q>Z_ò AZw^ddmXr
VdkmZmMr EH$ nanamM {Z_mU Pmbr.
9.2 {df` {ddoMZ :
9.2.1 O_OmV H$nZm
(Innate Ideas)-
bmH$Zo Amnbr kmZ{df`H$ ^y{_H$m d H$nZm`m {Z{_VrMr Cnnmr _mS>`mnydu O_OmV (CnOV)
H$nZm {gmVmda OmoaXma Q>rH$m H$$Z `mMm ApdH$ma Ho$bm Amho. Bgdr gZ nyd H$mimnmgyZMm A{Ve`
mMrZ dmagm Agbo`m O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmg VdkmZmV \$ma _hd Amho. JrH$ Vdk boQ>moZo g_WZ
Ho$bobm hm {gmV nwT>o _``wJrZ Vdk AmJQ>rZ `mZohr {VnmXZ Ho$bm Amho. AmYw{ZH$ H$mimV XoH$mV,
pnZmoPm d bm`ZrQ>P `m ~w{dmXr VdkmZr O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmMo g_WZ Ho$bo Amho. `m`m_Vo
{ZpMV d gwn> kmZ O_OmV H$nZmda AmYm[aV AgVo. EdT>oM Zho Va XoH$mVZo BdamMo ApVd {g
H$a`mgmR>r O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmMm AmYma KoVbm Amho. XoH$mV`m _Vo _mZdm`m _ZmV CnOVM
H$nZmMo ApVd AgVo. Aem H$nZm Amn`m _Zmda H$moUrhr $O{dbo`m ZgVmV, `m ~mho$Zhr Ambo`m
87
ZgVmV. hUyZ `m H$nZm O_V:M Amn`m _ZmV AgVmV `mZm O_OmV H$nZm Ago hUVmV.
Aem H$nZm B{` gdoXZmVyZ {Z_mU Pmbo`m ZgVmV. CXm.XoH$mV`m _Vo J{UVmVrb Vdo, ^y{_VrVrb
_oò, VH$emr` {Z`_ d BdamMo ApVd `m`m H$nZm CnOV AgVmV.
OmZ bmH$Zo "Essay Concerning Human Understanding" `m JWmV gw$dmVrg O_OmV H$nZm
{gmVmMo IS>Z Ho$bo Amho. bmH$`m _Vo Amn`m _ZmV H$moU`mhr H$ma`m CnOV qH$dm O_OmV H$nZm
ZgVmV. H$moU`mhr H$maMr O_OmV Z{VH$ qH$dm J{UVr qH$dm VH$emr` Vdo Amn`m _ZmV AmYrnmgyZM
CnOVnUo ApVdmV AgyM eH$V ZmhrV. H$maU bmH$`m _Vo gd kmZ ho AZw^dmVyZ {Z_mU hmoVo. _Z ho
O_V: EImm H$mo`m H$mJXmgmaIo qH$dm nyUnUo H$mo`m nmQ>rgmaIo (Blank Sheet / Tabula rasa) AgVo.
_Z _yiV: gH$mahrZ AgVo. B{` gdoXZmVyZ `mda N>mn qH$dm R>go C_Q>VmV d ~m dVy`m {V_m
V`ma hmoVmV Am{U `mVyZ {V_m qH$dm H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr hmoVo. O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmMo IS>U H$$Z
Aem H$ma`m O_OmV (CnOV) H$nZm ZgVmV ho {g H$a`mgmR>r bmH$Zo Ho$bobo `w{$dmX Imbrb_mUoO_OmV H$nZm {gmVmdarb Q>rH$m : bmH$Mo `w{$dmX 1)
gmdXo{eH$ (gmd{H$) g_Vrda AmYm[aV `w{$dmX - (Argument of Universal Assent)
bmH$Mm hm `w{$dmX gd _mUgm`m gmdXo{eH$ g_Vrda AmYmabobm Amho. `m`m _Vo H$mhr
`mdhm[aH$ Vdo Aer AgVmV H$s `m~m~V gd bmoH$mMo EH$_V hmoVo. H$mhr H$nZm gmd{H$nUo `{$JV
AZw^dm{edm` ApVdmV AgVmV. hUyZ Aer `mdhm[aH$ Vdo qH$dm H$nZm CnOV d$nmV ApVdmV
AgVmV Ago hQ>bo OmVo. naVw bmH$`m _Vo hm `w{$dmX Iam ZgyZ Vmo \$gdm Amho. H$mhr Vdm`m ~m~VrV
gdM _mUgmMo EH$_V hmoV AgVo Ago g_OUo MyH$ Amho. H$maU bhmZ _wbo, doS>r _mUgo, AS>mUr d {Z~w
`Vr `mZm Aem VdmMo kmZ A{O~mV ZgVo. `md$Z O_OmV H$nZmZm gmdXo{eH$ g_Vr AgVo ho _V
`WmW Zmhr. `m{edm` bmH$ Agohr n> H$aVmo H$s, gd _mUgmMo H$mhr Vdm{df`r Oar gmd{H$ EH$_V
(g_Vr) AgVo ho Oar Iao _mZbo Var `md$Z hr Vdo CnOV AgVmV ho {g hmoV Zmhr.
2) Z{VH$ Vdo d gXJwU (Virtue) `m`m ~m~VrV Or gmdXo{eH$ g_Vr AmT>iyZ òVo `mMo H$maU bmH$`m _Vo - `mMo CnOV d$n Zho, Va Vr gdmZm gma`mM [aVrZo {hVH$maH$ d Cn`wV AgVmV
hUyZ gd bmoH$ `mMm drH$ma H$aVmV, Aer dVwpWVr AgVo. `md$Z Z{VH$ VdmMm drH$ma gdmZr
Ho$bm Amho hUyZ Vr O_OmV AmhoV Ago hUUo ~amo~a R>aV Zmhr Ago bmH$ n> H$aVmo.
3) Amn`m _ZmV H$mhr H$nZm O_OmV ApVdmV AgVmV hr Jmo> Oar JhrV Yabr Varhr bmH$`m
_Vo Amn`m _ZmVrb H$nZmnH$s H$moU`m O_OmV AmhoV Am{U H$moU`m A``ZmZo mV Pmbo`m AmhoV
`mVrb \$aH$ n> H$aUo H$R>rU Amho. hUyZ O_OmV H$nZm ApVdmV ZgyyZ gd H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr Amn`m
XZ{XZ AZw^dmVyZ hmoV AgVo.
4) Vm{H$H$ `w{$dmX - Oa Aer O_OmV Vdo (H$nZm) AgVrb Va A``Z {H$òMo EH$Xa d$nM
CbQ> {XeoZo OmUmao dmQ>Vo Ago bmH$ n> H$aVmo. gm_m` VdmMm drH$ma H$a`mnyduM AmnUmg {d{e>
{dYmZmMo g` g_OVo Ago `md$Z n> hmoVo. naVw A`V A{Zdm` d `wV d$nm`m {dYmZmH$S>o Amnbo
bj Jo`m{edm` Vr AmnUmg g_OV ZmhrV. `md$Z CnOV H$nZmMo ApVd `Vr`m _ZmV O_V:M
AgVo, nU `mMo kmZ `mbm ZgVo Ago hUUo VH$ {dgJV Amho.
5) XoH$mVZo AmJhr {VnmXZ Ho$`m_mUo Z{VH$ Vdo qH$dm Zr{V{Z`_ O_OmV ZgVmV Ago bmH$
88
n> H$aVmo. `m`m_Vo gmd{H$ d d`{g d$nmMr Z{VH$ Vdo AmnUmg AmT>iV ZmhrV. H$maU gd
Zr{V{Z`_ d `mo`-A`mo` H$nZm Wb-H$mi n[apWVrgmnoj d$nm`m AgVmV. VgoM Z{VH$ VdmMo
Zoh_r n>rH$aU d g_WZ H$amdo bmJVo. EdT>oM Zho Va Z{VH$ AmMaUmg {Xem XoUmar gXgX{ddoH$ ~wr
j{UH$, Am_{dgJV, `{$nado ~XbUmar Am{U EH$mM `Vr`m ~m~VrV {d{dY gJr gKfO` AgVo.
hUyZ Z{VH$ {Z`_ CnOV ZgVmV.
6) `m{edm` Ym{_H$ lm, gd Y_mMr _wb^yV Vdo Am{U BdamMr gH$nZm `m gwm O_OmV
ZgVmV ho bmH$ n> H$aVmo. `m`m _Vo `m H$nZm gmd{H$ ZgVmV. H$maU H$mhr {d{e> O_mVrV Bda
H$nZoMm nyUnUo A^md {XgyZ òVmo. VgoM Ym{_H$ lm nana{damoYr d$nm`m AgVmV. `m{edm` {ZgJ
{Z`_mMo kmZ AmnUmg CnOVM AgVo `m _VmMohr bmH$ IS>Z H$aVmo. VgoM Oa H$mhr Vdo d H$nZm
CnOV AgVrb Va Vr gd _mZdr `Vr_ò {ZandmXnUo {XgyZ Ambr nm{hOoV nU dVwpWVr Ver AmT>iV
Zmhr.
7) eodQ>r bmH$ Ago n> H$aVmo H$s, Oa `m gd H$nZm O_OmV (CnOV) AgVrb Va `m AZw^dmmao
{MVrg Am`m nm{hOoV. VH$emmVrb A{Zdm` gò (Necessary truths), J{UVmVrb Vdo qH$dm
Zr{V{Z`_ O_OmV ZgVmV.Aem H$mao O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmMo IS>Z H$$Z bmH$ Ago {VnmXZ H$aVmo
H$s, Amnbo gd kmZ AZw^dmVyZ mV hmoVo. O_V: Amnbo _Z ho H$mo`m H$mJXm_mUo qH$dm AYm`m Imobr_mUo
(Dark Chamber) AgVo. O_V: _Z H$moU`mhr H$nZmnmgyZ _wV AgVo. B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ `mmao
_Zm_ò gH$mamMo R>go C_Qy>Z `mVyZM H$nZmMr Cnmr hmoVo.
9.2.2 H$nZmMr Cnmr
(Origin of Ideas)
O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmMo IS>U H$$Z bmH$ Amn`m kmZ {gmVmMr {dYm`H$ ^y{_Ho$VyZ _mS>Ur
H$aVmo. H$nZmMr Cnmr H$er hmoVo ho n> H$arV AgVm gd kmZ AZw^dmVyZ {ZnZ hmoVo (All knowledge
is derived from experience) Ago bmH$ {VnmXZ H$aVmo. Amnbo _Z O_V: H$mo`m nmQ>rgmaIo AgyZ gd
H$nZm AZw^dmmao gnm{XV Ho$`m OmVmV. `m`m _Vo B{` gdoXZ (sensation) Am{U qMVZ (reflection)
`mmao _Zm_ò H$nZmMr Cnmr hmoVo. AZw^d qH$dm ~m gdoXZmmaoM _ZmV H$nZm {Z_mU hmoVmV. H$moUVrhr
H$nZm O_OmV ZgVo Ago Vmo n> H$aVmo.
Aem H$mao bmH$`m _Vo B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ hrM kmZmMr XmoZ gmYZo AgyZ `mmao _Zm_ò
H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr qH$dm CJ_ hmoVmo. gd kmZ ho AZw^dmVyZ mV hmoV AgVo. Amn`m _Zm`m AYm`m
Imobr_ò kmZ H$memMr {H$aUo doe H$a`m`m XmoZ {IS>`m hUOoM B{` gdoXZ Am{U qMVZ hr gmYZo
hmoV. `mmao V`ma Pmbo`m _ZmVrb H$nZm hUOo kmZ hmo`. H$nZmMo bmH$Zo XmoZ _wI H$ma Ho$bo
