ch8 PDF
ch8 PDF
ch8 PDF
Hydrocarbon Petroleum
Tankage and Terminal
Design
This chapter summarizes but brings together the history and use as well as salient features of design, operation and maintenance of hydrocarbon liquids storage facilities.
Citations are provided in the list of reference to assist readers to source all documents
necessary for full comprehension of issues related to components making up such
systems. It is a reference chapter only on the subject matter and should not be used as
turnkey. Readers are encouraged to refer to and consult all standards listed herein.
407
Figure 8-1. Liquid hydrocarbon pipeline transportation storage and shipping facilities
Figure 8-3. Buncefield fire and explosion of Hertfordshire oil storage terminal [1, 2]
Figure 8-5. General view of hydrocarbon tankages system and tank farm
transportation with no backhaul, i.e., they are unidirectional with products that only
move in one direction through the line.
A tank farm includes many tankage systems and appurtenances (Figure 8-5). It is a
facility where various petroleum products are stored prior to being transported further,
shipped and disbursed to end consumers or retail facilities. They are also referred to
asoildepot.
Some tank farms are owned by a single company which uses the farm to meet
its needs, while others are administered by a group. It is also possible for facilities to
have their own tank farms for the purpose of storing fuel on site, with airports being
a classic example of a facility which needs to have a large quantity of fuel (mostly jet
fuel) on hand.
It is believed that the first permanent, professionally designed tank farm for storage hydrocarbon liquids was built at the turn of the century simultaneous with construction of major refineries.
Figure 8-4. D
iscovery of oil in Iran, Masjid Soleiman, 1908 (left photo [4]) and the Abadan
Oil Refinery, 2008 (right photo)
1910 Discovery of significant oil fields in Canada (in the province of Ontario)
1912 Completion of 1st largest Oil Refinery, Abadan, Iran
1914 1st record of Storage of Oil Fuel [5]
1916Establishment of National Tank Association (NSTA), now Steel Tank
Institute (STI), USA
191617 Formation of Underwriters Laboratories (UL)
1919 Formation of American Petroleum Institute (API)
1922First UL Standard UL142 Steel Above Ground Tanks for Flammable and
Combustible Liquids
1923 First floating-roof tank for the oil industry By CB&I
1942Destruction of oil tank farm by the bombing the US Army barracks at Fort
Mears, Amaknak Island in Unalaska Bay
1950 Construction of Milford Haven oil port
1951 Formation of Petroleum Equipment Institute (PEI)
1964 The Texaco oil refinery Milford Haven
1964Construction of 1st Largest Crude Oil Tank(160,000 BBLS, 109 m diameter, 18 m height), Kharg Island, Persian Gulf
1974 Construction of the largest Crude Oil Tank, Abu Zabi (182, 000 BBLS)
It is difficult to pin point the birth of hydrocarbon tankage and tank farms/depot
and early years of professional design tank farms for storage of hydrocarbons fuels
in large volumes. The only reference found is due to Lugoff and Camden [5], where
in a book published in 1914, titled Oil fuel for steam boilers, describe in a chapter
the Storage of Oil Fuel. There, they have a diagram of what they call a small or
medium size cylindrical steel tank. They also state that the common sizes of oil tanks.
However, search of literature indicates the birth date for large tankage systems to be in
the late 19th century.
Similar to liquid pipelines, storage tank systems have played an important role in
the transportation industry, particularly in the post-World War II era.
Early in the twentieth century, the oil companies operated the pipelines and storage facilities as integrated subsidiaries and often along with refineries. They also often
used them to control the oil industry.
Without storage facilities, pipelines are limited in the markets they can serve and
would be limited in the commodities they can haul. Pipelines are the only mode of
Figure 8-5. General view of hydrocarbon tankages system and tank farm
transportation with no backhaul, i.e., they are unidirectional with products that only
move in one direction through the line.
A tank farm includes many tankage systems and appurtenances (Figure 8-5). It is a
facility where various petroleum products are stored prior to being transported further,
shipped and disbursed to end consumers or retail facilities. They are also referred to
asoildepot.
Some tank farms are owned by a single company which uses the farm to meet
its needs, while others are administered by a group. It is also possible for facilities to
have their own tank farms for the purpose of storing fuel on site, with airports being
a classic example of a facility which needs to have a large quantity of fuel (mostly jet
fuel) on hand.
It is believed that the first permanent, professionally designed tank farm for storage hydrocarbon liquids was built at the turn of the century simultaneous with construction of major refineries.
Condensate (raw)
Propane (at 1000 kPa)
Heavy Crude
Medium Crude
Light Crude
Viscosity (CS)
Temperature (oC)
6.86
5.10
0.68
0.61
0.7
0.63
8
1.5
1.9
1.5
3
2.2
0.599
0.548
0.199
0.171
0.218
0.199
0.166
0.237
0.235
0.212
21.1
37.8
40
50
21.1
37.8
21.1
37.8
21.1
37.8
5
15
5
15
5
15
29
0
15
35
15
35
15
25
15
30
20
30
52
25
44
52
83
3.75
3.28
2.44
37
19
16.2
9.41
10.2
6.25
Density (kg/m3)*
847
820
711.3
699
690 (assumed)
774
708.8
688.8
572.3
547.5
500.6
483.5
446.9
560.8
535.12
529
For intermediate storage, (the storages that are for transferring and importing), the
following are typically applicable:
Crude charge: 1 to 2 days supply per crude grade plus one identical tank
Unit rundown: 1 to 4 days production capacity plus one identical tank per
group
Blending stock: 5 days storage at production (line blending) rates plus one
identical tank per group
Similarly, in the refined product storage, the following applies:
Pipeline shipment: for each product, frequency, rate, reliability
Truck and Rail: truck or tank car size, Time for loading, loading capacity
Marine Shipment: largest ship capacity and ship frequency, Number of ships
at one time
The storage of liquid hydrocarbons depends on the quantity and its physical
properties.
The physical properties include density/specific gravity and vapor pressure/boiling point; Their effects are described below:
Density and specific gravity: the density of the liquid is its mass per unit volume.
Water has a density of 1 gm/cm3 at 4C. The density of a liquid plays an important
role in the design of a tank because larger densities require thicker shells.
Specific gravity: another important physical property of the liquid stored. It is
a measure of the relative weight of one liquid compared to water. Specifically,
it is the ratio of the density of the liquid divided by the density of the water at
15.5C. For example, petroleum oil, kerosene, and gasoline have a specific
gravity of 0.82, 0.80, and 0.70, respectively. Care must be exercised if there is
a significant increase in the specific gravity of the new liquid because the effective hydrostatic pressure acting on the tank walls will be greater if the design
level is not reduced and could cause damage on the cylindrical shell.
Vapor pressure and boiling point: the vapor pressure of a pure hydrocarbon
liquid is the pressure of the vapor space above the liquid in a closed container,
and increases with increasing temperature. It is an important consideration in
order to select the type of tank and its roof and is crucial for the purpose of
characterizing fire hazardousness.
The boiling point: also important. It is necessary to know the temperatures at
which some liquids should be stored, always below its boiling point. For example, some flammable and combustible liquids are prohibited by the fire codes to
be stored at temperatures above their boiling point. A large number of tanks in
oil refineries or petrochemical industries, store flammable liquids.
8.4.2 Types
Types of tanks includes the following:
Atmospheric
Fixed roof, vertical and horizontal
Floating roof (external floating roof, domed external (or covered) floating
roof, internal floating roof)
Pressurized
Variable vapor space
High pressure
Low pressure
Heated Tanks (Hot fluids)
High viscosity Oil (bitumen, asphalt, etc.)
Refrigerated Tanks
Cryogenic
Refrigerated
The shape of the roof is an indicator of the type of a tank because it is selfe xplanatory to tank designer, fabricator and erector. The configuration of a vertical
aboveground tank design can be either an open top with the roof floating on the stored
liquid or a fixed roof. The safe design of floating roof tank offers a considerable level of
fire safety over other vertical tank designs. As a result, fire codes allow closer spacing
between floating roof tanks and for separation from adjacent properties or operations
providing a cost advantage in tank farm layout and arrangement.
8.4.2.1 Fixed Roof Tanks
Fixed roof tanks are generally for hydrocarbon liquids with very high flash points (e.g.,
heavy crude oil, diesel, heavy kerosene, fuel oil, bitumen/asphalt etc.). Vapor pressure
in such tanks is of the order of 3.5 kPa (0.5 Psia). Figure 8-6 illustrates vapor pressure
of hydrocarbon liquids commonly transported by pipelines and stored in storage tanks
[6]. Similar graphs were presented in Chapter 2, Figure 2-9.
Figure 8-6. V
apor pressure of liquid hydrocarbons commonly transported by pipelines (reproduced from [6])
Figure 8-7. Fixed roof tanks (dome and conical roofs and float)
welded into place (Figure 8-8). See Section 7 Petroleum Storage/Terminal Design
& Construction.
Cone and dome roofs can be either self-supported or column supported. Cone-roof
tanks typically have roof rafters and support columns (Figure 8-9 (column support)
and Figure 8-10 (Cone Roof and Roof Hob Details, [8])). Figure 8-9 is an indication
of some of the older design.
