Determinants of Youth Sexual Behaviour: Program Implications For India
Determinants of Youth Sexual Behaviour: Program Implications For India
Determinants of Youth Sexual Behaviour: Program Implications For India
Original Article
Department of Operational Research, National Institute for Research in Reproductive Health, J.M.Street, Parel
Abstract. The objective of this paper is to review the current trend of premarital sexual behaviour among youth in
India and the factors influencing this behaviour. Studies done in India in the last two decades were considered for
the review. However due to paucity of data it could not be a systematic review and data from other developing
countries was considered for comparison. Available data indicates high level of premarital and unsafe sexual
activity among youth in India. Limited evidence reveals that the risk and protective factors, which play a role in
determining the sexual activity of youth in developing countries are different from those in the west and they are
more centered on the youth themselves. Small-scale studies done in India also highlight the factors related to the
environment such as peers and family apart from individual factors. However the review highlights the need to
conduct large-scale representative studies to explore the comprehensive picture of risk and protective factors that
could apply to the youth in India, which has a diverse socio-cultural milieu across regions. Programs must focus on
the interventions, which improve the protective factors and reduce the risk factors and not focus only on risk
awareness alone. Adolescent's access to friendly services and an enabling environment in the community can
improve their health seeking behavior. However multiple players other than health sector such as education, media
and social agencies need to work in unison to promote protective factors that prevent unwanted health outcomes
due to unsafe premarital sex.
Key words: Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health (ARSH), premarital sexual activity, risk and protective
factors, safe sex, adolescents and youth
1. Introduction
Adolescents complete their physical, emotional
and psychological journey to adulthood in a
changing world that contains both: opportunities
as well as dangers. They need a balanced healthy
social, physical and mental environment to enable
them to cope with a list of vulnerable and delicate
issues. The adolescents are tempted more and
more to experiment with sexual activities
resulting in divergent sexual behaviors and casual
sexual relationships. They are exposed to risks of
unwanted
teenage
pregnancy,
sexually
transmitted infections including HIV/AIDS, drug
abuse,
nutritional
disorders
and
sexual
exploitation at workplace, especially child labor.
*
113
114
Original Article
adolescent and young women have experienced
non-consensual sexual relations (24).
Small-scale community-based studies of 1524year-olds in urban slums and rural settings in
Maharashtra reveal that overall 1618% of young
men and 1-2% of young women reported having
had premarital sex. (25,26) There seems to be
common pattern as regards to the age of coital
debut among boys, which is seventeen years as
reported in a number of studies. Findings from
youth survey across different states confirm that
pre-marital sex is by and large unsafe. Findings
also show that sizeable proportions of sexually
experienced youth had indeed engaged in
multiple partner relations before marriage. While
few young women reported that they had engaged
in sexual relations, very few reported multiple
pre-marital partners. Moreover, consistent
condom use was also limited. Among youth who
reported pre-marital sex, fewer than 10% of
young men and women in most states reported
that they had always used a condom (23).
National AIDS Control Organization has also
reported that sexual activity is frequently risky.
Casual sex and relations with sex workers are
often reported by young males (27). A behaviour
surveillance study conducted by AVERT in seven
districts of Maharashtra among female college
going students revealed 95% female college
students had reported penetrative sex and only
26% among them did not use condoms (28).
115
116
Original Article
Table 1. Risk (-) and protective factors (+) that affect adolescent sexual behaviour, pregnancy, childbearing, HIV AIDS
and STIs
Environmental factors
Individual factors
Family
Family structure
+ Father is present
- Stepfather is present
Mobility
-Residential mobility
Educational achievement
Peer
+ In school
Popularity
+ Literate
- Repeated a grade
Union status
- Engaged
Romantic partner
- Divorced/separated/widowed
Characteristics of partner
Biological factors
(K Mmari and Robert Blum, July 1, 2005, Department of Population and Family Health Sciences, John Hopkins
Bloomberg School of Public Health)
117
3. Discussion
The declining age at puberty and the increasing
age at marriage has created a growing period in
which young people may engage in premarital
sexual relations. Likewise, evidence that large
proportions of youth remain in school for
extended periods suggests that opportunities to
spend time together in acceptable places away
from the watchful eyes of parents will increase.