AmhoV. 1) gm`m H$nZm (Simple Ideas) Am{U 2) g{_l H$nZm (Complex Ideas).
1) gm`m H$nZm - bmH$`m _Vo gm`m H$nZm B{` gdoXZmVyZ _ZmZo JhU Ho$bo`m AgVmV. VgoM
gm`m H$nZm AUygma`m A{d^m` AgVmV d `mMr nwZamdmr H$aVm òVo. `mMm nwhm nwhm AZw^d
KoVm òVmo. CXm.dVyMm aJ, JY, ne, AmdmO, AmH$ma d $nmMr H$nZm hUOo gmYr H$nZm hmo`. gm`m
H$nZm hUOoM {Zad`d H$nZm hmoV. _mZdr _Zm`m AmV[aH$ {H$òmao hUOoM qMVZmmao gwm gm`m
H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr hmoV AgVo. qMVZmmao AmnUmg Amn`m AmV[aH$ AdWmMr OmUrd hmoV AgVo.
CXm.BN>m, gXoh, gdoXZ, {dMma, B`mXr. `m{edm` B{` gdoXZ Am{U qMVZ `m`m EH${H$aUmVyZ gm`m
H$nZmMo nwwhm Mma H$ma Ho$bo AmhoV. 1) \$V EH$mM kmZ|{`mH$Sy>Z {Z_mU hmoUm`m gm`m H$nZm hUOoM
89
EHo$p` H$nZm hmoV. CXm.aJ, AmdmO, $Mr, CUVm, WS>r, KZVm, B`mXr. 2) EH$mMdoir AZoH$
kmZ|{`mH$Sy>Z {Z_mU hmoUm`m H$nZm CXm.{XH$, {dVma, AmH$Vr, pWaVm d JVr B`mXr H$ma`m >r
d ne doXZ|{`mH$Sy>Z {_iUm`m H$nZm. 3) qMVZmVyZ {Z_mU hmoUmar gmYr H$nZm. CXm.gdoXZ, {dMma,
gXoh, BN>m, B. AmV{aH$ AdWm`m H$nZm. B{`mH$Sy>Z {Z_mU hmoUm`m H$nZmMo dJuH$aU, A_yVuH$aU,
g`moOZ d {d^mOZ _ZmZo H$$Z Oohm dVyMo kmZ hmoVo Vo qMVZm`m d$nmMo AgVo. 4) B{` gdoXZ
Am{U qMVZ `m XmoZ gmYZm`m g`wV ^mdmZo V`ma hmoUm`m gm`m H$nZm - CXm.gwI-Xw:ImMo doXZ,
eVr, ApVd, EH$Vm Am{U H$_ `mg~Yr`m H$nZm.
2)
g{_l H$nZm -
bmH$`m _Vo gm`m H$nZmnmgyZ g{_l H$nZm {Z_mU hmoVmV. gm`m H$nZmMo doJdoJ`m H$mao
EH$rH$aU d OwiUr H$$Z AmnUmg g{_l H$nZm ~Z{dVm òVmV. hUyZM AZoH$ gm`m H$nZmMo
EH$rH$aU (combination), VwbZm qH$dm g~Y (relation) Am{U A_yVuH$aU (abstraction) `mmao _Zm_ò
g{_l H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr Ho$br OmVo. WmoS>`mV AZoH$ gm`m H$nZmMo g{_lU d g`moOZ H$$Z `mVyZ
Or g`wV H$nZm {Z_mU Ho$br OmVo {Vbm g{_l H$nZm hUVmV. CXm.dVy - dVyVrb g~YmMr H$nZm,
gmX`, H$VkVm, g`, {dd, B. Aem H$mao gm`m H$nZmMr gm_Jr dmn$Z `m`mnmgyZ AmnUmg nm{hOo
Vem H$ma`m doJdoJ`m g{_l H$nZm _mZdr _Z V`ma H$arV AgVo. bmH$Zo g{_l H$nZmMo nwhm
VrZ H$ma Ho$bo AmhoV- {dH$ma (Modes) , ò (Substances) Am{U g~Y (Relation).
1)
{dH$mamMr H$nZm (Idea of Modes) -
Oohm AZoH$ gm`m H$nZm EH${V H$$Z `mMr EH$ {d{e> g{_l H$nZm V`ma Ho$br OmVo Vohm
{Vbm {dH$mamMr H$nZm hUVmV. CXm.{H$moU, S>PZ, _r, H$VkVm, gmX`, B. bmH$Zo {dH$mamMo bmH$Zo
XmoZ H$ma Ho$bo AmhoV - A) gmYo {dH$ma (Simple Modes) hUOo Ho$di EH$mM H$ma`m H$nZmMo EH$rH$aU
hmo`. CXm.S>PZ. `md$Z EH$mM H$ma`m ~mam dVy`m H$nZm EH$ H$$Z S>PZ hr g{_l H$nZm
~ZVo. {VbmM gmYm {dH$ma hUVmV. ~) g{_l {dH$ma (Complex Mode) - hUOo AZoH$ doJdooJ`m
H$ma`m gm`m H$nZmMr EH${V qH$dm g`wV H$nZm hmo`. CXm._r hr doJdoJ`m gm`m H$nZm`m
EH${H$aUm_wio ~Zbobr g{_l H$nZm hmo`. VgoM gmX` hr g{_l {dH$mamMr H$nZm hUOo _mU~Vm,
b`~Vm, aJ, AmH$fH$Vm, _mYw` `m`m EH${H$aUmVyZ ~Zbobr H$nZm hmo`.
2)
`{df`H$ g{_l H$nZm (Idea of Substance) -
`mZm dV:Mo dV ApVd AgVo Aem AZoH$ dVy`m gm`m H$nZm`m g`moJmVyZ V`ma Pmbobr
g{_l H$nZm hUOo ` hmo`. CXm.`mMr AYwH$ qH$dm {\$H$Q> aJmMr H$nZm qH$dm `m`m Q>UH$VoMr
H$nZm hr `m H$maMr AgVo.
3)
g~Y{df`H$ g{_l H$nZm (Idea of Relations) -
hUOo EH$m H$nZoMr Xwg`mer VwbZm Ho$`mZo qH$dm XmoZ H$nZm`m nana g~YmVyZ V`ma hmoUmar
g{_l H$nZm hmo`. CXm.H$maU{df`H$ H$nZm, Wb-H$mb g~YmMr H$nZm hr `m H$maMr AgVo. H$maU
hr H$nZm AZoH$ KQ>H$m`m nanag~YmVyZ ~ZVo. AemH$mao bmH$Zo B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ hr kmZmonmrMr
XmoZ gmYZo _mZbr AgyZ `m gmYZmVyZM gm`m H$nZm d g{_l H$nZm V`ma hmoVmV Ago hQ>bo Amho.
90
9.2.3 kmZ {gmV (Theory of Knowledge) OmZ bmH$`m kmZ {gmVmbm kmZ{__mgoV AZ`gmYmaU _hd Amho. _mZdm`m kmZ {H$òMr
VnerbmV OmdyZ {M{H$gm d gemoYZ H$aUmam bmH$ hm n{hbm Vdk _mZbm OmVmo. bmH$`m nydu gmHo$Q>rg
boQ>mo, A[aQ>mQ>b, XoH$mV, ~oH$Z d hmO `mZr _mZdr kmZm{df`rMr _r_mgm Ho$br Amho. naVw `m gdmnojm
bmH$Mr kmZ{df`H$ ^y{_H$m d{eQ>nyU Am{U Zm{d`nyU Amho. bmH$Zo _mZdm`m AmH$bZmMo d$n, `mMr
`mVr d _`mXm `m{df`r gemoYZ Ho$bo. `mZo Amn`m VdkmZmV kmZmMr Cnmr, kmZmMr CJ_WmZo,
kmZmMo d$n-H$ma d _`mXm `mg~Yr Vnerbdma {ddoMZ Ho$bobo Amho. Amnbo gnyU VdqMVZ kmZmMo
AdofU H$a`mV Kmb{dUmam bmH$ hm EH$_od Vdk hmo`. AmYw{ZH$ VdkmZmV kmZ {df`H$ g_òbm Oo
_hd mV Pmbo Amho `mMo gd lo` bmH$bm Amho. `mZo kmZemr` AZw^ddmXmMr ^y{_H$m 'Essay Concerning human understandinng' `m JWmV {dVmamZo _mS>br Amho.
kmZmonmr (Origin of Knowledge) bmH$`m _Vo gd kmZ AZw^dmVyZ {Z_mU hmoV AgVo d AZw^dmdaM AmYmabobo AgVo. _ZmV CnOV
H$nZmZm _wirM ApVd ZgVo Ago Vmo n> H$aVmo. gd H$ma`m kmZmMm AWdm H$nZmMm CJ_ AZw^dmVyZ
hmoV AgVmo Aer AZw^d{Z> ^y{_H$m KoD$Z bmH$Zo kmZ_r_mgm Ho$bobr Amho. `m`m _Vo O_V: _mZdmMo
_Z H$moar nmQ>r qH$dm H$mo`m H$mJXmgmaIo AgVo. _Zm_ò gw$dmVrg gH$ma AWdm H$nZm `mnH$s H$mhrhr
ZgVo. B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ `mmao _ZmV N>mn qH$dm R>go C_Qy>Z _JM `mnmgyZ gH$ma, H$nZm d gH$nZm
`mMm hiyhiy doe hmoV AgVmo. Aem [aVrZo kmZmMr Cnmr hmoV AgVo. B{` gdoXZ Am{U qMVZ `mmao
{Z_mU hmoUm`m gm`m d g{_l H$nZmmao kmZmMr Cnmr hmoVo.
kmZmMo d$n d H$ma - bmH$`m _Vo Amn`m _ZmMm `j g~Y \$V H$nZmerM òVmo d `j
^m{VH$ dVyn`V AmnU H$nZm`m _m`_mVyZ nmohmoMVmo. H$nZmVrb nana g~YmVyZ kmZmMr {Z{_Vr
hmoVo.
`m`m - bmH$Zo kmZmMr `m`m Imbrb_mUo Ho$br Amho - ""H$moU`mhr H$nZmVrb nana g~Y,
Ad` (gdmX) qH$dm `{VaoH$ ({dgdmX) Am{U {damoY `mMo gdoXZ hmoUo hUOo kmZ hmo`.''("Knowledge
seems to be nothing but the perception of the connection and agreement or disagreement and repugnancy
of any of our ideas")
Aem H$mao B{` gdoXZ Am{U qMVZ `m`m _mJ} H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr hmoD$Z `mVyZ
kmZmMr Cnmr hmoVo. bmH$`m _Vo `WmW qH$dm `wV kmZ hmo`mgmR>r H$nZm gwn> (clear) Am{U {ZpMV
(distinct) d$nm`m Ag`m nm{hOoV. H$maU An> d Xw~m}Y H$nZmmao g` d dmVd kmZ {_iy eH$V
Zmhr. {edm` H$nZm n`mV Ag`m nm{hOoV, H$maU n`mV H$nZmZrM {df`mMo kmZ nyUnUo hmoD$ eH$Vo.
VgoM bmH$`m _Vo Amnbo gdmV {ZpMV kmZ ho H$nZm_ò AgUmam Ad`, `{VaoH$ d {damoY `mMo
gdoXZ AgVo. `m doJdoJ`m _mJmZr _Z H$nZm_Yrb nanag~Y nmhVo `mZwgma kmZmMr n>Vm ~XbV
AgVo. kmZm`m n>Vo`m AemZwgma `mMo d$n d nmVir R>aVo. bmH$Zo _mZdr kmZm`m VrZ nmV`m
n> H$$Z kmZmMo VrZ H$ma gm{JVbo AmhoV.
kmZmMo H$ma 1)
AVkmZ (Intuitive Knowledge)
2)
{ZXeZm_H$ kmZ (Domonstrative Knowledge)
3)
gdoXZm_H$ kmZ (Sensitive Knowledge)

