06 BDNG3103 T2
06 BDNG3103 T2
06 BDNG3103 T2
2 Political, Legal
and Economic
Systems
LEARNING OUTCOMES
By the end of this topic, you should be able to:
1. Explain the diversity of culture and how the various elements of
culture impact the international firms decisions;
2. Describe the basic political ideologies that exist;
3. Examine the types of political risks faced by international firms
operating in countries with differing systems;
4. Assess the basic legal systems of the world and how they influence
the international firm; and
5. Appraise several types of economic systems and their impact on
firms.
INTRODUCTION
In this topic, we will shift our attention to study in greater depth on the
differences among countries in the aspects of their culture, political and legal,
and economic systems of which we have briefly mentioned in the first topic.
products to be sold, how they are promoted and distributed, and pricing
strategies will all be strongly influenced by these factors.
2.1 CULTURE
The following subtopics explain the elements that constitute culture and how the
activities of international business can be affected when cultures differ among
foreign countries.
The Center for Advance Research on Language Acquisition goes a step further,
defining culture as shared patterns of behaviours and interactions, cognitive
constructs, and understanding that are learned by socialisation. Thus, it can be
seen as the growth of a group identity fostered by social patterns unique to the
group.
Culture can be defined as a system of values and norms that are shared
among a group of people (such as in a society) and when taken together,
they constitute a design for living.
Values are shared assumptions about how things ought to be, for example,
about what a group believes to be good, right and desirable.
Norms mean the social rules and guidelines that prescribe the appropriate
behaviour in particular situations within the society. A society may be
equivalent to a country.
SELF-CHECK 2.1
The process of adjusting and adapting to a specific culture other than our
own is known as acculturation, a key success factor in international
operations.
Definition of Acculturation
(a) Cultural modification of an individual, group, or people by adapting to
or borrowing traits from another culture.
(b) A merging of culture as a result of prolonged contact.
(c) The process by which a human being acquires the culture of a
particular society from infancy.
Source: www.Merriam-Webster.com/dictionary/acculturation
A societys culture determines the rules that govern how firms operate in the
society. Firms must build awareness of the cultural diversity of international
markets to operate effectively. Problems may arise when a person from one
culture has to adjust to another culture.
The basic elements that determine culture are social structure, religion, values
and attitudes, language and education, as seen in Figure 2.1, followed by
explanations of each in the subsequent subtopics.
Although all societies involve individuals living in family units and work
groups, they define family and groups differently and place different importance
on the role of the individual. Americans define the basic family unit as
comprising parents and their children. The Arabs consider uncles, cousins and
in-laws as part of the family unit, while the Somalian society is organised into
clans comprising individuals of the same tribe. American societies therefore
promote individualism and encourage the development of individual talents.
Japanese societies are group-focused and the individuals role is to serve the
group. As employees, their work attitudes will also be similarly focused.
Social stratification systems exist because each culture values some people more
highly than others and distinguish a person by their social class or status. The
caste system in India and the British class structure are examples of this system.
Firms operating in such societies need to take class differences, for example
between supervisors and workers, into account when hiring and promoting
employees. This is to avoid assigning jobs traditionally performed by members of
one group to another group as it may lower the morale and productivity of the
groups concerned.
Social mobility refers to the ability of individuals to move from one class to
another within society. In a rigid system like in India, a lower caste member may
face difficulty interacting and gaining the cooperation of colleagues when they
are promoted to higher supervisory roles.
Apart from workplace relations, the international firm may also need to tailor
promotional messages more carefully so as not to offend groups not targeted.
There are numerous religions in the world today, some of which are very
influential in certain parts of the world. The major ones, in terms of number of
followers are Christianity with 1.7 billion followers, Islam with 1 billion,
Hinduism with 750 million and Buddhism with 350 million followers. Although
Confucianism is more a set of guiding principles than a religion, it also has an
important ethical influence on culture and behaviour in certain parts of Asia.
Christianity has three main branches which are Roman Catholic, Orthodox and
Protestant. According to the German sociologist Max Weber, Protestant ethics
emphasises on the importance of individual hard work, achievement and
frugality for the glory of God. They strive constantly for efficiency, savings and
reinvestment of profits for future productivity, all of which are necessary in a
capitalist economy and entrepreneurial activity.
Hinduism and Buddhism stress the afterlife and spiritual achievement rather
than involvement in this world. Hinduism believes that the way to achieve
spiritual perfection is by leading a severe ascetic lifestyle of material and physical
self-denial. However, Buddhism does not support the Hindu caste system and
may be more encouraging towards entrepreneurial activity than Hinduism.