The trends of premarital sexual activity among
adolescents and young people in India in the last
two decades have not shown an increase and have
Table 2. Role of different sectors in improving adolescent reproductive health common programming framework
developed globally by WHO, UNFPA and UNICEF - Action for adolescent health towards a common agenda
recommendations from a joint study group WHO, UNFPA, UNICEF
Health sector
Education
sector
Media
+++
++
++
Services and
counselling
+++
Safe and
supportive
environment
++
++
+++
Opportunities to
participate
++
Issues
Information and
life skills
+ Denotes the grades in which different sectors can play a major role and influence adolescents
118
Original Article
high divorce rates are related to early sexual
initiation (41). However, strict parental
supervision did not prove to be a protective
factor. Studies done in African countries also
showed that communication with parents and
family members about avoiding sex and the use
of contraception had only nominal effects among
youth (42). Religious beliefs, education,
occupation and income of parents also did not
influence the sexual behaviors of youth (37).
These studies reveal that having restrictions and
supervisions and strict social norms on youth of
today seem to be less effective. Gatekeepers and
peers must communicate with adolescents and
young people on issues of sex and sexuality, the
risk of experimentation and empower them to
make safe decisions in order to achieve better
reproductive health outcomes.
A review of risk factors associated with
premarital sexual activity in developing countries
showed that they were primarily related to the
adolescents' themselves (39). Very few factors
outside the individual were found to be related to
sexual risk behaviors. Only one study in the
Indian context looking at premarital sex as an
outcome was available for this review. Most of
the studies were from African context. However
the conclusions cannot be generalized to
developing countries as such because the sociocultural milieu is very different in Africa
compared to India even though both are
developing countries. At the individual level with
the exception of exchanging sex for money, the
factors that were found significant for adolescent
reproductive health outcomes in developing
countries were also found significant in the
United States of America. However our review
did not highlight any such factor in the Indian
context. Education status or being academically
good turned out to be significant protective
factor. However, with the growing literacy rates
and young people finding many more
opportunities to interact with the opposite sex
while in school/college, this dimension needs
further exploration in India.
4. Conclusions
Under the RCH-II framework of Government of
India, a National Adolescent Reproductive and
Sexual Health (ARSH) Strategy to implement
adolescent health component in the existing
public health system has been designed. The
strategy highlights the need to create awareness
and a supportive environment for improving
health-seeking behaviour of adolescents. It
focuses on awareness generation communication
119
7.
References
16.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
120
Original Article
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
Maharashtra,
International
Family
Planning
Perspectives December 2007; India Volume 33,
Number 4.
Joshi B, Chauhan S, Ghule M, Kulkarni R.
Developing Service Delivery Models for providing
adolescent reproductive and sexual health services:
NIRRH experiences in Gynecological Manual on
Adolescent girls and young women A FOGSI
publication by Jaypee publishers 2009; 401-421.
NACO; National Baseline General Population
Behaviour Surveillance Survey 2001; 52-56.
Gerard JM, Buehler C. Cumulative environmental
risk and youth maladjustment: the role of youth
attributes. Child Dev 2004; 75: 1832-1849.
Jessor R. Adolescence as a critical life stage, paper
presented at the WHO/UNICEF Adolescence
Consultative Meeting, Washington, DC 2000; 12
16.
Kirby D. Antecedents of adolescent initiation of
sex, contraceptive use, and pregnancy. Am J Health
Behav 2002; 26: 473-485.
Serovich J, Green K. Predictors of adolescent sexual
risk taking behaviors which put them at risk for
contracting HIV. Journal of Youth and Adolescence
1997; 26: 429444.
Mott FL, Fondell MM, Hu PN, Kowaleski-Jones L,
Menaghan EG. The determinants of first sex by age
14 in a high-risk adolescent population. Fam Plann
Perspect 1996; 28: 13-18.
Holtzman D, Rubinson R. Parent and peer
communication effects on AIDS-related behavior
among U.S. high school students. Fam Plann
Perspect 1995; 27: 235-240.
Blum RW, Ireland M. Reducing risk, increasing
protective factors: findings from the Caribbean
Youth Health Survey. J Adolesc Health 2004; 35:
493-500.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
121