Assmann Egyptian Mortuary Liturgies 1990 PDF
Assmann Egyptian Mortuary Liturgies 1990 PDF
Assmann Egyptian Mortuary Liturgies 1990 PDF
1,
Jerusalem 1990, S. 1-45
l iterature: Pyramid Texts, Coffin Texts and Book of the Dead. What
* A preliminary version of this article has been read at the Toronto Conference
in 1982. I am g rateful to Aleida Assmann, who translated the German text, to
John Baines, who revised the translation, to Harry James and to Peter Dorman,
who provided me with important unpublished material and to the Deutsche For-
schung sg emeinschaft, who supported my work on s3§w during the years 1968-1971
and 1981-82. My g ratitude to Miriam Lichtheim, to whom I dedicate this report,
is of a less specific character. But in addition to the debt of gratitude, which
everyone of us owes her for her magistral volumes of Ancient Egyptian Lite
rature, I feel a special oblig ation, for her article on harper's song s was
among the vital instig ations which, once, set me on the track of mortuary litur
gies .
!
There is no German equivalent for the English distinction between »funerary«
and »mortuary«, and with regard to the functional context of s3})w I feel myself
1
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
genre. 3 The def inition of the new corpus is theref ore entirely dif
f erent f rom that of the other corpora whose texts are heteroge
the mortuary cult. They did not serve the dead as a text to be read
in the hereaf ter but are meant at least were originally meant
f or the use of the living, i.e. the mortuary priest perf orming his
parate f rom the three known corpora. There are substantial over
laps. My leading motive in gathering this corpus was not only the
collection of new texts, but also the classif ication of known texts
reluctant to make this distinction. The recitation of s3^v accompanied both the
rites of the f uneral and the mortuary cult. I use »funerary« with regard to the
funerary equipment, and »mortuary« with regard to the cult of the deceased.
3
For the theo'retical and methodical implications see Assmann (1975), 625 and
7894.
2
JAN A S S M A N
tion of the spells (> 33%<) has an affinity with our genre, in the
but with time it became separated from the cult and d eveloped its own
(Goyon 1974). I shall therefore start there, at the end , and work
backward s.
of Ptolemaic priests
tically become only known when, a nd insofar as, they aire record ed
4
Pace Barta (1981), who takes the whole corpus of Pyramid Texts to consist of
s3hw and renounces by this proced ure any further d ifferentiation in terms of
genreanalysis.
3
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
liturgies and rituals on these late papyri, 4 b ear the title s3t)w.
rituals (fig.1).
doub t that they are temple liturgies and not mortuary spells. This
is explicitly stated in the title rub rics, which link the texts
god Osiris Khontamenti and not a private Osiris NN, who is addres
sed throug hout the texts. It is, however, equally evident that these
coffin texts, the rest being spells of a similar form and content.
The title of these liturg ies, s3ljw, points rather to the cult of
the dead than to that of the g ods. 3h is the term for the
deceased (Eng lund 1978); the rite of »reciting many s3frw« is attes
ted already in the mortuary cult of the OK and the title s3hw
words, we are dealing with mortuary liturg ies which were performed
3
"livres rituels usurpes": Goyon (1974), 77ff., cf. also Burkard (1988), 18.
4
JAN ASSMAN
r e dc
a tion, transmission and l oc a t i o n a l c o n t e x t , and the intratex
6
All t h i s a p p l i e s o n l y t o 3 of t h e s e 4 s3$w. These 3 s h a r e t h e c h a r ac t e r i s t ic
f e a t u r e s of f u n e r a r y s p e l l s and have many p a r a l l e l s i n t h e f u n e r a r y l i t e r a t u r e .
T h e i r t i t l e s i n d i c a t e t h a t t h e y a r e t o be r e c i t e d by t h e c h i e f l ec t o r p r i e s t of
t h e t e m p l e , whereas t h e 4l:h s J / j w l i t u r g y i s t o be r e c i t e d as lamentations by
p r i e s t e s s e s t a k i n g t h e p a r t of I s i s and Nephthys ( s e e Goyon 1967 and 1974, 81
n . l ) . As t h i s c o n s t i t u t e s a g e n r e of i t s own, I s h a l l r e s t r ic t myself t o t h e
f i r s t three l i t u r g i e s .