91
1) AVkmZ - `m kmZ H$mamV `Vr Amn`m _Zm`m ghm`mZo H$nZmVrb g~Y BVa H$nZmMr
_XV Z KoVm Wm{nV H$arV AgVo. hUOo Oohm _Zmbm H$nZm_Yrb Ad` d {dgdmX BVa H$nZmMr
_XV Z KoVm Wm{nV H$arV AgVo. hUOo Oohm _Zmbm H$nZm_Yrb Ad` d {dgdmX BVa H$nZm`m
_`Wr{edm` `j XeZmZo H$iVmo Aem kmZmbm AVkmZ hUVmV. CXm.dVwi ho {H$moU ZgVo, XmoZ Am{U
XmoZ {_iyZ Mma hmoVmV. `m H$maMo kmZ gdmV lo> XOmMo AgVo. Vo gy`H$memBVHo$ dN> d n> AgVo.
`m H$ma`m kmZm~b _ZmV gXoh, ge` d A{ZpMVVm `mZm dmd ZgVmo. `m kmZm`m {gVoMr JaO
ZgVo. bmH$`m _Vo AVkmZ ho gdmV A{YH$ n>, dN> d {ZpMV AgVo. `mMr gwn>Vm d {ZpMVr
{g H$aUo e` ZgVo. H$maU Vo d`{g d d`H$mer AgVo.
2) {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ - Oohm XmoZ H$nZm_Yrb Ad` qH$dm {dgdmX BVa H$nZm`m _`Wr{edm`
`jnUo {Xgy eH$V Zmhr, Vohm BVa H$nZmMo ghm` KoD$Z `m XmohmoVrb g~Y n> Ho$bm OmVmo. Vohm
Aem kmZmg {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ Ago hUVmV. {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ ho ~w{{Z> Am{U VH$ew AgVo. `mV
m_w`mZo J{UV d ^y{_VrVrb kmZmMm g_mdoe hmoVmo. bmH$`m _Vo {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ ho AVkmZmBVHo$ n>
d {ZpMV ZgVo. H$nZm_ò Oa VH$m{Y{>V g~Y Zgob Va {ZXeH$ kmZmbm _`mXm nS>VmV.
3) gdoXZm_H$ kmZ - kmZ|{`m`m gmhm`mZo qH$dm _`WrZo hmoUmao kmZ hUOoM gdoXZm_H$
kmZ hmo`. ~m OJmVrb dVyMo kmZ AmnUmg gdoXZmZo hmoVo. CXm.gy`, M, Zm, S>m|Ja, B. dVyMo AmnUmg
gdoXZmZo hmoUmao kmZ. ho kmZ BVHo$ n> d dN> AgVo H$s `mMr n>Vm d {ZpMVVm AmnU ZmH$maUo
e`M ZgVo. naVw Amnbr kmZ|{ò hr Zoh_rM dVwMo dmVd kmZ H$$Z XoVmV Ago Zmhr. H$mhrdoim AmnUmg
hmoUmao kmZ ^_m_H$ (Illusion) AgVo qH$dm \$mago AdVwgdoXZ AgVo. hUyZ gdoXZm_H$ kmZmg AVkmZ
qH$dm {ZXeZm_H$ kmZmBVH$s n>Vm d {ZpMVVm ZgVo. H$maU ho kmZ gddr kmZ|{`mda Adb~yZ AgVo.
VgoM H$mhrdoim A{VXyaMr qH$dm A{VOdiMr dVy ZrQ>nUo kmZ|{`mZm {XgV Zmhr. `m_wio gdoXZm_H$
kmZmV ^_ Am{U {d^_ `mgmaIo Xmof {Z_mU hmo`mMr e`Vm AgVo. VgoM B{` gdoXZmMo d$n ApWa,
MMb, `{${Z>, gXmof d _`m{XV d$nmMo AgVo. VWm{n gdoXZm_H$ kmZ _aUm_H$ kmZmnojm Am{U
dZmVrb AZw^dmnojm {ZpMV AgVo Ago bmH$ n> H$aVmo.
bmH$Zo darb VrZ H$ma`m kmZmV Omo \$aH$ Ho$bm Amho Vmo kmZmMo {ZpMV d gwn> d$n
XmI{d`mgmR>r Ho$bm Amho. gwn>Vm d {ZpMVVo`m d$nmZwgma `mZo kmZmMo VrZ H$ma qH$dm AdWm
n> Ho$`m AmhoV. `mnH$s AVkmZ gdmV A{YH$ n> d {ZpMV AgVo, `mZVa {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ hr
AdWm òVo. nU gdoXZm_H$ kmZmV BVH$s {ZpMVVm ZgVo. bmH$`m _Vo AmnUmg dV:`m ApVdmMo
AVkmZ AgVo, Bdam`m ApVdmMo {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ AgVo Am{U ~m OJmVrb gd dVyMo gdoXZm_H$
kmZ AgVo. B{` gdoXZmmao AmnUmg ^m{VH$ dVyMo hmoUmao kmZ ho dV:`m d Bdam`m kmZmBVHo$ Oar
{ZpMV Zgbo Var `mdhm[aH$ >rZo Vo {ZpMV AgVo.
9.2.4 A_yV H$nZm
(Abstract Ideas)
bmH$Zo Amn`m kmZ{gmVmMo {VnmXZ H$aVmZm A_yV H$nZmZm _hd {Xbobo Amho. AmnUmg ^m{VH$
dVyMo kmZ H$go hmoVo ho n> H$aVmZm `mZo A_yV H$nZm {gmV _mS>bm Amho. `m`m _Vo ^m{VH$ dVyMo
XmoZ H$maMo JwUY_ AgVmV - mW{_H$ d Xw`_ JwUY_. JwUmZm AmYma AgUmar dVy ApVdmV AgVo.
Aem A_yV JwUm`m mao Vmo A_yV H$nZmMo ApVd _m` H$aVmo. bmH$`m _Vo A_yVuH$aUm`m qH$dm
{d`moJrH$aUm`m {H$òoVyZ A_yV H$nZm V`ma hmoVmV. A_yVuH$aU (abstraction) H$aUo hm _mZdr d^md
92
AgyZ Amn`m kmZm`m gmo`rgmR>r A_yVuH$aU Ho$bo OmVo. A_yVuH$aU hUOo OJmVrb dVyZm {Xbobr
dJdmMr qH$dm gm_m` Zmdo hmoV. OJmV AZV dVy AmhoV VgoM AZV H$nZm AmhoV. `m AZV dVyZm
{d{e> Zmdo XoD$Z AmoiImdmd`mMo Pm`mg gdM Zmdo bjmV R>odUo Ae` hmoBb. `mgmR>r AmnU ^mfoV
H$mhr gm_m` H$nZm V`ma H$aVmo. `m_wio {dMmamMr XodmUKodmU e` hmoVo. AemH$mao OJmVrb {d{dY
dVy Am{U H$nZm `m`mV Agbobm gmYmaU JwU bjmV KoD$Z _mZdr _Z A_yVuH$aU H$arV AgVo d`mVyZ
A_yV H$nZm V`ma Ho$`m OmVmV. CXm.gd _mUgmV AmT>iyZ òUm`m "_Zw`d' `m gmYmaU JwUm`m
AmYmao "_Zw`' hr A_yV H$nZm AmnU V`ma H$aVmo.
`md$Z A_yV H$nZm hUOo {d{dYVo_ò gm_m`d emoYyZ V`ma Ho$bobr H$nZm hmo`. VgoM
{d{dYVoV EH$Vm emoY`mMm `Z hUOo A_yVuH$aU hmo`. `mbmM gm_m` H$nZm Agohr hQ>bo OmVo.
OJmV Ag` dVy AgyZ `m gd dVy - \w$bo, \$io, mUr, njr hr d`{$H$[a`m bjmV R>odUo Ae`
R>aVo. bmH$`m _Vo dJ qH$dm gm_m` nXo dmna`m{edm` {dMmamMr XodmU-KodmU H$aVm òUma Zmhr. hUyZM
^mfoMr XodmU-KodmU gwb^VoZo H$a`mgmR>r gm_m` nXo qH$dm A_yV H$nZmMo ghm` Amd`H$ R>aVo. CXm.Jm`,
KmoS>m, dj, \$io, _mUyg, S>m|Ja, ZXr, gmJa, B`mXr gm_m` nXm`m gmmZo OJmVrb gd Jm`r, gd
KmoS>o, gd dj, gd \$io, gd _mUgo, gd S>m|Ja, gd Zm, gd gmJa {ZX}{eV Ho$bo OmVmV. hUOo `{$dmMr
nXoM gm_m` nXo qH$dm A_yV H$nZm ~ZVmV. dVy_ò {XgyZ òUm`m gm_mBH$ JwUY_mZm EH$ H$$Z
Or gm_m` H$nZm V`ma Ho$br OmVo `mg "A_yV H$nZm' Ago hUVmV. A_yV H$nZm Wb-H$mbn[apWVr {Zanoj AgVmV. `m H$Yrhr Zmhrem hmoV ZmhrV. `m {Z`, An[adVZr` d pWa AgVmV.
9.2.5 d`-A``ZmgmR>r Z 1) Imbrb {dYmZo MyH$ H$s ~amo~a Vo gmJm.
A)
bmH$ hm ~w{dmXr Vdk hmo`.
~)
bmH$Zo O_OmV H$nZmMo g_WZ Ho$bo Amho.
H$)
bmH$Zo H$nZmMo XmoZ _wI H$ma Ho$bo AmhoV.
S>)
bmH$`m _Vo gd kmZ AZw^dmVyZ mV hmoVo.
B)
A_yV H$nZm hUOoM g{_l H$nZm hmoV.
2) [aH$m`m OmJr `mo` n`m` {ZdSy>Z Imbrb {dYmZo nyU H$am.