Umbrella-roof tanks: They are very similar to cone-roof tanks, but the roof looks
like an umbrella. They are usually constructed with diameters < 20 to 30 m. Another
difference is that the umbrella-roof does not have to be supported by columns to the
bottom of the tank, so that they can be a self-supporting structure. The umbrella types
are spherical design.
Typical fixed roof storage tank together with appurtenances are shown in Figure
8-11.
Geodesic dome-roof tanks: Although most tanks are made of steel, some fixedroof tanks have aluminum geodesic dome-roof. Some advantages include that they
have a superior corrosion resistance for a wide range of conditions compared with
steel tanks (Figure 8-12). Also they are often an economical choice and are clear-span
Figure 8-9. Cone roof tank with column support (under construction) [8]
Figure 8-24. R
esilient foam (left) or liquid filled (right) primary rim seal with secondary
seal[11]
The core provides the flexibility and support, while the fabric provides the vapor barrier and wear surface.
A secondary seal (Figure 8-23) may be used to provide some additional evaporative loss control over that achieved by the primary seal. Secondary seals can be either
flexible wiper seals or resilient filled seals.
A resilient foam-filled seal, can also be mounted to eliminate the vapor space between the rim seal and liquid surface (liquid mounted, Figure 8-24) or to allow a vapor
space between the rim seal and the liquid surface (vapor mounted, Figure 8-25). Resilient filled seals work because of the expansion and contraction of a resilient material to
maintain contact with the tank shell while accommodating varying annular rim space
widths. These rim seals allow the roof to move up and down freely, without binding.
Resilient filled seals typically consist of a core of open-cell foam encapsulated in
a coated fabric. The seals are attached to a mounting on the deck perimeter and extend
around the deck circumference. Polyurethane-coated nylon fabric and polyurethane
foam are commonly used materials. For emission control, it is important that the attachment of the seal to the deck and the radial seal joints be vapor-tight and that the
seal be in substantial contact with the tank shell.
The scuff band as shown in Figure 8-24 is usually thin metal band that acts as
protection against snags and tears in the foam bag fabric from the tank shell.
A mechanical/metallic rim mounted shoe seal (Figure 8-26) uses a light-gauge
metallic band as the sliding contact with the shell of the tank. The band is formed as a
series of sheets (shoes) which are joined together to form a ring, and are held against
the tank shell by a mechanical device. The shoes are normally 1 to 1.5 m (3 to 5 ft)
deep, providing a potentially large contact area with the tank shell. Expansion and
Pan type
Pontoon type
Double deck type
Buoy roof type
Most floating decks that are currently in use in the industry are constructed of
welded steel plate and are of two general types: pontoon (Figure 8-13) or double-deck
(Figure 8-14).
A typical external floating roof tank (EFRT) consists of an open-topped cylindrical steel shell equipped with a roof that floats on the surface of the stored liquid. The
floating roof consists of a deck, fittings, and rim seal system. With all types of external
floating roof tanks, the roof rises and falls with the liquid level in the tank.
Figure 8-14. T
ypical floating roof tank component make up and appurtenances (double
deck)[13,14]
Figure 8-16. S
ectional view of floating roofs (reproduced from ref. [11]) and a double design
details [12]
shell at the base of the tank. The hose often develops leaks and drains both water
and product.
Domed External Floating Roof Tanks: Domed external (or covered) floating
roof tanks have the heavier type of deck used in external floating roof tanks (EFRT)
described previously, as well as a fixed roof at the top of the shell like internal floating roof tanks. Aluminum floating roofs may also be used in a tank with an aluminum
geodesic dome. In many cases the aluminum Internal Floating Roof (IFR) is supported
from the dome rather than on legs.
Domed external floating roof tanks usually result from retrofitting an external
floating roof tank with a fixed roof. This type of tank is very similar to an internal
floating roof tank with a welded deck and a self-supporting fixed roof. A typical domed
external floating roof tank is shown in Figure 8-17.
As with the internal floating roof tanks, the function of the fixed roof or geodesic
dome is not to act as a vapor barrier, but to block the wind and as well keep rain and
snow out of the tank and off the floating roof. The type of fixed roof most commonly
used is a self-supporting aluminum dome roof, which is of bolted construction. Like the
internal floating roof tanks, these tanks are freely vented by circulation vents at the top
of the fixed roof. The deck fittings and rim seals, however, are identical to those on external floating roof tanks. In the event that the floating deck is replaced with the lighter
IFRT-type deck, the tank would then be considered an internal floating roof tank.
Internal Floating Roof: An internal floating roof tank (IFRT) has both a permanent fixed roof and a floating roof inside. There are two basic types of internal floating
roof tanks: tanks in which the fixed roof is supported by vertical columns within the
tank, and tanks with a self-supporting fixed roof and no internal support columns.
Fixed roof tanks that have been retrofitted to use a floating roof are typically of the
first type.
The advantages of using internal floating roofs are as follows:
Decrease in the level of evaporation of stored product;
Lower risk of fire there almost are no cases of fire in the world practice;
Aluminum internal floating roof. It has low height and storage capacity is
increased;
Protection from ambient climatic conditions therefore the tanks could be used
in various earth regions;
No requirement for mounting of roof drain.
External floating roof tanks that have been converted to internal floating roof tanks
typically have a self-supporting roof. Newly constructed internal floating roof tanks
may be of either type. The deck in internal floating roof tanks rises and falls with the
Figure 8-37. Floating roof deck fittings: gauge hatch/sample port [13,14]
Figure 8-19. A typical internal floating roof tank (IFRT) details [13,14] (inset [11])
Installing a floating roof minimizes evaporative losses of the stored liquid. Both
contact and noncontact decks incorporate rim seals and deck fittings for the same purposes previously described for external floating roof tanks. Evaporative losses from
floating roofs may come from deck fittings, non-welded deck seams, and the annular
space between the deck and tank wall. In addition, these tanks are freely vented by
circulation vents at the top of the fixed roof. The vents minimize the possibility of
organic vapor accumulation in the tank vapor space in concentrations approaching the
flammable range.
It may be noted that an internal floating roof tank that is not freely vented is considered a pressure tank.
Pressurized Storage Tanks: Pressure tanks generally are used for storing hydro
carbon liquids and gases with high vapor pressures and are available in many sizes
and shapes, depending on the operating pressure of the tank. These depending on the
pressure maintenance requirements will be either low pressure or high pressure as
follows:
Low-pressure tanks
Cylindrical (15 kPa to 100 kPa, 2.5 to 15 psig)
Spheroid (15 to 210 kPa, 2.5 to 30 PSI)
Noded Spheroid
High-pressure storage tanks
Bullets (15400 PSI), Figure 8-20
Spheres (153000 PSI), Figure 8-21
Pressure tanks are equipped with a pressure/vacuum vent that is set to prevent
venting loss from boiling and breathing loss from daily temperature or barometric
pressure changes.
Organic liquids/petroleum liquids, generally, are mixtures of hydrocarbons having dissimilar true vapor pressures (for example, gasoline and crude oil, etc.). Organic
liquids in the chemical industry, usually called volatile organic liquids, are composed
of pure chemicals or mixtures of chemicals with similar true vapor pressures (for example, condensate, benzene or a mixture of isopropyl and butyl alcohols).
Once stored, hydrocarbon products (unless they are under pressure) will evaporate. Total emission from storage tanks includes withdrawal as well as standing storage
losses.
Therefore, storage tanks are usually equipped with seals and vapor controls and
sometime leak detection systems to assure minimal emissions and as well increased
safety.
8.4.3.1 Tank Rim Sealing Systems: Floating Roof Tanks
Emissions from floating roof tanks are the sum of withdrawal losses and standing
storage losses. Withdrawal losses occur as the liquid level, and thus the floating roof,
is lowered. Some liquid remains on the inner tank wall surface and evaporates. For
an internal floating roof tank that has a column supported fixed roof, some liquid also
Figure 8-22. V
apor mounted primary rim seal with secondary seal (left flexible wiper and
right resilient foam) [12]
that the blade is flexed, and its elasticity provides a sealing pressure against the tank
shell.
Wiper seals are vapor mounted; a vapor space exists between the liquid stock and
the bottom of the seal. For emission control, it is important that the mounting be vaportight, that the seal extend around the circumference of the deck and that the blade be in
substantial contact with the tank shell. Two types of materials are commonly used to
make the wipers. One type consists of a cellular, elastomeric material tapered in cross
section with the thicker portion at the mounting. Rubber is a commonly used material;
urethane and cellular plastic are also available. All radial joints in the blade are joined.
The second type of material that can be used is a foam core wrapped with a coated
fabric. Polyurethane on nylon fabric and polyurethane foam are common materials.
Figure 8-23. Typical secondary seal (A rim mounted and B wiper type) [11,12]
Figure 8-24. R
esilient foam (left) or liquid filled (right) primary rim seal with secondary
seal[11]
The core provides the flexibility and support, while the fabric provides the vapor barrier and wear surface.
A secondary seal (Figure 8-23) may be used to provide some additional evaporative loss control over that achieved by the primary seal. Secondary seals can be either
flexible wiper seals or resilient filled seals.
