Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils From Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda
Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils From Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda
Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils From Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda
WRJAS
Vol. 5(1), pp. 141-146, March, 2018. ©www.premierpublishers.org. ISSN: XXXX-XXXX
Case Study
Different soil properties from Gatumba Mining Area were assessed to characterize them and
contribute in setting up practices for soil restoration. The present study was conducted to assess
the soil status in degraded soils from tantalum mining in Gatumba. Nine soil profiles which were
prepared in 2009 during dry season were sharpened and soils from all visible horizons were
sampled. Soil analysis was performed in the soil laboratory at National University of Rwanda.
Results showed that the active soil pH was lower in technosol developed on schist (4.8) and
higher in technosol composed by pegmatite dump (5.61) and ranged from slightly acid (5.61) to
acidic (4.73). Acid saturation was lower in strongly disturbed fluvisol (3.4%) and higher in
technosol composed by pegmatite (10.78%) while base saturation was lower in cambic-fluvisol
(37.5%) and higher in technosol composed by pegmatite (89.3%). However, a significant difference
(p=0.012) only observed in base saturation between soil profiles. In general, soils affected by
mining had low base saturation and higher acid saturation than unaffected. Therefore,
recommendation of more soluble amendment such as lime and dolomite would improve the soil
pH and provide macronutrients like Ca2+ and Mg2+.
Key words: Acid saturation, Base saturation, Gatumba mining area, Rwanda and Soil pH
INTRODUCTION
Since many decades, soil acidity has been a major topsoil’s which are rich in soil nutrients and replaced either
growing-limiting factor for plants in many parts of the world by invaluable cropland or bare wasteland. Soil acidity is a
(Mc Lean, 1976; Kamprath; 1978; Adams, 1978, 1981). major limiting factor of soil productivity (Mc Lean, 1976;
Estimates of the total area of the top soils affected by Kamprath, 1978; Adams, 1978; 1981). Most of Rwandan
acidity throughout the world vary from 3.777.109 to soils are acid with pH levels below 5 and low base
3.950.10 9 ha, representing approximately 30% of the total saturation of about <35% as confirmed by Mutuyimana
land area of the world. The total area affected by subsoil (2011).
acidity is estimated as 2.918.109 ha, meaning that
approximately 75% of the acid soils of the world suffer from
subsoil limitations due to acidity (Zdenko, 2003). Rwanda,
most arable soils are acidic and poor in vital
macronutrients (Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium) for
plant growth. The lack of these elements leads to *Corresponding Author: Imanirareba Dative, Faculty of
continuous decline of agricultural production Agriculture, Uganda Martyrs University P.O. Box 5498
(Mutwewingabo et al, 1987). Many factors have Kampala, Uganda: E-mail: dirareba@gmail.com Tel:
contributed to soil acidity include erosion, overcultivation, +250788271026 Co-Author E-mail:
anthropogenic activities such as mining which deteriorate naramabuyefrancois@gmail.com Tel: +250788874486
soil fertility through soil degradation by removing the
Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils from Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda
Imanirareba and Naramabuye 142
In addition, soils become acidic during geological evolution MATERIALS AND METHODS
and when their parent materials were acid and poor in
base cation (Ca2+, Mg2+, K+, Na+) or because these Site description
elements have been removed from the soil profile by
normal rainfall or the harvesting of crops (Kamprath and The study was conducted in 2012 in Gatumba mining
Foy; 1972). In addition, soil acidification is frequently District (GMD) (figure 1) Western Province of Rwanda and
inevitable in agriculture. Soils of Gatumba mining area is located next to the Nyabarongo River between the
are not only influenced by parent material, climate, relief longitudes 29°37’ and 29°40’ E and the latitudes 1°53’ and
and cultivation, coltan mining activities but also climate 1°56’S. With an average altitude of 1,700 m above sea
that may cause several changes in physical and chemical level (ASL), the highest hilltops are about 1,900 m ASL
properties of soils leading to soil degradation or soil fertility while the Nyabarongo River reaches an altitude of about
depletion through erosion and leaching of basic cation. 1,370 m ASL in the area (Reetsch, 2008). The natural soils
Soil developed on mine spoils are shallow and in early (soils which have developed outside of the mining areas)
stages of the development characterized by the of the GMD are representative for the tropical highlands of
deficiencies of soil organic matter and nutrients as other Rwanda. Typical Soil Reference Groups found in GMD
reclamation area. The most cultivated annual crops in include Lixisols, Nitisols, Cambisols, Gleysols and
mine spoils includes cassava and sweet potato (Anika, Umbrisols (IUSS Working Group WRB, 2006).