1)
----------- hm AZw^ddmXmMm OZH$ hmo`.

A) bmH$
2)
~) ~mH$bo
bmH$Zo ----------- {gmVmMo IS>U Ho$bo Amho.

A) O_OmV H$nZm~) A_yV H$nZm
3)
H$) Bda
B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ hr ----------- Mr gmYZo AmhoV.

A) kmZmMr
4)
H$) y_
~) g`mMr
H$) {dMmamMr
bmH$`m _Vo ----------- H$nZmnmgyZ g{_l H$nZm {Z_mU hmoVmV.

A) A_yV
~) gm`m
93
H$) gm_m`
5)
{dH$ma, ` Am{U g~Y ho ----------- H$nZmMo VrZ H$ma AmhoV.

A) gm`m
6)
~) VrZ
H$) Mma
bmH$`m _Vo ----------- kmZ gdmV lo> XOmMo AgVo.

A) AVkmZ
~) {ZXeZm_H$
9.3 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW, B`mX

AZw^ddmX - Empiricism
kmZ{__mgmem - Epistemology
~w{dmX - Rationalism
O_OmV (CnOV) H$nZm - Innate Ideas
gm`m H$nZm - Simple Ideas
g{_l H$nZm - Complex Ideas
B{` gdoXZ - Sensation
qMVZ - Reflection
A_yVuH$aU - Abstraction
A_yV H$nZm - Abstract Ideas
` - Substance
{dH$ma - Modes
g~Y - Relations
AVkmZ - Intuitive Knowledge
{ZXeZm_H$ kmZ - Demonstrative Knowledge
gdoXZm_H$ kmZ - Sensitive Knowledge
^_ - Illusion
gm_m` H$nZm - General Ideas
A{Zdm` g` - Necessary Truth
9.4 d`-A``Z ZmMr Cmao 1)
H$) A_yV
bmH$Zo kmZmMo ----------- H$ma Ho$bo AmhoV.

A) XmoZ
7)
~) g{_l
A)
MyH$
~)
MyH$
94
H$) gdoXZm_H$
2)
H$)
~amo~a
S>)
~amo~a
B)
MyH$
1)
A) bmH$
2)
A) O_OmV H$nZm
3)
A) kmZmMr
4)
~) gm`m
5)
~) g{_l
6)
~) VrZ
7)
A) AVkmZ
9.5 gmame OmZ bmH$ hm AZw^ddmXmMm OZH$ AgyZ `mZo kmZ{gmVmda {deof â {Xbm Amho. gd kmZ ho
AZw^dmVyZ mV hmoVo Ago Vmo n> H$aVmo.bmH$Zo O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmda Q>rH$m Ho$br AgyZ _mZdr
_ZmV O_V: qH$dm CnOV H$nZm Agy eH$V ZmhrV ho {g H$a`mgmR>r `mZo `w{$dmX _mS>bo.bmH$`m
_Vo _mZdr _Z ho O_V: H$mo`m H$mJXm_mUo gH$mahrZ AgVo. B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ `mmao _Zm_ò
gH$mamMo R>go C_Qy>Z `mVyZM H$nZmMr {Z{_Vr hmoVo.H$nZmMo XmoZ H$ma bmH$Zo Ho$bo AmhoV.
1) gm`m H$nZm - B{` gdoXZmVyZ _ZmZo JhU Ho$bo`m H$nZm hUOo gm`m H$nZm hmo`.
gm`m H$nZm AUygma`m A{d^m` AgyZ `mMr nwZamdmr H$aVm òVo. gm`m H$nZmMo Mma H$ma
AmhoV.
2) g{_l H$nZm - gm`m H$nZmMo doJdoJ`m H$mao EH${H$aU d OwiUr H$$Z g{_l H$nZm
{Z_mU Ho$`m OmVmV. `m VrZ H$ma`m AgVmV - `, {dH$ma Am{U g~Y.
kmZ{gmV - gd kmZ AZw^dmVyZ {Z_mU hmoV AgVo d AZw^dmdaM AmYmabobo Ago bmH$ Amn`m
kmZ_r_mgoV n> H$aVmo.
kmZmMr `m`m - H$moU`mhr H$nZmVrb nana g~Y, Ad` qH$dm `{VaoH$ Am{U {damoY `mMo
gdoXZ hUOo kmZ hmo`.
kmZmMo VrZ H$ma 1) AVkmZ - `Vr Amn`m _Zm`m ghm`mZo H$nZmVrb g~Y BVa H$nZm`m _XVr{edm`
ôQ> Wm{nV H$aVo `mg AVkmZ hUVmV.
2) {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ - BVa H$nZm`m gmhm`mZo Oohm XmoZ H$nZm_Yrb g~Y n> Ho$bm OmVmo
Vohm `mg {ZXeZm_H$ kmZ hUVmV.
3) gdoXZm_H$ kmZ - hUOo kmZ|{`m`m gmhm`mZo hmoUmao kmZ hmo`.
95
A_yV H$nZm - {d{dYVo_Yrb gm_m`V: emoYyZ V`ma Ho$bobr H$nZm hUOo A_yV H$nZm hmo`.
OJmVrb AZV dVwZm {Xbobr dJdmMr qH$dm gm_m` Zmdo hUOo A_yV H$nZm hmoV.
9.6 gamdmgmR>r dm`m` 1) O_OmV H$nZm {gmVmMo bmH$Zo H$go IS>U Ho$bo Amho Vo n> H$am.
2) H$nZm`m Cnmr g~Yr`m bmH$`m {gmVmMo nQ>rH$aU H$am.
3) gm`m d g{_l H$nZmMo d$n d H$ma n> H$am.
4) bmH$Mr kmZ{df`H$ Cnnmr n> H$am.
5) _mZdr kmZmMo bmH$Zo gm{JVbobo H$ma n> H$am.
6) Q>rnm {bhm - A) bmH$Mm AZw^ddmX
~) A_yV H$nZm
9.7 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$ H$n`m JWm`m eodQ>r gyMr nhmdr.
666
96
KQ>H$ -10
~H$bo$( Berkeley )
10.0 C{Q>o
10.1 mVm{dH$ - M[a, H$m` d VdkmZ
10.2 {df` - {ddoMZ
10.2.1
bmH$ - ~H$bo g~Y
10.2.2
A_yV H$nZmMo IS>U
10.2.3
"ApVd hUOo gdoXZ'

( "Esse est percipi" )
10.2.4
A^m{VH$dmX
10.2.5
BdamMo WmZ
10.2.6
d`-A``ZmgmR>r Z
( Immaterialism )
10.3 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW, B`mXr