A resilient foam-filled seal, can also be mounted to eliminate the vapor space between the rim seal and liquid surface (liquid mounted, Figure 8-24) or to allow a vapor
space between the rim seal and the liquid surface (vapor mounted, Figure 8-25). Resilient filled seals work because of the expansion and contraction of a resilient material to
maintain contact with the tank shell while accommodating varying annular rim space
widths. These rim seals allow the roof to move up and down freely, without binding.
Resilient filled seals typically consist of a core of open-cell foam encapsulated in
a coated fabric. The seals are attached to a mounting on the deck perimeter and extend
around the deck circumference. Polyurethane-coated nylon fabric and polyurethane
foam are commonly used materials. For emission control, it is important that the attachment of the seal to the deck and the radial seal joints be vapor-tight and that the
seal be in substantial contact with the tank shell.
The scuff band as shown in Figure 8-24 is usually thin metal band that acts as
protection against snags and tears in the foam bag fabric from the tank shell.
A mechanical/metallic rim mounted shoe seal (Figure 8-26) uses a light-gauge
metallic band as the sliding contact with the shell of the tank. The band is formed as a
series of sheets (shoes) which are joined together to form a ring, and are held against
the tank shell by a mechanical device. The shoes are normally 1 to 1.5 m (3 to 5 ft)
deep, providing a potentially large contact area with the tank shell. Expansion and
contraction of the ring can be provided for as the ring passes over shell irregularities
or rivets by jointing narrow pieces of fabric into the ring or by crimping the shoes at
intervals. The bottoms of the shoes extend below the liquid surface (as shown in Figure
8-25 above) to confine the rim vapor space between the shoe and the floating deck.
The rim vapor space, which is bounded by the shoe, the rim of the floating deck,
and the liquid surface, is sealed from the atmosphere by bolting or clamping a coated
fabric, called the primary seal fabric, which extends from the shoe to the rim to form
an envelope. Two locations are used for attaching the primary seal fabric. The fabric
is most commonly attached to the top of the shoe and the rim of the floating deck. To
reduce the rim vapor space, the fabric can be attached to the shoe and the floating deck
rim near the liquid surface. Rim vents can be used to relieve any excess pressure or
vacuum in the vapor space.
Some primary seals on external floating roof tanks are protected by a weather
shield. Weather shields are usually simple metal pieces without fabric barriers but can
be of elastomeric, or composite construction and provide the primary seal with longer
Figure 8-26. T
ypical mechanical shoe primary rim seal with a shoe mounted secondary seal
system, from [11,18,19]
Figure 8-27. Flex-a-seal double wiper seal system including weather shield [11,20]
life by protecting the primary seal fabric from deterioration due to exposure to weather,
debris, and sunlight. However, it may be noted that when a weather shield is combined
with a continuous vapor fabric, it can also can act as a secondary seal. Without such a
continuous vapor fabric, it cannot be considered as a secondary seal.
On external floating roofs, the most common secondary seal systems incorporate
a compression/protection plate over a continuous fabric to provide additional vapor
Figure 8-29. Weather shield and secondary seal system (Horton VS 200 [20])
Figure 8-30. H
MT seal-king (left) and HMT secondary low profile wiper (right) seals (courtesy of HMT Inc.)
Figure 8-34. HMT seal-master primary and secondary seal (IFR) courtesy of HMT Inc.
Figure 8-37. Floating roof deck fittings: gauge hatch/sample port [13,14]
Figure 8-41. Floating roof deck fittings: un-slotted (A) and slotted (B) guide poles, [13,14]
Figure 8-43. Internal floating roof tank (IFRT) support (un-slotted), [13,14]
The columns pass through deck openings via peripheral vertical wells. With noncontact decks, the well should extend down into the liquid stock. Generally, a closure
device exists between the top of the well and the column. Several proprietary designs
exist for this closure, including sliding covers and fabric sleeves, which must accommodate the movements of the deck relative to the column as the liquid level changes.
A sliding cover rests on the upper rim of the column well (which is normally fixed to
Figure 8-44. Internal floating roof tank (IFRT) - support (slotted) [13,14]
Figure 8-45. Internal floating roof tank (IFRT) ladders and wells design [13,14]
the deck) and bridges the gap or space between the column well and the column. The
cover, which has a cutout, or opening, around the column slides vertically relative to
the column as the deck raises and lowers. At the same time, the cover slides horizontally relative to the rim of the well. A gasket around the rim of the well reduces emissions from this fitting. A flexible fabric sleeve seal between the rim of the well and
thecolumn (with a cutout or opening, to allow vertical motion of the seal relative to
the columns) similarly accommodates limited horizontal motion of the deck relative
to the column.
Ladders and wells. Some tanks are equipped with internal ladders that extend
from a manhole in the fixed roof to the tank bottom. The deck opening through which
the ladder passes is constructed with similar design details and considerations to deck
openings for column wells, as previously discussed. A typical ladder well is shown in
Figure 8-45.
Land size
Number of tanks
Tank sizes (height and diameter)
Types of tanks
Consider the logical unit/equipment locations
Look at overall site layout for process units
Consider key separations on grounds of safety (e.g. Bund wall and distance
from bund walls, tanks and fence line), wind directions, Security (Inner and
outer walls/fences)
Consider environmental factors (flood, spills )
Consider requirements for access/maintenance
Locate key equipment into each module
Produce initial plan & elevation to scale
Prepare isometric sketches for pipe-runs, utilities, cabling
Location of control centre and offices, parking
Nearest community
Future expansion
Offices
EMR facilities
Emergency backup facilities
Geotechnical considerations including
Subsoil conditions
Tank foundation design, monitoring of settlements, see Figure 8-46 for typical
example (refer to Section 8.7.3 for typical settlement calculation)
Hydrotesting (API 653)
General terrain
Safety and environment
Regulations, land acquisition, native title,
Flammable/non-flammable products
High-/low-pressure units
Pumping facilities
Maintenance, utilities
Storage Tank Spacing for Chemical/Oil Plants: Codes and standards generally
do not specify/recommend a safe distance between tankage facilities, however NFPA
30 Flammable and Combustible Liquids Code refers to minimum safe distances.
American Institute of Chemical Engineers, Center for Chemical Process Safety indicate distances between tankages as given in Figure 8-47 [27].
Based on the layout consideration and the requirements for safe spacing between
tanks a typical plot plan for a tank farm is indicated in Figures 8-48 and 8-49.
It may be noted that minimum standards of control (including tankage spacing,
piping arrangement, access, etc.) must be in place at all locations/terminals storing
large volumes of petroleum and similar products capable of giving rise to a large flammable vapor cloud in the event of a loss of primary containment [28,29].
Figure 8-47. Storage tank spacing for chemical/oil plants (adapted from ref. [27])
Figure 8-49. Typical tank farm with safe distances between tankages
Design Code
Tank Location
Nominal capacity of tank
Tank diameter and/or height restrictions;
Internal tank pressure
(8 1)
where:
= absolute internal tank pressure at which vacuum vent opens, kPa (abs)
f = required storage pressure, kPa (abs)
Bmax = vapor pressure of liquid at maximum surface temperature, kPa (abs)
Bmin = vapor pressure of liquid at minimum surface temperature, kPa (abs)
P = absolute pressure, kPa (abs)
Pa = atmospheric pressure, kPa (abs)
T = temperature, K
Ta = ambient air temperature, C
Tmax = maximum average temperature, C
Tmin = minimum average temperature, C
The above relation holds only when Bmin is less than ; that is, when the minimum
vapor pressure is so low that air is admitted into the vapor space through the vacuum
vent. When Bmin is equal to or greater than , the required storage pressure is,
f = Bmax - Pa
(8 2)
Under this condition, air is kept out of the vapor space. Figure 8-50 is presented as a
general guide to storage pressures for gasolines of various volatilities in uninsulated tanks.
These data for plotting the curves were computed from Eqs. (8-1) and (8-2) using
the following assumptions:
Minimum liquid surface temperature is 5C less than the maximum liquid surface temperature.
Maximum vapor space temperature is 22C greater than the maximum liquid
surface temperature.
Minimum vapor space temperature is 8C less than the maximum liquid surface temperature.
Stable ambient conditions (ambient temperature 38C).
These temperature variations are far greater than would be experienced from normal night to day changes. Therefore, the lower, nearly horizontal line, which shows a
required storage pressure of 17 kPa (ga) for the less volatile gasolines is conservative
and allows a wide operating margin.
Maximum liquid surface temperatures vary from 29 to 46C. Sufficient accuracy
will generally result from the assumption that it is 5C higher than the maximum temperature of the body of the liquid in a tank at that location.
Figure 8-50. Storage pressure vs. true vapor pressure (TVP), redrawn from GPSA [30]
Example 8-1 To illustrate the use of Figure 8-50, suppose a 165 kPa (abs) true
vapor pressure (TVP) natural gasoline is to be stored where the liquid surface temperature may reach a maximum of 38C. A vertical line extended upward fromthe 165kPa
(abs) mark at the bottom of the chart intersects the 38C line at 64 kPa (abs). The design pressure of the tank should be a minimum of 70.5 kPa (abs) (64 kPa +10%).