Confucianism has 150 million followers throughout Asia. It has been characterised
more as a code of conduct rather than a religion with the emphasis on loyalty and
relationships. The economic success of Japan, South Korea, Singapore and China
could be a result of loyalty to central authority and placing the good of the group
before that of the individual.
Values are the principles and standards that have been internalised and
accepted by members of a society.
Attitudes are the thoughts, feelings and actions resulting from those values.
Thus, cultural attitudes towards time, age and status may reflect these values and
influence the opportunities available to international business in a given society.
(a) Time
Attitude towards time differ greatly among cultures. In western cultures,
time means an opportunity to produce more and increase ones income and
is not to be wasted. In Latin America, it is not unusual if meetings begin 45
minutes late and meetings may be interrupted by the host entertaining
unscheduled visitors like family and friends. Westerners may wrongly
interpret the hospitality of the host as a sign of rudeness and disrespect.
In other cultures like the Japanese and the Arabs, meetings may start on
time but initial meetings would focus on establishing relationships and
determining whether the parties can trust and work with each other
comfortably. In contrast, Westerners expect to get down to business
immediately after exchanging a few pleasantries and follow a set agenda.
(b) Age
While youthfulness is considered a virtue in a society like the United States
and may send young high achievers to negotiate with international
partners, the Asian and Arab cultures respect age and correlates a
managers stature with age. Similarly, the Chinese would prefer to deal
with older and more senior members of a firm and may feel offended when
dealing with young counterparts.
(c) Status
Values and attitudes towards the means by which a person achieves
his/her status also vary across the different cultures. In some societies,
status may be inherited through the wealth or rank of a persons ancestors,
such as the noble class in some European countries. In the United States,
however, hard working entrepreneurs are held in high regard and their
children would not be similarly respected if they fail to match their parents
achievements.
2.1.5 Language
Language shapes the way people perceive the world and helps define culture. In
countries with more than one language, we may also find more than one culture,
such as the English-speaking and the French-speaking cultures in Canada.
Language may be verbal and messages are conveyed by the words used and how
they are spoken, for example, the tone of the voice. Messages may also be
communicated through non-verbal means by way of gestures, body position and
eye contact.
Firms also need to exercise more care in the use of language in conveying
advertising messages. There often is a need for advertisements originally in the
language of the home country to be accurately translated into the local language
and words used have to be carefully selected to avoid difficulty in pronouncing
them.
2.1.6 Education
A countrys education system, both public and private, plays an important role in
the transmitting and sharing of culture. Countries education systems have
varying emphasis on the quality of their education, whether based on particular
skills or the overall level of the education. Japan and South Korea emphasise on
the sciences more than the Western countries and Germany on apprenticeship
programmes for craftsmen and machinists. The United States system stresses on
the development of self-reliance, creativity and self-esteem, and provides
widespread access to higher education.
ACTIVITY 2.1
Which basic culture element do you think has the biggest influence on
the growth of international business?
EXERCISE 2.1
We shall now learn about the political ideologies upon which countries base their
political systems and the risks associated with doing business in different
countries.
(a) Collectivism
This refers to a political system that places primary importance on
collective goals rather than individual goals. The needs of society as a
whole are generally held as more important than individual freedom.
Collectivism was firstly advocated by Plato (427347 B.C), who believed
that individual rights should be sacrificed for the good of the majority,
property should be commonly owned and society should be divided into
classes with philosophers and soldiers who would rule for the benefit of all.
In the 20th century, the socialist ideology can be divided into the
communists, who believed that socialism can be achieved only through
violent revolutions and totalitarian dictatorship, and the social democrats,
who strived to achieve socialism by democratic means. Communism has
weakened with the collapse of the Soviet Union and in the countries of
Eastern Europe in 1989, as well as other nations such as Cambodia, Laos,
Vietnam, Angola and Mozambique. Many believe that it is now only a
matter of time before communism in China will also collapse. In Great
Britain, France, Germany, India and Brazil, social democratic parties have
held power from time to time, where private companies in certain
industries have been nationalised into state-owned enterprises to be run for
the good of the public. However, it has been shown that state-run
companies performed poorly and has become inefficient, counter to public
(b) Individualism
Individualism refers to a philosophy that the individual should have the
freedom to pursue his or her own economic and political beliefs. It stresses
that the interest of the individual should take precedence over the interest
of the state. This ideology can be traced to another Greek philosopher,
Aristotle (384322 B.C.). He argued that private property receive the
greatest care and is therefore more highly productive.