10.4 d`-A``Z ZmMr Cmao
10.5 gmame
10.0 C{Q>o :
`m KQ>H$m`m A`mgmZo Amn`mbm * bmH$ Am{U ~H$bo `m`mVrb g~YmMo d$n g_OyZ òBb.
* bmH$`m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmda ~H$bo `mZo Ho$bobr Q>rH$m n> H$aVm òBb.
* "ApVd hUOoM gdoXZ' `m ~H$bo`m VdkmZmVrb _`dVu {gmVmMo d$n, `mVr d
_hd `m{df`r _m{hVr {_iob.
* OS>`m`m dV ApVdmMo `mZo Ho$bobo IS>U - hUOoM ~H$bo`m A^m{VH$ dmXmMo d$n
n> hmoBb.
* ~H$bo`m VdkmZmVrb BdamMo WmZ H$m` Amho `m{df`r _m{hVr {_iy eHo$b.
10.1 mVm{dH$ : M[a, H$m` d VdkmZ
~H$boMm O_ EH$m Bpbe Hw$Qw>~mV 12 _mM 1685 amoOr Am`bS>_ò Pmbm. 1700 _ò `mZo
97
{Q>{ZQ>r H$mboO_ò doe KoVbm. VoWo `mZo J{UV, ^mfm, VH$em d VdkmZ `m {df`mMm A`mg Ho$bm
Am{U 1704 _ò ~r.E. hr nXdr gnmXZ Ho$br. nwT>o 1707 _ò `mM H$mboO_ò Vmo \o$bmo (Fellow)
hUyZ $Oy Pmbm. 1709 _ò Bpbe MM_ò {~en hUyZ `mMr Zo_UyH$ Pmbr. VgoM `mZo Amnbm
A`V _hdnyU JW - An Essay towards a new Theory of Vision {g Ho$bm.
~H$bo`m {dMmamda bmH$ Am{U _mb~e `mMm ^md {XgyZ òVmo. bmH$`m AZw^ddmXmMm Vmo dmag
_mZbm OmVmo. H$nZm`m Cnmr{df`rMo bmH$Mo _mZgemr` {dbofU `mZo _m` Ho$bo. ~H$boZo Oar
bmH$`m AZw^ddmXmMo g_WZ Ho$bo Agbo Var Vmo bmH$Mm AmYim AZw`m`r ZhVm. `mZo bmH$`m A_yV
H$nZm {gmVmda Ho$bo`m Q>rHo$d$Z ho n> hmoVo. `mMo VdkmZ bmH$`m VdkmZmnojm doJio AgyZ
`mZo AZw^d{Z> {MXdmXmMm (Empirical Idealism) nwaH$ma Ho$bm Amho.
~H$bo hm Ho$di VdqMVH$ ZhVm Va Va Vmo EH$ MmJbm {OrMm d Vi_irMm H$m`H$Vmhr hmoVm.
`mZo {ejU gmamMo H$m` Ho$bo Amho. VgoM gm_m` OZVoMo `mdhm[aH$ OrdZmV ^m{VH$ d A`mp_H$
H$`mU hmdo Aer `mMr Vrd BN>m hmoVr. Y_m}nXoeH$ hUyZ `mMr H$m_{Jar IynM _hdmMr Amho. `mMo
OrdZ d VdkmZ ho Ym{_H$ d A`mp_H$ H$m`mbm dm{hbobo hmoVo. `m_wio ~H$bo hm "Ym{_H$ ~moYZH$Vm'
_mZbm OmVmo. ~H$bo `mZo {d{dY d$nmMo boIZ Ho$bo AgyZ `mMo _hdmMo JW Imbrb_mUo AmhoV 1)
Arithmetica
2)
A Treatise Concerning the principless of Human Knowledge
3)
The Minute Philosopher (1732)
Amg\$S> òWo `mZo eodQ>Mo {Xdg Kmb{dbo. 14 OmZodmar 1753 amoOr ~H$boMo {ZYZ Pmbo.
10.2 {df` {ddoMZ :10.2.1 bmH$ - ~H$bo g~Y ~H$bo hm AZw^ddmXr nanaoVrb EH$ _hdmMm VdqMVH$ hmo`. AZw^ddmXmMr gw$dmV {~Q>Z_ò
OmZ bmH$Zo Ho$br. kmZmMr {Z{_Vr d d$n, H$nZmMr Cnmr `m{df`r bmH$Zo Ho$bobr {__mgm ~H$bo `mZo
_m` Ho$br AgyZ bmH$`m AZww^ddmXmMo `mZo g_WZ Amho. bmH$`m AZw^ddmXr gXm`mMm dmagm
~H$bog {_imbm Ag`mZo `m`m VdkmZmda bmH$Mm ^md {XgyZ òVmo. VWm{n bmH$`m VdkmZmVrb
gdM {gmV `mg _m` hmoVo Ago hUVm òV Zmhr. H$maU bmH$`m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmda ~H$bo `mZo
{Q>H$m Ho$br Amho
bmH$ Am{U ~H$bo `mMo {dMma d VdkmZ `mV ~aoM gm` {XgyZ òVo. H$maU ~H$bo hm bmH$Zo gw$
Ho$bo`m AZw^ddmXmMm nwaH$Vm hmoVm. bmH$`m AZw^ddmXr kmZ{gmVmer Vmo gh_V hmoVm. B{` gdoXZ
d qMVZ `m _mJmZr kmZmMr {Z{_Vr hmoVo hr AZw^ddmXr {dMmagaUr bmH$_mUo `mbm _m` hmoVr. ^m{VH$
OJmMo kmZ B{` AZw^dmVyZ hmoVo Ago ~H$bogwm _m` H$aVmo. ~H$boMm bmH$er Agbobm g~Y `m`m
AZw^ddmXr VdkmZm`m nwaH$mamVyZ n> hmoVmo. {~Q>re AZw^ddmXm`m {dH$mgm_ò bmH$ d ~H$bo `mMo
`moJXmZ _hdmMo R>aVo.
Aem [aVrZo ~H$bo hm bmH$`m AZw^ddmXr VdkmZmMm AmYma KoD$Z {MXdmX Wm{nV H$aVmo.
bmH$ AZw`m`r AgyZhr `mMo VdkmZ bmH$nojm doJio Amho. `mZo AZw^d{Z> {MXdmXmMm nwaH$ma Ho$bm
98
Amho. VgoM ~H$bo `mZo ^m{VH$dmXmMo Am{U {Z[adadmXmMo IS>U Ho$bobo Amho. OmUrd {Zanoj d dV Ago
OS>`mg ApVd AgyM eH$V Zmhr Ago ~H$bo nQ> H$aVmo. `md$Z bmH$ d ~H$bo `m`m VdUmbr_ò
Ago gm` AmT>iyZ òVo. `mM_mUo ôXhr {XgyZ òVmo. bmH$`m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmda Q>rH$m H$$Z
~H$bo Ago n> H$aVmo H$s _Zmbm A_V H$nZm V`ma H$aVm òVmV Ago hUUo MyH$ Amho.
10.2.2 A_yV H$nZmMo IS>U bmH$Zo Amn`m kmZ{gmVmMo {VnmXZ H$aVmZm A_yV H$nZmMo ApVd _m` Ho$bo Amho. `m`m
_Vo _Zw` Amn`m kmZm`m gmo`rgmR>r A_yVuH$aUmMo ghm` KoV AgVmo. A_yVuH$aU hUOo OJmVrb
dVyZm {Xbobr dJdmMr qH$dm gm_m` Zmdo hmoV. WmoS>`mV, A_yV H$nZm hUOo {d{dYVoV gm_m`d
emoYyZ V`ma Ho$bobr H$nZm hmo`. AZoH$ dVy_ò {XgyZ òUm`m gm_mBH$ JwUY_mZm EH${V H$$Z Or
gm_m` H$nZm V`ma Ho$br OmVo `mg A_yV H$nZm hUVmV. CXm. gd _mUgmV AmT>iyZ òUmam
"_Zw`d' hm gmYmaU JwU AgyZ `m`m AmYmao AmnU "_Zw`'hr A_yV H$nZm V`ma H$aVmo. bmH$`m
_Vo A_yV H$nZm Wb-H$mb {Zanoj AgVmV. `m H$Yrhr Zmhrem hmoV ZmhrV. `m H$m`_ AgVmV.
bmH$`m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmda ~H$bo Imbrb_mUo Q>rH$m H$aVmo.
~H$boMr A_yV H$nZodarb Q>rH$m 1) OJmVrb gd dVy d KQ>Zm `m`mVrb gmYmaU JwUY_ bjmV KoD$Z _mZdr _Z A_yV
H$nZm V`ma H$arV AgVo Am{U `m A_yV H$nZo`m ghm`mZoM nwhm {d{e> dVy d KQ>Zm `mMo kmZ
hmoVo. `m bmH$`m {dMmamer ~H$bo gh_V Zmhr. ~H$bo`m _Vo Aem A_yV H$nZm aM`mMr j_Vm
_Zm_ò ZgVo. {edm` A_yV H$nZm AmnUmg H$Yrhr AZw^dmg òV ZmhrV. A_yV H$nZm `m eXmZr
{ZX}{eV Ho$`m OmVmV Vo \$V "eX' AgVmV. eXmhZ A{YH$ BVa H$mhrhr ZgVo. CXm.{H$moUm`m
gm_m` H$nZobm AZw$n Agm H$moUVmhr gm_m` {H$moU dmVd OJmV ApVdmV ZgVmo.
2) A_yV H$nZoZo {ZX}{eV hmoUmar Jmo> `j/dmV{dH$ OJmV AZw^dmg òV Zmhr. hUyZ
"A_yV H$nZm' hUOo Xwgao {Vgao H$mhrhr ZgyZ Ho$di EH$ "eX' AgVmo Ago ~H$bo n> H$aVmo. hm eX
{d{e> dVyMm {ZX}e H$a`mgmR>r AmnU AZoH$doim dmnaVmo d `m_wio Vmo "gm_m`' ~ZVmo. dmVdmV
gm_m` eX qH$dm A_yV H$nZm hr Ho$di EH$ VrH$ Amho. Ho$di EH$ eX Amho.
3) ~H$bo`m _Vo _Zmbm A_yV H$nZm V`ma H$aVm òVmV Ago hUUo MwH$s`m g_OwVrda
AmYm[aV Amho. EImXm eX {Z_mU Pmbm hUOo `m eXmZo {ZX}{eV Ho$bobr dVy `jmV ApVdmV
Agbr nm{hOo Ago g_OUo MyH$ Amho. WmoS>`mV, eX Agbm hUOo `mbm AZw$n Aer dVy/KQ>Zm
`j OJmV AgVoM Aer MwH$sMr g_OyV H$$Z KoV`m_wio Iyn Jm|Yi {Z_mU Pmbobm Amho. eX Am{U
dmVd dVy `mZm EH$M g_OUo MyH$ Amho. hUyZ ~H$bo n> H$aVmo H$s, eX ~mOybm R>odyZ `j dVy`m
H$nZmZmM AmnU OmdyZ {^S>bo nm{hOo. eXmMm AS>ga Xya Ho$`m{edm` AmnUmg dVyMo g` kmZ hmoD$
eH$V Zmhr.
4) eodQ>r ~H$bo Agm `wVrdmX H$aVmo H$s, A_yV H$nZm aMUo Ho$di Ae` Amho. `m_wio
bmH$Mm A_yV H$nZm {gmV AdrH$mamh Amho. CXm."_Zw`' `m A_yV H$nZoV gd _mUgmMo {d{dY,
nana{damoYr JwU AV^yV AgyM eH$V ZmhrV. H$maU Amnbm AZw^d Agm Amho H$s, ^modVmb`m OJmV
{d{dY _mUgo AgyZ `m`m {R>H$mUr {d{dY nana {damoYr d$nmMo JwUY_ AmhoV. `m`m~m~VrV
H$mhrhr gm` Zmhr. CMr, aJ, d^md, $n-gmX`, ~w{_mm, B. JwUY_m-~m~VrV `Vr-`Vr_ò
99
{^ZVm qH$dm {d{dYVm {XgyZ òVo. `m_wio nana {damoYr JwU Agbo`m `Vr`m {R>H$mUr gm_m`d
qH$dm gm_m` JwU H$gm Agy eHo$b ? `md$Z Aem nana {damoYr JwUmZm gm_mdyZ KoUmar A_yV H$nZm
ApVdmV AgUo Ae` Amho Agm ~H$boMm {ZH$f Amho.
AmYw{ZH$ _mZgemkmZmhr ~H$boMr A_yV H$nZm {gmVmMo IS>U H$aUmar ^y{_H$m _m` Amho.
H$maU `m`m_Vo AmnU "gm_m` _mUyg' qH$dm "gm_m` {H$moU' Aem H$maMr H$nZm _ZmV V`ma H$$
eH$V Zmhr. H$moUVrhr H$nZm ({V_m) hr EImm {d{e> _mUgmer qH$dm {d{e> {H$moUmer g~{YV
AgVo. hUyZ "{H$moU' hr A_yV H$nZm hUOo Ho$di EH$ eX hmo`.`m gd `wVrdmXmd$Z ~H$bo Ago
nQ> H$aVmo H$s, _Zmbm A_yV H$nZm V`ma H$aVm òV Zmhr Am{U A_yV H$nZm `m Ho$di eX/Zm_
AgVmV. dmVdmV `m H$mhrhr ZgVmV. A_yV H$nZmZm eXm{edm` Xwgao _hd Zmhr. AemH$mao
~H$boZo A_yV H$nZmMo IS>U Ho$bo Amho.
10.2.3 "ApVd hUOo gdoXZ'
("Esse est percipi") -
~H$bo`m VdkmZm`m XmoZ ~mOy AmhoV - {ZfoYm_H$ (Negative) Am{U {dYm`H$ (Positive). gdW_
`mZo bmH$`m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmMo IS>U Ho$bo Amho. `mZVa OS>`mg dV OmUrd {Zanoj
ApVd ZgVo Ago Vmo nQ> H$aVmo. kmZmMr Cnmr d kmZmMr gmYZo (B{` gdoXZ d qMVZ) `m{df`rMr
bmH$Mr AZw^ddmXr _r_mgm `mZo _m` Ho$br Amho. naVw ~H$bo`m _Vo ^m{VH$ dVy`m {V_m, R>go qH$dm
gH$ma `mZm _Zm~mhoa ApVd ZgVo. `m `m doir ^m{VH$ dVyMo kmZ hmoVo `mdoir Vr ^m{VH$ dVy
Amn`m (`Vr`m) _ZmV AgVo. `Vr`m _Zm{edm` ^m{VH$ dVyMo kmZ hmoD$ eH$V Zmhr. `md$Z
^m{VH$ dVy`m ApVdmMo kmZ _Z gmnoj AgVo Ago ~H$bo hUVmo. ~H$bo`m VdkmZmMr hr {dYm`H$
~mOy hmo`. "ApVd hUOoM gdoXZ (Existence is perception)' hm `m`m VdkmZmVrb _`dVu
{gmV AgyZ `mMo gd VdkmZ `m {gmVmdaM AmYm[aV Amho.
_Zm{edm` ^m{VH$ dVyMo kmZ d ApVd {g hmoV Zmhr hr ~H$boMr ^y{_H$m VH$ew AgyZ `mMm
hm {dMma ~hVoH$ gd {dMmadVmZr _m` Ho$bm Amho. `Vr`m _Zm{edm` H$nZm AJa {dMma `mZm
dV ApVd ZgVo ho n> H$$Z ~H$bo ^m{VH$ dVy`m kmZmg~Yr d ApVdmg~Yr {dMma H$aVmo.
`m~m~V bmH$Mr ^y{_H$m ~H$bobm _m` Zmhr. `m`m _Vo gdoXZm{edm` ^m{VH$ dVyMo dV ApVd
Ae` Amho. ~H$bo`m _Vo `mMo gdoXZ hmoV Zmhr Aer ^m{VH$ dVy ApVdmV AgUo e` Zmhr.
gdoXZm{edm` ^m{VH$ dVyMr AmnUmg H$nZm XoIrb H$aVm òUma Zmhr. AgdoXZr` d AkmV `mMr
H$nZm Ae` hmo`. ~H$bo`m _Vo OJmV OS>dVy AmhoV ho AmnUmg Ho$di H$nZm`m _m\$V g_OVo
Am{U H$nZm _Zm{edm` Agy eH$V ZmhrV. H$nZmZm _ZmVM ApVd AgVo. gdoXZj_ _Zm{edm`
H$nZmMo kmZ hmoD$ eH$V Zmhr.
"dVyZm ApVd AgVo' `m {dYmZm`m Zo_`m AWm{df`r ~H$bo {M{H$gm H$aVmo. gdo dVyZm
ApVd AgVo Ago Oohm AmnU hUVmo Vohm "gdo' `m eXmMm Zo_H$m AW Vmo n> H$aVmo. Vmo hUVmo
"_r `m Q>o~bmda {b{hVmo Amho Ago Oohm _r hUVmo Vohm `mMm AW _r Vo nmhVmo d Vo _bm OmUdVo'. _r
Imobr`m ~mhoa Jo`mdahr - "ImobrV Q>o~b Amho' Ago _r hUVmo. Vohm _m`m hU`mMm AW Agm H$s,
_r Oa ImobrV Agob Va Vo _bm {Xgbo AgVo. nU AkmV d Ako` ^m{VH$ `mMo ApVd H$go {g
H$aVm òBb ? hUyZ ~H$bo`m _Vo Oo AkmV Amho `mMo gdoXZ hmoUma Zmhr Am{U `mMo gdoXZ hmoUma Zmhr
`mMr H$nZmhr V`ma hmoUma Zmhr. `m_wio H$nZm Zgob Va ^m{VH$ ` ApVdmV Amho Ago hU`mg
100
H$moUVmhr Vm{H$H$ nwamdm Amn`mOdi Zmhr. AemH$mao gd dVyMo d ^m{VH$ OJmMo ApVd `Vr`m
_Zmbm hmoUm`m gdoXZmda Adb~yZ AgVo Ago n> H$$Z ~H$bo "ApVd hUOoM gdoXZ' hm {gmV
_hdmMm _mZVmo.
~H$bo`m _Vo `mMo `mMo AmnUmg gdoXZ hmoVo Vo gd ApVdmV AgVo. Amnbo {dMma d H$nZm
Amn`m _ZmV ApVdmV AgVmV. `mMo ApVd ho AmnUmg `mMo gdoXZ hmo`mV gm_mdbobo AgVo.
AemH$mao ~H$bo "ApVd = gdoXZ' Ago g_rH$aU _mSy>Z XmoKmZm nanamer EH$$n g_OVmo. hUOo
EImXr Jmo> - _J Vr aJ, AmH$ma H$mhrhr Agmo - Omon`V EImXr `Vr gdoXZm`m _mJmZo Vr AZw^drV
AgVo, Vmon`V {Vbm ApVd AgVo. `m OJmV Oo H$moUm`mhr AZw^dmg H$Yrhr Ambobo Zmhr, `mbm
ApVd AgVo Ago hUUo ~H$bo`m _Vo "dXVmo `mKmV' Amho. hUyZM dVyMo ApVdmV AgUo hUOo
{VMo gdoXZ hmoUo d Vr _ZmV AgUo hmo` Ago ~H$bo n> H$aVmo (To be is to be percieved).
"A{Vd hUOo gdoXZ' `m ~H$bo`m _wI {gmVmVrb R>iH$ JmoQ>r Imbrb_mUo1) Amn`m H$nZm, {V_m Am{U ^mdZm `mZm _Zm~mhoa qH$dm _Zm{edm` ApVd Agy eH$V
Zmhr. (Our ideas, feelings and images have no existence apart from the mind.)
2) OmUUm`m `Vr{edm` gwm H$nZmZm ApVd ZgVo. hUOo `Vr`m _Zm~mhoa H$nZm
AgVo Ago hUVm òV Zmhr. (Ideas independent of the knower also have no existence.)
3) Oohm "ApVd' hm eX ^m{VH$ dVy`m gX^mV dmnabm OmVmo Vohm `mMm AW gdoXm{edm`
BVa H$mhrhr ZgVmo. hUOo EImXr dVy ApVdmV Amho `mMm AW Vr gdoXZr` Amho Agm hmoVmo.
4) H$moU`mhr dVyMm {dMma H$aVmZm qH$dm `m dVy~b ~mobVmZm Vr dVy gdoXZr` Zmhr Ago
hUUo AWhrZ d {Z$n`moJr Amho. hUOoM dVy "Amho' nU Vr gdoXZr` Zmhr Ago hUUo {ZaWH$ Amho.
hUyZM ApVdmV AgUo hUOoM gdoXZ hmoUo hmo`.
~H$bo`m {gmVmdarb Q>rH$m 1)
_wa-agobMr {Q>H$m -
^m{VH$ dVyMo ApVd `Vr`m OmUrdoda qH$dm gdoXZmda Adb~yZ AgVo. VgoM ^m{VH$
dVybm OmUrd {Zanoj dV ApVd ZgVo Ago ~H$bo n> H$aVmo. Amn`m "Esse est percipie' `m
{gmVmMo g_WZ H$aVmZm ~H$bo hUVmo H$s, ^m{VH$ dVyMr OmUrd Am{U ^m{VH$ dVy `m Xmohr EH$M
AgyZ ^m{VH$ dVy ApVdmV AgUm`mgmR>r `Vr`m OmUrdoMr JaO Amho. naVw _ya d agob `mZm ho
_m` Zmhr. _ya Am{U agob `mZr ^m{VH$ dVy`m ApVdm~b dmVddmXr ^y{_H$m drH$mabr Amho.
`m`m _Vo ^m{VH$ dVyZm OmUrd {Zanoj, dV d d`^y ApVd AgVo. VgoM OmUrd d OmUrdoV
òUmar ^m{VH$ dVy `m Xmohr Jmo>r {^Z AgyZ ^m{VH$ dVybm dV dmVd ApVd AgVo.
~H$bo`m {gmVmda Q>rH$m H$aVmZm _ya d agob Ago n> H$aVmV H$s, OmUrd hr _mZ{gH$ AdWm
AgyZ ^m{VH$ dVy `m OmUrdobm H$maU hmoV AgVmV. ^m{VH$ dVy _Zm~mhoa AgVmV. VgoM OmUrd hr
_mZ{gH$ {H$`m AgyZ ^m{VH$ ` hr ~m dVwpWVrV Agbobr Jmo> Amho. hUyZ _ya-agob `m`m_Vo
OmUrd d ^m{VH$ dVy `m Xmohr Jmo>r {^Z AmhoV ho _m` Ho$`m{edm` ^m{VH$ dVyMo kmZ hmoUo Ae`
Amho. CXm.aJ hr ^m{VH$ dVy dV ApVdmV AgyZ {VMr OmUrd Amn`m _ZmV Amho. hUyZ {ndim
aJhr _ZmV Amho Ago hUUo MwH$ Amho. OmUrdobm H$maU hmoUm`m ^m{VH$ dVybm OmUrd g_OyZ ~H$boZo
101
_moR>r MyH$ Ho$br Amho ho _ya-agob hUVmV. hUyZ "ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' hm ~H$boMm {gmV _wimVM
gXmof Amho.
2)
Zd- dmVddmmMr Q>rH$m -
Zd dmVddmmZr ~H$bo`m ApVd hUOo gdoXZ `m {gmVmVrb Imbrb_mUo Xmof XmI{dbo