Figure 8-51 below can also be used for the determination of working pressure of
storage tanks storing LPG and natural gasoline such as condensate. It is not to be used
for crude oil.
In relation to Figure 8-51, the following definitions apply:
RVP = Reid Vapor Pressure is a vapor pressure for liquid products as determined
by ASTM test procedure D-323.
The Reid vapor pressure is defined as pounds per sq in (kPa) at 37.8C. The RVP
is always less than the true vapor pressure at 37.8C.
TVP = true vapor pressure is the pressure at which the gas and liquid in a closed
container are in equilibrium at a given temperature.
Figure 8-51 can be used as follows:
As quick reference to determine true vapor pressures of typical LPGs, natural
gasolines, and motor fuel components at various temperatures.
To estimate the operating pressure of a storage tank necessary to maintain the
stored fluid in a liquid state at various temperatures.
For converting from true vapor pressure to Reid Vapor Pressure (RVP).
For simple evaluation of refrigerated storage versus ambient temperature storage for LPGs.
Figure 8-51. T
rue vapor pressures vs. temperatures for typical LPG, motor, and natural gasolines (not to be used for crude oil vapor pressure), courtesy of GPSA [30]
(8 3)
Using this formula for the 83 kPa, RVP gasoline example would calculate a 93 kPa
(abs) TVP versus the 91 determined.
However, Figure 8-52 below can be used to determine the true vapor pressure of
crude oils [32].
Similarly, Figure 8-53 below can be used for the determination of petroleum products.
8.7.2.2.2 Mechanical Design The following provides calculation methods for the
determination of permissible stresses and of major tank elements:
Tank Internal Pressure: Internal pressure of tanks can be calculated as follows
Pmax =
39W
+ 77t , N/m 2
D 2
or
4W
+ 7.85t , kgf/m 2
D 2
(8 4)
Figure 8-52. T
rue vapor pressure of crude oils with a Reid vapor pressure of 2 to 15 pounds
per square inch [32], courtesy of API
(8 5)
Figure 8-53. T
rue vapor pressure of refined petroleum stocks with a Reid vapor pressure of
1to 20 pounds per square inch [32], courtesy of API
(8 6)
where
t = minimum thickness in mm;
D = nominal diameter of tank in m;
H = height from the bottom of the course under consideration to top of top curb
angle or to bottom of any overflow which limits tank filling height in m;
G = specific gravity of liquid to be stored, but in no case less than 1.0;
S = allowable stress; and
E = joint efficiency factor
The following should be considered in the determination of shell plate thickness:
Loads: Stresses in the tank shell can be computed on the assumption that the
tank is filled with water of specific gravity 1.00 or the liquid to be stored, if
heavier than water. The tension in each course shall be computed at 30 cm
above the centre line of the lower horizontal joint of the course in question.
Isolated radial loads on tank shells, such as that caused by heavy loads from
platforms and elevated walkways between tanks may be distributed appropriately, preferably in a horizontal position.
Wind and internal vacuum loads should be considered together to check the
stability of tank shells. Wind loads may be as specified as per design data.
Internal vacuum in the tank is usually taken as a minimum of 500 N/m2
(50 kg/m2, 0.5 kPa) vacuum by the industry. API 650 requires a minimum
external pressure of 0.25 kPa
Joint Efficiency Factor This is usually taken as 0.85 for double welded butt
joints, to determine the minimum thickness of shell plates computed from the
stress on the vertical joints, subject to all vertical and horizontal butt welds being spot radiographed. Where welds are not to be so examined by radiography,
the joint efficiency factor considered for design shall be 0.70. It may be note
however that the base tank design procedure of API 650 requires a joint efficiency of 1.0 unless the tank is very small and has a maximum shell thickness
of 13 mm (1/2).
The nominal thickness of shell plates refers to the tank shell as constructed and
is based on stability rather than stress. Any required corrosion allowance for the shell
plates must be added to the calculated thickness.
Stability of tank shells against external loads shall be checked by determining
the maximum height of the shell from the tap curb angle or wind girder that does not
buckle under this loading and providing stiffening to the shell if required.
The maximum height of un-stiffened shell in meters, is not to exceed H1 as determined by the following equation:
H1 = [14700t/p]
H1 = [1500 t/p]
D
3 if p is in N/m2
t
(8 7)
D
2
t 3 if p is in kgf/m
(8 8)
geotechnical study of the site is thus required in the design of the foundation; however,
in many cases (especially for tanks located in coastal areas), the soils are susceptible to
have uniform or differential settlements. The buckling of the shell due to the foundation settlement however must be considered in details.
Various forms of settlements (D) could take place so it is important to define types
of settlement (Figure 8-54) and all required variables for calculations:
D = Diameter of the tank.
R = Radius of the tank.
H = Height of the tank.
L = distance between two points with differential settlement.
Dmax = max Total maximum settlement: This type of settlement illustrates in
Figure8-54A, ave = Average settlement: This type of settlement is an
average of the settlement of all points of a tank Figure 8-54B. See also
previous Figure 8-46.
Other parameters are:
w
= Tilt: This component rotates the tank in a tilt plane (Figure 8-55A).
d
= Differential settlement between two points.
dbottom = Edge settlement occurs when the tank shell settles sharply around the
periphery, resulting in deformation of the bottom plate near the shellto-bottom corner junction (Figure 8-55B), or the depth of the depressed
area of the bottom plate (Figure 8-56).
dshell = This component of settlement at the bottom edge leads to the lack of circularity and creates stresses in the shell. Shell d is defined as differential
outline settlement between settlement of one measurement point with
respect to the average of settlements of its two adjacent points (Figure
8-54B).
d i = Ui - (0.5 Ui +1 - 0.5 Ui -1 )
(8 9)
Figure 8-55. Steel tank settlement (A tilt and B bottom-edge differential settlement) [33]
where
di = Differential settlement between one point and average settlement of its adjacent points
Ui = Settlement of each points in Figure 8-57 and previous Figure 8-46
API 653 is the related document for the calculation of tank settlements as follows
[26, 33]:
Uniform settlement: This component often can be predicted in advance, with
sufficient accuracy from soil tests, and does not induce stresses in the tank
structure. However, piping, tank nozzles, and attachments must be designed
with adequate consideration to prevent problems caused by such settlement.
Therefore, piping must be adequately supported to avoid undue stresses.
Planer tilt: This type of settlement could affect tank nozzles which may have
piping attached to them. The tilt will cause an increase in liquid level.
Outline settlement of the shell: Use the following formula to calculate the maximum allowable outline settlement:
shell = ( L 2 y 5.5 ) / ( H )
(8 10)
Figure 8-58. A
llowable bottom-edge differential settlement, (Reproduced from API 653,
Appendix-B)
Figure 8-60. T
ypical concrete ring wall foundation (smaller diameter tanks), all dimensions
in mm
Slab foundations: The concrete slab foundation has the advantages of the concrete ring-wall but is usually limited to tanks with diameters less than 10 m. Often the
edge of the slab will be sufficiently thick to provide for anchorage. A slab foundation is
very versatile, but its high cost limits it to use in small tanks. The slab provides a level
and plane-working surface that facilitates rapid field erection.
Pile-supported foundations: The pile-supported foundation is usually found
where the soil bearing pressures are very low. Examples might be river deltas and land
adjacent to bays. They are also used where high foundation uplift forces are encountered resulting from internal pressure or seismic loading.
Foundation design must conform to welded tank bottom design. A tank bottom
may be broadly classified as flat bottom or conical.
A Flat bottom: They are the most common end closures of tanks. These tanks
appear flat but usually have a small designed slope and shape. These tanks are further
categorized as follows:
Flat: For tanks less than about 5 to 10 m in diameter, the flat-bottom tank is
used. The inclusion of a small slope as described above does not provide any
substantial benefit, so they are fabricated as close to flat as possible.
Cone up: These bottoms are built with a high point in the center of the tank.
Crowning the foundation and constructing the tank on the crown accomplish
this. The slope is limited to about 25 to 50 mm per 3 m run. This is the design
mostly adopted in large diameter above ground storage tanks.
Cone down: The cone-down design slopes toward the center of the tank. Usually, there is a collection sump at the center. It is very effective for water removal from tanks. This design is inherently more complex because it requires a
sump, underground piping, and an external sump outside the tank and therefore
not used in design of very large tanks.
Figure 8-63. Typical oil storage tank bund wall and security fencing design
Concrete works very well for many liquids, but it is unsuitable for some applications like containing strong acids. Using earth berms for bunding is not recommended
for most situations, though liners can be used to decrease permeability.
Large, exposed bunding will need a sump pump or some other system to remove
precipitation, though it may also be used to transfer spilled liquid into another container. Rainwater must be treated if the liquid being stored is toxic because there may
be small amounts of it surrounding the tank.
If the bund wall is over a meter high, it generally requires a ladder or steps to allow ease of escape from the bunded area. Another design uses a channel that drains the
liquid to a secondary container.
8.7.3.3.3Bunding Failures In 1919, a 15-m high molasses tank in Boston burst
(Figure 8-64) killing 21 and injuring 150. A few other tanks have failed in a similar
manner in the United States, but they have usually resulted in relatively few deaths.
