A Fiber-Optic Chemical Sensor Based On Surface Plasmon Resonance
A Fiber-Optic Chemical Sensor Based On Surface Plasmon Resonance
A Fiber-Optic Chemical Sensor Based On Surface Plasmon Resonance
(Received September 23, 1992;in revised form December 15, 1992;accepted f&ember 20, 1992)
A fiber-optic chemical sensor is presented which utilizes surface plasmon resonance excitation. The sensing element
of the fiber has been fabricated by removing a section of the fiber cladding and symmetricaBy depositing a thin layer
of highly refleoting metal onto the fiber core. A white-hgbt source is used to introduce a range of wavelengths into
the fiber optic. Changes in the sensed parameters (e.g., bulk refractive index, film thickness and f&a refractive index)
are determined by measuring the transmitted spectral-intensitydistribution, Experimentalresults of the sensitivity
and the dynamic range in the measurementof the refractiveindices of aqueous solutions are in agreementwith the
theoreticalmodel of the sensor.
The sensing element is a segment of fiber in which the permittivities of the metal, a,,,, and the dielectric, ad.
cladding has been removed and a 550 8, thick silver film The propagation constant is expressed as
has been symmetrically deposited on the fiber core, via l/2
electron-beam evaporation. The length of the cladding (2)
removed was calculated to optimize the average number
of reflections for ah the propagating rays of light in the At the resonance angle 0,, the propagation constant of
fiber. Unlike traditional SPR measurements, which em- the /ncident beam parallel to the prism base (i.e., along
ploy a discrete excitation wavelength while modulating the z-direction, konp sin,&,) is equal to the real part of
the angle of incidence, the SPR fiber-optic sensor sys- the SPR propagation constant. This equality condition
tem uses a white-light source, resulting in a large range is expressed by
of excitation wavelengths. The range of incident angles
ki = k,,np sin t?,, (3)
is limited to only those angles that propagate in the
optical fiber. The sensed parameters can then be deter- where np is the refractive index of the prism.
mined from the measured resonance spectrum in the Equations (2) and (3) provide for the theoretical
transmitted spectral intensity distribution. transduction mechanism for SPR as a sensor. Specifi-
cally, an increase in refractive index of the sensed
dielectric will cause a shift in the resonance spectrum
2. Theory toward larger SPR coupling angles. By measuring the
SPR resonance parameters (coupling angle, Q,, full
2.1. Background width at half maximum, A@,and the reflected light
SPR is a resonance phenomenon in which surface intensity at the resonance coupling angle, Z&,) one can
plasmon waves (SPWs) are excited at a metal/dielectric determine the complex refractive index of the dielectric
interface. The electric field, E, of the SPW propagating using the calculated SPR propagation constant, k, [8].
in the z-direction (Fig. I) is expressed as [7] The SPR reflection spectrum in Fig. 2 is for a discrete
wavelength. For other excitation wavelengths the SPR
E,(x, 2, 1) = Et(x) exp(iwl-ik,z) (1) propagation constant will change accordingly, since the
where o = angular frequency and prism refractive index, bulk dielectric refractive index
and the metal permittivity are all a function of wave-
k,=k:+ik:
length [9]. A theoretical three-dimensional SPR reflec-
is the SPR propagation constant along the z-direction. tion spectrum for a range of wavelengths is illustrated
The SPR propagation constant, k,, is dependent in Fig. 3 with the value of one minus the normalized
upon the free-space wave number, k,, and the complex reflected intensity versus the angle of incidence and
Fig. 3. Theoretical three-dimensional SPR reflection spectra for a bulk dielectric of water, a 550 A thick silver film, and a fused silica
prism. The unlabelled axis is equal to 1-normalized reflection intensity.
215
Sensed Medium
I Fig. Illustration of the SPR fiber-optic sensing element.