AmhoV1) Am_H|$rV {ZH$f H$mT>`mMm Xmof- `m~m~V Zd dmVddmXr {dMmadV Ago n> H$aVmV H$s,
Amn`m ^modVmbr AZV nXmW AgVmV. "_r' `m dVy AJa KQ>Zm nmhVmo `m gdm`m H|$WmZr "_r'
(Self / Ego) AgVmoM. Oohm Oohm "_r' H$mhrVar nmhVmo qH$dm AZw^{dVmo Vohm Vohm `m`m H|$WmZr "_r'
gXd AgVmoM, {H$~hZm OmUUmam "_r' Oa Ho$WmZr Zgbmo Va hmoUmao kmZ _mPo dV:Mo AgUma Zmhr.
`m_wio _mUgmbm Ago dmQ>Vo H$s, _m`m OmUrdodaM (kmZmdaM) nXmWmMo ApVd Adb~yZ Amho. `mbmM
Am_H|$rV {ZH$f H$mT>`mMm Xmof hUVmV. ~H$bo`m {gmVmV hm Xmof {XgyZ òVmo.
2) {deofrH$aUmMm Xmof- ~H$bo Amn`m {gmVmV nXmWmZm gHw${MV d$n XoVmo. OJmV EImXm
nXmW EH$ jomer g~YrV AgVmZm Vmo BVa jomer gwm g~{YV AgVmo hr dVwpWVr ~H$bo {dgaVmo.
hUOoM ^m{VH$ nXmW Amn`m OmUrdoer g~{YV AgVmZm BVa jomerhr nXmWmMm g~Y AgVmo ho _m`
Ho$bo nm{hOo. naVw ~H$bo Ago Z H$aVm nXmWmg dV:`m OmUrdoer g~{YV H$$Z `mMo d$n gHw${MV
H$aVmo, Am{U OmUUm`m qH$dm nmhUm`m `VrdaM ^m{VH$ nXmWmMo ApVd Adb~yZ AgVo Agm
{ZH$f H$mT>Vmo. `m_wio gdoXZ hmoUo hUOoM nXmW (dVy) Agm {deofrH$aUmMm VH$Xmof òWo {Z_mU hmoVmo.
3) ^m{VH$ dVy`m ma{^H$ gdoXZmbmM `mòV Ko`mMm Xmof ~H$bo`m ^y{_Ho$V {XgyZ òVmo.
10.2.4 A^m{VH$dmX
(Immaterialism)
~H$bo hm bmH$_mUoM AZw^ddmXr Vdk Amho. nU bmH$Zo ^m{VH$ `mMo dV ApVd _m`
Ho$bo Va ~H$bo `mZo ^m{VH$ `m`m dV OmUrd{Zanoj ApVdmMr e`Vm ZmH$mabr. hUyyZ Vmo
A^m{VH$dmXr _mZbm OmVmo. ~H$bo`m _Vo OJmV \$V XmoZ H$ma`m dVy ApVdmV AmhoV `m hUOo
- gdoXZm`m AZw^d KoUmam Am_m Am{U gdoXZm`m {df` hmoUm`m H$nZm. Am_m (Soul) Am{U H$nZm
(Ideas) `m{edm` OJmV H$mhrhr ApVdmV ZgVo. `mH$mao ~H$bo ^m{VH$ `m`m ApVdmMr e`Vm
ZmH$maVmo. bmH$`m ^y{_Ho$g {damoY H$$Z `mZo Amnbm A^m{VH$dmXmMm {gmV _mS>bm Amho.
bmH$`m _Vo ^m{VH$ `m`m {R>H$mUr mW{_H$ d Xw`_ JwU AgyZ `mZo mW{_H$ d Xw`_
JwUmVrb \$aH$ nQ> Ho$bm Amho. bmH$`m _Vo Xw`_ JwUmMo kmZ _Zmda Adb~yZ AgVo, Va mW{_H$ JwU
AkmV ^m{VH$ `mV AgVmV H$s, Oo ^m{VH$ ` _Zm~mhoa AgVo. hUOoM mW{_H$ JwUmZm YmaU
H$aUmao ho AkmV ` H$s Oo _Zm~mhoa ApVdmV AgVo `mg bmH$Zo ^m{VH$ ` (Matter) Ago hQ>bo
Amho. `m`m _Vo Xw`_ d mW{_H$ JwU ho dmdb~r d d`nyU ZgVmV. `mZm YmaU H$a`mgmR>r EImXr
AmYma^y_r qH$dm A{Y>mZ bmJVo. hUyZ `m JwUmZm YmaU H$aUmao ` hUOo ^m{VH$ ` hmo`.
AemH$mao bmH$Zo ^m{VH$ `mMo dV ApVd _m` Ho$bo Amho. `mCbQ> ~H$bo `mZo ^m{VH$ `mMo
dV ApVd ZmH$mabo Amho.
^m{VH$ `m{damoYrMo ~H$boMo `wVrdmX ^m{VH$ `m`m dV ApVdmMo IS>U H$a`mgmR>r ~H$bo Imbrb_mUo `wVrdmX H$aVmo
102
1)
^m{VH$ `mMo mW{_H$ JwUhr `{${Z> AgVmV-
bmH$Zo {VnmXZ Ho$bobr mW{_H$ Am{U Xw`_ JwUmVrb ôXmMr _r_mgm ~H$bo _m` H$aVmo. bmH$`m
_Vo mW{_H$ JwU An[adVZr` AgyZ Vo `Vr{Zanoj AgVmV, Va Xw`_ JwU n[adVZr` AgyZ Vo
`Vrgmnoj AgVmV. ~H$bo`m _Vo ^m{VH$ `m`m Xw`_ JwUm_mUoM mW{_H$ JwUgwm `{${Z>
AgVmV. H$maU ^m{VH$ `mMr `mnH$Vm, JVr Am{U AdH$me `m mW{_H$ JwUmMo kmZ `Vr{edm`
qH$dm OmUUm`m _Zm{edm` hmoD$ eH$V Zmhr.
2)
AkmV ^m{VH$ ` JwUmMm AmYma Agy eH$V Zmhr -
bmH$`m _Vo JwUmZm AmYma qH$dm A{Y>mZ hUyZ ^m{VH$ ` _m` H$amdo bmJVo. nU ^m{VH$ `
ho AkmV d Ako` AgVo. nU ~H$bog bmH$Mo ho _V _m` Zmhr. ~H$bo`m _Vo, JwUmZm AmYma XoUmao ^m{VH$
` ho `Vr`m kmZmMmM ^mJ AgyZ Vo AkmV Amho Ago hUUo MyH$ Amho. hUyZ ^m{VH$ ` Am{U
`m`m JwUmMo kmZ `Vr`m _Zmda Adb~yZ AgVo. _Zm{edm` qH$dm _Z{Zanoj Ago ^m{VH$ `
JwUmMm AmYma AgyM eH$V Zmhr.
3) bmH$Zo ^m{VH$ ` {H$`mhrZ AgVo Ago hQ>bo Amho. naVw ~H$bo Agm `wVrdmX H$aVmo H$s,
{H$`mhrZ ^m{VH$ ` Amn`m _ZmV H$nZm {Z_mU H$$ eH$V Zmhr. Am{U Oa Vo `Vr`m _ZmV
H$nZm {Z_mU H$a`mg Ag_W Agob Va Vo ApVdmV Amho `mbm nwamdm H$moUVm ? {H$`merb _ZM
H$nZm {Z_mU H$$ eH$Vo, {H$`mhrZ ^m{VH$ `m`m ghm`mZo H$nZm {Z_mU hmoV ZmhrV Ago ~H$bo
_mZVmo. hUyZM _Zm{edm` ^m{VH$ ` ApVdmV AgV Zmhr.
4) ~H$bo`m _Vo AkmV ^m{VH$ `mMr H$nZm Ag` AgyZ Vr H$nmobH$pnV Amho. bmH$ hUVmo
`m_mUo ^m{VH$ ` AkmV ZgVo. `mMm AW ^m{VH$ ` AZw^dmg òV Zmhr, Vo AZw^d n{bH$S>o Amho
Agm hmoVmo. ~H$bo`m _Vo `mMo Amn`m kmZ|{`mZm doXZ hmoV Zmhr, Oo Amn`m AZw^dmg òD$ eH$V
Zmhr `mMo _bm kmZ H$go hmoD$ eHo$b ? hUyZM Oo AZw^dmg òD$ eH$V Zmhr Ago AkmV ^m{VH$ `
Ag` AgyZ _Zm{edm` ^m{VH$ `mMr H$nZmM H$aVm òUma Zmhr. AemH$mao OmUrd {ZanojnUo hUOo
OmUUm`m `Vr`m OmUrdo~mhoa ^m{VH$ ` dVnUo ApVdmV AgyM eH$V Zmhr.
~H$bo`m darb `wVrdmXmd$Z Ago n> hmoVo H$s, Xw`_ JwUm_mUo mW{_H$ JwU gwm `Vr`m
_Zmda Adb~yZ AgVmV Am{U ho JwU YmaU H$aUmar ^m{VH$ dVyhr _Zmda Adb~yZ AgVo. hUOo bmH$
hUVmo `m_mUo ^m{VH$ dVy _Z{Zanoj ZgyZ Vr _Zgmnoj - `Vrgmnoj AgVo. H$moUVrhr H$nZm
_Zm{edm` ApVdmV Agy eH$V Zmhr. OJmV ^m{VH$ dVy AgVmV `mMm AW `m Hw$Um`m Var AZw^dmMm
{df` AgVmV. `mMm Hw$Umbmhr AZw^d òV Zmhr Aer OmUrd {Zanoj AkmV ^m{VH$ dVy ApVdmV
AgUo e` Zmhr Ago ~H$boMo {VnmXZ Amho.
`md$Z ^m{VH$ dVy ApVdmV Amho `mMm AW Vr gdoXZr` Amho Agm hmoVmo. hUyZ "ApVdmV
AgUo hUOo gdoXZr` AgUo' Agm {gmV ~H$bo _mS>Vmo. "Oo Oo gdoXZr` Amho Vo Vo ApVdmV Amho'
(Existence is perception), `mMo gdoXZ hmoV Zmhr Ago H$mhrhr ApVdmV Agy eH$V Zmhr. OmUrdo{edm`
dV d d`^y Ago ^m{VH$ ` ApVdmV Agy eH$V Zmhr Ago ~H$bo n> H$aVmo.
10.2.5 ~H$bo`m VdkmZmVrb BdamMo WmZ
(Place of God) -
~H$bo Amn`m VdkmZmV OS>`mMo dV ApVd ZmH$maVmo. VgoM ^m{VH$dmX d {ZardadmX