Figure 8-68. A
utomatic welding of large crude oil tanks (photo source: KHK, Safety &
Tomorrow, Mar. 2000, [34])
Figure 8-69. T
ypical vertical and horizontal weld joint design (all dimensions in mm) (Reproduced from [34])
Figure 8-70. Outline of horizontal submerged arc welding (Reproduced from [34])
Figure 8-71. A
pplication of horizontal submerged arc welding (photo source: KHK, Safety &
Tomorrow, Mar. 2000 [34])
Figure 8-72. T
he SEGARC (submerged electro-gas arc welding) process for one-run vertical
butt welding (KHK, Safety & Tomorrow, Mar. 2000 [34])
For the filling passes and the capping passes, SAW provides the highest efficiency.
Due to the severe welding environment, the best flux-wire combination for this joint
should emphasize porosity resistance.
With these flux-wire combinations, DCEP polarity will produce better bead appearance in single SAW than AC polarity. Figure 8-74 shows a typical weld pass sequence for this joint, combining SMAW for the root pass and single SAW for the filling
and capping passes.
Figure 8-73. S
EGARC (submerged electro-gas arc welding) process: a portable EGW process
for vertical welding (Courtesy Kobe Steel [34])
Figure 8-74. A
typical pass sequence for shell plate to annular plate tee joint welded by using
a combination of SMAW and single SAW processes [34]
Figure 8-75. Typical layout of tank bottom and weld joint design (all dimensions in mm) [34]
made by applying a backing strip 3 mm thick or heavier by tack welding to the underside of the plate (see Figure 8-76B, Section XX). A metal spacer may be used, if
necessary, to maintain the root opening between the adjacent plates.
In bottom plate butt welding three-plate joints are generally not be closer than
300mm from each other and also from the tank shell.
Tank erectors may however propose other methods of butt welding the tank bottom.
8.7.4.2.5 Nozzle Peripheral and Manhole Joint (Figure 8-77): Some tanks are
fitted with manholes. Such manholes are welded in the factory in advance. They can
be welded by SAW using special automatic welding equipment that can track along the
three-dimensional saddle-shaped welding line.
However, where such automatic welding equipment is not available, semi-automatic
GMAW and SMAW are the second and third best processes respectively in terms of
welding efficiency. These welds are postweld heat treated to remove the residual stresses;
therefore, the filler metal should be selected taking into account the weld metal properties
after the post-weld heat treatment at the specified temperature and soaking time.
8.7.4.3 Post Weld Heat Treatment of Welded Tanks Structures
Post Weld Heat Treatment (PWHT) is generally carried out to relieve residual stresses,
remove diffusible hydrogen, and temper hard transformation microstructures of the
weld, thereby preventing brittle fractures and obtaining the desired properties of the
product. PWHT, however, can have some negative effects, such as stress relief cracking (SR Cracking) Rogantea et al. [35]. It may be noted that For High Strength Material
with an Ultimate Tensile Strength > 415 MPa, shell openings 2 require a PWHT insert plate assembly in shells greater than 13 mm. For a material with a UTS < 415MPa,
A PWHT assembly is required for nozzles >12 in shell plates 25.4 mm.
Figure 8-76. Tank bottom plate arrangement under tank shell [34]
SR cracking can become a problem particularly in the PWHT of high tensile strength
steel, heat-resistant low alloy steel and stainless steel weldments. Figure 8-78 shows a typical example of SR Cracking that occurred in a 780-MPa high tensile strength steel weld
that was heat treated at 600C for 2 hours after welding. It is believed that this microscopic
crack was initiated by the creep of the metal during relaxation of the residual stress at high
temperatures particularly at the coarse grain area in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) at the toe
Figure 8-77. Welds at the periphery of a manhole in a tank shell plate [34]
(8 11)
1.5%Cr max,
0.10 to 0.25%C,
1.0%Cu max,
2.0%Mo max,
0.15%V max,
0.15%Nb max, and
0.15%Ti max.
Figure 8-78. T
ypical SR cracks occurring in a 780-MPa high tensile strength steel weld
(PWHT: 600C 2 h), KHK, Safety & Tomorrow, Mar. 2000 [34], http://www.
kobelco.co.jp/english/welding/files/kwt2006-01.pdf
Figure 8-79. S
R crack susceptibility of Cr-Mo steel (0.16%C, 0.30%Si, 0.60%Mn, 0.99%Cr,
0.46%Mo) as a function of PWHT temperature and additional alloying elements
in groove restraint cracking test [31, 36]
Some of the above mechanical components along with other fitting arrangements
are illustrated in previous Figures 8-33 to 8-43 (see Section 8.4.4).
8.7.5.2 Instrumentation and Controls
Storage tank instrumentation includes all gauges (sampling, temperature, pressure,
densitometer, viscometer level/volume/mass measurements) and instruments (including rain and wind gauges) for hydrocarbon liquid handling and controls. It can also
Figure 8-83. A
typical level gauging system incorporated seamlessly into terminal automation
systems [37]
LT = LS + LW
(8 12)
where
LT = total losses, lb/year
LS = standing storage/breathing loss, lb/year
LW = working loss, lb/year
Standing Storage or Breathing Loss is calculated as follows
LS = nVVWV K E K S
(8 13)
where
LS = Standing storage losses, lb/month
n = number of days in the respective each year (usually 365, a constant)
VV = pD 2 /4 H VO
(8 14)
where
VV = vapor space volume, ft3
D = tank diameter, ft,
HVO = vapor space outage, ft, see Eq. (8-15)
The vapor space outage, HVO is the height of a cylinder of tank of diameter D,
whose volume is equivalent to the vapor space volume of a fixed roof tank, including
the volume under the cone or dome roof.
The vapor space outage, HVO, can be estimated from:
H VO = HS - H L + H RO
(8 15)
where
HVO = vapor space outage, ft
HS = tank shell height, ft
HL = liquid height, ft
HRO = roof outage, ft;
For a cone roof, the roof outage, HRO, is calculated as follows:
H RO = 1/3H R
(8 16)
where
HRO = roof outage (or shell height equivalent to the volume contained under the
roof), ft
HR = tank roof height, ft
H R = SR RS
(8 17)
where
SR = tank cone roof slope, ft/ft; if unknown, a standard value of 0.0625 can be
used
RS = tank shell radius, ft
For a dome roof, the roof outage, HRO, is calculated as follows
2
H RO = H R + 1/6 ( H R /RS)
(8 18)
where
HRO = roof outage, ft
RS = tank shell radius, ft
HR = tank roof height, ft
H R = RR - RR2 - RR2
0.5
(8 19)
(8 20)
The standing storage loss LS equation can be simplified by combining Eq. (8-12)
with Eq. (8-13) and consider n = 365. The result is
(8 21)
(8 22)
where
KE
= vapor space expansion factor, dimensionless
DTV = daily vapor temperature range, R
TAX = daily maximum ambient temperature, R
TAN = daily minimum ambient temperature, R
a
= tank paint solar absorptance, dimensionless
I
= daily total solar insolation on a horizontal surface, Btu/(ft2 day)
0.0018 = constant, (R)-1
0.72 = constant, dimensionless
0.028 = constant, (R ft2 day)/Btu
K E = 0.04
(8 23)
However, when the liquid stock has a true vapor pressure greater than 0.1 psia,
a more accurate estimate of the vapor space expansion factor, KE, is obtained by Eq.
(8-24) below. As shown in the equation, KE is greater than zero. If KE is less than zero,
standing storage losses will not occur.
(8 24)
where
KE = vapor space expansion factor, dimensionless
DTV = daily vapor temperature range, R
DPV = daily vapor pressure range, psi
DPB = breather vent pressure setting range, psi
14.7 = atmospheric pressure, psi
PVA = vapor pressure at daily average liquid surface temperature, psi (derived
earlier)
TLA = daily average liquid (gasoline) surface temperature, R (derived earlier)
The daily vapor temperature range, DTV, is calculated below using the daily
maximum and daily minimum liquid (gasoline) surface temperatures (derived
earlier):
Assumption: The vapor temperature range is equal to the liquid (gasoline) surface temperature range.
(8 25)
The daily vapor pressure range, PV, is calculated using the following
equation:
(8 26)
where
PVX = vapor pressure PVA at daily maximum liquid (gasoline) surface temperature, psi
PVN = vapor pressure PVA at daily minimum liquid (gasoline) surface temperature, psi
Using the daily maximum and daily minimum liquid (gasoline) surface temperatures, the respective vapor pressures can be calculated as:
(8 27)
(8 28)
where
RVP = 7 psi, A = 11.83 and B = 5500.90R
RVP = 9 psi, A = 11.75 and B = 5314.31R
The breather vent pressure setting range, delta PB, is calculated using the
following equation:
DPB = PBP - PBV
(8 29)
where
DPB = breather vent range (psi)
PBP = breather vent pressure setting (psi)
PBV = breather vent vacuum setting (psi)
For ASTs with a pressure/vacuum vent valve
PBP = 2 in H2O @ 0.0722 psi
PBV = 4 in H2O @ 0.1444 psi
For ASTs with no pressure/vacuum vent valve
PBP = 0 in H2O @ 0 psi
PBV = 0 in H2O @ 0 psi
The vapor pressure at daily average liquid (gasoline) surface temperature,
PVA, is calculated as shown earlier.