(c) Democracy
Democracy refers to a political system by which a country is governed by
the people, exercised directly or through elected representatives. It goes
hand-in-hand with individualism.
In ancient Greece, the pure form of democracy was practised with the
citizens direct involvement in government decision making. However, the
large populations of modern societies have made this impractical. Todays
democratic countries practise what is known as representative democracy,
where the citizens elect individuals to represent them in government. If the
elected representatives fail to perform his/her job adequately, they will be
voted out at the next election. An ideal representative democracy is
indicated by the following basic characteristics:
(iii) A regular election in which all eligible citizens are allowed to vote;
(d) Totalitarianism
Totalitarianism is a form of government in which one person or one
political party exercises absolute control over all areas of human life and
prohibits opposing political parties. The individuals right to freedom of
expression and organisation, free media and regular elections are denied to
the citizens.
There are four major forms of totalitarianism in the world today. Up to the
demise of the Soviet Union, the most widespread form was communist
totalitarianism, which is a version of collectivism advocating that socialism
can only be achieved through totalitarian dictatorship.
ACTIVITY 2.2
(a) Ownership risks, whereby the property of the firm is threatened through
expropriation or confiscation.
(c) Transfer risks, when the government interferes with a firms ability to shift
funds into and out of the country.
Political risks may be the result of government actions through passing of laws. It
may also arise from non-governmental actions, such as kidnappings, extortion
and terrorism. Although political risks may occur in democratic as well as in
totalitarian political regimes, they are more likely to happen in totalitarian
countries.
Legal systems differ based on their historical, cultural, political and religious
backgrounds. There are three basic systems of law:
Common law and civil law differ because the former is based on the courts
interpretation of events, whereas civil law is based on how the law is
applied to the facts of the case. For example, contracts in a common law
country tend to be detailed, with all the terms and conditions spelled out. In
Copyright Open University Malaysia (OUM)
48 TOPIC 2 CULTURAL, POLITICAL, LEGAL AND ECONOMIC SYSTEMS
a civil law country, they tend to be shorter and less specific because many
of the issues detailed in a common law contract are already included in the
civil code. The courts will interpret civil law with reference to these codes.
Islamic law not only concerns moral behaviour but it also extends to cover
commercial activities. It is intended to govern all aspects of life. Several
Islamic countries such as Iran, Sudan, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, for
example, have adopted Islamic banking systems and banned traditional
commercial banking. They have pronounced interest to be non-Islamic and
illegal. Banks therefore cannot charge interest or benefit from interest and
instead structure fees into their loans to allow them to make a profit.
ACTIVITY 2.3
However, the international practice of law is not without barriers. Cultural and
political differences between countries which influence the law still remain.
Apart from the law itself, rules and procedures pertaining to the practice of law
also varies from country to country. There are different professional codes
governing lawyers standards of conduct regarding issues such as confidentiality,
fees, conflicts of interest and publicity.
Law firms also face barriers in extending their services due to government
restrictions on foreign firms from hiring local lawyers, forming partnerships with
local law firms or entering the country to practice law. Other countries may allow
foreigners to open offices within their borders to offer their services. For
example, until 1986 the Japanese market for legal services was closed to foreign
lawyers who wanted to practise in Japan. Germany blocks the practice of foreign
lawyers and the establishment of foreign firms within their country until very
recently. Hong Kong and Singapore, however, welcome foreign law firms, while
the European Community (EC) countries are beginning to relax their rules for
lawyers from other EC member countries.
For the international business firm, its need for legal services can be obtained
through several ways. The larger firms may set up its in-house legal department
by recruiting trained lawyers. When it is necessary to have local representation,
they may choose a law firm that has overseas connections who can represent
them through their foreign branch offices, affiliates or correspondent
relationships. However, smaller international business firms still rely on outside
legal counsel for their needs.
EXERCISE 2.2
6. What are the three types of political risks? How may they affect the
international business firm?
In most market economies, monopolies are against the law, such as the anti-
trust laws in the United States. Monopolies emerge when they are allowed
to restrict supply. Rather than increasing output when demand increases,
the monopolist restricts output and let prices increase. Since they have no
competitors, they have no incentive to look for better ways to lower their
production costs. Although this situation is good for the monopoly firm, it
is bad for consumers and society as a whole.
ACTIVITY 2.4
Table 2.1: List of Countries by GDP (PPP) Per Capita Growth Rate from 19902014
From Table 2.1, among the richest countries are Japan, Switzerland,
Germany and the United Kingdom 5,701% respectively. Switzerland, one of
the worlds richest nations had a GDP per capita (per head of population)
of USD59,540 (2014), whereas Mozambique (not shown in table), with a
GNP per capita of only USD1,129 (2014), is one of the worlds poorest.
