WLAN - 802.11 A, B, G and N: Wireless Standards White Paper Series
WLAN - 802.11 A, B, G and N: Wireless Standards White Paper Series
WLAN - 802.11 A, B, G and N: Wireless Standards White Paper Series
11 a,b,g and n
Publish Date: Sep 23, 2015
Overview
This paper compares the different Wi-Fi standards that exist today. Some of the advantages and disadvantages of each standard,
and the technical specifications are discussed in the paper below.
Table of Contents
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
802.11: In 1997, the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) created the first WLAN standard. They called it 802.11
after the name of the group formed to oversee its development. Unfortunately, 802.11 only supported a maximum network
bandwidth of 2 Mbps - too slow for most applications. For this reason, ordinary 802.11 wireless products are no longer
manufactured. The figure below shows the packet structure for the 802.11 standard.
www.ni.com
point. Although there may be two or more antennas, there is only one set of components to process the signal, or RF chain. The
receiver has a single input chain, and the transmitter has a single output chain.
2. Applications
A Wi-Fi-enabled device such as a PC, game console, cell phone, MP3 player or PDA can connect to the Internet when within
range of a wireless network connected to the Internet. The coverage of one or more interconnected access points called a
hotspot can comprise an area as small as a single room with wireless-opaque walls or as large as many square miles covered
by overlapping access points. Organizations and businesses such as airports, hotels and restaurants often provide free hotspots
to attract or assist clients. Enthusiasts or authorities who wish to provide services or even to promote business in a given area
sometimes provide free Wi-Fi access. Metropolitan-wide Wi-Fi (Muni-Fi) already has more than 300 projects in process. Wi-Fi
also allows connectivity in peer-to-peer (wireless ad-hoc network) mode, which enables devices to connect directly with each
other. This connectivity mode can prove useful in consumer electronics and gaming applications. Many consumer devices use
Wi-Fi. Amongst others, personal computers can network to each other and connect to the Internet, mobile computers can connect
to the Internet from any Wi-Fi hotspot, and digital cameras can transfer images wirelessly.
Routers which incorporate a DSL-modem or a cable-modem and a Wi-Fi access point, often set up in homes and other premises,
provide Internet-access and inter-networking to all devices connected (wirelessly or by cable) to them. One can also connect Wi-Fi
devices in ad-hoc mode for client-to-client connections without a router. WLAN is also increasingly being used in Internet
telephony, music, streaming, gaming, and even photo viewing and in-home video transmission. Personal video recorders and
other A/V storage appliances that collect content in one spot for enjoyment around the home are accelerating this trend.
3. Technical Specifications
The OSI layer consists of 7 different layers. This application layer interfaces directly to and performs application services for the
application processes; it also issues requests to the presentation layer. The presentation layer establishes a context between
application layer entities, in which the higher-layer entities can use different syntax and semantics, as long as the Presentation
Service understands both and the mapping between them. The session layer controls the dialogues/connections (sessions)
between computers. The transport layer provides transport of data between the end clients. This layer provides reliable data
transfer to the upper layers. The network layer provides the functional and procedural means of transferring variable length data
sequences from a source to a destination. This layer also maintains the quality of service requested by the Transport layer. The
data link layer provides the functional and procedural means to transfer data between network entities and to detect and correct
errors that may occur in the physical layer.
2/10
www.ni.com
Data Rate
1101
6Mbps
1111
9Mbps
0101
12Mbps
0111
18Mbps
1001
24Mbps
1011
36Mbps
0001
48Mbps
0011
54Mbps
www.ni.com
PSDU. The PSDU, which stands for Physical Layer Service Data Unit, represents the contents of the PPDU (i.e., the actual
802.11 frame being sent).
Tail. This field consists of six bits (all zeros) for receiver processing functions.
Pad Bits. This field contains a number of bits in order to modify the frame size to equal a specific multiple of bits coded in an
OFDM symbol.
Channel Number
Transmit Frequency
40
5.200 GHz
40mW
36
5.180 GHz
44
5.220 GHz
48
5.240 GHz
52
5.260 GHz
56
5.280 GHz
60
5.300 GHz
64
5.320 GHz
149
5.745 GHz
153
5.765 GHz
157
5.785 GHz
161
5.805 GHz
200mW
800mW
OFDM is becoming very popular for high-speed transmission. In addition to being selected for use within the 802.11g PHY Layer,
OFDM is the basis for the European-based HiperLAN/2 wireless LAN standards. In fact the 802.11a PHY Layer is very similar to
the HiperLAN/2 PHY. In addition, OFDM has also been around for a while supporting the global standard for asymmetric digital
subscriber line (ADSL).