The daily average liquid (gasoline) surface temperature, TLA, is calculated
as shown earlier.
Vented Vapor Saturation Factor, KS The vented vapor saturation factor is
calculated using the following equation:
Ks =
1
= 1
1 + ( 0.053* PVA * H VO )
(8 30)
where
KS = dimensionless factor
PVA = vapor pressure at daily average fuel surface temperature, psi
HVO = vapor space outage = 0 ft
(as mentioned earlier, the ASTs being considered in this evaluation are
horizontal with no roof outage or vapor space outage factor)
Calculation of Vapor Properties WV
Vapor Density, WV, is the density of the vapor and is calculated using the following equation:
WV = M V PVA /RTLA
(8 31)
where
WV = vapor density, lb/ft3
MV = vapor molecular weight, lb/lb-mole
R = the ideal gas constant, 10.731 psiaft3/lb-moleR
PVA = vapor pressure at daily average liquid-surface temperature, psia
(8 32)
where
exp = exponential function
TLA = daily average liquid (gasoline) surface temperature, R
Figure 3-5 in AP-42 [38] shows the equations that can be used to determine vapor
pressure constants, A (dimensionless) and B (R) for each corresponding RVP of
gasoline:
Example:
RVP = 7 psi, A = 11.83 and B = 5500.90,R
RVP = 9 psi, A = 11.75 and B = 5314.31,R
Daily average liquid (gasoline) surface temperature (TLA) is calculated
using the following equation:
TLA = ( TLN + TLX ) /2
(8 33)
Table 8-4. Properties (MV, PVA, WL) of typical petroleum liquids (reproduced from GPSA [30])
Hydrocarbon
Liquid
Crude RVP 5
Fuel Oil #2,
(Distillated)
Gasoline RVP 7
Gasoline RVP 7.8
Gasoline RVP 8.3
Gasoline RVP 10
Gasoline RVP 11.5
Gasoline RVP 13
Gasoline RVP 13.5
Gasoline RVP 15
Jet Kerosene
Jet Naphta (JP -4)
Naphta Oil #6
Vapor Mole
Liquid
Weight (60F) Density (60F)
1b/1b-mole
lb/gal
50oF
60oF
70oF
80oF
90oF
4
0.012
4.8
0.016
50
130
7.1
7.1
1.8
0.0031
2.3
0.0045
2.8
0.0065
3.4
0.009
68
68
68
65
62
62
62
60
130
80
190
5.6
5.6
5.6
5.6
5.6
5.6
5.6
5.6
7
6.4
7.9
2.3
2.5929
2.7888
3.4
4.087
4.7
4.932
5.58.02
0.0041
0.8
0.00002
2.9
3.2079
3.444
4.2
4.9997
5.7
6.0054
6.774
0.006
1
0.00003
3.5
3.9363
4.2188
5.2
6.069
6.9
7.2573
8.1621
0.0085
1.3
0.00004
4.3
5.2
4.793
5.7937
5.1284
6.1891
6.2
7.4
7.3132
8.7519
8.3
9.9
8.7076 10.3774
9.7656 11.6067
0.011
0.015
1.6
1.9
0.00006 0.00009
100oF
5.7
0.022
62
7.4
6.9552
8.2952
7.4184
8.8344
8.8
10.5
10.4053
12.2949
11.7
13.8
12.2888
14.4646
13.7085
16.0948
0.021
0.029
2.4
2.7
0.00013
0.00019
as:
(8 36)
where
LW = working loss, lb/yr
MV = vapor molecular weight, lb/lb-mole; (MV) can be obtained from the Table
8-4 [38]. It may be noted that the molecular weight of gasoline changes
with the change in Reid Vapor Pressure (RVP).
PVA = vapor pressure at daily average liquid surface temperature, psia; see Eq.
(7-20)
Q = annual net throughput (tank capacity [bbl] times annual turnover rate),
bbl/yr
Figure 8-84. A
mbient temperature compared to gasoline surface temperature in a single-wall
(non-insulated) storage tank [39]
N = 5.614 Q / VLX
(8 37)
where
VLX = tank maximum liquid volume, ft3
VLX = p /4 D 2 HLX
(8 38)
D = diameter, ft
HLX = maximum liquid height, ft
KP = working loss product factor, dimensionless for crude oils KP = 0.75
for all other organic liquids, KP = 1
Using the following steps, Eq. (7-36) can be simplified to combine all variables
into one equation.
Using Eq. (8-31), the term MVPVA can be replaced with Eq. (8-38).
MV PVA = WV R TLA
(8 39)
Using a combination of Eq. (7-37) and Eq. (7-38), the term Q can be replaced
with the following Eq. (8-40).
Q = [ N H LX / 5.614 ] ( p /4 ) D 2
(8 40)
LX
( p /4 ) D 2 KN KP WV KB
(8 41)
Figure 8-85. Turn over factors for fixed roof tanks (note: for 36 turnovers/year, or loss, KN = 1.0)
(8 42)
where
LT = total loss, lb/yr
LR = rim seal loss, lb/yr;
LWD = withdrawal loss, lb/yr;
LF = deck fitting loss, lb/yr;
LD = deck seam loss (internal floating roof tanks only), lb/yr.
Loss factors may be estimated for deck fitting configurations at the zero miles-perhour wind speed condition (for internal floating roof tanks-IFRTs and coned floating
roof tanks CFRTs), using standard AP-42 [38].
Figure 8-87. Treatment oil storm water from floating roof tank
Preserve Assets
Reduce Maintenance Costs
Reduce Inspection Cost
Company/Government Requirement
Preserve the Environment
For corrosion to take place, the formation of a corrosion cell is essential. A corrosion cell is comprised of the following four components:
Anode
Cathode
Electrolyte
Metallic path
2. Cathode:
One of the two electrodes in an electrolytic cell represented as a positive
terminal of a cell.
Reduction takes place at the cathode and electrons are consumed.
Volt (Oxidation)
2714 AKTF
2363
1662
1180
0.763
0.440
0.403
0
0.337
0.401
0.799
1500
*Note: The typical potentials given in the above table are normally observed in neutral soils
and water, measured with respect to copper sulfate electrode reference (CSE). It may be
noted that material with more negative potential can protect the less electronegative potential. Thus for example copper can be protected by lead, but not by carbon graphite coke.
Figure 8-90. F
actors affecting defect/crevice corrosion (reproduced after [41]), (Legend: 1Electrolyte, 2Electrolytic environment, 3Mass convection (in/out of defect), 4Defect
solution, 5Electrochemical reaction (metal solution, O2 reduction, H2 evolution),
6Alloy composition (major/minor base elements, impurities), 7Passive film characteristics (passive current or film stability), 8Defect type (metal/metal, metal/nonmetal, metal/marine growth), 9Defect geometry (gap-width, depth), 10Overall
geometry (exterior to interior defect area ratio, number of defects), after [42])
4 Pitting Corrosion
It is a form of localized corrosion of a metal surface where small areas corrode preferentially leading to the formation of cavities or pits, and the bulk
of the surface remains un-attacked (Figure 8-91).
Metals which form passive films, such as aluminum and steels, are more
susceptible to this form of corrosion.
It is the most insidious form of corrosion. It causes failure by penetration
with only a small percent weight-loss of the entire structure.
It is a major type of failure in chemical processing industry. The destructive
nature of pitting is illustrated by the fact that usually the entire system must
be replaced.
Generally, the most conducive environment for pitting is the marine environment. Ions, such as Cl, Br and I, in appreciable concentrations tend to
cause pitting of steel. The sulfate ions also induce pitting of steels.
Aluminum also pits in an environment that cause the pitting of steel. If traces
of Cu2+ are present in water, or Fe+3 ions are in water, copper or iron would
be deposited on aluminum metal surface and pitting would be initiated.
Oxidizing metal ions with chloride, such as cupric, ferric and mercuric,
cause severe pitting.
Presence of dust or dirt particles in water may also lead to pitting corrosion
in copper pipes transporting seawater.
5 Stress Corrosion Cracking and Hydrogen Blistering/Damage
Stress corrosion is the failure of a metal resulting from the conjoint action of stress
and chemical attack (Figure 8-92).
It is a phenomenon associated with a combination of static tensile stress,
environment and in some systems, a metallurgical condition which leads
to component failure due to the initiation and propagation of a high aspect ratio crack.
It is characterized by fine cracks which lead to failure of components are
potentially the structure concerned. Stress corrosion cracking is abbreviated as SCC.
The following conditions are necessary for SCC to occur:
A susceptible metal.
A specific environment.
A tensile or residual stress.
Applications
Rapid heating and quenching
Thermal expansions
Vibrations
Rotation
Bolting (flanged joints)
Pressure (internal or external)
Structural loading
Figure 8-95. Sulfide stress corrosion cracking mechanism (reproduced from [41])
Figure 8-97. AExternal corrosion of tank bottom and Bcorrosion cell [44,45]
(a) There must be an anode, a cathode, an electrolyte and a metallic path for the
transfer of electrons.