7
The numbering f o l l o w s Assmar.n (1986), 999. As I am h e r e working ba c kwards, I do
not s t a r t with N r . l , but r a t h e r a t t h e end, w i t h N r s . 1 3 1 5 . For s3hw I s e e Goyon
( 1 9 7 4 ) , 7 9 f . and Sz c zudlowska ( 1 9 7 2 ) .
5
E G Y P T I A N M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
in the late papyri. There are 7 copies of Nr. I, 4 of Nr.II and one
rubrics with the words s3hw or kjj (another, vie. spell). There
f orm »0:2«. Fig.3 shows how this change of interpersonal f orm cor
8
Szczudlowska (1972), 51.
9
Note, however, the many pyramid Texts which have been transposed from one in
terpersonal fo'rm to another, most frequently from »1:0« to »0:0«, sometimes from
»0:2« via »1:0« to »0:0«.
6
JAN A S S M A N
Isis and Nephthys, the main agents of the beginning, again take
Re were to be recited d uring the night, and those includ ing refe
rences to him,d uring the d ay. We can infer that the liturgy starts
There is further evid ence for this hypothesis: the d aytime spells
10
See Assmann (1985) and Smith (1987), 22f£. For shorter versions on sarcophagi
of Dyn. XXV and XXVI see Soukiassian (1982).
7
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
ritua l. The night spells a ccompa ny the emba lming rites a nd ena ct
center around the main theme of the integration of the decea sed in
the community of the gods a nd, a bove a ll, in the compa ny of the
Fig.4 summa rizes the textua l pa ra llels for our liturgy. It is not
cea sed in the »0:2« form a nd conta in the sa me thema tic ma teria l.
11
Those other texts are given individual provisional numbers starting with 100
in my notation:
12
See Moller (1900); Goyon (1974), 80; Assmann (1986). 999 Nr.14.
8
JAN A S S M A N
inserted:
Found upon a nother lea ther roll from the time of king Thutmo
si III and Amenophis III in the libra ry of the temple of Osi
ris at Abydos.14
The most striking fea ture of this liturgy is tha t (excluding spell
teristics of the genre a s in the first liturgy. All the spells ex
cept the short Spell 15 are in the typica l »0:2« form. Spell 24 is
theme of the Stundenwachen is not fully ela bora ted in the Pyra mid
13
Inserted in the middle of PT 690 = spell 19.
"* Inserted before CT sp. 837 = spell 24.
9
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
so signif icant as the f act that they occur in the same order-as
early as the MK cof f ins (f ig.6). 13 This shows that the rubricized
of the MK cof f ins. The liturgy s3hw II thus points directly back
esting that the context is quite dif f erent f rom that of the occu
inscribed with spells. These all address the owner of the tomb in
PT. But every one of these texts also occurs in the liturgy s3i}w
II, so that they probably derive not f rom the Pyramid Texts but
13
See Altenmuller (1972), 4951.
'« Cf. Assmann (1973), 9597 and (1977), 2628.
17
To be published by E.Graefe, who brought this version to my attention and
provided me with his handcopies.
10
JAN A S S M A N
1. MK coffins
lemaic mss.)
spells of the Theban tombs, to whic h I have given the nrs. 199
so far produc ed 35 texts. Muc h more might be expec ted from the MK
proac h. But before going deeper into this matter, let me desc ribe
werem. 1 ' The 16 spells of this liturgy are written (in pBM 10081)
18
Goyon (1974), 80; Assmann (1986) , 999 Nr.15.
19
Schott (1930) and (1956). For another papyrus of this library see Cam inos
(1972).
11
E G Y P T I A N M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
three seq uences. Part A (Spells 1-6) centers on ascension and re
7 PT, all of which are based on the "Osirian" idea of the deceased
16) contains spells of the Stundenwachen type: this conf irms our
Texts of this group occur in identical order not only in the Saite
those which contain s3$w II. On these cof f ins, they immediately
precede this liturgy. In the other sources, they end with 373 or
12
JAN A S S M A N
2.5 Resume
th e MK too.