2008). it has also shown that mining affects both the living
and non-living things through the physical modification of In Gatumba, the open cast mining has disturbed large
the soil environment (Adewole and Adesina, 2011). areas of land and has formed entire landscapes with deep
escarpments owing to the high price of tantalum and the
The present study was designed to assess the soil status increasing demand in the world market. The annual rainfall
in degraded soils from tantalum mining in Gatumba during in Gatumba varies between 1,300 and 1,500 mm. This
the rainy season. The assessment of different soil abundant rainfall has totally leached the soils that have
properties helped us to generally characterize the soils developed from poor parent materials such as sandstone,
from that study area and contribute in setting up practices quartzite, quartzophyllite and granite. The average annual
for soil restoration. temperature of the area is between 15 and 18°C mainly
due to high altitude (2,100 m above sea level).
Figure 1: Location of the investigation area Gatumba Mining District (red circle), Rwanda (Paulmann, 2012)
Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils from Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda
World Res. J. Agric. Sci. 143
The vegetation of the study area is mainly derived The soil samples were air-dried and passed through a 2-
savannah with some reforested patches on the top of the mm sized sieve. The following soil characteristics were
hills (Ndabaneze et al., 2007). Three agricultural seasons determined: (i) pH water (1:2.5 soil/water ratio) and pH KCl
have been developed. Two correspond with the rainy (1:2.5, soil/1N KCl solution ratio); (ii) Exchangeable
seasons. The third season (from June to September) cations (Ca, Mg, K, and Na) extracted with 1M NH4OAc
allows a third harvest of crops cultivated in poorly drained buffered to pH 7 (Jones, 2001) and the elements
valleys (Verdoot and van Ranst, 2003). determined using atomic absorption spectrophotometer
(AAS) and exchangeable aluminum was obtained
Geographically, Rwanda is divided into two parts: the according to 1N KCl extraction (Cottenie et al., 1982).
western and the eastern part. The mountainous Effective cation exchange capacity (ECEC) was calculated
topography of western Rwanda where GMD located, as the sum of basic cations in addition to exchangeable Al
originates from the eastern rim of the Albertine Rift Valley using the laboratory methods of soil and plant analysis as
which is part of the Great Rift Valley. The Rift Valley described by Okalebo et al., (2002).
escarpment also forms the watershed between the Congo
River and the Nile in the highlands of Rwanda (Reetsch, Data analysis
2008). At the western border the largest freshwater body
of the country, the Kivu Lake, is located and Nyabarongo The data collected from field samples was entered in
River flows through the tropical highlands of Rwanda. Microsoft Excel and analyzed using GenStat (5 th edition)
While, the Eastern Rwanda is characterized by less software at 5% level of significance. Soil data parameters
mountainous landscapes. Swamps and small lakes are were subjected to “one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA)
spread over the eastern regions and along the border to in Randomized blocks". The results were presented in the
Tanzania. The Akagera River marks the border to form of table.
Tanzania.
Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils from Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda
Imanirareba and Naramabuye 144
of environmental studies and management vol.4 No2 Mc lean, E.o. (1976). Chemistry of soil Aluminium
2011. common. Soil sci.plant Anol.7:619-636
Anderson, G.D. (1973). Potassium responses of various Moore, D.P. (1974). Physiological effects of pH on
crops in East Africa. In Proceedings of the 10th roots.p.565-600. In E. W Carson (ed.) the plants root
colloquium of the International Potash Institute, and its environment univ. press of Virginia,
Abidjan, Ivory Coast. International Potash Institute, Charlottesville.
Abidjan. pp. 113-437 Mutuyimana Y. (2011). Investigation of acidity parameters
Anika Reetsch (2008). Effect of Coltan Mining on from 16 soil profiles from Gatumba Mining Area during
properties and quality of soils of the open-cost Mining the rainy season. Dissertation for award of BSc
District Gatumba, Rwanda degree at National University of Rwanda.
Brady N.C and Weil R.R.R, (2002). The nature and Mutwewingabo B. Rutunga V. (1987). Projet d'
properties of soils, 13th ed. Prentice Hall, New Jersey Intensification Agricole de Gikongoro (Rwanda)
USA. Universite Nationale du Rwanda, Butare (Rwanda).