(b) A source of DC current to supply electrons.
(c) Sufficient direct current should be applied to eliminate the potential difference
between the anode and the cathode.
Two types of cathodic protection systems exist: Gavanic and Impressed current.
8.7.8.5.1 Galvanic Anode or Sacrificial Anode CP System (Figure 8-99)
Cathodic protection can be applied by connecting sacrificial anodes to a
structure.
Basically, the principle is to create a galvanic cell, with the anode representing
the less noble material that is consumed in the galvanic interaction.
The following advantages are associated with sacrificial anode CP systems:
However, these relatively simple systems also have some limitations such as:
Limited current and power output.
High-resistivity environments or large structures may require excessive
number of electrodes. Maximum resistivity of 6000 to 10,000 ohm-cm is
generally regarded as the limit, depending on coating quality.
Anodes may have to be replaced frequently under high current
demand.
Anodes can increase structural weight if directly attached to a
structure.
Anode types:
For land-based CP applications of structural steel, anodes based on zinc or
magnesium are the most important.
1 Zinc Anode (Figure 8-100)
Zinc anodes employed underground are high-purity Zn alloys, as specified in ASTM B418-95a.
Only the Type II anodes in this standard are applicable to buried soil
applications.
For zinc anodes, the mass-based theoretical capacity is relatively low at
780 Ah/kg, but efficiencies are high at around 90%.
2 Magnesium Anode (Figure 8-101)
Magnesium anodes generally have a low efficiency at 50% or even lower.
The theoretical capacity is around 2200 Ah/kg (Amper.hour/kg)
The magnesium alloys are also high-purity grades and have the advantage
of a higher driving voltage.
3 Aluminum-Indium Anode
These are mostly employed for seawater applications.
The base metal contains 98-99% of aluminum.
The rate of consumption varies between 7 and 9 lb/A-year. The efficiency
varies between 87 and 95%.
8.7.8.5.2 Impressed Current CP System In impressed current systems cathodic
protection is applied by means of an external power current source (Figure 8-102).
In contrast to the sacrificial anode systems, the anode consumption rate is usually
much lower. Unless a consumable scrap anode is used, a negligible anode consumption rate is actually a key requirement for long system life.
Impressed current systems typically are favored under high-current requirements
and/or high-resistance electrolyte.
Advantages:
High current and power output range.
Ability to adjust (tune) the protection levels.
Figure 8-104. Anode and reference cell placement in high resistance sand under tank bottom
Figure 8-105. C
P installation on double tank bottom with liner [44, 45]. Inset: rain water seepage under tank bottom
NACE RP0193-01 - External Cathodic Protection of On-Grade Metallic Storage Tanks: Galvanic protection systems can be applied to tank bottoms where
the metallic surface area exposed to the electrolyte can be minimized through
the application of a dielectric coating or the area is small due to the tank size
or configuration.
Figure 8-106. A
node installation and CP cable conduit under an Above Ground Storage Tank
(AST)
Tank Shell
CP Rectifier
Tank Bottom
Tank Pad
Tank Pad
CP Rectifier
-ve
+ve
Power
Supply
Conduit to Reference
Cell monitoring
Figure 8-110. Typical impressed current CP system in above ground storage tank
liquid. In such a design, the fire would more likely be limited to the damaged tank and
the contents would not be spilled. This section describes the types of tanks that may
be prone to catastrophic failure and maintenance practices that can help prevent the
accidents [46].
8.8.1.1 Past Accidents
Several accidents have occurred in which storage tanks have failed catastrophically
when the flammable vapors inside an atmospheric tank exploded (Table 8-8). Table
8-8 indicates some of the incidences due to catastrophic hydrocarbon storage tank
failures.
The specific incidents demonstrate the potential dangers posed to personnel, the
public, and the environment when these storage tanks fail catastrophically. Often
maintenance personnel were performing tank maintenance or other activities that introduced an ignition source. The vapors were ignited either inside the tank or outside
and then flashed back into the tank.
From Table 8-8, it is clear that catastrophic failures of tanks have occurred in the
past, resulting in either complete removal of the tank wall when the tank rockets due to
an explosion in the vapor space, or an unzipping due to rapid brittle fracture initiated
at a defect. Failures have also occurred in earthquakes, although it is not clear how
rapid the failures were.
8.8.1.2 Causes of Tank Failures Hazards
Tank design and inspection/maintenance practices are factors directly related to catastrophic tank failure.
Tank design: Historically, accidents where the shell-to-bottom seam fails
are more common among older storage tanks. Steel storage tanks built before
1950 generally do not conform to current industry standards for explosion and
fire venting. Atmospheric tanks used for storage of flammable and combustible
liquids should be designed to fail along the shell-to-roof seam when an explosion
occurs in the tank. This prevents the tank from propelling upward or splitting
along the side. Several organizations have developed standards and specifications
for storage tank design. Published standards relevant to this design feature include
API-650 Welded Steel Tanks for Oil Storage issued by the American Petroleum
Institute (API). Additional codes and standards, published by API and other organizations, address tank design, construction, venting, and safe welding and are
listed at the end of this alert.
Inspection, maintenance, and repair practices: Tanks that are poorly maintained, rarely inspected, or repaired without attention to design, risk catastrophic
failure in the event of a vapor explosion. Either weakening of the shell-to-bottom
seam through corrosion or strengthening the shell-to-roof seam relative to the
shell-to-bottom seamwill increase the vulnerability of the tank to failure along
the shell-to-bottom seam. The practice of placing gravel and spill absorbants
around the base of the tank, may increase the likelihood of bottom corrosion.
Given years of this practice, the bottom of some tanks, especially older ones, may
be below ground level, thereby trapping moisture along the tank bottom. This
1970
1976
1978
1987
1988
1989
1992
1994
1995
1997
2000
2001
2003
2003
2009
(Figure 8-111)
can weaken the bottom and the shell-to-bottom seam. Alternatively, changes to
the roof seam such as modifications to or replacement of the roof, or attachments
to the roof, could make the roof-to-shell seam stronger relative to the shell-tobottom seam.
Other hazards that can contribute to a tank explosion and possible consequences
are:
Emission of Combustible vapor
Presence of ignition source
Proximity
Figure 8-111. Puerto Rico refinery/tank farm explosion (Oct 2009, www.ffti.com.au)
Some of the above steps not covered elsewhere in this document are described
below.
8.8.2.1.1 Fluid in the Tank The information on type and characteristics of the
stored liquid hydrocarbon is essential to understanding the inherent hazards of the
liquid. This should include specific data and whether or not the liquid is a flammable
or combustible liquid.
Such a data is essential for developing an effective site fire protection plan. Data
related to specific hazards of fuel stored should include data from the Material Safety
Data Sheet (MSDS) on flash and boiling points, molecular weight, vapor density, and
flammable range. The key terms that define flammable and combustible liquids fire
hazards are Flashpoint and Vapor Pressure. These information provide the vital information used for emergency planning and fire prevention.
Flashpoint This is the liquid temperature at which a liquid releases sufficient
vapor to form an ignitable mixture with air, either near the liquid surface or
within a storage tank. Flashpoint can be determined by a flashpoint tester and
is the basis for hazard classification.
There is a direct connection between volatility and flashpoint. A liquid with a flashpoint near normal temperatures, without being heated, will produce vapor that can
be ignited by a small ignition source; such as a spark or pilot flame. Flashpoint and
boiling point temperatures are reduced as altitude increases since liquid volatility
increases with reduced atmospheric pressure. Hydrocarbon liquids that are combustible at sea level may be more hazardous as atmospheric pressure is reduced.
Vapor Pressure This is the pressure, measured in kPa (Psia) is exerted by vapor
against the atmosphere. Just as the atmosphere exerts pressure on the hydrocarbon
Flammable Liquids Any liquid with a closed-cup (type of flashpoint test) flashpoint below 37.8C (100F) and a Reid vapor pressure not exceeding 2068 mm Hg
(6 kPa, 40 psia) is a flammable liquid. These liquids are referred to as Class I liquids.
Liquid classifications are further divided into three classifications as follows:
Class IA liquids have flashpoints below 22.8C (73F) and boiling points
below 37.8C (100F).
Class IB liquids have flashpoints below 22.8C (73F) and boiling points at
or above 37.8C (100F).
Class IC liquids have flashpoints at or above 22.8C (73F), but below
37.8C (100F).
Gasoline, Jet B, and JP 4 are typical examples of a flammable liquid.
Tank Type
Floating roof
Internal
External
Domed
Fixed roof
Overfill
Fire
Vent Fire
Rim-Seal
Fire
Obstructed Full
Surface Fire
Unobstructed
Full Surface Fire
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Figure 8-112. Fire scenario in above ground open floating roof tank
Where the roof is a pan configuration, see discussion below on Fixed Roof
Tanks.
Fixed (Cone) Roof Tanks Fire exposure to a tank increases internal pressure
from boiling liquids or, very rarely, from an internal explosion. Fixed roof tanks
are designed to vent during an emergency by opening weak roof-to-shell joint
seams at the point of panel attachment to the tank shell. The weak seam allows
the roof to tear free from the tank shell to prevent failure of other joints.