802.11b
The CCK modulation is based on the use of the poly-phase complementary codes. The codes posses nearly orthogonal (close to
zero auto-correlation if shift is not 0) properties. The poly-phase complementary codes are not binary, they are complex codes.
The picture below shows a poly-phase code with its real component placed in the vertical plane and the complex component in the
horizontal plane. Assuming the data transmission rate is set to 11Mbps, the CCK modulator is fed by bytes of data at the rate of
1.375MBytes/sec. The modulator uses 6 bits of each byte to pick one of 64 unique orthogonal eight chips long poly-phase
complementary codes (like the one on the picture). The other two bits of the byte are used to rotate the whole code word (0, 90,
180 or 270 degrees). Finally, 11 million times per second, the real and complex parts of the resulted code go to the I (in-phase)
and Q (quadrature) channels of the IQ modulator. The resulted symbol rate is 11Mbps, the bandwidth occupied by the channel is
22MHz and consequently the CCK modulation may coexist with original 802.11 DSSS.
4/10
www.ni.com
The 802.11g standard includes mandatory and optional components. It uses OFDM, (from 802.11a) and CCK (from 802.11b as
the mandatory modulation schemes with 24 Mbps as the maximum mandatory data rate. It also provides for optional higher data
rates of 36, 48 and 54 Mbps.
The 802.11g standard defines several rate extensions, as part of the Extended Rate PHY (ERP) specification, to the PHY for the
Direct Sequence Spread Spectrum (DSSS) implementation. The 802.11g PHY specification includes four sets of modulation
schemes ERPDSSS/CCK (Mandatory), ERPOFDM (Mandatory), ERPPBCC (Optional) and DSSSOFDM (Optional. The initial
802.11 standard (IEEE Std. 802.111999) defines a long preamble PLCP framing and later in standard (IEEE Std. 802.11b, 1999)
a short (optional) preamble for the PPDU w as defined; however in the 802.1 1g standard the short preamble PPDU capability has
been defined as mandatory.
5/10
www.ni.com
The emerging 802.11n specification differs from its predecessors in that it provides for a variety of optional modes and
configurations that dictate different maximum raw data rates. This enables the standard to provide baseline performance
parameters for all 802.11n devices, while allowing manufacturers to enhance or tune capabilities to accommodate different
applications and price points. With every possible option enabled, 802.11n could offer raw data rates up to 600 Mbps. But WLAN
hardware does not need to support every option to be compliant with the standard. In 2006, for example, most draft-n WLAN
hardware available is expected to support raw data rates up to 300 Mbps. In comparison, every 802.11b-compliant product must
support data rates up to 11 Mbps, and all 802.11a and 802.11g hardware must support data rates up to 54 Mbps.
In the 802.11n draft, the first requirement is to support an OFDM implementation that improves upon the one employed in the
802.11a/g standards, using a higher maximum code rate and slightly wider bandwidth. This change improves the highest
attainable raw data rate to 65 Mbps from 54 Mbps in the existing standards.
Up until 2004, 802.11 interfaces had a single antenna. To be sure, some interfaces had two antennas in a diversity configuration,
6/10
www.ni.com
Up until 2004, 802.11 interfaces had a single antenna. To be sure, some interfaces had two antennas in a diversity configuration,
but the basis of diversity is that the best antenna is selected. In diversity configurations, only a single antenna is used at any
point. Although there may be two or more antennas, there is only one set of components to process the signal, or RF chain. The
receiver has a single input chain, and the transmitter has a single output chain.
The next step beyond diversity is to attach an RF chain to each antenna in the system. This is the basis of
Multiple-Input/Multiple-Output (MIMO) operation.* Each RF chain is capable of simultaneous reception or transmission, which can
dramatically improve throughput. Furthermore, simultaneous receiver processing has benefits in resolving multipath interference,
and may improve the quality of the received signal far beyond simple diversity. Each RF chain and its corresponding antenna are
responsible for transmitting a spatial stream. A single frame can be broken up and multiplexed across multiple spatial streams,
which are reassembled at the receiver.