13
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
dex shows that it remained the most popularinto the Late Period.
posite the offering ritual on the N wall (Osing 1987). In the lo
20
Cf. Altenrauller (1972), 46f. "Spruchfolge A"; Osing (1987), "C".
14
JAN A S S M A N
3 . 2 . 1 s3hw 1: CT s p e l l s 1-26.
B e g i n n i n g of t h e Book of J u s t i f y i n g a Man i n t h e N e t h e r w o r l d ,
e m p h a s i z i n g t h e s p e c i f i c t h e m a t i c f o c u s of t h i s liturgy.
21
Assmann (1986), 999 Nrs. 4-6.
22
S ystematically, Nr.l should have been reserved for PT 213-222, the oldest and
» c l a s s i c a l « l i t u r g y . But,there are most c e r t a i n l y several other l i t u r g i e s s t i l l
to be i d e n t i f i e d within the abundant mass of sj/jv-like s p e l l s in the pyramids,
which should also precede, in numerotation, the CT S3§H. Thus ,I p r e f e r to indicate
the PT l i t u r g i e s by l e t t e r s (A to . . . ) and to s t a r t anew with the CT l i t u r g i e s .
23
For T2C see CT spell 844.
24
There are good reasons to assume that .liturgy 1 o r i g i n a l l y s t a r t e d with S pell
7, as do MC 105, T9C, TIL and TINY, because in S pell 62 the l i t u r g y seems to be
quoted by i t s incipit »$£s cJ« (CT I 268f).
15
EGYPTIAN MORTUARY LITURGIES
MK co ffins 2 5 , and was later taken o ver as Ch.169 o f the BD. The 1st
fore a divine ac c usant. Both this version and the later "c lassi
c al" c onc eption share the assumption that the dec eased c an enter
Spells 16 have an introduc tory c harac ter. In the typic al form of
»0:2«, they awaken the dead and provide him with equipment for the
c
trial. The refrain m3 -hrw.k "so that you may be justified" shows
that there are ac tually 4 (and not 6) spells. Spells 1019 address
the dead after the—trial. In the »0:2« form ,they ac c laim him in
his new identity of a justified and vic torious Horus. Here, again,
mss. Part 1 is,therefore,c onc erned exc lusively with the justific a
tion of the dec eased. This is the reason why this part is missing
in later versions. With the c hange in the c onc eption of the judg
ment of the dead> this sec tion grew obsolete and was substituted by
The sec ond part is one of the few mortuary liturgies whic h pe
c c
netrated into the BD. There it bears the title: r3 n s h hnkjjt
25
HC 105; T9C; TIL; BH5C.
16
JAN A S S M A N
situation of the vigil, the embalment and funer al,and concer ns the
tr ansfigur ation of the outstr etched cor pse. This is confir med by
169 per for med in the context of a mor tuar y litur gy. The cor r e
val period of 8 days. I h ave recently come across some arch eologi
sible part of th e tomb by a pit, but is kept accessible even after the
or ancient copyists (wh o sh ould h ave used red ink for it):
26
Hari (1985) pis. XXIX and XXXIII s e e p . 4 2 f . and 46f.
17
EGYPTIAN MORTUARY LITURGIES
this litu rgy, most probably pronou nced on the day of his death and
honor a mong the dea d. Since this reca lls the theme of justific a
a lso a bsent from the BD. Instea d ,BD 169 supplies a lenghthy contin
a nd the 4 sons of Horus. These deities a ddress the decea sed with
provide further confirma tion for the supposition tha t these texts
28
were mea nt for recita tion during the hourly vigil.
27
See Assmann (1984), 288 n.60.
28
For the very strong connection between the ritual of the hourly vigil and the
decorations of coffins a nd sa rcopha gi see Assma nn (1972), (1977) a nd Wa itkus
(1987) .
18
JAN A S S M A N
t i me s :
Be t a ke yourse lf to m e , d r a w n e a r to m e ,
be not far from t h y t o m b , t u r n to m e ! 2 9
All the se concluding utte rance s are marke d by the de sire to conti
nually renew and assure contact between speaker and hearer. This
tive statements.
the wrjjt at night. 60B marks daybreak, and the action then turns
outwards. The doors of the wrjjt open,and the next group of reci
leis. This part of the liturgy contains several surprises for us.