103
ZmH$maVmo Am{U `{${Z> qH$dm AZw^d{Z> {MXdmXmMr _mS>Ur H$aVmo. OS> `m`m d ^m{VH$ OJm`m
ApVdmMm {dMma H$arV AgVm ~H$bo BdamMr H$nZm _m` H$aVmo. ~H$bo`m {gmVm_mUo dVyMo
ApVd Oa Amn`m gdoXZmda Adb~yZ Agob Va AmnU S>moio {_Q>`mda gd OJ {XgoZmgo hmoD$Z
Zmhrgo hmoVo H$m` ? dVy _bm {XgV ZmhrV hUyZ `m ApVdmV ZmhrV Ago hUVm òBb H$m` ? ~H$bo
hUVmo H$s, amr _r Pmon`mda _mPo Ka, AJUmVrb PmS>o, KamVrb dVy, g_moaMm S>m|Ja d ZXr hoo gd
_bm {XgoZmgo hmoVmV. `mMm AW `mMo ApVd Zmhrgo hmoVo H$s H$m` ? nwhm gH$mir Oohm _r S>moio CKSy>Z
nmhVmoo Va `m gd dVy hmo`m Vem Am{U VoWoM AgVmV. hUOo `m dVy {Z`nUo AgVmVM. ~H$bo`m
_Vo _r Pmonr Jo`mda `m dVy {XgoZmem Pm`m Var `mMo gdoXZ BVa OmU`m `Vr`m _Zmbm hmoV
AgVo Am{U gd EH$mMdoir Pmonbr Var `m Bdam`m _Zmbm {XgV AgVmV. Bda gXd OmJV
Ag`mZo d `mMo ApVd {Z` d emdV Ag`mZo OJm`m ApVdmMr Bdam_wio h_r {_iVo.
Aem [aVrZo ~H$bo Amn`m VdkmZmV EH$ H$mao BdamMr `moOZm H$aVmo. Oohm dVyMo _bm gdoXZ
hmoV Zmhr qH$dm BVa H$moUmbmM gdoXZ hmoV Zmhr Aemdoir Vr dVy ApVdmV Zmhr Ago hUVm òV Zmhr.
H$maU Aem dVyMo gdoXZ _m`m{edm` qH$dm BVa _mZdr _Zm{edm` Bdambm hmoV AgVo Ago ~H$bo
hUVmo. `m`m _Vo Oohm EImm dVyMo _bm/BVamZm gdoXZ hmoV Zmhr, Vohm Vo Bdar _Zmbm hmoV
Agbo nm{hOo. hUyZ Bda ApVdmV Agbm nm{hOo. H$maU A{Ib {ddmVrb dVy_mmMm H$Vm, gdk,
gdeVr_mZ Agm Bda AgyZ `mbm gd dVw_mm`m ApVdmMo kmZ hmoV AgVo Ago ~H$bo hUVmo.
`m`m_Vo `m gnyU OJmMm d {ddmMm >m, gdoXH$ Bda AgVmo.
~H$bo`m _Vo AmnUmg `mMo gdoXZ hmoVo Aem dVy hUOo Bdam`m gdoXZmVrb {MaVZ
H$nZm`m {VH$Vr hmoV. Oohm AmnUmg gdoXZ hmoV Zmhr Vohm `m gd dVyZm Bdam`m _ZmVrb
H$nZm hUyZ ApVd AgVoM. Bda hUOo gd dVw_mmMo _yi H$maU AgyZ `m`m {R>H$mUr gd
dVyZm ApVd AgVoM. AemH$mao "ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' `m Amn`m _wI {gmVmMm BdamMo
ApVd {g H$a`mgmR>r EH$ `w{$dmX hUyZ ~H$bo Cn`moJ H$aVmo. `m`m_Vo H$moU`mhr dVyMo ApVd
gdoXZ qH$dm OmUrdo{edm` Agy eH$V Zmhr d A{V_V: `m dVyMo ApVd gdk Aem Bdam`m _ZmV
AgVo.
~H$bo`m _Vo Bda hUOo EH$_odm{Vr` gdk, gd`mnr Ago {MXVd AgyZ òH$ dVyMo
ApVd Bdamda Adb~yZ AgVo. Bda hUOo gdmV n[anyU Ago ApVd, ew {H$`merbVm Am{U
dmgZm {da{hV d ew ~wrMr AdWm hmo`. Bda hm na_m_m Ag`mZo Vmo gd {Z{_VrMo _yi AgVmo.
Bda {Z`, gZmVZ, gd dVyMm {Z_mVm d YmaUH$Vm AgVmo. ~H$bo`m _Vo Agm Bda hUOo EH$_od
A_`mX gX^md`wV, kmZr d n[anyU AgVmo.
AemH$mao "ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' hm Amnbm _yi {gmV A~m{YV d H$m`_ R>odyZ `mVrb
AS>MUr Q>mi`mgmR>r ~H$bo Amn`m VdkmZmV BdamMr `moOZm H$aVmo. dVw_mmMo qH$dm OJmMo ApVd
{dMmamV KoV AgVmZm Vmo Bdar gdoXZmMm {dMma H$aVmo. `m`m_Vo gnyU OJmMo ApVd ho Bdam`m
gd `mnH$, {Z`, emdV, {Z`{_V d gw`dpWV Aem gdoXZmda Adb~yZ AgVo. `md$Z ~H$boMo
VdkmZ _mZdH|$r Z amhVm BdaHo$r ~Zbo Amho.
Aem BdamZo kmZ AmnUmg H$go hmoVo `m~m~V ~H$bo Ago nQ> H$aVmo H$s, Bdam`m ApVdmMo
AmnUmg gdoXZ hmoV Zmhr. Vmo Amn`m OmUrdo`m H$joV òV Zmhr. Bdam{df`r _`m{XV _mZdm`m _ZmV
H$nZm {Z_mU hmoD$ eH$V Zmhr. Va {dd`mnH$ MV` qH$dm gdk Aem Bdam{df`r AmnU n[anyU
104
H$nZm (Notion) H$$ eH$Vmo. Amn`m ~wrg BdamMo AmH$bZ hmoV Zmhr. hUyZ ~H$bo`m _Vo Bda
hUOo EH$ H$maMo A`mp_H$ ` (Spiritual Substance) hmo`.
10.2.6 d`-A``ZmgmR>r Z :1)
Imbrb {dYmZo MyH$ H$s ~amo~a Vo gmJm.