Brady, N.C., and R.R. Weil (2001). The nature and Institut des Sciences Agronomiques du Rwanda,
properties of soils (13th ed.) Prentice Hall, Upper Butare (Rwanda).
Saddle River, NJ Ndabaneze, P., Habarugira, N., and Muhongere, C.
Cottenie, A., Verloo, M., Kiekens, L., Velghe, G. and (2007). Sustainable Restitution/Recultivation of
Camerlynck, R. (1982). Chemical analysis of plant and artisanal Tantalum mining wastelands in Central Africa,
soils. Laborator of Analytical and Agrochemistry, State Gatumba flora and vegetation study (Rwanda). Kigali
University of Gent, Belgium. 63p. Institute of Education, Coltan Meeting November 2007
Donahue R.L., Miller R.W. and Shickluna J.C., (1983). An Ndoli A., (2013). Effect of tithonia biomass and mineral
introduction to soils and plant growth 5th edition. fertilizer application on soybean performance in
Prentices Hall Inc, Englewood chiffs, New Jersey, USA. degraded technosols from tantalum mining in Gatumba,
Driessen, P. M. and Dudal, R. (eds.) (1989). Lecture Notes Rwanda.
on the Geography, Formation, Properties and Use of Okalebo, J. B., Gathua, K. W. & Woomer, P.W. (2002).
the Major Soils of the World. Agricultural University Laboratory Methods of Soil and Plant Analysis, Second
Wageningen and Katholike Universiteit Leuven. Edition, Nairobi. 128pp.
Fageria, N. K., V. C. Baligar, and D. G. Edwards. (1990a). Paulmann, I. (2012). Trace element exposure in soils and
Soil-plant nutrient relationships at low pH stress. In V. vegetation of the Gatumba Mining District, Rwanda.
C. Baligar and R. R. Duncan (eds.), Crops as Technical University Braunschweig, Germany.
Enhancers of Nutrient Use. Academic Press, San Scheffer, F. and Schachtschabel, P. (2002). Lehrbuch der
Diego, CA, pp. 475– 507. Bodenkunde. 15. Auflage, Spektrum Akademischer
Igwe, C. A., Zarei, M. and Stahr, K. (2004). Chemical Verlag, Heidelberg, Germany.
properties of the Niger floodplain soils, eastern Nigeria, Schwartz, H.F. and Corrales, M.A.P. (1989). Nutritional
in relation to mineralogy. Paddy Water Environment, 2 disorders in beans. In Schwartz, H.F. And Corrales,
(2), 51–58. M.A.P. (eds.) Bean Production Problems in the Tropics.
Islam, A.K.M.S., D.G.Edwards, and C.J.Asher. (1980). pH Second Edition. International Center for Tropical
optima for crop growth results of a flowing solution Agriculture (CIAT), Cali.pp.57-604
culture experiment with six species. Plant soil 54:339- Verdoot, van Ranst, E. (2003). Land Evaluation for
357. Agricultural Production in the Topics– A Large-Scale
IUSS Working Group WRB (2006). World reference base Land Suitability Classification for Rwanda”, Ghent
for soil resources, World Soil Resources Reports, 103, University, Laboratory of Soil Science, Belgium
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Zdenko R. (2003). Handbook of Soil Acidity (Books in
Nations, Rome, Italy. Soils, Plants, and Environment). University of Western
Jones, J.B. (2001). Laboratory guide for conducting soil Australia; Perth, Western Australia
tests and plant analysis.CRC Press LLC.
Kamprath E.J., and C.D.Foy. (1972). Lime-fertilizer-plant Accepted 20 February 2018
interactions in acid soil. P. 105-151. In R.W.Olsen it al.
(ed.) Fertilizes technology and use.2nd ed. Soil Citation: Imanirareba D, Naramabuye FX (2018).
sci.toc.of Am.Madison, Wis. Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils from
Landon, J.R., (1991). Booker Tropical Soil Manual. A Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda. World Research
handbook for soil survey and Agricultural land Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 5(1): 141-146.
evaluation in the tropics and subtropics. Longman,
Booker Tate Limited, Oxon, UK. 474p.
Marx, E.S., Hart, J. and Stevens, R.G. (1996). Soil Test Copyright: © 2018 Imanirareba and Naramabuye. This is
Interpretation Guide. Oregon State University an open-access article distributed under the terms of the
Extension Services. Oregan State University, Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
Corvallis.7pp unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original author and source are cited.
Investigation of Soil Status in Degraded Soils from Tantalum Mining in Gatumba, Rwanda