PHY Layers
In the 802.11n system, based on the WLAN OFDM system, two new formats are defined for the PLCP (Physical Layer
Convergence Protocol): the Mixed Mode and the Green Field. These two formats are called HT (High Throughput) formats. In
addition to the HT formats, there is a legacy duplicate format that duplicates the 20 MHz legacy packet in two 20 MHz halves of a
40 MHz channel.
So, the 802.11n physical layer operates in one of 3 modes in the time domain: Legacy mode, Mixed Mode and Green Field Mode.
In legacy mode and HT mode, transmission is over a 20 MHz channel, and the channel is divided into 64 sub-carriers. Four pilot
signals are inserted in sub-carriers -21, -7, 7 and 21. In the legacy mode, signal is transmitted on sub-carriers -26 to -1 and 1 to
26, with 0 being the center (DC) carrier. In the HT modes, signal is transmitted on sub-carriers -28 to -1 and 1 to 28.
In the 40 MHz HT transmission, two adjacent 20 MHz channels are used. The channel is divided into 128 sub-carriers. 6 pilot
signals are inserted in sub-carriers -53, -25, -11, 11, 25, 53. Signal is transmitted on sub-carriers -58 to -2 and 2 to 58.
In the case of the legacy duplicate mode over 40 MHz, the same data are transmitted over two adjacent 20 MHz channels. In this
case the 40 MHz channel is divided into 128 sub-carriers and the data are transmitted on carriers -58 to -6 and 6 to 58.
Legacy Mode: In the legacy mode, frames are transmitted in the legacy 802.11a/g OFDM format.
Mixed Mode: In the Mixed Mode, packets are transmitted with a preamble compatible with the legacy 802.11a/g. The legacy Short
Training Sequence, the legacy Long Training sequence, and the legacy signal description are transmitted so they can be decoded
by legacy 802.11a/g devices. The rest of the packet has a new MIMO training sequence format. Figure 2 shows the Mixed Mode
format. Click the various parts of the figure for more details on each field.
Green Field Mode: In the Green Field mode, high throughput packets are transmitted without a legacy-compatible part. Figure 3
shows the Green Field format. Click the various parts of the figure for more details on each field.
www.ni.com
High Throughput Short Training Field (HT-STF) The purpose of the High Throughput Short Training Field is to improve AGC
(Automatic Gain Control) training in a multi-transmit and multi-receive system. The duration of the HT-STF is 4sec.
High Throughput Long Training Field (HT-LTF) The High Throughput Long Training field provides means for the receiver to
estimate the channel between each spatial mapping input (or spatial stream transmitter if no STBC is applied) and receive chain;
the number of training symbols is equal or greater than the number of space-time streams (with an exception in the case of 3
space-time streams).
The HT-LTF portion has one or two parts. The first part consists of from one to four HT long training fields (HT-LTFs) that are
necessary for demodulation of the HT-Data portion of the PPDU. These HT-LTFs are referred to as Data HT-LTFs. The optional
second part consists of from zero to four HT-LTFs that may be used to probe extra spatial dimensions of the MIMO channel that
are not utilized by the HT-Data portion of the PPDU. These HT-LTFs are referred to as Extension HT-LTFs. If a receiver has not
advertised its ability to receive Extension HT-LTFs, it may discard a frame including Extension HT-LTFs as an unknown frame
type.
Both the WWiSE and TGnSync proposals employ MIMO technology to boost the data rate, though their applications differ. MIMO
antenna configurations are often described with the shorthand YxZ, where Y and Z are integers, used to refer to the number of
transmitter antennas and the number of receiver antennas. For example, both WWiSE and TGnSync require 2x2 operations,
which has two transmit chains, two receive chains, and two spatial streams multiplexed across the radio link. Both proposals also
have additional required and optional modes. I expect that the common hardware configurations will have two RF chains on the
client side to save cost and battery power, while at least three RF chains will be used on most access points. This configuration
would use 2x3 MIMO for its uplink and 3x2 MIMO on the downlink.
www.ni.com
The SIGNAL-N field is used in all transmission modes. It has information to recover the bit stream from the data symbols. The
SIGNAL-N field is shown below.
802.11a operates at the fastest speed and supports more simultaneous users. The operating frequencies of 802.11 a are
regulated and this prevents interference from other devices.