I
f we hitherto considered the Stundenwachen to be part of the late
29
CT I 182h183c; 190g191a; 238ac; Pyr. §§ 216; 645; 1342; pBM 10819, VII, 3
4.
30
See Soukoussian (1982), Assmann (1985) and Smith (1987), 22 ff.
19
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
rites,and stress their value for the deceased. The middle stanza
2. All three liturgies are present on the same coffin which is the
diversions are none other than the wellk nown motifs of tombdeco
31
CT I 268 fj.
as CT I 268 k 270 d. The sw.t njwt £ms-jl> are mentioned I 269 a.
20
JAN A S S M A N
21
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
(PT 670 a nd PT 532 once a ga in) . At this point comes the sequence
performed in/a t the tomb, the 2nd being concerned with rites for
(TT 3 5 3 ) . 3 4 In this tomb, the 4 wa lls of the second cha mber a re de
33
For similar divisions in Stundenwachen-texts, corre sponding to the diffe re nt
hours (ofte n marke d by hut "stanza") se e Smith (1987), 80 (a) and Junke r (1910),
24.
34
To be publishe d by Pe te r F.Dorman in the MMA se rie s, who has kindly provide d
me with his copie s of the te xts.
22
JAN A S S M A N
the text. In the J8th Dyn. tombs, mortuary l iturgies are for the
cati on. They are si tuated on walls and pi llars of the accessi ble
ferenti ati on, as I have called i t, can be dated more preci sely. At
li terature (the BD) , we f i nd evi dence for them i n the 18th Dyn.
(Davi es 1943)
hed)
30
See Assmann (1986), 999.
23
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
(Hari 1985).
pt wn n.k t3 ("The sky is opened for thee, the earth is opened for
Re, the spel l jnjw.k m pt bears the titl e r3 n jnt 3t} r djt ssp.f
this spell in the CT, all of which are also attested in the NK and
texts were not copied from ancient tomb s and coffins, but from cur
The title of the other popular spell, wn n.k pt wn n.k t3, indica
24
JAN A S S M A N
is similar with many spells among the mortuary liturg ies, althoug h
parallels and free variants, but also new spells of the same type
4.2 Papyri
the corpus. The remaining 8 spells conf irm this identif ication,
stood. It reads:
38
The title is indicated in the oldest preserved parallel on a f unerary pot
from Harageh, see Gunn (1923), pi.79. For a recent publication of one of the in
numerable variants see Testa (1986) .
25
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
The title shows this liturgy to be connected with the Theban mor
fore, conclude tha t s3hw 12 is much closer to the pra ctica l func
ha ve a practical function.
39
F.Ha ika l (1972), 16 rea ds jnj <b3> r s3hw n h.3b jnt and translates "Book of
bringing (the soul) to the glorifica tions of the Festiva l of the Va lley". The
true reading is jnj r sfdw (or another term for book, scroll) n h3b jnt. jnj r
has the technica l mea ning "extra cted from" or "rendered a ccordir.g to", s. Ass
mann (1969), 222 n.171.
26
JAN A S S M A N
18th. Dynasty contains neither a Book of the Dead nor any temple
is not quite complete. The first column(s) are missing. The 8 co
the verso contain 25 spells. Some of them occur more than once.
Most of the spells from TT 100 and TT 29, and from TT 50 and TT
353 reappear in this liturgy. This papyrus must once have served
context in which the liturgies were used. The l)3bt or »fest roll*
its proper place and not in its usual displaced position in coffin
or tomb decoration.*1
"° It was in 1971 when I first came across this unique piece, then labelled
»medical«, in the exhibition of the BM. Thanks to the extraordinary generosity
of H.James, who sent me a set of excellent photographs, I have been able to take
a more specific notice of its content. In view of the publication by
T.G.H.James, which is in preparation, I restrict myself here to very few remarks
of a more general character.
41
Another f est roll {h3bt) , which is explicitly designated as such on its
verso, is pBerlin 10482 (ed.Grapow 1915). It contains, however, only one s3hv-
spell (CT sp.225), the rest being food and transformation spells (CT spells
169171; 109; 329; 417; 89; 149) see Lesko (1979), 72.