An internal pan roof floats on the liquid. These roofs are typically constructed of honeycombed aluminum panels, metal on plastic/foam floats or similar style roof design.
This type of roof lacks substantial support and stability inherent in an open or covered
floating roof tank and is not fire resistant. A common failure mode for this style of roof
is tilting or sinking resulting in fire exposure to the tank. This style of roof is commonly
used for emission control purposes, but is unlikely to have a substantial effect on tank
fire safety. Installation of a pan roof can also result in blocking application of foam
during a fire, especially where the tank is protected by sub-surface foam and/or the roof
sinks blocked foam inlets.
8.8.2.1.3 Tank Location/Accessibility The location of a tank facility has a direct
impact on fire safety. The tank location should be arranged to prevent exposing fires from
spreading into the tank farm; and conversely adjacent buildings should be located so that
a fire in the tank farm will not spread off of the property or spread to adjacent tanks.
NFPA 30 contains requirements for spacing between tanks and to or from property
lines and adjacent structures and facilities. These distances are minimal and increased
spacing may be beneficial when constructing a new facility since increased separation
will reduce risk of fire exposure. Reference should be made to NFPA 30 minimum
spacing requirements during emergency planning to prepare for exposure protection
during fire fighting operations. See also previous Figure 8-45 Storage Tank Spacing
for Chemical/Oil Plants.
Accessibility is a key factor in effective storage tank fire control.Fire fighting operations require separation from the tanks in order to avoid fire exposure to fire equipment and personnel. Where subsurface inlets are installed for tank fire control, access
to foam inlets should be outside the dike area or in an easily accessible location where
tank shell connections are utilized.
Welding, cutting and similar spark producing operations should only be conducted
under a strict hot work control system. Adequate controls for hot work should include
comprehensive testing of the area to assure that flammable vapors are not present in the
work area. All combustibles that may be ignited by hot sparks from hot work should be
removed or properly protected to prevent against ignition.
Static electricity controls start with proper operating practices and controls to
minimize the potential for generation of static electricity. Metallic equipment should
be bonded or grounded when used in areas where an ignitable mixture could be
present. All non-metallic equipment and piping, where an ignitable mixture could
be present, should be carefully reviewed to assure that the generation of static is not
a possibility.
NFPA 70, The National Electrical Code addresses electrical equipment design
and installation. In areas where there is likely to be the presence of an ignitable vapor
mixture, the equipment would be required to meet requirements for electrical area classification in accordance with NFPA 30 and 70.
NFPA 30 requires an engineering evaluation of the installation and operation to
determine the extent of fire prevention and control measures followed by the application of sound fire protection and process engineering principles. The analysis is required to include:
Analysis of fire and explosion hazards of the facility;
Analysis of local conditions, such as exposure to and from adjacent properties,
flood potential or earthquake potential; and
Fire department or mutual aid response.
8.8.2.1.7 Fire Prevention Measures Fire Protection measures for storage
tanks would be best to consider the relative hazard of the stored materials instead
of on every tank regardless of hazard. Consideration would include the relative
hazard of the stored materials, the hazards inherent in the type of tanks in the
storage facility, and the availability of public and private fire fighting support and
equipment.
NFPA 30 requires that a fire-extinguishing system be provided for vertical atmospheric fixed-roof storage tanks storing Class I flammable liquids larger than 1.2 106I
(1200 bbls) capacity. Fire Protection is especially desirable where tanks are located
in a congested area with an unusual exposure hazard between the tank and adjacent
property. Fixed roof tanks storing Class II or III liquids at temperatures below their
flashpoints and floating roof tanks storing any liquid, generally do not require protection when the tanks are installed in compliance with spacing and installation requirements of NFPA 30.
Water Pressure Water cooling streams can be taken directly from fire hydrants,
however, hydrant residual pressure less than 550 kPag (80 psig) will require fire
truck booster pumps to supply hose streams. As an example, a 945 liter/minute
(250 gpm) cooling stream will reach over the curb angle of about 22m (75 foot)
high tank from a horizontal distance of 20 m (65 ft) with 345 kPag (50 psig) nozzle
pressure using a solid stream nozzle of 28 mm (11/8 inches). Minimum residual
hydrant outlet pressure should be 550 kPag (80psig) in order to supply 189 liter/
minute (50 gpm) through 75 m (250 ft) of 38mm (1in.) fire hose.
Fire Mains and Hydrants The storage tank farm fire water demand is based on
the quantity of water required to protect the largest cone roof tank, plus the water
needed for cooling hose streams to protect exposed tanks or adjacent facilities.
As a general rule of thumb sufficient water will be required to extinguish a fire
in the largest tank, plus the amount of water required for protection of unshielded
neighboring tanks. Water pressure in the hydrants and the water system should be
adequate to provide 700 kPag (100 psig) residual pressure when flowing sufficient
water to supply cooling streams directly from hydrants.
A fire water system looped around the facility provides flexibility during use.
Isolation of damaged sections without impairment of the entire fire protection system can be aided by provision of division valves arranged so that any section of
the fire main grid or loop may be removed from service while fire water continues
Kerosene,
Diesel,
Jet Fuel,
Heptane,
Crude Oil
Ethanol,
Methanol,
Ketone,
Acetone
Minimum Discharge
Time
Minimum
Application Rate
30 min.
0.10 gpm/ft.
4.1 L/min./m2
55 min.
0.10 gpm/ft.
4.1 L/min./m2
Crude Petroleum
55 min.
0.10 gpm/ft.
4.1 L/min./m2
NOTE: The maximum application rate shall be 0.20 gpm/ft. (8.1 L/min./m.)
Tank diameter, m
Minimum number
outlets
24
24 to 36
36 to 42
42 to 48
48 to 54
54 to 60
1
2
3
4
5
6
Figure 8-113. T
ypical foam system: balance pressure pump skid with proportioner (from [49]
www.Buckeyef.com, [11])
Foam Dam installed on roof Yes 2 ft. from tank wall and 2 ft. in height
Sq. ft. area of annular ring 930 sq. ft.
Application Rate 0.30 gpm per sq. ft. (Per NFPA 11),0.30 930 sq. ft. = 279
gpm of foam solution required.
Type of Discharge Device Foam Makers
Discharge Duration 20 min. 279 20 = 5,580 gallons of foam solution
0.03 (3% AFFF) = 167.4 gallons of foam concentrated
Quantity of Foam Makers Required (Per NFPA 11) 6 required.
Supplementary hose lines may be added as per example for Cone Roof.
Figure 8-114. T
ypical semi fixed foam system (with mobile apparatus supplying the foam
solution), Buckeye www.buckeyef.com, [49], Inset: Chemguards [48]
Hydrocarbon Type
Minimum Application
Rate gpm/ft2
(L/min.)/m2 (min.)
Minimum
Discharge
Time
0.16 6.5
50
0.16 6.5
65
0.16 6.5
65
fire fighting chemicals, develop procedures for all operations and plans for controlling
emergencies, and last but not least, conducting drills to practice emergency plans and
procedures.
Because of the large foam demands required for ground spill fires, Command should
consider assigning at least one group to ensure the availability of required volume and
type of foam. This group is responsible for ensuring that a sufficient volume of foam is
available to control the fire and to assist in maintaining a constant supply during foam
water solution application. The group is also responsible for ensuring that enough foam
remains on-hand for continuous application if, after extinguishment, fire firefighters
Figure 8-115. T
ypical connection for firefighting facilities, A Siamese Twin and B: dual fitting
foam connection
must enter into the spill area. It is usual that at least 50% of the amount of foam required for extinguishment be available, especially if tank overhaul is required.
8.9.4.2 Water Supply
The Complexs Tank Tactical Guidelines must contain water supply data and available
sources for the tank farm.
8.9.4.3 Exposure Protection
When exposure protection is required, large volume water streams should be used for
reach and cooling capacity. Water application must be managed to avoid breaking-up
foam blankets or increasing the problems of fuel spills.
Steam production should be used as a guide to protecting exposures: If steam is
created when water strikes the surface of the tank, the need for protection is indicated.
Tanks generally require little protection on vertical surfaces below the liquid level.
Some of the tank farm facilities have fixed monitor nozzles that can be used to apply cooling water onto tanks that require exposure protection. Such facilities are usually
identified in the Storage Tank Tactical Guidelines book for the Tank farm complex.
a- Valve Protection
Product control valves on the storage tanks are beneficial because they can be used
to route liquid from a fire-involved tank to an empty or partially full tank. Failing to
protect these valves in the event of a ground spill fire may prevent tank farm personnel
from routing liquid from fire exposed or damaged tanks. In the event of a ground spill
fire that does not submerge the valve in liquid, a fire stream should be applied to each
valve that may be subjected to heat damage. The use of protective streams will protect
the operating components of the valves so that they are not damaged.
b- Utility Control
If disconnecting the electric power is considered as part of the incident tactics, it is
necessary to discuss the requirement with the tank farm personnel of the implications
of this disconnection. Disconnecting power can shut down transfer pumps used to remove spilled products at loading racks, cause motor operated valves on storage tanks
to close which prevents subsurface foam injection, and disable controls for all the
storage tanks.
REFERENCES