500 600 700 800 900 loo0
Wavelength (mn)
2.2. Principle of the SPRJiber-optic sensor
Fig. 4. The set of curves labeled ‘Water’ is the contour plot of the
three-dimensional SPR spectra illustrated in Fig. 3. The set of The SPR sensor has eliminated the need for the
curves labeled ‘Sucrose Sol’n’ is the contour plot of the theoretical coupling prism by depositing the metal directly onto the
spectra assuming a 37.1% concentration of sucrose. core of the fiber as illustrated in Fig. 5. The SPR
sensing method of fixed angle of incidence and modu-
lated wavelength was selected since the wavelength in-
wavelength. Note that the discrete peaks in Fig. 3 tensity distribution may be preserved in a fiber optic,
correspond to the use of discrete data points in order to whereas the angular intensity distribution of light will
create the graph. However, in theory the three-dimen- be indistinguishable due to mode mixing as a result of
sional surface is actually a continuous peaked surface. the inherent bending of the multimode fiber optic in
The spectrum was calculated using a matrix method to practical sensing applications. Furthermore, since the
determine the Fresnel reflection coefficients of a multi- sensor is fabricated on a multimode fiber there is not a
layered structure [lo]. The calculations were made as- fixed angle of incidence, but rather a range of incident
suming a fused silica prism, a 550 8, thick silver layer, a angles that are allowed to propagate in the fiber.
bulk dielectric of water, and TM-polarized light. The The multimode fiber optic has a numerical aperture
refractive-index values used in our SPR spectra calcula- of 0.36. The fiber supports internal propagating angles
tions for the silver layer [ 111, fused silica prism [ 121, of light from 90.0 to 78.5”, with respect to the normal
and water [13] were obtained from the literature. The of the core/cladding interface. Within this incident an-
change in the SPR coupling angle as a function of gular region the predicted SPR coupling wavelengths
wavelength shown in Fig. 3 is almost exclusively due to are between 560 and 620 nm for a bulk dielectric of
the increased magnitude of the silver complex refractive water, as shown in Fig. 4. Thus the light intensity at
index over the wavelength range 400-1000 nm. This these wavelengths is expected to be attenuated due to
large change in the silver refractive index (i.e., one the excitation of surface plasmon waves at the silver
order of magnitude) is compared to the relatively small film/bulk dielectric interface. An optical system re-
change in both silica and water refractive indices, 0.019 quired for this fiber-optic sensor must have the capabil-
and 0.028 index of refraction units, respectively. ity for coupling a wide range of optical wavelengths
Figure 4 is a contour plot of two theoretical three- into the optical fiber and for measuring the transmitted
dimensional SPR reflection spectra for water and a spectral intensity distribution (intensity versus wave-
sucrose solution (37.1 wt.%) as the bulk dielectric me- length) at the output of the fiber.
dia. This plot illustrates the resonance coupling angle
dependency upon wavelength, and the three-dimen- 2.3. Modeling of thefiber-optic signal
sional SPR spectra dependence upon the bulk refractive Three considerations must be addressed in order to
index. It is clear from Fig. 4 that a very sharp reso- model the theoretical SPR fiber-optic sensor transmit-
nance would be observed at the longer-wavelength re- ted spectral intensity distribution. These considerations
gion for the fused silica prism and silver metal layer are: (1) the three-dimensional SPR reflection spectra;
configuration. Thus, it explains why many researchers (2) the number of reflections each propagating mode
involved in SPR sensing have employed the method of undergoes; (3) the density of propagating modes in the
fixed wavelength and modulated angle of incidence at fiber-optic sensor.
long wavelengths. These contour plots illustrate that it Figure 6 illustrates the theoretical SPR spectra of
is also possible to measure a resonance spectrum by the reflected intensity for one reflection versus wavelength for
method of fixing the angle of incidence and modulating a number of angles propagating inside the fiber-optic
the excitation wavelength, which is the fundamental sensor (90,87,84,81, and 78” with respect to the normal
basis for the development of the SPR fiber-optic sensor. of the core/metal interface). However, the number of
216
90
1
0.15.
80 BZ 84 86 88 90
B 0.8
fiB 0.6
%
cc 0.4
Fig. 9. Theoretical SPR fiber-optic spectra for a bulk refractive
G index of water and a 37.1% sucrose solution, assuming random
g 0.2
polarized light.