OFDM has fundamental propagation advantages when in a high multipath environment, such as an indoor office, and the higher
frequencies enable the building of smaller antennas with higher RF system gain which counteract the disadvantage of a higher
band of operation. The increased number of usable channels (4 to 8 times as many in FCC countries) and the near absence of
other interfering systems, (microwave ovens, cordless phones, baby monitors) give 802.11a significant aggregate bandwidth and
reliability advantages over 802.11b/g.
Since the 2.4 GHz band is heavily used to the point of being crowded, using the 5 GHz band gives 802.11a a significant
advantage. However, this high carrier frequency also brings a slight disadvantage: The effective overall range of 802.11a is slightly
less than that of 802.11b/g; 802.11a signals cannot penetrate as far as those for 802.11b because they are absorbed more readily
by walls and other solid objects in their path.
802.11b
802.11b is the lowest cost amongst the standards and the signal range is the best. The signal is not easily obstructed either.
Some of the disadvantages are that is has the slowest maximum speed and supports fewer simultaneous users. The appliances
may also interfere on the unregulated frequency band.
Since the selection of the 802.11g draft standard technology, some observers have questioned the merits of continuing
development activity in the 2.4 GHz band. The reasoning has predominantly cited the increased crowding of this spectrum, versus
that of the relatively clearer 5.2 GHz spectrum utilized by802.11a. Certainly the past performance of already-installed 802.11b
networks provides evidence that the 2.4 GHz band is well suited to wireless networking and the 802.11b devices have continued
to provide excellent performance in the presence of increasing interference. In addition, the 2.4 GHz ISM band is available
throughout the world with relatively few, if any, regulatory restrictions. In contrast, the 5.2 GHz band is used by military applications
such as high-energy radar and, as a result, several major global markets, including Western Europe and Japan, have to date
placed regulatory restrictions on the commercial use of this band. Even in the United States there are questions concerning
security risks for military operations with 802.11aoperating in the 5.2 GHz band. Utilizing the 2.4 GHz band ensures that
802.11gWLANs will avoid the regulatory restrictions that are likely to been countered, while offering backwards compatibility with
9/10
www.ni.com
802.11gWLANs will avoid the regulatory restrictions that are likely to been countered, while offering backwards compatibility with
802.11b systems.
802.11g
802.11g has a fast maximum speed and support simultaneous users. The signal range is the best and is not easily obstructed
either.
Some of the disadvantages are that it costs more than 802.11b and some of the appliances may also interfere with the
unregulated signal frequency.
802.11n
One of the most widely known components of the draft specification is known as Multiple Input Multiple Output, or MIMO. MIMO
exploits a radio-wave phenomenon called multipath: transmitted information bounces off walls, doors, and other objects, reaching
the receiving antenna multiple times via different routes and at slightly different times. Uncontrolled, multipath distorts the original
signal, making it more difficult to decipher and degrading Wi-Fi performance. MIMO harnesses multipath with a technique known
as space-division multiplexing. The transmitting WLAN device actually splits a data stream into multiple parts, called spatial
streams, and transmits each spatial stream through separate antennas to corresponding antennas on the receiving end. The
current 802.11n draft provides for up to four spatial streams, even though compliant hardware is not required to support that
many. Doubling the number of spatial streams from one to two effectively doubles the raw data rate. There are trade-offs,
however, such as increased power consumption and, to a lesser extent, cost. The draft-n specification includes a MIMO
power-save mode, which mitigates power consumption by using multiple paths only when communication would benefit from the
additional performance. The MIMO powersave mode is a required feature in the draft-n specification.
Another optional mode in the 802.11n draft effectively doubles data rates by doubling the width of a WLAN communications
channel from 20 MHz to 40 MHz. The primary trade-off here is fewer channels available for other devices. In the case of the
2.4-GHz band, there is enough room for three non-overlapping 20-MHz channels. Needless to say, a 40-MHz channel does not
leave much room for other devices to join the network or transmit in the same airspace. This means intelligent, dynamic
management is critical to ensuring that the 40-MHz channel option improves overall WLAN performance by balancing the
high-bandwidth demands of some clients with the needs of other clients to remain connected to the network.
5. National Instruments Hardware
National Instruments provides products for both Vector Signal Analysis and Vector Signal Generation. Using the Modulation toolkit
different modulation techniques can be used to test and implement the various standards.
PXI-5661
PXIe-5672
10/10
www.ni.com