Large countries such as India and China are among the poorest and very
dynamic countries. Large nations such as China and India achieved
USD13,206 and USD5,701 with 1247.62% and 397.43% GDP growth rates
respectively from 19902014.
GDP per capita figures, however, can be misleading because it does not
consider the differences in the cost of living between countries. For
example, although the GDP of Switzerland showed USD59,540 (2014)
exceeding that of the United States at USD54,629 (2014) (not shown in
table), the higher cost of living in Switzerland meant that American citizens
could actually afford more goods and services than the Swiss.
The Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) method adjusts the GDP of countries
with the cost of living and allows a more direct comparison of living
standards between countries. Let us use the cost of living in the United
States as a base for comparison with India. While the GDP per capita for
India was USD5,701, the PPP per capita was USD5,610 (2014) (not shown in
table). This may indicate that the cost of living in India was lower than in
the United States, and that USD5,701 in India could buy as much as
USD5,610 worth of goods and services in the United States, as much as
USD55,837 (2014) and PPP as USD55,140 (2014).
The above figures further suggest that the standard of living among
countries also differ drastically. The average Indian citizen can afford to
consume only about (5,610 55,140 100%) 10.17% of the goods and
services that the average US citizen can. Therefore, despite having a
population of 1 billion, India does not appear to be an attractive market for
consumer goods. This conclusion, however, may not be accurate because
India has a wealthy middle class, although the majority may be poor.
The GDP and PPP figures are also a static picture of a countrys economic
development. We will need to further rely on the rate of growth in Gross
Domestic Product (GDP). For example, India may be shown as poorer than
the United States, but it does not tell us whether the income gap is closing.
They may currently be poor but it is growing at a much quicker rate than
the advanced countries. With their potential, they may in future become
more advanced and be huge markets for the international firms products.
Currently, they may contribute little to revenues, but their future
contributions could be much higher and firms may want to gain a foothold
in the market now.
(i) Life expectancy at birth, which depends on the quality level of health
care accorded;
(i) East Asia and the Pacific countries such as Korea, China and Japan;
(ii) Latin America and the Caribbean, such as Brazil, Argentina and Chile;
(iii) The Middle East and North African countries such as Saudi Arabia,
Egypt, Algeria and Libya;
(vi) Eastern Europe and Central Asia, such as the Czech Republic,
Ukraine, Poland and the countries of Russia.
The regions of North America, Western Europe and Australia, and Japan
are categorised as high income countries, or members of the Organisation
for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries.
It is also important to note that although these countries are located within
similar regions, they may be very different from each other in terms of
ethnic origin, history, politics and economics.
ACTIVITY 2.5
The major underlying reason for economic transition was that command and
mixed economies have revealed weaknesses that generally failed to deliver the
kind of economic achievement that was achieved by free market-based systems,
such as the United States, Switzerland and Taiwan.
The process of shifting towards a free market-based system requires several steps
as shall be explained in the paragraphs that follow.
(a) Deregulation
In the command economies, deregulation of the markets means the
removing of legally imposed restrictions to allow the free play of market
forces, the formation of private enterprises and how they operate, uplifting
controls over prices and outputs and international trade.
In the mixed economies where the role of the government is more limited,
deregulation is much easier to implement because a private sector already
exist. India, for example, has reformed their industrial licensing system that
made it difficult for new private enterprises to be established and opened
up sectors such as electricity generation, steel making, air transport and
some areas of the telecommunications industry to the private sector. India
has also removed limitations placed on foreign ownership of Indian assets
and lowered the barriers to international trade.
(b) Privatisation
Privatisation is the transfer of ownership of state-owned properties to
private individuals. It was first implemented by the British government in
1979 when 20 state firms were converted into privately owned companies.
Foreign capital may be hesitant due to the weak system of law which
cannot offer adequate protection for their investments. In the event of
contract disputes, procedures for resolving them are either insufficient or
poorly developed.
In the long-term, major changes in the flow of trade and investments will take
place as these emerging economies continue their effort to become major players
in global trade.
EXERCISE 2.3
6. What are the major features that differentiates between the three
economic systems of the world today?
7. What are the three steps that need to be taken by the emerging
market economies in their efforts to transform to a free market-based
system?
In this topic, we have focused on the existing issues of culture, politics, legal
and economic systems in the external environment of the international
business firm.
We also learned that political and legal systems tend to differ from country to
country, even among those sharing similar political ideologies.
The topic ends with a discussion on these former communist countries which
are now termed as the emerging market economies.