0
540 560 580 600 620 640 five of the propagating angles. The spectrum with the
Wavelength (nm) lowest-order mode, 90” angle of propagation, travels
Fig. 7. Theoretical SPR spectra taking into account the number
parallel to the meridonial axis of the fiber and does not
of reflections each angle encounters. reflect off the interface. Therefore, the expected spec-
trum is that of the 90” spectrum in Fig. 6 raised to the
power of zero, which yields a constant spectrum corre-
reflections in the fiber-sensor area is a function of the sponding to no surface plasmon waves excited by the
mode propagation angle, 0, as well as of the diameter of 90” propagating mode. Correspondingly, the smallest
the fiber, d, and the length of the sensing area, L. This propagating angle in the fiber (78”) has an effective
relationship is given by spectrum that is greatly broadened since it has 5.31
L reflections within the sensing length of the sensor.
Number of reflections = - (4) The SPR fiber-optic signal represents an accumulated
d tan(Q)
spectrum for the entire range of propagating angles,
The calculated numbers of reflections for the angles since one cannot measure the SPR spectrum for a
propagating in the fiber are 0.00, 1.31, 2.63, 3.96, and specific mode. However, the signal is not an equally
5.31 for incident angles of 90, 87, 84, 81, and 78”, weighted average of all the angles propagating in the
respectively. The number of reflections was calculated fiber; it must be weighted with the non-constant density-
assuming a 400 pm fiber diameter and a sensing area distribution function of propagating angles in the fiber
length of 10 mm. (Fig. 8). The propagation angle density-distribution
To determine the effective SPR spectra (taking into function is assumed to be Gaussian, spanning the range
account multiple reflections), the spectrum for a single of the allowed propagating angles in the fiber. Figure 9
reflection (Fig. 6) is raised to the power of the number represents the theoretical SPR fiber-optic signal ob-
of reflections the specific propagating angle undergoes tained by weight averaging the angular spectra in Fig. 7
with the sensor interface. Figure 7 illustrates these with the density distribution of Fig. 8 for the bulk
effective SPR spectra of intensity versus wavelength for chemical water sample and a 37.1% concentration of
217
sucrose. An approximate 200 run shift in the SPR cou- evaporator system in an ~r~gement whereby the flux
pling wavelength is observed; it corresponds to a of the evaporated metal was perpendicular to the axis
change of 0.06 index of refraction units of the chemical of the fiber. The fibers were then rotated during silver
sample. deposition, resulting in a 550 A silver film deposited
symmetrically about the fiber core. The deposition pro-
cess was monitored using a quartz-crystal detector.
Six sample solutions of high-fructo~ corn syrup di-
luted with deionized water were prepared, resulting in
The block diagram of the experimental set-up is various real refractive indices. The real refractive in-
shown in Fig. 10. The output of a tungsten-halogen dices of these sample solutions (1.333, 1.351, 1.364,
lamp is focused into a fiber optic. An SPR sensing 1.381, 1.393, and 1.404) were independently measured
surface has been fabricated in the middle section of the using an Abbe refractometer (Milton Roy Tabletop
length of fiber. A mode scrambler is used to populate Ref~ctometer 3L) at the 589 nm ~velength. The same
all the modes of the fiber optic. The SPR sensing experimental procedure was used for measuring the
surface is enclosed by a 3 ml flow cell constructed using transmitted fiber-optic SPR spectra in all three sensors.
a syringe with two syringe stoppers and inlet and outlet First, the transmitted spectral intensity distribution was
ports. The output of the fiber-optic sensor is connected measured while air was in the flow cell. Secondly, the
to a fiber-optic spectrograph (American Holographic, transmitted spectral intensity distribution was measured
Littleton, MA) via an SMA connector. The flat field for each of the six prepared sucrose solutions. 15 ml of
grating is an American Holographic model ##6.33, each sample solution was introduced via a syringe at
which disperses a range of wavelengths from 400 to the input port of the flow cell.