1)
~H$bo hm bmH$Mm AZw`m`r hmoVm.
2)
~H$boZo A_yV H$nZmMo ApVd _m` Ho$bo Amho.
3)
A_yV H$nZm hUOoM gm_m` H$nZm hmoV.
4)
A_yV H$nZm hUOo Ho$di EH$ eX hmo`.
5)
OS>`mg dV ApVd AgVo Ago ~H$boMo _V Amho.
6)
~H$bo `mZo A^m{VH$dmXmMo g_WZ Ho$bo Amho.
7)
~H$bo BdamMo ApVd ZmH$maVmo.
8)
~H$bo hm `{${Z> {MXdmXr hmo`.
9)
Bdam`m ApVdmMo AmnUmg gdoXZ hmoVo Ago ~H$bo hUVmo.
10) Bda hUOo A`mp_H$ ` hmo`.

2)
[aH$m`m OmJr `mo` n`m` {ZdSy>Z Imbrb {dYmZo nyU H$am.

1)
--------- `m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmda ~H$bo `mZo Q>rH$m Ho$br Amho.

A) XoH$mV
2)
H$) Cn`wV
~) ~H$bo
H$) y_
~) {MXdmX
H$) `{${Z> {MXdmX
~H$bo`m _Vo OS> `mbm OmUrd {Zanoj d dV ApVd --------A) AgVo
7)
~) Ae`
~H$bo`m VdkmZmbm --------- Ago hQ>bo OmVo.

A) OS>dmX
6)
H$) O_OmV
"ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' hm {gmV --------- `mZr _mS>bm Amho.

A) bmH$
5)
~) {d{eQ>
AgdoXZr` d AkmV `mMr H$nZm --------- AgVo.

A) e`
4)
H$) bmH$
~H$bo`m _Vo --------- H$nZm aM`mMr j_Vm _Zm_ò ZgVo.

A) A_yV
3)
~) y_
~) ZgVo
H$) gmJVm òV Zmhr
~H$bo`m _Vo --------- hUOo A`mp_H$ ` hmo`.

A) ^m{VH$ OJ
~) Bda
105
H$) Am_m
10.3 nm[a^m{fH$ eX, eXmW, B`mXr :AZw^d{Z> {MXdmX
Empirical Idealism
A_yV H$nZm
Abstract Ideas
^m{VH$ `
Matter
A^m{VH$dmX
Immaterialism
{MXdmX
Idealism
`{${Z> {MXdmX
Subjective Idealism
10.4 d`-A``Z ZmMr Cmao :1)
2)
1) MyH$
2) ~amo~a
3) MyH$
4) ~amo~a
5) MyH$
6) ~amo~a
7) MyH$
8) ~amo~a
9) MyyH$
10) ~amo~a
1) H$) bmH$
2) A) A_yV
3) ~) Ae`
4) ~) ~H$bo
5) H$) `{${Z> {MXdmX
6) A) AgVo
7) ~) Bda
10.5 gmame :bmH$ Am{U ~H$bo `m`m VdkmZmV ~aoM gm` AgyZ ~H$boZo bmH$Mr AZw^ddmXr kmZ_r_mgm
_m` Ho$br Amho. VWm{n bmH$`m A_yV H$nZm {gmVmMo `mZo IS>U Ho$bo Amho. `m`m _Vo A_yV
H$nZm aM`mMr j_Vm _Zm_ò ZgVo. A_yV H$nZm hUOo Ho$di "eX' AgVmV. dmVdmV `m
H$mhrhr ZgVmV.~H$bo`m VdkmZmVrb _`dVu {gmV "ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' hm AgyZ `mZwgma
dVyMo ApVdmV AgUo hUOo {VMo gdoXZ hmoUo hmo`.~H$boZo ^m{VH$ `m`m OmUrd {Zanoj d dV
ApVdmMo IS>U H$$Z A^m{VH$dmXmMm drH$ma Ho$bm Amho. `mgmR>r `mZo `wVrdmX Ho$bo AmhoV.~H$bo`m
VdkmZmVrb BdamMo WmZ _hdnyU AgyZ `mZo "ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' `m {gmVmg AZwg$ZM
BdamMo ApVd _m` Ho$bo Amho. `m`m _Vo Bda hUOo EH$_odm{Vr` gdk, gd`mnr d {Z`
d$nmMo {MXVd AgyZ Vmo gd {Z{_VrMo _yi d n[anyU ApVd hmo`. ~H$bo`m AZw^ddmXmg `{${Z>
{MXdmX Ago hQ>bo OmVo.
bmH$ d ~H$bo `m`mVrb g~Y n> H$am.
2)
~H$boZo A_yV H$nZmMo IS>U H$go Ho$bo Amho Vo nQ> H$am.
3)
"ApVd hUOo gdoXZ' `m ~H$bo`m {gmVmMo g{dVa n>rH$aU H$am.
4)
OS> `m`m dV ApVdmg~Yr ~H$boZo Ho$bobr Q>rH$m n> H$am.
5)
~H$bo`m VdkmZmVrb BdamMo WmZ d d$n n> H$am.

106
6)
Q>rnm {bhm :A) bmH$ - ~H$bo g~Y

~) A^m{VH$dmX
H$) BdamMo WmZ
10.7 A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$ :Q>rn : nwVH$m`m eodQ>r `mXr {Xbr Amho.
666
gX^ JW
1. lr. h. Xr{jV : ^maVr` VdkmZ
2.
Ho$VH$a ^m. J. (AZwdmX) : ^maVr` VdkmZmMr $naofm (nwUo {dmnrR>)
3. nr. S>r. MmYar : ^maVr` VdkmZmMm B{Vhmg
A{YH$ dmMZmgmR>r nwVHo$

1.
M. Hirryanna : Outlines of Indian Philosophy (Allen and Unwin)
2.
S.Radhakrishnan : Indian Philosophy Vols. I and II
3. OmoJ d. dm. : ^maVr` XeZ gJh

4.
F. Copleston : A History of Philosophy
5.
D.J.O'Connor : A critical History of western philosophy
6. J. Zm. Omoer : nmMm` VdkmZmMm B{Vhmg IS> 1 d 2

7.
Datta and Chatterjee : Introduction to Indian Philosophy
8.
Stace, Wright : A critical History of Greek Philosophy
9.
W. K. Wright : A History of modern Philosophy
10. {d. `. XoenmS>o : AdmMrZ nmMm` VdkmZ ^mJ 1 d 2

11. Xo. X. dmS>oH$a : _amR>r VdkmZ _hmH$moe IS> 1 Vo 3
12. J. {d. Vwinwio : JrH$ VdkmZ
13. J. Zm. Omoer : ^maVr` VdkmZmMm ~hX B{Vhmg
666
107

B. A. Part-I Outlines of Philosophy Marathi Version PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

B. A. Part-I Outlines of Philosophy Marathi Version PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

B. A. Part-I Outlines of Philosophy Marathi Version PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

"VdkmZmMr naofm'

~r. E. ^mJ-1 : VdkmZ

oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya

Hw$bg{Md, {edmOr {dmnrR>, H$mohmnya (_hmamQ>)

Xya oejU H|$, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya

_m. m. (S>m.) E_. E_. gmiwI>{ ,

S>m. amO| X. H$mH$na`m

lr. ]r. Eg. [mQ>rc

gMmcH$, _hmodmc`rZ odH$mg _S>i,

odm d c{Im AoYH$mar,

lr. E. gr. [m{dma

m. (S>m.) Cm_amd ^m{BQ>{

cmc ]hma emr _mJ, ^maVr` odm[rR>, [wU{.

S>m. E. EZ. Om{er

S>m. ]r. [r. gm]i{,

gMmcH$, oejUem odmemIm,

"AWdgmX' Q>r-3, 32/11, Vmam]mB [mH$, H$m{hm[ya.

S>m. (lr_Vr) dmgVr amg_

lr. O{. Ama. OmYd

AoYR>mVm, gm_moOH$ em{, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.

AoYR>mVm, H$cm odmemIm, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.

S>m. H{$. EZ. gmJi{

S>m. Q>r. ]r. OJVm[

m. (S>m.) hr. Eg. [mQ>rc,

m. S>m. (lr_Vr) gr_m `{dc{ (gX` goMd)

AoYR>mVm, dmoU` odmemIm, oedmOr odm[rR>>, H$m{hm[ya.

AoYR>mVm, odkmZ odmemIm, oedmOr odm[rR>, H$m{hm[ya.

m. (S>m.) Eg. E. ]mar,

A`j - lr. ZmJa{ H$Uamd ]S>m{]m

lr. o[Q>H{$ gwYra _mYd

_wYm{Or H$mc{O, \$cQ>U, oO. gmVmam.

VdkmZ AoYod^mJ, [wU{ odm[rR>, [wU{.

lr. dmK_m{S>{ amOmam_ gm{Zm

]idV H$mc{O odQ>m, Vm. ImZm[ya, oO. gmJcr.

S>m. Jm{Ic{ [r. [r.

lr. aKwZmW gmXmJa ohad{

Xya oejU H|$

A`mg KQ>H$mMo boIH$

lr. ZmJao H$Uamd ~S>mo~m

lr. {nQ>Ho$ gwYra _mYd

lr. \$aVmao Ama. hr.

lr. dmK_moS>o amOmam_ gmoZm

lr. {hado Ama. Eg.

m. Ho$. ~r. ZmJao, H$amS>

m. Ama. Eg. {hado

m. Eg. E_. {nQ>Ho$, g_d`H$

^maVr` VdkmZmMo d$n

`{H$ KQ>H$mMr gwdmV CoQ>mZ r hm{Bc

VdkmZ hUOo H$m`?

^maVr` XeZmMo dJuH$aU

^maVr` VdkmZmMr g_mZ d{e>o

VdkmZ ho emmMo em Amho. (Philosophy as Science of all Sciences.)

VdkmZ hUOo kmZm~Xc kmZcmcgm, AmnwcH$s ~miJUo, kmZmda o_ H$aUo hmo`.(Philosophy

VdkmZ hUOo gd H$mhr Amho Am{U / gd H$mhr Zmhr.(Philosophy as evertyhing / or Nothing)

5) nyd_r_mgm 6) Cma _r_mgm (doXmV)

`mVrc AV doXmV `m d{XH$ XeZmMm Am{U

doX ho Mma H$maMo AmhoV. 1) F$doX

{dm_mJrc A{V_ `o {H$Vr d H$moUVr AmhoV?

lw{VMo m_m` _mZmdo H$m`?