27
EGYPTIAN MORTUARY LITURGIES
Bibliography
Assmann, J. (1972), "Neith spricht als Mutter und Sarg", in: MDAIK
28, 115-139.
York.
raonique. Upsala.
Goyon, J.C. (1967), "Le ceremonial de glorification d'Osiris du
28
JAN A S S M A N
14-15.
SO). Genf.
Silverman.. D. (1982), "Coffin Text Spell 902 and fts Later Usages
de recherches, I, 67-70.
29
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
30
JAN A S S M A N
s3hw I - f - a a d b - f b - - 7
s3hw II a - a - b - c - - - - - 4
s3hw III c - - - -| - - 1
s3hn iv - - - - c - - b g - a a 5
Bringing in Sokar - d - - - d e g - - b - 5
c c c
s r s
A = pBM 10081
B = pBM 10252
C = pBM 10255
D
= pBM 10317
E
= pBM 10319
F
= pLouvre 3129
G
= pBerlin 3057
H
= pNew York 35.9.21
1
= pLeiden T 31
K = pKrakau
L
= pLouvre 3079
M =PBM 10208
F
ig.l: Distribution of liturgies in liturgical papyri of the
Ptolemaic Period
31
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
5 J ft J m jrw.k 0:2
13 dj sdt dramatic
32
JAN A S S M A N
0:2 Re
worship
8 0:2 Re
33
EGYPTIAN MO R T U A R Y LITURGIES
1 Stundenwachen (SW)
107.85-108.98
4 §5: 126
5 146
6 PT 482/670
7 ill; 114
12 PT 677+365+373A 155
s3t}W III 8-9
13 PT 269-70
14 PT-style
15 "BD 191"
16 153
17
18
34
JAN A S S M A N
1 jjti - 0:2
2
hj j jhj wtz tw N pw: szp n.k tp.k PT 373 0:2
35
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
CT 837 Nr . 24
CT 838-39 Nr .25
36
JAN ASSMAN
1 Texts 2, 4
6 424 L 39-42
7 366 L 43-50
8 367 R 46-48
9 368
11 423
12 370
13 371
14 372 R 20-45
15 332/CT 518
16 468
17 412 Texts 9, 10
37
EGYPTIAN MORTUARY LITURGIES
1 16
6 22 (b)= PT §634
7 23a = PT 593
b = PT 356
c = PT 357
" n °' r i in" r i t e
d = PT 364
^r^'in'l f h a out -
8 24 = PT 677 = s3hw I 12A
., , str0*-^ho,i '""•vrp~c
9 25a = PT 365 = s3hw I 12B
10 26 s s3hw I 2 to be recited
"by night"
11 27 fc.
s3hw I 2 4 geese
12 28 s3hw I 2 4 geese
$ tuwi^ri —
13 29 sla ughtering
rjar>he>n
14 30 CT 839 = s3hw II 25B
15 31 Stundenwachen
38
JAN A S S M A N
Nr. CT
spell incipit theme and interpersonal form
39
EGYPTIAN M O R T U A R Y LITURGIES
12 51 jm hr njswt T afflon t a h i o n
J.dlllcil i d (.lull
„
13 52 ntr.w, mj m mh3w.j pn
0 n
14 53 rs. tj n nh
„
15- 20 54 -59 hnm m zhw
40
JAN A S S M A N
7 69 Q
nr wr hr gs.f 0: 0:2 clos.utt.
s«slf -pres . (Horus) : s3\}w pn
14 P
T 670 wn c3wj pt zn c3wj qbhw
15 PT 532 cf. Nr. 11 wh c
Dd m ndt
41
EGYPTIAN M O RT U A RY LITUR GIES
CT PT
spell spell cf.
61k 667
67B 666B
69 412
71 §64b
73 532
832 306
670
532
837 477
42
JAN A S S M A N
43
EGYPTIAN MORTUARY LITURGIES
b T r3 n sntr w° b n k3.k
S k3p tp.k m sntr
c) jrt htp-dj-njswt
44
JAN ASSMAN
45