900 nm with a linear dispersion value of 20 run/mm.
The detector inside the spectrograph is a 1024-element
CCD linear array detector. The theoretical wavelength 4. Experimentalresults and discussion
resolution dete~ned by the linear dispersion value of
the grating and the 25.4 pm width of the CCD elements The air spectrum was used as a reference to normal-
is 0.5 nm. A data-acquisition board is used with an ize all the SPR fiber-optic sensor spectra taken of the
IBM-compatible computer for automated data acquisi- sample solutions, since there was no surface plasmon
tion. resonance excitation in this wavelength range for the
The fiber optic chosen for the experiment was a bulk refractive index of air, 1.0. This calibration pro-
silica~pol~er fiber (3M, Mi~~polis, MN, type FP- vided an effective means to measure the system transfer
400 LJHT). The ~0~~~760 pm (core, cladding and function, attributed by the light-source spectral output,
buffer diameters, respectively) fiber had a numerical the photodiode array spectral sensitivity, and the fiber
aperture of 0.36. The buffer and cladding layers were spectral absorbance. Figure 11 shows the normalized
removed using a technique employed by Weber and transmitted light intensity as a function of wavelength
Schultz [ 141.A hobby torch was used to burn away the measured by the 1Omm exposed core sensor for the
layers, and the resultant surface was wiped with Dyna- fructose solutions with refractive indices of 1.351, 1.393,
solve 100 (Dynaloy Inc.). and 1.404. The r~on~~ wavelength shift for increas-
Three fiber-optic sensors were fabricated by removing
6, 10, and 18 mm in length of the cladding/buffer layers.
The sensors were then mounted in an electron-beam
Wavelength(MI)
Fig. 11. SPR spectra collcctcd using the SPR fiber sensor with
1Omm of fiber core exposed. The spectra were cokctad from
Fig. 10. Illustration of the SPR fiber-optic experimentalapparatus. fructose samples with refractive indices of 1.351,1.393,and 1.404.
218
0.6
l
Fig. 12. SPR spectra collected from all three fabricated sensors
j&//y jg
with the same fructose concentration with a refractive index of
1.351. 1.33 1.34 1.35 1.36 1.37 1.38 1.39 1.4 41
Real Refractive Index
Acknowledgements
13 I. H. Malitson, Interspecimen comparison of the refractive Battelle Memorial Institute (1987, 1988) investigating
index of fused silica. J. Oat. Sot. Am.. 55(1%5) 1205-1216. bulk-optic surface plasmon resonance for the measure-
14 A. Weber and .I. S. &h&z, Fiber-optic fludrimefry in biosen-
ment of in situ protein adsorption. His main research
sors: comparison between evanescent wave generation and
distal-face generation of fluorescent light, Biosensors Bioelec-
interests are in chemical and biomedical optical sensors.
won., 7 (1992) 193-197.
15 Abbe Refractometer Operator’s Manual and Dispersion Table, Sinclair S. Yee received B.S., M.S., and Ph.D. degrees
Milton Roy Company, Analytical Products Division, in electrical engineering from the University of Califor-
Rochester, New York, 1986.
nia, Berkeley, in 1959, 1961, and 1965, respectively. In
1964, he joined the Lawrence Livermore Laboratory as
Biographies a research engineer working on semiconductor devices.
Since 1966 he has been on the faculty of the Department
Ralph C. Jorgenson received B.S. and MS. degrees in of Electrical Engineering at the University of Washing-
electrical engineering from the University of Washing- ton, where in 1974 he became a full professor. In
ton in 1988 and 1991, respectively. He is currently a 1972-1974, he was an NIH Special Research Fellow,
Ph.D. candidate in the Department of Electrical En- and since 1979, he has been an IEEE Fellow. His main
gineering at the University of Washington. He has research interests are concerned with silicon-based and
interned at International Biomedics Inc. (1986), re- GaAs quantum-well optical modulator devices and sur-
searching an in vivo fiber-optic blood-gas sensor and at face plasmon resonance, as well as microsensor arrays.